# The Sin Padre Pio Said Is More Dangerous Than Lust or Greed

An episode of [AfterMass](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1823710125), 23 Apr 2026, 6:31.

Audio: https://traffic.megaphone.fm/APO2383329448.mp3

a respected doctor walked into confession expecting absolution.. and Padre Pio refused him. not once, not twice, but three times. this wasn’t a man living in obvious sin. he was generous, faithful, disciplined.. everything most people would call a “good Catholic.” so what did Padre Pio see that no one else could? in this video, we break down the one sin Padre Pio warned about repeatedly, a sin that looks like devotion. something that can quietly grow in the lives of people who pray, serve and take their faith seriously.

## Transcript

[0:00] There's a story from 1947 about Padre Pio that starts with a man
[0:04] who looked like he was doing everything right.
[0:07] He was a well known Italian doctor and somebody who had
[0:10] helped countless patients. He gave generously and stayed
[0:13] faithful to the church. Kind of person who you'd
[0:16] probably point to as an example of a solid Catholic life.
[0:20] So when he traveled to San Giovanni Rotundo, these words
[0:26] guys. But when he traveled there to
[0:28] confess to Padre Pio, he came expecting to receive absolution
[0:34] like anybody else. But instead, Padre Pio refused
[0:37] him absolution with no explanation, no long correction,
[0:41] just refusal. The doctor left, confused.
[0:44] He came back the next day, and it happened again.
[0:47] And then again on the third day. Three refusals of absolution in
[0:52] a row. People around him, his friends
[0:54] and family, they didn't understand it, because Padre Pio
[0:57] was known for showing mercy to people with far worse and far
[1:01] more obvious sins. And yet this man who outwardly
[1:05] seemed faithful and generous was turned away each time.
[1:09] Well, Padre Pio was addressing wasn't something that was
[1:12] obvious on the surface. It wasn't the kind of sin that
[1:15] you can easily point to. He spoke often about something
[1:18] much quieter that can exist underneath very real and genuine
[1:22] devotion. He called it spiritual
[1:25] self-reliance. Not discipline, not consistency.
[1:28] Not taking your faith seriously, but that interior shift where
[1:32] you begin to trust your own effort as the thing that makes
[1:35] you acceptable to God, where your prayer life, your
[1:39] sacrifices, your consistency starts to feel like the reason
[1:43] that you can stand before Him instead of something that flows
[1:47] from depending on him. On the outside, everything still
[1:50] looks faithful, but underneath it, it becomes less about trust
[1:55] and more about control. You can actually see it in your
[1:58] own life. And I am guilty of this too.
[2:01] If you pay attention to certain moments when you've been
[2:04] consistent and praying, you've been disciplined, doing what
[2:07] you're supposed to do, and you feel very steady, almost like
[2:11] things are exactly how they should be or where they should
[2:13] be. And then the moment that that
[2:15] consistency slips, everything else feels off, like something
[2:19] broke between you and God. And I have to be honest, I think
[2:22] perhaps maybe potentially this is what I might have experienced
[2:27] Lent. I don't know if you guys saw a
[2:28] couple of those videos, but I was struggling big time during
[2:31] Lent. And I had this moment where I
[2:33] was like, but I'm praying, I'm reading, I'm this, I'm that, I'm
[2:38] where's God? Why did he leave me?
[2:40] That's how I felt. But you can kind of feel like
[2:44] something broke between you and God, even if what really changed
[2:48] is your sense of how well you've been doing.
[2:51] And that was literally my Lent. So this kind of thing, it shows
[2:54] up in confession where you feel the need to explain yourself
[2:58] instead of just being direct when you maybe soften things or
[3:02] add context or even mention the good alongside the bad.
[3:06] For me, again, I'm, I'm just being brutally honest today, but
[3:10] for me that looks like, well, I experienced some envy or
[3:14] jealousy and that turned into anger and resentment.
[3:16] But the reason I did that was because my husband and I have
[3:18] been trying to have more children and it's just really
[3:21] hard. And this person's doing IVF and
[3:23] this one's pregnant with her 10th baby.
[3:25] And no, I, I, I experience envy and jealousy and anger.
[3:31] That's where I need to stop. So that's kind of an example of
[3:34] that. But the reason that we're doing
[3:35] that kind of explaining a little bit is because we want to show
[3:38] the good side along with the bad.
[3:40] Like, well, I'm not that bad enough.
[3:41] Let me explain to you why I kind of fell into the sin.
[3:43] And that's, that's not right. It also shows up in how you
[3:47] think about sacrifice when you start to notice that maybe what
[3:51] you've given up or how much you've endured, how disciplined
[3:53] you've been. And then there's this quiet
[3:55] sense that, well, it should count for something, even if you
[3:58] never say it out loud. You're like, well, maybe that's
[4:00] a little time off purgatory or well, at least God knows I'm
[4:03] really faithful or devoted to him because I'm, I'm enduring
[4:06] this bad thing and that's not how it should go.
[4:09] And, and again, I'm guilty of all of these things.
[4:11] By the way, this is not me preaching from the pulpit here,
[4:15] but another way it shows up is in the frustration that you can
[4:18] experience when things don't go the way that you expected,
[4:20] especially when you feel like, well, I've been very faithful.
[4:23] I've been committed to my faith. I've been living out my faith.
[4:26] So why isn't this thing happening for me?
[4:28] And that also is not right, because underneath all of that
[4:32] is the assumption that our effort should lead to a certain
[4:36] outcome, and the outcome should be the one that we want, not
[4:39] God's will or what God desires for us.
[4:42] It also shows up in how uncomfortable it can feel to
[4:45] come before God with nothing to point to, no consistency, no
[4:49] strong prayer, no sense of doing well, just showing up honestly,
[4:53] as you are. So Padre Pio didn't treat this
[4:57] as something small or minute. He warned that it was actually
[5:00] one of the most dangerous places that a soul could be, because
[5:04] someone caught up in obvious sin usually knows that something is
[5:07] wrong and then eventually turns back.
[5:09] But somebody caught up in this, in this spiritual self-reliance,
[5:13] can feel secure, and that sense of security keeps them from
[5:17] fully surrendering. So when that doctor kept coming
[5:20] back, Padre Pio wasn't rejecting him.
[5:23] He was waiting. Waiting for the moment where the
[5:27] man stopped presenting his life like a record of achievements
[5:30] and came without anything else to lean on.
[5:33] On the 4th day the doctor returned.
[5:35] He knelt down and instead of listing what he had done, he
[5:38] simply admitted that he had nothing to offer and didn't even
[5:42] understand why he had been refused.
[5:44] And that was the moment the Padre Pio gave him absolution.
[5:47] Immediately what changed wasn't the doctor's actions, it was
[5:51] what he was relying on. The warning wasn't directed at
[5:55] the people who don't care about their faith, it was directed at
[5:58] the ones who do. The ones who pray and serve and
[6:02] try and stay consistent. Because the danger isn't in
[6:05] doing those things, it's in slowly trusting those things
[6:09] more than you trust God's mercy. Padre Pio wrote that the soul
[6:13] closest to God is the one with the longest list of sacrifices,
[6:17] but the one most aware of how little it can do without grace.
[6:20] Because at the end of it, God is not asking what you've built up.
[6:25] He's asking for what you're willing to surrender.
[6:28] That is all I have for today. Thank you guys so much for
[6:30] listening and I'll see you guys.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.