Opening the book…
Candor and active dialogue with the client are just as necessary when the consultant’s proposal is not accepted as they are when you win the project. We have established that your agenda as a consultant and businessperson is to build mutually beneficial long-term relationships. Those relationships are much more significant than any individual project, and a “no” from a client organization at one point in time may lead to a “yes” at a later point. You can still present yourself as being a valuable advisor in the context of losing the deal—the key is to be authentic in your efforts. Being authentic, at any stage of a client relationship, is much more important than being smart or clever, and authenticity strengthens your credibility with the client (see Block, 1981, for an extended discussion of authenticity).
If you are interested in a long-term relationship with the client and have genuine concern for their needs, you will want to know why your proposal was turned down. Contact the client immediately after hearing their decision, and request a conversation (ideally in person) to find out the reason(s) behind it. Assuming this is a project you really wanted, and gave significant preparation and attention to winning, a formal, technical approach to this client conversation (such as the one below) is not authentic:
We appreciate your notification of the decision you’ve made about consultant support for the scenario planning project. I realize you had many choices in whom to work with, and I am sure that ABC Firm will serve your needs effectively. We certainly hope we can work with your organization in the future, and we wish you success with the project.
Why is this approach insufficient?
- It ends the conversation. There is little motivation for the client to call you again.
- It doesn’t show the client that you are genuinely concerned about their issues.
- You have created no opportunity to learn about their decision and why you were declined.
From a conversation like this, it will be hard to reinvigorate this client relationship going forward. By contrast, an authentic response allows you to put the relationship first and the project second:
We are disappointed that we won’t be working with you on this project. We have been enthusiastic about partnering with you, and felt that we had a great understanding of your needs and had proposed a powerful solution. Though I realize the decision is made, I would like to understand what was missing and what you preferred about the consultant you chose so that we can better match your needs the next time an opportunity arises. I’m quite eager for your feedback—can we meet over lunch to discuss it?
Why is this approach effective?
- It demonstrates a sincere interest in the client.
- It assumes there will be a long-term relationship and possible future work together.
- It opens the door for future meetings.
At the debriefing meeting with the client, your role stays the same: to listen well and to be responsive, and to show genuine concern for their needs. Demonstrate through your words and behavior that you are open to your client’s feedback about your work, even if it is difficult to hear—you are modeling the trust that you eventually hope this client will place in you. New consultants often assume that when they don’t win work, it must be due to a deficit in their technical skills. Often, this is not the case, and the decision may have very little to do with technical ability. Purchase decisions can be driven by multiple factors, including firm location, pre-existing internal relationships, or decisions handed down by leaders with very little involvement in the actual proposal review, among others. It is important not to personalize the feedback, but to use it as a helpful way to gain experience and information. In fact, it is valuable to ask, “What should we have asked you about, but didn’t?” (Beich, 2001). You may be surprised by the client’s willingness to share information with you. As the client shares feedback, read between the lines and listen for clues about what this organization values, and for possible other project opportunities that may exist. End the meeting by showing your appreciation for their feedback, and affirming your interest in partnering with them in the future.
After the meeting, continue to keep the client’s interests and concerns active in your mind. Stay on top of trends in their industry. Clip a magazine article or send a book that has relevant information for them. Alert the client to conferences and workshops on this topic area, and ideally, offer to attend the event with them. Check in periodically to see if their issues are getting adequately resolved. Clearly, you do not want to become a nuisance to the client, but you want to maintain sufficient rapport that they view you as a valued resource and confidante. The key is to demonstrate that your interest in them goes far beyond the scope of the project that you proposed. Loss of a single deal does not equal the end of the relationship.
We recently lost a project with a utility company where we had built a strong relationship based on delivering a very high-quality training evaluation. During the initial engagement, we spent considerable time teaching the client’s staff about evaluation and answering questions about how to use the information within the organization. When they requested an evaluation of a public outreach program about gas lines in residential areas, we happily wrote a detailed proposal, which was accepted. We were waiting for the initial payment before beginning the work when the director of training (the sponsor) called in a panic, having realized there were many legal and regulatory implications for the project. We immediately visited the client to discuss the project. In the first 5 minutes, the director shared with us that he had found several firms who specialized in this particular type of program (including legal support services). Realizing we were not the best firm for the job, we quickly shifted to helping the client think about how to select among the handful of specialists they had discovered. When we left the meeting, the client repeatedly thanked us for our help and asserted that they would be looking for the next opportunity to work together. While our initial intent with our visit was to “save” the deal, the fact is that when we walked into the meeting, we had lost the deal already. No amount of persuasiveness would have changed the client’s mind, and rightfully so. The client had already found a better solution, and our best option was to reinforce the relationship and find a way to add value in the meeting. We lost the project, but we kept the relationship and are far more likely to get the next one!
This page titled 8.5: The Client-Centered Response to Losing Projects was last modified on Fri, 14 Mar 2025 06:01:38 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Judah Viola and Susan Dvorak McMahon.
The book could not be loaded just now.