Opening the book…
Ex. A: Read this article about the ways in which graphs can distort information or mislead.
Numbers Don’t Lie. Or Do They?
Well-designed graphs help readers understand complex information. However, poorly designed graphs can distort information and mislead readers. Even worse, sometimes graphs are intentionally manipulated to persuade people. Here are some common issues to be aware of.
Vague or missing information
Context is needed in order to accurately interpret a graph. For example, suppose a graph shows that crime decreased by 20% during one year. At first glance, this seems like excellent news. However, several important questions remain unanswered. For example, what years are being compared? Was crime unusually high before the decline? Which types of crime were measured? Did the population increase during the same period?
Similarly, if the labels on a graph are vague, readers may draw incorrect conclusions. For example, imagine a graph labeled "Average Salary." Does it represent all workers? Full-time workers only? One company? One country? Before or after taxes?
A Non-Zero Baseline
One of the most common ways to distort data is by truncating (shortening) the vertical axis. Instead of beginning at zero, the graph starts at a much higher number. This technique is called using a non-zero baseline. This technique does not change the data, but it changes how people perceive the difference. It can make a small change look dramatic. Look at these two examples which both present the same data. Notice how different the information looks in the graph on the right where the Y-axis starts at 0.
Inconsistent Scales
A graph should use a consistent measuring system (scale) with equal intervals or spacing. When the intervals are inconsistent, the data can be distorted. For example, one section of the horizontal axis might represent one year while another section represents five years. This can hide trends in the data. In the example below, the graph on the right reveals a significant fluctuation in Sue’s tomato harvest when all of the years are included on the X-axis.
Misleading Pie Charts
Pie charts should show how a whole is divided into parts. Therefore all the slices of the pie should add up to 100%.
Source Reliability
When you read a graph, look for the source of the data. Reliable sources usually explain where the data came from and when and how it was collected. Government agencies, universities, and established research organizations often provide detailed information that allow other researchers to verify the results. If a graph appears on social media without a source, or if important information is missing, readers should be cautious.
Becoming a Critical Reader
Graphs are valuable tools because they can quickly reveal important patterns. However, graphs are not always reliable simply because they contain numbers. Whether the distortion is intentional or unintentional, readers should always examine the scale, the labels, the completeness of the information, and the original source. By asking thoughtful questions instead of accepting every graph at face value, you can become a more informed reader and a better decision-maker.
Ex. B: Discuss these questions.
- Based on the article, think of at least three questions readers should ask before trusting a graph.
- What is a non-zero baseline, and how can it distort readers’ perception of the information?
- Why is it important for the intervals on a graph's axis to be consistent?
- Explain why a graph showing crime decreasing by 20% does not provide enough information by itself.
- The article says that some misleading graphs are intentional while others are unintentional. Explain the difference between these two situations. Give one possible example of each.
- Imagine you see a graph on social media showing that housing prices have increased dramatically over the past year. Based on the article, what information would you look for before deciding whether the graph is trustworthy?
- Why do you think people are often persuaded by graphs more easily than by tables of numbers?
- Do you think companies, politicians, or news organizations sometimes intentionally manipulate graphs? Why or why not? Can you think of examples?
This page titled 4.9: Reading Skills- Evaluating Graphs was last modified on Fri, 13 Nov 2026 23:09:26 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Luciana Diniz, Jennifer Snyder, Sarah Bailie and Sarah Barrett.
The book could not be loaded just now.