Opening the book…
Cytotoxicity is a harmful effect that causes cell injury or death. Cytostasis is reduced cell proliferation without necessarily causing cell death. A treated well can contain fewer cells than its control because cells divided more slowly. The difference is biologically meaningful, but calling it cell killing requires additional evidence.
Viability describes whether cells are alive according to a stated measurement. Dye exclusion tests membrane integrity. Metabolic assays estimate cell health through biochemical activity. Clonogenic survival asks whether cells retain the ability to produce colonies. These methods examine different properties and can disagree without any measurement being automatically wrong.
For example, suppose two groups each begin with 20,000 cells. The control reaches 80,000 cells and the treatment reaches 40,000 cells. If both groups remain mostly dye-excluding, the treatment has half as many endpoint cells but has still doubled from its starting number. “The treatment killed half the cells” is not supported by that observation. A time-zero reference helps distinguish reduced accumulation from a decrease below the starting population.
|
Measurement |
Main property measured |
Interpretation limit |
|
Direct cell count |
Number of recovered or imaged cells |
Requires a separate way to identify viable cells |
|
Dye exclusion |
Membrane integrity |
Does not test long-term reproduction |
|
ATP or reagent conversion |
Biochemical activity in the sample |
Activity per cell and interference can change |
|
Colony formation |
Capacity to form qualifying colonies |
Depends on plating and growth conditions |
|
Scratch closure |
Change in cell-free gap |
Movement, division, and loss can all contribute |
ATP assays produce light related to the ATP in a sample. Under validated conditions, this signal can estimate metabolically active cell abundance. However, ATP per cell can change without the same change in live-cell count. Common endpoint ATP assays break open cells. Plan separate wells if later growth or microscopy will also be measured.
Tetrazolium assays, such as MTT or MTS, and resazurin assays rely on biochemical conversion of an assay reagent. Metabolic state, incubation time, and assay conditions affect the response. Verify the useful signal range for the chosen cell density. A saturated reading cannot distinguish two different cell populations.
An orthogonal assay uses a different measurement principle to examine the same general question. For example, membrane-integrity staining and a cell count can help interpret a reduced ATP result. Agreement across different methods makes the interpretation stronger; disagreement identifies a question that needs investigation.
An assay interference effect occurs when the treatment changes the measurement process rather than the intended biological endpoint. Colored compounds can affect absorbance, fluorescent compounds can affect fluorescence, and treatments can alter reagent chemistry. A no-cell compound control can reveal some interference. Other effects require additional checks, such as adding compound to a defined assay standard.
This page titled 13.5: Cell Number, Viability, and Cytotoxicity was last modified on Wed, 21 Oct 2026 01:36:15 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Emalee MacKenzie.
The book could not be loaded just now.