# Episode 18: Strait Outta Hormuz w/ Laleh Khalili

An episode of [Turbulence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1847060038), 31 Mar 2026, 1 h 10 min.

Audio: https://api.substack.com/feed/podcast/192700087/473ddf0c444c60b303af57444a1a3ea6.mp3

Laleh Khalili joins us to discuss the mechanics, strategy, and economics of Iran’s wartime closure of the Strait of Hormuz. Laleh Khalili is a professor of Gulf Studies at the University of Exeter and the author or editor of seven books, including Heroes and Martyrs of Palestine: The Politics of National Commemoration (Cambridge 2007), Sinews of War and Trade: Shipping and Capitalism in the Arabian Peninsula (Verso 2020), and Extractive Capitalism: How Commodities and Cronyism Drive the Global Economy (Profile Books 2025). We’re committed to independence and will never run ads or take money from institutions. That means Turbulence is entirely listener-funded. For $5 a month, paid subscribers gain access to weekly news analysis bonus episodes, where we respond to events as they unfold, follow up on previous discussions, and draw connections across the conflicts shaping our world. Most importantly, paid subscriptions make it possible for us to keep doing this work independently, week after week. Subscribe today at turbulencepod.substack.com Follow along on Twitter/X and Instagram @turbulence_pod Theme: Eye for an Eye, Haram (2017) Art: Vivek Venkatraman This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit turbulencepod.substack.com/subscribe

## Transcript

[0:01] SPEAKER_00: Very strange.
[0:02] SPEAKER_00: There were eight ships of oil coming out of Iran,
[0:07] SPEAKER_00: and then they actually said,
[0:08] SPEAKER_00: we're going to add an extra two.
[0:10] SPEAKER_00: And they added an extra two,
[0:11] SPEAKER_00: so we had ten ships,
[0:12] SPEAKER_00: and then people realized we were actually negotiating.
[0:15] We're negotiating now,
[0:16] and it'd be great if we could do something,
[0:18] but they have to open it up.
[0:19] SPEAKER_00: They have to open up the Strait of Trump.
[0:24] SPEAKER_00: I mean, Hormuz.
[0:28] SPEAKER_00: Excuse me for...
[0:30] SPEAKER_00: I'm so sorry.
[0:33] SPEAKER_00: Such a terrible mistake.
[0:34] The fake news will say he accidentally said,
[0:36] no,
[0:37] there's no accidents with me.
[0:39] SPEAKER_00: Not too many.
[0:41] SPEAKER_00: If there were, we'd have a major story.
[1:16] SPEAKER_02: Hello,
[1:16] SPEAKER_02: dear listeners,
[1:18] SPEAKER_02: friends,
[1:18] SPEAKER_02: comrades,
[1:19] SPEAKER_02: subjects,
[1:20] SPEAKER_02: citizens,
[1:21] SPEAKER_02: insurgents,
[1:22] SPEAKER_02: fugitives,
[1:23] SPEAKER_02: defectors,
[1:24] SPEAKER_02: dissidents,
[1:25] SPEAKER_02: even the haters and losers.
[1:27] SPEAKER_02: Welcome to Turbulence.
[1:29] SPEAKER_02: My name is Dylan Saba,
[1:30] SPEAKER_02: and I'm here with my co-host,
[1:32] SPEAKER_02: Seamus Malikafselli,
[1:33] SPEAKER_02: along with our producer,
[1:35] SPEAKER_02: M.
[1:35] SPEAKER_02: Siniza.
[1:36] SPEAKER_02: We're recording from New York City,
[1:38] SPEAKER_02: the center of a world empire that is dying,
[1:41] SPEAKER_02: but still pretty far from dead.
[1:44] SPEAKER_02: Now,
[1:44] SPEAKER_02: if you've listened to this show before,
[1:46] you'll notice that I had to switch that up a little bit because
[1:50] we are now in week
[1:52] SPEAKER_02: five of what could reasonably be described as the dumbest war in U.S.
[1:58] SPEAKER_02: history.
[1:59] SPEAKER_02: where,
[1:59] for reasons it is functionally impossible to articulate in
[2:03] terms of our own
[2:04] SPEAKER_02: national interests,
[2:05] we have directly caused the biggest energy crisis in world
[2:09] history and have
[2:10] jeopardized our ability to project power in perhaps the most
[2:14] strategically vital
[2:15] SPEAKER_02: region in the world.
[2:17] SPEAKER_02: So right now,
[2:18] SPEAKER_03: as of the recording of this intro on March 30th,
[2:21] SPEAKER_03: which is still a couple days after we recorded the episode,
[2:24] SPEAKER_03: the situation in the Strait of Hormuz has remained essentially the same.
[2:29] SPEAKER_03: The toll regime that was implemented several weeks ago is still in place.
[2:34] SPEAKER_03: Right now,
[2:34] SPEAKER_03: apparently $2 million are being demanded from ships passing through,
[2:39] SPEAKER_03: the ones that are approved to pass through.
[2:41] SPEAKER_03: Trump is saying that these ships that are passing through,
[2:43] SPEAKER_03: for example,
[2:44] SPEAKER_03: belonging to Thailand and Pakistan are gifts.
[2:47] SPEAKER_03: to the Trump administration.
[2:49] SPEAKER_03: There is not any kind of talk like that coming from the Iranian side.
[2:52] SPEAKER_03: They are just ships that have been approved,
[2:54] SPEAKER_03: nor are they American ships in any way,
[2:57] SPEAKER_03: shape or form.
[2:58] SPEAKER_03: Right now,
[2:59] SPEAKER_03: what is being suggested is less a complex or,
[3:03] SPEAKER_03: in Trump's words,
[3:04] SPEAKER_03: simple military maneuver to reopen the strait,
[3:06] SPEAKER_03: but a potential ground operation invasion on Khark Island,
[3:12] SPEAKER_03: which we did discuss in the episode.
[3:14] SPEAKER_03: Right now,
[3:14] SPEAKER_03: according to the Wall Street Journal,
[3:16] apparently 17,000 potential troops are being moved into the
[3:21] region for a potential
[3:22] SPEAKER_03: operation against the island,
[3:24] SPEAKER_03: or potentially to take all of the enriched uranium,
[3:28] SPEAKER_03: or as Trump says it,
[3:29] SPEAKER_03: nuclear dust?
[3:31] SPEAKER_03: I want to say, Dylan, have you heard this phrase?
[3:33] SPEAKER_03: I have, I have, yeah.
[3:34] SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
[3:34] nuclear dust in what would be the most complex special op in
[3:39] United States military
[3:40] SPEAKER_03: history.
[3:41] They're going to send in a nuclear Roomba to go in and hoover
[3:44] up all the nuclear dust.
[3:47] SPEAKER_03: You know what, man?
[3:49] SPEAKER_03: I'm thinking either he can seize the operation as that,
[3:52] SPEAKER_03: essentially,
[3:54] SPEAKER_03: or he thinks it's going to be like The Rock,
[3:56] SPEAKER_03: if you've seen that movie.
[3:57] SPEAKER_03: Have you seen this movie?
[4:00] SPEAKER_02: The Rock as in the actor?
[4:02] SPEAKER_03: No, the movie The Rock.
[4:03] SPEAKER_03: Just 10 second thing.
[4:06] SPEAKER_03: In that movie,
[4:07] Nicolas Cage and Sean Connery have to go to Alcatraz and
[4:10] evacuate nerve gas
[4:12] capsules from Alcatraz being held by Ed Harris and his gang of
[4:17] terrorists.
[4:18] SPEAKER_03: It's a delicate operation, but it's a very simple operation.
[4:21] It's also said that the curveball lies about the chemical
[4:24] weapons in Iraq were
[4:25] SPEAKER_03: taken from scenes in that movie.
[4:27] SPEAKER_03: I'm sure that that is also influencing it today.
[4:29] Nevertheless,
[4:31] all of these operations are much more difficult than Trump is
[4:36] conceiving of them.
[4:37] SPEAKER_03: And there are no current ways in which these three to four moves,
[4:41] SPEAKER_03: at least from my vantage point,
[4:43] SPEAKER_03: can be opened in a simple,
[4:46] SPEAKER_03: short amount of time.
[4:49] SPEAKER_02: That sounds like an incredible film.
[4:52] SPEAKER_02: Unfortunately, Em and I have been on a GWAT movie watching binge.
[4:57] SPEAKER_02: We have recently logged American Sniper.
[5:00] SPEAKER_02: And then last night we watched Jarhead,
[5:02] SPEAKER_02: which although is not an Iraq war film,
[5:05] SPEAKER_02: came out in that era as well.
[5:07] SPEAKER_02: So we will certainly be adding that to the queue.
[5:09] SPEAKER_02: Now,
[5:10] despite everything that we are hearing from Trump and the White
[5:13] House about all the
[5:15] winning that is happening and how they've destroyed the Iranian
[5:19] Navy and they've
[5:20] SPEAKER_02: completed all their objectives,
[5:21] SPEAKER_02: really this entire war has become about opening the Strait of Hormuz.
[5:26] SPEAKER_02: And why?
[5:27] Because they realize that they need to take away Iran's
[5:30] leverage in whatever
[5:32] negotiations will ultimately serve as an off-ramp to this
[5:36] clusterfuck of a
[5:37] SPEAKER_02: situation.
[5:38] SPEAKER_02: And that leverage is very real.
[5:39] SPEAKER_02: Through market manipulation, the U.S.
[5:41] SPEAKER_02: has been able to largely keep a lid on oil prices so far.
[5:45] SPEAKER_02: Those prices are creeping upwards,
[5:48] and the real material impacts of the straits closure are going
[5:51] to start percolating
[5:52] SPEAKER_02: through the global economy pretty much imminently.
[5:55] SPEAKER_02: And these impacts are not limited to oil.
[5:57] Hormuz is a choke point for chemicals vital to the world's
[6:00] fertilizer production
[6:01] SPEAKER_02: and many other key industrial inputs.
[6:04] So it's not an exaggeration to say that if the strait is not
[6:07] reopened soon,
[6:08] we are likely to have a worldwide economic recession or even
[6:12] possibly a depression.
[6:13] SPEAKER_03: Now,
[6:14] all of this is being treated by the American administration as
[6:18] if it was a complete
[6:19] SPEAKER_03: surprise that nobody knew this was going to happen,
[6:22] SPEAKER_03: that all of these things that Iran is doing were never prophesied.
[6:25] But all of this stuff has been threatened and the ramifications
[6:29] of it have been
[6:30] SPEAKER_03: predicted for years and years and years.
[6:34] SPEAKER_03: I mean, 2011.
[6:37] The rear admiral of the Iranian Navy was telling TV cameras
[6:40] that closing the Strait
[6:42] SPEAKER_03: of Hormuz would be like drinking water.
[6:45] SPEAKER_03: It would be so easy for the Iranian military to do.
[6:47] SPEAKER_03: And they have been repeating it through various military commanders,
[6:51] SPEAKER_03: political officials,
[6:53] SPEAKER_03: economic analysts,
[6:54] SPEAKER_03: that this was a real threat.
[6:56] that Iran could act upon if a war between them and the United
[7:01] States broke out.
[7:02] SPEAKER_03: And now it finally has, and America is left looking fairly flat-footed.
[7:08] SPEAKER_02: Now,
[7:09] SPEAKER_02: despite all of that,
[7:10] SPEAKER_02: in recent days,
[7:11] SPEAKER_02: the US plans have somehow both escalated and deteriorated.
[7:16] SPEAKER_02: Over the weekend,
[7:17] SPEAKER_02: Trump told the FT in an interview,
[7:20] SPEAKER_02: quote,
[7:20] SPEAKER_02: to be honest with you,
[7:22] SPEAKER_02: my favorite thing is to take the oil in Iran.
[7:25] SPEAKER_02: But some stupid people back in the US say, why are you doing that?
[7:30] SPEAKER_02: But they're stupid people.
[7:32] SPEAKER_02: Taking Iran's oil apparently means seizing Khark Island,
[7:36] SPEAKER_02: where much of it is exported from,
[7:37] SPEAKER_02: but it's unclear how long he would expect U.S.
[7:41] forces to hold the island under Iranian fire,
[7:44] and how exactly he imagines the U.S.
[7:46] SPEAKER_02: would, quote, take the oil, seeing as it is not produced on the island.
[7:50] SPEAKER_03: While they have been discussing all of this,
[7:53] SPEAKER_03: Iran is seeking to formalize the toll regime in the Strait of Hormuz.
[7:58] SPEAKER_03: They are demanding the implementation of that,
[8:01] SPEAKER_03: the permanent implementation,
[8:03] SPEAKER_03: I should say,
[8:04] SPEAKER_03: in whatever peace negotiations take place.
[8:06] And parliament just today passed some sort of framework to
[8:10] implement that.
[8:11] SPEAKER_03: Details to be revealed.
[8:12] SPEAKER_03: But one of the more interesting things is that they're including Oman,
[8:16] SPEAKER_03: whose territory also serves the Strait of Hormuz,
[8:18] SPEAKER_03: within that official toll regime.
[8:21] SPEAKER_03: They want to make this last, folks.
[8:23] SPEAKER_03: Yep.
[8:23] SPEAKER_02: And while the U.S.
[8:24] SPEAKER_02: is floundering and trying to spread blame and responsibility,
[8:28] I even saw a comment from the White House today where they are
[8:31] floating the idea of
[8:32] the Gulf states paying for the United States' portion of
[8:35] prosecuting this war.
[8:37] SPEAKER_02: Iran is steadily bolstering its strategic position.
[8:40] SPEAKER_02: which it very sensibly believes is improving by the day.
[8:43] And that's because every day that thousands of ships sit
[8:48] trapped on either side of
[8:49] SPEAKER_02: the strait,
[8:50] that giant hole smack dab in the middle of the world economy
[8:53] gets bigger and bigger
[8:55] SPEAKER_02: and bigger.
[8:55] And it's going to continue to do so because in between
[8:58] recording this episode and
[8:59] SPEAKER_03: recording this intro,
[9:01] SPEAKER_03: the Yemenis entered the war.
[9:03] They are reserving their extra steps of escalation for if the
[9:08] Gulf states enter
[9:09] SPEAKER_03: into the war or America launches a ground operation.
[9:12] But they have already begun flying missiles against Israeli
[9:16] territory and there is
[9:17] no indication that they are afraid of closing the Bab al-Mandeb
[9:21] should they be
[9:23] SPEAKER_03: requested to.
[9:24] SPEAKER_03: So,
[9:25] SPEAKER_03: interesting thing is,
[9:26] we already talked about this kind of blockading in our very
[9:28] first episode with the
[9:31] SPEAKER_03: illustrious Laleh Khalili,
[9:33] SPEAKER_03: and we are speaking to her again for the Strait of Hormuz this time.
[9:38] Laleh Khalili is a professor of golf studies at the University
[9:42] of Exeter and is the
[9:44] SPEAKER_03: author of a number of great books,
[9:47] SPEAKER_03: most recently Extractive Capitalism,
[9:49] SPEAKER_03: How Commodities...
[9:50] and cronyism drive the global economy and we were very happy to
[9:54] have her on again
[9:55] to speak with us before we get into the conversation we do have
[9:59] a pitch to you the
[10:00] listener turbulence is entirely listener funded we don't run
[10:04] ads we don't take
[10:05] money from institutions and that independence is the foundation
[10:09] of this project it
[10:10] SPEAKER_02: only exists because of you
[10:12] Because we're committed to providing you the in-depth history
[10:15] and present context
[10:16] SPEAKER_02: you need to make sense of each of these topics,
[10:19] SPEAKER_02: these episodes take a great deal of time and effort to produce,
[10:22] SPEAKER_02: from conception to research to editing.
[10:25] It's because we value your time as a listener and because we
[10:28] want to produce
[10:29] something lasting and useful that we think this level of effort
[10:32] is worth investing
[10:33] SPEAKER_02: in.
[10:34] SPEAKER_02: but that means we can't quite move as nimbly as we might otherwise like.
[10:37] SPEAKER_02: So in addition to our free public episodes,
[10:40] SPEAKER_02: we're also dropping weekly episodes behind the paywall.
[10:43] That's where we'll be able to respond to events as they unfold
[10:45] in closer to real
[10:46] SPEAKER_02: time,
[10:47] SPEAKER_02: providing our analysis,
[10:48] SPEAKER_02: following up on threads and conversations from prior episodes,
[10:51] SPEAKER_02: and drawing connections across the topics we've covered.
[10:54] SPEAKER_03: To do all this, we need your support.
[10:56] SPEAKER_03: A $5 monthly subscription will give you access to the bonus feed,
[11:00] SPEAKER_03: our Substack community,
[11:01] SPEAKER_03: and most importantly,
[11:03] you'll make it possible for us to keep doing this work
[11:05] independently week after
[11:07] SPEAKER_03: week.
[11:07] Subscribe today at turbulencepod.substack.com and follow along
[11:11] on Twitter and
[11:12] SPEAKER_03: Instagram at turbulence underscore pod.
[11:15] SPEAKER_03: We hope you'll join us.
[11:44] SPEAKER_03: We are speaking again with Dr. Laleh Khalili.
[11:48] SPEAKER_03: Welcome back.
[11:50] SPEAKER_01: Oh, it's so great to be back to talk to you guys again.
[11:53] SPEAKER_01: Well,
[11:53] SPEAKER_01: I wish it was under better circumstances,
[11:55] SPEAKER_01: but it is really lovely to see your faces,
[11:57] SPEAKER_01: which nobody else is going to see because we're on a podcast.
[12:00] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, we're so glad to have you back.
[12:02] SPEAKER_01: Thank you.
[12:03] So I think a lot of our listenership has been obviously seeing
[12:08] what's been
[12:09] SPEAKER_03: happening in the Strait of Hormuz.
[12:10] That seems to be all that the United States is talking about at
[12:14] the moment.
[12:14] But can you just lay out in as detailed a way as possible what
[12:18] precisely is
[12:19] SPEAKER_03: happening right now in the Strait?
[12:21] SPEAKER_03: What mechanisms is the Iranian military, what are they utilizing?
[12:26] SPEAKER_03: What is the current status of shipping?
[12:28] SPEAKER_03: What is happening in the Strait right now?
[12:30] SPEAKER_01: Okay, things are really fluid right now.
[12:32] SPEAKER_01: And actually, things have shifted a little bit today and yesterday.
[12:35] SPEAKER_01: I'll start pontificating as one does chronologically.
[12:38] SPEAKER_01: So the war starts at the end of February, right?
[12:41] SPEAKER_01: The US begins bombing, the US and Israel begin bombing Iran.
[12:44] And the immediate thing that begins happening is that Iranians
[12:48] begin to use drones,
[12:51] SPEAKER_01: missiles,
[12:52] SPEAKER_01: and threaten to mine the shipping lanes in the Hormuz Strait.
[12:57] And what they do is that they basically threaten that any ships
[13:01] going through,
[13:02] SPEAKER_01: they also have like these fast skiffs,
[13:04] SPEAKER_01: motorboats,
[13:05] SPEAKER_01: which the IRGC guys usually use to patrol the area.
[13:09] SPEAKER_01: And so they start, you know, going into the Hormuz then.
[13:12] SPEAKER_01: And...
[13:12] The immediate effect that that has in that moment is that
[13:17] although a lot of ships
[13:17] SPEAKER_01: were coming in to the Hormuz,
[13:20] SPEAKER_01: the ships leaving begin to actually slow down.
[13:22] SPEAKER_01: They stop leaving,
[13:23] SPEAKER_01: A,
[13:24] SPEAKER_01: because of the threat of the drones or being stopped by the IRGC boats,
[13:27] SPEAKER_01: but also because...
[13:29] SPEAKER_01: Immediately,
[13:30] SPEAKER_01: the insurance providers,
[13:31] SPEAKER_01: particularly those based at Lloyd's here in London,
[13:34] but also other maritime insurance providers in New York and in
[13:38] Hong Kong and,
[13:39] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[13:39] SPEAKER_01: the big maritime finance places,
[13:41] SPEAKER_01: they institute what is called a war risk premium,
[13:44] which is an addition to the insurance that ships have to have
[13:48] for various things.
[13:49] SPEAKER_01: So there's the hull insurance, which basically insures the ship itself.
[13:55] There's the cargo insurance,
[13:56] which insures the cargo,
[13:58] whatever that may be,
[13:58] oil or whatever.
[13:59] SPEAKER_01: And then there's like a series of other insurance,
[14:02] which also sort of indicates the fact that we don't hear as
[14:04] much about them.
[14:05] SPEAKER_01: It also indicates the value that the industry places.
[14:08] So including sort of liability insurance for the life of the
[14:11] seafarers on there.
[14:12] We know about the Holland cargo insurance and the premiums on
[14:15] those going up,
[14:16] SPEAKER_01: but we don't hear much about life insurance,
[14:18] SPEAKER_01: for example,
[14:18] on a poor Indian or Filipino seafarer who's going to be on one
[14:21] of these ships
[14:22] SPEAKER_01: that's going to be hit.
[14:23] SPEAKER_01: So the war risk premium immediately goes into effect.
[14:26] SPEAKER_01: And obviously, the insurance rates are different.
[14:28] SPEAKER_01: They're different for different routes.
[14:29] SPEAKER_01: They're different for different shipping companies.
[14:31] SPEAKER_01: They're different for the kind of flag a ship flies under because,
[14:35] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[14:35] SPEAKER_01: the inspection regimes for different flags are different.
[14:38] SPEAKER_01: Some are much stricter inspection regimes.
[14:41] SPEAKER_01: Some are not.
[14:41] So there is a whole range of different insurance rates that are
[14:44] instituted based
[14:45] SPEAKER_01: on,
[14:46] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[14:46] SPEAKER_01: they're modeled on lots of different factors.
[14:48] SPEAKER_01: But nevertheless,
[14:49] the war risk premium immediately goes up for all of the ships
[14:53] that are going
[14:54] SPEAKER_01: through the Strait of Hormuz to varying degrees.
[14:57] So if you're going in and you're empty because you're a tanker
[15:00] and you're going in
[15:01] and you're empty and you're going to pick up some oil or
[15:03] natural gas or whatever...
[15:04] If you're empty,
[15:05] obviously you have this haul insurance,
[15:06] which is significant.
[15:07] SPEAKER_01: But if you've got cargo on, then your cargo insurance also goes up.
[15:11] And these amounts going up are more or less immediate because
[15:15] obviously the
[15:15] insurance companies want to be able to extract what they need
[15:17] to out of that.
[15:18] And so this affects obviously shipping companies lifting oil or
[15:23] lifting other
[15:24] SPEAKER_01: products,
[15:24] which I'm also going to come to because it's not just oil and
[15:27] gas that is affected,
[15:28] SPEAKER_01: but also some of the other products,
[15:29] SPEAKER_01: which are also really important to
[15:32] SPEAKER_01: But as soon as the insurance goes up,
[15:34] SPEAKER_01: of course,
[15:35] SPEAKER_01: the shipping companies say,
[15:36] SPEAKER_01: we're not going to go and lift oil.
[15:38] SPEAKER_01: It's just not going to happen.
[15:39] SPEAKER_01: And this element is also introduced into the mix.
[15:44] SPEAKER_01: And so the World Trade Organization online site has a Hormuz tracker.
[15:48] SPEAKER_01: And if you go and look at this Hormuz tracker online,
[15:51] SPEAKER_01: what you'll find is that you have,
[15:53] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[15:54] SPEAKER_01: a regular flow of ships,
[15:56] SPEAKER_01: a hundred or so,
[15:57] SPEAKER_01: like daily and suddenly or weekly or whatever it is.
[16:00] SPEAKER_01: whatever number it is,
[16:01] and the numbers again fluctuate depending on seasons and how
[16:04] much oil people need
[16:05] SPEAKER_01: and blah,
[16:06] SPEAKER_01: blah,
[16:06] SPEAKER_01: blah,
[16:06] SPEAKER_01: blah.
[16:06] But suddenly you have a complete goes off a cliff and just
[16:11] basically all shipping
[16:12] SPEAKER_01: stops at the end of February.
[16:13] Part of this,
[16:14] as I said,
[16:14] is obviously Iranians begins attacking some ships.
[16:18] SPEAKER_01: They set some tankers on fire.
[16:19] But part of it also is that they start hitting oil terminals or
[16:24] various other kinds
[16:25] SPEAKER_01: of logistics ports in the region with short range,
[16:29] SPEAKER_01: medium range
[16:30] SPEAKER_01: We didn't know about their sort of longer range ballistic missiles,
[16:34] SPEAKER_01: but primarily really with drones.
[16:36] And their drones are cheap to make and they're becoming more
[16:39] precise over time.
[16:41] So from what I've been reading from people that understand
[16:44] these kinds of things,
[16:44] the drones in the 12-day war of 2025 were much less precise
[16:50] than the drones of this
[16:51] SPEAKER_01: year.
[16:51] SPEAKER_01: And
[16:51] SPEAKER_01: So there's obviously been an improvement in technology,
[16:55] SPEAKER_01: certainly in targeting technology,
[16:56] or perhaps in the intelligence that guides the drones in the
[17:00] seven or eight months
[17:01] SPEAKER_01: since the previous round of attacks.
[17:03] SPEAKER_01: So you've got all of this coming together,
[17:05] SPEAKER_01: the Iranians threatening to attack,
[17:07] SPEAKER_01: there being skiffs in the water,
[17:11] SPEAKER_01: intercepting ships,
[17:12] SPEAKER_01: there being attacks against
[17:14] SPEAKER_01: oil terminals,
[17:15] which will definitely stop a captain of a ship who's
[17:18] responsible for the lives of
[17:19] all of the seafarers on the ship from going to that terminal if
[17:22] they think that
[17:23] SPEAKER_01: they're going to be hit.
[17:24] SPEAKER_01: But very significantly,
[17:25] and I think this is one of the cleverest things about the
[17:28] strategy chosen here,
[17:29] SPEAKER_01: is that the Iranian strategy was to basically turn the global capitalist
[17:35] SPEAKER_01: circulatory system,
[17:37] SPEAKER_01: the logistics web,
[17:39] SPEAKER_01: against itself.
[17:40] just as the Houthis did when they were trying to blockade the
[17:43] Red Sea on behalf of
[17:44] SPEAKER_01: Palestinians.
[17:45] SPEAKER_01: Okay, now why Hormuz?
[17:47] SPEAKER_01: Hormuz is an interesting choke point.
[17:49] It is basically where the Persian slash Arabian Gulf on the
[17:53] west meets the Gulf of
[17:55] SPEAKER_01: Oman on the east.
[17:57] SPEAKER_01: And it's about 35 miles wide,
[18:00] SPEAKER_01: and about 30% of the world's oil goes through the Strait of Hormuz.
[18:06] SPEAKER_01: Not all of it goes through the Strait of Hormuz, obviously.
[18:08] Not even all the oil that is produced around the Gulf goes
[18:12] through the Strait of Hormuz.
[18:13] SPEAKER_01: Some goes through pipelines, which I'll also talk about in a minute.
[18:15] And some of it will go through other ports,
[18:18] which are outside of the Gulf.
[18:20] SPEAKER_01: And I'll talk about that in a minute as well.
[18:21] But it is a 35 mile wide strait and the deeper channels
[18:27] actually lie closer to the
[18:29] SPEAKER_01: Iranian border.
[18:31] SPEAKER_01: On the southern side,
[18:32] SPEAKER_01: also,
[18:33] SPEAKER_01: it is a little sliver of land that actually doesn't belong to the Emirat.
[18:39] SPEAKER_01: which was what you would have imagined being,
[18:41] SPEAKER_01: but it's actually an extension of Oman called Musandam Peninsula,
[18:45] SPEAKER_01: which is one of the most beautiful places on earth.
[18:48] SPEAKER_01: It's basically,
[18:48] SPEAKER_01: imagine some incredibly dramatic wind and water eroded fjords,
[18:55] SPEAKER_01: but very rocky and brown on just like turquoise green water.
[18:58] And the Musendam Peninsula,
[19:00] as I said,
[19:00] it's very rocky,
[19:01] it's very mountainous.
[19:02] It didn't actually have roads that could get to it until 30,
[19:05] 40 years ago.
[19:06] SPEAKER_01: Most people, even now, it's kind of difficult to get there by road.
[19:09] SPEAKER_01: You have to sort of take a boat into it.
[19:11] SPEAKER_01: There's not much on the Musendam Peninsula.
[19:13] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[19:13] SPEAKER_01: yeah,
[19:13] SPEAKER_01: there is like some military bases and things,
[19:16] SPEAKER_01: but it's really a difficult place to project power from.
[19:18] And so really Iran controls because Iran sits on the northern
[19:22] edge and there's also
[19:23] SPEAKER_01: the long Qashmai land,
[19:25] SPEAKER_01: which is right there at just alongside on the Gulf side of the strait.
[19:29] SPEAKER_01: Basically,
[19:30] that means that Iran controls that region because of its
[19:33] domination of Qashm and
[19:35] SPEAKER_01: because of the depth of the sea there.
[19:37] SPEAKER_01: So Iranian control over that,
[19:40] SPEAKER_01: which has been,
[19:40] SPEAKER_01: I would say they have never asserted it in this way,
[19:43] except for a short period between 84 and 88 during the
[19:47] Iran-Iraq war in what was
[19:49] SPEAKER_01: called the tanker wars,
[19:50] SPEAKER_01: which you can also ask me about.
[19:51] And it has never really asserted this power before,
[19:54] but it is now really asking for control.
[19:57] SPEAKER_01: Now,
[19:57] SPEAKER_01: when I started pontificating,
[19:59] I began by saying that things are fluid and things have changed
[20:03] in the last few
[20:04] SPEAKER_01: days.
[20:05] SPEAKER_01: So Iran began to set a series of conditions.
[20:09] SPEAKER_01: And the news of this was coming from various sources.
[20:12] SPEAKER_01: It wasn't necessarily official.
[20:13] SPEAKER_01: But in the last couple of days, it has been made official.
[20:16] SPEAKER_01: So some of the conditions that Iranians were putting on the shipping was,
[20:20] SPEAKER_01: number one,
[20:21] that the ships could not be carrying oil or touching Israel or
[20:26] doing stuff for the
[20:27] SPEAKER_01: U.S.,
[20:27] SPEAKER_01: So that was the first condition.
[20:29] The second thing that eventually came out was that maybe ships
[20:32] that were carrying
[20:33] SPEAKER_01: oil for China could get through.
[20:35] SPEAKER_01: The third thing that they said was that,
[20:38] SPEAKER_01: well,
[20:38] they could then enter bilateral negotiations with whichever
[20:41] state they wanted to.
[20:43] SPEAKER_01: And I think yesterday or the day before yesterday,
[20:45] SPEAKER_01: they let a few Indian tankers,
[20:47] which had already lifted oil before and had been sitting in the
[20:51] Gulf for two,
[20:52] SPEAKER_01: three weeks,
[20:52] SPEAKER_01: they let them go through because the Indian government entered a set of
[20:56] SPEAKER_01: negotiations with Iran.
[20:57] SPEAKER_01: And then I saw today,
[20:58] SPEAKER_01: this morning,
[20:59] SPEAKER_01: that Spain has also now won a waiver on its ships going through.
[21:04] So there's a particular element emerging around what sorts of
[21:08] conditions Iran is putting.
[21:10] SPEAKER_01: At some point,
[21:10] Iran was saying that it will allow any ship that is trading in
[21:14] petroyuans rather
[21:15] SPEAKER_01: than petrodollars to go through.
[21:17] SPEAKER_01: I don't know how they can enforce that.
[21:19] SPEAKER_01: I don't know how they can actually figure that out.
[21:20] But it's a very interesting way to sort of acknowledge the
[21:24] power of the US rests
[21:26] SPEAKER_01: not only on its control of oil,
[21:29] SPEAKER_01: not just for itself,
[21:30] SPEAKER_01: but also for the control of its web of trade around the world,
[21:34] SPEAKER_01: but also on the currency in which oil and other goods are traded.
[21:38] SPEAKER_01: So there's been a lot of different events happening,
[21:40] SPEAKER_01: but this is basically the lay of the land in the last three weeks.
[21:44] SPEAKER_01: Now, ask me any questions you want about the details of this.
[21:47] SPEAKER_03: You're saying a lot of things that are accurate,
[21:49] SPEAKER_03: but I personally listen a lot to the White House press secretary.
[21:54] And she has been talking a lot about the fact that the Iranian
[21:58] Navy has been destroyed.
[22:01] SPEAKER_03: Previous numbers, there were 20 vessels sunk, 50 vessels sunk.
[22:04] SPEAKER_03: Just this morning, 120 vessels sunk.
[22:06] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[22:08] SPEAKER_03: That was a number that they said.
[22:09] SPEAKER_03: I've been told the Iranian Navy has been destroyed.
[22:13] SPEAKER_03: So has the American people.
[22:15] SPEAKER_03: Does that decimation actually affect any of this?
[22:19] SPEAKER_01: The point of the matter is that the U.S.
[22:22] SPEAKER_01: press secretary or indeed anybody actually representing the U.S.
[22:25] SPEAKER_01: government speaking right now is probably lying.
[22:28] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[22:29] SPEAKER_01: we know that the president himself,
[22:31] SPEAKER_01: whenever he talks about anything,
[22:33] SPEAKER_01: he is trying to move the markets.
[22:35] I actually learned a term from Qalibov,
[22:38] Iran's Qalibov,
[22:38] called jawboning.
[22:40] It's apparently a term that is used to indicate people who try
[22:43] to move the market
[22:45] SPEAKER_01: by,
[22:45] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[22:45] SPEAKER_01: saying something on social media.
[22:48] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[22:48] SPEAKER_01: the greatest jawboner of all,
[22:50] SPEAKER_01: that sounds actually dirtier than I meant to,
[22:53] SPEAKER_01: but I think it is right,
[22:55] SPEAKER_01: is,
[22:55] SPEAKER_01: of course,
[22:55] SPEAKER_01: Elon Musk.
[22:56] SPEAKER_01: So because Elon Musk used to,
[22:58] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[22:59] cause fluctuations in the price of whatever company he owned by
[23:03] going on Twitter
[23:03] SPEAKER_01: and saying shit.
[23:04] SPEAKER_01: And I think that Trump does the same.
[23:06] SPEAKER_01: So he goes on Twitter and he announces that something is going to happen.
[23:12] SPEAKER_01: And then like 15 minutes before his announcement,
[23:15] SPEAKER_01: obviously somebody attached to him that has insider knowledge,
[23:17] places really large trades in oil futures and moves the market
[23:22] in particular ways.
[23:23] SPEAKER_01: And it's become a pattern where on Fridays,
[23:27] SPEAKER_01: Trump announces something really horrific is going to happen.
[23:30] SPEAKER_01: And then on Monday, two hours before the market opens, he walks it back.
[23:35] And so there is a particular way in which he is basically being
[23:39] the kind of con man
[23:41] SPEAKER_01: that tries to move the market.
[23:42] So let's begin with the premise that nothing that comes out of
[23:45] any American mouth
[23:46] SPEAKER_01: is actually to be relied on,
[23:48] SPEAKER_01: basically.
[23:49] SPEAKER_01: American official mouth is to be relied on.
[23:51] SPEAKER_01: I would agree on it.
[23:51] SPEAKER_01: But the second thing is,
[23:52] SPEAKER_01: they have,
[23:53] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[23:54] SPEAKER_01: in the last three weeks,
[23:55] the number of times that they have said they have destroyed
[23:58] ex-Iranian capability,
[24:01] SPEAKER_01: they've destroyed Iran's missile system,
[24:03] SPEAKER_01: they've destroyed Iran's missile reserves,
[24:06] SPEAKER_01: they've destroyed Iran's navy.
[24:09] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[24:10] SPEAKER_01: at this rate,
[24:11] SPEAKER_01: they have destroyed 25,000% of Iran's military,
[24:15] SPEAKER_01: and yet Iran seems to be still functioning.
[24:17] SPEAKER_01: So I'm not 100% sure who or what they're talking about.
[24:22] SPEAKER_01: But let's also mention that the biggest attack on the Iranian Navy was,
[24:28] SPEAKER_01: of course,
[24:29] SPEAKER_01: a completely illegal attack on an Iranian Navy ship,
[24:33] SPEAKER_01: which was near Sri Lanka in international waters,
[24:36] which had not had any warning given it and which was torpedoed
[24:40] by an American
[24:41] SPEAKER_01: submarine.
[24:41] SPEAKER_01: And then apparently they also did double tapping there too,
[24:44] where they also killed the people that had been clinging on for
[24:48] dear life,
[24:48] SPEAKER_01: although some were rescued and are apparently being held in Sri Lanka.
[24:52] SPEAKER_01: That is probably the biggest attack on the Iranian Navy.
[24:54] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, they probably have blown a bunch of IRGC ships out of the water.
[24:59] Yes,
[24:59] I don't have any doubt that they have bombed a bunch of Iranian
[25:02] ports.
[25:02] We're also,
[25:03] of course,
[25:03] not getting a lot of information what is coming out of Iran.
[25:06] SPEAKER_01: So it's not we don't really know.
[25:08] SPEAKER_01: And I certainly don't rely on the U.S.
[25:11] SPEAKER_01: government announcements or the CENTCOM or anybody else for this.
[25:14] SPEAKER_01: We also know that the U.S.
[25:16] has also asked for severe restrictions on commercial satellite
[25:21] imagery that is being provided.
[25:23] We have discovered that basically the best kind of commercial
[25:27] satellite imagery,
[25:28] SPEAKER_01: which the US provided,
[25:30] SPEAKER_01: which had extremely detailed,
[25:32] SPEAKER_01: very close information,
[25:33] SPEAKER_01: imagery provided is basically unavailable now.
[25:36] And so most people have to either rely on satellite imagery
[25:39] that Iranians have
[25:40] SPEAKER_01: provided,
[25:41] SPEAKER_01: which yesterday I was reading some,
[25:43] SPEAKER_01: I think,
[25:44] some European analysts saying that they're probably getting
[25:46] these images from
[25:48] SPEAKER_01: China,
[25:49] SPEAKER_01: or on Copernicus,
[25:50] SPEAKER_01: which has very low resolution.
[25:52] SPEAKER_01: And so it's very difficult to see actually what has happened.
[25:54] SPEAKER_01: So, no, I don't think that the Iranian Navy has been destroyed.
[25:58] SPEAKER_01: They probably have destroyed or decimated is probably a better word.
[26:01] They've probably destroyed about 10 percent or 12 percent or
[26:04] however many percent of it.
[26:05] But the fact is that Iran doesn't have to have an aircraft
[26:09] carrier to do what it does.
[26:11] SPEAKER_01: All it has to have is a bunch of really cheap-ass drones that it goes up,
[26:15] SPEAKER_01: and it just has to be a credible threat.
[26:17] SPEAKER_01: And then the capitalist market does its job.
[26:21] A credible threat to a big old tanker going through is going to
[26:26] mean really high
[26:27] SPEAKER_01: insurance,
[26:28] SPEAKER_01: and the shipping companies are going to say,
[26:30] SPEAKER_01: no way,
[26:30] SPEAKER_01: Jose.
[26:31] SPEAKER_02: So, okay, I have two questions about this.
[26:32] SPEAKER_02: One is a small question just to follow up on something you said earlier,
[26:35] SPEAKER_02: and then a kind of more abstract question.
[26:37] But the small one is you talked about the depth of the
[26:40] territorial waters of Iran
[26:42] SPEAKER_02: and how it's deeper on the Iranian side of the strait.
[26:45] SPEAKER_02: Can you just explain for people...
[26:47] SPEAKER_02: how big these oil tankers are.
[26:49] SPEAKER_02: Because you talked about hundreds getting through a day.
[26:52] That actually doesn't sound like very much to carry 20% of the
[26:55] world's energy supplies.
[26:57] SPEAKER_02: So I'm curious if you can just explain for people,
[27:00] SPEAKER_02: what are we talking about when we're talking about an oil tanker?
[27:03] SPEAKER_02: Because it does seem like that plays into the broader calculus, right?
[27:08] If they have to go through very deep waters and also you just
[27:11] have to hit one to do
[27:13] SPEAKER_02: a sizable impact to the market.
[27:14] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[27:15] So they're very large crude carriers,
[27:18] VLCCs,
[27:19] and ultra large crude carriers.
[27:21] SPEAKER_01: The largest crude carrier ever was built in the 1970s and was scrapped,
[27:26] SPEAKER_01: I think,
[27:27] SPEAKER_01: in the 1980s or 90s.
[27:28] SPEAKER_01: And it has not yet been surpassed.
[27:30] SPEAKER_01: I think it was 460 meters long.
[27:32] SPEAKER_01: So that would be about 1300 feet long.
[27:36] SPEAKER_01: The biggest ones now are somewhere between 300 and 400,
[27:40] SPEAKER_01: leaning closer to 400 meters long,
[27:43] SPEAKER_01: which means,
[27:44] SPEAKER_01: again,
[27:44] SPEAKER_01: around,
[27:44] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[27:45] SPEAKER_01: 12,
[27:45] SPEAKER_01: 1300,
[27:45] which is basically these ships are as long or longer than if
[27:50] the Empire State
[27:51] SPEAKER_01: Building was lying down on its side.
[27:53] SPEAKER_01: So they're really, really long.
[27:57] SPEAKER_01: And then if they are laden or not laden,
[28:00] SPEAKER_01: if they have a cargo or they're in ballast,
[28:04] SPEAKER_01: when they're in ballast means they don't have cargo,
[28:06] SPEAKER_01: the depth of the ship also changes.
[28:09] SPEAKER_01: And as the ships are getting bigger and bigger,
[28:12] SPEAKER_01: the depth of the ship,
[28:14] SPEAKER_01: or what is called the draft,
[28:16] SPEAKER_01: also gets deeper and can be 20,
[28:19] SPEAKER_01: 22 meters,
[28:20] SPEAKER_01: which is about 60,
[28:22] SPEAKER_01: 70 feet deep.
[28:24] SPEAKER_01: The problem is that it's not just that you worry about this depth.
[28:29] SPEAKER_01: It's also that over on this,
[28:32] SPEAKER_01: actually,
[28:33] SPEAKER_01: both the Persian Gulf,
[28:34] SPEAKER_01: Persian Arabian Gulf and Gulf of Oman,
[28:37] SPEAKER_01: But also the Red Sea have very large reefs,
[28:42] quite damaging coral reefs along one shore or the other in
[28:45] different places,
[28:47] SPEAKER_01: number one.
[28:47] SPEAKER_01: And number two,
[28:48] SPEAKER_01: the Gulf,
[28:50] SPEAKER_01: the Persian slash Arabian Gulf,
[28:51] SPEAKER_01: it's a very shallow sea in relative to the other.
[28:55] Like the Red Sea is really,
[28:56] really deep because it's basically sitting on a continental
[28:58] divide.
[28:59] SPEAKER_01: But the Gulf is actually quite shallow.
[29:01] SPEAKER_01: And indeed,
[29:02] SPEAKER_01: in order for ships to come in,
[29:03] SPEAKER_01: for example,
[29:04] SPEAKER_01: to Jabal Ali,
[29:04] SPEAKER_01: which is the biggest port in the Middle East,
[29:07] they have to constantly dredge the channel at which it comes
[29:10] because there are
[29:10] SPEAKER_01: parts of it where,
[29:11] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[29:11] SPEAKER_01: there are ships coming in which have 20 meter drafts,
[29:15] but there are parts of the Gulf that are only about seven or
[29:17] eight meters.
[29:18] SPEAKER_01: So a ship can very easily ground or it can hit reefs or whatever.
[29:22] And so I think this really matters in terms of how many ships
[29:25] can come through.
[29:26] SPEAKER_01: That's the first thing.
[29:27] SPEAKER_01: The second thing is, remember that ships are going in both directions.
[29:30] SPEAKER_01: So you have a two-way traffic.
[29:32] SPEAKER_01: And often ships have to convoy in order not to,
[29:35] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[29:35] SPEAKER_01: it's not like a highway where you try to pass each other.
[29:38] SPEAKER_01: There are multiple channels also.
[29:41] SPEAKER_01: If you look at the Gulf, in the center of it,
[29:44] SPEAKER_01: not geographic center,
[29:45] SPEAKER_01: but in the deepest part of it,
[29:47] SPEAKER_01: it's basically two lanes of the biggest ships going in two directions.
[29:51] There are slightly shallower channels supporting that,
[29:54] which smaller ships can go through.
[29:56] SPEAKER_01: And then there's coastal sort of travel along that.
[30:00] SPEAKER_01: But ships do cross one another.
[30:02] And so you have to be really super careful because of the heavy
[30:06] traffic going through there.
[30:07] SPEAKER_01: I mean, it's one of the highest traffic areas
[30:10] The Strait of Malacca in Southeast Asia is actually probably
[30:15] the only other place
[30:16] that's busier than the Gulf in terms of the amount of traffic
[30:20] that goes through it.
[30:21] And so I think that's part of the reason why Iran can also
[30:25] control it is because of
[30:28] SPEAKER_01: the way that these ships are really big.
[30:30] SPEAKER_01: They have to convoy to go through,
[30:32] SPEAKER_01: or at least they have to order themselves in order to go through,
[30:36] SPEAKER_01: because
[30:36] There is traffic,
[30:37] basically,
[30:38] and there are traffic rules around ships going.
[30:40] SPEAKER_01: They can't just willy-nilly go where they want to.
[30:43] They usually follow particular established routes and they have
[30:47] to inform as a ship
[30:49] SPEAKER_01: goes through a really narrow space,
[30:51] SPEAKER_01: whatever that narrow space might be,
[30:53] SPEAKER_01: it has to inform the port authorities on both sides of that narrow space,
[30:58] SPEAKER_01: if it's the Hormuz Strait or Bab al-Mandab or whatever,
[31:00] SPEAKER_01: to
[31:00] SPEAKER_01: It has to inform both sides to let them know that it is going through,
[31:05] SPEAKER_01: because that's kind of a little bit like air traffic control,
[31:07] SPEAKER_01: where they have also a sense.
[31:09] SPEAKER_01: And then there's also questions of sovereign waters and things like that.
[31:12] SPEAKER_01: But it's a very complex situation.
[31:14] And when you have a strait that is as narrow as this is,
[31:18] 35 miles is really not that wide.
[31:21] SPEAKER_01: It obviously gives a certain amount of leverage to Iran,
[31:24] SPEAKER_01: which has the ability to control these places with its cheapy skiffs,
[31:29] SPEAKER_01: with its cheapy
[31:30] SPEAKER_01: drones.
[31:31] SPEAKER_01: It doesn't have to have,
[31:32] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[31:33] massive warships in order to be able to control the strait and
[31:36] the traffic through
[31:37] SPEAKER_01: it.
[31:38] So I want to get into in a little bit even more specific detail
[31:41] how it is using its
[31:42] SPEAKER_02: power to control the strait.
[31:44] SPEAKER_02: Because before the war,
[31:46] I think there had long been speculation that in the event of
[31:49] some broader conflict,
[31:51] SPEAKER_02: Iran could always play this card,
[31:53] they could always close the strait and wreak havoc upon the
[31:56] global economy.
[31:57] SPEAKER_02: But at least as I was privy to this discourse,
[32:00] SPEAKER_02: it was always understood to be a kind of last resort.
[32:03] Because it was assumed that that would be somewhat
[32:06] self-destructive insofar as Iran
[32:08] SPEAKER_02: is also exporting oil.
[32:10] SPEAKER_02: But that speculation,
[32:11] SPEAKER_02: I don't know,
[32:12] SPEAKER_02: like ever really reached the kind of specifics,
[32:15] SPEAKER_02: the mechanics of how it would work.
[32:17] SPEAKER_02: Because in practice,
[32:18] it actually seems a lot more sophisticated than just pulling
[32:22] down on some giant
[32:23] SPEAKER_02: on-off switch and closing the strait.
[32:25] And in fact,
[32:26] the Iranians themselves are not even insisting that it's
[32:29] closed.
[32:30] SPEAKER_02: They're saying that the strait is open.
[32:32] SPEAKER_02: And they're pointing to things like that you mentioned that,
[32:34] SPEAKER_02: you know,
[32:35] SPEAKER_02: okay,
[32:35] SPEAKER_02: there's,
[32:35] SPEAKER_02: you know,
[32:36] SPEAKER_02: war risk premium insurance.
[32:38] SPEAKER_02: And,
[32:38] SPEAKER_02: you know,
[32:38] SPEAKER_02: I think recently,
[32:39] SPEAKER_02: even the foreign ministry put out this explanatory statement that says,
[32:43] SPEAKER_02: non aggressing ships are allowed to pass through,
[32:46] SPEAKER_02: they just have to follow certain protocols.
[32:50] SPEAKER_02: And so I don't know, to
[32:52] SPEAKER_02: To my mind,
[32:53] it seems like what they're doing is not so much closing the
[32:57] strait entirely,
[32:58] SPEAKER_02: but using the strait to modulate different pressures.
[33:02] SPEAKER_02: And clearly, one of the pressures is their own export situation.
[33:06] Another pressure is on the global economy and their ability to
[33:11] modulate the overall
[33:12] SPEAKER_02: price of oil as an international commodity.
[33:14] And then also it seems like they're using it to cultivate
[33:18] relationships with third
[33:19] SPEAKER_02: parties,
[33:20] SPEAKER_02: with other countries.
[33:21] SPEAKER_02: And yeah,
[33:22] SPEAKER_02: so I wonder if you could just talk a little bit about those pressures,
[33:25] SPEAKER_02: like where are they going in different directions?
[33:28] SPEAKER_01: That's a really brilliant question.
[33:30] SPEAKER_01: And I think it's actually quite analytically sound as well.
[33:32] So let's start with the last one,
[33:34] because that's really kind of the most straightforward one.
[33:36] Because the very fact that the Iranians are making a difference
[33:39] between what kind
[33:40] of ships can go through is indicative of the fact that they're
[33:43] using it as a
[33:44] SPEAKER_01: diplomatic tool,
[33:45] SPEAKER_01: that they are basically distinguishing between the wheat and the chaff,
[33:48] SPEAKER_01: their enemies and their allies.
[33:50] SPEAKER_01: or even at least neutral powers,
[33:51] SPEAKER_01: because very obviously India is not necessarily an Iranian ally,
[33:55] SPEAKER_01: given its very close relationships with both Amarat and Israel.
[33:59] But nevertheless,
[33:59] Iran is actually being really reasonable in its relationship
[34:03] with India.
[34:04] And I think that that element of instituting or deepening the
[34:09] relations that it has
[34:10] SPEAKER_01: with these different states is
[34:11] SPEAKER_01: But also in the old school Marxist kind of thing,
[34:14] SPEAKER_01: intensifying,
[34:16] deepening the contradictions that exist or deepening the
[34:18] fissures that exist in the
[34:20] SPEAKER_01: global north has been really fascinating to see.
[34:23] So I think that's certainly one way that Iran is using the
[34:27] Strait of Hormuz in a
[34:28] SPEAKER_01: way that doesn't necessarily mesh with the way that the US press or the
[34:32] SPEAKER_01: administration in the US are calling it a closure.
[34:34] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[34:35] The second thing that has been really interesting is the extent
[34:38] to which Iran is
[34:40] SPEAKER_01: affecting markets.
[34:41] SPEAKER_01: So this has been interesting to me because not only,
[34:45] SPEAKER_01: of course,
[34:45] SPEAKER_01: there's a question of the war risk premium insurance,
[34:48] SPEAKER_01: but there's also the incredibly fascinating thing that...
[34:52] Scott Besant comes on some television show and talks about how
[34:58] he's jujitsu-ing
[34:59] SPEAKER_01: Iranians because although they're fighting with Iran,
[35:02] SPEAKER_01: they have let Iranians sell their oil in order to lower the price of oil,
[35:07] SPEAKER_01: which is kind of...
[35:09] SPEAKER_01: Interesting.
[35:10] SPEAKER_01: You know,
[35:11] SPEAKER_01: it's like the sanctions weapon,
[35:14] SPEAKER_01: which was used against both Russian oil and Iranian oil,
[35:18] SPEAKER_01: is basically being waived,
[35:21] SPEAKER_01: being set aside for the purposes of the oil prices.
[35:24] SPEAKER_01: Because, of course, the United States is a car culture.
[35:27] SPEAKER_01: And my husband,
[35:28] SPEAKER_01: who's from the US,
[35:29] SPEAKER_01: showed me a picture today of crazy prices at the pumps in California,
[35:33] SPEAKER_01: $10 a gallon or something.
[35:35] SPEAKER_01: And so, I mean, that's crazy.
[35:36] That is,
[35:37] you know,
[35:38] it affects,
[35:38] obviously,
[35:39] politics in the US almost more than anything else.
[35:41] SPEAKER_01: It has also an interesting effect in that because the U.S.
[35:45] SPEAKER_01: has waived some sanctions on Russian oil,
[35:48] I heard that Ukrainians are actually now bombing the Baltic oil
[35:52] terminals,
[35:52] SPEAKER_01: Russia's Baltic oil terminals,
[35:54] SPEAKER_01: because I think they're pissed off that this source of income,
[35:57] SPEAKER_01: this bigot has been opened for Russia.
[35:59] And so they're trying to sort of intervene in this in this
[36:01] particular way.
[36:02] SPEAKER_01: So this is having like secondary, tertiary effects beyond the Gulf.
[36:06] And of course,
[36:06] you know,
[36:07] as I said,
[36:07] the jujitsu is who's playing jujitsu here.
[36:10] If Iranians have actually managed to get sanctions waivers,
[36:13] that's fascinating.
[36:14] It also has other tertiary effects,
[36:16] which are actually quite fascinating to me.
[36:18] Two of the things that the administration has waived
[36:21] domestically in response to
[36:23] SPEAKER_01: the potential rise in the price of oil has been,
[36:26] SPEAKER_01: one,
[36:26] SPEAKER_01: a waiver of the Jones Act.
[36:29] SPEAKER_01: The Jones Act is a law,
[36:32] SPEAKER_01: a hundred and something years old,
[36:34] SPEAKER_01: that requires that any ships that go between two U.S.
[36:37] SPEAKER_01: ports, fly a U.S.
[36:38] SPEAKER_01: flag, are manufactured, and the ship itself was manufactured in the U.S.
[36:42] SPEAKER_01: and is operated by U.S.
[36:44] SPEAKER_01: seafarers.
[36:45] And they are waiving this in order to allow for more ships to
[36:49] arrive in the United States.
[36:51] SPEAKER_01: The second thing that the U.S.
[36:52] SPEAKER_01: has waived is rules on smog.
[36:55] SPEAKER_01: So if you guys live in a city that has a lot of or has a history of smog,
[36:59] SPEAKER_01: Los Angeles,
[37:00] SPEAKER_01: New York,
[37:01] SPEAKER_01: whatever,
[37:01] SPEAKER_01: good luck,
[37:02] SPEAKER_01: guys,
[37:02] SPEAKER_01: because for the next few weeks,
[37:04] SPEAKER_01: months,
[37:05] SPEAKER_01: however long this lasts,
[37:06] SPEAKER_01: the rules on smog have been waived and really crappy,
[37:09] SPEAKER_01: terrible car fuels,
[37:11] car and other vehicle fuels are going to be all over in the air
[37:15] and there's not
[37:15] SPEAKER_01: going to be any limitations placed on that.
[37:17] SPEAKER_01: So that's another tertiary effect.
[37:18] SPEAKER_01: But then going to the question of, is this closure foreseen or not?
[37:25] So this is where I wanted to sort of roll back a little bit to
[37:29] the 1980s and talk
[37:30] SPEAKER_01: about the tanker wars,
[37:32] because I think that the Iranians had an experience of how this
[37:35] might affect Iran,
[37:37] SPEAKER_01: how such a war might affect Iran from the Iran-Iraq war.
[37:41] In 1984,
[37:42] when Iranians were actually getting the upper hand on the
[37:45] battlefields,
[37:47] The Europeans came to the aid of Iraq under Saddam Hussein,
[37:51] Iraq's Ba'ath regimes.
[37:53] SPEAKER_01: The most significant aid that the Europeans and actually the U.S.
[37:57] gave the regime was the Saddam Hussein regime was exoset
[38:01] missiles and Mirage
[38:02] SPEAKER_01: airplanes were given to the regime by France and the U.S.
[38:06] provided intelligence and the Germans were giving them
[38:09] chemicals and various other
[38:10] SPEAKER_01: kinds of things.
[38:10] SPEAKER_01: Just perfect, you know.
[38:12] SPEAKER_01: And the way that the Ba'ath regime,
[38:14] SPEAKER_01: the Iraqi regime,
[38:16] SPEAKER_01: used those exoset missiles,
[38:18] SPEAKER_01: because it was losing on the battlefields,
[38:20] SPEAKER_01: it started targeting Iran's oil terminals,
[38:24] SPEAKER_01: particularly the Kharkh terminal,
[38:25] SPEAKER_01: which you should also ask me about,
[38:27] SPEAKER_01: where,
[38:27] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[38:28] SPEAKER_01: the U.S.
[38:29] SPEAKER_01: has threatened to take over.
[38:31] SPEAKER_01: But also started attacking tankers,
[38:33] SPEAKER_01: both Iranian tankers and tankers that were lifting oil from Iran.
[38:37] SPEAKER_01: And so Iran did a tit-for-tat answer.
[38:39] SPEAKER_01: And it started attacking both Iraqi oil terminals,
[38:42] SPEAKER_01: but significantly it started attacking Kuwait.
[38:45] And the reason that it was attacking Kuwait was because
[38:47] although we've forgotten
[38:49] SPEAKER_01: this because of the war that followed,
[38:51] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[38:51] SPEAKER_01: five,
[38:51] SPEAKER_01: six years later,
[38:52] SPEAKER_01: in fact,
[38:52] SPEAKER_01: Kuwait was attacked.
[38:54] SPEAKER_01: acting as a kind of extension of Iraq,
[38:57] SPEAKER_01: providing the ability for Iraq to export its oil through Kuwait.
[39:02] SPEAKER_01: And so Iran attacks Kuwait,
[39:05] SPEAKER_01: and this immediately takes the price of oil through the roof,
[39:09] but it also immediately also takes the insurance premiums
[39:12] through the roof.
[39:13] SPEAKER_01: And Iranians catch on.
[39:15] And this becomes such a big deal that the US actually then
[39:19] decides to flag Kuwaiti
[39:22] SPEAKER_01: ships to US flags and to supposedly escort.
[39:27] SPEAKER_01: And I say supposedly because I'll explain in a minute.
[39:30] SPEAKER_01: for show, supposedly escorts ships carrying oil out of the Gulf.
[39:37] SPEAKER_01: I say supposedly because as Toby Craig Jones,
[39:41] SPEAKER_01: a really great historian of the Gulf,
[39:44] SPEAKER_01: has shown,
[39:45] SPEAKER_01: in fact,
[39:46] SPEAKER_01: they weren't escorting them.
[39:47] SPEAKER_01: They were letting the convoy,
[39:48] SPEAKER_01: the oil tankers,
[39:50] SPEAKER_01: to go first,
[39:51] SPEAKER_01: which is kind of funny because all of the mines were up front.
[39:54] SPEAKER_01: So basically, they were letting the tankers blow up.
[39:56] So that they could assert their sovereignty and swing their
[39:59] dick out behind in the
[40:01] SPEAKER_01: back of the convoy with their warships.
[40:04] SPEAKER_01: And did this work?
[40:06] SPEAKER_01: Maybe a little bit.
[40:08] SPEAKER_01: I mean, certainly it kind of escalated the war.
[40:11] There were something like 400 and something ships hit over the
[40:15] course of the next four years.
[40:16] SPEAKER_01: We know the number of the ships.
[40:18] SPEAKER_01: If you look it up on Wikipedia, every single ship is named.
[40:20] SPEAKER_01: We don't know the number of seafarers that were killed,
[40:23] SPEAKER_01: which is also kind of horrific and horrendous.
[40:25] because it's a horrific way to die,
[40:27] actually,
[40:27] on a burning tanker in the middle of the sea.
[40:29] SPEAKER_01: And it increased the risk of Third World War,
[40:34] because obviously the Soviets weren't liking too much that
[40:37] ships were being flagged
[40:38] SPEAKER_01: to the US.
[40:39] SPEAKER_01: So Iranians have had an experience of this.
[40:42] And I suspect that some of what they have planned strategically
[40:48] has been in response to.
[40:50] SPEAKER_01: They haven't had to war game this.
[40:52] SPEAKER_01: They've actually lived through it.
[40:53] SPEAKER_01: And so Iran,
[40:54] Some of the tactics that they have used in the way that they're
[40:57] using the leverage
[40:58] SPEAKER_01: of global economy and,
[41:00] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[41:01] the sort of the credible threat perception element as a way to
[41:05] ensure that they
[41:07] have the upper hand in the flow of oil traffic or any kind of
[41:12] traffic through the
[41:14] SPEAKER_01: Strait of Hormuz.
[41:16] SPEAKER_03: I'm glad you teed me up to talk about Khark,
[41:19] because that has been obviously on the lips of everybody in the
[41:23] friendly media to
[41:24] SPEAKER_03: the current Trump administration.
[41:26] SPEAKER_03: The pitch is that if American troops,
[41:29] SPEAKER_03: of which there are seemingly thousands now traveling to the Gulf region,
[41:32] SPEAKER_03: that if they land on Khark,
[41:34] SPEAKER_03: if they seize the island,
[41:36] SPEAKER_03: which I think is around 80 to 90 percent of Iranian exports,
[41:40] SPEAKER_03: oil exports,
[41:42] SPEAKER_03: that they will cut off a significant lifeline for the Islamic Republic.
[41:45] SPEAKER_03: If the U.S.,
[41:46] SPEAKER_03: God forbid,
[41:47] SPEAKER_03: does go in and seize Khark,
[41:50] what would the options be for the Iranian government to take
[41:54] that oil exporting
[41:56] SPEAKER_03: elsewhere?
[41:57] SPEAKER_03: And if the U.S.
[41:58] SPEAKER_03: decides to take Lorak,
[42:00] SPEAKER_03: Quiche,
[42:02] SPEAKER_03: other islands like Abu Musa,
[42:04] SPEAKER_03: what would the effect of those be as well?
[42:06] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[42:06] this is like one of those questions that is really difficult to
[42:09] answer because I
[42:10] SPEAKER_01: think before we even talk about the economic effects of those,
[42:13] we'd have to talk about the fact that these are not little
[42:15] rocks in the middle of
[42:16] SPEAKER_01: the sea.
[42:17] SPEAKER_01: Harg Island has something like 8,000 people living on it.
[42:20] SPEAKER_01: 8,000 people that are not military, that are not oil related.
[42:23] SPEAKER_01: They're 8,000 people.
[42:24] SPEAKER_01: It's got one of the oldest Portuguese forts on it.
[42:26] It is also one of those places that has enormous historic and
[42:30] archaeological significance.
[42:31] It is an incredibly significant and important place,
[42:36] without even thinking about the oil.
[42:40] SPEAKER_01: Yes, a significant amount of Iran's oil goes through Khark.
[42:43] But it's also notable that actually when the Iraqis were
[42:48] attacking Khark in the
[42:49] SPEAKER_01: Iran-Iraq war,
[42:51] SPEAKER_01: Iran actually immediately built buoys elsewhere to ship oil elsewhere.
[42:56] SPEAKER_01: For example, to Chabahar and other places.
[42:58] The difficulty would be the shipping of oil or gas from
[43:04] internally rather than externally.
[43:06] SPEAKER_01: Because indeed,
[43:07] SPEAKER_01: to actually have a ship come and load themselves,
[43:12] SPEAKER_01: you basically need a big old pipe,
[43:13] SPEAKER_01: big old hose.
[43:14] SPEAKER_01: And then you just attach it and that goes.
[43:16] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[43:17] the automation of this process of loading of petroleum is one
[43:21] of the things that
[43:22] SPEAKER_01: I've written about this.
[43:22] It's massively automated and inexpensive to create a buoy
[43:26] that's about a mile off
[43:27] SPEAKER_01: the coast in order to ship that.
[43:29] I don't know the status of the Iranian infrastructure on land
[43:33] to be able to
[43:34] SPEAKER_01: redirect Iranian oil into other locations.
[43:39] But I can see actually oil being sent to Iraq and being shipped
[43:43] out of Iraq,
[43:44] SPEAKER_01: for example,
[43:45] SPEAKER_01: particularly southern Iraq,
[43:46] SPEAKER_01: where,
[43:47] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[43:47] SPEAKER_01: the people in control are sympathetic to Iran.
[43:50] SPEAKER_01: And so and even in northern Iraq.
[43:52] SPEAKER_01: Even with the KRG,
[43:53] SPEAKER_01: the Kurdish government in Iraq,
[43:55] SPEAKER_01: because I can even see them,
[43:57] although they house Americans and they probably have lots of
[44:00] Israelis on the
[44:01] SPEAKER_01: ground,
[44:02] SPEAKER_01: they are actually not hostile to Iran.
[44:04] SPEAKER_01: And so I can totally,
[44:05] SPEAKER_01: or through Turkey,
[44:06] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[44:07] I can totally see Iran actually finding other ways of shipping
[44:10] oil out of the
[44:11] SPEAKER_01: country.
[44:12] SPEAKER_01: some of which can even be maritime.
[44:14] SPEAKER_01: I think the more important question to ask is,
[44:17] SPEAKER_01: will the US really,
[44:18] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[44:19] SPEAKER_01: yes,
[44:19] SPEAKER_01: okay,
[44:19] they're sending 82nd Airborne and they were talking about
[44:22] sending the Marines
[44:22] SPEAKER_01: before.
[44:23] Will they really put boots on the ground and start having
[44:27] coffins come back to the US?
[44:29] SPEAKER_01: Is the administration going to do that?
[44:31] It seems like they're hurtling in that direction without there
[44:35] being any breaks,
[44:36] SPEAKER_01: without there being anybody telling them that you're stupid.
[44:39] SPEAKER_01: I'm surprised,
[44:40] SPEAKER_01: actually,
[44:40] SPEAKER_01: that the US military is agreeing to this,
[44:43] SPEAKER_01: that there is not anybody saying to him,
[44:45] SPEAKER_01: hey,
[44:45] SPEAKER_01: dude,
[44:46] SPEAKER_01: this is not going to be like fighting Iraq.
[44:49] This is not going to be like blowing fishing boats out of the
[44:53] water in the
[44:54] Caribbean and pretending that there's some kind of a high
[44:56] powered narco terrorist.
[44:58] SPEAKER_01: This is the Iranians have had long experience of fighting.
[45:02] both against their external enemies and training sort of
[45:08] irregular forces elsewhere.
[45:10] SPEAKER_01: So are they really going to get into it with Iran?
[45:14] SPEAKER_01: I would be shocked.
[45:15] SPEAKER_01: I wonder if this is, again, some...
[45:19] SPEAKER_01: real kind of Trump loves to bluff.
[45:22] SPEAKER_01: And maybe this is just a bluff because genuinely,
[45:26] SPEAKER_01: if they do put boots on the ground,
[45:27] it might be a stupider mistake than even the Gulf of Tonkin
[45:32] because they don't know
[45:33] SPEAKER_01: what they're getting themselves into.
[45:35] SPEAKER_01: In Vietnam, they had been around for 10 or 15 years.
[45:39] SPEAKER_01: They had all sorts of intelligence that they could gather.
[45:42] SPEAKER_01: They have no clue what they're walking into.
[45:44] SPEAKER_01: They just don't.
[45:45] SPEAKER_01: They don't know.
[45:46] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that's my response.
[45:48] SPEAKER_01: It's yeah, they may be able to destroy Khark.
[45:50] SPEAKER_01: They may be able to momentarily destroy Iran's ability to export oil.
[45:55] SPEAKER_01: But again,
[45:55] Iran has the engineering know-how to switch to create temporary
[45:59] oil lifting
[46:00] SPEAKER_01: terminals and probably will find other ways of exporting oil,
[46:03] SPEAKER_01: perhaps not to the same extent as it has been through its shadow fleets.
[46:07] SPEAKER_01: But, you know, it'll do what it needs to.
[46:09] I think that you are correct that it is totally insane for them
[46:12] to try this,
[46:13] SPEAKER_02: and nevertheless,
[46:14] SPEAKER_02: I think they still might.
[46:15] SPEAKER_02: But yeah, I think, as I understand it, the U.S.
[46:18] SPEAKER_02: has not done an amphibious assault under fire since,
[46:22] SPEAKER_02: like,
[46:22] SPEAKER_02: Okinawa,
[46:23] and they're contemplating doing it against a country that has
[46:26] prepped for this
[46:26] SPEAKER_02: invasion for 40 years.
[46:28] SPEAKER_03: If I can just add something briefly onto what Dylan is saying,
[46:30] SPEAKER_03: Lindsey Graham said that if America could do Iwo Jima...
[46:36] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[46:36] Oh my God,
[46:36] if that's a comparison point,
[46:38] then they're really going to go for it.
[46:39] SPEAKER_02: Well, it might happen even sooner than we think.
[46:42] SPEAKER_02: This episode is being recorded on Thursday,
[46:45] SPEAKER_02: March 26th and may not go up for a few days,
[46:49] SPEAKER_02: which includes the very dangerous weekend when the markets are closed.
[46:53] SPEAKER_01: I was going to say in Iwo Jima,
[46:54] a force of 50-some thousand Americans faced 18,000 Japanese and
[47:00] 27,000 Americans
[47:01] SPEAKER_01: died.
[47:02] So,
[47:02] I mean,
[47:05] I don't expect historical or geographic literacy from anybody
[47:09] less Lindsay Graham.
[47:11] SPEAKER_01: But I mean...
[47:12] SPEAKER_01: That's your fucking history, you know?
[47:15] SPEAKER_01: His fucking history.
[47:16] SPEAKER_01: He should know that.
[47:17] SPEAKER_01: If he's citing that,
[47:18] he should know at least a little bit about the lives lost in
[47:21] order to secure that
[47:22] SPEAKER_01: famous flag-raising picture.
[47:24] SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
[47:24] SPEAKER_02: all this to,
[47:26] ostensibly to just restore the status quo ante of the
[47:29] straight-up world being open.
[47:30] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[47:30] But I do want to return back to the kind of the economics of
[47:34] things because you
[47:35] made a really interesting point when you first came on this
[47:38] show that was somewhat
[47:39] SPEAKER_02: in passing,
[47:40] SPEAKER_02: but I've been thinking about it a lot in recent days.
[47:42] SPEAKER_02: You talked about how the oil shock of 1973,
[47:47] SPEAKER_02: which gets attributed to the Arab oil embargo,
[47:50] SPEAKER_02: wasn't really a supply shock at all.
[47:53] SPEAKER_02: It was actually more of a price hike.
[47:55] SPEAKER_02: And we could spend a lot of time getting into the actual history of that.
[47:59] SPEAKER_02: But what I wanted to talk about is a comparison to today.
[48:02] SPEAKER_02: Because...
[48:03] SPEAKER_02: What we are seeing today is much different.
[48:06] There are millions of barrels of oil and gas that are
[48:10] physically coming offline.
[48:12] And in the case of natural gas,
[48:14] literally sitting on ships and evaporating in the Persian Gulf.
[48:19] SPEAKER_02: And they're not being exported.
[48:21] SPEAKER_02: And that physical shortage is now on the precipice of hitting Asia,
[48:27] will quickly spread to Europe and eventually to here in the
[48:30] United States.
[48:31] So I'm curious how you see the comparison with 1973 and how are
[48:37] these actual
[48:38] SPEAKER_02: physical shortfalls of gas going to hit the broader economy?
[48:41] SPEAKER_01: So that's really actually a good point.
[48:43] SPEAKER_01: There is one big difference between the 1970s and now,
[48:46] SPEAKER_01: and that is that back then there weren't,
[48:49] SPEAKER_01: although you had this kind of a way of pricing the oil,
[48:52] SPEAKER_01: you did not have futures markets in oil.
[48:55] SPEAKER_01: The futures markets in oil were developed in the,
[48:57] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[48:57] SPEAKER_01: they started developing them in the 80s,
[48:59] SPEAKER_01: but they really took off in the 1990s.
[49:01] And then they became actually the most significant way through
[49:03] which oil is priced
[49:05] SPEAKER_01: in the sense that it's the spot price,
[49:07] SPEAKER_01: the price that you pay at
[49:09] SPEAKER_01: when a ship goes to pick up the oil,
[49:11] SPEAKER_01: is not as significant in setting what we would call the benchmark prices,
[49:16] West Texas Intermediate or Brent or a couple of different
[49:20] grades that are sold
[49:21] SPEAKER_01: through Dubai and Oman,
[49:23] SPEAKER_01: and the futures prices are.
[49:25] And what's really interesting here is that there is a
[49:29] disconnect between the
[49:32] SPEAKER_01: future's pricing of oil on the one hand,
[49:35] which is what the jawboning that I talked about a little bit
[49:37] earlier speaks to,
[49:39] SPEAKER_01: particularly Trump's jawboning speaks to.
[49:41] SPEAKER_01: And then there is the actuality of the oil,
[49:44] SPEAKER_01: the sort of the molecules,
[49:45] SPEAKER_01: if you will,
[49:46] SPEAKER_01: and the gas that is flowing through.
[49:48] SPEAKER_01: Apparently,
[49:49] the ships that left the Gulf at the time of the US and Israeli
[49:54] attacks on Iran,
[49:56] SPEAKER_01: the last tanker is arriving in Asia this week.
[50:00] SPEAKER_01: These are the ships that left before the hostilities began,
[50:02] SPEAKER_01: not the ones that have negotiated exit.
[50:05] SPEAKER_01: And then the ones that left to Europe,
[50:06] SPEAKER_01: there's three that are arriving in Europe in the next week or two.
[50:12] After that,
[50:13] there is no oil and gas coming from the Gulf unless it's
[50:17] negotiated.
[50:18] SPEAKER_01: So India negotiated these two massive tankers,
[50:22] SPEAKER_01: I think it's 60 million tons or something or 60 million.
[50:25] SPEAKER_01: I can't remember what that exact amount was,
[50:27] SPEAKER_01: which is going to be going directly to its energy production,
[50:30] SPEAKER_01: electricity production nodes.
[50:32] What happens after when it actually we do hit the cliff and the
[50:36] precipice and go
[50:37] SPEAKER_01: down is something that is not anticipated.
[50:40] SPEAKER_01: There's also a market,
[50:42] SPEAKER_01: of course,
[50:42] SPEAKER_01: in futures,
[50:43] SPEAKER_01: and that is where people are manipulating the market,
[50:46] SPEAKER_01: particularly through sort of placing shorts or longs on future pricing,
[50:52] SPEAKER_01: meaning that they're betting either what the future is going to be.
[50:56] And it's basically a speculative instrument that bets on what
[51:00] they think the price
[51:01] SPEAKER_01: of oil is going to be at the end of the term of a futures contract.
[51:05] SPEAKER_01: It's basically wagering.
[51:06] It's like calci,
[51:07] but it's institutionalized in commodities form,
[51:11] commodities trade form.
[51:13] SPEAKER_01: Now, that has been moving up and down.
[51:15] As Javier Bluff,
[51:16] Bloomberg pointed out,
[51:18] it's actually not a lot of these amounts.
[51:20] The numbers that we're seeing are not as dramatic as they were
[51:24] in 2022 when Russia
[51:26] SPEAKER_01: invaded Ukraine.
[51:27] SPEAKER_01: But we don't know what's going to happen next.
[51:30] SPEAKER_01: I think it's going to be in the next week or so,
[51:32] we're going to really find out where the divergence is between
[51:36] the molecules versus
[51:38] SPEAKER_01: the futures,
[51:38] SPEAKER_01: the speculative pricing.
[51:40] SPEAKER_01: The other thing that is going to trickle in,
[51:43] SPEAKER_01: and its effect is going to trickle in over the long term,
[51:46] SPEAKER_01: is that the futures contracts that are being signed,
[51:50] SPEAKER_01: that you're going to sell oil at $100 in six months' time.
[51:54] If there is a negotiated settlement and the price of oil drops
[51:58] down to $60,000,
[51:59] There's going to be a lot of market shenanigans in trying to
[52:02] sort of unload these
[52:04] SPEAKER_01: futures contracts at 100,
[52:05] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[52:07] SPEAKER_01: which are planning for $100 oil.
[52:09] SPEAKER_01: These two factors are really enormously significant.
[52:11] SPEAKER_01: But then there's also,
[52:12] SPEAKER_01: on top of all of this,
[52:14] SPEAKER_01: there's also the fact that Iran has hit a number of different production
[52:19] SPEAKER_01: facilities,
[52:19] SPEAKER_01: Ras Al-Affan in Qatar.
[52:21] SPEAKER_01: It has attacked Aramco and a couple of other places.
[52:25] SPEAKER_01: It has also attacked lifting terminals.
[52:27] SPEAKER_01: It has also attacked oil terminals.
[52:29] SPEAKER_01: Fujairah on the Gulf of Oman side,
[52:32] SPEAKER_01: where a pipeline ends up carrying from Abu Dhabi to Fujairah,
[52:36] SPEAKER_01: and it avoids the Gulf of Hormuz.
[52:37] SPEAKER_01: But Iran has hit that.
[52:39] SPEAKER_01: And Iran has also hit Yambu,
[52:41] SPEAKER_01: which is on the Red Sea,
[52:43] SPEAKER_01: and it is the terminus of a pipeline between Jubail and Yambu,
[52:46] SPEAKER_01: which carries oil.
[52:47] SPEAKER_01: And in fact,
[52:48] SPEAKER_01: the amount of oil that's going through there,
[52:50] SPEAKER_01: the graphs that I've seen are like skyrocketing.
[52:52] Because the Red Sea,
[52:54] which we'll talk about,
[52:54] I'm sure,
[52:55] in a minute,
[52:55] is not yet a domain of war.
[52:59] SPEAKER_01: So Qataris have come and said that it's going to take them months,
[53:02] SPEAKER_01: if not years,
[53:03] SPEAKER_01: to rebuild Rasulafan.
[53:04] SPEAKER_01: So the echoes,
[53:06] the after effects of this are going to continue rolling on and
[53:09] we're going to
[53:10] SPEAKER_01: really feel it in the next week or two.
[53:12] SPEAKER_01: So who knows?
[53:13] SPEAKER_01: We're in uncharted waters.
[53:15] SPEAKER_03: So I think the matter of the Yemeni entrance into this war,
[53:20] SPEAKER_03: I don't think it's a question of if it's a question of when.
[53:23] Political bureau officials have said the decision to stand with
[53:26] Iran militarily has been made.
[53:27] SPEAKER_03: There was a threat,
[53:28] SPEAKER_03: I believe,
[53:29] by the IRTC last night that the Bab al-Mandeb could be a new
[53:32] front if there is a
[53:34] military move to reopen the strait militarily or if there are
[53:38] landings on Khark and
[53:39] SPEAKER_03: other islands.
[53:40] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[53:41] If there is a closure in the Strait of Hormuz and the Bab
[53:46] al-Mandeb at the same
[53:47] SPEAKER_03: time,
[53:48] SPEAKER_03: because the Yemenis do not have as sophisticated of a toll regime,
[53:53] SPEAKER_03: of an ability to discern.
[53:54] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[53:54] the Yemeni navy literally had a public email address where you
[53:57] could email them to
[53:58] SPEAKER_03: get clearance.
[53:59] If both of these are essentially closed to almost all shipping
[54:03] traffic at the same
[54:04] SPEAKER_03: time,
[54:04] how difficult would it be for the economy on top of what is
[54:09] already happening?
[54:10] SPEAKER_03: Is it even possible to predict that, to consider that?
[54:13] SPEAKER_01: No, it's not possible to predict that.
[54:15] And the reason that it's not possible to predict that is
[54:17] because we know that the
[54:20] closure of the bubble mandap by the Houthis had a massive
[54:24] effect on inflation in
[54:26] SPEAKER_01: Europe,
[54:27] SPEAKER_01: certainly.
[54:28] We know that the addition of the costs of ships going around
[54:32] Cape of Good Hope
[54:33] SPEAKER_01: actually does exacerbate the pricing processes.
[54:36] SPEAKER_01: It exacerbates the just-in-time manufacturing.
[54:39] SPEAKER_01: It exacerbates...
[54:41] basically the length of time it takes for goods to travel
[54:45] between Asia and Europe.
[54:46] SPEAKER_01: And so it is significant.
[54:49] It is enormously significant that this kind of a closure or the
[54:54] blockade of the Red
[54:55] SPEAKER_01: Sea,
[54:56] which resulted in the container ship traffic through the Suez
[55:00] Canal dropping by
[55:01] SPEAKER_01: something like 60%.
[55:03] SPEAKER_01: had this massive effect on inflation in Europe.
[55:06] SPEAKER_01: Now,
[55:06] imagine combining that with a reduction in the natural gas
[55:11] production arising from
[55:13] SPEAKER_01: Ras al-Afan being out of commission,
[55:16] SPEAKER_01: as is Iran's South Pars field,
[55:19] SPEAKER_01: for example,
[55:20] SPEAKER_01: will be out of commission if the U.S.
[55:21] SPEAKER_01: tries to take over.
[55:23] SPEAKER_01: And with war risk premium in all of these areas,
[55:27] SPEAKER_01: basically in Western Indian Ocean,
[55:29] SPEAKER_01: going through the roof.
[55:30] SPEAKER_01: I can't, I mean, I don't know of a scenario.
[55:33] This is a kind of a World War III,
[55:35] but fought in the maritime space of Western Indian Ocean.
[55:38] SPEAKER_01: And I really...
[55:39] SPEAKER_01: I don't know what's going to happen.
[55:41] SPEAKER_01: I don't want to even think about it,
[55:43] because what I also worry about is that the response to any
[55:48] such a thing will be
[55:49] SPEAKER_01: the madman's response of unleashing nuclear weapons,
[55:53] SPEAKER_01: which is not beyond Israel.
[55:56] And the US would sort of turn a blind eye,
[55:59] as Europeans will too,
[56:00] probably.
[56:01] SPEAKER_01: And so it's kind of,
[56:03] it's such an apocalyptic thought that the only thing that I can
[56:07] hope for is that
[56:09] SPEAKER_01: the Europeans have pushed back a little bit,
[56:13] SPEAKER_01: not a huge amount,
[56:13] SPEAKER_01: but a little bit against this war.
[56:15] If it's going to affect them in the dramatic way that it will
[56:19] if Bab al-Mandab is
[56:20] SPEAKER_01: closed on top of the Strait of Hormuz,
[56:22] SPEAKER_01: I would hope that they push back in some way against the US.
[56:26] SPEAKER_01: But who knows?
[56:27] SPEAKER_02: So in this program,
[56:28] we are in the business of being optimistic and looking for the
[56:33] silver lining in any
[56:34] SPEAKER_02: situation.
[56:34] SPEAKER_01: Good, which is we should.
[56:36] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[56:37] SPEAKER_01: I have to say the silver lining on this is,
[56:40] SPEAKER_01: OK,
[56:40] SPEAKER_01: so the government of Iran,
[56:42] SPEAKER_01: my parents were political prisoners there.
[56:44] SPEAKER_01: Setting that aside,
[56:45] the fact of the matter is that they have displayed in what Ho
[56:48] Chi Minh said in the
[56:49] SPEAKER_01: 19...
[56:49] SPEAKER_01: Was it Ho Chi Minh or was it Mao?
[56:51] SPEAKER_01: That the U.S.
[56:52] SPEAKER_01: is basically a paper tiger.
[56:53] SPEAKER_01: That so much of the way that the U.S.
[56:56] SPEAKER_01: thinks about war fighting,
[56:58] SPEAKER_01: thinks about its imperial control,
[57:01] SPEAKER_01: is basically proven to be ineffective.
[57:04] And not only because the current administration have dismantled
[57:09] the instruments of U.S.
[57:11] SPEAKER_01: hegemony, which they have,
[57:13] And not only because Trump is an idiot and his court are a
[57:19] bunch of bootlicking
[57:20] suckers that just feed him two-minute reels of US victories
[57:24] rather than the reality
[57:25] SPEAKER_01: of what's going on,
[57:26] but because structurally the US is at a place where it simply
[57:32] does not have the
[57:34] SPEAKER_01: capability,
[57:34] SPEAKER_01: I think,
[57:35] SPEAKER_01: to...
[57:36] SPEAKER_01: be any kind of a hegemonic project in the globe.
[57:41] It is now reliant on its annual one trillion plus dollar
[57:46] expenditure on the
[57:47] SPEAKER_01: military in order to survive.
[57:49] It basically operates on the basis of strong arming everybody
[57:54] into doing what it
[57:55] SPEAKER_01: wants,
[57:55] SPEAKER_01: which Trump has only laid bare.
[57:57] SPEAKER_01: He's just, you know, peeled off the niceties off the top of that.
[58:01] SPEAKER_01: But that's basically what the U.S.
[58:02] SPEAKER_01: used to do.
[58:03] SPEAKER_01: And it has,
[58:05] it and Israel have made Israel the most vulnerable it has been
[58:09] in its entire
[58:11] SPEAKER_01: history.
[58:11] SPEAKER_01: And so maybe that's something good.
[58:13] SPEAKER_01: Maybe those are the silver linings.
[58:16] I wanted to ask about the silver lining from a related angle to
[58:19] hegemonic decline,
[58:20] SPEAKER_02: but it's in the direction of what this potentially could open up.
[58:24] Because another difference from the 70s is that there are now
[58:29] much more developed countries
[58:30] energy alternatives to oil and gas and coal,
[58:34] non-fossil fuel energy sources.
[58:36] And so I'm wondering if you think that sustained higher oil
[58:40] prices coming from this
[58:41] SPEAKER_02: shock,
[58:42] SPEAKER_02: from the expansion of this shock,
[58:44] could have the inadvertent effect of accelerating something
[58:49] like an energy
[58:49] SPEAKER_02: transition,
[58:50] SPEAKER_02: or at the very least if sustained price hikes
[58:54] SPEAKER_02: caused the demand destruction in fossil fuels.
[58:57] Do you see any like potential broader environmentalist upside
[59:01] to this conflict?
[59:03] SPEAKER_01: I mean, it's a really great question, actually.
[59:05] SPEAKER_01: So yes, this is really quite significant.
[59:08] SPEAKER_01: So because every global hegemon operates on the basis,
[59:12] SPEAKER_01: at least in the last couple of hundred years,
[59:14] it's operated on the basis of having a particular kind of fuel
[59:17] that fuels the
[59:18] SPEAKER_01: industry and the energy needs of that global hegemon.
[59:21] SPEAKER_01: And then it has also had a global currency, which trades.
[59:24] So we went from the British with coal and sterling to the US
[59:27] with oil and oil.
[59:29] SPEAKER_01: And so now we're looking actually at China,
[59:32] which is sitting back as the world's kind of leader on
[59:35] sustainable energy,
[59:36] SPEAKER_01: on battery,
[59:37] SPEAKER_01: on various kinds of solar and wind and other kinds of energy.
[59:40] SPEAKER_01: And they're probably laughing their asses off at the fact that the U.S.
[59:44] SPEAKER_01: is shooting itself in the foot in this particular way.
[59:47] SPEAKER_01: Of course,
[59:47] SPEAKER_01: this could potentially also open up the vista for lots of other,
[59:53] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[59:53] SPEAKER_01: already the Chinese are producing incredibly cheap solar panels.
[59:56] If we can come up with interesting solutions to sort of the
[59:59] battery storage of
[1:00:01] SPEAKER_01: electricity,
[1:00:02] SPEAKER_01: which I'm sure the Chinese are also on top of,
[1:00:04] SPEAKER_01: they could potentially also affect this in a major way.
[1:00:07] But there's also other elements about this current closure of
[1:00:11] the Gulf that are
[1:00:12] interesting and unintended consequences of the US and Israel
[1:00:17] blundering into this
[1:00:18] SPEAKER_01: war,
[1:00:19] which is that we know about oil being oil and gas coming
[1:00:23] through the Gulf,
[1:00:24] SPEAKER_01: right?
[1:00:24] SPEAKER_01: But there are also two other products that come through the Gulf,
[1:00:29] SPEAKER_01: which the Gulf is the most significant area for the production of these.
[1:00:33] Urea,
[1:00:33] which is used in production of fertilizer,
[1:00:36] but also other stuff that needs nitrogen.
[1:00:38] SPEAKER_01: And about 30 to 50 percent of the global urea travel.
[1:00:42] And it's a byproduct of a lot of the production kinds of
[1:00:44] processes of production of petroleum.
[1:00:47] SPEAKER_01: And so a lot of urea actually comes through the Persian Gulf,
[1:00:51] SPEAKER_01: comes through the Strait of Hormuz.
[1:00:53] SPEAKER_01: And there has been a closure of that.
[1:00:55] So that's not a positive thing because obviously urea is used
[1:00:58] for fertilizer and
[1:01:00] SPEAKER_01: it's needed for agriculture.
[1:01:01] SPEAKER_01: We're probably going to see longer term effects of this in a year or two.
[1:01:05] But there is another thing which I actually think is a little
[1:01:08] bit better and kind
[1:01:08] of more positive is that West Point just published something
[1:01:12] that I had no idea
[1:01:13] SPEAKER_01: about.
[1:01:13] SPEAKER_01: And it was fascinating.
[1:01:15] SPEAKER_01: Fifty percent of the world's sulfur,
[1:01:17] SPEAKER_01: which is also a byproduct of petroleum production,
[1:01:21] SPEAKER_01: also comes through the Strait of Hormuz.
[1:01:23] SPEAKER_01: Sulfur is necessary for the production of sulfuric acid,
[1:01:26] SPEAKER_01: and sulfuric acid is necessary for the smelting of copper,
[1:01:30] SPEAKER_01: which is enormously important for electricity production,
[1:01:34] SPEAKER_01: for semiconductors,
[1:01:36] SPEAKER_01: and the West Point article that
[1:01:38] SPEAKER_01: that noted this,
[1:01:40] said that this actually is going to affect the military
[1:01:44] industrial readiness of the
[1:01:46] SPEAKER_01: United States,
[1:01:46] because the United States relies almost more than anybody else
[1:01:49] on the importation
[1:01:50] SPEAKER_01: of sulfur and the use of sulfuric acid for weapons production.
[1:01:54] SPEAKER_01: So it would be really a wonderful kind of irony,
[1:01:58] a wonderful kind of silver lining if the US is shooting itself
[1:02:01] in the foot.
[1:02:02] Its military industrial readiness is being affected by its
[1:02:06] stupid blunder into the Gulf.
[1:02:08] Our friend Jake Rahm was commenting on the beautiful symbolic
[1:02:12] irony of the great
[1:02:13] Satan running out of sulfur and thus losing its ability to
[1:02:18] build a kingdom of evil
[1:02:19] SPEAKER_02: on earth.
[1:02:20] SPEAKER_01: That's really good.
[1:02:21] SPEAKER_01: I like it.
[1:02:22] SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
[1:02:23] SPEAKER_03: So I wanted to close out this discussion,
[1:02:27] SPEAKER_03: which I'm sad to do because we always love talking to you.
[1:02:30] I wanted to ask about the long-term plan ahead for the Strait
[1:02:36] of Hormuz and control over it.
[1:02:38] SPEAKER_03: I'm so glad that you brought up the Iranian people on these islands.
[1:02:41] America is going to try to impose control over the Strait by
[1:02:44] potentially placing a
[1:02:45] SPEAKER_03: thousand people on Khark,
[1:02:47] SPEAKER_03: a thousand people on Lorak,
[1:02:48] SPEAKER_03: the
[1:02:49] maybe 55,000 people on quiche,
[1:02:50] God knows where else,
[1:02:52] under American military occupation.
[1:02:54] There's talk from the UAE and Saudi Arabia of joining some sort
[1:02:59] of mission to
[1:03:00] SPEAKER_03: militarily reopen the strait.
[1:03:02] SPEAKER_03: I don't know what precisely they could do.
[1:03:04] But what Iran has put forward in their points to American
[1:03:09] negotiators is that they
[1:03:11] SPEAKER_03: want full sovereignty over the strait.
[1:03:14] SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I saw that.
[1:03:15] SPEAKER_03: That is at least what they said through press TV.
[1:03:18] So,
[1:03:18] I mean,
[1:03:18] what are the chances,
[1:03:20] if you could say so,
[1:03:23] that they would be able to achieve this?
[1:03:25] SPEAKER_03: And the Gulf states, would they accept it, this kind of arrangement?
[1:03:30] SPEAKER_01: No, well, it depends on which Gulf states.
[1:03:32] Because I suspect that Qatar would be quite happy to come to a
[1:03:35] negotiated solution with Iran.
[1:03:37] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[1:03:37] SPEAKER_01: Qatar and Iran have been sharing what Iranians call the South Pars field,
[1:03:41] SPEAKER_01: the Qataris call the North Dome,
[1:03:43] SPEAKER_01: a basic gas field.
[1:03:44] And they've been coordinating the extraction of natural gas
[1:03:47] from this field for 20 years.
[1:03:49] SPEAKER_01: And they've been having a very good relationship of negotiating that.
[1:03:51] SPEAKER_01: I could see the Qataris making, you know, a deal.
[1:03:54] SPEAKER_01: I could see Kuwaitis even making a deal.
[1:03:56] SPEAKER_01: But I suspect the Emirates probably won't.
[1:03:58] SPEAKER_01: And even within the Emirates,
[1:03:59] there's going to be probably differences because I think Abu
[1:04:02] Dhabi will not allow,
[1:04:03] SPEAKER_01: for example,
[1:04:03] SPEAKER_01: for Dubai,
[1:04:04] which would want to have much more of a commercial
[1:04:06] laissez-faire relationship with
[1:04:08] SPEAKER_01: Iran to have that kind of a control.
[1:04:10] I don't know how Iran would enforce full sovereignty over the
[1:04:16] Strait of Hormuz.
[1:04:17] SPEAKER_01: And I think that it would be an act of hubris.
[1:04:20] Much the same as the Shah of Iran arguing in the 1975 Algiers
[1:04:26] Accord with Iraq,
[1:04:28] pushing for the full control of Shattal Arab all the way to the
[1:04:32] Iraqi banks and
[1:04:33] SPEAKER_01: getting it because the U.S.
[1:04:35] SPEAKER_01: supported Iran was a fool's errand that was,
[1:04:38] SPEAKER_01: if nothing else,
[1:04:39] SPEAKER_01: was used as an alibi by the Iraqi regime for invading Iran in 1980.
[1:04:44] SPEAKER_01: Having said that,
[1:04:46] I think that they are putting maximalist demands on the
[1:04:50] negotiation table because
[1:04:52] this is a moment at which they can extract a degree of
[1:04:55] concessions that maybe
[1:04:57] somebody like a Russia or China will guarantee and therefore
[1:05:02] will prevent another
[1:05:05] SPEAKER_01: know-nothing president like Trump to back out of as he did with JCPOA.
[1:05:10] SPEAKER_01: So do I think it's a good idea?
[1:05:11] SPEAKER_01: Do I think Iran can assert its sovereignty?
[1:05:14] SPEAKER_01: I mean, obviously, you know, it'll find a way to do so.
[1:05:17] SPEAKER_01: But is it a good idea?
[1:05:18] SPEAKER_01: I'm not so sure.
[1:05:19] SPEAKER_01: What do you think, Seamus?
[1:05:20] SPEAKER_03: I think, OK, I wanted to ask.
[1:05:22] I wanted to ask this because I was asked this on CGTM and I did
[1:05:26] not have an answer
[1:05:26] SPEAKER_03: because Trump said that whole thing about sharing the Strait of Hormuz.
[1:05:32] SPEAKER_01: Well, fuck Trump.
[1:05:34] But I also don't think that full sovereignty over the Hormuz
[1:05:37] international waters.
[1:05:40] SPEAKER_03: It seems like, yeah, essentially a maximalist demand.
[1:05:43] SPEAKER_03: The one thing that I think I know,
[1:05:44] SPEAKER_03: or at least I hope won't happen,
[1:05:47] is some sort of board of peace argued dual sovereignty
[1:05:51] neocolonial nonsense.
[1:05:53] I can at least rest easy being like,
[1:05:55] okay,
[1:05:55] I don't think that's going to happen.
[1:05:56] SPEAKER_01: No, that definitely won't happen.
[1:05:58] SPEAKER_01: And it's kind of funny,
[1:05:59] SPEAKER_01: the Iranians were posting,
[1:06:00] SPEAKER_01: some embassy,
[1:06:02] SPEAKER_01: some Iranian embassy posted,
[1:06:04] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[1:06:04] SPEAKER_01: the quote that Trump had,
[1:06:07] SPEAKER_01: me and the ayatollah are going to control Hormuz,
[1:06:10] SPEAKER_01: and they posted a picture of a dashboard,
[1:06:13] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[1:06:14] SPEAKER_01: with a wheel on one side and a kitty,
[1:06:17] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[1:06:18] SPEAKER_01: one of those attached kitty driving wheels on the other side.
[1:06:22] SPEAKER_01: So...
[1:06:23] SPEAKER_02: That was my tweet.
[1:06:24] SPEAKER_02: The embassy stole it from me.
[1:06:27] I tweeted that and then I saw the Iranian embassy had taken the
[1:06:32] exact same image.
[1:06:33] SPEAKER_02: I was like, okay, I'm honored.
[1:06:38] SPEAKER_01: We're not worthy.
[1:06:41] SPEAKER_01: He was so proud of me.
[1:06:45] I was literally in the grocery store with Em,
[1:06:47] and she was like,
[1:06:48] what are you smiling about?
[1:06:49] SPEAKER_02: And I was like, looking at my phone.
[1:06:53] SPEAKER_01: No, that won't happen.
[1:06:56] SPEAKER_01: That definitely will not happen.
[1:06:58] SPEAKER_01: The U.S.
[1:06:59] SPEAKER_01: doesn't have the fucking stomach.
[1:07:00] They don't even have the stomach to go back and reinvade Panama
[1:07:03] like Trump claimed
[1:07:04] SPEAKER_01: that he was going to.
[1:07:06] SPEAKER_01: So I don't think they're going to.
[1:07:08] SPEAKER_01: They can't.
[1:07:10] SPEAKER_01: Iran may not have the capability, but the U.S.
[1:07:12] SPEAKER_01: definitely doesn't have the capability to control the strait reformers.
[1:07:15] SPEAKER_01: It just doesn't.
[1:07:17] SPEAKER_01: And it will not have some kind of a board of peace bullshit.
[1:07:21] SPEAKER_01: It won't ever come to that.
[1:07:22] But I think that if Iran decides that it wants to have full
[1:07:25] sovereignty over the
[1:07:27] SPEAKER_01: Hormuz,
[1:07:28] which means control over the strait all the way to the Musendam
[1:07:31] Peninsula,
[1:07:32] SPEAKER_01: I think that would be a bit of an act of a hubris.
[1:07:34] Negotiations over the sea lanes and,
[1:07:37] you know,
[1:07:37] territorial waters is something different.
[1:07:40] SPEAKER_02: I mean,
[1:07:40] the way I read it is as a counter hegemonic threat that the
[1:07:44] whole their whole
[1:07:45] SPEAKER_02: strategy in this war has been to weaponize the strait and to say,
[1:07:48] SPEAKER_02: OK,
[1:07:49] SPEAKER_02: we are using this as a weapon of asymmetric warfare.
[1:07:52] If the Americans and the Israelis are going to have this
[1:07:54] attitude of we can come in
[1:07:56] SPEAKER_02: whenever and do whatever we want.
[1:07:58] SPEAKER_02: And this is what the Israelis say, right?
[1:08:00] SPEAKER_02: That they were like,
[1:08:00] SPEAKER_02: okay,
[1:08:01] SPEAKER_02: well,
[1:08:01] SPEAKER_02: you know,
[1:08:01] SPEAKER_02: if you're going to back off here and you're going to settle this war,
[1:08:05] SPEAKER_02: whatever,
[1:08:05] SPEAKER_02: we need to maintain our freedom of action.
[1:08:07] And I read the Iranian posture as saying,
[1:08:09] okay,
[1:08:10] well,
[1:08:10] then we will have our freedom of action.
[1:08:12] SPEAKER_02: And we may not,
[1:08:13] SPEAKER_02: you know,
[1:08:14] SPEAKER_02: be able to send a missile to the United States,
[1:08:16] SPEAKER_02: but we do have this very strategic choke point right here.
[1:08:20] SPEAKER_02: And we are demonstrating now our capacity to use it.
[1:08:24] SPEAKER_02: And we are clearly not scared to do so.
[1:08:26] And so I read it in the context of a kind of maximalist
[1:08:29] counterpressure with a
[1:08:31] SPEAKER_02: vision towards securing a longer term arrangement.
[1:08:35] SPEAKER_01: I think I'm willing to believe that.
[1:08:36] I think the idea that this is a kind of a negotiation point
[1:08:39] rather than an actual
[1:08:41] SPEAKER_01: plan is far more believable and far more palatable.
[1:08:45] SPEAKER_01: Because I think also,
[1:08:47] SPEAKER_01: really,
[1:08:47] SPEAKER_01: does Iran want to,
[1:08:49] SPEAKER_01: you know,
[1:08:49] SPEAKER_01: go to war also against all of its across the water neighbors?
[1:08:52] SPEAKER_01: You know, it's a question.
[1:08:54] SPEAKER_01: So...
[1:08:55] SPEAKER_03: Lale, thank you so much for coming back on.
[1:08:58] SPEAKER_01: It's been great.
[1:09:00] We love having you,
[1:09:01] and I'm sure we'll have you back in the future as well.
[1:09:03] SPEAKER_01: Well,
[1:09:04] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[1:09:04] given how incredibly depressing it is that you want me on
[1:09:07] because things are really
[1:09:08] SPEAKER_01: shitty,
[1:09:09] SPEAKER_01: I really,
[1:09:09] SPEAKER_01: I mean,
[1:09:09] SPEAKER_01: in a way,
[1:09:10] SPEAKER_01: it's kind of,
[1:09:10] SPEAKER_01: it's like the Chinese curse.
[1:09:12] SPEAKER_01: We all live in interesting times.
[1:09:14] SPEAKER_01: That's right.
[1:09:15] SPEAKER_01: Let's hope for more boring times where you won't need me on.
[1:09:18] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[1:09:18] SPEAKER_01: All right.
[1:09:18] SPEAKER_01: Lovely to see you both.
[1:09:20] SPEAKER_01: All three of you, actually.
[1:09:21] SPEAKER_01: Hi, Em.
[1:09:21] SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
[1:09:23] SPEAKER_01: See you guys later.
[1:09:24] SPEAKER_01: Take care.
[1:09:25] SPEAKER_02: Bye-bye.
[1:10:00] Bye.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
