Opening the book…
Federal agencies such as the FDA use rulemaking to develop regulations and adjudication to decide individual matters. For example, the FDA uses rulemaking to establish requirements that apply to a group of products. It uses adjudication when it makes a decision on a specific product application. The steps the agency follows depend on the product and the law that applies.
From a proposed rule to a regulation
When an agency proposes a rule, it usually publishes the proposal in the Federal Register and gives the public a chance to comment. The proposal describes what the agency is considering. If the agency issues a final rule, it publishes that rule in the Federal Register as well. The introduction to the final rule, called the preamble, usually explains the agency’s reasons for the rule and how it responded to significant comments.
A final rule identifies its effective date, when the rule takes effect. It may also list a separate compliance date, when regulated companies must begin following certain requirements. The Federal Register publishes proposed rules, final rules, and notices. Regulations of general and lasting application are organized in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR). The eCFR is a regularly updated online version of the CFR.
How to read FDA guidance
FDA guidance explains the agency’s current thinking and often describes ways to meet a legal requirement. When reading guidance, ask where the obligation comes from. A guidance document may quote a law or regulation that companies must follow. The guidance itself generally offers recommendations. A company may use a different approach if it meets the applicable laws and regulations.
Check the document’s status before relying on it. Draft guidance is issued for comment and may change before the FDA finalizes it. Final guidance reflects the agency’s thinking when issued and can later be updated or withdrawn. Some older FDA biotechnology documents use the title Points to Consider. If you find one, check whether the FDA has revised, withdrawn, or replaced it.
This page titled 11.4: Rulemaking Adjudication and Guidance was last modified on Tue, 03 Nov 2026 04:43:50 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Emalee MacKenzie.
The book could not be loaded just now.