# Fed Governor Sues Trump & Cashless Bail

An episode of [Bloomberg Law](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/277975394), 29 Aug 2025, 34 min.

Audio: https://podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/e73c998e-6e60-432f-8610-ae210140c5b1/7c892d84-801f-4c0b-b0e9-ae2b0012ff5f/dc3e165c-4c8c-42f1-aed5-b348002776f4/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=91224201-26a6-429d-ac3c-ae2b0012ff6d

Elliott Stein, Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation analyst, discusses Fed Governor Lisa Cook’s lawsuit to stop President Trump from firing her. Vida Johnson, a professor at Georgetown law and co-director of the school’s criminal justice clinic, discusses Trump’s executive order to end cashless bail. June Grasso hosts. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:02] Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grossel from Bloomberg Radio.
[0:09] Speaker 2: It will be an unprecedented legal battle that could reshape
[0:13] Speaker 2: the Federal Reserve's longstanding political independence. No president in history
[0:19] Speaker 2: has tried to fire a FED governor, but President Trump
[0:22] Speaker 2: is attempting to fire Lisa Cook, the first black woman
[0:26] Speaker 2: to serve as a FED governor. It's over allegations that
[0:30] Speaker 2: she committed mortgage fraud before she joined the Central Banks
[0:34] Speaker 2: Governing Board.
[0:36] Speaker 3: She seems to have had an infraction, and she can't
[0:40] Speaker 3: have an infraction, especially that infraction, because she's in charge of,
[0:43] Speaker 3: if you think about it, mortgages, and we need people
[0:46] Speaker 3: that are one hundred percent above board.
[0:49] Speaker 2: But Cook is fighting back by filing a lawsuit against Trump,
[0:53] Speaker 2: saying he doesn't have the power to remove her from
[0:56] Speaker 2: office and that he violated the federal law that allows
[1:00] Speaker 2: seem to remove a FED governor only for cause. This
[1:03] Speaker 2: is a major escalation in the growing clash between the
[1:07] Speaker 2: White House and the Fed, which has resisted Trump's demands
[1:10] Speaker 2: to lower interest rates. It presents novel issues and will
[1:14] Speaker 2: almost certainly end up before the Supreme Court. Joining me
[1:19] Speaker 2: is Elliott Stein, Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation analyst Elliott tell
[1:24] Speaker 2: us about the big picture of Cook's lawsuit.
[1:27] Speaker 1: Sure, well, I mean, you know, the four cause is,
[1:29] Speaker 1: obviously if the central legal focus of her lawsuit, saying
[1:34] Speaker 1: that that standard hasn't been met, But bigger pictures, she's
[1:38] Speaker 1: arguing that the allegations of mortgage fraud are really a
[1:42] Speaker 1: pretext to get rid of her for policy disagreement purposes,
[1:47] Speaker 1: which you know goes against FED independence, which is why
[1:51] Speaker 1: you have a four cause removal restriction in the first place.
[1:54] Speaker 1: And you know that fits into the broader theme. And they,
[1:58] Speaker 1: you know, talk about all this as well in the
[1:59] Speaker 1: com how Trump has been pushing for lower interest rates
[2:04] Speaker 1: for a long time, has been critical of fedhare Powell
[2:08] Speaker 1: and initially was going after him for not lowering rates
[2:12] Speaker 1: quickly enough. And they tried to use allegations against him
[2:16] Speaker 1: of cost overruns related to the renovations of the Federal
[2:20] Speaker 1: Reserve building, And so you know, they tied allegations against POLICEA.
[2:24] Speaker 1: Cook into sort of that broader context.
[2:27] Speaker 2: Not only a lot of legal research went into this,
[2:30] Speaker 2: but a lot of factual research too about what's been
[2:32] Speaker 2: happening recently. So now let's talk about the center of
[2:36] Speaker 2: the legal fight, which is the four cause removal protection
[2:41] Speaker 2: in the Federal Reserve Act. The Act doesn't define what
[2:45] Speaker 2: cause means, how do they define it?
[2:47] Speaker 1: So that's exactly right. The Federal Reserve Act says that
[2:51] Speaker 1: the President can remove a Federal Reserve Board governor for cause,
[2:56] Speaker 1: but as you say, it doesn't say what cause means.
[2:59] Speaker 1: It doesn't give any examples of that. So the complaint says,
[3:03] Speaker 1: you know, when courts have had to grapple with this
[3:06] Speaker 1: question before, they usually point to the Humphreys Executor case
[3:10] Speaker 1: from nineteen thirty five, which is sort of the seminal
[3:13] Speaker 1: case about whether four cause removal restrictions are even constitutional.
[3:17] Speaker 1: And in that case, the removal restriction said that, you know,
[3:20] Speaker 1: an FTC commissioner could be removed for inefficiency or a
[3:25] Speaker 1: neglective duty or malfeasance in office. So the argument in
[3:30] Speaker 1: Lisa Cook's complaint is sort of twofold. One is that
[3:33] Speaker 1: it can't just be bare allegations. It has to be
[3:36] Speaker 1: some sort of malfeasance or some sort of you know,
[3:39] Speaker 1: neglect of duty. And then the other thing is that
[3:41] Speaker 1: it has to have occurred while she's been in office.
[3:45] Speaker 1: And you refer to some of the factual underpinnings of
[3:48] Speaker 1: the complaint related to that. They talk about how the
[3:52] Speaker 1: mortgage applications that are being accused of, you know, being
[3:56] Speaker 1: fraudulently completed, those were filled out in twenty twenty one,
[3:59] Speaker 1: and she wasn't even appointed and confirmed to the board
[4:02] Speaker 1: until the following year. So part of the argument is
[4:06] Speaker 1: that the four cause removal restriction really applies to misconduct
[4:12] Speaker 1: that took place while in office.
[4:14] Speaker 2: Let's take a step back and look at the allegations
[4:17] Speaker 2: of mortgage fraud. Trump claims that Cook fraudulently listed homes
[4:23] Speaker 2: in Michigan and Georgia as her primary residences when she
[4:27] Speaker 2: got mortgages in twenty twenty one. So explain where these
[4:32] Speaker 2: allegations of mortgage fraud came from.
[4:37] Speaker 1: They first appeared in social media posts by Bill Poulti,
[4:43] Speaker 1: who is the director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency,
[4:46] Speaker 1: the Fahferry, which is the conservator and essentially the regulator
[4:50] Speaker 1: for Fannie May, Freddie Mack, and the Federal Home Loan banks.
[4:54] Speaker 1: Poulty posted those on social media. He made a referral
[4:57] Speaker 1: to the Justice Department saying that these were indications of
[5:01] Speaker 1: mortgage fraud. The President then sort of adopted those allegations
[5:05] Speaker 1: as well and posted on his social media about them,
[5:09] Speaker 1: and then ultimately those documents were also used as justification
[5:14] Speaker 1: for the President's letter on August twenty fifth attempting to
[5:19] Speaker 1: fire Lisa Cook.
[5:21] Speaker 2: The complaint also refers to other criminal referrals that Poulty
[5:25] Speaker 2: made before, where he referred Adam Schiff, the Democratic Senator
[5:30] Speaker 2: from California, and Letitia James, the Democratic Attorney General of
[5:35] Speaker 2: New York, with similar allegations. And they say quote, each
[5:39] Speaker 2: of Director Poultice's criminal referrals have notably been, at one
[5:43] Speaker 2: time or another, political targets of President Trump's aire prior
[5:47] Speaker 2: to any mortgage fraud allegations. Both Schiff and James have
[5:53] Speaker 2: denied the allegations, and there have been no criminal charges
[5:57] Speaker 2: brought against either of them. And here with Cook, there
[6:00] Speaker 2: hasn't even been an investigation, has there.
[6:03] Speaker 1: That's exactly right. We don't know any more about these
[6:07] Speaker 1: documents than we've seen in Bill Polti's posts. And so
[6:11] Speaker 1: you know, in order for there to be fraud, you
[6:15] Speaker 1: need some sort of fraudulent intent, right, you have to
[6:18] Speaker 1: have intended to deceive another party, essentially, and that other
[6:22] Speaker 1: party has to have relied on your misrepresentations to their detriment.
[6:27] Speaker 1: We don't know any of that, right, I mean, we
[6:29] Speaker 1: don't even know if these documents are accurate or if
[6:33] Speaker 1: they're real. In this day and age, impossible to know
[6:36] Speaker 1: whether a social media post is real or made up.
[6:38] Speaker 1: But taking you know the director at his word that
[6:40] Speaker 1: these are accurate documents and reflect what's on them. We
[6:44] Speaker 1: don't know what Lisa Cook meant when she signed both
[6:48] Speaker 1: of them. We don't know if it was a clerical error,
[6:51] Speaker 1: which is what her complaint suggests. And we don't know
[6:54] Speaker 1: what kind of communications she may have had with the
[6:57] Speaker 1: mortgage lenders on the other side and whether they were
[7:00] Speaker 1: deceived or whether they were harmed, because you also need
[7:04] Speaker 1: that in order for there to be mortgage fraud.
[7:07] Speaker 2: Now, the lawsuit doesn't provide an explanation for why she
[7:10] Speaker 2: might have listed two residences as her primary residence, but
[7:14] Speaker 2: it does suggest that she could have quote mislabeled a
[7:18] Speaker 2: home's purpose unintentionally, and that wasn't in the complaint, that
[7:23] Speaker 2: was in the motion for a tro So are they
[7:27] Speaker 2: trying to offer an innocent explanation and to blunt the
[7:31] Speaker 2: fraudulent intent.
[7:33] Speaker 1: Yeah, they're sort of hinting at that. You know, they're
[7:35] Speaker 1: sticking primarily to sort of the legal standard in this complaint, right,
[7:40] Speaker 1: that essentially the actual facts of what happened aren't necessary
[7:45] Speaker 1: at this point in order to allow Lisa Cook to
[7:48] Speaker 1: continue and to basically render ineffective President Trump's termination letter
[7:54] Speaker 1: there arguing in their complaint that on these unsubstantiated allegations alone,
[8:01] Speaker 1: that is not enough to meet the four cause standard.
[8:04] Speaker 1: You know, if the case does go forward in some
[8:07] Speaker 1: capacity to determine what cause means and whether at least
[8:13] Speaker 1: the Cook's conduct rises to that level, then I expect
[8:17] Speaker 1: development of the facts in a more fulsome way, in
[8:20] Speaker 1: which case we'll probably know more about, you know, what
[8:24] Speaker 1: happened with these documents.
[8:26] Speaker 2: The Trump administration is going to respond. I mean, would
[8:29] Speaker 2: one of their arguments be that the way for cause
[8:33] Speaker 2: is being described by Cook's lawyers is incorrect.
[8:38] Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, they'll say, look, the statute only says
[8:42] Speaker 1: for cause when Congress inserted that language into the Federal
[8:46] Speaker 1: Reserve Act in nineteen thirty five, And the complaint talks
[8:49] Speaker 1: about this how they inserted that language after the Humphrey's
[8:53] Speaker 1: Executor decision right, sort of As a response to that,
[8:56] Speaker 1: the President's argument will be Congress knew that it could
[9:00] Speaker 1: have articulated what four cause means. It could have limited
[9:04] Speaker 1: it to inefficiency, neglect, and malfeasans, but it chose not to,
[9:08] Speaker 1: and as a result, what actually constitutes cause is broader
[9:12] Speaker 1: than just those three things. That is most likely what
[9:14] Speaker 1: the President is going to argue, And he's also going
[9:17] Speaker 1: to argue that it's within his discretion to determine what
[9:21] Speaker 1: cause is because he's the president and the statue gives
[9:25] Speaker 1: the president the power to remove a Federal Reserve Board
[9:29] Speaker 1: governor for cause. I think that's what the president's team
[9:33] Speaker 1: is going to argue.
[9:35] Speaker 2: After the lawsuit was filed, the White House said that
[9:38] Speaker 2: Trump was acting lawfully. Quote, the President determined there was
[9:42] Speaker 2: cause to remove a governor who was credibly accused of
[9:45] Speaker 2: lying in financial documents from a highly sensitive position overseeing
[9:50] Speaker 2: financial institutions.
[9:52] Speaker 1: Lisa Cook is obviously going to contest a lot of
[9:55] Speaker 1: what's in that statement. Right. He's going to say these
[9:57] Speaker 1: aren't credible accusations because you know, there's been no investigation
[10:01] Speaker 1: related to them. He's gonna take issue with the fact
[10:03] Speaker 1: that he's been accused of lying when there's been no
[10:06] Speaker 1: development or investigation to bolster that accusation. So we know
[10:10] Speaker 1: what each side is going to say. I think what's
[10:14] Speaker 1: going to be interesting is what the courts say, and
[10:16] Speaker 1: you know, eventually this will go up to the Supreme Court.
[10:19] Speaker 1: I think the Supreme Court's decision in May in the
[10:22] Speaker 1: Wilcox case, which concerned the termination of commissioners at the
[10:26] Speaker 1: National Labor Relations Board and the Merit Systems Protection Board,
[10:29] Speaker 1: I think that decision is going to be key because
[10:32] Speaker 1: there the Supreme Court sort of went out of its
[10:34] Speaker 1: way to distinguish the Federal Reserve from these other agencies.
[10:39] Speaker 1: Because for those other agencies, it seems like the Supreme
[10:41] Speaker 1: Court is leaning towards finding the four cause removal restrictions
[10:45] Speaker 1: in those statutes unconstitutional. But it seems like it distinguished
[10:49] Speaker 1: the Federal Reserve with the intent of allowing the Federal
[10:53] Speaker 1: Reserve Acts for cause removal restriction to be deemed constitutional.
[10:59] Speaker 1: And then you know, if you allow the President to
[11:01] Speaker 1: make that decision unilaterally as to what causes, you're really
[11:06] Speaker 1: rendering toothless and meaningless before cause removal restriction in the statute.
[11:11] Speaker 2: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Lawn Show. I'll continue
[11:13] Speaker 2: this conversation with Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation analyst Elliot Stein.
[11:19] Speaker 2: Cook is asking a judge for an emergency injunction to
[11:23] Speaker 2: block her firing and confirm her status as a member
[11:26] Speaker 2: of the Fed's governing board. I'm June GROANSO, and this
[11:30] Speaker 2: is Bloomberg. No president in history has tried to fire
[11:35] Speaker 2: a FED governor, but President Trump is attempting to fire
[11:39] Speaker 2: Lisa Cook, the first black woman to serve as a
[11:42] Speaker 2: federal governor. It's over allegations that she committed mortgage fraud
[11:47] Speaker 2: before she joined the Central Bank's governing board by listing
[11:51] Speaker 2: homes in both Michigan and Georgia as her primary residences
[11:55] Speaker 2: when she got mortgages in twenty twenty one. Cook is
[11:59] Speaker 2: fighting back by by filing a lawsuit saying Trump doesn't
[12:02] Speaker 2: have the power to remove her from office and that
[12:05] Speaker 2: he violated the federal law that allows him to remove
[12:08] Speaker 2: a federal governor only for cause. It's an unprecedented legal
[12:13] Speaker 2: battle that could reshape the Federal Reserve's longstanding political independence.
[12:19] Speaker 2: Scott Alvarez, a former General counsel at the Federal Reserve Board,
[12:23] Speaker 2: expressed his concerns if the president is allowed to fire
[12:27] Speaker 2: a Federal Board member without proper cause.
[12:30] Speaker 3: It's definitely worse for the institution if the president can
[12:35] Speaker 3: fire a member of the Board at will or based
[12:39] Speaker 3: solely on an allegation that's unproven, undemonstrated. I think in
[12:44] Speaker 3: that situation, there really is no independence of the Federal
[12:48] Speaker 3: Reserve and its ability to act, and that's got to
[12:50] Speaker 3: set markets, make markets uneasy.
[12:54] Speaker 2: I've been talking to Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation analyst Elliott Stein.
[12:59] Speaker 2: There's so many interlocking issues here. The complaint also says
[13:03] Speaker 2: that Trump violated Cook's right to due process and her
[13:07] Speaker 2: right to notice in hearing under the Federal Reserve Act.
[13:11] Speaker 1: That argument really revolves around the fact that she has
[13:15] Speaker 1: a property interest essentially in her role as a Federal
[13:18] Speaker 1: Reserve Board governor, and that by taking away that seat
[13:22] Speaker 1: from her without any notice or opportunity to be heard,
[13:26] Speaker 1: her due process rights are being violated. So that's a
[13:29] Speaker 1: constitutional argument. They also have a statutory argument related to that,
[13:33] Speaker 1: which says that for roles where you have a fixed
[13:37] Speaker 1: number of years in service and you're terminated, that you're
[13:41] Speaker 1: entitled to some sort of notice and opportunity to be
[13:44] Speaker 1: heard as well.
[13:45] Speaker 2: Cook is seeking an emergency injunction to block her firing
[13:49] Speaker 2: and confirm her status as a member of the fed's
[13:52] Speaker 2: governing board, and DC Federal Judge Gia Cobb has scheduled
[13:57] Speaker 2: an emergency hearing for tomorrow. Explain the reasons Cook gives
[14:02] Speaker 2: for asking for a temporary restraining order.
[14:06] Speaker 1: So you know, right now, this is the question I
[14:08] Speaker 1: get from clients a lot is is she actually still
[14:11] Speaker 1: a Federal Reserve Board governor? You know, if there were
[14:14] Speaker 1: a meeting tomorrow, could she participate? You know, if you
[14:17] Speaker 1: asked the President, he would say, no, she's been fired.
[14:21] Speaker 1: If you asked her, she would say, you know, the
[14:24] Speaker 1: purport determination was improper. So yeah, void, I'm still a
[14:27] Speaker 1: Federal Reserve Board governor. This tro application is a way
[14:33] Speaker 1: to get the court to opine on that quickly. Right.
[14:35] Speaker 1: It's an emergency application essentially to say that President Trump's
[14:40] Speaker 1: termination letter on August twenty fifth has no effect. Right.
[14:44] Speaker 1: And you know what's interesting is that, in addition to
[14:46] Speaker 1: President Trump being named as a defendant, the Federal Reserve
[14:50] Speaker 1: Board is named as a defendant, as are the governors,
[14:53] Speaker 1: as is FED Chair Powell. Because part of Lisa Cook's
[14:58] Speaker 1: tro application is to stop the Federal Reserve Board from
[15:03] Speaker 1: effectuating President Trump's termination letter.
[15:06] Speaker 2: Who has the stronger argument for.
[15:08] Speaker 1: The TRO Well, I think Governor Cook got a very
[15:12] Speaker 1: good judicial draw so to speak. The judge, as you said,
[15:15] Speaker 1: is Biden appointee. I think it's likely that the judge
[15:20] Speaker 1: is going to view favorably Lisa Cook's arguments for FED
[15:24] Speaker 1: independence and going to view unfavorably President Trump's arguments, saying
[15:29] Speaker 1: that allegations alone are enough for cause and if the
[15:31] Speaker 1: president alone can make that determination. So I would not
[15:34] Speaker 1: be surprised to see Judge Cobb grant the tro potentially,
[15:39] Speaker 1: you know, as soon as the end of the hearing
[15:40] Speaker 1: tomorrow which starts at ten am, or perhaps later in
[15:43] Speaker 1: the day. Just given the magnitude of this case, I
[15:47] Speaker 1: think a very quick decision is warranted.
[15:50] Speaker 2: The Supreme Court in May block the reinstatement of NLRB
[15:56] Speaker 2: and Merit Systems Protection Board commissioners while their suits played out.
[16:00] Speaker 2: Did the same for Consumer Product Safety commission heads in July.
[16:05] Speaker 2: Might the Court do the same here?
[16:07] Speaker 1: I think this is where that decision in May is
[16:10] Speaker 1: so important, because the Supreme Court really went out of
[16:12] Speaker 1: its way to distinguish the Federal Reserve from these other agencies.
[16:17] Speaker 1: It wasn't a definitive rule in it was sort of
[16:20] Speaker 1: dicta but it didn't even need to include that language.
[16:22] Speaker 1: And when you talk about whether you know someone like
[16:27] Speaker 1: Lisa Cook or these other commissioners should serve while the
[16:30] Speaker 1: litigation plays out, you know, the factors you consider are
[16:33] Speaker 1: likelihood of success on the merits, whether there's irreparable harm
[16:36] Speaker 1: to either side, and you also look at the public
[16:38] Speaker 1: interest in terms of likelihood of success on the merits.
[16:42] Speaker 1: I think Lisa Cook has very good arguments that the
[16:46] Speaker 1: four cause provision can't be satisfied by mere allegations alone,
[16:51] Speaker 1: because then that really again renders meaningless the standard because
[16:56] Speaker 1: anyone could drum up accusations in terms of mobile harm.
[17:00] Speaker 1: I think it's important that again, in the May ruling,
[17:04] Speaker 1: the Supreme Court essentially carved out the Federal Reserve from
[17:09] Speaker 1: the executive branch in the sense that it suggested strongly
[17:14] Speaker 1: that the Federal Reserve is quasi private. It has a
[17:18] Speaker 1: unique historical structure, and as a result, it doesn't really
[17:22] Speaker 1: wield executive authority like other agencies do. So in terms
[17:27] Speaker 1: of the president's executive authority being harmed by her continuing
[17:32] Speaker 1: to serve on the board. I think it's unlikely that
[17:35] Speaker 1: the court is going to say that he is suffering
[17:38] Speaker 1: harm like it did in the Wilcox case. And then
[17:41] Speaker 1: in terms of the public interest, you know, I think
[17:43] Speaker 1: the Supreme Court is likely to consider things like Federal
[17:47] Speaker 1: Reserve independence very strongly, and so all these things I
[17:50] Speaker 1: think wigh in favor of Lisa Cook's arguments.
[17:53] Speaker 2: Elliott tell us what the Fed's response to the lawsuit
[17:57] Speaker 2: has been.
[17:58] Speaker 1: The FED is sort of staying silent and not picking
[18:02] Speaker 1: aside and saying they'll abide by any court decision, which
[18:06] Speaker 1: is why Lisa Cook's complaint names the Federal Reserve Board
[18:10] Speaker 1: governors both collectively and in their individual capacity as defendants,
[18:14] Speaker 1: along with FED Chair Jpwell explain.
[18:16] Speaker 2: Why timing might be important for Trump here.
[18:19] Speaker 1: In the near term. You have an SOMC meeting in
[18:21] Speaker 1: mid September, right where everyone's expecting some sort of rate cuts.
[18:25] Speaker 1: It seems I actually don't think that's the most important
[18:27] Speaker 1: date because for that date, Lisa Cook is just one
[18:31] Speaker 1: seat on the FMC out of twelve. In July when
[18:34] Speaker 1: they met, and they did at lower rates. You only
[18:37] Speaker 1: had two dissenting votes, so I don't think her vote
[18:39] Speaker 1: is necessarily going to sway anything in September. But to me,
[18:43] Speaker 1: the more important dates to keep in mind are the
[18:46] Speaker 1: end of February, when the Federal Reserve Board gets to
[18:50] Speaker 1: reappoint or block reappointment of the regional Federal Reserve Bank
[18:55] Speaker 1: presidents who rotate onto the FMC. The President can elst
[19:02] Speaker 1: least a cook. By February, he essentially on the Federal
[19:06] Speaker 1: Reserve Board will have three sympathetic votes. You'll have Waller
[19:11] Speaker 1: Bowman and presumably Stephen Merron, who is probably going to
[19:17] Speaker 1: start his confirmation process next week to replace the Adrianna
[19:20] Speaker 1: Kugler who resigned earlier in August. And on the other side,
[19:23] Speaker 1: you'd have three votes you know that probably don't align
[19:28] Speaker 1: with the President Powell, Michael Barr, and Vice Jared Jefferson,
[19:32] Speaker 1: And you wouldn't have all these other Regional Reserve Bank
[19:35] Speaker 1: presidents who for the most part have been voting consistently
[19:38] Speaker 1: with Jay Powell against lowering rates. So you know, FEDRUAR
[19:43] Speaker 1: is important because it starts to potentially change the composition
[19:48] Speaker 1: of the FOMC in a direction that's more favorable to
[19:51] Speaker 1: President Trump, and.
[19:52] Speaker 2: Trump is continuing to fire board members. We learned that
[19:56] Speaker 2: Trump has fired one of two Democratic members of the
[20:00] Speaker 2: US Service Transportation Board to break a two to two
[20:03] Speaker 2: tie before the board considers the largest railroad merger ever.
[20:08] Speaker 2: Proposed Board member Roger E. Primus was the only board
[20:12] Speaker 2: member to oppose Canada Pacific's acquisition of Kansas City's Southern
[20:17] Speaker 2: Railroad when it was approved two years ago.
[20:20] Speaker 1: You know, I think the hallmark of this investigation when
[20:23] Speaker 1: the history books are written, is its efforts to expand
[20:27] Speaker 1: executive authority over almost every aspect of the government. You know,
[20:32] Speaker 1: we do have this Supreme Court decision in May that
[20:34] Speaker 1: suggested the Federal Reserve is a little different. We'll sort
[20:37] Speaker 1: of see how that plays out.
[20:39] Speaker 2: We'll certainly be watching this closely. Thanks so much, Elliott.
[20:43] Speaker 2: That's Bloomberg Intelligence Senior litigation analyst Elliott Stein coming up
[20:48] Speaker 2: next on the Bloomberg Law Show. President Trump wants to
[20:51] Speaker 2: get rid of cashless bail and I'm June Grosso. When
[20:55] Speaker 2: you're listening to Bloomberg, President Trump has signed an executive
[21:00] Speaker 2: order threatening to revoke federal funding to local and state
[21:04] Speaker 2: governments that allow cashless bail, arguing that it's a threat
[21:08] Speaker 2: to public safety cashless bail.
[21:11] Speaker 3: They thought it was discriminatory to make people put up
[21:14] Speaker 3: money because they just killed three people lying on the street.
[21:18] Speaker 3: Any street all over the country. Cashless bail. We're ending it,
[21:23] Speaker 3: but we're starting by ending it in DC.
[21:25] Speaker 2: But defense attorneys and criminal justice advocates say ending cashless
[21:30] Speaker 2: bail will negatively impact lower income defendants who could be
[21:35] Speaker 2: behind bars unlawfully, and Washington DC Mayor Muriel Bowser points
[21:40] Speaker 2: out that this is not a new policy for many
[21:43] Speaker 2: of these cities.
[21:44] Speaker 1: Cashless bail is not a new phenomenon in the district.
[21:48] Speaker 4: I think it's been in place since the mid nineties.
[21:52] Speaker 2: My guest is Vita Johnson, a professor at Georgetown Law
[21:56] Speaker 2: and co director of the school's Criminal Justice Clinic, is
[22:00] Speaker 2: formally a public defender in DC. Vita, will you explain
[22:04] Speaker 2: what is cashless bail? Exactly?
[22:07] Speaker 1: Sure.
[22:08] Speaker 4: So, DC's bail system is identical to the federal bail statute,
[22:15] Speaker 4: and what it does is it takes a person's ability
[22:19] Speaker 4: to pay out of the equation in deciding whether someone
[22:23] Speaker 4: should be held before trial or not. So DC's system,
[22:30] Speaker 4: just like the federal one, is based on whether someone
[22:33] Speaker 4: is a danger or risk of flight, and that helps
[22:37] Speaker 4: a judge determine whether or not someone should be held
[22:41] Speaker 4: rather than the amount of money in their bank account.
[22:44] Speaker 4: So if the person is charged with a dangerous crime
[22:48] Speaker 4: or a violent crime, the judge can hold them. So
[22:53] Speaker 4: it's a way of helping the judge make a decision
[22:57] Speaker 4: that is most closely related to public welfare while still
[23:02] Speaker 4: preserving the accused person's presumption of innocence. There are other
[23:07] Speaker 4: ways that a person can be held if they are
[23:10] Speaker 4: on probation or parole or supervisor release for another matter,
[23:14] Speaker 4: or if they have a pending case, they can be
[23:17] Speaker 4: held without bond. So again, money is not part of
[23:21] Speaker 4: the equation because in DC we've decided that it is
[23:26] Speaker 4: important to make a determination about fail based on the
[23:31] Speaker 4: accusations and the person's history and characteristics rather than their
[23:36] Speaker 4: ability to pay.
[23:38] Speaker 2: Was DC the model for other states and cities who
[23:42] Speaker 2: have cashless bail.
[23:44] Speaker 4: Yes, absolutely, and we've had this since the nineties, so
[23:47] Speaker 4: it's not anything new and it has truly been the
[23:50] Speaker 4: model for you know, criminal legal reform. Again, we don't
[23:56] Speaker 4: want a system where rich people, you know, get to
[24:00] Speaker 4: wait for their trial in the luxury of their homes,
[24:03] Speaker 4: while poor people are held a taxpayer expense no less
[24:09] Speaker 4: at the jail just because they don't have bail money.
[24:12] Speaker 2: President Trump has talked a lot about cash list bail
[24:15] Speaker 2: and how it's the problem leading to crime in the
[24:18] Speaker 2: Democratic led cities. And he said, no cash come back
[24:22] Speaker 2: in a couple of months, will give you a trial,
[24:24] Speaker 2: you never see the person again.
[24:26] Speaker 4: That's just not true. I mean, the bail system looks
[24:32] Speaker 4: at whether someone has a history of failing to appear
[24:35] Speaker 4: in deciding whether or not someone should be held before trial.
[24:40] Speaker 4: Remember that someone who's accused of a crime is presumed innocent.
[24:44] Speaker 4: That's something our whole criminal legal system is based on
[24:47] Speaker 4: that premise, and so when you hold someone prior to trial,
[24:53] Speaker 4: it really undermines that presumption. Normally that it can truly
[24:58] Speaker 4: ruin a person. Let's say someone's falsely accused of a shoplifting,
[25:04] Speaker 4: but they don't have a lot of money and so
[25:07] Speaker 4: they can't pay the bail. Should that person lose their
[25:11] Speaker 4: housing because they're not home to pay the rent. Should
[25:15] Speaker 4: they lose their job because they're at the jail and
[25:18] Speaker 4: can't work, Should they lose the custody of their children,
[25:21] Speaker 4: based just solely on the government say so, I think
[25:25] Speaker 4: most people would think absolutely not. And imagine the cost
[25:30] Speaker 4: to the taxpayer of holding someone on a really low
[25:33] Speaker 4: level offense like that at the jail. It's a tremendous expense.
[25:38] Speaker 4: It costs, you know, hundreds of dollars every day to
[25:41] Speaker 4: hold someone pre trial. And so DC, just like the
[25:44] Speaker 4: federal system, has decided that for you know, for someone
[25:47] Speaker 4: who with no record, who's accused of a non dangerous
[25:51] Speaker 4: crime and has no history of not appearing in court,
[25:55] Speaker 4: that they should be released pending trial.
[25:58] Speaker 2: One of the things that led to New York passing
[26:01] Speaker 2: cashless bail was a Bronx High school student who was
[26:05] Speaker 2: accused of stealing a backpack and was in prison for
[26:09] Speaker 2: three years on Rikers Island awaiting trial because his family
[26:13] Speaker 2: couldn't afford the bail, which was three thousand dollars, and
[26:17] Speaker 2: he attempted suicide at Rikers and committed suicide after he
[26:21] Speaker 2: was released.
[26:22] Speaker 4: Yes, absolutely, and we just don't want those kinds of
[26:25] Speaker 4: tragedies because someone just couldn't pay or their family couldn't
[26:29] Speaker 4: afford to pay the bail.
[26:31] Speaker 2: What's the other side, Why are people so determined to
[26:35] Speaker 2: get rid of cashless bail.
[26:37] Speaker 4: Well, the reason that prosecutors want people held before trial
[26:44] Speaker 4: is because it coerces pleased from people. So a prosecutor
[26:48] Speaker 4: would love for everyone to be held before trial if
[26:53] Speaker 4: they don't want to have a trial. Right, So let's
[26:57] Speaker 4: take that shoplifting. That innocent person accuse of a sh uplifting.
[27:00] Speaker 4: If they're held at the jail at risk of losing
[27:05] Speaker 4: everything in their life, their home, their children, their job,
[27:09] Speaker 4: when the government offers them a plea to a time served,
[27:12] Speaker 4: even if they're innocent, there's going to be a strong
[27:17] Speaker 4: motive for that person to take that plea offer, right
[27:20] Speaker 4: to accept that offer so that they can get out
[27:22] Speaker 4: of jail. And that happens in New York all the time.
[27:25] Speaker 4: In New York, often plea offers are extended at arrangments
[27:29] Speaker 4: so the first day and people often especially for low
[27:33] Speaker 4: level cases, or the government's request is for you know,
[27:36] Speaker 4: time served, they often accept those deals as a way
[27:40] Speaker 4: to get out of jail. So that's why you see
[27:43] Speaker 4: folks that aren't necessarily concerned with the constitutional rights of
[27:47] Speaker 4: poor people really pressing for pre trial's attention.
[27:52] Speaker 2: According to data from DC's Pre Trial Services Agency, in
[27:57] Speaker 2: twenty twenty five, ninety percent of individual Jewels on pre
[28:00] Speaker 2: trial release remained a rest free while eighty nine percent
[28:05] Speaker 2: of those awaiting trial made all their scheduled court appearances.
[28:10] Speaker 2: And have there been studies done as to whether there's
[28:13] Speaker 2: more crime in cities that have cashless bail as opposed
[28:18] Speaker 2: to those that don't.
[28:20] Speaker 4: I don't think so. I think we all know what
[28:22] Speaker 4: causes crime, and it's not based on our bail systems.
[28:26] Speaker 4: It's whether people have support, whether people have you know,
[28:31] Speaker 4: ways to meet their basic needs, you know, whether they
[28:33] Speaker 4: have access to health services and mental health services and
[28:37] Speaker 4: substance abuse treatment. The bail regimen in a particular city
[28:42] Speaker 4: or state is not the driver of crime.
[28:46] Speaker 2: What is Trump trying to do with this executive order?
[28:48] Speaker 2: Because DC is different from the rest of the country.
[28:53] Speaker 4: Well, yes, DC, because you know, when our framers were
[29:00] Speaker 4: dreaming of, you know, what they wanted the country to
[29:03] Speaker 4: look like. They didn't want the center of federal government
[29:07] Speaker 4: to be in any particular state. And so we are
[29:11] Speaker 4: a city without a state and in many ways controlled
[29:15] Speaker 4: by the federal government. But since the nineteen seventies and
[29:20] Speaker 4: when the Home Rule Act was passed, DC has had
[29:24] Speaker 4: a lot more autonomy. And we've enjoyed that autonomy for
[29:26] Speaker 4: now fifty years. So we have our own DC council,
[29:30] Speaker 4: we have a mayor. Now, you know, there's a lot
[29:33] Speaker 4: of self governance. Didn't remember everyone it was in the
[29:36] Speaker 4: district as a US citizen, So they should have the
[29:38] Speaker 4: right to enjoy the same things that people who reside
[29:41] Speaker 4: in states reside, right getting to pick their leaders and
[29:45] Speaker 4: having those people be the ones who decide what the
[29:47] Speaker 4: laws are and being accountable to the people who actually
[29:50] Speaker 4: live in the district when Congress makes laws about the district.
[29:54] Speaker 4: You know, it's really unfair because the people who live
[29:57] Speaker 4: here in Washington, d C. Have the opportunity to elect
[30:01] Speaker 4: those people. And so by declaring that he wants there
[30:06] Speaker 4: to be a changed in the DC bail statute, you know,
[30:10] Speaker 4: it's a way to exert control over a city that
[30:15] Speaker 4: didn't vote for Trump. I think it was about ninety
[30:18] Speaker 4: percent of people voted for Harris in d C. And
[30:21] Speaker 4: that you know, has a sizeable number of people of color.
[30:25] Speaker 1: DC.
[30:25] Speaker 4: You know used to be called Chocolate City, right, there's
[30:28] Speaker 4: a sizeable black population here, and you know what we're
[30:31] Speaker 4: seeing isn't you know, grounded in any reality, crime in
[30:36] Speaker 4: DC is at a thirty year low. There are at
[30:40] Speaker 4: least thirty cities with higher crime rates than Washington, d C.
[30:46] Speaker 4: And so the fact that this is the city that
[30:48] Speaker 4: he has focused his efforts on is you know, certainly
[30:51] Speaker 4: because of DC's unique status, but it's not related to crime.
[30:56] Speaker 2: But can he do it because of DC's unique status?
[31:00] Speaker 2: Can he somehow eliminate cashless bail?
[31:03] Speaker 4: There No, not through an executive order. A law would
[31:06] Speaker 4: have to be passed. There's a statue that the judges
[31:09] Speaker 4: in DC Superior Court follow and they are governed by
[31:13] Speaker 4: the law. Now, if Congress changed the law that you know,
[31:18] Speaker 4: could impact you know, the law that the judges must follow.
[31:23] Speaker 4: But for now, we have the same bail statute we
[31:26] Speaker 4: had before the executive order. Let me also say that,
[31:30] Speaker 4: you know, one thing that we're seeing is because you know,
[31:34] Speaker 4: it's the US Attorney's Office who prosecute's crime in DC,
[31:37] Speaker 4: they're bringing a lot of cases in federal court. But
[31:40] Speaker 4: it's important to remember that it's the exact same statue.
[31:44] Speaker 4: There's cashless bail in federal court too, and in federal
[31:46] Speaker 4: courts across the country in New York and California. All
[31:50] Speaker 4: federal courts follow the same cashless bail scheme, and so
[31:55] Speaker 4: it just you know, this move by the President doesn't
[31:59] Speaker 4: seem in a lot of knowledge about the law.
[32:03] Speaker 2: He also wants major criminal cases in DC to be
[32:07] Speaker 2: moved to federal court.
[32:10] Speaker 4: Yes, that's been playing out in the last few weeks
[32:12] Speaker 4: since the federal occupation. Anything that can be brought in
[32:16] Speaker 4: federal court is being run in federal court. Prosecutors are
[32:20] Speaker 4: also charging the top charge that they can charge rather
[32:23] Speaker 4: than the charge that is just and so we've been
[32:27] Speaker 4: experiencing a really significant strain in our legal system, and
[32:31] Speaker 4: it's something that the courts and the lawyers simply can't
[32:33] Speaker 4: keep up with.
[32:34] Speaker 2: I understand that the DCUs attorney, Janine Pireau, has been
[32:39] Speaker 2: having some problems getting grand juries to indict.
[32:42] Speaker 4: On some of these Yes, so because she's bringing them
[32:45] Speaker 4: in federal court. She's been trying to bring these solim
[32:49] Speaker 4: police officer cases and charge them as felonies, which requires
[32:54] Speaker 4: the grand jury to make the charging decision. I think
[32:57] Speaker 4: the grand jury in DC is made up byc residents.
[33:01] Speaker 4: And you know, fortunately in our from a legal system,
[33:05] Speaker 4: in felony cases, the people have the last day, and
[33:08] Speaker 4: they have not been indicting in those cases.
[33:11] Speaker 2: And the old saying is that a prosecutor can get
[33:13] Speaker 2: a grand jury to indict a ham sandwich, but I
[33:17] Speaker 2: guess not. Thanks so much, Vita. That's Professor Vita Johnson
[33:21] Speaker 2: of Georgetown Law. And that's it for this edition of
[33:24] Speaker 2: the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get the
[33:27] Speaker 2: latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can
[33:30] Speaker 2: find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot
[33:34] Speaker 2: Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, Slash Law, And remember to
[33:38] Speaker 2: tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at ten
[33:41] Speaker 2: pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're listening
[33:45] Speaker 2: to Bloomberg

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
