# A Complete Guide to Neanderthals

An episode of [Human History ASMR](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/6793196842), 9 Sep 2026, 1 h 06 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/74777223/a_complete_guide_to_neanderthals_human_voiced_no_ads.mp3

Journey deep into prehistoric Europe and Asia and discover the fascinating story of the Neanderthals, one of our closest and most intriguing human relatives. This episode explores who the Neanderthals were, where they lived, how they evolved, and what everyday life was like for these remarkable people. Discover their anatomy, intelligence, hunting strategies, tools, shelters, clothing, diet, social relationships, and ability to survive in some of the harshest environments of the Ice Age. Explore the archaeological evidence for Neanderthal culture, including stone tools, controlled use of fire, burials, pigments, personal ornaments, and possible symbolic behavior. We also examine what their fossils reveal about their physical adaptations, health, injuries, and demanding way of life. The episode follows the long history of Neanderthals across Europe and western Asia, including their encounters with Homo sapiens and other human populations. Discover what ancient DNA has revealed about interbreeding between Neanderthals and modern humans, and explore the competing theories surrounding their eventual disappearance. Drawing on paleoanthropology, archaeology, genetics, fossil discoveries, and modern scientific research, this episode separates established evidence from outdated stereotypes and popular myths about Neanderthals. Narrated with a calm, human voice, this immersive journey into human prehistory is perfect for history enthusiasts, archaeology lovers, anthropology fans, documentary listeners, relaxation, or listening before sleep. Discover the lives, abilities, struggles, and legacy of the Neanderthals and their place in the story of human evolution.

## Transcript

[0:01] Speaker 1: It was back in 1856 when workers cracking open limestone
[0:06] Speaker 1: in Germany's Neander Valley pulled bones from a cave and
[0:10] Speaker 1: handed them to a local schoolteacher. Nobody had a clue
[0:15] Speaker 1: what they were. Scientists called them a deformed human. A
[0:20] Speaker 1: few said it might have been a diseased skeleton or
[0:24] Speaker 1: even a lost Cossack soldier. All of them were wrong.
[0:29] Speaker 1: Because these bones belonged to an entirely different kind of human.
[0:34] Speaker 1: One who had walked the earth for hundreds of thousands
[0:37] Speaker 1: of years before we ever showed up. And here's what
[0:42] Speaker 1: makes the story worth telling. Almost everything you think you
[0:47] Speaker 1: know about Neanderthals is probably a little misinformed too. It's
[0:53] Speaker 1: not your fault. They weren't hunched. They weren't stupid. Their
[0:58] Speaker 1: brains were actually bigger than ours. It's nothing like how
[1:01] Speaker 1: they've been depicted in media. They made tools, they buried
[1:05] Speaker 1: their dead and cared for the sick. And perhaps most
[1:10] Speaker 1: surprisingly of all, they didn't just simply vanish. In fact,
[1:15] Speaker 1: there's a little Neanderthal DNA in pretty much everybody alive today. So,
[1:22] Speaker 1: being a part of us, we may as well understand
[1:26] Speaker 1: who we are. The Neanderthals actually were. Hello everyone, welcome
[1:31] Speaker 1: to the channel. Back on the pre-history videos. Hope you enjoy.
[1:37] Speaker 1: Thank you for everyone keeping it ad-free by supporting on Patreon,
[1:41] Speaker 1: YouTube memberships, merch store and donations. Links in description. Otherwise,
[1:46] Speaker 1: click a few times on the like, comment and subscribe
[1:49] Speaker 1: and that helps push us out. Anyway, with all that
[1:52] Speaker 1: being said, let's go back in time again. Well, the
[1:58] Speaker 1: Neanderthals emerged from the Homo heidelbergensis population of Europe and
[2:03] Speaker 1: Western Asia sometime between 400,000 and 250,000 years ago, accumulating
[2:12] Speaker 1: over time the specific anatomical features that distinguished them from
[2:15] Speaker 1: their heidelbergensis ancestors and from their contemporaneous cousins in Africa
[2:20] Speaker 1: who were moving more toward this modern Homo sapiens. Now,
[2:26] Speaker 1: just before we do go ahead, we have made a
[2:29] Speaker 1: video recently about pre-Homo sapien bipeds. We have a lot
[2:37] Speaker 1: of things like Homo floresiensis, Homo heidelbergensis, and all the rest,
[2:41] Speaker 1: and a little bit about Neanderthals too, but mainly before Neanderthals.
[2:46] Speaker 1: So maybe that's a little bit of homework. You need
[2:49] Speaker 1: to go watch that one too for more context. Anyway,
[2:53] Speaker 1: not needed for this, but just a suggestion. The classic
[2:56] Speaker 1: Neanderthal anatomy, fully established by approximately 130,000 years ago, is
[3:04] Speaker 1: one of the most precisely described in hominin paleontology. Why? Well,
[3:10] Speaker 1: mainly because the fossil record is rich enough and well-preserved
[3:15] Speaker 1: enough to allow a comprehensive skeletal portrait. We've come a
[3:19] Speaker 1: long way since 1856, and those workers pulled those bones
[3:24] Speaker 1: out of the limestone cave And now we've got a
[3:27] Speaker 1: pretty damn good picture of what a Neanderthal was. Now
[3:33] Speaker 1: the first thing is the skull. You see a Neanderthal's
[3:37] Speaker 1: skull and you immediately know what it is. It's a long,
[3:42] Speaker 1: low cranium, with a characteristic bun-shaped occipital region in the back,
[3:49] Speaker 1: a large projecting midface, the nose and cheekbones pushed forward
[3:53] Speaker 1: relative to the brain case in a way that has...
[3:56] Speaker 1: No real parallel in modern humans. Massive, supra-orbital tori. The
[4:03] Speaker 1: brow ridges that form the continuous bar of bone above
[4:07] Speaker 1: the eye sockets. The most visibly, visually rather dramatic feature
[4:12] Speaker 1: of the Neanderthal face. And then you have that receding chin.
[4:16] Speaker 1: A mandible lacks the pronounced mental protuberance that gives modern
[4:22] Speaker 1: humans our distinctive chin. give or take on some of
[4:26] Speaker 1: those jaw lines, and a retromolar space, i.e. a gap
[4:33] Speaker 1: behind the last molar where the lower jaw extends past
[4:36] Speaker 1: the tooth row, a feature unique to Neanderthals among hominins.
[4:42] Speaker 1: The brain contained within this distinctive skull was pretty large.
[4:46] Speaker 1: The average Neanderthal brain volume of approximately 1410 cubic centimetres
[4:51] Speaker 1: exceeds the modern human average of approximately 1350 centimetres. Though,
[4:57] Speaker 1: by the way, this comparison requires an important caveat. You see,
[5:02] Speaker 1: brain volume alone is a poor predictor of cognitive capability,
[5:07] Speaker 1: and that the internal organization of the brain matters far
[5:11] Speaker 1: more than its overall size. I mean, think about it.
[5:15] Speaker 1: If we were just going on brain size, you'd think
[5:17] Speaker 1: that whales and elephants would be doing superhuman calculus. Or
[5:23] Speaker 1: perhaps we would say super mammalian calculus, things like that.
[5:28] Speaker 1: It's more about the bumps in the brain and the
[5:31] Speaker 1: complexity of the actual brain tissue. Yeah, it's a little complicated,
[5:36] Speaker 1: but we're not going to go into that. That's basically
[5:39] Speaker 1: the gist of it. Now, below the skull, the Neanderthal
[5:43] Speaker 1: body was robustly built in ways that reflect both the
[5:46] Speaker 1: evolutionary heritage of a large-bodied hominid lineage and the specific
[5:50] Speaker 1: demands of Ice Age Europe. Cause the environmental factors always
[5:58] Speaker 1: influence things. Neanderthal bones are thick-walled and heavily muscled, with
[6:05] Speaker 1: large joint surfaces indicating substantial body weight and exceptional muscular force.
[6:11] Speaker 1: The ribcage was barrel-shaped, wider at the bottom than in
[6:15] Speaker 1: modern humans, accommodating a larger gut for processing a high-calorie diet.
[6:22] Speaker 1: The limb proportions... i.e. shorter forearms and lower legs relative
[6:26] Speaker 1: to upper arms and thighs, follow the pattern predicted by
[6:30] Speaker 1: Allen's rule for warm-blooded animals in cold climates, i.e. a
[6:36] Speaker 1: cold reduced surface area body form that minimalizes heat loss,
[6:41] Speaker 1: once again environment dictating evolution. Neanderthals were cold-adapted animals, and
[6:49] Speaker 1: their anatomy shows that, Modern Inuit populations living in comparable
[6:53] Speaker 1: climates show some of the same proportional trends, though they
[6:58] Speaker 1: are less extremely expressed. You can still see the hints, though.
[7:04] Speaker 1: The wear patterns on Neanderthal teeth and bones are a
[7:07] Speaker 1: biography written in calcium. Now the front teeth, the incisors
[7:12] Speaker 1: and the canines, if you're feeling around with your thumb now,
[7:16] Speaker 1: I hope you washed your hands. show heavy wear consistent
[7:19] Speaker 1: with using the teeth as a tool for holding and
[7:22] Speaker 1: processing material, gripping skins while scraping them, holding wood while
[7:28] Speaker 1: working it, stripping meat from bones. We don't quite use
[7:35] Speaker 1: teeth like that anymore, and there is quite a lot
[7:38] Speaker 1: to be said for us taking in a softer diet,
[7:42] Speaker 1: the palate expansion with these more... dense foods, this harder
[7:50] Speaker 1: sort of chewing, giving us, say, a different dental structure
[7:55] Speaker 1: in those earlier times. In fact, we're not as wide-mouthed
[8:01] Speaker 1: as our ancestors were because of this. Neanderthal skeletons frequently
[8:07] Speaker 1: show evidence of healed injuries, fractures, joint damage, dislocated shoulders,
[8:12] Speaker 1: and crushed vertebrae. And the injury patterns... have actually been
[8:16] Speaker 1: compared to those of modern rodeo riders and professional bull riders.
[8:22] Speaker 1: Injuries consistent with close quarters contact with large and powerful
[8:27] Speaker 1: animals struggling at short range. Think about a few kicks
[8:32] Speaker 1: to the ribs, perhaps. Things like this. The Neanderthals were
[8:36] Speaker 1: apparently hunting by driving spears into prey at close quarters,
[8:41] Speaker 1: rather than throwing them from a safe distance. Well, somewhat
[8:45] Speaker 1: safe at least. a strategy that produced meat efficiently, but
[8:49] Speaker 1: at significant personal risk. Almost every well-studied Neanderthal skeleton shows
[8:56] Speaker 1: injury evidence of some kind, and a significant proportion show
[9:00] Speaker 1: injuries that required time to heal, especially back then. No medicine,
[9:06] Speaker 1: I'm afraid. Time during which the injured individual was dependent
[9:10] Speaker 1: on others for food and protection. The injuries and the
[9:15] Speaker 1: Evidence of their healing is simultaneously a record of a
[9:18] Speaker 1: dangerous life and of social bonds that made their survival
[9:21] Speaker 1: possible after injury. After all, we have to lean on
[9:25] Speaker 1: those around us, and that's something that has not changed
[9:30] Speaker 1: over hundreds of thousands of years. Anyway, let's move on
[9:35] Speaker 1: from the general picture of the Neanderthal, from its bone
[9:39] Speaker 1: structure and skull structure, its teeth and body and all
[9:44] Speaker 1: the rest, into when and where they actually lived. Let's
[9:51] Speaker 1: call it the Neanderthal world. Neanderthals occupied a geographic range
[9:59] Speaker 1: extending from the Atlantic coast of Europe in the west
[10:02] Speaker 1: to the Altai Mountains of Siberia in the east, and
[10:06] Speaker 1: from Britain and northern Germany in the north to the
[10:09] Speaker 1: Levant and the Arabian Peninsula in the south, i.e. a
[10:14] Speaker 1: very big area. This is a vast territory encompassing an
[10:18] Speaker 1: extraordinary range of environments, the cold steppes and tundras, the
[10:22] Speaker 1: temperate forests, the Mediterranean scrublands, and the semi-arid landscapes of
[10:28] Speaker 1: the Near East. A little bit of everything. Their temporal
[10:33] Speaker 1: range from approximately 400,000 years ago to approximately 40,000 years
[10:39] Speaker 1: ago spans a period of dramatic and repeated climate change,
[10:44] Speaker 1: with glacial-interglacial cycles. producing alternating periods of cold, dry conditions
[10:51] Speaker 1: and warmer, wetter ones in timescales of tens of thousands
[10:55] Speaker 1: of years. The Neanderthals' ability to persist through all these
[11:00] Speaker 1: environmental shifts is perhaps one of the most impressive things
[11:03] Speaker 1: about them. During cold periods, much of northern Europe became
[11:09] Speaker 1: more or less uninhabitable. and Neanderthal populations contracted southward to
[11:16] Speaker 1: Refugio in the Iberian Peninsula, Italy in the Balkans. During
[11:21] Speaker 1: warmer interglacials, they expanded back north, recolonizing Britain, and reaching
[11:27] Speaker 1: as far north as Jersey in the Channel Islands, where
[11:30] Speaker 1: the site of La Cote de San Berlade preserves extraordinary
[11:34] Speaker 1: evidence of Neanderthal hunting, a mass accumulation of mammoth and
[11:39] Speaker 1: woolly rhinoceros bones in a ravine below a cliff. suggesting
[11:43] Speaker 1: that the Neanderthals were driving these enormous animals over the
[11:47] Speaker 1: edge in a coordinated ambush strategy. Now, think about that.
[11:52] Speaker 1: That requires an extreme amount of planning, communication, and multiple
[11:57] Speaker 1: participants working in unison. Doesn't sound like something the average, quote,
[12:04] Speaker 1: caveman would be doing, right? You see, driving a woolly
[12:08] Speaker 1: rhinoceros off a cliff is not something that you do
[12:12] Speaker 1: by accident. You've got to get the boys together. And
[12:17] Speaker 1: probably the women too, it's probably all hands on deck.
[12:20] Speaker 1: It requires a group of people who have agreed in
[12:22] Speaker 1: advance on who does what, when they do it, and
[12:27] Speaker 1: escape routes if things go wrong. They would operate in coordination.
[12:33] Speaker 1: That can only be described as planned collective action. So
[12:38] Speaker 1: then it brings the question to, you've got to think
[12:41] Speaker 1: about language. You've got to think about their communication for this.
[12:47] Speaker 1: I mean, we can very easily think of the Neanderthal leader,
[12:52] Speaker 1: if they had these kind of structures, or perhaps just
[12:55] Speaker 1: the most experienced hunter, drawing out with his finger in
[12:59] Speaker 1: the dust on the ground to see where we're going
[13:03] Speaker 1: to drive the mammoth off the cliff, who's going here,
[13:05] Speaker 1: who's doing what, and What happens just in case? These
[13:11] Speaker 1: are things that we might not have the evidence of,
[13:13] Speaker 1: but we can safely use our educated imagination. The coastal
[13:20] Speaker 1: and marine dimensions of Neanderthal subsistence has only been recently appreciated.
[13:28] Speaker 1: For most of the 20th century, Neanderthals were assumed to
[13:31] Speaker 1: be exclusively terrestrial hunters. with no significant exploitation of marine
[13:36] Speaker 1: or coastal resources, a distinction that was used to mark
[13:40] Speaker 1: a behavioral boundary between them and more advanced modern humans.
[13:46] Speaker 1: The evidence has been dissolved now at this boundary. At
[13:52] Speaker 1: several coastal sites in Portugal, Gibraltar, and southern Italy, Neanderthal
[13:59] Speaker 1: occupation layers contained substantial quantities of shellfish, marine fish bones,
[14:06] Speaker 1: and the remains of marine mammals, including dolphins and seals,
[14:10] Speaker 1: alongside the bones of raptor birds that were apparently being
[14:14] Speaker 1: taken for their feathers and claws. The exploitation of coastal
[14:18] Speaker 1: resources requires knowledge of tidal patterns, seasonal availability, and the
[14:24] Speaker 1: specific behaviors of marine prey, a form of environmental knowledge
[14:29] Speaker 1: just as demanding as that required for big game hunting
[14:32] Speaker 1: on the steppe. The Neanderthal diet was not a single thing.
[14:38] Speaker 1: It was flexible. It was an environmentally adapted strategy that
[14:42] Speaker 1: varied substantially across their geographic range, and that was capable
[14:47] Speaker 1: of incorporating resources as varied as mammoth, shellfish, cave bear,
[14:51] Speaker 1: and migratory birds. The specific sites at which Neanderthals lived
[14:58] Speaker 1: give us detailed windows into their day-to-day existence. Shanidar Cave
[15:03] Speaker 1: in the Zagros Mountains of what is now Iraqi Kurdistan
[15:07] Speaker 1: is one of the most famous, partly for the remarkable
[15:10] Speaker 1: fossilized remains found there and partly for an interpretation, subsequently debated,
[15:17] Speaker 1: that one of the burials contained flower pollen, suggesting the
[15:21] Speaker 1: deliberate placement of flowers for the dead. The flower burial
[15:26] Speaker 1: interpretation was proposed by Ralph Selecki in the 70s, and
[15:31] Speaker 1: it has been challenged on the grounds that the pollen
[15:34] Speaker 1: may have been deposited by rodents or by natural wind transport.
[15:39] Speaker 1: But the site retains its significance for the exceptional quality
[15:43] Speaker 1: of the fossils themselves. The individual, known as Shanidar I,
[15:49] Speaker 1: an older male with a withered right arm, a severe
[15:52] Speaker 1: blow to the skull that likely caused partial blindness, arthritis
[15:56] Speaker 1: so severe that several joints were essentially fused together, good lord,
[16:02] Speaker 1: and multiple other injuries, survived to middle age despite these disabilities. Now,
[16:08] Speaker 1: he was, by any assessment, a man who could not
[16:11] Speaker 1: have survived without sustained and deliberate support from his community.
[16:17] Speaker 1: And that means someone fed him Someone sheltered him and
[16:21] Speaker 1: protected him for years after he had lost the capacity
[16:25] Speaker 1: to do so for himself, or even to contribute much
[16:28] Speaker 1: to the group at all. Shanidar I is one of
[16:32] Speaker 1: the most compelling pieces of evidence in the entire human
[16:36] Speaker 1: fossil record for the existence in a pre-modern human species
[16:40] Speaker 1: of genuine compassion, in practice rather than just in sentiment.
[16:47] Speaker 1: while the distribution of Neanderthal sites across Europe and Western
[16:50] Speaker 1: Asia reflects both their settlement patterns and the biases of
[16:54] Speaker 1: archaeological research. Some regions, France, Belgium, Spain, Croatia, have been
[17:00] Speaker 1: intensively studied over a century and yield quantities of material
[17:05] Speaker 1: in large amounts. Others, Central Asia and the Arabian Peninsula,
[17:10] Speaker 1: the Levant, have been less intensively investigated. but increasingly reveal
[17:16] Speaker 1: evidence of Neanderthal presence in environments that the older Europe-centric
[17:21] Speaker 1: literature had not quite anticipated. The discovery of Neanderthal-made tools
[17:27] Speaker 1: at sites in the Arabian Peninsula dated to periods when
[17:30] Speaker 1: the climate was substantially wetter than today, has extended their
[17:34] Speaker 1: known range into regions once considered too arid for them,
[17:39] Speaker 1: and suggested the migrations of the Neanderthals and early modern
[17:43] Speaker 1: humans through this corridor were quite a bit more complex
[17:47] Speaker 1: and frequent than earlier models had proposed. Well, next up,
[17:54] Speaker 1: let's talk about a little bit of the technology, because
[17:59] Speaker 1: we did mention the tools, right? The stone tool industry
[18:03] Speaker 1: associated with Neanderthals, the Mosterian, named after the site of
[18:07] Speaker 1: Le Mostier in the Dordogne region of France, is one
[18:12] Speaker 1: of the most extensively analysed lithic traditions, lithic meaning stone
[18:16] Speaker 1: in the archaeological record, and it is considerably more sophisticated
[18:23] Speaker 1: than the popular image of Neanderthals as crude stone nappers
[18:28] Speaker 1: as suggested. The Mysterion is characterised primarily by the production
[18:34] Speaker 1: of prepared core tools, The napper first shaped the stone
[18:40] Speaker 1: core through careful preliminary flaking to predetermine the size and
[18:45] Speaker 1: shape of the flake that would be detached, and then
[18:48] Speaker 1: struck off the prepared flake in a single blow. The result?
[18:52] Speaker 1: A consistently shaped tool of predictable size and appropriate sharpness,
[18:58] Speaker 1: produced with an efficiency that required both skill and a
[19:01] Speaker 1: mental model of the intended product maintained through a multi-stage
[19:05] Speaker 1: reduction sequence. Pretty much just a tool for the job.
[19:11] Speaker 1: Really interesting to think about that. Because remember, you have
[19:15] Speaker 1: to have this picture in your mind of it. So
[19:18] Speaker 1: we are thinking of a Neanderthal having this mental map
[19:24] Speaker 1: of exactly what they want to create. And then going
[19:27] Speaker 1: through all these stages of creating it. With this passed
[19:31] Speaker 1: down knowledge from previous experts. It's not very animalistic, isn't it?
[19:37] Speaker 1: Very human, rather. Well, humans are animals, yeah. We don't
[19:41] Speaker 1: want to get technical. Anyway. Now, the levallois technique, rather.
[19:47] Speaker 1: The most distinctive prepared technique. core method of the Mysterian,
[19:52] Speaker 1: required the napper to shape a core into a tortoise
[19:55] Speaker 1: shell form through careful peripheral flaking, then to strike a
[19:59] Speaker 1: single flake from the prepared surface with a blow calibrated
[20:02] Speaker 1: to detach a tool of predetermined size, shape, and thickness.
[20:07] Speaker 1: The cognitive demands of the levallois production have been extensively
[20:11] Speaker 1: studied through experimental replication, and the consensus is that producing
[20:16] Speaker 1: a Levalois flake requires planning several steps ahead, the ability
[20:21] Speaker 1: to mentally represent a three-dimensional object in multiple stages of reduction,
[20:27] Speaker 1: and a fine motor control that takes years of practice
[20:30] Speaker 1: to develop. It is not, in other words, simple. And
[20:37] Speaker 1: if you think it is, Well, why don't you walk
[20:40] Speaker 1: outside and try to do it? Good luck. When experimental
[20:45] Speaker 1: archaeologists teach modern humans to produce Le Valois tools, the
[20:50] Speaker 1: learning process takes months of sustained practice before acceptable results
[20:54] Speaker 1: are consistently achieved. And there's not much beginner's luck in
[20:58] Speaker 1: it either. Neanderthals were making them all the time, across
[21:03] Speaker 1: the full geographic range of their distribution, and for tens
[21:07] Speaker 1: of thousands of years. Beyond stone tools, the evidence for
[21:13] Speaker 1: Neanderthal material culture had expanded dramatically in recent decades. The
[21:17] Speaker 1: use of adhesives, specifically birch bark tar and pine pitch
[21:22] Speaker 1: as hafting compounds to attach stone tool heads to wooden handles,
[21:26] Speaker 1: has been documented at multiple Neanderthal sites, and represents a
[21:30] Speaker 1: multi-stage technological process of considerable complexity. Producing birch bark tar
[21:38] Speaker 1: requires heating birch bark in a controlled, oxygen-reduced environment, and
[21:43] Speaker 1: collecting the resulting tar without burning it, another process that
[21:48] Speaker 1: cannot be achieved accidentally, and that requires either a specific
[21:53] Speaker 1: pyrotechnical procedure, or the recognition and collection of naturally occurring
[21:58] Speaker 1: tar under very specific conditions. Either way, It implies a
[22:02] Speaker 1: level of chemical and technological knowledge that contradicts any simple
[22:06] Speaker 1: picture of Neanderthal technological capability. You know, it's kind of ironic.
[22:12] Speaker 1: Because if you were to sit there with a group
[22:14] Speaker 1: of Neanderthals and try to do these kinds of things
[22:17] Speaker 1: and you were unable to replicate the results, they'd probably
[22:20] Speaker 1: look at you and say, Hmm, this guy's a bit stupid,
[22:24] Speaker 1: isn't he? Maybe not. if you can find a group
[22:30] Speaker 1: of Neanderthals to sit with and practice these things. Anyway,
[22:34] Speaker 1: I don't think we'll be finding them any time soon,
[22:37] Speaker 1: at least not living ones. Now, the wooden spear is
[22:41] Speaker 1: the Neanderthal weapon most directly attested in the record. Though
[22:46] Speaker 1: the evidence is limited by the poor preservation of organic
[22:49] Speaker 1: materials over hundreds of thousands of years, you spears, that
[22:53] Speaker 1: is Y-E-W from Clacton to Liringan, though associated with pre-Neanderthal hominins,
[23:00] Speaker 1: established the tradition of wooden spear manufacture in Europe that
[23:04] Speaker 1: Neanderthals continued. Now, the design of the Mosterian stone points,
[23:12] Speaker 1: many of which show impact fractures consistent with use as
[23:16] Speaker 1: spear tips, rather than as handheld cutting tools, combined with
[23:21] Speaker 1: the injury patterns on Neanderthal skeletons, is consistent with the
[23:25] Speaker 1: close-range thrusting spear warfare we discussed earlier. Some sites show
[23:31] Speaker 1: evidence for composite tools, hafted stone points with adhesive traces,
[23:36] Speaker 1: indicating the tool was bound to a wooden handle. The
[23:40] Speaker 1: Neanderthal hunter, going after a mammoth or rhinoceros, was not
[23:45] Speaker 1: a naked creature screaming and wielding a rock. They were
[23:49] Speaker 1: carrying a purpose-built composite weapon, whose components required preparation skill
[23:54] Speaker 1: and materials acquired from multiple sources. The diet of Neanderthals
[24:00] Speaker 1: is one of those areas where evidence is most detailed
[24:04] Speaker 1: and most informative about their behavioral ecology. Isotopic analysis of
[24:10] Speaker 1: Neanderthal bones, measuring the ratios of different isotopes of carbon, nitrogen,
[24:16] Speaker 1: and other elements preserved in collagen, has been extraordinarily revealing.
[24:22] Speaker 1: Nitrogen isotope values are a proxy for dietary protein sources.
[24:26] Speaker 1: High nitrogen-15 values indicate a diet rich in animal protein
[24:31] Speaker 1: from higher trophic levels. Neanderthal nitrogen isotope values are consistently high,
[24:38] Speaker 1: as high or higher than contemporary large carnivores in the
[24:42] Speaker 1: same environments. This is a species eating large quantities of
[24:48] Speaker 1: animal protein, probably from large game. You got the mammoth,
[24:53] Speaker 1: the rhinoceros, the bison, reindeer, horses, even. They were apex
[24:58] Speaker 1: predators in their ecosystems, occupying a dietary niche comparable to
[25:03] Speaker 1: wolves and lions. The image of Neanderthals as primarily vegetarian
[25:08] Speaker 1: gatherers supplemented by occasional scavenging seems to not be supported
[25:13] Speaker 1: by that isotopic evidence. You just need to look at
[25:16] Speaker 1: the bones. We know exactly what they were eating. And
[25:21] Speaker 1: it was mainly animals. Now, there is a question. And
[25:27] Speaker 1: that is the question of Neanderthal cognitive capability. In layman's terms,
[25:33] Speaker 1: how smart were they? What did they understand? What exactly
[25:38] Speaker 1: could they represent and communicate? It is probably the most
[25:42] Speaker 1: hotly debated aspect of Neanderthal studies. And the evidence has
[25:46] Speaker 1: shifted quite a lot in the past 20 years. rather
[25:50] Speaker 1: in a direction that the older literature would not have predicted.
[25:55] Speaker 1: Still not quite enough to put that insult function of
[26:00] Speaker 1: the word Neanderthal to bed, but I wouldn't call someone
[26:03] Speaker 1: a Neanderthal. In fact, calling a stupid person a Neanderthal
[26:08] Speaker 1: is an insult to the Neanderthals themselves. Anyway, the traditional
[26:13] Speaker 1: position was quite clear, and that was that Neanderthals were
[26:17] Speaker 1: capable technicians whose intelligence was adequate for their ecological niche.
[26:23] Speaker 1: But they lacked the symbolic thinking, language, and social complexity
[26:27] Speaker 1: that distinguished Homo sapiens, and therefore just didn't stand the
[26:31] Speaker 1: test of time. But this position is now untenable, in
[26:36] Speaker 1: the form in which it was held at least, though
[26:39] Speaker 1: the precise nature of Neanderthal cognitive abilities still will remain
[26:43] Speaker 1: genuinely contested. But at least now we've got a bit
[26:46] Speaker 1: more insight. The evidence for Neanderthal symbolic behavior comes from
[26:51] Speaker 1: multiple sites and multiple artifact types. Eagle talons, the claws
[26:56] Speaker 1: of white-tailed eagles found at the Krapina site in Croatia,
[27:01] Speaker 1: dated to approximately 130,000 years ago, show cut marks and
[27:06] Speaker 1: polishing consistent with their removal from the bird and their
[27:10] Speaker 1: processing into personal ornaments. The kind of ornaments you would
[27:15] Speaker 1: expect prehistoric people to be wearing, I suppose. Now, white-tailed
[27:22] Speaker 1: eagles are nothing to be trifled with. They're powerful. They're
[27:26] Speaker 1: difficult to catch. Raptors whose talons are not a food resource,
[27:32] Speaker 1: unless you're really desperate. The deliberate acquisition and modification of
[27:37] Speaker 1: eagle talons for ornamental purposes implies the concept of personal adornment.
[27:43] Speaker 1: which in turn implies a self-concept sophisticated enough to represent
[27:48] Speaker 1: the self through material symbols. This is so-and-so's necklace, or
[27:53] Speaker 1: so-and-so's headband, this kind of thing. People wanted to express themselves,
[27:59] Speaker 1: even back then. Be individuals. The Kripina Eagle talons predate
[28:04] Speaker 1: the arrival of anatomically modern humans in Europe by approximately 90,000 years.
[28:11] Speaker 1: And they were made. by Neanderthals. Perforated shells, marine shells
[28:18] Speaker 1: with deliberately made holes strung up as beads, have been
[28:21] Speaker 1: found at several Neanderthal sites in the Iberian Peninsula, including
[28:26] Speaker 1: Cueva de los Aviones, in the Cueva Anton in Spain.
[28:31] Speaker 1: The original interpretations of these as Neanderthal ornaments were disputed,
[28:35] Speaker 1: partly on dating grounds. Until uranium series dating published in
[28:41] Speaker 1: 2018 established that shells were approximately 115,000 years old. Again,
[28:48] Speaker 1: tens of thousands of years before modern humans showed up
[28:50] Speaker 1: in the region. The shells contained traces of pigment, red
[28:55] Speaker 1: and yellow ochre. Well, that suggests that they were painted
[29:00] Speaker 1: as well as worn. The combination of deliberate perforation, collection
[29:05] Speaker 1: of shells from distant beaches, and the application of pigment
[29:09] Speaker 1: to their surfaces, shows a behavioral package that's very difficult
[29:13] Speaker 1: to explain without invoking some kind of symbolic thinking. The
[29:18] Speaker 1: use of pigments by Neanderthals is attested at multiple sites.
[29:22] Speaker 1: Black manganese dioxide and red ogre were collected, processed, and
[29:27] Speaker 1: apparently applied to surfaces or bodies at numerous Neanderthal sites
[29:31] Speaker 1: across Europe and the Levant. The 2018 paper by D. L.
[29:35] Speaker 1: Hoffman and colleagues, reported uranium series dating of KVAR. in
[29:40] Speaker 1: three Spanish caves, La Vasiega, Mal Travieso, and Ardales, placing
[29:47] Speaker 1: the minimum age of some of the paintings at over 65,000 years,
[29:52] Speaker 1: once again tens of thousands of years before modern humans
[29:55] Speaker 1: arrived in Europe. The painted motifs, Geometric shapes, handprints produced
[30:02] Speaker 1: by blowing pigment around a hand pressed to the wall,
[30:06] Speaker 1: are not complex figurative art, but they are intentional. They
[30:10] Speaker 1: require the preparation and application of pigment to specific surfaces,
[30:15] Speaker 1: and they were made by Neanderthals. The finding remains somewhat
[30:22] Speaker 1: contested within the field, however, we should say. Some researchers
[30:25] Speaker 1: have questioned the dating mythology, and this is something that
[30:30] Speaker 1: Carbon dating is always going to be subjected to. But
[30:34] Speaker 1: the evidence for at least some Neanderthal cave art production
[30:38] Speaker 1: is currently accepted by a significant portion of the relevant
[30:42] Speaker 1: scientific community. The question of language is central to any
[30:47] Speaker 1: assessment of Neanderthal cognitive capability, and it is one on
[30:54] Speaker 1: which the evidence is genuinely ambiguous. the FOXP2 gene involved
[31:01] Speaker 1: in the fine motor control of speech, as the modern
[31:04] Speaker 1: human variant in Neanderthals, as we discussed in a previous episode.
[31:10] Speaker 1: The hyoid bone, the horseshoe-shaped bone in the throat that
[31:14] Speaker 1: anchors the muscles of the tongue and larynx, is one
[31:17] Speaker 1: of the elements of the vocal apparatus that occasionally fossilizes.
[31:22] Speaker 1: And the Neanderthal hyoid, known from the Cabara specimen in
[31:26] Speaker 1: the Levant, is anatomically essentially identical to the modern human hyoid. Now,
[31:33] Speaker 1: this suggests the vocal tract capable of producing a range
[31:36] Speaker 1: of sounds required for articulate speech. The neuroanatomical evidence inferred
[31:43] Speaker 1: from the shape of the brain case interior, which preserves
[31:46] Speaker 1: a rough impression of the outer surface of the brain,
[31:49] Speaker 1: suggests that Neanderthal brains had an enlarged brocas area, the
[31:53] Speaker 1: region associated with speech production in modern humans. relative to
[31:58] Speaker 1: earlier hominins. None of this proves language, of course, but
[32:03] Speaker 1: it does accumulate into a picture of a species with
[32:06] Speaker 1: the anatomical prerequisites for spoken communication that was at least
[32:12] Speaker 1: in the same ballpark as modern human speech capability. I mean,
[32:17] Speaker 1: they're off to the right start, if anything. Now, the
[32:22] Speaker 1: next big point of contention is Neanderthal burial. It's one
[32:29] Speaker 1: of the most debated issues in the field, and it
[32:32] Speaker 1: goes a little bit beyond the technical question of whether
[32:35] Speaker 1: Neanderthals placed bodies in pits intentionally. Let me explain. Deliberate
[32:42] Speaker 1: burial implies a relationship to death and to the dead person.
[32:48] Speaker 1: That involves more than just disposal of a corpse. You know,
[32:52] Speaker 1: we've got practical concerns like bodies smell if you don't
[32:55] Speaker 1: bury them, but Well, does that really matter to nomadic people?
[33:02] Speaker 1: Not really. Well, it does imply at minimum that the
[33:06] Speaker 1: dead individual's body was treated differently from the bodies of
[33:10] Speaker 1: animals or of strangers, that members of the group engaged
[33:13] Speaker 1: in some form of deliberate action in response to death,
[33:18] Speaker 1: and that the physical remains of a known individual continued
[33:21] Speaker 1: to matter to living after the individual's death. This is
[33:25] Speaker 1: not a trivial cognitive and emotional capacity, and its presence
[33:32] Speaker 1: or absence in Neanderthals has been a proxy for deeper
[33:35] Speaker 1: arguments about the presence or absence of symbolic and emotional life.
[33:40] Speaker 1: The evidence for intentional Neanderthal burial comes primarily from a
[33:44] Speaker 1: handful of sites where Neanderthal skeletal remains are found in
[33:48] Speaker 1: anatomical articulation. That is to be said with the bones
[33:53] Speaker 1: on there, correct. positional relationships, which is only possible if
[33:57] Speaker 1: the body was covered before decay and scattered, and scattering
[34:02] Speaker 1: by carnivores and natural processes could occur. Well, at La
[34:09] Speaker 1: Forassée in Dordogne, multiple Neanderthal individuals were found in separate pits,
[34:16] Speaker 1: their bodies placed in specific orientations, some with stone tools
[34:20] Speaker 1: apparently associated with the burial. at Cabara Cave in the Levant,
[34:26] Speaker 1: the burial of a young adult male, preserved with his
[34:30] Speaker 1: hyoid bone intact, and his arms folded across his chest,
[34:34] Speaker 1: in a deliberately dug pit with the skull missing, removed
[34:38] Speaker 1: aboundly after the flesh had decayed, in what may reflect
[34:41] Speaker 1: a specific treatment of the head after death, suggests a
[34:45] Speaker 1: funerary procedure of some kind, even if its meaning cannot
[34:49] Speaker 1: be completely recovered. At Roque de Marseille in France, The
[34:54] Speaker 1: burial of a Neanderthal child in a pit beneath a
[34:57] Speaker 1: rock overhang in a position consistent with deliberate placement has
[35:01] Speaker 1: been analyzed repeatedly with increasingly sophisticated methods and continues to
[35:06] Speaker 1: be regarded by most researchers as a genuinely intentional burial.
[35:12] Speaker 1: The most persuasive evidence for intentional burial and the most
[35:16] Speaker 1: moving in its human resonance comes from the combination of
[35:20] Speaker 1: burial evidence with the evidence of social care for the
[35:23] Speaker 1: living Shanidar, the severely disabled individual that we discussed, blind
[35:30] Speaker 1: in one eye and arthritic, mortally injured, well, he survived
[35:34] Speaker 1: the Middle Age. At a site in Iraq, another Neanderthal
[35:39] Speaker 1: individual with severe developmental abnormalities was apparently kept alive for
[35:44] Speaker 1: years by community support. At Chabot-aux-Seine in France, the original
[35:51] Speaker 1: Old man Neanderthal, as they call him, whose arthritic skeleton
[35:55] Speaker 1: led to the stooped posture misinterpretation that had lost most
[36:00] Speaker 1: of its teeth long before its death and showed bone
[36:03] Speaker 1: remodeling consistent with a soft food diet maintained over years.
[36:08] Speaker 1: Someone was processing the food for him. The combination of
[36:13] Speaker 1: evidence paints a picture of a species with strong social bonds.
[36:18] Speaker 1: genuine emotional investments and individual members of the group, and
[36:22] Speaker 1: a treatment of death that involved more than just passive indifference.
[36:28] Speaker 1: The cannibalism evidence is the dark side of this picture,
[36:32] Speaker 1: and it deserves honest acknowledgement. We did a full video
[36:36] Speaker 1: about prehistoric cannibalism if you're interested, but we'll just gloss
[36:40] Speaker 1: over it quickly here. At several Neanderthal sites, Goyette Cave
[36:45] Speaker 1: in Belgium, Muller-Gercy in France, El Cidron in Spain, etc.
[36:52] Speaker 1: Human bones show cut marks, impact fractures from marrow extraction,
[36:57] Speaker 1: and other processing marks identical to those found on the
[36:59] Speaker 1: bones of hunted animals at the same sites. This is
[37:03] Speaker 1: unambiguous evidence that Neanderthals at these sites ate other Neanderthals.
[37:11] Speaker 1: It's just obvious. Now, The question is whether this was
[37:16] Speaker 1: nutritional cannibalism driven by hunger, or ritual cannibalism with a
[37:21] Speaker 1: symbolic or mortuary dimension, or perhaps just the opportunistic processing
[37:26] Speaker 1: of individuals who had died from other causes, perhaps out
[37:29] Speaker 1: of desperation. That's the real question. It's impossible to determine
[37:34] Speaker 1: from the physical evidence alone, so it's not really something
[37:37] Speaker 1: we can make a judgment about. Now, what can be said?
[37:42] Speaker 1: is that the evidence for cannibalism coexists in the Neanderthal
[37:46] Speaker 1: record with the evidence for burial and social care. Which
[37:50] Speaker 1: means that the Neanderthal relationship to the dead was not
[37:54] Speaker 1: uniform across populations or contexts. A conclusion that, on reflection,
[38:01] Speaker 1: is consistent with the diversity of mortuary practices documented across
[38:04] Speaker 1: the breadth of all human cultures. No one size fits all,
[38:09] Speaker 1: I'm afraid. Now let's move on to a bit of
[38:14] Speaker 1: hard science. The sequencing of the first high-quality Neanderthal genome,
[38:20] Speaker 1: published by Svant Pablo's team in 2010, and the subsequent
[38:25] Speaker 1: sequencing of multiple additional Neanderthal genomes from sites across Europe
[38:29] Speaker 1: and Western Asia, has transformed our understanding of Neanderthal biology
[38:34] Speaker 1: and population history in ways that fossils and archaeology alone
[38:40] Speaker 1: could never have achieved. The genomic evidence addresses questions ranging
[38:46] Speaker 1: from Neanderthal population size to structure, to their relationships with
[38:51] Speaker 1: other hominin populations, to the specific biological traits encoded in
[38:57] Speaker 1: their genome that can be compared to the modern human equivalent.
[39:04] Speaker 1: The most consequential finding of the genomic work is the
[39:07] Speaker 1: confirmation of interbreeding between Neanderthals and some humans. at least
[39:12] Speaker 1: modern humans, Homo sapiens, etc. The genomes of all modern
[39:17] Speaker 1: humans of non-African ancestry contain between 1 and 4% Neanderthal DNA,
[39:24] Speaker 1: inherited from ancestors who interbred with Neanderthals after the out-of-Africa dispersal.
[39:31] Speaker 1: most likely in the Near East between approximately 60 and 80,000
[39:35] Speaker 1: years ago, as modern humans moving out of Africa encountered
[39:39] Speaker 1: Neanderthal populations that had been in the region for hundreds
[39:42] Speaker 1: of thousands of years. Now, this is not a trivial
[39:47] Speaker 1: genetic legacy. 1-4% of the genome represents billions of base pairs.
[39:56] Speaker 1: And the Neanderthal sequences are not randomly distributed across the
[40:00] Speaker 1: modern human genome. They are enriched in some regions and
[40:04] Speaker 1: depleted in others, which tells us about the functional consequences
[40:09] Speaker 1: of introgression. Neanderthal sequences appear to be relatively common in
[40:14] Speaker 1: genes related to the immune system. specifically genes involved in
[40:19] Speaker 1: the innate immune response to pathogens, suggesting that the Neanderthal
[40:23] Speaker 1: immune variants were selectively beneficial to modern humans moving into
[40:28] Speaker 1: environments where Neanderthals had been adapting to local pathogens for
[40:31] Speaker 1: hundreds of thousands of years. We may carry Neanderthal immune
[40:36] Speaker 1: genes because those genes helped our ancestors survive diseases that
[40:41] Speaker 1: the Neanderthals had already evolved resistance to. The interbreeding was
[40:46] Speaker 1: not a single event. Multiple genomic studies have identified signatures
[40:52] Speaker 1: consistent with several separate episodes of gene flow between modern
[40:56] Speaker 1: humans and Neanderthals, just at different times and in different locations.
[41:02] Speaker 1: Including a possible earlier episode of gene flow in the
[41:07] Speaker 1: opposite direction, from early modern humans into Neanderthals. identified in
[41:12] Speaker 1: the genome of a Neanderthal from the Altai Mountains whose
[41:15] Speaker 1: ancestry included modern human sequences predating the main out-of-Africa dispersal.
[41:21] Speaker 1: This bidirectionality is significant. It suggests that the interactions between
[41:27] Speaker 1: the two species were not purely one-directional, but they involved
[41:32] Speaker 1: the gene flow in multiple directions over an extended period.
[41:37] Speaker 1: consistent with the kind of complex population dynamics that characterize
[41:40] Speaker 1: closely related and geographically adjacent species in general. The genomic
[41:46] Speaker 1: evidence has also illuminated the internal diversity of the Neanderthal lineage.
[41:53] Speaker 1: Neanderthal genomes from different sites and time periods show that
[41:57] Speaker 1: the species had a complex population history involving multiple subpopulations
[42:02] Speaker 1: with some degree of isolation from each other and periodic admixtures.
[42:07] Speaker 1: the overall Neanderthal affective population size. The genetic measure of
[42:13] Speaker 1: how many breeding individuals contributed to the ancestry of any
[42:17] Speaker 1: given individual was small, probably in the range of a
[42:21] Speaker 1: few thousand to a few tens of thousands at any
[42:24] Speaker 1: given time. This is substantially smaller than the contemporary modern
[42:30] Speaker 1: human affective population size, and it implies that Neanderthals lived
[42:35] Speaker 1: in relatively small isolated groups, with limited gene flow between them.
[42:41] Speaker 1: The consequences of small population size over extended periods include
[42:45] Speaker 1: the accumulation of mildly deleterious mutations through genetic drift, a
[42:51] Speaker 1: process that may have reduced the overall fitness of Neanderthal
[42:55] Speaker 1: populations relative to the larger and more connected modern human
[42:59] Speaker 1: populations which they were eventually in competition with. This one
[43:05] Speaker 1: of the genetic mechanisms that has been proposed to explain
[43:09] Speaker 1: the eventual demographic success of modern humans relative to Neanderthals,
[43:15] Speaker 1: though the relationship between genetic load and population-level fitness is
[43:19] Speaker 1: complex and, once again, another argument that remains under investigation.
[43:27] Speaker 1: Specific physical traits can now be inferred from the Neanderthal
[43:31] Speaker 1: genome with varying degrees of confidence. The MC1R gene, involved
[43:39] Speaker 1: in pigmentation, has variants in some Neanderthal genomes that, in
[43:44] Speaker 1: modern humans, are associated with red hair and pale skin.
[43:49] Speaker 1: Whether these variants produce the same phenotype in Neanderthals, we
[43:52] Speaker 1: can't really be certain, because the cellular context of gene
[43:56] Speaker 1: expression matters enormously. But the possibility... that at least some
[44:01] Speaker 1: Neanderthal populations were pale-skinned and red hair has been widely reported. Now,
[44:08] Speaker 1: what about blood type? We've done analysis on that too,
[44:13] Speaker 1: and it suggests that Neanderthals had the same ABO blood
[44:16] Speaker 1: group system as modern humans. They apparently lacked the EPAS1
[44:22] Speaker 1: high-altitude adaptation that Tibetan populations carry. And if you've ever
[44:27] Speaker 1: been to Tibet, you know, If you don't have that,
[44:31] Speaker 1: you certainly find out quickly. It's hard to breathe. Anyway, well,
[44:37] Speaker 1: this is a variant that they acquired from the Denisovans
[44:40] Speaker 1: rather than the Neanderthals, suggesting that Neanderthal populations did not
[44:45] Speaker 1: specifically adapt to high-altitude environments, despite living in the mountainous
[44:50] Speaker 1: regions of Europe and Western Asia. The medical consequence of
[44:55] Speaker 1: Neanderthal introgression in modern humans is another growing area of research.
[45:01] Speaker 1: Certain Neanderthal-derived genetic variants in modern humans have been associated
[45:06] Speaker 1: with increased risk of specific conditions. A haplotype near the
[45:11] Speaker 1: OAS gene cluster involved in the antiviral innate immunity. It
[45:19] Speaker 1: appears that this has been inherited from Neanderthals and is
[45:23] Speaker 1: associated with both stronger responses to some RNA viruses. and
[45:28] Speaker 1: actually increased risk of severe COVID-19 outcomes in some carriers.
[45:34] Speaker 1: This is a striking example of the conditional nature of
[45:38] Speaker 1: adaptive value, a gene variant that was presumably beneficial in
[45:43] Speaker 1: the ancestral Neanderthal environment, and that might have been beneficial
[45:47] Speaker 1: to early modern humans encountering new Eurasian pathogens. Turns out
[45:52] Speaker 1: to be quite a risk factor for diseases that didn't
[45:55] Speaker 1: exist until the 21st century, The Neanderthal immune legacy is
[46:01] Speaker 1: not a simple gift or burden, rather a set of
[46:04] Speaker 1: adaptations that fit the conditions of 50,000 years ago, and
[46:09] Speaker 1: that interact with modern conditions in ways that could not
[46:13] Speaker 1: have been predicted, and, of course, ones we're only beginning
[46:17] Speaker 1: to understand. For at least 50,000 years, and maybe even
[46:26] Speaker 1: considerably longer, Neanderthals and modern Homo sapiens were contemporaries. Different species,
[46:33] Speaker 1: same genus. Occupying overlapping or adjacent geographic ranges. Exploiting similar
[46:39] Speaker 1: ecological niches and interacting in ways that the evidence documents
[46:42] Speaker 1: with gradually increasing precision. They're probably going to discover something
[46:49] Speaker 1: next week and this video will be irrelevant, won't it?
[46:52] Speaker 1: Oh well, it is what it is. Well, the nature
[46:55] Speaker 1: of this interaction... what happened when the two species met,
[47:00] Speaker 1: or how they competed or maybe even cooperated, why one
[47:05] Speaker 1: persisted and the other did not, is one of the
[47:08] Speaker 1: questions that still has a lot of the paleoanthropologists scratching
[47:13] Speaker 1: their heads. And, well, it is one on which the
[47:17] Speaker 1: evidence constrains but doesn't fully determine the answer. Modern humans
[47:23] Speaker 1: first appear in the Levant, around Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, Palestine,
[47:28] Speaker 1: these areas, at sites dated to approximately 182 hundred thousand
[47:36] Speaker 1: years ago, in what appears to be an early, unsuccessful
[47:40] Speaker 1: dispersal from Africa that did not establish a permanent modern
[47:44] Speaker 1: human presence outside the continent. The major out-of-Africa dispersal that
[47:50] Speaker 1: populated Eurasia is conventionally dated to between 60 and 80
[47:54] Speaker 1: thousand years ago, consistent with the genomic evidence for the
[47:59] Speaker 1: timing of Neanderthal-modern human interbreeding events in the Near East.
[48:04] Speaker 1: As modern humans moved north and west into Europe and
[48:08] Speaker 1: east into Central Asia, they were entering territories where Neanderthals
[48:13] Speaker 1: had been established for hundreds of thousands of years. The
[48:17] Speaker 1: conventional picture of this process has been one of progressive replacement.
[48:22] Speaker 1: Modern humans advanced. Neanderthals retreated. the frontier moving steadily westward
[48:29] Speaker 1: until the last Neanderthal populations were confined to refugia in
[48:33] Speaker 1: the Iberian Peninsula and then disappeared around 40,000 years ago.
[48:39] Speaker 1: The reality appears to be a little bit more complex.
[48:44] Speaker 1: Radiocarbon dates from Neanderthal sites across Europe have been systematically
[48:48] Speaker 1: revised in recent years with improved dating methodology, and the
[48:53] Speaker 1: result has been a picture of mosaic replacements rather than
[48:57] Speaker 1: a simple advancing front. Modern humans present in some areas,
[49:02] Speaker 1: while Neanderthals remained in neighbouring regions, perhaps for several thousands
[49:07] Speaker 1: of years, the two populations possibly alternating in some locations
[49:13] Speaker 1: as climate fluctuations made some areas alternately favourable and others
[49:18] Speaker 1: not so favourable. At some sites, there is evidence for
[49:23] Speaker 1: what appears to be cultural exchange, or at least cultural
[49:27] Speaker 1: influence between the two populations. The Chateau-Baronian industry of France
[49:32] Speaker 1: and Spain, an upper Paleolithic tool tradition sometimes associated with
[49:37] Speaker 1: the last Neanderthals in the region, dated to approximately 40,000
[49:41] Speaker 1: to 45,000 years ago, contains body ornaments and perforated shells
[49:47] Speaker 1: that look more like the modern human Aurignacian tradition than
[49:52] Speaker 1: the earlier Mosterian. Now, whether this represents Neanderthals independently developing
[49:58] Speaker 1: ornamental behavior, or Neanderthals copying modern human practices, perhaps even
[50:04] Speaker 1: modern human industry misidentified as Neanderthal, That's once again a debate,
[50:11] Speaker 1: with different researchers reaching different conclusions from the same evidence.
[50:18] Speaker 1: The specific mechanisms of Neanderthal disappearance, replacement, assimilation or extinction
[50:23] Speaker 1: are not yet fully resolved. The genomic evidence establishes that
[50:28] Speaker 1: assimilation occurred to some degree. Neanderthal DNA in modern humans
[50:33] Speaker 1: means that some Neanderthals had children with modern humans. whose
[50:37] Speaker 1: descendants survived and contributed to the modern gene pool. But
[50:42] Speaker 1: the scale of this assimilation was apparently insufficient to prevent
[50:46] Speaker 1: the eventual disappearance of Neanderthals as a recognisable population, and
[50:51] Speaker 1: the question of what drove their demographic decline is still
[50:55] Speaker 1: genuinely open. Modern human demographic superiority, large population sizes and
[51:03] Speaker 1: more extensive social networks, more efficient long-distance exchange systems for
[51:08] Speaker 1: raw materials and information. They're all different proposed mechanisms. Disease
[51:14] Speaker 1: transmission from modern humans to immunologically naive Neanderthal populations is another.
[51:22] Speaker 1: I suppose it could happen. Stranger things have killed off populations.
[51:26] Speaker 1: Competition for specific resources during periods of stress is another one.
[51:32] Speaker 1: The truth is likely a combination of a lot of
[51:35] Speaker 1: these factors. Probably the same way that we look at
[51:37] Speaker 1: the Bronze Age collapse in much later and modern humans,
[51:43] Speaker 1: at least on the evolutionary timeline. You know, there's no
[51:46] Speaker 1: single clear explanation that covers the full geographic and temporal
[51:50] Speaker 1: range of the Neanderthal decline. And listen, the question of
[51:58] Speaker 1: when and where The last Neanderthals lived is the ultimate question.
[52:05] Speaker 1: That's been revised a bit by improvements in radiocarbon dating
[52:09] Speaker 1: over the past 20 years, so we're getting into quite
[52:12] Speaker 1: a lot of modern research here. Is this a history
[52:15] Speaker 1: video or a science video? I don't know. Anyway, it
[52:21] Speaker 1: doesn't matter. Well, the previous consensus placed Neanderthals surviving in
[52:26] Speaker 1: the Iberian Peninsula specifically in the Bayondillo Cave and other
[52:32] Speaker 1: southern Spanish sites, as recently as 27 or 29,000 years ago,
[52:39] Speaker 1: which would have placed the last Neanderthals tens of thousands
[52:43] Speaker 1: of years after the main arrival of modern humans in Europe,
[52:47] Speaker 1: and imply a long period of parallel existence. Improved radiocarbon dating,
[52:53] Speaker 1: using ultrafiltration techniques, that remove contaminants from bone collagen before dating,
[53:00] Speaker 1: has systematically pushed the last secure Neanderthal dates back to
[53:04] Speaker 1: approximately 40,000 years ago at most European sites, with some
[53:09] Speaker 1: dates going as late as 41 or 42,000 years ago
[53:13] Speaker 1: in the Caucasus and the Iberian Peninsula. The site of
[53:18] Speaker 1: Gorham's Cave on the Rock of Gibraltar has attracted particular
[53:22] Speaker 1: attention as a possible late Neanderthal refuge. Gibraltar at the
[53:27] Speaker 1: southern tip of the Iberian Peninsula, pretty much the entrance
[53:31] Speaker 1: to the Mediterranean. Well, not pretty much, it is the
[53:34] Speaker 1: entrance to the Mediterranean. Often a relatively mild maritime climate,
[53:40] Speaker 1: even during cold periods, but also access to diverse marine
[53:44] Speaker 1: and land food resources, and geographic isolation that may have
[53:51] Speaker 1: slowed the southward spread of modern human populations. Wosterian tools
[53:56] Speaker 1: at Gorham's Cave have been dated to approximately 24,000 to 32,000
[54:02] Speaker 1: years ago, which would make Gibraltar's Neanderthals the last surviving
[54:07] Speaker 1: populations of the species. These dates have been questioned, though,
[54:11] Speaker 1: right on methodological grounds, rather, and the current consensus is
[54:17] Speaker 1: a bit more cautious. The latest secure date for Neanderthals
[54:21] Speaker 1: anywhere is approximately 40,000 years ago, with the Gibraltar dates
[54:27] Speaker 1: remaining kind of uncertain, due to difficulties in dating in
[54:31] Speaker 1: a cave environment with complex depositional history. But the geographic
[54:37] Speaker 1: logic of Gibraltar as a final refuge is still pretty sound,
[54:41] Speaker 1: and the possibility that a small Neanderthal population clung on
[54:45] Speaker 1: for dear life there several thousand years after their European
[54:49] Speaker 1: counterparts were gone is not impossible. Well, it's not even
[54:55] Speaker 1: implausible The last Neanderthals, wherever and whenever they finally disappeared,
[55:03] Speaker 1: were not the same as the Neanderthals of 200,000 years ago.
[55:07] Speaker 1: Late Neanderthal populations in Europe were small, isolated, genetically impoverished
[55:13] Speaker 1: populations whose demographics were already under stress from the cumulative
[55:18] Speaker 1: effects of small population size and limited gene flow. The
[55:23] Speaker 1: genomic evidence suggests suggest that Neanderthal populations from whom we
[55:28] Speaker 1: have genomes were already showing signs of inbreeding. Runs of
[55:33] Speaker 1: homozygosity in their genomes consist with small communities with exchange
[55:39] Speaker 1: of mates with other groups being quite limited. A Neanderthal
[55:44] Speaker 1: community of the last 10 or 20,000 years was not robust.
[55:49] Speaker 1: It was not like the widespread series of the warm interglacials.
[55:54] Speaker 1: rather a remnant population, possibly aware in some behavioral sense
[55:59] Speaker 1: that times had changed, the good old days were over,
[56:03] Speaker 1: hunting in a landscape increasingly shared with or taken over
[56:07] Speaker 1: by a related but different kind of biped, coping with
[56:12] Speaker 1: the pressures of marginal environments and declining numbers with whatever
[56:17] Speaker 1: resources it had left. There was a Neanderthal from Spy
[56:22] Speaker 1: Cave in Belgium, dated to approximately 40,000 years ago, whose
[56:26] Speaker 1: genome shows a particularly clear signal of the final Neanderthal
[56:31] Speaker 1: population dynamics. A small, isolated group, whose genetic diversity had
[56:37] Speaker 1: been significantly reduced by a long history of small affected
[56:40] Speaker 1: population size. The individual from Spire was among the last
[56:45] Speaker 1: of their kind in northwestern Europe. They lived, hunted, used tools,
[56:52] Speaker 1: and presumably died without knowing that they were among the
[56:55] Speaker 1: last ones left. That's probably for the best, I suppose.
[57:01] Speaker 1: The concept of a species extinction is kind of a
[57:04] Speaker 1: retrospective thing. No member of a declining species experiences themselves
[57:10] Speaker 1: as the last of something. They experience themselves as themselves,
[57:16] Speaker 1: and they cope with the environment that they inhabit. That's
[57:20] Speaker 1: their world. the pathos that we project onto the last
[57:24] Speaker 1: Neanderthals is ours, and not theirs. So, what the genomic
[57:31] Speaker 1: evidence does suggest about the final Neanderthal populations is worth
[57:35] Speaker 1: stating quite plainly, because it complicates the simple narrative of
[57:40] Speaker 1: modern human replacement through direct computational warfare. The mitochondrial DNA
[57:46] Speaker 1: of Neanderthals, which is maternally inherited and therefore traces specifically
[57:51] Speaker 1: female lineages, shows an unusual pattern. European Neanderthal mitochondrial genomes
[57:58] Speaker 1: from the final period are less diverse than those from
[58:02] Speaker 1: earlier periods, suggesting a significant population bottleneck in which most
[58:07] Speaker 1: Neanderthal maternal lineages were lost sometime before the final disappearance.
[58:14] Speaker 1: This could reflect climate-driven population contraction during a cold period. disease,
[58:20] Speaker 1: competition with modern humans, maybe some combination of factors. Like
[58:25] Speaker 1: I said, the old Bronze Age collapse analogy. But what
[58:29] Speaker 1: it does not show is this sudden and dramatic collapse.
[58:35] Speaker 1: There was no big tidal wave that came through and
[58:38] Speaker 1: wiped all the Neanderthals out. It's very rarely that complicated.
[58:43] Speaker 1: Neither were there any sea peoples that came in and
[58:47] Speaker 1: cut all of them in half. No, the Neanderthal decline
[58:52] Speaker 1: appears to have been gradual. It happened over thousands of years.
[58:56] Speaker 1: A very slow erosion of population size and genetic diversity,
[59:01] Speaker 1: rather than a catastrophic event. The people it happened to
[59:06] Speaker 1: had presumably no framework for understanding that trend they were
[59:09] Speaker 1: living through, or rather, dying through. They experienced a world
[59:14] Speaker 1: that was changing. More unfamiliar faces, different tools in the landscape,
[59:21] Speaker 1: maybe encounters with beings that kind of look similar, but
[59:26] Speaker 1: were somehow different in ways that were difficult for them
[59:30] Speaker 1: to articulate. There's just something strange about them. They're not
[59:37] Speaker 1: like us. They adapted, as they always had, and eventually
[59:43] Speaker 1: they just ran out of space to adapt into. And
[59:51] Speaker 1: as for us, we've not run out of space, but
[59:54] Speaker 1: we have run out of time. See what I did there?
[59:58] Speaker 1: Nice little way to end the video. I hope I've
[1:00:03] Speaker 1: rehabilitated the Neanderthal a little bit. That is to be said,
[1:00:09] Speaker 1: the Neanderthal in its rehabilitated form is not this romantic
[1:00:15] Speaker 1: figure or noble savage. I'm not trying to put the
[1:00:18] Speaker 1: Neanderthal up on a pedestal and say, oh, how perfect
[1:00:22] Speaker 1: and intelligent he was. Of course, we're not doing that.
[1:00:26] Speaker 1: That's not realistic. But really what we want to put
[1:00:30] Speaker 1: across is an image that is more honest and interesting,
[1:00:35] Speaker 1: a very real species with real capabilities and real limitations,
[1:00:41] Speaker 1: whose evolutionary history was separate from our own for 400,000 years,
[1:00:46] Speaker 1: and whose evolutionary fate was to be absorbed, largely but
[1:00:51] Speaker 1: not entirely, into the expanding modern human population. Genuinely different
[1:00:57] Speaker 1: from us. anatomically, in some aspects of cognition and behavior,
[1:01:02] Speaker 1: we cannot fully reconstruct. But they were also similar to us. Warm, social, tool-using, fire-controlling,
[1:01:12] Speaker 1: symbolically aware beings that cared for the sick and buried
[1:01:16] Speaker 1: their dead, and wanted to be individualistic with a new
[1:01:22] Speaker 1: necklace or some kind of adornments. That skull was In
[1:01:28] Speaker 1: the Neander Valley, that fool rot picked up in 1856
[1:01:31] Speaker 1: was not, as the stoop Neanderthal misinterpretation suggested, the skull
[1:01:37] Speaker 1: of something lesser than us. It was the skull of
[1:01:41] Speaker 1: something that was just beside us. A species parallel and distinct.
[1:01:48] Speaker 1: A story intersected with ours at several points. Well... And,
[1:01:54] Speaker 1: of course, something that... survives today not as fossils in
[1:01:58] Speaker 1: a museum, but as part of your very own skin
[1:02:02] Speaker 1: and sequences of genomes in every non-African human alive today.
[1:02:08] Speaker 1: Just take a look at yourself. Pinch that skin of yours.
[1:02:11] Speaker 1: I'm currently pinching mine. A little bit of that came
[1:02:15] Speaker 1: from a Neanderthal, if you are non-African. Anyway, that is
[1:02:20] Speaker 1: not extinction. It is transformation. And it is, when you
[1:02:26] Speaker 1: think about it very carefully, one of the most remarkable
[1:02:30] Speaker 1: things in the history of our species. At least I
[1:02:33] Speaker 1: think so. Anyway, thank you so much for joining me.
[1:02:38] Speaker 1: We've had another whale of a time over here on
[1:02:41] Speaker 1: the prehistoric playlist. And I'm finishing up this recording right
[1:02:48] Speaker 1: on dinner time, so you know what I'm going to
[1:02:51] Speaker 1: go do. Anyway, it's been a pleasure. I will run
[1:02:55] Speaker 1: the list of patrons and supporters. Thank you for them,
[1:02:58] Speaker 1: keeping it all ad-free. Links in description and pinned comment.
[1:03:03] Speaker 1: Give it a like, comment, and subscribe. Tell your friends,
[1:03:05] Speaker 1: all that good stuff. Good night, farewell, and I'll see
[1:03:09] Speaker 1: you next time.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
