# Weekend Law: Fed Legal Fight, Flag Burning & Grant Cuts

An episode of [Bloomberg Law](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/277975394), 30 Aug 2025, 39 min.

Audio: https://podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/e73c998e-6e60-432f-8610-ae210140c5b1/7c892d84-801f-4c0b-b0e9-ae2b0012ff5f/deb71dc0-21b9-46e0-a0ca-b348018a131d/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=91224201-26a6-429d-ac3c-ae2b0012ff6d

June Grasso talks to leading experts about the top legal stories of the week. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:02] Speaker 1: Bloomberg Audio Studios, Podcasts, radio News.
[0:08] Speaker 2: This is Bloomberg Law.
[0:10] Speaker 3: Congress can have no say in making an office independent.
[0:12] Speaker 4: I think all agencies need a degree of autonomy. It
[0:16] Speaker 4: really tests whether the amendments to the law have.
[0:19] Speaker 2: Keith interviews with prominent attorneys and Bloomberg legal experts.
[0:23] Speaker 5: Joining me is Constitutional law professor David Super, Bloomberg News,
[0:26] Speaker 5: Supreme Court reporter Greg Store.
[0:28] Speaker 2: And analysis of important legal issues, cases and headlines. Apples
[0:32] Speaker 2: of Waltgarden.
[0:33] Speaker 4: They don't license their technology.
[0:35] Speaker 3: That is a valid basis to dismiss the case.
[0:38] Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
[0:45] Speaker 5: Welcome to the Bloomberg Law Show. I'm June Grosso. Ahead
[0:49] Speaker 5: in this hour, President Trump's battle with the Fed escalates
[0:53] Speaker 5: into an emergency court hearing. Can Trump jail protesters who
[0:57] Speaker 5: burn the American flag? And the Supreme Court allows the
[1:01] Speaker 5: administration to do what it wants again. It's an unprecedented
[1:14] Speaker 5: legal battle that could reshape the Federal Reserve's longstanding political independence.
[1:20] Speaker 5: President Trump is the first president in history to try
[1:24] Speaker 5: to oust a sitting FED governor. Trump says he's firing
[1:28] Speaker 5: Lisa Cook, the first black woman to serve as a
[1:31] Speaker 5: FED governor because she committed mortgage fraud by listing homes
[1:35] Speaker 5: in both Michigan and Georgia as her primary residence is
[1:39] Speaker 5: when she got mortgages in twenty twenty one.
[1:42] Speaker 1: She seems to have had an infraction, and she can't
[1:46] Speaker 1: have an infraction, especially that infraction, because she's in charge of,
[1:50] Speaker 1: if you think about it, mortgages, and we need people
[1:53] Speaker 1: that are one hundred percent above board.
[1:55] Speaker 5: Cook is fighting back by filing a lawsuit saying Trump
[1:59] Speaker 5: doesn't have the power to remove her from office and
[2:02] Speaker 5: that he violated the federal law that allows him to
[2:05] Speaker 5: remove a FED governor only for cause. Cook's lawsuit is
[2:09] Speaker 5: a major escalation in the growing clash between the White
[2:13] Speaker 5: House and the FED, which has resisted Trump's demands for
[2:16] Speaker 5: lower interest rates. It presents novel issues and will almost
[2:21] Speaker 5: certainly end up at the Supreme Court. It's just a
[2:24] Speaker 5: matter of when. Cook is seeking an emergency in junction
[2:28] Speaker 5: to block her firing and confirm her status as a
[2:31] Speaker 5: member of the Fed's governing board. Federal Judge Ga Cobb
[2:35] Speaker 5: held an emergency hearing on Friday, but her decision isn't
[2:39] Speaker 5: likely until next week or perhaps even later joining me
[2:43] Speaker 5: is Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation analyst Elliott Stein. Elliot tell
[2:48] Speaker 5: us about Cook's arguments for why Trump can't fire her
[2:51] Speaker 5: for these mortgage fraud allegations that took place before she
[2:55] Speaker 5: became a Fed governor.
[2:57] Speaker 6: Well, the first argument is that the four cause requirement
[3:02] Speaker 6: hasn't been met. And their argument is that cause requires
[3:07] Speaker 6: more than mere allegations on truth's social that you know,
[3:12] Speaker 6: you look to the Humphreys executor's standard, which is that
[3:16] Speaker 6: there has to be some sort of inefficiency, neglective duty,
[3:19] Speaker 6: or malfeasance in office. These allegations don't rise. So that
[3:23] Speaker 6: and in any event, she wasn't given an opportunity to
[3:26] Speaker 6: be heard on this and to contest the allegations. End
[3:30] Speaker 6: is that she has a right to receive notice of
[3:34] Speaker 6: the accusations and to contest them.
[3:36] Speaker 5: And is the administration's main argument that basically the president
[3:41] Speaker 5: is the president and the courts have to defer to him.
[3:45] Speaker 6: Yeah, that's a lot of it. I mean, their argument
[3:47] Speaker 6: first is that the statutory text only refers to cause,
[3:51] Speaker 6: it doesn't refer to inefficiency, neglective duty, or malfeasance in office,
[3:54] Speaker 6: So that gives him a broader removal authority, and then
[3:58] Speaker 6: there's also nothing in the statute. The case law is
[4:00] Speaker 6: their argument that a court can even review that determination.
[4:05] Speaker 6: That the statute gives the president the right to determine
[4:07] Speaker 6: if there was cause, and that's not reviewable, and that
[4:10] Speaker 6: there's also nothing about giving the person the notice or
[4:14] Speaker 6: an opportunity to be heard. And in fact, the case law,
[4:18] Speaker 6: they argue, goes against Liza Cook's argument on that. And
[4:21] Speaker 6: if notice was required, she got noticed because she was
[4:24] Speaker 6: aware for several days about these allegations before she was
[4:27] Speaker 6: actually terminated, and she never tried to rebut the allegations factually,
[4:31] Speaker 6: and in that event, you know, a hearing. This is
[4:34] Speaker 6: the government's argument. The hearing seems like it would be
[4:37] Speaker 6: unnecessary because she hasn't even contested the allegations and given
[4:41] Speaker 6: a reason for why these documents would have been filled
[4:45] Speaker 6: out in the way that they were.
[4:47] Speaker 5: The only sort of explanation she gave in her papers
[4:51] Speaker 5: was that there might have been an unintentional clerical error
[4:55] Speaker 5: in her mortgage application, a mislabeling, but no real life
[5:00] Speaker 5: explanation beyond that. And as far as the administration's claimed
[5:03] Speaker 5: that Trump's truth, social posts constituted notice of the allegations.
[5:09] Speaker 5: Judge Cobbs said to the government's lawyer, you're not suggesting
[5:13] Speaker 5: what happened would satisfy due process requirements, and he replied
[5:18] Speaker 5: that he was.
[5:19] Speaker 6: Yeah. Their argument is that the truth Social posts do
[5:23] Speaker 6: provide sufficient notice, and as a result, if notice is required,
[5:28] Speaker 6: they satisfied it. And Abby Lowell had a sort of
[5:32] Speaker 6: funny line, you know, he said, notice shouldn't require having
[5:35] Speaker 6: to sign up for truth Social in order to see
[5:39] Speaker 6: the president's truth Social posts directly. And Abbie Lowell's argument is,
[5:43] Speaker 6: you know, it has to be something a little more
[5:46] Speaker 6: formal than that, not necessarily, you know, full blown investigation,
[5:51] Speaker 6: but some opportunity to butt the allegations.
[5:55] Speaker 5: In May, the Supreme Court blocked the reinstatement of nlr
[6:00] Speaker 5: the and Merit Systems Protection Board commissioners while their suits
[6:04] Speaker 5: played out, and did the same for Consumer Product Safety
[6:08] Speaker 5: Commission heads in July. So was there an argument that
[6:11] Speaker 5: this judge should follow that precedent here?
[6:15] Speaker 6: That did come up in a few contexts, one of
[6:17] Speaker 6: which was the irreparable harm argument, because you know, Lisa
[6:21] Speaker 6: Cook's argument is that if she can't continue to serve
[6:24] Speaker 6: on the Federal Reserve Board while the litigation plays out,
[6:26] Speaker 6: she'll be irreparably harmed because you know, she's unable to
[6:29] Speaker 6: perform her duties that she was appointed and confirmed to perform.
[6:34] Speaker 6: And the government cited all these cases, including Wilcox right
[6:37] Speaker 6: where the NRB and the Emerit Systems Protection Board commissioners
[6:41] Speaker 6: were not reinstated by the Supreme Court while those cases
[6:44] Speaker 6: played out, And you know, the government argued those cases
[6:48] Speaker 6: stand for the proposition that it's harmful to the president
[6:51] Speaker 6: if you know he's unable to perform his statutory duties
[6:54] Speaker 6: to remove federal officers. You know, the Wilcos case. Really
[6:58] Speaker 6: it's a good example of how it can be by
[7:00] Speaker 6: both sides to support their argument.
[7:02] Speaker 5: But a different factor here is the independence of the
[7:06] Speaker 5: Fed and that was a highlight of Cook's complaint. Did
[7:10] Speaker 5: it play in the hearing as well.
[7:12] Speaker 6: Judge cob herself alluded to it. It came up obviously
[7:16] Speaker 6: several times in Abby Lowell's arguments as well. And I
[7:20] Speaker 6: think you know it's relevant because the Supreme Court in
[7:23] Speaker 6: May and Wilcox sort of alluded to it in the
[7:26] Speaker 6: sense that the Federal Reserve is more of a quasi
[7:28] Speaker 6: private uniquely structured institution, whereas so much of the case
[7:34] Speaker 6: law deals with agencies, some of which don't even exist anymore.
[7:38] Speaker 6: The cases are from more than one hundred years ago,
[7:40] Speaker 6: so the context may be a little different. We'll just
[7:43] Speaker 6: see how much that actually matters to the various judges
[7:45] Speaker 6: that are going to hear this.
[7:46] Speaker 5: This was an emergency hearing. What turned it into not
[7:50] Speaker 5: so much of an emergency?
[7:52] Speaker 6: Yeah, well, where one side seeks a TRO a temper
[7:57] Speaker 6: or restaining order, but they're only good if they're granted.
[8:00] Speaker 6: They're only good for like ten days, maybe two weeks,
[8:02] Speaker 6: and then the party has to seek a preliminary injunction
[8:05] Speaker 6: in order to basically keep the status quo in place
[8:09] Speaker 6: for the rest of the litigation. And what often happens
[8:12] Speaker 6: I think is probably going to happen here is because
[8:14] Speaker 6: the issues are so similar per a tro and a
[8:17] Speaker 6: preliminary junction, the parties don't want to have to go
[8:19] Speaker 6: through the same motions twice. So the way the court
[8:22] Speaker 6: left it was that they're going to finish briefing the
[8:26] Speaker 6: tro on Tuesday at Leasta Cook will file her reply
[8:29] Speaker 6: to the President Trump's papers, and in the meantime, the
[8:32] Speaker 6: parties will talk about potentially basically converting the tro motion
[8:37] Speaker 6: to a preliminary in junction motion again, because the issues
[8:40] Speaker 6: basically are the same, and it would just allow the
[8:43] Speaker 6: ruling to stay in place longer, and it would allow
[8:46] Speaker 6: the rulining to be appealed.
[8:48] Speaker 5: We're at a very early stage of this litigation, But
[8:54] Speaker 5: after the hearing, do you think Trump or Cook has
[8:57] Speaker 5: the edge?
[8:59] Speaker 6: Well, this is such a close case. I think President
[9:02] Speaker 6: Trump has very good arguments based on the text of
[9:06] Speaker 6: the Federal Reserve Act, which only says for cause and
[9:10] Speaker 6: doesn't say anything more than that case law. I think
[9:13] Speaker 6: also in large measure helps President Trump. But you have
[9:19] Speaker 6: to overlay over all that that we're talking about the
[9:22] Speaker 6: Federal Reserve here, and the Supreme Court in the Wilcox
[9:26] Speaker 6: decision in May, went out of its way to distinguish
[9:30] Speaker 6: the Federal Reserve when it comes to a lot of
[9:32] Speaker 6: these issues, and so much of the case law that
[9:36] Speaker 6: is being discussed deals with agencies that really fall more
[9:39] Speaker 6: clearly under executive authority. So it's going to really be
[9:43] Speaker 6: up to the various courts that are going to hear
[9:45] Speaker 6: this to decide how much they want to distinguish the
[9:48] Speaker 6: Federal Reserve from all that precedent, and you know, I
[9:53] Speaker 6: think Judge Cobb alluded to that. You know, she said
[9:56] Speaker 6: she has to map Federal Reserve independence over all these issues.
[10:00] Speaker 6: To me, that suggests Lisa Cook has a good shot
[10:03] Speaker 6: at winning before Judge Cobb, at least at this early stage.
[10:07] Speaker 6: And then you know, from there, we'll go up to
[10:10] Speaker 6: the DC Circuit and then the Supreme Court, and we'll
[10:12] Speaker 6: see how they deal with their Wilcox decision. From May
[10:16] Speaker 6: Elliott tell.
[10:16] Speaker 5: Us what the fed's response to the lawsuit has been.
[10:20] Speaker 6: The FED is sort of staying silent and not picking
[10:25] Speaker 6: aside and saying they'll bide by any court decision, which
[10:28] Speaker 6: is why Lisa Cook's complaint names the Federal Reserve Board governors,
[10:33] Speaker 6: both collectively and in their individual capacity as defendants, along
[10:36] Speaker 6: with FED chair J. Powell.
[10:37] Speaker 5: Explain why timing might be important for Trump here in.
[10:41] Speaker 6: The near term. You have an FMC meeting in mid September,
[10:44] Speaker 6: right where everyone's expecting some sort of rate cuts. It
[10:47] Speaker 6: seems I actually don't think that's the most important date
[10:50] Speaker 6: because for that date, Lisa Cook is just one seat
[10:53] Speaker 6: on the FMC out of twelve. In July, when they
[10:57] Speaker 6: met and they did at lower rates. You only had
[10:59] Speaker 6: two dissenting votes, So I don't think her vote is
[11:02] Speaker 6: necessarily going to sway anything in September. But to me,
[11:05] Speaker 6: the more important dates to keep in mind are the
[11:08] Speaker 6: end of February, when the Federal Reserve Board gets to
[11:12] Speaker 6: reappoint or block reappointment of the regional Federal Reserve Bank
[11:17] Speaker 6: presidents who rotate onto the FOMC. So if the President
[11:23] Speaker 6: can elst least a cook by February, he essentially on
[11:28] Speaker 6: the Federal Reserve Board will have three sympathetic votes and
[11:32] Speaker 6: on the other side, you'd have three votes you know
[11:36] Speaker 6: that probably don't align with the President Powell, Michael Barr,
[11:40] Speaker 6: and Vice Jared Jefferson, and you wouldn't have all these
[11:43] Speaker 6: other Regional Reserve Bank presidents who for the most part
[11:45] Speaker 6: have been voting consistently with Jay Powell against lowering rates.
[11:50] Speaker 6: So you know, February is important because it starts to
[11:54] Speaker 6: potentially change the composition of the FOMC in a direction
[11:59] Speaker 6: that's more fai or both to President Trump.
[12:01] Speaker 5: And Trump is continuing to fire board members. On Wednesday,
[12:05] Speaker 5: he fired one of two Democratic members of the US
[12:09] Speaker 5: Service Transportation Board to break a two to two tie
[12:13] Speaker 5: before the board considers the largest railroad merger ever proposed.
[12:18] Speaker 6: You know, I think the hallmark of this when the
[12:20] Speaker 6: history books are written, is its efforts to expand executive
[12:24] Speaker 6: authority over almost every aspect of the government. You know,
[12:28] Speaker 6: we do have this Supreme Court decision in May that
[12:30] Speaker 6: suggested the Federal Reserve is a little different. We'll sort
[12:33] Speaker 6: of see how that plays out.
[12:35] Speaker 5: Thanks, Elliot. That's Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation analyst Elliott Stein.
[12:40] Speaker 5: Coming up next. Trump wants to jail flag burners. I'm
[12:44] Speaker 5: June Grosso. When you're listening to Bloomberg.
[13:00] Speaker 2: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grossel from Bloomberg Radio, and.
[13:07] Speaker 7: What the penalty is going to be. If you burn
[13:09] Speaker 7: a flag, you get one year in jail, no early exits,
[13:15] Speaker 7: no nothing. You get one year in jail. If you're
[13:17] Speaker 7: burn a flag, you get And what it does is
[13:20] Speaker 7: insight to write it.
[13:21] Speaker 5: President Trump signed an executive order on Monday directing the
[13:25] Speaker 5: US Attorney General to prosecute people for burning the American flag.
[13:30] Speaker 5: But flag burning is protected under the First Amendment under
[13:35] Speaker 5: well settled Supreme Court precedence. In fact, none other than
[13:39] Speaker 5: the late Justice Antonin Scalia, a conservative icon, was part
[13:44] Speaker 5: of the majority in the nineteen eighty nine case that
[13:47] Speaker 5: established that the Constitution protects burning the flag as a
[13:51] Speaker 5: form of symbolic speech.
[13:53] Speaker 8: Yeah, if I were king, I would not allow people
[13:56] Speaker 8: to go about burning the American flag. However, we have
[13:59] Speaker 8: a First Amendment which says that the right of free
[14:04] Speaker 8: speech shall not be abridged, and it is addressed in
[14:08] Speaker 8: particular to speech critical of the government. I mean that
[14:11] Speaker 8: was the main kind of speech that tyrants would seek
[14:14] Speaker 8: to suppress. Burning the flag is a form of expression.
[14:19] Speaker 5: Trump call the justices who made that decision a quote
[14:23] Speaker 5: very sad court. And the order directs the Attorney General
[14:27] Speaker 5: to pursue litigation to challenge that. Nineteen eighty nine President,
[14:32] Speaker 5: you get.
[14:32] Speaker 7: One year in jail, and it goes on your record,
[14:36] Speaker 7: and you will see flag burning stopping immediately.
[14:38] Speaker 5: But just two hours later, a combat veteran burned an
[14:42] Speaker 5: American flag across the street from the White House to
[14:46] Speaker 5: protest the executive order targeting flag burning.
[14:50] Speaker 6: I'm burning flag the progress that illegal fast as president,
[14:56] Speaker 6: that's sits.
[14:56] Speaker 9: In that house.
[14:57] Speaker 5: My guest is David Cole, a professor at Georgetown law.
[15:01] Speaker 5: He represented the men who burned the flags in the
[15:04] Speaker 5: two leading Supreme Court cases. David, there's a long history
[15:08] Speaker 5: in this country of desecrating or burning the flag as
[15:13] Speaker 5: a form of political protest that goes back to the
[15:15] Speaker 5: Civil War. But states and even Congress have passed laws
[15:20] Speaker 5: to prevent flag burning. Tell us about the Seminole case
[15:23] Speaker 5: the Supreme Court decided in nineteen eighty nine, where you
[15:27] Speaker 5: represented Gregory Lee Johnson.
[15:29] Speaker 3: Sure so. Gregory Johnson burned an American flag in Dallas, Texas,
[15:35] Speaker 3: in a protest outside of the Republican National Convention that year,
[15:40] Speaker 3: and was prosecuted under a Texas statute that made it
[15:44] Speaker 3: a crime to burn the flag in a way that
[15:47] Speaker 3: would deeply offend onlookers. He was convicted in the trial court.
[15:52] Speaker 3: That conviction was overturned by the highest court in Texas,
[15:56] Speaker 3: but Texas took the case up to the Supreme Court,
[15:59] Speaker 3: and the Supreme Court in Texas versus Johnson, ruled that
[16:03] Speaker 3: the government may not criminalize expression through the burning of
[16:08] Speaker 3: a flag simply because people find that message offensive.
[16:13] Speaker 5: It was a five to four decision, but it didn't
[16:16] Speaker 5: divide the court down ideological lines. In fact, conservative icon
[16:21] Speaker 5: Justice Antonin Scalia was in the majority. Why do you
[16:24] Speaker 5: think it didn't go down ideological lines?
[16:27] Speaker 3: So that's a great question. We won the case with
[16:30] Speaker 3: the votes of two Republican appointees, Justice Kennedy and Justice Scalia.
[16:36] Speaker 3: Both of them, I think, you know, over time, showed
[16:38] Speaker 3: themselves to be committed to the First Amendment. Justice Stevens
[16:42] Speaker 3: also a committed First Amendment. Justice dissented. I think in
[16:46] Speaker 3: his case it came down to the fact that he
[16:49] Speaker 3: was a veteran World War Two. He clearly was deeply
[16:54] Speaker 3: offended by the very practice of burning a flag and
[16:58] Speaker 3: therefore dissented. But over time, I think, you know, if
[17:01] Speaker 3: you look back at the cases that preceded Texas sersus. Johnson,
[17:05] Speaker 3: many justices, including liberal justices, expressed some reservation about whether
[17:12] Speaker 3: or not flag burning should be protected by the First Amendment.
[17:15] Speaker 3: So it's not something that has divided the country along
[17:19] Speaker 3: partisan lines.
[17:20] Speaker 5: And will you explain the thinking of the justices in
[17:23] Speaker 5: the majority and in the descent.
[17:25] Speaker 3: So the majority held that the justification for throwing someone
[17:31] Speaker 3: in jail for burning the flag is that the message
[17:36] Speaker 3: sent by engaging in that conduct is offensive. And the
[17:40] Speaker 3: court held that under the First Amendment. The government has
[17:44] Speaker 3: to maintain neutrality in the field of expression. Can't punish
[17:49] Speaker 3: speech simply because it or a majority of people find
[17:54] Speaker 3: a particular message to be offensive. Once you go down
[17:57] Speaker 3: that road, virtually anything can be prohibited by the government
[18:02] Speaker 3: because one man's offense is another man's truth. The dissent argued, well,
[18:07] Speaker 3: this is really not so essential a form of expression.
[18:12] Speaker 3: Chief Justice Rank was called flag burning quote an inarticulate grunt.
[18:17] Speaker 3: And there's a very powerful interest in preserving the unity
[18:22] Speaker 3: that the symbol expresses, and therefore states should be permitted
[18:27] Speaker 3: to prescribe how people can use the flag. They can
[18:31] Speaker 3: waive it, but they can't burn it.
[18:34] Speaker 5: So President Trump is also with this executive order calling
[18:38] Speaker 5: for Attorney General Pam Bondi to pursue litigation to challenge
[18:42] Speaker 5: the Supreme Court's ruling in nineteen eighty nine. This Supreme
[18:46] Speaker 5: Court is very different from that Supreme Court. Do you
[18:50] Speaker 5: think that they would still uphold the president.
[18:54] Speaker 3: Yes, this court is different from the court from nineteen
[18:58] Speaker 3: eighty nine to nineteen ninety but if anything, an even
[19:01] Speaker 3: stronger pro First Amendment court and Texas versus Johnson is
[19:05] Speaker 3: not just the kind of one off It is cited
[19:08] Speaker 3: again and again and again for this basic premise, probably
[19:13] Speaker 3: the most fundamental premise of pre speech law, which is
[19:17] Speaker 3: the fact that speech offends somebody is not a justification
[19:21] Speaker 3: for the government to throw the speaker in jail. And
[19:24] Speaker 3: that's ultimately what punishing flag burners is about. It's about
[19:28] Speaker 3: throwing them in jail because we would be, you know,
[19:32] Speaker 3: very pleased if they waive the flag. We are very
[19:35] Speaker 3: upset if they burn the flag. But either way, you
[19:38] Speaker 3: are using the flag to express a message, and the
[19:41] Speaker 3: government is not allowed to tell us what messages we
[19:45] Speaker 3: can and cannot express through symbolic speech or otherwise.
[19:49] Speaker 5: Now, Trump's executive order doesn't direct the Attorney General to
[19:54] Speaker 5: prosecute those who burn flags for the flag burning itself,
[19:58] Speaker 5: but it says the Justice this Department should bring cases
[20:01] Speaker 5: quote against acts of American flag desecration that violate applicable
[20:06] Speaker 5: content neutral laws while causing harm unrelated to expression, consistent
[20:12] Speaker 5: with the First Amendment. So the cases are going to
[20:15] Speaker 5: be limited to those where there's a violation of other laws.
[20:21] Speaker 3: So this executive order is I suppose, as befitting something
[20:25] Speaker 3: that is ultimately about symbols, almost entirely symbolic because it acknowledges,
[20:30] Speaker 3: as it must, that the Supreme Court has decisively ruled
[20:34] Speaker 3: that you can't punish someone for burning a flag. And
[20:38] Speaker 3: what it does is says, well, there may be some
[20:41] Speaker 3: circumstances in which one could where the reason you're engaged
[20:46] Speaker 3: in the prosecution is not the burning of the flag
[20:50] Speaker 3: per se, but some other interests altogether. So, for example,
[20:55] Speaker 3: many towns and cities prohibit burning of anything in public
[21:00] Speaker 3: without a permit. You can't burn leaves, you can't burn
[21:03] Speaker 3: wood in public without a permit. That law can be
[21:06] Speaker 3: applied to the burning of an American flag because the
[21:09] Speaker 3: law is not about speech. It's not about what burning
[21:13] Speaker 3: a flag communicates. It's an environmental law or fire safety
[21:18] Speaker 3: law that is neutral as to speech. And it's long
[21:20] Speaker 3: been the case that that kind of law. In fact,
[21:23] Speaker 3: the Supreme Court is said that kind of law would
[21:25] Speaker 3: be perfectly permissible. It is very rare that that is
[21:29] Speaker 3: sphasis for a flag desecration prosecution. However, and the other
[21:33] Speaker 3: example that Trump puts forth these as well, if somebody
[21:36] Speaker 3: burned a flag in such a way as it constituted
[21:39] Speaker 3: incitement to imminent lawless action or fighting words, those are
[21:44] Speaker 3: not protected by the First Amendment. Even pure speech, if
[21:48] Speaker 3: it constitutes incitement to eminent law of action or fighting words,
[21:52] Speaker 3: is not protected by the First Amendment. So if flag
[21:55] Speaker 3: burning fell into those very, very narrow categories, you could
[21:59] Speaker 3: probably that's true, but sort of trivial and largely irrelevant,
[22:04] Speaker 3: because people burn flags not to engage in fighting words,
[22:09] Speaker 3: not to incite some imminent lawless action, but to protest
[22:14] Speaker 3: what the American government is doing. That's why they burn flags,
[22:18] Speaker 3: and that is exactly why flag desecration laws were enacted,
[22:23] Speaker 3: and that the Supreme Court is held is an impermissible
[22:27] Speaker 3: justification for targeting any form of speech. So, yeah, if
[22:31] Speaker 3: you come up with a case, and I've not seen
[22:34] Speaker 3: one in my entire lifetime where someone burns a flag
[22:37] Speaker 3: in order to send a signal to some group that
[22:41] Speaker 3: is steeled to action to engage in illegal conduct, well sure,
[22:46] Speaker 3: just as you could criminalize that person from raising his
[22:50] Speaker 3: hand to incite that lawless action, you could penalize burning
[22:55] Speaker 3: a flag if it's being used for that purpose. But
[22:58] Speaker 3: it's really a null set And so I think at
[23:00] Speaker 3: the end of the day, Trump's executive order is itself
[23:05] Speaker 3: a kind of a nullity. It's a political act. It's
[23:08] Speaker 3: not going to have any real world effects, and it's
[23:11] Speaker 3: essentially theater engaged in by the president. Because it's good politics.
[23:17] Speaker 3: It's easy to be on the side of condemning the
[23:20] Speaker 3: burning of the American flag. That's why Democrats and Republicans
[23:24] Speaker 3: have done that for a long time. That's why forty
[23:27] Speaker 3: nine state legislatures voted to amend the Constitution after Texas
[23:32] Speaker 3: versus Johnson and the United States versus Aikman, and the
[23:35] Speaker 3: amendment effort only failed by a few votes in the Senate.
[23:39] Speaker 3: Because the easy political act is to condemn these kinds
[23:44] Speaker 3: of expressions. The hard thing, the courageous thing, is to
[23:47] Speaker 3: protect them, even if we find them, and even because
[23:51] Speaker 3: we find them detestable and offensive.
[23:53] Speaker 5: A combat veteran burned a flag outside the White House
[23:57] Speaker 5: on Monday in protest of Trump's executive order targeting flag burning.
[24:03] Speaker 5: He was detained by Secret Service for igniting an object,
[24:06] Speaker 5: then turned over the US Park Police and arrested. He
[24:10] Speaker 5: was issued two citations, not for burning the flag, but
[24:13] Speaker 5: for setting a fire in an unsecured place and for
[24:17] Speaker 5: damaging park property. Does he have a defense that he's
[24:21] Speaker 5: being selectively prosecuted or is that a straightforward citation?
[24:27] Speaker 3: So I think in the absence of Trump's executive order,
[24:30] Speaker 3: it would be a straightforward citation. That is, of course,
[24:34] Speaker 3: the federal government is permitted to ban burning things on
[24:37] Speaker 3: federal property, and it can ban burning flags along with
[24:41] Speaker 3: burning leaves or anything else on federal property, and that
[24:44] Speaker 3: wouldn't raise a serious First Amendment objection even if someone
[24:48] Speaker 3: burned a flag for protest. But now that Trump has
[24:51] Speaker 3: issued this executive order and basically announced as the president
[24:55] Speaker 3: I states, I am directing the Justice Department to prosecute
[24:59] Speaker 3: flag Why because flag burning expresses an offensive message that
[25:05] Speaker 3: essentially gives this protester evidence of selective prosecution. He can
[25:11] Speaker 3: introduce as exhibit A in his defense the fact that
[25:14] Speaker 3: the President announced the day before he was arrested that
[25:19] Speaker 3: the government would target people who burn flags using other laws,
[25:24] Speaker 3: but doing so because the President disapproves of the message
[25:28] Speaker 3: that is sent. And so he now has a defense
[25:31] Speaker 3: that he wouldn't have had had the President not issued
[25:34] Speaker 3: that executive order.
[25:35] Speaker 5: And he already has a lawyer and says he welcomes
[25:38] Speaker 5: the legal challenge. Thanks so much, David. That's Georgetown law
[25:42] Speaker 5: professor David Cole coming up next. The Supreme Court hands
[25:45] Speaker 5: Trump another victory. I'm June GROSSEO. When you're listening to Bloomberg.
[25:52] Speaker 2: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grossel from Bloomberg Radio.
[25:58] Speaker 9: I ordered the end to all of the lawless diversity
[26:01] Speaker 9: equity and inclusion nonsense policies across the government and all
[26:07] Speaker 9: across the private sector and the military.
[26:10] Speaker 5: President Trump has tried to wipe out diversity, equity and
[26:14] Speaker 5: inclusion programs in both the public and private sectors, and
[26:19] Speaker 5: early this year, the National Institutes of Health began terminating
[26:23] Speaker 5: thousands of medical research grants that don't align with the
[26:27] Speaker 5: president's policies. On DEI, more than a dozen states researchers, universities,
[26:32] Speaker 5: and public health organizations sued, saying the cuts would set
[26:36] Speaker 5: back crucial research by years, if not decades. They won
[26:41] Speaker 5: at the district court level and at the appellate court level,
[26:45] Speaker 5: but the Supreme Court, in a five to four decision,
[26:48] Speaker 5: sided with the Trump administration, clearing the way for it
[26:51] Speaker 5: to cut nearly eight hundred million dollars in medical research grants.
[26:56] Speaker 5: While legal battles over the funding play out in the
[26:59] Speaker 5: lower courts, sorts joining me is constitutional law expert David super,
[27:03] Speaker 5: a professor at Georgetown Law. David what kinds of grants
[27:07] Speaker 5: were cut here?
[27:09] Speaker 4: The administration canceled thousands of grants the NIH had provided
[27:17] Speaker 4: for research on a wide range of topics. Ostensibly, these
[27:23] Speaker 4: grants were cut off because they related to diversity, equity,
[27:29] Speaker 4: and inclusion, or because they related to gender or gender
[27:34] Speaker 4: identity as understood by the administration. In fact, it took
[27:39] Speaker 4: little more than having the word diversity or equity in
[27:43] Speaker 4: the name of the project to get it cut off.
[27:47] Speaker 4: Some projects that had nothing to do with race or
[27:51] Speaker 4: racial equity or racial inclusion were cut off, but the
[27:56] Speaker 4: district court found that disproportionately research into health problems that
[28:01] Speaker 4: affect people of color were target of this cutoff.
[28:05] Speaker 5: Federal Judge William Young, a Reagan appointee, said, following a
[28:09] Speaker 5: bench trial, this represents racial discrimination and discrimination against America's
[28:14] Speaker 5: LGBTQ community. I would be blind not to call it out.
[28:18] Speaker 6: Yes.
[28:19] Speaker 4: He also found that the cutoffs showed remarkable insensitivity to
[28:25] Speaker 4: the health problems affecting women.
[28:28] Speaker 5: In the past, have administrations cut off grants for arbitrary
[28:33] Speaker 5: reasons or because they don't comply with the administration's objectives.
[28:37] Speaker 4: This is almost unheard of. Sure, if someone is taking
[28:41] Speaker 4: a grant and they're not doing the work, they get
[28:43] Speaker 4: cut off. But the notion that we wouldn't have given
[28:47] Speaker 4: this grant, so we're simply going to cut it off
[28:50] Speaker 4: is extraordinarily wasteful, and administrations at both parties in the
[28:54] Speaker 4: past have refrained from doing it.
[28:56] Speaker 5: Explain the Supreme Court's ruling, which was five to four.
[29:00] Speaker 4: The question came to the Supreme Court whether to stay
[29:04] Speaker 4: whether to suspend the order that the District Court judge
[29:09] Speaker 4: had issued. And the District Court judge did two things.
[29:12] Speaker 4: He struck down the policy guidance the administration based its
[29:17] Speaker 4: terminations on, and it struck down the terminations. It fell
[29:22] Speaker 4: four justices, the three Liberals and the Chief Justice voted
[29:26] Speaker 4: to deny any interference with the District Court's order to
[29:31] Speaker 4: let the order take effect. Four justices voted to stay
[29:36] Speaker 4: the entirety of the court order, and the deciding vote
[29:39] Speaker 4: was cast by Justice Barrett, who said that she wanted
[29:45] Speaker 4: to stay the resumption of funding, but would not interfere
[29:51] Speaker 4: with the finding that the policy guidance was illegal.
[29:55] Speaker 5: And what was the reasoning of the majority in all
[30:00] Speaker 5: allowing the government to withhold the grant money.
[30:03] Speaker 4: Their reasoning was that anyone who'd had their grant cutoff
[30:08] Speaker 4: should have gone to the Court of Federal Claims, not
[30:11] Speaker 4: federal district court, and that's the place that it is
[30:15] Speaker 4: proper to pursue depths from the federal government.
[30:19] Speaker 5: Will you explain why? Justice Barrett came down differently on
[30:24] Speaker 5: the nih cutting the grants and on the policy.
[30:29] Speaker 4: Justice Barrett held that the federal district courts are completely
[30:34] Speaker 4: proper places to challenge the legality of guidance that is
[30:39] Speaker 4: issued by the administration. So if the challenge is that
[30:43] Speaker 4: this guidance is without solid legal basis, that it's contrary
[30:48] Speaker 4: to the federal government's legal obligations, that it violate civil
[30:51] Speaker 4: rights laws, those are proper claims to bring in federal
[30:55] Speaker 4: district court into get an injunction, she said. But she
[30:58] Speaker 4: said that if you actually we want money, that has
[31:01] Speaker 4: to come from the Court of Federal claim So.
[31:04] Speaker 5: That means that the challenges here would have to go
[31:06] Speaker 5: to two separate courts and bring two separate actions.
[31:10] Speaker 4: Yes, she said, there's precedent for that, and she asserted
[31:14] Speaker 4: that that was the result of Congress's passing the jurisdictional
[31:19] Speaker 4: statues they have and the Supreme Court's prior interpretations, the.
[31:23] Speaker 5: Court of Federal Claims is, to say the least, not
[31:27] Speaker 5: well known. Do you think Barrett and the other four
[31:30] Speaker 5: Conservatives were right about its jurisdiction.
[31:33] Speaker 4: No, I don't. The Court of Federal Claims is there
[31:37] Speaker 4: to handle a lot of routine matters where there's a
[31:42] Speaker 4: question about the quality of the paint job that was
[31:45] Speaker 4: done on a federal office building and the federal government's
[31:48] Speaker 4: refusing to pay, and the painting contractor wants to be paid.
[31:52] Speaker 4: There's a need for that, But that's very different from
[31:55] Speaker 4: a systematic violation of thousands of contract asserting a power
[32:02] Speaker 4: that has never previously been recognized. Those are the kinds
[32:06] Speaker 4: of statutory and constitutional issues that have long been the
[32:11] Speaker 4: province of the general federal court system, the district courts,
[32:15] Speaker 4: and the circuit courts of appeal.
[32:16] Speaker 5: Can the groups here, now that they have this decision
[32:20] Speaker 5: on the policy, can they now go to the Court
[32:22] Speaker 5: of Federal Claims and get the money?
[32:25] Speaker 4: If only it were that simple. This was not a
[32:28] Speaker 4: decision on the merits of those policies. It was simply
[32:32] Speaker 4: about how the litigation should proceed, and Justice Barrett, joining
[32:37] Speaker 4: with the Chief Justice and the three Liberals, held that
[32:41] Speaker 4: the litigation can continue in the first Circuit Court of
[32:46] Speaker 4: Appeals about whether or not those policy documents are legal,
[32:52] Speaker 4: and if they are struck down again in that court,
[32:58] Speaker 4: the Trump administration could appeal bater active Supreme Court on
[33:01] Speaker 4: the merits. She indicated that there were some open questions
[33:05] Speaker 4: in her mind that would need to be resolved before
[33:08] Speaker 4: a final decision could be made about the legitimacy of
[33:12] Speaker 4: those policy documents, so she was only keeping the litigation alive,
[33:16] Speaker 4: she wasn't resolving it in the favor of the challengers.
[33:20] Speaker 5: And the majority found that the government would be irreparably
[33:23] Speaker 5: harmed if it had to pay out this money.
[33:26] Speaker 4: How so, yes, that's a particularly disturbing part of it.
[33:31] Speaker 4: They said that because the recipients wouldn't be able to
[33:35] Speaker 4: repay the government if it was ultimately found that the
[33:39] Speaker 4: money was not owing, that the federal government shouldn't have
[33:42] Speaker 4: to pay out the money until after a final judgment
[33:46] Speaker 4: is issued, which, once appeals are accounted for, it could
[33:49] Speaker 4: take several years. This is treating the entire matter as
[33:53] Speaker 4: a debt collection issue rather than an issue of democratic governance.
[33:59] Speaker 4: It could be that at the end of the day,
[34:01] Speaker 4: the parties entitled to money will get some money, but
[34:05] Speaker 4: the research will long since has been abandoned, the employees
[34:10] Speaker 4: long since has been laid off. Many of the nonprofits
[34:13] Speaker 4: will have been bankrupted by the long delay. And this
[34:18] Speaker 4: is essentially saying that the federal government is too big
[34:22] Speaker 4: to comply rather than too big to fail. Too big
[34:25] Speaker 4: to comply because the size of the grants it gives
[34:28] Speaker 4: out and the importance of the grants it gives out
[34:31] Speaker 4: are such that the recipients don't have the money to
[34:34] Speaker 4: pay it back.
[34:35] Speaker 5: Justice Neil Gorse had sort of scolded the lower court
[34:38] Speaker 5: judges here for not following the Supreme Court's emergency ruling
[34:43] Speaker 5: in April that allowed the Trump administration to cancel sixty
[34:47] Speaker 5: five million dollars in teaching grants. Quote. Lower court judges
[34:51] Speaker 5: may sometimes disagree with this Court's decisions, but they are
[34:56] Speaker 5: never free to defy them. He also complained about two
[34:59] Speaker 5: other strict courts not following Supreme Court rulings quote. So
[35:04] Speaker 5: this is now the third time in a matter of
[35:06] Speaker 5: weeks this Court has to intercede in a case squarely
[35:10] Speaker 5: controlled by one of its precedents. But he's referring to
[35:13] Speaker 5: rulings on the shadow docket where there aren't full briefings
[35:17] Speaker 5: or oral arguments or sometimes even opinions.
[35:21] Speaker 4: Well, it's a very curious position they're taking. Most of
[35:25] Speaker 4: the history the Supreme Court has been through formal consideration
[35:30] Speaker 4: of cases, oral arguments, briefs, and thorough opinions from the justices.
[35:35] Speaker 4: Increasingly under the first Trump administration, the Bodi administration, and
[35:42] Speaker 4: now the Supreme Court is not accepting full briefs, not
[35:46] Speaker 4: listening to oral argument, not writing full opinion, sometimes not
[35:50] Speaker 4: writing any opinions at all. And what justice goursa you're
[35:53] Speaker 4: saying is, even when the Supreme Court is issuing an
[35:57] Speaker 4: emergency order, and even when it's not at all clear
[36:00] Speaker 4: what the basis for that order is, the lower courts
[36:03] Speaker 4: somehow must read the Supreme Court's mind. If the Supreme
[36:07] Speaker 4: Court wants lower courts to follow it, it needs to
[36:10] Speaker 4: tell them what it's doing.
[36:11] Speaker 5: Chief Justice Roberts joined the liberals in the case involving
[36:16] Speaker 5: the teaching related grants. And in this case, is that
[36:19] Speaker 5: surprising in any respect?
[36:21] Speaker 1: No.
[36:22] Speaker 4: Chief Justice Roberts has been very concerned about business climate
[36:26] Speaker 4: and allowing businesses to function freely, and the federal government
[36:30] Speaker 4: that isn't bound to comply with its contract is very
[36:33] Speaker 4: bad for business. Throughout the country's history, contract has been
[36:39] Speaker 4: a central part of its law and the notion that
[36:42] Speaker 4: the government above all complies with its contracts. It's been central.
[36:47] Speaker 4: We have a new administration that doesn't want to and
[36:50] Speaker 4: rather than bringing it to heal, this court has been
[36:53] Speaker 4: over backwards to accommodate it. If I were a private
[36:57] Speaker 4: business person, I would be doing anything I could to
[37:00] Speaker 4: avoid having a contract with the federal government because the
[37:03] Speaker 4: effect of these decisions isn't The contract isn't worth anything.
[37:07] Speaker 5: Is there any other avenue that the researchers and the
[37:10] Speaker 5: organizations and the states can pursue or is it just
[37:15] Speaker 5: the Court of Federal Claims?
[37:17] Speaker 4: They can go to the Court of Federal Claims, there
[37:20] Speaker 4: are significant obstacles to getting relief from that court. It's
[37:25] Speaker 4: a real court. People do win real judgments there. I
[37:28] Speaker 4: don't mean to disparage it in that way, but it's
[37:31] Speaker 4: going to be a very difficult way to proceed. Lots
[37:34] Speaker 4: of money that is owed probably will never be ordered
[37:37] Speaker 4: to be paid out of that court, and the result
[37:41] Speaker 4: of all of this is likely to be that many
[37:45] Speaker 4: of these programs are indeed disbanded.
[37:48] Speaker 5: Between this decision and the April decision. It's not good
[37:52] Speaker 5: news for those who have grants.
[37:54] Speaker 4: This isn't really a liberal conservative thing. This is just
[37:57] Speaker 4: a rule of law thing. And if the govern it
[38:00] Speaker 4: doesn't have to keep its contracts, no one should do
[38:03] Speaker 4: business with it.
[38:04] Speaker 5: It's always a pleasure, David, thanks so much. That's Professor
[38:07] Speaker 5: David Super of Georgetown Law. And that's it for this
[38:11] Speaker 5: edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always
[38:14] Speaker 5: get the latest legal news by listening to our Bloomberg
[38:17] Speaker 5: Law podcasts. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
[38:21] Speaker 5: and at Bloomberg dot com slash podcast Slash Law. I'm
[38:25] Speaker 5: June Grosso. Stay with us. Today's top stories and global
[38:29] Speaker 5: business headlines are coming up right now.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
