# Never trust the members of a SECRET SOCIETY - MrBallen

An episode of [Crime and Horror](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/6813298400), 8 Sep 2026, 26 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/74776026/never_trust_the_members_of_a_secret_society_mrballen_64k.mp3

Never trust the members of a SECRET SOCIETY - MrBallen

## Transcript

[0:00] Speaker 1: Today, I'm going to tell you two stories that both
[0:02] Speaker 1: have very unexpected killers. But before we get into those stories,
[0:07] Speaker 1: if you're a fan of the Strange, Dark, and Mysterious
[0:09] Speaker 1: delivered in story format, then you've come to the right
[0:11] Speaker 1: place because that's all we do and we upload once
[0:14] Speaker 1: a week. So, if that's of interest to you, please
[0:17] Speaker 1: gift the like button a brand new signed copy of Mr.
[0:20] Speaker 1: Ballin's brand new graphic novel, Where Nightmares Live. but make
[0:24] Speaker 1: sure you first rip out one page from each story. Also,
[0:28] Speaker 1: please subscribe to our channel and turn on all notifications
[0:31] Speaker 1: so you don't miss any of our weekly uploads.
[0:33] Speaker 2: Okay, let's get into today's stories.
[0:52] Speaker 1: On the morning of September 12, 2007, 20-year-old Ashley Wallace
[0:56] Speaker 1: was in her dorm room at Bryant & Stratton College
[0:59] Speaker 1: in Buffalo, New York, getting ready for her very first
[1:01] Speaker 1: day of classes. And this was really exciting for her.
[1:04] Speaker 1: I mean, she had just moved out on her own
[1:05] Speaker 1: for the first time. You know, it feels like she's
[1:07] Speaker 1: an adult here. And so today was a big day.
[1:10] Speaker 1: You know, she looked herself in the mirror and made
[1:12] Speaker 1: sure her look was just right. She gathered up all
[1:14] Speaker 1: her books and her journals and all the stuff she
[1:16] Speaker 1: would need. And then once she was ready, she began
[1:19] Speaker 1: heading towards the door. But before she got there, she
[1:22] Speaker 1: heard a knock on her door. And Ashley felt sort
[1:24] Speaker 1: of confused, like she hadn't lived here long enough for
[1:28] Speaker 1: people to actually know she lived here.
[1:30] Speaker 2: So who would be coming to visit her? And she
[1:32] Speaker 2: certainly didn't have any plans to see anybody today.
[1:36] Speaker 1: And so she's thinking, like, I have no idea who
[1:39] Speaker 1: could be at my door right now. So she walks
[1:41] Speaker 1: to the door, she opens it up, and she is
[1:44] Speaker 1: truly shocked now to see who's standing there. But her
[1:46] Speaker 1: shock quickly turns into fear. So there were two police
[1:50] Speaker 1: officers standing in the hallway looking right at Ashley. And
[1:53] Speaker 1: the looks on their faces were very serious. Now, Ashley,
[1:56] Speaker 1: the reason she felt so scared when she saw these
[1:58] Speaker 1: police officers was not because she had, you know, done
[2:01] Speaker 1: something wrong. It was because in her life, you know,
[2:04] Speaker 1: before she got to college, she had experienced some pretty
[2:07] Speaker 1: severe trauma. So her father had passed away when she
[2:10] Speaker 1: was 13, a sudden heart attack. And it had been
[2:13] Speaker 1: very traumatic for her. It sort of threw the family
[2:15] Speaker 1: for a loop. And then her mother had remarried and
[2:19] Speaker 1: her stepfather who had, you know, raised her from that
[2:21] Speaker 1: point on, he had sort of struggled with depression on
[2:24] Speaker 1: and off.
[2:24] Speaker 2: And it seemed like he was doing okay, but not long.
[2:28] Speaker 1: After her biological father had suddenly died, her stepfather took
[2:32] Speaker 1: his own life. And so once again, you know, Ashley
[2:35] Speaker 1: and her family's lives were turned upside down. And so
[2:37] Speaker 1: in many ways, Ashley had not really recovered from those
[2:40] Speaker 1: two losses. You know, those happened not that long ago.
[2:43] Speaker 1: And now she was out here on her own trying
[2:45] Speaker 1: to be an adult, you know, trying her best to
[2:48] Speaker 1: stay composed. But she just had this awful feeling when
[2:51] Speaker 1: she saw these police officers that they were there to
[2:54] Speaker 1: tell her that, you know, somebody else close to her
[2:56] Speaker 1: had died. But when the officers actually began speaking to Ashley,
[3:00] Speaker 1: it was clear they were not here to notify her about,
[3:03] Speaker 1: you know, a new death.
[3:04] Speaker 2: But they were here to talk about her family.
[3:06] Speaker 1: They told her that they were there to speak to
[3:08] Speaker 1: her about her father, her biological father, who had passed
[3:11] Speaker 1: away seven years earlier.
[3:12] Speaker 2: And so when they said that to Ashley, she was like, okay.
[3:16] Speaker 1: You know, what do you mean? What do you want
[3:17] Speaker 1: to know about my dad? And they told her that,
[3:20] Speaker 1: you know, Ashley, we exhumed your father. And it turns
[3:23] Speaker 1: out he very likely did not die of a heart attack.
[3:27] Speaker 1: We think he was murdered. About 30 minutes later, when
[3:30] Speaker 1: these officers had finally left Ashley's room, Ashley was left
[3:33] Speaker 1: feeling completely distraught. I mean, number one, she just found
[3:37] Speaker 1: out that there is suspicion that her father was killed
[3:40] Speaker 1: by somebody. But worse than that, was these two officers
[3:43] Speaker 1: who had been here were not here to console Ashley.
[3:46] Speaker 1: They were here to effectively interrogate her. They were looking
[3:49] Speaker 1: into the family to see if, you know, Ashley was
[3:51] Speaker 1: involved in what happened to her father. And so for Ashley,
[3:55] Speaker 1: this had really caught her off guard. She felt like
[3:57] Speaker 1: she was stammering and confused in all of her answers,
[4:00] Speaker 1: which only made her seem more suspicious. And it was like,
[4:03] Speaker 1: Every little misstep she had, the police would dial in
[4:05] Speaker 1: and ask even more pointed questions. And by the end
[4:08] Speaker 1: of it, she was just sobbing and telling them like,
[4:10] Speaker 1: I didn't do this.
[4:11] Speaker 2: I didn't hurt my dad. I have no idea who
[4:13] Speaker 2: would do that.
[4:14] Speaker 1: And so eventually the police had gotten up and left,
[4:17] Speaker 1: but they told Ashley they were going to be in
[4:18] Speaker 1: touch and then they were gone. And so Ashley's just
[4:21] Speaker 1: left there in her room wondering what she's supposed to
[4:23] Speaker 1: do now. She thought about, you know, sucking it up
[4:25] Speaker 1: and just going to class, but she's thinking like, how
[4:28] Speaker 1: can I possibly focus on class right now when I've
[4:31] Speaker 1: just learned what I've learned and had this horrible experience
[4:34] Speaker 1: with the police. And so Ashley ended up calling her mother,
[4:37] Speaker 1: and her mother was obviously very upset when she picked up,
[4:40] Speaker 1: even before Ashley said anything. And Ashley quickly learned that
[4:43] Speaker 1: her mother also had a sort of similar experience with
[4:46] Speaker 1: police that day, that she had also been told that,
[4:49] Speaker 1: you know, her husband apparently had been killed, and they
[4:52] Speaker 1: were now investigating her to see if maybe she had
[4:54] Speaker 1: something to do with it. And so the two women
[4:56] Speaker 1: just sort of cried on the phone, and they began saying, like,
[4:59] Speaker 1: I just don't understand, like, who would want to hurt him?
[5:02] Speaker 1: It just doesn't make any sense. Like they've got to
[5:04] Speaker 1: be wrong. Like none of this makes any sense. And
[5:07] Speaker 1: so eventually Ashley's mother, whose name was Stacy, just told
[5:10] Speaker 1: her daughter to come home, forget about classes. We can
[5:13] Speaker 1: deal with that stuff later. Just come home, be with
[5:15] Speaker 1: your family. Ashley agreed that was the most reasonable thing
[5:18] Speaker 1: to do here. And so she grabbed her stuff. She
[5:20] Speaker 1: left the dorm, hopped in her car, and she drove
[5:23] Speaker 1: the hour back to her mom's place. And when she
[5:25] Speaker 1: gets there and she goes inside, The first person she
[5:28] Speaker 1: sees is actually her younger sister.
[5:30] Speaker 2: Bree, who was 16 years old. And Bree's eyes were red.
[5:33] Speaker 2: She obviously had been crying.
[5:35] Speaker 1: And, you know, in the first couple of seconds they spoke,
[5:37] Speaker 1: it was clear that Bree, too, had had a sort
[5:39] Speaker 1: of rough interaction with police as well that day. And
[5:42] Speaker 1: so it's like the whole family has been thrust into
[5:44] Speaker 1: this chaotic moment that none of them can make any
[5:46] Speaker 1: sense of. On the one hand, it's like, who would
[5:50] Speaker 1: want to hurt dad? But on the other, it's like,
[5:53] Speaker 1: did this really happen?
[5:54] Speaker 2: Is this a mistake?
[5:54] Speaker 1: Like, Why did they exhume his body in the first place? Like,
[5:57] Speaker 1: what's going on here? There was just so much unknown.
[6:00] Speaker 1: And so that afternoon, Ashley, her sister Bree, and their
[6:03] Speaker 1: mom just retreated to their mother's kitchen. And there they
[6:07] Speaker 1: mostly cried together and just sort of talked through this
[6:10] Speaker 1: horrible situation. But eventually, later in the day, when the
[6:13] Speaker 1: tears had sort of stopped flowing and reality had set
[6:16] Speaker 1: in that this was now a very complicated situation, if
[6:19] Speaker 1: nothing else, I mean, basically they were all under investigation
[6:23] Speaker 1: for the potential murder of their father slash husband. And
[6:26] Speaker 1: they sort of didn't know what was going to happen next,
[6:28] Speaker 1: but there was a lot of stress around, you know,
[6:30] Speaker 1: the next couple of days, you know, they didn't know.
[6:32] Speaker 1: And so under all this stress, Stacey, the mom was like,
[6:36] Speaker 1: you know what? I'm getting a drink. Do any of
[6:38] Speaker 1: you guys want a drink? And Bree was only 16
[6:41] Speaker 1: and she declined, but Ashley said, sure. You know, she
[6:44] Speaker 1: was 20, not 21 yet, but you know, she was
[6:46] Speaker 1: drinking at this point. And so she said, yep, I'll
[6:48] Speaker 1: take a drink. And so Stacy mixed some drinks for
[6:50] Speaker 1: her and Ashley, as well as a non-alcoholic drink for Bree.
[6:53] Speaker 1: And so for the rest of the night, the girls
[6:55] Speaker 1: just sat in the kitchen having their drinks and trying
[6:58] Speaker 1: hard not to let this horrible situation totally wreck them.
[7:01] Speaker 1: The next morning, when Ashley woke up inside of her
[7:04] Speaker 1: mother's house, she found she was really hungover. Now, she
[7:08] Speaker 1: obviously had had some drinks the night before with her
[7:10] Speaker 1: mom and her sister, but she was thinking to herself, like,
[7:13] Speaker 1: the level of hungover she was feeling felt disproportionate. Like
[7:16] Speaker 1: she was really hungover despite a relatively small amount of alcohol.
[7:20] Speaker 1: But Ashley was wondering if maybe part of the reason
[7:23] Speaker 1: she felt so bad was not just a hangover. Maybe
[7:27] Speaker 1: it was like this emotional fallout from this horrible thing
[7:30] Speaker 1: that happened the day before. And so Ashley, she's laying
[7:33] Speaker 1: in bed feeling so bad and she's just convincing herself
[7:36] Speaker 1: that I just need to get up. I need to
[7:38] Speaker 1: go to my classes. I need to sort of treat
[7:41] Speaker 1: the day like a normal day and sort of get
[7:43] Speaker 1: my life back together and be ready to potentially deal
[7:46] Speaker 1: with police or, you know, whatever else is going to
[7:48] Speaker 1: happen here.
[7:49] Speaker 2: And so Ashley sort of wills herself out of bed.
[7:51] Speaker 2: She's got a blinding headache.
[7:53] Speaker 1: She feels horrible, but nonetheless, you know, she takes a shower,
[7:57] Speaker 1: she gets herself together. And before long, she's saying bye
[8:00] Speaker 1: to her mom and sister and she's driving back to
[8:02] Speaker 1: the campus. And when she gets there, she still feels terrible,
[8:06] Speaker 1: but you know, she goes to her classes and and
[8:08] Speaker 1: she does her best to focus, which really turned out
[8:10] Speaker 1: to be a gargantuan.
[8:11] Speaker 2: Task, but she did it. And then finally, at the
[8:14] Speaker 2: end of the day.
[8:15] Speaker 1: During her last class, Ashley began to sort of break
[8:18] Speaker 1: out of this fog, this hangover fog that she was in,
[8:21] Speaker 1: and she began sort of feeling normal again. And so
[8:24] Speaker 1: by the time she left the lecture hall and was
[8:26] Speaker 1: done for the day, she actually felt good enough that
[8:28] Speaker 1: she hopped.
[8:29] Speaker 2: Right back in her car and drove right back to
[8:31] Speaker 2: her mother's house.
[8:31] Speaker 1: And that night, again, just like the night before, she,
[8:35] Speaker 1: her sister, and her mom just sat in the kitchen,
[8:38] Speaker 1: just sort of having this cathartic moment together, you know,
[8:40] Speaker 1: crying together, talking about their dad, sharing memories, sharing theories,
[8:44] Speaker 1: and also having a few drinks. And again, Bree did
[8:47] Speaker 1: not have any alcohol, but Ashley and her mother did.
[8:50] Speaker 1: The next morning, when Ashley woke up, once again, her
[8:54] Speaker 1: head was pounding. She was so hungover, way.
[8:57] Speaker 2: Worse than the day before.
[8:59] Speaker 1: Except when she opened her eyes and kind of looked around,
[9:02] Speaker 1: that really was not the first thing that hit her.
[9:04] Speaker 1: The first thing that hit her is, I don't know
[9:07] Speaker 1: where I am. the room looked different. And as she
[9:09] Speaker 1: kind of adjusted and looked around, she realized she was
[9:13] Speaker 1: in a hospital room. And so Ashley began to panic
[9:15] Speaker 1: and began looking around for her family or anybody she recognized,
[9:19] Speaker 1: but nobody that she knew was in there. There were
[9:21] Speaker 1: just these two police officers sitting against the wall in
[9:24] Speaker 1: her room. And these two officers, when they saw Ashley
[9:27] Speaker 1: coming to, they got up and they walked over to
[9:30] Speaker 1: her and they explained to her that she was very
[9:32] Speaker 1: lucky that her mother had actually found her in her
[9:35] Speaker 1: bed at her mother's house that morning then Ashley had
[9:38] Speaker 1: been unresponsive. And so her mother had called an ambulance
[9:41] Speaker 1: and they had rushed her here. And, you know, luckily
[9:43] Speaker 1: she was stabilized now, but apparently she was very close
[9:47] Speaker 1: to full-blown organ failure.
[9:49] Speaker 2: Like she almost died. It was very lucky she got
[9:51] Speaker 2: here when she did.
[9:52] Speaker 1: But before Ashley could ask any questions, you know, like, well,
[9:56] Speaker 1: what was it that was causing my body to shut down?
[9:58] Speaker 2: Like, what's going on here?
[9:59] Speaker 1: The two police officers kind of looked at each other,
[10:01] Speaker 1: and then one of them pulled a piece of paper
[10:04] Speaker 1: out of their pocket, and they.
[10:06] Speaker 2: Handed it to Ashley. And they said, you need to
[10:09] Speaker 2: explain yourself.
[10:10] Speaker 1: It would turn out the way Ashley's stepfather had taken
[10:13] Speaker 1: his own life was by drinking antifreeze.
[10:16] Speaker 2: At least that was the initial theory. But pretty quickly.
[10:18] Speaker 1: investigators started to say, like, why would somebody take their
[10:22] Speaker 1: own life that way? Drinking antifreeze is slow and painful. Like,
[10:26] Speaker 1: that's not a good first choice if you're going to
[10:28] Speaker 1: take your own life. And so as suspicions rose around
[10:30] Speaker 1: the stepfather, investigators thought, okay, well, the biological father died
[10:35] Speaker 1: just a few years before, and apparently he died of
[10:38] Speaker 1: a heart attack, but maybe we ought to make sure,
[10:41] Speaker 1: because we're basically suggesting that maybe somebody did this to
[10:44] Speaker 1: the stepfather. Is it possible somebody, you know, killed the
[10:48] Speaker 1: biological father. And so they exhumed the biological father. And
[10:52] Speaker 1: during the autopsy, they discovered antifreeze in his remains. And
[10:56] Speaker 1: so now fast forward to the hospital where Ashley has
[10:59] Speaker 1: woken up. These officers have walked over to her. They've
[11:02] Speaker 1: handed her a note and told her to explain herself.
[11:05] Speaker 1: And this note was effectively a confession. The writer of
[11:08] Speaker 1: this note said they killed Ashley's biological father. Then they
[11:13] Speaker 1: also killed Ashley's stepfather. But now, because of the blood
[11:17] Speaker 1: on their hands, they're going to take their own lives.
[11:20] Speaker 1: So this was a suicide note slash confession. And at
[11:23] Speaker 1: the bottom of this note, it was signed by Ashley.
[11:27] Speaker 1: Except Ashley did not kill her father or stepfather. Her
[11:31] Speaker 1: mother did. Her mother used antifreeze to poison and kill
[11:35] Speaker 1: both men. And then when police began poking around saying,
[11:39] Speaker 1: what's going on here? We think somebody killed this guy
[11:41] Speaker 1: and maybe him too. Well, what did Ashley's beloved mother do?
[11:45] Speaker 2: She tried to poison her own daughter.
[11:47] Speaker 1: She laced those alcoholic drinks they were having in her
[11:50] Speaker 1: kitchen with all these painkillers to make it look like.
[11:53] Speaker 2: Ashley had taken her own life because she felt so
[11:56] Speaker 2: guilty about murdering these two men.
[11:58] Speaker 1: Except Ashley's mother called the ambulance a little bit too
[12:02] Speaker 1: early the following day, you know, feigning that she had
[12:05] Speaker 1: just found her daughter unresponsive because the ambulance, they showed
[12:08] Speaker 1: up and first responders, they saved Ashley's life narrowly.
[12:12] Speaker 2: Apparently, She was within 15 minutes of dying when she
[12:16] Speaker 2: showed up at the hospital.
[12:17] Speaker 1: Stacey was convicted of two murders, as well as the
[12:20] Speaker 1: attempted murder of her daughter, and she was sentenced to
[12:23] Speaker 1: 51 years in prison.
[12:24] Speaker 2: However, she would die behind bars in 2016.
[12:37] Speaker 1: Around lunchtime on March 31, 2010, a man in his
[12:41] Speaker 1: mid-50s named John Schmeier was sitting at a table with
[12:44] Speaker 1: a bunch of his friends inside of a Hooters restaurant
[12:47] Speaker 1: in the small city of York, Pennsylvania. So John was
[12:50] Speaker 1: a retired eye doctor. He'd had a very successful career,
[12:53] Speaker 1: made a bunch of money, and his friends that were
[12:56] Speaker 1: at this table with him were also pretty successful guys,
[12:59] Speaker 1: sort of like mid to upper tier professionals with very
[13:02] Speaker 1: successful careers too. But what they were doing today had
[13:05] Speaker 1: nothing to do with career.
[13:07] Speaker 2: This was pure pleasure.
[13:08] Speaker 1: This group of guys, this specific group of friends who
[13:11] Speaker 1: were very, very close, They would meet up a couple
[13:14] Speaker 1: times a month at this particular Hooters.
[13:16] Speaker 2: They would sit at the same table. They would order
[13:19] Speaker 2: the same things. They loved it.
[13:21] Speaker 1: It was sort of like their little clubhouse. And in fact,
[13:23] Speaker 1: they had even come up with a name for this
[13:26] Speaker 1: group of friends. They called themselves the Orange Shorts Society.
[13:30] Speaker 1: And so the reason they did that is because Hooters
[13:34] Speaker 1: has a sort of vibe to it that if you've
[13:36] Speaker 1: been there, you know exactly what I'm talking about. If
[13:39] Speaker 1: you haven't been there, basically the the waitresses dress in
[13:43] Speaker 1: very scantily clad clothing, and they all wear these sort
[13:47] Speaker 1: of iconic white tank tops and orange shorts. And so
[13:51] Speaker 1: basically these men were sort of joking that they were
[13:54] Speaker 1: the Orange Shorts Society because of the shorts these women
[13:58] Speaker 1: would all wear.
[13:58] Speaker 2: And so that afternoon, John and.
[14:00] Speaker 1: The rest of the members of the Orange Shorts Society
[14:03] Speaker 1: all sat around chatting and, you know, BSing with each other,
[14:06] Speaker 1: just being guys. And at some point, John brought up
[14:10] Speaker 1: a subject that the rest of the society was accustomed
[14:14] Speaker 1: to him bringing up, and that was his ex-wife, Monica.
[14:17] Speaker 1: So all of his friends knew that John had been
[14:20] Speaker 1: married to Monica for 20 years, but then they got
[14:23] Speaker 1: divorced in 2003, so seven years earlier. But still, Monica
[14:27] Speaker 1: was a thorn in John's side because he had to
[14:30] Speaker 1: pay her alimony. And, you know, he understood that that
[14:32] Speaker 1: comes with the territory of divorce.
[14:34] Speaker 2: It is what it is. But Monica.
[14:37] Speaker 1: had made the way John paid her the alimony really cumbersome.
[14:41] Speaker 1: And John was convinced, as he would tell his buddies
[14:44] Speaker 1: in the Orange Shorts Society, that it was totally intentional,
[14:48] Speaker 1: that she had made it cumbersome.
[14:49] Speaker 2: She wanted it to be hard. She didn't like John,
[14:52] Speaker 2: and she was punishing him.
[14:53] Speaker 1: And so what Monica did is she made John literally
[14:57] Speaker 1: each week take cash out of an ATM, put it
[15:00] Speaker 1: in an envelope, and then physically drive it to her
[15:03] Speaker 1: house and drop it off.
[15:05] Speaker 2: She would not accept payment any other way.
[15:07] Speaker 1: And the reason she was able to do that is
[15:09] Speaker 1: because she claimed she did not have a bank account
[15:12] Speaker 1: and she couldn't be forced to make a bank account.
[15:15] Speaker 1: And so either John made these cumbersome payments in cash
[15:19] Speaker 1: or he risked not making the payment at all.
[15:21] Speaker 2: And then she could come after him legally.
[15:23] Speaker 1: And so he was sort of trapped making this trek
[15:25] Speaker 1: once a week, to hand over cash to his ex-wife,
[15:28] Speaker 1: who he really couldn't stand. Now, their divorce was not
[15:31] Speaker 1: super contentious. The two of them just sort of drifted apart.
[15:34] Speaker 1: They stopped seeing eye to eye. And actually, Monica really
[15:37] Speaker 1: didn't like the whole Orange Shorts Society thing. She thought
[15:40] Speaker 1: it was totally scummy and that John and his buddies
[15:43] Speaker 1: were just kind of gross for going to that restaurant
[15:45] Speaker 1: and sort of making jokes about, you know, what these
[15:48] Speaker 1: women are wearing and making that part of their identity,
[15:50] Speaker 1: the Orange Shorts Society.
[15:52] Speaker 2: She didn't like it. And so they just kind of
[15:53] Speaker 2: drifted apart. That was all it was.
[15:55] Speaker 1: But now it had become this sort of bitter feud
[15:58] Speaker 1: between the two of them. And so at the same
[16:00] Speaker 1: time that John and his buddies in the Orange Shorts
[16:02] Speaker 1: Society are sitting in the restaurant and John is going
[16:05] Speaker 1: on his tirade once again about Monica's alimony. Simultaneously, on
[16:09] Speaker 1: the other side of town, police rushed to Monica's house.
[16:14] Speaker 1: Minutes earlier, there had been a 911 call that came
[16:17] Speaker 1: from Monica's house, but when the operator answered, there was
[16:21] Speaker 1: no answer. And so by protocol, they had just sent
[16:24] Speaker 1: first responders out to the house to see if whoever
[16:26] Speaker 1: had called was okay. And so the police, they get
[16:28] Speaker 1: to Monica's house, they park, they go right up to
[16:30] Speaker 1: the front door, knocking on the door there's no answer
[16:34] Speaker 1: they're looking around there's no sign of forced entry no
[16:37] Speaker 1: sign of anything really going on here it's just a
[16:39] Speaker 1: quiet day in the neighborhood but they go to the
[16:41] Speaker 1: door again they knock a few more times and when
[16:43] Speaker 1: there's no answer they try the doorknob and it's unlocked
[16:46] Speaker 1: so they open the door up right away they look
[16:49] Speaker 1: in and there's monica and she's dead on the ground
[16:52] Speaker 1: with the phone right next to her and she's been
[16:55] Speaker 1: shot in the head shortly after this discovery the lead
[16:58] Speaker 1: detective douglas demagon along with his team began to survey
[17:01] Speaker 1: the crime scene, and they quickly found a purse next
[17:04] Speaker 1: to Monica's body, and inside was her license.
[17:06] Speaker 2: That was how they identified her. And then they also
[17:09] Speaker 2: found a.
[17:09] Speaker 1: 32 caliber shell casing lying near the body that clearly
[17:13] Speaker 1: seemed to be from the round that struck her in
[17:15] Speaker 1: the head and killed her. But perhaps the most unusual
[17:18] Speaker 1: aspect of this crime scene had really nothing to do
[17:21] Speaker 1: with the body.
[17:22] Speaker 2: It was all the money. they found all over the house,
[17:25] Speaker 2: specifically cash, cash in envelopes. There were these envelopes in
[17:29] Speaker 2: trash cans and drawers on tables.
[17:31] Speaker 1: I mean, it was kind of like all over the place,
[17:33] Speaker 1: some out in the open, some hidden, but there was
[17:35] Speaker 1: lots of money stashed in this home. And so Demogon
[17:39] Speaker 1: and the other investigators began to wonder if, you know, okay,
[17:42] Speaker 1: maybe this was a robbery and Monica got killed in
[17:45] Speaker 1: the process. But it's like, okay, if it was a robbery,
[17:47] Speaker 1: why is there so much cash out in the open
[17:50] Speaker 1: and literally packaged up in envelopes, easy to, you know,
[17:53] Speaker 1: remove from the house.
[17:55] Speaker 2: Why is it all here?
[17:56] Speaker 1: It's almost like no cash was taken or certainly not
[17:59] Speaker 1: very much was taken. And also other valuables are still
[18:01] Speaker 1: in place. You know, it just, it didn't have the
[18:04] Speaker 1: feel of somebody ransacking the house. It just sort of
[18:07] Speaker 1: felt like somebody came in here and killed Monica. Detective
[18:10] Speaker 1: Demagon and his team searched the whole house and they
[18:13] Speaker 1: couldn't find any sign of forced entry.
[18:16] Speaker 2: So basically whoever came in.
[18:17] Speaker 1: Here and did this either, you know, just walked in
[18:20] Speaker 1: because a door or window was unlocked, or maybe Monica
[18:23] Speaker 1: let them in, maybe she knew who they were, or
[18:26] Speaker 1: they had a key. Detective Demogon asked the forensics team
[18:29] Speaker 1: to begin sweeping the house for DNA, to see if
[18:32] Speaker 1: maybe they could find something that could show them who
[18:34] Speaker 1: had been here lately. And so while that team got started,
[18:36] Speaker 1: Demogon continued to walk around the house, and he eventually
[18:40] Speaker 1: found a Rolodex, which is basically like a big book
[18:43] Speaker 1: full of phone numbers and addresses. And as the detective
[18:46] Speaker 1: was flipping through that book, that was how he discovered
[18:49] Speaker 1: that Monica had an ex-husband, John Schmeier. That evening, Detective
[18:53] Speaker 1: Demagon and another investigator rolled up to John Schmeier's house.
[18:57] Speaker 1: They walked up to the front door and they knocked.
[18:59] Speaker 1: And then a moment later, the door opened. And John
[19:02] Speaker 1: was standing there looking very surprised. So in homicide cases,
[19:06] Speaker 1: generally speaking, the spouse or ex-spouse is always suspect number one.
[19:11] Speaker 1: And so even though Demogon didn't really have any evidence
[19:13] Speaker 1: linking John to the crime, he did have the fact that.
[19:17] Speaker 2: This was her ex-spouse. And so therefore, he is suspicious.
[19:21] Speaker 1: Before John could ask any questions, Demogon and his partner
[19:24] Speaker 1: introduced themselves and said they'd like to come in and
[19:26] Speaker 1: speak to John. So John said, okay, come on in.
[19:29] Speaker 1: So they walked inside, they sat down, and then once
[19:31] Speaker 1: they were seated, Detective Demagon watched John very closely as
[19:36] Speaker 1: he told him why they were there. Basically, your ex-wife
[19:39] Speaker 1: has been murdered and we're here to talk to you
[19:42] Speaker 1: about it. Detective Demagon wanted to see if John would
[19:44] Speaker 1: have a big reaction or maybe a subdued reaction. You know,
[19:47] Speaker 1: whatever reaction he might have could be tell. to how
[19:51] Speaker 1: involved he maybe was or wasn't in this case. When
[19:53] Speaker 1: Demagon told John that Monica had been shot to death,
[19:57] Speaker 1: John's reaction was huge. His eyes went wide, he clutched
[20:02] Speaker 1: at his chest like he was having a heart attack,
[20:04] Speaker 1: and then he kind of leaned forward and began sobbing.
[20:06] Speaker 2: But when he came back up again.
[20:09] Speaker 1: The detective noticed there were no tears in John's eyes.
[20:12] Speaker 1: It was just this sort of huge reaction, but Demogon
[20:15] Speaker 1: couldn't really tell if it was genuine or not. He
[20:17] Speaker 1: also didn't have a baseline for John. He didn't know
[20:19] Speaker 1: if this was normal, but this seemed really dramatic, almost
[20:23] Speaker 1: like he might be acting. So instead of trying to
[20:25] Speaker 1: console John, Demogon just asked point blank, where were you
[20:30] Speaker 1: earlier this afternoon at the time of the shooting? And
[20:32] Speaker 1: when he asked this, John, who still was sort of
[20:35] Speaker 1: rocking back and forth and grabbing his chest and acting
[20:37] Speaker 1: very upset, he suddenly stopped, put his hands by his side,
[20:41] Speaker 1: and just said, oh, I was at Hooters with my friends.
[20:44] Speaker 1: A few days later, Detective Demogon went to the Hooters,
[20:47] Speaker 1: where John and his friends would always meet up, and
[20:49] Speaker 1: he asked the manager to see the security footage from
[20:52] Speaker 1: the previous Wednesday, the day of the shooting. So by
[20:54] Speaker 1: this point, Demogon had actually already interviewed all of the
[20:58] Speaker 1: friends who had been at the Hooters with John. The
[21:01] Speaker 1: so-called Orange Shorts Society had And he had asked them
[21:04] Speaker 1: all about John.
[21:05] Speaker 2: Like, had he really been there? What was he doing?
[21:07] Speaker 2: What was he saying?
[21:08] Speaker 1: And they all said John absolutely was there the whole time. Like,
[21:11] Speaker 1: there's no way he could have left and done anything
[21:14] Speaker 1: to Monica.
[21:15] Speaker 2: He was here with us. I promise you he was here.
[21:17] Speaker 1: Now, they would admit to the detective that, you know,
[21:20] Speaker 1: John did speak disparagingly about Monica. He would talk about
[21:23] Speaker 1: how mad he was about her alimony and definitely didn't
[21:26] Speaker 1: like her very much.
[21:28] Speaker 2: But that was it. That was the extent of his hatred.
[21:30] Speaker 1: Now, despite how convincingly these friends said John was there
[21:33] Speaker 1: the whole time, he couldn't have done this, Demogon still
[21:36] Speaker 1: needed proof. He needed to really see that John had
[21:39] Speaker 1: been here when he said he was here. So John
[21:40] Speaker 1: went to the manager, they pulled up the security footage
[21:43] Speaker 1: from the previous Wednesday, and wouldn't you know it, there's John,
[21:47] Speaker 1: he comes in, he sits down, he's with his buddies,
[21:49] Speaker 1: and he is there. the whole time during the time
[21:53] Speaker 1: that Monica was killed. And so at this point, Demogon
[21:55] Speaker 1: did feel like it sort of was impossible that John
[21:58] Speaker 1: actually went and killed Monica. But given the contention between them,
[22:03] Speaker 1: I mean, John apparently really doesn't like Monica.
[22:05] Speaker 2: He hates making these payments to her.
[22:07] Speaker 1: Like there's obvious friction that comes up at these orange
[22:10] Speaker 1: short society meetings all the time. You know, maybe it
[22:13] Speaker 1: was possible that John, who was pretty well off, had
[22:15] Speaker 1: a bunch of money. You know, maybe he hired somebody
[22:19] Speaker 1: to do his dirty work for him. Maybe he hired
[22:21] Speaker 1: a hitman. And so over the next week or so,
[22:23] Speaker 1: Demagon and his team began exploring this hitman lead. And
[22:26] Speaker 1: they found that John had been taking out a whole
[22:29] Speaker 1: bunch of cash.
[22:30] Speaker 2: Over the last several weeks.
[22:32] Speaker 1: But it sort of lined up with how much cash
[22:34] Speaker 1: he owed Monica in the form of alimony. And they
[22:37] Speaker 1: knew he had to, per Monica's orders... deliver this alimony
[22:41] Speaker 1: payment in cash to her in these envelopes and they
[22:44] Speaker 1: found all those envelopes of cash at Monica's house and
[22:47] Speaker 1: so it seemed like that was all he was doing
[22:49] Speaker 1: taking money out to give to Monica and so John
[22:51] Speaker 1: was basically Demogon's only suspect at this point and there
[22:55] Speaker 1: was basically no evidence against him and so Demogon knew
[22:58] Speaker 1: he really needed to look into other leads here like
[23:00] Speaker 1: the John lead kind of going nowhere and so he
[23:03] Speaker 1: and his team began looking into local gang activity and
[23:06] Speaker 1: you know, crimes in the area? Could this have just
[23:08] Speaker 1: been random or something completely unrelated? But after three months
[23:12] Speaker 1: of looking for any connection anywhere in the area, there
[23:16] Speaker 1: wasn't one.
[23:17] Speaker 2: And the case kind of came to a stall.
[23:19] Speaker 1: And so at this point, Demogon decided that the only
[23:22] Speaker 1: thing he could do realistically was just kind of start over,
[23:25] Speaker 1: go back to square one, and basically re-examine all the
[23:29] Speaker 1: evidence all over again. And that included going back and
[23:32] Speaker 1: looking at the security footage from the Hooters on that
[23:35] Speaker 1: Wednesday when the Orange Shorts Society was there.
[23:37] Speaker 2: And so Demogon, he sat down, he starts watching.
[23:40] Speaker 1: This tape over and over and over again.
[23:42] Speaker 2: It's like the thousandth.
[23:43] Speaker 1: Time he's looked at this grainy footage and suddenly something
[23:47] Speaker 1: stands out to him. Something he missed all the other
[23:50] Speaker 1: times he looked. And as he replayed the footage over
[23:53] Speaker 1: and over again, he realized he now knew almost certainly
[23:57] Speaker 1: what happened to Monica. It would turn out the footage
[24:00] Speaker 1: of the Orange Shorts Society meeting did hold the secret
[24:03] Speaker 1: to Monica's murder. John Schmeier did not kill his ex-wife,
[24:06] Speaker 1: nor did he hire a hitman to do it. He
[24:08] Speaker 1: really had nothing to do with her death. The only
[24:10] Speaker 1: thing he did do is, you know, at these Orange
[24:13] Speaker 1: Shorts Society meetups, he would talk openly about how he
[24:16] Speaker 1: didn't really like Monica. In particular, he resented the fact
[24:19] Speaker 1: that she was making him deliver all this cash to
[24:22] Speaker 1: her to pay his alimony payments. It just felt totally cumbersome.
[24:26] Speaker 1: But that meant John, on a regular basis, was telling
[24:30] Speaker 1: these men... in the Orange Shorts Society, that Monica was
[24:33] Speaker 1: flush with cash.
[24:34] Speaker 2: She was given her tons of cash every single week.
[24:37] Speaker 2: This woman has so much cash at her house.
[24:40] Speaker 1: And eventually, one of the Orange Shorts Society members, a
[24:43] Speaker 1: man named Tim Jacoby, decided, you know what? I'm going
[24:46] Speaker 1: to go to Monica's house, and I'm going to take
[24:48] Speaker 1: that cash. Demogon had been operating under the assumption that
[24:52] Speaker 1: all the men who were present on that Wednesday meetup
[24:55] Speaker 1: at Hooters, the Orange Shorts Society meeting, that that was
[24:58] Speaker 1: the totality of the group.
[25:00] Speaker 2: Those were all the members.
[25:01] Speaker 1: Because the way the men talked about their group was
[25:04] Speaker 1: they all meet up.
[25:05] Speaker 2: Every single time.
[25:06] Speaker 1: Same group, same seats, same restaurant. And so Demogon assumed, okay,
[25:10] Speaker 1: then it's the same people.
[25:11] Speaker 2: This is it. This is the totality of the group.
[25:14] Speaker 2: Everybody is accounted for. But no. On the day of
[25:16] Speaker 2: the murder, one regular member of.
[25:19] Speaker 1: The Orange Shorts Society was not present.
[25:22] Speaker 2: Tim Jacoby.
[25:23] Speaker 1: And that is the discrepancy that Demogon caught immediately When
[25:26] Speaker 1: he watched that footage for the thousandth time, he realized,
[25:29] Speaker 1: wait a minute.
[25:30] Speaker 2: There's another guy. I heard another guy's name, Tim Jacoby.
[25:34] Speaker 2: He's not here.
[25:36] Speaker 1: Police would later tie Tim to the crime scene with
[25:38] Speaker 1: DNA evidence. They determined that Tim went to her house
[25:41] Speaker 1: with the intention of robbing her. But when Monica fought back,
[25:45] Speaker 1: he shot and killed her and then fled without taking
[25:48] Speaker 1: any money. Tim was convicted of first degree murder and.
[25:50] Speaker 2: Sentenced to death. He is currently on death row in Pennsylvania.
[25:59] Speaker 2: Thank you so much for watching. Let me know what
[26:01] Speaker 2: you thought of today's episode in the comments.
[26:03] Speaker 1: And remember, we have hundreds of videos for you to
[26:06] Speaker 1: binge right now. But if you're looking for a recommendation
[26:09] Speaker 1: from me of that one video that's worth your time, well,
[26:13] Speaker 1: it's this one right here.
[26:15] Speaker 2: So give it a watch. All right, until next time,
[26:17] Speaker 2: see ya.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
