Opening the book…
The team now has several findings to classify. A valid result meets the required 
control and performance conditions and can be interpreted within the method’s scope. For a detection assay, a valid finding may be positive or negative. Quantitative assays can also provide valid numerical results. Validity describes whether the evidence is interpretable, not whether the outcome is desirable.
An invalid result cannot be interpreted for its intended purpose because a required condition failed. Examples include a failed positive control, a contaminated negative control, an incorrect reaction program, or failed sample suitability. An inconclusive result leaves the decision unresolved under the method’s interpretation rules, even when required controls pass. A borderline or method-defined indeterminate signal may require planned follow-up.
A deviation is a departure from an approved instruction or expected condition. Document what happened, when it occurred, which materials were affected, and how it might influence the result. Compare “procedure error” with “the positive-control tube was omitted during setup.” The second statement gives the investigation a concrete starting point.
A corrective action addresses an identified problem. Revising a plate map after repeated omissions, replacing a failed reagent lot, or adjusting sample preparation after demonstrated interference are possible actions. Repeat the assay for a documented reason. Repeatedly testing until one acceptable-looking value appears hides uncertainty instead of resolving it.
Keep these quality findings linked to the scratch measurements. Faster closure remains an observation even if the treatment preparation has unresolved endotoxin interference. The team must disclose the unresolved issue and limit its conclusions. Even satisfactory screening would not, by itself, show that EVs caused the response; other components of the preparation may contribute.
Attribution: Images AI-generated using ChatGPT Modified by Emalee Mackenzie, Irvine Valley College. Licensed under CC BY-NC-SA
This page titled 15.6: Valid Invalid and Inconclusive Results was last modified on Wed, 21 Oct 2026 01:35:51 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Emalee MacKenzie.
The book could not be loaded just now.