11.12: Deciding between SN1, SN2, E1, and E2

CHEM 231: Organic Chemistry I Textbook · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    11.12: Deciding between SN1, SN2, E1, and E2

    SN1, SN2, E1, E1cB, E2—how can you keep it all straight and predict what will happen in any given case? Will substitution or elimination occur? Will the reaction be bimolecular or unimolecular? There are no rigid answers to these questions, but it’s possible to recognize some trends and make some generalizations.

    • Primary substrates: SN2 substitution occurs if a good nucleophile is used, E2 elimination occurs if a strong, sterically hindered base is used, and E1cB elimination occurs if the leaving group is two carbons away from a carbonyl group.
    • The one general exception to the rule that ethers don’t typically undergo SN2 reactions pertains to epoxides, the three-membered cyclic ethers that we saw in Section 8.7. Because of the angle strain in their three-membered ring, epoxides are much more reactive than other ethers. They react with aqueous acid to give 1,2-diols, as we saw in Section 8.7, and they react readily with many other nucleophiles as well. Propene oxide, for instance, reacts with HCl to give 1-chloro-2-propanol by an SN2 backside attack on the less hindered primary carbon atom.
      A reaction mechanism of propene oxide with hydrogen chloride produces a protonated epoxide intermediate, which reacts by S N 2 to form 1-chloro-2-propanol.
    • Secondary alkyl halides: SN2 substitution occurs if a weakly basic nucleophile is used in a polar aprotic solvent, E2 elimination predominates if a strong base is used, and E1cB elimination takes place if the leaving group is two carbons away from a carbonyl group. Secondary allylic and benzylic alkyl halides can also undergo SN1 and E1 reactions if a weakly basic nucleophile is used in a protic solvent.
    • Tertiary alkyl halides: E2 elimination occurs when a base is used, but SN1 substitution and E1 elimination occur together under neutral conditions, such as in pure ethanol or water. E1cB elimination takes place if the leaving group is two carbons away from a carbonyl group.
    Worked Example \(\PageIndex{1}\): Predicting the Product and Mechanism of Reactions

    Tell whether each of the following reactions is likely to be SN1, SN2, E1, E1cB, or E2, and predict the product of each:

    A reaction of chloropentane with sodium methoxide and methanol yields an unknown product, depicted by a question mark. A reaction of 1-bromoethylbenzene in the presence of formic acid and water yields an unknown product, depicted by a question mark.
    Strategy

    Look carefully in each reaction at the structure of the substrate, the leaving group, the nucleophile, and the solvent. Then decide from the preceding summary which kind of reaction is likely to be favored.

    Solution

    The E2 reaction of chloropentane with sodium methoxide and methanol to form cyclopentene.(a) A secondary, nonallylic substrate can undergo an SN2 reaction with a good nucleophile in a polar aprotic solvent but will undergo an E2 reaction on treatment with a strong base in a protic solvent. In this case, E2 reaction is likely to predominate.

     

    1-bromoethylbenzene reacts in the presence of formic acid and water. The two products come from S N 1 (formate replaces bromine) and E1 (product is styrene).

    (b) A secondary benzylic substrate can undergo an SN2 reaction on treatment with a nonbasic nucleophile in a polar aprotic solvent and will undergo an E2 reaction on treatment with a base. Under protic conditions, such as aqueous formic acid (HCO2H), an SN1 reaction is likely, along with some E1 reaction.

    Exercises 

    Exercises\(\PageIndex{1}\)

    1) For the following, please determine what kind of reaction is occurring and predict the product(s).

    a)Exampl 1 Question .svg       b)Example 2 Question .svg          c)Example 3 Question .svg

    Answer

    a) The substrate is a secondary halide, so the product is determined by the nature of the nucleophile used in the reaction. Cyanide (-CN) is a good nucleophile, which is a weak base. The fact that the nucleophile is a weak base means that an E2 reaction is not favored. Also, the fact that cyanide is a good nucleophile means that SN2 substitutions are favored over SN1. When a secondary halide is reacted with a good nucleophile, which is a weak base, the preferred reaction is SN2. After SN2 substitution, the product is a nitrile.

    Exampl 1 Answer .svg

    b) The substrate is a secondary halide so the product is determined by the nature of the nucleophile used in the reaction. Methoxide (-OCH3) is a strong base so it could prefer to remove a hydrogen from the substrate. This makes an E2 elimination the preferred reaction and an alkene the product.

    Example 2 Answer .svg

    c) The substrate is a secondary halide so the product is determined by the nature of the nucleophile used in the reaction. Methanol (HOCH3) is a weak nucleophile that is a weak base. Being a weak base means that methanol is not capable of actively removing a hydrogen to cause an E2 reaction. Also, because methanol is a weak nucleophile is not capable of attacking the substrate and causing an SN2 reaction. For the methanol nucleophile to react the substrate must first eject it leaving group to form the highly reactive carbocation intermediate. Formation of the carbocation is the rate-determining step for both the SN1 and E1 reactions, so they each form a separate product.

    Example 3 Answer .svg

    Exercise \(\PageIndex{2}\)

    Identify the function of the following reagents. The reagents will be a strong/weak nucleophile and/or a strong/weak base.

    a) Cl-    b) NaH.    c) t-BuO-     d) OH-     e) H2O     f) HS-     g) MeOH

    Answer
    a) Cl- ; strong nucleophile.    b) NaH ; strong base.   
    c) t-BuO- ; strong base.     d) OH- ; strong nucleophile ; strong base.   
    e) H2O ; weak nucleophile ; weak base.     f) HS- ; strong nucleophile.   
    g) MeOH ; weak nucleophile ; weak base.
    Exercise \(\PageIndex{3}\)

    Identify the dominant reaction mechanism (SN1, SN2, E1, or E2) and predict the major product for the following reactions.

    a) Rdo2XrKQ2hw6TcbSepKx6CM8c3Kr146NiL2gwWKhP3cidu3Si0YbR1i-wquDkoGYyLFx9W7HMqagkBLqILTYBhrwOl4OWHTMZbCYcmH8zNA3LVnuVpFSdwqw-Whzl2gGp9afjkDU   b)e-W8kFVYj5Fhx3nl9EmLcpkDEG_DX4taVcdt8kBlz69JL0mWyWI5GIAlF4ql0XZtDaw5pXb-wZqqI_Fd-7FjRaJAkgEkPr849g2oZBwqJ2xakrmtd5rImd2cjp0FoNGhNXU_L4_t    c)lPOjennqKsaCzlxzhGs8nqIkCXaYCQq765lWmKzb_f57SY7biVmDaQ8uRMsVLCJkp8ApTgJExY6njbGVteURG-nXg1072ExYmdif37aZwvaYpV-40uqYX-2E9xjuW6GWZmaDjIPj

    d)VtgFdpBO1CcfikJi39bPGidkxwd6f0TtwSsy5dK7wnaN_zESFoNbO57u0jiQY13_8So_7TnourpvVtQ1Uu_Y79EiNahmBCldebwu_piBBJia4paIRC1I4jEELolXi1PXhJzBifW5   e) Illustration

    Answer

    a) E2, SN1    b) SN2, E2    c) SN2     d) SN1, E1     e) E2, SN1

    Exercise \(\PageIndex{4}\)

    Identify all the products of the following reactions and specify the major product.

    a)Illustration   b)KlfOvoOna7_5A6I6kuMNiGaJ-o2on_Z7bX5sF0rbrpfQyvhtP4FqUfPZ-YI62ASiRuLEyDPRsKRuST0CjJ0_IDhafBD-eyfld340-CmIXZPq48Tb9eTo9ArPSnkvarI4GFVC0ifq    c)LOmc6XfFjGNgy9RrUcID6LMp53yNhKNn4mAMsosn-I4kEI8kRnYw-VipxXQYuxdCQmCW812hR5Yc2igS2MaoCFV0jqi9g5_D3tl1dVtLxWdg91MdzUx1eiKHUO5Lp2IbN_NKfHTe

    d)EOgI5PPDAmQt4ieBkeCPHA_kqbi4r-VGSSBEN5S1sGyHkO3FVXMHECnq-mPSourY-TvP3S0N8xb-CdfS5fq6cCtr_QrX-rXafHHFSQoEQPJW7n4HDBWDa1N9L08bDoKNt6zCKmdo   e) 3XmYuZpxO8gU8lU_0-ji68K3-v_v5cURUT1UUa3jFtTAFSBu6deCqJWrpEdq6bQuUT54nc7fvk1-BU7zH6PdUDMydnXLKB0kv56z7J_1EZWrIJ45UyWyk_-SiXMAzl1NMiTqeabj

    Answer

    a)Illustration b)2QKalqyamcJMJglDMQ5BLXgTcnfA4OEx540WBUqJCZKl2s3vi8Vhbw3xCYBfewisvCutqm-KuwYlptitSWUPkVEqD45X_QzfChfL6xXCgmxKPr6iGZ_IYFqjfhmtGdqgS28yenyu 

    c)8goeD5NH4HG95180mnLWhm6B_mxtG6q6CW_CovgQS3wc9am2tHSop3DjXY0-OWhJvItBJLyb8UkSFBb7BJhmbQA8sueL66Qe5ApYhiodvJrIHwPex5ze-onx5CqhNPBxjJ2Irf_y  d)It-ybsifOx9Cr4aL2DZs1q3szIBCBUwuddxPCcDu0sUYpsegcv3iOmC5KjAm7T-1kBSL9clsPSQa-RA-x9pt-H5_VuOuebpQ6RPQm4Gwlhh6NXgyGWeu2jX503E-NuvrLBIA9CQL 

    e)BrJ5jZ_x0cTuSw3x7GkNoGdHORKqg1xvSe3iXIsiVpLU4iI-5fYQTGZe8qgtEJwaldHaIkQFUjVzcna4HB5Hhpayz-iloF4AEw_e6jDYElRkruyIoQvQW4W962eb-VZL0s-BJrY7

    Exercise \(\PageIndex{5}\)

    Tell whether each of the following reactions is likely to be SN1, SN2, E1, E1cB, or E2:

    a.1-bromobutane reacts with sodium azide in T H F to form a 1-azidobutane.   

    b. 3-chloropentane reacts with K O H in ethanol to produce 2-pentene.

    c. 1-chloro-1-methylcyclohexane reacts with acetic acid. Product has acetate substituted for chlorine.        d. A tertiary alcohol reacts in the presence of sodium hydroxide and ethanol to form a product with a double bond.

    Answer
    1. SN2     b. E2     c. SN1      d. E1cB
    Exercise \(\PageIndex{6}\)
    The following reaction yields five different products. Give the mechanisms for how each is formed.
    Illustration
    Answer

    Illustration

     


    This page titled 11.12: Deciding between SN1, SN2, E1, and E2 was last modified on Mon, 20 Oct 2025 22:28:02 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Sol Parajon Puenzo (Cañada College) via source content that was edited to the style and standards of the LibreTexts platform.