# Is Jordan Peterson a Christian? - Glen Scrivener

An episode of [The Next Generation](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1772698742), 3 Aug 2025, 9:55.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/107851968/podcast/play/106380100/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2025-7-3%2F405038539-44100-2-fc5bfa60d879d.mp3

I and Glen Scrivener discuss Jordan Peterson's recent Surrounded interview, looking deeper into the Peterson's faith. My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotbewick/TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliotbewickX: https://x.com/elliotbewickABOUT THE NEXT GENERATION: In a world saturated by social media and marked by skyrocketing rates of anxiety, depression, and ADHD among Gen Z, young people are growing up in a landscape of chaos and contradiction. While protests swell in city streets and activists hurl soup at famous artworks to demand climate action, a quieter crisis unfolds within - the mental and emotional battles faced by a generation trying to make sense of it all.The Next Generation is hosted by 20-year-old Elliot Bewick, offering a raw and honest look at the world through the eyes of those living in it. Bringing together insight from professionals and young people on the ground, this podcast isn’t here to complain or chase clout. It’s here to bend the arc of the modern world towards solutions, truth and a love for the beautiful adventure of life itself.

## Transcript

[0:00] The whole Jordan Peterson situation recently I think was a
[0:03] good example of someone tossed into a media format that they're
[0:06] not familiar with. With him going on surrounded, it
[0:10] seems like no one came out of that happy.
[0:13] Do you think that was symbolic of anything greater than him
[0:17] just having a bad day? Or do you think it was just just
[0:22] an off day for him? I heard Jonathan Pejo reflect on
[0:25] that surrounded debate and, and he said it's, it's interesting.
[0:30] It's, it's, it can be too easy to see Jordan Peterson as being
[0:35] very cagey about the faith issue and not telling us what he
[0:38] thinks. But Jonathan, who's a great
[0:40] friend of, of Jordan Peterson, said he's actually being
[0:43] incredibly honest in those moments.
[0:45] He genuinely doesn't want to be pinned down and doesn't feel
[0:50] able to be pinned down on the faith question.
[0:53] And so when he's asked, he's not boxing clever when he, when he's
[0:56] asks, you know, he, he, he is so reflective upon.
[1:02] Well, my elephants today did not go in a very Christian
[1:06] direction. So I, how would I have the
[1:08] audacity to say that I'm Christian?
[1:10] Because when I, when I do my elephant tracker app, I discover
[1:14] that, that I've gone off into all sorts of non Christian
[1:16] directions. And so I, I thought that was,
[1:18] that was interesting. I, I don't think the, the format
[1:21] of surrounded is geared towards truth.
[1:25] It's geared towards spectacle and fair play to them.
[1:28] You know, they, they, they are getting the views, but they're,
[1:31] they're certainly not clarifying very many, very many issues.
[1:35] But yeah, I, I did think that was interesting that the Peugeot
[1:38] was saying Peterson is not being disingenuous at that point.
[1:41] He's genuinely telling you he doesn't know.
[1:43] So believe him. Last time you were on the show,
[1:46] we spoke about Peterson's impact on Christianity, but we didn't
[1:49] actually really flesh out if he is a Christian at all.
[1:54] What do you think he gets wrong about Christianity?
[1:57] I've seen a lot of Christians criticizing certain arguments he
[2:01] made in that surrounded debate. Yeah, I think a lot of people
[2:07] are leapfrogging him into church and finding him a very helpful
[2:12] route into church. I think, you know, he wrote 12
[2:16] rules for life and then 12 more rules for life.
[2:20] And I think what he gets in Christian terms is the law, and
[2:24] what he misses is the gospel. The law is this is the good
[2:29] life. Thou shalt do it.
[2:32] The gospel is, but you don't live it, do you?
[2:37] You need forgiveness, right? And, and essentially, I, I think
[2:41] Jordan Peterson is very good at describing the law, describing
[2:44] the good life. You, you read, I haven't read
[2:46] more, more rules for life or whatever that one one is, but I,
[2:49] I did read 12 rules for life and he quotes Scripture in it again
[2:53] and again. And when he quotes Scripture, it
[2:55] lands in ways that are heavier and more powerful than in many
[2:58] Christian books that I read. He will just talk about the
[3:01] sermon on the mountain, something from Proverbs or
[3:03] something. And, and it really, really
[3:05] lands. And, and that is kind of
[3:08] Christianity as a ladder. But nobody, neither neither
[3:14] Protestants nor Catholics nor Orthodox think that Christianity
[3:16] ultimately is a ladder. The sign of Christianity is a
[3:18] cross in which the one from heaven comes down not simply to
[3:23] teach us how to be good. It comes down because we're bad
[3:26] to die for our Vadnais to set us on our feet again as children
[3:31] and say, you know, now as a forgiven child, you can live
[3:35] those rules for life, but the rules for life are not the way
[3:38] into a family because you, you can't earn your way into a
[3:40] family. You've got to be born into a
[3:42] family. That's why Jesus says you've got
[3:43] to be born again right into the family.
[3:45] So the God, the gospel is what Christianity is most
[3:48] fundamentally about. The law is really helpful.
[3:51] It's good, but it's not the way in.
[3:54] And I think that's, it's so interesting that Moses in the
[3:56] Bible is like, narratively, this is what happened.
[3:59] Moses is the guy who gives the law from Mount Sinai.
[4:03] He ends up dying short of the promised land.
[4:05] Like he, he gets to look up, he he goes up a mountain and he
[4:09] gets to see the land of milk and honey that's been promised to
[4:11] the children of Israel. And Mr. Law doesn't make it into
[4:16] the promised land, but his young assistant Joshua, whose name
[4:20] means Jesus, he gets into the promised land and those who
[4:24] trust him. Right.
[4:26] And so I, I think narratively the Old Testament is, is kind of
[4:28] saying the law is good, gets you so far, but you need, you need
[4:33] Jesus and to trust Jesus to, to get the new life that he's
[4:37] offering. I wanted to share with you an
[4:40] update on my position on faith since we last podcasted last saw
[4:44] each other. Updates are live.
[4:46] OK, Yeah. Here we go.
[4:47] And I, I spoke to Justin about this on our pod as well.
[4:50] And that is that it used to be, if I looked deep within that my
[4:55] heart didn't want Christianity to be true because I wanted to
[4:59] be in control of my own destiny. I wanted to build my own life
[5:03] and not have God impose anything on me.
[5:08] Whereas intellectually I was open to the idea of of God's
[5:11] existence. Now I feel like I've experienced
[5:15] a flip where I really wish it was true.
[5:20] I've engaged with a lot of the apologetic surrounding it, the
[5:24] intellectual side, and that's actually brought, if you want to
[5:28] call it my heart, my heart into wanting it.
[5:33] So many things to unpack there. But even just to pick up on the
[5:36] point of before wanting to create my own destiny, whatever
[5:40] that may mean. And I think that's wired into
[5:42] all of us. I've kind of realized
[5:44] intellectually that without a God, there's no free will
[5:48] anyway. So everything's determined.
[5:50] There's no morality. I'd quite like there to be an
[5:53] objective morality where man is made in the image of God.
[5:56] You certainly live that way. Precisely.
[5:59] So my heart, I very much feel is is open to the idea.
[6:03] And I had a whole conversation with Justin about non resistant
[6:07] non believers and whether they exist.
[6:09] And I don't know, maybe there's something stopping me from quite
[6:13] wanting it in my heart truly, because maybe that would
[6:15] actually mean that I made the leap of faith.
[6:18] But what I struggle with is this leap of faith.
[6:20] Intellectually, I'm very much persuaded by the possibility
[6:26] that religion is a necessity for society to flourish.
[6:32] But it's not true that it aids a better society.
[6:37] That seems more just. And imposing an objective
[6:40] morality on the world is good for us, generally speaking.
[6:43] But I'm not convinced that it's the truth.
[6:46] And there are plenty of things, and you know, any Christian
[6:49] would accept that. There are some pretty wild
[6:50] claims in the Bible that I need to grapple with and become more
[6:56] attuned to before I can make that leap of faith.
[6:59] And you know, we've we've discussed faith a lot in this
[7:01] podcast and I completely get and respect that idea of faith that
[7:06] I can't just think my way into Christianity.
[7:10] That's not how it works. But I do have doubts and there
[7:16] are things that I don't believe. So it's kind of that flip, and I
[7:22] really, really feel, for what it's worth, there is some sort
[7:28] of way of squaring the whole ethical morality question
[7:33] without having to go to the metaphysical.
[7:35] That's kind of where my faith lies, is that there is some sort
[7:40] of moral landscape that Sam Harris speaks about, although
[7:43] he's been slated by Alex O'Connor even about his ideas on
[7:48] an objective grounding in morality.
[7:50] But I think that there is a project that can be put together
[7:53] that may outdo the moral landscape and actually come to a
[7:56] solid bedrock. That's where my faith lies at
[7:59] the moment, and that's what makes me convinced for now that
[8:06] Christianity perhaps isn't true and it's just a nice thing that
[8:11] leads us to flourishing. Well, you might come up with the
[8:17] moral landscape 2 point O and then you don't need Jesus on the
[8:22] cross. And at that point my heart just
[8:26] says you're not going to do better as a as a vision of
[8:31] ultimate reality. Like who can out narrate this
[8:35] vision of ultimate reality is that you've got the highest
[8:38] figure descending to the lowest depth to give the greatest
[8:41] sacrifice for the entire world to make everything OK forever.
[8:46] The dimensions to this story are unimprovable.
[8:50] Why walk away from the picture of, of Christ on the cross?
[8:55] And, and I guess what I'd encourage you to do is you're,
[8:59] you're quite right. You're not going to think your
[9:00] way into this. That's not that that is to put
[9:04] too much faith in the writer, right?
[9:05] You're not going to think your way into this.
[9:07] But Rupert Short has written some beautiful books.
[9:10] He he says we, we don't think our way into a new way of
[9:12] living. We live our way into a new way
[9:14] of thinking and the there's something about embodied
[9:18] practice. There's something about
[9:19] community. There's something about hearing
[9:21] the word from beyond. There's something about putting
[9:25] yourself in the way of this grand narrative, this great
[9:28] story that that I think ultimately does win the heart
[9:33] and head. And I just encourage you to
[9:35] keep, keep looking at that because I, I, I don't think
[9:38] you'll do better than God poured out with every drop of his blood
[9:44] for you. I, I think even technically
[9:48] there's not a better story than that, right?
[9:50] So why, why go for the pale imitations, Elliot?
[9:54] That's what I say.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
