Opening the book…
Choose the method before the discussion becomes a contest between preferred outcomes. Start with the decision itself. Is the team selecting a routine arrangement, recommending an improvement, interpreting technical evidence, or responding to an urgent concern? These questions require different combinations of participation, expertise, and authority.
Decision criteria are the factors used to compare
options. They may include quality requirements, staff access, cost, time, and available support. Identify mandatory requirements first. An option that fails a required condition should not win because it is convenient or popular.
For decisions that need broad cooperation, consensus may help people understand the tradeoffs and support implementation. Voting may suit a limited choice among acceptable options when the group has agreed to the rule. A designated decision maker may need to act after consulting specialists when authority or time demands it. Urgent concerns should follow established response procedures rather than waiting for a full team discussion.
A decision matrix compares options against agreed criteria. It can make tradeoffs visible, but scores depend on the information and judgments used. Explain the ratings and test uncertain assumptions. A high total should not hide failure to meet a mandatory requirement. First screen out options that do not meet those requirements; then compare the remaining options using the agreed criteria.
When consensus is not reached, state the unresolved issue and choose the next route. More evidence, a revised proposal, or additional expertise may help. A designated decision maker may decide if the agreed governance allows it, but record that as the authorized person’s decision, not consensus. Sponsor support does not transfer technical approval authority.
This page titled 10.9: Selecting an appropriate decision method was last modified on Sun, 08 Nov 2026 13:09:35 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Emalee MacKenzie.
The book could not be loaded just now.