# True Crime Cases So Twisted… They Shock Detectives | 278

An episode of [Lazy Chill True Crime](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1815534472), 18 Jul 2026, 46 min.

Audio: https://traffic.megaphone.fm/APO2618512152.mp3

Join me for some of the most chilling cold cases imaginable. Episode 278 of the true crime podcast btw. Also don't forget to follow, rate and share if you enjoy my content. 👇 Youtube links: Lazy Chill History Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@LazyChillHistory Lazy Chill Zone Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@LazyChillZone 👇 Support My Work: 🛍️ Merch: https://lazy-chill-zone-shop.fourthwall.com ❤️ Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/lazychillzone 👇Social Media Links: https://www.instagram.com/lazychillzone/ 👇 Podcast links: ⚡History Video Podcast on Spotify⚡: https://open.spotify.com/show/7km5pLWpYWEj1mrPpEfRUr?si=0FHYnZf-Qs2FY1GyLevfig ⚡True Crime Podcast on Spotify⚡: https://open.spotify.com/show/0klIz08pAr7wR4we0Ia4sk?si=68qZxCeAQkysXzMZrHE0Iw 🍏 True Crime Podcast on Apple 🍎: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/lazy-chill-true-crime/id1815534472 unsolved mysteries, true crime, cold cases, unsolved mysteries, missing persons, murder investigation, forensic evidence, serial killers, crime scene analysis, dark history, criminal psychology, real life horror, police investigations, DNA breakthroughs, forensic genealogy, crime documentaries, criminal profiling, mysterious disappearances, solved cases, justice system, law enforcement stories, cold case files, creepy mysteries, true crime storytelling, crime reconstruction, chilling cases, investigative reporting, modern forensics, victim advocacy, unidentified remains, crime scene forensics, disturbing cases, true crime analysis, hidden clues, infamous crimes, real crime stories, forensic evidence, serial killers, heists

## Transcript

[0:00] On the morning of June 19th, 2026, a park Ranger near
[0:04] Independence Hall in Philadelphia noticed a black BMW
[0:08] parked where it shouldn't have been.
[0:11] Then came a sound from inside the car, a woman's voice telling
[0:15] the man with her that he was going to hurt her.
[0:18] When officers asked the woman in the back seat for
[0:20] identification, she handed over a card bearing the name Blair
[0:25] Tonzelli. There were two problems with
[0:29] this situation. Blair Tonzelli had been missing
[0:32] for more than three years and the woman holding the card
[0:36] wasn't her. That piece of plastic would
[0:40] crack open one of the strangest missing persons investigations
[0:43] Philadelphia has seen in years. To understand why, we have to go
[0:48] back to a boarded up house in Olney.
[0:51] And to a woman the city had already forgotten.
[0:55] Blair Tanzelli attended Archbishop Ryan High School in
[0:58] Philly, according to her own Facebook page.
[1:01] Her mother passed away when Blair was 18, and sometime after
[1:05] that, Blair drifted from her family.
[1:08] By the time she vanished at 35, Tanzelli was estranged from her
[1:12] relatives, though she had a son she talked about often.
[1:17] By then, her world had narrowed to Kensington, the center of the
[1:20] city's opioid crisis. She struggled with addiction and
[1:25] cycled in and out of jail on a variety of charges related to
[1:29] her addiction. For a stretch, she lived in a
[1:32] house on Wensley Street with a friend named David McCarty, a
[1:36] man in his 70s, part of a circle of people on the outskirts of
[1:40] life that looked out for one another.
[1:43] Tonzelli carried a severe drug related wound that ran from her
[1:47] armpit down to her knee. McCarty said he changed the
[1:50] dressing and applied ointment twice a day and that she needed
[1:54] daily medication to keep the infection down.
[1:58] He'd lost count of the times he'd gotten her into a hospital,
[2:01] and he claimed that she couldn't survive without her medication.
[2:06] McCarty noticed that Tanzelli would vanish for stretches at a
[2:09] time, usually in the company of a man from Olney who sold pot.
[2:14] She told him she was going to visit someone named Raymond, and
[2:18] detectives came to believe he was almost certainly Raymond
[2:21] Horsch, better known as RC. He was a convicted drug dealer
[2:27] who lived in a twin house on West Shoe Ave. with his adult
[2:31] son, Eugene. The elder Horsch made his name
[2:35] producing disturbing adult films and novels, and his catalog was
[2:39] unsettling even by the loose standards of that industry.
[2:43] His work fixated on serial killers and the exploitation of
[2:48] women struggling with addiction, and he often cast women he found
[2:52] on the streets of Kensington. And to put it in some
[2:55] perspective on how prolific and widely known the elder Horsch
[2:58] was, he has a fairly substantial Wikipedia page dedicated to him.
[3:05] The house, for its part, had a significant history before
[3:08] Tanzeli ever set foot in it. Amy McHale, Ray Horsch's much
[3:13] younger ex-wife, was last seen at the West Shoe Ave. property
[3:16] in 2016. She was 44, a grandmother, and
[3:21] according to her daughter, she'd stayed close with her ex-husband
[3:24] after their divorce, possibly because he supplied her with
[3:28] dope. She's never been found.
[3:31] So by the time Blair started making trips to see a man named
[3:34] Raymond and Olney, that address had already been the site of the
[3:38] disappearance of one woman. McCarty stopped hearing from
[3:43] Tanzania after August 2022, but that didn't alarm anyone at
[3:47] first, since she'd gone quiet before and always resurfaced.
[3:52] Now, I don't claim to fully understand the link between
[3:55] these two, but for whatever reason, McCarty never reached
[3:59] out to report her missing. In February 2023, a friend named
[4:05] Joseph Gunkel and another acquaintance called police and
[4:09] reported her missing. A friend told officers she'd
[4:13] last been seen at the only home of a sketchy man who frightened
[4:16] her, and that she'd missed a meeting one afternoon.
[4:20] Nobody in her circle, which ran from Philly all the way down to
[4:23] Florida, had heard from her since.
[4:27] The federal missing persons database would eventually list
[4:30] her date of last contact as February 21st, 2023, though the
[4:36] people who knew her believed the real trail went cold months
[4:39] earlier. And then essentially nothing
[4:42] happened, and Gunkel said police never followed up with him.
[4:47] There was no search of the only house in connection with her
[4:50] case, and her mysterious disappearance attracted no
[4:53] public attention. Tanzelli was a woman with an
[4:57] addiction and a criminal record, missing from a neighborhood
[5:02] where people slip through the cracks every week, and her case
[5:05] sank without a ripple. Notably, her profile in the
[5:09] National Missing Persons Database wasn't created until
[5:13] late June 2026, more than three years after her friends 1st
[5:17] called police. The search of Eugene Horsch's
[5:21] BMW that morning got stranger by the minute.
[5:25] They reportedly found two weapons with obliterated serial
[5:28] numbers, plus coke, fent and weed.
[5:32] There was also a cattle prod, switchblades, handcuffs and a
[5:37] fake Drug Enforcement Administration badge featuring
[5:40] Eugene's own photo. The woman in the back seat told
[5:43] police that Eugene had made the fake ID in Tanzeli's name
[5:47] himself, and that he'd urged her to use it if she ever got into
[5:51] trouble. Eugene Horsch was jailed on
[5:54] firearms and drug charges, with bail set at half, $1,000,000,
[5:59] and federal prosecutors soon filed their own case.
[6:03] At least two women told detectives they believed
[6:05] something bad may have happened to Tonzelli, 1, described Eugene
[6:10] Horsch as a sociopath with a violent temper.
[6:13] He'd never been violent toward her personally, she said, but he
[6:16] talked in ways that suggested he'd hurt other people.
[6:19] He also once allegedly claimed he knew the three chemicals
[6:22] needed to melt remains and that he could reduce a body until it
[6:26] was small enough to flush down a toilet.
[6:29] The same woman said Tanzelli had worked in the horse house as a
[6:33] home health care aide, that she and Eugene had fallen out over
[6:37] money and that he still had access to a Cash app account in
[6:41] her name. Those statements gave local and
[6:45] federal investigators what they needed, and for more than a
[6:48] week, they worked through the boarded up house.
[6:51] Officers recovered several fake IDs in Tanzelli's name, along
[6:56] with her bank card, weapons, various substances, vats of
[7:01] unknown chemicals, and a 55 gallon drum.
[7:05] They also found urns that appeared to hold cremated
[7:08] remains, at least some apparently belonging to Horsh
[7:11] family members. There was also a multi page,
[7:15] unsigned handwritten letter that referenced Ted Bundy in a
[7:19] positive light. Investigators were reportedly
[7:23] weighing whether that letter was a confession or something less
[7:26] grounded in reality given the elder horses literary output.
[7:32] No remains turned up, but law enforcement sources described a
[7:36] significant amount of blood inside the house.
[7:39] They also announced that forensic testing to determine
[7:42] whose blood it was, or whether it was even human, would take
[7:46] weeks. Police prepared to excavate the
[7:49] front and back yards, and investigators reportedly
[7:53] examined the sewers beneath the block for traces of DNA
[7:56] evidence. Neighbors weren't exactly
[8:00] shocked, and they described a property that had curdled into
[8:03] an eyesore of boarded windows and security cameras.
[8:08] Notably, Eugene allegedly tried to aim one of those cameras at a
[8:12] neighbor's bathroom window, only removing it after a dispute.
[8:17] Two more details hang over all of this, and as you may have
[8:20] noticed, I've been speaking about Raymond in the past tense.
[8:24] The elder Horsch died inside the house in 2025 in his 80s, and
[8:30] Eugene's defense attorney has suggested that the disturbing
[8:33] items found there belong to the father.
[8:36] Notably, police had searched the same house about a year before
[8:40] the missing persons probe in an unrelated drug investigation
[8:44] without anything. So before I get into the
[8:48] theories of the case, it has to be said plainly that Eugene
[8:52] Horsch hasn't been charged with any crime connected to Blair at
[8:55] present. The first theory, which is very
[8:59] popular online, suggests that something happened to Tanzeli at
[9:03] the house on West Shoe Ave. Her documents were inside, her
[9:07] bank card was inside, and a man with access to her money
[9:11] allegedly talked about dissolving bodies.
[9:14] The blood evidence could turn this theory into a prosecution,
[9:18] but until the testing comes back, it remains circumstantial.
[9:23] The second theory is the one the defense gestures toward, that
[9:27] anything sinister in that house traces back to Raymond rather
[9:30] than to Eugene. The father had a well documented
[9:34] fixation on vulnerable women, to put it very mildly.
[9:39] There is, of course, the possibility that Blair passed
[9:41] away somewhere in Kensington unnoticed and unidentified. 1
[9:45] casualty among many of the opioid crisis.
[9:49] Since nobody entered her into the federal database until 2026,
[9:53] the odds of anyone connecting an unidentified woman to her name
[9:57] were slim to none. Given the number of John and
[10:00] Jane Doe's The Streets are sadly producing lately, I think this
[10:04] remains A distinct possibility. In 1995, a 20 year old rapper
[10:14] from Harlem recorded a warning about his own corner of the
[10:16] city. He told listeners that 100 39th
[10:20] St. and Lenox Ave. was the kind of place you didn't wander into
[10:24] after dark. Four years later, on that very
[10:28] block, somebody proved him right.
[10:32] At around 8:30 on a February evening, a car rolled down W
[10:37] 139th St. and someone inside put 9 bullets into him.
[10:43] The man police eventually arrested wasn't a stranger or an
[10:46] industry rival. He was a friend Big L had known
[10:50] since childhood, A man who reportedly appeared in the
[10:53] photos on the back cover of his debut album.
[10:57] Lamont Coleman was born on May 30th, 1974 in Harlem, the
[11:02] youngest of three boys raised by his mother Gilda Terry.
[11:07] His father, Charles Davis left the family while Lamont was
[11:10] still a child and his older half brothers, Donald and Leroy
[11:14] Phanasi helped fill that gap around the neighborhood.
[11:19] The boy following his brothers became known as Little LA name
[11:23] that would be reworked slightly as he grew up.
[11:26] When Lamont was young, his older brother Donald took him to see
[11:30] Run DMC at the Beacon Theatre. According to Donald, the show
[11:35] hit his little brother like a lightning strike and by the age
[11:38] of 12, Lamont was already impressing people with his
[11:41] freestyle raps. He started writing rhymes
[11:44] seriously around 1990 and put together a short lived group
[11:48] with two friends, though it fell apart before releasing anything.
[11:53] In his final interview, he looked back on those years and
[11:57] described a kid who verbally battled anybody who'd take him
[11:59] on rhyming on street corners and in school hallways.
[12:04] He took the opportunity to grab the microphone at every house
[12:07] party and block party that would let him and show off his lyrical
[12:10] prowess. What mattered to him most was
[12:14] that people on the block had stopped saying Little L and
[12:17] started calling him Big L because everyone thought he was
[12:21] going to be big time one day. The real break came in the
[12:26] summer of 1990 at a record shop on 125th St.
[12:31] Lord Finesse, A Bronx rapper with a growing reputation, was
[12:35] signing autographs when a teenager stepped up and asked to
[12:38] rhyme for him. And while you may not know the
[12:41] name, he's the rapper who was sampled on Fat Boy Slim's 1998
[12:46] mega hit, The Rockefeller Skank. But I digress.
[12:50] Finesse listened, was impressed enough to swap phone numbers,
[12:55] and before long the kid from 139th St. had been pulled into
[12:59] Finesse's circle, which included Fat Joe.
[13:03] In 1992, L had already made his first appearance on an album the
[13:08] same year he graduated from high school.
[13:11] That same year he also won an amateur freestyle rap battle
[13:15] competition, beating out 2000 other contestants from around
[13:19] New York City. Big L quickly built a reputation
[13:23] as a specialist, the kind of rapper other rappers studied,
[13:27] even if he wasn't a household name.
[13:30] His style stacked multi syllable rhymes into dense, vicious
[13:34] couplets, each one landing like a jab, and he delivered all of
[13:39] it in a cool way that made the word play hit even harder.
[13:43] Legendary rapper Nas later admitted that hearing Elle on
[13:47] tape scared him because he couldn't imagine having to
[13:51] compete with someone rhyming at that level.
[13:54] Now, I'm no historian of hip hop by any means, but my
[13:58] understanding is this is about the highest theoretical praise a
[14:01] rapper could hope to achieve from a fellow artist.
[14:05] Columbia Records signed him in 1993, and his first promotional
[14:09] single, Devil's Son, was dark enough that he later described
[14:13] it as one of the earliest horror core records.
[14:17] His debut album, Lifestyles of the Poor and Dangerous, arrived
[14:21] in March 1995, with its cover shot right on his home corner of
[14:27] 139th and Lennox. The album is also notable
[14:31] because it featured a young Jay-Z on a track as well, and
[14:35] that connection to Jay-Z would be important going forward.
[14:39] Two of its singles cracked the top 25 of the rap charts, and
[14:42] the album eventually sold over 200,000 copies.
[14:46] But it wasn't a commercial smash by Columbia's standards.
[14:50] In early 1996, Columbia dropped him over creative differences,
[14:55] and Elle later said he'd felt surrounded by strangers who
[14:59] didn't understand his music. What may have snuffed out the
[15:03] career of other musicians became fuel for Elle, and he founded
[15:07] his own label and released a single called Ebonics that
[15:11] became an underground sensation. The hip hop press ranked it
[15:15] among the best independent releases of the year, and the
[15:18] industry took notice all over again.
[15:21] Damon Dash, the CEO of Rockefeller Records, offered him
[15:26] a deal, and Jay-Z later confirmed to MTV that signing L
[15:31] had essentially been finished business.
[15:34] In the words of Jay-Z, it was a done deal, halted only by what
[15:38] happened next, because L refused to sign on alone.
[15:43] He had a few friends who had been with him through the
[15:45] troubles with Columbia, and he wanted them signed along with
[15:48] him as part of a group he'd lead called the Wolfpack.
[15:53] Little did L know, he only had one week left and no deal would
[15:58] ever actually be inked. On the evening of February 15th,
[16:03] 1999, Big L was on his home block near 45 W 139th St. the
[16:10] same stretch of Harlem he'd grown up on and rhymed about.
[16:14] At around 8:30 PM, according to the police account, a vehicle
[16:18] came down the street and a gunman opened fire.
[16:21] L was struck 9 times in the face and chest, and by the time he
[16:24] was transported to the hospital, he was already gone.
[16:29] He was cut down in the middle of what he called the Danger Zone,
[16:33] the corner he'd immortalized on his debut album, steps from the
[16:37] building where he'd been raised. It's the kind of coincidence an
[16:41] editor would reject AS2 on the nose.
[16:44] He'd rapped for years in his darkest register about death,
[16:48] stalking those streets, and in the end, it found him exactly
[16:52] where he said it would. The reaction in the hip hop
[16:56] community was immediate grief for the loss of a talent that
[17:01] was genuinely admired by other legendary rappers.
[17:05] This was roughly 2 1/2 years after Tupac Shakur passed, and
[17:09] just under two years after Biggie and now a third gifted
[17:13] rapper in his 20s had been gunned down.
[17:16] The loss carried an extra sting because unlike Tupac and Biggie,
[17:21] L hadn't been at the center of any publicized feud.
[17:25] There was no coastal dispute for the media to blame this time,
[17:28] and no obvious enemy waiting in the wings of the narrative.
[17:32] Whatever this was, it seemed like it had come from somewhere
[17:36] much closer to home. Three months later, in May 1999,
[17:42] detectives arrested Gerard Woodley, a man from the same
[17:45] neighborhood who'd known Elle since they were kids.
[17:48] From the beginning, the police theory wasn't really about Elle
[17:52] at all. A department spokesperson said
[17:55] publicly that the shooting was quite possibly retaliation for
[17:58] something L's brother had done, or for something Woodley
[18:02] believed he'd done. That brother was Leroy Finazzi,
[18:07] known around Harlem as Bigley, a man with serious St. ties who
[18:11] was sitting in prison when L was shot.
[18:14] The case never made it to trial, and the Manhattan District
[18:17] attorney's office reportedly concluded it lacked sufficient
[18:20] witnesses tying Woodley to the shooting.
[18:24] Woodley walked, maintaining his innocence, and the investigation
[18:28] calcified into a cold case. Then the people closest to the
[18:33] case started slowly, meeting violent ends, one by one.
[18:38] In March 2002, Big Lee was fatally shot in Harlem,
[18:43] reportedly just two blocks from where his little brother had
[18:45] been cut down three years earlier.
[18:49] Accounts from the neighborhood suggest that in the time before
[18:51] his passing, Lee had been pressing for information about
[18:55] who was behind Elle's shooting. This raises the obvious and
[18:59] unanswerable question of whether he found it, or whether someone
[19:02] thought he was coming a bit too close to the truth. 14 years
[19:07] after that, on the night of June 23rd, 2016, Gerard Woodley was
[19:14] shot in the head outside his home on West 139th St.
[19:19] No one was arrested, and investigators indicated at the
[19:23] time that they didn't believe it was connected to the Big L case,
[19:27] but couldn't say for certain. Whatever Woodley knew about
[19:31] February 15th, 1999, whether it was everything or nothing, went
[19:37] to the grave with him. Nobody else has ever been
[19:41] arrested. And the file on Lamont Coleman,
[19:44] the man the world knew as Big L, stays open with the NYPD to this
[19:49] day. There's a bitter irony of the
[19:53] Big L story. Commercially, he became A star
[19:57] only after he was deceased. His second album, The Big
[20:01] Picture, had been left unfinished at his death, and his
[20:05] manager assembled it from completed songs and unused A
[20:08] cappella recordings. Other big names in the hip hop
[20:13] industry were brought on to help complete the album.
[20:16] Released on August 1st, 2000, it debuted at #13 on the Billboard
[20:22] 200, moved over 72,000 copies in its first week, and was
[20:27] certified gold within months. The single Flamboyant reached
[20:31] number one on the rap chart, the only chart Topper of his career
[20:35] achieved more than a year after his death.
[20:39] In the years since, the tributes kept coming as Big L's technical
[20:43] proficiency came to be appreciated even more in the
[20:46] industry. Eminem honored him in the 2004
[20:50] video for Like Toy Soldiers, where his face appears in the
[20:53] closing memorial alongside hip hop's fallen.
[20:57] Jay-Z spoke publicly about what might have been had L survived,
[21:02] saying that hip hop in the 2000s may have looked completely
[21:05] different. Successive generations of
[21:08] artists cited him as the sharpest pen of his era, and
[21:12] critics have routinely placed him among the most technically
[21:15] gifted lyricist the genre has produced.
[21:18] So in the end, we're left with the question of who ended Big
[21:22] L's life and why. Nearly 3 decades on, there are
[21:27] several competing answers, and none of them has ever been
[21:30] proven. The first is the police theory
[21:33] of a proxy retaliation, and it seems to be the one they still
[21:37] prefer till this day. In this version, Woodley or
[21:41] someone aligned with him had a grievance against Big Lee, who
[21:44] was largely untouchable behind prison walls, so that debt was
[21:48] collected from the brother who was reachable on the block.
[21:52] According to this theory, the nine shots to the face and chest
[21:56] suggest rage and a personal message rather than a random
[22:01] drive by. The weakness is equally plain,
[22:05] since ultimately there's no evidence that Woodley was
[22:08] involved. Woodley endured 17 years of side
[22:12] eye from a neighborhood that never stopped whispering and
[22:15] then met an ending identical to the one he was accused of
[22:18] delivering. Some see that as retribution
[22:22] finally arriving, and others see an ordinary cycle of
[22:25] neighborhood violence that proves nothing about 1999.
[22:30] What I'll say is that if it was some sort of payback, it was
[22:33] remarkably patient, especially since Woodley's whereabouts
[22:37] weren't exactly unknown during this period.
[22:41] I'd also like to challenge the idea that Bigley was somehow
[22:44] untouchable in prison. Prison is an incredibly
[22:47] dangerous place, and gangland hits on the outside get ordered
[22:52] from inside prison, and hits from the outside get carried out
[22:55] on the inside too. Nothing suggests that Big Lee
[22:59] was in any sort of protective custody or anything, so he may
[23:02] have been even easier to eliminate in prison if this was
[23:05] true. Another possibility is mistaken
[23:09] identity in the most literal sense that the shooter wanted
[23:13] another target entirely. Investigators reportedly
[23:17] considered early on that L may not have been the intended
[23:20] victim, and in a night time drive by on a dark block, that
[23:24] reading is hard to dismiss. Ultimately, this was a street
[23:28] corner that was so notorious for violence that Elle himself had
[23:32] immortalized the danger posed by it.
[23:35] And then there's the theory that it may have been someone else
[23:38] who was close to Elle, someone who perhaps felt jealous of his
[23:42] success. Elle was currently in the
[23:45] process of signing to Rockefeller, and he brought
[23:48] along some of the people who had been with him while he was at
[23:51] his lowest point. It's possible that someone close
[23:55] to his inner circle felt that they were left out and chose to
[23:58] resort to violence as a result. Envy is one of the most
[24:02] universally understood causes of violent crimes like this since
[24:07] time immemorial. It's a motive that would be
[24:10] equally understood by the ancient Greek poet Homer or a
[24:15] Pulp Fiction writer of the 20th century.
[24:18] This theory is supported by the fact that L took nine shots that
[24:21] night, since this suggests a serious degree of personal
[24:25] animosity towards him. Another theory suggests that he
[24:29] was hit due to his own criminal involvement, but having looked
[24:33] into it, there's little evidence to support this.
[24:37] L was involved in low level St. crime in his youth and by his
[24:41] own admission he had spent some time dealing drugs.
[24:45] However, by the time of his shooting, there was no
[24:48] indication that he had any personal involvement with the
[24:51] criminal underworld. He knew people who were
[24:53] involved, of course, which brings us back to the theory
[24:56] involving his brother. But that's different from
[24:59] personal involvement. Ultimately, I don't think we'll
[25:02] ever get a clear answer to what happened to Big L Someone knows
[25:06] what happened, but whoever it is hasn't talked.
[25:09] And if it was Woodley, he took the truth with him to the grave.
[25:17] On a Saturday night in October 2002, a man fired a single shot
[25:21] on a dark Maryland road and walked away without taking a
[25:24] thing. He chose the one month in modern
[25:27] American history when a shooting in the Washington suburbs would
[25:31] be blamed almost automatically on somebody else.
[25:36] Whether that was coincidence or calculation is a question nobody
[25:40] has ever managed to answer. Irina Hans was 26 years old, and
[25:46] she'd been in Washington, DC, for all of five weeks.
[25:50] She was born in Ukraine and trained as an art historian, and
[25:54] what she wanted more than anything was to become a museum
[25:57] curator. That ambition carried her a long
[26:00] way from home, and it took her first to the University of
[26:03] Missouri, where she earned a master's degree, and then to the
[26:07] capital itself. She'd landed a prestigious
[26:11] internship at the Smithsonian American Art Museum, and for a
[26:15] young curator in training, it doesn't get much better than
[26:19] that. The Smithsonian is the kind of
[26:22] name that opens every door that comes after it in the museum
[26:26] world, a dream job for someone like her.
[26:30] She'd been at the museum for barely a month, but it was the
[26:33] job she'd spent her whole education working toward.
[26:37] She made the move alone, and her husband, Jason Hans, stayed
[26:41] behind in Missouri, where he was starting an academic career of
[26:44] his own. The two had been married for
[26:47] five years, and they'd recently collected master's degrees from
[26:51] the same university. Money was tight, so they did the
[26:55] long distance thing and kept in touch by phone while she chased
[26:58] the internship that was supposed to launch her career.
[27:01] That tight budget mattered in one specific way The housing
[27:05] arena could afford sat in a neighborhood in Prince George's
[27:08] County, Maryland, just outside the district line.
[27:12] That was an area that her husband would later describe as
[27:15] something less than safe. She seems to have known it, too,
[27:19] since she carried a can of Mace when she walked shortly before
[27:24] her death. She'd been awarded a $5000
[27:27] scholarship, and the plan was to use that money to move somewhere
[27:31] better. But she never got the chance.
[27:35] When police found her, she was lying just a couple 100 yards
[27:38] from the temporary home. She was preparing to leave as
[27:40] soon as possible. October 12th, 2002.
[27:45] Fell on a Saturday and Arena spent the evening at a National
[27:49] Symphony Orchestra concert. When it ended, she made her way
[27:54] home on the Metro, riding out to Branch Ave. at the end of the
[27:58] Green Line, the closest stop to where she was staying.
[28:02] The station had opened only the year before, and it sat among
[28:06] commuter lots and quiet residential streets.
[28:09] From there, she walked. It was late, and the entire
[28:13] region had spent 10 days being warned that a sniper was at
[28:16] large. Around 11:00 that night, on an
[28:20] isolated road near her home, a single gunshot ended the walk
[28:25] and she was struck once in the head.
[28:28] Investigators would later conclude that she fell exactly
[28:31] where she was hit, that there was no sign of any struggle, and
[28:35] that she almost certainly never saw her attacker coming.
[28:39] A neighbor heard the shot, but nobody, as far as police could
[28:44] ever determine, saw the man come or go.
[28:47] A patrol officer canvassing the area found her body and her
[28:52] backpack, held her cash, her credit cards, and her driver's
[28:56] license all untouched. Whoever fired that shot hadn't
[29:01] come for her money, and he hadn't stayed one second longer
[29:04] than he needed to. Back in Missouri, Jason Hans had
[29:08] missed a call from his wife earlier that evening because
[29:11] he'd fallen asleep watching football.
[29:14] In the early hours of the morning, 2 police officers
[29:17] knocked on his door. Detectives in Maryland had asked
[29:20] a local department to deliver the news in person rather than
[29:24] over a phone line, which is standard practice for a death
[29:27] notification. Jason's first assumption was
[29:31] that something was going on in the building and it didn't occur
[29:34] to him that the knock had anything to do with Arena.
[29:38] To fully understand what happened next, you have to
[29:41] remember what October 2002 felt like in the Capital area.
[29:46] On the evening of October 2nd, a program analyst named James
[29:50] Martin was shot in a grocery store parking lot in Wheaton,
[29:53] MD. The next day, five more people
[29:56] were shot down while doing errands no more dangerous than
[30:00] pumping gas, mowing a lawn, or sitting on a bench.
[30:04] The Beltway snipers, later identified as John Allen
[30:08] Muhammad and 17 year old Lee Boyd Malvo, would cut down 10
[30:13] innocent people across Maryland, Virginia and DC schools
[30:19] cancelled outdoor recess, gas stations hung tarp so customers
[30:23] couldn't be seen from the road, and people crouched behind their
[30:27] cars while they filled the tank. For weeks, the entire region
[30:31] haunted a phantom white box truck that turned out not to
[30:35] exist. The actual shooters moved
[30:38] through the area in a battered blue Chevy Caprice with a firing
[30:42] hole cut into the trunk. The timing of Arena's death sat
[30:46] right in the middle of it. And the day before she was shot,
[30:50] a man named Kenneth Bridges had been shot at a gas station near
[30:53] Fredericksburg, VA, 2 days after an FBI analyst named Linda
[30:59] Franklin would be shot in a Home Depot parking garage in Falls
[31:03] Church. So when the report came in of a
[31:06] young woman shot in the head on a Prince George's County St.,
[31:09] the response was enormous. By her husband's account second
[31:14] hand, from what he heard from cops, more than 100 law
[31:18] enforcement officers descended on the area, fearing the snipers
[31:22] had claimed their ninth life. The Sergeant who worked her case
[31:26] would later say that at 1st, every pattern from the other
[31:30] sniper shootings seemed to fit for the first few months.
[31:36] This would be the theory of the case that detectives would work
[31:39] with to the exclusion of all others, but investigators
[31:43] unwound that theory quickly once they actually started looking at
[31:47] the forensics. The caliber was wrong, the
[31:50] weapon was wrong, and the method didn't fit.
[31:54] It was noted that the snipers shot people in busy public
[31:57] places because they wanted their victims found and the fear
[32:00] broadcast. Irina was shot at 11 at night on
[32:05] an empty Rd. with no one around to see it, which is the
[32:09] signature of someone who wanted the opposite.
[32:13] By early 2003, forensic testing on the bullet had confirmed what
[32:18] detectives already believed, that the attack was almost
[32:21] certainly unrelated. That ruling brought a cruel side
[32:25] effect because it meant that her case functionally hadn't been
[32:29] investigated at all. It had been caught up in the
[32:33] manhunt for the Beltway snipers, meaning that for the crucial
[32:37] first months, it was assumed that when the two were caught,
[32:41] Irina's case was resolved. With the sniper theory buried,
[32:46] detectives had to start over and rebuild the case around Arena
[32:49] herself, her movements, her habits, and the people who'd
[32:53] crossed her path. After months had passed, what
[32:58] they were left with was close to nothing, and there were no
[33:01] eyewitnesses at all. The only person who registered
[33:05] the crime as it happened was a neighbor who heard the shot,
[33:08] what investigators call an ear witness.
[33:12] The scene gave up no DNA and no fingerprints that could point
[33:16] the cops in the right direction. As for motive, robbery was off
[33:21] the table since her valuables never left her backpack.
[33:26] Perhaps unsurprisingly, Arena's own personal life turned up no
[33:30] relevant history whatsoever, which tracks given that she was
[33:34] a bookish, aspiring museum curator.
[33:37] She had no criminal record, no feuds, and absolutely no
[33:41] connection whatsoever to anything dangerous, perhaps
[33:45] beyond her neighborhood. Now, I know some of you will be
[33:49] saying what about the husband and detectives did their due
[33:53] diligence on Jason Hands. He was in Missouri when his wife
[33:58] was shot hundreds of miles away, and a background investigation
[34:02] turned up nothing that connected him to it.
[34:06] Everyone agreed that there was no marital turmoil at all and
[34:10] his finances were investigated for any unusual activity, but
[34:14] nothing ever turned up. The police confirmed that he was
[34:18] ruled out very quickly and he was never considered a suspect
[34:22] at any point in the investigation.
[34:25] That left exactly 1 thread. About 3 weeks before the
[34:30] shooting, a man in the neighborhood had approached
[34:33] Arena and tried to ask her out. This was an encounter that
[34:37] reportedly left her deeply unsettled, since the man was
[34:41] very aggressive. When detectives canvassed the
[34:44] area, they found that the same man had approached practically
[34:48] every young woman in the neighborhood trying to get their
[34:51] phone numbers. None of them described him as
[34:54] violent or explicitly threatening, but he was
[34:58] extremely persistent in a way that was implicitly aggressive.
[35:03] Police named him a person of interest and then ran into a
[35:06] wall because absolutely nobody could tell them who he was.
[35:10] He was never identified at the time, and more than two decades
[35:14] later he still hasn't been. No description of the man has
[35:19] ever been released, at least not that I could locate, which seems
[35:23] like a major oversight on the part of investigators.
[35:28] One of the most prominent theories suggests that the
[35:31] unknown man was responsible. He fixated on local women.
[35:35] He'd approached Arena directly, and the encounter alarmed her
[35:39] more than a simple, unwanted advance usually would.
[35:42] If he took her rejection badly, he had proximity, familiarity
[35:47] with the streets she walked, and a reason to know her routine.
[35:51] Detectives clearly took him seriously, since they tracked
[35:54] down other women in the area who dealt with him.
[35:57] However, nothing on record suggests that he was ever
[36:00] outwardly violent, and there's a long distance from being a creep
[36:04] to the crime that occurred. Another hangs on the events that
[36:09] were going on, and it essentially suggests that
[36:12] someone in Arena's life wanted to use sniper attacks as a
[36:15] smokescreen. If someone wanted a person gone,
[36:18] the sniper panic offered ready made cover, and while nothing
[36:22] but the timing supports this theory, the timing is hard to
[36:26] ignore. And then there's the bleakest
[36:29] possibility that it was purely random, a shooter with no motive
[36:34] beyond the ACT itself who crossed paths with a malevolent
[36:38] stranger. This theory assumes that the
[36:41] attacker simply used the panic as cover to shoot a random
[36:44] person. Truly, random attacks are the
[36:48] rarest kind on paper, but they're also the ones that leave
[36:52] cold case files looking exactly like this one.
[36:55] It would explain why no connection to Arena has ever
[36:58] surfaced, and it's also the version detectives can do the
[37:01] least with from a practical standpoint.
[37:07] Hey everyone, it's Jimmy with my usual quick reminder to ring the
[37:10] notification bell and turn on all notifications.
[37:14] Also, don't forget to hit that share button and send this video
[37:17] to your friends and family members who enjoy true crime
[37:20] content and mysteries. Within a day or two of a 14 year
[37:27] old vanishing from a Navy base in South Carolina, someone
[37:31] working at a nearby construction site came across clothes lying
[37:34] along a road. It was a brown and white striped
[37:37] shirt and a pair of white pants dropped 5 or 10 feet apart.
[37:42] They weren't torn and there wasn't a drop of blood on them
[37:45] or anything to suggest foul play.
[37:48] They matched what Kevin Mcclam had been wearing when his mother
[37:51] said goodnight to him around 1:00 in the morning.
[37:54] He'd been at home playing video games three days shy of his 15th
[37:59] birthday, and the last thing he told his mother was that he
[38:03] wanted to keep playing. Kevin was born in Indianapolis,
[38:08] IN on April 2nd, 1982. His stepfather served in the
[38:13] United States Navy, which meant packing up and relocating
[38:17] whenever new orders came through.
[38:19] By 1997, they'd landed in base housing at the Charleston Naval
[38:24] Weapons Station, a sprawling installation on the edge of
[38:28] Goose Creek, SC, just north of Charleston.
[38:32] Kevin lived there with his mother, Tracy, his stepfather,
[38:36] and his younger sister. He was an eighth grader at
[38:40] Merrington Middle School who kept a tight circle of friends
[38:43] and spent his free time playing basketball or video games.
[38:48] He was shy, got good grades, and had never run away or been in
[38:52] trouble. His mother later emphasized 2
[38:55] details that stuck with investigators.
[38:59] Kevin never missed a meal with his family and he was always
[39:02] home before dark. Whatever happened on the night
[39:05] of March 29th, 1997, it wasn't part of any wider pattern in his
[39:10] behavior. That Saturday night, Tracy
[39:14] Mcclam came home to find Kevin and his little sister up late
[39:18] playing video games. The three of them sat and talked
[39:22] for a while, and around 1:00 in the morning, now technically the
[39:26] early hours of Easter Sunday, March 30th, Tracy and her
[39:30] daughter headed to bed. Kevin said he wanted to stay up
[39:33] a little longer with the game, and that conversation was the
[39:37] family's last confirmed contact with him.
[39:41] When the household woke up later that morning, Kevin was gone.
[39:45] There was no sign of forced entry and no indication of any
[39:49] struggle inside the home. Nothing appeared disturbed.
[39:53] He'd simply left or been drawn out sometime between 1:00 AM and
[39:58] sunrise from a house on a military base.
[40:02] Tracy's best guess was that her son had snuck out to meet his
[40:05] friends, maybe for the first time in his life, and it would
[40:10] have explained a lot. She figured that he was getting
[40:14] at the age where kids tend to do those sort of things.
[40:17] So she reached out to the families of his friends to
[40:21] confirm. The problem was that when she
[40:24] reached out, every single one of Kevin's friends denied seeing
[40:28] him that night or even having any late night plans.
[40:33] The first physical evidence surfaced within two days.
[40:36] Some accounts say March 31st and others April 1st.
[40:40] When Kevin's clothing turned up at a construction site near his
[40:43] home, the striped shirt and white pants he'd been wearing
[40:47] lay scattered along the road. The items separated by roughly 5
[40:51] to 10 feet, and they were reportedly covered in spray
[40:54] paint. The clothes showed no evidence
[40:57] of any form of struggle, and there were no rips or cuts and
[41:02] no blood. If something terrible had
[41:05] happened to Kevin, his clothing didn't record it.
[41:09] Then, around the same time, there were the sightings of a
[41:12] boy who looked like Kevin. During the afternoon of March
[41:17] 30th, technically the same day Kevin disappeared, witnesses
[41:21] reported seeing a person matching his description.
[41:26] He was walking along a dirt road near a construction site, and
[41:29] the figure was wearing only boxer shorts and sneakers.
[41:33] He appeared to be alone, uninjured, and under no visible
[41:37] duress beyond his odd dress. Two additional witnesses
[41:42] reportedly saw someone who looked like Kevin at the
[41:44] McDonald's on the base, once on March 31st and again on April
[41:49] 1st, alone both times. If those witnesses really saw
[41:55] Kevin, he was alive and moving around the base for up to two
[41:59] days after he left the house. The initial investigation
[42:04] produced plenty of motion and no answers.
[42:07] Kevin was classified as an endangered missing person, and
[42:11] over the years, investigators reportedly chased sightings as
[42:14] far away as Florida and California.
[42:17] In 1998, the family left South Carolina, eventually settling in
[42:22] Georgia and leaving the base and the unanswered question behind
[42:26] them. For eight years, that was where
[42:30] things stood. And then, in May 2005, a
[42:34] television station out of Columbia aired a fresh story
[42:38] about the case as part of a series on Unresolved Mysteries.
[42:43] Credible tips started arriving, and agents with the Naval
[42:47] Criminal Investigative Service later acknowledged that the
[42:50] broadcast played a real role in what happened next.
[42:54] In January 2006, NCIS staged a news conference on a basketball
[43:00] court described as one of the last places Kevin was reported
[43:04] seen. A special agent announced that
[43:06] the case was no longer a missing persons investigation and that
[43:10] they believed that Kevin had met with foul play.
[43:14] The agent said publicly that someone was lying, that someone
[43:19] knew more about Kevin's disappearance than they'd
[43:21] admitted. According to investigators, new
[43:25] forensic evidence suggested Kevin may have known the person
[43:28] responsible for whatever happened to him.
[43:31] The agency committed serious resources to Kevin's file,
[43:35] hoping to resolve the case once and for all.
[43:39] A cold case unit from Washington, DC was assigned to
[43:42] stay in the Charleston area until the case closed and a
[43:46] reward was offered for information leading to a
[43:48] conviction. One agent told reporters the
[43:51] unit had built its reputation solving cases other people
[43:55] considered unsolvable, a claim that would sadly not come true
[43:58] here. In October 2006, investigators
[44:03] conducted a search for Kevin's remains in the Goose Creek area,
[44:07] but they found nothing. Then in December 2006 came the
[44:13] name that everyone thought meant the case would be wrapping up
[44:16] shortly. Investigators publicly
[44:20] identified 26 year old Thomas McArdle as one of three suspects
[44:24] in Kevin's case. McArdle was already behind bars
[44:28] on an unrelated robbery conviction and he would have
[44:31] been a teenager himself back in 1997.
[44:35] Investigators told reporters they weren't releasing the other
[44:38] suspects names, but expected more arrests within a month.
[44:43] However, those arrests never came, and the second name that
[44:47] eventually surfaced was Michael Moorcroft.
[44:51] He was a man who had allegedly bragged that he and McArdle were
[44:54] responsible for ending Kevin's life.
[44:57] Moorcroft later insisted he'd made the whole story up,
[45:01] attempting to win some sort of disturbing accolades from his
[45:04] friends. Investigators brought cadaver
[45:07] dogs to his childhood home, where the animals alerted to the
[45:11] possible scent of human remains beneath a shed.
[45:14] Police dug up the yard and found nothing of interest whatsoever.
[45:18] Neither Moorcroft nor McArdle was ever charged with anything
[45:22] connected to Kevin, and the case that was supposed to close
[45:25] within weeks of the announcement never closed at all.
[45:30] Right now, our best guess as to what happened to Kevin is the
[45:33] vague theory Detective settled on.
[45:36] Under that framework, Kevin met with foul play at the hands of
[45:40] someone he knew, possibly other teenagers from the area.
[45:44] Unfortunately though, as of yet, there's been insufficient
[45:48] evidence to actually charge anyone in this case.
[45:51] Personally, I think this is a case that needs a lot more
[45:54] attention, and with the right amount of publicity I think it
[45:57] could be solved. Someone out there knows what
[46:00] happened to Kevin and they've been keeping it a secret for
[46:02] years.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.