3.10: Comparing Center of Mass Equation (CM) and First Law of Thermodynamics (FLT)

Calculus-based Mechanics (Workbook) · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    3.10: Comparing Center of Mass Equation (CM) and First Law of Thermodynamics (FLT)

    Center of Mass Equation and First Law of Thermodynamics Applications

    Critical Thinking & Concept Invention

    1. Was the same operation performed on each side of the equals sign from step 3 to step 4? If not, what was different?
    2. Is the action used to go from line 3 to line 4 mathematically valid? Explain your reasoning.
    3. Why did the multiplication action from line 3 to line 4 require a dot product rather than ordinary multiplication?
    4. Evaluate: \[ \int_{v_1}^{v_2} v \, dv \] Your answer should be expressed in terms of variables.
    5. Something should cancel on the left side in line 4. Cross out the quantity that cancels.
    6. Create a line 5 by replacing both sides of the equation with your responses from the previous question, then integrate both sides. Simplify what you can without moving terms across the equals sign.
    7. Examine the equation you just wrote. Does the left-hand side look familiar? Does the right-hand side look familiar? Identify what physical quantities each side resembles.

    Summary

    The process outlined in this model effectively takes a line integral of Newton’s Second Law. By multiplying each side by velocity, it becomes possible to transform time-based quantities into position-based quantities. This is useful when the change in position is known but the elapsed time is not known.

    The resulting equation is called the Center of Mass Equation:

    \[ \int_{r_1}^{r_2} \sum \vec{F}_{ext}\cdot d\vec{r}_{CM} = \frac{1}{2}M_{system} \left. v_{CM}^{\,2} \right|_{v(r_1)}^{v(r_2)} \]

    Not Work          Not Change in Kinetic Energy

    This equation is simply another form of Newton’s Second Law that works well for position-based problems. It is not an independent energy principle like the First Law of Thermodynamics. Although the units resemble energy units and the mathematics appears similar, the quantities in this equation are neither work nor energy. Do not combine this equation with energy equations.


    2 FLT and Center of Mass Equation Scenarios

    We previously developed the First Law of Thermodynamics (FLT), one of the most important principles in physics:

    \[ \Delta E_{system}=W+Q \]

    The changes in system energy can include kinetic energy, potential energy, and internal energy changes within the chosen system. The work done on the system is the sum of all external forces integrated over the displacement of those forces. Internal interactions do not do work on the system.

    \[ \Delta E_{sys} = \sum \Delta K + \sum \Delta U + \sum \Delta E \]

    \[ W = \sum_i \int \vec{F}_i \cdot d\vec{s}_i \]

    We also developed the Center of Mass Equation. Unlike FLT, it is not an energy equation. It focuses on the net external force and the motion of the system’s center of mass.

    \[ \int_{s_1}^{s_2} \sum \vec{F}_{ext}\cdot d\vec{s}_{CM} = \frac{1}{2}M_{system} \left. v_{CM}^{\,2} \right|_{v(s_1)}^{v(s_2)} \]

    Both equations can be useful, and one may be easier to apply than the other depending on the situation. Assume all forces are constant unless otherwise stated.


    3.10.1 Car Speeds Up to the Right on Level Ground

    Model

    An electric car increases its speed on level ground from 5 m/s to 15 m/s. The model below applies both the First Law of Thermodynamics and the Center of Mass Equation. To simplify the model, assume there is no change in thermal energy.

    Electric car accelerating on level ground with force diagram and equation comparison

    FLT Model

    \[ \Delta E_{system}=W \]

    \[ \Delta U_{electric}+\Delta K_{trans}=0 \]

    \[ \Delta U_{electric} + \frac12 Mv^2 \Big|_{5}^{15} =0 \]

    \[ \Delta U_{electric} = -\frac{M(15^2-5^2)}{2} \]

    Center of Mass Equation Model

    \[ \int \sum \vec{F}\cdot d\vec{s}_{CM} = \frac12 M_{system} v_{CM}^{2} \Big|_{5}^{15} \]

    \[ \int F_s\,ds = \frac12 M(15^2-5^2) \]

    \[ F_s = \frac{M(15^2-5^2)}{2\Delta s} \]

    Explore

    1. Draw a force diagram that includes \(\vec{F}_g\), \(\vec{F}_N\), and \(\vec{F}_s\).
    2. How many energy terms change in the FLT equation?
    3. How many forces do work? Explain using the definition of work as a dot product.
    4. Which energy term from the FLT equation also appears in the CM Equation?
    5. How many forces remain in the integral after the dot product?
    6. If the mass is known, what quantity can be determined from the FLT equation?
    7. If the mass and displacement are known, what quantity can be determined from the CM Equation?

    Critical Thinking & Concept Invention

    1. In this situation, is \[ \frac12 M_{system}v_{CM}^{2} \Big|_{v(s_1)}^{v(s_2)} \] equal to the change in kinetic energy of the system? Explain.
    2. In this situation, is \[ \int \vec{F}_s\cdot d\vec{s} \] also equal to the work done on the system? Explain.
    3. What does each equation tell you about the car?

    3.10.2 Blocks Pulled Apart

    Model

    A force of 10 N is applied in the directions shown to two different 0.5 kg blocks. The blocks are initially at rest and move across a frictionless table a distance of 3 m.

    Two blocks pulled apart on a frictionless surface by equal forces in opposite directions

    Explore

    1. What is the net force on the system?
    2. What is the initial velocity of the center of mass? Does it change?
    3. What is the initial velocity of each individual block? Does it change?

    Critical Thinking & Concept Invention

    1. Solve both equations:
      • \[ \int \sum \vec{F}\cdot d\vec{s}_{CM} = \frac12 M_{system}v_{CM}^{2} \Big|_{v(s_1)}^{v(s_2)} \]
      • \[ \Delta E_{system}=W \]
    2. Which equation allowed you to calculate something about the system?
    3. Why was the other equation not particularly useful in this situation?
    4. Summarize when you would use the more useful equation instead of the other.

    3.10.3 Collision with a Spring

    Model

    A 1.5 kg box slides on a surface with a coefficient of friction of 0.4. It begins with a speed of 8 m/s and travels 1.5 m before reaching a spring. Determine how far the spring compresses before the box stops if the spring constant is 24 J/m.

    Box sliding into a spring on a rough surface with friction

    FLT Equation

    \[ \Delta E_{system}=W \]

    \[ \Delta K_{trans} + \Delta E_{thermal} = \int_{0}^{d}\vec{F}_{ela}\cdot d\vec{s} + \int_{1.5}^{d_f}\vec{F}_k\cdot d\vec{s} \]

    \[ \frac12 Mv^2 \Big|_{8}^{0} + \Delta E_{thermal} = \int_{0}^{d}(-kx)\,dx + \int_{1.5}^{d_f}\mu_k mg\,dx \]

    Center of Mass Equation

    \[ \int_{1.5}^{d} \sum \vec{F}\cdot d\vec{s}_{CM} = \frac12 M_{system}v_{CM}^{2} \Big|_{8}^{0} \]

    \[ \int_{0}^{d}(-kx)\,dx + \int_{1.5}^{d}\mu_kmg\,dx = \frac12 Mv^2 \Big|_{8}^{0} \]

    Explore

    1. Compare the second line of each equation and identify terms unique to each.
    2. Circle the unknowns in each equation.
    3. For each equation identify:
      • Number of forces
      • What the force integrals equal
      • Number of unknowns

    Critical Thinking & Concept Invention

    1. Is the variable \(d\) in the integral limit positive or negative? Explain.
    2. Which equation appears easier to solve?
    3. Besides kinetic energy, what energy changes because of friction? Which equation shows this?
    4. Why is the work done by friction difficult to calculate?
    5. Summarize situations where the CM Equation may be a better choice than FLT.

    Apply

    1. Solve for the final position of the spring using whichever equation is easier.

    3.10.4 Driving Up a Hill at a Constant Speed

    Model

    A 1200 kg car drives up a hill inclined at an angle \(\theta\) with a constant speed of 30 m/s. The system consists only of the car.

    Car traveling uphill at constant speed with force components on an incline

    The net force is composed of:

    \[ \sum \vec{F} = \vec{F}_g + \vec{F}_N + \vec{F}_s \]

    \[ \begin{bmatrix} -mg\sin(\theta)\\ -mg\cos(\theta) \end{bmatrix} + \begin{bmatrix} 0\\ mg\cos(\theta) \end{bmatrix} + \begin{bmatrix} F_s\\ 0 \end{bmatrix} \]

    FLT Equation

    \[ \Delta E_{system}=W \]

    \[ \Delta E_{electrical} = \int \vec{F}_g\cdot d\vec{s} + \int \vec{F}_N\cdot d\vec{s} + \int \vec{F}_s\cdot d\vec{s} \]

    \[ \Delta E_{electrical} = \int_0^d -mg\sin(\theta)\,dx \]

    Center of Mass Equation

    \[ \int_{s_1}^{s_2} \sum \vec{F}\cdot d\vec{s}_{CM} = \frac12 M_{system} v_{CM}^{2} \Big|_{v(s_1)}^{v(s_2)} \]

    \[ \int_{s_1}^{s_2}(0)\cdot d\vec{s} = \frac12 M_{system}(0) \]

    \[ 0=0 \]

    Explore

    1. What is the chosen system?
    2. For each equation identify:
      • Number of forces before the dot product
      • Number of forces after the dot product
      • What the force integrals equal

    Critical Thinking & Concept Invention

    1. What should \(\sum\vec{F}\) equal for this situation?
    2. Why are there no forces left in the CM Equation?
    3. Why is there one force remaining in the FLT equation?
    4. Does the FLT equation provide useful information? If so, what?
    5. Does the CM Equation provide useful information? If so, what?
    6. Under what conditions does the CM Equation reduce to zero?

    Apply

    1. Assume the car accelerates uphill and the static friction force is: \( F_s=2mg\sin(\theta) \) directed uphill (\(+x\)). Construct both the FLT and CM equations. Then choose the equation that allows you to determine the speed of the car after traveling 20 m on a hill inclined at \( 20^\circ. \)

    This page titled 3.10: Comparing Center of Mass Equation (CM) and First Law of Thermodynamics (FLT) was last modified on Wed, 28 Oct 2026 22:16:40 GMT and is shared under a CC BY 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Andrew Totah-McCarty.