Podcasts · Making the Argument with Nick Freitas

America Has 3 Identities & We Forgot One

3 Sep 2026 · 1 h 27 min

Who are the “real” Americans…what does it even mean to be an American? Today we discuss 3 notions of what it means to be an “American”. The legal, historical, and cultural traditions that define a country and people MATTER. But to what degree does each matter, and are there exceptions to certain rules?

SPONSOR: Human Coalition

Human Coalition rescues women and babies from abortion by reaching mothers before the abortion industry does. For just $26, your gift becomes a lifeline: free ultrasounds, real resources, and a Continuum of Care that walks with her until she is stable. They have already helped more than 36,000 women choose life, with over a million more still to reach.

Give $26 and leave a legacy of life at https://www.humancoalition.org/nick

-----

BLAZETV: BlazeTV is the home of Making the Argument. Subscribing is the best way to support the show, and it gives you unlimited access to our show plus every other Blaze host, including Glenn Beck, Mark Levin, Jason Whitlock, Allie Beth Stuckey, and Liz Wheeler. Use code NICK for $20 off at https://BlazeTV.com/Nick.

-----

GET YOUR MERCH HERE: https://shop.nickjfreitas.com/

BECOME A MEMBER OF THE IC: https://NickJFreitas.com

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/nickjfreitas/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/NickFreitasVA

Twitter: https://twitter.com/NickJFreitas

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@Nickjfreitas

TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@nickjfreitas3.0

00:00 – Legal, historical, or creedal: what actually makes an American?

02:49 – The JD Vance speech that set the whole thing off

09:25 – Rome was extremely good at assimilation, right up until it wasn't

17:00 – Why the innovation happened here and not somewhere with a head start

23:36 – The actual ten steps to becoming a US citizen

34:32 – The American's Creed that Congress passed in 1918

41:27 – Equality is the word that opened the gates

47:58 – Rugged individualism, with a strong sense of community

52:54 – A founding father already answered this, and he wasn't subtle

58:12 – The 1965 law that changed who comes here

1:04:57 – They came here to build it, not to receive it

1:10:24 – Who I actually count as my countrymen

1:18:49 – Where the English way of living actually came from, 2,000 years back

1:25:32 – If I became French tomorrow, would I understand France?

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Links in the notes 1

• https://megaphone.fm/adchoices