# The Benin Bronzes: Loot, Legacy, and the Fight for Return

An episode of [The History of Nigeria: Kingdoms, Colonies, and Africa's Giant — Fexingo History](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1895453661), 17 Aug 2026, 9:31.

Audio: https://audio.fexingo.com/history/the-history-of-nigeria/episode-0207.mp3

In 1897, a British punitive expedition sacked Benin City and carried off thousands of brass plaques, ivory tusks, and wooden carvings. Today, those objects are scattered across museums in Berlin, London, and New York — known collectively as the Benin Bronzes. This episode traces the journey of a single brass plaque from the Oba's palace to a museum shelf, and asks what its return would mean. We follow the looting of Ughoron, the royal compound, the role of the Igun-Eronmwon guild in casting the plaques, and the painstaking work of curators like Dan Hicks, whose book 'The Brutish Museums' reignited the debate. We hear how Germany agreed to return its holdings in 2022, and how Nigeria's Edo Museum of West African Art is preparing to receive them. But who owns the past when the past was stolen? And what happens when museums say they want to return objects, but the legal frameworks — and the politics — make it almost impossible? This is the story of the Benin Bronzes: not just looted art, but a living archive of a kingdom that refuses to be forgotten. #BeninBronzes #PunitiveExpedition #Ovonramwen #Ughoron #IgunEronmwon #DanHicks #BrutishMuseums #EdoMuseum #Germany #restitution #lootedart #1897 #BeninCity #Nigeria #colonialism #artrepatriation #museumethics #History Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo

## Transcript

Lucas: So we've talked about the fall of Benin in a couple of episodes, but I want to zoom in on something we only touched on: the objects themselves. You know, the so-called Benin Bronzes. After the Punitive Expedition in 1897, thousands of plaques, carvings, and tusks were taken from the palace in Benin City. And they ended up scattered across the world — Berlin, London, New York, Vienna. For over a century, they've been the crown jewels of Western museums, but there's a movement now to bring them home.
Luna: I've heard about the Benin Bronzes, but I never really understood what they actually are. Are they all bronze?
Lucas: That's a great question, because the name is a bit of a misnomer. They're not all bronze — many are brass, some are ivory, some are wood. The famous ones are the brass plaques that used to line the Oba's palace. They were cast using a technique called lost-wax casting, which is incredibly intricate. The guild responsible was the Igun-Eronmwon, and they still exist today, by the way — they're still casting in the same tradition. But the plaques weren't just decoration. They were historical records, showing the Oba's power, his warriors, his court, even his interactions with Europeans who'd come to trade.
Luna: So they were like a visual chronicle of the kingdom.
Lucas: Exactly. And they were housed in the royal compound, Ughoron, which was the heart of the palace complex. When the British expedition arrived in February 1897, they found the city largely abandoned — the Oba Ovonramwen had fled — but the palace was full of these objects. And the British officers, they didn't see them as art at first. They saw them as spoils of war, or even just curios. Some were sold to pay for the expedition's costs. Others were given to officers as souvenirs. And a huge number ended up in the British Museum, which then distributed them to other institutions.
Luna: It's hard to imagine the scale. How many objects are we talking about?
Lucas: Somewhere between three and five thousand objects were taken. And they were sold to museums across Europe and America. The British Museum alone has around nine hundred. Berlin has over five hundred. So you've got this massive diaspora of Benin's heritage, spread across the globe. And for decades, they were studied as 'African art' — which they are, of course — but often without much attention to the fact that they were looted. It's only in the last twenty years or so that museums have started to seriously reckon with that.
Luna: So what changed? Why are museums now talking about returning them?
Lucas: Partly it's a shift in public opinion, and partly it's the work of people like Dan Hicks, a curator at the Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford. He wrote a book called 'The Brutish Museums' in 2020, which really forced the issue into the mainstream. He argued that the Benin Bronzes are not just art — they're evidence of a violent colonial encounter, and that holding onto them is a form of ongoing violence. That book sparked a lot of conversations, and some museums have started to return objects. The big breakthrough came in 2022 when Germany signed an agreement to return its Benin Bronzes to Nigeria. That was a huge deal.
Luna: Germany returning them — that's a start. But what about the British Museum?
Lucas: That's the thorny one. The British Museum is legally prohibited from returning objects unless they're deemed unfit for the collection, and they've been resistant. They claim to be a 'universal museum' — that they hold objects for all humanity. But that argument doesn't hold much water for people who see the Benin Bronzes as the property of the Oba and the people of Benin. There have been requests for loans, but even that's been complicated. The Nigerian government has formally asked for the return, but the museum's position has been that it's not possible under current law. That's where things stand — a lot of talk, but slow action.
Luna: It sounds like there's a lot of frustration.
Lucas: There is, and honestly, if this episode has been worth a coffee to you, that's the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. We keep this show going because listeners like you chip in when they can. No pressure, just a thought.
Luna: Yeah, it's a small way to say thanks for the stories.
Lucas: And we do appreciate it. But back to the Benin Bronzes — there's a plan to build the Edo Museum of West African Art in Benin City, and it's designed to house the returned objects. It's a massive project, and it's not just about display. It's about creating a space where the descendants of the people who made these objects can see them in context, with the history and the culture around them. That's the kind of thing that makes the fight for return so meaningful.
Luna: That museum — when is it expected to open?
Lucas: It's been in the works for a few years now. The architect is David Adjaye, who designed the National Museum of African American History in Washington. But there are delays, of course — funding, logistics. The hope was to open by 2025, but that's probably optimistic. The point is that there's a vision, and the momentum is real. Whether the British Museum ever lets go of its share remains to be seen.
Luna: So what's the counterargument? I mean, why not just give them all back?
Lucas: Well, there are a few. Some argue that the objects are safer in European museums — that they have better conservation facilities. That's a patronizing argument, in my view, because Nigeria has capable professionals. There's also the claim that they're part of world heritage, and that people from all over the world should have access. But that doesn't really hold up when you consider that the people they were stolen from have had no say in how they're displayed or interpreted. And there's a legal argument — that the British Museum Act of 1963 prevents deaccessioning, and changing that law would open the floodgates. But as Dan Hicks points out, that law was passed because of the Benin Bronzes in the first place. So it's a kind of catch-22.
Luna: Wait, the law was passed because of the Benin Bronzes? That's ironic.
Lucas: Exactly. In the early twentieth century, there were proposals to return some objects, and the museum establishment wanted to make sure that didn't happen. So they pushed for a law that made it almost impossible to return anything. It's a bit of colonial legislation that's still doing its work today. And that's the kind of detail that makes the whole debate so charged. It's not just about objects — it's about power, about who gets to tell the story of a kingdom that was deliberately destroyed.
Luna: It's a story that's still being written.
Lucas: It is. And I think that's why we keep coming back to it. The Benin Bronzes are a living archive. They're not just relics of a past kingdom — they're part of the present, because they're still contested. Every time a museum returns one, it's a small act of justice. But there are hundreds of them out there, and the process is slow. The Oba of Benin, the current Oba Ewuare II, has been very vocal about demanding the return of his ancestors' works. And in 2023, some museums in the US are starting to follow suit. So there is change happening, but it's incremental.
Luna: Have any major museums actually returned them, or is it still just promises?
Lucas: A few have. The University of Aberdeen in Scotland returned a bronze head in 2021. The Smithsonian in Washington returned about thirty objects in 2022. And Germany returned over a thousand objects to Nigeria in 2022 — though many were on loan, not outright transfers. So it's happening, but the British Museum still holds the largest collection, and they haven't budged. They've said they want to 'reimagine' their relationship with Nigeria, but they haven't committed to full restitution. It's a kind of diplomatic dance that's been going on for decades.
Luna: It's amazing that something that happened over a hundred years ago is still so alive.
Lucas: And it's not just about the Benin Bronzes. They've become a symbol for all the colonial loot that's still in Western museums — the Parthenon Marbles, the Maqdala treasures from Ethiopia, the list goes on. The conversation about the Benin Bronzes has opened a door, and now people are questioning the whole structure of the universal museum. It's a reckoning that's long overdue.
Luna: It makes you wonder what the kingdom would look like if the bronzes had never been taken.
Lucas: That's a beautiful thought. But we don't have to imagine entirely — the Igun-Eronmwon guild is still casting plaques in the same style, and the Oba's palace still stands, though it was rebuilt after the fire. The culture was bent, but not broken. And if the bronzes do come back, they'll be placed in a museum that's being built to honor them. That's the hope, anyway. It's a story of resilience, of a kingdom that refuses to be erased. And for us, it's a reminder that history isn't just about the past — it's about what we do with it now.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
