# Episode 6: Lebanon and the Party of God w/ Rania Khalek

An episode of [Turbulence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1847060038), 9 Dec 2025, 1 h 24 min.

Audio: https://api.substack.com/feed/podcast/181117989/cec8acd8fd8c03d9017eacdee404d90b.mp3

Rania Khalek joins us to discuss the history of Hezbollah, Lebanon’s struggle for sovereignty in the face of US interference and Israeli aggression, and the country’s current political dilemmas. Watch Khalek’s documentary with Breakthrough News on Israel’s 2024 pager attacks here. Rania Khalek is an award-winning Lebanese-American journalist and host of Dispatches on Breakthrough News, where she investigates the global consequences of imperialism, war, and systemic oppression. With over a decade of frontline reporting from conflict zones and marginalized communities, her work has been featured in The Nation, The Intercept, Al Jazeera, FAIR, and The Electronic Intifada, where she served on the editorial board. X: @RaniaKhalek IG: @RaniaKhalek In this episode, we mentioned the campaign to support one of our movement elders, Xinachtli (Alvaro Hernández), who is being killed by the Texas carceral system. X is the longest-held Indigenous political prisoner and has suffered over 23 years of his imprisonment in solitary confinement. Urgent action is needed to save his life. Sign up for the phone/email blast: bit.ly/xphoneblast Sign the support letter: tinyurl.com/xsupportletter For updates and to donate to Xinachtli’s campaign, visit their instagram page: @freexinachtlinow or website. We’re committed to independence and will never run ads or have institutional affiliations. That means we’re entirely listener funded. For $5, paid subscribers will get regular bonus episodes, which will usually be news roundups (but may also include bonus interviews). Paid subscribers will also have access to monthly livestreams, book giveaways, and Q&A. Most importantly, our paid subscribers help us keep this project going. Subscribe today at turbulencepod.substack.com Follow along on Twitter/X and Instagram @turbulence_pod Theme: Eye for an Eye, Haram (2017) Art: Vivek Venkatraman This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit turbulencepod.substack.com/subscribe

## Transcript

[0:01] We are asking and we are demanding and hoping for generational
[0:06] change in Lebanon.
[0:07] SPEAKER_01: What we are asking of them is not easy.
[0:09] SPEAKER_01: But if they don't do it, they won't save their country.
[0:12] SPEAKER_01: And ultimately, decline is a choice.
[0:14] SPEAKER_01: So they can choose to decline even further into the abyss,
[0:18] or they can choose this once in a generation moment to take
[0:21] their country back.
[0:22] SPEAKER_01: I think President Aoun can do it.
[0:24] SPEAKER_01: I think Nawaf Salam can do it.
[0:26] SPEAKER_01: They will have U.S.
[0:26] SPEAKER_01: support if they make the tough and hard decisions.
[0:29] SPEAKER_01: And they're on that road to do so.
[0:30] There are concerns that disarming Hezbollah quickly could lead
[0:34] to a civil war.
[0:35] SPEAKER_01: What is the U.S.
[0:36] SPEAKER_01: response to that fear?
[0:37] SPEAKER_01: We've been hearing that for 20 years.
[0:39] SPEAKER_01: When you have cancer,
[0:40] you don't treat part of the cancer in your body and let the
[0:43] rest of it grow and
[0:44] SPEAKER_01: fester.
[0:45] When you have cancer and you want to be a whole patient,
[0:47] you cut the cancer out.
[1:22] SPEAKER_02: Hello,
[1:23] SPEAKER_02: dear listeners,
[1:24] SPEAKER_02: friends,
[1:25] SPEAKER_02: comrades,
[1:25] SPEAKER_02: subjects,
[1:26] SPEAKER_02: citizens,
[1:27] SPEAKER_02: insurgents,
[1:28] SPEAKER_02: fugitives,
[1:28] SPEAKER_02: defectors,
[1:29] SPEAKER_02: dissidents,
[1:30] SPEAKER_02: even the haters and losers.
[1:32] SPEAKER_02: Welcome to Turbulence.
[1:34] SPEAKER_02: My name is Dylan Saba,
[1:35] SPEAKER_02: and I'm here with my co-host,
[1:37] SPEAKER_02: Seamus Malik Afzeli,
[1:38] SPEAKER_02: and our producer,
[1:40] SPEAKER_02: M.
[1:40] SPEAKER_02: Siniza.
[1:41] SPEAKER_02: We're recording from New York City,
[1:43] SPEAKER_02: the center of a world empire that is dying,
[1:45] SPEAKER_02: but so,
[1:46] SPEAKER_02: so far from dead.
[1:48] SPEAKER_02: So over the holidays,
[1:49] SPEAKER_02: Em and I were back in the Bay,
[1:51] and we were chatting with my dad about the recent difficult
[1:55] incident in Beijing
[1:57] where local Syrians attacked invading IDF troops who were
[2:00] raiding the village and
[2:01] SPEAKER_02: attempting to make an arrest.
[2:03] And he was telling us about something that happened at least a
[2:07] little bit similar
[2:08] SPEAKER_02: in September of 1982,
[2:11] at the tail end of the Israeli invasion of Beirut during the
[2:14] Lebanese Civil War.
[2:15] SPEAKER_02: My dad was 20 years old at the time,
[2:17] SPEAKER_02: and he'd been living in West Beirut,
[2:19] SPEAKER_02: which is where our family was based at the time.
[2:21] SPEAKER_02: So the Israelis had been in the country since June,
[2:24] SPEAKER_02: when they invaded the south and advanced all the way up to the capital.
[2:28] They were chasing down the PLO,
[2:29] which at that point was based in southern Lebanon.
[2:32] SPEAKER_02: But by late September,
[2:33] SPEAKER_02: the residents of Beirut were getting tired,
[2:35] SPEAKER_02: to say the least,
[2:36] SPEAKER_02: of the IDF presence in the city.
[2:38] SPEAKER_02: Seamus, do you know about the Wimpy operation?
[2:41] SPEAKER_03: I do.
[2:42] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[2:42] when I was living in Beirut and also when I was going to
[2:46] college in Beirut,
[2:47] you only had to go about two or three blocks from campus and
[2:50] you would come by the
[2:51] SPEAKER_03: Wimpy Cafe,
[2:52] SPEAKER_03: which is still there,
[2:53] SPEAKER_03: though I think it's under a different...
[2:55] SPEAKER_03: business owner now,
[2:56] but there is a plaque in front of it that shows the face of the
[3:01] person who did the
[3:02] SPEAKER_03: operation,
[3:03] SPEAKER_03: and the Wimpy Cafe sign is still very much there.
[3:07] SPEAKER_03: The story goes that Khaled Alwan,
[3:09] SPEAKER_03: who was a leftist member of the Syrian Social Nationalist Party,
[3:14] SPEAKER_03: he didn't witness a raid or a military assault,
[3:17] SPEAKER_03: but he was simply near the Wimpy Cafe on Hamra Street in Beirut,
[3:22] SPEAKER_03: when he witnessed an Israeli officer attempting to pay for his meal,
[3:27] SPEAKER_03: not the local currency,
[3:28] SPEAKER_03: which is the lira,
[3:29] SPEAKER_03: but in Israeli shekels.
[3:32] SPEAKER_03: Now that year,
[3:33] SPEAKER_03: Israel had besieged Beirut,
[3:35] SPEAKER_03: starved its residents,
[3:37] SPEAKER_03: killed thousands of civilians,
[3:39] SPEAKER_03: paved the way for an election of an Israeli puppet president,
[3:42] and had aided and abetted the massacre in Sabra and Shatila
[3:46] only the week before
[3:48] SPEAKER_03: Alouane,
[3:49] SPEAKER_03: only 19,
[3:50] SPEAKER_03: enraged,
[3:52] shot the officer and the two Israeli soldiers next to him
[3:55] before walking home.
[3:57] SPEAKER_03: Now,
[3:57] SPEAKER_03: in Beijing,
[3:59] Israel has tried to concoct a conspiracy going all the way up
[4:03] to Jolani that's
[4:04] SPEAKER_03: somehow being attacked by locals while invading sovereign territory.
[4:09] SPEAKER_03: is some sort of terroristic violation of their operational freedom.
[4:14] And that resistance of this kind can only come from the Muslim
[4:19] Brotherhood or any
[4:20] SPEAKER_03: other some such evil sounding organization.
[4:23] SPEAKER_03: But the reality of the situation is the same as it was with Al-Wan,
[4:27] SPEAKER_03: that people,
[4:29] SPEAKER_03: generally speaking,
[4:30] SPEAKER_03: do not like being occupied.
[4:33] My dad mentioned when he was telling this story that at the
[4:35] time he had no idea
[4:36] SPEAKER_02: that Wimpy Operation was a funny name at all,
[4:38] I guess because his familiarity with the English language was
[4:42] not quite as
[4:42] SPEAKER_02: developed.
[4:44] SPEAKER_02: But in any case,
[4:45] the Israelis withdrew from Beirut a week later and from Lebanon
[4:48] after decades of
[4:49] SPEAKER_02: resistance in 2000.
[4:51] Israel's withdrawal from South Lebanon was the only time in
[4:54] history when Israel's
[4:56] SPEAKER_03: withdrawal from territory was unilateral,
[4:58] SPEAKER_03: without negotiations,
[5:00] SPEAKER_03: without a deal,
[5:01] SPEAKER_03: without any concessions from the Lebanese side.
[5:04] The day when Israeli forces left and the proxy force known as
[5:07] the South Lebanon
[5:08] Army collapsed is celebrated as Resistance and Liberation Day
[5:13] on May 25th.
[5:14] SPEAKER_03: Since the 2000s,
[5:15] SPEAKER_03: however,
[5:16] the attitude of the Lebanese government toward opposing Israel
[5:19] has changed.
[5:21] SPEAKER_03: Now,
[5:22] in pursuit of unlocking American economic assistance and
[5:25] fulfilling the dictates of
[5:26] SPEAKER_03: what is known in the Arab press as the,
[5:28] SPEAKER_03: quote,
[5:31] SPEAKER_03: The Lebanese state under President Joseph Aoun,
[5:34] SPEAKER_03: former commander in chief of the army,
[5:36] SPEAKER_03: and Prime Minister Nawaf Salam,
[5:39] SPEAKER_03: former president of the ICJ,
[5:41] SPEAKER_03: has been to not only disarm Hezbollah,
[5:44] SPEAKER_03: but to disarm Palestinian organizations in refugee camps.
[5:50] That includes the camps that were massacred by Israel allied
[5:53] forces during the
[5:54] SPEAKER_03: civil war,
[5:55] SPEAKER_03: like Shetila.
[5:56] SPEAKER_03: Lebanon sits at a very delicate crossroads right now,
[6:00] caught between the devastating effects of last year's war on
[6:03] the South and in
[6:04] SPEAKER_03: Beirut,
[6:05] and a potential new escalation by Israel that may be
[6:08] approaching at the end of this
[6:10] SPEAKER_03: year,
[6:11] SPEAKER_03: when the deadline for Hezbollah to be disarmed supposedly is reached.
[6:16] SPEAKER_02: So as I mentioned,
[6:17] SPEAKER_02: my dad grew up in Lebanon,
[6:19] SPEAKER_02: although he and his family are Palestinians from Gaza.
[6:22] And I would always hear about Lebanon in his descriptions as
[6:27] this example of the
[6:29] SPEAKER_02: pitfalls of ethno-religious identitarianism.
[6:33] SPEAKER_02: And I mean, it makes sense, right?
[6:35] SPEAKER_02: Lebanon was basically fucked by design.
[6:38] It was carved out of greater Syria by France intentionally to
[6:43] have this empowered
[6:45] SPEAKER_02: Christian minority,
[6:46] SPEAKER_02: the population around Mount Lebanon,
[6:48] SPEAKER_02: so that France could secure its neo-colonial bind with the country.
[6:55] SPEAKER_02: But it's not just Christian versus Muslim in the country, right?
[6:58] SPEAKER_02: I mean,
[6:58] SPEAKER_02: Lebanon has a massive number of ethno-religious sects,
[7:01] SPEAKER_02: each with its own internal communal relations,
[7:04] SPEAKER_02: but also its interests and relationship to outside actors.
[7:08] SPEAKER_02: And as we discuss in this episode,
[7:10] SPEAKER_02: right,
[7:10] SPEAKER_02: that makes demographics hugely important in the politics of Lebanon.
[7:15] It also creates these somewhat absurd outcomes,
[7:18] which were kind of always the
[7:20] SPEAKER_02: the punchline or the moral of the stories that my dad would talk about.
[7:25] SPEAKER_02: Like I said,
[7:26] SPEAKER_02: he and his family are Palestinians from Gaza,
[7:29] SPEAKER_02: but because they were Christians,
[7:32] SPEAKER_02: when they sought to move to Lebanon,
[7:34] SPEAKER_02: they were not accepted into the country as refugees.
[7:38] SPEAKER_02: They were granted citizenship because demographics in Lebanon,
[7:41] SPEAKER_02: the ethno-religious demographics are so hugely determinative.
[7:46] But because they're Palestinian,
[7:47] and that is the overarching,
[7:49] the overriding,
[7:50] SPEAKER_02: political identity.
[7:52] SPEAKER_02: They didn't live on the Christian side of Beirut.
[7:54] SPEAKER_02: They didn't live in East Beirut.
[7:55] SPEAKER_02: They lived in West Beirut.
[7:56] And in a sense,
[7:57] they were politically Muslim through the civil war in a crude
[8:00] sense.
[8:01] And I think that kind of sets up that there's really two ways
[8:06] of viewing Lebanon or
[8:08] SPEAKER_02: viewing the problems of Lebanon.
[8:10] One is this internal facing question of with all of these
[8:15] multitude of sex,
[8:16] SPEAKER_02: of ethno-religious identities,
[8:18] SPEAKER_02: the political challenge being
[8:20] Can Lebanon overcome these divisions to create or galvanize
[8:25] behind something like a
[8:27] SPEAKER_02: cohesive national identity or national set of interests?
[8:31] SPEAKER_02: But then the other way of looking at it,
[8:32] SPEAKER_02: right,
[8:33] SPEAKER_02: is can the country overcome all of the external influence that
[8:39] SPEAKER_02: that is seeking to take advantage of this situation,
[8:43] exploit ethno-religious difference in order to do power plays
[8:48] and engage in broader
[8:49] SPEAKER_02: conflicts within the country.
[8:51] SPEAKER_02: And I think that is a really fundamental challenge in question, right?
[8:54] Like if we think about Lebanon as being designed specifically
[9:00] to be a battlefield,
[9:02] SPEAKER_02: to be a site of this power struggle,
[9:04] how can those internal divisions ever be overcome if those
[9:08] external influences
[9:10] SPEAKER_02: still remain?
[9:11] I think that sets up a lot of the challenges and contemporary
[9:14] political conflicts
[9:15] SPEAKER_02: that we talk about in this episode,
[9:17] where we have a group like Hezbollah that has to face those
[9:22] internal challenges,
[9:23] SPEAKER_02: those internal balances of power,
[9:25] while at the same time maintaining its identity as a force
[9:29] against external
[9:30] SPEAKER_02: influence,
[9:31] SPEAKER_02: namely the Israeli invasion and occupation of Lebanese land.
[9:35] Something that I think a lot of outside observers find
[9:38] difficult to comprehend is
[9:39] how Lebanese politics really is not formulated between left and
[9:45] right in the way
[9:46] SPEAKER_03: that it is in most countries.
[9:49] SPEAKER_03: It is entirely formulated through what you're saying.
[9:51] SPEAKER_03: It's a relationship to outside powers and internal religious divisions.
[9:55] SPEAKER_03: There are some parties like Citizens in a State,
[9:58] SPEAKER_03: MMFD,
[9:59] that attempted to formulate some sort of left of center
[10:03] position where Lebanon,
[10:05] SPEAKER_03: its politics could be forced through that funnel,
[10:08] SPEAKER_03: but they failed horribly.
[10:10] SPEAKER_03: In the last elections,
[10:12] SPEAKER_03: because they were up against force,
[10:13] SPEAKER_03: not only forces that were stringently against this,
[10:16] SPEAKER_03: formulating attacks against them that,
[10:19] SPEAKER_03: again,
[10:19] SPEAKER_03: were from the lens of like,
[10:20] SPEAKER_03: oh,
[10:21] SPEAKER_03: if you're trying to move past this lens,
[10:23] SPEAKER_03: then you must be pro-Iran.
[10:25] SPEAKER_03: You must not be sufficiently against Hezbollah.
[10:28] SPEAKER_03: But also because of the confessional system.
[10:30] it meant that Lebanon did not vote in the same way that most
[10:34] elections vote,
[10:35] SPEAKER_03: which is universal suffrage.
[10:38] SPEAKER_03: You vote in an individual district,
[10:40] SPEAKER_03: but all the different complexities,
[10:42] SPEAKER_03: fundamentally,
[10:43] SPEAKER_03: an election is an election.
[10:45] SPEAKER_03: Whereas in Lebanon,
[10:46] SPEAKER_03: people vote,
[10:47] SPEAKER_03: but they have to vote for MPs that are apportioned to specific sects.
[10:52] SPEAKER_03: And you also don't vote in the district that you live in.
[10:56] SPEAKER_03: You vote in the district where your family is from.
[11:00] So you have people voting on Hezbollah-friendly lists who,
[11:04] you know,
[11:04] they're doctors.
[11:06] SPEAKER_03: Like Elias Sheradda, who is a doctor in Beirut.
[11:09] SPEAKER_03: He has worked at hospitals that I have been to.
[11:12] But he ran in Marjayum,
[11:15] which is on the Israeli border,
[11:16] because that's where he had to run.
[11:19] And it results in this impossibility to move out of these
[11:24] things because if you are
[11:26] SPEAKER_03: forced to run in your family's district,
[11:28] SPEAKER_03: you inevitably have to get caught up
[11:31] SPEAKER_03: in these internal religious conflicts based on who lives where,
[11:36] SPEAKER_03: what refugee populations fled where.
[11:39] It's a mind numbing thing to have to deal with because also on
[11:42] a neighborhood level.
[11:43] I mean,
[11:44] when I was living in Beirut,
[11:46] I lived in a very Christian neighborhood.
[11:50] SPEAKER_03: One that was very well acquainted,
[11:52] SPEAKER_03: let's say,
[11:53] SPEAKER_03: with Qadab,
[11:54] SPEAKER_03: with the Lebanese forces,
[11:55] because they put their flags up over most of the buildings in
[11:59] the neighborhood
[12:00] SPEAKER_03: after the assassination of Bashir Jamal one year,
[12:02] SPEAKER_03: and they just never got taken down.
[12:04] SPEAKER_03: That is a place where as soon as you enter in through certain blocks,
[12:09] SPEAKER_03: suddenly any sort of relationship with Palestine breaks down.
[12:12] SPEAKER_03: Mm-hmm.
[12:13] SPEAKER_03: which you might find,
[12:14] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[12:14] SPEAKER_03: only like 10 minutes away by car,
[12:17] SPEAKER_03: you might go into a place where you will see Hezbollah martyr posters up.
[12:22] SPEAKER_03: You will see flags of Palestine.
[12:24] SPEAKER_03: You will see communist iconography.
[12:26] Go even less than a mile and you will be in a place where those
[12:30] kinds of things are
[12:30] SPEAKER_03: completely taboo in a way that American political dynamics,
[12:35] SPEAKER_03: I don't think really has an equivalent for.
[12:37] SPEAKER_03: It's a very difficult situation to borrow a phrase.
[12:42] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[12:42] SPEAKER_02: I mean, I think you're touching on something really important, right?
[12:44] SPEAKER_02: In the desire,
[12:46] SPEAKER_02: especially from an outsider perspective,
[12:48] SPEAKER_02: to want to map on left-right politics into a situation like this.
[12:53] SPEAKER_02: And I think what you're naming is in a concretely colonial situation.
[12:58] SPEAKER_02: And we can say,
[12:59] SPEAKER_02: you know,
[12:59] SPEAKER_02: Lebanon isn't directly colonized,
[13:01] SPEAKER_02: but they're dealing with a colonial power on their southern border.
[13:04] SPEAKER_02: And that is actually occupying Lebanese land.
[13:08] SPEAKER_02: In the colonial situation, right, the national question,
[13:12] SPEAKER_02: becomes the predominant line of political antagonism.
[13:17] SPEAKER_02: This is something we've seen from other national liberation struggles,
[13:21] SPEAKER_02: from Ireland,
[13:22] SPEAKER_02: for example.
[13:23] SPEAKER_02: When that is the case,
[13:25] the left-right alignment does not map on neatly because you are
[13:30] not just engaging
[13:32] SPEAKER_02: in
[13:33] SPEAKER_02: a question of political economy or class struggle, right?
[13:37] That the national question becomes the predominant structuring
[13:41] political force.
[13:42] And you have alignments that are alignments between communist
[13:48] or left-wing parties
[13:49] SPEAKER_02: and more socially conservative forces.
[13:52] Because the antagonism is based around what kind of
[13:55] confrontation are you prepared for?
[13:57] SPEAKER_02: Are you willing to have with the colonizer, with the occupier?
[14:00] And I think that makes understanding political struggle and
[14:05] political alliances in
[14:07] SPEAKER_02: some of these countries very difficult for people.
[14:12] SPEAKER_02: people in the West,
[14:13] SPEAKER_02: especially people on the left in the West,
[14:15] who just have this mentality of the enemy is always the class
[14:20] enemy narrowly
[14:21] SPEAKER_02: defined.
[14:22] And people are looking for guidance of like,
[14:25] okay,
[14:26] well,
[14:26] what are the leftists doing and saying?
[14:28] And conversely,
[14:29] is this national liberation group actually a force of
[14:33] neoliberalism?
[14:34] Are they actually a force of,
[14:36] quote unquote,
[14:37] reactionary conservative social forces?
[14:40] SPEAKER_02: And thus, must we reject them?
[14:42] And I think that in engaging with a national liberation
[14:46] struggle and national
[14:47] liberation movements requires the hard work of doing some of
[14:52] that contextualization
[14:53] and truly understanding the nuances of the political struggle
[14:56] that's ongoing.
[14:57] SPEAKER_03: I think what makes Lebanon so infuriating is that not only is the
[15:04] Hezbollah or the Lebanese Communist Party or any number of
[15:08] different disparate
[15:10] SPEAKER_03: groups,
[15:11] SPEAKER_03: they're not the only ones adopting that sort of framework.
[15:15] There is also the framework adopted by these Lebanese Christian
[15:18] parties where even
[15:19] SPEAKER_03: though they are siding with the colonial neighbor,
[15:24] they are also adopting the framework that they themselves are
[15:26] occupied by the
[15:28] SPEAKER_03: Iranians,
[15:30] SPEAKER_03: by Hezbollah,
[15:31] SPEAKER_03: by Hezbollah controlling all their things.
[15:32] SPEAKER_03: I mean, I just want to
[15:34] SPEAKER_03: This crazy fucking framework should be laughable on its face.
[15:39] SPEAKER_03: And it doesn't give them any pause.
[15:41] I just want to bring this up because I saw this morning I was
[15:45] dumbfounded.
[15:46] SPEAKER_03: This is a official post from the Israel foreign ministry.
[15:51] SPEAKER_03: This, from the force...
[16:08] SPEAKER_03: that is literally occupying Lebanese territory right now,
[16:11] SPEAKER_03: that just launched a raid on multiple Lebanese villages last night,
[16:15] SPEAKER_03: that bombs the capital,
[16:17] SPEAKER_03: that bombs so many different towns every single day.
[16:22] SPEAKER_03: But no, it is Lebanon that is under Iranian occupation.
[16:27] SPEAKER_03: And whenever I would speak to people who had this belief inside Lebanon,
[16:32] SPEAKER_03: they would always point,
[16:33] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[16:33] SPEAKER_03: not just Hezbollah,
[16:35] but soon they would speak about the manifestations that they
[16:37] thought existed within
[16:39] SPEAKER_03: that occupation.
[16:40] The fact that they would sometimes see pictures of Qasem
[16:43] Soleimani occasionally,
[16:45] SPEAKER_03: or Khomeini in some people's homes,
[16:47] SPEAKER_03: or Khamenei on some street corridors in South Beirut.
[16:51] It was never about the Israeli drones or the fact that Israel
[16:56] invaded the country
[16:57] once upon a time or was going to invade the country in the very
[17:00] near future when I
[17:01] SPEAKER_03: was speaking to these people.
[17:03] It was always the fact that they had to be reminded of the
[17:06] existence of Shias in the country.
[17:09] and the relationship that they would have had with the largest
[17:11] Shia country in the
[17:13] SPEAKER_03: region by default,
[17:14] SPEAKER_03: the fact that so many Shia marges come from this country.
[17:17] It's the fact that they have to be reminded at all that there
[17:21] are oppressed
[17:22] SPEAKER_03: populations that really stuck in their craw.
[17:25] SPEAKER_03: And that, I think, was at the root of it.
[17:27] SPEAKER_03: And it makes these conversations so impossible.
[17:30] SPEAKER_03: Because if you believe that someone else entirely is occupying you,
[17:35] and formulating your decisions,
[17:37] then that sort of discourse never needs to stop.
[17:41] SPEAKER_03: It's always fighting against something that never has a firm endpoint.
[17:46] SPEAKER_03: And it makes moving out of this framework on either side impossible.
[17:51] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[17:51] SPEAKER_02: I mean,
[17:52] I think this is a classic example of what I refer to as the
[17:56] Peter Griffin style
[17:58] SPEAKER_02: argumentation of Zionism.
[17:59] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[18:01] SPEAKER_02: I don't watch Family Guy, but I did see- That's fine, I do.
[18:04] SPEAKER_03: I can inform you.
[18:05] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[18:05] SPEAKER_02: Well, I did see a clip one time that I thought was funny.
[18:09] SPEAKER_02: I mean,
[18:09] SPEAKER_02: it's very stupid,
[18:10] SPEAKER_02: but it's just Peter Griffin is in an elevator with someone else,
[18:14] SPEAKER_02: and he just lets one rip.
[18:16] SPEAKER_02: And then they look at each other, and Peter goes, it was you.
[18:19] SPEAKER_02: It was you.
[18:21] SPEAKER_02: Ha.
[18:21] SPEAKER_02: Ha.
[18:24] SPEAKER_02: It was you.
[18:24] SPEAKER_02: And that is just the style of Zionist argumentation.
[18:29] SPEAKER_02: Everyone smells the fart, right?
[18:31] No one can deny that there's colonialism at play,
[18:34] that there's an occupation ongoing.
[18:36] And the only style of argument that the Zionist has is actually
[18:40] you're doing it.
[18:40] SPEAKER_02: You're colonizing yourself.
[18:42] SPEAKER_02: You're occupying yourself.
[18:43] SPEAKER_02: It's not us.
[18:44] SPEAKER_02: It's you.
[18:44] SPEAKER_02: You are the ones doing apartheid.
[18:46] SPEAKER_02: You are the ones doing genocide.
[18:48] SPEAKER_02: And it's like,
[18:49] SPEAKER_02: it's obviously so fucking stupid,
[18:51] but it just demonstrates that there are undeniable consequences
[18:55] of Israeli action.
[18:56] SPEAKER_02: And they can't even deny that it exists.
[18:59] And they just have to point to their victims and say,
[19:01] you are actually the ones doing this.
[19:04] SPEAKER_03: And the Lebanese forces are perfectly willing to be the willing,
[19:07] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[19:08] SPEAKER_03: I'll be frank,
[19:08] the willing lapdogs of this government and everything that
[19:11] they're saying.
[19:11] SPEAKER_03: I mean, this was just from yesterday.
[19:13] This is a Lebanese forces MP speaking to the Saudi-owned
[19:17] channel Al-Hadef,
[19:19] SPEAKER_03: speaking about people's homes in the south of the country.
[19:22] SPEAKER_03: They are no longer homes.
[19:24] SPEAKER_03: They are camouflaged barracks and armed centers that must be raided.
[19:29] And therefore,
[19:30] Israel and the international community are not convinced that
[19:35] SPEAKER_03: No,
[19:36] and there were people also from that same party during the war
[19:39] who were saying that
[19:39] SPEAKER_03: Israel was doing everything it could to protect civilians in Lebanon.
[19:44] SPEAKER_03: I love Lebanon so much.
[19:48] SPEAKER_03: I miss it terribly.
[19:49] But its political system is deeply infuriating to try to speak
[19:54] about because so
[19:55] SPEAKER_03: many of its politicians are desperately trying to be American.
[20:00] SPEAKER_03: And this is something that we spoke about at length with Rania Khalek.
[20:04] who is a great friend and a great speaker and a very
[20:08] intelligent reporter.
[20:09] SPEAKER_03: Before we go into the conversation,
[20:11] SPEAKER_03: I just want to say we're committed to independence,
[20:14] SPEAKER_03: so we will never run ads or have any institutional affiliations,
[20:18] SPEAKER_03: which means we're entirely listener funded.
[20:20] SPEAKER_03: So for $5,
[20:22] paid subscribers will have access to regular news roundup bonus
[20:25] episodes and will
[20:26] SPEAKER_03: also be eligible for a book giveaway this holiday season.
[20:31] Most importantly,
[20:32] our paid subscribers will help us keep this project going.
[20:35] SPEAKER_03: You can subscribe today at turbulencepod.substack.com.
[20:40] You can follow along on Twitter slash X and Instagram at
[20:43] turbulence underscore pod.
[20:45] And one more note we have for our listeners regarding an urgent
[20:48] campaign to save
[20:50] SPEAKER_02: the life of an aging revolutionary political prisoner.
[20:53] SPEAKER_02: Sinatli,
[20:54] SPEAKER_02: also known as Alvaro Hernandez,
[20:56] is a 73-year-old Chicano revolutionary organizer who has
[21:00] survived 23 years of
[21:02] SPEAKER_02: solitary confinement under the Texas carceral system.
[21:06] SPEAKER_02: Today,
[21:06] SPEAKER_02: his health has collapsed under the weight of state violence,
[21:10] SPEAKER_02: rapid weight loss,
[21:11] SPEAKER_02: multiple falls,
[21:12] SPEAKER_02: severe mobility issues,
[21:13] SPEAKER_02: and increasing difficulty breathing.
[21:16] He's being held in the McConnell Unit Infirmary and is being
[21:18] denied real medical
[21:19] SPEAKER_02: treatment and access to his own medical records.
[21:22] SPEAKER_02: During his time in the infirmary,
[21:24] SPEAKER_02: prison staff threw away his belongings,
[21:26] SPEAKER_02: quote-unquote lost his commissary card,
[21:29] and have intentionally given him incorrect forms to obstruct
[21:32] medical visitations
[21:33] SPEAKER_02: and access to care.
[21:35] SPEAKER_02: Sinatli is hungry, isolated, and his health is rapidly declining.
[21:40] SPEAKER_02: The state has made clear that they intend to let him die.
[21:43] SPEAKER_02: The campaign's demands are,
[21:45] SPEAKER_02: one,
[21:45] immediate reinstatement of his access to commissary so he can
[21:48] obtain food,
[21:50] SPEAKER_02: hygiene supplies,
[21:50] SPEAKER_02: and other critical items necessary for survival.
[21:54] SPEAKER_02: Two,
[21:55] immediate transfer to the TDCJ Hospital in Galveston for a
[21:59] comprehensive medical
[22:00] SPEAKER_02: evaluation and treatment,
[22:02] with complete access to his medical records and full
[22:04] transparency regarding all
[22:06] SPEAKER_02: procedures.
[22:07] SPEAKER_02: Three,
[22:08] transfer to an ADA-accessible geriatric and medical unit with
[22:12] Sinatly requesting
[22:13] SPEAKER_02: placement at the Richard P.
[22:15] SPEAKER_02: LeBlanc unit in Beaumont,
[22:16] SPEAKER_02: Texas.
[22:17] SPEAKER_02: And four,
[22:18] approval of medical-recommended intensive supervision in
[22:22] recognition of the
[22:23] SPEAKER_02: severity and progression of his medical condition,
[22:26] ensuring he can receive appropriate care outside of TDCJ's
[22:29] abusive environment.
[22:31] SPEAKER_02: We will post the links to sign up for the phone slash email blast,
[22:34] SPEAKER_02: the demand letter to be signed,
[22:36] SPEAKER_02: and also for fundraising.
[22:38] SPEAKER_02: You can follow at FreeSanatlyNow on Instagram and FreeAlvaro.net for more
[22:44] SPEAKER_02: information on their campaign.
[22:46] SPEAKER_02: The End
[23:15] SPEAKER_03: We are speaking today with the illustrious Rania Kallek.
[23:20] SPEAKER_03: She is a host on Breakthrough News.
[23:23] SPEAKER_03: She's speaking with us now from Northern Virginia.
[23:27] SPEAKER_03: Rania, how are you doing?
[23:29] SPEAKER_00: Just over here on the front line in Nova.
[23:32] SPEAKER_00: Thank you for calling me illustrious.
[23:33] SPEAKER_00: I'm doing well.
[23:34] SPEAKER_00: How are you?
[23:35] SPEAKER_03: We're all doing great.
[23:36] SPEAKER_03: All doing great.
[23:38] SPEAKER_03: At this moment,
[23:39] SPEAKER_03: there is currently a ceasefire in Lebanon,
[23:42] SPEAKER_03: in as big of air quotes as I can must say.
[23:45] SPEAKER_03: Despite this,
[23:46] SPEAKER_03: as is the case in Gaza right now,
[23:48] SPEAKER_03: Lebanon is being bombed every single day,
[23:50] SPEAKER_03: almost without fail,
[23:52] SPEAKER_03: not only in the south near the border,
[23:54] SPEAKER_03: but also in the capital,
[23:55] SPEAKER_03: in Beirut itself,
[23:56] SPEAKER_03: in the southern suburbs,
[23:57] SPEAKER_03: in Dahyeh.
[23:59] SPEAKER_03: Hezbollah has only fired rockets back as a warning,
[24:01] SPEAKER_03: I believe once,
[24:03] SPEAKER_03: back in November of 2024,
[24:04] SPEAKER_03: very early on in the ceasefire.
[24:07] SPEAKER_03: But the exchange is 99.9% on the side of the IDF.
[24:12] Can you describe in more detail the conditions that are at hand
[24:18] with Hezbollah and the South?
[24:20] SPEAKER_03: I mean, is the group able to rebuild?
[24:22] SPEAKER_03: Are people in these communities able to rebuild in any capacity?
[24:25] SPEAKER_00: I mean, it's a really messed up situation.
[24:27] SPEAKER_00: As you said,
[24:27] SPEAKER_00: Seamus,
[24:28] SPEAKER_00: since the ceasefire last November,
[24:30] SPEAKER_00: the Israelis have been exclusively pretty much violating it.
[24:35] SPEAKER_00: The Israelis have violated the ceasefire nearly 10,000 times.
[24:39] SPEAKER_00: Like that's actually a crazy number.
[24:41] SPEAKER_00: And that includes bombings.
[24:42] SPEAKER_00: That includes raids.
[24:44] SPEAKER_00: They've killed at least a documented 127 Lebanese civilians in that time.
[24:50] And every time they bomb,
[24:50] they claim they're bombing Hezbollah infrastructure and
[24:53] weapons.
[24:54] SPEAKER_00: They've been bombing homes.
[24:56] SPEAKER_00: They've been basically making it impossible for people to be rebuilt.
[24:59] They're occupying five what they call strategic points inside
[25:02] Lebanese territory.
[25:03] SPEAKER_00: So they're basically occupying...
[25:05] SPEAKER_00: different areas of southern Lebanon and they refuse to leave.
[25:08] They have not abided by any of the terms of their side of the
[25:11] ceasefire agreement.
[25:12] SPEAKER_00: They violate it every day.
[25:13] SPEAKER_00: And Hezbollah has largely not responded,
[25:16] SPEAKER_00: mostly because they were very weakened during the escalation last year.
[25:19] They lost their leader,
[25:20] Hassan Nasrallah,
[25:21] which was a huge blow,
[25:22] obviously not just to
[25:23] SPEAKER_00: Hezbollah, but to the entire resistance axis across the region.
[25:26] SPEAKER_00: Their entire senior leadership was basically killed.
[25:29] And Israel has continued to pick off new leaders in Hezbollah
[25:32] since last year,
[25:33] SPEAKER_00: just a few weeks ago.
[25:34] I mean,
[25:34] you mentioned that the southern suburbs of Beirut,
[25:36] Dahyeh,
[25:36] was bombed.
[25:37] And that was an assassination of a senior level official in
[25:41] Hezbollah,
[25:42] also a violation of
[25:43] SPEAKER_00: of the ceasefire agreement.
[25:45] SPEAKER_00: I mean, bombing the Capitol, assassinating figures, all of these things.
[25:48] SPEAKER_00: And I think what it shows is this is more than just a Lebanon problem.
[25:51] This is part of a broader regional problem where we've reached
[25:53] an era where there
[25:54] SPEAKER_00: is no such thing as a ceasefire with Israel.
[25:57] What a ceasefire means is the side that's resisting the
[26:01] Israelis stops firing,
[26:02] SPEAKER_00: but the Israelis have the freedom as they see it to do whatever they want
[26:06] SPEAKER_00: militarily without consequence.
[26:08] SPEAKER_00: They're doing it in Lebanon.
[26:09] SPEAKER_00: They're doing it in Gaza.
[26:11] SPEAKER_00: They're doing it in Syria.
[26:12] And it doesn't matter whether you fire back as the resistance
[26:16] or you don't fire back.
[26:17] SPEAKER_00: And that's the tough spot that Hezbollah is in right now.
[26:20] SPEAKER_00: No matter what they do, Israel is going to keep bombing.
[26:23] Israel is going to keep occupying and Israel is going to
[26:26] continue to expand its borders.
[26:28] SPEAKER_00: And that leaves every force of resistance in the region,
[26:31] SPEAKER_00: including Hezbollah,
[26:32] in a very difficult position because it's hard to figure out
[26:36] how to respond to such
[26:38] SPEAKER_00: a technologically militarily superior enemy that
[26:42] SPEAKER_00: that has zero red lines, and that seems to be undeterred by being hit.
[26:47] I think we should return to the current moment and the
[26:50] strategic impasse that the
[26:51] SPEAKER_02: region faces,
[26:52] but I think it'd be good to back up a little bit and go over
[26:55] some history because I
[26:56] think most of our audience is probably familiar with Hezbollah
[27:00] as it exists today,
[27:02] SPEAKER_02: but may not know its history in Lebanon.
[27:04] Can you speak a bit to the party's origins in Israel's 1982
[27:09] invasion of Lebanon and
[27:11] SPEAKER_02: talk about how it developed both
[27:14] as a military force against Israel,
[27:16] but also as a political organization in its own right?
[27:19] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[27:19] SPEAKER_00: So Lebanon,
[27:20] SPEAKER_00: as we know,
[27:21] had a civil war that kicked off in the mid to late 70s that was
[27:25] provoked in many
[27:26] SPEAKER_00: ways by internal issues related to,
[27:29] SPEAKER_00: of course,
[27:29] SPEAKER_00: the Palestinian refugee issue,
[27:31] SPEAKER_00: but also the backing of various fascistic forces in Lebanon by the US,
[27:37] SPEAKER_00: by the Israelis,
[27:38] SPEAKER_00: by the French.
[27:39] SPEAKER_00: And other actors as well to try to basically defeat the Lebanese,
[27:43] SPEAKER_00: Palestinian and also regional left inside Lebanon.
[27:46] SPEAKER_00: And there were kind of different eras of that civil war.
[27:48] And 1982 is an area that's often highlighted because that is
[27:52] when Israel that's
[27:53] like after basically the Palestinians in Lebanon were kind of
[27:55] defeated and the
[27:56] SPEAKER_00: Palestinian resistance was forced out.
[27:58] That's when the Sabra and Shatila massacres happened as a
[28:01] result of forcing the
[28:02] SPEAKER_00: armed Palestinian resistance out of those refugee camps.
[28:05] SPEAKER_00: The Israelis' proxies committed those massacres.
[28:07] SPEAKER_00: But also that year,
[28:08] SPEAKER_00: the Israelis,
[28:09] SPEAKER_00: because the resistance was so defeated and the left had been so defeated,
[28:13] the Israelis felt they could actually invade and occupy huge
[28:16] swaths of Lebanon,
[28:17] SPEAKER_00: which is always what they had wanted to do.
[28:19] SPEAKER_00: So there was, in 1982, an Israeli ground invasion of Lebanon.
[28:25] That reached all the way actually into my parent,
[28:28] like near my family's village.
[28:29] They actually occupied my grandmother's house for a brief
[28:31] period of time and left a mess.
[28:34] SPEAKER_00: But all that, they left.
[28:35] And when I say they left a mess,
[28:36] I mean they smeared like shit on the walls.
[28:39] SPEAKER_00: They love to do that.
[28:40] SPEAKER_00: That's like a great Israeli pastime.
[28:42] But all that's to say the Israelis invaded and basically there
[28:47] was a siege on
[28:48] SPEAKER_00: Beirut that led to like people couldn't get access to food and water and
[28:52] SPEAKER_00: electricity for months.
[28:53] I think something like 20,000 people in the course of a few
[28:56] months were killed in Beirut.
[28:58] As a result,
[28:59] it was really brutal and it reached such a brutal point that
[29:02] you had people.
[29:03] Ronald Reagan at the time calling up the Israeli leader
[29:07] Menachem Begin and telling
[29:09] SPEAKER_00: him to stop what Ronald Reagan called a Holocaust on Beirut.
[29:12] SPEAKER_00: So, I mean, think about that language.
[29:14] SPEAKER_00: That's how brutal what Israel did was.
[29:16] SPEAKER_00: But after that invasion.
[29:18] SPEAKER_02: We used to have U.S.
[29:20] SPEAKER_02: leaders that would pull on the leash.
[29:21] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[29:21] SPEAKER_00: Exactly.
[29:22] SPEAKER_00: Even Ronald Reagan would pull on the leash.
[29:24] SPEAKER_00: Now there's like, of course, I don't even know.
[29:25] SPEAKER_00: There is no leash.
[29:26] SPEAKER_00: But all that's to say,
[29:28] then the Israelis occupied southern Lebanon and they occupied
[29:31] southern Lebanon for
[29:32] SPEAKER_00: years.
[29:33] And,
[29:33] you know,
[29:33] when people are occupied,
[29:34] they get really pissed off and they fight back.
[29:36] SPEAKER_00: And that's where the group known as Hezbollah emerged.
[29:39] It emerged in the aftermath of that Israeli occupation of
[29:44] southern Lebanon.
[29:44] SPEAKER_00: And that occupation was brutal.
[29:46] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[29:47] SPEAKER_00: It was I mean,
[29:47] think of any basically like Israeli occupation that you can of
[29:51] the West Bank of
[29:52] SPEAKER_00: Gaza.
[29:53] SPEAKER_00: There was checkpoints.
[29:54] SPEAKER_00: There was Israeli soldiers.
[29:56] SPEAKER_00: There was Israeli proxies.
[29:57] SPEAKER_00: There was constant raids and kidnappings.
[29:59] People didn't have rights like the people of the South were
[30:02] treated horrifically
[30:03] SPEAKER_00: during this occupation.
[30:04] SPEAKER_00: Their land was stolen.
[30:05] SPEAKER_00: They were put in prison and tortured.
[30:07] There was torture facilities all across the South that were
[30:10] oftentimes administered
[30:11] by Israel's allies on the ground because they had local
[30:13] Lebanese collaborators that
[30:14] SPEAKER_00: worked with them.
[30:15] SPEAKER_00: One very well-known one was the South Lebanon Army, the SLA.
[30:19] SPEAKER_00: And so the Israelis occupied southern Lebanon from the 80s until 2000.
[30:23] And in the 80s,
[30:25] under that occupation,
[30:27] Hezbollah emerged as this resistance force.
[30:29] SPEAKER_00: It emerged out of the Emma movement.
[30:31] SPEAKER_00: And it was allied with the Iranians.
[30:33] SPEAKER_00: The Iranians helped arm it and fund it.
[30:35] SPEAKER_00: It took care of its community.
[30:36] And it basically organized local villagers to use armed
[30:41] resistance against the
[30:41] SPEAKER_00: Israeli occupiers.
[30:43] And it actually made the occupation of southern Lebanon very
[30:45] difficult for the Israelis.
[30:46] SPEAKER_00: And it's why ultimately in the year 2000, the Israelis left Lebanon.
[30:51] SPEAKER_00: They were kicked out by Hezbollah.
[30:53] SPEAKER_00: It was considered a huge victory.
[30:55] It was a really big deal across the region because since
[30:58] Israel's inception that
[30:59] SPEAKER_00: was forced on the region in 1948 in this very violent way,
[31:03] SPEAKER_00: they always had the technological and military superiority.
[31:06] SPEAKER_00: And they were always stealing land and defeating everyone.
[31:09] And so the year 2000 was the first time that Arabs across the
[31:13] region felt some sort of victory.
[31:14] It was the first time people of the region had managed to
[31:18] liberate their land.
[31:20] I think maybe something similar would have been the Israelis
[31:22] leaving Gaza.
[31:23] SPEAKER_00: But though that was like an Israeli decision,
[31:25] it was because the occupation of Gaza was made very difficult
[31:28] due to armed
[31:29] SPEAKER_00: resistance.
[31:30] But Hezbollah pushing Israel out was an even bigger deal,
[31:32] I think,
[31:33] in 2000.
[31:34] SPEAKER_00: And it made the group incredibly popular.
[31:37] SPEAKER_00: And then came the year 2006,
[31:40] SPEAKER_00: when,
[31:40] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[31:40] SPEAKER_00: after the Israelis were kicked out,
[31:42] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[31:42] SPEAKER_00: the Israelis are never done.
[31:44] SPEAKER_00: They don't take being kicked out or defeated lightly.
[31:47] SPEAKER_00: And they want that land.
[31:48] They have ambitions across the region that they've had since
[31:51] they were created as
[31:52] SPEAKER_00: this,
[31:52] SPEAKER_00: like,
[31:52] SPEAKER_00: ethno-supremacist,
[31:53] SPEAKER_00: fascistic state.
[31:54] And so in the year 2006,
[31:55] you had the Israelis basically go to war with Hezbollah.
[32:00] actually tried to invade the country and it was a big
[32:03] humiliation failure it seemed
[32:05] like they were winning for a bit until they weren't because the
[32:07] Israelis even till
[32:09] now like they don't despite like all the toys they have that
[32:12] the Americans give
[32:13] them they don't do well on the ground and so they didn't do
[32:17] well on the ground in
[32:17] 2006 and once again they were ejected from southern Lebanon by
[32:22] Hezbollah and
[32:22] Hezbollah once again became this very popular resistance force
[32:26] across the region
[32:27] SPEAKER_00: and
[32:27] SPEAKER_00: And I mean,
[32:28] SPEAKER_00: across sects,
[32:29] it was it actually really alarmed the Americans how popular
[32:32] Hezbollah was.
[32:33] SPEAKER_00: I think that back then there was this poll that was done in Egypt,
[32:36] which obviously is a huge country and a very Sunni Muslim
[32:39] country in terms of the
[32:41] SPEAKER_00: makeup of the sects in Egypt.
[32:43] SPEAKER_00: And they were asked who their top three most admired people were.
[32:46] SPEAKER_00: And I think Hassan Nasrallah came in third.
[32:48] SPEAKER_03: And I also,
[32:49] SPEAKER_03: I remember right after October 7th,
[32:50] SPEAKER_03: there were chants in the streets of Egypt for the Sala.
[32:54] SPEAKER_00: Oh, I forgot about that.
[32:55] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[32:56] SPEAKER_00: And that's actually an even bigger deal because,
[32:58] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[32:58] SPEAKER_00: after 2006,
[33:00] SPEAKER_00: you had the Bush administration,
[33:01] SPEAKER_00: you had the war on terror,
[33:02] SPEAKER_00: and you had the war in Iraq,
[33:04] SPEAKER_00: which had taken on a very sectarian nature.
[33:06] SPEAKER_00: You had Sunni al-Qaeda groups like blowing up Shia mosques.
[33:10] SPEAKER_00: You had Shia militias.
[33:12] SPEAKER_00: that were getting blamed for everything.
[33:13] SPEAKER_00: I'm not saying they were angels, but the narrative that the U.S.
[33:16] SPEAKER_00: had on Iraq had kind of shifted from, you know, in 2003.
[33:19] Sorry,
[33:19] not to divert too much from Lebanon,
[33:21] but I promise this is tangentially related.
[33:23] SPEAKER_00: In 2003, when the U.S.
[33:24] SPEAKER_00: invaded Iraq,
[33:25] the narrative was at the time that Saddam was a Sunni
[33:29] supremacist leader that was
[33:31] SPEAKER_00: repressing the majority Shia population.
[33:33] SPEAKER_00: of Iraq.
[33:34] It was like the Shias were,
[33:36] you know,
[33:36] the Jews of Nazi Germany and Saddam was Hitler.
[33:39] SPEAKER_00: That was a very prominent narrative,
[33:41] especially among like the most neoconservative hawks who were
[33:44] promoting the Iraq
[33:44] SPEAKER_00: war.
[33:45] And then it's interesting because that narrative completely
[33:48] shifted later on as the
[33:50] SPEAKER_00: you had these Shia forces who were armed,
[33:53] SPEAKER_00: who were fighting the American occupiers,
[33:55] SPEAKER_00: who were aligned with the Iranians.
[33:57] SPEAKER_00: And the Americans were like, oh, hell no.
[33:59] SPEAKER_00: And then you have like Hezbollah in Lebanon defeating the Israelis.
[34:02] And then that's when you start hearing this narrative of the
[34:05] Shia crescent,
[34:07] right?
[34:08] This idea,
[34:08] it's so racist,
[34:10] but this idea that like the Shias of Lebanon to the Shias of
[34:14] SPEAKER_00: You know,
[34:14] SPEAKER_00: Iraq to Iran,
[34:16] like there's a line that threads them all and they're a huge
[34:19] threat to American and
[34:20] SPEAKER_00: Israeli hegemony.
[34:21] SPEAKER_00: And then,
[34:21] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[34:22] SPEAKER_00: Syria gets thrown in the mix because Assad's Alawite and that,
[34:24] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[34:25] SPEAKER_00: might as well just call that Shia.
[34:26] SPEAKER_00: And by the year 2007, you've got the Americans and the Saudis.
[34:31] Getting together and formulating this plan to basically spread
[34:36] anti-Shia propaganda
[34:37] across the region to make Hezbollah and Iran less popular
[34:42] through the prison of
[34:43] SPEAKER_00: anti-Shia sectarian hatred.
[34:45] SPEAKER_00: In Iraq,
[34:45] this had already started happening with the way the Gulf states
[34:47] were funding
[34:48] SPEAKER_00: certain media and Iraq and the narratives.
[34:50] SPEAKER_00: That were taking place in Iraq,
[34:51] SPEAKER_00: but it had been kind of isolated to Iraq,
[34:53] SPEAKER_00: but then it exploded into the rest of the region,
[34:56] SPEAKER_00: especially as the U.S.
[34:57] was also embarking on a plan to arm Sunni militias that were
[35:00] essentially just
[35:01] Al-Qaeda precursors to Al-Qaeda across Lebanon and across Iraq
[35:05] to fight the big bad
[35:07] SPEAKER_00: Shia threat.
[35:08] And so all of these Arabs across the region are now being
[35:10] subjected to billions of
[35:12] dollars worth of Gulf state funded propaganda on the news
[35:15] saying that the big bad
[35:17] SPEAKER_00: people were,
[35:18] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[35:18] SPEAKER_00: these evil Shias that just want to kill all the Sunnis.
[35:21] SPEAKER_00: And then this,
[35:22] SPEAKER_00: of course,
[35:22] I think culminated in the most kind of sectarian hatred we've
[35:26] seen once the 2011
[35:27] SPEAKER_00: uprisings,
[35:28] SPEAKER_00: after the 2011 uprisings happened.
[35:30] First Tunisia and Egypt and then in Syria you have uprisings
[35:33] and that quickly
[35:34] SPEAKER_00: becomes militarized.
[35:35] And then got these al-Qaeda groups in Iraq taking over huge
[35:39] swaths of areas in Iraq
[35:40] SPEAKER_00: and then going into Syria to try to do the same.
[35:42] SPEAKER_00: And that's where you get ISIS and al-Nusra.
[35:44] SPEAKER_00: And then the hate takes on a new phase there across the region.
[35:48] SPEAKER_00: And again, being pushed by the Americans, pushed by the Gulf states.
[35:51] SPEAKER_00: But I raise all this to say this impacted dramatically.
[35:55] the way people interpreted or viewed hezbollah through this
[35:59] very sectarian
[36:00] anti-shia lens which already existed to some degree in lebanon
[36:04] but in lebanon
[36:04] before this it had been more like oh gross they're muslims if
[36:07] you know because like
[36:08] lebanon has a different sect makeup than the rest of the region
[36:11] but then across the
[36:11] region it became no they're not just muslims they're shias and
[36:14] shias are the worst
[36:15] SPEAKER_00: because shias are all iranians it's as black and white as that
[36:19] SPEAKER_03: I do hear this thing.
[36:20] SPEAKER_03: I did want to ask about this later on.
[36:22] I do hear this thing constantly where people are accusing
[36:25] Hezbollah of not only
[36:27] SPEAKER_03: being Iranian agents,
[36:29] SPEAKER_03: but being populated by like ethnic Iranians themselves.
[36:32] SPEAKER_00: Like they're not even Lebanese.
[36:34] SPEAKER_00: They're not even Arab.
[36:35] SPEAKER_00: They're actually.
[36:35] No,
[36:35] because if they were Lebanese,
[36:36] they would care about the country,
[36:38] etc.,
[36:38] etc.,
[36:39] etc.
[36:40] SPEAKER_00: Exactly.
[36:40] SPEAKER_00: It's like this propaganda.
[36:41] SPEAKER_00: I mean, if people hear it enough, it really works.
[36:43] SPEAKER_00: And it comes from so many different angles.
[36:45] SPEAKER_00: And this is just the anti-Shia angle.
[36:47] SPEAKER_00: And I also have to say,
[36:48] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[36:48] SPEAKER_00: historically speaking,
[36:49] SPEAKER_00: when we talk about the roots of Hezbollah and the Shias of the South,
[36:52] SPEAKER_00: I mean...
[36:53] SPEAKER_00: The South used to be the Shias of the South.
[36:56] It was like a peasant class of people worked in agriculture,
[36:59] worked on farmland.
[37:00] SPEAKER_00: And so they were also looked down through a class lens.
[37:04] SPEAKER_00: So it's like the dirty peasant sort of like Shias of the South.
[37:08] SPEAKER_00: And they also before,
[37:10] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[37:10] SPEAKER_00: Hezbollah and,
[37:11] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[37:11] SPEAKER_00: before the Iranian revolution,
[37:13] SPEAKER_00: these were mostly communists.
[37:15] SPEAKER_00: The communists were popular in the South.
[37:16] SPEAKER_00: And I think something similar applies to Iraq, by the way.
[37:19] SPEAKER_00: So there is a class makeup of Hezbollah back then.
[37:22] SPEAKER_00: These are the working class, poor peasants occupied by the Israelis.
[37:26] SPEAKER_00: They're kind of like abused from every angle you can think of.
[37:30] SPEAKER_00: And so there's other sort of dynamics of the way they're looked down on,
[37:35] SPEAKER_00: even till today,
[37:36] SPEAKER_00: that go back to certain class roots as well,
[37:38] SPEAKER_00: in addition to the sectarianism.
[37:40] SPEAKER_00: But once Hezbollah got involved in the Syrian war,
[37:43] SPEAKER_00: Which,
[37:43] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[37:43] SPEAKER_00: I know we call it a civil war,
[37:44] SPEAKER_00: but man,
[37:45] SPEAKER_00: was every country involved in that war or what?
[37:48] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[37:48] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[37:48] people still argue to this day whether it was wise or not for
[37:51] Hezbollah to get
[37:51] SPEAKER_00: involved.
[37:52] SPEAKER_00: I mean, as they saw it, Bashar al-Assad was their ally.
[37:55] As far as the Syrian government goes,
[37:56] it's an important ally in the resistance axis.
[37:59] SPEAKER_00: And if Syria falls, they're super fucked.
[38:01] SPEAKER_00: You know, they're not going to be able to get as many weapons.
[38:04] SPEAKER_00: They lose like a huge I mean, Syria is massive.
[38:07] SPEAKER_00: compared to Lebanon.
[38:08] And Syria also historically played this kind of parental is not
[38:11] the right word,
[38:11] SPEAKER_00: but a very imposing role in Lebanon.
[38:13] SPEAKER_00: I mean, they occupied Lebanon for a lengthy period of time.
[38:16] SPEAKER_00: And so the idea was that if Syria falls,
[38:19] it's obviously going to fall to some pro-US government that's
[38:22] going to make peace
[38:22] SPEAKER_00: with Israel.
[38:23] SPEAKER_00: And that is a catastrophe.
[38:24] SPEAKER_00: That was one.
[38:25] Two,
[38:25] Syria was under the threat of being taken over by ISIS and
[38:28] Al-Qaeda,
[38:29] right?
[38:29] SPEAKER_00: So huge areas of Syria actually were
[38:31] SPEAKER_00: And of being balkanized.
[38:33] SPEAKER_00: And so we have to prevent that.
[38:34] SPEAKER_00: That was the thinking.
[38:35] SPEAKER_00: And actually,
[38:35] this poses a threat to Lebanon because these Al Qaeda groups
[38:39] are trying to come
[38:40] SPEAKER_00: into Lebanon.
[38:41] SPEAKER_00: They actually did come into areas of Lebanon.
[38:43] SPEAKER_00: They were blowing up, you know, Shia mosques.
[38:46] SPEAKER_00: They were killing people, beheading people.
[38:49] SPEAKER_03: In Jolani, he sent fighters into South Beirut to bomb it.
[38:54] SPEAKER_03: And now he's meeting with the Lebanese president.
[38:55] SPEAKER_00: And I don't think he's ever apologized for that, by the way.
[38:58] SPEAKER_03: No, no, he was a teenager when 9-11 happened.
[39:01] SPEAKER_03: It doesn't matter.
[39:02] SPEAKER_02: Those decisions were above his head, right?
[39:04] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[39:04] Who among us hasn't at some point in our lives gone through an
[39:09] all kind of phase?
[39:09] SPEAKER_02: Youthful indiscretions.
[39:11] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, it happens.
[39:14] I want to actually jump back to 2000 because we talked about
[39:17] kind of like the class...
[39:19] basis of Hezbollah and the religious identity,
[39:21] or at least the narrative around it.
[39:23] SPEAKER_02: But I kind of want to come back to the ideological, right?
[39:25] Because the 2000 moment is really interesting because you have
[39:30] Hezbollah as an
[39:31] SPEAKER_02: armed resistance movement ejecting the Israelis,
[39:34] but it's also at the same time that there's massive pushes on
[39:37] the diplomatic front,
[39:38] SPEAKER_02: right?
[39:38] SPEAKER_02: Syria is in negotiations.
[39:40] SPEAKER_02: with Israel.
[39:41] SPEAKER_02: The Camp David Accords are kind of this falsely hopeful moment for peace.
[39:46] SPEAKER_02: And I think part of the appeal,
[39:49] SPEAKER_02: at least like the later appeal of a character like Nasrallah,
[39:52] SPEAKER_02: is that he was deeply skeptical,
[39:54] SPEAKER_02: right,
[39:54] SPEAKER_02: of these diplomatic tracts.
[39:56] Nasrallah has always said that you can try to achieve peace
[39:59] with Israel through
[40:01] SPEAKER_02: diplomacy,
[40:02] SPEAKER_02: but they will never concede anything without force,
[40:04] SPEAKER_02: that we need to maintain our deterrent capacity,
[40:07] SPEAKER_02: and that he ultimately proved correct in that assessment.
[40:10] SPEAKER_02: The Camp David Accord never went anywhere.
[40:13] Israel obviously never stopped its project of colonial
[40:16] expansion and invasion going forward.
[40:18] SPEAKER_00: No, absolutely.
[40:18] SPEAKER_00: I mean, I think he's been proven right.
[40:20] SPEAKER_00: There's no question.
[40:21] Everywhere you look,
[40:21] even countries that have normalized with Israel,
[40:23] like look at Egypt.
[40:24] SPEAKER_00: I mean, Egypt hasn't normalized with Israel a long time ago.
[40:29] SPEAKER_00: And Israel still threatens Egypt.
[40:31] SPEAKER_00: You know,
[40:31] like it's like they've been threatening to send Palestinians
[40:34] from Gaza to go live
[40:35] SPEAKER_00: in the Sinai.
[40:36] SPEAKER_00: And they've actually threatened force to make it happen.
[40:38] SPEAKER_00: I mean, whether they follow through on that is another story.
[40:40] Because the Americans are a bit more like putting their foot
[40:42] down about certain red lines.
[40:44] SPEAKER_00: But the point is,
[40:44] SPEAKER_00: is that a normalization deal with the Israelis,
[40:47] SPEAKER_00: if you border them or even if you don't border them,
[40:49] SPEAKER_00: does not make you safe from their aggression.
[40:52] Because at the end of the day,
[40:53] it just shows your weakness and that you're controllable.
[40:56] And especially for a country like Lebanon,
[40:58] Lebanon is different from like the UAE,
[41:00] for example.
[41:00] SPEAKER_00: The Israelis are not trying to take over Emirati territory.
[41:03] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[41:04] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[41:04] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[41:04] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[41:27] SPEAKER_00: Like they want to ethnically cleanse them into Jordan.
[41:29] SPEAKER_00: They steal Jordan's water, like no matter what you do with the Israelis.
[41:34] SPEAKER_00: And I think that's what the tough call is today.
[41:36] SPEAKER_00: And this is what Nasrullah would often say.
[41:38] SPEAKER_00: He's like, basically, you either have to fight or you're a slave.
[41:42] SPEAKER_00: And I'd rather fight than be a slave.
[41:44] SPEAKER_00: And people have different ideas of what they would rather do.
[41:47] And surrender for an organization like Hezbollah isn't an
[41:50] option because they're
[41:51] SPEAKER_00: from the South.
[41:52] Surrender for them means something very different than like
[41:55] surrender for someone
[41:56] SPEAKER_00: who lives in like the north of Lebanon.
[41:58] And the Israelis also have been very smart at geographically
[42:02] targeting only certain
[42:03] SPEAKER_00: areas of Lebanon and leaving other areas alone.
[42:05] SPEAKER_00: Media, in addition to that, has done a really good job.
[42:08] The propaganda apparatus across the region has done a really
[42:10] good job of portraying
[42:12] SPEAKER_00: the problems of Lebanon,
[42:13] SPEAKER_00: of southern Lebanon specifically,
[42:15] SPEAKER_00: as just their problem.
[42:17] Like Israel can bomb the South and I can still go about my life
[42:21] uninterrupted,
[42:21] SPEAKER_00: even though that's not really true.
[42:23] I did want to ask more about this because it speaks to my
[42:26] information bubble,
[42:27] certainly.
[42:28] SPEAKER_03: But my own Twitter feed is a watch and clips from Lebanese TV,
[42:32] SPEAKER_03: from Lebanese internet shows,
[42:35] SPEAKER_03: podcasts,
[42:35] SPEAKER_03: where they're interviewing politicians from the Lebanese forces,
[42:39] these militias that you mentioned that committed these
[42:41] massacres in Sabran Shatila.
[42:43] SPEAKER_03: who are now just political parties, civilian political parties.
[42:46] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[42:46] SPEAKER_03: obviously they're supportive of the disarmament of Hezbollah,
[42:49] but they're also speaking very unabashedly about the desperate
[42:52] need for Lebanon to
[42:54] SPEAKER_03: make peace with Israel.
[42:55] SPEAKER_03: These wars aren't in Lebanon's interest.
[42:57] SPEAKER_03: Nobody wants confrontation.
[43:00] SPEAKER_03: How prevalent are these attitudes inside Lebanon?
[43:04] Are they just the select few or does it speak to a larger
[43:07] popularity of those ideas?
[43:09] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[43:09] SPEAKER_00: so I don't have like numbers in front of me,
[43:11] SPEAKER_00: but I know that generally speaking,
[43:13] SPEAKER_00: polling shows that people are not supportive of normalizing with Israel,
[43:17] though I imagine that over the last couple of years that may
[43:20] have changed in the
[43:21] SPEAKER_00: direction of people being more pro-normalizing.
[43:23] SPEAKER_00: And there's a few different reasons behind that.
[43:25] SPEAKER_00: But for the most part,
[43:26] SPEAKER_00: I think the majority of people do see Israel as an enemy.
[43:29] SPEAKER_00: And the majority of people,
[43:31] SPEAKER_00: even if they don't like Hezbollah,
[43:33] SPEAKER_00: do believe Lebanon has a right to resist the Israelis,
[43:38] SPEAKER_00: right?
[43:38] SPEAKER_00: Which is a good thing that a lot of people do still see it that way.
[43:41] SPEAKER_00: That being said,
[43:42] SPEAKER_00: obviously,
[43:43] there has been a decades-long attempt to sectarianize political
[43:50] attitudes in
[43:50] SPEAKER_00: Lebanon,
[43:51] SPEAKER_00: where through that sort of anti-Shia,
[43:54] SPEAKER_00: anti-Muslim lens I mentioned,
[43:57] You have communal leaders of these right wing Christian
[44:01] political parties like like
[44:03] SPEAKER_00: Lebanese forces that have this attitude of we're not actually Arab.
[44:07] SPEAKER_00: We're Phoenician.
[44:09] SPEAKER_00: We hate Palestinians.
[44:10] They're basically responsible for everything that's gone wrong
[44:13] here and everywhere.
[44:14] SPEAKER_00: And if not, Palestinians and Syrians were better than all these people.
[44:18] SPEAKER_00: We're basically white people.
[44:19] And the Israelis are our allies and they should be our allies
[44:22] because we are
[44:23] SPEAKER_00: pro-American and we're pro-Israel.
[44:25] And if we could just make peace with Israel and give them what
[44:29] they want,
[44:29] we can be like Dubai.
[44:31] SPEAKER_03: If I can think of like the neighborhood that I lived in,
[44:33] SPEAKER_03: in Beirut,
[44:34] SPEAKER_03: in Ashrafia,
[44:35] like there were big arguments when someone tried to put up a
[44:39] Palestinian flag on
[44:40] SPEAKER_03: their balcony.
[44:41] SPEAKER_03: The keffiyeh was banned at the local ABC mall.
[44:44] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I remember that.
[44:46] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[44:46] SPEAKER_03: In Sassin Square,
[44:48] SPEAKER_03: there are those big memorials,
[44:50] SPEAKER_03: two different memorials to Bashir Jamal,
[44:52] SPEAKER_03: whose assassination precipitated the Sabah and Shatila massacre.
[44:57] SPEAKER_03: And when I remember the Israelis were talking about,
[45:01] they published a video once of supposedly Lebanese all over the
[45:06] country who wanted
[45:07] SPEAKER_03: normalization with Israel,
[45:08] SPEAKER_03: and they're all in Sassin Square.
[45:11] SPEAKER_03: They're all in the same street.
[45:13] And that is the thing that is being projected out into the
[45:16] world about Lebanese attitudes.
[45:17] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, exactly.
[45:18] SPEAKER_00: Because these are like the people who get the most airtime.
[45:20] SPEAKER_00: I mean, as you know, Seamus, you lived in Lebanon.
[45:22] SPEAKER_00: Like, where do all the journalists live?
[45:23] SPEAKER_00: Where do all the foreign correspondents live?
[45:25] SPEAKER_03: They live in... No, no, they don't live in Dahya.
[45:28] SPEAKER_03: I only know of one.
[45:29] SPEAKER_00: I mean, not even just Dhani.
[45:30] SPEAKER_00: They all live in,
[45:31] SPEAKER_00: like,
[45:31] SPEAKER_00: Shafi'i or Qamad Mikhail or just these areas where,
[45:35] SPEAKER_00: like,
[45:35] SPEAKER_00: the political attitudes around them,
[45:37] SPEAKER_00: they're not homogenous,
[45:38] SPEAKER_00: but the majority of them are going to be anti-Palestinian and pro...
[45:43] I don't want to say pro-Israel because I don't know that people
[45:45] have those
[45:46] SPEAKER_00: attitudes quite openly.
[45:47] SPEAKER_00: Maybe they do, just not around me.
[45:49] SPEAKER_00: But definitely, like, a pro-French, pro-American, pro-Western...
[45:54] Desperately wondering why they aren't able to be like these
[45:58] Western countries.
[45:59] And their narrative about everything is that Hezbollah
[46:02] terrorizes us here in Lebanon.
[46:04] It's a militia that's basically Iranian that terrorizes us
[46:08] because it has power and
[46:09] SPEAKER_00: we're scared of that.
[46:10] SPEAKER_00: And basically, we just don't like Muslims.
[46:11] SPEAKER_00: And let's not forget, Lebanon was supposed to be
[46:14] SPEAKER_00: after Saxe-Pico, right?
[46:15] SPEAKER_00: It was like kind of given to the French as this like colony, if you will.
[46:19] SPEAKER_00: It was supposed to be a Christian country,
[46:21] SPEAKER_00: a Maronite country,
[46:22] SPEAKER_00: in the way that Israel is supposed to be a Jewish country.
[46:25] SPEAKER_00: So there is this still desire for Lebanon to be that way.
[46:29] SPEAKER_00: I mean, one of the reasons Lebanon hasn't had a census in like...
[46:33] SPEAKER_00: 70 years is because if it did,
[46:35] SPEAKER_00: it would demonstrate that it basically a vastly majority Muslim and the
[46:39] SPEAKER_00: parliamentary split,
[46:40] SPEAKER_00: which actually gives,
[46:41] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[46:41] SPEAKER_00: these Maronite parties more power,
[46:43] SPEAKER_00: it would give them less.
[46:44] SPEAKER_00: So all that's to say, Lebanon's an incredibly polarized country.
[46:47] And it doesn't mean if someone's Maronite,
[46:49] they're just automatically going to have
[46:50] SPEAKER_00: fascistic politics.
[46:52] SPEAKER_00: It just means that politics in Lebanon,
[46:54] because they're largely bisect and because they have these like
[46:57] sectarian leaders
[46:58] SPEAKER_00: that make up these political parties,
[46:59] SPEAKER_00: if you pull Maronites,
[47:01] SPEAKER_00: it's going to come out differently than if you pull Shias,
[47:04] SPEAKER_00: than if you pull Sunnis,
[47:05] SPEAKER_00: than if you pull the Druze.
[47:06] SPEAKER_00: You know what I mean?
[47:07] Because everybody kind of follows specific media that aligns
[47:10] with their communal
[47:11] SPEAKER_00: leadership and the politics that's associated with that.
[47:14] SPEAKER_00: But all that's to say, like, Lebanon's incredibly polarized.
[47:17] SPEAKER_00: But I think a lot of there's also another angle here, Seamus.
[47:20] SPEAKER_00: It's not just the sectarian anti-Shia parties that are like,
[47:24] SPEAKER_00: get rid of Hezbollah,
[47:25] SPEAKER_00: disarm them,
[47:26] SPEAKER_00: normalize with Israel.
[47:28] SPEAKER_00: There's also a defeatist,
[47:31] exhausted attitude that has been told for the past few decades
[47:36] that everything
[47:37] SPEAKER_00: wrong with the country is because of Hezbollah's weapons.
[47:40] SPEAKER_00: Like if you hear that over and over again,
[47:42] SPEAKER_00: every time you turn on the media,
[47:44] SPEAKER_00: you don't have electricity because Hezbollah has weapons.
[47:47] SPEAKER_00: You're the banks collapse because Hezbollah has weapons.
[47:50] There's been a really fantastically done propaganda campaign
[47:54] that has tied all of
[47:55] SPEAKER_00: the inconveniences of Lebanon,
[47:57] SPEAKER_00: which are just the inconveniences of a corrupt country.
[48:00] SPEAKER_00: in a capitalistic global South atmosphere.
[48:03] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[48:04] SPEAKER_00: you do see this kind of problem from country to country,
[48:06] SPEAKER_00: sadly,
[48:07] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[48:07] in this era that associates all of that with the fact that
[48:11] there's a group that
[48:12] SPEAKER_00: continues to resist Israel.
[48:13] SPEAKER_00: And if they would just put down their weapons and stop, we could breathe.
[48:17] SPEAKER_00: This is not true,
[48:18] SPEAKER_00: by the way,
[48:19] but enough people believe it that you are starting to see and
[48:22] it's kind of
[48:24] SPEAKER_00: faction of people form,
[48:25] SPEAKER_00: just your common person being like,
[48:27] SPEAKER_00: yeah,
[48:27] SPEAKER_00: of course,
[48:28] SPEAKER_00: the Israelis are the devils and genocide everybody,
[48:30] SPEAKER_00: but we're not powerful enough to defeat them.
[48:32] SPEAKER_00: And I just want electricity.
[48:34] SPEAKER_00: You know what I'm saying?
[48:35] SPEAKER_00: So that's also quite dangerous as well.
[48:37] SPEAKER_00: That said,
[48:38] SPEAKER_00: there's also a different dynamic at play today,
[48:40] which is that there was a regime change war on Syria that
[48:43] lasted for like a decade
[48:44] SPEAKER_00: and ultimately won.
[48:45] SPEAKER_00: And that was a huge loss for not just Hezbollah,
[48:48] SPEAKER_00: but any force of resistance across the region,
[48:50] SPEAKER_00: because now you have in power
[48:52] Say what you want about Bashar al-Assad and Syria before and
[48:56] what it was doing for
[48:57] SPEAKER_00: the resistance or not doing,
[48:58] SPEAKER_00: fine.
[48:59] SPEAKER_00: But now you have Ahmad al-Shadda,
[49:02] SPEAKER_00: former ISIS and al-Qaeda leader,
[49:04] SPEAKER_00: as president of Syria,
[49:05] SPEAKER_00: and he's begging to normalize with Israel.
[49:08] The Israelis have destroyed Syria's entire basically military
[49:11] infrastructure,
[49:12] SPEAKER_00: and the Syrians didn't respond at all.
[49:15] SPEAKER_00: They just let it happen under Ahmad al-Shadda.
[49:17] The internal divisions in Syria have led to,
[49:20] especially with these HTS guys,
[49:22] occupying high levels of like the intelligence and security
[49:25] apparatus under Ahmad
[49:26] al-Shadda have led to sectarian massacres across the coast and
[49:30] in the south against
[49:31] SPEAKER_00: the Alawites and Druze.
[49:33] And that is giving Israel exactly what it needs to try to
[49:36] portray itself as like a
[49:37] SPEAKER_00: potential savior for these people being massacred by the evil Muslims.
[49:41] Ahmad al-Shadda is begging for normalization and actually
[49:44] certain parts of the
[49:44] SPEAKER_00: American ruling class
[49:46] SPEAKER_00: are on his side and pushing for that as well.
[49:48] SPEAKER_00: But the Israelis are like, absolutely not.
[49:50] SPEAKER_00: We're going to keep bombing you.
[49:51] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[49:51] SPEAKER_00: just last week,
[49:52] I'm sure you saw the Israelis did a raid in the countryside of
[49:55] Damascus and killed
[49:57] SPEAKER_00: 13 people and kidnapped people.
[50:00] SPEAKER_03: Implicating a group in Lebanon that has operations in Syria.
[50:03] They claim that they were going after the Lebanese branch of
[50:06] the Muslim Brotherhood
[50:07] SPEAKER_00: that is aligned with Hamas,
[50:08] SPEAKER_00: but somehow is in the countryside of Damascus.
[50:11] SPEAKER_00: And the locals,
[50:11] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[50:12] it's not like the Syrian government hit back or did anything to
[50:14] protect its people
[50:15] because we're in the era of no governments doing anything to
[50:17] protect their people
[50:18] SPEAKER_00: anywhere from Israel.
[50:20] SPEAKER_00: It was locals who have, you know, most people have guns.
[50:23] So locals shot back because what do you do when someone busts
[50:26] into your village or
[50:27] SPEAKER_00: your neighborhood or your house?
[50:29] SPEAKER_00: You fight back, especially if they're coming for your family.
[50:32] So you had clashes and the Israelis were whining because six of
[50:36] their soldiers were injured.
[50:37] SPEAKER_00: Because how dare you not let me just come in?
[50:40] SPEAKER_02: They were whining because Syrians were burning Israeli flags.
[50:42] SPEAKER_00: I mean, how could you?
[50:44] SPEAKER_02: The audacity.
[50:46] The audacity of burning that flag after it's been used to
[50:50] murder your family.
[50:51] SPEAKER_02: I think this kind of raises the question,
[50:53] SPEAKER_02: too,
[50:53] SPEAKER_02: of what Israel's strategy genuinely is with Lebanon,
[50:57] SPEAKER_02: right?
[50:57] I think the Syria example kind of undermines a lot of the
[51:01] narratives that some of
[51:02] these sectarian groups within Lebanon are perpetrating about
[51:06] what's possible with
[51:07] SPEAKER_02: respect to Israel.
[51:08] SPEAKER_02: I'm curious,
[51:09] we talked about all of the sectarian issues in Lebanon and how
[51:13] Israel has exploited
[51:14] SPEAKER_02: them.
[51:14] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[51:14] I think it's worth asking the question of what Israel's actual
[51:18] strategy is with
[51:19] SPEAKER_02: respect to Lebanon.
[51:20] SPEAKER_02: We know,
[51:21] SPEAKER_02: and as you mentioned,
[51:22] SPEAKER_02: during the Lebanese civil war,
[51:24] SPEAKER_02: Israel had direct relationships with some of these groups.
[51:27] SPEAKER_02: Have those direct relationships continued?
[51:31] SPEAKER_02: And also, how is Israel relating to the Lebanese state itself today?
[51:35] We've just seen that there's recently been mutual civilian
[51:40] participation in the US
[51:43] SPEAKER_02: ceasefire committee,
[51:44] which is the first time that there's direct talks between
[51:47] civilian leadership
[51:48] SPEAKER_02: between Israel and Lebanon for 40 years.
[51:50] SPEAKER_02: What are they looking for?
[51:51] SPEAKER_02: Are they pushing for something like normalization?
[51:54] SPEAKER_02: And what would normalization even mean
[51:56] SPEAKER_02: in a situation where Israel demands the disarmament of Hezbollah,
[52:01] but does not seem willing to tolerate any kind of Lebanese
[52:04] state that has the
[52:06] SPEAKER_02: actual capacity to enforce sovereignty?
[52:08] SPEAKER_00: Those are all really great points and good questions.
[52:11] SPEAKER_00: And yes, so what do the Israelis want in Lebanon?
[52:14] SPEAKER_00: They want Lebanon to be devoid of any force of resistance.
[52:19] SPEAKER_00: They want the Lebanese government to be completely subservient to Israeli
[52:24] SPEAKER_00: interests,
[52:24] SPEAKER_00: and that means American interests as well.
[52:26] And they just want to knock it out as a threat to any of
[52:29] Israel's greater ambitions.
[52:30] And that includes at some point Israel does want we talk about
[52:34] greater Israel.
[52:35] SPEAKER_00: There is a real desire for greater Israel.
[52:37] SPEAKER_00: And that includes huge portions of South Lebanon.
[52:40] SPEAKER_00: But, you know, that's kind of like maybe later on.
[52:43] SPEAKER_00: Right now, what the Israelis want is they want Hezbollah disarmed.
[52:46] SPEAKER_00: They actually want Hezbollah to not exist anymore.
[52:48] SPEAKER_00: They want no more Hezbollah.
[52:49] SPEAKER_00: And the Israelis feel very powerful right now.
[52:52] SPEAKER_00: So they feel that they can actually do it themselves.
[52:56] They don't trust the Lebanese government to do it,
[52:58] even though that's this.
[52:59] SPEAKER_00: I'll talk about that.
[52:59] SPEAKER_00: That's a situation the U.S.
[53:00] SPEAKER_00: is trying to set up.
[53:02] SPEAKER_00: And the Israelis also want peace with Lebanon.
[53:05] SPEAKER_00: I put peace in quotes.
[53:06] They want Lebanon to normalize with Israel,
[53:08] have diplomatic relations with Israel.
[53:10] SPEAKER_00: That would be a huge, mungous win for the Israelis.
[53:14] SPEAKER_00: That's their big dream is to have the entire region normalized with them
[53:18] SPEAKER_00: economically,
[53:19] SPEAKER_00: diplomatically,
[53:20] but in a way where they're all subservient to the Israelis and
[53:23] also like basically
[53:24] SPEAKER_00: taking their land without any resistance whatsoever.
[53:27] SPEAKER_00: That's what the Israelis want with Lebanon.
[53:29] SPEAKER_00: Now, what can they actually get?
[53:31] SPEAKER_00: It stands to be seen.
[53:32] But as you mentioned,
[53:34] this week,
[53:35] I mean,
[53:35] when this airs,
[53:36] it'll have been last week.
[53:38] SPEAKER_00: This mechanism by which the U.S.
[53:41] SPEAKER_00: is supposed to oversee the ceasefire has now turned into this,
[53:45] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[53:46] what the Israelis are claiming is like this direct negotiation
[53:50] finally with the
[53:51] SPEAKER_00: Lebanese for normalization.
[53:52] SPEAKER_00: That includes civilian elements.
[53:54] This takes place in an area that would have a unifil house or
[53:58] building where you have a U.S.
[54:00] representative and Israeli representative and now a Lebanese
[54:03] representative meeting
[54:05] SPEAKER_00: to supposedly talk about the ceasefire.
[54:06] SPEAKER_00: The Lebanese are denying what the Israelis are saying.
[54:08] SPEAKER_00: They're saying, no, no, this is not.
[54:10] SPEAKER_00: to talk about normalization,
[54:12] SPEAKER_00: which we'd like to do someday,
[54:13] SPEAKER_00: but only after there's been a Palestinian state.
[54:16] This is to talk about how we effectively monitor and implement
[54:19] the ceasefire.
[54:20] SPEAKER_00: But just to be clear about the Lebanese government,
[54:22] SPEAKER_00: for those who don't know,
[54:23] SPEAKER_00: the Lebanese government is not Hezbollah.
[54:24] Hezbollah serves in the Lebanese government because its
[54:27] political leadership is
[54:29] SPEAKER_00: elected to parliament because Lebanon does have parliamentary elections.
[54:32] SPEAKER_00: Their bloc has the biggest number of parliamentary seats still.
[54:36] SPEAKER_00: We'll see if that lasts.
[54:37] SPEAKER_00: But they aren't the Lebanese government.
[54:39] SPEAKER_00: The Lebanese government is the prime minister.
[54:41] SPEAKER_00: Making the decisions here is like the prime minister,
[54:43] SPEAKER_00: who's Nawaf Salem,
[54:44] SPEAKER_00: and this guy,
[54:45] SPEAKER_00: Joseph Aoun,
[54:45] SPEAKER_00: who's the president.
[54:46] And these guys have agreed with the American plan to disarm
[54:50] Hezbollah and to use
[54:52] SPEAKER_00: the Lebanese army to do that.
[54:53] SPEAKER_00: And that's a very dangerous plan.
[54:55] SPEAKER_00: Because, you know, the Lebanese army is not like a normal army.
[54:58] SPEAKER_00: It's an army that is completely dependent on the U.S.
[55:02] SPEAKER_00: and the countries to like feed their forces,
[55:04] SPEAKER_00: clothe them and to give them,
[55:07] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[55:07] SPEAKER_00: really mediocre U.S.
[55:08] SPEAKER_00: hand-me-down weapons that barely work.
[55:10] SPEAKER_00: That's on purpose so that they can never fight the Israelis.
[55:13] I should also say paid terribly to their salaries by the
[55:17] Qataris to the point where
[55:18] there is a whole stir up over the fact that a lot of these
[55:21] soldiers were working as
[55:23] SPEAKER_03: delivery drivers.
[55:24] SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
[55:25] I know a bunch of Lebanese soldiers like who have like
[55:27] different jobs because it's
[55:28] SPEAKER_00: like being a soldier used to be able to pay a salary.
[55:31] SPEAKER_00: But after the economic collapse, not so much.
[55:34] But the Lebanese army is well-respected across the country
[55:37] because it's made up of all sects.
[55:38] SPEAKER_00: But when you pit the Lebanese army,
[55:40] SPEAKER_00: as the Americans are pressuring the Lebanese government to do,
[55:44] SPEAKER_00: against Hezbollah,
[55:45] you are pitting the army against its own people and you are
[55:48] creating the conditions
[55:49] SPEAKER_00: for potential civil unrest.
[55:51] SPEAKER_00: Because if they're going to have to go and confront and...
[55:55] forcibly disarm people who are just trying to protect their
[55:58] houses and their
[55:59] villages and their land and basically take away their ability
[56:01] to do that and make
[56:02] SPEAKER_00: them sitting ducks,
[56:03] SPEAKER_00: you're going to have a real problem.
[56:05] SPEAKER_00: And so the Lebanese government is in a tough situation,
[56:09] SPEAKER_00: but they have agreed with this idea,
[56:10] SPEAKER_00: but they kind of keep trying to push the deadline,
[56:12] SPEAKER_00: push the deadline,
[56:13] SPEAKER_00: kick the can down the road.
[56:14] SPEAKER_00: The Israelis don't trust the Lebanese government to disarm Hezbollah.
[56:19] SPEAKER_00: They just want to escalate, bomb,
[56:22] Maybe ground invade again and try to do it themselves because
[56:24] they really think
[56:24] SPEAKER_00: they I think they think they can.
[56:25] They think they can bomb Hezbollah out of existence and just
[56:29] keep putting the
[56:29] SPEAKER_00: military pressure on.
[56:31] SPEAKER_00: So everybody expects an escalation very soon.
[56:34] SPEAKER_00: This recent meeting that took place has delayed that escalation.
[56:39] SPEAKER_00: It hasn't prevented it, but it has delayed it.
[56:41] SPEAKER_00: Netanyahu is kind of labeling it in the Israeli media as a win.
[56:45] Like,
[56:46] oh,
[56:46] the Lebanese are sitting down with us with direct negotiations.
[56:49] SPEAKER_00: We're going to normalize with them soon.
[56:51] SPEAKER_00: This is like closer to what we want.
[56:53] SPEAKER_00: That's working in his favor politically and domestically in his country.
[56:56] SPEAKER_00: That doesn't mean there's not going to be an escalation, though.
[56:58] SPEAKER_00: But it seems like it's maybe we can say it's been delayed.
[57:01] SPEAKER_00: And by delayed, I mean maybe for like a month.
[57:03] SPEAKER_00: But everyone expects a massive Israeli escalation.
[57:06] Just to put pressure on Hezbollah,
[57:08] there are guesses it'll happen in January.
[57:11] SPEAKER_00: We'll see.
[57:12] SPEAKER_00: But they've already increased their attacks.
[57:15] And when I say escalation,
[57:16] I don't mean like what happened last year,
[57:18] though.
[57:19] SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
[57:19] SPEAKER_00: I don't have a crystal ball,
[57:20] but I don't think it'll be as across the board as what we saw
[57:22] last year in 2024.
[57:24] But it will be bigger than what's been taking place over the
[57:27] last year and more targets.
[57:29] SPEAKER_00: And Hezbollah, look, no one knows.
[57:30] SPEAKER_00: Has Hezbollah been rebuilding?
[57:32] SPEAKER_00: I'm sure they're working on rebuilding.
[57:34] But because they were so infiltrated and because their entire
[57:37] senior leadership was
[57:38] SPEAKER_00: wiped out,
[57:38] they've had to completely reorganize and figure out how they're
[57:43] going to move
[57:43] SPEAKER_00: forward.
[57:44] SPEAKER_00: And they've gone largely underground.
[57:46] It's all just one big guess whether they're capable or not of
[57:50] taking on the Israelis again.
[57:52] SPEAKER_00: But at some point, they're not going to have a choice.
[57:54] I would say they're still so infiltrated because when
[57:56] Hezbollah's chief of staff
[57:57] SPEAKER_03: was assassinated,
[57:59] SPEAKER_03: the IDF put up a elimination message,
[58:02] SPEAKER_03: but they didn't even have a photo to release.
[58:04] They could track his movements without even knowing what he
[58:07] looked like to give to the press.
[58:09] SPEAKER_00: And there's a lot of frustration in the community.
[58:11] SPEAKER_00: I mean, it's not so vocalized.
[58:13] It's not going to diminish support for Hezbollah because
[58:15] attacks like this just
[58:17] SPEAKER_00: make people cling to their protection harder.
[58:19] So I think it's a really big miscalculation if the Americans or
[58:22] Israelis think that
[58:23] SPEAKER_00: they can pull Hezbollah's base away from them.
[58:25] SPEAKER_00: They're not going to be able to.
[58:27] But people are upset because they don't see a response from
[58:29] Hezbollah,
[58:30] right?
[58:30] SPEAKER_00: It's like, what's the red line?
[58:32] SPEAKER_00: And this was also a problem post-October 8th,
[58:35] SPEAKER_00: is Hezbollah kept making these really,
[58:37] SPEAKER_00: really big promises about Tel Aviv for Dahyeh,
[58:42] SPEAKER_00: and then Dahyeh gets hit,
[58:43] SPEAKER_00: and there's no attacks on Tel Aviv.
[58:44] SPEAKER_00: And it's like,
[58:45] SPEAKER_00: okay,
[58:45] so why did you make that threat if you weren't going to follow
[58:48] through on it?
[58:48] SPEAKER_00: What is your red line?
[58:49] SPEAKER_00: Because every time Israel crosses your red lines,
[58:53] SPEAKER_00: you're not responding,
[58:54] SPEAKER_00: so you're just emboldening them.
[58:55] SPEAKER_00: But also, on the other hand, a response...
[58:59] SPEAKER_00: also emboldens the Israelis because then they hit back harder too.
[59:01] SPEAKER_00: So it's like you can't, this is the difficulty.
[59:04] SPEAKER_00: And I go back to the regional element of this.
[59:06] The region is at a really difficult position because Israel is
[59:10] more powerful.
[59:10] SPEAKER_00: It has bigger weapons.
[59:12] SPEAKER_00: It can sustain a longer bombing campaign.
[59:14] The only people who can really take on the Israelis for at
[59:18] least some period of
[59:18] time are the Iranians because that's like a country and an
[59:21] actual military.
[59:22] We're talking about armed forces who aren't even in charge of
[59:26] the apparatus of the state.
[59:28] SPEAKER_00: You know,
[59:28] SPEAKER_00: we're talking except for maybe the Yemenis,
[59:30] SPEAKER_00: I guess,
[59:30] SPEAKER_00: but like they're really far away and it's just not the same.
[59:33] So it's a very difficult question because it's like when you
[59:35] are so much weaker and
[59:38] you've already lost so much and the Israelis are at a point
[59:42] where it's like,
[59:43] SPEAKER_00: forget the Daya doctrine.
[59:44] We're talking about the Gaza doctrine now,
[59:46] right,
[59:47] where they just annihilate everything.
[59:49] SPEAKER_00: What are your options?
[59:50] SPEAKER_00: How do you fight this?
[59:52] And I think it speaks to the fact that there's always going to
[59:54] be resistance to Israel.
[59:56] SPEAKER_00: But right now, that resistance is very weak.
[59:58] SPEAKER_00: And the Israelis understand that.
[59:59] SPEAKER_00: They feel like they're in a very strong position in the Middle East.
[1:00:03] SPEAKER_00: And I don't mean to take this away from Lebanon,
[1:00:05] SPEAKER_00: but that's why the focus has become so much more about the West,
[1:00:09] SPEAKER_00: because the Israelis are like,
[1:00:10] SPEAKER_00: all right,
[1:00:10] we've taken care of this for now and we can just keep bombing
[1:00:13] whenever we feel like
[1:00:13] SPEAKER_00: because we have absolute impunity.
[1:00:15] SPEAKER_00: At this point, the U.N.
[1:00:17] SPEAKER_00: Security Council supports our colonization of Gaza.
[1:00:21] SPEAKER_00: We're good.
[1:00:22] We can just keep screwing Lebanon and Syria and no one's going
[1:00:24] to do anything about it.
[1:00:25] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[1:00:26] So now let's put all of our resources into trying to fix the
[1:00:29] public opinion in the West.
[1:00:31] SPEAKER_00: And if we can't fix it,
[1:00:32] allying with fascist forces in the West to try to shut down the
[1:00:36] right to free
[1:00:36] SPEAKER_00: speech.
[1:00:37] SPEAKER_03: You're talking about fascists in the West,
[1:00:40] SPEAKER_03: which I guess gives me a good segue into talking about Morgan Ortegas.
[1:00:44] SPEAKER_03: Ortegas,
[1:00:45] SPEAKER_03: there was a recent revelation on the Israel's Channel 14 that she was the
[1:00:49] mysterious American official who recommended that Israel bomb
[1:00:53] the funeral of Hassan
[1:00:55] SPEAKER_03: the Sproul that was attended by more than a million people.
[1:00:58] SPEAKER_03: And Israel...
[1:00:59] rejected that as too much even for them nevertheless ortegas
[1:01:04] will be in lebanon i
[1:01:05] think the week that this will air so i wanted to ask where did
[1:01:09] these people come
[1:01:10] from tom barrack who is a special envoy to syria and and
[1:01:13] ortegas who is now the
[1:01:14] deputy special envoy of the middle east how did these two
[1:01:17] people become the total
[1:01:19] arbiters of american policy and why do these people cause so
[1:01:24] much controversy and
[1:01:26] SPEAKER_03: anxiety in the country whenever they come
[1:01:28] SPEAKER_00: So I think we have to go back to the fact that,
[1:01:30] SPEAKER_00: yes,
[1:01:30] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[1:01:31] SPEAKER_00: these people themselves are horrible people for their own,
[1:01:34] SPEAKER_00: like,
[1:01:34] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[1:01:35] SPEAKER_00: messed up personalities in politics,
[1:01:37] SPEAKER_00: but they're enforcing the political line of the administration.
[1:01:40] SPEAKER_00: Morgan Ortega is awful.
[1:01:42] She does these really provocative things to piss off the
[1:01:46] Lebanese and talk down to
[1:01:47] SPEAKER_00: them and condescend to them.
[1:01:48] SPEAKER_00: So same thing with Tom Barrack.
[1:01:49] SPEAKER_00: And we can get into what those things are.
[1:01:51] SPEAKER_00: But at the end of the day, they're carrying out and enforcing
[1:01:55] SPEAKER_00: The political line of the Trump administration,
[1:01:57] just like Amos Hochstein was carrying out and enforcing the
[1:02:01] political line of the
[1:02:02] SPEAKER_00: Biden administration.
[1:02:03] SPEAKER_00: And I just say that to say,
[1:02:04] SPEAKER_00: like,
[1:02:04] even if they were nice people who weren't atrocious and who
[1:02:08] didn't make you want to
[1:02:09] SPEAKER_00: call your face off.
[1:02:11] SPEAKER_00: they would still be enforcing this horrible political line.
[1:02:15] SPEAKER_00: That's their job.
[1:02:16] SPEAKER_00: In the case of Tom Barrack,
[1:02:17] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[1:02:17] SPEAKER_00: he's this real estate developer who is the ambassador to Turkey.
[1:02:20] SPEAKER_00: But somehow,
[1:02:21] SPEAKER_00: at some point,
[1:02:22] Morgan Ortegas got kind of pushed out of her job because she
[1:02:24] just upset too many
[1:02:25] SPEAKER_00: people around her.
[1:02:26] And so he kind of became the unofficial envoy or maybe the
[1:02:29] official envoy to the
[1:02:31] SPEAKER_00: Middle East,
[1:02:31] SPEAKER_00: specifically with regard to Lebanon.
[1:02:32] SPEAKER_00: He is of Lebanese descent and
[1:02:35] SPEAKER_00: And he managed to piss a lot of people off.
[1:02:36] SPEAKER_00: I mean, we all remember the animalistic comments.
[1:02:38] SPEAKER_00: Also seems to be a character in the Epstein files.
[1:02:41] SPEAKER_00: Just throwing that out there.
[1:02:42] SPEAKER_02: I missed that.
[1:02:44] SPEAKER_00: But who is it?
[1:02:44] SPEAKER_00: I mean, he has a rough past, just like Ahmed El-Shadow, really.
[1:02:48] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, it's disgusting.
[1:02:50] SPEAKER_00: It's disgusting.
[1:02:51] SPEAKER_00: It's a depressing time.
[1:02:52] SPEAKER_00: I think Israel will ultimately...
[1:02:54] fall someday like I don't think Zionism will last I don't think
[1:02:57] it's a sustainable
[1:02:58] SPEAKER_00: project but as long as it has the backing of the Americans like this
[1:03:02] unconditionally which is going to continue for a while longer I
[1:03:05] just don't think
[1:03:06] we're not in a moment where Israel is about to be defeated
[1:03:09] we're in a moment where
[1:03:10] Israel's at its most violent stage just having these eruptions
[1:03:16] of insane cruelty
[1:03:17] SPEAKER_00: and violence to get everything it possibly wants
[1:03:21] SPEAKER_02: Speaking of insane Israeli cruelty backed by the Americans,
[1:03:25] SPEAKER_02: I think it's worth returning to the 2024 war,
[1:03:28] SPEAKER_02: at least the beginning of it.
[1:03:29] I think in retrospect,
[1:03:30] it's clear that that escalation or that war began in full
[1:03:35] with the pager and walkie-talkie attacks on the 17th and 18th
[1:03:39] of September.
[1:03:39] SPEAKER_02: You know,
[1:03:40] SPEAKER_02: I reject the terrorism framework entirely,
[1:03:43] SPEAKER_02: but it's very clear that this operation from the Mossad was an act of
[1:03:47] SPEAKER_02: indiscriminate violence that killed dozens and maimed thousands,
[1:03:51] SPEAKER_02: including many civilians,
[1:03:53] SPEAKER_02: many children.
[1:03:54] And yet it was celebrated in the West,
[1:03:56] in the Western press,
[1:03:57] and even by some US politicians.
[1:04:00] SPEAKER_02: I know that you've done reporting on this.
[1:04:02] Can you talk a bit about those attacks and their impact on
[1:04:05] people across southern Lebanon?
[1:04:06] SPEAKER_00: Yeah,
[1:04:07] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[1:04:07] SPEAKER_00: those attacks were brutal and it really kicked off,
[1:04:10] SPEAKER_00: like you said,
[1:04:10] SPEAKER_00: that 2024 escalation.
[1:04:12] It completely disoriented the country and the resistance for
[1:04:16] like several days.
[1:04:18] SPEAKER_00: Seamus, you were still in Lebanon when that happened, I believe.
[1:04:21] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:04:21] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:04:22] SPEAKER_03: That was terrifying.
[1:04:22] SPEAKER_03: I,
[1:04:23] SPEAKER_00: well,
[1:04:23] SPEAKER_00: I,
[1:04:23] so I was in the U S I had left the U S just a few days before
[1:04:27] to cover the UN
[1:04:27] SPEAKER_00: general assembly.
[1:04:28] SPEAKER_00: And I remember my phone just started blowing up with like,
[1:04:32] SPEAKER_00: Oh my God,
[1:04:33] SPEAKER_00: there's at first it was like electronics are exploding.
[1:04:36] SPEAKER_00: Everybody was really scared.
[1:04:37] Cause like Israel was saying,
[1:04:38] Oh,
[1:04:38] like we,
[1:04:39] we can get into any electronic at first.
[1:04:41] SPEAKER_00: We didn't know like what had happened.
[1:04:42] SPEAKER_00: So when people were scared,
[1:04:43] SPEAKER_00: their ACs or their solar panels or just any,
[1:04:46] SPEAKER_00: like your computer was going to explode.
[1:04:49] I bought my laptop like just a couple of weeks ago from a
[1:04:52] Lebanese shop and I was
[1:04:54] SPEAKER_03: genuinely afraid like something.
[1:04:56] If they had infiltrated the supply chain to that extent and
[1:04:58] they were exploding in
[1:04:59] SPEAKER_03: doctor's offices and kids were being killed,
[1:05:02] SPEAKER_03: everything was up for infiltration.
[1:05:05] SPEAKER_00: Exactly.
[1:05:06] SPEAKER_00: It was really scary.
[1:05:07] SPEAKER_00: But like you said,
[1:05:07] SPEAKER_00: yeah,
[1:05:08] SPEAKER_00: so September 17th,
[1:05:09] SPEAKER_00: these pagers that Hezbollah had bought,
[1:05:12] turns out they were actually made by a fake company that the
[1:05:17] Mossad had set up to
[1:05:18] SPEAKER_00: look because they knew Hezbollah was like in the market to buy pagers.
[1:05:21] SPEAKER_00: And they wanted to use pagers because,
[1:05:23] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[1:05:23] SPEAKER_00: I'm sure,
[1:05:24] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[1:05:24] SPEAKER_00: there definitely were Hezbollah fighters who had pagers,
[1:05:27] but there was people across the community who had pagers
[1:05:29] because in Lebanon,
[1:05:30] SPEAKER_00: like I mentioned before,
[1:05:31] SPEAKER_00: these political parties,
[1:05:32] SPEAKER_00: which are largely by sect,
[1:05:34] SPEAKER_00: You know,
[1:05:34] SPEAKER_00: when they're voted into power,
[1:05:36] the public institutions that are in your municipality are run
[1:05:42] by the political
[1:05:42] SPEAKER_00: party in charge that got voted into power.
[1:05:44] So in these areas where Hezbollah won,
[1:05:46] they run schools,
[1:05:48] they run hospitals.
[1:05:50] SPEAKER_00: And so that's why you have people administratively like again,
[1:05:53] SPEAKER_00: this is a this is a military organization,
[1:05:55] SPEAKER_00: but it's also a political party.
[1:05:56] SPEAKER_00: So it has administrative functions like any political party would.
[1:05:59] So these are devices that people who were not fighters were
[1:06:03] also carrying.
[1:06:05] SPEAKER_00: It's just seen as a secure means of communication inside this community.
[1:06:08] SPEAKER_00: And the Israelis had messed with the supply chain,
[1:06:11] lured Hezbollah to buy these batches of pagers and basically
[1:06:14] put some kind of
[1:06:15] SPEAKER_00: explosive substance that was hard to trace.
[1:06:17] SPEAKER_00: the battery.
[1:06:18] SPEAKER_00: So even when Hezbollah scanned them, they seemed fine.
[1:06:21] SPEAKER_00: And so the Israelis, they started planning for this in like 2015.
[1:06:25] SPEAKER_00: This was like a weapon they have in their back pocket.
[1:06:27] SPEAKER_00: And last September,
[1:06:28] SPEAKER_00: they decided that it was time to push the button on that project,
[1:06:31] SPEAKER_00: that campaign of terror.
[1:06:33] They were claiming that they had no choice because somebody
[1:06:35] inside Hezbollah had
[1:06:36] SPEAKER_00: found out and it was going to ruin the entire plan.
[1:06:39] SPEAKER_00: You know, I don't know if I believe that.
[1:06:40] SPEAKER_00: I don't
[1:06:41] SPEAKER_00: I don't really know what to believe on that front,
[1:06:43] SPEAKER_00: but all that's to say this was absolutely indiscriminate.
[1:06:46] SPEAKER_00: It violates every international law,
[1:06:49] SPEAKER_00: every law of war you can think of,
[1:06:51] SPEAKER_00: the booby-trapping of civilian devices,
[1:06:54] the indiscriminate nature of it because you can't differentiate
[1:06:57] between combatants
[1:06:57] SPEAKER_00: and non-combatants.
[1:06:58] SPEAKER_00: It's far from any battlefield.
[1:07:00] SPEAKER_03: Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
[1:07:02] I read very clearly in many different mainstream media reports
[1:07:06] that this was the
[1:07:06] SPEAKER_03: most specifically targeted attack ever.
[1:07:10] SPEAKER_03: Because every pager went into the hands of a Hezbollah fighter.
[1:07:14] SPEAKER_03: Yes.
[1:07:14] SPEAKER_03: I mean, how could this not be the case?
[1:07:17] I mean,
[1:07:17] I think the word you're looking for,
[1:07:18] the word I saw the most in the media was precise.
[1:07:20] And for anyone who's listening,
[1:07:21] like I did make a short documentary about the pager attacks.
[1:07:23] You can go watch it on the Breakthrough News YouTube channel
[1:07:26] under our documentary section.
[1:07:28] SPEAKER_00: But yeah,
[1:07:28] SPEAKER_00: the media celebrated it as targeted and precise,
[1:07:31] even though it just turned human beings who happened to have
[1:07:35] one of these pagers
[1:07:35] SPEAKER_00: into walking bombs.
[1:07:38] SPEAKER_03: Exploded in grocery stores.
[1:07:39] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, like somebody was like hospitals, killed nurses.
[1:07:41] SPEAKER_00: Yes.
[1:07:42] SPEAKER_00: Yes.
[1:07:43] SPEAKER_00: There's actually a guy you can follow on Instagram.
[1:07:45] I forget his name right now,
[1:07:46] but he is a physical therapist and he's back to his work.
[1:07:49] He has lost a lot of his fingers and I think he's like,
[1:07:51] can't see very well.
[1:07:52] SPEAKER_00: Still doing his job,
[1:07:53] but he kind of like shows you his difficulties in life now that
[1:07:56] he's basically
[1:07:57] SPEAKER_00: disabled.
[1:07:58] SPEAKER_00: But yeah, I mean, it's horrible.
[1:07:59] And also like the other thing too,
[1:08:00] like,
[1:08:01] so they made these pagers all go off at once.
[1:08:03] SPEAKER_00: The only way to stop the beeping is to press okay, but with both fingers.
[1:08:07] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[1:08:07] SPEAKER_00: So it was to maximize the damage to a person.
[1:08:11] SPEAKER_00: So a lot of people,
[1:08:12] SPEAKER_00: you know,
[1:08:13] SPEAKER_00: they're pressing OK on this pager with both hands,
[1:08:16] looking at the screen in the directions of what it says to do
[1:08:19] to turn it off.
[1:08:21] SPEAKER_00: And so it explodes in their hands and faces.
[1:08:23] And the reason I point out that it exploded into both is like a
[1:08:26] lot of people were left blind.
[1:08:28] SPEAKER_00: or like lost eyes or an eye.
[1:08:30] SPEAKER_00: And so when you think about being blind,
[1:08:32] SPEAKER_00: one of the ways that you continue to be able to read is with Braille,
[1:08:34] SPEAKER_00: but these people had their fingers blown off too,
[1:08:36] SPEAKER_00: so they can't even learn Braille.
[1:08:37] SPEAKER_00: Ugh.
[1:08:40] SPEAKER_00: It was really horrible.
[1:08:41] SPEAKER_00: And it also looked militarily.
[1:08:42] SPEAKER_00: It disoriented Hezbollah.
[1:08:44] SPEAKER_00: The Israelis don't care about terrorism.
[1:08:46] SPEAKER_00: They'll do whatever they have to to win.
[1:08:47] SPEAKER_00: They don't follow rules.
[1:08:49] SPEAKER_00: So it disoriented Hezbollah for a few days.
[1:08:51] And then a week later,
[1:08:52] the Israelis murdered Hassan Yisraelah by dropping 80,000 tons
[1:08:56] of U.S.
[1:08:57] supplied bunker buster bombs onto like a six block radius of
[1:09:02] buildings to kill him.
[1:09:04] SPEAKER_00: So brave, so precise.
[1:09:06] Actually,
[1:09:06] one of my friends,
[1:09:07] his dad,
[1:09:08] he lived in one of those buildings and died.
[1:09:10] SPEAKER_00: He was killed in that strike that I think,
[1:09:13] SPEAKER_00: I can't remember if it was Biden or Kamala Harris,
[1:09:14] SPEAKER_00: but one of them called it like a beautiful day or something ridiculous,
[1:09:17] SPEAKER_00: like the way they were praising it.
[1:09:18] SPEAKER_03: Official statement for the White House, I remember.
[1:09:20] SPEAKER_00: Oh, yeah, yeah, exactly.
[1:09:21] SPEAKER_00: And I'm just like, wow, so you think it's beautiful?
[1:09:23] SPEAKER_00: Like my friend's dad was killed.
[1:09:25] SPEAKER_00: Fuck you.
[1:09:26] SPEAKER_02: I just think one thing that's just so upsetting about this, right?
[1:09:28] SPEAKER_02: We see now in the liberal press about,
[1:09:30] SPEAKER_02: you know,
[1:09:31] all of the hay made about the really horrendous actions the
[1:09:34] Trump administration is
[1:09:35] SPEAKER_02: taking in the Caribbean,
[1:09:36] SPEAKER_02: right?
[1:09:36] SPEAKER_02: Just wantonly...
[1:09:38] SPEAKER_02: assassinating civilians.
[1:09:41] SPEAKER_02: This is what Israel was doing with US permission,
[1:09:43] SPEAKER_02: and not only US permission,
[1:09:45] SPEAKER_02: but US celebration.
[1:09:47] SPEAKER_02: As you said,
[1:09:48] SPEAKER_02: these attacks,
[1:09:50] SPEAKER_02: the pager attacks,
[1:09:50] SPEAKER_02: but also the bunker busters,
[1:09:52] SPEAKER_02: violate basically every principle of international law.
[1:09:56] SPEAKER_02: The pager attacks, not distinguishing between civilians and combatants.
[1:10:01] No attempt to make sure that the attack was proportional and no
[1:10:05] necessity,
[1:10:06] right?
[1:10:06] SPEAKER_02: They're not stopping any imminent military maneuver.
[1:10:09] SPEAKER_02: They are the ones escalating, right?
[1:10:12] SPEAKER_02: And you see not only the Randy Fiennes of the world celebrating this,
[1:10:18] although they were doing it and you had also many right-wing
[1:10:21] groups handing out
[1:10:22] SPEAKER_02: pagers on the streets of New York City.
[1:10:24] SPEAKER_02: John Fetterman receiving a golden pager from Netanyahu himself.
[1:10:30] SPEAKER_02: People in the Democratic Party, John Fetterman, what have you.
[1:10:33] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, basically saying this was beautiful.
[1:10:35] SPEAKER_02: I loved it.
[1:10:37] SPEAKER_02: It is just disgusting.
[1:10:38] SPEAKER_02: We talk a lot about how Gaza ended the liberal international order.
[1:10:43] SPEAKER_02: And it did so by stretching US hegemony, stretching it to the point of
[1:10:47] SPEAKER_02: breaking ultimately,
[1:10:49] but also just the way that it exposed and has exposed the total
[1:10:54] hypocrisy that's
[1:10:55] SPEAKER_02: supposed to be at the core here,
[1:10:57] the fundamental principles that are supposed to bind all
[1:10:59] nations and governments,
[1:11:01] SPEAKER_02: Israel just tramples all over them.
[1:11:03] SPEAKER_02: And in the West, all people can do is laugh and clap like seals.
[1:11:06] SPEAKER_02: It's truly horrendous.
[1:11:07] SPEAKER_02: And that's what I was thinking when I was watching your documentary about
[1:11:11] those poor children who are disfigured permanently and the
[1:11:16] sacrifices that they've
[1:11:17] SPEAKER_02: made for Gaza,
[1:11:19] SPEAKER_02: but at the hands of these just monstrous,
[1:11:22] SPEAKER_02: monstrous governments.
[1:11:23] SPEAKER_00: genocidal racist ghouls.
[1:11:24] SPEAKER_00: And you're absolutely right.
[1:11:26] SPEAKER_00: Gaza changed the world.
[1:11:28] SPEAKER_00: And I hope in 20 years or even,
[1:11:31] SPEAKER_00: God,
[1:11:31] SPEAKER_00: please,
[1:11:31] SPEAKER_00: Les,
[1:11:31] SPEAKER_00: I hope we can say that ultimately like all this,
[1:11:35] SPEAKER_00: and I really do believe this,
[1:11:36] SPEAKER_00: like all this sacrifice,
[1:11:38] all this destruction was not in vain because I think it will be
[1:11:41] like the graveyard
[1:11:42] SPEAKER_00: of
[1:11:43] ultimately of zionism and eventually like american empire i
[1:11:46] can't tell you exactly
[1:11:47] how but i think they're overplaying their hand i do find it
[1:11:50] really alarming though
[1:11:51] and i think that we can actually look back and say that the
[1:11:54] destruction not just in
[1:11:55] gaza across the middle east west asia whatever your preference
[1:11:59] is to call it i'm
[1:12:00] going to say the middle east because that's just more natural
[1:12:02] for me to say that so
[1:12:02] SPEAKER_00: if anybody wants to accuse me of being like
[1:12:06] SPEAKER_00: No, no, no.
[1:12:07] SPEAKER_03: Iran flag emojis on Twitter are going to be really mad at you.
[1:12:09] SPEAKER_00: It's West Asia!
[1:12:11] SPEAKER_03: I accept everything that you do.
[1:12:13] SPEAKER_00: I appreciate that.
[1:12:14] SPEAKER_00: But no,
[1:12:15] everything we've seen in the war on terror for the last two
[1:12:17] decades has normalized
[1:12:20] SPEAKER_00: so much.
[1:12:21] I don't think you could have those strikes in the Caribbean
[1:12:25] without a lot of things.
[1:12:26] SPEAKER_00: One of which, I mean, we can go back to the Obama era, you guys.
[1:12:30] SPEAKER_00: The idea of...
[1:12:31] SPEAKER_00: being able to label an organization,
[1:12:33] SPEAKER_00: a terrorist organization,
[1:12:34] and therefore not needing congressional authorization to then
[1:12:38] just extrajudicially
[1:12:39] SPEAKER_00: execute people,
[1:12:41] SPEAKER_00: that was a precedent set during the Obama administration.
[1:12:43] And that's the exact precedent that the Trump administration is
[1:12:46] using to justify
[1:12:48] SPEAKER_00: murdering people in fishing boats in the Caribbean.
[1:12:51] SPEAKER_00: They've basically just made up some drug cartels,
[1:12:54] SPEAKER_00: in some cases,
[1:12:55] SPEAKER_00: labeled them as terrorist organization,
[1:12:57] SPEAKER_00: and woo,
[1:12:58] SPEAKER_00: You know, like magic.
[1:12:59] SPEAKER_00: Now you don't need any approval from anywhere.
[1:13:01] SPEAKER_00: As the executive branch,
[1:13:02] you can just say you're fighting international terrorists and
[1:13:05] extrajudicially
[1:13:06] SPEAKER_00: execute them.
[1:13:07] And like that double tap strike by Pete Hexeth,
[1:13:10] which is outrageous and should be a scandal.
[1:13:12] Are we really going to pretend that our country hasn't been
[1:13:15] doing that across the
[1:13:15] SPEAKER_00: Middle East for like the last two decades under both parties?
[1:13:18] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, Obama did it in Pakistan.
[1:13:19] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, exactly.
[1:13:20] SPEAKER_00: Like double tap strikes become like the norm.
[1:13:22] SPEAKER_00: In Israel's case,
[1:13:23] SPEAKER_00: like in Gaza,
[1:13:24] SPEAKER_00: it's triple tap strikes,
[1:13:25] SPEAKER_00: like what they did with those health kitchen workers.
[1:13:27] And then I really don't think you would see what we're seeing
[1:13:29] in the Caribbean
[1:13:30] without the cruelty and aggression and the raising of the
[1:13:33] threshold of that kind of
[1:13:35] SPEAKER_00: genocidal destruction that has been so normalized with Gaza.
[1:13:39] SPEAKER_00: Whereas had the Caribbean stuff been happening...
[1:13:42] SPEAKER_00: Like three years ago,
[1:13:43] I think that there would be even more outrage and it would be
[1:13:47] more unacceptable
[1:13:48] than it is today because so much has been done to just raise
[1:13:53] that threshold of
[1:13:55] SPEAKER_00: acceptable cruelty.
[1:13:56] SPEAKER_00: Where even like us, we would have been more shocked three years ago.
[1:13:59] And now we're like,
[1:14:00] yeah,
[1:14:00] this is really horrifying,
[1:14:02] but it's pretty on brand.
[1:14:03] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[1:14:03] SPEAKER_00: That's where we're at.
[1:14:04] SPEAKER_00: We're on the precipice of a devastating war potentially on Venezuela.
[1:14:08] SPEAKER_00: It's crazy.
[1:14:09] SPEAKER_00: But this is the era that we're in.
[1:14:11] SPEAKER_00: And I would also add that what's really scary is the U.S.
[1:14:14] SPEAKER_00: is this global hegemon that has so much power and it always has.
[1:14:19] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[1:14:19] SPEAKER_00: For a very, very long time.
[1:14:20] SPEAKER_00: But it used to have this and I'm not suggesting the U.S.
[1:14:23] wasn't violent or horrible before,
[1:14:25] but this is just brute naked force everywhere.
[1:14:29] It's like anyone who doesn't capitulate 100 percent to our
[1:14:33] demands will be
[1:14:34] SPEAKER_00: destroyed with the full force of the U.S.,
[1:14:38] SPEAKER_00: whether it's like economically,
[1:14:39] SPEAKER_00: whether it's with bombs,
[1:14:40] SPEAKER_00: whether it's with both.
[1:14:42] SPEAKER_00: That's the area we're in.
[1:14:43] SPEAKER_00: And what's scary is that there's no forces willing to stand up to it.
[1:14:47] SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
[1:14:47] SPEAKER_00: I think back to World War II,
[1:14:49] SPEAKER_00: you had these Western countries supporting fascists all over the place,
[1:14:53] SPEAKER_00: but eventually Nazi Germany became too much of a threat.
[1:14:55] They had to all come together to defeat this zombie force of
[1:14:58] destructive Nazis.
[1:15:00] Today,
[1:15:01] there's no pull of power willing to do anything except for the
[1:15:04] Yemenis.
[1:15:06] SPEAKER_00: You know what I mean?
[1:15:08] SPEAKER_00: And it's just it's really scary.
[1:15:10] SPEAKER_00: You've got countries like China and Russia,
[1:15:12] SPEAKER_00: but they're not ideologically internationalist in any way.
[1:15:15] SPEAKER_00: Like, I guess not their problem.
[1:15:16] SPEAKER_00: But I think that's very unwise because ultimately what the U.S.
[1:15:20] SPEAKER_00: is doing against Gaza,
[1:15:22] SPEAKER_00: against the Middle East,
[1:15:23] SPEAKER_00: now against Latin America,
[1:15:25] SPEAKER_00: that is the new script.
[1:15:27] SPEAKER_00: That is the new framework that will be used everywhere.
[1:15:30] SPEAKER_00: And eventually it'll be at your own doorstep if you don't stand up to it.
[1:15:33] And I think what you're naming is the particular strategic bind
[1:15:37] that an actor like
[1:15:38] SPEAKER_02: Hezbollah is in,
[1:15:39] SPEAKER_02: right?
[1:15:40] SPEAKER_02: So you're talking about the switch to brute force.
[1:15:43] SPEAKER_02: And what that means is that the option,
[1:15:48] SPEAKER_02: the thing to try and instigate is over extension,
[1:15:51] SPEAKER_02: military over extension,
[1:15:52] SPEAKER_02: right?
[1:15:52] If the rules of norms and hegemony are not a constraint on the
[1:15:56] actions of powers
[1:15:57] SPEAKER_02: like the US and Israel,
[1:15:59] then military over extension is potentially what precipitates
[1:16:02] its decline.
[1:16:03] But as we've named,
[1:16:05] Israel has been so adept at dividing its enemies,
[1:16:09] right?
[1:16:09] SPEAKER_02: And this was what was so devastating,
[1:16:10] SPEAKER_02: right,
[1:16:10] about the ceasefire in Lebanon was that it represented a
[1:16:14] fracturing of the fronts,
[1:16:16] SPEAKER_02: right?
[1:16:16] The whole premise of the Axis of Resistance strategy was about
[1:16:19] a unity of the fronts.
[1:16:21] SPEAKER_02: And so by being able to split them apart,
[1:16:24] Israel put itself in a position where it could cycle these
[1:16:27] fronts and fight them
[1:16:28] SPEAKER_02: one at a time.
[1:16:29] SPEAKER_02: And so yes, you have Yemen being willing to engage Israel, but
[1:16:33] SPEAKER_02: But Israel is capable of fighting Yemen if Yemen is isolated.
[1:16:37] And so I think that it just kind of brings home the strategic
[1:16:40] bind here of
[1:16:41] SPEAKER_02: Hezbollah can't do it alone.
[1:16:42] SPEAKER_02: Nobody can do it alone.
[1:16:44] But how to meaningfully coordinate or come up with a
[1:16:48] comprehensive strategy when
[1:16:50] SPEAKER_02: each of these actors,
[1:16:52] SPEAKER_02: each of these resistance actors,
[1:16:53] SPEAKER_02: or those actors that are willing to engage in resistance,
[1:16:56] have their own domestic concerns,
[1:16:58] their own territorial incongruity with one another.
[1:17:02] SPEAKER_02: And I think it's just worth reflecting on that.
[1:17:04] We talked about the upside or what was persuasive about the
[1:17:09] strategy of deterrence in 2000.
[1:17:11] SPEAKER_02: And I think we have to acknowledge the downside of it now,
[1:17:15] SPEAKER_02: where if there's no mechanism to coordinate a strategy of resistance,
[1:17:21] SPEAKER_02: then it becomes much more difficult to defeat Israel by force.
[1:17:24] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[1:17:24] And I also think we have to recognize that the Israelis have a
[1:17:27] higher threshold of
[1:17:28] SPEAKER_00: what they're willing to deal with as well,
[1:17:30] SPEAKER_00: right?
[1:17:31] SPEAKER_00: 20 years ago, the Israelis couldn't handle the death of a soldier.
[1:17:34] SPEAKER_00: Now they've got the Hannibal Directive.
[1:17:36] SPEAKER_00: They'll kill their own soldiers if they have to.
[1:17:37] SPEAKER_00: They won't blink twice about it, you know?
[1:17:40] SPEAKER_00: So the Israelis also,
[1:17:42] SPEAKER_00: the Israeli psyche,
[1:17:43] SPEAKER_00: the way the Israelis operate today is different than before as well,
[1:17:47] SPEAKER_00: which makes them more difficult to fight.
[1:17:49] SPEAKER_00: Because how do you deter a force that seems...
[1:17:53] SPEAKER_00: so unmoved by losing its own people.
[1:17:55] SPEAKER_00: Because that used to be the one thing we had, right?
[1:17:58] SPEAKER_00: As the Arabs,
[1:17:59] the deterrence was the Israelis can't handle having to be in
[1:18:03] bomb shelters,
[1:18:04] SPEAKER_00: having injuries and having deaths.
[1:18:06] SPEAKER_00: And that's still true to a certain extent,
[1:18:08] because the Israelis are used to having more normal lives than
[1:18:11] the rest of us in
[1:18:11] SPEAKER_00: the region.
[1:18:12] SPEAKER_00: And when that is, you know, temporarily halted.
[1:18:14] SPEAKER_00: And I think that that's why the Iranian-Israeli war of earlier this year
[1:18:18] did ultimately lead to a ceasefire because it was actually
[1:18:22] doing a kind of harm to
[1:18:23] SPEAKER_00: Israel that they weren't used to,
[1:18:24] SPEAKER_00: where they had rubble for once.
[1:18:26] But the reality is that Hezbollah,
[1:18:28] Hamas,
[1:18:29] the Yemenis are not able to exact that kind of damage.
[1:18:32] I did notice this disparity that you're talking about when
[1:18:35] Yemen in particular,
[1:18:37] SPEAKER_03: when they would do those daily ballistic missile launches at like 3 a.m.,
[1:18:41] SPEAKER_03: 4 a.m.,
[1:18:42] it would result in these Twitter posts from people demanding
[1:18:46] that Yemen be
[1:18:47] SPEAKER_03: destroyed because it was interrupting their sleep.
[1:18:50] SPEAKER_03: But conversely,
[1:18:51] SPEAKER_03: The conversations that were happening on far-right channels,
[1:18:55] SPEAKER_03: like Channel 14,
[1:18:57] SPEAKER_03: right before the invasion of Lebanon,
[1:18:58] SPEAKER_03: there was a discussion on,
[1:19:00] SPEAKER_03: I think,
[1:19:01] SPEAKER_03: HaPetio Team,
[1:19:02] SPEAKER_03: the Patriots,
[1:19:04] where one of their guests was talking about the body bags that
[1:19:08] would be needed if
[1:19:10] SPEAKER_03: Lebanon,
[1:19:11] SPEAKER_03: if Hezbollah unleashed their full arsenal.
[1:19:14] SPEAKER_03: And he was smiling.
[1:19:16] This idea that this would be something that could just...
[1:19:20] A non-issue for the Israelis.
[1:19:22] SPEAKER_03: The people who are...
[1:19:25] SPEAKER_03: Those people that fear this still exist within Israeli society,
[1:19:29] SPEAKER_03: but they're being replaced by this new generation of far-righters.
[1:19:33] SPEAKER_03: They want to be inoculated against this.
[1:19:35] They want the quote-unquote new Israeli that does not care what
[1:19:39] happens to them.
[1:19:40] SPEAKER_03: As long as it conquers South Lebanon...
[1:19:43] conquers all the way up to Damascus as Bezel al-Smotlich wants,
[1:19:47] conquers everything.
[1:19:48] SPEAKER_03: They want it all and they are willing to sacrifice for that.
[1:19:51] SPEAKER_03: And that is a very difficult thing for the current Israeli project,
[1:19:56] SPEAKER_03: but also for other Arabs,
[1:19:57] SPEAKER_03: because even if Israel eventually disbands,
[1:20:00] SPEAKER_03: that it's unsustainable,
[1:20:01] SPEAKER_03: as we're saying,
[1:20:02] SPEAKER_03: It's going to go down fighting.
[1:20:05] SPEAKER_03: It's not going to dissolve itself quietly.
[1:20:09] SPEAKER_02: That's the death drive.
[1:20:10] SPEAKER_02: That is Israel's core death drive.
[1:20:12] SPEAKER_02: They narrate this to themselves from their origins.
[1:20:15] SPEAKER_02: We are Samson, right?
[1:20:17] SPEAKER_02: They tell themselves this all the time,
[1:20:19] is that we're going to bring the temple down on top of us and
[1:20:21] ultimately...
[1:20:22] SPEAKER_02: On some core level, it's what they want.
[1:20:24] SPEAKER_00: You're absolutely right.
[1:20:25] SPEAKER_00: I like that phrase you use, death drive.
[1:20:26] SPEAKER_00: But the psychology you just explained, Seamus, is absolutely right.
[1:20:29] I think it's the sort of messianic elements that have taken
[1:20:31] over Israeli society
[1:20:33] SPEAKER_00: and Israeli politics are the ones willing to do that kind of stuff.
[1:20:36] SPEAKER_00: And that definitely, like, that's a huge challenge.
[1:20:38] SPEAKER_00: It's like, so what's the deterrent now?
[1:20:40] SPEAKER_00: It leaves you with way fewer options.
[1:20:43] SPEAKER_03: We're reaching close to the maximum time.
[1:20:46] SPEAKER_03: So I just want to close out by bringing things back more closer to home.
[1:20:50] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:20:50] SPEAKER_03: Back in Lebanon.
[1:20:51] SPEAKER_03: Because we've discussed all these existential matters.
[1:20:54] SPEAKER_03: The existential nature of this war,
[1:20:55] which makes the Lebanese government's attitude towards all of
[1:20:59] us so confounding.
[1:21:02] SPEAKER_03: I think we both know about the foreign minister Yusuf Raji,
[1:21:07] SPEAKER_03: who does not comment on Israeli strikes on Lebanese territory,
[1:21:10] SPEAKER_03: but has infinite amounts of time to...
[1:21:12] SPEAKER_03: Reply on Twitter to Iran's foreign minister.
[1:21:16] SPEAKER_03: Nawaf Salem seems to be in a different earth.
[1:21:20] And Joseph Aoun is so amiable to the Israeli government that
[1:21:25] his quotes are posted
[1:21:27] SPEAKER_03: on Israel's Arabic language state accounts.
[1:21:30] SPEAKER_00: It's so embarrassing.
[1:21:32] I mean,
[1:21:34] you've already said that you expect an escalation to happen in
[1:21:37] January.
[1:21:38] SPEAKER_03: But I guess my main question to you would be,
[1:21:41] outside of the scope of that immediate escalation that is
[1:21:43] likely going to happen,
[1:21:44] SPEAKER_03: unfortunately,
[1:21:45] SPEAKER_03: how do you see within the next few years,
[1:21:48] SPEAKER_03: in the short term,
[1:21:49] SPEAKER_03: within their term,
[1:21:51] SPEAKER_03: how do you see them going about the relationship with Hezbollah,
[1:21:56] SPEAKER_03: with the South,
[1:21:57] SPEAKER_03: with Israel?
[1:21:58] SPEAKER_03: How do you think that's going to go?
[1:22:00] SPEAKER_00: I mean, I don't I don't know because it's hard to predict.
[1:22:04] SPEAKER_00: But if things continue in the direction they're going in,
[1:22:06] SPEAKER_00: Lebanon is on the path to normalization.
[1:22:08] SPEAKER_00: And it really pains me to say that.
[1:22:11] SPEAKER_00: But if nothing,
[1:22:12] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[1:22:12] SPEAKER_00: if Hezbollah's strategy right now is to kind of sit tight,
[1:22:15] SPEAKER_00: but if they keep sitting tight and not responding,
[1:22:17] SPEAKER_00: then like,
[1:22:17] SPEAKER_00: what are they you know,
[1:22:18] SPEAKER_00: what are they for is going to be the question.
[1:22:20] SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
[1:22:21] SPEAKER_00: It's like I go back and forth on this.
[1:22:22] I'm like,
[1:22:22] but there's people in Lebanon who would never allow
[1:22:24] normalization.
[1:22:25] SPEAKER_00: They'll go to war if they have to.
[1:22:26] SPEAKER_00: But will they?
[1:22:27] SPEAKER_00: Maybe.
[1:22:28] SPEAKER_00: Either way, it's not good for Lebanon.
[1:22:30] There's no scenario in the near term where things are good for
[1:22:34] Lebanon,
[1:22:34] unfortunately.
[1:22:35] SPEAKER_00: That's how I see it.
[1:22:37] Whether it means you have a situation where the Israelis have
[1:22:41] decided that they
[1:22:41] have the freedom to operate militarily whenever the hell they
[1:22:44] feel like it.
[1:22:44] SPEAKER_00: Nobody's stopping them.
[1:22:45] SPEAKER_00: Nobody's putting red lines on them.
[1:22:47] And I think that's going to be the situation where for the next
[1:22:50] several years,
[1:22:52] the Israelis will just strike when they feel like it make it
[1:22:54] impossible to rebuild.
[1:22:55] And we're going to have this looming confrontation between the
[1:22:58] army and Hezbollah
[1:22:59] SPEAKER_00: that could lead to civil unrest.
[1:23:00] And we're going to have Israeli escalations and potential
[1:23:03] ground invasions whenever
[1:23:04] SPEAKER_00: they get the itch to do it.
[1:23:06] SPEAKER_00: That's what I see happening over the next several years.
[1:23:08] And an increasing attempt by the Americans to turn the Lebanese
[1:23:11] government into a
[1:23:11] SPEAKER_00: Palestinian authority,
[1:23:13] SPEAKER_00: which is kind of what's happening now,
[1:23:14] SPEAKER_00: where they're just being used to disarm their own people and essentially
[1:23:18] collaborate with the Israeli project to weaken Lebanon and just
[1:23:23] like whine about it
[1:23:24] and make complaints to the UN that they know are never going to
[1:23:26] go anywhere to save
[1:23:27] face while being the ones carrying out the actual destruction
[1:23:32] of any potential
[1:23:34] SPEAKER_00: deterrence in their own country.
[1:23:35] SPEAKER_00: Whether that will succeed stands to be seen.
[1:23:38] SPEAKER_00: And I get like, I don't want to make big predictions.
[1:23:40] And then in five years,
[1:23:41] people being like,
[1:23:42] oh my God,
[1:23:43] everything was liberated.
[1:23:44] SPEAKER_00: What the hell, Rania?
[1:23:45] SPEAKER_00: I hope that's what happens.
[1:23:46] SPEAKER_00: You know?
[1:23:48] SPEAKER_03: Please, we would love, we would love to be wrong.
[1:23:50] I would love like,
[1:23:51] yes,
[1:23:51] I would love for everything to just be liberated and Zionism to
[1:23:54] fall.
[1:23:54] SPEAKER_00: And I think that will one day happen.
[1:23:56] SPEAKER_00: I don't think it'll happen in the next five years.
[1:23:58] SPEAKER_00: And I do see,
[1:23:59] SPEAKER_00: unfortunately,
[1:24:00] SPEAKER_00: a scenario where Lebanon is forced into a situation of normalization.
[1:24:03] SPEAKER_00: So let's see.
[1:24:04] SPEAKER_00: Let's see what happens.
[1:24:05] SPEAKER_00: The developments will show us where things go.
[1:24:07] SPEAKER_03: Thank you, Rania, for speaking with us today.
[1:24:10] SPEAKER_00: Thank you so much for having me.
[1:24:11] SPEAKER_00: It was a pleasure.
[1:24:12] SPEAKER_00: You guys are awesome.
[1:24:13] SPEAKER_02: Thanks, Rania.
[1:24:13] SPEAKER_02: Appreciate it.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
