# Trump vs Federal Judges, Retaliatory Redistricting & Tattoo Lawsuit

An episode of [Bloomberg Law](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/277975394), 26 Jul 2025, 41 min.

Audio: https://podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/e73c998e-6e60-432f-8610-ae210140c5b1/7c892d84-801f-4c0b-b0e9-ae2b0012ff5f/c248c0eb-7622-4538-bc1d-b326015f18e9/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=91224201-26a6-429d-ac3c-ae2b0012ff6d

Retired federal judge Andre Davis, a member of Keep Our Republic’s Article III Coalition, discusses the Trump administration’s unprecedented lawsuit against all the federal judges on the Maryland bench. Richard Briffault, a professor at Columbia Law School, discusses Texas redistricting plans. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:02] Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grossel from Bloomberg Radio.
[0:08] Speaker 2: The Trump administration has been locked in a showdown with
[0:11] Speaker 2: the federal judiciary, as judge after judge has blocked President
[0:15] Speaker 2: Trump's agenda, and the country's chief law enforcement officer, Attorney
[0:21] Speaker 2: General Pam Bondi, has repeatedly attacked federal judges.
[0:25] Speaker 3: They're deranged, is all I can think of. I cannot believe.
[0:29] Speaker 3: I think some of these judges think they are beyond
[0:31] Speaker 3: and above the law, and they are not. We are
[0:35] Speaker 3: in court every day fighting against these activist judges. We're
[0:39] Speaker 3: not going to stop. Many of them should be recused
[0:42] Speaker 3: from these cases. They will be recused from these cases.
[0:44] Speaker 3: We're appealing them. Look at Chuckin. Look at Judge Chuckin
[0:47] Speaker 3: with the EPA trying to control our money. Judge Chang
[0:51] Speaker 3: trying to control the money of the USA. Judge Reyes,
[0:54] Speaker 3: look what she did to Pete Hegseath. These injunctions have
[0:58] Speaker 3: a loud District Court judge to be emperors. They vetoed
[1:02] Speaker 3: all of President Trump's power, and they cannot do that.
[1:07] Speaker 2: The Justice Department went from rhetoric to legal action, filing
[1:12] Speaker 2: an unprecedented lawsuit against all fifteen federal district judges in
[1:17] Speaker 2: Maryland over an order that grant's a two days stay
[1:20] Speaker 2: of deportation to migrants who file habeas corpus petitions. This week,
[1:26] Speaker 2: Maryland's federal judges responded by asking a court to dismiss
[1:30] Speaker 2: the lawsuit, saying it was an assault on the separation
[1:34] Speaker 2: of powers. My guest has retired federal Judge Andre Davis.
[1:38] Speaker 2: He set on the US Court of Appeals for the
[1:41] Speaker 2: Fourth Circuit, and he's one of more than forty judges
[1:44] Speaker 2: working with the nonpartisan group Keep our Republic's Article three coalition.
[1:49] Speaker 2: Thanks so much for joining me. Judge Davis, you are
[1:52] Speaker 2: once a federal judge in Maryland. What's your reaction to
[1:56] Speaker 2: the Trump administration suing the entire federal bench in the state.
[2:00] Speaker 4: Well, June, you know, I don't know that the language
[2:05] Speaker 4: exists honestly to express my reaction. The words that have
[2:10] Speaker 4: been used, of course, unprecedented, extraordinary, which is true. But honestly,
[2:17] Speaker 4: I don't have a rhetorical device myself to capture just
[2:22] Speaker 4: how extraordinary it is for the executive branch to actually
[2:28] Speaker 4: follow a lawsuit, a purported lawsuit against an entire District
[2:33] Speaker 4: court bitch naming each of the individual judges in their
[2:38] Speaker 4: official capacities over the court's use of a fairly routine
[2:45] Speaker 4: administrative order. It's just off the charts extraordinary. That was
[2:50] Speaker 4: my initial reaction, and the more I've thought about it
[2:53] Speaker 4: over the last two weeks, that reaction has really solidified
[2:57] Speaker 4: inside me.
[2:58] Speaker 2: This suit is about a standing order by the chief
[3:01] Speaker 2: judge that stopped the administration from deporting migrants who filed
[3:07] Speaker 2: a habeas petition for two days. The Maryland judges say
[3:11] Speaker 2: that these kinds of temporary stays are common and pointed
[3:15] Speaker 2: to similar stays in the Fourth Circuit. But the Trump
[3:18] Speaker 2: administration says it's extraordinary.
[3:21] Speaker 4: What's extraordinary is the administration's decision to challenge the order
[3:27] Speaker 4: through the means of a purported lawsuit. The order is
[3:32] Speaker 4: absolutely routine, as you just said, the Fourth Circuit, the
[3:36] Speaker 4: Ninth Circuit, a number of circuit courts of appeal use
[3:41] Speaker 4: these kinds of standing orders to manage their docket to
[3:46] Speaker 4: pace the work, as well as a number of district
[3:50] Speaker 4: courts around the country. So this is as routine as
[3:53] Speaker 4: it gets, honestly, and the idea that somehow this is
[3:59] Speaker 4: different because it requires a two business day hiatus to
[4:05] Speaker 4: give a judge a full opportunity to consider a request
[4:09] Speaker 4: for emergency relief. As I say, the rhetoric to capture
[4:14] Speaker 4: the extraordinary nature of this act by the administration honestly
[4:18] Speaker 4: just doesn't exist.
[4:20] Speaker 2: Do you see this as a ratcheting up of the
[4:23] Speaker 2: Trump administration's assault on the judiciary or is it an
[4:27] Speaker 2: attempt by Trump to further expand executive powers or both
[4:32] Speaker 2: or neither.
[4:33] Speaker 4: I'll have to believe that for others to judge. What
[4:36] Speaker 4: I can tell you is that one aggressive enforcement of
[4:41] Speaker 4: the executive branches priorities. That's a decision for an administration
[4:46] Speaker 4: as to how they wish to pursue their priorities. What's
[4:50] Speaker 4: not for any administration to do is to call into
[4:54] Speaker 4: question the rule of law, the legitimacy of courts, and
[4:59] Speaker 4: the separation of powers, which is exactly what this action does.
[5:04] Speaker 4: If they want to be aggressive, they can be aggressive,
[5:06] Speaker 4: and they are aggressive. But the Court is entitled, and
[5:09] Speaker 4: not just entitled, but the court is duty bound to
[5:14] Speaker 4: protect its jurisdiction to ensure that it can fairly, really
[5:21] Speaker 4: unbiased way decide the disputes that come before the court.
[5:26] Speaker 4: And so an administration that sets up a system in
[5:30] Speaker 4: which an effort can be made to deprive the court
[5:33] Speaker 4: of jurisdiction. If that's what's happening by these rushed removals,
[5:39] Speaker 4: then the courts have a duty to make sure that
[5:42] Speaker 4: that jurisdiction is protected.
[5:44] Speaker 2: I want to go over some of the arguments that
[5:46] Speaker 2: judges make in their dismissal motion. As you're referred to.
[5:50] Speaker 2: They argue that the lawsuit is a violation of the
[5:53] Speaker 2: separation of powers. Quote. A lawsuit captioned Congress versus executive
[5:59] Speaker 2: or vice vers would be dismissed in a heartbeat. A
[6:03] Speaker 2: suit effectively captioned executive versus judiciary fares no better.
[6:09] Speaker 4: Well, first of all, how can the United States sue itself? Right?
[6:13] Speaker 4: I mean, it's like this part of the United States
[6:16] Speaker 4: suing that part of the United States. It cuts to
[6:19] Speaker 4: separation of powers. In this way, the coequal branches of
[6:24] Speaker 4: government are co equal. Each has pharmacy in its lane,
[6:31] Speaker 4: and the judicial lane is the adjudication of disputes both
[6:36] Speaker 4: between the government and non governmental actors as well as
[6:40] Speaker 4: between private parties including corporations, nonprofits, and individuals. That's how
[6:47] Speaker 4: the system is designed. That's how it has worked for
[6:51] Speaker 4: nearly two hundred and fifty years, and now we have
[6:55] Speaker 4: this situation where one part of the government claims to
[6:59] Speaker 4: be able to coerce another part of the government to
[7:03] Speaker 4: do what it wants. Think about it, jes take a
[7:06] Speaker 4: step back from it for a moment. Here we have
[7:10] Speaker 4: the executive branch asking a single district judge from somewhere
[7:16] Speaker 4: in the country to beliefs the administrative practices of another
[7:24] Speaker 4: group of federal district judges. I mean, it's enough to
[7:27] Speaker 4: give you a headache. That can't possibly that can't possibly
[7:32] Speaker 4: be consistent with separation of powers. The executive branch is
[7:37] Speaker 4: purporting to capture one part of the judicial branch to
[7:43] Speaker 4: use as a pugel against another part of the judicial branch.
[7:49] Speaker 4: Thomas Jefferson is turning over a grain.
[7:53] Speaker 2: So another argument that the Maryland judges are making is
[7:57] Speaker 2: that the court is shielded under sovereign immunity and that
[8:01] Speaker 2: the judges and court clerks are protected under judicial immunity.
[8:06] Speaker 4: Absolutely bull stop. In my judgment, there's simply no legitimate
[8:11] Speaker 4: response to that other than that's correct. It's absolutely correct.
[8:17] Speaker 4: There's just no.
[8:18] Speaker 2: Answer to it because all the judges in Maryland are
[8:22] Speaker 2: being sued here. The Fourth Circuit appointed a judge from
[8:25] Speaker 2: outside the circuit to hear the case. So the Circuit
[8:30] Speaker 2: appointed Virginia Federal Judge Thomas Cullin, a Trump appointee, to
[8:35] Speaker 2: handle the case. He's only been on the bench since
[8:38] Speaker 2: twenty twenty, and he hasn't handled any high profile cases.
[8:42] Speaker 2: Any idea why he.
[8:43] Speaker 4: Was chosen, No, I don't. I can tell you generally
[8:48] Speaker 4: what the Fort tries to do when they have to
[8:51] Speaker 4: choose judges who are willing to go out of district
[8:55] Speaker 4: or out of circuit for a special assignment. They look
[8:59] Speaker 4: at I think one, frankly, who's workload at the moment
[9:04] Speaker 4: will allow that judge to take on a little bit
[9:08] Speaker 4: of extra work. I myself, in fact, on two separate
[9:11] Speaker 4: occasions when I was on the Fourth Circuit, I volunteered
[9:15] Speaker 4: and was appointed by the Chief Justice to sit as
[9:19] Speaker 4: a visiting judge in the Third Circuit in Philadelphia in
[9:22] Speaker 4: a couple of cases where the entire bench of the
[9:27] Speaker 4: Third Circuit, all seventeen judges for a couple of reasons,
[9:31] Speaker 4: were we acused from hearing the case. So the Chief
[9:35] Speaker 4: Justice appointed myself and two other visiting judges to go
[9:38] Speaker 4: to Philadelphia to hear argument and decide the case. So
[9:41] Speaker 4: it does happen from time to time. And as I say,
[9:45] Speaker 4: one of the first considerations is who among you can
[9:48] Speaker 4: devote additional time to this extra work? And I suspect
[9:53] Speaker 4: that that was a principal reason. But you know, any
[9:56] Speaker 4: district judge willing to do it and able to do
[9:58] Speaker 4: it would have been fine. Short to the fourth sercit.
[10:02] Speaker 2: The Maryland judges also say that this wouldn't be the
[10:05] Speaker 2: last such lawsuit if it's not quickly rejected. Do you
[10:09] Speaker 2: see this as a broader attack by the Trump administration
[10:13] Speaker 2: on the federal judiciary as sort of the first step,
[10:17] Speaker 2: or is it more isolated targeting the Maryland bench, which
[10:21] Speaker 2: is handed down a lot of decisions curbing the Trump
[10:24] Speaker 2: administration in high profile cases like that of Kilmar Orbrigo Garcia.
[10:30] Speaker 4: I frankly think it's impossible to believe, based on what
[10:34] Speaker 4: has occurred up until now, that this was on one
[10:38] Speaker 4: off that if this were somehow to succeed, It's hard
[10:43] Speaker 4: to imagine that this practice wouldn't see itself duplicated around
[10:49] Speaker 4: the country. Why was Maryland chosen in particular here? I
[10:54] Speaker 4: don't know. I can't answer that. There have been rulings
[10:58] Speaker 4: that the executive brand which has objected to all over
[11:02] Speaker 4: the country on a number of issues, including the issue
[11:06] Speaker 4: present in this instance of expedit at removal. But I
[11:11] Speaker 4: don't see a world in which if this case somehow succeeds,
[11:16] Speaker 4: even succeeds at the motion to dismiss stage, which I
[11:19] Speaker 4: don't believe it will, It's going to be duplicated around
[11:22] Speaker 4: the country if it succeeds here.
[11:25] Speaker 2: So you think that the motion to dismiss will be granted?
[11:28] Speaker 4: I do believe that. I do believe that.
[11:31] Speaker 2: The Trump administration basically appeals every decision that goes against them.
[11:36] Speaker 2: Do you think that this case will end up at
[11:38] Speaker 2: the Supreme Court.
[11:40] Speaker 4: That's a good question if they choose to appeal, just
[11:44] Speaker 4: as I believe the case is going to be dismissed
[11:47] Speaker 4: at the district court level, I believe that the Fourth
[11:50] Speaker 4: Circuit will reject any appeal that's taken, and frankly, I
[11:56] Speaker 4: believe that the Supreme Court will reject any appeal that
[12:01] Speaker 4: is sought from them. But whether such an appeal or
[12:04] Speaker 4: a petition for cert eventually gets filed is entirely up
[12:08] Speaker 4: to the Department of Justice and the administration and Judge.
[12:13] Speaker 2: Davis, why did you join Keep our Republic's Article three Coalition?
[12:19] Speaker 4: Oh, it took me all about a half a second
[12:23] Speaker 4: when I learned of the Article three coalition and the
[12:27] Speaker 4: extraordinary retired judges who I know, many of them are
[12:30] Speaker 4: my friends. I've served with them over many years. The
[12:33] Speaker 4: idea that we retired federal judges have a special voice
[12:40] Speaker 4: that we can use to educate the public, to speak
[12:45] Speaker 4: on behalf of the federal judiciary, which we all love
[12:49] Speaker 4: and respect and honor so much. The idea that we
[12:53] Speaker 4: can have some space where people can hear us, question us,
[13:00] Speaker 4: check our answers against historical sources, and assess our experience
[13:06] Speaker 4: to lift the public's understanding of the importance of the
[13:10] Speaker 4: rule of law, the separation of powers, the imperative of
[13:14] Speaker 4: judicial independence, all of that together, June is what immediately
[13:19] Speaker 4: prompted me to say, yes, I want to be a
[13:21] Speaker 4: part of this. I want to add my voice to
[13:24] Speaker 4: those of other retired judges who will raise the understanding
[13:30] Speaker 4: of the public and that's really our audience, the understanding
[13:34] Speaker 4: of the public about how courts work, the rule of
[13:38] Speaker 4: law and the foundations of our democracy because there's a
[13:42] Speaker 4: real need for additional efforts in those regards. We are
[13:45] Speaker 4: not the only ones doing this work, and we are
[13:48] Speaker 4: not doing all the work that needs to be done
[13:50] Speaker 4: in this area. But I think retired federal judges have
[13:53] Speaker 4: a legitimacy and aflaim to legitimacy that I think many
[13:58] Speaker 4: many members of the public will respect, listen to, and
[14:02] Speaker 4: learn from. And so that's why I'm very happy to
[14:05] Speaker 4: be a part of this extraordinary coalition.
[14:08] Speaker 2: Thanks so much for joining me, Judge Davis. It's great
[14:11] Speaker 2: to get a judge's perspective on these issues. That's retired
[14:15] Speaker 2: federal Judge Andre Davis. President Donald Trump has been very
[14:20] Speaker 2: open about his plans to use redistricting to help Republicans
[14:25] Speaker 2: retain control of the House in the twenty twenty six
[14:28] Speaker 2: midterm elections. Trump has pushed to get Republican lawmakers in
[14:32] Speaker 2: Texas to redraw the state's congressional maps in favor of
[14:37] Speaker 2: the GOP, saying it would add as many as five
[14:40] Speaker 2: seats for the party five.
[14:42] Speaker 5: I think we get five, and there could be some
[14:45] Speaker 5: other states we're.
[14:46] Speaker 4: Going to get another three or four or five. In addition,
[14:49] Speaker 4: Texas would be the biggest one, and that'll be five.
[14:52] Speaker 2: And when Governor Greg Abbott announced his agenda for the
[14:56] Speaker 2: legislature a special session that started on Monday, redistricting was
[15:01] Speaker 2: on the list. That's led prominent Democrats to talk about
[15:05] Speaker 2: countering Texas with retaliatory redistricting in blue states. House Minority
[15:11] Speaker 2: Leader Hakim Jeffries is reportedly exploring the possibility of redrawing
[15:17] Speaker 2: house maps in California, New York, New Jersey, and Minnesota.
[15:22] Speaker 2: And California Governor Gavin Newsom has already laid out two
[15:27] Speaker 2: options for retaliatory redistricting in that state, saying Democrats have
[15:32] Speaker 2: to be aggressive.
[15:34] Speaker 4: They're playing by different sever rules.
[15:37] Speaker 5: They can't win by the traditional game, so they want
[15:40] Speaker 5: to change the game.
[15:41] Speaker 4: We can act taller than now.
[15:44] Speaker 2: We could sit on the sidelines, talk about the way
[15:46] Speaker 2: the world should be.
[15:48] Speaker 4: What we can recognize the existential nature.
[15:53] Speaker 2: That is this moment joining me is elections law expert
[15:57] Speaker 2: Richard Brefald, a professor at Columbia Law School. Rich States
[16:01] Speaker 2: are required to draw new congressional maps once a decade
[16:05] Speaker 2: after each census. How unusual is it to redraw the
[16:09] Speaker 2: maps at this time?
[16:11] Speaker 6: This kind of what might be called mid cycle regitioning
[16:13] Speaker 6: is very unusual. It's not that it's never happened before.
[16:16] Speaker 6: It has sometimes happened. Although it's unusual, it happened sometimes.
[16:19] Speaker 6: It happens when a new party takes over state legislature
[16:23] Speaker 6: that they hadn't had at the beginning of the decade.
[16:25] Speaker 6: Here is actually talking to states where the Republicans were
[16:28] Speaker 6: already in charge of doing the districting in twenty twenty
[16:31] Speaker 6: one and saying, well, I want you to do it
[16:34] Speaker 6: even more so now. And it's very rare that it's
[16:37] Speaker 6: being gone so kind of blatantly nakedly partisan purposes. There
[16:42] Speaker 6: usually has some justification for it, but this time, I
[16:45] Speaker 6: mean it's being announced as purely partisan, purely gerrymandering, rather
[16:50] Speaker 6: than any claim that there was kind of a problem
[16:52] Speaker 6: of representation with the older districts.
[16:54] Speaker 2: And the Supreme Court has said partisan gerrymandering is okay,
[17:00] Speaker 2: racial jerry mandering is not.
[17:02] Speaker 6: That's correct. I mean, I guess technically what they have
[17:04] Speaker 6: said is that partisan jerry mandering is not unconstitutional. They
[17:08] Speaker 6: don't endorse it, but they have said that there's nothing
[17:11] Speaker 6: the federal courts can do about it. Racial jerry mandering,
[17:14] Speaker 6: districting designed to help one race over another. That does
[17:18] Speaker 6: raise a constitutional concern, but race and party are often
[17:22] Speaker 6: very closely intertwined, and in their most recent cases, the
[17:25] Speaker 6: Court has basically said, if the state says it's partisan,
[17:28] Speaker 6: because partisan is constitutional, we're going to defer them. We're
[17:31] Speaker 6: going to put a very heavy burden of proof on
[17:33] Speaker 6: the other side, challenging to show that it's not partisan,
[17:36] Speaker 6: it's racial. And here, at least what's going on in Texas,
[17:40] Speaker 6: the announcement is so clearly that it's partisan, and it
[17:42] Speaker 6: seems to be that. But I think it would be
[17:44] Speaker 6: very hard to show that even if there's a racial
[17:47] Speaker 6: component to it, it'd be very hard to show that
[17:49] Speaker 6: it wasn't primarily partisan.
[17:51] Speaker 2: Techas Republican Governor Greg Abbott said his decision to put
[17:55] Speaker 2: redistricting on the list for the special session was because
[18:00] Speaker 2: of a letter he got from the Justice Department that
[18:03] Speaker 2: alleges that four of the current districts were racial gerrymanders
[18:07] Speaker 2: that violate the Fourteenth Amendment. I mean, does that letter
[18:10] Speaker 2: make any sense legally? Is it pretextual?
[18:15] Speaker 6: It sure seems that way. I mean, these districts were
[18:17] Speaker 6: adopted two years ago, and they were designed to provide
[18:21] Speaker 6: representation for minority groups. I think for African Americans and Latinos.
[18:25] Speaker 6: I think they were primarily Latino districts. The Constitution does
[18:29] Speaker 6: not forbid that in the Voting Rights Act. Actually, if
[18:31] Speaker 6: it doesn't require that, at least it promotes that idea
[18:34] Speaker 6: a fair representation for minorities. So no one has ever
[18:37] Speaker 6: challenged those districts, and basically the current administration seems to
[18:41] Speaker 6: be that anything that even thinks about race is unconstitutional.
[18:45] Speaker 6: That's not been the standard until now. The Supreme Court
[18:48] Speaker 6: standard is that race can be taken into account in districting,
[18:51] Speaker 6: it just can't be the overwhelming factor, the predominant factor.
[18:55] Speaker 6: And I think you would have to show that these districts,
[18:58] Speaker 6: of course did help minority representation, but you would have
[19:02] Speaker 6: to show that that was the overwhelming factor as opposed
[19:05] Speaker 6: to other factors, including respect for political subdivision mindes following
[19:09] Speaker 6: the course of pre existing districts. It does seem as
[19:11] Speaker 6: though this was designed purely to give a justification for
[19:15] Speaker 6: a re redistricting without anyone going to court and suing.
[19:18] Speaker 6: No one has gone to court to sue to challenge
[19:20] Speaker 6: those districts. If anything, there was another lawsuit that was
[19:24] Speaker 6: brought from the other perspectives, saying that some other districts
[19:27] Speaker 6: in Texas violated the Voting Rights Act in terms of
[19:30] Speaker 6: limiting minority representation, and the state had been defending them
[19:34] Speaker 6: saying that the state's districting plan was entirely constitutional. So
[19:37] Speaker 6: the state has now kind of flipped its position, you know,
[19:40] Speaker 6: moving away from its position that everything is fine, and
[19:43] Speaker 6: is now considering redoing the.
[19:44] Speaker 2: District rich This could also be risky for Republicans, not
[19:48] Speaker 2: just legally but at the ballot box. Here's what former
[19:51] Speaker 2: Texas Congressman betow O Rourke said.
[19:55] Speaker 1: And then it may come back to bite these Republicans
[19:57] Speaker 1: because in order to create more districts that they can win,
[20:01] Speaker 1: they're going to have to lose some Republican voters in
[20:04] Speaker 1: current Republicans strongholds. So there may be an opportunity for Democrats.
[20:08] Speaker 2: Do you see a real risk here?
[20:10] Speaker 6: It depends on exactly what the Republicans do. But I
[20:13] Speaker 6: think if they take some districts where Republicans are strong
[20:18] Speaker 6: and move some Republican voters into nearby districts currently held
[20:23] Speaker 6: by a Democrat but have been trending Republican, I think
[20:26] Speaker 6: what happened is that in the twenty twenty four election,
[20:29] Speaker 6: a lot of districts that are held by Democrats voted
[20:32] Speaker 6: for Trump, and so I think what they're thinking is
[20:35] Speaker 6: that they may be able to move some Republican voters
[20:39] Speaker 6: from what are clearly Republican districts into districts which have
[20:43] Speaker 6: been Democratic districts but night tip Republican with a few
[20:46] Speaker 6: more Republican voters. So that's the idea. In what I've
[20:49] Speaker 6: seen numbers, they think they can find as many as
[20:51] Speaker 6: five districts that look like that. What Aururke is getting
[20:54] Speaker 6: at is they're risking the possibility that not only won't
[20:57] Speaker 6: these districts tip, but by moving Republicans out of the
[21:01] Speaker 6: other districts, they risk losing those districts. A lot will
[21:04] Speaker 6: turn on what the political climate is next fall in
[21:08] Speaker 6: twenty twenty six. If it's a democratic year, that is
[21:12] Speaker 6: a real risk. If it's not, then the Republican strategy
[21:15] Speaker 6: may work. But you know, at some point, there are
[21:17] Speaker 6: only so many Republican and Democratic voters in a state,
[21:20] Speaker 6: and the idea is to try and arrange them in
[21:23] Speaker 6: such a way to maximize your party's vote. But people
[21:26] Speaker 6: don't always vote exactly the same each time, and it
[21:29] Speaker 6: could be that some voters switched back and the Republicans
[21:32] Speaker 6: did very well in what had been Democratic districts last time,
[21:36] Speaker 6: will they do as well next time?
[21:37] Speaker 2: There's also a risk of retaliation. Minority Leader Hakim Jeffries
[21:42] Speaker 2: is reportedly exploring the possibility of redrawing house maps in California,
[21:47] Speaker 2: New York, New Jersey, Minnesota, and Washington. And California Governor
[21:52] Speaker 2: Gavin Newsom has been pretty blunt about saying, we're going
[21:56] Speaker 2: to try to redistrict here in California.
[21:58] Speaker 6: I think would be very hard to do this in
[22:00] Speaker 6: California because they have a constitutional amendment that governs how
[22:04] Speaker 6: redistricting is done. They would basically have to either supersede
[22:08] Speaker 6: that amendment with a new amendment that either forever for
[22:12] Speaker 6: one time only it would change the districting process. That's
[22:15] Speaker 6: really hard. I mean, I think they'd have to get
[22:17] Speaker 6: something through the legislature and to the voters, and then
[22:20] Speaker 6: the voters would have to approve that, and then they'd
[22:23] Speaker 6: have to go and then write a new plan. And
[22:25] Speaker 6: you know, that's a big list. And whether or not
[22:28] Speaker 6: they could get a constitutional amendment to the voters in
[22:30] Speaker 6: time this year and whether the voters would approve it.
[22:34] Speaker 6: I mean, it's also pretty blatant, and although California runs Democratic,
[22:38] Speaker 6: it's not clear to me that the voters would approve this.
[22:41] Speaker 6: I mean the might and then of course they'd have
[22:43] Speaker 6: to write a plan in a way that doesn't follow
[22:46] Speaker 6: the constitutional pattern they have there. They have to come
[22:48] Speaker 6: up with an entirely new system, so I guess they'd
[22:50] Speaker 6: have to take it away from the Constitutional Commission and
[22:52] Speaker 6: give it to the legislature, either always or this one time.
[22:56] Speaker 6: I'm not sure what the proposal is.
[22:58] Speaker 2: And what about redistricting in other Democratic controlled states.
[23:03] Speaker 6: Well, again, New York also has adopted a new constitutional
[23:06] Speaker 6: format redistricting, and that I think currently governs. I don't
[23:11] Speaker 6: know about the other states. I think in the other
[23:13] Speaker 6: states it may be possible that the legislature would they
[23:16] Speaker 6: have a democratic legislature and a democratic governor. You mentioned Minnesota.
[23:20] Speaker 6: I think the Minnesota legislature is very closely divided, and
[23:24] Speaker 6: I think a key Democrat is just convicted of a
[23:26] Speaker 6: crime and they have to resign. On which case, it's
[23:28] Speaker 6: not hear the Democrats have the Minnesota legislature. You mentioned
[23:31] Speaker 6: Washington state, that might be possible and you're talking about
[23:34] Speaker 6: picking up maybe one seat I think on a place
[23:36] Speaker 6: like that.
[23:37] Speaker 2: The term jerry mandering was coined back in the eighteen hundreds,
[23:42] Speaker 2: so it's been around for quite a while, and both
[23:45] Speaker 2: parties are guilty of jerry mandering. But has it gotten
[23:49] Speaker 2: worse lately?
[23:51] Speaker 7: Oh?
[23:51] Speaker 6: Absolutely, Basically because the computer power has gotten so much better.
[23:55] Speaker 6: It has become much easier for computers to generate multiple
[23:59] Speaker 6: maps of thousands of maps that all comply with one person,
[24:03] Speaker 6: one vote and use pre existing voting or voter registration
[24:07] Speaker 6: data to maximize the number of Republican or Democratic districts.
[24:10] Speaker 6: So it's no longer taking out big maps using crayon
[24:14] Speaker 6: and drawing on the floor. You can generate almost an
[24:17] Speaker 6: infinite number of maps by programming them to respect certain
[24:21] Speaker 6: factors and not others, and that makes it incredibly easy.
[24:25] Speaker 6: Now the level of you know, hyperpartisanship legislatures as such
[24:28] Speaker 6: that they're also willing to do it. There's been something
[24:30] Speaker 6: of a pushback, and I mentioned in California and New
[24:33] Speaker 6: York have cons social amendments that can try to limitary mandering.
[24:37] Speaker 6: A handful of other states there have been limits placed
[24:40] Speaker 6: on jerrymandering either by constcial amendment or by state Supreme
[24:43] Speaker 6: Court decision. But where the legislatures are not limited, they
[24:48] Speaker 6: have kind of infinite capacity to come up with maps
[24:52] Speaker 6: that will do as much as possible to maximize the
[24:56] Speaker 6: power of the party in power.
[24:58] Speaker 2: And it seems like the Democratic states are there ones
[25:00] Speaker 2: with those independent commissions, etc. Whereas the Republican states are
[25:06] Speaker 2: still mostly relying on their legislatures.
[25:09] Speaker 6: You're right, and Arizona, which I guess is a purple state,
[25:12] Speaker 6: has a commission. But I think you know, we're talking
[25:14] Speaker 6: about California, New York, New Jersey, and then court decisions.
[25:19] Speaker 6: I think Pennsylvania maybe now Wisconsin.
[25:22] Speaker 2: Well, there's a lot to watch with the maps and
[25:25] Speaker 2: possible legal challenges before the midterms. Thanks so much, rich
[25:30] Speaker 2: that's Professor Richard Rfault of Columbia Law School. You can't
[25:34] Speaker 2: erase a tattoo, but can you erase a jury verdict
[25:38] Speaker 2: about a tattoo? That's what photographer Jeffrey Sedlick is asking
[25:42] Speaker 2: the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to do. The photographer
[25:46] Speaker 2: sued celebrity tattoo artist Cat von Dee over a tattoo
[25:50] Speaker 2: she inked of legendary jazz musician Miles Davis, based on
[25:55] Speaker 2: Sedlick's copyrighted photograph of Davis. The jury took only three
[25:59] Speaker 2: hours hours of deliberating before it returned a verdict for
[26:03] Speaker 2: cat Vonde, finding that the tattoo wasn't substantially similar to
[26:07] Speaker 2: the photo and didn't violate the copyright laws. But on
[26:11] Speaker 2: appeal to the Ninth Circuit, the judges seemed to be
[26:15] Speaker 2: struggling to understand how the jury could reach that verdict
[26:19] Speaker 2: when the tattoo and photo look alike. Here are judges
[26:22] Speaker 2: Kim McLane, Ward Law and Anthony D. Johnstone.
[26:26] Speaker 7: We look at it, we say this is the same photograph.
[26:30] Speaker 7: Yet through all these machinations it ended up being the
[26:34] Speaker 7: jury saying, oh, but it's not substantially similar. And I
[26:39] Speaker 7: think it kind of defies rationality to suggest that it's
[26:46] Speaker 7: not the same photograph. It is the same photograph, it's
[26:50] Speaker 7: on a different medium. So how did the jury get
[26:52] Speaker 7: where it got?
[26:54] Speaker 8: But I think we've also said that just transferring out
[26:57] Speaker 8: onto a different medium alone be a difference. Right, We're
[27:02] Speaker 8: looking at similarities rather than difference. And so if you
[27:04] Speaker 8: have everything else is the same and we're just going
[27:06] Speaker 8: to change it from being on photo paper to someone's skin.
[27:10] Speaker 8: How's that?
[27:10] Speaker 2: But even if the judges thought the jury was wrong,
[27:14] Speaker 2: what could they do about it? The Ninth Circuit has
[27:16] Speaker 2: never reversed a jury verdict on substantial similarity A subjective
[27:21] Speaker 2: test joining me to answer these questions that the judges
[27:25] Speaker 2: struggle with is intellectual property litigator Terrence Ross, a partner
[27:29] Speaker 2: at catin Utchen Rosenmann, Terry, will you explain the test
[27:33] Speaker 2: us here for copyright infringement?
[27:35] Speaker 5: So in order to prove up a case of copyright infringement,
[27:39] Speaker 5: you have to show ownership of a register copyright and
[27:43] Speaker 5: proof of infringement. The test for infringement in the Ninth
[27:47] Speaker 5: Circuit where this case takes place is well developed over
[27:51] Speaker 5: many years, a little bit complicated, but very well developed,
[27:54] Speaker 5: and it's a two part test with respect to substantial similarity.
[27:59] Speaker 5: First is what's known as the extrinsic test, which is
[28:04] Speaker 5: really an objective test, a fancy word for saying objective tests,
[28:08] Speaker 5: and that's undertaken by the court by the judge who
[28:13] Speaker 5: determines whether or not there are objective elements that have
[28:18] Speaker 5: been copied that constitute the literary works expression. In this case,
[28:23] Speaker 5: the photographic works expression, So is there reason to believe
[28:28] Speaker 5: that a protected element of the work was copied? Now,
[28:31] Speaker 5: this is easier to do, in my opinion, in cases
[28:34] Speaker 5: of photographs then in movies, television shows, plays books where
[28:39] Speaker 5: small portions are copied and they slightly change the characters
[28:43] Speaker 5: or the setting or the plot, and their judges are
[28:46] Speaker 5: really presented with a challenging first step in this infringement
[28:49] Speaker 5: process that they have to undertake to determine whether or
[28:53] Speaker 5: not protected elements of copyright we're infringed, and they get
[28:57] Speaker 5: help from experts on that. The second step, assuming that
[29:01] Speaker 5: the copyright owner passes the first test, which is sort
[29:05] Speaker 5: of a gate keeping function that the judge performs, the
[29:07] Speaker 5: judge that allows the infringement charge through the gate so
[29:11] Speaker 5: to speak to the jury, and then the jury looks
[29:14] Speaker 5: at the two works, engages what's done as an intrinsic test,
[29:17] Speaker 5: which is essentially a subjective review. And the expression you
[29:20] Speaker 5: often here used in the case law is does the
[29:24] Speaker 5: look and feel of the copied work constitute an infringement
[29:29] Speaker 5: i e. An improper copying of the original work. So
[29:32] Speaker 5: there's this two part test. Part one done by the court,
[29:35] Speaker 5: part two done by the jury.
[29:37] Speaker 2: So the judge in this case allowed the infringement charged
[29:40] Speaker 2: through the gate, and the jury decided on the intrinsic
[29:44] Speaker 2: subjective test that the tattoo wasn't substantially similar to the photo.
[29:51] Speaker 2: But during the Ninth Circuit arguments, Judge Wardlaw said they
[29:55] Speaker 2: were struggling to figure out why the jury didn't find
[29:58] Speaker 2: that they were substanti similar. She said, it defied rationality,
[30:03] Speaker 2: and it is the same photo, it's just in a
[30:06] Speaker 2: different medium. And it seemed like the other judges agreed
[30:09] Speaker 2: with her. Can they say the jury was wrong and
[30:11] Speaker 2: reverse the verdict.
[30:13] Speaker 5: Not really. There are some rare instances where that's happened
[30:17] Speaker 5: in copyright cases, but not in the context of substantial similarity.
[30:22] Speaker 5: I know of at least two cases out there in
[30:23] Speaker 5: the Ninth Circuit that involved the defense of day minimous
[30:27] Speaker 5: use where he takes such a small portion of copyright
[30:30] Speaker 5: at worked that the law allows you to do it.
[30:32] Speaker 5: And I know there have been a couple of cases
[30:34] Speaker 5: where the appellate court reversed a jury finding on that.
[30:38] Speaker 5: I've never seen it done in the context of substantial
[30:41] Speaker 5: similarity case here, and a lot of this battle was
[30:45] Speaker 5: lost by the plaintiff when the district court judge, the
[30:48] Speaker 5: trial judge ruled that this was not a case of
[30:51] Speaker 5: substantial similarity. At summary judgment, the copyright owner the photographer
[30:57] Speaker 5: had moved for summary judgment saying, look, this is no
[30:59] Speaker 5: different than putting a book on a xerox machine. It's
[31:02] Speaker 5: literal copyright infringement and we don't need a trial. And
[31:06] Speaker 5: the judge discreet said it was not literal copying and
[31:10] Speaker 5: said that they would have to proceed to trial on
[31:13] Speaker 5: a theory of substantial similarity, and in many respects that
[31:17] Speaker 5: cost them the advantage that they had the copyright owner,
[31:20] Speaker 5: because then you're putting it up for grabs with a jury.
[31:23] Speaker 5: You just don't know how jury's going to come out,
[31:25] Speaker 5: particularly where you have a celebrity defendant here kat Van
[31:29] Speaker 5: d who's apparently famous tattoo artists in California, and potentially
[31:33] Speaker 5: you know, more interesting trial counts in the courtroom presenting
[31:37] Speaker 5: the case, and by all accounts, the defendants trial attorney
[31:43] Speaker 5: did a just fabulous job in the courtroom of getting
[31:48] Speaker 5: the jury to understand the process that the tattoo artists
[31:52] Speaker 5: went through and how that constituted original art in a way.
[31:58] Speaker 5: So to a certa think got out lawyer in the courtroom.
[32:02] Speaker 2: Some of the judges asked the photographer's lawyer to cite
[32:07] Speaker 2: grounds that would allow them to overturn the jury verdict,
[32:10] Speaker 2: and Judge Anthony Johnston saying it appeared to be beyond
[32:14] Speaker 2: our review. I mean, is there any way if they
[32:17] Speaker 2: feel that it's obvious that this is not substantially similar
[32:21] Speaker 2: and that the jury maybe was taken by the celebrity factor.
[32:26] Speaker 2: I mean, is there any way that they would reverse
[32:29] Speaker 2: the jury verdict?
[32:30] Speaker 5: Let me start off by saying this. The council for
[32:33] Speaker 5: the photographer who argued before the Ninth Circuit is a
[32:37] Speaker 5: well known, well respected copyright lawyer by the name of
[32:40] Speaker 5: William Patrie. He has written one of the leading treatises
[32:44] Speaker 5: on copyright law, was the copyright lawyer for the House
[32:48] Speaker 5: of Representatives during several periods of time in which really
[32:51] Speaker 5: significant revisions were made for the Copyright Act, and then
[32:55] Speaker 5: taught copyright law for a number of years. Very well respected,
[32:59] Speaker 5: knows copy right law. As you say, this question was
[33:01] Speaker 5: put to him before he had completed his first sentence
[33:06] Speaker 5: at oral argument before the Ninth Circuit. Can we do this?
[33:10] Speaker 5: Can you cite us to authority that allows us to
[33:12] Speaker 5: do this. And the only case is he was able
[33:14] Speaker 5: to cite to were not in the context of substantial
[33:17] Speaker 5: similarity cases. They were in other contexts. And certainly from
[33:22] Speaker 5: listening to the argument on tape, I came away convinced,
[33:26] Speaker 5: as apparently you do, that the judges would not have
[33:29] Speaker 5: reached the same verdict as the jury. But we're going
[33:32] Speaker 5: to respect the jury's verdict and affirm it. And this
[33:37] Speaker 5: is the whole problem with losing on the second part
[33:42] Speaker 5: of the test, the intrinsic subjective test that depends on
[33:47] Speaker 5: the subjective view the jury is to the look and
[33:49] Speaker 5: feel of the two works. You cannot substitute as an
[33:53] Speaker 5: appellate judge your opinion for that of the juries. And
[33:57] Speaker 5: so I don't see any way that this is going
[33:59] Speaker 5: to be overturned.
[34:01] Speaker 2: I love this line from Photographer's Council. We don't know
[34:05] Speaker 2: what the jury did, and we don't know what the
[34:07] Speaker 2: mystery of Stonehenge is either, but we do know the
[34:10] Speaker 2: jury should never have done this. It must be frustrating
[34:14] Speaker 2: to have, you know, judges see that a jury made
[34:17] Speaker 2: a mistake and still can't do anything about it.
[34:21] Speaker 5: As a baseball guy. The only analogy I can give
[34:22] Speaker 5: you is the umpires call balls and strikes at hum plate.
[34:26] Speaker 5: I mean, it's absolutely verboten for a manager or player
[34:30] Speaker 5: to challenge the calls of balls and strikes in some
[34:33] Speaker 5: sort of objective sense, you know, measured by a robot.
[34:36] Speaker 5: The ball may have been slightly outside the plate, but
[34:38] Speaker 5: that does not make it a ball. The call of
[34:42] Speaker 5: the umpire makes it a strike, and for all purposes
[34:46] Speaker 5: it is a strike. And to go around saying, oh,
[34:48] Speaker 5: got that call wrong, No, there's no appeal from that.
[34:51] Speaker 5: And it's the same with a jury verdict for the
[34:53] Speaker 5: most part, absent fraud, jury being bribed or something like that,
[34:57] Speaker 5: the jury verdict stands up because you're not a ab
[35:00] Speaker 5: to replace your view, your personal view as a judge,
[35:04] Speaker 5: with that of the twelve men and women of the jury.
[35:06] Speaker 5: It simply isn't done in Anglo American law. And that's
[35:11] Speaker 5: the problem you here expressed at the oral argument from
[35:15] Speaker 5: these judges. They would have decided it differently, but they
[35:18] Speaker 5: realized that they're handcuffed.
[35:21] Speaker 2: Terry Judge Johnstone seemed to have some broader concerns.
[35:26] Speaker 8: I guess my concern is we're kind of washing out
[35:29] Speaker 8: the value and the principle of copyright by allowing a
[35:34] Speaker 8: jury to reach unreviewable subjective determinations on an intrinsic test.
[35:40] Speaker 5: Well, he's complaining about the test that has been established
[35:45] Speaker 5: in the Ninth Circuit, and not just in the Ninth Circuit,
[35:47] Speaker 5: multiple other circuit courts. You know, the Sixth Circuit where
[35:50] Speaker 5: you have Nashville and Detroit, you get a clock copyright cases.
[35:53] Speaker 5: Second Circuit where you have New York and get a
[35:55] Speaker 5: lot of copyright case. Seventh Circuit cad get a block
[35:57] Speaker 5: copyright cases. All these courts have adopted the test, although
[36:00] Speaker 5: it was pioneered by the Ninth Circuit, and that was
[36:03] Speaker 5: thirty five forty years ago, and it's lasted the test
[36:07] Speaker 5: of time. In the majority of cases it works. In
[36:11] Speaker 5: this one case, you might be able to argue the
[36:14] Speaker 5: jury got it wrong. I actually unlike you. You see
[36:17] Speaker 5: some differences in the photograph and the tattoo. Now, whether
[36:21] Speaker 5: or not they're enough to have me vote non infringement,
[36:25] Speaker 5: I don't know. I haven't thought about it enough. But
[36:27] Speaker 5: the complaint that the judge here has is fundamentally a
[36:31] Speaker 5: complaint about existing law, and in order to change existing law,
[36:36] Speaker 5: somebody is going to have to petition for an on
[36:39] Speaker 5: bank review at the Ninth Circuit. So what should happen
[36:42] Speaker 5: here is the panel of three judges affirms the jury's verdict,
[36:46] Speaker 5: and then the photographer the planetiff files a petition for
[36:50] Speaker 5: review on bank, meaning the entire Ninth Circuit. All the
[36:53] Speaker 5: active judges of the Ninth Circuit sit and reconsider whether
[36:56] Speaker 5: this is the appropriate test, And that perhaps is what
[37:00] Speaker 5: is being suggested here, But it is sort of like
[37:03] Speaker 5: you know, whistling in the wind. There are always going
[37:06] Speaker 5: to be jury verdicts that people think the jury got wrong,
[37:11] Speaker 5: and that's for being civil cases, and that's going to
[37:12] Speaker 5: be in criminal cases. It's fundamental to our jurisprudence that
[37:16] Speaker 5: we accept that margin of error in order to allow
[37:20] Speaker 5: the sort of due process we want to have II
[37:22] Speaker 5: to have regular citizens decide the cases. And I think
[37:27] Speaker 5: it's very misplaced for a pellet judge on a prominent
[37:31] Speaker 5: court of appeals like this in effect bad mouth the jury.
[37:34] Speaker 2: We've talked about copyright and tattoos before. Does this stand
[37:37] Speaker 2: for any broader principle about you know, tattoos of copyrighted works.
[37:43] Speaker 5: I don't believe it does. I don't believe it stands
[37:46] Speaker 5: for any broad principle and copyright law generally, both attorneys,
[37:50] Speaker 5: the attorney for the photographer attorney for the tattoo artist,
[37:54] Speaker 5: when asked this question at the Ninth Circuit World Argument,
[37:57] Speaker 5: said that they did not believe the decision here impacted
[38:00] Speaker 5: more broadly than the dispute between the two parties. And
[38:04] Speaker 5: I agree with that this is a relatively run of
[38:08] Speaker 5: the mill copyright case. It doesn't set any new copyright law.
[38:12] Speaker 5: It doesn't set any new precedent, and that's why I'm
[38:15] Speaker 5: not super concerned about the fact that maybe the jury
[38:17] Speaker 5: got it wrong. Jury verdicts don't set precedent, and so
[38:21] Speaker 5: the law will continue to be the same man the
[38:23] Speaker 5: next jury might have a completely different view of a tattoo.
[38:27] Speaker 5: But in all cases like this that come back to
[38:31] Speaker 5: this fundamental proposition, the courtroom is not a neutral playing ground.
[38:38] Speaker 5: It is shaped by the attorneys on either side. And
[38:42] Speaker 5: there are attorneys who are really good trial lawyers, who
[38:47] Speaker 5: are really good in a courtroom, and who can shape
[38:51] Speaker 5: the case and the jury's verdict of the case in
[38:54] Speaker 5: a manner that benefits their client. And there are lots
[38:58] Speaker 5: and lots of attorneys who don't fit that bill, and
[39:02] Speaker 5: that's more often than not the real explanation for why
[39:07] Speaker 5: a particular case comes out one way or the other.
[39:11] Speaker 5: For people who simply hire lawyers without considering, well, if
[39:15] Speaker 5: this case goes to trial, how good is my guy
[39:18] Speaker 5: my girl going to be in the courtroom doing mono
[39:22] Speaker 5: amano battle And they simply don't consider things like that,
[39:26] Speaker 5: And that's a mistake, and you get what you deserve
[39:30] Speaker 5: when you make that kind of mistake, and you don't
[39:32] Speaker 5: hire a really good trial lawyer. And you know, I
[39:36] Speaker 5: wasn't there for the trial, but based on what observers
[39:38] Speaker 5: did say and everything I've heard about the case, it
[39:41] Speaker 5: seems to me that the combination of a celebrity defendant
[39:45] Speaker 5: and the defendant out lawyering the plaintiff may have led
[39:49] Speaker 5: to what, at least these judges on the Ninth Circuit
[39:53] Speaker 5: felt was a wrong decision by the jury.
[39:55] Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Terry for those insights from an experienced
[39:58] Speaker 2: trial Lawyerawrence Ross of Captain Mutchen Rosenman. And that's it
[40:03] Speaker 2: for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you
[40:05] Speaker 2: can always get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg
[40:08] Speaker 2: Law podcasts. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
[40:12] Speaker 2: and at www dot bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, slash Law,
[40:17] Speaker 2: and remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every
[40:20] Speaker 2: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso
[40:24] Speaker 2: and you're listening to Bloomberg

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
