Opening the book…
Before calculating anything, it pays to ask what symmetry alone can tell us about a field. The key idea is simple: if a charge distribution looks exactly the same after some operation, such as a rotation, a reflection, or a translation, then its field must look exactly the same after that operation too. The field is produced by the charges and by nothing else, so it cannot have any feature that the charges lack. Three kinds of symmetry come up again and again: spherical, cylindrical, and planar (Figure 17.1).
Spherical symmetry. A point charge, a uniformly charged sphere, or a set of concentric spherical shells looks the same however it is rotated about its center. Its field must therefore point radially, straight toward or away from the center. Any sideways component would have to point in some particular direction, east rather than west, say, and nothing in the charge distribution picks out such a direction. For the same reason the field’s magnitude can depend only on the distance \(r\) from the center, not on the direction. Such a distribution has spherical symmetry.
Cylindrical symmetry. An infinitely long line of charge, or an infinitely long uniformly charged cylinder, looks the same when rotated about its axis, when slid along its axis, and when flipped end for end. Its field must point radially away from (or toward) the axis, with a magnitude that depends only on the perpendicular distance \(r\) from the axis. A component along the axis is ruled out by the end-for-end flip, which would reverse it while leaving the charges unchanged. This is cylindrical symmetry.
Planar symmetry. An infinite plane of charge, or an infinite slab, looks the same when slid in any direction parallel to it and when rotated about any line perpendicular to it. Its field must be perpendicular to the plane, with a magnitude that depends only on the distance from it. If the charge is spread symmetrically about the plane’s midpoint, reflecting through that midplane tells us that the field points away from the plane on both sides (or toward it on both sides), with equal magnitude at equal distances. This is planar symmetry.
Symmetry has told us the direction of the field everywhere, and which single variable its magnitude can depend on. What it cannot tell us is how the magnitude depends on that variable. That last step is where Gauss’s law comes in. Chapter 16 used symmetry too, but only to cancel components inside an integral. Gauss’s law uses it far more powerfully, to avoid the integral altogether.
Note: Symmetry must be exact
The arguments above need the symmetry to be complete. A rod \(10\,\mathrm{cm}\) long is not cylindrically symmetric, because sliding it along its axis changes where its ends are. Its field near the middle is close to that of an infinite line (Section 16.3), but not exactly, and near the ends it is quite different. Gauss’s law is true for the finite rod, as it is for every charge distribution, but without full symmetry it is not enough, on its own, to find the field. For such cases the integrals of Chapter 16, or a computer, are still needed.
Checkpoint 17.1
For each distribution, decide whether it has spherical, cylindrical, or planar symmetry, or none of these: (a) a uniformly charged solid ball; (b) a uniformly charged cube; (c) a very long, straight, charged copper pipe; (d) two concentric charged spherical shells carrying different charges; (e) a charged ring; (f) a very large, thick, uniformly charged sheet of plastic.
Answers to Checkpoints
Checkpoint 17.1. (a) Spherical. (b) None: a cube looks different along a face direction than along a diagonal, so the field is not the same at all points a given distance from the center. (c) Cylindrical, away from its ends. (d) Spherical: each shell is spherically symmetric about the common center, so their sum is too. (e) None. A ring has symmetry about its axis, but not enough for Gauss’s law: no surface has a field of constant magnitude on it. (f) Planar, away from its edges.
This page titled 17.1: The Importance of Symmetry was last modified on Thu, 12 Nov 2026 04:27:10 GMT and is shared under a CC BY 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Michael Ragsdale.
The book could not be loaded just now.