10.1: Introduction to Mind Everywhere

Health 9: Integrative Mind-Body Connection and Mindfulness · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    10.1: Introduction to Mind Everywhere

    Introduction: The Mind Everywhere – Understanding Mind Beyond the Brain

    Where does the mind begin, and where does it end? For much of modern history, the mind has been understood primarily as something that happens inside the brain. Thinking, remembering, feeling, perceiving, and making decisions have traditionally been associated with neurological activity. While the brain plays an essential role in human mental functioning, emerging perspectives in cognitive science, developmental biology, bioelectricity, neuroscience, and philosophy invite us to reconsider whether the brain is the only place where the principles of mind can be understood.

    The idea of Mind Everywhere introduces a broader perspective: the processes associated with intelligence, information processing, adaptation, communication, and self-organization may be found across multiple levels of living systems. These processes are not necessarily equivalent to human consciousness or subjective experience. Rather, they suggest that the biological foundations of cognition and intelligent behavior extend beyond the nervous system.

    This perspective brings together the work of three important areas of scholarship. Francisco Varela and Evan Thompson, along with psychologist Eleanor Rosch, explored how the mind emerges through the relationship between the brain, body, and environment. Daniel Siegel developed interpersonal neurobiology to examine how mental processes emerge through the integration of brain, body, relationships, and experience. Developmental and regenerative biologist Michael Levin has expanded our understanding of biological intelligence by investigating how cells and tissues communicate, process information, coordinate activity, and organize themselves toward larger biological goals.

    Together, these perspectives encourage a fundamental shift in how we understand the mind. Instead of viewing intelligence and mental activity exclusively as products of the human brain, we can investigate how information processing, adaptation, and self-organization operate throughout living systems.

    This broader understanding has important implications for health and well-being. It invites us to examine how biological processes, bodily experiences, relationships, and environments interact to influence the functioning of the whole person.

    Moving Beyond the Brain: The Embodied and Enactive Mind

    In The Embodied Mind, Varela, Thompson, and Rosch (1991/2017) challenged traditional approaches that treated cognition primarily as the processing of information inside the brain. They proposed that cognition is embodied and enactive, meaning that mental processes emerge through the continuous interaction of an organism with its environment.

    From this perspective, perception is not simply the passive reception of sensory information. It involves an active relationship between the organism and its surroundings. Movement, bodily sensations, previous experiences, emotions, and environmental conditions all contribute to how individuals interpret and respond to the world.

    For example, walking through a forest involves much more than visual processing. The body adjusts to the terrain, the senses respond to sounds and smells, breathing and heart rate change, and emotional experiences emerge through engagement with the surroundings. The experience of being in nature develops through the interaction of the brain, body, and environment.

    Varela and Thompson's work helps establish an important foundation for understanding the mind as an ongoing process rather than an isolated object. The mind is embodied in the living organism and develops through its interactions with the world.

    Michael Levin: Biological Intelligence Beyond the Brain

    One of the most intriguing contributions to the idea of Mind Everywhere comes from developmental and regenerative biologist Michael Levin, whose research explores how intelligence-like processes operate throughout living systems, including individual cells and groups of cells.

    Levin's work challenges the assumption that intelligence requires a brain or nervous system. Through research on bioelectricity, cellular communication, tissue organization, and regeneration, he investigates how living cells gather information, communicate, coordinate behavior, and work collectively toward biological outcomes.

    His research introduces the concept of basal cognition, which refers to basic forms of information processing, memory, decision-making, and adaptive behavior that can occur in living systems without a centralized nervous system (Levin, 2023).

    This does not mean that an individual cell thinks or experiences consciousness in the same way a human does. Instead, Levin proposes that some of the fundamental processes associated with cognition can be studied at much simpler biological levels. These include the ability to sense changes, process signals, modify behavior, retain information, and coordinate activity in response to challenges.

    Bioelectricity: How Cells Communicate and Coordinate

    A central focus of Levin's research is bioelectricity, the electrical activity generated by living cells. Although electrical signaling is commonly associated with neurons and the nervous system, Levin demonstrates that electrical communication also plays important roles in non-neural tissues.

    Cells maintain electrical differences across their membranes through ion channels and pumps. These differences create membrane voltage patterns that influence cellular behavior. Cells can also communicate electrically through connections such as gap junctions, allowing information to move across groups of cells.

    Levin (2014) describes how these bioelectric signals help regulate cell growth, differentiation, shape, and organization during development and regeneration. Importantly, bioelectric networks can provide information that coordinates the activities of individual cells toward larger anatomical outcomes.

    For example, during embryonic development, individual cells must coordinate their activities to form complex structures such as organs, limbs, and facial features. This organization cannot be understood simply by examining what each individual cell does independently. Cells communicate and respond to one another through networks of biochemical, genetic, and electrical signals.

    Levin's research suggests that bioelectric networks help store and communicate information about the larger structures that developing tissues are organized to create (Levin, 2014a, 2014b).

    [Figure Placeholder: Cellular Bioelectric Communication. Illustrate individual cells connected through gap junctions, with membrane voltage differences and electrical signaling coordinating collective tissue organization.]

    Cellular Intelligence and Collective Problem-Solving

    Another important contribution of Levin's work is the idea that intelligence can emerge through collective biological organization.

    Individual cells have particular functions, but they also participate in larger networks that coordinate activity toward shared outcomes. These networks demonstrate forms of adaptation and problem-solving that cannot always be explained by examining individual cellular components in isolation.

    For example, during tissue regeneration, cells must coordinate their activities to restore damaged structures. They communicate, respond to local conditions, and adjust their behavior as the regenerative process unfolds. This requires an organized exchange of information across multiple levels of biological functioning.

    Levin (2023) argues that these processes can be understood through the framework of collective intelligence. In this view, biological systems possess different levels of problem-solving capacity, from individual cells to tissues and whole organisms.

    His later work extends this idea into the concept of multiscale intelligence, examining how biological systems coordinate information and behavior across different levels of organization (Levin, 2025).

    This perspective is particularly relevant to the idea of Mind Everywhere because it suggests that the foundations of intelligent organization are not exclusive to the human brain. Biological systems demonstrate different forms of information processing, adaptation, and self-organization throughout the living world.

    [Figure Placeholder: Multiscale Biological Intelligence. Show a progression from molecules and individual cells to tissues, organs, and whole organisms, illustrating how information and coordination operate across biological levels.]

    Connecting Levin, Varela, and Thompson: A Broader Understanding of Mind

    Although Michael Levin and Varela and Thompson approach the study of mind from different scientific and philosophical perspectives, their work offers complementary insights.

    Varela and Thompson emphasize that human cognition is embodied and emerges through interactions between the organism and its environment. Their work focuses on perception, experience, consciousness, and the relationship between living organisms and the worlds they inhabit.

    Levin extends the investigation of cognition into developmental and cellular biology. His research explores how biological systems process information, coordinate behavior, adapt, and organize themselves even in the absence of a nervous system.

    Together, their work encourages us to examine intelligence and cognition across multiple levels of biological organization.

    Research perspective

    Central contribution

    Varela and Thompson

    Cognition emerges through embodied interaction between the organism and its environment.

    Michael Levin

    Intelligence-like processes, information processing, and collective problem-solving occur across biological systems.

    Daniel Siegel

    The mind involves embodied, relational processes that integrate brain, body, and relationships.

    These perspectives should not be treated as interchangeable. In particular, the ability of cells to process information and adapt does not establish that cells possess subjective consciousness. Levin's work concerns biological competencies and basal cognition, while Varela and Thompson also address the nature of lived experience and consciousness.

    The connection among these approaches is their shared interest in understanding living systems as dynamic, interconnected, and capable of organizing themselves through ongoing interactions.

    The Mind Everywhere: A Multilevel Perspective on Health and Well-Being

    The integration of these perspectives creates an opportunity to understand health as a multilevel biological and experiential process. Human well-being is influenced by interactions occurring at many levels, from cellular communication and metabolic activity to brain function, emotional experience, relationships, and environmental conditions.

    Levin's research is particularly valuable because it draws attention to the biological intelligence that supports the development, maintenance, and repair of living organisms. His work raises important questions about how cells communicate, how tissues maintain organization, and how biological systems respond to disruption (Levin, 2023, 2025).

    PubMed+1

    When considered alongside embodied cognition and interpersonal neurobiology, this research encourages a more comprehensive understanding of health. The body is not simply a structure controlled by the brain. It is a complex living system containing multiple interacting networks that continuously communicate and adapt.

    This perspective also creates connections to several topics explored throughout this textbook, including mitochondria, the microbiome, neuroplasticity, epigenetics, stress physiology, and the mind-body connection. Each provides another opportunity to examine how information, biological regulation, and environmental experience influence the functioning of living systems.

    Ultimately, Mind Everywhere invites us to reconsider the boundaries of the mind and the relationship between intelligence, life, and health. It encourages us to move beyond the idea that the mind exists exclusively within the brain and toward an understanding of living systems as interconnected networks of communication, adaptation, and self-organization.

    The central question becomes not simply where the mind is located, but how the processes associated with mind emerge, operate, and interact throughout the living world.

    Reflection: Thinking About Mind Everywhere

    1. How does Michael Levin's research on cellular intelligence challenge traditional assumptions about the relationship between the brain and intelligence?
    2. What connections can you identify between Varela and Thompson's embodied mind and Levin's research on biological intelligence?
    3. How might understanding the body as a network of communicating and self-organizing systems change the way we approach health and well-being?
    4. Consider the relationship between your physical environment, cellular functioning, emotional experiences, and relationships. How might these different levels of organization influence one another?

    References

    Levin, M. (2014a). Endogenous bioelectrical networks store non-genetic patterning information during development and regeneration. The Journal of Physiology, 592(11), 2295–2305. https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.2014.271940

    Levin, M. (2014b). Molecular bioelectricity: How endogenous voltage potentials control cell behavior and instruct pattern regulation in vivo. Molecular Biology of the Cell, 25(24), 3835–3850. https://doi.org/10.1091/mbc.E13-12-0708

    Levin, M. (2023). Bioelectric networks: The cognitive glue enabling evolutionary scaling from physiology to mind. Animal Cognition, 26, 1865–1891. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-023-01780-3

    Levin, M. (2025). The multiscale wisdom of the body: Collective intelligence as a tractable interface for next-generation biomedicine. BioEssays, 47(3), e202400196. https://doi.org/10.1002/bies.202400196

    Siegel, D. J. (2020). The developing mind: How relationships and the brain interact to shape who we are (3rd ed.). Guilford Press.

    Thompson, E., & Varela, F. J. (2001). Radical embodiment: Neural dynamics and consciousness. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 5(10), 418–425. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1364-6613(00)01750-2

    Varela, F. J., Thompson, E., & Rosch, E. (2017). The embodied mind: Cognitive science and human experience (Revised ed.). MIT Press. (Original work published 1991)


    10.1: Introduction to Mind Everywhere is shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by LibreTexts.