# Psychotherapist: The Real Reason Young People Are ‘Mentally Ill’ - Stella O’Malley | #55

An episode of [The Next Generation](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1772698742), 14 Nov 2025, 1 h 11 min.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/107851968/podcast/play/111069365/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2025-10-12%2F412331510-44100-2-b287ceffa1fca.mp3

I was so excited to speak to psychotherapist Stella O'Malley, who I’ve followed for years now. She believes trans-identification is a mental health issue, and provides psychological support to many with gender dysphoria, as well as detransitioners. Some of what she told me was shocking, and some of it made so much sense once explained. Check out the chapters below to see the kind of wild stuff we covered! As well as her extensive work in private practice, Stella is a best-selling author, having written five books on parenting, mental health and gender dysphoria. She is also the founder of ‘Genspect’, an international organisation that advocates for a healthy approach to sex and gender. Subscribe to my Substack to see the bonus questions and send in your own for future guests! https://elliotbewick.substack.com/ Stella’s website: https://www.stellaomalley.com/ Genspect: https://genspect.org/ CHAPTERS 00:00 Why transitioning is evidence of mental illness 06:58 How medical transition harms the body 13:40 Suicidality increases after medical transition 15:00 Why are so many trans-identifying people autistic? 19:23 ‘If I’m not happy all the time, something is wrong’ 28:57 Stella’s personal experience of gender dysphoria 35:11 “My Sexual awakening released me from gender dysphoria” 42:01 What would have happened to you if you’d grown up in this era? 45:18 Where did the therapy industry go wrong? 55:57 Online therapy is a sh*t show 59:11 The concept of ‘professional deformation’ 1:00:49 Technology is robbing Gen Z and future generations 1:10:22 The huge rise in autism diagnoses My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotbewick/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliotbewick X: https://x.com/elliotbewick ABOUT THE NEXT GENERATION: In a world saturated by social media and marked by skyrocketing rates of anxiety, depression, and ADHD among Gen Z, young people are growing up in a landscape of chaos and contradiction. While protests swell in city streets and activists hurl soup at famous artworks to demand climate action, a quieter crisis unfolds within - the mental and emotional battles faced by a generation trying to make sense of it all. The Next Generation is hosted by 20-year-old Elliot Bewick, offering a raw and honest look at the world through the eyes of those living in it. Bringing together insight from professionals and young people on the ground, this podcast isn’t here to complain or chase clout. It’s here to bend the arc of the modern world towards solutions, truth and a love for the beautiful adventure of life itself.

## Transcript

[0:00] You're an established psychotherapist and a lot of the
[0:03] conclusions from your lifelong work have led you to be hesitant
[0:08] of the over pathologization of Gen.
[0:10] Z. You've recently been pushing for
[0:13] the re psychopathologization of trans.
[0:17] Can you unpack this for me? I have no idea what's going on
[0:19] here, it's all very confusing. Good question.
[0:23] Yeah, I suppose I've spent my life's work, you know,
[0:27] criticizing the overpathologization of so many
[0:32] common challenges. And I, I do lean into it a lot.
[0:36] And I, I, I don't intend to lean away from it.
[0:39] I think it's true that people have been overdiagnosed, over
[0:42] medicalized, over categorized, especially your generation,
[0:46] especially young people. And I think it does shape
[0:49] people's life concept, their self concept and who they are at
[0:53] a very young age. Like I, I'd have kids coming to
[0:55] me like only recently, you know, and they would have been
[0:58] diagnosed with maybe ADHD, autism and then say, Oh no, that
[1:04] was a misdiagnosis. And I'm actually anxious.
[1:07] It's generalized anxiety disorder.
[1:09] I'm like, wow, they're 20 and they've had three life defining
[1:13] diagnosis and each time they're changing their self concepts.
[1:17] So I, I think it's not only misdiagnosis, it's over
[1:20] diagnosis. So I think it's a, it's a huge
[1:23] issue. However, there is another
[1:25] parallel issue going on and I, I inadvertently have got myself
[1:29] caught up in the entire trans phenomenon.
[1:31] I certainly didn't intend to. I've been a general
[1:34] psychotherapist for 20 odd years and umm, because of a few twists
[1:40] and turns, I ended up speaking a lot about trans and gender
[1:45] dysphoria. And I'm like, well, when it
[1:48] actually is pathological behaviour, I would like to be
[1:51] able to say that's pathological. It's like, you know, the boy who
[1:55] cried wolf insofar as like if everything is being diagnosed,
[1:59] we can't figure out well what is actually very serious behaviour.
[2:03] So there's a big difference. For example, somebody who's a
[2:05] Dieter, somebody who's an extreme Dieter and has kind of
[2:08] lost their way a bit, and somebody who's been hospitalized
[2:11] for anorexia. These are, you know, three
[2:13] different stages of quite a significant, umm condition.
[2:18] And anybody know who knows somebody who's been hospitalized
[2:22] for anorexia would know it is really difficult working with
[2:26] that person. I would say the same for the
[2:28] transphenomenon. Some people dabble and they
[2:31] might be non binary and they're having a bit of a laugh,
[2:33] frankly. Some people are really wrapped
[2:35] up in it and they're losing their way and they're becoming
[2:37] quite confused and they're frankly, they're walking along
[2:40] the edge of a Cliff face that they could fall into.
[2:44] And some people are actually having mastectomies, having
[2:48] phalloplasties, having vaginoplasties, having their
[2:51] penis removed. And that's pathological
[2:53] behaviour. It needs to be able to.
[2:54] We need to live in a world that can define these three different
[2:58] stages. So while it might seem
[3:00] contradictory, it's completely, completely coherent.
[3:04] Thank you very much. Well.
[3:07] Laid out for me a little bit more because I feel like we
[3:09] still haven't actually classified at what point it gets
[3:13] to a pathology. And I need to make sure that I
[3:16] don't just wholeheartedly agree with you the whole time because
[3:18] I do and I want to voice my concerns on behalf of other
[3:23] people. Who's to say the mutilating your
[3:27] genitals? Or perhaps let's not use that
[3:29] word, Let's use something else that others would use that
[3:31] disagree with you. Chopping off your genitals isn't
[3:36] the same as extreme cases of people loving tattoos and
[3:43] filling up their body and altering it.
[3:45] These different body modifications and ear piercings
[3:48] that kind of stretch your earlobes.
[3:50] It might seem really trivial, but where is the line here?
[3:55] And importantly, how do we make sure that we're not also
[3:58] encroaching on people's freedom and agency by doing the very
[4:02] thing you've fought against your whole career of over over
[4:04] pathologizing? Got it.
[4:07] There's a few things in that and for starters, I welcome robust
[4:11] criticism. So that will be enjoyable for
[4:14] me, that part. But I think we have to be able,
[4:20] I'm a clinician, so I have to be able to say, and now you're
[4:24] going into a new category. Now you're going into, there's
[4:27] different phases of any sort of behaviour.
[4:31] And so somebody, for example, let's first of all do tattoos
[4:34] and don't body modifications and then go into how gender could
[4:37] work that way. So somebody who's getting
[4:40] tattoos and we've seen it, you know what I mean?
[4:42] We've seen people who are getting tattoos and they get
[4:43] their sleeve and they get their tattoos.
[4:45] And you're kind of thinking, yeah, yeah.
[4:48] Umm, fine, knock yourself out free world.
[4:51] And then they've got tattoos all over their face and you're like,
[4:54] OK, that's that's really quite extreme behaviour.
[4:56] And you're arguably, you're arguably fixating on something
[5:01] there if you follow me. And if you are going to the
[5:05] point that you were, you know, putting yourself into penury
[5:09] just to pay for tattoos that you needed to do, I'd be like, yeah,
[5:13] you've lost it. You've lost it.
[5:14] You've, you've lost whatever thread you had, you've lost it.
[5:18] So the, the rule of thumb has always been if you're harming
[5:21] yourself or if you're harming other people, then there's an
[5:25] issue. It's the same with alcoholism.
[5:26] It's the same with anorexia. It's the same with almost any
[5:29] behaviour that that's the easy, umm, way to kind of define.
[5:36] Have we got problematic behaviour here or is it just
[5:39] free will? You know, you're free to do
[5:41] whatever you want. So with somebody with gender
[5:44] dysphoria, you'd start with, OK, you, you want to be a boy.
[5:49] I had my own experiences as a kid.
[5:50] I'd be very sympathetic to it. You want to dress as a boy, You
[5:53] might want to have mannerisms as a boy, whatever that means in
[5:56] their own mind. Free as you go, you know what I
[5:59] mean? Wear boys clothes, you know,
[6:02] spread your legs, talk like a bloke.
[6:05] No act like a truck or whatever you want.
[6:07] I take no issue. Umm, when you're changing your
[6:10] name and pronouns, cool, knock yourself out.
[6:13] However, compelling other people to use different pronouns, I
[6:17] would say is quite controlling behaviour and is now kind of now
[6:21] moving into something a different realm because who am I
[6:25] to kind of tell you how to speak about me?
[6:27] So there's a, there's a certain kind of control aspect that I'd
[6:30] be, I would be certainly exploring.
[6:32] But when you've moved into, and now I'm taking hormones to
[6:36] change my face and my body. And those hormones are without a
[6:40] doubt, because we have the evidence going to, to harm my
[6:44] body. You're now harming yourself.
[6:46] So remember I said that the kind of rule of thumb is, is it
[6:48] harmful to you or is it harmful to other people?
[6:50] The same with alcoholism. You're having a great time,
[6:53] you're out party and it's great fun when it's moving into you're
[6:57] harming yourself. Well, how is it harming your
[6:59] body? For anyone that's looking to
[7:01] take hormones. Well, testosterone has been
[7:04] shown to cause quite severe, you know, very severe body harm.
[7:10] For example, is, is it's quite graphic, but it enlarges your
[7:15] clitoris. So at the start, the first few
[7:18] years of testosterone is frankly amazing for females.
[7:23] It's very like cocaine because you feel much stronger, you are
[7:27] much stronger. Your body has been masculinized,
[7:29] so you're growing muscles, you've much more energy.
[7:32] I work a lot with trans identified people and
[7:36] detransitionists so I I know an awful lot of kind of actual on
[7:40] the ground, not just the research.
[7:41] You feel stronger, you feel full of energy.
[7:44] You also feel a very increased libido.
[7:47] So your, your, your sex energy is way up.
[7:51] But because of the, uh, the clitters being enlarged
[7:56] continuously, sex becomes really painful.
[7:59] So the actual, so it's, it's like some sort of weird type
[8:01] Chinese torture. But yeah, because it's the
[8:05] start, it's great. You're having great sex and
[8:07] you're turned on and it's amazing a few years in and it
[8:10] takes a few years. It's too painful to have an
[8:13] orgasm. It's, it's awful.
[8:15] So it's, that's particularly difficult.
[8:17] There's an awful lot of urinary infections, an awful lot of
[8:20] vaginal infections, an awful lot of pain in your bones.
[8:24] It's about 3-4, five years in. It doesn't happen immediately.
[8:28] And so we're talking about osteoporosis first of all,
[8:32] osteopenia and then osteoporosis and then a lot of cardiac
[8:37] problems. There's an awful lot of heart
[8:41] complications. When you get deep into it,
[8:44] you'll ultimately about five years in you, you either have to
[8:48] have a hysterectomy or you will have an awful lot of problems
[8:52] around your reproductive system. So it's not minor these
[8:56] problems. And how common are they?
[8:58] Well, pretty much across the board you're putting, you're
[9:02] putting diesel into a petrol tank.
[9:04] Some people it's not as bad. There's death.
[9:06] There's always going to be exceptions to the rule.
[9:08] So there's definitely going to be some people who say I've been
[9:10] taking testosterone for 20 years and it's fine, but they are
[9:13] exceptions to the rule. The vast majority of females who
[9:17] take testosterone will have a lot of problems with the
[9:20] reproductive system centered around the vagina.
[9:24] Well, I'm looking at this and you're putting diesel into a
[9:27] petrol car. It's not going to end well, yet
[9:32] people are still being allowed and perhaps even encouraged to
[9:36] do it. So either you're lying and
[9:39] you're wrong and those people that are fine aren't the
[9:42] exception, or there's something pretty weird and twisted going
[9:46] on here. Oh, I think there is something
[9:49] very, very dark going on here. I I think it will take different
[9:55] people, different levels of time.
[9:57] I want, I want to qualify what I said because I want to be
[9:59] strictly accurate. So I'm going to make an analogy
[10:03] because it's easy and it makes the point some people would come
[10:08] into alcoholism, it would take many years before alcohol would
[10:11] kick in, if you follow me, that it would.
[10:13] Some people get drunk on one pint, some people get drunk on 8
[10:16] pints. So some people take testosterone
[10:18] and it it's amazing how fast it impacts their body that they're
[10:22] losing their voice, you know, and becoming a male voice within
[10:27] perhaps three months. But somebody else they could
[10:31] take for 12 months and their voices change.
[10:33] So it definitely depends on the person.
[10:35] Therefore the pain and the the the pain on intercourse, the
[10:39] pain on orgasm, the infertility, the heart complications could
[10:44] take a lot longer. It might be 8 years for one
[10:46] person, it might be 3 years for something.
[10:47] It's definitely very individual. So yeah, the pain and the
[10:52] problems come, but when do they come as up to the person?
[10:56] I, I, I couldn't give a, a, a very definitive answer on that.
[11:00] But yeah, I do think that there has been a massive celebration
[11:04] of medical transition with, uh, an absolute disregard of the
[11:10] problems that have been caused. And I, I, I, I work, I, you
[11:14] know, run an organization called Genspect and we offer different
[11:19] open online meetings every week. So every Saturday I'd have an
[11:23] open meeting. And that would be people who
[11:25] have identified as trans, people who've medicalised, people who
[11:28] regret their medicalisation and people who detransition.
[11:32] And they all come into the meetings and they're lovely
[11:33] meetings because it's all sides of the aisle and they swap their
[11:38] stories and the grand plan. I'm just the facilitator.
[11:41] I'm a psychotherapist and, uh, the ground plan is they will
[11:45] learn from each other and they do learn from each other.
[11:48] And the people who identify as trans quite quickly say, yeah,
[11:52] I'm not going to medicalize because they just hear the
[11:56] incontinence. Urinary incontinence is really,
[11:58] really common. They hear the hysterectomies,
[12:01] they hear the, the problems with the mastectomies.
[12:04] They hear, you know, the, the extraordinary litany are
[12:08] painful. I remember one person coming in
[12:11] saying I basically had a urinary infection over the last three
[12:14] years. It's hell.
[12:15] So it like, you know, there is a lot of pain being caused, but it
[12:20] doesn't happen immediately. So that's why we're on the on
[12:24] the cusp of, of hearing a lot of these stories.
[12:27] And certainly when I started following D trans Reddit.
[12:29] And anybody who wants to know about it should read up on D
[12:33] trans Reddit. It was in 2019 that there was
[12:35] less than 1000 members. Now there's over 55,000 members
[12:38] on that. And just take 10 minutes and
[12:41] read the transit. And it's not all people like who
[12:44] are detransition. There's about 1/3 of the numbers
[12:46] would be people like me who are just reading them.
[12:49] But you learn a lot about it was great for the first few years
[12:53] and then it wasn't. Then it became actually hellish.
[12:56] Well, what really angers me time and time again, going down these
[13:00] rabbit holes, interviewing different people about this.
[13:03] I spoke to Jana Moncrief, who's one of the lead researchers on
[13:06] the impact of serotonin and depression.
[13:09] And it breaks my heart seeing people that have normal
[13:13] reactions to an adverse set of situations and circumstances
[13:17] being told they're broken and need to be fixed.
[13:21] And the very thing that they're told is going to fix them is
[13:25] what breaks them and takes them down this dark path.
[13:29] To talk to me about some of those circumstantial factors
[13:32] that actually play into gender dysphoria, things like autism,
[13:38] childhood experiences. Yeah, I just want to say on your
[13:42] point, it's such a good point that when you think the solution
[13:45] hasn't worked for you. So imagine if you're distressed
[13:50] and you have something like childhood under onset gender
[13:52] dysphoria. You you're a bird girl and you
[13:54] want to be a boy. You've wanted to be a boy for
[13:56] many years. And people tell you the solution
[13:58] is to medically transition. And you follow the solution.
[14:01] When the solution doesn't work, the despair that you feel
[14:05] because you feel I'm the freak. I'm the one that it doesn't work
[14:09] for. There's something wrong with me.
[14:12] Yeah. And that's when you know the the
[14:14] facts of the matter. Is that the escalation of
[14:17] suicide seems to happen post medical transition.
[14:21] And I can see why because I think the solution didn't work.
[14:24] Well, now I'm out. It's it's it's frightening.
[14:27] So like, you know, post met, there's very little stats.
[14:30] So I don't like looking at too much on the stats, but
[14:33] consistently, about 8 to 10 years after medical transition,
[14:39] the likelihood of suicide is escalated.
[14:43] And it's something that clinicians need to be aware of.
[14:45] And why wouldn't it be? Because the solution has turned
[14:48] into a painful, awfully difficult challenge, a medical
[14:53] challenge. A consistent kind of list of
[14:56] different medical challenges are coming in the door and you're
[14:59] thinking, this is awful. But yeah, the, the, the factors
[15:02] that would lead somebody to medically transition, autism is
[15:07] a big one. Umm, this is, you know, these
[15:10] are people, autistic people very often are non conforming and
[15:14] they're not only gender non conforming, they're non
[15:16] conforming and lots of things, but they also like frameworks.
[15:20] So it's that kind of contradiction.
[15:22] So they might like be gender non conforming because everything is
[15:27] logical and everything needs to make sense.
[15:29] So I, I want to wear these trousers because these are the
[15:31] comfortable ones and I have sensory processing issues.
[15:34] And so this is the only top I'm going to use.
[15:36] And the fact that it's pink or blue or whatever is kind of
[15:40] irrelevant because it's all about the, the texture of the
[15:42] top. And so a lot of children who are
[15:46] autistic, they might, uh, there might be non conforming as far
[15:50] as, let's say a little boy might wear a pink satin top or a
[15:54] particular top because that's what he likes.
[15:57] But then they're rigid and inflexible and that's the top
[16:00] they always want to like wear. And then they could end up being
[16:04] considered gender non conforming because of the sensory point.
[16:08] But yeah, there is a notable correlation between people who
[16:11] are autistic and people who are gender non conforming.
[16:13] They seem to be quite commonly together.
[16:17] On top of that, you have the autistic mind likes frameworks
[16:22] and I believe that the LGBTQ framework as it is now is very
[16:28] autistic. It's like, first do this, then
[16:31] you do that, then you do the other.
[16:32] It's offering you this very clear path, which is frankly, I
[16:36] think a, a false promise because life is rarely so clear.
[16:40] But first you, you know, change your name, change your pronouns,
[16:43] make everybody else change your name and pronouns and speak in
[16:46] the way that you want to. The autistic mind likes that.
[16:49] They've often been called, you know, society's policemen.
[16:52] They like to say, this is what you have to do and this is how
[16:54] you have to do it. And then you medicalize.
[16:57] First of all, you take hormones. Then you might get a mastectomy
[17:00] in a female case. Then you might get phalloplasty.
[17:03] And you're on a path. And the, that is very, very
[17:08] alluring to somebody that you know, that distressed feeling
[17:12] you have inside and you know, the feeling of being lost and
[17:15] lonely and you don't know who you are and you feel unhappy a
[17:18] lot of the time. Well, there's a reason.
[17:20] It's because you've been born in the wrong body.
[17:22] And what you need to do is change your body, change your
[17:25] pronouns, change your name. And one day you will be
[17:30] integrated. You will be a boy.
[17:32] You might be like that boy that you follow on YouTube and the
[17:36] promise, the inherent promises, and then you'll be happy.
[17:39] And that's what I Rage Against because actually there's no,
[17:43] there's no grand Gold Cup of happiness at the end of this.
[17:47] You're you're still there's a great book, you know, by John
[17:49] Cabot's in is the grandfather of mindfulness.
[17:51] And he says wherever you go, there you are.
[17:54] And you, you can't get away from yourself.
[17:56] So you make all of these changes.
[17:58] You do all the changes. You, you follow the framework
[18:02] and you end up with your phalloplasty and your mastectomy
[18:04] and you're fully masculinized body.
[18:06] You've got hair in your, you know, you have a beard, maybe
[18:09] hair in your chest, hair in your body.
[18:12] And you're like, and I still wake up insecure and I still
[18:15] wake up lonely and isolated and I still feel neurotic a lot of
[18:19] the time. I'm still myself.
[18:22] I didn't manage to get away from myself.
[18:24] That is dreadfully frightening for somebody.
[18:29] They did it all. And that's, you can see why
[18:31] there'd be an escalation of suicide at that point because
[18:33] they think it didn't work. There's something wrong with me.
[18:36] And so I want to jump in and the false promise of that and say,
[18:40] hang on. That's the human condition, you
[18:43] know, feeling insecure, neurotic, confused, unsure.
[18:48] Glimpses of happiness, glimpses of satisfaction, glimpses of of
[18:52] real joy mixed in with an awful lot of worry, tension,
[18:57] irritability, neurosis. That's being human.
[19:01] That's actually kind of what we're stuck with.
[19:03] That's where all the great art comes from.
[19:05] That's where all the poetry comes from, the music, the
[19:07] literature. It's part of the human
[19:09] condition. And I think we've missed it.
[19:10] And I think your generation in particular have been sold a
[19:14] false promise that policies need to be brought into place,
[19:17] treatments need to be brought into place, diagnosis need to be
[19:20] brought in when you feel like that.
[19:22] And I'm like, no, that's being human.
[19:24] Yeah, well, I'm so curious about this point of the endless
[19:27] pursuit of happiness and identity.
[19:30] And you refer to Trans as a Canary in the coal mine for
[19:32] these other issues going on with Gen.
[19:34] Z mental health. And I'm always very cognizant of
[19:36] not over prioritizing trans stuff on my channel for clicks
[19:40] and views, although it is important and the consequences
[19:44] of trans ideology are shocking. I think there are other things
[19:48] that deserve talking about too. But the Canary in the coal mine
[19:52] thing, it takes us on to this kind of perpetual gamifying
[19:58] approach almost to identity, where there is this end goal,
[20:03] there is this Valhalla of identity that we're constantly
[20:06] striving towards. And I don't think that would be
[20:09] possible a few decades ago before I was born.
[20:12] Whereas now when we're so chronically online and
[20:15] everything is a status competition and it's all
[20:18] outwards facing rather than becoming comfortable with within
[20:22] yourself. Of course, when you give people
[20:25] this clear autistic path that they can take with a promise at
[20:29] the end of it of winning, they're going to take it.
[20:32] Yeah, well, it's so alluring. Life is so great.
[20:36] Like we don't know what we're doing.
[20:38] You don't know what you're going to be doing next week.
[20:40] I don't know what we're doing. Which is frustrating.
[20:42] I want to know. Brain damaging.
[20:44] It's really difficult. The the uncertainty of life is,
[20:48] is what we're all grappling with all the time.
[20:50] We don't know where we've come from.
[20:51] I don't know who I was before I was in my mother's womb.
[20:54] I don't know where I'm going. I don't know where I'm going
[20:56] when I die. None of us do.
[20:58] There's all sorts of theories and we don't even know what's
[21:01] going to happen tomorrow. We, it's very hard to plan life.
[21:04] You can have your plans, but God bless you.
[21:06] Like I don't believe in God, but like, you know, life gets in the
[21:10] way. And so I think you're right.
[21:12] Gamifying is what's happening here.
[21:14] The idea I'd start with trans and move on to other stuff.
[21:18] The idea that you can go from level 1 to level 2 to Level 3,
[21:21] then the jackpot, it's like, give it to me please.
[21:24] At at least there's something to follow and there's something at
[21:28] the end of it. And there is.
[21:30] That's the thing. There is a very definite level
[21:32] 1, level 2, Level 3, fully masculinized and that is very
[21:37] alluring. It also kicks the can down the
[21:39] road because you don't have to check in on your happiness
[21:42] because you're on a route, you're on a journey.
[21:44] And it's only at the very end that you say, well, have you?
[21:49] Have you made it? Have you got happiness?
[21:51] But by then you will almost undoubtedly the physical
[21:56] problems will be coming in. And so I meet them because I'm
[21:58] having these, by the way. So I started with my Saturday
[22:01] meetings as the open meetings. My Sunday meetings is just the
[22:04] detrans meetings. They're just detransitioners.
[22:07] Then have other meetings and Mondays and Tuesdays and stuff,
[22:10] which would be chill people who ident who transitioned as
[22:14] children because they're different than people who
[22:16] transitioned as adults. Yeah.
[22:17] So I've, I'm getting a huge range of quite high numbers of
[22:23] people I'm working with because these are all online groups if
[22:27] you follow me. And so I'm meeting a lot of
[22:29] different umm experiences And what a lot of them say by the
[22:34] time they've reached the end of the rainbow and they've got
[22:36] their phalloplasty, vaginoplasty, by then the
[22:39] medical complications have kicked in.
[22:41] And so then they think when I sort out this issue, they don't
[22:44] know that you're 1 of you're 1 of many, all of you have issues.
[22:48] They don't realise that until they commit to the groups.
[22:50] And you can see them looking around going, you have
[22:52] incontinence too. You have infections too.
[22:56] Oh my God, this is a thing. This isn't just my crappy body
[23:00] because they all think it's my crappy body.
[23:02] If it was all perfect. I just have this one problem and
[23:06] it's like, no, no, no. You know, it's actually, it's
[23:09] baked into the solution. So it's, it's, it's devastating
[23:14] for them to realize, no, it's not your body.
[23:18] You bought into a false promise, but it's also liberating because
[23:23] they're like, hang on a second. I was sold something here and it
[23:27] didn't work. Bush to continue.
[23:29] Joanna Moncrief. I think is is an amazing person.
[23:32] I think she's, you know what she's talking about, which is
[23:35] the over prescription of antidepressants and necessaries.
[23:40] I think it's really important that people understand trans is
[23:44] a Canary in the coal mine. Trans is just a reflection of an
[23:47] overdiagnosed, overprescribed culture.
[23:49] It's just the, the, the larger version of it, as in you change
[23:53] your body. But the idea is that if you
[23:58] aren't happy and if you're feeling there's something wrong
[24:02] with you, maybe your channel is anxiety, somebody else's channel
[24:06] is despair, somebody else's channel is my body.
[24:10] You know, it means some sort of body monomania about your body.
[24:14] It you choose your poison in light.
[24:16] So you know what I mean? One person might go for anxiety,
[24:18] somebody else might go for an obsession around their body.
[24:22] The point is, I suppose that that is part of life's
[24:28] challenge, and it's not really something that needs to have a
[24:34] prescription and a policy around us.
[24:36] We're selling young people, especially young people, because
[24:39] they they've been brought up in it, this idea that there's a
[24:43] solution to life. And, you know, Samuel Beck at
[24:46] the Playwright said that, you know, there's no, there's no
[24:48] solution to life. I think it's we're stuck at it.
[24:52] I think one of the biggest messages that Gen.
[24:55] Z need to hear is that it's not about the pursuit of happiness,
[24:59] it's about the happiness of pursuit.
[25:01] It's about being there in the moment and accepting the things
[25:05] that may come your way. One of my favorite bands, the
[25:07] real people who Oasis later ripped off and stole their music
[25:10] from, they sing about how they don't know their way.
[25:14] They know where they're going or where they're heading.
[25:18] And it's this idea where you don't know what path you're
[25:22] going to take directly. You may have an idea of the
[25:24] future and it's OK to have goals, but when you over index
[25:31] on wanting to know every step of the process and by the way, like
[25:34] I'm guilty of this all the time. I want to know exactly what's
[25:37] happening. You forget to actually live and
[25:41] that's so damaging. And you see this everywhere.
[25:44] There are so many different paths we can go down here and
[25:47] speak about, one of which is the self development cult, as I see
[25:52] it. And there's this paradox of self
[25:55] improvement that I see unfolding where people who want to improve
[25:59] their lives neglect living to optimize.
[26:04] And it's so sad. They look back a few years later
[26:06] and they go, oh, all I've done is cold plunges and no strips
[26:10] posted on my story to flex how optimized and robotic my life
[26:14] is. But it's like, do you really
[26:16] want to be prioritizing the most robotic efficient life possible?
[26:20] I don't think so. Yeah, I think it's so true.
[26:24] I think. And I, I, I'm cringing because
[26:27] I'm guilty of it and I've always been guilty of it.
[26:30] I'm like, the most guilty of it, yeah.
[26:32] I know it well. You don't need to stress.
[26:34] It yeah. And it you you, you know, you
[26:39] know that line, you know, a man comes to the end of his life and
[26:42] he thinks, oh Lord, if I could live my life over.
[26:45] And then he fell dead. You know, I I kind of I worry
[26:49] that a lot of us who. Who I keep on thinking, I'll
[26:53] just get this one done. I'll just do this, I'll just get
[26:55] this one. I'll just, I, you know, I
[26:57] totally buy it. But like, let's say an awful lot
[27:00] of people think I just get through school, I'll get good
[27:03] results and I'll get to college and then I'll be able to start
[27:05] living. You know, once I get the
[27:06] qualifications, then I'll start being able to, or once I get the
[27:09] career I want, then I'll start living.
[27:11] Once I get, you know, the partner I want, then I'll start
[27:13] living. We keep on pushing it down, but
[27:15] it is the human condition to do that.
[27:18] You know, that's why we're not cows in the field just chewing
[27:20] the code that we, that's why we create great stuff.
[27:24] It doesn't make for happiness, but it does make for great
[27:27] productivity. You know, like beautiful
[27:29] buildings, you know, Saint Paul's Cathedral, like
[27:32] everything, kind of almost everything I'd say brilliant has
[27:37] been created through not happiness.
[27:41] If you follow me, it's not happiness that got us there.
[27:43] And the people who create less arguably would probably be
[27:47] happier in a way, if we can snatch kind of glimpses of
[27:52] happiness on our way. I like, I like that because
[27:55] that's all I seem to be able to do.
[27:57] And I've kind of made my peace with that.
[28:00] That's all fine. What what, what my issue is with
[28:03] is with this culture is we're, we're selling an idea that we
[28:10] need diagnosis around this and we need and something is wrong
[28:14] with you if you're like that. And I'm like, no, we're all like
[28:16] that. Look, look around you.
[28:18] Every one of us are always pushing happiness down the road.
[28:23] I I'm, yeah, I don't meet many people who could say that I'm
[28:26] waking up every day. I do think I'm kind of rambling
[28:29] here, but I do think some people have the gift of happiness and
[28:31] some people don't. I see it in my own kids, like my
[28:35] my son has a great welcome for himself, as they say, you know,
[28:39] he's just, he's very content in himself.
[28:41] Well, my daughter would be more like myself.
[28:42] Pushing, pushing, pushing, pushing forward different.
[28:46] You come out differently. And I would imagine you know
[28:50] somebody who's just more content in themselves, achieves less,
[28:53] but is happier depressive. You mentioned earlier that you
[28:59] had your own personal experiences with trans when you
[29:02] were younger. Perhaps before that was a term
[29:04] that was thrown around too much. Yeah, talk to me about that.
[29:07] Sure. Umm, like, yeah, trans was
[29:09] certainly not a term. In fact, they've, they've traced
[29:12] back the usage of that word. So, umm, when I was a kid, I was
[29:17] born in 1974. And so from the age of about
[29:20] three, I would have had what would be now considered severe
[29:23] gender dysphoria and the lasted many years.
[29:27] From three, yeah. Wow, so really well, actually
[29:31] now I know I did. I didn't know much about
[29:33] obviously then umm, but I've become an expert in this and
[29:37] yeah, it's, it's kind of classic.
[29:38] That would be around about 3 or 4 for childhood onset.
[29:42] There's different stages, but childhood onset, I was classic
[29:45] and it lasted many years. Now some lots of girls say, Oh
[29:49] yeah, I was a tomboy and I'm like, yeah, yeah, fine.
[29:53] OK. That mine was a much darker
[29:56] experience than that. You know, it was way beyond.
[29:58] I'm a tomboy. I certainly was a tomboy.
[30:01] And I liked that word because it's got Tom and it's good boy.
[30:05] So that suited me fine. I'll be a tomboy.
[30:07] By the way, there's no equivalent word for boys who are
[30:11] girlish. It would need to be something
[30:13] like Amy girl, like it would need to have the word girl, and
[30:16] it would need, yeah, there is all.
[30:17] There's no words. You just get called gay.
[30:20] Yeah, yeah, yeah, whatever. Yeah.
[30:25] And you know, statistically, actually feminine boys from want
[30:29] of a better phrase or much are about 8% of them, if not higher.
[30:33] 90% of some studies do end up being gay.
[30:36] So you could argue it's it's proto gay, However, that
[30:41] sexualizing an experience for a three-year old or a four year
[30:44] old, which is a bit weird. And I don't think we know how to
[30:47] navigate that fact that like 80%, I said 80 to 90 for boys,
[30:51] like it's higher for boys. It's more like 78 for girls of
[30:56] the kids who are gender non conforming, like I was, umm, end
[30:59] up being gay, lesbian or bisexual.
[31:01] So there's definitely a link and nobody has quite figured out
[31:04] what that is. There's different theories.
[31:06] Why are, you know, boyish girls and girlish boys, gay and
[31:11] lesbian? I, you know, the instinct is
[31:14] correct. Hmm.
[31:15] Do you have any ideas as to why? I do, I do.
[31:18] I'll first tell you what happened, my own experience, and
[31:20] then we'll go back to that. So yeah, it lasted many, many
[31:23] years and it was horrible. Actually, the first two years is
[31:25] fine because you're 3:00 and 4:00 and 5:00 and 6:00 and
[31:28] frankly you quite enjoy your power because you look people in
[31:31] the eye and like I'm a boy and they're like, I now know they
[31:34] were pandering to me. They were adults and older
[31:36] people. So it for them, it was playful.
[31:39] For me, it was dead. This year.
[31:40] I was a 5 year old who took myself very seriously.
[31:43] So for me it was deadly serious. But there comes a time in every
[31:47] child's life when they realize they grow up a little bit and
[31:50] you know, developmentally it was appropriate that by about 8
[31:54] you're moving out of make believe.
[31:55] You're moving out of believing inside, you're moving.
[31:57] But you know, and you're starting to realize the adults
[32:00] are are playing with me here. The part I thought I was, I did.
[32:04] I remember being aware of the power I had in the room when I'd
[32:08] say I was a boy and they test me and I knew they were testing me
[32:11] and I could beat the tests as such, that I really was a boy.
[32:15] How would they test you? I suppose I, I was, you know,
[32:19] the best fighter and I was, you could see it in their faces
[32:23] thinking she really pulls it off all the way.
[32:26] If you follow me. Umm, like in, in, in Ireland and
[32:29] schools back then, the girls wore kilts and the boys wore,
[32:34] you know, grey flannel trousers. And I was the only kid in the
[32:37] school who wore the only girl in the school who wore trousers and
[32:41] nobody made a policy around that.
[32:43] They just let the odd kid be odd.
[32:46] And it was odd. I remember somebody said, Jesus
[32:49] tell you were the strangest. And I was, and I, I didn't, I
[32:53] kind of enjoyed it for those years.
[32:55] I was cool, like, you know what I mean?
[32:57] I, it was fine because I was very young, but when you go into
[33:00] puberty, it was harrowing. It was horrible.
[33:04] It was a horrible, dark, really horrible experience of realizing
[33:10] I can will this all I want my mind over matter which I've been
[33:15] playing for many years. Nature is bigger than me.
[33:18] I don't know if you've ever experienced nearly drowning, but
[33:21] there comes a point when you're drowning if you're if you've
[33:24] kind of experienced, we realize, oh, this is so much bigger than
[33:29] me. The water's going over me and
[33:33] I'm way I'm a minnow to this. And that's how I experienced
[33:37] nature taken over my body because puberty was like, I can
[33:42] will this all I want. I can tell the whole class.
[33:45] I can tell all everybody who lives in my Rd.
[33:48] I'm a boy and then puberty has just taken my body.
[33:52] I felt, I remember I hated going to the toilet because I felt
[33:55] like I was going to grow an extra head every time hair was
[33:58] coming in and my body was just like, and I had no control.
[34:02] My mind over matter was an absolute failure and it was
[34:06] horrible, a horrible experience. Now imagine like obviously this
[34:11] was the mid 80s. Imagine that kid being told you
[34:14] can stop puberty. You know, you'd sail the seven
[34:17] seas in case stop it. Now I've been taken over by
[34:21] aliens. It was horrible.
[34:22] I'm laughing. But it was a really dark, dark,
[34:26] horrible time. You know what I mean?
[34:28] I was definitely highly suicidal and I was lost and lonely and
[34:33] very very isolated. Had no idea that this was a
[34:38] thing. If you follow me I'd know I'd
[34:40] I'd never heard of anything like childhood onset gender.
[34:43] This for you. Don't forget you're in 80s
[34:45] Dublin in a normal family. I was just an odd kid.
[34:48] It was just like, what's going down?
[34:51] It was awful, awful. However, I want to be very
[34:54] clear, the sexual awakening that took place, and sexual awakening
[34:58] takes place between the ages of 10 and 20 for humans.
[35:02] You know what I mean? It's a long awakening.
[35:03] For boys, it's much more definitive and it's much more
[35:06] direct and it's much more clear for girls.
[35:09] It's a much slower process, but the sexual awakening that took
[35:13] place because of puberty was what released me from my gender
[35:17] dysphoria. You fall in love.
[35:19] More importantly, people fall in love with you.
[35:22] If you follow me, People fell for me.
[35:24] They fancied me, and the result of that may their loving my body
[35:30] made me come to terms with my body.
[35:32] If you finally brought me around to who I was, and it was a very,
[35:39] it was a very important experience.
[35:40] It wasn't only that there was other parts of me.
[35:42] You know, you, you complexify between 10 and 20 because I now
[35:47] know the sexual awakening. It's not just sex.
[35:50] You're also awakening the instinct to pair bond, which is
[35:53] to kind of have a mate for life. And so all that loneliness that
[35:57] you experienced during adolescence also, you know, the,
[36:01] the music you love. Yeah.
[36:02] The literature, the films, the poetry, the art, all of that is
[36:06] part of that longing to find a mate.
[36:09] The falling in love, the connection, the loneliness is
[36:13] part of the pair bonding that you're seeking.
[36:16] All of that complexification is happening during adolescence.
[36:20] It has a point. That's such an important point
[36:23] as well. It's massive.
[36:26] And so if you block puberty, none of that is happening.
[36:30] So I know a man, James Linnean, he had an intersex condition,
[36:33] which is called a DSD, a difference of sexual, just just,
[36:37] you know, development, IE he was born with a condition that's,
[36:42] you know, that had something wrong with his reproductive
[36:44] system. So another person I was know was
[36:47] born without a womb and she has MRKH, which is one of those
[36:51] DSDS. Some people called them intersex
[36:53] conditions, some people called them DSDS.
[36:55] James Lynn had another intersex condition where he never went
[36:59] into puberty. So when he was 16, he said I was
[37:02] hanging around with the 10 year olds and I didn't care about my
[37:04] my mates who were all kind of eyeing each other up and go to
[37:08] the cinema and all that. He's like, I have more toys.
[37:11] He was childlike because he wasn't complexifying because he
[37:14] wasn't caring about loneliness or pair bonding or falling in
[37:18] love or any of his body was changing.
[37:21] So it's really important that people understand this is not
[37:24] just a sexual experience. It's a very complex, massive
[37:29] adulterifying experience so that you think, for example, for
[37:33] myself, I realize I need to up my game.
[37:36] Nobody's going to fancy me if I'm walking around like they're
[37:39] saying I'm going to punch you. You know what I mean?
[37:41] I realize I need to be attractive.
[37:44] I need to actually learn how to be attractive, which was a a
[37:47] massively difficult thing for me because I had completely bought
[37:50] into, I'm a boy and I'm tough. So how the hell am I going to
[37:54] move from that? It was a horrible prison that I
[37:56] found it very difficult to move out of.
[37:58] I'm tough and I'm a boy to I'm attractive and I'm a woman.
[38:03] It took years and it was a shit show and I'm not sure if I ever
[38:05] really, really pulled it off. I certainly never learned to
[38:08] flirt or anything like it. And I think it's very connected
[38:11] that I never learned to flirt. And of course I didn't.
[38:13] I was, I was in this weird self-made prison.
[38:18] The hell did I get over to the other side?
[38:20] So it wasn't just that I was falling for people and I was
[38:24] having extremely intense crushes that were blown my head off,
[38:29] which I think is actually very late because a lot of people
[38:31] with gender dysphoria has said they they had the same, that
[38:34] intensity and weird hyper focus. Hmm went from my body to them.
[38:38] And how the hell was any of them going to fancy me because I was
[38:41] walking around like an intimidating boy?
[38:44] Sorry I'm rambling, but yeah, it's huge.
[38:47] Experiences are happening between 10 and 20 and I don't
[38:50] think people quite realize when they're talking about puberty
[38:52] blockers. I've now set up in an
[38:54] organization that is pro and non medicalized approach to gender
[38:58] dysphoria. I've a lot of sympathy for
[39:00] people who have gender dysphoria.
[39:02] I think I had it myself. It wasn't called that at the
[39:05] time. It had a different name for the
[39:07] diagnosis. However, I don't think we should
[39:09] medicalize these things. I don't think we should stop
[39:12] puberty. Oh my God, I think that's a
[39:14] barbaric thing to do. And in England, you know,
[39:17] there's a £10,000,000 funded puberty trial about to start and
[39:21] it's going to be an absolute disaster for these kids because
[39:24] they will never experience a sexual awakening.
[39:27] What they will experience is the puberty will be blocked.
[39:30] They're going to be out of sync with their with their mates
[39:32] until they're about 18, depending on the age.
[39:35] Then they will have a synthetic sexual awakening, a chemical
[39:40] sexual awakening of the opposite sex.
[39:43] This won't be puberty because they're pretty reproductive
[39:46] system won't be awakened. It will be a chemical insurgents
[39:50] into their body that will heighten their libido, but they
[39:54] won't get the complexification of pair bonding that I was just
[39:57] discussing. And so they will go into a kind
[40:00] of a childlike adulthood, hmm, that nobody has really
[40:05] conceptualized. And off they go, becoming male.
[40:10] From female and I remember 1 detransitioner.
[40:12] Well, he's, he's, he calls himself a, a gentleman of the
[40:16] trans experience. Corey Cohn, born male at 19.
[40:21] He was, he's actually the exact same age as me.
[40:22] He's about 50. At 19.
[40:25] He, he was actually gay, but he came from a, a background that
[40:28] kind of suppressed being gay. And so he medicalised and it's
[40:32] very sad. He, he, he thought he wouldn't
[40:35] lose his virginity until he became a girl.
[40:38] So he had vaginoplasty, you know, he, he, he medicalised
[40:41] over to, uh, being female and then realised his sexual
[40:47] functioning was completely impaired, that the vaginoplasty
[40:50] was a neo vagina. It was a, uh, you know, a
[40:54] simulation of a vagina, but it's not a real vagina.
[40:58] And he's never had, uh, sexual experiences.
[41:01] He's now 50 and he said it's like crossing over to the river
[41:05] but never getting to the other side.
[41:08] And he's, you know, whether he did transitions or not, he seems
[41:12] to go by, he, him, he calls himself Corey.
[41:15] You can look him up. He's brilliant.
[41:16] He's very, very interesting. Umm, a lot of people that I work
[41:20] with, they, they've medicalised, they feel they've passed the
[41:23] point of no return and so they don't actually detransition.
[41:28] What they do is they say things like I've been a victim of
[41:31] medical abuse. You know, I present as male, I
[41:36] was born female. I know it's very complicated and
[41:39] I'm thrown a lot of terms around, but it's, it's, I think
[41:42] it's an ongoing medical scandal. And I think what we need to do
[41:45] is speak about it very plainly. That's why I discuss things like
[41:48] puberty. People don't get into what
[41:49] puberty blockers are. They don't have a clue.
[41:52] They just go, you know what I mean, Trans label slogans and I
[41:56] want to get into the actual details of what happens so
[41:59] people can talk about it intelligently.
[42:01] This is perhaps a horrible question to ask, but you've
[42:04] piqued my curiosity. As someone who experienced very
[42:08] intense gender dysphoria, you said you were borderline
[42:11] suicidal. Well, I was suicidal.
[42:13] Yeah, I was suicidal. Yeah, 100%.
[42:15] And you were growing up in the 80s here.
[42:19] In Ireland. In Ireland, what would have
[42:22] happened if you experienced that now?
[42:27] Umm, the you know the reason I'm speaking about trans like I
[42:30] spent many many years as a general psychotherapist and I
[42:33] always wanted to stay general because it suits my personality
[42:38] that likes go from here, there and everywhere.
[42:40] However, umm, I strongly believe had I had the experience and
[42:45] I've met enough, Kira Bell would be a good example, umm, of kids
[42:49] who were like me. They had that childhood onset
[42:53] gender dysphoria. But when they were brought up in
[42:57] the last 20 years, they were told, well, you could be a boy,
[43:02] identify as a boy would maybe, uh, puberty blockers might be
[43:05] the right treatment path for you.
[43:07] So I think I would have medically transitioned.
[43:10] I don't know, you know what I mean.
[43:11] It's very, very hard to go back in your childhood and these
[43:14] sliding doors questions. But I would almost certainly
[43:18] have been diagnosed with childhood answer gender
[43:20] dysphoria. Almost certainly teachers in my
[43:23] life would have got over involved and thought they could
[43:25] save me. Clinicians would have suggested
[43:28] treatment paths for me. And I think it would have been a
[43:32] disaster for me. I'm now very comfortable being a
[43:35] woman, and I have two children. I've fallen in love.
[43:41] I have a lovely husband. I would have had this
[43:44] medicalized life, and I would have become, you know, a
[43:47] simulated man, for want of a better phrase, a trans man.
[43:51] And I don't know how that would have worked out, but I know I
[43:55] wouldn't have been able to have my children when I was talking
[43:57] about the medical complications. And fertility is obviously a
[44:00] huge side effect. And I, I, I think the very
[44:06] strength of the urge for people to medically transition in their
[44:10] teen years is matched by the urge of many, especially women
[44:15] who want to have children in the 30s.
[44:17] It becomes incredibly focused, like, get out of my way, I need
[44:22] to have children if you follow me.
[44:24] So I, I, I, I know enough about this to know that the vast
[44:29] majority, we're talking about 95% of kids who've been puberty
[44:33] blocked and have then gone on to medically transition haven't yet
[44:37] reached their 30s. So they have not yet reached the
[44:40] fertility pain that I fear and I think I can predict is going to
[44:48] hit them off. I'm you won't be able to
[44:50] reproduce. It's prevalent with everyone,
[44:54] transgender dysphoric or not, this fertility crisis that's
[44:57] going on and speak about it all the time in the show.
[44:59] It's one of the most pressing concerns, this whole
[45:02] depopulation bomb that's about to go off.
[45:04] And I think the fertility right now in the UK is like 1.41,
[45:07] which is devastatingly low. Like 75% of the world is below
[45:11] replacement level, and then you start transing people as well on
[45:15] top of that. It's not going to go too well,
[45:17] is it? Talk to me about the therapy
[45:20] industry as a whole. I'd love to get your insight on
[45:23] this as a psychotherapist. Where have we actually gone
[45:26] wrong? We've been saying this whole
[45:28] interview that things are going wrong, but what specifically has
[45:32] happened the last few decades? Yeah, I've been studying this
[45:39] for some time and I'm starting to.
[45:41] I feel like a priest has lost his faith, really.
[45:44] It's psychotherapy, and I love speaking psychologically and I'm
[45:48] happiest when I'm speaking with other people psychologically.
[45:52] But something awful has happened.
[45:54] And when I trace it back, I realized from Freud's time
[45:56] onwards, it was a very paternal, on high, kind of a paritarian
[46:04] industry from the beginning, which was pretty dubious.
[46:07] Like when you look up Freud's life and Carl Jung's life, and I
[46:11] love their theory, but their lives were pretty awful.
[46:13] Like they're, you know, they certainly didn't live it, in my
[46:17] view, affairs with patients and things like that.
[46:21] And then you move on. So it was a very paternalistic,
[46:26] authoritarian psychological approach for decades and then
[46:33] somewhere in the last few decades it became this Carl
[46:38] Rogers, he's a psychologist, He kind of brought in human centred
[46:43] person centred care in the 70s. So when you start talking,
[46:46] sorry, I'm going to give a long answer because there's a lot to
[46:49] say really, please do. But when you look at all the
[46:51] theories, it would start with Freud and psychoanalysis.
[46:54] And that was a very much, you'll come to me, I'll say very
[46:58] little. You'll lie on your couch like
[47:01] Woody Allen. For those who remember Woody
[47:02] Allen and I will ever so often give pronouncements and that's
[47:07] psychoanalysis. Now people shout at me, that's
[47:09] not psychoanalysis, but I would say in a, in a reductive way
[47:13] that is, it's kind of analytical.
[47:16] It, it's very highly intellectual.
[47:19] It's very, very, umm, uh, what would I say?
[47:23] Very thought out, very cognitive, very cerebral, but
[47:27] it's it's own thing. And it was very often people who
[47:31] were quite rich because to go to psychoanalysis, you were often
[47:34] gone two to three times a week. So you had to have the time and
[47:38] the money to do that. So that was really the preserve
[47:41] of very rich people, I would argue.
[47:44] Then it got equalized and different people came in with
[47:48] different theories. Aaron Beckham in with, you know,
[47:50] his his approach and Al Albert Ellis come in with his approach.
[47:55] But Carol Rogers really changed things with his personal
[47:58] centered approach from the 50s, sixties, 70s.
[48:01] He started saying, I just listened to the person I work
[48:04] with the person you know, you have trust in the person.
[48:07] They know they're always the person is the expert of
[48:10] themselves. And that changed from that
[48:12] psychoanalytical kind of patriarchal.
[48:15] I'll tell you what's wrong with you.
[48:16] You haven't an ocean. Tell me your dreams and I'll
[48:19] tell you what's going down to now.
[48:21] I'm reducing it. But for want of a podcast, you
[48:23] have to to to Carl Rogers saying no, no, no, no.
[48:27] The person is the expert of themselves and I'm just
[48:31] facilitating their process. I'm giving them a safe harbour.
[48:35] If they have time with me, I will just be just give them kind
[48:40] of unconditional positive regard.
[48:43] I will give them a safe harbour to work through themselves, work
[48:46] through all their neurosis. I will not challenge them.
[48:49] I'll just be there as a safe place.
[48:52] They will find themselves if you just give themselves enough
[48:55] time. It's a beautiful theory and I've
[48:57] seen Carl Rogers working. He could do it.
[48:59] If I went to him, I think I would I would be a very very
[49:03] very eh, contented person. But very few people can do it.
[49:06] And that is like a lot of theories.
[49:09] It's morphed into this bastardized version.
[49:12] Sorry for your clicks. I think YouTube.
[49:14] You can swear OK as much as you fucking want.
[49:17] OK, thank God because I'm over. But yeah, it's turned it as
[49:22] Mongol version. It's awful, awful version of
[49:25] person centered care where people just as people call it
[49:29] nodding dog dog therapy where you come in, you ramble on all
[49:34] day, every day for hours, for weeks, for months, for years.
[49:39] And I, the therapist just not just I don't challenge, I don't.
[49:44] And an awful lot of people listening will say, yeah, that's
[49:46] what I got. It was really unsatisfying.
[49:49] Therapist was just nodding, just agreeing with everything I said.
[49:52] That's not person centered. That's not really how he
[49:55] theorize it. That's what it's become.
[49:57] So his theoretical approach really took over from the
[50:02] psychoanalytical approach. And that's in a way where the
[50:05] rock became, you know what I mean?
[50:08] So when I started studying, I started studying, as you know, I
[50:11] had a difficult childhood and a difficult adolescence.
[50:14] I didn't go to the school, I didn't go to college after
[50:16] school. And I, I went to College in I
[50:18] think my early 30s, maybe late 20s.
[50:21] And umm, well, I thought I was going to go into this
[50:25] intellectually part provoking deep kind of scene.
[50:29] And I was like, this is clown world, this is stupid.
[50:33] And people, every class you'd be in, somebody would stand up and
[50:36] say, I think everybody should have therapy in Iceland.
[50:40] What is this? What is this?
[50:41] But actually now we're in the 20 twenties, everybody has therapy.
[50:46] Everybody is just going to this kind of very vague, nebulous
[50:52] kind of therapy that just doesn't seem to challenge
[50:55] people, doesn't seem to kind of have a process.
[50:57] I had learned that you have a process, a start, middle and end
[51:01] to your therapeutic process. It's it's valuable, it's
[51:04] confronting, it's challenging. We got somewhere and we've
[51:07] finished rather than I just keep going every Thursday to Case,
[51:11] who's kind of like my best friend and she, she's lovely.
[51:15] They're always lovely. But I think it's lost its way,
[51:19] sadly, in the very long answer, because of personal centered
[51:23] care. Well, that's what I wanted.
[51:25] I want us to really unpack this and you're the best person to do
[51:28] this, laying out that history. Where's the right place to go
[51:33] from here? There's this whole anti
[51:35] psychiatry movement that happened in the 70s and maybe
[51:39] you can talk about that a little bit and where that went wrong,
[51:42] although there were perhaps some positives from it too.
[51:45] We can't just go cold Turkey here and refute therapy as
[51:49] perhaps I've had impulses to do on my podcast and my intuition,
[51:55] my knee jerk reaction to all of these problems.
[51:58] I don't know if it's a male thing, kind of high agency.
[52:01] Thinking I can conquer the world by myself is to go fuck this
[52:05] shit. Therapy is awful.
[52:07] None of it is good. And through speaking to experts
[52:11] much wiser than I, I've completely turned my back on
[52:14] that stance. And I think therapy is important
[52:16] if it's done right. I spoke to Doctor Andrew Hartz
[52:19] about this, who's a therapist in New York.
[52:21] I know he was saying how therapy isn't bad in and of itself, it's
[52:27] just done badly nowadays. And I certainly agree with that.
[52:31] Where do we go from here and how does the online world play into
[52:36] this where everyone's therapized, as you said, weekly.
[52:40] And a lot of it it's easy to get because you just jump on a Zoom
[52:43] call. Oh yeah, which has made it E
[52:47] what had become quite a superficial experience.
[52:49] It's become even more superficial when it went on
[52:52] Zoom. I'll go back to that in a
[52:53] second. I want to add that not only did
[52:56] the person centered care, you know, Carl Rogers thing came in
[52:59] at the same time as well. A decade or two later, CBT,
[53:04] cognitive behavioural therapy came in and it was like the
[53:07] antidote to person center. It's a person center.
[53:09] Was this, it became, it wasn't immediately a kind of a nebulous
[53:13] rambling eternal therapy that was very pleasant because you
[53:17] weren't going to get challenged, though I know that's not good
[53:19] person centered therapy, but it's what it became.
[53:22] At the same time people said no, let's have much more structured
[53:25] process. Let's offer a cognitive
[53:27] behavioural therapy. 6 sessions, you're in, you're out, you're
[53:29] thinking is wrong, I'll tell you how and go.
[53:32] And that's a very commercialized package, which is equally
[53:35] superficial. And you know, some people on the
[53:38] bounce of the ball, if you get it right, it can go, it could
[53:40] change your life. And for CBT, it can be really,
[53:43] really, really powerful. For some people, they might have
[53:46] a phobia, they might have one thing, well, they get some CBT
[53:49] and they're straightened out. So it can be brilliant.
[53:52] Very same with person centered. You can say I had so much trauma
[53:56] as a child. I needed those four years.
[53:58] I needed the safe place. And actually I went on.
[54:01] So I'm not saying they don't work at all times.
[54:04] I'm saying a lot of it doesn't work.
[54:07] So to answer bad therapy is the problem.
[54:09] There's an awful lot of very bad therapy.
[54:11] Abigail Schreyer wrote a brilliant book called Bad
[54:13] Therapy, Absolutely brilliant and therapeutic culture of all
[54:17] these teachers and youth workers and everybody's a psychologist
[54:21] and everybody's got this pop psychology and you know, in pubs
[54:25] and stuff like that. Everybody is just kind of using
[54:29] techniques and words and framing that are are they don't do well
[54:35] out in the outer world, but they've just become part of our
[54:38] speak. You know, our lexicon is people
[54:41] saying, Oh, well, you know, you're, you're projecting, you
[54:44] know what I mean? And things like that.
[54:46] And it's, it's really sad that I think our industry, I wonder has
[54:51] it been, I hate to be so negative, but I wonder has it
[54:55] kind of past the point of no return?
[54:57] I, I don't know if it's really salvageable at this stage,
[55:00] certainly in the way it is now. There's techniques all over the
[55:04] place, you know what I mean? The DBT and CBT and or, you
[55:08] know, there's so many or EBT and there's so many kind of
[55:11] acronyms. Everybody's got a new theory.
[55:14] And there's an awful lot of people who I meet who've had
[55:17] therapy and I just whatever, you know what I mean?
[55:21] There's an awful, very bad therapy.
[55:23] Thankfully, I'm lucky enough, I think I'm lucky enough to be a
[55:27] good therapist. I, I know I'm good at it.
[55:29] You know, when you're good at something, it's like if
[55:31] somebody's good with ball sports, they know it, They get
[55:33] the ball and they have a certain skill, which I thankfully I, I
[55:38] believe I do. But I do think that there's so
[55:40] much bad therapy. I don't, I don't know why, but
[55:43] there really is. Well, I do have theories and
[55:46] you've heard some of them, but I think we, our culture, the
[55:51] therapeutic culture, the wider world is the problem.
[55:55] Umm, yeah. I don't know where I went with
[55:57] that. Oh, but the Zoom thing, Oh my
[55:59] God, can I just jump in on the Zoom, please?
[56:01] What a shit show. So when I, when COVID first
[56:05] happened and I was already doing online, you know, group support
[56:10] for a lot of parents and for people who are trans identified
[56:13] and things. And I was like, yeah, that's
[56:16] fine. But actual therapeutic process,
[56:18] you can't, you can't do that in the Zoom.
[56:20] Like there's a difference between group facilitation, hmm,
[56:23] where frankly you're meeting lots of different experiences.
[56:26] That's very different than one to one therapeutic process.
[56:30] And suddenly now I'm on Zoom like everybody else.
[56:32] And I'm really sad about that. I'm really sad that we've all
[56:36] become these Zoom councillors. And I'll be very straight.
[56:39] It's not as good. It's not where near as good.
[56:42] You lose an awful lot. Yeah, you gain with convenience.
[56:45] And so there's some people who would come to me.
[56:48] They might live in, you know, I don't know, Dallas, or they
[56:52] might live in California, or they might live in Singapore.
[56:55] They couldn't access me except through Zoom.
[56:58] However, you lose an awful lot. My colleague of mine, a friend
[57:02] of mine, Sasha, she only sees clients on Zoom because it's a
[57:06] specialized. And she said I'd never seen
[57:08] their bottom half. I've never seen the way they
[57:11] walk. I've never seen the physicality
[57:13] of meeting them. When you meet people, it's very,
[57:16] very, very different, as you know, because you're having one,
[57:19] one in these, in these, yeah, it's a completely different
[57:22] experience. It's a lot more superficial.
[57:24] So I've lost a lot of faith in any sort of zoom therapy and now
[57:30] I've moved into group facilitation for now anyway.
[57:33] But I can't seem as have gone back to serious therapy over
[57:37] zoom like we've had COVID. I think the only therapy you can
[57:40] really give is 1 to one in person.
[57:44] I was on a Battle of Ideas panel yesterday and you were there as
[57:46] well and the battle and Georgina Mumford was on my panel and she
[57:50] spoke about this issue between girls and boys sort of dividing,
[57:54] bifurcating and seemingly feeling alienated from one
[57:58] another and it really stuck with me.
[58:00] She's speaking about how we spend more time now talking
[58:04] about each other rather than to each other.
[58:08] And to bring that into this conversation, when you speak
[58:12] about things like venting and mapping on all of these terms to
[58:15] reality, I wonder if it's the same thing that we're speaking
[58:19] about reality rather than to it and going through it and
[58:25] experiencing it. Because we are living these
[58:28] lives detached from the real world.
[58:31] We're chronically online where these terms are good, especially
[58:35] even just to break it down and sort of the medium is the
[58:38] message thing. If we're on text based platforms
[58:41] that aren't 3D, it's just us typing words on our keyboards.
[58:45] Of course, flashy, good, easy to understand words are going to
[58:49] dominate and proliferate because that's all you have.
[58:52] Yeah, compared to reality slapping you in the face when
[58:56] you're actually amongst it. So I wonder if that's one of the
[58:58] problems here with the overmedicalization and
[59:01] pathologization of everything is the spaces that we're
[59:05] inhabiting. Yeah, I, I think it's dreadful.
[59:10] I don't, I don't like being so depressing.
[59:13] I wish I wasn't. You know, my own kids tell me
[59:16] they're 16 and 17. They say, ah, Mama, you know,
[59:18] there's a concept called professional deformation that
[59:21] you're deformed from your own profession.
[59:24] If you What do you mean? So let's say I could be arguably
[59:27] deformed from my profession so that I'm a psychotherapist and I
[59:31] think everything is awful. And the last hour would suggest
[59:35] I am, that I'm seeing everything through the prism of my work.
[59:39] So somebody else might, let's say a classic one would be a
[59:42] journalist scene. Is there a column in this as a
[59:44] copy? In this, Everything is copy.
[59:46] You know what means you become deformed by your profession?
[59:49] So you could be seen everything as is there an interview?
[59:51] What's the headlines? What's the clicks?
[59:53] What's the you know, what's the time?
[59:54] I'll tell you what mine is, Yeah, mine is the podcast bro
[59:57] thing that we all fall prey to, of trying to quantify everything
[1:00:01] as well in my own sense of coming up with.
[1:00:03] Some pithy atherism. So instead of, oh, you're.
[1:00:07] You're all Oscar Miles. Yeah, instead of saying, oh,
[1:00:10] you're experiencing life and this is circumstantial and
[1:00:12] you're going to get through, it's like, oh, you're
[1:00:15] experiencing the self development paradox.
[1:00:17] So I must be cautious with that. Mike Drought.
[1:00:20] Yeah, exactly. Exactly.
[1:00:22] So it is a very good phrase. Professional deformation.
[1:00:26] And so my kids are like, Mommy, you've lost the head entirely.
[1:00:29] We're having a good time. And you keep on acting like this
[1:00:33] generation is in bits. You know what I mean?
[1:00:35] They're like, you know, it's it's not true.
[1:00:37] So there is an argument that I have it wrong.
[1:00:40] And I'm just seeing the darkest side continuously, which I am,
[1:00:44] there's no doubt about it. I've seen the harder, darker
[1:00:48] side in my work. However, I do believe that this
[1:00:53] generation have lost a lot of fun from not being around each
[1:00:57] other and because of devices have been in the way so that
[1:01:00] when you're having a laugh and I don't know, you're doing stupid
[1:01:03] silly things that that laugh that I laughed between the ages
[1:01:09] of 10 and 20, there's nothing quite like it.
[1:01:11] The liberating like, you know what I mean?
[1:01:15] And you're whacking each other and you're so free.
[1:01:18] That kind of intense, wacky, wild adolescent experience has
[1:01:26] got has been encroached by phones that somebody could be
[1:01:29] filming you. So because in fact, it's not all
[1:01:33] that unlikely you're being filmed or recorded.
[1:01:37] And so when you're at your wildest, I just feel that I had
[1:01:40] it on Fetter. There was no physical way to be.
[1:01:43] It wasn't even in a concept. So I could have been doing
[1:01:47] something really insane, but it was everybody in the room saw it
[1:01:51] and nobody else. And the liberation of that is
[1:01:56] hard to describe. And I'm feeling very sad that
[1:02:00] you guys couldn't have had that. You couldn't have had it because
[1:02:05] of course somebody could be filming.
[1:02:06] You can only have a slightly more professional demeanor even
[1:02:09] after what you can tell me how wide you are.
[1:02:11] And I'm like, I don't care. The thresh of phones and
[1:02:13] recording. And it's just there because I'm
[1:02:17] in this world now and I know it. And so I think you've lost
[1:02:21] something that you'll never be able to experience.
[1:02:25] And I think you're missing out on that.
[1:02:30] There's something about that. I haven't developed it, but I
[1:02:32] think it's really important that people go through it because
[1:02:37] there's something about the humanity of going to your most
[1:02:41] wildest and having a laugh at their friends and still being
[1:02:45] friends the next day. There's something very, very
[1:02:48] intimate about that that makes you as a person.
[1:02:52] And there's some sort of veneer that's over the teenage
[1:02:57] experience now, because there's a kind of a branding that's
[1:03:01] happening from the age of 10, if you follow me.
[1:03:06] Yeah, my friend Frey India speaks about this, how
[1:03:09] everyone's their own personal brand now, their relationships
[1:03:13] are based on how marketable they are online and the selfies they
[1:03:17] take aren't capturing the moment they're promoting how good their
[1:03:21] union is That falls apart a month later because they weren't
[1:03:24] good enough for each other or whatever.
[1:03:27] But something I've been thinking about a lot recently and push
[1:03:32] back if you think this is a. Oh yeah, we have to have an
[1:03:34] argument. Let's get one in.
[1:03:40] Is how in the business world, and I'm not a business guy, I'm
[1:03:44] clueless when it comes to marketing and money and growing
[1:03:48] the commercial business. I just want to sit here and have
[1:03:50] amazing conversations like this and chat to people.
[1:03:53] But there's this concept of perceived value and how the
[1:03:57] price of something is based on the perceived value rather than
[1:04:01] the actual value, which is rather hard to quantify because
[1:04:05] in a world that's capitalist, all that matters is the
[1:04:08] perception of others as to how much they're willing to pay for
[1:04:11] an item. So you take that into a world
[1:04:15] where we're always marketing ourselves, we're a personal
[1:04:19] brand, we're online, everything is.
[1:04:23] What's the best way of marketing this experience?
[1:04:27] You start prioritizing the perceived value of life choices
[1:04:33] to others rather than the actual value of them long term.
[1:04:38] And I think that's very dangerous because eventually,
[1:04:42] unlike businesses, you are struck with the actual
[1:04:47] biological value of your decisions.
[1:04:50] And I guess one of the easiest examples that very much goes
[1:04:54] hand in hand with the conversations I've been having
[1:04:56] recently on the show is this whole fertility crisis.
[1:04:59] It's like, OK, the perceived value of my actions now in my
[1:05:03] 20s is I'm going to have an illustrious career.
[1:05:07] I'm going to get to the top. I'm going to climb the career
[1:05:09] ladder, and I'm going to be a boss bitch with a penthouse and
[1:05:12] a poodle or a guy smoking a cigar by my pool.
[1:05:17] But but then you don't prioritize or engage at all in
[1:05:21] proper romantic relationships. You don't work that muscle, and
[1:05:26] you're 35 years old. Your fertility window has
[1:05:29] closed, both the men and women, and you're stuck for the rest of
[1:05:33] your life. It's this thing, this thing that
[1:05:35] you're talking about, about almost drowning and being struck
[1:05:39] with this overwhelming realization of the fact that the
[1:05:42] world is a lot mightier than you.
[1:05:46] And that's the problem I see. It's this detachment from
[1:05:49] reality, detachment from the consequences of our actions.
[1:05:54] And because this is such a new phenomenon, it hasn't hit the
[1:05:59] first generation in the face yet.
[1:06:00] Yeah, yeah. Like to pause on this for a
[1:06:04] second. This massive transition
[1:06:09] societally and culturally, it hasn't actually been tested.
[1:06:13] We haven't seen the results yet, so I think it's why it's so
[1:06:18] important to have these conversations and give people
[1:06:22] that realization without having been close to drowning, that
[1:06:27] some things are outside of your control.
[1:06:31] Although we all do have agency and we can't keep on playing God
[1:06:35] forever. Yeah, I think sadly the the way
[1:06:41] it's going to go will continue to be a simulation of real life
[1:06:45] experiences. I agree with you.
[1:06:47] I think the branding, the peop, the fact that people are
[1:06:51] branding from the age of 10 or so onwards is, is
[1:06:55] psychologically really worrying. But to pause on that for a
[1:07:00] second to go to the fertility thing, I think the way it's
[1:07:03] going to go is, is quite clearly it's gone into egg donation
[1:07:06] surrogacy. And I think it will, it'd be
[1:07:12] some time before people say, well, that wasn't the same
[1:07:16] experience and it was a different experience.
[1:07:19] And I think there's going to be I again and going to be
[1:07:22] depressing. But like, I think there's going
[1:07:24] to be definitely disconnects between parents and children in
[1:07:29] a way that we haven't seen before because they won't be as
[1:07:32] connected with their children. I remember a really sad case of
[1:07:37] a, of a, a child who was born through a surrogacy and they,
[1:07:43] uh, the parents rejected the child because of the problems
[1:07:46] the child had. Now with the rise, and there is
[1:07:50] a distinct rise in issues such as autism, there's
[1:07:53] overdiagnosis, but there's also a rise, there's no doubt about
[1:07:56] it. And then there's a rise in
[1:07:59] surrogacy. I think there's going to be a
[1:08:00] rise in parents rejecting their children in ways that I think
[1:08:07] people haven't conceived. I think there's going to be a
[1:08:09] lot of parents rejecting children, saying that's not what
[1:08:14] I was buying into. Yeah.
[1:08:16] So I, I because usually parent love overcomes that because it's
[1:08:21] your child, it's of you. But when it's not of you, I
[1:08:25] think the likelihood of rejection is going to be much
[1:08:28] harder. So those kids are going to
[1:08:30] really suffer. And, you know, like, I don't
[1:08:33] know if you've have you read Kazyushi Guru's books and
[1:08:36] they're, they're fascinating because he's talking about kind
[1:08:39] of Clara and the son is a kind of a simulated person.
[1:08:43] And Clara is, you know, the effectively is, is bought in a
[1:08:47] shop and she's a simulated person, a friend for somebody
[1:08:50] else. It's, it's a great book, but
[1:08:52] it's an indication of maybe where we'll be going, where
[1:08:54] we'll be basically, you know, if you have kids in 20 years and
[1:08:58] then you buy a simulated friend for your kids that they're never
[1:09:01] lonely and it's effectively a robot friend that they have.
[1:09:06] That's what Claire and the son is.
[1:09:07] It's, it's extraordinary. I think there's going to be an
[1:09:10] awful lot of simulated experiences that they won't know
[1:09:13] what they're missing. If you follow me, they won't
[1:09:15] know what I described at the teenage years.
[1:09:17] They won't know what they're missing.
[1:09:19] And that's the problem, because I think what will actually be
[1:09:23] the outcome will be a much higher level of of kind of just
[1:09:28] not in joylessness because they won't be getting the real
[1:09:32] experience and they won't know they're not getting the real
[1:09:34] experience. So they'll be missing out on
[1:09:37] something. What I described about the
[1:09:38] laughing and the extremities of adolescence, which I believe one
[1:09:43] should go through. I fear that if you miss it,
[1:09:47] it'll just be a kind of incremental step of feeling this
[1:09:53] life isn't really worth it. It's a bit joyless, it's a bit
[1:09:57] difficult. It's not really engaging enough
[1:10:01] because everything is. It's like a Zoom, but me and you
[1:10:03] were on Zoom. It just wouldn't be as
[1:10:04] interesting. I know I might be flicking on my
[1:10:07] phone or looking at something. I know I wouldn't be as engaged
[1:10:11] because when it's not real life, we miss something and we're,
[1:10:15] we're, we're, we're kind of ignoring that at our peril and
[1:10:18] we are ignoring it. I'm not sure if I answered
[1:10:21] anything to do with your question.
[1:10:22] You absolutely didn't want to pick you up on the autism point
[1:10:24] as well. Yeah, you said autism used to be
[1:10:26] one in 2500 back in the 80s, and it's about one in 100 worldwide.
[1:10:32] And yet in Northern Ireland, schoolchildren are one in 20
[1:10:36] being diagnosed with autism. I want to do that over on Sub
[1:10:40] Stack. So we'll wrap up here.
[1:10:42] Stella, thank you so much for coming on the show.
[1:10:44] Enjoy that. Where can people find more of
[1:10:46] your work? Oh well, I'm easily found on
[1:10:48] Twitter and stuff. And James Beck, please look us
[1:10:51] up and support us if you like our work, because we've got a
[1:10:54] lot of work to do. And head on over sub stack where
[1:10:57] Stella's going to answer your questions.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
