Opening the book…
If earlier modernist photography often asked viewers to admire the photograph as a beautifully resolved object, the 1960s and 1970s began asking a different question: what if the point of the photograph was not its purity, elegance, or formal perfection, but the idea it carried? That shift matters because formalism, in the classic art-historical sense, privileged form above all else—how a work looked, how it was organized, how its internal visual structure held together.¹ By the late 1960s, many artists and critics were no longer satisfied with that as the main story. They were living in a world shaped by war, protest, bureaucracy, media expansion, and political struggle. In that context, a photograph could not remain just a pristine object for detached viewing. It had become entangled with systems of information, persuasion, control, and critique.²
Conceptual art helped push that change into focus. As the Museum of Modern Art explains, Conceptual art fundamentally challenged traditional ideas about visual art by emphasizing ideas over objects.³ That did not mean artists stopped caring about appearance altogether. It meant appearance was no longer enough. A photograph might now function as a document, a record, a proposition, a fragment of evidence, or part of a larger linguistic or social system. The camera was still present, but its job description was changing. Instead of simply making singular images meant to stand alone as autonomous artworks, photographers and artists increasingly used photographs to track actions, organize information, test language, or expose the assumptions built into representation itself.⁴
This is where the idea of photographic “purity” starts to fall apart in a productive way. For a long time, photography had fought for legitimacy by proving it had its own formal strengths—its own visual language, its own internal discipline, its own distinctive way of seeing. That history mattered, and it does not suddenly disappear. But in the 1960s and 1970s, artists began treating photography less as a sealed medium and more as something flexible, portable, and usable. A photograph could sit next to text. It could appear in a grid, a book, an archive, an installation, a dossier, a newspaper, or an artist’s proposition. It could borrow the look of administration or reportage while quietly undermining both. In other words, photography moved away from the dream of medium purity and toward an expanded field of conceptual inquiry.⁵
That shift also changed how people understood photographic truth. A conceptual photograph did not need to claim, “this is the world exactly as it is.” Instead, it might ask how the world gets turned into information in the first place. The photograph could still serve as evidence, but evidence of what? A place? An event? A system? A social fiction? A gap between language and lived reality? This is one of the most important turns of the period: photographs were no longer trusted only because they looked factual. They became powerful because they could reveal the structures that made facts visible, legible, and believable.⁶
Martha Rosler, The Bowery in Two Inadequate Descriptive Systems, 1974–75.
Martha Rosler’s The Bowery in Two Inadequate Descriptive Systems is one of the clearest examples of this change. The work pairs photographs of Bowery storefronts with panels of words associated with drunkenness, but it deliberately refuses the old documentary promise of transparent social truth. Rosler does not give viewers the comforting feeling that they have “seen” poverty and therefore understood it. Instead, she exposes the inadequacy of both image and language. The photographs do not show the stereotyped bodies a sensational documentary might have centered, and the words do not solve the problem either. The result is deliberately frustrating—and that is exactly the point. Rosler turns documentary inside out. She shows that representation is never innocent and that neither photographs nor descriptive language can be taken as complete access to social reality.⁷
If Rosler reveals how documentary can fail, Cildo Meireles shows how conceptual practice could leave the gallery altogether and move directly into political circulation. His Insertions into Ideological Circuits: Banknote Project used stamped Brazilian banknotes as vehicles for critical messages, which were then returned to everyday exchange. MoMA identifies the work as a 1970 project made with rubber stamp impressions on Brazilian currency, and Meireles later described the broader series as a way of anonymously inserting political questions into existing circuits of distribution.⁸ In MoMA’s account, some stamped messages included “Quem Matou Herzog?” and “Yankees Go Home,” linking the work directly to Brazil’s military dictatorship and to larger geopolitical pressures.⁹ This is not a conventional photograph, and that is precisely why it is so useful here. It shows how photographic culture in this period was being absorbed into a larger conceptual logic of reproduction, repetition, circulation, and public address. The image was no longer just a picture on a wall. It was part of a system.
Cildo Meireles, Insertions into Ideological Circuits: Banknote Project, 1970.
Seen together, Rosler and Meireles help define what this section is really about. The move away from modernist purity was not simply a stylistic change. It was a change in what artists believed photography could do. Instead of treating the image as a self-contained aesthetic object, they used it as a tool for inquiry. It could question language, documentary authority, political systems, circulation networks, and the relationship between seeing and knowing. That is why conceptual inquiry matters so much to the history of photography in the 1960s and 1970s: it did not reject the photograph outright. It made the photograph think harder about itself.¹⁰
Footnotes
- “Formalism.” Tate, n.d., www.tate.org.uk/art/art-terms/f/formalism. Accessed 4 Mar. 2026. (Tate)
- Bajac, Quentin. Photography at MoMA. Vol. 2, The Museum of Modern Art, 2015, pp. 14–15. MoMA notes that 1970s exhibitions such as Information included conceptual works with a strong photographic presence and reflected a more diverse understanding of contemporary photography. (The Museum of Modern Art)
- Modern Art and Ideas 8: 1962–1974. The Museum of Modern Art, 2007, p. 4. The guide states that Conceptual art “fundamentally challenged traditional notions of visual art by emphasizing ideas over objects.”
- “This is the way your leverage lies: The Seth Siegelaub Papers as Institutional Critique.” The Museum of Modern Art Archives Exhibitions, n.d. The Museum describes Siegelaub’s projects and books as raising questions about the making, display, ownership, distribution, and sale of art in the late 1960s and early 1970s. (The Museum of Modern Art)
- Bajac, Quentin. Photography at MoMA. Vol. 2, The Museum of Modern Art, 2015, pp. 14–15. (The Museum of Modern Art)
- Rosler, Martha. The Bowery in Two Inadequate Descriptive Systems. 1974–75. The Museum of Modern Art, audio page. The work is a series of 45 gelatin silver prints of text and images on 24 backing boards. (The Museum of Modern Art)
- Rosler, Martha. The Bowery in Two Inadequate Descriptive Systems. 1974–75. The Museum of Modern Art, audio page. (The Museum of Modern Art)
- Meireles, Cildo. Insertions into Ideological Circuits: Banknote Project (Inserções em circuitos ideológicos: Projeto Cédula). 1970. The Museum of Modern Art. MoMA lists the medium as rubber stamp printed on a Brazilian banknote and notes the work was issued in an unlimited edition. (The Museum of Modern Art)
- Gilbert, Zanna, and Cildo Meireles. “‘Pop Art Is Poison.’ Cildo Meireles on Ideological Circuits.” post: notes on modern & contemporary art around the globe, The Museum of Modern Art, 13 Nov. 2013. (post)
- Gilbert, Zanna. “Conceptualism, Dematerialization, Arte no-objetual? Historicizing the ’60s and ’70s in Latin America.” post: notes on modern & contemporary art around the globe, The Museum of Modern Art, 11 July 2013. The essay distinguishes Latin American conceptualism’s often more direct engagement with sociopolitical systems from more institution-centered critiques in New York. (post)
This page titled 14.3: From Modernist Purity to Conceptual Inquiry was last modified on Wed, 05 Aug 2026 02:40:23 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by James William Moore.
The book could not be loaded just now.