Opening the book…
Linking Sound and Image
We have established that most silent films were shown with some kind of musical accompaniment. Even today, the vast majority of films are made with at least some music. Before the technology existed to encode a musical track onto the actual film, there were attempts to sync up sound and visuals. Thomas Edison's Kinetophone was an early experiment in linking up sound and picture, but it was designed for the single viewer. The next Edison system took things a step further. In 1926, Edison's Vitaphone system (remember that his projector was called the Vitascope) paired up sound recorded on a phonograph record with projected visual images. Each reel was designed to be the length of one side of a record.
The following are two videos made in 1926 to demonstrate the Vitaphone system in action. They star Edward B. Craft, Vice President of Bell Laboratories, who is clearly the most awkward man on the planet. The first video shows the recording process, and the second one shows how the system would be used in a moviehouse:
Part 1:
And here's Part #2:
Let's pause for a second to talk about Edison the ruthless businessman. The following is from Roger Hickman's book Reel Music:
"Unhappy that new faces were entering the motion picture arena, Edison attempted to block others from working in the field. In 1902 a Supreme Court decision concluded that since Edison did not invent motion pictures, he could not own a patent on the process. Angered by the decision, Edison turned his attention to controlling the marketplace. In 1909 he consolidated Vitagraph, Biograph, Pathé, Méliès, and other companies into the Motion Picture Patents Company. The key to this trust was George Eastman, who was bullied into a restrictive contract that prevented him from selling his film to anyone who did not cooperate with Edison's company....Edison assumed dictatorial powers in the field. He limited films to no more than two reels, and he did not allow the names of actors to appear on the credits, in order to keep them from demanding more money. Some filmmakers were forced to sign contracts to work for Edison. Others, threatened with bodily harm, fled west, eventually making a new home in Hollywood in order to avoid Edison's gangsters. Finally William Fox decided to fight Edison, and in 1917 an antitrust action dissolved Edison's company." (Hickman 64)
Anyway, recording technology was still very much in its infancy, and in order to record speech one had to stand near the microphone. It did not lend itself to naturalistic acting performances. When the Vitaphone system premiered in 1926, it showed short films that were synced up to the recordings (basically music videos). The big feature performance of the Vitaphone premiere was essentially a silent film, Don Juan. Its musical accompaniment was synced to it, but it still used intertitles--the frames of film with words written on them. Take a look:
If you want to know a bit more about the Vitaphone system, I highly recommend reading the Wikipedia page on the topic. If you want to read a modern critic's opinion of this film, check out this excellent review from 2013.
What was notable about the music for Don Juan was the score which was written and assembled by William Axt and played by the New York Philharmonic. Between 1921 and 1943 Axt composed more than two hundred film scores. Axt's score for Don Juan consisted of original themes and other musical ideas derived from pre-existent sources. The score also utilized leitmotifs, which we talkwed about in the previous module. In case you forgot, leitmotifs are short musical ideas that can represent characters, objects, feelings, and other ideas in a film. The use of leitmotifs comes from nineteenth-century opera, specifically the operas of German composer, Richard Wagner.
The next giant step came with 1927's The Jazz Singer, starring Al Jolson. This was also a Vitaphone production. Most of it was a silent film like Don Juan, but the narrative concerned a vaudeville singer, so scenes of Jolson singing were synced up using the discs. Here is the scene with the fateful first words ever spoken in a sound film: "Wait a minute! Wait a minute! You ain't heard nothing yet!":
Jolson also did some singing in the minstrel tradition in this film, which meant that he wore blackface. Some practices that were considered acceptable by some audiences are just abhorrent now. When we study history, we can acknowledge these things and contextualize them, without condoning them.
8.1: Early Experiments with Sound and Image is shared under a CC BY-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by LibreTexts.
The book could not be loaded just now.