Opening the book…
Synthetic (Inorganic) and organic fertilizers can be used to meet the nutrient demands of the crop. Synthetic fertilizers are manufactured artificially and contain minerals or synthetic chemicals. Organic fertilizers contain only plant or animal-based materials that are either a byproduct or an end product of a naturally occurring process such as manures, leaves and compost. There are pros and cons to either side of the organic/synthetic fertilizer battle.
Synthetic fertilizers are typically easy to apply. They are often granular and dry thus making them easily applied through spreader equipment or by hand. Organic fertilizers on the other hand often contain large amounts of water and therefore are very heavy. Due to both weight and how difficult it can be to portion and applied, special handling is often required.
If applying a fertilizer in response to a deficiency in an existing crop, synthetic fertilizers will provide that missing nutrient immediately. Organic fertilizers, however, must actually break down to release the nutrients so this will take time once the organic fertilizer is added to the soil. On the other hand, synthetic fertilizers are subject to leaching because of this availability while the slow release of organic fertilizers make them less susceptible to leaching. Thus, synthetic fertilizers are susceptible to runoff and therefore are more likely to enter streams, rivers, and lakes. The organic material being slow released is less likely to run off and enter our watersheds.
Since synthetic fertilizers are synthesized or come from minerals, the exact ratio of nutrients can easily be determined. With organic fertilizers the nutrient availability can change with time. This means that the application rates can be more difficult to determine with organic fertilizers as compared to synthetic fertilizers.
Because organic fertilizers are the byproduct or end-product of a naturally occurring process the energy required to produce it is very low. In many cases it is formed by recycling spent organic material. The synthetic fertilizers on the other hand require high-energy processes in order to produce them. Organic materials that are part of the organic fertilizers adding significant organic material to the soil. This can improve soil structure and water holding abilities. Synthetic fertilizers lack organic material and therefore do not improve soil structure. On the other hand, synthetic fertilizers are sterile while organic fertilizers have the potential to introduce pathogens into the soil. Another issue with organic fertilizers is its lack of appeal to neighbors and surrounding areas. Organic fertilizers can often smell and look unappealing. If you have close neighbors, they may object to the smell of manure in your garden. In contrast the inorganic fertilizers have little smell. Table 8-5 summaries some of these points.
| Trait | Inorganic fertilizers | Organic fertilizers |
|---|---|---|
| Ease of application | Very | Can be labor intensive |
| Immediate access | Yes | No |
| Subject to leaching | Yes | No |
| Application rates | Known | Subject to change |
| Environmental impact – energy | High | Low – recycled organic material |
| Environmental impact – run-off | High | Low – slow release |
| Sterile | Yes | No |
| Appeal (smell & look) | Acceptable | Can be offensive |
| Improve soil structure | No | Yes |
This page titled 8.5.1: Synthetic and Organic Fertilizers was last modified on Fri, 06 Nov 2026 14:11:54 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by .
The book could not be loaded just now.