# How the Internet Killed Critical Thinking - Meghan Daum | #61

An episode of [The Next Generation](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1772698742), 9 Dec 2025, 2 h 00 min.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/107851968/podcast/play/112019467/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2025-11-2%2F413598548-44100-2-8aead9bd5d2a.mp3

I had such a good time talking with Meghan Daum in LA! She is the author of seven books including My Misspent Youth, The Problem With Everything, and the award-winning The Unspeakable: And Other Subjects Of Discussion. She’s also the host of The Unspeakeasy Podcast and founder of The Unspeakeasy, a forum devoted to viewpoint diversity and free expression.This production was made possible by DFI Rentals - book gear for your next shoot here: https://www.dfirentals.com/Subscribe to my Substack to send in questions for upcoming guests! https://elliotbewick.substack.com/Check out Meghan’s Substack: https://www.theunspeakablepodcast.com/Find more from Meghan: https://www.meghandaum.com/CHAPTERS:00:00 “Culture is being held hostage by its own hyperbole”08:39 Why don’t Gen Z want normal jobs?15:03 Seductive half truths18:57 Amusing ourselves to death24:17 Where the Gen Z pursuit of happiness goes wrong32:20 “Hysteria is monetisable” and the flaws of feminism45:37 How feminism negatively affects both sexes49:07 How do we move forward from this?52:42 The Gen Z shift towards Christianity56:55 Charlie Kirk’s assassination59:20 Is it irresponsible to sit on the fence?1:13:14 New media pushes us into echo chambers1:22:10 Are Gen Z growing up in a uniquely difficult time?1:27:45 Are too many people going to university?1:32:34 Why are you so vocal in the trans debate?1:39:36 Should we use preferred pronouns?1:45:30 Attitudes around transgenderism are changing1:53:12 Is there such a thing as ‘true trans’?1:55:56 What’s the way forward for Gen Z?1:58:48 Final thoughtsMy Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotbewick/TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliotbewickX: https://x.com/elliotbewickABOUT THE NEXT GENERATION: In a world saturated by social media and marked by skyrocketing rates of anxiety, depression, and ADHD among Gen Z, young people are growing up in a landscape of chaos and contradiction. While protests swell in city streets and activists hurl soup at famous artworks to demand climate action, a quieter crisis unfolds within - the mental and emotional battles faced by a generation trying to make sense of it all.The Next Generation is hosted by 20-year-old Elliot Bewick, offering a raw and honest look at the world through the eyes of those living in it. Bringing together insight from professionals and young people on the ground, this podcast isn’t here to complain or chase clout. It’s here to bend the arc of the modern world towards solutions, truth and a love for the beautiful adventure of life itself.

## Transcript

[0:00] You say the culture is effectively being held hostage
[0:02] by its own hyperbole. What does that mean?
[0:05] Why? That is from my 2019 book, The
[0:09] Problem with Everything. So I probably wrote that
[0:12] sentence. I don't know 2017.
[0:16] And at the time I was just referring to the fact that
[0:20] everything is extreme, right? Everything is the most of the
[0:24] worst. The you know, we've never been
[0:26] in a worse time. Believe all women, don't believe
[0:31] anybody, don't believe any institutions.
[0:33] So I think that we slipped into this mode of speaking and
[0:38] therefore this way of thinking in my view. 20/13/2014 I started
[0:44] to notice it. So when I wrote that sentence,
[0:48] we're being held hostage by our own hyperbole.
[0:51] I was talking about something that I think is, to speak in a
[0:54] hyperbolic way, infinitely worse now.
[0:57] Well, unpack that for me a little bit more.
[0:58] You said you started noticing it in 20/13/2014.
[1:01] What was actually going on then? What was going on was that you
[1:06] had the rise of these digital platforms, the blogosphere, you
[1:12] had a lot of people who had been in journalism, who had been kind
[1:15] of public intellectual writers, essayists, observers of the
[1:19] culture, writing on digital platforms that were not really
[1:24] gate capped. They were not edited
[1:26] necessarily. There was not a lot of rewriting
[1:30] going on. There was a lot of instant
[1:32] response. And there's a lot that's good
[1:35] about that, obviously. But I was noticing that people
[1:39] who had I had considered quite thoughtful, quite nuanced in
[1:42] their thinking, quite experienced.
[1:44] We're just saying stuff off the cuff that sort of maybe felt
[1:49] good in the moment but was either wrong or didn't make any
[1:52] sense. And people were eating it up.
[1:54] They loved it. And so that became, instead of
[1:59] this kind of fringe part of the culture, a kind of alternative
[2:02] media space. It became the mainstream.
[2:05] So it was creeping up and up. And so, you know, as somebody
[2:10] who has been writing and publishing since the early
[2:14] 1990s, I was first curious and then I became alarmed because to
[2:21] me, that's not, it's not sophisticated thinking.
[2:24] And there were a lot of supposedly sophisticated people
[2:27] carrying on this way. And I found it disturbing.
[2:31] Why do you think it's been able to dominate the discourse so
[2:34] much? We've got all these
[2:35] intellectuals at the top that you speak about, that you've
[2:38] heard speaking on different formats.
[2:42] They've written books. Yet suddenly now they keep on
[2:46] retreating to the most basic, polarizing sloganeering.
[2:51] Surely if they're intellectuals, they're going to be better than
[2:54] that. They're going to keep on pushing
[2:56] the nuanced message and churning out their books rather than
[2:59] clips on TikTok. Some of them are not
[3:02] intellectuals, they are thought leaders.
[3:05] It's not the same thing. Why isn't it the same thing?
[3:08] I mean, to me, look, this is all semantic, right?
[3:11] In my mind, an intellectual is somebody who is deeply read,
[3:15] widely read, knows, you know, has really in depth knowledge of
[3:23] a lot of different things, science, art, literature,
[3:27] philosophy, and can synthesize these things in a way that
[3:31] brings forth original ideas. Now, maybe that bar is too high.
[3:34] And by the way, I'm not even putting myself in that category.
[3:38] I think you have a lot of people talking about ideas in a pretty
[3:43] facile way. I think the Ted Talk phenomenon
[3:46] really gave rise to this. You had people standing on
[3:49] stages with fancy backgrounds and, you know, like headset
[3:54] microphones and talking about ideas worth spreading, right?
[3:59] And ideas worth spreading became a substitute for ideas worth
[4:05] considering. We were just spreading them
[4:09] without critiquing them necessarily or checking them.
[4:13] And I think people got really seduced by this.
[4:16] And obviously then you had digital media and you had social
[4:20] media and it was a lot easier to get stuff out there.
[4:23] You didn't have to run stuff past an editor or a publisher or
[4:26] God forbid, a lawyer who was working for a media company.
[4:31] So I, I just think that we had a, we have a different set of
[4:36] standards, you know. The flip that I've noticed with
[4:40] social media specifically enabling this, is that the media
[4:44] used to reflect reality, but now it seems that reality is
[4:48] reflected based on social media. It comes second rather than
[4:54] first. We're work shopping the
[4:56] thumbnails and the titles and the clips before we actually
[5:00] interact with reality. And that might sound really
[5:03] trivial to some people and they'll go yeah, game's the
[5:06] game. But to me that's terrifying.
[5:08] The fact that single handedly social media can change the
[5:13] entire direction of the planet to optimize for clicks and views
[5:17] and engagement rather than actually unfolding in a natural
[5:21] way and potentially pseudo bro scientific evolution brain on
[5:25] here. You start to open up all of
[5:28] these evolutionary mismatches where for all of history so far
[5:31] we've been able to survive as human beings through engaging
[5:36] with the environment and optimizing for survival.
[5:39] Big pivot. We're optimizing for clicks
[5:42] online and trivial forms of engagement.
[5:46] Potentially the glorification of things like having a career and
[5:51] not prioritizing kids just leads to population collapse and
[5:54] extinction. Yeah, So maybe maybe this is all
[5:58] we're just setting ourselves up for.
[6:00] This is a mass extinction event. No, I think you're on to
[6:02] something. I'm always curious.
[6:04] And I'm. I'm curious what you think about
[6:06] this. I mean, I'm Gen.
[6:07] X, right? So I was born in 1970.
[6:10] All right? I'm probably older than your
[6:12] parents. And for us, like the worst thing
[6:17] you could be was like a sellout or giving off any kind of vibe
[6:24] that you were trying hard or that you were, that you were
[6:28] caring what people thought or that you were promoting
[6:30] yourself, especially if you're an artist or creative person.
[6:33] Like that was the least cool thing.
[6:35] And so even now for me as a content creator and as an
[6:39] independent creator, it's very, very difficult for me to do any
[6:44] of these things. I can tell you I've been doing a
[6:46] podcast for five years, more than five years, and I have
[6:50] never once done AB testing on like a show title or a clip or
[6:57] anything like that. And that is probably evidence
[6:59] with, you know, considering my audience would probably be a lot
[7:03] bigger if I did those things. But I just can't do it because
[7:06] it's it's anathema to my sense of self as a as a creative
[7:10] person and, and, and as in, you know, as a semi public quasi
[7:14] intellectual. Yeah, I wonder where the line
[7:17] is. It's something I do is optimize
[7:19] titles, thumbnails and important.
[7:22] Importantly, I try really hard not to spill over into clickbait
[7:24] and being disingenuous, and I've had countless debates with
[7:27] different creators about them doing that and me calling them
[7:31] out for it. But with that optimization,
[7:35] you're essentially gamifying conversations about culture and
[7:39] politics and religion and philosophy and all of these
[7:43] things that run much deeper than a quantifiable best way to
[7:49] engage an audience over Instagram.
[7:51] So I wonder where the line is of optimization versus like you
[7:57] want to do, letting the creative juices flow and kind of just
[8:00] seeing what happens because I think there's a magic in that
[8:03] too. There is a magic in that.
[8:06] I mean, I have had a very long career based on that magic.
[8:09] I started publishing books in the in the 90s.
[8:13] I managed to write them all by myself and put the, you know,
[8:17] get them published by publishers who were not using AI to
[8:22] generate press releases and getting reviewed by critics and
[8:25] major publications and, and kind of floating along that way, not
[8:30] floating along. I mean, it took a lot of effort,
[8:32] but I, you know, it did work for a long time.
[8:36] I'm not going to sit here and say it can still work.
[8:38] Obviously it can't. But, you know, one of the things
[8:41] that I notice with young people, and again, this is something I'd
[8:44] be curious to hear your thoughts about is like, why does nobody
[8:47] just want to get like a regular job anymore and, and have a have
[8:53] a nice life and settle down? We have all this conversation
[8:56] about population collapse in the mating crisis and I'm super
[8:59] interested in that stuff. But, you know, I think to your
[9:02] point, part of what makes that difficult is because people
[9:06] they, they think that they have to like have a, you know,
[9:10] establish themselves economically or professionally
[9:13] before they settle down. OK, fair enough.
[9:15] But when they, when they think that the only way to establish
[9:18] yourself is to like have a YouTube channel or be an
[9:21] influencer or self propel in this way, that's going to
[9:26] eliminate most people because most people can't do that.
[9:29] Like what what is So what? What is so unappealing about
[9:34] just like getting a job at some company?
[9:37] I mean, I, I know I sound like a boomer, but these things still
[9:40] exist, right? They you you can still get a
[9:43] good job with good benefits and have a nice life.
[9:47] Can can you not? I don't know what came
[9:50] downstream from what but it seems especially in the UK, it
[9:54] might be different here in America.
[9:56] So push back on me if you disagree.
[9:57] But in the UK specifically if you have a normal job,
[10:02] especially living in London where really you want to live.
[10:05] The rest of the UK, especially north of the M25, not a nice
[10:08] place, always rainy, cold, miserable and questionable food
[10:13] choices. So if you're going to live in
[10:15] London, you kind of just need to have an above average job to be
[10:22] able to survive there. The cost of living is so high.
[10:25] But the problem is coming with that.
[10:28] And again, I don't know that if this is downstream from us
[10:31] prioritizing shiny objects and more marketable things rather
[10:34] than what we actually need. We've got all of these modern
[10:39] furnished apartments that are super expensive, super poor
[10:43] build quality and you're not really able to live in them
[10:47] properly. There's not this lower bar to
[10:50] entry that you can actually cross and have a comfortable
[10:53] life in because a lot of people make excuses for the reasons why
[10:57] people aren't having kids or are prioritizing hedonistic
[11:01] activities. A lot of the time they are just
[11:04] excuses and actually if you just had the bare essentials, you
[11:08] would be able to do the things that give you more fulfilment.
[11:11] The problem I see in the West is that we've kind of lost that
[11:17] working class element and now everything is not even middle
[11:22] class, but it's like aspiring to live like a royal with no option
[11:26] to not with no option to just have a normal 2 bedroom house
[11:31] with a couple of kids. So that's one of the challenges.
[11:36] Another thing as well, to answer your question of why young kids
[11:39] don't just want to have a normal job is I think we've just cut
[11:44] ties with wanting to make our families proud because the
[11:49] family unit is less relevant to us than ever when we can jump on
[11:55] a flight to LA for a couple of $100.
[11:58] If we get a good deal where we can interact with people across
[12:01] the world via Instagram, it means that the stakes are lower
[12:06] with pleasing your family because they're not the only
[12:09] thing out there for you. Whereas before, I can imagine if
[12:13] you're living in a village, you want to make your parents proud
[12:17] because they're some of the only people you will ever meet.
[12:19] You're not going to venture out, venture outside of your village.
[12:21] Therefore, you're going to take over the blacksmiths from your
[12:25] dad or whatever it may be. So family pride is a big thing
[12:31] that I think there's been a death of.
[12:32] And having spent a lot of time in Saudi Arabia and the Middle
[12:36] East where they have the complete opposite, they have
[12:39] managed to maintain those structures of family pride
[12:42] through conservative values and through their religion.
[12:45] And they will take up their dad's job.
[12:49] So I think it's pursuit of shiny objects.
[12:52] It's access to the global village rather than the local
[12:55] village, and it's a lack of access to easier normal options.
[13:03] Right. We have the same situation here
[13:06] for sure in the big cities, what you just described about housing
[13:10] costs in London, exactly the same in New York and Los Angeles
[13:17] to some extent, places like Seattle, San Francisco.
[13:23] But I just again, I see a lot of discourse online like why can't
[13:30] you, you know, it, just find a what I mean, I follow a lot of
[13:33] manosphere content. Actually, I, I actually
[13:36] fascinated by it and I see a lot of like, well, why can't we
[13:43] just, why, why can't you just live in a 2 bedroom house?
[13:47] Why do you have to live in a big city?
[13:48] Like why can't you move to Columbus, OH and live in a
[13:52] modest house and start your family and move up in the
[13:57] world's as did many people. And I actually don't know the
[14:00] answer to that question. Why?
[14:01] Why not? I mean, Cleveland, OH, forget
[14:04] Columbus, OK, you can go to College in Columbus.
[14:06] Cleveland, OH is a great city. There's a world class orchestra.
[14:11] The Cleveland Orchestra is arguably the best orchestra in
[14:13] the world. People don't realize this.
[14:16] There's art museums. It's 8 hour drive from the
[14:20] George Washington Bridge in New York City actually.
[14:23] And yet, you know, I see very few people.
[14:27] I see very few influencers living just like, you know, a
[14:31] decent middle class on the way to upper middle class life in a
[14:37] city like that. Everything is like the
[14:40] Kardashians or Mormon trad wives.
[14:44] That's a sort of another version of it that are usually
[14:46] bankrolled by, you know, some kind of corporate entity,
[14:51] sometimes their husband. I think it's all on the way this
[14:55] rise of people that are sick of these half truths that are
[14:58] constantly fed to them online, telling them that they're going
[15:00] to be happy once they achieve ex material superficial thing.
[15:04] And you've written about this, you say.
[15:05] So seduced by the half truths propagated by our own side, we
[15:08] have no interest in. We have have no interest in the
[15:11] half truths roaming in distant pastures.
[15:13] So wary from trying to manage cognitive dissonance kicked up
[15:16] by our own gospel, we forget to have empathy for those grappling
[15:19] with the confusions of their own doctrines.
[15:21] We forget that in the end, to be human is to be confused.
[15:27] Unpack that for me. Well, that's again from my book
[15:30] The Problem with Everything and the Half Truths.
[15:34] The idea came from a Joan Didion review from the early 1970s in
[15:41] the New York Times about a bunch of books coming out of second
[15:43] wave feminism. And, you know, a lot of what got
[15:47] me into this culture war stuff had to do with the way that the
[15:53] women's movement had been, in my view, been hijacked by like, a
[15:56] new wave of stupidity. Even before Me Too came along, I
[16:01] was critiquing this. But to answer your question in
[16:05] that in that review, Joan Didion, who was revered by young
[16:11] millennial feminists, right? She's just like a goddess.
[16:14] You know, she was actually very conservative and she was talking
[16:17] about how these kind of platitudes about women's
[16:20] oppression and the patriarchy we're actually half truths.
[16:24] And she was saying this in 1972, I believe.
[16:28] And then they just keep getting circulated and like, it just
[16:30] becomes an article of faith. Somehow the idea that a woman
[16:34] makes $0.74 on the dollar to a man, that is not true.
[16:40] Like that just became like a statistical platitude and it got
[16:45] internalized by a lot of people. And a lot of people walk around
[16:47] assuming that that that's the case.
[16:49] You know the idea that you know the number of black unarmed
[16:54] black men killed by cops in in the United States, People walk
[16:57] around assuming it it's in the thousands or the 10 thousands.
[16:59] It's like double digits, you know, low double digits.
[17:03] I think it goes both ways as well.
[17:05] Yes, you see someone like Matt Walsh go on Joe Rogan.
[17:08] He's speaking about conversion therapy and trans people having
[17:12] their gender affirmed and their genitalia mutilated.
[17:15] And he was millions of people. And then Rogan goes, Jamie, pull
[17:21] that up. It's like 5000.
[17:24] I mean, it depends on how you how you count.
[17:27] I mean, mutilated by surgery is one thing.
[17:29] The word mutilated is a problem. Yeah, the the gender thing is a
[17:32] whole other subject. I mean, I could go on about that
[17:35] for for hours, partly because it it really touches on all of what
[17:42] this is about on a very existential level.
[17:44] Like what is reality? What is material reality?
[17:47] So anyway, but to get back to your question, in my view what
[17:51] started to happen is that the material reality that we had all
[17:55] enjoyed collectively shared that we could acknowledge was true,
[17:59] it started to erode probably in the in the 1980s.
[18:04] Just the media landscape changed.
[18:07] I mean, this has been written about Neil Postman amusing
[18:10] ourselves to death. This has been covered.
[18:13] And in the beginning it was television, right?
[18:15] All that's going to change everything.
[18:17] And then it was 24 hour cable news and then it was it was in
[18:21] the 90 was it was talk radio. Oh my gosh, Rush Limbaugh is
[18:25] ruining, you know, American political life because he's just
[18:28] spouting off nonsense, you know, 4 hours a day on, you know, AM
[18:33] drive radio and not that was all just nothing compared to what
[18:37] happened with the Internet and social media.
[18:40] So people can choose their own reality and I guess it kind of
[18:45] makes you, it's sort of a short term gratification because you
[18:48] can be kind of gratified in your own little silo, but the fact is
[18:52] you're disconnected from the rest of the world because we're
[18:55] just not on the same page. George Orwell was wrong.
[18:59] We weren't going to have our power taken away by some
[19:01] authoritarian master. We were going to hand it to them
[19:04] in pursuit of cheap dopamine. I think that's what's happened,
[19:07] and amusing ourselves to death is a perfect illustration of
[19:10] that. What do you think to politics,
[19:15] societal issues and culture being viewed as forms of
[19:19] entertainment? Do you take issue with that or
[19:21] do you think that's fine? Well, it depends on what you
[19:25] find entertaining, right? Because you could go back and
[19:28] watch William F Buckley debating James Baldwin and I find that
[19:32] very entertaining. And that was certainly a lot
[19:37] more substantive than what we have now.
[19:38] I mean, I thought the Dick Cavett show was entertaining
[19:41] back in the 70s. This was a, you know, a talk
[19:45] show, late, late night talk show that everybody watched where the
[19:49] host would interview political leader one minute and then like
[19:53] a jazz legend, Oscar Peterson the next.
[19:55] Like American intellectual life. And I this, I'm sure this is
[19:59] true in the UK. This is true everywhere.
[20:01] It was. It had a meaning to it.
[20:04] It had, there was like real stuff.
[20:06] And you know, you had like, let's not forget that as
[20:10] recently as, you know, the 1960s, you had people who were
[20:13] like farmers in Nebraska who had read Shakespeare in their high
[20:18] school English classes. And for a whole bunch of reasons
[20:23] that has that has deteriorated. And we not, not only do we not
[20:28] read Shakespeare, we don't read anything because our attention
[20:31] spans have been eroded. And so it's means and like
[20:38] random thoughts that people had and put in a thought bubble on
[20:43] on social media or Instagram and has, you know, some somehow
[20:47] we're supposed to see this as a deep thought because it's in
[20:49] like a, you know, little, little bubble on a pink square.
[20:55] I wonder if we're idealizing the wrong things.
[20:59] Back in the day, you would put someone on a pedestal that was a
[21:02] thinker. They're a great intellectual.
[21:05] They're a powerhouse. They're a Renaissance man.
[21:06] They can kind of juggle everything.
[21:08] Whereas now, especially speaking for my generation, if you ask
[21:13] someone who's your favorite philosopher, they'll say like
[21:18] Plato or Socrates. OK, who's your favorite
[21:21] contemporary philosopher? Is that still a thing?
[21:26] I thought philosophy was like something they did back in
[21:28] ancient Greeks. Like ancient.
[21:30] Greeks. Yeah, Isn't that like an old
[21:31] school thing when everything was black and white?
[21:33] And like, that was my view of stuff a couple of years ago
[21:35] before I went down the rabbit hole as I did and got into the
[21:39] podcasting world. But putting my hands up here,
[21:41] that was my outlook on the world too.
[21:43] I thought idea formation was a thing of the past, which is a
[21:49] really odd thing to say. And I think it stems from this
[21:53] kind of end of history, Francis Fukuyama approach to life and
[21:57] the world and the short sightedness that comes with that
[22:01] of thinking this is it. We're so evolved, we're
[22:04] flourishing, even though we're also complaining about
[22:07] everything going on in culture. This is the end of history.
[22:10] We've got the Internet, we've got AI being developed now.
[22:12] And it kind of just stops here. So one of the key factors at
[22:17] play here, I think for Gen. Z is a paralysis caused by a
[22:23] lack of understanding that things always progress.
[22:26] They keep on going on you're. Reminding me probably sometime
[22:33] in the 90s, I started observing that people would talk about
[22:38] philosophy and what they really meant was like business
[22:41] philosophy or business books. Like I'd be talking to people,
[22:44] especially I remember having this experience, like I'd be
[22:47] talking to men, you know, sort of men in their 20s and 30s And
[22:50] they'd say, you know, I'd be like, I'm a writer.
[22:52] So I'd be like, what do you like to read?
[22:53] And they go, oh, I read a lot of philosophy.
[22:55] I read a lot of philosophy And I was like, oh, well, what do you
[22:57] mean? Like what's your, you know, like
[22:59] Hegel or Nietzsche or and he'd go like, oh, what color is your
[23:03] parachute? That that's what I mean, you
[23:05] know, these kind of business books about how to how to, you
[23:10] know, figure out your true calling.
[23:12] I mean, this was before the kind of like, you know, life hacking
[23:17] kind of business, business bro mode that we have now.
[23:20] But the, the, the, the word philosophy is really elastic,
[23:26] right? I mean, it can mean a lot of
[23:27] things. It can mean, you know, self help
[23:29] philosophy became self help. I think that was another thing.
[23:31] So you would talk to men and they would say, I read a lot of
[23:34] business philosophy business books.
[23:37] And then women would say I read a lot of spiritual books or
[23:40] something. And what they really meant was
[23:42] self help. And that's, that's not, that's
[23:47] really not my definition of philosophy.
[23:49] But maybe I'm being a snob so I wouldn't be the first time.
[23:52] I don't think you are being a snob.
[23:54] I feel we're lacking the deeper, more difficult things to
[23:58] acquire. It's not easy to work out what
[24:02] your stance is on if we have free will or what faith means to
[24:07] you, or what consciousness is. First of all, it's not sexy to
[24:12] talk about other than on some small infographic short and
[24:15] snappy on socials. But it's this whole Blaise
[24:19] Pascal thing of like all of man's suffering and problems
[24:22] stem from an inability to sit in a room in silence.
[24:26] We can't sit in a room in silence now because we doom
[24:29] scroll instead. So I wonder if that lack of
[24:34] difficult to attain thought has led to us replacing and patching
[24:41] over religion and community with new religions.
[24:48] The self help space not just becoming a means to an end,
[24:53] which is a fulfilled life full of meaning and family or
[24:57] whatever else. That now is the thing.
[25:00] The self help is the thing. So there are all of these stops
[25:05] along the way that have become the destination.
[25:08] And you see it all over the place.
[25:10] You even see it with things like trans ideology that we can speak
[25:13] about where the identity which is part of living a fulfilled
[25:19] life, right? You want to know your identity.
[25:22] And we've forgotten that, like you say, humans are confused.
[25:26] We want this rigid identity. We want to understand it so that
[25:30] we can live a happy life. Right.
[25:33] But that's no longer the case. The identity is correlated with
[25:38] the happy life. It is the happy life life.
[25:42] What's going on there? Is it because a lot of the
[25:47] people who are caught up in this are not old enough to realize
[25:50] that the less you think about yourself, the happier you end up
[25:55] being? I mean, it might take a step to,
[25:59] to get to that. And certainly when you're in
[26:01] your 20s, like, who am I? Who am I?
[26:04] And I'm going to, I'm going to find some kind of not even
[26:08] fulfillment, but I'm going to arrive at some kind of Nirvana
[26:11] if I like, figure out my true self, you know, But I think the
[26:15] happiness construct is really faulty.
[26:18] I, I always have talked about and thought about for myself,
[26:21] the notion of contentment. Like I, I want to be content.
[26:25] I want to not be agitated. I want to be agitated as little
[26:30] as possible. Obviously you can't eliminate
[26:32] that. I want to feel like I'm in the
[26:34] right life. And that is not the same as
[26:37] being happy necessarily, but it's, it's feeling aligned with,
[26:44] with whatever your, your happen to be it like whatever life that
[26:48] you have landed in, you got to kind of accept that it really
[26:51] doesn't have that much to do with you.
[26:53] You can make some efforts to kind of tweak it here and there
[26:56] and you can kind of, you know, try to try to land your plane
[26:59] and more or less the right place.
[27:02] But we have very little control over this.
[27:05] And to me, the idea of happiness, it feels very chaotic
[27:08] because I don't know about you, but my feeling about happiness
[27:12] is that it's fleeting. Like we have these moments of it
[27:15] and I feel like a joy. Or maybe I'm, you know, taking a
[27:18] walk and the light is just right and the air is just right.
[27:22] And if things feel right and I have like a moment of, of true
[27:26] happiness. But I don't think you could
[27:27] sustain that around the clock. I think you would go insane.
[27:33] We're pursuing fleeting things existing forever and permanently
[27:41] in our life. We think we can just sidestep
[27:44] reality and make these fleeting things permanent.
[27:50] Yeah. Look, to some degree, well, I'm
[27:53] not even to some degree, People have always done this.
[27:56] People have lived through art. They have looked to ancient
[28:02] texts in ancient days, They have played music.
[28:06] They have, they have tried to, I would imagine many people.
[28:13] I would, I have always been this way.
[28:15] They have tried to go through life thinking of themselves as
[28:19] part of a larger narrative. Like for me, you know, growing
[28:24] up in the 1980s and then I was in my 20s in the 1990s, I just
[28:28] imagine myself as being in like a foreign film, like a French
[28:31] film, like or, or, or a novel. I would, I would walk around, I
[28:37] would be in the city, I would be with my friends.
[28:39] I would be writing. I would be looking out the
[28:41] window. I would be smoking a cigarette,
[28:43] you know, with contemplation. And I felt if I could picture
[28:50] myself as a character in like an artsy independent film doing
[28:54] this, then I thought, OK, I'm living my life right.
[28:58] This is where I want to be if I'm sitting on the roof of my,
[29:02] you know, crumbling brownstone on the Lower East Side of New
[29:06] York City and there's water towers around and there's a, you
[29:09] know, particular kind of feel like I am in the moment.
[29:13] This could be a cinematographer could have been here and like
[29:16] captured this moment and and I am in my life in the right way.
[29:20] And I spent a lot of my time in those kinds of moments before
[29:25] social media came around. And to me, and maybe this is a
[29:30] solipsistic way of thinking about this, but this is
[29:32] something I have written about quite a bit and people have
[29:35] related to it. You know, the, the, the
[29:39] construct, the narrative construct that I was trying to
[29:42] place myself in back then was something that required some
[29:46] kind of attention span to, to even know about.
[29:49] Like I had to sit through the, the, the foreign film in, in
[29:53] order to internalize it, to then walk around and think of myself
[29:56] as being in that film. I had to read the novel in order
[29:59] to have it playing in my mind. And now what we have is I'm
[30:04] going to sit on my roof and, you know, look all around me.
[30:08] And then I'm going to sit here and take a selfie of myself and
[30:10] post it somewhere. And that's a totally different
[30:12] experience. And it's not a private
[30:14] experience we had. We lived in a series of private
[30:18] moments in the past. And if we were lucky, if
[30:20] somebody was there, we would share them with somebody else,
[30:22] but it would still be private. And that is what has fallen
[30:26] away. And that is a profound change.
[30:29] Why is that important? It's important because otherwise
[30:33] you're not you're, you're not actually with yourself, right?
[30:39] If you are taking a selfie and posting it on Instagram before
[30:43] the moment is over or actually probably you're probably sitting
[30:45] there and like messing with the filter and trying to make
[30:48] yourself look better before you post it.
[30:51] I mean, you are, you are, you have a master and that is this
[30:58] baseless public or people that you're trying to impress or
[31:00] clicks that you're trying to get or likes or whatever it is.
[31:03] You know, you are a slave to your dopamine hit.
[31:06] The dopamine is coming from the response that you get from
[31:10] posting something that represents your experience,
[31:13] where in the past ideally the dopamine would happen in the
[31:16] moment during the experience. Yeah, that just rubs off on
[31:23] every single experience you're ever going to have if you
[31:26] fundamentally rewire your brain to only get pleasure from this
[31:31] external validation specifically as well in the online world,
[31:35] rather than looking at what's directly in front of you.
[31:40] Yeah, I mean, you're taking the experience away from yourself.
[31:44] Look, I know I sound, I'm sure people are going to be watching
[31:47] this and saying like, Oh yeah, yeah, yeah.
[31:49] This is like, you know, an old person, you know, shaking fists
[31:53] at clouds, etcetera. But I don't think people are any
[31:58] happier this way. I think they're really unhappy
[32:01] or uncontain. Not content, let's put it that
[32:03] way. Forget about happiness.
[32:05] But there does seem to be a real kind of baseline.
[32:11] I don't want to say misery, but distress.
[32:14] A dis ease that is pretty hard to to kick.
[32:21] I want us to dig even deeper on this point of half truths.
[32:24] You say hysteria is monetizable. Why'd you phrase it in that way?
[32:32] Well, it is because you get it. The algorithm favors it, and you
[32:37] know, if you want to, if you want to run around saying that
[32:40] one out of five or one out of four women are being sexually
[32:44] assaulted on a college campus, that will get you pretty far.
[32:49] People started saying that kind of stuff around 20, 2013, 2014
[32:55] and it caught on pretty quick, especially in the sort of
[32:59] feminist blogosphere. I mean, I write about this a lot
[33:02] in the, in the book that, that you're citing The Problem with
[33:05] Everything, which by the way, was going to be called Woke Me
[33:07] When It's over, that that was my working title for that book,
[33:10] Woke Me when it's Over. And I thought, well, I don't
[33:14] want to maybe this is self sabotage, but I thought that's
[33:17] not a, that's a very funny line, but it's not a, it's not a
[33:20] serious title. But like that, that statistic is
[33:25] just wrong. One out of five women being
[33:28] raped is patently wrong. If that were true, nobody would
[33:32] send their daughter to college. Why would you do that?
[33:35] Like you would be, you would be a negligent parent.
[33:39] But that just caught on. And I think it was because it,
[33:43] you know, it was one of those grab you by the collar false
[33:47] statistics. But then I think that on some
[33:50] level women, especially young women, kind of unconsciously
[33:56] liked the idea that they were in danger in this way because I
[34:00] think it made them feel like they were alive in a certain
[34:05] way. Like if it's a form of
[34:06] unconscious cosplay, this idea that you're in this kind of
[34:10] danger. But the, the, the, the
[34:13] dissemination of that kind of myth did an incredible amount of
[34:15] damage, obviously did a lot of damage to men and then did a lot
[34:20] of damage to people's psyches generally.
[34:23] And so I was very, very angry about that kind of thing in
[34:27] particular, especially when it came to women's experiences.
[34:30] So that's really why I started writing in a more direct way
[34:34] about the culture wars. Well, what do you think to this
[34:37] bifurcation going on of young men, young women, especially
[34:41] politically, people say that men are becoming ever more
[34:44] conservative, young women are becoming ever more liberal.
[34:47] And actually to pick people up on that statistic, because
[34:49] again, it's always quoted as 1/2 truth, Gen.
[34:52] Z young men, especially 18 to 24, they're still liberal.
[34:57] They're just much less liberal than women who are very liberal
[35:01] it. Wouldn't be hard, right?
[35:02] Yes. It's not, not hard to be less
[35:04] liberal than a lot of those women.
[35:06] Well, look, I mean, I think that third and 4th wave feminism
[35:09] created that situation totally. I mean, the the, the dynamics
[35:14] that I was so frustrated by starting 1012 years ago directly
[35:20] set the stage for what we have now.
[35:22] There's no way that young men could not have become
[35:26] radicalized or at least deeply affected politically by the
[35:31] landscape of feminist politics. And it was.
[35:35] So what's so frustrating about it is that it was not even
[35:39] representative of most women. It was a particular subset of
[35:43] women. They were more they, they were
[35:45] more likely to be not just in college, but in a particular
[35:48] kind of college that had purchased in in the media.
[35:52] The New York Times doesn't really care what's going on at
[35:56] University of Alabama. They care about what's going on
[35:58] at Yale and Oberlin. And it's a very particular kind
[36:03] of person who was saying, oh, actually, we've just the world
[36:06] is this way. We've decided.
[36:08] We've decided that it's never been a worse time in history to
[36:11] be a woman. Never been a worse time. 2015,
[36:15] 2016, 2017, the worst possible time in the history of
[36:19] civilization to be a woman. I mean, that's laughable.
[36:22] But there was, I think, a need among people in the Academy and
[36:27] in the media, frankly, with nothing better to do.
[36:32] There was a need to kind of chew on this idea and, and take it to
[36:38] the next level and kind of take it to some kind of thing where
[36:41] they could write academic papers about it or think pieces in New
[36:45] York magazine. But they also kind of wanted to
[36:47] believe it was true because the world was had become pretty,
[36:51] pretty great for women, you know?
[36:53] Steel man, their argument for me.
[36:54] Is there anything in there that is a truth they could be hanging
[36:58] onto? Yeah.
[36:58] So I do think that the rise of digital pornography played a
[37:03] huge role in this. And that's actually something,
[37:06] and I've said this, that I was a little bit myopic about.
[37:10] I am of a generation where it wasn't really part of our
[37:14] experience, so I wasn't aware of how pervasive it was.
[37:18] So yes, I think that if you are a young woman and you have grown
[37:24] up knowing nothing but this particular kind of sexual
[37:30] expression and you are dealing with men and trying to date men
[37:33] and trying to have relationships with men who have been like
[37:38] their, their idea of what is sexual pleasure is completely
[37:42] artificial. It's, it has nothing to do with
[37:44] actual human connection. I think that would be very, very
[37:48] frustrating if not if, if, if not disastrous.
[37:53] And I think that would make you really angry.
[37:55] So I do think that that played a huge role.
[37:58] Well, map that out for me a little bit further.
[38:00] Why does that then? It transcends just sex and
[38:04] experiences within that and impact the whole culture to the
[38:07] point where people can go. This is the worst time to ever
[38:10] be a woman. Well, because they think if I
[38:16] don't get choked during sex, I if I don't like that I am not
[38:20] sexually appealing or they are, they're noticing this phenomenon
[38:25] and then they are coupling it with false statistics about
[38:28] sexual assault. They're not realizing that what
[38:31] is now being classified as sexual assault can be anything
[38:34] from being violently raped to somebody like, you know, putting
[38:40] his hand on you and in not great way at a crowded party.
[38:46] I just think that people got barraged with a lot of
[38:49] information that was wrong and it happened to be piled on top
[38:53] of a sort of ambient experience with the other sex that was
[38:58] pretty negative because of the combination of pornography and
[39:04] again, social media. And I don't know, just a kind of
[39:11] there is I don't, I again, I really would be curious what you
[39:14] think about this, Elliot, because I, you know, when I was
[39:18] growing up and when I was in my 20s, it was like men and women
[39:22] were just kind of all together. Like we would hang out, we'd go
[39:25] out and get drinks after work and make jokes and make
[39:29] politically incorrect, as we called it back then, jokes.
[39:32] And it wasn't a big deal. Like there, there wasn't this
[39:36] sense that there was some kind of like that there was some kind
[39:41] of animosity, default baseline animosity between the sexes.
[39:46] And I guess, you know, division. Division is monetizable.
[39:51] So any place you can find division, the culture will run
[39:54] with it. And that's what happened.
[39:57] I wonder if we all just need to get laid more.
[39:59] Well, apparently so. Apparently nobody does.
[40:01] Nobody gets laid. Now, according to statistics.
[40:04] Now that may be wrong. You know, that's might be
[40:06] another one of those things that's a half truth.
[40:09] I don't know. Yeah, I think as soon as
[40:12] something is very foreign to you, you're actually going to
[40:15] perceive it as more of a threat. So we've put up these artificial
[40:19] walls because division is monetizable and hysteria is
[40:22] monetizable. Therefore, of course your
[40:25] natural state is going to be suspicion when you're speaking
[40:28] to the opposite sex. It makes complete sense.
[40:31] And tagged onto that as well is specifically this rise in, I
[40:37] guess you can call it, Miss Andrew I, I don't want to throw
[40:41] around labels lightly here because that's what people do
[40:44] far too often with things like misogynist or transphobal,
[40:47] whatever. I would call it ironic misandry,
[40:50] yes. What does that mean?
[40:52] Oh, that was just a sort of, you know, I drink male tears coffee
[40:56] mug and this idea that men are so powerful that you can be mean
[41:02] to them and make fun of them because they can't be hurt by it
[41:07] because they have all the power. So it's I'm really just being
[41:11] ironic. You're punching up.
[41:13] Yes, yeah. So I real problem with that
[41:17] because it's one thing to assume that all the men have the power.
[41:22] If you're back in the Mad Men era, if it's 1960s, if you, if,
[41:27] if it is 2016 and you are still pretending and you are a college
[41:35] student woman and you are still pretending that the male species
[41:41] has power over you, you, you, you need to like you.
[41:44] You. You're in the wrong decade,
[41:46] lady, because it hasn't been that way for a very long time.
[41:50] I had an old friend message me the other day on Instagram and
[41:53] she responded to one of my clips going, I can't believe you would
[41:57] make this assumption about women when we live in a patriarchy and
[42:01] they are suppressed and men have all the power, especially in
[42:05] institutions like college and I go, are you serious?
[42:11] Men are behind every single stage of education.
[42:15] Every single stage. Women account for 65% of
[42:18] master's degrees. The wage gap has now reversed in
[42:21] the UK between the age of 18 to 24.
[42:23] Women are 9% more than men on average.
[42:27] Where is this patriarchy that you speak about and specifically
[42:31] the ironic misandry that comes from that?
[42:35] I'm just sat there and I'm going.
[42:38] When true masculinity is outlawed, only the outlaws are
[42:42] going to be brave enough to be masculine.
[42:44] That's how you give birth to someone like Tate.
[42:47] Yes. And whoever said I will not take
[42:50] credit for this construct, it might have been Richard Reeves.
[42:53] This the great he's studying all this author of boys and men
[42:59] said, you know, you had we had Jordan Peterson out there for a
[43:02] while doing really good things like as eccentric guy he was
[43:06] said some things that were a little bit.
[43:08] He isn't abrasive. He doesn't always do himself
[43:10] favors, but he was saying some really important stuff that made
[43:14] a lot of difference to a lot of young people, especially men and
[43:20] mainstream media decided he was the devil.
[43:23] Like they just threw him out. Like, we're not going to listen
[43:25] to any of this. This is a bad guy.
[43:28] And so we got Andrew Tate instead.
[43:30] If you would just kept Jordan Peterson, just held on to him,
[43:35] OK, let him in, let him stay. We wouldn't have ended up with
[43:39] somebody like Andrew Tate necessarily.
[43:42] No, the the whole punching up idea drives me crazy when it
[43:46] comes to men and women. Because to assume that any given
[43:52] man has power over you to the point where you can belittle
[43:55] him, berate him, can sell T-shirts for little girls and
[43:59] Target or Walmart that say boys are stupid, throw rocks at them.
[44:04] In target. Yes, apparently so yes.
[44:07] Well, Target also had their whole like trans transgender
[44:12] tuckable tuckable underwear tuckable bathing suit line for a
[44:17] while, although that that quickly that quickly fell away.
[44:20] But but to to assume that that you can kind of have this
[44:24] vernacular just be part of the accepted way of carrying on
[44:29] because obviously men have so much more power.
[44:32] And obviously we can shake our fists and, and, you know, throw
[44:35] tantrums because we are by definition subjugated by them.
[44:40] That's actually handing them power that they don't have.
[44:43] They didn't have the power. But by acting this way, you just
[44:46] gave it to them. And that makes me insane.
[44:50] It it it truly does. It's not good for women.
[44:54] And people would say to me when I started critiquing this stuff,
[44:56] I lost so many friends over this.
[44:58] And and they would say, Megan, why are you doing this?
[45:02] Why are you carrying on about this?
[45:04] Why do you care so much? You know, women are still
[45:07] suffering. Men are still in these top
[45:09] positions. Don't you care about feminism?
[45:13] And I say, yeah, I care about it more than you do.
[45:15] Actually, I care about it a lot. I care about it enough to see
[45:19] the amount of damage that you are doing to women and, and I'm
[45:25] going to speak up about it and it still boggles my mind the way
[45:29] people just think they don't understand, like they they don't
[45:32] understand how truly counterproductive this mode is.
[45:38] I see it in myself, the impact the the culture has had on me.
[45:43] And I can sit here at this ridiculously large podcast table
[45:47] on my moral high horse thinking that I have all the solutions
[45:50] and because I'm discussing what's unfolding, I'm immune to
[45:53] it. But then I do sit in my room in
[45:56] silence and I go, whoa. My whole life trajectory has
[46:00] been impacted by this too. I mean, I recently filmed an
[46:03] interview with my friend Chris Griffin at LEAD Hamilton's house
[46:07] here in LA, And we were having lunch afterwards.
[46:10] We're having a nice chat. And then his wife came and ate
[46:12] with us. And she kind of shook my hand
[46:14] when we were on the way out. And I said thank you, like,
[46:16] lovely to meet you. And I thought that was going to
[46:19] be that. And she stops me.
[46:21] She goes no, no, no, no, wait, take step back.
[46:25] Shake my hand properly, like you mean it.
[46:29] Look at me in the eyes and don't be scared.
[46:32] Shake my hand. And it kind of made me reflect
[46:37] on the fact that I myself, as a very extroverted person, I still
[46:43] have all of these fears of overstepping with a woman when
[46:47] all I'm doing is shaking her hand and saying hello or
[46:50] goodbye. We're like back to, I mean, you
[46:52] might as well be living in Saudi Arabia.
[46:53] Yeah, and that's the irony with all of this.
[46:57] It's this sort of social media rage bait, division, horseshoe
[47:03] that's going on where you go so far to one end that you come
[47:08] back to these stereotypes, the division and segregation that
[47:13] you see in authoritarian theocracies.
[47:18] Yeah, look, think about the number of women who don't don't
[47:25] get necessarily to go on a business trip in there for their
[47:29] company anymore because men are afraid of potentially being in a
[47:35] situation where there would be a misunderstanding.
[47:37] She would make an accusation, something like that.
[47:40] This has done huge damage to women professionally,
[47:45] personally, politically. That's the irony of this whole
[47:50] thing. Like by demanding your rights in
[47:53] this particular way, you have given them up.
[47:56] And it, it requires like, you know, a couple steps of logic to
[48:01] get there. And, you know, is it fair that a
[48:04] woman would not be asked to go on a business trip?
[48:07] I mean, I'm not talking about like a woman in a very high
[48:09] position. I'm talking like if you are a
[48:11] junior level executive or somebody who's, you know, coming
[48:14] up in the company, is it fair that the man in charge would be,
[48:18] you know, uncomfortable or wary or maybe stay away from you, not
[48:22] be willing to mentor you, for example, because they're worried
[48:27] about something happening? No, it's not fair, but that's
[48:32] the reality. And this has been caused by
[48:34] this. I cannot tell you the number of
[48:36] women in business who have said I want to be mentored by men.
[48:42] I want to be mentored by women too.
[48:43] Yes, fine. But there are men in my company,
[48:46] in my professional world who have things to offer me who I
[48:49] would like to learn from, who won't like, they're not up for
[48:55] that kind of dynamic. They, they don't want to have
[48:58] lunch, you know, because they're, they just don't want to
[49:02] risk it. And if that is, that's tragic.
[49:08] How do we move forwards from this?
[49:12] You know, I, I, I would, I would, I hate to do that thing
[49:15] where I turn it back on you, but I really don't know because my
[49:20] solutions are so they're so rooted in, in the past and I,
[49:27] I'm not bullish enough on technology to, to kind of figure
[49:33] out a way. I, I do think that a more analog
[49:36] kind of life, I mean, it already is being glamorized.
[49:39] It's already kind of becoming a thing.
[49:41] It's like a lifestyle flex, right?
[49:42] You know, and I, I do think that we're going to get to a point
[49:48] where being offline, having in person events, conversations,
[49:54] gatherings that are not, you know, social media is not
[49:58] allowed. I mean, I run events, for
[50:00] instance, where we are not allowed to have our phones out,
[50:02] We're not allowed to use social media.
[50:05] I think that that's going to become more appealing to people.
[50:08] The problem is it's not available to everybody.
[50:11] Like it's, it's expensive to get together.
[50:15] It's hard to go to bring yourself to get out of your
[50:18] house, Like you've got to get dressed and get in your car or
[50:23] an Uber or get on the bus or something and go someplace and
[50:26] meet people and sit down and order a soda or whatever it is
[50:30] and have an experience. And I just feel like people are
[50:34] going to come up with all sorts of excuses as to why that's not
[50:37] available to them. And I don't know how we're going
[50:40] to get past that. How much of this complaining do
[50:42] you think is just cope for a lack of discipline, a lack of
[50:46] self regulation and short sightedness?
[50:49] Because I see this all the time and as someone who's grown up
[50:52] not religious especially, I often have conversations with
[50:56] Christians and they'll speak about the value of a family unit
[51:00] and getting married and monogamy and all things that I buy into.
[51:06] But at first I'd be more suspicious.
[51:09] And importantly, my first thought is, you're a bit boring,
[51:14] aren't you? Oh.
[51:16] And it certainly isn't anymore. But it was, and I see this all
[51:20] the time, especially when I introduce new friends to
[51:22] religious friends or people who are just a little bit older.
[51:26] Their first intuition seems to always be when I speak to them
[51:28] after they are boring. But I think the tide is changing
[51:34] and I think people are cottoning on to the fact that a lot of
[51:37] these boring things are just a sign of more maturity and more
[51:42] ability to refute our hedonistic impulses.
[51:46] So I am bullish on Gen. Z especially.
[51:49] And, and so the next generation coming up that we are starting
[51:53] to turn around and that we perhaps are realizing that a lot
[51:57] of these things we throw around, especially our ambitions of I'm
[52:02] going to sleep with as many women as possible.
[52:04] I'm going to buy the Ferrari. I'm going to buy the Rolex.
[52:07] They're just cope for us being immature.
[52:09] Yeah, I'm laughing because, like, when I was in my 20s, that
[52:15] kind of stuff was so uncool. Like you would roll your eyes at
[52:20] somebody like that. You know it, because it was just
[52:25] so clearly overcompensating. I mean, you know, like somebody
[52:28] had like a I mean, we would always joke if somebody had like
[52:31] a hot car, like a muscle car, you know, like, oh, that's a
[52:34] small penis car. Everybody said that.
[52:36] It was just sort of assumed. Yeah, the whole the whole going
[52:48] to church thing is really interesting too, because I
[52:50] remember even like a three or two years ago, three years ago,
[52:54] I was always seeing the stuff online like on Twitter and like,
[52:57] oh, all these, all these women who want, they want to settle
[53:00] down, like they, you know, their biological clock is ticking.
[53:02] Whatever they want to find a mate.
[53:04] Like they're going to they're going to go to church.
[53:06] Like you'd see all these like manosphere guys being like, why
[53:08] doesn't she go to church? Why doesn't she go to church?
[53:10] Why is she hanging out in the bar?
[53:12] Like what? You know, all they're all doing
[53:14] only fans. What a bunch of hoes.
[53:15] Like, you know, these girls would go to church and then
[53:17] you're like, there's no men in church.
[53:19] Like these girls are supposed to go to church.
[53:21] And what, like hang around with 80 year olds?
[53:24] Like, I don't know. But now we're seeing ostensibly
[53:29] men going to church. Are they really?
[53:31] Are they going to the same church as these young women who
[53:35] want to settle down? Or like, are they making their
[53:37] own churches like the Church of YouTube?
[53:39] What? What is it?
[53:44] I wonder again how much of this church thing is cope.
[53:48] It goes both ways, and I'm bullish on people finding these
[53:52] more meaningful attributes in their life and actually pursuing
[53:56] stuff that is forever. I mean nothing's forever, but
[53:59] that's at least closer to being permanent rather than just a
[54:02] car. And but again like we're both 2,
[54:07] I'd say quite politically non binary individuals sat at a
[54:11] table the the heterodox sphere so to speak.
[54:14] That's a church, by the way. What I see as well is people
[54:21] then overcorrect and they go all in.
[54:24] I'm converting to Christianity within a month of finding Jordan
[54:27] Peterson, speaking and lecturing about the Gospels, and I'm going
[54:31] to go celibate until I'm married and I'm not going to drink ever
[54:33] again and blah, blah blah, the list goes on.
[54:36] And there again, the key thing here is it's this attachment to
[54:40] identity. And actually that too is an
[54:44] inability to have balance. There's the hedonism at one end
[54:48] of the spectrum, hook up culture, blah blah, blah.
[54:52] Then the other end of the spectrum is being so introverted
[54:57] and scared of confrontation that you you masquerade as a
[55:03] conservative Christian in a tweed jacket.
[55:06] Yeah, This is why you see a lot of gender detransitioners
[55:13] becoming very conservative. I have noticed this.
[55:16] So people who get swept up in gender stuff, trans identity,
[55:20] that sort of thing, they, you know, they get really political,
[55:25] they get into that whole movement.
[55:27] We we all know what that's about.
[55:28] And then I have seen many cases where somebody suddenly doesn't
[55:33] about face they they realize this is not a real thing.
[55:36] They D transition, but then suddenly they're like trad, like
[55:41] it's not just enough to not be transgender anymore.
[55:44] Like now they want like, you know, they're going to be super
[55:47] Christian or they're going to they want to settle down and
[55:49] have a bunch of kids and then they're lecturing everybody on
[55:52] that. It's the same pathology, right?
[55:54] Like people want extremes. There's there's a reason that,
[55:57] you know, people who have addictions, they they trade one
[56:00] addiction for another. Like that's just the classic,
[56:03] right? Look, everything is cope.
[56:07] Everything is cope. I see people talking about, you
[56:11] know, how having, having a child is the best thing.
[56:16] They, they don't even know how they lived before.
[56:18] How was I even alive before I had a child?
[56:20] How did I, what was the point of anything?
[56:22] And you know, now I, I just, I, I only know what love is because
[56:26] I have a family and I have a wife and all this.
[56:28] And it's like you are being awfully effusive.
[56:32] If, if, if, if you were really, really enjoying your life at
[56:36] this particular moment as you sit there typing, I kind of
[56:38] doubt you would be this insistent on how this is the
[56:42] only way that smells a little bit like cope.
[56:46] The production of this video is made possible by gear from
[56:49] dfirentalsbookyournextfilmequipmentinstantly@dfirentals.com. I want us to keep on trying to
[56:57] work towards solutions here rather than trying to talking.
[57:01] To the wrong person then. Play the game of playing on
[57:05] people's negativity bias and and just complaining.
[57:07] So one of the things I think we're missing off here is we're
[57:11] never going to get any solutions if we're blocked from speaking
[57:14] about what those may be. And the recent assassination of
[57:18] Charlie Kirk has had me thinking about this relentlessly.
[57:21] The difference between saying the words of violence, then
[57:27] saying that silence is violence all of a sudden, and then us now
[57:32] seeing what actual violence looks like.
[57:35] Right. Talk to me about your thoughts
[57:39] since that assassination, the reaction from both sides of the
[57:43] political aisle. Well, I have been heartened to
[57:48] see that Most serious people, most adults, political leaders,
[57:56] people in the media, most of them not all have been able to
[57:58] say this is a tragedy, this is a human life.
[58:02] This is not acceptable. I didn't agree with what he
[58:04] said, but we, we cannot tolerate this.
[58:07] OK. I, I think that for the most
[58:10] part that's being said. What I don't like is that we
[58:15] don't, we can't seem to agree on what he actually did say.
[58:19] I, I, I, I, I did not follow Charlie Kirk closely.
[58:25] I saw his little videos, I saw snippets of things.
[58:30] I knew that he had been a kind of edge Lord type when he was
[58:33] much younger, but they're just. There's not even.
[58:39] It's not even a lack of consensus about what he said,
[58:41] but an unwillingness to even learn.
[58:44] Like I know plenty of people on the left who are uninterested in
[58:48] any narrative other than that he was a hate monger.
[58:52] And I know people more on the right or even in the center who
[58:55] are uninterested in the possibility that he might have
[58:58] said really vile things at certain points and that what he
[59:03] was doing may not have been as productive as his highly curated
[59:08] edited video clips made it look like.
[59:12] I don't know what the reality is.
[59:15] I can just tell you that these are the 2 interpretations and
[59:18] that they are both wrong. So I suppose the question
[59:23] becomes, are you right? Always.
[59:27] No, I'm never right. The problem is, is that, you
[59:32] know, people always say there's two sides to every story.
[59:35] There's infinite sides to every story.
[59:38] There's, there's a side for everybody telling the story.
[59:43] You know, I think in my book, The Unspeakable, you know, I, I
[59:47] have an essay in there and I talk about, you know, just, I
[59:52] think, you know, I was, I was talking about my relationship
[59:54] with my mother and her death and her relationship with her
[59:57] mother. And, you know, I say in the
[1:00:00] history of the world, a whole story has never been told.
[1:00:03] I can't tell you the whole story because I'm just one person.
[1:00:06] By definition, I can't tell it. Nobody can tell the whole story.
[1:00:10] They can tell their story, a version of it that they happen
[1:00:15] to have concocted. It's not even the whole, it's
[1:00:17] not even their whole story because by the time you
[1:00:19] metabolize it, it just becomes a story.
[1:00:24] So I don't know. I do think that.
[1:00:28] I think we're at a pretty negative place now in human
[1:00:32] civilization and people feel pretty crummy.
[1:00:36] But part of the reason for it is that it has been not just
[1:00:39] normalized, but almost mandated to feel bad.
[1:00:43] Like if you don't feel bad about the world, you're a bad person.
[1:00:49] And so that doesn't help. I mean, there's a, there's a
[1:00:53] reinforcement of, of catastrophe, right?
[1:00:57] And if you're just kind of happy in your life and going along and
[1:01:00] feeling good about things and, or even just trying to feel good
[1:01:03] about what you're personally doing because it's too much to
[1:01:05] think about the larger world, you're not paying attention,
[1:01:10] right? You're not upset.
[1:01:12] You're not, you're not angry. You're not paying attention.
[1:01:17] Maybe just payless attention and be less angry.
[1:01:22] Is that a crime? Well I want to workshop this
[1:01:26] with you as someone that is 20 years old.
[1:01:29] I try not to lean either way and belong to a tribe.
[1:01:34] I try and call out the retardation on the both sides
[1:01:38] always. But perhaps a blind spot for us
[1:01:42] is dying on the fence and never actually committing to one
[1:01:48] position. We're constantly trying to play
[1:01:51] the wise guy and be nuanced and balanced rather than just taking
[1:01:55] action and going, OK, there are infinite stories, but truth is
[1:02:00] also a thing that exists. So we need to make a move here.
[1:02:04] I mean, how do you deal with that?
[1:02:07] Well, I guess it depends on what the proposition is.
[1:02:10] What are you trying to accomplish?
[1:02:11] Are you actually trying to solve a problem?
[1:02:14] I'm not an activist, I'm a writer.
[1:02:18] I'm a podcaster, yes, and I'm an interviewer, but fundamentally
[1:02:21] I'm a writer. It's my job as a writer is not
[1:02:24] to solve the problem, but to correctly state the problem.
[1:02:28] So I believe it was Chekhov who said that it was.
[1:02:32] The job of the writer is not to solve the problem, but to state
[1:02:37] it in a way that is legible, that is clear, that it's
[1:02:40] concise, that helps to other people to see what the problem
[1:02:43] is. Look, if I could solve the
[1:02:45] problem, I would be doing something else.
[1:02:48] But I do think that the unwillingness to look at the
[1:02:53] facts and state what is actually happening has been a gigantic
[1:02:58] problem. I mean, we see that now with the
[1:02:59] state of our cities. We were just talking before we
[1:03:01] started rolling about homelessness in Los Angeles,
[1:03:04] which is literally right outside our door in a huge way.
[1:03:08] And just not to get off on that for too long, but there's for a
[1:03:12] long time been a narrative that a lot of people on the left have
[1:03:17] blombed onto that, oh, there's homelessness like this on the
[1:03:19] street because of the cost of housing.
[1:03:22] Yes, the cost of housing is a problem for the reasons you
[1:03:26] stated earlier and and more, but that is not the direct reason
[1:03:31] that there are people lying on the sidewalk, in some cases
[1:03:38] literally dead because of drug overdoses and fentanyl and the
[1:03:41] type of opioids that have come into our cities over the last
[1:03:46] decade. Like that is a different thing.
[1:03:48] And if people refuse to state that, if they refuse to say this
[1:03:52] is happening for a bunch of reasons, including like, you
[1:03:55] know, the way our municipalities are run and services for people
[1:03:59] and misplaced empathy, then that's the problem.
[1:04:04] I want them to, I want them to actually be honest about the
[1:04:06] situation. And from there, maybe we can
[1:04:10] solve it. But you know, look, Thomas
[1:04:12] Sewell, there's no solutions, only trade-offs.
[1:04:17] So maybe the problem is that we're even seeking solutions.
[1:04:20] Maybe maybe the the mission should be let's seek compromise.
[1:04:27] It's not as sexy, right? I think we should certainly
[1:04:31] pursue solutions. And when you say your job is to
[1:04:36] articulate what's going on rather than come up with the
[1:04:38] solution to it, I just don't know where we go with that
[1:04:43] narrative when the fact is that people are tuning into your
[1:04:48] podcast looking to have the problems articulated.
[1:04:52] But I think they are also looking for solutions.
[1:04:54] And frankly, a lot of people aren't as lucky as us to be able
[1:04:58] to commentate on what's going on.
[1:05:01] So they're not going to physically have the time or
[1:05:03] capacity to solve things. So I wonder about this a lot.
[1:05:07] I mean, this whole cultural landscape online and podcast is
[1:05:11] stand of articulating problems constantly and not really
[1:05:15] feeling a need to come up with solutions, especially going,
[1:05:20] yeah, but what do I know? I am just a commentator.
[1:05:23] I'm just a comedian. Whatever it may be.
[1:05:26] It's like, that is true, but you're also aware of the fact
[1:05:32] that the legacy media dead because you constantly say it on
[1:05:36] your podcast. Yet you're not willing to take
[1:05:38] that to the logical conclusion, which is the legacy media is
[1:05:42] dead because you now are the mainstream podcasts, writers,
[1:05:46] whatever else, and sub stack. Therefore, there is a
[1:05:49] responsibility there to step up to game time and show up as the
[1:05:54] mainstream platforms that we now are.
[1:05:58] And I think that's a responsibility to not take
[1:06:00] lightly. Yes.
[1:06:03] And I would see my job as to put people on the podcast who in
[1:06:09] many cases do offer solutions. Richard Reeves, who I mentioned
[1:06:12] a little bit ago, is an example. He studies this masculinity
[1:06:16] crisis, looking at how boys have fallen behind.
[1:06:19] He has some very specific solutions.
[1:06:21] He will suggest, for instance, this concept of red shirting,
[1:06:24] which is holding boys back a year before they start
[1:06:28] kindergarten. So if the boys really, you know,
[1:06:30] they, they don't mature as fast. We've all these, you know, we've
[1:06:32] got all this data the the girls are soaring ahead.
[1:06:35] He will propose. Don't send your son to
[1:06:38] kindergarten until he's seven, you know, And then there will be
[1:06:43] some kind of there, there will be the, the playing field will
[1:06:46] be more equal. So like, that's an example of a
[1:06:48] very specific solution that he's proposing.
[1:06:52] I've had other people propose things like, you know, this is
[1:06:57] what we need, You know, in terms of homelessness, people do have
[1:07:00] all kinds of solutions. Let's build a compound out in
[1:07:03] the desert that has a wrap around services and, you know,
[1:07:07] meets people where they are and yet doesn't tolerate all the
[1:07:11] things that housing first seem to tolerate.
[1:07:12] You know, that's an example of a solution.
[1:07:14] It's kind of messy. I think they're out there, but
[1:07:19] I, I will not presume to offer solutions.
[1:07:22] I mean, I can, I'm a writing teacher.
[1:07:24] I can, I can have somebody come and take my writing class and
[1:07:27] say, here's how to solve this problem, this logic problem that
[1:07:29] you have in this paragraph that you're not making your point.
[1:07:32] I can do that. But no, you know, I, my job as a
[1:07:38] podcaster, frankly, is to have people on that will say the
[1:07:44] things that need to be said, but they will say them in a way that
[1:07:47] is palatable to the people who still need to be reached.
[1:07:50] I think of my friends, sort of liberals, progressives and my
[1:07:55] generational cohort or, or, or, you know, a little younger, a
[1:07:59] little older, but people who are not listening to Joe Rogan, they
[1:08:03] don't have the appetite for that.
[1:08:05] They listen to NPR, you know, for or the BBC, you know, for
[1:08:09] years and years and years their whole lives.
[1:08:11] They are never going to tear themselves away from that.
[1:08:14] But if I can have a conversation on my podcast that makes them
[1:08:19] think and gets them to move their move the needle a little
[1:08:24] bit because it's not threatening to them and it's truly nuanced
[1:08:29] and it's not edge lordy that I feel is my job.
[1:08:34] And I think I I do it often. I think that's a very important
[1:08:38] factor at play here, but I want to push you on this because I
[1:08:40] think it's interesting and push back.
[1:08:41] Let's workshop this a little bit here.
[1:08:45] As soon as you Give your opinion to me, and this is me thinking
[1:08:50] out loud here, you're essentially saying the world
[1:08:54] ought to be a certain way, right?
[1:08:57] And you're either coming up with a solution or it's a complaint
[1:09:04] that carries water. And I think it's more than just
[1:09:08] stating what's at play. We're all influencing the
[1:09:12] culture in our own tiny, tiny ways.
[1:09:17] And at the top, these big dogs are influencing the culture in
[1:09:20] big ways. They're they're changing the
[1:09:22] trajectory. So I just wonder where the
[1:09:25] responsibility lies on the new media to actually come at things
[1:09:31] with a solution and to invest in something like a fact checker
[1:09:36] for all they do. And that actually it should be
[1:09:39] the case that within a few years, now that podcasts are
[1:09:42] growing and there's more funding being poured into it, it should
[1:09:45] be commonplace practice to have fact checks and graphics that
[1:09:49] pop up saying this is incorrect, this is the actual stat.
[1:09:51] So we essentially become the same corporate institutions as
[1:09:56] the old mainstream media, right? There are loads of problems
[1:10:00] there 2 But I just wonder if that's the only necessary next
[1:10:05] step, if we're actually being responsible with the directions
[1:10:08] we're pushing the culture in. I mean, it's hard because, I
[1:10:12] mean, we're not regulated, right?
[1:10:13] So I mean, we're not subject to FCC regulations.
[1:10:17] So nobody can make us say anything.
[1:10:21] You know, when you publish a book, the author is responsible
[1:10:25] for fact checking the book. I mean, if you write an article
[1:10:28] for The New Yorker or The Atlantic or The New York Times,
[1:10:31] for instance, there are standards and practices that
[1:10:35] those entities are responsible for.
[1:10:39] They're going to have lawyers. They're going to correct
[1:10:42] something if it's wrong. I don't think people realize the
[1:10:45] degree to which an author publishing a book, even if it's
[1:10:48] published by a major house, is really on his or her own.
[1:10:51] There are a lot of books out there that are just BS.
[1:10:55] Wrong stuff is wrong all over them.
[1:10:58] It's basically a podcast on between 2 covers, you know?
[1:11:06] And so there's always been a lot of garbage out there and
[1:11:08] misinformation. It's just takes more effort to
[1:11:12] read something than it does to listen to a podcast.
[1:11:17] I don't know. We could hire fact checkers,
[1:11:18] Yes, but the fact checkers have their own bias.
[1:11:20] What kind of fact checkers that? Who is that?
[1:11:23] How do you do you trust that person?
[1:11:25] I mean, Wikipedia is sort of a Fact Check entity, but it's also
[1:11:32] pretty biased. You know, it's funny, I asked
[1:11:35] ChatGPT the other day. I was just kind of messing
[1:11:38] around and I said, I said something like, are you woke?
[1:11:44] I asked touchy PT and it said, well, it depends on how you
[1:11:47] interpret that. And you know, that's a great
[1:11:49] question. First of all, it said that's a
[1:11:50] great question. And then it it, it, it intimated
[1:11:55] that it was a little more left-leaning than than not
[1:12:02] actually. So I don't know.
[1:12:04] I mean, we're going to have, you could get AI, obviously you can
[1:12:08] get AI fact checking in place. That will probably be the next
[1:12:11] thing. I don't think that the human, I
[1:12:13] don't think that we have the human capital to hire a bunch of
[1:12:16] actual real time fact checkers. I mean, are there people who are
[1:12:19] really going to do that job? It's hard to find anybody to do
[1:12:22] anything. I would really like to know if a
[1:12:24] young person is going to want to sign up to be, you know, random
[1:12:29] podcasters fact checker before they, you know, six months down
[1:12:34] the road, then they just start their own podcast.
[1:12:38] Yeah, we've all got main character syndrome.
[1:12:41] Yes. And that gets back to my earlier
[1:12:43] question, why? Why can't people just get a
[1:12:46] regular job? I mean, I'm not talking about
[1:12:48] getting a crappy job like go to law school and get a job in a
[1:12:52] law firm. Is that, is that the worst thing
[1:12:57] in the world? I mean yes, but but you know,
[1:13:03] being a being an independent creator is really not not the
[1:13:08] best life for for the vast majority of independent
[1:13:12] creators, let alone normal people.
[1:13:15] I think something that we've been skirting around the edges
[1:13:18] of is the actual medium being the message, that classic saying
[1:13:22] and it's such an obvious saying that people kind of under
[1:13:25] appreciate it now. I guess the fact that we had the
[1:13:29] mainstream media and there were certain shows on there, they
[1:13:32] present the news in a certain way.
[1:13:33] Now it's podcast is done, it's 2 hour extended one take
[1:13:37] conversations and with that comes a certain set of fixed
[1:13:43] attributes based on that content and also a certain path of
[1:13:48] unlocks that can occur. You can't have a valid
[1:13:51] conversation philosophically about something.
[1:13:54] I don't know if free will exists on a one minute news bulletin,
[1:13:59] right? Podcasts have unlocked that.
[1:14:02] So what I'm sat here wondering as a podcaster is what the
[1:14:08] direction of the medium, what direction the medium will take
[1:14:12] us in now that we can have two hour conversations.
[1:14:17] Does it mean that we're going to be enabled to go away from this
[1:14:21] cringe small penis Lamborghini instant flexing and actually the
[1:14:26] flex and the aspiration does become being a philosopher,
[1:14:31] being able to speak for two hours.
[1:14:33] Or do we just open up another can of worms where there are
[1:14:37] loads of problems that come with a 2 hour extended conversation
[1:14:40] and we actually use our left brain with super cerebral and we
[1:14:44] want to quantify everything into cool quotes rather than just
[1:14:49] going step back and look at the big picture.
[1:14:52] Well, there are two hour conversations with small penis
[1:14:56] Lamborghini Bros going on all the time.
[1:14:58] So I don't think that those are mutually exclusive.
[1:15:04] I know. Isn't it funny?
[1:15:05] It's like it's either it's either like 6 hours of Lex
[1:15:09] Friedman or 12 second TikTok clip, right?
[1:15:14] Is there no medium here? Does anybody, does anybody watch
[1:15:17] anything or listen to anything for say 40 minutes anymore?
[1:15:22] I wonder again, I just, I think that and I know I'm, I'm
[1:15:29] probably not directly answering your question, but I'm really
[1:15:32] not sure what else to to say. I think that there is just,
[1:15:36] there's a lack of interest in what you're not necessarily
[1:15:40] interested in. I mean, the thing with the
[1:15:44] legacy media was that it would force you to take in content
[1:15:51] that you didn't know anything about.
[1:15:53] I mean, Terry Gross, for instance, whose legendary
[1:15:56] interview here in the US, she had a, she still has a show
[1:15:59] called Fresh Air. It's on public radio.
[1:16:02] She's in her 70s now. She will retire probably fairly
[1:16:06] soon, and it will be a very big deal.
[1:16:08] She was a huge influence on how people conduct interviews.
[1:16:12] She's a huge influence on how I conduct interviews.
[1:16:15] The show was five days a week on almost every public radio
[1:16:19] station in America. And she would talk to everybody,
[1:16:23] authors, scientists, philosophers, politicians, you
[1:16:28] know, a lot of jazz musicians. Her husband was a jazz critic.
[1:16:32] But she was truly, It was a Renaissance kind of show, and
[1:16:38] people loved it. And the thing about it was that
[1:16:42] it was one of the few shows that the the the key to her, she was
[1:16:46] a good interviewer. But to me, the reason the show
[1:16:48] works is because she had a lot of time.
[1:16:51] She had an hour, 50 minutes, an hour or so.
[1:16:54] And she could book anybody because it was huge.
[1:16:57] If you published a book you wanted to get on fresh air, that
[1:17:02] was whatever or Charlie Rose at the time back in the day.
[1:17:05] Now it would be Bill Maher, let's say, but booking fresh air
[1:17:11] and getting a review in the New York Times were the two things
[1:17:15] you wanted to do if you published a book.
[1:17:18] And the, the beauty of, of that kind of programming, and there
[1:17:22] was, there was other examples of it on public radio, for
[1:17:25] instance, was that it was you, you, you really learned stuff.
[1:17:30] I mean, they would call them, you're too young to probably
[1:17:33] remember this, but they would call this driveway moments.
[1:17:36] This was a thing on public radio.
[1:17:37] So that meant that you were in your car, you were listening to
[1:17:40] Terry Gross or whatever it was. Talk of the Nation was another
[1:17:43] fantastic show and you would get home and you would sit in your
[1:17:49] driveway in order to finish listening to the whole thing
[1:17:51] because you didn't want to miss it.
[1:17:52] I mean, obviously it was live. You can't go back and play it.
[1:17:55] You couldn't go play it on the Internet later.
[1:17:56] And so you would sit there and listen to the rest of it in your
[1:17:59] driveway. And I think that what was so
[1:18:05] beautiful about that is that you would find yourself sitting
[1:18:08] there listening to something that you thought you had no
[1:18:10] interest in. And now I never pull up a
[1:18:16] podcast about something I'm not interested in.
[1:18:18] I just want to get reinforced all the time.
[1:18:20] I just want to hear it again and again.
[1:18:23] I'm also reminded of how, you know, when I was, I was a
[1:18:27] newspaper columnist for 12 years in Los Angeles Times.
[1:18:30] I wrote on the opinion page, and I had 750 words.
[1:18:37] I had to hit that mark because it was in the actual newspaper
[1:18:40] as well as online. And I was read by people who
[1:18:44] really liked me, who read me every week, who were fans, but
[1:18:48] also a whole lot of people who either hated me or were
[1:18:51] indifferent. And I would have to deal with
[1:18:54] them as an audience because it was just on their breakfast
[1:18:57] table. It was, it crossed their line of
[1:18:59] vision and they had to read me. And they never would have
[1:19:02] normally. And they would write to me and
[1:19:04] say like, oh, you suck. I can't believe you're in the
[1:19:06] paper every week. But then occasionally they would
[1:19:08] be like, wow, you really made me think of something.
[1:19:10] I you really, I would never have thought about this.
[1:19:13] And that's what's lost. We are not actually forced to
[1:19:18] encounter things that we are not already interested in.
[1:19:22] Yeah, everything's so curated. And it was the case a few years
[1:19:26] ago, even, like in my living memory, that we'd be able to
[1:19:29] curate our feeds. We'd be able to follow certain
[1:19:32] people, certain friends, influences that we like, people
[1:19:36] with political leanings that we agree with.
[1:19:38] And that would be our own safe space, this fluffy echo chamber.
[1:19:44] Now it's going to step further. When the entire app is curated,
[1:19:50] you now have Blue Sky and you have X, and you can tell a lot
[1:19:54] about a person based on whether they're on Blue Sky or.
[1:19:58] XI hate both of those people by the way, but.
[1:20:00] Saying I stay away from both, But then even on these more
[1:20:06] lifestyle Y social media apps of Instagram and TikTok, it's gone
[1:20:10] away from you creating your feed yourself to having it curated
[1:20:14] for you by an algorithm. And I think that gets pretty
[1:20:18] dangerous pretty damn fast. Oh yeah.
[1:20:21] I mean, it's terrible. If you really want to know
[1:20:23] somebody, you should see what their algorithm looks like,
[1:20:26] right? I mean, it does not reflect.
[1:20:28] Well, I can tell you what, what the algorithm thinks I want to
[1:20:31] see is not something I would necessarily the bring up at a
[1:20:37] dinner party. Oh, there's a lot of stuff about
[1:20:40] dogs. It shows me a lot of Saint
[1:20:42] Bernard footage. Well, it's a lot of Saint
[1:20:45] Bernard content. That's the redeeming factor
[1:20:47] then. But I mean, I see people and
[1:20:49] friends, they have all these burner accounts on Twitter and
[1:20:52] Blue Sky and Instagram, just that they can program their
[1:20:55] algorithm diff differently. Should you really have to do
[1:20:59] that? I mean, I don't do that, but I
[1:21:01] don't. To get an opposing viewpoint.
[1:21:04] I think it should be much easier than that.
[1:21:06] Yeah, Yeah, I but do you think people are just going to become
[1:21:11] so sick of this that it it stops?
[1:21:14] I mean, my hope, maybe this is cope.
[1:21:17] It's hope and cope is that we are just in a particularly
[1:21:21] pernicious blip and that 50 years from now we're going to
[1:21:27] look back on this time is like that was really tumultuous like
[1:21:30] that was a transition period after the rise of digital media
[1:21:35] that was very uncomfortable and very negative and had a lot of
[1:21:39] really I'll effects. No among, you know, our, our,
[1:21:44] our political administrations. High among them.
[1:21:48] I, I, I hope I, I do feel like the human mind and spirit is, is
[1:21:57] crave something better and this will ultimately kind of tip over
[1:22:02] into that place. I mean, it may not happen in my
[1:22:05] lifetime, but I would hope that would happen in yours.
[1:22:09] I wonder what you think about that.
[1:22:11] Well, it's fascinating hearing that you think we are in a
[1:22:13] specifically tumultuous period now because a lot of people,
[1:22:17] especially from Gen. X, they will say, yeah, this is
[1:22:21] just part of growing up. You're going to be an activist,
[1:22:26] you're going to have your tribe, you're going to be an emo or a
[1:22:29] punk or whatever it is, and that's normal.
[1:22:30] You're going to be a communist, right?
[1:22:32] So they kind of try and play down what Gen.
[1:22:35] Z are facing, especially putting it down to just the natural
[1:22:40] progression of life. Why don't you think it's that?
[1:22:44] Why do you think it's more than that?
[1:22:44] And it's specifically the time that we're in.
[1:22:46] Well, I think it's both of those things.
[1:22:48] I don't think that's wrong, but I, I guess I mean just the slop,
[1:22:54] I mean just the, the we are bombarded with negative,
[1:23:02] destructive, erroneous, just fault.
[1:23:08] Just it's, I mean, it's like an avalanche of crap all the time.
[1:23:14] The digital clutter. I mean, I was having this
[1:23:16] conversation the other day, like I don't know about you, but I
[1:23:18] can't, my, I don't even my e-mail doesn't even work anymore
[1:23:22] basically because it's just crap.
[1:23:25] You know, Oh, your thing is going to expire.
[1:23:27] Like you're, you know, if, if you don't click on this now or
[1:23:31] all your photos are going to be a lot like it's, you know, that
[1:23:33] or they're selling you something or it's commerce or whatever, it
[1:23:36] doesn't work anymore. There's a feeling that, of
[1:23:40] brokenness. I think that, you know, the,
[1:23:43] the, every, everything feels broken.
[1:23:44] I mean, Alana Newhouse, who's the editor of Tablet magazine,
[1:23:47] has written beautifully about this, and I've spoken with her
[1:23:49] about it. And so it's it's this feeling of
[1:23:52] brokenness that I'm talking about.
[1:23:54] Yeah, obviously people are going to go through their e-mail
[1:23:57] phases and everything. They used to go through them
[1:23:59] privately. You know, the problem is it's
[1:24:02] now their emo phases is an identity and a protected class.
[1:24:07] It used to be just kind of a fashion you were messing around
[1:24:10] with. But no, there does.
[1:24:14] There's something that feels uniquely, uniquely difficult and
[1:24:20] even terrible about this time. I think you've touched on it
[1:24:23] that perfectly, this identity problem that we have, I see that
[1:24:28] as at the heart of a lot of this stuff.
[1:24:30] Because as soon as you attach something to your identity and
[1:24:34] you don't sever it as just an idea and keep it at arm's
[1:24:38] length, if someone disagrees with you, they're not, they're
[1:24:42] not disagreeing with you. It's a personal attack and that
[1:24:48] leads to people just blocking out everything else that said,
[1:24:51] because it's encroaching on them and who they are, and there are
[1:24:55] loads of problems to unpack there with what we actually mean
[1:24:58] by who we are too. How do you think university
[1:25:02] plays into all of this? How have you seen that develop
[1:25:06] in all your years writing? I graduated College in 1992.
[1:25:15] I at that time never had a sense that critical thinking was
[1:25:22] anything but the coin of the realm.
[1:25:25] That's what we did. We argued we did not take things
[1:25:29] personally. I mean, maybe there was some, a
[1:25:31] few, you know, a few proto woke people and like your feminist
[1:25:35] film theory class that weren't into that stuff, you know.
[1:25:38] But for the most part it was all about ideas and arguing was fun.
[1:25:45] Actually. It was a way, it was kind of
[1:25:47] sexy. Like it was how you, it was how
[1:25:51] you showed that you had energy. There was a spark to that.
[1:25:54] I mean, it was actually seducted, you know, like a way
[1:25:56] to kind of people kind of like hook up with somebody by
[1:25:59] flirting with them, arguing about them.
[1:26:01] Yeah, seriously. It was a an intellectual
[1:26:03] argument was like a form of flirtation.
[1:26:05] There was a real kind of erotic energy to it, often for me
[1:26:11] anyway. But I think probably by the late
[1:26:16] 90s it started to change, I think.
[1:26:19] I mean, Camille Paulia has written really great stuff about
[1:26:22] this. She says that a cohort of
[1:26:25] professors started coming up. You know, the old guard started
[1:26:30] to retire, you know, people who had been academics probably
[1:26:34] starting in the 50s, sixties, 70s, you know, that generation
[1:26:37] retired. You had people coming up through
[1:26:39] the humanities that were not as rigorous in their thinking.
[1:26:44] You had the downstream effects of affirmative action, DEI, this
[1:26:49] kind of thing. So you just had a different
[1:26:52] sensibility and also like more people were going to colleges.
[1:26:56] Liberal arts departments were changing a lot.
[1:27:00] They were expanding. So you had people coming in and
[1:27:02] teaching in liberal arts programs that just had a
[1:27:04] different, they were, they were more woke like it was it was the
[1:27:08] beginning of that. And so that became the baseline
[1:27:13] sensibility for college, for certain kinds of colleges.
[1:27:16] Again, not all of them, not tech schools, not trade schools, not
[1:27:20] big, big public universities at that time.
[1:27:22] This was happening in an elite liberal arts colleges, the ones
[1:27:26] that then fed into the New York Times.
[1:27:28] You graduate from Yale, you can get you go, if you don't go work
[1:27:32] for McKenzie, maybe you go work for the New York Times or NPR or
[1:27:36] you go, you know, become an academic teacher somewhere.
[1:27:38] So I just think it was a different, it was a different
[1:27:40] generation of academics. And that was a huge part of the
[1:27:45] of the change. Do you think too many people are
[1:27:47] going to University A? 100% as they say.
[1:27:50] Podcast Land. 1000% Elliot Yeah, there's no, there's no need for
[1:27:56] it. We need people to, I mean, I'm
[1:28:00] not the first person to say this.
[1:28:01] We need people to go to trade school and learn how to fix your
[1:28:03] refrigerator because that's something that Chat ChatGPT
[1:28:06] cannot do for you. Yeah, I think it's, again, it's
[1:28:11] choosing comfort instantly and choosing the status associated
[1:28:16] with a piece of paper that is actually pretty meaningless now.
[1:28:20] And post grad jobs don't seem to be earning you more money until
[1:28:25] you eventually climb up the greasy pole of careers through
[1:28:29] networking anyway. A lot of people, they graduate
[1:28:32] and then they go and work in a coffee shop for years because
[1:28:35] they can't get employed because they don't have enough
[1:28:37] experience. There's that paradox going on.
[1:28:39] And so things partly down to lazy employers as well.
[1:28:44] There's kind of this paradox where on one hand people are
[1:28:47] graduating and everyone's graduating, so everyone's going
[1:28:50] to university. They're doing these jobs because
[1:28:54] degrees are required. Yet they get to their interview
[1:28:58] and the interviewer goes, you don't have enough experience for
[1:29:00] me. You haven't demonstrated any
[1:29:02] potential, any proactivity, because you've just been at
[1:29:05] university, and I don't know where we go from here in terms
[1:29:11] of the massive cohort that is coming through at the moment in
[1:29:15] Gen. Z.
[1:29:16] Most of my friends are at university.
[1:29:18] I chose not to go because I'm just a contrarian asshole, but I
[1:29:23] don't know where they're going to go.
[1:29:25] It's fascinating to me what's going to happen in the next 10
[1:29:28] years when all of my friends and all the people around me do
[1:29:32] graduate and there's just not room for them in jobs.
[1:29:35] Are they going to have to go back to trade school and not
[1:29:38] graduate until they're 30? Well, so do they not have the
[1:29:43] idea that going to college will help them network and get a job?
[1:29:47] I mean, that was the idea before you wanted to go to an elite
[1:29:50] college because that would be your network and you would get a
[1:29:53] job through some Yale alum. Is that off the table now?
[1:29:59] That's certainly not what college is for.
[1:30:01] It's about partying, but all those things making friends for
[1:30:07] life, right? But it's not networking, really
[1:30:11] anyone I speak to. It's not about the network, it's
[1:30:14] about the experience of having done college.
[1:30:16] It's now a bucket list thing rather than a network and a way
[1:30:21] into employment. OK.
[1:30:22] But don't you think that they will realize later that that is
[1:30:25] their network? I mean, what do they think?
[1:30:27] Is it because we can network online that you that it that it
[1:30:31] obviates the need for your alumni network?
[1:30:35] Perhaps, but especially, and it might be different in the US,
[1:30:38] you guys have frats and sororities and it seems to be
[1:30:44] much more cohesive. Whereas in the UK, people that I
[1:30:49] speak to at least, they kind of just graduate from university
[1:30:53] and that's it. In regards to their friend
[1:30:54] groups, they had drinking buddies, not friends for life.
[1:30:58] Huh. OK, wow.
[1:31:01] That's interesting because you know that the the whole reason,
[1:31:06] the upward mobility was all around this idea of you would go
[1:31:10] to fancy college and then you would know those people and they
[1:31:13] would help you get a job or they would introduce you to your your
[1:31:17] future spouse. And you know, this is how the
[1:31:20] elite sustains itself. Well, I can't remember your
[1:31:28] initial question. Yes, definitely too many people
[1:31:31] go to college and you know, it's I mean, it's so much harder to
[1:31:36] get into college than it used to be too, because it's an
[1:31:38] international marketplace, right?
[1:31:40] Like you're some, you know, average, above average American
[1:31:44] kid is competing with people from all over the world to get
[1:31:48] into some second tier college. But.
[1:31:51] What's happening in the UK is the grade standards are dropped
[1:31:55] for international students because they bring in more
[1:31:58] money. So you're lowering the quality
[1:32:01] that you're aspiring to have on your campuses just as a money
[1:32:04] grab. Yes, So that's an example of a
[1:32:07] problem that could be solved if the problem was stated
[1:32:11] correctly, right? So like that's a thing that
[1:32:13] probably people are afraid to, they have been afraid to say out
[1:32:16] loud because they're going to seem xenophobic or racist or
[1:32:19] whatever it is. But hopefully we can get to a
[1:32:21] point where we say, Oh no, this is happening.
[1:32:23] This is just an economic reality and we need to address it by not
[1:32:31] by holding everybody to the same standard perhaps.
[1:32:35] I want us to sidestep and speak about the trans debate that's
[1:32:39] unfolding, and I try not to cover it too excessively.
[1:32:43] Why? Because I think there are more
[1:32:45] important things we should be speaking.
[1:32:47] About. However, I am aware of the
[1:32:52] importance of it in its own right.
[1:32:55] I just think in terms of my airtime, there are more valuable
[1:32:58] things and more pressing things to be discussing.
[1:33:02] What's going on here in America and why do you care so much
[1:33:06] about the trans? Debate, Why do I care so much?
[1:33:08] Because it, it's about everything, you know, we are
[1:33:14] arguing over what is material reality.
[1:33:18] It's the the trans debate. It's a tapestry.
[1:33:21] I mean, it has everything it has like, you know, the medical
[1:33:25] institution that it has issues of mental health and it has
[1:33:29] issues of style and, and the entertainment world.
[1:33:33] And it has, you know, the, the rise in, in autism has the rise
[1:33:38] in autism diagnosis and, and, and the gay movement and what
[1:33:43] that means. And, and like medical
[1:33:47] malpractice and recovered memory and issue, just all these
[1:33:52] things. And it's like all of the kind of
[1:33:55] all of the sort of major threads to pull on in the culture, I
[1:33:59] think over the last 50 years have coalesced into this
[1:34:03] movement of people deciding that they are materially the opposite
[1:34:10] of what they are and then asking us to go along with it.
[1:34:16] I mean, to me, it's, it's a microcosm of what's happening
[1:34:19] more broadly. Like we are being presented with
[1:34:22] things that are not true and being asked to go along with
[1:34:26] them in a big way across a lot of metrics, right?
[1:34:30] And so it gets distilled into this weird little movement
[1:34:34] that's actually not so little because it's happening all over
[1:34:37] the place. And I just, I just think it's
[1:34:43] fascinating. In the next few years, because
[1:34:45] in the UK we're tough. Island.
[1:34:47] Yes, I know. Yes, very different to the US.
[1:34:51] Do you see America? As moving in.
[1:34:53] The right direction, yeah, I think that liberals are starting
[1:34:57] to catch on part of what's. Happened part of, you know, the
[1:35:01] reason that that we've been so slow is that we have this, we're
[1:35:06] so haunted by the specter of, of gay, you know, oppression of, of
[1:35:13] gay people, lack of marriage equality, all this kind of thing
[1:35:17] and conversion therapy and it had this religious balance.
[1:35:21] I mean, part of the reason I think you don't have this as as
[1:35:23] much in the UK is that you don't have this sort of legacy of
[1:35:26] religious fundamentalism, Christian preachers converting
[1:35:29] gay people. I mean, really horrible things
[1:35:31] that were done. And so a lot of people in the US
[1:35:34] have assumed that trans is just gay rights. 2 point O, like, Oh
[1:35:38] well, we were wrong about that, so we're not going to make the
[1:35:41] same mistake again. And I think slowly people are
[1:35:45] starting to realize that not only is it not gay rights, 2
[1:35:48] point O, it actually is a form of conversion therapy because
[1:35:52] some significant percentage of these trans identified kids are
[1:35:55] actually gay and they don't want to be gay either because of
[1:35:58] internalized homophobia or their own families are homophobic.
[1:36:02] I mean, I know many instances of families that would rather have
[1:36:06] a trans kid than a gay kid. So, but these are complicated
[1:36:10] issues. And unfortunately, it was the
[1:36:13] political right who was talking about this for longer and in a
[1:36:18] way that wasn't very palatable to the left.
[1:36:21] And it really has taken some a critical mass of voices that
[1:36:27] were more careful, I think, and more respected among liberals
[1:36:29] to, to start speaking up. So I think we'll start to see a
[1:36:32] change. But a lot of people are, are
[1:36:33] hanging on, you know, Well, I really value your input as an
[1:36:37] authoritative voice on this. And I I know you've covered it.
[1:36:40] A lot on your show. Talk to me about the actual
[1:36:46] severance of sex and gender and where we should go semantically
[1:36:51] from here. For anyone that's watching
[1:36:52] listening that buys into gender ideology.
[1:36:56] Well, sex is that has to do with phenotype, right?
[1:37:00] Like. There's two sexes.
[1:37:01] There's male and female gender. Judith Butler, who was, you
[1:37:06] know, kind of the original sin here, coined the idea of, coined
[1:37:11] the idea of gender. And she saw it as the
[1:37:13] performance of your sex. So gender is, is like a
[1:37:18] philosophical concept. It's an idea.
[1:37:20] Sex is a real thing. OK.
[1:37:22] That's a biological reality. Part of what happened is that
[1:37:27] people did not want to use the word sex because it means sexual
[1:37:30] intercourse also, right? So even someone like Ruth Bader
[1:37:33] Ginsburg, famous Supreme Court Justice, she would argue for,
[1:37:37] you know, she sex, sex based rights.
[1:37:40] When she was putting her arguments forth, she would use
[1:37:43] the word gender because sex was like icky.
[1:37:46] And especially back then, people didn't want to hear it.
[1:37:49] So you hear this all the time as people, people all, you know,
[1:37:52] use, use those words just alternatively.
[1:37:56] And that's been very confusing to people.
[1:37:58] So if somebody wants to say I, I identify as a different gender,
[1:38:05] I still think that's a little silly, but I'm like, OK, well,
[1:38:08] you're not literally saying you can change sex, but I think that
[1:38:13] it just, it's concept creep, right?
[1:38:15] So be like, oh, I can be a different gender and gender
[1:38:18] means sex. So I can change sex therefore
[1:38:22] and you can't. So I think there's a big,
[1:38:24] there's a big semantic issue there and it, and it remains so
[1:38:28] to this day. I mean, Americans are very
[1:38:29] puritanical. We don't like to talk about sex,
[1:38:31] apparently, but we'll talk about gender.
[1:38:33] Yeah, well, I I wonder if there's any weight in having the
[1:38:36] word gender at. All it's so difficult to
[1:38:41] separate things because because everything's gotten so messy.
[1:38:44] And I was, I was reading into the history of where gender
[1:38:46] actually comes from. And it, it used to be sort of a
[1:38:49] label for inanimate objects versus animate objects.
[1:38:53] And then eventually it progressed to sort of, yeah.
[1:38:56] In language, I mean, right. Like it, you know, if you're
[1:38:58] like if in a Romance language. It they're gendered, you know,
[1:39:03] there's, you know, the, the nouns and verbs are gendered,
[1:39:07] right? They're not sexed.
[1:39:09] So yes, exactly. And then it kind of crept into a
[1:39:13] rough proxy for gendered. Norms and duties that you would
[1:39:17] carry out. So something like a sword would
[1:39:21] be masculine because men would be fighting.
[1:39:23] And then eventually you get down and it sort of creeps into sex
[1:39:26] and encroaches on your actual physical sex.
[1:39:33] Yeah, I I wonder if there is. Any compromise to be had?
[1:39:38] With pronouns or if we just go all out he him, sheeha.
[1:39:45] I'm really torn about this. On one hand.
[1:39:50] I I know the dangers of playing along and kind of humoring
[1:39:58] somebody out of kindness when there is material reality.
[1:40:04] You know, just as silence is not violence, using a particular
[1:40:07] pronoun is not violence. So I totally understand people
[1:40:13] who take the position that they are going to use biological
[1:40:17] pronouns. Even for people who are
[1:40:20] presenting pretty convincingly as the opposite sex, I
[1:40:25] understand their position intellectually.
[1:40:28] On the other hand, I'm not sure that's a hill worth dying on.
[1:40:33] You can make all kinds of cogent, careful, respectful
[1:40:37] arguments about the folly of the transgender movement, about the
[1:40:44] fact, and I would say it is a fact, that the vast majority of
[1:40:47] people who are trans identified are not trans.
[1:40:49] I'm not even sure what trans means at this point, although
[1:40:53] that's slightly off to the side. You can, you can get into it.
[1:40:58] You can be pretty honest about this.
[1:41:00] You can be pretty blunt and fearless.
[1:41:04] I'm not sure why refusing to use somebody.
[1:41:07] 'S preferred pronouns. Is really that helpful as part
[1:41:11] of the mix? I find that you lose the room.
[1:41:15] I can have a pretty respectful disagreement with somebody if I
[1:41:21] use their preferred pronouns. The minute I start doing it,
[1:41:25] I've lost them. Now, is that intellectually
[1:41:28] honest of me? No, it's not.
[1:41:29] It's convenient, so I don't know.
[1:41:33] I'm really torn. Yeah, I suppose the problem is
[1:41:36] that rules are written in language and if.
[1:41:38] You buy into the wrong use of language.
[1:41:41] You have no way of arguing because you're going no, the
[1:41:45] trans woman, she's not a woman. Like, OK, cool, but you just
[1:41:51] called her she. And I'm torn on this too.
[1:41:53] And I've been going back and forth on it and deliberating for
[1:41:55] so long, especially having produced the Trigonometry
[1:41:58] podcast where I've sat in for all the big dogs coming into
[1:42:01] studio and giving their take on on the trans debate.
[1:42:06] I just don't know if there's any other solution than being.
[1:42:09] Harsh and. Going look, I'm not going to
[1:42:13] call you by your preferred pronouns because that is
[1:42:15] contrary to reality. The question may be, can we
[1:42:19] sever pronouns from reality? Pronouns become your vibe.
[1:42:26] So you are she her because you are a female vibe.
[1:42:31] And we just draw a harder line in the sand and go, OK you're a
[1:42:34] female vibe, but you're not a female so you're not allowed
[1:42:38] into female changing rooms. But then the problem comes of,
[1:42:41] OK, you're a female vibe. What on earth does that mean?
[1:42:45] Well, yeah, I was going to say Vibe is in the.
[1:42:47] Eye of the Beholder, right? You just.
[1:42:49] Have to stereotype you Go. Yeah, you're a female vibe
[1:42:52] because you like wearing flowery.
[1:42:53] Dresses and doing housework like that is everything that these
[1:42:59] people fought for fought against for decades.
[1:43:02] So with that issue and before I've argued that there is a
[1:43:06] compromise that you can go, yeah, you're a female vibe, but
[1:43:09] there's there's a distinction there between vibe and sex.
[1:43:13] I've argued that before. But what I've realized is the
[1:43:17] logical conclusion of that is you have to answer what is a
[1:43:19] female vibe? And it's a circular answer
[1:43:21] because you just go whatever you say a female vibe is.
[1:43:24] So I don't think there is any other solution than refusing to
[1:43:29] use preferred pronouns. I'll go out and put it on the
[1:43:31] table, get myself cancelled as a Gen.
[1:43:33] Z turf. There it is.
[1:43:34] No, I mean, I think that's a very intellectually honest.
[1:43:39] Appraisal also like what is a vibe?
[1:43:42] What's any vibe Like that's totally subjective.
[1:43:47] Like I can you know, somebody can say somebody thinks somebody
[1:43:50] has a female vibe and another person could say I don't think
[1:43:52] that's female vibe at all. You know, that's one of the
[1:43:55] things that I run up against when people say, well, I guess
[1:43:58] I'm going to make my pronoun decision based on how I see this
[1:44:02] person. Like, and they'll cite an
[1:44:03] example of somebody who passes very, very well, like Blair
[1:44:06] White, for instance, as a trans, as a biological male, trans
[1:44:11] identified woman who you would never clock as male, right?
[1:44:18] So, OK, someone will say, well, I'm going to extend my courtesy
[1:44:21] to somebody like Blair, right White, but not to somebody like,
[1:44:25] you know, who's clearly has not passed as well.
[1:44:28] My problem with that is you. That's you.
[1:44:30] You are granting privileges to somebody just because they're
[1:44:33] passing. Like that seems unfair.
[1:44:35] That's like you're discriminating against somebody
[1:44:37] because of their attractiveness or something.
[1:44:39] Like not everybody, like Blair White, yes, she's done a lot of
[1:44:42] work to look that way, but she also is just has a particular
[1:44:45] kind of frame. Like there's all kinds of
[1:44:46] genetic advantages and you're incentivizing excessive work
[1:44:52] there. Yeah.
[1:44:53] I mean it's. Just that then you get into you
[1:44:55] are just prioritizing people. Based on their appearance and
[1:44:59] their attractiveness. And so that doesn't seem right
[1:45:02] to me. You're rewarding them for
[1:45:04] passing. That's unfair.
[1:45:07] So yeah, I don't know. I, I really don't know the
[1:45:12] answer. I do, I mean, I, I do think they
[1:45:14] should just build more gender neutral bathrooms.
[1:45:16] I mean, that seems like a very obvious solution, right?
[1:45:19] It's, I know it's cost more, but the more bathrooms the better
[1:45:23] everywhere. I think it's so tough to.
[1:45:29] Unpack and the thing that's important to.
[1:45:33] Stay, especially with the positions that we have here is
[1:45:39] the pity that I feel and perhaps pity is too patronizing of a
[1:45:43] word. But the the empathy I feel for
[1:45:46] people that are affected by this and they have bought into the
[1:45:51] myth that they do need to cut off genitalia to affirm their
[1:45:56] real identity as a 20 year old growing growing up amongst this,
[1:46:01] especially in Brighton. Hove which is the.
[1:46:03] LGBT capital of Europe, pretty much in the world.
[1:46:07] I just look at it and it's so, so sad.
[1:46:11] It really, really genuinely upsets me.
[1:46:14] I know so many people that have transitioned and that have made
[1:46:20] all these compromises about life and about their long term
[1:46:23] fulfillment for this short term thing that they were sold when
[1:46:26] they were like 13. And it just terrifies me that
[1:46:30] something can hijack a culture in this way.
[1:46:34] And that's the big thing with the trans issue, like I was
[1:46:37] saying earlier that I try not to cover it too much because I
[1:46:40] think there are other bigger things to be a bit utilitarian,
[1:46:44] something like social media or depopulation, like I think it
[1:46:48] affects us all more so, but in its own individual right for the
[1:46:53] people that it does affect, the the trans thing is disgusting
[1:46:57] and horrifying and upsetting. So I'm sat here trying to find
[1:47:01] the balance of how much I should discuss it without also being
[1:47:05] grifty and just jumping on it because it's going to give me a
[1:47:08] bunch of views. I discuss it because I feel I
[1:47:12] discuss it in the right way. Not to put too fine a point on
[1:47:16] it, when I started my podcast in 2020, I knew I wanted to talk
[1:47:20] about it in a pretty early episode, and I looked really
[1:47:26] hard to for the right person. I did not want to have somebody
[1:47:29] who'd already been on a lot of podcasts.
[1:47:31] I did not want to have somebody who, you know, was good at
[1:47:34] getting attention about it but still use kind of polarizing
[1:47:38] language. I was being a bit of a squish,
[1:47:40] OK. But I just again, my goal was to
[1:47:46] present a conversation that my nice public radio listening
[1:47:50] friends could hear and think, oh, OK, I get it.
[1:47:54] I get why this is important and I get why we need to talk about
[1:47:58] this. And I get what where I've been
[1:48:01] misinformed by this. And you know, I pulled Sasha
[1:48:05] Ayad out of the ether. I had heard she's a, a therapist
[1:48:11] here in the US who specializes in teen mental health and, and
[1:48:15] gender. And I had heard her on some
[1:48:17] random podcast somewhere like Deep in the Depths.
[1:48:21] And I brought her and I tracked her down.
[1:48:23] I brought her and I think it was my fifth episode, and we had an
[1:48:26] amazing conversation. And she was like, she said she
[1:48:30] was so nervous. She later told me she was like
[1:48:31] in her bathroom because it was the only, like, soundproof area
[1:48:34] she could find. And she had all these notes and
[1:48:36] she was trying to figure out how to talk about it.
[1:48:38] And this was 2020. We were talking about in a very
[1:48:40] different way. And, you know, several people
[1:48:43] said to me that was the best conversation I've ever heard
[1:48:45] about this topic ever. And I had to agree.
[1:48:49] Actually, I was really pleased with how it went.
[1:48:52] And you know, five years later, 5 1/2 years later, everybody's
[1:48:58] talking about this. Sasha has had her own podcast
[1:49:02] with Stella O'Malley, who's in in Ireland.
[1:49:04] She's now doing her own thing. She's a major voice in this
[1:49:08] issue and she remains very, very nuanced.
[1:49:13] Lisa Sellen Davis is somebody also I have on a lot and I
[1:49:16] really like the way she reports on this and talks about this.
[1:49:19] But there are so many people who have just veered into the like,
[1:49:25] oh, this is all, you know, they're all mutilating
[1:49:29] themselves. They're all crazy.
[1:49:31] You know, just let's no, no sympathies should be extended.
[1:49:35] You know, we've got Matt Walsh who makes very funny
[1:49:37] documentaries. I really enjoyed this
[1:49:39] documentary about this. But that's not winning over the
[1:49:43] people that we need to win over. It's not winning over the nice
[1:49:47] Volvo driving progressives. And those are the people who
[1:49:51] need to hear this. It's not the people on the
[1:49:53] right, it's the people on the left.
[1:49:56] And so I keep talking about it because I really want to reach
[1:50:02] those people. I want to do the conversation in
[1:50:04] a way that they will feel comfortable sharing with their
[1:50:07] friends. So yeah, do you think you're
[1:50:12] being optimistic? Do you think there is a pulling
[1:50:13] them? Out with a podcast and with a
[1:50:15] reason. I think there is.
[1:50:17] It's already starting to happen. People are realizing that this
[1:50:20] is. Not right.
[1:50:22] They just didn't, they didn't know like you, you know, you
[1:50:25] would say things like the the whole phenomenon of AGP, which
[1:50:28] again, I know that's how we don't get demonetized.
[1:50:30] We're talking about this is autogonophilia.
[1:50:32] This is a certain typology of a trans identification.
[1:50:35] It's not everybody, it's not the kids, but it's a certain type of
[1:50:40] male who is aroused by the idea of himself as a female.
[1:50:44] Typically those have been the kind of middle-aged
[1:50:46] crossdressers that we would see. Again, that's not all of them,
[1:50:50] but it's a, it's a significant percentage.
[1:50:52] And a lot of the trans activism is dominated by men in that
[1:50:57] subset, and they're very aggressive and they're very
[1:51:00] stereotypically male. Ironically, it's a movement that
[1:51:05] is being dominated by pretty aggressive male voices, which is
[1:51:09] why you get a lot of very angry feminists who I think in a lot
[1:51:13] of ways take it too far. But I understand what they're
[1:51:15] reacting to, just the existence of that phenomenon.
[1:51:19] It needs to be articulated in a way that people can understand
[1:51:22] because otherwise they just think all these kids just want
[1:51:25] to be themselves. They just want to be who they
[1:51:27] are. They're just like gay kids.
[1:51:29] And it's like, no, that's actually not what is going on.
[1:51:34] It is a homophobic movement. It is a movement that
[1:51:37] perpetuates the. Very gender.
[1:51:38] Stereotypes that the second wife.
[1:51:40] Feminists fought against and so that's why it's so fascinating.
[1:51:45] And, and I just think that any opportunity to talk about it
[1:51:49] responsibly and with great nuance needs to be taken
[1:51:54] advantage of. Well, I want to push you on this
[1:51:57] mostly for my own benefit of working this out.
[1:52:00] It does perpetuate stereotypes that we're far beyond, but
[1:52:05] that's part of buying into this kind of.
[1:52:09] Vibe idea. And I'll use your preferred
[1:52:12] preferred pronouns idea. I just don't see any escaping
[1:52:16] the fact that you either buy into the stereotypes or you
[1:52:20] don't use preferred pronouns. Back to the pronoun question
[1:52:26] again, I don't know. I don't know how to answer that.
[1:52:29] I guess at this point I feel like if I refuse to use
[1:52:33] pronouns, I would alienate enough people that it would it
[1:52:38] would dilute what I'm trying to do.
[1:52:41] And again, that is a compromise that is not intellectually
[1:52:45] honest. But I don't if I, if I just
[1:52:52] refuse to use anybody's pronouns.
[1:52:54] I just think that I just don't know what the point of that
[1:52:56] would be. I want to say, I want to, I want
[1:52:59] to say what I have to say and I think it would undermine my
[1:53:02] credibility a lot. A whole lot of turfs think I've
[1:53:05] already done that because I I kowtow to some of this and I've
[1:53:09] said this before, you know, are there are there some does does
[1:53:14] true trans exist? That's a question, right?
[1:53:18] I don't know the answer. I tend to think it does not.
[1:53:24] I also know people who transitioned as children began
[1:53:30] that process and appeared to be thriving, so I don't know what
[1:53:35] to do with that information. Clarify for me what you mean by
[1:53:37] true trans it is. Is it possible to actually be
[1:53:40] quote UN quote? Born in the wrong body.
[1:53:42] That's how we used to. Frame it right.
[1:53:44] Can you be true trans? Can you have a female brain in a
[1:53:48] male body? I guess that would be the
[1:53:51] definition of true trans. I suppose it depends on what you
[1:53:55] mean by wrong exactly. So you know, I had a guest on my
[1:54:00] show once. This was an anonymous guest,
[1:54:03] this was a detransitioner, A biological male, and he gave the
[1:54:07] best definition of trans that I'd ever heard.
[1:54:10] And he said if you you're trans, if transitioning makes you
[1:54:17] happier and keeps you happier, then you're trans.
[1:54:23] So in so far as there are people who have.
[1:54:26] Transitioned who? Are happier, OK, but I don't
[1:54:31] think you can look I know you cannot look at a 2 year old and
[1:54:36] say that is a transgender child. No, when can you?
[1:54:43] I mean, people would say there's no such.
[1:54:44] Thing as a trans child I. Guess if you're going to follow
[1:54:50] that logic. I guess if you're an adult.
[1:54:53] And you make the decision. On your own and you transition
[1:54:55] and you're happier, then you're then you're trans.
[1:54:59] But then you get into this passing problem.
[1:55:00] I mean, the whole, the only reason childhood transition came
[1:55:03] about was because people who were older and transitioned
[1:55:07] couldn't pass as well. And so they wanted to extend
[1:55:11] this opportunity to to children. I mean, that's what the Dutch
[1:55:15] protocol was all about. So this again, it all comes
[1:55:17] back. It all comes down to passing and
[1:55:20] that, you know, yeah, it would suck.
[1:55:23] It would really suck if you were coming into puberty and not the
[1:55:27] body that you want and profoundly not the body you
[1:55:30] want. Not just like, I don't like
[1:55:32] puberty, which most people don't.
[1:55:33] I think that would be horrible. But the number of people that
[1:55:39] we're seeing that think that they are truly, truly going into
[1:55:43] puberty in the wrong body, that just that's doesn't line up with
[1:55:46] any kind of like, you know, biological statistical
[1:55:50] probability. What do you see as the way
[1:55:54] forward for Gen. Z all of these issues?
[1:55:57] Seems to be some overarching things.
[1:56:00] Identity, social media, selling hysteria.
[1:56:05] Where do we go in the next couple of decades?
[1:56:07] I think Gen. Z is pretty good about saying
[1:56:10] you know. This was the sort of like post
[1:56:16] 60s liberal project. These are the.
[1:56:19] Parts of it that worked and. There are parts of it that did
[1:56:21] not, that simply did not work. I think they're saying like, you
[1:56:26] know, we were, we, we were sold this idea that women should be
[1:56:30] in the workplace in the same way that men are, that you can raise
[1:56:35] a family with. Two working.
[1:56:37] Parents that that was by definition better because it was
[1:56:42] more equal. Sometimes it's better.
[1:56:43] Of course it's better for some families, but it's not always.
[1:56:47] I think that there's a critique of of sort of baby boomer era
[1:56:54] liberalism and progressivism that is very worthwhile.
[1:57:00] I just think that they need to make sure to do it in a
[1:57:04] responsible way and actually do it with logic and conversation
[1:57:07] and not memes. I know I sound like a scold.
[1:57:10] I'm a, you know, I'm really into respectability politics.
[1:57:13] I really AM. And I talk about it a lot in my
[1:57:15] book The problem with Everything.
[1:57:18] But I think how you comport yourself is huge.
[1:57:22] Don't do yourself the disservice of coming across like an
[1:57:26] unserious person, like be the adult in the room.
[1:57:29] So much of what's happened is that the adults left the room.
[1:57:33] The whole wokeness project is because they're the adults left.
[1:57:36] The people running the New York Times were suddenly the
[1:57:39] children, the the teenagers and the adults were like, Oh my God,
[1:57:43] I don't want to get cancelled, so I'm not going to participate
[1:57:45] in this. I got to retire.
[1:57:46] I got to hobble through the next 10 years, pay my kids college
[1:57:50] tuition, pay off my mortgage, and then I'm out of here.
[1:57:53] So they just ceded all authority to people whose brains just
[1:57:59] weren't all the way developed, right?
[1:58:01] Their brains were. So their minds were so open that
[1:58:03] their brains were falling out, right?
[1:58:05] So I would look to Gen. Z to kind of be the adult,
[1:58:10] actually, to go back like, what is an adult?
[1:58:13] It got very out of fashion. You know, the Boomers hated
[1:58:16] being adults. That's why all the adult men
[1:58:18] were like backwards baseball caps all the time.
[1:58:21] They wanted to not be the man, right?
[1:58:23] They wanted to be cool. And I think there you had a lot
[1:58:27] of people get going well into middle age, still identifying as
[1:58:32] the teenager because they were used to being in opposition to
[1:58:35] some kind of authority. But I think that Gen.
[1:58:38] Z is in a unique position to say like, oh, actually we're going
[1:58:41] to be the adults. It's cool to be the adults.
[1:58:45] There's so many questions to ask you from that.
[1:58:48] And I also want to pick you up on your.
[1:58:49] Liberalism point and ask you about the link between feminism
[1:58:54] and the progression of feminism and female unhappiness.
[1:58:58] But we'll do that over on sub stack.
[1:59:00] So OK, Megan, thank you so much for coming on the show.
[1:59:02] I'm resisting saying your surname because I see every
[1:59:05] single podcast to make this point as that opening question
[1:59:07] and they're like, oh, tell me about the history of your name.
[1:59:09] Is it down? Is it dorm?
[1:59:12] And I know. Oh yeah, this is the whole thing
[1:59:14] I keep. I keep changing it.
[1:59:16] You can. I don't know.
[1:59:17] You can say either say Megan, Megan, I'm just going to I'm
[1:59:20] going to be like a one name person, like share or.
[1:59:23] Something like. That Yeah, your preferred your
[1:59:25] preferred name and pronouns, Yes.
[1:59:27] Where can people find more of your work?
[1:59:29] Oh my gosh too. Many places I'm on sub stack the
[1:59:33] my podcast is. Now called the Unspeak.
[1:59:35] Easy and they can go to they can look up the Unspeak easy, they
[1:59:39] can go to megandown.substack.com to find me or just the
[1:59:44] Unspeakable podcast, which is the previous name of it.
[1:59:48] Go to megandown.com to learn about my books.
[1:59:52] The Unspeak easy.com is my Unspeak easy project.
[1:59:56] And I don't know, just Google me and all kinds of horrible things
[1:59:59] will come up and have Nova sub stack where Megan will answer
[2:00:03] your questions. See you there.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
