Opening the book…
This Workbook includes the LGAS rubric, the LGAS annotations, an explanation of implementing the peer review process with the rubric and annotations, and suggestions for training librarians and library staff to use the rubric and annotations for the peer review process.
The LGAS Rubric
The LGAS rubric includes 32 assessment standards following the best practices vetted by SUNY-OSCQR for course development and additional standards addressed from the literature to improve the pedagogical value of library guides. Standards 1-9 cover the library guide’s general overview and information. Standard 10 focuses on the guide’s technology and tools. Standards 11-20 cover the library guide’s design and layout. Standards 21-30 include best practices for the guide’s content and activities. Standards 31-32 cover assessment and feedback. The LGAS rubric is a pedagogical resource for building library guides. It can be used as a professional activity or during the peer-review process, with the annotations found in this workbook included. Reviewers will have space to mark each standard as “Met” or “Not Met” as well as to provide notes/feedback to the author.

The Peer Review Process
It is suggested that a team of 2 librarians/library staff/students/administrators work together to provide feedback to the library guide author regarding the 32 standards. First, each peer reviewer should scrutinize each standard individually. Next, both peer reviewers will meet and discuss their findings and compare feedback for the library guide author. The peer review process is based on camaraderie. Peer reviewers are tasked to look for evidence of each standard in the guide, point to this evidence, and make suggestions for improvement in the “Notes” field when applicable. They may use the copy of the rubric to mark each standard as “Met” or “Not Met” depending on the evidence.
A standard can be marked as “Met” after two reviewers mark the standard as being “Met.” Should the peer reviewers disagree, they may invite the peer review coordinator to mediate and help interpret the standards. An author will receive feedback regarding a “Not Met’ standard to be worked on when the review team does not provide evidence of a 2/2 vote to mark the standard as being “Met.” You may incorporate the peer review coordinator into the group or the library guide assessment process overall to streamline the iterative nature of the peer review process.
Peer-Review Training
Librarians wishing to implement the LGAS rubric (with annotations) should have the designated peer review coordinator host a general overview session of the standards and several hands-on workshops for reviewers to practice reviewing library guides using this workbook. It takes practice to provide friendly suggestions to a library guide author.
Next, you will learn more about the peer review coordinator's role. You will also review the LGAS rubric with annotations. The final section of this workbook will provide suggestions for training and workshops for libraries implementing the LGAS rubric with annotations.
Peer Review Coordinator
An appointed peer review coordinator will be a go-between for the peer review team and the library guide author. Additionally, they will participate in the collegial peer review process when the peer review team meets with the library guide author to provide feedback. The peer review coordinator will determine a system for recruiting, training, and selecting peer reviewers to review guides. They may consider whether they want to make an electronic form of the review standards or to have the team use paper and pencil. They will be responsible for keeping the peer review team committed to honoring deadlines and re-evaluating prior standards marked as “Not Met” after the author makes corrections. The peer review coordinator may be designated as the point person to share their “quality-checked” badge once the author passes the peer review process. A guide can be given a quality-checked badge after the team determines that the author met 85% of the standards at an 85% level or higher.
2: How to Use the LGAS Rubric is shared under a CC BY license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Sarah Moukhliss, University of North Florida & Trina McCowan Adams, Flagler College.
The book could not be loaded just now.