# California and DC Sue Trump

An episode of [Bloomberg Law](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/277975394), 17 Aug 2025, 37 min.

Audio: https://podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/e73c998e-6e60-432f-8610-ae210140c5b1/7c892d84-801f-4c0b-b0e9-ae2b0012ff5f/a68709bb-fa99-491a-a52e-b33c002f2cf7/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=91224201-26a6-429d-ac3c-ae2b0012ff6d

Three Republican-led states said Saturday that they were deploying hundreds of National Guard members to the nation’s capital to bolster the Trump administration’s effort to overhaul policing in Washington through a federal crackdown on crime and homelessness. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:02] Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grossel from Bloomberg Radio.
[0:08] Speaker 2: This is liberation Day in DC, and we're going to
[0:12] Speaker 2: take our capital back. We're taking it back.
[0:15] Speaker 3: On Monday, President Trump announced that he would take federal
[0:19] Speaker 3: control of Washington, d C's police Department, citing what he
[0:23] Speaker 3: called out of control crime to declare a public safety emergency.
[0:28] Speaker 4: The city will no longer be a sanctuary for illegal
[0:31] Speaker 4: alien criminals. We will have full, seamless, integrated cooperation at
[0:37] Speaker 4: all levels of law enforcement, and will deploy offices across
[0:41] Speaker 4: the district. With an overwhelming presidence you'll have more police
[0:45] Speaker 4: and you'll be so happy.
[0:47] Speaker 3: Well, DC Mayor Muriel Browser didn't seem so happy. She
[0:52] Speaker 3: said violent crime in the Capitol was at a thirty
[0:55] Speaker 3: year low, but that the president's authority is pretty broad.
[0:59] Speaker 3: Under DC's Home Rule Act.
[1:01] Speaker 5: The Home Rule Charter requires the mayor to provide the
[1:05] Speaker 5: services of MPD during special conditions of an emergency, and
[1:12] Speaker 5: we will follow the law, though there's a question about
[1:16] Speaker 5: the subjectivity of that declaration.
[1:20] Speaker 3: But three days later, tensions flared when the mayor and
[1:23] Speaker 3: DC's Attorney general rejected an order from US Attorney General
[1:28] Speaker 3: Pam BONDI that would have stripped the Metropolitan Police Department's
[1:32] Speaker 3: chief of her authority and place the agency under federal control.
[1:37] Speaker 3: And on Friday morning, DC Attorney General Brian Schwab sued
[1:42] Speaker 3: the Trump administration, saying the attempted takeover of the city's
[1:46] Speaker 3: police force was illegal.
[1:48] Speaker 6: And the Home Rule Charter and the Home Rule Act
[1:50] Speaker 6: is very clear with respect to when the President can
[1:53] Speaker 6: request limited services of MPD, limited by time, limited by
[1:58] Speaker 6: emergency circumstances, and limited for federal purposes, and in all
[2:02] Speaker 6: cases those services must be requested to the mayor to
[2:06] Speaker 6: be provided by the chief of Police. Not a hostile
[2:09] Speaker 6: takeover of our police.
[2:10] Speaker 3: By Friday afternoon, both sides were in court for hearing
[2:14] Speaker 3: on DC's request for a temporary restraining order to avoid
[2:18] Speaker 3: sidelining DC's police chief. My guest is former federal prosecutor
[2:23] Speaker 3: Mary McCord, a professor at Georgetown Law. It seemed like
[2:27] Speaker 3: Mayor Browser was grudgingly complying with the federalizing of the
[2:31] Speaker 3: DC Police force until this order from the US Attorney
[2:35] Speaker 3: General naming the head of the dea Emergency Police Commissioner
[2:41] Speaker 3: of d C.
[2:42] Speaker 7: Well, I mean, certainly even before the new order from
[2:46] Speaker 7: the Attorney General. There were I think a lot of
[2:48] Speaker 7: problems with the declaration of an emergency in terms of
[2:51] Speaker 7: just not really having a factual basis, but the DC
[2:54] Speaker 7: Attorney General had decided obviously not to sue based on that,
[2:58] Speaker 7: and I think you're right that the trigger event was
[3:01] Speaker 7: this order from Attorney General Bondie that basically really did
[3:06] Speaker 7: take over the Metropolitan Police Department. It pointed Terry Cole,
[3:12] Speaker 7: the DEA Commissioner, as the commissioner to assume all of
[3:15] Speaker 7: the powers and duties of the DC Police Chief required
[3:19] Speaker 7: that anything the DC Police Chief or the Mayor or
[3:23] Speaker 7: the commanders of Police wanted to do had to get
[3:26] Speaker 7: approval from Commissioner Cole before doing it. And then it
[3:31] Speaker 7: actually rescinded various police executive orders and general orders, and
[3:36] Speaker 7: so that really is a takeover, and that's what prompted
[3:40] Speaker 7: DC Attorney General Brian Schwab to come in with the complaint.
[3:45] Speaker 3: In the lawsuit, DC alleged that Trump doesn't have the
[3:48] Speaker 3: authority to take control over the police force, and he
[3:52] Speaker 3: can only require the mayor to offer assistance from the
[3:55] Speaker 3: police in certain emergency circumstances. About the suit, well.
[4:01] Speaker 7: I mean it's really the DC Attorney General saying you've
[4:04] Speaker 7: got to comply with the law, and the law that
[4:07] Speaker 7: President Trump invogud. That's part of the Home Rule Act
[4:10] Speaker 7: that gave the District of Columbia starting in nineteen seventy three,
[4:14] Speaker 7: the authority to elect its own mayor and elect the
[4:17] Speaker 7: DC Council, and enact legislation for the city, and to
[4:21] Speaker 7: have its own police chief and its own police force.
[4:23] Speaker 7: But that Home Rule Acts vegatory provision that the President
[4:26] Speaker 7: relied on, doesn't say anything about taking over the Metropolitan
[4:31] Speaker 7: to Police Department. It says that whenever the President determines
[4:34] Speaker 7: that special conditions of an emergency nature exist which require
[4:39] Speaker 7: the use of the Metropolitan Police Force for federal purposes,
[4:43] Speaker 7: he may direct the mayor to provide him and the
[4:46] Speaker 7: mayor shall provide such services of the Metropolitan Police Force
[4:51] Speaker 7: as the President may be necessary and appropriate. And that
[4:54] Speaker 7: is also time limited, no more than thirty days. So
[4:58] Speaker 7: what the PC Attorney General is said is there's nothing
[5:01] Speaker 7: about that language that says that the President can actually
[5:05] Speaker 7: appoint someone to completely take over the entire Metropolitan too
[5:09] Speaker 7: Police Department, restind general orders, and require all activity to
[5:15] Speaker 7: go through him. What this is saying is that the
[5:17] Speaker 7: president can require the mayor to provide services of MPD.
[5:21] Speaker 7: So if you think about it, let's assume, you know,
[5:24] Speaker 7: there's some sort of assault on a federal building that
[5:27] Speaker 7: houses a federal agency. You know, protesters rioting and throwing
[5:32] Speaker 7: rocks at the building and maybe lighting fires, what have you.
[5:36] Speaker 7: You can imagine the president saying, we have a state
[5:38] Speaker 7: of emergency. I don't have enough federal agents to protect
[5:41] Speaker 7: this federal property. I'm going to invoke this provision and
[5:45] Speaker 7: require the mayor to provide Metropolitan Police Department officers to
[5:50] Speaker 7: go and help protect this building and quell the you know,
[5:54] Speaker 7: the disturbance and the criminal activity there. That's like requesting services,
[5:58] Speaker 7: and services must be provided. And I will just say,
[6:01] Speaker 7: as a footnote, having been a prosecutor in GC for
[6:03] Speaker 7: twenty years and lived in this area for thirty five years,
[6:07] Speaker 7: a president would never need to invoke this in order
[6:09] Speaker 7: to get that kind of assistance from the Metropolitan Police
[6:13] Speaker 7: Department if there was a real emergency. Because the Metropolitan
[6:17] Speaker 7: the Police Department and federal law enforcement work together all
[6:21] Speaker 7: the time. They have all kinds of passporces, they have
[6:23] Speaker 7: mutual assistance agreements and if you had a real emergency,
[6:27] Speaker 7: MPD would be going to help. There was a real
[6:30] Speaker 7: emergency at the Capitol in January sixth of twenty twenty one,
[6:33] Speaker 7: and even though there are US Capitol Police, which are
[6:36] Speaker 7: federal police that protect the capital. DC's Metropolitan Police Department
[6:40] Speaker 7: went immediately to help with the emergency there. President of
[6:43] Speaker 7: course didn't ask for it, but didn't request it and
[6:46] Speaker 7: didn't use this provision. But at any rate, this complete
[6:49] Speaker 7: is saying you can't just come in and take over
[6:51] Speaker 7: the entire DC police.
[6:53] Speaker 3: And it seems like in these lawsuits against the Trump
[6:55] Speaker 3: administration there is almost always an allegation that the Strative
[7:00] Speaker 3: Procedure Act is being violated. What was it here?
[7:04] Speaker 7: In this case, what the President did is he delegated
[7:07] Speaker 7: his authority to the Attorney General, Pam Bondi, who then
[7:11] Speaker 7: is the one who put out this order actually effectuating
[7:15] Speaker 7: or trying to effectuate this takeover. And so part of
[7:18] Speaker 7: the causes of actions in the complaint or that that
[7:21] Speaker 7: is an administrative action taken by the head of an
[7:24] Speaker 7: administrative agency that is contrary to law and arbitrary and capricious.
[7:29] Speaker 7: So a number of different causes of actions in the complaint,
[7:32] Speaker 7: but it really all comes down to there's just no
[7:35] Speaker 7: authority to completely take over the police department.
[7:38] Speaker 3: Let's talk about the hearing over DC's request for a
[7:42] Speaker 3: temporary restraining order before Judge Anna Reyes, what were her
[7:46] Speaker 3: main concerns.
[7:48] Speaker 7: So she agreed that section one of Attorney General Bondi's order,
[7:52] Speaker 7: this is the section by which Attorney General Bondi purported
[7:56] Speaker 7: to basically give mister Cole all of the authorities of
[8:00] Speaker 7: the Chief of Police and complete direction and control really
[8:03] Speaker 7: over the Metropolitan Police Department. She agreed that that is
[8:07] Speaker 7: inconsistent with the Home Rule Act in terms of the
[8:10] Speaker 7: other parts of the order where Attorney General Bondi purported
[8:14] Speaker 7: to rescind executive orders and general orders that operate within
[8:19] Speaker 7: the Police Department, which are all immigration related. They have
[8:22] Speaker 7: to do with not voluntarily cooperating with ice enforcement unless
[8:27] Speaker 7: it's something that's required by law, and there's very little
[8:29] Speaker 7: that's actually required by law. So what the judge was
[8:33] Speaker 7: focused on is isn't it a problem to have these
[8:36] Speaker 7: things be rescinded. Don't you need to put things in
[8:38] Speaker 7: a framework of asking for services from the mayor and
[8:44] Speaker 7: the mayor providing those services. What you seem to be
[8:47] Speaker 7: trying to do US government is you seem to be
[8:50] Speaker 7: essentially bypassing the mayor and saying we're just taking over.
[8:53] Speaker 7: And that can't be the way the statute works, because
[8:56] Speaker 7: when Congress enacted the Home Rule Act, they consider a
[9:00] Speaker 7: provision that would have just allowed the president to just
[9:03] Speaker 7: take over the police Department, and that was rejected because
[9:06] Speaker 7: the members of Congress who were considering the Home Rule Act,
[9:10] Speaker 7: they were doing so for the very purpose of there
[9:12] Speaker 7: being local control, you know, turning over local government, local
[9:16] Speaker 7: policing to local control, and so it would be the
[9:20] Speaker 7: antithesis of that to have the president actually take over
[9:23] Speaker 7: the police department.
[9:25] Speaker 3: And what was the government's argument in support of this
[9:28] Speaker 3: order from the US Attorney General.
[9:32] Speaker 7: The government was trying to argue that really the request
[9:35] Speaker 7: could simply be to the mayor that we require the
[9:38] Speaker 7: services of MPD, and that then the President, pursuant to
[9:42] Speaker 7: the Home Rule Act, has the discretion to ask for
[9:45] Speaker 7: services as the president may be necessary and appropriate. And
[9:50] Speaker 7: in the view of the government, that kind of meant
[9:52] Speaker 7: you can ask for anything, and you can have a
[9:55] Speaker 7: federal official actually controlling the police department. That's not where
[9:59] Speaker 7: we ended up. We ended up in the judge taking
[10:02] Speaker 7: a very long break to see if the parties could
[10:05] Speaker 7: work something out between them, because she said, you know,
[10:09] Speaker 7: I'll asure at cro if I have to, but if
[10:12] Speaker 7: it's violated, that's going to be contemptive court. And I
[10:15] Speaker 7: really think that this is the kind of thing that
[10:17] Speaker 7: the parties should try to work out on their own.
[10:20] Speaker 3: And they did. Both sides agreed to leave the DC
[10:23] Speaker 3: Police Chief in control of the department. The DEA chief
[10:28] Speaker 3: is required to go through the mayor, and the mayor
[10:31] Speaker 3: is still required to fulfill policing requests from the Trump administration.
[10:36] Speaker 3: Thanks so much for joining me, Mary. That's Mary McCord,
[10:39] Speaker 3: a professor at Georgetown Law. Coming up next on the
[10:43] Speaker 3: Bloomberg Law Show, California and the Trump administration face off
[10:48] Speaker 3: at a landmark federal trial over Trump's deployment of troops
[10:52] Speaker 3: to Los Angeles in June. I'm June Grosso. When you're
[10:55] Speaker 3: listening to Bloomberg, President Trump has repeatedly said that sending
[11:01] Speaker 3: about four thousand troops to Los Angeles in June saved
[11:05] Speaker 3: the city.
[11:06] Speaker 2: And you watched crimes out, but you wouldn't have Los Angeles.
[11:09] Speaker 2: It wouldn't be existing today. We would have had to
[11:11] Speaker 2: cancel the Olympics if I let that go on.
[11:14] Speaker 3: But LA's mayor and California's governor have said that the
[11:18] Speaker 3: troops weren't needed to handle the limited protests, and the
[11:22] Speaker 3: presence of the military actually inflamed tensions.
[11:26] Speaker 1: The Marines that were never needed here, that never played
[11:29] Speaker 1: a role in crowd control, they're not trained to do that.
[11:32] Speaker 1: They're trained to kill the enemy on foreign lands. The
[11:35] Speaker 1: enemy is not Angelina's. But there's a bottom line.
[11:39] Speaker 4: The police do policing military.
[11:43] Speaker 1: It's for the battlefield.
[11:45] Speaker 3: After hearing testimony in a landmark trial in San Francisco
[11:49] Speaker 3: this week, a federal judge will decide whether Trump's deployment
[11:53] Speaker 3: of the National Guarden Marines to Los Angeles was legal.
[11:58] Speaker 3: My guest is an expert in wars and national security,
[12:02] Speaker 3: Claire Finkelstein, a professor of law at the University of Pennsylvania.
[12:06] Speaker 3: Claire tell us about California's sued against the Trump administration.
[12:10] Speaker 8: There were two bases that the Trump administration has claimed
[12:15] Speaker 8: for federalizing the California National Guard, and one is the
[12:20] Speaker 8: protective power. This is claimed to be an inherent article
[12:24] Speaker 8: to power that the president can wield in order to
[12:29] Speaker 8: protect federal assets. That means federal persons, federal buildings, and
[12:34] Speaker 8: to say we're out there in order to protect anything federal,
[12:39] Speaker 8: so that means ICE agents, and the claim is ice
[12:43] Speaker 8: agents couldn't do their jobs. There are also federal buildings
[12:47] Speaker 8: under threat, and so we had to federalize the National
[12:51] Speaker 8: Guard in order to protect federal assets. So that's number one,
[12:54] Speaker 8: and then the other one is ten USD twelve four
[12:57] Speaker 8: h six, which is a little use statue. The last
[13:00] Speaker 8: time it was used was actually in the Nixon era
[13:03] Speaker 8: to federalize the Guard on the grounds that there was
[13:08] Speaker 8: a rebellion or that they could not otherwise get compliance
[13:13] Speaker 8: with the law, and that was something that the Trump
[13:16] Speaker 8: administration was claiming in this instance. The State of California
[13:21] Speaker 8: challenged that and said, what's the basis for the federal
[13:24] Speaker 8: government thinking that there was a rebellion? No signs of
[13:27] Speaker 8: rebellion here, just some law enforcement issues which we, the
[13:31] Speaker 8: state of California, can handle on top of it. California
[13:34] Speaker 8: was saying, this is a violation of the Tenth Amendment.
[13:37] Speaker 8: We the State of California, California Governor, California officials are
[13:42] Speaker 8: in charge of law enforcement and police powers, and we
[13:48] Speaker 8: are not asking you to come in. So that, in general,
[13:50] Speaker 8: when there is federalization to assist with police thing, that
[13:54] Speaker 8: is normally at the request of a governor. Twelve four
[13:59] Speaker 8: h sixs that troops be deployed through the governor, and
[14:03] Speaker 8: that wasn't done. Governor Newsom wasn't even informed about the
[14:07] Speaker 8: federalization of the National Guard before it occurred. That's the
[14:11] Speaker 8: gist of their claim.
[14:13] Speaker 3: The trial judge Charles Bryer, who by the way, is
[14:16] Speaker 3: retired Justice Stephen Bryer's younger brother, So that the factual
[14:21] Speaker 3: issue is did the Marines and National Guard violate the
[14:25] Speaker 3: Passcomma Tatis Act? Tell us about that Act from eighteen
[14:30] Speaker 3: seventy eight.
[14:31] Speaker 8: So the pass Commatatas says that federal troops normally cannot
[14:37] Speaker 8: engage in law enforcement. So that is very different from
[14:41] Speaker 8: when the governor is in control of the California National
[14:45] Speaker 8: Guard under states active duty status or Title thirty two,
[14:49] Speaker 8: because in that case there is an exception to possecommatadis
[14:54] Speaker 8: when it is under control of state and local authorities.
[14:58] Speaker 8: But when troops are federalized, the pussy Commatatis Act applies,
[15:03] Speaker 8: and that is a criminal statute that says federal troops
[15:07] Speaker 8: cannot engage in law enforcement activities. Now, the federal government says,
[15:11] Speaker 8: in this case, under the protective Power and under twelve
[15:15] Speaker 8: four h six number one, we were not engaged in
[15:18] Speaker 8: law enforcement activities. The rules for the use of force
[15:21] Speaker 8: that we gave to the troops, that's like their rules
[15:25] Speaker 8: of engagement, except in domestic context. We call that rules
[15:28] Speaker 8: for the use of force did not involve, for example,
[15:31] Speaker 8: making arrest. Troops were told that they could not make
[15:33] Speaker 8: arrests specifically, and therefore they were not violating pussy coommatadis
[15:38] Speaker 8: because they weren't involved in law enforcement activities. But California
[15:42] Speaker 8: has said, in fact, you were involved in law enforcement
[15:46] Speaker 8: activities and cited a number of instances such as the
[15:51] Speaker 8: ability to detain individuals waiting for law enforcements such as
[15:56] Speaker 8: LAPD to show up. They maintained that that's a violation
[16:00] Speaker 8: of posscommatatas.
[16:01] Speaker 3: And why does the administration say that posskomma tatis doesn't
[16:05] Speaker 3: even apply here?
[16:07] Speaker 8: The administration, in addition to everything else, rejects the claim
[16:13] Speaker 8: that possecommatatus applies when the troops are deployed in their
[16:22] Speaker 8: protective capacity, namely engaged in protection for federal assets. They
[16:28] Speaker 8: also deny that it applies under twelve four oh six,
[16:33] Speaker 8: and they say twelve four oh six is like the
[16:35] Speaker 8: Insurrection Act. Under the Insurrection Act is generally recognized that
[16:41] Speaker 8: there is an exception to prosecommatatus and that the president
[16:46] Speaker 8: is allowed to deploy federal troops in a law enforcement capacity,
[16:52] Speaker 8: but only because there is deemed to be a situation
[16:57] Speaker 8: that is so serious that fact there's a full blown
[17:01] Speaker 8: insurrection and there was no way to gain control over
[17:06] Speaker 8: the region or that part of the country without having
[17:10] Speaker 8: federal troops engaged in law enforcement activities.
[17:13] Speaker 3: The testimony of one of the witnesses exposed the internal
[17:17] Speaker 3: tensions over the deployment. Longtime military leader, Major General Scott Sherman,
[17:22] Speaker 3: who commanded the Guard troops in La testified he'd never
[17:27] Speaker 3: heard the word rebellion used to describe the situation in
[17:31] Speaker 3: the city, and also that he had expressed resistance when
[17:35] Speaker 3: immigration officials initially asked for military support.
[17:40] Speaker 8: So his testimony was important for a couple of reasons.
[17:42] Speaker 8: The first reason is that he testified that he expressed
[17:47] Speaker 8: reservations and stronger than that, that he voiced opposition to
[17:52] Speaker 8: this operation, and that he was rebuked by a senior
[17:57] Speaker 8: Customs and Border Patrol official who questioned his loyalty to
[18:01] Speaker 8: the nation, which is very surprising. It's very important that
[18:04] Speaker 8: the military are able to express their concerns about the
[18:09] Speaker 8: boundaries of the operations that they're being asked to undertake,
[18:13] Speaker 8: and normally that would be given an awful lot of
[18:17] Speaker 8: difference when you have a senior military leader who was saying,
[18:21] Speaker 8: this is not an operation that we should be undertaking.
[18:23] Speaker 8: It's not appropriate for the military. You would expect an
[18:27] Speaker 8: administration to be sensitive and respectful of that. But it
[18:31] Speaker 8: also suggests that there was a sort of pecking order
[18:36] Speaker 8: and that was a concern about this operation to begin with,
[18:40] Speaker 8: that Customs and Border Patrol were sort of calling the
[18:44] Speaker 8: shot and that the military was going to be placed
[18:49] Speaker 8: in a subordinate position to Customs and Border patrol. That's
[18:54] Speaker 8: problematic from the standpoint of passecomatatas, since the military is
[18:59] Speaker 8: not supposed to be subordinate to civilian law enforcement agents
[19:04] Speaker 8: because it sort of turns them into law enforcement agents.
[19:09] Speaker 8: So that's one reason this is problematic. Another reason his
[19:13] Speaker 8: testimony was important is that he talked about what troops
[19:18] Speaker 8: were told they were allowed to do and what they
[19:20] Speaker 8: were not allowed to do. So though the administration has
[19:24] Speaker 8: been very insistent that the orders to troops did not
[19:29] Speaker 8: violate Pulsicoma tatis, his testimony suggested that they were allowed
[19:37] Speaker 8: to turn military force to civilians if civilians were impeding
[19:44] Speaker 8: federal operations such as ICE operations. Now, that might be
[19:48] Speaker 8: what you would expect if they're there in their protective capacity,
[19:53] Speaker 8: but it shows how tricky it is to have troops
[19:56] Speaker 8: out there and to expect that they're not going to
[19:58] Speaker 8: be involved in law enforcement activity, because it's very hard
[20:03] Speaker 8: to draw the boundary there. If they're in a protective capacity,
[20:06] Speaker 8: they could very well end up having to engage in
[20:09] Speaker 8: law enforcement activities. And typically our troops are not trained
[20:14] Speaker 8: for that. They don't know how to conduct arrests. They
[20:17] Speaker 8: don't necessarily know how to intersect with civilians who were
[20:22] Speaker 8: engaged in criminal activities. They don't know how to preserve
[20:25] Speaker 8: a crime scene. They're not necessarily trained in that. And
[20:29] Speaker 8: so though our National Guard troops are excellent at what
[20:33] Speaker 8: they do, crime control is not their beat. And this
[20:36] Speaker 8: is presumably one of the reasons why General Sherman was
[20:40] Speaker 8: concerned about this operation.
[20:42] Speaker 3: If all the troops were doing was guarding the ice agents,
[20:46] Speaker 3: would that still be a problem under possecoma tatis.
[20:49] Speaker 8: Well, in theory no, but as soon as you're guarding personnel,
[20:55] Speaker 8: you could very easily stray into activity that case passcomatatas.
[21:01] Speaker 8: So what if there's an attack on a federal officer
[21:06] Speaker 8: and there's no one around but National Guard troops to
[21:11] Speaker 8: engage in the detention or make that arrest. This is
[21:15] Speaker 8: what happened in one incident involving a veteran who was
[21:19] Speaker 8: trying to enter the Dureau of Veterans' Affairs, and the
[21:23] Speaker 8: Marines detained him and he was detained for two hours. Roughly.
[21:29] Speaker 8: It was really a mistake, but because there were no
[21:33] Speaker 8: LAPD present at the time, they viewed it necessary to
[21:37] Speaker 8: hold him and detain him until law enforcement officers could
[21:41] Speaker 8: show up. The question is whether or not there was
[21:45] Speaker 8: a violation of posse commatadas just in the detention itself.
[21:50] Speaker 3: Trump has made threats against other cities.
[21:53] Speaker 2: That's going to serve as a beacon for New York, Chicago,
[21:57] Speaker 2: Los Angeles and other places. All over the country. This
[22:01] Speaker 2: whole our whole country is going to be so different
[22:04] Speaker 2: and so great.
[22:05] Speaker 8: If President Trump tries to, for example, take over the
[22:10] Speaker 8: New York Police or the Chicago Police there, he will
[22:14] Speaker 8: not have the home rule advantage that he has in DC,
[22:18] Speaker 8: and he will not find himself in a very good
[22:20] Speaker 8: legal posture there. He really doesn't have any basis and
[22:24] Speaker 8: the control over the police is strictly reserved to the
[22:27] Speaker 8: state under the Tenth Amendment. That's core Tenth Amendment doctrine.
[22:32] Speaker 8: I think that's something that any federal judge would reject
[22:35] Speaker 8: very quickly. Now. As far as federalization of the National
[22:40] Speaker 8: Guard in any other states, he will be in a
[22:43] Speaker 8: similar posture to California, which is why this California trial
[22:48] Speaker 8: is so important. It will teach judges what Judge Briar
[22:53] Speaker 8: is going through right now, and the evidence that Judge
[22:56] Speaker 8: Briar is fifting through will be extremely instructive for federal
[23:00] Speaker 8: judges in other jurisdictions as they inevitably wait posscommatadis issues
[23:07] Speaker 8: in potentially the state of New York or the state
[23:09] Speaker 8: of Illinois. I think we're going to find a situation
[23:12] Speaker 8: replicated in clarity about the boundaries set by possycommatatis and
[23:17] Speaker 8: what federal troops are permitted to do and not do
[23:19] Speaker 8: will be extremely important in the coming weeks.
[23:23] Speaker 3: I'm sure we'll be talking again. Thanks so much, Claire.
[23:26] Speaker 3: That's professor Claire Finkelstein at the University of Pennsylvania. Coming
[23:30] Speaker 3: up next. A win for the administration as a federal
[23:34] Speaker 3: circuit court allows it to block billions of dollars in
[23:37] Speaker 3: foreign aid. I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
[23:44] Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
[23:49] Speaker 3: Attorney General Pam Bondi has frequently chastised federal judges who've
[23:55] Speaker 3: held back President Trump's agenda, calling them liberal activists and
[24:00] Speaker 3: of control.
[24:01] Speaker 9: Judges have used these injunctions to block virtually all of
[24:05] Speaker 9: President Trump's policies. To put this in perspective, there are
[24:10] Speaker 9: ninety four federal judicial districts. Five of those districts throughout
[24:17] Speaker 9: this country held thirty five of the nationwide injunctions. Think
[24:22] Speaker 9: about that, ninety four districts and thirty five out of
[24:26] Speaker 9: the forty opinions with nationwide injunctions came from five liberal
[24:31] Speaker 9: districts in this country.
[24:33] Speaker 3: One of those so called liberal districts where nationwide injunctions
[24:37] Speaker 3: have been issued is the District of Maryland, and the
[24:41] Speaker 3: Justice Department has picked that district to file an unprecedented
[24:45] Speaker 3: lawsuit against all the federal judges in the district. It's
[24:50] Speaker 3: over a standing order that blocks for two days the
[24:53] Speaker 3: deportations of detained immigrants who file habeas petitions. Of course,
[24:59] Speaker 3: Maryland is also the district that drew national attention in
[25:03] Speaker 3: the case of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, who was wrongfully deported
[25:07] Speaker 3: to l Salvador. Joining me is constitutional law expert Harold Krant,
[25:12] Speaker 3: a professor at the Chicago Kent College of Law. How
[25:16] Speaker 3: this lawsuit is unprecedented? How much is this a ratcheting
[25:20] Speaker 3: up of the Trump administration's power struggle with the judiciary.
[25:24] Speaker 10: The Department of Justice had options here. They could have
[25:27] Speaker 10: easily chosen one of the twelve cases in which the
[25:30] Speaker 10: automatic stay had been imposed to file an appeal, and
[25:33] Speaker 10: they would have been able to obtain an orderly fashion
[25:36] Speaker 10: of pellet review of the propriety of the District of
[25:40] Speaker 10: Maryland standing order which imposed the automatic stay in an
[25:43] Speaker 10: immigration Abeast context. They chose not to do that. They
[25:47] Speaker 10: ratcheted up the tension by filing an unteralbleled lawsuit against
[25:51] Speaker 10: all members of the District of Maryland individually as judges,
[25:56] Speaker 10: and that sets the framework for a very important separation
[26:00] Speaker 10: of powish challenge, namely whether the executive branch can sue
[26:05] Speaker 10: judges get information about them depositions because they don't like
[26:10] Speaker 10: a standing order. So the procedural posture itself is what
[26:13] Speaker 10: is the most troubling aspect of this case, not the
[26:16] Speaker 10: only one that's certainly the most troubling.
[26:18] Speaker 3: The government says that two day pause in deportations inhibits
[26:22] Speaker 3: the president's ability to enforce federal immigration laws, and that
[26:26] Speaker 3: the Chief Judge has no authority to issue such a
[26:29] Speaker 3: blanket order.
[26:30] Speaker 10: And so many courts of appeals, and in the case
[26:34] Speaker 10: I think they cited five courts of appeals have automatic
[26:37] Speaker 10: stays in certain contexts in order to preserve the jurisdiction
[26:40] Speaker 10: of the court. And so the District of Maryland is
[26:43] Speaker 10: the site which famously gave rise to the Kilmer Abrago
[26:47] Speaker 10: Garcia case, where the government shipped Garcia out of the
[26:52] Speaker 10: country surreptitiously while a challenge was going on. And so
[26:57] Speaker 10: because they had been burned, and the Department just had
[27:00] Speaker 10: interfered with the jurisdiction of the court previously. That's what
[27:04] Speaker 10: led to this standing order being promulgated. So, I mean,
[27:08] Speaker 10: the Department Justice is right in the sense that an
[27:10] Speaker 10: automatic stay does interfere with cases in which the individual
[27:16] Speaker 10: has no claim whatsoever not to be deported. But you know,
[27:18] Speaker 10: the delay is only for two days, and given what's
[27:21] Speaker 10: happened before in terms of the due process violation that
[27:24] Speaker 10: the government has committed by transporting Garcia and others away
[27:28] Speaker 10: without any kind of chance for hearing, the court followed
[27:31] Speaker 10: the lead of other court's appeals, which said, look, just
[27:34] Speaker 10: give us two days to see if there's any substance here,
[27:37] Speaker 10: and if there's no substance, we'll say, go ahead, shift
[27:40] Speaker 10: the person out. So the Department Justice has taken a
[27:43] Speaker 10: very unusual stance in this context to again increase the
[27:47] Speaker 10: pressure on judges by suing them, which is unparalleled. And
[27:52] Speaker 10: the hearing the Trump appointee seems very dubious as to
[27:56] Speaker 10: the validity of the Department of Justices challenge and.
[28:01] Speaker 3: Judge Thomas Cullen normally sits in Roanoke, Virginia, but the
[28:05] Speaker 3: Fourth Circuit assigned him to hear this case because all
[28:09] Speaker 3: the federal judges in Maryland were being sued and so
[28:13] Speaker 3: were conflicted out. So Judge Cullin, a Trump appointee, tell
[28:18] Speaker 3: the government lawyer, one of the things about me is
[28:21] Speaker 3: I don't have a very good poker face, and I
[28:23] Speaker 3: think you've probably picked up on the fact that I
[28:26] Speaker 3: have some skepticism. He had a lot of skepticism if
[28:29] Speaker 3: you look at what happened at the hearing. He also
[28:32] Speaker 3: questioned whether this could lead to other executive branch litigation
[28:37] Speaker 3: against federal benches all the way up to the Supreme Court.
[28:41] Speaker 4: Yeah.
[28:41] Speaker 10: I mean, we don't want the specter of DOJ suing
[28:45] Speaker 10: judges and having other judges than sitting to judge the
[28:49] Speaker 10: lawsuit against judges, and that comes with subpoenas, depositions, discovery.
[28:56] Speaker 10: Not only said unseemly, it was certainly chill independent judging.
[29:00] Speaker 10: So the very fact of rumging around and the judge's
[29:05] Speaker 10: files to determine what lay behind in this case, the
[29:08] Speaker 10: standing order kind of correspondence there was, would inhibit judicial
[29:12] Speaker 10: freedom and really compromise the independence of the judiciary as
[29:16] Speaker 10: we know it. So I think the Judge came was
[29:18] Speaker 10: right on in saying that even if there were some
[29:21] Speaker 10: kind of issue on the merits here and there's something
[29:25] Speaker 10: of a case that the Department Justice has, this is
[29:27] Speaker 10: not the way to challenge it. Take it normally and
[29:31] Speaker 10: challenge it up to the Four Circuit, and if you
[29:33] Speaker 10: need to the Supreme Court, don't sue the judges themselves.
[29:38] Speaker 3: This illustrates the Trump administration's offensive against the federal judiciary.
[29:44] Speaker 3: There's the inflammatory rhetoric, allegations that the administration has ignored
[29:49] Speaker 3: court orders, and they filed ethics complaints against two federal
[29:54] Speaker 3: judges for things that they said in the courtroom. What's
[29:57] Speaker 3: the administration's strategy.
[30:00] Speaker 10: Certainly part of the rationale of the Trump administration is
[30:04] Speaker 10: to receive a softer reception in the courts. So the theory,
[30:10] Speaker 10: I guess, is that you have a broadside here and
[30:13] Speaker 10: a broadside there that judges down the road will be
[30:16] Speaker 10: more receptive to their arguments. But it could backfire. This
[30:20] Speaker 10: kind of action could scare even judges who would otherwise
[30:23] Speaker 10: be sympathetic with the Trump administration peak say, if we
[30:26] Speaker 10: want to have any kind of independent judging left in
[30:29] Speaker 10: this country, we can't have the executive grant, suing and
[30:33] Speaker 10: deposing and seeking private correspondence from judges in particular cases.
[30:39] Speaker 10: So that's the spectru of what we have through this lawsuit.
[30:42] Speaker 10: And again I don't think the Trumper administration will achieve
[30:45] Speaker 10: their ends through this means.
[30:47] Speaker 3: I want to turn out of a significant win for
[30:49] Speaker 3: President Trump in his efforts to dissolve the US Agency
[30:53] Speaker 3: for International Development and to withhold funding from other programs.
[30:58] Speaker 3: The DC Circuit Court sort of Appeals, in a split
[31:01] Speaker 3: decision this week, rule that the Trump administration can cut
[31:05] Speaker 3: billions of dollars in foreign assistance funds already approved by
[31:10] Speaker 3: Congress for this year. How significant is this decision?
[31:14] Speaker 10: So, I think this is a huge way in on
[31:16] Speaker 10: several different grounds for the Trump administration. And in this case,
[31:19] Speaker 10: the District Court had ordered the money to be dispersed
[31:22] Speaker 10: and said that Congress was clear President has no independent
[31:26] Speaker 10: poundment authority these acting and violation of the Empowerment Control Act. Therefore,
[31:30] Speaker 10: the disrect Court judge directed the administration to spend the money,
[31:34] Speaker 10: and the two to one decision the DC Court of
[31:36] Speaker 10: Appeals overturned that on two different rationales. The first rationale,
[31:41] Speaker 10: which I considered to be the broad one, and more
[31:43] Speaker 10: frightening is that the court said that if you only
[31:47] Speaker 10: are arguing that the president violates the statute, you don't
[31:51] Speaker 10: have a cause of action. There is no power for
[31:54] Speaker 10: anybody who's injured by direct presidential action based upon violation
[31:59] Speaker 10: of statute that can be brought in the federal courts.
[32:02] Speaker 10: This is an astounding decision of immense significance because the
[32:06] Speaker 10: argument is whether the president just stonewalls violates a statute,
[32:11] Speaker 10: ignores a statute, et cetera, et cetera, that no one
[32:14] Speaker 10: can sue to challenge that because the president is immune
[32:18] Speaker 10: from suit. So to me, that is a very consequential,
[32:22] Speaker 10: incredibly broad understanding of precedent and would be very deleterious
[32:28] Speaker 10: in terms of establishing constraints on presidential authority. The majority
[32:33] Speaker 10: also use the second rational that's much more narrow and
[32:36] Speaker 10: I think has some plausibility to it. There, the Court
[32:39] Speaker 10: said that Congress, in creating the Empowerment Control Act, established
[32:43] Speaker 10: the very sensitive procedure by which the Controller General, an
[32:48] Speaker 10: agent of Congress, can decide to sue the president the
[32:52] Speaker 10: violation of the directions from Congress. And so the Court
[32:57] Speaker 10: said that there is an implicit preclusion of review, that
[33:01] Speaker 10: Congress wanted these kinds of empowerment controversies to be adjudicated
[33:05] Speaker 10: only by the Controller General after consultation with Congress, not
[33:10] Speaker 10: by private third parties. I think the issue may be closer,
[33:13] Speaker 10: but certainly my point is that this would have a
[33:16] Speaker 10: much more narrow impact upon future cases. In most of
[33:20] Speaker 10: these other cases we have, the federal employee cases, the
[33:22] Speaker 10: grant cases, there is no implicit alternative procedure, at least arguably,
[33:28] Speaker 10: and so there would not be as much of an
[33:30] Speaker 10: impact upon future litigation. But this first rationale forwarded by
[33:34] Speaker 10: the Court is astonishing again, and they've said, as shocking
[33:38] Speaker 10: as there may be, that no one can sue for
[33:41] Speaker 10: statutory violation by the president, that the president's simply immune
[33:46] Speaker 10: from that suit because the Administrative Procedure Act doesn't waive
[33:48] Speaker 10: his his immunity and there's no other cause of action
[33:51] Speaker 10: available to make sure that the president follows statutes.
[33:56] Speaker 3: And could this same theory of immunity be applied if
[34:00] Speaker 3: the president violates other statutes.
[34:03] Speaker 10: That's one of the basic assumptions of our entire separation
[34:06] Speaker 10: of powers is that the president must comply with statutes,
[34:10] Speaker 10: and so this decision would intensive munize the president from
[34:15] Speaker 10: suits not only about releasing foreign aid as in this case,
[34:18] Speaker 10: but in so many other contexts as well, discharging employees,
[34:23] Speaker 10: canceling grants, et cetera, et cetera. If you could sue
[34:26] Speaker 10: a subordinate executive grant official, that would enable the plaintiffs
[34:31] Speaker 10: to get into court. But according to the DC Circuit
[34:33] Speaker 10: in this case, there could be no direct claim against
[34:36] Speaker 10: the President in this case himself.
[34:39] Speaker 3: So, as you mentioned, there was a two to one decision,
[34:42] Speaker 3: with judges appointed by Donald Trump and George H. W.
[34:46] Speaker 3: Bush in the majority, and of Biden appointee dissenting. If
[34:52] Speaker 3: the challengers ask the DC Circuit, the entire DC Circuit
[34:57] Speaker 3: to reconsider the decision, judges appointed by Democrats hold the majority.
[35:01] Speaker 6: There.
[35:02] Speaker 3: I mean, it's sad to look at this as democratic
[35:05] Speaker 3: appointed judges versus Republican appointed judges, but that's the way
[35:09] Speaker 3: it seems to be breaking down in many of these
[35:12] Speaker 3: cases at the DC Circuit, including on Friday in a
[35:16] Speaker 3: case okaying the dismantling of the CFPB.
[35:20] Speaker 10: Yeah, and in this case, I just find that one
[35:22] Speaker 10: aspect of the majority's decision so frightening and so destructive
[35:27] Speaker 10: of our constitutional order. I'm sure that the entire court
[35:30] Speaker 10: that took up this case would at least narrow the
[35:32] Speaker 10: scope of the majority's decision. And again going back to
[35:37] Speaker 10: the case we discussed with respect to the standing order
[35:40] Speaker 10: of the District of Maryland. They're at least a Trump appointee,
[35:44] Speaker 10: I think will have the independence of minds seemingly so
[35:47] Speaker 10: far to say no, the Justice Department has gone too far,
[35:50] Speaker 10: and I think that's healthy. It's healthy to have sometimes
[35:54] Speaker 10: Biden judges going against Biden or against democratic sort of positions,
[35:58] Speaker 10: and publican judges the same. So we'll have to see
[36:02] Speaker 10: what happens and plays out if the full court takes
[36:05] Speaker 10: this case as a whole, and that remains to be seen.
[36:08] Speaker 3: I'll be keeping my eye on the DC's circuit. Thanks Hal.
[36:11] Speaker 3: That's Professor Harold Krent of the Chicago Kent College of Law.
[36:15] Speaker 3: And that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show.
[36:18] Speaker 3: Remember you can always get the latest legal news on
[36:20] Speaker 3: our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
[36:25] Speaker 3: and at www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law,
[36:30] Speaker 3: and remember to tune into the Bloomberg Law Show every
[36:33] Speaker 3: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time, I'm June Grosso
[36:37] Speaker 3: and you're listening to Bloomberg

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
