10.3: The Individual as an Integral Systems

Health 9: Integrative Mind-Body Connection and Mindfulness · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    10.3: The Individual as an Integral Systems

    The Individual as an Integral System: Understanding the Self Through Michael Levin’s Mind Everywhere Framework

    The Individual as an Integrated Biological System

    Understanding the individual as an integral system requires moving beyond the traditional view that a person is simply a collection of separate organs, tissues, and biological processes. Although the human body contains specialized systems responsible for functions such as circulation, digestion, respiration, and nervous system activity, these systems do not operate independently. They continuously communicate, coordinate, adapt, and respond to one another to maintain the organization of the whole organism. The individual is therefore better understood as an integrated, dynamic system in which biological, neurological, physiological, psychological, and environmental processes interact to produce the experience of being a unified person.

    This perspective has important connections to the work of biologist Michael Levin and his framework known as Mind Everywhere. Levin challenges the assumption that intelligence, decision-making, memory, and goal-directed behavior are exclusive properties of the human brain or nervous system. Instead, he proposes that cognitive processes exist across different levels of biological organization, including individual cells, cellular networks, tissues, and whole organisms. From this perspective, the human individual represents an extraordinary example of biological integration, in which countless smaller living systems coordinate their activities to create a larger, unified entity (Levin, 2022, 2023).

    This approach expands our understanding of what it means to be an individual. Rather than viewing the self as something produced exclusively by the brain, it suggests that individuality emerges through the coordinated activity of multiple biological systems. The brain contributes to conscious thought, memory, emotion, and behavior, but the broader biological organization of the body also contributes to maintaining the conditions that make human life and experience possible.

    Michael Levin's Mind Everywhere: Intelligence Across Biological Systems

    Michael Levin's Mind Everywhere framework draws from the emerging field of basal cognition, which examines the fundamental properties of cognition in living systems that do not possess brains or conventional nervous systems. Basal cognition considers how organisms and biological structures sense information, respond to environmental conditions, regulate internal states, and pursue outcomes that support their continued organization.

    In his 2022 article, Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere, Levin introduces the Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere (TAME), a framework for understanding and comparing different forms of embodied intelligence. Rather than defining cognition through a strict division between intelligent and non-intelligent systems, Levin proposes examining cognitive capacities along a continuum. This allows researchers to investigate how different biological systems process information, maintain internal stability, adapt to challenges, and coordinate activity toward particular outcomes (Levin, 2022).

    One of Levin's central arguments is that intelligence can emerge from the collective activity of smaller components. Individual cells possess mechanisms for sensing, communicating, and responding to their surroundings. When cells become organized into larger networks, their collective activities can produce capabilities that extend beyond those of any individual cell. The resulting system can maintain structures, repair damage, and regulate complex biological processes.

    This idea changes how we understand the human body. A person is not simply a brain directing a collection of passive biological components. Instead, the person is a living collective whose cells, tissues, organs, and nervous system participate in maintaining the organization of the whole.

    FIGURE PLACEHOLDER 1: Mind Everywhere—Levels of Biological Organization

    Suggested figure: A nested visual showing molecular networks within cells, cells within tissues, tissues within organs, organs within physiological systems, and physiological systems within the whole individual. Include communication pathways connecting the different levels to illustrate how intelligence and biological regulation emerge through collective activity.

    The Emergence of Individuality Through Collective Intelligence

    A particularly important contribution of Levin's work is his explanation of how individual biological components can collectively produce a larger, integrated individual. This concept is described through collective intelligence, the capacity of multiple interacting components to coordinate their activities and accomplish outcomes that cannot be explained solely by examining each component independently.

    For example, a single human cell maintains its internal conditions, responds to chemical signals, and participates in local biological processes. However, during embryonic development, cells must coordinate with thousands or millions of other cells to produce organized structures such as the heart, brain, limbs, and other organs. This process requires cells to communicate, interpret information, adjust their behavior, and contribute to the development of a larger anatomical structure.

    Levin's research examines how these cellular communities maintain anatomical organization and respond to disruptions. Importantly, cells do not simply follow a predetermined sequence of instructions in a passive manner. They participate in dynamic processes of communication and regulation that allow developing and regenerating organisms to maintain or restore anatomical patterns (Levin, 2019, 2023).

    The implications extend beyond embryonic development. The same principle of coordination operates throughout life as cells continually respond to changing conditions, maintain tissues, replace damaged components, and support physiological functioning. The individual is therefore not a static biological object but an ongoing achievement of collective organization.

    From this perspective, the human self can be understood as an emergent property of biological relationships. The whole organism possesses characteristics that cannot be attributed to any single cell, organ, or biological structure. These characteristics emerge through the continuous coordination of its components.

    Bioelectricity: How Cells Communicate and Coordinate

    One of the most significant mechanisms in Levin's research is bioelectricity, which refers to the electrical properties and signaling processes of living cells. Although electrical activity is commonly associated with the brain, nervous system, and muscles, cells throughout the body use electrical signals to communicate and coordinate biological activity.

    Cell membranes maintain differences in electrical potential between the inside and outside of the cell. These voltage differences are influenced by ion channels, ion pumps, and other membrane transport mechanisms. Cells can communicate through electrical signals and networks involving gap junctions, which allow neighboring cells to exchange ions and small signaling molecules.

    Levin's research demonstrates that bioelectric signaling plays an important role in coordinating cellular activity during development, regeneration, and the maintenance of anatomical structures. These electrical networks can help groups of cells coordinate their behavior toward larger organizational outcomes (Levin, 2022, 2023).

    This research is especially relevant to understanding the individual as an integrated system because it demonstrates that biological communication extends far beyond the brain. Electrical signaling is part of the body's broader organizational network, connecting cellular activity to tissue development and physiological regulation.

    For example, during tissue development, cells must coordinate their growth, differentiation, and spatial organization. Bioelectric communication helps regulate these processes by providing information about the larger biological environment in which individual cells operate. In this way, cellular networks contribute to maintaining the structure and organization of the developing organism.

    Bioelectricity provides an important example of how the individual is maintained through communication across multiple biological levels. The body's organization depends not only on the activities of individual cells but also on the relationships and information exchanged among them.

    FIGURE PLACEHOLDER 2: Bioelectric Communication Across the Body

    Suggested figure: Illustrate neighboring cells communicating through membrane voltage changes and gap junctions. Show how local electrical signals contribute to coordinated tissue activity and larger patterns of biological organization.

    The Individual as a Nested System of Interacting Selves

    Another important concept in Levin's framework is that biological individuality exists at multiple levels of organization. A human being can be understood as a collection of nested biological systems, each with its own regulatory processes and capacities for responding to environmental conditions.

    At the cellular level, individual cells regulate their internal environments and respond to surrounding signals. At the tissue level, groups of cells coordinate their activities to maintain structural and functional organization. At the organ level, specialized tissues work together to accomplish more complex physiological functions. At the whole-organism level, these systems collectively sustain the life and functioning of the individual.

    These levels are not completely independent. They are interconnected and continuously influence one another. A change in one level can affect the organization and functioning of other levels. For example, cellular stress can influence tissue functioning, tissue inflammation can affect organ activity, and changes in organ functioning can influence the physiological conditions experienced throughout the body.

    Levin (2019) explores this concept through his discussion of the computational boundaries of the self. He proposes that biological individuality can be understood in relation to the scale of goals a system is capable of pursuing. He describes a concept called the cognitive light cone, referring to the spatial and temporal range of information and outcomes that a system can sense, model, and attempt to influence.

    A single cell operates within a relatively limited biological environment, responding to local conditions and maintaining its internal stability. A cellular collective, however, can coordinate activity across a larger space and work toward maintaining the organization of an entire tissue or anatomical structure. A whole organism operates across an even broader range of biological and environmental conditions.

    The cognitive light cone provides a way to conceptualize how increasingly complex forms of organization emerge through the coordination of smaller systems. It also challenges the assumption that the boundaries of an individual are always identical to the physical boundaries of a single organism. Biological systems contain overlapping levels of organization, cooperation, and regulation.

    For understanding human health, this perspective suggests that the individual cannot be fully understood by examining isolated biological processes. Health emerges through the relationships among systems, including the ways in which cells, organs, physiological processes, and the nervous system coordinate their activities.

    The Relationship Between the Brain, Body, and Biological Intelligence

    Levin's framework also provides a broader context for understanding the relationship between the brain and the rest of the body. Traditional approaches to neuroscience often emphasize the brain as the central structure responsible for cognition, decision-making, and behavior. Although the brain plays an essential role in these functions, Levin's work suggests that biological information processing and adaptive regulation are not limited to neural tissue.

    The nervous system itself is a highly integrated network of specialized cells that communicate through electrical and chemical signals. However, similar principles of communication and coordination also occur outside the nervous system. Cells throughout the body respond to chemical, mechanical, and electrical information, helping maintain the conditions necessary for biological functioning.

    This does not mean that every cell possesses human-like consciousness, thoughts, or subjective experiences. Rather, Levin uses cognition in a broader biological sense to describe capacities such as information processing, adaptation, memory, and goal-directed regulation. The distinction is important because cellular problem-solving and human conscious thought represent different levels of organization and complexity.

    In this framework, the brain is one important component of a much larger biological system. Brain activity is influenced by signals from the body, while the brain also regulates physiological processes through neural, hormonal, and autonomic pathways. These interactions demonstrate that mental processes are embodied within the functioning of the organism.

    For example, when a person experiences a stressful situation, the response involves more than conscious thoughts or emotional reactions. The nervous system, endocrine system, cardiovascular system, immune system, and metabolic processes participate in coordinating the body's response. These systems communicate and adjust their activities to respond to the perceived challenge.

    Understanding the individual as an integral system therefore requires recognizing that mental and physical processes are interconnected expressions of a living organism.

    The Individual, Adaptation, and Health

    The concept of the individual as an integrated biological system has important implications for health and well-being. If biological organization emerges through communication and coordination across multiple levels, then health cannot be understood exclusively through the functioning of individual organs or the absence of disease.

    Instead, health can be considered in relation to the capacity of the whole organism to maintain internal stability, adapt to changing conditions, repair disruptions, and coordinate biological activity. These capacities involve interactions among cellular processes, physiological systems, psychological experiences, and environmental influences.

    Levin's research is particularly relevant to understanding the relationship between cellular regulation and the larger organization of the body. His work on developmental bioelectricity and collective intelligence demonstrates how biological systems maintain anatomical organization and respond to disruptions. These findings offer new ways to investigate regeneration, tissue repair, and the relationship between cellular communication and health (Levin, 2022, 2023).

    This perspective also connects with broader approaches to integrative health. Nutrition, physical activity, sleep, stress, social relationships, and environmental exposures can influence biological processes at multiple levels. For instance, inadequate sleep can affect hormonal regulation, immune functioning, metabolism, and cognitive performance. Chronic stress can influence autonomic nervous system activity and endocrine responses, potentially affecting multiple physiological systems over time.

    These examples illustrate how the condition of the whole individual reflects the interaction of multiple biological and environmental processes. They do not establish that every lifestyle influence directly changes cellular bioelectric networks in a predictable way. Rather, they demonstrate why health is best approached through an understanding of interconnected biological systems.

    From an integrative health perspective, the goal is not simply to treat isolated symptoms but to understand the relationships among the processes that contribute to the individual's overall functioning. Levin's framework expands this perspective by emphasizing that the body itself is an active, adaptive, and self-organizing biological system.

    The Individual as an Open and Adaptive System

    Although the human organism maintains a degree of internal organization, it is not biologically isolated from its surroundings. Individuals continuously exchange energy, matter, and information with their environments. Food, water, oxygen, temperature, physical activity, social interactions, and environmental exposures all contribute to the conditions under which biological systems function.

    The individual can therefore be understood as an open biological system that maintains its organization through ongoing interactions with the external environment. This organization is dynamic rather than fixed. Cells change their activity, tissues respond to physiological demands, and the body adjusts to environmental challenges.

    Levin's work adds another dimension to this understanding by examining how living systems actively respond to conditions rather than functioning only as passive recipients of environmental information. Biological systems possess regulatory capacities that allow them to maintain or restore preferred patterns of organization. At the cellular and tissue levels, these processes contribute to development, adaptation, and regeneration (Levin, 2019, 2023).

    Consider how the human body responds to physical exercise. Muscle cells adjust their metabolic activity, cardiovascular and respiratory systems respond to increased demands, and the nervous system coordinates movement. With repeated training and adequate recovery, the body can develop adaptations that improve its capacity to perform the activity. These changes occur through interactions across multiple levels of biological organization.

    The individual is therefore continuously being shaped by the relationship between internal biological processes and external conditions. This understanding challenges the idea that health is simply a fixed state and instead emphasizes the organism's capacity for adaptation and ongoing regulation.

    FIGURE PLACEHOLDER 3: The Individual as an Open, Adaptive System

    Suggested figure: Place the human organism at the center of a diagram. Surround it with environmental influences such as nutrition, movement, sleep, stress, social relationships, and physical surroundings. Use two-way arrows to demonstrate that the individual both responds to and influences the environment. Include internal connections among the nervous, endocrine, immune, digestive, and cardiovascular systems.

    Applying Mind Everywhere to Integrative Health

    Levin's Mind Everywhere framework provides a useful conceptual foundation for integrative health because it encourages us to examine health across multiple levels of biological organization. Rather than treating the individual as a collection of separate parts, it emphasizes the importance of understanding how those parts communicate and contribute to the functioning of the whole.

    For example, consider the relationship between stress and physical health. Stress may begin with an individual's interpretation of a situation, but the response involves multiple interacting systems. The brain processes information about the perceived challenge, the autonomic nervous system adjusts physiological activity, and hormonal signaling influences metabolism and other bodily functions. Immune and inflammatory processes may also be affected by prolonged stress exposure.

    An integrative approach examines these interactions rather than separating psychological experiences from physical functioning. It also considers how practices such as mindfulness, yoga, physical activity, supportive relationships, and adequate sleep may contribute to overall well-being through different pathways.

    Levin's work does not directly establish the effectiveness of these particular health practices. Instead, his framework offers a broader way to understand why human health involves interconnected regulatory processes and why interventions affecting one part of the individual may have consequences elsewhere in the system.

    Ultimately, the individual can be understood as an integrated biological community whose organization emerges through ongoing communication, cooperation, adaptation, and regulation. The brain, body, cells, and physiological systems are not separate entities but interconnected dimensions of a living whole.

    This perspective invites a broader understanding of the self. Human individuality is not simply located in one organ or biological structure. It emerges through the coordinated activity of countless living components that collectively sustain the organism. Through Levin's Mind Everywhere framework, the human individual becomes an example of how complex biological organization can give rise to increasingly sophisticated forms of intelligence, agency, and adaptive behavior.

    APPLIED LEARNING

    Hypothetical Case Study: Understanding the Individual as a Collective Biological System

    Consider an individual who experiences ongoing stress, disrupted sleep, and reduced physical activity. Initially, these experiences may appear to be separate lifestyle concerns. However, when examined through an integrated systems perspective, they reveal relationships among multiple levels of biological organization.

    Changes in sleep patterns can influence hormonal regulation, immune activity, metabolism, and cognitive functioning. Stress can influence nervous system activity and physiological regulation. Reduced movement can affect cardiovascular health, metabolic functioning, and muscular adaptation.

    From Levin's perspective, the individual is not simply a collection of separate systems experiencing unrelated problems. The individual is a coordinated biological system in which multiple levels of organization continuously interact.

    This perspective encourages health professionals to consider the broader conditions influencing an individual's health rather than focusing exclusively on isolated symptoms. It also highlights the importance of understanding the body's capacity for adaptation, regulation, and recovery.

    The case illustrates how the concept of collective biological intelligence can contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of human health, while recognizing that Levin's framework is a theoretical and research-oriented approach rather than a clinical diagnostic model.

    REFLECTION AND APPLICATION

    Reflection: The Individual as an Integral System

    Consider how understanding the individual as an integrated biological system might change the way we approach health, wellness, and disease.

    1. How does Levin's concept of collective intelligence challenge the traditional understanding of the human individual as a brain-centered system?

    2. If cells, tissues, organs, and physiological systems participate in maintaining the organization of the whole organism, what does this suggest about the relationship between individual biological processes and overall health?

    3. How might the concept of the cognitive light cone help explain the emergence of increasingly complex forms of biological organization?

    4. How could an integrative health approach incorporate the understanding that the individual is a dynamic system influenced by biological, psychological, social, and environmental conditions?

    References

    Levin, M. (2019). The computational boundary of a "self": Developmental bioelectricity drives multicellularity and scale-free cognition. Frontiers in Psychology, 10, Article 2688. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02688

    Levin, M. (2022). Technological approach to mind everywhere: An experimentally-grounded framework for understanding diverse bodies and minds. Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience, 16, Article 768201. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnsys.2022.768201

    Levin, M. (2023). Bioelectric networks: The cognitive glue enabling evolutionary scaling from physiology to mind. Animal Cognition, 26, 1865–1891. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-023-01780-3

    Additional reading: Levin and Resnik's 2026 two-part series, Mind Everywhere: A Framework for Conceptualizing Goal-Directedness in Biology and Other Domains, extends this discussion into the philosophical and scientific understanding of goal-directedness across biological and nonbiological systems.


    10.3: The Individual as an Integral Systems is shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by LibreTexts.