1.2: How do we learn about Neuroscience?

Open Neuroscience Initiative · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    1.2: How do we learn about Neuroscience?

    Generally speaking, there are three main research designs that have been used - and will likely continue to be used - to learn about the brain.

    Experimental design

    The gold standard in science is the use of experimental design. In an experiment, the scientist uses a stepwise process of developing a research question and hypothesis, then answering that question by performing tests. The main goal of an experiment is to establish a causal relationship between one factor that is being changed, the independent variable, and the factor that is influenced, the dependent variable. A well-designed experiment has variables that are carefully controlled, which minimizes the influence of extraneous variables, often called confounding variables. The influence of confounding variables can be eliminated by comparing the experimental group with a control group, a group that is as similar as possible in every way except for the manipulation of the independent variable. Importantly, subjects or patients are generally assigned to the experimental or control group at random.

    Illustration
    Figure 1.4 The scientific method is a circular, stepwise process used to establish causality between variables.

    For example, consider the research question: “Does studying more increase performance on exams?” Here, the independent variable is the number of hours studied, while the dependent variable is the grade on the exam. A potential confounding variable could be the number of hours slept before the exam, since poor sleep causes poor memory recall performance, and students may choose to study instead of sleep. To eliminate this confounding variable, it would be good to only compare grades for the students who slept for roughly the same amount of time. A control group in this experiment would be a group of students who are given the test without the opportunity to study. Ideally, these students will be as similar to the experimental group as possible: roughly the same age, gender distribution, educational history, and so on.

    Illustration
    Figure 1.5 A good experiment establishes causality between an independent variable and a dependent variable by eliminating the influence of confounding variables.

    The strength of a well-designed experiment is that it establishes causality: a change in the independent variable causes a change in the dependent variable. Because of this, assuming that the sample population is representative (the distribution of the characteristics in the sample is proportionally similar to the distribution in the total population,) experiments allow us to extrapolate findings to a larger population.

    Patients who participate in an experiment are often placed into an artificial environment or unnatural circumstances, which can affect their performance. For example, imagine you were participating in the “studying / test score experiment.” Having the added pressure of knowing you were in a study could cause you to perform worse. Alternatively, knowing that you are in the experimental group might cause you to focus more intently during your study time, which could increase the group’s average. To ameliorate this unintended effect, it’s important for participants in the experimental group and the control group to be subjected to the exact same circumstances.

    Observational study

    A second way to gain scientific information is through an observational study, one type of which is a quasiexperimental design. These studies do not benefit from separation of patients into groups randomly, and therefore may have several uncontrolled variables. Quasiexperimental studies are usually done when conducting an experimental study that may be impractical or otherwise unethical.

    An example of this type of study might aim to answer the question “Do people with traumatic brain injury have worse hand-eye coordination?” Performing an experiment with this question would be wildly unethical, since you cannot intentionally give your patients head injuries (It would also be challenging to find people willing to get hit on the head for science!). Instead of conducting this unethical experiment, you could answer this question with a quasiexperimental study. In the study, there would be two different populations of patients, an experimental group containing people who have already been diagnosed with head injury, and a control group that is demographically similar, but without a diagnosis of head injury. You could then ask both groups to perform a hand-eye coordination task and see if there are differences in their performance.

    Illustration
    Figure 1.6 The Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) was a large-scale quasi-experimental CDC study examining 17,000 people, linking childhood trauma with premature death.

    The weakness here is that there is no true randomness in the groups, thus the influence of confounding variables may affect our interpretation of the data. If the head injury group performed worse on the hand-eye coordination task, you would be able to demonstrate correlation, but not causation, which may present as a “chicken or the egg” problem. Perhaps the head injury group already had poor hand-eye coordination, which led to a car / workplace / sports accident, resulting in their head injury. In this example, we cannot conclude whether the brain injury directly causes a worsening of hand-eye coordination.

    Case Study

    A third strategy is the case study, a highly detailed description of a single patient and their condition. A case study documents the details regarding a specific deficit or enhancement, and is an opportunity to examine individuals with very rare conditions, which are useful for informing about the functions of different brain structures. Examining millions of healthy people may not give us the same insight as studying just one person with a specific injury or disorder. For example, case studies have been instrumental in teaching us about the brain structures involved with memory (Patient HM; chapter 13), language (Patient Tan; chapter 14), and fear processing (Patient SM; chapter 15).

    Illustration
    Figure 1.7 A study of a single individual with special circumstances, such as Phineas Gage (left) and his brain damage (right), is called a case study.

    Perhaps the most famous case study in all of neuroscience is the 1848 story of the railroad worker Phineas Gage. An unfortunate workplace accident left him with significant brain damage, largely to his frontal lobe. The subsequent changes in his personality taught us that one of the functions of this area of the brain is regulating our inhibitions (chapter 2).

    Like a quasi-experimental study, case studies only show correlation, not causation. It is difficult to generalize the findings from a case study to the population at large. Usually, case studies are descriptions of nearly-one-of-a-kind individuals: A man with memory deficits in response to his brain being punctured by a toy fencing sword, a woman who had never experienced fear in her life, or a man who became overwhelmingly light-hearted and joyful after recovering from being shot in the head.

    Case studies can be helpful for the development of hypotheses that can later be tested experimentally. For example, consider Patient HM, the man who had his left and right hippocampus surgically removed and couldn’t create certain types of memory. A research question based on this case study might be “Is the hippocampus needed for the creation of navigational memory?” Then, an experimental study could be performed in rodents, where we surgically remove the hippocampus (experimental group) or a different part of the brain (control group) and see how well the rodents perform on a memory task.


    This page titled 1.2: How do we learn about Neuroscience? was last modified on Wed, 08 Jul 2026 03:46:41 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Austin Lim via source content that was edited to the style and standards of the LibreTexts platform.