10.8: Electronegativity and Polarity - Why Oil and Water Don’t Mix

CHEM 114: Introductory Chemistry · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    10.8: Electronegativity and Polarity - Why Oil and Water Don’t Mix

    Chapter 1
    1. Chapter 1: The Chemical World
    2. 1.1: The Scope of Chemistry
    3. 1.2: Chemicals Compose Ordinary Things
    4. 1.3: Hypothesis, Theories, and Laws
    5. 1.4: The Scientific Method: How Chemists Think
    6. 1.5: A Beginning Chemist: How to Succeed
     •  Chapter 2
    1. Chapter 2: Measurement and Problem Solving
    2. 2.1: Taking Measurements
    3. 2.2: Scientific Notation: Writing Large and Small Numbers
    4. 2.3: Significant Figures: Writing Numbers to Reflect Precision
    5. 2.4: Significant Figures in Calculations
    6. 2.5: The Basic Units of Measurement
    7. 2.6: Problem Solving and Unit Conversions
    8. 2.7: Solving Multistep Conversion Problems
    9. 2.8: Units Raised to a Power
    10. 2.9: Density
    11. 2.10: Numerical Problem-Solving Strategies and the Solution Map
    12. 2.E: Measurement and Problem Solving (Exercises)
     •  Chapter 3
    1. Chapter 3: Matter and Energy
    2. 3.1: In Your Room
    3. 3.2: What is Matter?
    4. 3.3: Classifying Matter According to Its State: Solid, Liquid, and Gas
    5. 3.4: Classifying Matter According to Its Composition
    6. 3.5: Differences in Matter: Physical and Chemical Properties
    7. 3.6: Changes in Matter: Physical and Chemical Changes
    8. 3.7: Conservation of Mass: There is No New Matter
    9. 3.8: Energy
    10. 3.9: Energy and Chemical and Physical Change
    11. 3.10: Temperature: Random Motion of Molecules and Atoms
    12. 3.11: Temperature Changes: Heat Capacity
    13. 3.12: Energy and Heat Capacity Calculations
    14. 3.E: Exercises
     •  Chapter 4
    1. Chapter 4: Atoms and Elements
    2. 4.1: Experiencing Atoms at Tiburon
    3. 4.2: Indivisible: The Atomic Theory
    4. 4.3: The Nuclear Atom
    5. 4.4: The Properties of Protons, Neutrons, and Electrons
    6. 4.5: Elements: Defined by Their Numbers of Protons
    7. 4.6: Looking for Patterns: The Periodic Law and the Periodic Table
    8. 4.7: Ions: Losing and Gaining Electrons
    9. 4.8: Isotopes: When the Number of Neutrons Varies
    10. 4.9: Atomic Mass: The Average Mass of an Element’s Atoms
      •  Chapter 5
    1. Chapter 5: Molecules and Compounds
    2. 5.1: Sugar and Salt
    3. 5.2: Compounds Display Constant Composition
    4. 5.3: Chemical Formulas: How to Represent Compounds
    5. 5.4: A Molecular View of Elements and Compounds
    6. 5.5: Writing Formulas for Ionic Compounds
    7. 5.6: Nomenclature: Naming Compounds
    8. 5.7: Naming Ionic Compounds
    9. 5.8: Naming Molecular Compounds
    10. 5.9: Naming Acids
    11. 5.10: Nomenclature Summary
    12. 5.11: Formula Mass: The Mass of a Molecule or Formula Unit
      •  Chapter 6
    1. Chapter 6: Chemical Composition
    2. 6.1: How Much Sodium?
    3. 6.2: Counting Nails by the Pound
    4. 6.3: Counting Atoms by the Gram
    5. 6.4: Counting Molecules by the Gram
    6. 6.5: Chemical Formulas as Conversion Factors
    7. 6.6: Mass Percent Composition of Compounds
    8. 6.7: Mass Percent Composition from a Chemical Formula
    9. 6.8: Calculating Empirical Formulas for Compounds
    10. 6.9: Calculating Molecular Formulas for Compounds
      •  Chapter 7
    1. Chapter 7: Chemical Reactions
    2. 7.1: Grade School Volcanoes, Automobiles, and Laundry Detergents
    3. 7.2: Evidence of a Chemical Reaction
    4. 7.3: The Chemical Equation
    5. 7.4: How to Write Balanced Chemical Equations
    6. 7.5: Aqueous Solutions and Solubility: Compounds Dissolved in Water
    7. 7.6: Precipitation Reactions: Reactions in Aqueous Solution That Form a Solid
    8. 7.7: Writing Chemical Equations for Reactions in Solution: Molecular, Complete Ionic, and Net Ionic Equations
    9. 7.8: Acid–Base and Gas Evolution Reactions
    10. 7.9: Oxidation–Reduction Reactions
    11. 7.10: Classifying Chemical Reactions
    12. 7.11: The Activity Series
     •  Chapter 8
    1. Chapter 8: Quantities in Chemical Reactions
    2. 8.1: Climate Change: Too Much Carbon Dioxide
    3. 8.2: Stoichiometry
    4. 8.3: Making Molecules: Mole-to-Mole Conversions
    5. 8.4: Making Molecules: Mass-to-Mass Conversions
    6. 8.5: Limiting Reactant, Theoretical Yield, and Percent Yield
    7. 8.6: Limiting Reactant, Theoretical Yield, and Percent Yield from Initial Masses of Reactants
    8. 8.7: Enthalpy: A Measure of the Heat Evolved or Absorbed in a Reaction
    Chapter 9
    1. Chapter 9: Electrons in Atoms and the Periodic Table
    2. 9.1: Blimps, Balloons, and Models of the Atom
    3. 9.2: Light: Electromagnetic Radiation
    4. 9.3: The Electromagnetic Spectrum
    5. 9.4: The Bohr Model: Atoms with Orbits
    6. 9.5: The Quantum-Mechanical Model: Atoms with Orbitals
    7. 9.6: Quantum-Mechanical Orbitals and Electron Configurations
    8. 9.7: Electron Configurations and the Periodic Table
    9. 9.8: The Explanatory Power of the Quantum-Mechanical Model
    10. 9.9: Periodic Trends: Atomic Size, Ionization Energy, and Metallic Character
     •  Chapter 10
    1. Chapter 10: Chemical Bonding
    2. 10.1: Bonding Models and AIDS Drugs
    3. 10.2: Representing Valence Electrons with Dots
    4. 10.3: Lewis Structures of Ionic Compounds: Electrons Transferred
    5. 10.4: Covalent Lewis Structures: Electrons Shared
    6. 10.5: Writing Lewis Structures for Covalent Compounds
    7. 10.6: Resonance: Equivalent Lewis Structures for the Same Molecule
    8. 10.7: Predicting the Shapes of Molecules
    9. 10.8: Electronegativity and Polarity: Why Oil and Water Don’t Mix
     •  Chapter 11
    1. Chapter 11: Gases
    2. 11.1: Extra-Long Straws
    3. 11.2: Kinetic Molecular Theory: A Model for Gases
    4. 11.3: Pressure: The Result of Constant Molecular Collisions
    5. 11.4: Boyle’s Law: Pressure and Volume
    6. 11.5: Charles’s Law: Volume and Temperature
    7. 11.6: Gay-Lussac's Law: Temperature and Pressure
    8. 11.7: The Combined Gas Law: Pressure, Volume, and Temperature
    9. 11.8: Avogadro’s Law: Volume and Moles
    10. 11.9: The Ideal Gas Law: Pressure, Volume, Temperature, and Moles
    11. 11.10: Mixtures of Gases: Why Deep-Sea Divers Breathe a Mixture of Helium and Oxygen
    12. 11.11: Gases in Chemical Reactions
     •  Chapter 12
    1. Chapter 12: Liquids, Solids, and Intermolecular Forces
    2. 12.1: Interactions between Molecules
    3. 12.2: Properties of Liquids and Solids
    4. 12.3: Intermolecular Forces in Action: Surface Tension and Viscosity
    5. 12.4: Evaporation and Condensation
    6. 12.5: Melting, Freezing, and Sublimation
    7. 12.6: Types of Intermolecular Forces: Dispersion, Dipole–Dipole, Hydrogen Bonding, and Ion-Dipole
    8. 12.7: Types of Crystalline Solids: Molecular, Ionic, and Atomic
    9. 12.8: Water: A Remarkable Molecule
     •  Chapter 13
    1. Chapter 13: Solutions
    2. 13.1: Prelude - Tragedy in Cameroon
    3. 13.2: Solutions: Homogeneous Mixtures
    4. 13.3: Solutions of Solids Dissolved in Water: How to Make Rock Candy
    5. 13.4: Solutions of Gases in Water: How Soda Pop Gets Its Fizz
    6. 13.5: Solution Concentration: Mass Percent
    7. 13.6: Solution Concentration: Molarity
    8. 13.7: Solution Dilution
    9. 13.8: Solution Stoichiometry
    10. 13.9: Freezing Point Depression and Boiling Point Elevation: Making Water Freeze Colder and Boil Hotter
    11. 13.10: Osmosis: Why Drinking Salt Water Causes Dehydration
      •  Chapter 14
    1. Chapter 14: Acids and Bases
    2. 14.1: Sour Patch Kids and International Spy Movies
    3. 14.2: Acids: Properties and Examples
    4. 14.3: Bases: Properties and Examples
    5. 14.4: Molecular Definitions of Acids and Bases
    6. 14.5: Reactions of Acids and Bases
    7. 14.6: Acid–Base Titration: A Way to Quantify the Amount of Acid or Base in a Solution
    8. 14.7: Strong and Weak Acids and Bases
    9. 14.8: Water: Acid and Base in One
    10. 14.9: The pH and pOH Scales: Ways to Express Acidity and Basicity
    11. 14.10: Buffers: Solutions That Resist pH Change
     

    Template:HideTOC

    Learning Objectives
    • Explain how polar compounds differ from nonpolar compounds.
    • Determine if a molecule is polar or nonpolar.
    • Given a pair of compounds, predict which would have a higher melting or boiling point.

    Bond Polarity

    The ability of an atom in a molecule to attract shared electrons is called electronegativity. When two atoms combine, the difference between their electronegativities is an indication of the type of bond that will form. If the difference between the electronegativities of the two atoms is small, neither atom can take the shared electrons completely away from the other atom, and the bond will be covalent. If the difference between the electronegativities is large, the more electronegative atom will take the bonding electrons completely away from the other atom (electron transfer will occur), and the bond will be ionic. This is why metals (low electronegativities) bonded with nonmetals (high electronegativities) typically produce ionic compounds.

    A bond may be so polar that an electron actually transfers from one atom to another, forming a true ionic bond. How do we judge the degree of polarity? Scientists have devised a scale called electronegativity, a scale for judging how much atoms of any element attract electrons. Electronegativity is a unitless number; the higher the number, the more an atom attracts electrons. A common scale for electronegativity is shown in Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\).

    Periodic table of elements displaying atomic numbers, symbols, and color-coded categories for different groups.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\): Electronegativities of the Elements. Electronegativities are used to determine the polarity of covalent bonds.

    The polarity of a covalent bond can be judged by determining the difference of the electronegativities of the two atoms involved in the covalent bond, as summarized in the following table:

    difference of the electronegativities of the two atoms involved in the covalent bond
    Electronegativity Difference Bond Type
    0–0.4 pure covalent
    0.5–2.0 polar covalent
    >2.0 likely ionic

    Nonpolar Covalent Bonds

    A bond in which the electronegativity difference is less than 1.9 is considered to be mostly covalent in character. However, at this point we need to distinguish between two general types of covalent bonds. A nonpolar covalent bond is a covalent bond in which the bonding electrons are shared equally between the two atoms. In a nonpolar covalent bond, the distribution of electrical charge is balanced between the two atoms.

    Diagram illustrating nonpolar covalent bonding between two chlorine (Cl) atoms, with electronegativity values and their difference shown.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{2}\): A nonpolar covalent bond is one in which the distribution of electron density between the two atoms is equal.

    The two chlorine atoms share the pair of electrons in the single covalent bond equally, and the electron density surrounding the \(\ce{Cl_2}\) molecule is symmetrical. Also note that molecules in which the electronegativity difference is very small (<0.5) are also considered nonpolar covalent. An example would be a bond between chlorine and bromine (\(\Delta\)EN \(=3.0 - 2.8 = 0.2\)).

    Polar Covalent Bonds

    A bond in which the electronegativity difference between the atoms is between 0.5 and 2.0 is called a polar covalent bond. A polar covalent bond is a covalent bond in which the atoms have an unequal attraction for electrons and so the sharing is unequal. In a polar covalent bond, sometimes simply called a polar bond, the distribution of electrons around the molecule is no longer symmetrical.

    Illustration of a molecule showing two colored spheres representing atoms, connected with a gradient background.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{3}\): In the polar covalent bond of \(\ce{HF}\), the electron density is unevenly distributed. There is a higher density (red) near the fluorine atom, and a lower density (blue) near the hydrogen atom.

    An easy way to illustrate the uneven electron distribution in a polar covalent bond is to use the Greek letter delta \(\left( \delta \right)\).

    Chemical structure of hydrogen fluoride (HF) showing dipole moments with δ+ and δ- symbols.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{4}\): Use of \(\delta\) to indicate partial charge.

    The atom with the greater electronegativity acquires a partial negative charge, while the atom with the lesser electronegativity acquires a partial positive charge. The delta symbol is used to indicate that the quantity of charge is less than one. A crossed arrow can also be used to indicate the direction of greater electron density.

    Chemical structure diagram of hydrogen fluoride (HF) with hydrogen and fluorine atoms indicated.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{5}\): Use of crossed arrow to indicate polarity.

    Electronegativity differences in bonding using Pauling scale. Differences in electronegativity classify bonds as covalent, polar covalent, or ionic.

    Example \(\PageIndex{1}\): Bond Polarity

    What is the polarity of each bond?

    1. C–H
    2. O–H
    Solution

    Using Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\), we can calculate the difference of the electronegativities of the atoms involved in the bond.

    1. For the C–H bond, the difference in the electronegativities is 2.5 − 2.1 = 0.4. Thus we predict that this bond will be nonpolar covalent.
    2. For the O–H bond, the difference in electronegativities is 3.5 − 2.1 = 1.4, so we predict that this bond will be polar covalent.
    Exercise \(\PageIndex{1}\)

    What is the polarity of each bond?

    1. Rb–F
    2. P–Cl
    Answer a

    likely ionic

    Answer b

    polar covalent

    Molecular Polarity

    To determine if a molecule is polar or nonpolar, it is generally useful to look at Lewis structures. Nonpolar compounds will be symmetric, meaning all of the sides around the central atom are identical—bonded to the same element with no unshared pairs of electrons. Polar molecules are asymmetric, either containing lone pairs of electrons on a central atom or having atoms with different electronegativities bonded. This works pretty well, as long as you can visualize the molecular geometry. That's the hard part. To know how the bonds are oriented in space, you have to have a strong grasp of Lewis structures and VSEPR theory. Assuming that you do, you can look at the structure of each one and decide if it is polar or not, whether or not you know the individual atom's electronegativity. This is because you know that all bonds between dissimilar elements are polar, and in these particular examples, it doesn't matter which direction the dipole moment vectors are pointing (out or in).

    A polar molecule is a molecule in which one end of the molecule is slightly positive, while the other end is slightly negative. A diatomic molecule that consists of a polar covalent bond, such as \(\ce{HF}\), is a polar molecule. The two electrically charged regions on either end of the molecule are called poles, similar to a magnet having a north and a south pole. A molecule with two poles is called a dipole (see figure below). Hydrogen fluoride is a dipole.

    A light beige oval shape with the Greek letter delta (δ) on either side.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{6}\): A dipole is any molecule with a positive end and a negative end, resulting from unequal distribution of electron density throughout the molecule.

    For molecules with more than two atoms, the molecular geometry must also be taken into account when determining if the molecule is polar or nonpolar. The figure below shows a comparison between carbon dioxide and water. Carbon dioxide \(\left( \ce{CO_2} \right)\) is a linear molecule. The oxygen atoms are more electronegative than the carbon atom, so there are two individual dipoles pointing outward from the \(\ce{C}\) atom to each \(\ce{O}\) atom. However, since the dipoles are of equal strength and are oriented this way, they cancel out and the overall molecular polarity of \(\ce{CO_2}\) is zero.

    Water is a bent molecule because of the two lone pairs on the central oxygen atom. The individual dipoles point from the \(\ce{H}\) atoms toward the \(\ce{O}\) atom. Because of the shape, the dipoles do not cancel each other out and the water molecule is polar. In the figure below, the net dipole is shown in blue and points upward.

    Illustration of molecular dipoles, showing a carbon atom with no overall dipole on the left and a water molecule with dipole direction on the right.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{7}\): The molecular geometry of a molecule affects its polarity. Each CO bond has a dipole moment, but they point in opposite directions so that the net CO2 molecule is nonpolar. In contrast, water is polar because the OH bond moments do not cancel out.

    Some other molecules are shown in the figure below. Notice that a tetrahedral molecule such as \(\ce{CH_4}\) is nonpolar. However, if one of the peripheral \(\ce{H}\) atoms is replaced with another atom that has a different electronegativity, the molecule becomes polar. A trigonal planar molecule \(\left( \ce{BF_3} \right)\) may be nonpolar if all three peripheral atoms are the same, but a trigonal pyramidal molecule \(\left( \ce{NH_3} \right)\) is polar.

    Diagram illustrating polar and nonpolar molecular structures with hydrogen (H), chlorine (Cl), and fluorine (F) atoms.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{8}\): Some examples of polar and nonpolar molecules based on molecular geometry.

    To summarize, to be polar, a molecule must:

    1. Contain at least one polar covalent bond.
    2. Have a molecular structure such that the sum of the vectors of each bond dipole moment do not cancel.
    Steps to Identify Polar Molecules
    1. Draw the Lewis structure.
    2. Figure out the geometry (using VSEPR theory).
    3. Visualize or draw the geometry.
    4. Find the net dipole moment (you don't have to actually do calculations if you can visualize it).
    5. If the net dipole moment is zero, it is non-polar. Otherwise, it is polar.

    Properties of Polar Molecules

    Polar molecules tend to align when placed in an electric field with the positive end of the molecule oriented toward the negative plate and the negative end toward the positive plate (Figure \(\PageIndex{14}\)). We can use an electrically charged object to attract polar molecules, but nonpolar molecules are not attracted. Also, polar solvents are better at dissolving polar substances, and nonpolar solvents are better at dissolving nonpolar substances.

    Illustration showing green spheres representing molecules, separated by barriers, demonstrating molecular arrangement in two scenarios.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{9}\): (a) Molecules are always randomly distributed in the liquid state in the absence of an electric field. (b) When an electric field is applied, polar molecules like HF will align to the dipoles with the field direction. (OpenStax CC-BY-SA);

    While molecules can be described as "polar covalent" or "ionic", it must be noted that this is often a relative term, with one molecule simply being more polar or less polar than another. However, the following properties are typical of such molecules. Polar molecules tend to:

    • have higher melting points than nonpolar molecules
    • have higher boiling points than nonpolar molecules
    • be more soluble in water (dissolve better) than nonpolar molecules
    • have lower vapor pressures than nonpolar molecules
    Example \(\PageIndex{2}\):

    Label each of the following as polar or nonpolar.

    1. Water, H2O: Chemical structure of water (H₂O) with oxygen atom bonded to two hydrogen atoms.
    2. Methanol, CH3OH: Chemical structure of methanol, showing one carbon atom bonded to three hydrogen atoms and one hydroxyl group (OH).
    3. Hydrogen Cyanide, HCN: Chemical structure depicting hydrogen (H), carbon (C), and nitrogen (N) atoms connected by bonds.
    4. Oxygen, O2: Chemical structure illustration showing two identical groups connected by a double bond.
    5. Propane, C3H8: Structural formula of butane, showing its four carbon atoms and associated hydrogen atoms.
    Solution
    1. Water is polar. Any molecule with lone pairs of electrons around the central atom is polar.
    2. Methanol is polar. This is not a symmetric molecule. The \(\ce{-OH}\) side is different from the other 3 \(\ce{-H}\) sides.
    3. Hydrogen cyanide is polar. The molecule is not symmetric. The nitrogen and hydrogen have different electronegativities, creating an uneven pull on the electrons.
    4. Oxygen is nonpolar. The molecule is symmetric. The two oxygen atoms pull on the electrons by exactly the same amount.
    5. Propane is nonpolar, because it is symmetric, with \(\ce{H}\) atoms bonded to every side around the central atoms and no unshared pairs of electrons.
    Exercise \(\PageIndex{2}\)

    Label each of the following as polar or nonpolar.

    1. \(\ce{SO3}\)
    2. \(\ce{NH3}\)
    Answer a
    nonpolar
    Answer b
    polar

    Contributions & Attributions


    10.8: Electronegativity and Polarity - Why Oil and Water Don’t Mix is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by LibreTexts.