Opening the book…
Embodiment and Experience: The Enactive Approach of Varela and Thompson
Introduction: Understanding the Mind Through the Body
Traditional approaches to understanding the mind have often treated cognition as something that occurs primarily within the brain. From this perspective, the brain receives information from the external environment, processes that information, and produces thoughts, emotions, and behaviors. However, this model does not fully explain how our physical bodies, lived experiences, relationships, and environments shape the ways we think, feel, and understand the world.
The work of Chilean biologist and neuroscientist Francisco Varela and philosopher Evan Thompson offers a different perspective. Through their contributions to embodied cognitive science and the development of the enactive approach, they challenged the idea that the mind can be understood independently of the body and its interactions with the environment. Their work suggests that cognition is not simply a process of representing an external world inside the brain. Instead, cognition emerges through the ongoing relationship between the brain, body, and world (Varela et al., 1991).
This perspective has important implications for understanding health and well-being. Human experience is shaped by biological processes, bodily sensations, emotional responses, movement, social relationships, and environmental conditions. The body is not merely a vehicle that carries the brain; it actively participates in how we perceive, interpret, and respond to life.
The Embodied Mind: Cognition as a Lived Experience
In The Embodied Mind: Cognitive Science and Human Experience, Varela, Thompson, and Eleanor Rosch (1991) introduced an influential framework that brought together cognitive science, biology, phenomenology, and Buddhist philosophy. Their central argument was that cognition cannot be adequately explained by studying the brain in isolation. Instead, mental processes must be understood in relation to the body and the world in which a person lives.
Embodiment refers to the ways in which cognitive processes are shaped by the physical body, including its sensory systems, movement, biological organization, and ongoing interactions with the environment. Our experiences are not detached observations of the world. They are lived through a body that has particular needs, capabilities, histories, and limitations.
Consider how the experience of stress influences perception. When a person feels threatened, the body may respond with increased heart rate, muscle tension, changes in breathing, and heightened vigilance. These physical changes can influence attention, memory, emotional interpretation, and decision-making. The person does not simply think about stress; the experience of stress is also expressed through the body and influences how the surrounding world is perceived.
Similarly, feelings of safety, connection, and physical comfort can influence how a person experiences their environment. A supportive social interaction may produce feelings of relaxation and belonging, while an unfamiliar or threatening environment may generate tension and alertness. These examples illustrate how cognition, emotion, and bodily processes operate together rather than as separate systems.
[Figure Placeholder 1: The Embodied Mind. Insert a conceptual diagram showing the interconnected relationship among the brain, body, lived experience, and physical and social environment. Use bidirectional arrows to illustrate continuous interaction.]
The Enactive Approach: How We Bring Forth Our World
One of the most important contributions of Varela and Thompson is the concept of enaction. The term describes how organisms actively participate in creating meaning through their interactions with the world. Rather than viewing perception as a passive process in which the brain receives and interprets information, the enactive approach understands perception as something that develops through action.
For example, consider walking through a familiar neighborhood. A person does not simply receive visual information about buildings, streets, trees, and other people. Their perception is influenced by their intentions, memories, physical abilities, emotional state, and previous experiences. A person who enjoys walking may experience the neighborhood as inviting and relaxing. Someone who has previously experienced danger in that location may perceive the same surroundings as threatening. The physical environment has not necessarily changed, but the person's embodied relationship with it influences what the environment means.
Varela and his colleagues (1991) describe this process as the bringing forth of a world through embodied action. The organism and its environment are not understood as completely separate entities. Instead, they continuously influence one another. Through movement, perception, and interaction, individuals develop meaningful relationships with the world around them.
This perspective also challenges the idea that perception is simply an accurate internal representation of an objective external reality. Human beings experience the world through their particular biological and sensory capacities. For instance, the experience of temperature, sound, pain, balance, and physical space depends on the sensory systems and bodily conditions through which these experiences are interpreted.
The enactive approach does not mean that individuals invent reality or that the external environment does not exist. Rather, it emphasizes that the world as experienced is shaped through the ongoing relationship between the organism and its surroundings (Varela et al., 1991).
Autopoiesis: The Self-Organizing Nature of Living Systems
The foundations of Varela's work on embodiment are closely connected to his research with biologist Humberto Maturana on autopoiesis. The term refers to the capacity of living systems to continually produce and maintain themselves through interconnected biological processes (Maturana & Varela, 1980).
A living organism is not a static structure. It is a dynamic system that must continuously regulate and renew itself. Cells produce the components necessary for their functioning, tissues maintain their organization, and physiological systems interact to sustain the organism. These processes demonstrate that life depends on ongoing patterns of self-organization.
Autopoiesis provides an important foundation for understanding the relationship between biological life and cognition. Varela's work suggested that living organisms are not simply passive systems responding to external stimuli. They actively regulate their relationship with the environment in ways that support their continued existence.
For example, when the body becomes overheated, physiological processes help regulate temperature through mechanisms such as sweating and changes in blood flow. When an individual becomes dehydrated, bodily signals contribute to the experience of thirst and motivate behaviors that help restore fluid balance. These responses demonstrate how biological organization influences what becomes meaningful to an organism.
Thompson (2007) extended these ideas by exploring the relationship between biological self-organization, consciousness, and lived experience. In Mind in Life: Biology, Phenomenology, and the Sciences of Mind, he develops an account of the continuity between life and mind. From this perspective, cognition is deeply connected to the activities through which living organisms maintain themselves and engage with their environments.
This does not mean that every biological process involves conscious thought. Rather, it suggests that the foundations of cognition are rooted in the organization and adaptive activity of living systems. Human consciousness develops within this broader biological context.
Sense-Making: How Experience Becomes Meaningful
An important concept in enactive cognitive science is sense-making. Sense-making describes how living organisms establish meaningful relationships with their environments based on their biological needs, capacities, and ongoing experiences (Thompson & Stapleton, 2009).
The environment does not have the same meaning for every organism. A particular environmental condition may be beneficial, harmful, or irrelevant depending on the needs and circumstances of the organism encountering it.
For example, water has particular significance for a person experiencing dehydration. A loud sound may be interpreted as a warning when someone feels unsafe, while the same sound may be perceived as ordinary background noise in another context. These experiences illustrate how perception is connected to the organism's ongoing efforts to regulate itself and respond to its surroundings.
In human beings, sense-making extends beyond immediate biological needs. Personal history, emotional experiences, cultural background, social relationships, and learned expectations influence how individuals interpret events.
Consider two people receiving the same constructive feedback from an instructor. One person may interpret the feedback as encouragement and an opportunity to improve. Another may experience it as criticism or rejection. Their interpretations are influenced by previous experiences, expectations, emotional responses, and their sense of safety in the learning environment.
From an enactive perspective, these differences are not simply differences in thinking. They reflect the ways individuals bring their histories, bodily states, and relationships into present experience.
Sense-making is particularly relevant to health because individuals do not experience their environments as neutral collections of physical conditions. They experience them through relationships involving safety, belonging, stress, opportunity, and personal meaning.
The Role of Lived Experience and Phenomenology
Varela and Thompson also emphasized the importance of phenomenology, the philosophical study of lived experience and how the world appears from a first-person perspective. While neuroscience and biology investigate the brain and body through observable processes, phenomenology examines what it is like to experience being a living person.
For example, neuroscience can investigate the physiological processes associated with anxiety, including changes in nervous system activity, heart rate, and stress-related responses. Phenomenology asks how anxiety is actually experienced: What does it feel like in the body? How does it influence a person's perception of time, relationships, and surroundings? How does the experience change the way a person understands themselves?
Varela argued that scientific investigations of consciousness should take subjective experience seriously rather than treating it as an irrelevant byproduct of brain activity. He developed neurophenomenology, an approach that seeks to establish productive connections between first-person descriptions of experience and third-person scientific investigations of the brain and body (Varela, 1996).
This approach does not suggest that personal accounts should replace scientific measurement. Instead, it proposes that carefully examined descriptions of experience can contribute to scientific investigations of consciousness. Researchers can examine how reported experiences relate to patterns of brain activity, physiological responses, and behavior.
For example, a study of meditation might examine participants' descriptions of attention, bodily awareness, and emotional experience alongside physiological or neurological measurements. This allows researchers to investigate both what is happening within the body and how those processes are experienced by the individual.
Thompson (2007) further develops this integration of biology and phenomenology by arguing that the study of consciousness requires attention to both the living organism and its lived experience.
[Figure Placeholder 2: First-Person and Third-Person Perspectives. Insert a diagram showing how subjective experience, behavioral observation, physiological measurement, and neurological investigation can contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of human experience.]
Embodiment, Emotion, and the Mind-Body Connection
The enactive approach provides a useful framework for understanding the relationship between bodily processes and emotional experience. Emotions are not simply mental events occurring inside the brain. They involve coordinated changes in the nervous system, cardiovascular system, respiratory system, muscular activity, hormonal regulation, and other physiological processes.
From an embodied perspective, emotional experiences emerge through interactions among these systems and the situations in which individuals find themselves. The experience of fear, for example, may involve changes in breathing, heart rate, muscle tension, attention, and bodily awareness. These changes also influence how individuals interpret their surroundings and decide how to respond.
Thompson and Stapleton (2009) explain that cognition and emotion are deeply interconnected within the enactive approach. An organism's relationship with its environment is not emotionally neutral. Experiences acquire significance because they relate to the organism's needs, concerns, and possibilities for action.
This perspective challenges the traditional separation between thinking and feeling. Rather than viewing emotion as something that interferes with rational thought, embodied cognitive science recognizes that emotions participate in perception, attention, decision-making, and the interpretation of experience.
For health education, this relationship is particularly important. Chronic stress, social isolation, environmental uncertainty, and experiences of safety or belonging can influence both physiological functioning and emotional well-being. Understanding these connections requires looking beyond isolated mental or physical symptoms and examining the broader conditions in which people live.
The Body as an Active Participant in Experience
A central contribution of Varela and Thompson is the recognition that the body actively participates in cognition. The body provides the sensory and movement-related capacities through which individuals engage with their surroundings. These capacities influence what people notice, how they respond, and what they are able to experience.
For example, physical movement changes how individuals interact with their environments. Walking, dancing, practicing yoga, or participating in sports involves continuous coordination between perception, movement, attention, and bodily feedback. Individuals adjust their actions based on sensory information and changing environmental conditions.
In yoga, this relationship can be observed through the practice of balancing postures. Maintaining a balance requires coordination among visual information, vestibular input, proprioception, muscular activity, and attention. The practitioner continuously makes small adjustments in response to bodily sensations and environmental conditions.
From an enactive perspective, this is more than a physical exercise. It is an example of cognition emerging through embodied action. The individual learns through doing, sensing, adjusting, and responding.
[Figure Placeholder 3: Embodied Cognition in Movement. Insert an illustration of a person practicing a balancing yoga posture. Identify the brain, vestibular system, proprioception, muscular activity, breathing, and environmental feedback as interconnected contributors to balance and awareness.]
This understanding also has implications for health-promoting activities. Practices that encourage movement, bodily awareness, and attention to present experience may provide opportunities for individuals to develop a more conscious relationship with their physical and emotional states. However, the philosophical framework of enaction should be distinguished from empirical claims about the effectiveness of any particular health intervention. Specific health outcomes require supporting research.
Mindfulness, Awareness, and First-Person Experience
Varela and his colleagues (2017) incorporated insights from Buddhist philosophy and contemplative practices into their examination of cognition and human experience. They argued that understanding the mind requires more than observing behavior or measuring brain activity. It also requires developing ways to investigate experience from the perspective of the person having that experience.
Mindfulness provides one example of how first-person awareness can become part of this investigation. Mindfulness involves attending to present-moment experience, including thoughts, emotions, and bodily sensations, with an attitude of openness and reduced automatic judgment.
From an embodied perspective, mindfulness can help individuals become more attentive to the relationship between bodily sensations and emotional experiences. For example, someone experiencing anxiety might begin to recognize that certain situations are associated with shallow breathing, muscle tension, or changes in heart rate. Developing awareness of these experiences may help the individual recognize patterns in how they respond to stress.
The significance of mindfulness within Varela's work extends beyond stress reduction. It also offers a methodological opportunity to investigate consciousness and experience more carefully. By developing greater awareness of subjective experience, individuals may be able to provide more detailed descriptions of their perceptions, emotions, and bodily states.
Varela's (1996) work on neurophenomenology proposed bringing these first-person observations into dialogue with scientific investigations of the brain and body. Rather than treating subjective experience as separate from scientific research, this approach recognizes it as an important dimension of understanding consciousness.
Applications to Health and Well-Being
The work of Varela and Thompson offers a broader framework for understanding health because it connects biological functioning with lived experience. Health is not simply the absence of disease or the proper functioning of individual organs. It also involves how individuals experience their bodies, navigate their environments, respond to challenges, and develop relationships with others.
Several applications follow from this perspective.
Stress and emotional regulation: Stress can be understood as an embodied experience involving physiological responses, emotional interpretation, and environmental conditions. Investigating stress therefore requires attention to both measurable biological responses and how individuals experience stressful situations.
Physical activity and body awareness: Movement provides continuous opportunities for interaction between sensory information, bodily regulation, and environmental feedback. Activities such as walking, yoga, and dance illustrate how physical action participates in perception and learning.
Social relationships and belonging: Human experience develops within social environments. Relationships influence how individuals interpret situations, experience safety, and understand themselves. The enactive approach provides a framework for examining how social interaction contributes to meaningful experience.
Environmental influences on health: The physical environment shapes opportunities for action and experience. Access to green spaces, safe walking areas, supportive learning environments, and opportunities for social participation can influence how individuals interact with their surroundings.
These applications reinforce an important idea: understanding health requires examining the dynamic relationship among the individual, the body, and the environment. This approach complements biological and psychological models by emphasizing the lived experience of being a human organism.
Hypothetical Case Study: Experiencing Stress Through the Body
Consider a college student who begins experiencing anxiety when preparing for examinations. The student notices increased muscle tension, shallow breathing, difficulty concentrating, and a racing heartbeat. Initially, the student interprets these sensations as evidence of being unprepared or incapable of succeeding.
Using an embodied and enactive perspective, the student's experience can be examined through several interconnected dimensions.
First, the student's physical responses are part of the experience of stress. Changes in breathing, muscle tension, and heart rate are not separate from the student's emotional state. They contribute to how the student experiences the examination situation.
Second, the student's interpretation of these sensations influences how the environment is perceived. An examination may come to represent a threat rather than an opportunity to demonstrate learning. Previous experiences, expectations, and beliefs contribute to this interpretation.
Third, the student's environment influences the experience. A noisy study area, lack of social support, limited preparation time, or uncertainty about academic expectations may contribute to the student's sense of stress.
Finally, the student begins incorporating brief walking breaks, mindful breathing, and a more supportive study environment into their routine. These activities provide opportunities to engage differently with bodily sensations and the surrounding environment.
From an enactive perspective, the student's experience is not simply a problem located in the brain or a physical response occurring in the body. It emerges through the ongoing relationship among biological processes, emotional interpretation, personal history, behavior, and environmental conditions.
This example illustrates why health education benefits from examining the whole person rather than approaching physical and psychological experiences as unrelated concerns.
Limitations and Considerations
Although the enactive approach provides an influential framework for understanding human experience, several distinctions are important.
First, the theory is primarily a philosophical and scientific framework for understanding cognition, life, and consciousness. It should not be interpreted as proof that every aspect of consciousness has been explained through bodily processes.
Second, the concept of embodiment does not mean that the brain is unimportant. Rather, it emphasizes that brain activity must be understood within the broader organization of the living body and its interactions with the environment.
Third, subjective experience and objective physiological measurement provide different but potentially complementary forms of information. A person's description of anxiety, for example, cannot automatically establish the physiological mechanisms involved. Similarly, measuring heart rate alone does not fully explain what anxiety feels like to that individual.
Finally, health outcomes are influenced by multiple biological, psychological, social, and environmental factors. The enactive approach offers a way to understand their interrelationships, but specific interventions and health claims must still be evaluated through appropriate empirical research.
Reflection: Connecting Embodiment and Experience
Consider how your own bodily experiences influence the way you perceive and interact with the world.
1. Think of a situation in which your physical state influenced your emotional experience. How did changes in your body affect the way you interpreted your surroundings?
2. How might Varela and Thompson's enactive approach change the way we understand the relationship between the brain, body, and environment? How does this perspective differ from viewing cognition as something that occurs exclusively in the brain?
3. Consider how practices such as yoga, walking, meditation, or dance involve interactions between perception, movement, and awareness. How might these activities illustrate embodied cognition?
4. How could understanding embodiment and lived experience change the way public health professionals approach stress, mental health, and community well-being?
References
Maturana, H. R., & Varela, F. J. (1980). Autopoiesis and cognition: The realization of the living. D. Reidel Publishing Company. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-009-8947-4
Thompson, E. (2007). Mind in life: Biology, phenomenology, and the sciences of mind. Harvard University Press.
Thompson, E., & Stapleton, M. (2009). Making sense of sense-making: Reflections on enactive and extended mind theories. Topoi, 28, 23–30. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11245-008-9043-2
Varela, F. J. (1996). Neurophenomenology: A methodological remedy for the hard problem. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 3(4), 330–349.
Varela, F. J., Thompson, E., & Rosch, E. (2017). The embodied mind: Cognitive science and human experience (Revised ed.). The MIT Press. (Original work published 1991). https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/9780262529365.001.0001
8.3: Embodiment and Experience is shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by LibreTexts.
The book could not be loaded just now.