# 1 Hour of Unsolved Cold Cases Detectives Struggle With | 176

An episode of [Lazy Chill True Crime](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1815534472), 3 Feb 2026, 1 h 02 min.

Audio: https://traffic.megaphone.fm/APO5854911225.mp3

Don't forget to follow and turn on all notifications. Also don't forget to drop a rating as well and check out Lazy Chill Zone and Lazy Chill True Crime on Youtube. Episode 176 of the true crime podcast btw. 👇 Youtube links: Lazy Chill True Crime Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC8dVJtzeHcJgd_Z0bHrJTHQ Lazy Chill History Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@LazyChillHistory Lazy Chill Zone Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@LazyChillZone 👇 Support My Work: 🛍️ Merch: https://lazy-chill-zone-shop.fourthwall.com ❤️ Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/lazychillzone 👇Social Media Links: https://www.instagram.com/lazychillzone/ 👇 Podcast links: ⚡History Video Podcast on Spotify⚡: https://open.spotify.com/show/7km5pLWpYWEj1mrPpEfRUr?si=0FHYnZf-Qs2FY1GyLevfig ⚡True Crime Podcast on Spotify⚡: https://open.spotify.com/show/0klIz08pAr7wR4we0Ia4sk?si=68qZxCeAQkysXzMZrHE0Iw 🍏 True Crime Podcast on Apple 🍎: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/lazy-chill-true-crime/id1815534472 unsolved mysteries, true crime, cold cases, unsolved mysteries, missing persons, murder investigation, forensic evidence, serial killers, crime scene analysis, dark history, criminal psychology, real life horror, police investigations, DNA breakthroughs, forensic genealogy, crime documentaries, criminal profiling, mysterious disappearances, solved cases, justice system, law enforcement stories, cold case files, creepy mysteries, true crime storytelling, crime reconstruction, chilling cases, investigative reporting, modern forensics, victim advocacy, unidentified remains, crime scene forensics, disturbing cases, true crime analysis, hidden clues, infamous crimes, real crime stories, los angeles true crime, hollywood true crime

## Transcript

[0:00] In the early morning hours of June 16th, 1959, a single shot
[0:05] shattered the silence of a Benedict Canyon home in Los
[0:08] Angeles. The man who had embodied truth,
[0:12] justice and the American way for millions of television viewers
[0:16] lay dead in his bedroom, a Luger pistol.
[0:20] Nearby, George Reeves, the 45 year old actor who had brought
[0:25] Superman to life on the small screen, was gone.
[0:30] The Los Angeles Police Department quickly ruled that he
[0:32] did it himself, but the circumstances surrounding that
[0:36] night have fueled speculation for more than six decades.
[0:40] From a weapon with no fingerprints to a fiance who
[0:43] allegedly predicted his death before it happened, this death
[0:47] remains one of Hollywood's most enduring mysteries.
[0:52] George Reeves was born George Brewer on January 5th, 1914 in
[0:57] Woolstock, Iowa. His early life was marked by
[1:01] instability after his parents separated, and he eventually
[1:04] took the surname Reeves from his stepfather.
[1:08] Blessed with rugged good looks and natural charisma, young
[1:11] George set his sights on Hollywood.
[1:14] He made his film debut in 1939 with a small but memorable role
[1:19] in Gone with the Wind, playing one of the Tarleton twins who
[1:22] flirt with Scarlett O'Hara in the opening scene.
[1:26] The roll seemed to promise a bright future in motion
[1:28] pictures, and Reeves spent the next decade appearing in a
[1:32] string of films, though none brought him the stardom he
[1:36] craved. After a fairly brief hiatus
[1:40] serving in the Army, he returned to Hollywood hoping for his big
[1:43] break. That break came in 1951 when
[1:49] Reeves was cast in the theatrical film Superman and the
[1:52] Mole Men, which led to the television series Adventures of
[1:55] Superman. Beginning in 1952, the show
[1:59] became a phenomenon, particularly among children who
[2:02] idolized the square jawed hero who could fly through the air
[2:06] and stop bullets with his chest. Reeves embraced the role with
[2:10] enthusiasm, making personal appearances at schools and
[2:14] hospitals where young fans could meet their hero in the flesh.
[2:19] Given that he was an idol to so many youngsters, he cleaned up
[2:23] his personal life, quitting smoking so as not to set a bad
[2:27] example. For six seasons, he was the face
[2:31] of Superman, and his portrayal became so iconic that it would
[2:36] define the character for an entire generation.
[2:39] However, success came with a price.
[2:43] Reeves found himself hopelessly typecast, unable to escape the
[2:47] Cape and tights that had made him famous.
[2:50] Producers saw only Superman when they looked at him, and serious
[2:54] dramatic roles dried up. A particularly painful blow came
[2:59] when his scenes in the prestigious 1953 film From Here
[3:03] to Eternity were cut because test audiences laughed at seeing
[3:07] Superman in a different context. By the time Adventures of
[3:12] Superman ended in 1958, Reeves was struggling professionally
[3:18] and, according to some accounts, personally.
[3:20] He had begun drinking heavily and was frustrated by his
[3:24] stalled career, worried that he would never be able to break out
[3:28] of his starring role. Nevertheless, he had recently
[3:32] signed on to direct and possibly star in new projects, suggesting
[3:37] that his future was not as bleak as some have claimed.
[3:41] The final night of George Reeves's life began innocuously
[3:44] enough. He and his fiance, Leonor Lemon,
[3:48] had dinner with friends before returning to his Benedict Canyon
[3:52] home around midnight. Reeves went upstairs to bed
[3:57] while Lemon continued entertaining guests downstairs.
[4:02] When additional visitors arrived, the noise apparently
[4:05] disturbed Reeves, who came downstairs irritated and
[4:09] reportedly had words with Lemon before returning to the bedroom.
[4:14] What happened next depends on whose account one believes, but
[4:18] around 1:30 that morning, a shot was heard from upstairs.
[4:23] According to witnesses, Leonor had made a strange comment
[4:26] moments before, telling guests that Reeves was going to shoot
[4:30] himself. In a strange and detached way.
[4:33] The remark seemed oddly prophetic, and some
[4:36] investigators would later find it deeply suspicious.
[4:40] When police arrived, they found Reeves unclothed on his bed with
[4:44] a single wound to his right temple.
[4:46] A Luger, the iconic German pistol, lay on the floor between
[4:51] his feet, and a spent shell casing was discovered beneath
[4:54] his body. The scene was quickly deemed to
[4:57] have been caused by him alone, and the case was closed within
[5:01] weeks. But almost immediately,
[5:04] troubling questions emerged. The Luger had no fingerprints on
[5:08] it, which seemed impossible if Reeves had fired it himself.
[5:14] Bruises were found on his head and body that couldn't be easily
[5:17] explained. 2 additional bullet holes were discovered in the
[5:21] bedroom floor, suggesting the gun had been fired on previous
[5:25] occasions or that the death scene was not what it appeared.
[5:30] Perhaps most damning, the witnesses downstairs had waited
[5:33] between 30 and 45 minutes before calling the police, a delay that
[5:37] has never been satisfactorily explained.
[5:41] The investigation into potential suspects inevitably focused on
[5:45] the complicated romantic life of George Reeves.
[5:48] For nearly eight years before his death, he had been involved
[5:52] in a passionate affair with Tony Mannix, the wife of Eddie
[5:56] Mannix. He was a powerful MGM executive
[6:00] known throughout Hollywood as a fixer with alleged connections
[6:04] to the mob. Tony had showered Reeves with
[6:07] expensive gifts during their relationship, including helping
[6:11] him purchase the very house where he would perish.
[6:14] When Reeves ended the affair in 1958 to pursue a relationship
[6:18] with the much younger Leonor Lemon, Tony was reportedly
[6:22] devastated and furious. In the months before his death,
[6:28] Reeves complained of receiving harassing phone calls and
[6:31] threats that he attributed to his scorned former lover.
[6:35] The situation became so troublesome that he allegedly
[6:38] considered taking legal action. Some investigators have
[6:42] theorized that Eddie Mannix, despite appearing to tolerate
[6:46] the affair, may have arranged for Reeves to be eliminated,
[6:50] either to avenge his wife's honor or at her request.
[6:55] Others have pointed the finger directly at Tony herself,
[6:58] suggesting she hired someone to off the man who had broken her
[7:02] heart. Neither theory has ever been
[7:05] proven, and the Mannixes were never charged with any crime
[7:08] related to the death. Leonor also drew suspicion.
[7:15] Her peculiar comment predicting the shot, combined with the long
[7:18] delay and calling authorities, struck many observers as highly
[7:22] unusual. Some have speculated that an
[7:25] argument between Lemon and Reeves that night escalated to
[7:29] violence, perhaps accidentally, and that the scene was then
[7:33] staged. Lemon herself gave inconsistent
[7:37] statements to police and later fled to New York, refusing to
[7:40] cooperate with subsequent investigations.
[7:44] She maintained until her own death in 1989 that Reeves had
[7:48] done it himself, but her behavior in the aftermath has
[7:52] never stopped raising eyebrows. The official ruling that Reeves
[7:58] turned the Luger on himself has never been changed.
[8:01] Despite multiple attempts to reopen the case.
[8:04] More than 60 years later, the truth about what happened to
[8:08] George Reeves potentially remains locked away.
[8:12] The fingerprint free Luger. The unexplained bruises.
[8:16] The bizarre behavior of the witnesses and the tangled web of
[8:20] jealousy and Hollywood power all point to something darker.
[8:26] I keep coming back to the significant delay between the
[8:28] shot and the call to police because it feels inherently
[8:32] suspicious to me. If a shot erupts in a house full
[8:36] of people, and the explanation is truly straightforward, why
[8:40] does nearly an hour pass before anyone picks up the phone?
[8:45] That window looks like time to talk, to calm nerves, to move
[8:49] objects, to decide what story everyone will tell.
[8:52] When authorities arrive. Real panic calls happen
[8:56] immediately. This pause suggests calculation.
[9:00] It suggests people realizing in real time that what just
[9:04] happened couldn't be allowed to stand on its own without some
[9:07] coaching. At midnight on June 29th, 2001,
[9:16] Patricia Adkins clocked out from her shift at the Honda plant in
[9:19] Marysville, OH and walked into the darkness of the parking lot.
[9:24] The 29 year old single mother believed she was about to embark
[9:27] on the romantic adventure of her life, a secret getaway to Canada
[9:32] with the man she loved. Instead, she vanished without a
[9:36] trace, her car remained in the lot and the married Co worker
[9:41] she had trusted with her secrets and nearly all of her savings
[9:45] would become the prime suspect. More than two decades later,
[9:50] Patty Adkins has never been found and no one has been held
[9:54] accountable for whatever happened to her that night.
[9:59] Patty was born on May 4th, 1972 and raised in the Marysville
[10:03] area. By 29, she had worked her way up
[10:06] to a supervisory position at the massive Honda Assembly plant.
[10:10] It was a good job with very solid pay in a community where
[10:14] such opportunities didn't grow on trees.
[10:17] She was a devoted mother to her young daughter and maintained
[10:20] close relationships with her family.
[10:23] Friends described her as warm, trusting, and perhaps a little
[10:28] too willing to see the best in people.
[10:31] That trusting nature would prove to be her undoing when she fell
[10:34] for a Co worker who had no intention of giving her the
[10:38] future she dreamed about. His name was Brian Flowers and
[10:43] he was also a supervisor at the Honda plant.
[10:46] He was married with children, but that didn't stop him from
[10:50] pursuing a secret relationship with Patty that lasted
[10:53] approximately 2 years. Brian convinced Patty to keep
[10:57] their affair hidden from everyone, telling her that he
[11:01] needed time to leave his wife and that secrecy was essential.
[11:06] Patty believed him completely, so much so that she gave him
[11:10] approximately $90,000 from her savings, money supposedly meant
[11:15] to help them start their new life together.
[11:19] As the summer of 2001 approached, Brian presented
[11:22] Patty with an exciting plan. They would take a romantic trip
[11:26] to Canada over the 4th of July holiday weekend, but to maintain
[11:31] secrecy, Patty would need to hide in the bed of Brian's Ford
[11:35] pickup truck while he drove out of the Honda parking lot.
[11:39] Once safely away, she could climb into the cab and they
[11:43] would head north together. It was an unusual arrangement,
[11:47] but Patty agreed without hesitation.
[11:50] Patty withdrew money from her account and told her family she
[11:54] was going on a trip. Though she remained vague about
[11:57] the details, she arranged for her daughter to stay with
[12:00] relatives. On the night of June 29th, Patty
[12:05] finished her shift, said goodbye to Co workers and headed out to
[12:09] the parking lot where Brian was waiting.
[12:12] She was never seen again. When Patty failed to return home
[12:18] or contact her family over the holiday weekend, concern quickly
[12:22] turned to alarm. Her car was discovered still
[12:25] parked at the Honda plant. Her family reported her missing,
[12:30] and investigators began piercing together The Secret Life she had
[12:33] been living. They soon learned about the
[12:36] affair with Brian Flowers and the plan to hide in his truck.
[12:41] When confronted, Brian initially denied everything, claiming he
[12:45] barely knew Patty. But evidence and witness
[12:48] accounts told a different story, and he eventually admitted to
[12:52] the affair. Brian insisted that Patty never
[12:55] got into his truck that night. He claimed he went straight home
[12:59] after work. He insisted that he spent the
[13:01] holiday weekend camping with his wife and family and had no idea
[13:06] what happened to his former lover.
[13:09] His wife backed up his alibi, but investigators found
[13:13] troubling inconsistencies in his story.
[13:16] Shortly after Patty vanished, Brian had taken his truck to a
[13:20] car wash and thoroughly scrubbed the bed.
[13:25] When forensic technicians later examined the vehicle, they
[13:28] discovered a small speck of blood that DNA testing
[13:31] determined was consistent with Patty's genetic profile.
[13:36] That single drop of blood has haunted the case ever since.
[13:40] It suggests that something happened in the bed of that
[13:42] truck, something that Brian Flowers has never adequately
[13:46] explained. Yet despite years of
[13:48] investigation, prosecutors have never felt they had enough to
[13:52] bring charges. Without a body, without
[13:55] witnesses, without a confession, the case against Flowers has
[14:00] remained frustratingly incomplete.
[14:03] He has continued to maintain his innocence and has never been
[14:06] arrested or charged in relation to any offenses.
[14:12] In 2006, Patty Adkins was declared legally dead, though
[14:17] her remains have never been recovered.
[14:20] The Union County Sheriff's Office has periodically renewed
[14:23] appeals and assign new investigators to the case,
[14:27] though no breakthrough has yet to come.
[14:33] On the morning of September 10th, 2017, hotel security at
[14:37] the Crowne Plaza Chicago O'Hare in Rosemont, Illinois made a
[14:41] grim discovery in a place no one should ever die.
[14:45] The body of 19 year old Kenneka Jenkins lay inside a walk in
[14:49] freezer in the hotel's kitchen. Her life ended by the cold after
[14:54] she had apparently wandered into the unit and become trapped.
[14:59] Her mother had been at the hotel for hours pleading with staff to
[15:03] search for her missing daughter, only to be met with delays and
[15:06] indifference. By the time Kenneka was found,
[15:10] she had been dead for nearly a day.
[15:13] The official ruling called it an accident, but questions about
[15:16] what really happened that night continue to haunt her family and
[15:20] fuel speculation years later. Born on May 27th, 1998 and
[15:27] raised on the West side of Chicago, Kenneka was known to
[15:30] friends and family as a vibrant and outgoing person who loved to
[15:33] have fun. The evening of September 8th,
[15:37] 2017 began like countless other Friday nights for young people
[15:41] looking to blow off steam. Kenneka and a group of friends
[15:46] headed to the Crowne Plaza Hotel near O'Hare Airport, where a
[15:50] party was being held in a room on the 9th floor.
[15:54] The gathering was a typical scene of young adults drinking,
[15:57] socializing, and capturing the night on social media.
[16:02] Kenneka was drinking alcohol and had reportedly taken to Pyramid,
[16:06] a non recreational anticonvulsant medication that
[16:10] can amplify the effects of the substance.
[16:13] As the night wore on and the drinks flowed, Kenica became
[16:17] increasingly intoxicated. Surveillance footage would later
[16:21] show just how impaired she had become.
[16:25] Sometime in the early morning hours of September 9th, Kenica
[16:29] became separated from her friends.
[16:32] Accounts vary as to exactly how this happened, but the result
[16:35] was that a heavily intoxicated young woman found herself
[16:38] wandering alone through the hallways of a large hotel.
[16:42] Surveillance cameras captured her stumbling through corridors
[16:46] on various floors, clearly disoriented and struggling to
[16:50] walk. She bounced off walls, staggered
[16:54] in circles, and appeared completely unaware of her
[16:57] surroundings. Around 3:20 in the morning, the
[17:01] cameras recorded Kenneka entering the hotel's kitchen
[17:04] area. This was a section of the hotel
[17:07] that should have been off limits to guests, particularly at that
[17:11] hour, but apparently no security measures prevented her from
[17:15] wandering in. The kitchen led to a storage
[17:18] area that included a large walk in freezer used for food
[17:22] storage. At some point, Kenneka entered
[17:25] that freezer. The door latched behind her.
[17:29] Whether she pushed through it, accidentally mistaking it for an
[17:32] exit, or stumbled in without understanding where she was
[17:36] remains unclear. What is certain is that once
[17:40] inside, she couldn't get out. Hours passed before anyone
[17:46] raised the alarm. Around 4:30 in the morning,
[17:50] Kenneka's friends realized she was missing and called her
[17:52] mother. Teresa Martin rushed to the
[17:55] hotel, arriving around 5:00 AM, and immediately demanded that
[17:59] staff help find her daughter. According to Martin and her
[18:04] attorneys, the hotel was slow to respond and dismissive of her
[18:07] concerns. Staff reportedly told her that
[18:10] her daughter had probably left with someone or would turn up
[18:13] eventually. Martin grew increasingly frantic
[18:17] as the hours ticked by with no sign of Kenneka.
[18:20] She begged them to check the security footage and search the
[18:23] premises, but claims her pleas were ignored.
[18:29] It was not until approximately 12:30 AM on September 10th,
[18:33] nearly 24 hours after Kenneka was last seen on camera, that
[18:37] her body was finally discovered. A hotel security officer
[18:42] conducting a search found her in the walk in freezer, her body
[18:46] frozen and lifeless. The young woman who had been
[18:49] laughing and partying with friends just hours earlier, was
[18:54] gone. The medical examiner would later
[18:57] determine that Kenneka died from hypothermia caused by prolonged
[19:01] exposure to the freezing temperatures.
[19:04] Her blood alcohol level was measured at slightly above the
[19:07] legal driving limit, and the presence of topiramate in her
[19:10] system likely compounded her impairment.
[19:16] The official ruling was that Kenneka Jenkins died in an
[19:19] accident. According to investigators, she
[19:21] had wandered drunkenly into a restricted area and accidentally
[19:25] trapped herself in the freezer. The Rosemont Police Department
[19:29] closed the case in October 2017, concluding that there was no
[19:34] evidence of foul play. But for Kenneka's family and a
[19:38] massive online community that had become invested in the case,
[19:43] the official explanation raised more questions than it answered.
[19:47] Social media exploded with conspiracy theories in the days
[19:50] following Kenneka's death. Amateur sleuths poured over
[19:54] every frame of the surveillance footage, claiming to see
[19:57] evidence that she had been followed, attacked or even
[20:01] dragged into the freezer by unseen assailants.
[20:04] Videos posted by friends who had been at the party were
[20:07] scrutinized for hidden clues. Some theorists accused Kenica's
[20:12] friends of involvement in her death, pointing to their
[20:15] behavior on social media as suspicious.
[20:18] The hashtag justice for Kenica trended nationally as thousands
[20:23] demanded that authorities reopen the investigation and consider
[20:27] the possibility of a slaying. While the conspiracy theories
[20:32] never produced credible evidence, legitimate questions
[20:35] about hotel negligence proved more substantial.
[20:39] Kenneka's family filed A wrongful death lawsuit against
[20:42] the Crowne Plaza, arguing that the hotel had failed in its duty
[20:46] to protect guests. Their attorneys pointed out that
[20:49] the freezer door could latch from the outside, effectively
[20:52] trapping anyone who entered. They argued that security was
[20:56] inadequate, that restricted areas were too easily
[20:59] accessible, and that staff had been negligent in responding to
[21:03] a mother's desperate pleas. The lawsuit painted a picture of
[21:07] a tragedy that could and should have been prevented if some
[21:11] basic measures were in place. In December 2023, more than six
[21:18] years after Kenneka's death, the family reached a settlement with
[21:22] the hotel reported to be worth approximately $10 million.
[21:27] The settlement did not include an admission of wrongdoing, but
[21:30] it represented at least some measure of accountability that
[21:34] contributed to the tragedy. The death of Kenneka.
[21:38] Jenkins remains officially classified as an accident, the
[21:42] result of a young woman's impaired judgement leading her
[21:45] into a deadly situation. Ultimately.
[21:48] Despite the theories online, there's no credible evidence
[21:52] that anyone harmed her intentionally or forced her into
[21:56] that freezer. However, the question of how a
[21:58] 19 year old could stumble through a major hotel clearly in
[22:02] distress without a single employee noticing or intervening
[22:06] while on camera remains open. Hey everyone, it's.
[22:13] Jimmy here with a quick reminder to like and share this video if
[22:16] you're enjoying it and to hit the notification bell.
[22:19] Also, don't forget to check out the Patreon or the YouTube
[22:22] membership to take your support for my channel to the next
[22:25] level. On a brutally cold.
[22:30] November morning in 1985, a highway worker pulled into
[22:34] Montana's isolated Bad Route rest area in Dawson County and
[22:39] made a gruesome discovery. There was a car parked there,
[22:42] fully engulfed in flames, with no one inside the.
[22:46] Vehicle belonged. To 67 year old Dexter Stefonik
[22:49] of Wisconsin, who had been on a long drive home, this startling
[22:55] scene was the first hint of a mystery that would confound
[22:58] investigators for decades. Dexter was a.
[23:03] Retired widower from Rhinelander, WI in November
[23:06] 1985. After visiting his son's family
[23:10] in Oregon following his wife's death the year before, he
[23:14] decided it was time to drive back to Wisconsin alone.
[23:19] He set out on November 18th in his brown Plymouth Horizon and
[23:23] to save money, plan to sleep at rest stops instead of motels
[23:27] during the 2000 mile journey. The next morning.
[23:33] Dexter's car was found engulfed in flames at the Bad Root Rest
[23:36] area off Interstate 94. A highway worker who spotted the
[23:41] blaze alerted authorities, and the smoldering wreck was soon
[23:44] identified by its Wisconsin plates as Dexter's vehicle.
[23:48] There was no trace of Dexter himself.
[23:51] At first, there was no obvious evidence of a crime.
[23:55] With no body present, officials assumed it might simply be a
[23:59] stalled car and a missing driver.
[24:03] The incident was treated as a missing person case.
[24:06] Perhaps the driver had wandered away in the freezing -40 weather
[24:10] and hitched a ride after a breakdown.
[24:13] However, evidence at the scene quickly pointed to foul play.
[24:17] An arson investigator concluded the fire was deliberately set,
[24:21] with gasoline especially soaking the car's back seat.
[24:25] Furthermore, the driver's seat was found pushed all the way
[24:28] back, an odd position given Dexter's short stature, and this
[24:33] suggested someone much taller had been behind the wheel.
[24:37] Investigators began. Retracing events at the rest
[24:40] area that morning. They learned that earlier on
[24:43] November 19th, the rest stops custodian in a highway
[24:46] maintenance supervisor had noticed an unattended white
[24:50] Chevy Blazer with Arizona plates parked there.
[24:53] The truck sported A distinctive blue stripe and a cattle guard
[24:56] front bumper, and it appeared someone might have been living
[25:00] out of it since clothes and bedding were visible inside.
[25:04] Around 9:00. 30 AM. Not long before the fire was
[25:08] reported, the custodian encountered a tall, clean shaven
[25:12] man about 6 feet in height driving Dexter's car.
[25:17] The stranger was carrying. A couple of gasoline cans.
[25:20] When asked if he needed help, the man calmly explained that he
[25:24] had run out of gas and had fetched fuel.
[25:27] Nothing unusual on the surface. By the time the burning.
[25:31] Car was discovered this unknown man, and the white Chevy truck
[25:36] had vanished. The implication was chilling.
[25:40] Hours into his trip, Dexter likely crossed paths with this
[25:44] individual at the deserted rest stop.
[25:47] But for months, Dexter's fate remained unknown and the case
[25:51] stalled out quickly. Then on March. 8th, 1986 A local
[25:57] couple dumping garbage at a remote landfill about 17 miles
[26:01] from the rest area stumbled upon disturbing evidence.
[26:05] They found a wallet with Dexter's ID lying on the ground,
[26:09] and nearby spotted personal items that hadn't been there on
[26:12] earlier visits, including a suitcase, clothing and a shaving
[26:15] kit. Searching further, they made a
[26:19] horrific find, a human body partially buried under an old
[26:23] mattress with a booted foot protruding from underneath.
[26:28] Authorities were called and dental records confirmed the
[26:31] body to be Dexter Stefonic. The autopsy revealed he had been
[26:36] beaten and then shot twice in the back of the head.
[26:40] Despite the violence. Of the crime, some of Dexter's
[26:44] valuables were untouched. Cash was still in his suitcase,
[26:49] making robbery an unlikely motive.
[26:52] Investigators. Also noted a curious detail.
[26:56] Although Dexter's body had lain in the landfill for months, his
[26:59] clothing and luggage seemed to have been dropped off only
[27:02] recently. This strongly suggested that the
[27:05] perpetrator had returned to the dump site to dispose of evidence
[27:08] long after the slaying. Back at the bad root.
[27:13] Rest stop detectives uncovered one last eerie clue.
[27:17] Scrawled in pencil on a wall inside the men's restroom was a
[27:20] line of graffiti that appeared to reference the crime.
[27:24] It read Hot Jock Shot from Wisconsin 1185, followed by the
[27:29] statement Saturday the 3rd. The words were too specific to
[27:34] ignore. Investigators believe the
[27:36] perpetrator left this cryptic message as a taunt.
[27:40] They also believed he was possibly using Hot Jock to refer
[27:43] to himself and that it may have been his CB radio handle.
[27:48] The timing was also. Strange, since the writing was
[27:51] noticed only after Dexter's body was found months later.
[27:56] Whether genuine or a bizarre coincidence, the graffiti
[27:59] reinforced the sense that the perpetrator was brazenly
[28:02] bragging about the crime. Despite these.
[28:06] Clues The investigation struggled to make headway.
[28:10] Detectives chased down countless leads, trying to identify the
[28:14] tall stranger and his white truck under hypnosis.
[28:18] One witness recalled that the truck's Arizona license plate
[28:21] began with the numbers 147, which allowed police to narrow
[28:26] down a list of possible owners. Unfortunately, none of those
[28:30] leads panned out. Extensive interviews with people
[28:34] in Dexter's life also LED nowhere, and he was well liked
[28:38] and had no known enemies. With no arrests and few answers,
[28:43] the case eventually went cold once again.
[28:47] Investigators. Also feared that the
[28:49] unidentified predator, having gotten away, might strike again
[28:53] at another lonely rest stop. Even a televised segment on
[28:57] Unsolved Mysteries in 1989 failed to generate any useful
[29:02] tips. And as usual, I have to specify
[29:05] what a huge phenomenon this show was at the time.
[29:10] On broadcasts. And rebroadcasts unsolved
[29:13] mysteries would be seen by 10s of millions of households across
[29:16] the United States and Canada. In January 20. 24 Nearly 39
[29:23] years after Dexter's death, the Dawson County Sheriff's Office
[29:27] finally named a long suspected perpetrator.
[29:30] They announced that Charles Sullivan, a 79 year old man
[29:34] serving prison time in Nevada, was believed to likely have
[29:37] slain Dexter Stefonik. Sullivan had a.
[29:41] Violent past and He was convicted of a 1979 slaying but
[29:46] had been let out early and crucially, he fit the profile
[29:51] from 1985. He would have been in his.
[29:55] Late 30s at the time, the same age range as the mystery man,
[29:59] and drove a vehicle similar to the described Blazer in terms of
[30:04] appearance. He was tall, the sort of man who
[30:07] would have had to push a seat all the way back to drive
[30:09] comfortably. Investigators say.
[30:12] Sullivan's movements and appearance line up with the
[30:15] witness statements. He was even suspected in other
[30:18] unsolved slayings across the Western states, suggesting
[30:22] Dexter may have fallen victim to a serial predator traveling the
[30:26] highways. However, because no physical
[30:30] evidence links him conclusively to Dexter's case, prosecutors
[30:34] have decided to exercise extreme caution.
[30:38] When questioned by. Detectives about Dexter's
[30:40] slaying Sullivan invoked his right to remain silent, Lacking
[30:45] definitive evidence and wanting to keep the option open in case
[30:49] things change. They effectively closed the case
[30:52] with the belief that Sullivan is the one responsible.
[30:55] Sullivan currently remains behind bars, where he will stay
[30:59] for the rest of his natural life.
[31:08] In September. 1987 fifty year old Dale Kerstetter vanished
[31:12] from his job during an overnight shift at the Corning Glass Works
[31:16] plant in Bradford, PA. On that very same.
[31:20] Night more than a quarter, $1,000,000 worth of platinum
[31:22] disappeared from the facility. And yes, if you're a long time
[31:26] viewer, you know that I have a keen interest in both heists and
[31:30] missing persons cases, so I couldn't pass this one up.
[31:34] Kerstetter was a veteran maintenance man and security
[31:37] guard with 27 years experience at the Corning plant.
[31:41] He was scheduled to work his usual night shift on Saturday,
[31:44] September 12th, 1987. By the next morning.
[31:49] He was gone without a trace, leaving behind personal
[31:52] belongings and a mystery that endures to this day.
[31:56] Investigators and family alike have grappled with the question
[32:00] was Dale Karstadter an unsuspecting victim of a robbery
[32:05] or a willing participant in an elaborate theft?
[32:09] Dale was a trusted. Employee described as an
[32:11] ordinary well liked man devoted to his large family.
[32:17] Sometime during the night, approximately $250,000 worth of
[32:21] platinum pipe used in the glass manufacturing process went
[32:26] missing from the plants furnace area along with Kerstetter
[32:29] himself. When the next security?
[32:32] Guard John Lindquist showed up at 7:00 AM on Sunday to relieve
[32:35] Dale. He immediately sensed something
[32:38] was wrong. Kerstetter was nowhere to be
[32:41] found at his post. In the plants.
[32:44] Cafeteria Lindquist discovered Dale's lunch pail sitting on a
[32:48] table alongside his newspaper in keys.
[32:52] This was an alarming sign, as it appeared Dale had left in the
[32:56] middle of his shift without even consuming the dinner he brought.
[33:01] Later that morning. Security staff located
[33:04] Kerstetter's pickup truck still in the plant parking lot,
[33:09] yielding more puzzling clues. The truck's keys were still in
[33:13] the ignition, and inside the vehicle investigators found a
[33:17] full carton of cigarettes, Dale's food and an empty holster
[33:22] for his weapon, which itself was missing.
[33:26] There were no indications of forced entry at the plant or
[33:29] signs of a struggle at the scene.
[33:32] These early clues. Suggested that whatever
[33:34] happened, it occurred suddenly and likely not at Kerstetter's
[33:39] own initiative. For example, Dale was a heavy
[33:43] smoker, so leaving behind an entire carton of cigarettes was
[33:47] highly unusual if he had intended to leave voluntarily.
[33:52] Plant Procedures also called for the lone night guard to check in
[33:55] by phone with the company's headquarters every hour.
[33:59] However, it was later discovered that Dale never made any hourly
[34:02] check in calls after starting his shift.
[34:06] Unfortunately, a new employee in the remote monitoring office
[34:10] wasn't familiar with this protocol, so Kerstetter's missed
[34:13] check insurance went unnoticed in real time.
[34:17] Once Kerstetter's. Disappearance was recognized.
[34:20] Plant officials and authorities quickly launched a search of the
[34:23] sprawling facility and surrounding area.
[34:26] And when I say sprawling here, I'm not exaggerating.
[34:29] The facility itself is over 100,000 square feet and the
[34:34] property it's on is even larger. Fearing that the missing.
[34:39] Guard might have been injured or fallen I'll on the job.
[34:42] AK 9 unit was brought in to track his scent through the
[34:45] building. The Bloodhounds.
[34:48] Traced Dale's trail along his normal patrol route at first,
[34:52] then LED officers to the second floor area housing the plants
[34:56] glass furnace where the valuable platinum was kept.
[35:00] This. Location.
[35:01] Wasn't part of Kerstetter's usual rounds raising a red flag
[35:05] that something drew him there during the night?
[35:09] Upon inspecting. The furnace managers discovered
[35:12] that several pieces of platinum lining had been cut out and
[35:15] removed, confirming that a major theft had occurred.
[35:19] Despite an extensive search of the building, no sign of cursed
[35:23] Etter was found inside, and a sweep of the surrounding woods
[35:27] and a nearby Creek also turned up nothing.
[35:31] By later that day, the McKean County Sheriff's Office and
[35:34] Pennsylvania State Police were treating the incident as both a
[35:37] missing person case and a high value burglary A.
[35:41] Breakthrough in the. Early investigation came when
[35:43] officials reviewed the plant security camera footage.
[35:48] About four days. After the incident, Corning
[35:50] personnel Manager Patrick Foley scrutinized recordings from
[35:54] three surveillance cameras that monitored the facility.
[35:58] Also keep Foley. 'S name in mind for later
[36:01] because he's going to come up again in a bit and depending on
[36:04] how you see this case, you'll either love or hate him.
[36:08] What Foley saw was startling and completely changed the nature of
[36:12] the case and the investigation. At approximately 10:40 PM, only
[36:18] minutes after Kirsteder started his shift, the footage showed a
[36:22] masked intruder walking through the back area of the plant.
[36:26] At around 10:40. 5:00 PM. The cameras captured A brief
[36:30] encounter between Dale and this masked person in a corridor.
[36:34] Kerstetter could be seen walking up to the intruder and
[36:37] apparently engaging in a short conversation.
[36:40] The two then move together out of frame.
[36:43] Moments later, the intruder is seen walking through the plant
[36:46] alone, without Kerstetter. The next significant footage
[36:51] comes around midnight, when the intruder appears on camera in
[36:55] the furnace area on the 2nd floor, precisely where the
[36:58] platinum was stored. The.
[37:01] Video shows. The intruder in that area and
[37:04] later shows him Wheeling out a large, heavy bag through the
[37:07] building. Investigators speculated that
[37:10] the bag likely contained the stolen platinum or possibly even
[37:14] Kerstetter himself. Notably, during the brief
[37:18] corridor encounter on the tape, as Kerstetter and the masked man
[37:21] we're leaving the 2nd floor area together.
[37:24] Dale glances up directly into one of the security cameras.
[37:29] This peculiar moment would become a focal point of debate.
[37:33] Was Dale subtly? Looking into the camera to
[37:35] signal for help or was he acknowledging the camera Jim
[37:39] from the office style because he knew what was about to happen?
[37:44] Authorities at the time couldn't determine if Kerstetter's
[37:47] behavior indicated duress or complicity.
[37:50] The surveillance evidence made one thing clear.
[37:53] The unidentified intruder was able to navigate the plant with
[37:57] confidence. The individual knew exactly
[38:00] where to find the platinum, how to access the furnace even in
[38:04] the dark, and where equipment like carts or bags were located.
[38:09] This strongly suggested that someone familiar with the
[38:12] facility, perhaps a current or former employee, was involved in
[38:17] the heist. Notably, while the authorities
[38:20] have been uncertain about whether Dale was involved, the
[38:23] company he worked for for 27 years of his life literally
[38:27] immediately threw him under the bus.
[38:30] Patrick Foley, the plant manager I mentioned previously, went on
[38:34] the record saying that Dale was a common thief taking their
[38:37] platinum. Also as a complete.
[38:40] Aside, I hope Mr. Foley's words inspire someone to take this as
[38:44] a sign to follow their own dreams.
[38:47] By way of reminder, Dale gave 27 years of service to Corning
[38:52] Glass Works. Yet this was the thanks.
[38:55] He got at the end of the day where there was a significant
[38:57] likelihood that he was slain in the line of duty.
[39:01] Dale's family vehemently rejected the notion that Dale
[39:04] was a platinum thief. From the beginning, family
[39:07] members described Kirstetter as a devoted father of six who
[39:11] would never willingly abandoned his children and grandchildren
[39:14] without any word. In the months and years
[39:17] following the disappearance, the case remained A stubborn mystery
[39:23] law. Enforcement.
[39:23] Conducted numerous interviews and background checks, it came
[39:27] to light that Kerstetter had been under financial strain.
[39:31] He'd recently taken a pay cut of several $1000 and was reportedly
[39:35] $40,000 behind on various loan and bill payments.
[39:40] This information gave weight to a possible motive if he had
[39:43] engineered the theft. Investigators also noted that no
[39:47] trace of the missing Platinum or Dale himself surfaced in the
[39:50] aftermath. The Platinum A.
[39:53] Highly valuable commodity could have been melted down or sold on
[39:57] a black market, making it hard to trace.
[40:00] Meanwhile, despite occasional tips, police never identified
[40:04] the masked culprit seen on the tape.
[40:07] The uncertainty of Kerstetter's fate created legal and personal
[40:10] dilemmas for his family in. 1990.
[40:14] Three years after he vanished, Dale's daughter Wendy petitioned
[40:18] the court to have her father declared legally dead.
[40:21] She was hoping to bring some closure and possibly claim life
[40:24] insurance and his pension benefits.
[40:28] Corning Glass works. Fought this petition, contending
[40:31] that Dale could still be alive and may have been a participant
[40:34] in the crime. During the hearing, the.
[40:37] Company's lawyer argued there was no conclusive evidence that
[40:41] Kerstetter had met with foul play.
[40:44] The Pennsylvania Superior Court agreed that the evidence of
[40:47] Dale's demise was too vague and denied the petition in December
[40:51] 1990. As a result, Kerstetter remained
[40:55] legally a missing person, and Corning withheld his pension and
[40:58] insurance payouts from his family.
[41:01] Over the years, several theories have emerged to explain what
[41:05] might have happened to Dale Kerstetter.
[41:08] The core question is whether Kerstetter was an unwilling
[41:11] victim of foul play or whether he was a willing participant in
[41:15] the theft who disappeared by choice.
[41:18] Within these broad. Possibilities are variations,
[41:22] including the idea that he could have been involved in the crime
[41:26] but ultimately double crossed and harmed by accomplices.
[41:30] Each theory has its own evidence and arguments, with strengths
[41:34] and weaknesses supported by the known facts.
[41:38] One prominent. Theory is that Dale Kerstetter
[41:41] was the victim of foul play, meaning he encountered intruders
[41:45] during a robbery and was forcibly taken and slain.
[41:50] In this scenario, criminals, possibly one or more people,
[41:55] broke into the plant to steal the platinum and neutralize the
[41:58] security guard as an obstacle. Supporting evidence for this
[42:02] theory centers on indications that Kerstetter didn't leave on
[42:06] his own terms. The.
[42:08] Scene left. Behind at the plant strongly
[42:10] suggests an abrupt interruption. Investigators found no signs of
[42:15] a struggle at the guard station, but it's possible that the
[42:19] confrontation was quick, explaining the lack of obvious
[42:23] violence on the premises. After all, the thieves would
[42:27] have had strong motivation to be as silent as possible.
[42:31] The fact that his weapon was missing from its holster implies
[42:35] he might have armed himself when facing a threat, or that the
[42:38] intruder took his weapon from him.
[42:41] On the security tape. Kerstetter's behavior could be
[42:45] interpreted as that of a man under duress.
[42:48] The other main line of. Speculation is that Kerstetter
[42:51] was involved in the crime. In this view, the incident was
[42:55] an inside job and the masked intruder could have been an
[42:59] accomplice or Co conspirator rather than an unknown
[43:02] assailant. Proponents of this theory.
[43:05] Emphasized Kerstetter's possible motive and the inside knowledge
[43:09] required to carry out the theft. Investigators uncovered that
[43:14] Dale was under significant financial pressure, including
[43:17] 10s of thousands of dollars in debt and a recent pay cut at
[43:21] work. Some have suggested that this
[43:24] pay cut after 27 years alongside his mounting debt could have
[43:29] forced a good, loyal worker to turn bad.
[43:33] While the inside job. Theory is plausible.
[43:36] There are significant challenges and counter arguments that cast
[43:39] doubt on Kerstetter's willing complicity.
[43:43] The most major point is Dale's abrupt and total disappearance.
[43:48] Even if he initially escaped, can we believe that for decades
[43:52] he never contacted any of his loved ones or resurfaced?
[43:56] However, supporters of the theory that he was in on it
[43:59] speculate that Dale was double crossed by his Co conspirator.
[44:03] In assessing the competing theories, it's important to note
[44:07] that none of them have been proven.
[44:09] Simply put, this is a case with an abundance of strange evidence
[44:13] but little definitive proof. Personally, I have.
[44:16] Significant difficulty believing that a family man who worked for
[44:20] a company for 27 years would throw it all away for a platinum
[44:24] heist. I wasn't able to find the value
[44:27] of his pension in my research. That said, I suspect that the
[44:31] value of his pension after 27 years work was likely worth more
[44:36] than the platinum he allegedly stole.
[44:39] However, to put things in perspective, the company fought
[44:42] tooth and nail to deny his heirs any rights to the pension.
[44:46] And last I checked, lawyers aren't free.
[44:49] This is doubly true. Considering he would have at
[44:52] least had to split it 5050 with his accomplice, assuming there
[44:55] was only one further yet, I suspect Dale Kerstetter may not
[45:01] have had ready access to a fence, given that he clearly
[45:05] wasn't living a life of crime. He would have had to have taken.
[45:09] A massive hit on the exchange of the illicit platinum.
[45:13] In my view. The numbers just don't really
[45:15] add up, and I'd like to propose a theory I haven't run into so
[45:19] far. Dale was known to be the only
[45:21] person who worked security at the plant where the platinum was
[45:24] kept. It would have been extremely
[45:27] easy for a perpetrator to follow him back to his house, snap a
[45:31] few pictures and then confront him at a different location.
[45:35] At this point he would have been given an offer he couldn't
[45:38] refuse, and we know from his family that he was a loving
[45:43] family man with six kids plus grandkids.
[45:48] I think he could have been. Forced to do the whole thing and
[45:51] that last look at the security camera was a knowing goodbye.
[45:55] I admit this is purely speculation, but in my view it
[45:59] fits better with the evidence than him willingly throwing away
[46:02] significant pension based wealth for this heist.
[46:06] Anyway, I've gone on. Way too long about Dale
[46:08] Kerstetter's case, but I find his case endlessly fascinating.
[46:14] Let. Me know what theory?
[46:15] You prefer in the comments or propose your own.
[46:19] Hey everyone. It's Jimmy here with a reminder
[46:22] to hit that notification bell and share this video with two
[46:25] people. You know, sharing my videos
[46:28] helps my channel grow in a big way.
[46:30] And the best part is it's totally free and only takes a
[46:33] second. In November 19. 8026 year old
[46:39] Valerie McDonald, an aspiring actress and part time model,
[46:43] vanished from San Francisco under mysterious circumstances.
[46:48] She was last seen on November 9th, 1980, leaving her North
[46:52] Beach apartment with a young man who had promised her a bit part
[46:55] in a movie. On the day she.
[46:58] Disappeared. Valerie was in the process of
[47:00] moving out of her apartment and had been wary of the new
[47:03] building managers who were ex convicts.
[47:07] That afternoon. One of them, Michael John
[47:10] Hennessy, convinced her to accompany him by offering $200
[47:15] for a small role in a supposed Dustin Hoffman film being shot
[47:20] that night. Friends grew concerned.
[47:23] When Valerie didn't return and contacted police the next day,
[47:27] however, they were initially told they had to wait 72 hours
[47:31] to file a missing persons report.
[47:35] Valerie's friend. Spent days searching for her and
[47:38] eventually reached out to Valerie's parents.
[47:41] The parents flew to. San Francisco, only to be
[47:44] brushed off by authorities who speculated that their daughter
[47:47] might have gone to Las Vegas. It wasn't until.
[47:51] Roughly a week after Valerie's disappearance that police truly
[47:54] began investigating, and by then critical time had been lost.
[48:00] Once the San Francisco police delved into the case, suspicion
[48:04] quickly focused on the men running Valerie's building.
[48:07] These were Michael Hennessy and his two associates, John Abbott
[48:12] and Phillip Thompson. Investigators learned these
[48:15] three had taken over management of the apartment that fall, and
[48:19] all were recently out of prison. On November. 19th, 1980 About 10
[48:25] days after Valerie went missing, authorities went to question the
[48:29] trio, only to discover they had abruptly vanished.
[48:34] A break in the case came a week later in Canada on.
[48:37] November 20. 6th 1980 Abbott and Hennessy resurfaced in British
[48:43] Columbia where they were confronted by the Royal Canadian
[48:46] Mounted Police. During this encounter.
[48:49] Hennessy was eliminated by the police, while Abbott was
[48:53] captured after attempting to shoot 2 Mounties.
[48:57] In Abbott's vehicle. And belongings.
[48:59] Officers found multiple weapons and personal items of Valerie's,
[49:03] including her ID cards and the leather jacket she had been
[49:06] wearing on November 9th. These chilling discoveries
[49:10] confirmed that Valerie had been in the men's company and
[49:13] strongly suggested foul play. Authorities also learned that
[49:18] Phillip Thompson had been with Abbott and Hennessy in Canada,
[49:22] but had flown back to California shortly before the shootout.
[49:27] Despite the evidence. Linking the suspects to
[49:29] Valerie's disappearance, there was still no trace of Valerie
[49:33] herself. Without a body, a weapon or any
[49:37] direct evidence of foul play, San Francisco police felt they
[49:41] lacked enough proof to charge Abbott or Thompson at the time.
[49:45] Abbott was instead. Prosecuted in Canada for the
[49:48] attempted shooting of the officers and sentenced to prison
[49:52] there. Thompson was later.
[49:54] Arrested in California in 1983 on unrelated kidnapping and
[49:59] robbery charges, despite tantalizing circumstantial
[50:03] evidence, Valerie's case unfortunately went cold.
[50:07] Philip Thompson and John Abbott denied any involvement in
[50:10] Valerie's disappearance, and with one suspect dead and the
[50:14] others behind bars on other matters, Leeds grew cold.
[50:19] A major break finally came over a decade later.
[50:23] In October 1991, hunters in a remote area of Ferry County,
[50:27] Washington, not far from the Canada US border, stumbled upon
[50:32] partial skeletal remains near the Kettle River.
[50:35] The remains were initially recorded as an unidentified Jane
[50:38] Doe. At the time, forensic examiners
[50:42] could only determine that they belong to a woman in her mid 20s
[50:45] to 30s. Finally, in late 2000A review of
[50:51] dental records in California's missing persons database yielded
[50:55] a hit. In November 2001, authorities
[50:59] announced that the remains were identified as Valerie McDonald.
[51:04] The authorities officially determined that she had been
[51:06] rendered deceased non consensually, confirming what
[51:10] her family and investigators had long suspected.
[51:14] The location of the. Grim find along a river in
[51:17] Washington state strongly tied her death to the suspects flight
[51:21] path toward Canada. This discovery, 2 decades after
[51:26] Valerie vanished, provided some closure to her family, even as
[51:31] the question of who was responsible remained unanswered.
[51:36] Despite the strong. Circumstantial case against the
[51:39] trio. No one has ever been charged or
[51:41] prosecuted in this case. By the time Valerie's remains
[51:45] were identified IN200011, suspect Hennessy was long dead
[51:51] and another, Thompson, was incarcerated for life on a
[51:55] different slaying. The third, John Abbott, was
[51:59] living overseas and out of reach.
[52:02] After he was released from Canadian prison for his role in
[52:04] the shootout, he was deported to the United Kingdom, his home
[52:09] country, from. There he's lived in.
[52:11] Japan, New Zealand, and South Africa.
[52:14] He's never faced any charges whatsoever in relation to
[52:17] Valerie's case, and some theories online suggest that his
[52:21] dad is a politically powerful individual and pulled some
[52:24] strings. That said, I was only able to
[52:27] find this information in forum gossip, so I'd take that all
[52:30] with a grain of salt for the time being.
[52:34] In December 19. 93 Waterloo, IA was rocked by two brutal
[52:39] slayings that continue to confound investigators and haunt
[52:42] the local community. 2 elderly residents, 83 year old Gladys
[52:47] Held and 87 year old Jacob Barretts were found dead in
[52:51] their own apartments on consecutive nights.
[52:55] These cases, marked by striking similarities in method and
[52:59] timing, have led many to suspect a single elusive criminal may be
[53:04] responsible. Despite extensive.
[53:07] Investigations and modern forensic advances.
[53:11] The truth behind these acts remains a mystery.
[53:15] On the night of December 8th, 1993, Gladys Held, a retired
[53:20] secretary, was attacked in her apartment at the Walnut Court
[53:24] Retirement Community at 315 Walnut St. the following
[53:29] morning. When a concerned resident
[53:31] discovered that Gladys had missed her daily in house
[53:34] service, alarm bells were raised.
[53:37] Initially, staff suspected that she may have had a medical
[53:40] emergency. In the night, responding
[53:43] officers found her lying in bed in disarray with belongings
[53:47] scattered around the room. Evidence indicated that Gladys
[53:51] had been struck with her telephone and then strangled to
[53:55] death. Investigators.
[53:57] Later noted that Gladys's door was left unlocked and that a
[54:01] broken glass panel on an exterior door hinted at forced
[54:05] entry. A neighbor had even reported an
[54:08] unknown man entering an apartment the previous night and
[54:11] demanding money before retreating when refused.
[54:15] Although nothing of significant value appeared to have been
[54:17] stolen, the signs pointed to a burglary that escalated into a
[54:22] horrific act. The shocking nature.
[54:26] Of the crime left residents of Walnut Court fearful for their
[54:29] own safety, prompting the building's management to hire
[54:33] private security and urged tenants to remain vigilant.
[54:37] Less than 24 hours after the slaying of Gladys Held, another
[54:41] tragedy struck only a few blocks away.
[54:44] Jacob Barretts, affectionately known as Old Jake by locals, was
[54:50] found dead in his apartment at 311 Lafayette St. on the morning
[54:54] of December 10th, 1993. Buretz, A.
[54:59] Retired auto mechanic who lived a quiet and solitary life had
[55:03] already experienced a violent incident two weeks earlier
[55:06] during Thanksgiving weekend. In that previous home invasion,
[55:10] his apartment door was kicked in and an assailant, described as a
[55:15] man dressed entirely in black, pepper sprayed and brutally beat
[55:19] him before stealing cash. Adding to the eerie.
[55:23] Connection between this act and the later slayings.
[55:27] Part of this brutal assault included an attempt to strangle
[55:30] Jake. Jake advised the.
[55:32] Authorities that he had recently gotten into a dispute with a cab
[55:36] driver over what he believed to be unfair charges on a trip back
[55:39] to his apartment from a bar. Although Jake survived that
[55:43] attack, the scars of the assault were a painful reminder of the
[55:47] dangers he faced. On the night of December 9th, a
[55:51] neighbor noticed unusual activity near Barrett's
[55:54] apartment, reportedly observing a man wandering the complex and
[55:59] hearing a disturbance later that evening.
[56:02] When this neighbor and the landlady checked on Jake the
[56:05] next morning, they found him on his couch with his arms neatly
[56:08] crossed over his chest. The autopsy later.
[56:12] Determined that he had died from asphyxia caused by suffocation,
[56:16] likely the result of being smothered with a pillow.
[56:20] Unlike the extremely violent struggle in Held's apartment,
[56:24] Beretz's scene appeared controlled, almost as though the
[56:27] perpetrator had taken time to stage the scene.
[56:31] Given that Jake had. Already been targeted in a
[56:33] robbery, many began to wonder if the same criminal had returned
[56:37] to finish the job. The close timing and
[56:40] geographical proximity of these two slayings immediately raised
[56:44] suspicions that they might be the work of a single
[56:47] perpetrator. The two apartment.
[56:50] Buildings are situated only a few blocks apart, and both
[56:53] crimes occurred during the night.
[56:56] Although the exact details of each crime differ slightly, the
[57:00] overall pattern indicates that the perp might have been
[57:03] targeting vulnerable elderly residents, possibly with the
[57:07] intent to commit robbery. Police eventually.
[57:10] Began to treat the crimes as connected and by 2005 officials
[57:15] were openly stating their belief that one man was behind both
[57:19] crimes from the outset. The investigations into these
[57:23] slayings face significant obstacles both.
[57:27] Cases. Yielded very few leads, and
[57:30] despite an intensive police effort, no eyewitnesses came
[57:34] forward with any definitive information.
[57:37] Forensic teams collected blood samples, hair fibers and trace
[57:42] evidence from both scenes. Yet no usable fingerprints were
[57:46] found, suggesting that the perp may have taken precautions such
[57:51] as wearing gloves. Although DNA.
[57:54] Profiling was still emerging as an investigative tool at the
[57:57] time. The samples collected from both
[57:59] crime scenes have yet to match any known offender in the state
[58:03] database. And one question I had, and I'm
[58:06] sure you do too, is whether these two DNA samples match with
[58:10] one another. Well, I hate to break it to you,
[58:14] but the answer isn't readily available.
[58:16] That said, reading between the lines, you'll recall that in
[58:20] 2005, the cops said they think it was the same guy.
[58:25] I think that's confirmation that the DNA from the scenes matches.
[58:29] All that said, the lack of adna match to a database continues to
[58:34] be one of the major stumbling blocks in solving these cases.
[58:38] The limited physical. Evidence was compounded by the
[58:41] absence of clear eyewitness testimony.
[58:45] In the case of Gladys. Held Aside from a neighbor's
[58:48] report of a suspicious intruder demanding money, no one
[58:52] witnessed the crime. Similarly, although a neighbor
[58:56] reported hearing disturbances at Jacob Barrett's apartment, by
[59:00] the time anyone arrived, the assailant had already vanished
[59:04] into the night. In January 1994, Gladys Held's
[59:08] son even offered a reward for information that could lead to
[59:12] an arrest, but this too failed to produce any tangible leads.
[59:17] As a result, police were left with only circumstantial
[59:20] evidence to pursue, and despite periodic reviews by cold case
[59:24] units in later years, the perpetrator has never been
[59:27] identified. The scarcity of definitive
[59:30] evidence has given rise to numerous speculative theories
[59:34] about who might be behind these acts.
[59:37] One of the most popular. Ideas is that a single criminal
[59:40] was targeting elderly residents in Waterloo.
[59:45] Proponents of this theory. Point to the vulnerability of
[59:47] the victims and the methodical nature of the crimes as evidence
[59:51] that the assailant was experienced and calculated in
[59:54] his approach. According to this.
[59:56] View The perpetrator deliberately chose seniors who
[1:00:00] lived alone, making them easy targets for a burglary that
[1:00:04] quickly escalated. Another theory that has received
[1:00:08] significant attention centers on the individual implicated in
[1:00:11] Jacob Barrett's earlier robbery. Barrett's had expressed
[1:00:15] suspicion that a particular cab driver was responsible for his
[1:00:19] brutal assault during Thanksgiving weekend.
[1:00:22] Although this taxi driver theory is intriguing.
[1:00:25] Law enforcement has never publicly confirmed a strong link
[1:00:28] between him and either crime. Beyond the main theories,
[1:00:32] alternative ideas have circulated among amateur
[1:00:35] sleuths. Some speculate that.
[1:00:38] The acts were not solely crimes of opportunity, but part of a
[1:00:42] broader plan to instill fear in the community.
[1:00:45] A few online theorists have suggested that the perpetrator
[1:00:48] might have been emboldened by what he perceived as LAX
[1:00:51] security measures in senior housing.
[1:00:54] These theorists suggest this enabled him to target vulnerable
[1:00:58] residents with minimal risk of detection.
[1:01:01] Although there's little evidence to support a personal vendetta
[1:01:05] or a message driven motive, this possibility adds yet another
[1:01:09] layer of complexity to these cases.
[1:01:12] Personally, I think the. Best chance for resolution of
[1:01:15] these cases is through genetic genealogy.
[1:01:19] The perpetrator's. DNA has been cataloged, and
[1:01:22] these days, even if he isn't in a database, so long as one of
[1:01:25] his relatives wants to know what percentage Irish they are, he'll
[1:01:29] be caught.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.