13.6: Conclusion- A Cautionary Tale

Consulting and Evaluation to Nonprofit and Community-Based Organizations · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under not declared, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    13.6: Conclusion- A Cautionary Tale

    Organizational change is difficult to create and sustain. As consultants, we have succeeded as much as we have failed and, unfortunately, that success ratio actually puts us ahead of many in the change business. We will not expound here on the many reasons why change efforts fail but instead will provide the reader with some consulting tips that we have found useful when trying to create a learning system within an organization.

    13.6.1. Consulting Tip 1: Always Think Systems and Work to Change Mindsets of Team Member to also Think Systems First

    Systems thinking involves consideration of the interdependency, interconnectedness and interrelatedness of parts within the organization that constitutes the whole. An organizational system can be characterized by a continuous cycle of input, transformation, output and feedback whereby one element of experience influences the next. As a consultant who is focused on a learning orientation, one must be ready to push work groups to find the interrelatedness and interconnections that are critical factors for success. In this way, work groups can better understand key leverage points for improving alignment across systems. In our example, improving connections of the work group with various systems that interface with persons with disabilities was seen as a critical step in the process of meeting the overall goals of the work group.

    13.6.2. Consulting Tip 2: Build Capacity for Active Participation in the Change Process

    It is a widely held premise within the change field that those most affected by a change effort should be highly involved and empowered as the drivers of the change process. Employees and volunteers are more likely to support change if they have been involved as the architects of the initiative. For these reasons, when we were hired by the executive director of this agency we emphasized the importance of having work group members become partners within us in this process. For example, in the proposed work plan we created, we explicitly stated that this change process would only be effective if those most affected by the change were engaged from the beginning in the “driver’s seat.” We also detailed specific steps in our plan and how we would involve work group members throughout the process. Throughout the consulting project, we reminded the executive director of the need to be collaborative and, when necessary, suggested a more collaborative approach to the plans she put forth.

    This focus on a participatory process allowed those individuals who would be most affected by the change process determine the goals of the change effort and the change strategies they would implement. It also built their capacity to engage in learning processes in the future, as our process modeled for them how to collect data, transform it into shared knowledge, and create action steps from that process.

    In a transformation process, a number of positive outcomes can arise from involving employees in resolving organizational issues and problems. These include increased trust and confidence between leaders/supervisors and employees, increased communication and information flow, more effective decision making, increased self control, enhanced problem solving, and higher performance and quality goals. Of course, this process of employee empowerment is only effective when the larger system is able to support and allow employee control (Foster-Fishman & Keys, 1997). Thus, consultants need to also consider how organizational leaders will respond when other staff are given the opportunities to determine the processes and outcomes of a change effort.

    13.6.3. Consulting Tip 3: Build Leadership Capabilities to Lead Change

    Forrester and Drexel (1999) contend that highly effective teams move from oneness of mind to unity of action. The consultant can lead work groups through a series of exercises (as we have shown) to help build oneness of mind. A consultant can also facilitate the development of capabilities to generate unity of action. Nevertheless, ultimately, it is up to the organizational members on the team to take on greater and greater responsibility for making change happen. Thus generating commitment around goals must also include a discussion that making change happen requires individuals willing to step up to the plate and take on leadership roles such as coordination of actions (e.g., setting up communication and integrative mechanisms), encouragement of efforts (e.g., promoting creativity and innovation as well as dealing with failures), and maintaining the vitality of the project over time (e.g., focusing individuals on what has been achieved, what is needed to build on successes, and what can be learned so as not to reinvent the wheel). These roles (and others) require multiple leaders to emerge. The consultant needs to help the group to identify what is needed to drive unity of action and to push various group members to accept responsibility for driving certain parts of the change effort so that the burden does not fall on only one person. For example, we used the Group Action Planning exercise to clearly identify what and how as well as who needed to be involved to drive action.


    13.6: Conclusion- A Cautionary Tale is shared under a not declared license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by LibreTexts.