Opening the book…
Tampering, also called overadjustment, occurs when people react to common-cause variation as though each difference needs a separate correction. The adjustments can add variation rather than reduce it. Deming used the funnel experiment to demonstrate this risk: moving a funnel in response to ordinary differences in where a marble landed could worsen the overall pattern.
For the hypothetical filler, a reading of 10.03 mL is slightly above the target. The technician lowers the setting. The next reading is 9.97 mL, so the technician raises it. If the original process was stable and these differences were expected, the technician may now be introducing additional shifts. The equipment begins responding to the operator’s adjustments as well as its original sources of variation.
Avoiding tampering does not mean accepting bad output or ignoring a safety concern. A result outside specification still needs the required response. The distinction is between protecting affected output and making an unsupported adjustment to the process. Both the urgency and the technical response should be guided by evidence and applicable procedures.
Some processes have designed feedback controls that make justified adjustments automatically or at specified intervals. Following a validated or otherwise appropriate control strategy is different from an operator improvising a correction after every result. The goal is informed control, not a blanket ban on adjustments.
A useful pause before changing a setting is to ask: Is this a defined signal? Is the measurement reliable? What cause would the adjustment address? Is the adjustment authorized? How will its effect be checked? If the answers are unclear, escalation and investigation are often more useful than an immediate setting change.
This page titled 6.7: Risks of adjusting a stable process unnecessarily was last modified on Thu, 05 Nov 2026 09:13:07 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Emalee MacKenzie.
The book could not be loaded just now.