# The Mysterious Disappearance of Cindy Song

An episode of [Lazy Chill True Crime](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1815534472), 17 Sep 2025, 13 min.

Audio: https://traffic.megaphone.fm/APO6688012608.mp3

Join me as we discuss the mysterious case of Cindy Song. 👇 Youtube links: Lazy Chill True Crime Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC8dVJtzeHcJgd_Z0bHrJTHQ Lazy Chill History Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@LazyChillHistory Lazy Chill Zone Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@LazyChillZone 👇 Support My Work: 🛍️ Merch: https://lazy-chill-zone-shop.fourthwall.com ❤️ Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/lazychillzone 👇Social Media Links: https://www.instagram.com/lazychillzone/ 👇 Podcast links: ⚡History Video Podcast on Spotify⚡: https://open.spotify.com/show/7km5pLWpYWEj1mrPpEfRUr?si=0FHYnZf-Qs2FY1GyLevfig ⚡True Crime Podcast on Spotify⚡: https://open.spotify.com/show/0klIz08pAr7wR4we0Ia4sk?si=68qZxCeAQkysXzMZrHE0Iw 🍏 True Crime Podcast on Apple 🍎: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/lazy-chill-true-crime/id1815534472

## Transcript

[0:00] State College, PA on Halloween night 2001 was a town electric
[0:05] with the energy of a major university letting loose.
[0:09] For the thousands of students at Penn State, Halloween isn't just
[0:13] a holiday, it's an institution. And on that night, 21 year old
[0:19] Hyun Jiang Song, known to her friends as Cindy Song, was part
[0:24] of the celebration. Cindy was a bright and hard
[0:27] working student just months from graduation.
[0:30] She was juggling 2 part time jobs along with her studies, but
[0:34] she wasn't thinking about her responsibilities that night.
[0:38] That night was supposed to be all about fun.
[0:41] She and her friends had decided on a costume theme and Cindy was
[0:45] dressed as a Bunny. It was a simple, playful
[0:48] costume, and by the end of the night, it became the last known
[0:52] picture of her, a haunting symbol forever linked to the
[0:55] dark mystery that was about to unfold.
[1:00] The night began at Players Nightclub, a popular spot on
[1:04] West College Ave. where Cindy and her friends danced and
[1:08] socialized with other students. The party continued until around
[1:12] 2:00 that morning, at which point the group left the club
[1:16] and went to a friend's house to hang out for a while longer.
[1:20] At approximately 4:00 on the morning of November 1st, the
[1:24] Halloween festivities were finally over.
[1:27] A friend gave Cindy a ride back to her off campus apartment at
[1:31] the State College Park Apartments on W Clinton Ave.
[1:34] The car pulled up to the curb and Cindy got out in a small,
[1:39] seemingly insignificant decision.
[1:41] Her friend drove away without waiting to see her safely walk
[1:44] through her front door. That moment in the pre dawn
[1:48] quiet of a sleeping town was the vanishing point.
[1:53] It was the last time anyone is known to have seen Cindy Song
[1:56] alive, and the solid, verifiable timeline of her life ends right
[2:01] there on that sidewalk. For three days, there was
[2:06] complete radio silence from Cindy.
[2:09] Cindy didn't show up for her jobs, and she didn't answer her
[2:12] phone. Her friends, whose calls went
[2:14] unanswered, began to worry. Their concern grew into a quiet
[2:19] dread until on November 4th, they contacted the police and
[2:24] officially reported her missing. The news sent a shockwave
[2:29] through her community and reached her family in South
[2:31] Korea, who immediately flew to Pennsylvania to face a parent's
[2:35] worst nightmare. When the Ferguson Township
[2:40] police entered Cindy's apartment, they found a scene
[2:43] that was somehow both undisturbed and deeply
[2:46] disturbing. There were no signs of a
[2:49] struggle, no shattered windows or splintered door frame
[2:52] indicating a violent forced entry.
[2:55] Inside, her backpack was on the floor, where one might drop it
[2:59] after coming home. Her cell phone had been left
[3:02] behind, and on a surface lay the false eyelashes she had worn as
[3:07] part of her costume removed as if she were getting ready to
[3:10] wind down for the night. These details offered clear
[3:14] proof that Cindy had made it inside her apartment after being
[3:18] dropped off. But the scene also presented A
[3:23] fundamental contradiction. While her backpack and phone
[3:26] were there, her purse, which contained her wallet, credit
[3:30] cards, driver's license and keys, was gone.
[3:35] The items left behind suggested she had come home to stay, while
[3:39] the items that were missing suggested she had left again.
[3:44] The investigation was immediately Hanford by two
[3:47] critical losses of potential evidence, one a matter of bad
[3:50] luck and the other a tragic misunderstanding.
[3:54] Investigators theorized that Cindy, finding herself home
[3:58] after a night of drinking, might have decided to walk to a nearby
[4:01] 24 hour supermarket for a late night snack.
[4:05] It was a plausible idea, but by the time police went to the
[4:08] store to check, the window of opportunity had closed, the
[4:13] store's security camera system recorded on a loop, and the
[4:17] tapes from the morning of November 1st had already been
[4:20] recorded over. This routine activity erased
[4:23] what might have been the last images of Cindy or a potential
[4:27] abductor. Compounding this loss was a
[4:32] well-intentioned but devastating act.
[4:35] Shortly after the police conducted their initial search
[4:37] of the apartment, Cindy's grieving parents arrived.
[4:42] Unfamiliar with American law enforcement procedures and
[4:45] overwhelmed by their circumstances, they cleaned
[4:48] their daughter's apartment. In doing so, they potentially
[4:53] erased any subtle forensic clues that might have been left
[4:56] behind, as a forensic team had yet to go over the scene with a
[5:00] fine tooth comb. These two events, the erase
[5:04] tapes, and the clean department created an information vacuum in
[5:09] the crucial first 48 hours of the case.
[5:13] The trail went cold almost before the search had truly
[5:16] begun. With no physical evidence to
[5:20] guide them, investigators had to rely on tips.
[5:23] A few days into the investigation, a startling one
[5:27] came from nearly 200 miles away in Philadelphia.
[5:30] An eyewitness claimed to have seen a young woman who looked
[5:33] like Cindy in the city's Chinatown district.
[5:37] According to the witness, the woman was in a car with a man,
[5:42] visibly distressed, crying and yelling for help.
[5:47] The witness even provided a description of the man,
[5:50] described as being Asian and having a medium build, an olive
[5:54] to light brown complexion and medium length dark hair.
[5:59] This account was compelling enough for police to create a
[6:01] composite sketch, which was then circulated to the public.
[6:06] For a moment, it seemed like a major break, a tangible clue in
[6:11] a case that had none. Unfortunately, the promising
[6:17] lead soon dissolved under scrutiny.
[6:19] As police interviewed the eyewitness further, her story
[6:23] began to change and key details shifted, including the age of
[6:27] the woman who was seen. Investigators were ultimately
[6:31] unable to verify any part of her account, and the credibility of
[6:35] the tip collapsed. The consensus became that it was
[6:39] likely a tragic case of mistaken identity, or perhaps even
[6:44] someone who wanted to insert themselves into an investigation
[6:47] with a fake tip. Notably, this isn't that
[6:50] unlikely given that Cindy Song's disappearance had become quite a
[6:54] high profile case. For two years the case remained
[6:59] frozen until one day in 2003 when everything appeared to
[7:03] change. The break came from an unlikely
[7:06] source, a career criminal named Paul Weekly, who was facing
[7:10] felony charges and looking to make a deal.
[7:14] He told investigators A horrifying story involving 2 of
[7:17] his criminal pals. He claimed that Hugo Zelensky
[7:21] and Michael Krakowski had abducted and slain a young,
[7:24] attractive Asian woman from State College.
[7:28] Weekly's account included chilling details suggesting the
[7:32] men had kidnapped the woman and held her captive for a period
[7:35] before ultimately slaying her. For investigators who had
[7:39] nothing, this was the most significant lead they had ever
[7:42] received. Acting on Weekly's information,
[7:48] police from Centre County traveled to Lucerne County to
[7:50] execute a search warrant on Hugo Solinsky's six acre property.
[7:55] What they found there defied imagination, and it turned out
[7:58] the backyard was a clandestine cemetery.
[8:02] Investigators began unearthing human remains, some of which had
[8:06] been burned in a makeshift pit in an attempt to destroy
[8:10] evidence. Initially, 5 bodies were
[8:13] recovered, but a later grand jury report suggested the total
[8:16] number could be as high as 12. The discovery confirmed that
[8:21] Zelenski wasn't just a small time criminal, he was a
[8:24] monstrous and prolific serial predator.
[8:29] Weekly's credibility soared and the proof was right there,
[8:33] buried in these makeshift graves.
[8:36] Among the remains, police identified 2 of the individuals
[8:40] he had named, Michael Krakowski, one of Cindy's alleged
[8:44] abductors, and Krakowski's girlfriend Tammy Fassett.
[8:49] The discovery of this mass grave instantly made the story about a
[8:53] random college students abduction seemed terrifyingly
[8:56] plausible. Here, however, the case slams
[9:00] into its most enduring wall. While Weekly's testimony LED
[9:05] police to a mass grave and ultimately helped secure a 2015
[9:09] conviction against Hugo Zelensky for other slayings, there was
[9:13] one problem. Despite extensive searches of
[9:17] Zelensky's property, investigators found absolutely
[9:20] no evidence whatsoever related to Cindy Song.
[9:24] Furthermore, Weekly's motives and methods came under question.
[9:29] Investigators discovered that he had been extensively researching
[9:32] Cindy's case online before coming forward.
[9:36] This suggested he could have woven details of a famous
[9:39] unsolved disappearance into his true confessions to make his
[9:42] testimony more valuable. During Solinsky's trial, Weekly
[9:49] himself admitted on the stand that he had repeatedly lied to
[9:52] investigators in his initial interviews in an effort to
[9:55] minimize his own role in the crimes.
[9:58] This creates the central paradox of the Cindy Song case.
[10:02] Paul Weekly can't be entirely dismissed as a liar because his
[10:06] information led to the discovery of multiple victims.
[10:09] Yet he cannot be fully trusted because ultimately he's an
[10:13] admitted liar who researched the case and had a powerful
[10:17] incentive to fabricate parts of his story.
[10:22] This contradiction has left the investigation in a state of
[10:25] permanent limbo. Hugo Solinsky, now serving a
[10:29] life sentence, remains the primary person of interest, but
[10:33] without any direct evidence, the theory remains entirely
[10:37] unproven. While Cindy is officially still
[10:42] considered a missing person, she is presumed to have been slain
[10:46] despite her body never having been found.
[10:49] In 2013, a small measure of hope came through science when the
[10:54] authorities obtained DNA samples from Cindy's biological parents.
[10:59] Those samples were entered into national databases for missing
[11:02] persons and unidentified remains, a final desperate
[11:06] measure to find a match somewhere.
[11:10] Cindy's case file has never been closed, and her case remains an
[11:14] open and active investigation. Notably, her disappearance left
[11:18] such a mark on the community and the department that it was a key
[11:22] factor in the creation of a dedicated cold case task force.
[11:28] My theory on this one is simple. It wasn't Zelensky and Weekly
[11:33] lied to try to get a better deal.
[11:35] We know that Weekly was thoroughly researching Cindy's
[11:38] case prior to her disappearance. This wasn't just him confirming
[11:42] the facts, because he came to the cops and advised that
[11:46] Zelensky and his associate had slain a young Asian woman around
[11:50] that time. He tried to pass it off as if he
[11:53] knew nothing about Cindy's case, despite having fully researched
[11:57] all the public information prior to going to the authorities.
[12:03] My personal theory on this one is that this was a random
[12:06] abduction by a predatory stranger who was cruising the
[12:09] streets of a college town on Halloween night.
[12:13] While I can't prove it of course, this makes a lot more
[12:16] sense to me than the Zelensky theory since none of the hard
[12:19] evidence matches up with him. Hey everyone, Jimmy here.
[12:26] Just reminding you to hit the subscribe button and the
[12:29] notification bell and turn on all notifications.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.