# Anti-Depressants are Basically Placebos - Dr Joanna Moncrieff

An episode of [The Next Generation](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1772698742), 9 Oct 2025, 8:57.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/107851968/podcast/play/109201553/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2025-9-4%2F408648377-44100-2-672509338a608.mp3

Dr Joanna Moncrieff is a pracitsing psychiatrist and Professor of Critical and Social Psychiatry at University College London. In this clip, she explains to me the surprising truth about anti-depressants. My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotbewick/TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliotbewickX: https://x.com/elliotbewickABOUT THE NEXT GENERATION: In a world saturated by social media and marked by skyrocketing rates of anxiety, depression, and ADHD among Gen Z, young people are growing up in a landscape of chaos and contradiction. While protests swell in city streets and activists hurl soup at famous artworks to demand climate action, a quieter crisis unfolds within - the mental and emotional battles faced by a generation trying to make sense of it all.The Next Generation is hosted by 20-year-old Elliot Bewick, offering a raw and honest look at the world through the eyes of those living in it. Bringing together insight from professionals and young people on the ground, this podcast isn’t here to complain or chase clout. It’s here to bend the arc of the modern world towards solutions, truth and a love for the beautiful adventure of life itself.

## Transcript

[0:00] It is not controversial. I'm not going against the
[0:04] consensus to say that the difference between
[0:06] antidepressants and placebo is very small as it is actually
[0:11] measured. Now there are various ways in
[0:13] which that different, that small difference has been inflated by
[0:16] presenting the figures in different ways.
[0:18] But the actual difference that is measured using depression,
[0:21] these depression rating scales that we use, the validity of
[0:24] which is is questionable, but that's another, another issue.
[0:28] That's what we use. The the actual difference that
[0:32] is measured is the the most common scale that is used is
[0:36] called the Hamilton rating scale for depression.
[0:38] It is has a total of 52 points in its most commonly used
[0:42] version. And the difference between
[0:44] people taking an antidepressant and people taking placebo in
[0:47] terms of their levels of improvement is 2 points on that
[0:51] scale. It's a 52 point scale, A2 point
[0:53] difference doesn't even register as a clinically significant or
[0:57] even noticeable difference if you compare it to other ways of
[1:02] assessing the, the, the effects of of changes in mood.
[1:08] And, and as I say that, so this is this is not in dispute the
[1:12] the if you look at all the meta analysis that have been done of
[1:15] antidepressants compared with placebo, it may not be in the
[1:19] headlines because they may present their data differently.
[1:22] But if you dig down, you will find that the actual difference
[1:25] on the rating scale scores is this very small, is this very
[1:30] small amount. And as I say this, this small
[1:36] difference may be accounted for in a number of ways that does
[1:40] not necessarily reflect well on antidepressants or reflect
[1:44] benefits of antidepressants. It may be accounted for by the
[1:47] fact that people can are likely to be able to identify whether
[1:51] they're getting the real drug or the placebo because of the side
[1:54] effects that they get. And it may also be accounted for
[1:59] by a real pharmacological effect, by the emotional numbing
[2:02] effect of antidepressants, which as I've said, may be some people
[2:07] may find to be helpful, but some people find to be unpleasant.
[2:12] But the important thing to say is that even if it's even if
[2:15] some people find it a bit helpful overall, the actual
[2:18] benefit is it is having compared to placebo is is very, very
[2:22] small, but. It's still a benefit.
[2:25] If it's not, if that difference is not accounted for by
[2:28] amplified placebo effects, by the fact that people can just in
[2:31] these trials can just often recognise what they're taking,
[2:33] which I think it very likely is because because you can show,
[2:40] you can show that what people guess they're taking has a has a
[2:46] very strong effect on their outcome even in trials that
[2:50] don't show benefits of antidepressants.
[2:52] So it's not just that people are guessing they're taking the
[2:55] antidepressant because they feel better, they're guessing they're
[2:59] taking the antidepressant for some other reason.
[3:01] Overall, there's no difference from placebo, but people who
[3:04] think they're getting the real drug look as if they're doing
[3:07] better. Perhaps the means don't really
[3:09] matter if you are getting happier, whether it's a placebo
[3:11] or not, surely it's a good thing they are improving.
[3:16] So. So I think the arguments about
[3:19] giving people placebos are complicated and there are
[3:24] several reasons why I don't think that we should give people
[3:26] drugs if they are just acting as placebo.
[3:28] So the first is just an ethical, an ethical issue.
[3:31] I don't think we should be deceiving people.
[3:33] I don't think we should be giving something to people as if
[3:36] it's as if it's going to have a pharmacological effect when we
[3:39] think it's not going to. But apart from that, of course,
[3:43] you know, they're, they are not placebos in the sense that
[3:46] antidepressants are not inert substances.
[3:49] So therefore they do have, they have side effects or negative
[3:52] effects. They modern drugs like SSRIs
[3:59] commonly cause sexual dysfunction.
[4:01] Some of them make people feel a bit groggy and a bit a bit a bit
[4:06] mentally foggy. They interfere with sleep very
[4:10] often, and then they have some and they 'cause this emotional
[4:15] blunting which many people find unpleasant.
[4:17] Excessive weight gain weight. Gain, thank you weight gain,
[4:20] sweating, osteoporosis and falls in the elderly, lots of effects
[4:24] in pregnancy that maybe we'll come on to later.
[4:28] And then they have some rare effects such as they, they can
[4:31] cause bleeding that's well demonstrated.
[4:33] So they can cause hemorrhages. They, and in young people
[4:38] particularly, they, it can induce a state of agitation
[4:44] which it seems very occasionally is linked to people trying to
[4:50] kill themselves and maybe even killing themselves so they
[4:53] could. They can induce suicidal ideas
[4:55] and suicidal behaviour well. Wasn't there a study in Sweden
[4:59] that showed that suicide rates went up temporarily?
[5:03] I don't know if it was for the next two weeks or two months
[5:06] after actually starting antidepressants.
[5:09] Why would that be? So the the traditional
[5:12] explanation is that antidepressants might sort of
[5:14] activate people. So by lifting people out of a
[5:17] depressed state, they might become more suicidal.
[5:21] But the but the other possibility is that they're
[5:25] inducing a a suicidal state because of this state of
[5:28] agitation and impulsivity that they seem to induce.
[5:32] And for some reason, this particularly occurs in young
[5:34] people. Older people seem to experience
[5:37] more the sort of sedative effects, the lethargy, and young
[5:41] people seem to be more prone to being made getting into this
[5:46] sort of state of unpleasant agitation and tension, which
[5:49] sometimes can be linked with impulsive behaviours and
[5:52] suicidal sort of, you know, repetitive intrusive suicidal
[5:56] ideas. So coming back to the the point
[6:00] about why shouldn't we give placebos, there are all these,
[6:03] you know, common and less common adverse effects that are
[6:08] associated with antidepressants, which are a good reason for not
[6:12] using anti antidepressants as a placebo.
[6:15] And then finally, the we spoke earlier about the placebo
[6:19] effect. In the short term, definitely
[6:22] it's helpful to give someone something and say this is going
[6:25] to make you feel better. But in the long term, I suspect
[6:28] that actually this has a negative effect on people,
[6:31] partly because it doesn't make people feel better long term,
[6:36] because it doesn't resolve the the issues that were happening
[6:38] in the 1st place, and partly because it disempowers people.
[6:43] It gives people the idea that the problem is in their head.
[6:46] They need an external intervention, a medical
[6:49] intervention, a pill or some sort of manipulation of their
[6:53] brain to help them get better. It's beyond their control,
[6:56] beyond their agency. And, and, and, and that I think
[7:00] can make people worse because because people actually need
[7:04] their agency to get out of depression.
[7:06] And I just wanted to mention connected with something else
[7:09] you said on this subject. I did a study of the blogs of
[7:13] people who had depression online, which was, which was
[7:17] really interesting because many of them subscribed to this idea
[7:22] that they had a chemical imbalance and felt that.
[7:27] And, and, and often they said that this, you know, that
[7:30] adopting this understanding had been a relief, had been helpful
[7:33] to them, had made them feel that they weren't, you know, they
[7:35] weren't responsible. They weren't.
[7:37] They didn't have to feel guilty about.
[7:38] They were. Born that way, letting.
[7:40] People down something. Abnormal happened that meant
[7:42] they had lower levels of serotonin or what other whatever
[7:45] other chemical in their brain that had to be rectified, yes.
[7:48] Exactly so. So they often subscribe to this
[7:51] idea when they were talking about what they thought might,
[7:55] you know, might have caused their depression, but when they
[7:58] were talking about how they got better, some of them were taking
[8:01] antidepressants, but some of them weren't.
[8:02] But all of them, including the people who were taking
[8:05] antidepressants, emphasized the important role of their own
[8:09] agency in helping them to recover and how it what had been
[8:13] really helpful and crucial for them had been to look at their
[8:16] life, identify what was wrong with it and make changes.
[8:20] And, you know, people gave gave examples such as recognizing
[8:27] that they had been working very hard in a job that actually they
[8:30] didn't care about, wasn't really making them feel feel fulfilled,
[8:34] left their job or changed it in some way, did something that was
[8:38] more fulfilling and then felt much better about themselves and
[8:41] their lives. So I just thought it was very
[8:44] interesting that actually even people who were signed up to the
[8:48] idea that there there was some something biologically different
[8:51] about them were relying on their own agency when they were
[8:55] talking about how they got better.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
