Opening the book…
Emotions, their Defensive Mechanisms, and Impact
Looking at the landscape of projects and project/team management, we will focus on the eight primary emotions - anger, fear, sadness, disgust,surprise, anticipation (for project management, we will use a synonym, anxiety), trust, and joy. Also, to keep the discussions at a practical and experiential levels, we will stay away from the theoretical depths of emotions.
Plutchik’s reasoning for picking the primary emotions was that each triggered behavior with high survival value, such as the fight-or-flight response—a psychological defense mechanism. The complex, probabilistic sequence of events involved in the development of emotions, the resulting behavior, and the effect are captured in the following table.
|
Stimulus Event |
Inferred Cognition |
Feeling |
Behavior |
Effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Threat |
Danger |
Fear |
Running, or flying away |
Protection |
|
Obstacle |
Enemy |
Anger |
Biting, hitting |
Destruction |
|
Potential mate |
Possess |
Joy |
Courting, mating |
Reproduction |
|
Loss of valued person |
Isolation |
Sadness |
Crying for help |
Reintegration |
|
Group member |
Friend |
Trust, acceptance |
Grooming, sharing |
Affiliation |
|
Gruesome object |
Poison |
Disgust |
Pushing away |
Rejection |
|
Management’s eyes on the project |
Pressure |
Anxiety |
Critical and micromanaging |
Stress |
|
Sudden change |
What is it? |
Surprise |
Stopping, alerting |
Orientation |
The defense mechanisms, when not managed, can impact reasoning, decision-making, collaboration, and misinterpretation by both individual contributors and project managers. From the projects and project management points of view, we will focus on six emotions that trigger negative behaviors and outcomes. They are anger, fear, anxiety, sadness, surprise, and disgust. It will be more effective to review real-life workplace scenarios related to one of those six emotions, their behavior, and the impact the emotion created.
In a project, dealing with negative emotions is paramount to our project outcome and our own reputation. Negative emotions have the potential to trigger undesirable behaviors that could impact our progress. A common negative emotion and its potential impact are illustrated below using realistic sample scenarios. (CC BY 4.0; Ravi K Ravikumar).
Emotion: Fear
- Project Management Scenario
- Ben is the project manager working on a new product launch. The timeline between alpha test, beta test, and launch is very tight. Three days before the alpha (for internal testing) release, the team finds out that under certain realistic but not-so-common conditions, a key feature is failing. The team believes it can be fixed within a week. This is Ben's first opportunity for action.
- However, a few days later, the team finds out that they need at least two more weeks. With a cascade of tasks and a tight schedule, the beta release is pushed out, delaying the final rollout.
- Behavior
- Action #1: Ben, fearful of looking incompetent and believing that the feature can be fixed in days, decides not to inform the stakeholders—No Action.
- Action #2: Days after the identification of the problem, Ben informs the stakeholders of the delay.
- Impact
- Late escalation about the problem and redesign is not received well by management, which impacts Ben's reputation.
Emotion: Anxiety
- Project Management Scenario
- In the middle of a major software project, the engineering project manager learns that multiple executives were monitoring the project for its outcome. The visibility creates a feeling of anxiety for the PM.
- Behavior
- The anxiety creates the fear of failure, which in turn drives the PM to micromanage the team on deliverables.
- Impact
- The team feels distrusted and demotivated.
- As a result, the engagement and productivity drop.
Emotion: Anger
- Project Management Scenario
- During the project team meeting, a key contributor criticizes the PM's unrealistic deadlines.
- Behavior
- Feeling angry, the PM snaps back, blaming the team for incompetence.
- Impact
- The team withdraws from providing honest feedback.
- Morale and collaboration suffer.
Emotion: Surprise (Bad)
- Project Management Scenario
- A product manager (PM) was working with the engineering team and a key customer on a new product. The VP of engineering was also involved. Just weeks before the product rollout, the VP of marketing (the product manager's upper management) cancels the product without informing the PM. The VP of engineering was surprised and upset for having his team's time wasted by the PM. The VP of engineering lashed out at the PM only to find out that the PM had no idea that his project was cancelled.
- Behavior
- As a next step, the PM communicates the sudden cancellation to the team, inadvertently sharing some of his own frustration.
- Impact
- The team feels blindsided and feels that their time was wasted.
Emotion: Disgust
- Project Management Scenario
- A PM discovers that a senior engineer manipulated test results to meet a milestone in a key customer design project. The PM is disgusted by the unethical behavior.
- Behavior
- Disgust could drive the PM's behavior in at least two possible ways:
- Disengage with the senior engineer.
- Or, respond angrily to the senior engineer.
- Disgust could drive the PM's behavior in at least two possible ways:
- Impact
- Disengagement:
- Would have only allowed the issue to fester.
- The team's reputation would have been damaged with the customer.
- Angry response:
- Neither addresses the customer issue nor the unethical behavior.
- Disengagement:
In the next chapter, we will discuss the recognition and handling of emotions in greater detail both from a self-awareness and self-management points of view.
This page titled 3.1: Emotions and their Impact was last modified on Sat, 19 Sep 2026 01:06:28 GMT and is shared under a not declared license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Ravi Ravikumar.
The book could not be loaded just now.