# Cold Cases So Dark… They Still Haunt Detectives | 277

An episode of [Lazy Chill True Crime](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1815534472), 17 Jul 2026, 1 h 19 min.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/10f1e70d4/podcast/play/122921976/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2026-6-16%2F428076700-44100-2-470e435b08e06.mp3

Join me for some of the most chilling cold cases imaginable. Episode 277 of the true crime podcast btw. Also don't forget to follow, rate and share if you enjoy my content. 👇 Youtube links: Lazy Chill History Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@LazyChillHistory Lazy Chill Zone Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@LazyChillZone 👇 Support My Work: 🛍️ Merch: https://lazy-chill-zone-shop.fourthwall.com ❤️ Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/lazychillzone 👇Social Media Links: https://www.instagram.com/lazychillzone/ 👇 Podcast links: ⚡History Video Podcast on Spotify⚡: https://open.spotify.com/show/7km5pLWpYWEj1mrPpEfRUr?si=0FHYnZf-Qs2FY1GyLevfig ⚡True Crime Podcast on Spotify⚡: https://open.spotify.com/show/0klIz08pAr7wR4we0Ia4sk?si=68qZxCeAQkysXzMZrHE0Iw 🍏 True Crime Podcast on Apple 🍎: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/lazy-chill-true-crime/id1815534472 unsolved mysteries, true crime, cold cases, unsolved mysteries, missing persons, murder investigation, forensic evidence, serial killers, crime scene analysis, dark history, criminal psychology, real life horror, police investigations, DNA breakthroughs, forensic genealogy, crime documentaries, criminal profiling, mysterious disappearances, solved cases, justice system, law enforcement stories, cold case files, creepy mysteries, true crime storytelling, crime reconstruction, chilling cases, investigative reporting, modern forensics, victim advocacy, unidentified remains, crime scene forensics, disturbing cases, true crime analysis, hidden clues, infamous crimes, real crime stories, forensic evidence, serial killers, heists, john doe, jane doe

## Transcript

[0:00] In a Chicago hotel ballroom deep into the early hours of November
[0:03] 21st, 2006, about 50 college students were pretending it was
[0:08] 1990. They were debating how the
[0:11] United Nations Security Council should respond to Saddam
[0:14] Hussein's incursion into Kuwait. Sometime between 2:00 and 2:30
[0:19] AM, during a break in the session, a skinny, red haired 19
[0:23] year old in a green jacket got up from his seat.
[0:26] He rode an escalator down toward the hotel's lower level and
[0:30] walked out of the frame of the last camera that would ever
[0:33] record him. The pretend crisis carried on
[0:37] without him, but the real one was only getting started.
[0:42] Jesse Ross was born on February 18th, 1987 and grew up in
[0:47] Belton, MO, a suburb on the southern edge of Kansas City.
[0:51] His father, Don, worked for the phone company.
[0:54] His mother, Donna, and an older brother, Andy, rounded out the
[0:58] household. Jesse lived in his parents
[1:01] basement, his own little Kingdom, with plans to paint it
[1:05] in Kansas Jayhawks colors and have his friends sign the walls.
[1:10] By the fall of 2006, he was a sophomore communications major
[1:14] at the University of Missouri, Kansas City, and by any
[1:18] reasonable measure, his life was taking off.
[1:21] He'd started as an unpaid intern at 95.7 the Vibe, a Kansas City
[1:27] radio station, and made himself so useful that the station
[1:31] promoted him quickly. He ended up securing a paid on
[1:35] air role on its morning show, which at the time was a big deal
[1:38] for someone who wanted a career in radio.
[1:41] Because he was a pale, freckled redhead, the station gave him
[1:44] the on air name Opie Cunningham. This was a mash up of the two
[1:49] most famous characters Ron Howard ever played, Opie Taylor
[1:53] from The Andy Griffith Show and Richie Cunningham from Happy
[1:57] Days. The station leaned into the bit
[2:00] with a recurring segment called Where's Opie Cunningham?
[2:04] During this segment the show would send Jesse to a mystery
[2:06] location and invite listeners to guess where he was Where's Waldo
[2:11] style. But there was more to Jesse than
[2:14] the radio gig. He was a DJ who liked building
[2:18] his own mixes, and he managed a local rock band.
[2:23] He'd gone through Catholic schools, had no history of
[2:26] trouble, and was described by nearly everyone around him as
[2:30] driven and enthusiastic. A former Co worker later offered
[2:34] a more careful read. Jesse was maybe a little
[2:38] sheltered and a little naive, the kind of person who assumed
[2:42] that everyone had good intentions, according to some
[2:46] theories of the case. That positive attitude which had
[2:50] served him so well in life up until his mysterious
[2:52] disappearance, may have cost him deeply.
[2:57] On November 18th, 2006, Don Ross dropped his son off to meet the
[3:02] Model United Nations group, 14 students in all, who piled into
[3:07] a van for the drive to Chicago that afternoon.
[3:11] Jesse called his dad from the road somewhere near Joliet, IL
[3:15] just to check in and tell him not to worry.
[3:19] They chatted about the Blues Brothers, which, having done
[3:22] that myself on a similar trip, I assume is the style when you're
[3:25] driving into Chicago. Unfortunately though, this light
[3:29] hearted chat would be the last conversation they'd ever have.
[3:34] The event that brought Jesse to Chicago was the American Model
[3:37] United Nations Conference, a four day gathering that drew
[3:41] more than 1000 students from colleges across the country.
[3:45] The main sessions ran at the Sheraton Chicago Hotel and
[3:48] Towers, a huge property on EN Water St. backing onto the
[3:53] Chicago River. The delegates were spread across
[3:56] several hotels and Jesse and his roommate, a friend named Ralph
[4:00] Parker, were booked into the Four Points Hotel.
[4:04] This was a little over half a mile northwest of the conference
[4:07] venue. The first three days were the
[4:10] usual blur of committee meetings, speeches, and free
[4:13] time. On the third afternoon, during a
[4:17] 5 hour break, Jesse took a friend and fellow delegate named
[4:20] Megan to the Billy Goat Tavern. She reportedly found the place a
[4:25] bit dark and unsettling, but Jesse loved it.
[4:28] Some have claimed that Jesse's enjoyment of the location
[4:31] indicated that he had a penchant for gritty locations, which may
[4:35] have played a part in his eventual disappearance.
[4:39] On the final night, November 20th, the conference hosted a
[4:42] dance. Alcohol wasn't permitted at the
[4:45] event itself, but students who were there later acknowledged
[4:48] that plenty of delegates, Jesse among them, were drinking at
[4:52] gatherings before and after. At least one attendee recalled
[4:57] Jesse talking about wanting to find a rave while he was in
[5:01] Chicago, though nobody knows whether that idea ever went
[5:05] anywhere. Then, reportedly around 1:00 AM,
[5:09] the conference threw its signature curveball.
[5:12] Organizers convened an emergency session of the mock Security
[5:16] Council, an overnight crisis simulation reserved for a small
[5:20] subset of delegates. Roughly 50 students out of the
[5:24] 1400 were called in, and the scenario was historical.
[5:30] The year was 1990, and the council had to respond to Iraq's
[5:34] invasion of Kuwait. Jesse, sitting as part of the
[5:38] delegation representing Zaire, went in with the rest of them.
[5:43] Witnesses who sat through that session agreed on the basics.
[5:47] Jesse had reportedly been drinking earlier, but he didn't
[5:51] seem impaired, wasn't acting strangely, and gave no
[5:55] indication that anything was wrong.
[5:59] Sometime between 2:00 and 2:30 AM, during a break, he stepped
[6:03] out of the ballroom, and he reportedly told his friend Ralph
[6:06] that he needed a breather. Hotel cameras picked him up as
[6:10] he left the ballroom and rode an escalator down toward the lower
[6:13] level. He was wearing a white T-shirt,
[6:17] a green warm up jacket, blue jeans and black sneakers with
[6:21] dark wireframe glasses. Those who reviewed the footage
[6:25] said he showed no visible stagger, and nothing about him
[6:28] looked out of the ordinary. The Sheraton had security
[6:32] cameras covering every exit except the ones on the South
[6:35] side of the building, and not one of those cameras recorded
[6:39] Jesse leaving. The walk back to the Four Points
[6:42] was about 10 minutes through the heart of downtown Chicago, well
[6:47] lit and covered by outdoor cameras along the way.
[6:50] But none of them caught him either.
[6:53] The one uncovered route, the South Side, opens onto a
[6:56] Riverside Esplanade, and if Jesse left that way, he'd have
[7:00] come out beside the Chicago River.
[7:03] But that direction leads away from his hotel, and the walkway
[7:07] is lined with A4 foot iron barrier between pedestrians and
[7:11] the water. It isn't a place where someone
[7:13] just happens to stumble and slip beneath the current of the
[7:16] river. Ralph Parker got back to their
[7:20] shared room around 6:00 AM after the emergency session wrapped.
[7:25] The room was dark and there was a pile of clothes and other gear
[7:29] heaped on Jesse's bed. Ralph was tired and didn't
[7:32] investigate much further. He simply assumed the pile was
[7:36] Jesse and went to sleep, which was a fairly reasonable
[7:39] assumption. When he woke later that morning
[7:43] and realized his roommate wasn't there, the alarm spread quite
[7:47] slowly at first. The initial assumption was that
[7:51] he had perhaps stayed the night with someone else, perhaps
[7:54] another college student, as often happens at these sorts of
[7:58] events. Eventually, when it became clear
[8:02] this wasn't the case, the conference organizers were
[8:05] notified. The group he was with began the
[8:08] search and when the van was due to head back to Missouri and
[8:12] Jesse still hadn't surfaced, the call started.
[8:16] His father was contacted and around 4:00 PM on November 21st,
[8:21] a missing person report was filed with the Chicago Police.
[8:25] Detectives searched his hotel room and found nothing out of
[8:28] place and all his belongings were still there.
[8:32] His computer, examined later, held no unusual messages and no
[8:37] hint of any plan about where he may have gone.
[8:40] His cell phone went dead shortly after he vanished, with no odd
[8:44] calls before or after, and it has never registered activity
[8:48] since. His credit cards likewise never
[8:51] saw any further activity after the night of his mysterious
[8:55] disappearance. Whatever happened to Jesse Ross
[8:58] happened fast, and it left no paper trail at all.
[9:03] The Chicago police worked the obvious angle first.
[9:07] The river sits steps from the hotel's S exit.
[9:10] Students had been drinking and young man in urban waterways
[9:14] have a grim statistical relationship.
[9:17] The department's marine unit ran an extensive underwater search
[9:20] in the days after the disappearance and brought up
[9:22] nothing. Years later, a detective named
[9:25] Mike Roth, who inherited the cold case around 2012, sent the
[9:30] marine unit back in with newer, more sensitive sonar equipment.
[9:35] He described the river as a former dumping ground, littered
[9:38] with cars and decades of sunken household junk.
[9:42] The new sweep turned up nothing, and Roth was blunt about the
[9:46] environment, describing the river as dark and murky and
[9:50] laced with chemicals. It's a place where some bodies
[9:54] surface within a day and others take months, with no reliable
[9:59] rule beyond the fact that they do tend to surface.
[10:03] But he was equally blunt about the evidence, saying there
[10:07] wasn't the smallest shred of it to indicate Jesse had been the
[10:10] victim of a crime. He also rejected the runaway
[10:14] angle, pointing out that Jesse's trajectory was straight up a
[10:18] bright college student with a paid radio job at 19.
[10:23] And to give some context to it, having an actual paid radio job
[10:27] at a legitimate station while in college essentially put Jesse on
[10:33] his dream job trajectory. Roth also observed that Jesse
[10:37] didn't fit the profile of someone who ran away to any
[10:40] degree whatsoever. His parents, meanwhile, hired
[10:45] private investigators, gave interviews, printed Flyers, and
[10:49] essentially did everything they could to keep their son's name
[10:52] in the news. A short, televised appeal on
[10:55] America's Most Wanted shook loose a handful of leads that
[10:59] potentially seemed promising. A trucker in Texas thought he'd
[11:04] seen Jesse getting into a vehicle, though he couldn't be
[11:07] exactly sure. A couple running a Florida rehab
[11:11] facility thought he'd stayed with them for a period while he
[11:14] dried out from a Bender. Someone else believed they'd
[11:18] bought an item from him on Craigslist and that he looked
[11:21] like he was in rough shape. Ultimately, though, each one of
[11:26] these potential threads turned up absolutely nothing, and the
[11:29] sightings were never verified. I find the rehab one the most
[11:34] bizarre, since I assume that rehab facilities must have some
[11:38] sort of Know Your Customer protocols in place.
[11:42] Along the way, his parents came to feel that some of the
[11:45] students who'd been in Chicago that night were reluctant to
[11:48] talk to them or their investigator.
[11:51] A few reportedly told the family someone associated with the
[11:55] university had asked them to keep quiet about the entire
[11:58] affair, which the university denied.
[12:03] The university, for its part, said it had handed police a full
[12:07] roster of everyone on the trip and cooperated fully.
[12:11] Detective Roth likewise said nobody had refused to speak with
[12:14] his investigators. Then in 2010, the one person
[12:20] who'd shared a room with Jesse that week, Ralph Parker, lost
[12:24] control of his car in a late night alcohol fueled crash and
[12:29] perished. If Parker knew anything more
[12:33] about what happened to Jesse, he took it to the grave with him.
[12:38] The default theory has always been that the river was involved
[12:41] in Jesse's disappearance in some significant way.
[12:44] It's the explanation police offered the family early on, and
[12:48] it has real weight behind it. The only unmonitored exit points
[12:53] toward the water and alcohol was in the picture.
[12:57] Even though drowned bodies in the river generally do surface,
[13:01] they can theoretically vanish into silt and debris.
[13:05] But the problems are just as real.
[13:07] Since the river lies in the opposite direction from Jesse's
[13:10] hotel, the Esplanade's iron barrier means nobody slips in
[13:15] casually. You'd have to climb it, or be
[13:18] horsing around on it, or be put over it further.
[13:22] Yet repeated searches, including one with upgraded sonar years
[13:26] later, recovered nothing. The second theory is foul play
[13:31] on the street, a mugging gone wrong, or an opportunistic
[13:34] predator. On a quiet November night, the
[13:37] walk was short and considered safe, but at 2:30 AM the
[13:41] sidewalks were mostly empty and a slight trusting kid from the
[13:45] Missouri suburbs would have made an easy mark.
[13:49] The counter argument is the total absence of evidence.
[13:52] Nobody heard or saw a struggle, nothing of his was ever found,
[13:57] and no camera caught so much as his shadow on the route.
[14:01] Personally, having walked around Chicago before for a similar
[14:04] sort of conference when I was in university, I can see this being
[14:07] what happened. Things can get pretty hairy
[14:10] pretty quickly on the streets of Chicago at night, and given that
[14:13] everything suggests Jesse was a bit naive to the streets, a
[14:17] mugging gone wrong seems plausible.
[14:20] That said, of course, I do have to come back to the fact that
[14:22] there's absolutely no evidence that this happened.
[14:26] The third theory keeps the story inside the hotel, and in this
[14:30] version, something went wrong among the students themselves.
[14:35] Perhaps there was an overdose or a fight or some drunken
[14:38] accident, and someone concealed the outcome rather than face the
[14:42] consequences. It would explain why no exterior
[14:47] camera ever recorded Jesse leaving, and it's fed by the
[14:50] family's lingering sense that some attendees knew more than
[14:53] they said. Police never found any evidence
[14:57] for it, but Jesse's own mother has openly wondered whether
[15:00] another student could have moved his body out of the building.
[15:04] The 4th theory is that Jesse walked away on purpose, perhaps
[15:08] toward that rave he'd mentioned, and met trouble later on.
[15:12] Under this theory, some of the sightings later on may actually
[15:16] have been him. Of course, the problem with this
[15:19] theory is that it's completely out of character according to
[15:22] everyone who knew him. And then there's the fifth
[15:25] theory, the one the Internet loves, or perhaps more
[15:29] accurately, loved at one point a decade or so ago.
[15:33] Jesse's case is sometimes folded into the so-called :) killer
[15:38] theory. This is the claim by two retired
[15:41] New York City detectives that dozens of young men found in
[15:44] waterways across the Midwest weren't accidental drownings.
[15:49] Under this theory, these so-called drownings of college
[15:53] aged men are part of attacks carried out by a network of
[15:56] perpetrators. According to the detectives, one
[16:00] of the pieces of evidence that points to this is :) graffiti
[16:04] found nearby to where the crime occurred.
[16:08] Criminologists and the feds have largely dismissed the idea, and
[16:12] Jesse fits it awkwardly at best, since no trace of him has ever
[16:16] been recovered from anybody of water.
[16:19] His name stays on those lists anyway, because a 19 year old
[16:23] who vanished a few 100 feet from a river is exactly the kind of
[16:27] mystery a theory like that feeds on anyway.
[16:31] My personal theory is that Jesse likely ran into the wrong person
[16:35] while attempting to explore Chicago alone at night.
[16:38] The Billy Goat Tavern, which is a bit rough around the edges but
[16:42] isn't actually seedy, may have sparked his interest in
[16:45] exploring the darker side of the Windy City.
[16:48] It's also worth mentioning that he had spoken about attending a
[16:51] rave in the area, and if he did it alone, that could obviously
[16:55] pose some fairly serious risks as well.
[16:58] Ultimately, whatever the case, I just hope Jesse's family get
[17:02] some closure at some point. Hey everyone, it's Jimmy with my
[17:09] usual quick reminder to ring the notification bell and turn on
[17:13] all notifications. Also, don't forget to hit that
[17:16] share button and send this video to your friends and family
[17:19] members who enjoy true crime content and mysteries.
[17:27] On the night of September 18th, 1992, one of the most feared men
[17:31] in New England finished his dinner, stepped out onto the
[17:35] sidewalk and was shot down within steps of the door.
[17:39] Whoever did it knew exactly where he'd be and exactly when
[17:42] he'd walk out from that restaurant.
[17:44] Three shots, all to the head, and then nothing but footsteps
[17:49] fading into a neighborhood where nobody ever sees anything.
[17:53] In the decades since, the men who ordered the hit and planned
[17:56] it have been named in courtrooms and federal filings, but nobody
[18:00] has ever been charged with pulling the trigger.
[18:04] Kevin Hanrahan was born on June 25th, 1953 and grew up to become
[18:10] one of the more unusual fixtures of the New England underworld.
[18:14] He was an Irish American enforcer in an area where the
[18:18] Irish American mob was extremely powerful, but he was trusted
[18:22] with some of the ugliest work of an Italian American crime
[18:25] family. The patriarch of family had run
[18:28] organized crime across New England for decades, and for
[18:32] most of that run it was headquartered not in Boston but
[18:36] in Providence. From there, the elder Raymond
[18:39] Patriarcha directed the whole operation from a vending machine
[18:43] business on Atwells Ave. Under his rule, the family was
[18:47] famous for its discipline, and disputes got settled quietly,
[18:52] and such open violence required approval from the top.
[18:56] Federal Hill functioned as something close to neutral
[18:59] ground, the kind of neighborhood where tourists ate pasta a few
[19:03] doors down from men the FBI had been photographing for years.
[19:08] Atwell's Avenue was the neighborhood's main artery, a
[19:11] strip of restaurants, cafes and social clubs where the line
[19:15] between legitimate business and crime had a habit of blurring.
[19:21] Hanrahan's role in that world was simple.
[19:24] He was freelance muscle, hired whenever the situation required
[19:27] a heavy When a bookmaker got behind or a borrower stopped
[19:31] paying, the family reportedly sent Hanrahan to collect, and if
[19:36] the money still didn't appear, a beating did.
[19:41] He built a reputation as one of the most physically frightening
[19:44] men in the region, and he was the guy who was sent out to
[19:47] rough up other mob enforcers who stepped out of line.
[19:52] In 1975, while he was at a Providence spot called the Club
[19:56] Aries, an unidentified gunman shot him in the chest.
[20:01] When police got to the scene, they found Hanrahan wounded but
[20:05] fully conscious, entirely aware of what had happened and who'd
[20:08] done it. He refused to tell them a single
[20:11] useful thing, claiming he had no idea who had fired the blasts.
[20:16] He was only in his early 20s, and in his world there was no
[20:20] better advertisement. A man who takes a bullet and
[20:23] keeps his mouth shut is a man the mob can use.
[20:28] Authorities suspected him of involvement in several gangland
[20:31] slayings through the 1970s and 1980s, including that of a
[20:36] Providence man named Raymond Vecchio.
[20:39] Hanrahan had a way of slipping through the net for his most
[20:42] serious alleged crimes, though what did stick at various points
[20:47] were charges like jury tampering, witness intimidation,
[20:51] drug trafficking and counterfeiting, which kept him
[20:54] cycling in and out of prison through the 80s.
[20:58] By 1990, Hanrahan was working jobs alongside some of the
[21:02] biggest names in the Patriarcha crime family, and one of those
[21:06] names matters enormously to this story.
[21:09] That year, according to accounts of the case, Hanrahan joined a
[21:13] crew whose members included Francis Salemi, Timothy Mello,
[21:18] Gordon O'Brien and William Anthony.
[21:22] They were mixed up in a plot to grab a Patriarcha bookmaker
[21:25] named Blaze Marfeo outside his restaurant on Providence's east
[21:29] side and ransom him back for a six figure sum.
[21:34] The plan reportedly involved a staged arrest of the bookmaker,
[21:38] complete with a car dressed up to pass for an unmarked police
[21:41] vehicle. But the scheme collapsed.
[21:45] Accomplices were arrested, Hanrahan slipped away before
[21:48] police could grab him, and then Anthony implicated him, forcing
[21:52] him to turn himself in the next day.
[21:55] Remember that detail? In 1990, Hanrahan and Salemi
[22:00] were reportedly on the same side of a kidnapping plot.
[22:03] Within two years, one of them would allegedly be ordering the
[22:06] other's execution and the other would be plotting to fly an
[22:10] explosive remote controlled plane into the other's bedroom.
[22:15] After a stretch at Walpole State Prison, where he'd done time
[22:19] alongside Mello, the two reportedly went into business
[22:22] luring St. Level dealers to an abandoned
[22:25] warehouse. They lured them there with the
[22:27] promise of cheap goods, but when the dealers arrived, they were
[22:31] beaten and robbed. As career moves go, robbing drug
[22:35] dealers has one great advantage, if you want to call it that,
[22:40] which is that the victims don't file complaints with the cops.
[22:44] But it points to something important about Hanrahan in his
[22:47] final years, and it goes back to the fact that his upward
[22:50] mobility was limited. As an associate for an Italian
[22:53] American crime family, He wasn't a made man and never could be,
[23:00] and he'd stopped behaving like someone who answered to anybody.
[23:03] He took scores where he found them, sanctioned or not, and he
[23:07] was accumulating enemies on both sides of the law.
[23:11] He was also doing it at the worst possible moment.
[23:14] The old boss, Raymond Patriarcha Senior, had passed in 1984.
[23:21] The highly organized crime family he'd run for three
[23:23] decades came apart in slow motion under his son.
[23:28] By the early 90's, the organization had split into
[23:31] feuding Providence in Boston factions, and the man rising
[23:35] through the wreckage was Salemi. Frank Salemi was no stranger to
[23:39] spectacular violence himself. Back in 1968, he'd been involved
[23:45] in a car bombing in Everett, MA that tore the leg off an
[23:49] attorney named John Fitzgerald, who'd been representing a mob
[23:53] turncoat. Selemi went on the run, was
[23:56] eventually captured in New York, and served roughly 15 years for
[24:00] it. In June 1989, Selemi was
[24:05] ambushed and wounded outside a pancake house in Saugus, MA, an
[24:10] attack that announced just how contested the throne had become.
[24:14] By 1991, he'd come out on top as boss anyway, and a string of
[24:18] bodies followed. A gambler named Howard Ferrini
[24:22] was found in the trunk of his Cadillac at Logan Airport in
[24:25] August 1991, a plastic bag tied over his head.
[24:30] Robert Donati, A mobster some believed was involved in the
[24:33] Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum heist, turned up in the trunk of
[24:37] his own Cadillac a month later. Other figures in the New England
[24:41] organized crime world also disappeared or turned up dead
[24:45] during this period, and I'm probably not going to surprise
[24:49] many of you here, but these cases tended to go unsolved.
[24:54] Then, in 2021, the Ferrini case took a turn that reshuffled the
[24:59] whole picture. Investigators announced that a
[25:02] fingerprint lifted from the bag tied over Ferrini's head belong
[25:06] to Kevin Hanrahan. September 18th, 1992 was a
[25:12] Friday, and that evening Hanrahan sat down to dinner at
[25:15] The Arch, a restaurant on Atwells Ave.
[25:19] It was the heart of the neighborhood where he'd spent a
[25:21] career collecting money with his fists.
[25:24] His dinner company reportedly included a businessman named
[25:27] Polly Kalenda and at least one man who was already secretly
[25:31] working with law enforcement. Years later, speaking from
[25:36] inside the federal Witness Protection Program, that
[25:39] informant described the surreal experience of learning what
[25:42] happened after he left. He'd grown up seeing cops as the
[25:46] villains of the story and had wanted nothing more than to be a
[25:50] wise guy himself, which made the lesson land harder.
[25:55] He recalled being badly shaken when he heard the news the next
[25:58] morning, observing that it isn't a normal life event to share a
[26:02] meal with a man who gets whacked 20 minutes later.
[26:05] Hanrahan, for his part, had reportedly been telling friends
[26:09] he was expecting a big score, something substantial enough to
[26:13] be worth mentioning. He didn't mention what it was
[26:16] specifically, but whatever he thought was coming, it wasn't
[26:21] what came When he stepped out of the restaurant onto Atwells Ave.
[26:26] that night, the gunman closed in.
[26:29] Two of them by most accounts, but perhaps three.
[26:33] They shot him three times in the head and made sure the job was
[26:37] finished because with a man like Hanrahan, half measures meant
[26:41] that he would be coming for you next.
[26:44] Hanrahan was rushed to Rhode Island Hospital and passed away
[26:47] from his injuries that night. He was 39 years old.
[26:53] The location is an extremely important detail to the
[26:56] narrative here. And this was an execution on
[26:59] Federal Hill's Main Street. It was steps from busy
[27:02] restaurants on a Friday night in what amounted to the mob's
[27:06] living room. And it told investigators
[27:08] everything they needed to know except who pulled the trigger.
[27:12] Everything. Because nobody eliminates A
[27:14] feared patriarchal enforcer on Federal Hill without permission
[27:18] from the top. But it also said nothing because
[27:22] the people who might have seen it happen understood the
[27:25] neighborhood's oldest rule. If you thought you saw
[27:28] something, you didn't. And if you insisted you did see
[27:32] something, you might come down with a bout of amnesia before
[27:36] any trial actually took place. The Providence police had
[27:41] theories from the start, and the press had more.
[27:45] The obvious reading was that Hanrahan had been swallowed by
[27:48] the conflict inside the Patriarch of family, one more
[27:51] casualty in the Providence versus Boston feud.
[27:55] The other reading was simpler. A freelance shakedown artist had
[27:59] finally squeezed the wrong person, and that person was
[28:03] given the green light to take revenge.
[28:06] Neither theory produced a suspect, and the case settled
[28:10] into the long silence that mob crimes in Providence tended to
[28:13] enjoy during that period. Part of the problem was
[28:17] structural. The generation of men who knew
[28:20] what happened on Atwells Ave. had been raised on the
[28:23] patriarchal ethic of silence. This was the same ethic Hanrahan
[28:28] himself had demonstrated from a Providence club in 1975 when he
[28:32] was shot. Cases like his didn't get solved
[28:36] through fingerprints and Ballistics.
[28:39] They got solved when somebody with something to lose decided
[28:42] that talking was worth more than loyalty.
[28:44] And in the early 90s, that calculation hadn't tipped yet.
[28:49] The first real crack came in 2010, when two federal
[28:53] informants alleged that the hit had been greenlit by Frank
[28:56] Salemi himself. The reason, they claimed, was
[28:59] that Hanrahan had been shaking down a bookmaker in Taunton, MA,
[29:03] for protection money. And that bookmaker evidently had
[29:06] protection of his own. According to that account, word
[29:11] of the squeeze reached Gordon O'Brien, the same mobster who'd
[29:15] been part of a crew with Hanrahan previously.
[29:19] According to this allegation, O'Brien then picked up the phone
[29:22] and called Salemi, and within days, Hanrahan was hit.
[29:27] By 2016, a Rhode Island grand jury had reportedly been hearing
[29:32] evidence in the case for months. But what investigators needed
[29:36] was somebody on the inside willing to talk.
[29:40] As it turned out, somebody on the inside had already talked
[29:44] his way into a corner. Robert DeLuca was a made capo in
[29:48] the patriarch of family and eventually the single most
[29:52] consequential figure in this entire narrative.
[29:56] He came with a peculiar historical distinction.
[29:59] In October 1989, the FBI had secretly recorded a Mafia
[30:04] induction ceremony in a house in Medford, MA, the first time the
[30:09] ritual had ever been captured on tape.
[30:12] DeLuca was one of the men being formally made that day, and he'd
[30:15] sworn the oath of silence into a hidden federal microphone.
[30:20] His unraveling started in 2011, when he was charged in a federal
[30:24] case that would have seen him spend the rest of his life in
[30:27] prison. DeLuca cut a cooperation deal
[30:31] and did remarkably well out of it, receiving a sentence of a
[30:35] single day in prison in 2014. Then the ground shifted
[30:41] underneath him, and in 2016, investigators acting on new
[30:46] information dug up the remains of Steven Desarro, A nightclub
[30:50] owner who disappeared in 93. The body was found behind an old
[30:55] mill building in Providence. The discovery blew open a case
[30:59] DeLuca had claimed to know nothing about, and the
[31:02] government concluded he'd been lying to them the whole time,
[31:06] including Hanrahan's case. He was arrested again in June
[31:10] 2016, pleaded guilty in federal court to lying to investigators,
[31:15] and this time the truth started coming out in volume.
[31:19] In January 2017, at a surprise hearing in a Rhode Island
[31:24] courtroom, DeLuca entered a no contest plea in the Hanrahan
[31:28] hit, becoming the only person ever charged in this case.
[31:33] The account he gave investigators, which prosecutors
[31:36] later laid out in filings ahead of Salemi's 2018 trial in
[31:40] Boston, finally put shape to the case.
[31:44] Salemi, by this account, ordered Hanrahan eliminated because the
[31:49] enforcer was suspected of plotting to take out Salemi
[31:52] himself. DeLuca and a mobster named Rocco
[31:57] Argenti were assigned to the job, but Argenti couldn't
[32:00] confirm or deny any of it, having died of natural causes in
[32:04] 2002. Notably, these two weren't the
[32:09] triggerman, and DeLuca never named who was actually
[32:12] responsible for firing the shots.
[32:14] Salemi, whose trial concerned the hit on Desarro rather than
[32:18] Hanrahan, was convicted in 2018 with Deluca's help.
[32:23] DeLuca himself, by then in his 70s and telling anyone who'd
[32:27] listened that he'd renounced the mob and found God, was sentenced
[32:31] in the fall of 2020 to 10 years for the Hanrahan hit.
[32:36] However, as a result of his broader cooperation, time served
[32:41] as well as his failing health, a federal judge granted him
[32:45] compassionate release just weeks later.
[32:49] But that's far from the end of the story, and not just because
[32:52] the actual shooters remain unknown.
[32:56] There's the strangest chapter, the one that surfaced in May
[32:59] 2018 in a federal court filing that got sealed again within
[33:03] hours of appearing on the docket.
[33:06] Inside it was a report from March 2016 summarizing what yet
[33:10] another informant had claimed about the weeks before
[33:13] Hanrahan's death. According to that account,
[33:17] Hanrahan had been trying to buy plastic explosives from a Boston
[33:20] contact known as Smitty, and he had two uses in mind.
[33:25] The first was to pack explosives onto a remote control airplane
[33:29] and fly it through the bedroom window of Frank Salemi's home,
[33:33] taking the boss and his wife with it.
[33:36] The second was a briefcase bomb to be left and detonated at Euro
[33:41] Bistro and Atwell's Avenue restaurant with ties to the mob.
[33:46] Around the same time, Hanrahan had reportedly been seen lurking
[33:50] behind a dumpster near the rear of Salemi's house, possibly
[33:53] disguised as a woman. It reads like something out of a
[33:57] cartoon, and it's fair to hold informant claims at arm's
[34:00] length, especially colorful ones surfacing 1/4 century after the
[34:04] fact. But notice who the targets were.
[34:08] The bomb plots described in that report were aimed at precisely
[34:12] the men DeLuca identified as the architects of Hanrahan's death.
[34:18] Before the case fades into history, it's worth
[34:21] acknowledging that the accounts of why the hit was ordered don't
[34:24] fit together neatly. One version says Hanrahan shook
[34:28] down the wrong bookmaker, while another says Salemi believed
[34:32] Hanrahan was plotting to assassinate him.
[34:36] Then there's the extraordinary allegation that Hanrahan was
[34:39] trying to pull off an absolutely bizarre bomb plot.
[34:43] It's entirely possible that more than one of these stories
[34:46] contains a measure of truth, or that some were invented after
[34:50] the fact by informants with their own reasons for reshaping
[34:53] the past. That's the difficulty with
[34:56] organized crime history. By the time investigators
[34:59] finally hear the story, decades have passed and many of the
[35:03] people involved are dead. The other problem is that every
[35:07] informant was a former insider, someone with an angle.
[35:11] They're still working, at least to a certain degree.
[35:15] What remains clear is that Kevin Hanrahan made enough powerful
[35:19] enemies that someone with real authority decided he needed to
[35:23] be crossed off. Exactly why that decision was
[35:27] made and who ultimately carried it out may remain one of New
[35:31] England's great unsolved Mafia mysteries.
[35:36] Hey friends, it's Jimmy here welcoming you to episode 248 of
[35:40] this mystery series where we discuss all things unsolved.
[35:43] With that said, don't forget to hit the notification bell and
[35:46] turn on all notifications and drop a quick comment saying
[35:50] where you're listening from. Or if you don't want to do that,
[35:53] just leave a quick comment saying I'm doing my part.
[35:56] Just like the meme. Imagine a brilliant physicist,
[36:01] spoken of in the same breath as Galileo and Newton, stepping
[36:04] onto a ship one evening and vanishing without a trace.
[36:08] This is exactly what happened in 1938, when Ettore Maharana, a
[36:13] prodigious Italian scientist, disappeared under eerie
[36:16] circumstances. But this isn't your usual
[36:19] missing person case, and it turns out that there's very good
[36:23] evidence to suggest he actually lived his life out half a world
[36:26] away. Ettore Majorana was born in
[36:31] Catania, Sicily on August 5th 19 O 6 into a well off family of
[36:36] intellectuals. From a young age he showed
[36:39] exceptional and perhaps even prodigious mathematical talent.
[36:45] He initially pursued engineering at university, likely due to his
[36:49] father's influence, but ultimately switched to physics,
[36:53] where he fell into the circle of legendary physicist Enrico
[36:56] Fermi. Majorana quickly stood out even
[37:00] among these bright minds, astonishing peers and mentors
[37:03] with elegant solutions to tough problems.
[37:07] His contributions to theoretical physics were profound, Though he
[37:11] had little interest in publishing papers, he tackled
[37:14] quantum theory and subatomic particles, and he even
[37:18] anticipated the existence of the neutron before it was officially
[37:21] discovered. Mayerana's modesty and
[37:25] reluctance to publish meant he only authored 9 scientific
[37:29] papers in his life, but those few works left an enduring
[37:33] legacy. Despite, or perhaps because of
[37:37] his brilliance, Mayerana became increasingly reclusive and
[37:41] troubled. In the mid 1930s.
[37:44] After a fruitful period working with renowned physicists like
[37:47] Werner Heisenberg in Germany and Niels Bohr in Copenhagen,
[37:52] Majerana returned to Italy with a growing sense of isolation.
[37:57] He saw his own work as trivial and was often reluctant to share
[38:01] his breakthroughs. Friends and colleagues noted
[38:04] that he withdrew from social life.
[38:07] For several years he largely shut himself away, avoiding even
[38:11] close family and friends. In late 1937, however, he took a
[38:17] post as a full professor of theoretical physics at the
[38:20] University of Naples, an extraordinary appointment for a
[38:24] 31 year old. This role brought him out of
[38:27] isolation briefly as he began teaching in early 1938.
[38:32] Yet those around him could see he was not at ease.
[38:36] Magerano was devoutly Catholic and prone to what have been
[38:40] called mystical crises, and he seemed burdened by internal
[38:44] conflicts. These personal struggles, which
[38:47] may be viewed as bouts of acute mental illness, foreshadowed the
[38:51] dramatic steps he would soon take.
[38:56] In late March 1938, Mayorana's inner turmoil came to a head.
[39:01] Without warning, he withdrew all the money from his bank account
[39:04] and even collected back pay. He had never bothered to pick up
[39:08] signs that he was putting his affairs in order.
[39:12] On March 25th, 1938, Mayorana left Naples, likely aboard the
[39:17] steamer Sita di Palermo, bound for Sicily.
[39:22] Before departing, he penned A cryptic letter to his colleague
[39:25] and friend Antonio Corelli, the director of the Naples Physics
[39:30] Institute. In this note, Mayorana stated he
[39:34] had made an unavoidable decision and apologized for the trouble.
[39:38] His sudden disappearance would 'cause he asked Corelli to
[39:42] remember him kindly to colleagues and students, hinting
[39:45] that by the time the letter was read, he might already be gone,
[39:50] This sounded ominously like a farewell.
[39:53] Yet the very same evening, Mayorana sent a follow up
[39:57] telegram from Palermo in Sicily that baffled everyone.
[40:01] It's said that the sea had quote UN quote rejected him and that
[40:06] he'd be heading back tomorrow. This dramatic phrase suggested
[40:10] that Mayorana had a serious change of heart.
[40:13] Some interpret it to mean he might have tried eliminating
[40:16] himself by jumping into the sea during the voyage, but then
[40:21] survived or reconsidered. True to his word, he appeared to
[40:25] purchase a return ticket and may have boarded a ship back to
[40:29] Naples on March 26th. In fact, there were unconfirmed
[40:33] reports that colleagues saw him on the Naples bound boat or back
[40:37] in Naples shortly thereafter. However, after that point,
[40:41] Ettore Majerana was never seen again in the official record.
[40:47] When he failed to reappear, his family and friends panicked.
[40:51] Mayorana's disappearance was reported to the authorities and
[40:55] an intensive search was launched both in Sicily and on the
[40:58] Italian mainland. The news that such a famed
[41:02] physicist had vanished triggered a massive response.
[41:06] Meyerana's family, colleagues and the Italian police undertook
[41:10] A frantic search, scouring passenger lists, ports and
[41:15] coastlines for any trace of him. Even Meyerana's mentor, Enrico
[41:20] Fermi, intervened at the highest levels.
[41:23] Fermi, who deeply appreciated Meyerana's unique genius,
[41:27] reportedly told his wife that if Ettore had decided to disappear,
[41:32] he was clever enough that no one would ever find him.
[41:35] Notably, this statement has later been interpreted as
[41:38] indicating that Fermi may have known more than he was letting
[41:41] on. As you'll see shortly, despite
[41:45] this grim acknowledgement of Majorana's cunning, Fermi was
[41:49] determined to try. He even appealed to Italy's
[41:52] leader, Benito Mussolini, to dedicate government resources to
[41:56] finding the missing scientist, convincing Mussolini that this
[42:00] was a matter of national security.
[42:03] An extensive manhunt ensued, ships and hospitals were
[42:07] checked, and the Italian Navy combed the sea routes, but
[42:11] nothing concrete emerged. The only clues left behind were
[42:16] Mayorana's haunting letters. In his hotel room in Naples, a
[42:20] short note addressed to his family was found.
[42:24] It told them not to mourn him in traditional black clothing,
[42:28] perhaps signifying that he had simply disappeared and wasn't
[42:31] actually deceased. Over the ensuing decades,
[42:36] numerous theories emerged to explain what might have happened
[42:39] to The Vanishing genius. 1 popular idea is that Mayerana
[42:44] foresaw the destructive power of nuclear physics and chose to
[42:48] disappear to avoid any role in it.
[42:51] While Mayerana's colleagues like Fermi did go on to work on the
[42:55] Manhattan Project, there's no direct evidence that Mayerana
[42:59] himself voiced such fears before he vanished.
[43:03] Still, the timing and his brilliance make this theory
[43:06] enticing. A genius fleeing the future he
[43:09] predicted. Over the years, there were
[43:14] numerous reported sightings of Mayerana in places like
[43:17] Argentina and Venezuela. Some hypothesized that he
[43:21] secretly fled Italy, possibly motivated by guilt or a desire
[43:26] to live anonymously far from the looming conflict in Europe.
[43:31] In fact, in the 1950s, an Italian television claimed to
[43:34] have tracked him down to Venezuela, where he was living a
[43:38] simple life under an assumed identity.
[43:41] The only problem with this theory, though, is that they
[43:43] decided to continue to let him live his life of quiet
[43:46] anonymity. Some have speculated that the
[43:50] producers could have simply made-up this narrative for a
[43:52] television series, given the popularity of the case in Italy.
[43:58] That said, of course, it's also possible that they did track him
[44:01] down and that they chose to respect his wishes.
[44:05] I'll come back to this theory in a moment, though, since there
[44:08] was a recent explosive development relating to that
[44:10] Italian documentary. Others, of course, believe that
[44:16] Mayerana may have simply ended his own life, though this theory
[44:20] has been hotly contested. Mayerana's devout Catholic faith
[44:24] and the absence of a body, as well as the note telling his
[44:28] family not to mourn in black, are all factors against this.
[44:33] Further, there's also the fact that he appears to have rejected
[44:36] the idea of ending himself when he came back from Sicily.
[44:42] A theory favored by Mayorana's own family was that he suffered
[44:46] a spiritual or existential crisis and retreated to a
[44:49] monastery in Italy. Given his religious devotion,
[44:53] they speculated, he might have chosen a life of seclusion and
[44:57] contemplation over fame. Indeed, his priest and confessor
[45:03] hinted that Ettore had experienced deep mystical
[45:06] episodes and may have had other plans for his life.
[45:11] Naturally, though, this priest couldn't come out and say what
[45:13] happened even if he knew what did, so long as the context of
[45:18] what was said was during confession.
[45:21] This theory portrays Mayerana's disappearance almost as a
[45:25] deliberate act of spiritual exile, mirroring the idea of the
[45:29] more physical self exile from Italy.
[45:32] Like with Fermi, the fact that his confessor gave this cryptic
[45:36] statement has been viewed as somewhat unusual in light of
[45:40] subsequent happenings. There were even darker
[45:44] speculations that Mayerana might have been kidnapped or killed
[45:48] because of the sensitive knowledge he possessed.
[45:51] Some wondered if agents of a foreign power or even shadowy
[45:55] elements within Italy abducted him to prevent his intellect
[45:58] from aiding another country's atomic projects.
[46:02] Given that Mayorana would have almost certainly been working on
[46:04] the Manhattan Project if he had followed Fermi to America, this
[46:09] idea has gathered a lot of steam.
[46:12] That said, while it may be interesting to speculate about,
[46:15] there's no evidence whatsoever to suggest this was the case.
[46:20] Remarkably, the case saw a revival in the 21st century when
[46:25] new clues emerged. In 2011, an elderly witness came
[46:30] forward in Italy claiming not only to have seen Mayerana alive
[46:34] in the late 1940s, but even to have befriended him in Buenos
[46:38] Aires. This prompted the Rome
[46:41] Attorney's Office to officially reopen the investigation 73
[46:46] years after Mayerana vanished. Soon, a photograph surfaced
[46:51] allegedly showing Mayerana, under the name Mr. Beanie,
[46:56] living in Valencia in Venezuela in 1955.
[47:00] Forensic analysts compared this photo with images of Mayerana
[47:04] and found a number of striking similarities in facial features.
[47:09] Also, if you're one of those people who just listens, this
[47:12] may be a good time to take a look and see if you can see the
[47:15] resemblance between the two men. Adding to the intrigue, reports
[47:21] emerged of a postcard written by Mayerana's uncle that was
[47:25] purportedly found among the belongings of this mysterious
[47:28] individual. These pieces of evidence
[47:31] strongly suggested that Mayerana had survived and lived in South
[47:35] America under an assumed identity.
[47:38] Following these developments, Italian authorities announced an
[47:41] official conclusion. In February 2015, the Rome
[47:47] Attorney's Office declared that he likely lived abroad in
[47:50] Venezuela at least from 1955 to 1959.
[47:55] No criminal act was identified. In other words, the
[47:58] investigation found that Mayorana likely chose to remove
[48:02] himself from his former life. With that statement, the decades
[48:06] old case was closed. From a legal standpoint, it's an
[48:10] astonishing outcome. After so many years of
[48:13] uncertainty, the authorities essentially concluded that the
[48:17] genius physicist quietly lived out his life in obscurity.
[48:23] The official verdict has not put an end to the fascination with
[48:26] Mayorana's story. Even if he did live Incognito in
[48:30] Venezuela, many unanswered questions remain.
[48:34] Why would a scientist of Mayorana's caliber abandoned A
[48:38] promising career and family to live in hiding?
[48:42] Was he truly driven by a moral objection to nuclear weapons,
[48:46] overwhelming anxiety, or something else we may never
[48:49] understand? It's also unknown what
[48:53] ultimately became of him after 1959.
[48:56] If he lived longer, he appears to have kept an exceedingly low
[49:00] profile. In 2025, nearly 87 years after
[49:04] he vanished, an Italian court finally declared Ettore Majorana
[49:09] presumed dead, providing legal closure to his status.
[49:17] It was a routine spring afternoon on a quiet country Rd.
[49:20] in Texas when a mother stopped her pickup truck to drop off her
[49:24] two young daughters. Moments later, one of them, a 2
[49:29] year old girl named Desiree Carroll, vanished into thin air.
[49:35] In March 1983, two year old Desiree was living with her
[49:38] mother, Anne Elizabeth Carroll and five year old sister Heather
[49:43] in a rural area near the small town of Kos, Texas.
[49:47] They had moved into a house owned by Anne's boyfriend, David
[49:50] Morris. Desiree's parents were divorced,
[49:54] Anne had custody, but her ex-husband Reggie still visited
[49:58] the girls regularly. On March 25th, 1983, Anne set
[50:04] out on an errand in nearby Marlin and left her daughters at
[50:07] the start of the long dirt driveway leading up to their
[50:10] home. Heather was able to walk to the
[50:13] house on her own and Desiree was supposed to follow, but as
[50:18] Anne's pickup truck pulled away, Desiree tried to chase after it
[50:22] instead of going with her sister.
[50:24] That was the last time anyone saw her.
[50:28] When Anne returned later that day, Desiree was nowhere to be
[50:31] found, and a frantic search began.
[50:36] Authorities and volunteers immediately mobilized to scour
[50:40] the area for the missing toddler.
[50:42] Hundreds of people from several counties combed the woods around
[50:46] the Carroll home. Aided by law enforcement and
[50:49] even National Guard units, they searched tirelessly on foot and
[50:54] by air. At one point, heavy rain
[50:58] drenched the area, hindering the volunteers and possibly washing
[51:02] away any tracks or clues. Even with a full week of effort,
[51:07] not a single piece of evidence was found, not a footprint, not
[51:11] a scrap of clothing. Baffled, local authorities even
[51:15] called in help from the Texas Rangers and the FBI.
[51:19] As days passed with no sign of the child, with no leads from
[51:25] the search, investigators turned a wary eye toward those closest
[51:29] to the child. About a week after the
[51:32] disappearance, the Limestone County Sheriff held a meeting
[51:35] with other officers to share notes and observations.
[51:39] They found it odd that Anne and David displayed so little
[51:42] emotion in the wake of Desiree's disappearance.
[51:46] In a curious move, Anne and David left their home a few days
[51:50] after the tragedy and went to a motel in Waco, saying they
[51:55] needed to get away from the volunteer searchers.
[51:59] These circumstances raised suspicions that perhaps
[52:02] something other than a simple lost child scenario had
[52:05] occurred. That said, it's important to
[52:07] note that many of these searchers appear to have
[52:09] believed they were responsible for Desiree's disappearance.
[52:13] Personally, I suspect Anne's odd behavior may have stemmed from
[52:17] the fact that she left her toddler in the care of a 5 year
[52:20] old. Regardless if there was any
[52:22] criminal culpability to that act, leaving a 2 year old in
[52:26] that sort of situation is highly questionable.
[52:31] Investigators pursued every theory they could think of to
[52:34] explain Desiree's vanishing. They determined that she may
[52:38] have simply gotten lost in the woods in the wilderness near her
[52:41] home, but if this was accurate, it was odd that no signs were
[52:45] found. Of course, they also
[52:48] investigated if she had been killed by her parents, but they
[52:51] weren't able to find any evidence of this either.
[52:54] Another theory they pursued was that she was secretly given away
[52:57] to another person to raise since they didn't want the burden of
[53:01] dealing with her. Anne, burdened by grief and
[53:07] scrutiny that she may have been involved, turned to activism
[53:12] just weeks after her daughter vanished.
[53:14] She testified before the Texas Legislature to urge better
[53:17] protections for children. Her emotional testimony helped
[53:21] prompt a new state law offering free fingerprinting of children
[53:25] so that identifying records would be available if a child
[53:28] ever went missing. Personally, I suspect that she
[53:33] wouldn't have done this if she had actually been responsible
[53:36] for her daughter going missing. Decades have passed, but the
[53:42] mystery of what happened to Desiree Carroll endures.
[53:46] In 2018, Desiree's sister Heather passed away at age 40,
[53:52] and Heather's obituary listed Desiree as having predeceased
[53:55] her. Officially, Desiree is still a
[53:58] missing person and her profile remains in law enforcement
[54:02] databases. Tara Grinstead was a 30 year old
[54:07] high school history teacher and former beauty queen living in
[54:10] the small town of Ocilla, Georgia.
[54:13] She taught 11th grade history at Irwin County High School and was
[54:17] known for her vibrant personality and dedication to
[54:20] her students. During her college years, Tara
[54:23] had been active in pageants and she won a local Miss Tifton
[54:27] title and even competed for Miss Georgia using scholarship
[54:31] winnings to help pay for school. By 2005, she was a beloved
[54:36] figure in Ocilla's community and served as a mentor for young
[54:40] women on a similar life path that she had taken.
[54:44] Unfortunately, this beloved local teacher's life was about
[54:48] to be cut tragically short. On Saturday, October 22nd, 2005,
[54:57] Tara spent the day involved in the beauty pageant world she
[55:00] loved. She helped a friend prepare
[55:02] contestants for the local Miss Sweet Potato pageant and
[55:06] attended the event that evening as a coach and supporter.
[55:10] After the pageant, she visited a friend's house and then went to
[55:14] a neighbour's cookout, socializing into the night.
[55:19] Witnesses later recalled that around 11:00 PM, Tara was walked
[55:23] to her car by a friend after the cookout, and she then headed
[55:26] home to her nearby house by herself.
[55:29] That weekend, Tara failed to return phone calls and an
[55:33] acquaintance, a local police captain, reportedly tried to
[55:37] reach her multiple times on Sunday without success.
[55:41] However, it wasn't until Monday that her friends and family
[55:44] realized that something had gone terribly wrong.
[55:48] On the morning of Monday, October 24th, Tara did not show
[55:52] up for work at the high school and her unexplained absence
[55:56] immediately alarmed her Co workers.
[55:59] Concerned colleagues contacted the authorities to do a welfare
[56:02] check at her home. Police arrived at Tara
[56:07] Grinstead's residence later that day and found an eerie scene.
[56:11] Her car was parked in the driveway and inside the house
[56:15] they discovered Tara's cell phone and an unlocked door, but
[56:19] there was no sign of Tara herself.
[56:22] Oddly, her purse and keys were missing, suggesting she had left
[56:26] the house with those personal items and had not returned.
[56:30] Investigators noted there were no obvious signs of forced entry
[56:34] into the home and no indications of a struggle, such as broken
[56:38] furniture or blood evidence. The scene was essentially
[56:42] undisturbed apart from the mystery of Tara's disappearance.
[56:46] Given these suspicious circumstances, local police
[56:49] immediately called upon the Georgia Bureau of Investigation
[56:52] to take the lead. As the GBI took charge, a
[56:58] massive search effort unfolded in Ocilla and the surrounding
[57:01] areas. Law enforcement and volunteers
[57:04] from the community mobilized quickly.
[57:07] They canvassed neighborhoods, distributed Flyers, put up
[57:11] billboards, and organized ground searches in hopes of finding any
[57:15] trace of Terra. Despite these efforts, days and
[57:20] then weeks passed with no significant leads.
[57:25] Early on, investigators did recover one potentially crucial
[57:29] piece of evidence just outside Tara's home, a latex glove lying
[57:34] in her yard. Forensic testing revealed the
[57:37] glove bore DNA from an unknown male, raising the strong
[57:41] possibility that Tara had encountered someone the night
[57:44] she went missing. However, this clue led to
[57:48] frustration rather than a quick solution, as the DNA didn't
[57:53] match any of the dozens of men investigators tested.
[57:57] The glove's origin remained a mystery, suggesting the presence
[58:01] of an unidentified man at Tara's house but giving no further
[58:05] leads to pursue. With physical evidence scarce,
[58:11] the early investigation had to explore every conceivable angle.
[58:16] Detectives conducted interviews with people in Tara's life and
[58:19] checked her phone records and computer for hints.
[58:22] In the absence of quick answers, numerous theories and suspects
[58:26] were scrutinized during those early years.
[58:29] One focus of suspicion was Tara's ex-boyfriend, Marcus
[58:33] Harper, a former Ocilla police officer and Army Ranger.
[58:39] Their long relationship had ended not long before Tara
[58:42] disappeared, and some wondered if a jealous rage or dispute
[58:46] might explain her fate. Harper was thoroughly
[58:49] investigated by authorities and was fully cooperative
[58:53] throughout. He voluntarily provided DNA
[58:57] samples, allowed searches of his vehicle and fully accounted for
[59:02] his whereabouts on the night in question.
[59:05] His alibi checked out and his DNA didn't match the glove,
[59:09] leading police to conclude Harper wasn't involved.
[59:16] Another individual examined was Anthony Vickers, a former
[59:19] student of Tara's. Earlier in 2005, Vickers had
[59:24] caused a disturbance outside Tara's home, an incident that
[59:28] resulted in his arrest for disorderly conduct.
[59:32] Given that prior incident, investigators interviewed him
[59:35] regarding the disappearance, but they found no evidence tying
[59:39] Vickers to it and didn't consider him a suspect in Tara's
[59:42] case. With those close to Tara
[59:45] seemingly cleared, some theories speculated that she might have
[59:49] fallen victim to a stranger abduction or a crime of
[59:52] opportunity. After over a decade of
[59:57] frustration, a major break in the case finally arrived in
[1:00:01] 2017. The catalyst was an unexpected
[1:00:05] tip preceded by a resurgence of public interest.
[1:00:09] In 2016, a podcast called Up and Vanished devoted its first
[1:00:14] season to Tara's disappearance, bringing new attention to the
[1:00:17] long dormant mystery. Not long after the podcast
[1:00:21] aired, a young woman came forward to the GBI with crucial
[1:00:25] information. This woman, Brooke Sheridan, was
[1:00:29] the girlfriend of Beau Dukes, a former friend and classmate of a
[1:00:33] man named Ryan Duke. Both men had been students at
[1:00:37] Irwin County High when Tara taught there years before.
[1:00:40] She told investigators that after the increased publicity on
[1:00:44] the case brought on by the podcast, Beau Dukes had
[1:00:48] confessed to her that he knew what happened to Tara.
[1:00:51] Acting on this tip, authorities reinterviewed those involved and
[1:00:55] soon made a stunning announcement.
[1:00:58] On February 23rd, 2017, they arrested Ryan Duke and charged
[1:01:04] him with the slaying of Tara Grinstead.
[1:01:07] Days later, Beau Dukes was also arrested, accused of helping
[1:01:12] conceal the crime and tampering with evidence.
[1:01:17] According to GBI investigators, Ryan Duke, who was 21 at the
[1:01:22] time of the crime, had allegedly broken into Tara's house in the
[1:01:26] late hours of October 22nd, 2005.
[1:01:30] They believe Tara caught him in the act, leading Duke to fatally
[1:01:34] attack her. After slaying her, Duke
[1:01:37] reportedly removed her body from the home.
[1:01:41] It was then, investigators say, that he enlisted the help of his
[1:01:44] friend Beau Dukes to dispose of the remains.
[1:01:48] Dukes, whose family owned a large farm in a neighboring
[1:01:51] county, later admitted that he assisted Ryan in hiding Tara's
[1:01:55] body. The two men allegedly took
[1:01:58] Tara's remains to a remote corner of the Duke's family
[1:02:02] orchard and burned them to destroy evidence of the crime.
[1:02:07] This chilling revelation explained why exhaustive
[1:02:09] searches had never found Tara's body.
[1:02:12] Investigators even conducted a multi day excavation of the
[1:02:15] orchard land in 2017 after the arrests, but they turned up no
[1:02:21] identifiable remains. The arrests of Ryan Duke and
[1:02:25] Beau Dukes, nearly 12 years after Tara Grinstead vanished,
[1:02:30] marked an extraordinary breakthrough.
[1:02:33] At long last, law enforcement announced that the mystery of
[1:02:37] Tara's disappearance had been solved, pending final
[1:02:40] confirmation in court. Now, with both suspects in
[1:02:45] custody, the focus turned to the legal system to deliver justice
[1:02:49] for Tara. And you're never going to
[1:02:51] believe what happened next. In the years following the 2017
[1:02:58] arrests, the cases against the two men moved through the courts
[1:03:02] separately. Beau Dukes was the first to face
[1:03:05] trial. In March 2019, a jury convicted
[1:03:09] Dukes on charges related to covering up Tara's death.
[1:03:13] He was sentenced to the maximum of 25 years in prison for these
[1:03:17] offenses. Disturbingly, it was also
[1:03:20] revealed that he was a serial predator, committing multiple
[1:03:23] essay offenses against women in the intervening years.
[1:03:29] Ryan Duke, the alleged perpetrator himself, went to
[1:03:32] trial three years later in May 2022.
[1:03:37] The courtroom proceedings were dramatic.
[1:03:40] Although Ryan had initially confessed to the GBI, he
[1:03:43] recanted that confession and claimed it was actually Beau
[1:03:47] Dukes who was responsible. He now asserted that he had only
[1:03:51] helped destroy the evidence of the crime out of fear of Dukes.
[1:03:55] After a closely watched trial nearly 17 years after the crime,
[1:03:59] the jury delivered a split verdict.
[1:04:02] Ryan Duke was acquitted of Terror's slaying, as well as
[1:04:05] related charges of burglary and aggravated assault.
[1:04:09] This means the jury wasn't convinced beyond a reasonable
[1:04:11] doubt that he was the one who had ended her.
[1:04:14] However, the jury did find him guilty of the charge of
[1:04:17] concealing a death, reflecting his admitted involvement in the
[1:04:21] cover up. A judge subsequently sentenced
[1:04:25] Ryan Duke to 10 years in prison for concealing Tara's death, the
[1:04:29] maximum penalty for that crime. Rico Harris was a 37 year old
[1:04:36] former basketball prospect who once played for the Harlem
[1:04:40] Globetrotters. He disappeared in October 2014
[1:04:44] during a solo drive from his mother's home in Southern
[1:04:46] California on route to Seattle. A few days after he left,
[1:04:51] Harris's black Nissan Maxima was found abandoned at a park in
[1:04:56] rural Yolo County north of Sacramento, with no sign of
[1:05:00] Harris himself. Despite an intensive search of
[1:05:04] the surrounding wilderness by authorities, not a single trace
[1:05:08] of the six foot nine, £300 athlete was found.
[1:05:14] Rico grew up in Los Angeles County and showed early promise
[1:05:18] as a basketball player. In his late teens, he blossomed
[1:05:22] into a high school standout, becoming one of the nation's top
[1:05:26] 100 recruits, courted by elite college programs like
[1:05:30] Connecticut, Kentucky, and UCLA. Unfortunately, Harris's path
[1:05:36] through college was tumultuous. He first enrolled at Arizona
[1:05:40] State University, but left after a freshman year arrest and
[1:05:43] academic issues. Harris then dominated at Los
[1:05:47] Angeles City College, leading the team to a state junior
[1:05:50] college championship in 1997. However, an attempt to transfer
[1:05:55] to A Division One program fell through due to a poor academic
[1:05:59] record. He finished his college career
[1:06:02] at Cal State Northridge, but his time there was marked by
[1:06:05] suspensions and conflicts with his coach.
[1:06:08] By 1999, perhaps unsurprisingly, the once promising player went
[1:06:13] undrafted in the NBA. Harris continued to pursue
[1:06:19] professional basketball on the fringe.
[1:06:21] In 2000, Rico joined the world famous Harlem Globetrotters in
[1:06:27] hopes that this would raise his profile and he could move to a
[1:06:30] more legitimate basketball team. For those who aren't aware, the
[1:06:35] Globetrotters are a sports entertainment team rather than a
[1:06:39] competitive basketball team. His tenure with the
[1:06:43] Globetrotters lasted only a couple of months.
[1:06:46] He later said he left due to a combination of a nagging back
[1:06:49] injury and a serious concussion from being hit in the head with
[1:06:53] a baseball bat while trying to break up a fight.
[1:06:57] With that, Harris's basketball ambitions were effectively cut
[1:07:01] short, aside from a few attempts to play in a short lived semi
[1:07:05] pro league called the International Basketball League.
[1:07:11] Life after basketball proved challenging and Harris fell into
[1:07:15] substance abuse, with alcohol being his most major issue.
[1:07:19] He would struggle off and on, but by 2007 he committed to
[1:07:23] sobriety and pieced his life back together, finding steady
[1:07:27] work in private security in Los Angeles.
[1:07:31] In 2012, while working as a security manager at a nightclub,
[1:07:36] Harris met Jennifer Song, an insurance broker from Seattle
[1:07:40] who was visiting California. The two began a long distance
[1:07:44] relationship. For over 2 years they maintained
[1:07:48] their bond through phone calls, text messages, and weekend
[1:07:52] visits. By 2014, Harris was looking
[1:07:59] toward the future with new found optimism.
[1:08:02] He was nearing 7 years of sobriety and decided to relocate
[1:08:06] to Seattle to live with Jennifer permanently.
[1:08:10] He gradually moved his belongings into her Seattle
[1:08:12] townhouse and also secured A promising job interview in the
[1:08:16] area. This transition was not without
[1:08:20] difficulty, and Harris initially felt homesick and under
[1:08:23] pressure, and in late July 2014, he briefly relapsed into his old
[1:08:28] drinking habits. By early October 2014, Harris
[1:08:33] was still committed to his move and his new life in Seattle.
[1:08:37] Or at least that's what he wanted people to believe
[1:08:39] outwardly. In the first week of October
[1:08:44] 2014, Rico Harris decided to make an impromptu trip from
[1:08:49] Seattle down to Alhambra in California to visit his family
[1:08:53] before fully settling in Seattle.
[1:08:56] According to Jennifer, he felt he needed to talk with his
[1:08:59] mother and brother, possibly to find closure with some past
[1:09:03] issues and to reassure his family about his new path.
[1:09:08] On October 8th, 2014, Harris told Jennifer he was going out
[1:09:13] to explore Seattle while she went to the gym.
[1:09:16] Instead, he secretly began the 1000 Mile Dr. S to see his
[1:09:20] family. He drove through the night and
[1:09:23] arrived at his mother Margaret Fernandez's home in Alhambra
[1:09:27] around 2:00 in the morning on October 9th.
[1:09:31] Margaret was surprised and concerned by her son's sudden
[1:09:34] visit, and she later said she suspected he had been drinking
[1:09:37] when he showed up. Shortly after midnight in the
[1:09:41] early hours of October 10th, 2014, Rico Harris quietly
[1:09:48] slipped out of his mother's house and began the long drive
[1:09:51] back to Seattle. At about 1:00 AM, he phoned his
[1:09:55] mother, who hadn't even realized he had left.
[1:09:59] He then called Jennifer to let her know he was already on the
[1:10:02] road north. Jennifer was startled that he
[1:10:05] had left without sleeping, and the 2 spoke by phone for
[1:10:09] approximately 3 to 4 hours as Harris drove through Central
[1:10:13] California. Jennifer later said she grew
[1:10:16] increasingly concerned during that call and his speech and
[1:10:20] thoughts were giving her cause for worry.
[1:10:23] Eventually, sometime before dawn, Jennifer fell asleep while
[1:10:27] on the phone with him. Around 8:00 in the morning on
[1:10:33] October 10th, Jennifer awoke and called Harris back and he
[1:10:37] reported that he was near Sacramento.
[1:10:40] Not long after, at 10:45 that same morning, Harris left a
[1:10:44] voicemail for Jennifer saying that he was, quote, going up
[1:10:48] into the mountains to rest for a while before continuing the
[1:10:52] drive. He mentioned that he hadn't
[1:10:54] slept much and needed to pull over.
[1:10:57] Approximately 30 minutes later, around 11:15 AM, his cell phone
[1:11:02] was switched off, but whether Harris turned it off or the
[1:11:05] battery died is not clear. This was the last anyone ever
[1:11:09] heard from him, though panic didn't immediately set in.
[1:11:15] By October 13th, however, Harris had missed his important job
[1:11:18] interview in Seattle and still hadn't contacted anyone.
[1:11:23] That same day, far to the north in Yolo County, California, a
[1:11:27] sheriff's deputy was making a routine patrol through a
[1:11:30] secluded rest area known as Cash Creek Regional Park.
[1:11:36] The deputy noticed a black Nissan Maxima parked off to the
[1:11:39] side of the lot. It had been there the day before
[1:11:42] as well, which struck him as odd.
[1:11:46] On October 13th, after seeing the car again untouched, the
[1:11:50] deputy ran the license plates and discovered it was registered
[1:11:54] to Rico Harris. He contacted the Alhambra Police
[1:11:58] Department in Los Angeles County to inquire about the owner.
[1:12:02] Alhambra police, in turn, went to Margaret Fernandez's house
[1:12:06] that day to inform her that Rico's car had been found
[1:12:10] abandoned hundreds of miles away in Northern California.
[1:12:15] Margaret immediately realized something was very wrong and
[1:12:18] filed a missing person report for her son on October 13th,
[1:12:22] 2014, officially launching the investigation into his
[1:12:27] disappearance. In the days following the car's
[1:12:32] discovery, a few tantalizing clues emerged.
[1:12:36] Investigators learned that Harris had stopped for gas in
[1:12:39] Lodi, CA, around 100 miles South of where his car was found, and
[1:12:44] then apparently deviated from the main Interstate.
[1:12:47] Why he drove into the isolated Cache Creek area remains
[1:12:51] uncertain. He may have taken a wrong turn
[1:12:54] or intentionally driven into the hills to rest or sightsee.
[1:12:59] Several witnesses later reported seeing a large African American
[1:13:02] man fitting Harris's description in the vicinity on October 11th
[1:13:07] and 12th. 1 passerby recalled a tall man walking along Route 16
[1:13:13] in the early morning hours of October 11th.
[1:13:17] Another motorist believed he saw the same man sitting on a
[1:13:20] guardrail overlooking Cache Creek around that time.
[1:13:24] Additionally, a couple reported seeing a giant man wandering
[1:13:27] around a black car on October 12th, appearing disoriented.
[1:13:33] These sightings suggested that Harris was indeed alive and on
[1:13:36] foot in the area for at least a day or two after he left the
[1:13:40] highway. Search teams discovered very
[1:13:45] large shoe prints by the Creek near the parking lot, including
[1:13:49] one set of fresh impressions that match the size 18 sneakers
[1:13:52] Harris wore. They noted that the Prince went
[1:13:55] down toward the water and then back up, as if someone had
[1:13:59] walked to the Creek and returned in the same vicinity.
[1:14:04] Investigators found an insert from a shoe believed to be from
[1:14:07] Harris's footwear. Based upon the size alone.
[1:14:11] This indicated that Harris had likely been the person who
[1:14:14] parked the car there and had walked around the area.
[1:14:18] About 1500 feet up the road from the parking lot, searchers also
[1:14:22] recovered Harris's black backpack abandoned on the
[1:14:25] roadside. Inside it were jumper cables,
[1:14:29] some clothing and two plastic bottles, one empty and one
[1:14:34] partially filled with hard liquor.
[1:14:36] Crucially, the backpack also contained Harris's cell phone
[1:14:39] and charger. On October 18th, another
[1:14:42] sighting of Rico was reported and the authorities found fresh
[1:14:46] footprints again from size 18 shoes.
[1:14:50] Yet despite these leads, searchers couldn't locate
[1:14:53] Harris. Sniffer dogs were brought in and
[1:14:56] signaled interest in a particular spot along the Creek,
[1:15:00] prompting dive teams to search pools of water, but no evidence
[1:15:04] was found. In the absence of concrete
[1:15:09] answers, several theories have been put forward to explain what
[1:15:13] might have happened to Rico Harris.
[1:15:16] The lead detective on the case eventually came to believe that
[1:15:19] no foul play was involved and that Harris may have voluntarily
[1:15:23] walked away from his life. The investigation found no
[1:15:27] evidence of struggle or violence at the scene.
[1:15:30] The car, the phone, and the backpack all appeared to have
[1:15:33] been left undisturbed by anyone other than Harris himself.
[1:15:38] The lead detective theorized that Harris might have taken a
[1:15:40] wrong turn off the highway and upon finding the serene Cache
[1:15:44] Creek area, decided to stop and rest.
[1:15:48] It was noted that he had been under significant pressure.
[1:15:52] He was moving to a new city, potentially starting a new job,
[1:15:56] and struggling to maintain sobriety.
[1:15:59] Further, he was in the process of adjusting to living with his
[1:16:03] girlfriend. The authorities officially
[1:16:06] speculated that the weight of those unresolved personal issues
[1:16:10] and life changes may have led to Harris not returning to Seattle.
[1:16:15] Interestingly, the lead detective has gone on record
[1:16:18] saying that he believes that sometime after Rico's car was
[1:16:21] towed, Rico may have gotten a ride out of the area.
[1:16:28] A related theory has focused on Harris's psychological state.
[1:16:32] By all accounts, he was under severe stress, lack of sleep,
[1:16:37] The cross country move and his recent relapse might have
[1:16:40] created a perfect storm. It's possible Harris experienced
[1:16:44] a mental health crisis or emotional breakdown in the hours
[1:16:48] leading up to his disappearance. If Harris became disoriented or
[1:16:53] suffered some kind of break, he might have intentionally walked
[1:16:56] away into a new life or inadvertently placed himself in
[1:17:00] danger. Some believe that he may have
[1:17:03] entered into a dissociative fugue and started a new life,
[1:17:08] either being unaware of his old identity or simply preferring
[1:17:12] his new life. That said, others have observed
[1:17:16] that his physical appearance would likely make it harder for
[1:17:19] him to start fresh, since he literally stands head and
[1:17:22] shoulders above everyone else. Another possibility is that Rico
[1:17:29] Harris intended to return to his journey after resting, but fell
[1:17:33] victim to an accident in the remote wilderness.
[1:17:36] Harris may have been exhausted and possibly dehydrated, and as
[1:17:40] suggested by the bottles in his backpack, he had relapsed once
[1:17:44] again. It's conceivable that while
[1:17:47] walking around in a fatigued state, he could have slipped and
[1:17:51] injured himself or gotten lost in the wild.
[1:17:55] A fall down a ravine or into the fast moving Creek could prove
[1:17:58] fatal. If he succumbed to exposure or
[1:18:01] injury, his remains might have been missed in the initial
[1:18:04] search, especially if they ended up in a concealed spot or were
[1:18:08] moved by natural elements. From the start, investigators
[1:18:14] didn't see obvious signs of foul play.
[1:18:16] In Harris's case, there was no blood and no indication of a
[1:18:20] struggle at the car. Further yet, Harris was, to put
[1:18:25] it mildly, not an easy target, standing 6 foot 9 and with a
[1:18:30] powerful build. That said, his friends and
[1:18:33] family knew him to be a mild mannered individual who got
[1:18:37] along with everyone and suspect that he may have let his guard
[1:18:41] down around the wrong people.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.