The Historical Magazine, and Notes & Queries Concerning the Antiquities, History and Biography of America [Extra Number] (November, 1867)
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
THE 3 Vol. I. New Sextes. ] ————$ $$$ $ WHAT OUR NEIGHBORS SAY OF US. Wirn the liveliest satisfaction, we have the pleasure of presenting to our readers the following testimonials of the intrinsic merits of Tam H1s- TORICAL MAGAZINE, as a repository of important materials concerning ‘‘the Antiquities, History, and Biography of America.” It will be perceived that we have not hesitated to present, also, in their proper places, the out- pourings of a very few who have found nothing in Tue Historica Magazine that is worthy of their commendation or approval. We have done so because the great body of our readers will not fail to perceive, from the judgment of the greater number and the stronger minds, the country over, that either ignorance, or bigotry, or some private grief, rather than intelligence and integrity, un- 4 trammelled, has controlled the adverse judgments; and because we have been taught that ignorance, and falsehood, and self-interest, even in their worst forms, are harmless while Knowledge and the Truth are free to combat them. | .—EXxtTRAOT FROM THE REcoRDS OF THE MAINE HistToricaL Soolety, AT THE ANNUAL MEETING, Aveust, 1867. “ The following resolutions were proposed by the Rev. Mr. “ Dyke, and, on motion, were adopted. * Resoitvep. That Ture Hisrortca. Soorery or Marne ap- preciates the value of ‘ Tira Hisroztoan Magazine,’ pub- ** lished in New York, and desires to bear testimony to the _ zeal and ability of its present Editor, in collecting and preserving the materials for History, and the frankness _ with which historical questions are discussed and consid- * ered in its pages. ; _ “Resotvep. That the interests of history will be pro- _ *moted by the wider circulation of ‘Tus HisrortoaL Mae- _ azine’ in our State.” ; A true extract. Attest, Epwarp Batiarp, Recording Secretary. Brunswick, Aug. 16th, 1867, Hist. Maa. Von. mw. 21, NOVEMBER,’ 186%. Ide" HISTORICAL MAGAZINE. Pi. tok [Exrra NumBeEr. II.—From the Hon. E. E. Bourne, President of the Maine Historical Society. - I have been a subscriber to Tur Htstortoan Ma@azine, from its commencement, and have found it a very efficient. aid in my Historical pursuits. Some have objected to thespirit of the later numbers, But it is only by the warmth and zeal of those who are en- deavoring to ferret out the truth or to maintain conclusions to which their own researches have led them, that the real facts of History are to be established. A magazine which is spiritless is of little value and will do little for the object for which it is set on foot. In this monthly there is nothing ex- clusive. Its management is of the most liberal character. Every one disposed to contribute to its pages or reply to its editorials, may infuse as much spirit into his work as he thinks proper. No replication will be rejected on that ac- count. This I understand to be the position of Tux Hrs- TORICAL MaGaztne ; and I believe that no historical student will fail to tind in the numbers for a year much which will help him in his pursuits, X Kennebunk, Me., August, 1867, - E. E. Bourng, il.—From Rev. Epwarp Batrarp, D. D., Secretary of the Maine Historical Society. I fully concur in the expressions of commendation of Tue HisrortoaAt MAGAZzIngE, as given by Hon. Mr. Bourne; and be- lieving it to be a valuable repository of the ungathered facts of American History, and open for free discussion of contro- verted points. I wish it may have a wide circulation. Epwarp BALLARD. Brunswick, Me. ( LV.—From Hoy. Wittram- Wins, formerly Pre- sident of the Maine Historical Society, and author of The History of Portland, etc. Porr.anpd, July 31, 1867. t * * _ 4 * & % Ht » I do not lose sight of the Maaazrnz, having been an original subscriber and an occasional contributor. I can truly say that it has not been more ably conducted nor better tilled with varied and valuable matter than since you have taken it into your hands. But I must say that your trench- ant manner of treating New England, and _ especially Massachusetts, has given offence to many persons in this quarter, among whom are present and former subscribers to the work. Your historical researches are varied and comprehensive, and your criticisms are honest, very often just, although as often sarcastic and severe. They give life and character to the Magazine, but make enemies. I am examining, as I have leisure, old MSS. relatin to New York and Pennsylvania, and if I find anythin that will be likely to interest your readers I shall not fail to communicate it. fam truly, ‘ Your obedient servant, Witiiam WILuis,
Page 2
HISTORICAL 822 V.—From Rev. N. Bourton, D. D., Corresponding Secretary of the New Hampshire Historical Society ; Author of The History of Concord, etc. ; and Editor of The Collections of the N. H. Historical Society.* Conoorp, N. H., August 13, 1867. Henry B. Dawson, Esq. Dear Sir, ¢**T trust you will pardon me for saying, with all frankness and sincerity, that herct the criticisms in the Magazine, on New England, Ne gland Institutions, and especially on Massachusetts men and books, have been £0 severe, and in my judgment, so unjust that Icannot en- dorse it for the future. I think a work of such a character as Tne Historica, Macazineg, should be emenently imparteal and true. Very respectfully. Iam Yours, etc., N. Bourton, Cor. Sec. N. H. Hist. Soe. VI.—From Capiain W. F. Goopwin, U. S. A. Librarian of the New. Hampshire Historical So- ciety. This valuable monthly, the only one of the kind published in America, has recently passed into the hands of Henry B. Dawson, of Morrisania, N. Y., whose reputation as a histori- cal writer and author is too well known to need mention. The Magazine has entered upon its tenth year, and has an established reputation among the best scholars of the world, sufficient to find a place in their libraries. I can cordialy recommend this Magazine to the favorable consideration of the members of our New Hamresnire Hts- TORICAL Soorery, and hope that they will, one and all, sub- scribe tor. it. (From The Statesman, Concord, Sept. 28, 1866.) VII. From Rev. Pruuxy H. Wurre, D.D., Presi- dent of the Vermont Historical Society. The undersigned having been a reader of the Tire His- ToRicAL Magazine from its beginning until now, takes pleasure in attesting to its great value as a repository of American History and Biography, in which is contained much that cannot be found elsewhere, as well as much that an only elsewhere be found in sources quite inaccessible to the great majority of the students of History. Piiny Coventry, Vr., 12th August, 1867, VIII. From Hon. Hiianp Hatt, late President of the Vermont Historical Society, and formerly Governor of the State. TI have been a subscriber to the Hrstortcat. MaGaztne for nine years pat, and concur in the above statement: of the Rev. Pliny H. White. : Hinanp Hai. Nortn BEnnincrTon, Vt., August 22, 1867. IX. From Samvet G. Draxe, Esq., late President of The New England Historic Genealogical Soci- ety; Author of The History and Antiquities of the City of Boston, Biography and History of the Indians of North America, etc. ; and Kditor of The Old Indian Chronicle, The N. E. Historical and Genealogical Register, etc. Boston, 12th August, 1867, H. Wuts, Henry B. Dawson, Esq. My Dear Sir: Respecting the Histortcat. Maaazree, its great valne and usefulness, there can be but one opinion among students in American History ; and of your ability to conduct such a riodical, Ido not think there has ever been a question. hat there are those who express disapprobation of some of the statements and opinions is true ; and I must confess I ® Vide, Historical Magazine I, x, Supplement. §8, 89, MAGAZINE. - from its commencement, and we value it very highly. % [November, a ne tr en Let am among thatnumber. Yet, at the same time, suchs ‘ ments (by some termed “sectional aspersions”) and opie nions, have not sufficient influence upon me to cause me to- undervalue any historical facts, por to underrate the ability — of an Editor who has shown an acumen in intricate histo- rical investigations seldom equalled, and rarely surpassed, With my best wishes for your healih and prosperity, I remain truly yours 4 Samurt G. Drake X. From Joun Warp Dsan, Lsg., late Secretary of the New England Historic Genealogical Society, etc, Boston, August 1st, 1867. Ichee Ty recommend the Histortoat MaGazine to the | atro:. ce of the public. Its present editor, Henry B,- AWsON, Esq., possesses rare qualifications for that position, being a gentleman of extensive historical reading and great industry in research, while, at the same time, he possesses” a clear and vigorous style. Though differing from him in- some of his opinions, and disapproving the manner in which - he has presented them to his readers, I believe him to be a conscientious writer, who, while bold in promulgating his— own views, is always ready to open his pages to the com- munications of his opponents. 7 Joun Warp DEAN, XI. From Wiiu1am F. Poorz, Esq., Librarian of The Boston Atheneum, and Author of An- Index to Periodical Literature, etc.—the cele- brated ‘* P” of The Evening Transcript. Nov. 9, [1866.] 4 Mr. Dawson, Dear Sie : I have received several times a Circular from vou on the supposition that this Library did not take Tus Histortoat. MaGavtxe. This Library has taken the Magazine do not propose to do without it. . a W. F. Poo.r, Librarian, — P.S. Ihave written the above that you might not think we were so stupid at “ the Hub” as not to be aware of the merits of your Magazine. W.EP y XII. From J. Wincate Tuornton, Esq., Authe of Landing at Cape Ann, ¢éic. 4 20 Court Srreet, Boston, * My pear Dawson # I assure you that no more welcome page comes to my table than that of Tue Hisrortcat. MaGazrne, with its rich ane varied miscellany of historical lore and monthly record of and tiquarian learning. 5. ou rescue from oblivion original papers illustrative of every portion of our Republic, from the very beginning even” until now. The existence of such masses of unused materials. shows with what discrimination, if not skepticism, “ histo. * ries,” mere compendiums as they must be, should be receiv« el; and no writer can prudently omit an examination of the pages of the Magazine. Of course a thorough index of names of places, persons, and things, is indispensable; and the omise sion of this, in some of the earlier volumes, seriously ime pairs their usefulness, o Your Book notices are admirable; they are honest; and though sometimes a dissent may be entered, you always give **a reason for the faith that isin you,” if not always conclus sive. f That the editorial pen ig not nibbed in Boston, nor the edie torial spectacles furnished by Boston opticians, is very ape parent ; but why Boston nibs and lenses—not all ahke—— may not be quite as true and trusty as those of New York, - is not Spnarens. Your harsh words to ns in the East are useless, more th: useless, and cannot be classed under what Disraeli calls * Amenities of Literature.” i: Wishing you the full success which exact and thorough learning, untiring diligence, historical acumen, and honest conviction, may rightly challenge, E I ours sincere 3 scapes v J. Wiveats Tuonwtom,
Page 3
1867.] HMWISTORICAL MAGAZINE. 823 XIIl.—From Hon. J. Russertz Bartrert, Sec- retary of the State of Rhode Isiand, Author of The Progress of Ethnology; Dictionary of Americanisms, Report on the Mexican Boun- dary Line, ete. The editorship ofthis periodical has again passed into the thands of Mr. Henry B. Dawson, a gentleman better qualified for the task than any of whom we have knowledge. Mr. Daw- son has written and edited a large number of books and pamphlets upon American History, in which he has elucidated points which had previously been involved in obscurity; in- deed, he scems to have a taste for those subjects of historical and antiquarian. research which most writers avoid.—From The Providence Journal, September 19th, 1866. XIV.—From Professor Grorae WASHINGTON GREENE, Author of Life of Gen. Nathaniel Greene, etc. . : East Grrenwicn, R. I. 18th Sept. 1867. My pear Daws o: You ask me for my opinion of Tne Histortca, Maqazing, I give it without hesitation or reserve. -I think that the impulsiveness of your nature leads you at times into forms of expression which irritate without con- vincing, and awaken opposition where your real object is to invite impartial research. This is particularly apparent whenever you speak of New England or New England men. I feel it as a New Englander; and I deeply regret it as a stu- dent of History and your friend. The bitterness of opinions ds a dangerous element in the discussion of historical truth. T have told you candidly what I disapprove in the Magazine. I will tell you with equal candor what I admire. I admire * ele vigor, Fed industr ’, the depth and the range of your quiries. think that tse have succeeded in bringing to- gether a large number of important documents which might Otherwise have been lost—or what 1s equivalent to lost—have remained buried in private collections. I think that as a medium of enquiry upon historical questions your work is of inestimable value; and 1 should regard the suspension of it as a literary calamity. . Very truly yours, G. W. Grrenr, Mr. H. B. Dawson. XV.—From the late Wirt1aAM L. WeEaAveER, /3g., the Genealogist of Windham County, Conn. The Magazine contains articles of real historical value, From The Willimantic Journal, Sept. 20, 1866. The improved character of the work under the new man- agement noticed in the August number, is continued. They contain much curious and valuable historical information. From the same paper, Nov. 1, 1866. XVI.—From Officers and Members of Taz Lona Istanp Hisroricat Sociery. The Historica Magazine, now in its tenth volume, has always had a special interest for me, and I therefore most willingly recommend that the members of the Long Island Historical Society should give it their support, particularly as the Editor proposes to report the meetings of our Society. J. Carson BREvVooRT. Brooxry , October 13, 1866. Hen. C. Murry, Gro. S. SreruENnson, Josuva M. Van Cort, R. 8. Srorrs, Jr, A. Cooke Hutt, Jounx Buunt, E. S. Muss, Cuartes Congpon, Cuas. E. West, A. M. Woop, —~ Tnos. W. Firip From the testimony of the gentlemen signing above, I feel free to commend the Magazine. H. W. Bercuer. XVIL—From Officers and Members of Tur New York Hisroricar Sociery. The undersigned have great pleasure in recommending to the favor and apport of the public, Tur Historioat Mag- 44iNE, Which, under its present management, promises to J. GreENwoon, ALDEN J. SPooNneER, surpass its former high peniaten, and which, by reason of its Reports of Meetings, will be especially interesting to the members of The New York Historical Society. New York, September, 1866. ’ Tnomas DeWrirt, D. D.,! FREDERIO DE PEYSTER, Bens. R. Wrinturor, JoHn Romeyn Bropueap, Bens. H. Friern, AnpRew WARNER, Groree H. Moorg, Isaao Ferns, D. D., Cuaries P, Krexianp, E. C. Brenepior, James LENOX. XVITI.—From Officers and Members of Tot AMER- IOAN ETHNOLOGICAL Society. The undersigned cheerfully concur with the officers and members of The Long Island and The New York Historical Societies, in their good opinions of Tus Hisrortoan Maq@as ZINE, and in their commendation of it to the favor and sup- port of every scholar in the country. ; Tuos. Ewnank. E. H. Davis, M. D. Henry T. Drown. ° H. R. Srives. M. D. XIX.—From Tue Creray, in the City of New York. Tun Histortoat Magazine, under the editorial charge of Mr. Dawson has been enlarged and greatly increased in value. It is a periodical much needed, and in the collec- tion. of materials for History much industry and research are manifested. It has deserved claims upon a liberal and increased patronage in our commuunity. ~ Tuomas DeWitt, [Senior Pastor of the Collegiate Reformed Dutch Church,N.Y.] I concur in the foregoing recommendation of Tuz Histort- CAL MAGAZINE, considering it to be avery valuable and ime portant work, and deserving of a liberal support. . More@an Drx, [Rector of Trinity Church, New York.] We concur with the foregoing recommendations. E. H. Cutarrn, {Pastor of the Fourth Universalist Church, New York.] Epwin F. Hatrtevn. [Stated Clerk of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church.) SamuEt Oseoon, [Pastor of the Church of the Messiah, New York.} Howarp Crossy, (Pastor of Fourth Avenue Presbyterian Church.] Joun C. Lowniz, [Secretary of Board of Foreign Missions.] Tuos. D. ANDERSON, {Pastor of First Baptist Church.} XX.—From well-known Gentlemen residing in the - city of New York. ; New York, Aug. 19, 1867. _ Ihave for some years been a subscriber to Tur Hisrorican MAGAZINE. It contains a great amount of interesting and useful his- torical information, and may be consulted with advantage by all students of History, especially of the History of the City and State of New York. Its present Editor, Mr. Henry B. Dawson, is fully qualified by his tastes, acquirements, and studies to render the Maga zine hereafter, as it has been heretofore, a valuable acquisi-' tion to the student and the lover of our History. Cuarcies P. Kirkianp, | We fully concur in the expressions of opinion of Mr. Kirk- land, both as to the merits of Tuz HisTorioar. MaGazing, and of its present Editor, Mr. Henry B. Dawson. JOuUN CocuRANE, [Late Attorney-General of New York.] GeorGe-Orpy ke, [Late Mayor of the City of New York.] Hamitton Fisu. {President of the N. Y Historical Society, late Governor of the: State and Senator in Congress. } New York, Sept. 30, 1867. My Dear Sik: Ihave been a subscriber to Tus Historica MaGaztnr! from its beginning ; and regard it as a most useful and vale!
Page 4
324 table publication. As a permanent record of facts in respect to the early history of this City and State, which, if not now collected and preserved, would be liable to be lost forever, it supplies a necessity which no other journal fulfils; and de- serves the encouragement and support of all who take an interest in historical researches, or ieel a patriotic pride in the great Commonwealth or in the great Continental Me- tropolis to which we belong. With much respect, and with cordial regard, I remain, very truly yours, etc., Henry. B. Dawson, Esq. ; 8. J. Tinpen, I concur in the above. Joun T. HorrMan, (Mayor of the City of New York.} ITalso concur. The Magazine has Page improved under the management of Mr. Dawson, and in addition to being a vehicle for the publication of valuabie papers and historical documents, it seems destined to become the substitute in this country for Notes and Queries. ) Cuas P. Daty, (First Judgeof the Court of Common Pleas.) - I fully concur with Judge Daly in the above recommenda- on. ; G. C. VERPLANOK. XXI.—From Hon. Joun V. L. Pruyn, Chancellor the Regenis of the University of the State of 0 Kou York. Arsany, August 19th, 1867. The Histrortoat Magazine is a publication of great inter- est to all who are desirous to acquaint themselves with the History of our Country, and especially that of the State of New York. Great research is evinced in many of its arti- cles, and its tone is manly and independent. I hope that it will receive a liberal > from the public. oun V. L. Pruyn. XXII.---From Benson J. Losstna, Hsg., Author of The Pictorial Field Book ofthe Revolution, History of the United States, e7c. Poveukerrsiz, N. Y., Feb. 18, 1867. Frienp Dawson: It will give me great pleasure, I assure you, to contribute any way that I may to the columns and the support of the Magazine. You are doing a great public service in saving from possible annihilation valuable papers relating to the early History of our State. Fire might strike those docu- ments out of existence in MS. state: it would take many fires to annihilate them in your printed form. As ever, your sincere friend, Benson J. Lossrna. Povenkeepsir, N. Y., Aug. 17, 1867. H. B. Dawson, Esq. : I have been a.careful reader of Tae Histortoan Macazine from its commencement in 1857 until now, and [ regard it as one of the most useful publications of the day, for it is a re- pository and safe custodian of some of the rarest treasures of American History. But for its service these might be lost or remain forever unknown. « I heartily concur in the commendatory words of the officers and several distinguished members of The New York Histor- ical Society,saying that ‘‘ under its present management Tur ** HistortoaAL MAGAZINE promises to surpass its former high ‘reputation, and which, by its reports of meetings, will De * especially interesting to the New York Historical Society.” I will add that it is equally interesting to every student of American History. Brunson J. Lossina. XXII..—From Everr A. Duvyoxinox, £3¢., Author of Cyclopedia of American Literature, late Lditor of The Literary World, etc. 20 Crivron PLAog, New York, August 13, 1867. My Dear Sir: I learn with pleasure that you are continuing your efforts for the improvement and permanent establishment of Tu Histortoat Magazine. I have always regarded it as an im- portant enterprise, and heartily wish for its success. The series has already much valuable matter, which will in vain be looked for elsewhere. You have recently added to it HISTORICAL MAGAZINE. many features of interest, in Reports, Reviews, the publit tion of original Essays and rare Documents. Such resu challenge the support of all interested in American Histe and Literature. The value of the volumes must increase ¥ time. A subscription, in fact, will be in more senses th one a sound investment. 5 I am, dear Sir, yours truly, H. B. Dawson, Esq. XXIV.—From Daviv T. Vatentine, 2sq,, | well known Antiquary ; Author of The Histo of the City of New York; and Hiditor oft series of The Manual of the Corporation .of ) City of New York, etc. "7 . Orrice or Tus CLERK or THE Common Counot, 8 Crry Haut, New York, Sept. 11, 1867, J Henny B. Dawson, Esq., Editor of Historical Magazine, Dear Sir: I have been a subscriber for, and a careful reader of T HisroricaAL Magazine, for many years, and have been hi gratified to witness the display of talent, energy and ind try exhibited in each successive number by its Kditor. Is cerely trust the research, ability and impartiality manifes in the conduct of the work, meet with just appreciation a discerning public, and that the pecuniary reward is commensurate with the value of the Magazine as a stam work of reference to the students and admirers of a American History. i" Wishing you success, and a brilliant future for your valu ble publication, 3 Everr A. Duyogn 0 am, dear Sir, are uly yours, . >, T. Vaur rE XXV.—From James Parton, Esq., the dist guishea Biographer of Aaron Burr, Andre Jackson, Benjamin Franklin, ete. New York, 303 E. 18th Street, Sept. 17, 1 My pear Mr. Dawson: ; My opinion of Tux Hisroricat Maaaztnx cannot be ofy much value, for the reason that [ am an interested par Not one number has appeared in five years which did? contain at least one thing of use to me in my vocation. — might as well ask a carpenter what his candid opinion 4 hammer is. All he could say would be, that he could not without it. ;. Of all the persons connected with literature whom I hi ever known, you are by far the most industrious and pel vering. Often you say things in the Magazine from whit most vehemently dissent, but I like it all the better for t It is always a comfort to find any one who has an opinio whether wrong or right—and this is a solace which you ford your readers every month. Ido not see how any: occupied with historical pursuits, either as writer, stud or collector, can afford to do without the Hisrortoat M AZINE. 4 a¥ Very trul ; ical Jars Jas. Panton XXVI.—From James Riker, Esq., Author Annals of Newtown, Queen’s Co., N. Y. Herxrmer, N. Y., August 24, 361 My pear Dawson: y Your favor.of August 10th was delivered at my reside after I had left the city for a tour in the country, and finally reached me at this place. I beg you to accept 1 apology for my delay in answering it. me I fancy Tau Hisrortoat Magazine has gained a reputati in the field of choice historical literature which cannot essentially affected by anything which I may say in its half. But if my humble testimony to its permanent ex lence be worth anything, I can give it very cheerfully very wingge too. Having taken the Magazine from first issue, I have learned to appreciate it as an invalu repository of rare facts relating to American History, ¢t with care and discrimination, and, I may be perm ite add, never more so, nor with more editor al ability, under the present management. Iis articles are unifor interesting and of marked intrinsic worth, and its reproduction of our early Records adds a feature
Page 5
- cholar can dispense with it? _ Magazine of inestimable value to the student and lover of ancient historical lore. I trust the Hisrortcan MAGAZINE may ever enjoy a gener- - ous patronage, and its worthy and accomplished Editor be _ abundantly rewarded for his painstaking labors in the cause _ $f historic truth. . I remain, dear sir, yours truly, JAMES RIKER. XXVIL—From Rev. E. H. Girrert, D.D., Author of The Life and Times of John Huss, History of the Presbyterian Church in the United States, etc. j Haruem, N. Y. Crry, August 12, 1867. My prar Dawson: My heart is with you in your enterprise for extending the ¢irculation of the Magazine. I regard it as indispensable to all historical students, and many a single article like that _ of Mr. Moore in the June number is worth, to persons inves- _ tigating the facts of our Colonial History, ten times the - amount of a year’s subscription to the Magazine. _ _Idonot know that I can say anything worth your using. - But if.a stranger asked me for my opinion, my reply would ~ be something like this : _ Mr. Dawson is an enthusiast in historical studies, with _ clear and definite opinions of his own, not by any means > always accordant with those of perhaps the mass of his _ readers, and yet withal resolutely and boldly honest, disposed _ to give every one a fuir hearing, and let the facts of History cut their way right or left, as Truth demands. Tur Hisrori- _ at MaGazine, under his management, has become a valua- ble repository of curious and important matters, bearing upon the various phases of our Civil and Ecclesiastical His- tory. Noone who wishes to keep pace with the progress of historical investigation in this country, can afford to do with- _ @utit. He has enlisted as collaborators in his work a large - number of the ablest of our historical writers, and his enter- _ prise should receive a hearty support and large patronage throughout the entire country. Very truly yours, E. H. Gitierr. XXVIIL.—From Frimepricu Karp, Hsqg., Author of Life of the Baron Steuben, The Life of General e Kalb, ete. 4 Watt Street, N. Y., Aug. 24, 1867. _ My pear Mr. Dawson: ; Ihave always considered it my duty, and much more con- _ sidered it so since your accession to the editorship, to do all in pppewes for increasing the number of the subscribers to Tue Histortcat MAGAZINE. 7 Iam sorry that you are thus bound to look out for new subscribers, as your able and energetic efforts ought to have - secured to you the sympathy and codperation of all students _ of American History. _ Even in Germany, where they buy less books than in this country, almost every Province has its Historical Magazine, and besides, there is published an excellent Historical Quar- _ terly—Sybel’s Historische Zeitschrift—which outshines all - similar publications known to me, by the brilliancy of its _ Essays and Reviews, and by the completeness of its criti- _ «isms and materials. _ It ought to be the aim of every student to join you, and to make your paper, which is the only medium of historical _ reference in this country, still more interesting—more per- fect—and an absolute necessity to every lover of History. I thank you for your past services and trust that the future _ will bring you a greater success than the past. ; Yours truly, Frirpricu Karr. XXIX.—From Cuartts H. Hunt, Hsg., the Biog- rapher of Hdward Livingston. Morristown, N. J., August 15, 1867: _ My pear Sir: I trust the Historica Maaaztne is prospering in a busi- _ messsense. Surely there are enough scholars and students _ in the country to give it good support; and what student or here is no other man who could fill your place as its Editor; and I am therefore anxious “HISTORICAL MAGAZINE. 825 to hear that you are so satisfied with its prospects that there is no doubt of your perse#@rance in its publication. ery t@uy yours, Cuaries H. Hunt. Henry B. Dawson, Esq. XXX.—From Jonn Gimary Sua, LL.D, Au- thor of Discovery and Exploration of the Mis- sissippi Valley, History of the Catholic Missions, etc. ; Hditor of the series of American Linguistics, the Cramoisey series of Jesuit Relations, Cuar- LEVOIx’s History of New France, etc. New Yorks, Sept., 1867, The successful manner in which Mr. Henry B. Dawson hag not only sustained, but enlarged Tne Hisror1oaL MaGazinp, demands the hearty support of all who take an interest in the History of the country; and who will say that the subject is indifferent tohim? The increased amount of matter ig not the only service rendered by the present Editor. He brings to the examination of historic questions a fearles ertinacious research, that must tend to bring up the real acts of History, and in his pursuit of Truth knows no pare tiality or bias. Yours truly, J. G. Suma. XXXI.—From Frevenrto §. Cozzzns, Hsg., Author of The Sparrowgrass Papers, etc. Cuestnut CorraGce, Yonkers, Aug. 15, 1867. Henry B. Dawson, Esq., Editor of Historical Magazine: : My prar Srm:--I have not yet received the July and August numbers of Tum Hisrortoan Magazine. Will you please forward them to me? I take a peculiar pleasure in reading this peculiarly American book. Although its criti- cisms are sometimes severe a one cannot help but admire its candor and courage. The old Iconoclasts, or image. breakers, when they hewed down some of the most magnifi- cent sculptures of the Romish Church, managed to let in some chinks of light through the crevices of their destruction; and that light has illuminated the world, from their time down to ours. If you have broken down some of our Ameri« can idols, with a little too zealous severity, yet on the whole, the air has become purer, and the tottering steps of American History are not a little firmer placed upon the eternal foundas tions of Trurn! None of us like to accept unpalatable facts, especially those that contravene long-cherished opinions ag to men and events of former days. But the mind of man- kind finally adopts them, if urged with sincerity and sup- ported by undeniable proofs. Truly yours, . Freperio 8. Cozzzens. XXXII.—From H. R. Sritzes, M.D., Author of History of Ancient Windsor, History of the City of Brooklyn, etc. New Yors, Aug. 12, 1867. Frienp Dawson: * * * Tam especially pleased with your new department in Tus Hisrorican Magazine of Our Histor1oaAL WRITERS. which you have so happily inaugurated with a pleasant biog- raphy of the late David Dudley Field, D. D., Annalist and Historian. There is, as you know, much of interest and of profit in the lives of these humble laborers, who deal with . the dry bones of Genealogy, and who wander, at will, among the byways and hedges of Local History—unknown to the public at large—but happy in their work, and in their modest thought that their toil is appreciated by a chosen few, and that it may, perchance, smooth the path of some greater and > more famous scholar. I must contess no page of your Mag- azine will have so keen a relish for me, as those in which, from time to time, you enshrine the memories of the ‘rank and file” of our historic Brotherhood. I must take this occasion, also, to say, that I am well pleased with the Magazine since you took charge of it, a year ago. Its old friends, many of whom, like myself, have read it constantly since its initial number, and who have known of all its ups and downs, have drawn pleasant auguries from the past year’s pages, of its future success in your hands. You know we workers in historic matters cannot
Page 6
326 HISTORICAL Well dispense with its monthly visits—its eleven volumes are umong the best thumbed volumes upon our shelves—we look to its past with confidence, and we “ hanker” after its edi- todical visits as one waits impatiently for a chosen friend. This, I know, is- the feeling with which it is regarded b many others. Success to youin your endeavors to make it What you propose. Yours truly, H. R. Srivzs, M. D. XXXIII.—From Jeprna R. Stuns, Ls¢9., Author of Trappers of New York, History of Schoharie County and Border Wars of New York, ete. Fort Puan, N. Y., August 14, 1867. My prar Sir: Permit me to say that any necessity that should compel you to discontinue the publication of Tar Histortoar Maga- ‘zune, I should look upon as a public misfortune. Under your jable and fearless management of it, it is becoming invaluable ito the historical student; and almost any late number is worth a year’s subscription. The Magazine seems to supply & long-needed repository of historica] questions and answers, memoranda of increasing interest, etc., and not a few of the indispensable to the American writer, will of necessity find their way into it. The inquiry arises in the mind—who should aid in sustain- ing the Magazine? I answer, every individual who would garner up the odds and ends of historic lore; every newspa- per Editor; every Historical Society; every collegiate and classic School; as also every literary institute in the land; for they all will derive more or less benefit from its perusal. In- deed; every antiqurian needs it: besides, all who can afford to do it, should feel morally bound to aid in promoting so lauda- -ble an enterprise, and one calculated so liberally to benefit terity. PT rating that your ability, untiring industry, and devotion to the service of your country may meet with the recompense ‘{t deserves, I 7 — Your friend, ~ J. R. Sows, \XXXIV.—From Frank Moors, Lsg., Hditor of Specimens of American Eloquence, The Diary of the American Revolution, The Rebellion Record, ete. Orricr or Tux ‘‘ REBELLION RECORD,” New York,\Sept. 27,:1867. H. B. Dawson, Esq. : ' §rr: I congratulate you upon the success of Tur HistoRIoAn Macazrng, since you assumed the editorial chair of that peri- odical, and hope you will meet with that further success - which it really deserves. The material you are now garnering up is of the highest importance to those who desire to know the truths of History, not its special pleadings, and your asso- ciates in historical study must ever give you not only substan- tial encouragement but most earnest wishes. Your friend, “ Frank Moore. XXXV.—From Henry O’Rertty, Esq., the cele- brated Pioneer Telegraphist, and Author of Sketches of Rochester, etc. 24 Pine Street, New York, Oct. 17, 1867. Henry B. Dawson, Esq., Editor of Tur HistortoaAn MAGAZINE: My pear Sir: Many of your friends, as well as myself, are highly gratified with the arrangements you are making for increasing the usefulness and circulation of your valuable Magazine. The new Departments of Antiquities and Biog- raphy cannot fail to awaken additional interest in historical research. The frankness and fearlessness with which you discuss all relevant questions, indicate so plainly a desire that nothing but the truth and the whole truth shal! be allowed to pass under your imprint, that all minor differ- ences of opinion should be merged in the respect due to your Magazine as a trusty repository of historical data, With great regard, yours —_ ENRY O'REILLY. MAGAZINE. [November XXXVI.—From Wim Swinton, Esq., Author of The History of the Army of the Potomac, The Seven Decisive Battles, etc. 4 New York City, September 28, 1867, _ H. B. Dawson, Esq. @ My Dear Sir: I have been an attentive reader of Tor His- TORICAL MAGAZINE ever since you took its management, and have derived so much pleasure and instruction from its sal that I cannot refrain from expressing to you my satisfac tion. You have the courage, without fear or favor, to givea hospitable reception to whateyer bears the impress of histore ical truth ; while your bold, incisive editorial comments are of a character to shame our milk-and-water literature, Though it must need be that offence come to some of the weaker sort from your outspoken utterances, I know well that P rey) course gives a lively gratification to all independent minds. I trust the Magazine will prove a permanent success, for it deserves to be. I have in my possession a large nume- ber of original papers relating to the late war, and if ther are among them any that you would like to republish, would afford me much pleasure to furnish you with copies of em. With respect and esteem, yours truly, BA Wma. Swivrom, XXXVII.—From Cuaries Epwarps, Esq., Author _ of History of Finger-Rings, Pleasantries of the New York Bar, etc. New York, October, 1867. 4 My prar Mr. Dawson: “a Tue Histortoat MaGazine really requires no recomm ne dation at the hands ofits readers. Still, I can understand hoy its excellence may not have reached many who, on kno of its worth, would eagerly take it. I most readily, as follows, give my own certificate by of encouraging its circulation: It is edited and t topethe with great fearlessness, truth, tact and historical knowledge, There is always in it enough for present useful and interest ing reading; while it lays down lines of matter which will, in future time,make it eagerly sought after—in the same ws as is the Gentleman’s Magazine of England—by antiquariar and historian. Old volumes must become valuable. 4 I, unhesitatingly, say all this; and with my best wishes for and belief in the continued success of Tux Historioa Magazine while in your hands, q I remain, your friend, 3 CHARLES Epwarps. — XXXVIII.—From E. B. O'Cattacuan, LL.D, Author of History of New Netherlands, ete. ; and Editor of Documentary History of New York, Documents relating to the Colonial History of New York, etc. “— DEPARTMENT OF Histortcat Reoorns, be AxpBany, 14th October, 1867. jf Henry B. Dawson, Esq. Drar Srr: I have been a subscriber to Tuk Hrsrortoan Magazine from its birth; and have so continued through its vicissitudes. a? England has its Notes and Queries; France, her Interme= diare; Holland, its Navorscher ; and even Spain supports & similar periodical at Madrid. a The United States can and ought to support respectably a like publication, which has hitherto usefully served those engaged in Historical researches as a means of intercommt- nication; supplying, at the same time, Historical Documents _ not otherwise easy of access; and furnishing to all a neutral: ground where they can meet for mutual enlightenment and instruction, free from the acerbities of Politics and Polemics. As the merits of Tur Historioat MaGazine improve, 80 Iam satisfied will a industry and perseverance be re warded by a large subscription list, which is the sincere wish, Dear sir, 0 yours, most truly t or: E. B. O’CauLacian.. a — ;
Page 7
1867.] HISTORICAL MAGAZINE. 827 ES XXXIX.—From Wittiam L. Stone, Esq., Author of The Life of Sir William Johnson, and Hditor of The Letters aad Journals of the Baroness de Riedesel, etc. New York Crry, Sept. 30, 1867. My prar Mr. Dawson: Ihave your favor of the 28th asking my opinion of Tur Hisrorioan Macazingr, You say you wish me to answer frankly; and frankly I will try to reply. : I consider that it is, as at present conducted, an invalua- ble aid to every one of Literary and Historical tastes; one ‘that no person who desires to form correct opinions upon the historical events of the past and present days can safely be without. I have thought, at times, that its tone has been, perhaps, one of too mnch acerbity, and that the ink with which the Editor’s pen has been filled, has contained too great a pro- portion of gall. Still, in this age, which seems to be, par _ excellence, one of fulsome eulogy and flattery, this very char- acteristic may serve as a timely balance-wheel, or, to — the metaphor, as a wholesome correction to a false public sentiment. Wishing you success in your laudable endeavors, believe me, Cor y yours, Ws. L. Sronx. XL.—From Hon. Tuomas Ewsank, First Vice- President of the American Ethnological Society, —* Commissioner of Patents of the United New Yors, October t, 1867. My pear Sr: It ye me pleasure to hear of the continued encourage- ment Tug HisrortoaL Maaazrne receives under your man- agement. Your industry, learning, and acumen are shown in every number. The work increases in interest; and I trust the support of those engaged in Historical studies will enable you to prosecute your p with every advantage of BUCCESS. Yours truly, Tos, EwBanx. Henezr B. Dawson, Esq. XLI.—From Hon. Murtarp Firtmore, President of the Buffalo Historical Society, late President of the United States. Burrato, Oct. 8 1867. Mr. Henny B. Dawson: Dear Str: I have your note of yesterday requesting my opinion of Tur Histortoatn Mag@azine, and I take great pleasure in stating that I have the work from its commence- ment, and although I take several periodicals, there is none that I read with more pleasure and satisfaction than this. I regard it as avery useful publication, and should be happy to see its circulation = ruly yours, Mitiarp FIiuMmore. XLII.—From Doctor D. G. Brinton, the cele- brated Lthnologist. With the number for July commences the twelfth annual volume of this most interesti#g and valuable periodical. We doubt not many of our readers are familiar with it, and those who are not, and who take any interest in the History or An- tiquities of their country, we earnestly counsel them to be- come so at once by sending in their names as subscribers. For many years it has been the chief and oy repository of erican Historical and Antiquarian knowledge. Bancroft verett, fei Parkman, Shea, Schoolcraft, and nigh all the other distinguished writers on such topics have been con- tributors to previous volumes; and we venture nothing in saying that now ne one can claim to be acquainted with the ast of our country, who has not long and closely consulted pages. Its present Editor is well known for his uncom- binge on: impartiality and minute accuracy in the search for istorical truth, and we need not fear for its continued excel« lence in his hands. (In the Medical and Surgical Reporter, for June 29,1867. XLII.—From Rev. Howarp Matcom, D.D., President of The American Baptist Historical Society. Amerioan Bartist Htsrorioar Soorerty, PHLADELPHIA, Feb. 16, 1867, Dear Sir: ; No other periodical which comes under my notice can be relied on for honest notices of new publications. I rejoice that you dare to be singular. Your fellow laborer, Howarp Matcom, XLIV.—From Horatio Gatss Jonss, Hsq., Vice- President of the Pennsylvania Historical Society, etc, Puritapetruia, August, 1867, I have been a subscriber to and a constant reader of Tn HistorroaL Macazine from its commencement; and I regard its continuance as of great value to all who are interested in the History of America, As a means ofintercommunication, it is of the highest importance to historical students. Horatio Gates JONES, XLV.—/rom Hon. Brantz Mayer, President of the Maryland Historical Society. Battiuore, 19th August, 1867. My pEak Sir: I have been a subscriber to Tue HistortoaL Magazine since its commencement, and prize the whole series very much, though a part of it was not equal to the promise of the beginning. But I must especially thank you not only for the revival of the Magazine’s high character, but for the ad- ditional interest and permanent value of the papers you are now rescuing from destruction. The original articles con- tributed by yourself and your industrious corresponden by your brave and candid criticisms, have given force an authority to the Magazine; and 1 cannot doubt that it will continue to receive a prompt and remunerative support from the students of local and national History, who are so greatly your debtors. Most respectfully, your obt., Brantz Mayer, President of Maryland Historical Society. XLVI.—From Grorce Grsss, Esq., the well- known Ethnologist, Author of Memoirs of the Administration of Washington and John Adams, etc. Wasuineton, 24th Aug. 1867. H. B. Dawson, Esq. : Dear Sim: I am very glad to hear that = are about to push vigorous~ ly your periodical. Ithas always been a vaiuable one: it may be made invaluable. Very few even of our historical and literary students, comparatively speaking, are, I imagine, aware of the facilities that it affords for an extensive corres pondence; that in a few brief lines of inquiry one can reach thousands of persons, some of whom can probably throw light on the desired point; or that itis an admirable re- ceptazle where may be preserved detached facts. t often occurs to every student to stumble upon important statements or incidents, not in themselves warranting an es- say, or perhaps himself indifferent to the production of one, but none the less valuable to have preserved somewhere. In these two respects, independent of its record, it has no com- petitor in this country, and for these alone it deserves sup- port. . ; _ Very truly yours, GEORGE Gibbs,
Page 8
828 HISTORICAL XLVIL.—From Rev. Wiii1AM STEVENS PERRY, Clerk of the House of Clerical and Lay Dele- gates of the General Convention of the Pro- testant Episcopal Church in America. LirouFiecp, Ct., Oct. 21 67 My prar Mr. Dawson: Yours of the 7th came during my absence from home and Itake great pleasure in acknowledging its receipt at the earliest possible moment. For the variety and value of its articles, Taz Histortoan Magazine deserves the hearty and united support of all in- terested in historical studies. Under its present management, each number adds to the permanent value of the series, and no one who would keep up with the progress of his- torical investigation can afford to be without it. With the assurance of my hearty regard and sympathy, Tam Very truly Yours Wititam Stevens Perry. Henry B. Dawson, Esq. Mogrrisania, New York. XLVII.—From B. H. Hat, Hsqg., Author of The History of Eastern Vermont. Troy, N. Y., Oct., 17, 1867. My prar Sir: Iam in receipt of yours of the 7th inst, and at my earliest leisure have much pleasure in returning areply. I have been a subscriber for the Hisror10aAL Magazine since its begin- ing, and have received more general satisfaction from its ga than from any periodical I have taken in, during its e. The necessity for such a Magazine was very apparent to my mind when the Histozricat was undertaken, and that ne- cessity not only continues but has increased ten fold. - When the January number appeared, in 1857, we as a na- tion had made, comparatively, but very little history. Since that time, in ten years, we have filled a page in the History of the World, which will be forever turned and read by ail mankind. The little incidents, which are the unintentional but certain manifestation of men's motives, and which strewn along the pathway of this rebellion lie allungathered, are in the future to be collected, and in this work Tux His- TORIOAL Maq@azinz should properly take the foremost place. _ in the treatment and discussion of Historical matters, fairess of statement, and a regard to the time, the circum- stances, and toreason in reaching a conclusion, are absolute- ly necessary. During the greater portion of its career such a course has prevailed in the pages of Tur Hisrortoan Maga- ZINE; and a continuation in this course cannot but be re- warded with abundant success. If I can’be of service to you in tire 3 the circulation of the Magazine, I shall be glad to assist in this particular, and am ery respectfully as B. H. Hatt. XLIX.—From S. §. Ranpant, LL. D. Super- intendant of Public Instruction in the City of New York. New York, Oct., 21. 1867. My prar Sr: Permit me, as a subscriber and constant reader of your Magazine, to express my high appreciation of the ability with which it has uninformly been conducted while under your editorial supervision; and of the value and importance of its contributions to the past and present history of our Country. Yours very truly, 8S. S. Ranpa.u, H. B. Dawson, Esq., L.—From Major-general Joun E. Woot, U.S.A. Troy, 1ith November, 1867. My pear Sir: Some time since I received the back numbers of your His- ‘“TORIOAL Magazine. TheseI have perused with great inte are in the search of the truth in regard to disputed pointsi MAGAZINE. [Novemk r, They prove what has been frequently asserted that it requires many years to arrive at the truth of history. The many re miniscences and letters which your Hisroz1oan Magazm contains, relating to those who occupied positions and rendered important services during the period of our lutionary struggle, prove conclusively that we have yet muc to learn of those who offered * their lives, beh te 0 “‘ their sacred honor,” to secure freedom and independenes to the people of the United States ‘ “ay A periodical, the object of which is to maintain and secur the truth of history, deserves to be encouraged by all wh desire the correction of historical errors and the interst ce. of history to be filled, and, above all else, the history of th causes which led to the recent bloody rebellion the en of which is not yet. The pillars of our once prosperou Union are crumbling. Ten States have been decla out of the Union and pees under Military rule. How lo will it be before the thirty-six States are placed in a simili position ? Very Truly Yours a Joun E. Woon Henry B. Dawsoy, Esq., : Br Editor of Taz Historica Magazine. LI.—From Hon. Wiu1t1AM B. REep. Author ¢ The Life of President Reed, etc., and recent Minister of the United States to China. Puitapveiruta, Noy. 8. 1867. My pear Sir: SS Permit me to add my testimony to that of many bette witnesses to the value of your Magazine. You know ver well how highlyI estimate it. As an editor and historogn pher you are honest and more than that, brave. Social influ ences do not controul you; and even in your Anti-New-Ez land tendencies, which I admit should not be carried too fal and of which some of your friends complain, you show cot age. I sincerely wish you all manner of success. a Verv truly yr . ‘ Wit11aM B. Reep, H. B. Dawson Esq. ot mh i 6 LI.—From Professor Wiiitam C. Fowser, Lb. D. Author of History of Durham, Sectiona Controversy, ect. ‘a Dvuruam Center, Conn. Oct. 19, 1867. H. B. Dawson Esq,, Dear Ferenp: ¥ * * * * * * 4 The periodical arrival of the Histrortoat MAGAZINE: always welcomed, freighted as it is with facts which wou be lost, many of them, if not recorded in ap = bill of lad In your own reasonings, speculations, and descriptions, yo furnish proof that the muse of history is your muse, ins ing you with her own love of truth. Very Sincerely, yours, W. C. Fow me ‘Re > a ied LIl.—From Doctor Tuomas H. Wynne, Edi of The Wendover Papers, etc. Rroumonp Va., Noy. 3. 1867. “<4 e 7 , ’ 2 hi ws My prar Sir: Ihave read every number of the Hisror1oau Ma@az which has been issued since the war with an amount of sath faction and pleasure which I do not enjoy in the perusal any other Journal. So faras it is possible, it seems to be¢ ited with a degree of fairness towards all persons and part of whom it treats, and evidently aims to assist those wh our country’s ery 4 Wishing you and it all possible success, I am “ Very truly ‘ ‘'aomas H. Wynne.
Page 9
1867.] HISTORICAL MAGAZINE. 829 What the Press Says. L—From Tur Press of Maine. 4.—Some very instructive excerpts of a fragmentary eort, 1.—Established first as a medium of intercommunication between historical students and scholars interested in the Antiquities, History, and Biography of our Country, it has come to be a necessity, and we are glad to learn that its subscription list is largely increasing. In its pages will be found a large amount of information, upon the neglected, though important points, of American History an Anti- quities, Biographies of eminent Americans, &c.—Maine Farmer (Independent), Augusta, March 21, 1867. 2.—We have perused it with much interest, and commend M to the attention of those who take an interest in the Anti- 2 piesa History, and Biography of America.—Daily Eastern rgus (Democratic), Portland, August 27, 1867. 3.—It continues to show the marked improvement in in- terest and value which has characterized it since it came into the hands of the present Editor.—The Portland Daily Press (Republican), August ?4, 1867. 4,—The Historical rig. eee for February contains a great amount of interesting historical and antiquarian Lae together with the usual Notes and Queries. * * * This Magazine is a valuable publicatjon, and should receive the hearty WF te of all interested in historical pursuits. It is well conducted, = we notice that its Editor seems to have a spite against Massachusetts, and is disposed to go out of his way to gratify it.—Portland Transcript (Republi- ean), March 16, 1867. 5.—We find it full of interesting matter.— Waterville Mail (Republican), Waterville, Aug. 30th, 1867. 6.—This Magazine belonss to no party nor clique, but aims to be just to all without fearing any, which is the onl way to conduct any periodical. Zhe Evening Star (Republi- can), Portland, Aug. 30th, 1867. 7.—This Magazine is of peculiar interest to the Antiquarian. To those who would know the History of America, its Anti- quities,and other points of interest,it is indispensable—Zven- tng Journal (Republican), Lewiston, August 28, 1867. IIl.—#rom TuE..Press, of New Hampshire. 1.—Mr. Dawson has had the editorial charge of the Magazine for the past year, and has conducted it with equal ability and independence.. We say, independence, because that quality is required in managing such a periodical as well as in those of an unhistorical character. Members of the New Hamp- shire Historical Society should have it.—Nashua Gazette (Democratic), June 12, 1867. 2.—It contains much valuable historical reading, and is well conducted. It preserves many historical papers of value that would otherwise be buried in oblivion.—Portsmouth Journal (Republican), August 31st, 1867. Ill.—From the Press in Massachusetts. 1.—The Magazine contains much interesting and valuable matter relating to early American history.—The Daily Spy (Republican), Worcester, Sept. 17, 1866. 2.—Mr. Dawson is placing on permanent record in this Magazine a mass of perishable material relating to Ameri- can annals, which without the thoughtful care he has exer- eised would soon be utterly lost.—The same paper, Worcester, October 27, 1866. 3.—Tuer Histortoan Magazine always has a valuable table of contents, but the pleasure we should otherwise take in its agian is greatly marred by the anti-North, or more especial- y, anti-Massachusetts tone which pervades it. The Editor’s bitterness toward Boston betrays singular weakness, and the Preface to its last volume is in exceedingly poor taste.* With these exceptions we esteem the Magazine highly, and are always repaid for reading it.—The Congregationalist (Orthodox), Boston, March 1, 1867. * In that Preface we referred to the repudiation of their debts by some of the bap yon | men in Massachusetts, Poca the Magazine had ceased to flatter Boston = Massachusetts. THESE DEBTS HAVE SINCE BEEN PAL, with here and ther exception.—Ep. Hist. Maa, ; rg and some more elaborate and exhaustive pieces of historic interest fill up the number of the Magazine before us. It is evident that many diligent fe are engaged in providin for the ménthly contents of these pages, which are mos sure to engage the gratitude of readers the more free they are from especial pleading in behalf of the wrong side of our living politics.—The Evening Transcript (Radical), Boston, Novy. 30, 1866. : 5.—* * Thissketch of the contents ofthis single number will convey to our readers some idea of the quality of the Magazine, which, albeit, sometimes to our taste, over eee’ and scarcely fair in some directions, has yet a recogs nized, and, indeed, unique value, in our literature.—The Con- gregationalist and Recorder (Orthodox Congregational) Aug. 30, 1867. 6.—The enterprising and very able Editor of Tur Hisrorr- OAL MaGazine has given us the memorable sermon of Rev. John Wheelright, one of the ministers of New England in its earliest history. In so doing he has conferred a great obliga- tion not only upon the historical public, but especially as it enables us to see more clearly the grounds of the great Anti- nomian contention, which so agitated and rent the Churches of Boston and its vicinity. ] 2 * 2 e oy * a @ We greatly regret that we are obliged to omit Mr. Daw- son’s learned Introduction which fastens severe censure on Winthrop and his party. —Zhe Panoplist (Religious), Boston, July, 1867. 7.—Tue Histortoat Magazine is nowin able and accom- plished editorial hands, in correspondence with the best his- torical writers in all parts of our country, and conducted as it will be without any taint of partisanship, it is of the first value to every historical scholar and student.— Watchman and Reflector (Baptist), Boston, May 9, 1867. 8.—This valuable periodical has again passed into the hands of Henry B. Dawson, as Editor and Proprietor. Its speciality is the discussion of topics relating to the History, Antiquities, Biography, and Standard Literature of America. In carrying out this, it publishes much that is interesting, curious, rare, and vsluable, and which is not easily to be gaa in any other source.—Roxbury Journal, Sept. 15, 9.—This Magazine contains much valuable historical reading, and is well conducted. It preserves many histori- cal papers of value that would otherwise be buried in ob- livion.—7'he Salem Gazette (Republican), August 27, 1867. IV.—rom Tux Press of Rhode Island. 1.—This Magazine cannot fail to please a large circle of readers.—Newport (R. 1.) Daily News, Oct. 26, 1866. 2.—We have perused its contents with great interest and pleasure.—Providence Press, Sept. 15, 1866. V.—From Tur Press of Connecticut. 1.—If rightfully conducted, (and it seems to be now) it can- not but form an addition to the Magazine literature of the world.—New Haven Palladium (Republican), Aug. 18, 1866. 2.—The Historical Magazine, as usual, is full of interesting matier.—The same, Jan, 26, 1867. 3,—This Magazine fills a very valuable place in onr current: literature, and deserves a generous support. It is calculated to achieve a very wide circulation. Americans care too little for History; and this fact makes it the more incumbent on those who properly appreciate the value of a periodical devo- ted to so important a subject, to properly sustain its Editor in his conscientious and successful efforts to make a valuable historical magazine.—The same, Sept. 27, 1867. 4.—As we have before said, this work has a field unoccupied by others, and is eg | good service by placing on record. waifs of History and Biography, which otherwise would be rn ira Farmer (Democratic), Bridgeport, Nov. 12, 5.—The Magazine is of great value to all interested in histo- oo antiquities.—Bulletin (Republican), Norwich, Sept. 17,
Page 10
- 330 6.—It is fall of very interesting matter relative to our earlier history.—The same, Feb. 19, 1867. 7.—Of the usual interest to delvers into old historical matters.—T'he same, Mar, 28, 1867. 8.—The Historical Magazine, under the editorship of Mr. Henry B. Dawson, brings together a great deal that is curi- ous and interesting to historical students. The Notes and a are the most entertaining part of the Magazine.— vening Press (Republican), Hartford, Oct. 31, 1866, 9.—The Historical Magazine for December is a readable number, filled with matter that will attract the attention ofall historical students, with very much in it of popular interest. —The same, Jan. 24, 1866. 10.—The industrious Editor of The Historical Magazine con- stantly digs up interesting material and makes each number lively and readable.—Zhe same, Mar. 8, 1867. 11.—The contents of The Historical Magazine for March willinterest and “stir up”as many people as its issue usually does. * * * The Magazine shows continued industry.— The same, Mar. 26, 1867. 12.—Its Notes and Queries concerning the cine eon ‘History and Biography of America are always interesting an valuable for future reference, and show a large amount of able and patient research. — Daily Courant (Republican), Hartford, November 24, 1866. ViL.—From Tue Press of New York. 1—The Historical Magazine, under its new Editor, Mr. Henry B. Dawson, shows unwonted — The Angust number, which has just apyceres. is especially. interesting and valuable.—N. Y. Daily Tribune (Radical), Sept. 18, 1866. 2.—The Historical Magazine for July contains numerous articles of antiquarian and historical interest, combined with frequent incidental political discussions and allusions, strongly reflecting the personality of the Editor, who is a zealous advocate of the theory of State Sovereignty.*—The same paper, Aug. 24, 1867. 8.—Full of matter that will be regarded as valuable by an- tiquarians and historical students.—Hvening Post (Republi- can), New York, Sept. 18, 1866. 4.—The Historical Magazine has for its second title “‘ Notes ‘and Queries,” but in its general character has more merits than the English journal of that name, dealing less in triv- ial matters, and giving better considered and more impor- tant papers. It isan excellent Magazine, and is necessary to the student of history.—Day k (Ultra~Democratici, New York, Oct. 6, 1866. ' §.—The Historical Magazine is a serial of much value and _ little pretence, and is an absolute necessity for the literary table.—The same, Dec. 22, 1866. 3 6.—The January number is beyond donbt a “ golden num- ber. ” LJ . J e e e * ® ; e a e e e Following Brodhead’s article, we have a reply by the Edi- tor to some strictures of The Boston Transcript, which is less a dissection than a flaying of the subject—a flaying in which a considerable portion of the flesh is taken from the bones of the victim, leaving him writhing in terrorem.—The same. Mar. 23, 1867. 7.—Mr. Dawson’s Magazine is worthy of the support and confidence of students of American history. There is no substitute for it.—The same, June 15, 1867. 8.—A more useful, interesting, and truly valuable Magazine is not te be found either in Europe or Ameri~a. Its editor is Henry B. Dawson, Esq. so long, well, and favorably known to his fellow-citizens of this town and to the public at large, as a gentleman and scholar. * * *We cordially recommend it so the patronage of an enlightened and discriminating pub- lic.-- Westchester Journal [Democratic], Morrisania, Feb. 16th 1867. 9.—Mr. Dawson is an indefatigable worker in the depart- ment of history to which he has devoted so large a share of his life; and we cannot doubt the readers of the early history of our country—and all should be readers and students of it—will find this Magazine a mine of most valuable information.— _ Peekshill Messenger [Republican], Feb. 2d, 1867. * Vide Revised Statutes, Part I, Chap. I, Title Il, Sec. 1, 2, 8—Fourth Edition, i77.—Ed. Hist. Maa. HISTORICAL MAGAZINE. a id [November, my ¥ . 10.—The Boston Transcript is not pleased with Mr. Da 80n’s Historical Magazine. * * * The trouble with the Mage azine seems to be that it has mistaken the object of histe and conceived it to be to throw dirt at Massachusetts—@ Commonwealth that can stand the operation serrer x ANY OTHER STATE ON TUE GLOBE, and much better than the Editor of the Magazine.—Daily Union [Radical], Brooklyn, Feb. 25th, 1867. a 11.—The Historical Magazine, under the editorial direction of Mr. Henry B. Dawson, is filling an important place in pes riodical literature.—Daily Eagle [Democratic], Brooklya, July 16th, 1867. 4 12.—Its great forte is the correction of History and the fare nishing of Documentary evidence elucidating historical states” ments. Mr. Dawson is a careful writer, and is well “post. “‘ed,” as the phrase goes, in American History.—Daily Gi Press, Newburgh, Aug. 7, 1866. 13.—It contains matter very important to all who would have correct knowledge of the History of our Country,— Troy Press, Aug. 11, 1866. - 14.—We advise all who are interested in Antiquities to take it.—Journal, Fishkill, Oct. 18, 1866. “a 15.—The Historical Magazine, under the editorship of Mr, Henry B. Dawson, increases in interest with every number, Mr. Dawson is perfectly at home in historical matters, and considers anything in that line as a labor of love. He cot not fail, therefore, to infuse new life into The Historical Mag azine, The first number issued under his superintendence, evinced the presence of a new and experienced hand in the chair editorial, and in each succeeding number the intere: has been kept up. The Historical Magazine should have a place in every library.—Yonkers Gdzette (Democratic) Nov. 8, 1866. ae 16.—This Magazine is now edited by Mr. Henry B. Daw. son, who has made this —— line of literature his stud for years, and has gained a high reputation for his historica researches. * * The Magazine deserves success, ai should be in every scholar’s library.— Yonkers Ste [Republican], Nov. 22, 1866. * 17.—It shows the industry and research for which the Ed- itor is remarkable. * * The number altogether recom- mends itself to the student of American History.—The same, Jan. 31, 1867, ‘ 18.—There are few if any persons living better qualified every way for the compilation and editorship of such a mage azine, thanis Mr. Dawson. The subject of History has bhecn his study for years, and he has consequently become perfectly conversant with orecr ae in connection there. with. f his own article he fearlessly tells the truth about men woe their acts, though to do so may to some seem irreve eren ra The Magazine itself is worthy the oe of all lovers 0 History; and we believe that none of this numerous would be without it if wy & could peruse the number befo us.— Westchester Times (Republican), Morrisania, Feb. 15, 1867. . e 19.—No student of History should be without this work. Its researches are truly wonderful.—The same, Aug, 23, 1867, Bi 20.—From the appearance and contents of the July num- ber, which is before us, we have formed a high opinion of it character and value.—Christian Enquirer (Unitarian), N ij York, Sept. 6th, 1866, 1 21.—This Magazine contains a great deal of curious, vale able, and interesting matter; and in the rich but almost neglected field of American Antiquities is a gleaner whose monthly sh: af is more than welcome.—The same, Sept, 20th, 1866. —_— “aa 22.—The Historical Magazine is now under the editorship of Mr. Henry B. Dawson, than whom no one is more competen tor such atask. It appears in the handsomest typography, and its contents, which are exactly the sort for which the never any place in a daily newspaper, are in their kind, fresh and interesting to a degree never reached in former numbers of that old and valuable periodical.—Daily World (Demos: cratic), New York Nov. 3d. 1866. a 23.—Bancroft is skinned alive and likewise grilled in the June number of The Historical Mayazine, which periodica Mr. Vawson makes as readable as a daily newspaper,
Page 11
to 1867.] HISTORICAL MAGAZINE. 831. ee ee treating the dead as if they had once lived, and were of flesh nd blood and human passions, and by treating the living, who ought to be dead, in a way that must assist them in the discharge of that duty.—The same, NewYork, July 23d, 1867. 24.—Under Mr. Dawson’s judicious management this pub- lication has greatly increased in interest.—Journal of Com- merce, (Commercial), New York, Oct. 30th, 1866. 25.—It is a well-conducted monthly o gadege devoted to the exposition of the Antiquities, History, and Biogra- hy of America. It lately passed back under the control of Jenry B. Dawson of Morrisania, With him are associated many writers of eminence, who have the ability to render this magazine very useful to the progress of historic re- search. It is handsomely gotten up, and each number con- tains a large amount of curious and interesting mutter.— Christian Intelligencer, (Ref. Dutch) New York, Nov. 1st 26.—The Historical Magazine edited by Henry B. Dawson, Esq., has a peculiar value, and is entitled to the particular patronage of that large public which is interested in histori- inquiries.—Z'he Same, Aug. Ist, 1867. 27.—It is full of interest and variety.—Episcopalian, w%.~This is a very interesting and valuable periodical, and Jne wiich must find an entrance to every library.—The Sunday Mercury, New York, Feb, 3d. 1867. 29.—This important periodical, which is devoted to the col- lection and preservation of the Antiquities, History, and Biography of our country, has recently passed into the hands of Henry B. Dawson, Esq., who is devoting himself to its in- terests with all the enthusiasm of a genuine antiquary. The volume which was closed with the December number, has many original historical papers of great importance, which but for this channel would probably have perished. The Magazine is one which, for the apetrs interests of National Literature and History, should be sustained by the _— and the subscriptions of men of letters. —Observer, (Presbyterian) New York, Feb. 7th, 1867. 80.—The publication now commences its eleventh year with a new series ; and the lovers of true History and valuable An- tiquities will do well to subscribe at once.—American Bap- tist, New York, Feb. 19th, 1867. 31.—It is a valuable publication, and shows great research. “slag Field and Farm, (Sporting), New York, March 30, 867. 32.—A very useful, and, we are glad to learn, pecuniarily successful work.—Daily Times, (Republican), Jan. 21st, 1867. 33.—The I .rof The Historical Magazine. Mr. Dawson, of Federalist mciaory, is displaying a good deal of enterprise In making that publication a repository of things rare and curious. He is exhuming from their archives ancient docu- ments which throw new light on the history of the past.— Evangelist, (Presbyterian) New York, May 23d, 1867. 84.—The Magazine is well worthy of an extended tronage. The Editor has some theories not very gener- ally shared by the community, but he gives every party a fair hearing, and succeeds in bringing together a large mass of curious and valuable historical material from a great variety of sources .—T'he same paper, Sept. 5, 1867. 85.—This Magazine contains much curious and valuable information.—Protestant Churchman, (Episcopalian), New York, July 18, 1867. 36.—-It shows the careful and enterprising editorship of Mr. Henry B. Dawson. The number contains many very valuable papers, and a mass of interesting facts.—Com- ~ gag Advertiser, (Republican), New York City, Aug. 23, 867. ; 37.—This Magazine very faithfully adheres to its own speciality, which, however, is a subject of such extent and variety that there is no danger of necessary sameness in its matter. The Editor is not at all deficient of positive opin- jons nor of the courage to assert and maintain them. It is a publication that evinces real ability. * * * Altogether the Magazine is a work thit no one who is interested in American History can afford to do without.—The Christian Advocate, (Methodist Episcopal), Aug. 29, 1867. 88.—It is difficult to estimate too highly the histore ical value of many of the original documents gathered up from unexpected quarters and preserved from oblivion in the pages of this Magazine, To those who desire to acquire a.correct knowledge of facts relating to the early history of ‘the country without taking the trouble of consulting old authorities and musty volumes, to those who find amuse- ment in contrasting the homely dwelling-places and famil- iar haunts of their forefathers with the changed aspects wrought in these localities by wealth and civilization, and to others whose pride of family leads them to find grati- fication in seeing the names of their progenitors honorably mentioned in records dating back two centuries ago, the resent work will prove an inferesting repertory, which will ecome every year more valuable. * * * The selections are carefully made, and there is a mass of information col- lected in this work which maj be referred to in after times by all who seek for archelogical information about persons places, and things belonging to New York.—The Row Table (Bibliographical), New York City, Aug. 31, 1867. 33.—It is now a valuable repository of many original papers, printed for the first time, and of articles and notes relating to disputed points in the history of this country that tind no place so proper elsewhere.—The Nation, (Ree publican), New York, January 31st, 1867. 40.—The contents will compare favorably with those of any other publication ofits class in the country.—Daily Register, Hudson, Aug. 6 1866. ‘VIL.—From the PamApELPHIAN Press. 1.—It especially recommends itself to those who take an interest in our own country’s past history.—Philadelphia Inquirer, August 13, 1866. 2.—One of the most useful of American publications. * ® It contains a large amount of most interesting, curious, and rare information. It is a Magazine which should be sub- scribed for by every scholar and gentleman of literary attain- ments.—Sunday Dispatch, (Literary) edited by Thompson Wesco t, Esq., the Historian, February 17, 1867. 8.—It is one of the best, most useful, and instructive periodicals issued in this country.—The same paper, Sept. 21, 1867. 4.—We are glad to call the attention of those of our readers, who take an interest in such matters, to this valuable eriodical. Itis, by all odds, the best publication of the ind that has appeared in this country, more nearly re- sembling, in a single department, the English Notes and Queries, than any other. It appears monthly. Its Editor, Mr. Henry B. Dawson of Morrisania, is a thorough master of the details of American History, and entirely free from those social and political influences which have twisted the judgment of many astudent. Ifhe encounters a stubborn, well-attested fact, he givesit. Heis entirely catholic in his judgment; and, best of all, he is absolutely free from the wretched New England influence which has done so much and will, ifnot checked, do more, to poison the wells of historic Trath.—The Age (Democratic), Philadelphia, March 16, 1867. 5.—One of the most interesting publications of the day is Tux Hisrontoa, Magazine. ~ * Itis a handsome square octavo, of sixty-four pages, and the typography is all that could be desired by the most fastidious. Henry B. Dawson is the Kditor, and strives with his utmost power to make the | Magazine acceptable to its patrons. Such a work cannot be too widely extended, when the small price of the annual subscription—five dollars—is considered. We commend it to all who have any interest in American History.—The Daily Press, edited by Col. J. W. Forney (Republican), Philadelphia, March 26tb, 1867. VIII. From the Soutrnern Press. 3 1.—This monthly is specially valuable as discussing and settling questionable statements that may have become cure rentas History. While dealing with subjects that may not attract popalar attention, it must, ifit fulfils its peculiar mis- sion, be regarded as a valuable Periodical among literary ersons. It is very difficult to make such a Magazine what tought to be. e wish it abundant success in its laudable labors in behalf of Trath. Christian Advocate, (Methodist) Richmond, August 23d, 1866,
Page 12
332 HISTORICAL 2.—The December number is on our table, so beautifully printed that the very types seem to say, “ Read,” ‘* Read.” * * * The other articles have interest ; and there is many a dainty morsel for bookworms scattered through its pages.—7'he same, January 31st, 1867. 3.—It is indispensable to all historical students.—T7he same, August 15th, 1867. 4.—We have no hesitation in strongly recommending this Magazine to our readers. It 1s always full of information that cannot be got elsewhere, and it is of an impartial and honest tone that is wholly relieved of sectionalism and prej- udice. We know of no Northern publication more fair to- ‘ward all parts of the country than this. It is a high ascrip- tion of praise to say this in these days of partisan and sec- tional malignity.—Daily Haaminer, (Democratic), Rich- mond, September 18th, 1866. 5.—This Journal being National in its character and pat- riotic in its spirit, and with an eye single to Truth in all its investigations, is entitled to the patronage of all who desire to see the scattered fragments of our History garn- = up and preserved.—7’he same paper, February 19th, 6.—In the notices of new publications the Editor deals se- verely but justly and fearlessly. This sterling Magazine is admirably conducted, and it should be patronized by every one who feels the least interest in his country’s history.— The Same, June 12th, 1867. 7.—An admirable periodical. We with pleasure recom- mend it to the Public, and to Southern readers in particular. * * The design and scope of the work are admirable ; and it seems to be edited with industry and discriminating ability.—Daily Enquirer, (Democratic), Richmond, Septem- ber 20th, 1866. 8:—It pleases us. We like its style of getting ae Many of its papers are selected, and prepared from rare historical volumes and manuscripts, and evince care and research. * The design of this Magazine is good. Its numbers are not only worth reading as they are issued, but valuable to file.— a ond Iireside (Literary), Raleigh, N. C., September 9 * 9.—An able and highly valuable periodical. * * The American public owes to Mr. Moore and to Mr. Dawson, the trenchant and most vigilant Editor of this Magazine, its most grateful acknowledgments for their good services in the cause of Justice, History, and Truth—TZhe Mercury, Charleston, February, 1867. 10.—It is worthy of the support of all who are interested in historical truth ; and the Editor, Mr. Henry B. Dawson, is in every way admirably well yualitied for his position. — 7Z'he same paper, Sept. 4th, 1867. ,J1.—It makes valuable contributions to the historical literature of the age. It is not the organ of any party or clique, and deserves, we think, the most generous su port. * * * The Book Notices also are particularly clever, generally discriminating, and therefore a valuable feature of the Magazine.—Daily Enquirer and Examiner, Richmond, Va., August 26th, 1867. 12.—We have watched this periodical with great interes and have to express our high appreciation of the eminen judgment and general ability with which it is conducted. It deserves the warm support of all the friends of American [29° See next three pages for specimens of this work. a ay MAGAZINE. [November, 3 historical and antiquarian research; and no person a special interest in this department of knowledge can afford — to do without it. It seems to be managed with the greatest — independence, every subject entertained in its pages receiv- ing that calmness and carefulness of consideration which — belongs to historical research. We commend this Maga- — zine to the attention of all historical scholars in an especial~ — manner; and to all the cultivated public as well.—JVational — Intelligencer, Washington, D. C., September 16th, 1867, 13.—Tun Hrstortoat Macazrnz comes to us freighted with — its usual sterling variety of American History and Biog- — raphy. %. Me Dikwaen, the editor, is as indefatigable as he is judi- — cious and penetrating in his analysis. There are in the — present issue no less than eighteen different captions, rep- resenting as many different topics, and these in their turn, representing almost as many different sections of country, — all of which appeal, in interest, more or less to the nation at 2 large. We repeat our recommendations to the students of — American history, by all means to possess themselves of this _ valuable periodical.—Charieston (S. C.) Courier. on 14.—Tur Histortoar Mag@azrne, conducted by Henry B, qi Dawson, of New York, is a monthly, comprising notes and — ueries concerning the antiquities, history and biography of merica. This book is essential to the statesman, the poli- — tician, and the historical student. Its collection, already — made, of American materials, ancient records, documents, — correspondence, etc., is of singular value. Its editor,Mrn Dawson, has orn distinguished himself as an antiquarian and historical critic, and, with a dissecting process wholly — his own, not forbearing the pars pig knife and tomahaw has served up a goodly host of the humbugs in our prere % who, under false pretences and by the trickeries of ce ae sections, have acquired a celebrity and a reputation forgood — a ee ny of which they were wholly innocent. It is — elightful to see how deftly he can strip the barn door fowl = Py its peacock feathers.—Southern Society, Baltimore, — Addenda. : ‘ 1.—The good opinions that have greeted Tum Histortcan — Magazine from learned societies and scholars all over the — country, are familiar to all who have taken even a moderate — interest in the details of American history. The nation’s history is crowded with events from its earliest days; ithas run through a period so marked by strong opinions, free in- _ telligent criticism of men and ideas, and with these such © novel governmental problems have been in process of solu- tion, that the documents illustrative of this history deserve — most careful preservation. The collation of these docu- — ments, so as to display conflicting opinions with fairness, is — the chief duty of an’ Historical Magazine. Mr. Henry B. ~ Dawson, of Morrisania, who assumed the charge of the — Magazine with the new series, is a gentleman whose schol- — arly acquirements and candor are unquestioned.—Zast © Brooklyn Gazette. November, 1867. rt 2.—We have read a large majority of the articles and find — them of exceeding interest, discussing, as do their authors, — subjects not only of the past but of the present. Such a — magazine isof great value, not only in bringing to light the — occurrences of days gone by, but in setting right many con- © troverted poiuts. Historical students are great workersand — bene controversalists as well.— Brunswick (Me.) Te legraph, ‘ Fae, ctober 4, 1867.
Page 13
1867.] HISTORICAL MAGAZINE. 333 Camp; and that, until Washington had been for- mally invested with authority to ‘command the troops from Rhode Island, by Rhode Island’s own local authorities, he had less authority among them than any Corporal of their number. Yet such were the facts. Again: when General Greene would arrest David Mathews, a prominent Loyalist of New York, he did not presume to do so, even by his own troops, until he had obtained a warrant for the arrest, from the local civil authorities ; yet the Author of this work sees nothing in that notable instance of his grandfather’s recognition of the supremacy of the civil over the military power, even in the midst of a war, as worthy of a syl- lable of comment, notwithstanding he is very profuse in his admiration of what, in the same case, he regards as ‘‘ the domination of the strong **hand and absolute will” of his ancestor. Very much stronger than ‘‘the strong hand,” in this instance, we submit, was General Greene’s im- plicit obedience to the Civil law, even when ~ seams with a public enemy, in time of Civil ar. We will mention only another instance—that, on page 193, in which the Author speaks of ‘‘ the ‘*Park, then open ground and frequently used ‘* for drill and parades,” on which the General is said to have first seen Hamilton; without indi- cating where that ‘‘Park” was. As New York City had not been referred to, for many pages, no one who was previously unacquainted with the facts would have suspected that that acquaintance was formed, if Professor Greene is correct, on what was then the Common, now ‘‘ the Park,” in New York City. We mention these as instances of the Author’s forgetfulness that the usefulness of his volumes may be greatly impaired by the omission of a very few lines, which are absolutely necessary to enable the general reader to understand the details of the narrative; and we venture to express a hope that this fault may be avoided in the vol- umes which are to foliow. The typography is very good; but a work ,of this importance, one would suppose, might have secured a steel-plate portrait of its subject, instead of an ordinary photograph. 6.—Military Hist of Ulysses 8S. Grant, from April, 1861, to April, 1865. y Adam Badean, Colonel and Aide- de-camp to the Genera -in-chief, Brevet Brigadier-general U.S. Army. VolumelI. New Y Com- pany. 1868. This volume is the first of a series in which only the professional career of General Grant is to ork : D. Appleton _. be noticed ; and it is from the pen of a member of his personal staff having the free use of all the correspondence and documents at Head-quar- ters and the War Department, including the + papers of the enemy which were captured at the close of hostilities. It brings the subject down to the promotion of Grant to the Lieutenant-general- ship ; and as it is issued with the General’s entire personal approbation, it may be considered as nearly Autobiographical. | The authority of this volume, under these cir- cumstances, as far as its relation of facts is con- cerned, cannot be disputed, even if the expressions of its Author’s judgment shall sometimes be open to dissent; and it will continue to be regarded through all time to come, as one of the leading authorities con¢erning the War of Secession. It is very beautifully printed, on good paper ; and the profuse use of authoritative Maps renders the text much more intelligible to the non-pro- fessional reader than is usually the case. %—History of the American Civil War. By John Wil- liam Draper, M.D., LL.D. In three volumes. Volume I. containing the Causes of the War, and the events prepara- some toit, up to the close of President Buchanan’s Adminis- tration. New York: Harper & Brothers, 1867. Octavo, pp. 567. Price $3.50. In this handsome volume, we have the first of a series in which the learned Author proposes to treat of the causes which led to the recent Civil War, and of the events connected with it, not, | he says, in a partisan, but in a philosophical and impartial spirit ; which every one will admit is as unusual as it is commendable. Although this volume is merely introductory, the learned Author unfolds in it the leading fea- . tures of his system ; and, except in his description and discussion of military affairs, we are already enabled to judge of the general course of his reasoning and the general character of his work. The Doctor maintains, for instance, that the History of the United States may be divided into three distinct Divisions, each relating to a distinct period of what he styles the ‘‘ American National ‘¢ Life’—the first concerning the period during which the leading feature was ‘‘an earnest ac- ‘* ceptance of the Idea of Political Unity ;” the second concerning the period in which was mani- fested a tendency to a ‘‘ Decomposition of the ‘¢ Nation which had arisen from that Idea, into ‘*two Geographical and Opposing Political pow- ‘ers, the North and the South, or the Free and ‘* the Slave; ” and the third concerning ‘‘ the Con- ‘* flict of those two Powers for Supremacy.” In ~ the volume before us, the Doctor discusses the first two of these subjects; and that of the third is left for the second and third volumes of the series. , In the consideration of this work it may be well to ascertain, Frrst, the standpoint from which the Author has surveyed the Past of our Country and undertaken to describe it, histori- cally—for this work claims to be a ‘‘ History of
Page 14
334 HISTORICAL MAGAZINE. [Novembe Tammany Socrety.—I find in the New York Daily Gazette, for May 12. 1790, the following item of intelligence: ‘* The Society of St. Tammany being a national ** Society, consists of Americans born, who fill ‘fall offices, and adopted Americans who are “eligible to the honorary posts of Warrior and ‘* Hunter. ‘Tt is founded on the true principles of Pat- ‘‘riotism, and has for its motives, charity and ‘** brotherly love. | ‘‘Tts officers consist of one Grand Sachem, ** twelve Sachems, one Treasurer, one Secretary, one’ ** Door-keeper; it is divided into thirteen tribes, “‘ which severally represent a State; each tribe is ‘governed by a Sachem the honorary posts in *¢ which are one warrior and one hunter.” Is this organization still kept up, in its original form? G. 8. U. Brooxiyn, New York. XXI.—REPLIES. THE HOMESTEAD OF ETHAN ALLEN (i. M., Il., ii, 177.) Norra BENNINGTON, VT., January 17, 1868. My Dear Sm: Referring me to page 177 of the September number of the Hisrortcan Maea- ZINE, you inquire if the statement is correct that ‘Ethan Allen's house is still standing in Benning- ‘ton Center? I answer it is not. I am quite sure Colonel Allen never owned a residence in Bennington, and I do not think his family ever lived in the tow n; if they ever cid it was but for a very short per iod. He came to Ben- nington about 1770, and spent most of his time here until he was made prisoner at Montreal, in September, 1775—his Bennington home being at the public house of Captain. Stephen Fay—his family remaining at Salisbury, Connecticut, or Sheftield, Massachusetts. In 1777, during his captivity, his family. removed to Sunderland, fifteen miles North of this town, near the residence of his brother, Ira Allen. Colonel Allen was exchanged in the spring of 1778, and from that time his residence is understood to have been in that town until 1787, when he went to live at Burlington, where he died on the tenth of Febru- ary, 1789. He built a housein Sunderland, which is snid to have been taken down about 1845. While superintending the publication of lis Oracles of Reason, in 1784, he spent some months, probably without his family, at the house of his friend, Joseph Fay, and was frequently there after- wards, until he moved to Burlington. From this circumstance the house of Mr. Fay has sometimes been spoken of as having been the residence of Colonel Allen. It is doubtless the house which a gave rise to the statement which has been noticed in your Magazine. It could, however, in no proper sense “have been called Colonel Allen's _ homestead. It was a first class house for the time and place of its erection—its length fronting the street, a wide hall through the center, one story high, with gambrel roof and dormer windows It is still standing in a dilapidated condition a turned into a tinner's shop. a The tavern-house of ‘‘ Landlord Fay,” some- times called ‘‘the Green Mountain Tavern,” which was Allen's headquarters previous to his” captivity, and the headquarters of the ‘‘ Green ‘* Mountain Boys,” in their contests with the ‘York , ‘fers,” as it was also of the Vermont Council of Safety, during the trying campaign of 1777, is still” standing at Bennington Center. It is a two story : house, some forty feet square, substantially built, but fast going to decay. Until within the pé st year, it has been used and occupied as a prive dwelling by descendants of the original proprie tor. I am, dear Sir, Very truly yours, TiiAND TALL. "i Henry B. Dawson, Esq., Editor HisTORICAL MAGAZINE. si Ay s ; Commopors Tucker.—In answer to the Query of J. W., in the HisrortcAL MAGAZINE of Janu- ary last (II., iii, 51), ‘* A Life of Commodore ‘¢Tucker,” is now in press, and will be published early in March. It will bea volume of three hun- dred and eighty-four pages, handsomely printed, and containing an account of the principal Battles and achievements of this hero of the Revolutic a, from authentic sources. J. H. Sm Boston, February 24, 1868. a Mr. SUMNER ON SENECA’Ss PROPHECY CONCER N : inc America. (H. MZ. U, ii, 192.) i, » Kast Greenwicn, R. I., January 27, 1868. a My Dear Dawson: I have not seen Doctor Hedge’s note to The Transcript, but Sumners article is before me, and Iam at a loss to undet stand the ground upon which the charge of ¢o t founding the two Senecas and mistr anslating the well-known lines of the Medea is founded. His words are—‘ Foremost among all those were t “‘well-known verses of the Spaniard, Senet i ‘¢the chorus of his Medea.” Now, as this is the only mention which hi makes of Seneca, and both the Senecas, father ane son, were natives of Cordova, in Spain, how ha he confounded the philosopher and the tragedian’ Iam equally at a loss to discover in what th z
Page 15
1887.] HISTORICAL I.—A LEAF OF MASSACHUSETTS HISTORY. PouriTans, INDIANS AND Dogs. **Ent dnoav kai kuynyectov avopamev e&n\be.”— Pruranon: Alexander. ** Cry Havock, and let slip the dogs of war.”—Suakrspzare. In 1656, John Eliot, the Apostle to the Indians, appealed to the Commissioners of the United Colo- nies for the appointment of some agents ‘‘in the ** Massachusetts to promote and forward the worke *“famong the Indians; both in respect of theire ‘** rourment & Incurriging meet [Instruments or their ** further healp and Instruction.” The Commission- ers, conceiving the said Indians to belong to the jurisdiction of the Massachusetts, referred the matter, with power, to the wisdom and care of that government. | The next topic of consideration is so graphical- y stated in the Act by which it was disposed of, as to need no further comment by way of intro- duction. The reader may refer it to any branch of the ‘‘ Indian worke” of that generation which he may ‘‘thinke meete.” vara W ERAS it was p'sented to the Co- ‘missioners by Mr hollihock of << Sprinkfield that Mastiffe Doggs might “bee of good vse against the Indians in “case of any desturbance from them which **they Reddily apprehending thought meet ““to comend the same to the seuerall “© Generall Courts to take care and make *‘prouision thereof accordingly.”—Ph- mouth Colony Records, x.,168 ; Hazard, ii., 359- A marginal notein the Plymouth Colony Records is—‘‘this to be propounded to our Court.” Doubtless the ‘‘severall Generall Courts” did act with due promptness and discretion in the prem- ises, but we find no traces in the published records of any separate action at that time. It had been the practice previously for the town au- at any rate not restricted to the particular towns. Whether the ‘* Zunt Serjeant” was the highest in command, when the ‘ hunt was up,” isa question which we are unable to solve, and must refer to those who have access to the original documents in the Archives of the State. We have heard Mr. Bancroft speak of having met with accounts of parties going out against the Indians, ‘‘ doubdle- “* dogged.” We have met with a Law of the Province ‘ con- *‘ cerning dogs,” which is interesting and perhaps unique in the history of American Legislation— although it may have its parallel in later provis- ions of Southern Codes for improvement of the 3 MAGAZINE. 335 means of hunting for fugitive slaves. It was passed at the October Session of the Great and Gen- eral Court, 1706 ; and appears among the printed Laws of that period. The first Act of the Session was ‘*‘ An Act for ‘* Maintaining and Propagating of Religion.” It re-inforced, by suitable enactments, the previous laws for securing to all the towns in the Province, an ‘‘able, learned and orthodox” ministry, with a view to rendering the said Laws:more effectual, thorities to procure hounds for the use and at the expense of the towns. The object was to improve all means for the destruction of wolves; and no dog could be kept without the approbation of the Selectmen, who were also authorized to quart- er the town dogs on any of the inhabitants they should choose, excepting Magistrates, who could keep dogs of their own or decline to board the public dogs, at their pleasure. | From the character of the proposition of ‘‘ Mr. ‘‘hollihock,” it is apparent that the use of their hounds against Indians, was a novelty in 1656— at any rate was not a general custom, however successful it might have been previously in private practice. There is no room for doubt, however, that the suggestion was ‘‘ improved,” or that these four-footed auxiliaries played an important part in the long Indian Wars which fill so much of the Colonial and Provincial history of the Country. The business was reduced to a system, and an organization is indicated, in subsequent legisla- tion, which employed officers whose jurisdiction appears to have been general in the Frontiers, or and ‘‘to prevent the growth of Atheism, Irrelig- ‘*¢jon and Prophaneness.” On the next page—barely separated from the foregoing by a brief Act to revive a former Statute to protect her Majesty's soldiers and seamen from Arrest for debt, etc—is the following : An Act for the Raising & Increase of Dogs, for the better Security of the Frontiers. WHEREAS upon Tryal lately made of Rangeing and Scouring the Woods on the Frontiers, with Hounds and other Dogs used to Hunting, It has proved of great Service to discourage and keep off the In- dians, For Encouragement therefore to Raise and Train up a greater number of Dogs, to be improved. Be it Lnacted by His Lreellency the Gobernour, Council and Wep=
Page 16
836 HISTORICAL MAGAZINE. [November, 1867. 4 THR: HISTORICAL MAGAZINE; . AND Notes and Queries GOnCeT INS the Antiquities, History and Biography of keri, Tuis Magazine was solatbada in January, 1857; fir the purpose of furnishing — a medium of intercommunication between Historical Socicti »s, Authors, and Students — of History, and supplying an interesting and valuable journal—a miscellany of Ameri- | can History. On the first of July, 1866, it-passed into the hands of the undersigned, — _ by whom it is still conducted, with the support and aid of a large body of ntligeai readers, and the assistance of the foremost historical writers in the county y- Among the contributors to the past volumes are Hon. Edward Everett, Hon. George Bancroft, Jared Sparks, LL.D., Hon. Peter Force, Hon. James Savage, Hon. ; Robert C. Winthrop, Wm. Gilmore Simms, Esq., Henry R. Stiles, M.D., Geo. Gibbs, — Esq., Hon. John R. Brodhead, J. Carson Brevoort, Ksq., Henry R. Schooler aft, Esq. Benson J. Lossing, Hsq., Hon. Henry C. Murphy, Samuel G. Dri ake, Esq., Sebastian — F. Streeter, Esq., Alfred B: Street, Hsq., E. B. O'Callaghan, LL.D., Prof. W. WwW. Turner, Buckingham Smith, Esq., Evert A. Duyckinck, Esq. i Brantz Mayer, ae Hon. John R. Bartlett, Samuel F. Haven, Esq., Dr. R. W. Gibbs, John W. Francis, — M.D., D. G. Brinton, M. D., George H. Moore, Esq., John G: Shea, LL.D., Rev. Hy — H. Gillette, D.D., John Ward Dean, Esq., Henry O'Reilly, Hsq., Rev. Pliny H. White, Hon. E. E. Bourne, and Hon. Thomas Ewbank. The eleven volumes already published contain an immense mass of matter relating to American History and kindred studies, such as cannot be found collected olewneaa rendering it a work absolutely necessary in all libraries. Few histerical works now- appear that do not acknowledge indebtedness to it. The Contents of the Historical Magazine may be generally classed under the following heads: I. Original Papers, involving points of research in historical studies, presenting — new facts, or the discussion of Federal and Local topics of interest, in ‘Essays, ya writers versed in American History. II. The Collection of Original Letters, Correspondence, Diaries, Xc., hitherto unpublished, of Americans of Eminence. III. Biographical and Obituary Notices of persons distinguished in the service of the country, whether in office, political life, literature, or science. IV. Accurate reports of the proceedings of the numerous American Historical, Antiquarian, Geographical, Numismatic, and other kindred Societies. V. Notes and Queries of curious and important topics, new and old, with replies, by a large body of contributors. VI. Reprints of rare and interesting Tracts, old Poems out of print, &c., &e. VII. Miscellany and Anecdotes. ‘a VIII. Carefully prepared and impartial Notices of New Books and Engravings especially those relating to the History, Antiquities, or Biography of America. | IX. Historical and Literary Intelligence, Announcements, Xc. The Historical Magazine is printed on fine quality of paper, similar in form andl size to this sheet, and published i in monthly numbers, of sixty-four pages each, at FIVE DOLLARS A YEAR. Single numbers SEVENTY-FIVE CENTS. : HENRY B. DAWSON, Morrisania, N. Y,