# America's First Serial Killer Family: The Bloody Benders

An episode of [Lazy Chill True Crime](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1815534472), 30 Aug 2025, 21 min.

Audio: https://traffic.megaphone.fm/APO6889242462.mp3

Explore the horrifying story of America's first serial killer family, the Bloody Benders. This chilling true crime mystery uncovers the gruesome murders, disappearances, and dark history surrounding the infamous Kansas family who lured victims into their inn and vanished without a trace. Perfect for fans of true crime podcasts, unsolved mysteries, historic murder cases, and America's darkest legends. 👇 Support My Work: 🛍️ Merch: https://lazy-chill-zone-shop.fourthwall.com ❤️ Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/lazychillzone 👇 Youtube links: Lazy Chill True Crime Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC8dVJtzeHcJgd_Z0bHrJTHQ Lazy Chill History Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@LazyChillHistory Lazy Chill Zone Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@LazyChillZone 👇Social Media Links: https://www.instagram.com/lazychillzone/ 👇 Podcast links: ⚡History Video Podcast on Spotify⚡: https://open.spotify.com/show/7km5pLWpYWEj1mrPpEfRUr?si=0FHYnZf-Qs2FY1GyLevfig ⚡True Crime Podcast on Spotify⚡: https://open.spotify.com/show/0klIz08pAr7wR4we0Ia4sk?si=68qZxCeAQkysXzMZrHE0Iw 🍏 True Crime Podcast on Apple 🍎: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/lazy-chill-true-crime/id1815534472 Bloody Benders, America's first serial killer family, true crime podcast, unsolved mysteries, disturbing murders, historic true crime, Kansas serial killers, 19th century murders, frontier crime, infamous killers, serial killer history, American murder mystery, creepy legends, dark history podcast, true crime stories, unsolved murder cases

## Transcript

[0:00] This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance.
[0:03] Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to
[0:06] see if you could save some cash? Progressive makes it easy to see
[0:09] if you could save when you bundle your home and auto
[0:11] policies. Try it at progressive.com.
[0:15] Progressive Casualty insurance company and affiliates.
[0:17] Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states.
[0:19] Imagine you're a traveler in southeastern Kansas in the early
[0:22] 1870's. The country still has the fresh
[0:25] scars of conflict, and the promise of a new life of 160
[0:31] acres to call your own has pulled you W The landscape
[0:35] around you is an immense, unforgiving Prairie.
[0:38] It's a lonely expanse where homesteads are scattered like
[0:41] islands in a sea of grass. And your nearest neighbor might
[0:44] be miles away. This is Labette County, a place
[0:48] carved out of land recently seeded by the Osage Nation, a
[0:53] place defined by both boundless opportunity and profound
[0:56] isolation. Your journey follows the Great
[1:02] Osage Trail, a path worn into the earth, first by migrating
[1:06] Buffalo, then by Native American tribes, and now by the wagons of
[1:10] settlers like yourself. It's a vital artery of westward
[1:14] expansion, but it's also a place of great danger.
[1:19] The weather is harsh and unpredictable, with tornadoes,
[1:23] blizzards, and floods that can erase a homesteader's dreams
[1:26] overnight. Violence is a constant threat,
[1:30] whether from conflicts with displaced tribes or from the
[1:34] battle hardened American men who now work their way onto the
[1:37] frontier. In this vast emptiness, people
[1:41] simply vanish, and when they disappear, the Prairie keeps
[1:46] their secrets. As dusk begins to settle,
[1:51] casting long shadows across the plains, you spot a light.
[1:55] It comes from a small one room cabin, a welcome sign of life in
[1:59] the desolate landscape. A crude hand lettered sign above
[2:03] the door reads Groceries. This is the Bender Place, a
[2:08] wayside inn offering the promise of a hot meal, supplies, and
[2:13] most importantly, a safe place to rest for the night.
[2:19] For a weary traveller, it seems like a sanctuary, a fragile
[2:23] outpost of civilization where the unspoken code of frontier
[2:27] hospitality offers a moment of peace.
[2:30] You approach, unaware that the trust you're about to place in
[2:34] these strangers is the last mistake you'll ever make.
[2:37] This humble cabin wasn't a refuge, it was a slaughterhouse.
[2:41] And for at least a dozen travellers, this beacon of hope
[2:45] on this great migratory trail was the end of the line.
[2:50] This is the disturbing story of the Benders, a supposed family
[2:54] of innkeepers who committed horrific actions before
[2:58] performing one of American history's greatest vanishing
[3:01] acts. To understand the horror that
[3:06] unfolded in Labette County, one must first try to understand the
[3:10] perpetrators. But the Bender family itself is
[3:14] an enigma, a collection of four individuals whose true
[3:17] identities, origins and relationships remain a mystery.
[3:23] They presented themselves as a simple homesteading family, but
[3:27] they were a carefully constructed criminal conspiracy,
[3:30] a human machine where each member played a specific and
[3:33] deadly role. The patriarch, John Bender
[3:37] Senior was a man of about 60, described by those who met him
[3:41] as a repulsive and brutish figure.
[3:44] He was a giant of a man with piercing eyes and a sullen I'll
[3:48] tempered demeanour. Like the other members of this
[3:52] so-called family, he claimed to be from Germany.
[3:56] As with all the members of the family, it remains unclear what
[3:59] their true origins were as German was commonly spoken
[4:03] across Central and Eastern Europe.
[4:06] And to get in my 1 mandatory Simpsons reference per video, no
[4:10] one who speaks German could be an evil man, right?
[4:16] His wife, Elvira Bender, was around 55 and equally disliked
[4:20] by her neighbors, who called her a she devil.
[4:24] Unfriendly and sinister, she was rumoured to have slain previous
[4:28] husbands before arriving in Kansas, and she dabbled in folk
[4:32] magic, claiming to be a medium who could cast spells while she
[4:37] claimed not to understand English.
[4:39] A moment of rage during a confrontation later revealed her
[4:43] command of the language was far better than she led on.
[4:49] The younger generation presented a stark contrast.
[4:52] John Bender junior, about 25, was handsome and spoke English
[4:56] well, though with a German accent.
[4:59] He had a peculiar habit of laughing without cause, which
[5:03] led many in the community to suspect there was something
[5:06] wrong with him. This perception, whether genuine
[5:10] or an act, made him seem harmless and non threatening, a
[5:14] perfect disguise for the violence he was capable of.
[5:20] The public face and undisputed star of the operation was Kate
[5:24] Bender, around 23 years old. She was universally described as
[5:29] beautiful, intelligent and intensely charismatic.
[5:33] She was fluent in English and was the only member of the
[5:36] family who actively engaged with the surrounding community.
[5:41] Kate was the family's lure, and her chosen bait was
[5:44] spiritualism. In an era when communicating
[5:48] with the dead was a popular and widespread belief, Kate
[5:52] advertised herself as a powerful psychic, healer and spiritualist
[5:57] medium. She distributed Flyers and gave
[6:00] lectures claiming she could cure blindness and deafness with the
[6:03] laying on of hands, contact the spirits of the deceased and
[6:08] locate lost possessions. Her lectures also promoted
[6:12] radical ideas like free love, which, while scandalous, only
[6:17] added to her notoriety and drew curious visitors to the family
[6:21] inn. And by curious travellers, I
[6:24] mean men travelling alone who definitely thought they had a
[6:27] chance with this frontier cutie. Kate's persona was the perfect
[6:33] tool for disarming travellers and she was basically the
[6:36] honeypot that lured victims in. With her charm and supposed
[6:40] supernatural gifts, she could win their trust.
[6:44] This would draw them into intimate conversations where
[6:47] they would reveal their travel plans and most importantly,
[6:52] their financial situations. The very foundation of this
[6:57] group was built on lies. While they were widely believed
[7:01] to be German immigrants, no official documentation of their
[7:05] origins or even their real names has ever been discovered.
[7:10] The name Bender itself, while a fairly common German name, was
[7:15] almost certainly an alias. Even their family ties were
[7:20] likely a complete fabrication. Neighbors reported that the
[7:24] intimacy between John Junior and Kate seemed more like that of a
[7:27] husband and wife than siblings. The reason for doing this was
[7:32] also a part of their ruse. In a society built on the family
[7:36] unit, the image of a family run in offered a veneer of safety
[7:40] and respectability that was crucial to their predatory
[7:43] success. The Bender's genius for evil was
[7:48] not just in their deception, but in their engineering.
[7:52] They transformed their humble one room cabin into a highly
[7:56] efficient machine capable of quote UN quote processing
[8:00] guests. The cabin was a simple wooden
[8:04] structure measuring about 16 by 24 feet.
[8:08] Inside they had made a simple but critical modification.
[8:12] A large heavy canvas wagon cover was hung from a rope, splitting
[8:16] the single room in two. The front area was the public
[8:20] face of their operation, a small general store and a dining room
[8:25] where travellers could get a meal.
[8:28] The area behind the curtain was the family's private quarters,
[8:32] but it's true purpose was to serve as a blind from which to
[8:35] launch their ambush. Their modus operandi was a
[8:40] chillingly refined process. After Kate identified A suitable
[8:45] victim, usually a man traveling alone with significant money, he
[8:49] would be invited to dinner and given the seat of honor at the
[8:52] table. This seat wasn't a gesture of
[8:55] hospitality, it was a tactical position.
[8:59] It placed the guest with his back directly against the canvas
[9:02] partition, perfectly silhouetting his head for the
[9:05] attacker waiting behind it. As the unsuspecting traveller
[9:11] ate his meal, captivated by Kate's charm and conversation,
[9:15] one of the male benders would slip behind the curtain.
[9:18] At the right moment, the attacker would swing a heavy
[9:21] hammer, striking the victim on the back of the head with
[9:24] crushing force. Beneath the victim's chair, or
[9:28] immediately beside it was a concealed trapdoor.
[9:33] The stunned or dead man was immediately dropped through the
[9:36] opening into a dark stone lined cellar that was 6 feet deep.
[9:41] This allowed for the instant removal of the body from the
[9:44] main room, minimizing mess and the risk of discovery should
[9:48] another guest arrive. The body was then stripped of
[9:52] every valuable before being disposed of.
[9:57] Under the cover of night, the bodies were removed from this
[10:00] subterranean abattoir and buried in the family's two acre
[10:03] vegetable garden and apple orchard just north of the cabin.
[10:08] In a particularly macabre detail passed down through local lore,
[10:12] it was said that Elvira Bender used the apples from the trees
[10:16] growing over her victims graves to bake pies for future
[10:19] travellers. The Bender's reign of terror
[10:24] lasted for nearly two years, from May 1871 to the spring of
[10:29] 1873. During that time they eliminated
[10:32] at least a dozen people, though the true number may be much
[10:36] higher. Their victims were the forgotten
[10:38] travellers of the frontier, men whose disappearances created
[10:42] distant ripples of concern but no organized alarm.
[10:46] Until it was far too late. After all, Kate was an expert at
[10:51] finding men who were very far from home and whose
[10:54] disappearances wouldn't be noticed for months or even
[10:56] years. The case that finally brought an
[11:00] end to the Bender's slaughter began with the disappearance of
[11:03] George Newton Longcore and his 18 month old daughter, Mary Ann
[11:08] in the winter of 1872. A recent widower, Longcore, was
[11:14] travelling back to Iowa and was carrying a significant sum of
[11:17] money when they vanished. Long Core's former neighbor from
[11:22] Independence, a physician named Doctor William York, became
[11:26] concerned and set out to find them in the spring of 1873.
[11:31] Doctor York's search led him along the Osage Trail and
[11:35] inevitably to the Bender Inn, where he too disappeared.
[11:41] The attack on Doctor York was the Bender's final overreach.
[11:45] For two years, they had preyed on the anonymous and the
[11:47] transient, individuals whose disappearances could be easily
[11:51] dismissed. Dr. York, however, was a
[11:55] prominent man and more importantly, his brother was
[11:59] Colonel Alexander York, a Kansas State senator.
[12:03] Unlike the families of other victims, Colonel York had the
[12:07] influence, resources and unwavering determination to
[12:11] mobilize a search and demand answers.
[12:16] In March 1873, Colonel Alexander York arrived at the Benders Inn,
[12:21] methodically retracing his brother's last known movements.
[12:25] During his initial questioning, the family deployed their well
[12:29] practiced deception. They admitted Dr. York had
[12:32] stopped there, but insisted he'd continued on his way.
[12:37] They casually suggested he might have fallen victim to an attack
[12:40] by a local tribe or by highwaymen, Common and
[12:43] convenient explanations for such disappearances.
[12:47] Ready to level up? Shamba Casino is your playbook
[12:50] to fun. It's free to play with no
[12:52] purchase necessary. Enjoy hundreds of casino style
[12:55] games like bingo, slots and solitaire anytime, anywhere,
[12:59] with fresh releases every week. Whether you're at home or on the
[13:02] go, let Shamba Casino bring the excitement to you.
[13:05] Plus, get free daily login bonuses and a free welcome
[13:08] bonus. Join Now for your chance to
[13:10] redeem some serious prizes. Play Shamba Casino today no
[13:14] purchase necessary. VGW group void were prohibited
[13:16] by Law 18 plus TNC supply. Kate, the master manipulator,
[13:20] pretended to be deeply concerned and offered to hold a seance to
[13:24] contact his spirit, telling the Colonel to return another day.
[13:29] She let him know that he needed to come back alone in what was a
[13:32] brazen attempt to make the investigator their next victim.
[13:37] But Colonel York was not easily fooled, and he sensed A profound
[13:41] evil in the small cabin and left deeply suspicious.
[13:46] His doubts were confirmed when he learned of another traveller,
[13:50] a woman who had recently fled the inn in terror after Elvira
[13:54] threatened her with a knife. York returned, this time with an
[14:00] armed posse of men that definitely weren't clowning
[14:03] around. The confrontation was tense, and
[14:07] Elvira's subsequent explosion of rage shattered her facade as a
[14:12] simple woman who couldn't speak English.
[14:15] This outburst further solidified Colonel York's conviction that
[14:19] the family was hiding a dark secret.
[14:22] But in the end, nothing happened.
[14:24] Yet as York's investigation intensified, the wider
[14:29] community, already on edge from the string of disappearances,
[14:33] reached a breaking point. A town meeting was convened
[14:38] where dozens of local men gathered to decide on a course
[14:41] of action. They resolved to obtain a
[14:44] warrant and conduct a search of every single homestead in the
[14:48] Township. In an act of astonishing
[14:51] audacity, the Bender men were also present at that meeting.
[14:55] They sat among their neighbors, listening as the community
[14:58] organized the very search that would inevitably unearth the
[15:02] bodies buried in their own garden.
[15:05] It was a final, desperate gamble to appear innocent, an attempt
[15:09] to deflect suspicion that was doomed to fail.
[15:14] The benders knew the moment the vote was taken that their time
[15:17] was up. They could perhaps deceive a
[15:20] lone questioner. But they couldn't survive a
[15:24] systematic official search of their property.
[15:28] Sometime in the days following the meeting, under the cover of
[15:31] the vast Kansas night, they packed what they could,
[15:35] abandoned their homestead, and vanished.
[15:40] Their escape was discovered a few days later when a neighbor
[15:43] noticed their farm animals were starving and the inn was eerily
[15:46] silent. Unfortunately, a spell of bad
[15:50] weather delayed a formal investigation, giving the
[15:53] benders A crucial head start of nearly a month to disappear into
[15:57] the American frontier. When the search party finally
[16:02] forced their way into the abandoned Bender cabin in early
[16:05] May 1873, they were met with a scene of hurried departure and
[16:09] an overpowering stench of death. The source of the odor was
[16:14] quickly traced to a trap door under a bed which had been
[16:18] nailed shut. After prying it open, they
[16:21] peered down into the stone lined cellar.
[16:25] The pit was empty of bodies, but the floor was caked with so much
[16:28] clotted blood that it had soaked deep into the earth below,
[16:33] irrefutable proof that this had been a place of slaughter.
[16:39] The search then moved outside to the family's small apple orchard
[16:43] and vegetable garden. The ground in the orchard was
[16:46] soft and appeared to have been recently disturbed.
[16:50] The men began to probe the soil and it wasn't long before they
[16:54] made their first horrific discovery, the body of Doctor
[16:57] William York, buried in a shallow grave.
[17:01] The news spread and a full scale excavation began.
[17:06] Over the next day, the searchers unearthed a graveyard.
[17:09] One by one, they uncovered the remains of at least 10 more
[17:13] people, including George Longcore and his infant
[17:16] daughter. The story of the Benders House
[17:20] of Horrors became a national sensation.
[17:23] Newspapers from New York to Chicago sent reporters to the
[17:26] remote Kansas Prairie, and their lurid accounts of the Devil's
[17:30] Kitchen captivated the public. These accounts took the already
[17:35] horrific realities and added new fictionalized elements in an
[17:39] effort to sell more papers. After fleeing their farm, the
[17:45] Benders Trail quickly went cold. Investigators found their
[17:49] abandoned wagon near the town of Thayer, just 12 miles to the
[17:53] north, but from there, the trail vanished completely.
[17:58] A massive manhunt was launched and the Kansas governor offered
[18:01] a $2000 reward, a fortune at the time for information leading to
[18:07] their capture. What happened to the benders
[18:11] remains one of the great unsolved mysteries of the Old
[18:14] West, a narrative vacuum that has been filled with two
[18:18] powerful and competing theories. The first is that they simply
[18:22] got away. In the vast, unmapped expanse of
[18:26] 19th century America, it was entirely possible for four
[18:30] people to change their names, split up, and begin new lives
[18:34] without a trace. This theory is bolstered by the
[18:38] numerous false sightings and wrongful arrests that plagued
[18:41] investigators for decades. In 1880, a couple in Nebraska
[18:46] was arrested and even confessed, but they were soon exposed as
[18:50] imposters. In 1889, two women were arrested
[18:55] in Michigan and extradited to Kansas on suspicion of being
[18:59] Elvira and Kate, only to be exonerated when their alibis
[19:03] proved solid. These incidents reflect a
[19:06] public, desperate foreclosure, but they also highlight how
[19:10] easily the fugitives could have blended back into society,
[19:14] either in America or elsewhere. The second, more pervasive
[19:20] theory is that the benders met a swift and brutal end at the
[19:23] hands of a vigilante posse. According to this version of
[19:27] events, a group of enraged neighbors caught up with the
[19:30] family shortly after they fled. They dispensed their own form of
[19:34] frontier justice, forcing confessions from the benders
[19:38] before eliminating them. While no physical evidence
[19:42] supports this story, it aligns with the harsh realities of the
[19:46] frontier, where communities often took the law into their
[19:49] own hands when official channels failed.
[19:53] The secrecy of such an extrajudicial act would neatly
[19:56] explain why no one ever came forward to claim the substantial
[19:59] reward. Today, more than 150 years
[20:05] later, the search for answers continues, and who the Benders
[20:09] were and what happened to them remains a historical, unsolved
[20:12] mystery. This episode is brought to you
[20:16] by Progressive Insurance. You chose to hit play on this
[20:19] podcast today. Smart choice Make another smart
[20:22] choice with Auto Quote Explorer to compare rates from multiple
[20:25] car insurance companies all at once.
[20:27] Try it at progressive.com. Progressive casualty insurance
[20:30] company and affiliates. Not available in all states or
[20:32] situations. Prices vary based on how you
[20:34] buy. Marketing is hard, but I'll tell
[20:37] you a little secret. It doesn't have to be.
[20:39] Let me point something out. You're listening to a podcast
[20:41] right now and it's great. You love the host.
[20:43] You seek it out and download it. You listen to it while driving,
[20:45] working out, cooking, even going to the bathroom.
[20:48] Podcasts are a pretty close companion.
[20:51] And this is a podcast ad. Did I get your attention?
[20:54] You can reach great listeners like yourself with podcast
[20:57] advertising from Libsyn Ads. Choose from hundreds of top
[21:00] podcasts offering host endorsements or run a pre
[21:03] produced ad like this one across thousands of shows.
[21:05] To reach your target audience and their favorite podcasts with
[21:08] Libsyn Ads, go to libsynads.com. That's LIBSY nads.com today.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.