# Veteran Criminal Prosecutor: How AI Is Changing Crime Forever - Benny Forer | #58

An episode of [The Next Generation](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1772698742), 25 Nov 2025, 1 h 32 min.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/107851968/podcast/play/111415483/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2025-10-19%2F412789225-44100-2-c06b25389e11.mp3

Benny Forer is a veteran criminal prosecutor with experience prosecuting cases ranging from narcotics offences to gang m*rders to complex white collar crime. Currently, as a member of the prestigious Cyber Crime Unit, his job focuses on complex technologically based crimes and s*x crimes, including ch*ld p*rnography, solicitations of min*rs and other cyber-s*x crimes.This production was made possible by DFI Rentals - book gear for your next shoot here: https://www.dfirentals.com/Subscribe to my Substack to see bonus questions and send in your own for future guests! https://elliotbewick.substack.com/CHAPTERS:00:00 How does AI affect justice?04:58 Can surveillance footage be manipulated by AI?06:43 Should AI child s*xual ab*se material be illegal?15:57 Why should humans and robots be given different rights?18:01 What new crimes will AI bring about?20:44 What do you think of vigilante groups like Anonymous?26:14 Is law downstream from morality, or morality downstream from law?29:26 Should we have a Digital Death Penalty?37:48 Do people have a right to be anonymous online?51:17 Could AI be used to predict future criminals?55:06 How does facial recognition on devices change the game?01:01:29 Would constant surveillance lead to safety or dystopia?01:12:58 Debating the importance of privacy01:26:17 Are you concerned about government overreach?01:29:48 Wrapping upMy Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotbewick/TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliotbewickX: https://x.com/elliotbewickABOUT THE NEXT GENERATION: In a world saturated by social media and marked by skyrocketing rates of anxiety, depression, and ADHD among Gen Z, young people are growing up in a landscape of chaos and contradiction. While protests swell in city streets and activists hurl soup at famous artworks to demand climate action, a quieter crisis unfolds within - the mental and emotional battles faced by a generation trying to make sense of it all.The Next Generation is hosted by 20-year-old Elliot Bewick, offering a raw and honest look at the world through the eyes of those living in it. Bringing together insight from professionals and young people on the ground, this podcast isn’t here to complain or chase clout. It’s here to bend the arc of the modern world towards solutions, truth and a love for the beautiful adventure of life itself.

## Transcript

[0:00] Benny Furrow, welcome to the next generation.
[0:02] Thank you. We're.
[0:03] Moving into a world governed by AI where anything can be faked
[0:08] digitally. Yes.
[0:10] How does this affect justice? Oh, that's a great that's a
[0:13] hugely broad, amazing question. 5-7 years ago I wrote an
[0:17] article, a published article about the coming deep fakes and
[0:21] how that how would we pursue it as a culture, as a society,
[0:24] because you can commit cause extensive harm to an
[0:28] individual's, a business or an individual's reputation.
[0:32] AI in the sense of how we could fake incidences, embarrass,
[0:38] humiliate or defame somebody is a huge going to be a huge issue.
[0:42] It's going on, it's going to be huge.
[0:44] But the flip side of AI is it's a wonderful tool.
[0:46] It's amazing. And in terms of helping us as
[0:50] government, doing certain acts would be incredibly impactful
[0:54] towards a lot of our work. That's the truth.
[0:56] So it's it's a very complex question, what you're asking.
[1:00] I think one of the key elements here at play is trust.
[1:03] Trust in institutions, trust in individuals, and trust in the
[1:07] information that you're being presented.
[1:08] And I like to think of it as these three waves of the
[1:12] Internet where first it was brand new and you couldn't trust
[1:16] it because it was this new thing, right?
[1:18] You had all this wisdom from books, so people tell you don't
[1:22] believe everything that you see on Google.
[1:24] Then you get into this second wave that we're kind of
[1:28] transitioning from now, where you take the first Google search
[1:32] as gospel or the first video on Twitter that you see as being
[1:36] true. But we're transitioning away
[1:39] from that because we're all becoming aware of these AI fakes
[1:43] and deep fakes like you're speaking about that have come
[1:45] through. So the third stage is looping
[1:48] back and it's the same as the first one.
[1:51] But it's not because the internet's underdeveloped and
[1:54] new. It's because it's had time to
[1:56] progress and the technology is so much more powerful that you
[2:00] can't trust anything again because there could be an AI
[2:04] video of you robbing a bank, and it's clearly you doing that.
[2:07] There's proof. So how is that going to affect
[2:12] our society going forwards? Well, I mean, I think, I think
[2:15] the, the point is, is everything cyclical in a way, like I, I, I,
[2:19] I start using AI extensively at work in, in both my jobs, I'm a
[2:23] District Attorney and a professor and I start using AI,
[2:26] realizing the value of the tool if used properly.
[2:29] And there's a lot of people, old schools, you know, professors or
[2:31] old school district attorneys, like, no, this is terrible.
[2:33] And I was like, well, you can be Luddites, right?
[2:36] You can fight the evolution of of technology, but can be left
[2:40] behind. So we'll always go through the
[2:43] that evolution in every stage of new technologies.
[2:47] And so this is just another stage.
[2:49] Like I always tell my students, like when the iPhone came out,
[2:53] it blew my freaking mind. Like truly blew my mind.
[2:56] I never envisioned something like this.
[2:58] I was that guy, right? Like, and so I remember my
[3:01] friend holding, I was a District Attorney already at the time it
[3:03] came out and I had my, my close friend had a Apple one or
[3:06] whatever it was. And I and I, I, I was like, you
[3:09] just touched the screen like and stuff moves like there's no
[3:12] joystick, there's no keypad. And it blows your mind.
[3:16] You're like, well, wow, this is crazy.
[3:18] I can't deal. I think this is the next major
[3:20] breakthrough, technological breakthrough.
[3:23] We're going to have to learn to adapt and learn how to use it.
[3:26] So yes, we have an increase in, in video, in body cameras, in
[3:31] imagery that we can help solve crime.
[3:34] Certainly this will give us a step back for a minute.
[3:38] The moments people start claiming that the evidence is
[3:41] not accurate, it's not real and there's a place to say that, but
[3:46] we'll, we'll adjust. I've no doubt about them.
[3:47] Not intelligent enough to know we're, but I think we will,
[3:50] we'll figure out those methodologies of where we can
[3:53] figure out the fakeness of a, of a piece of evidence or not.
[3:57] But in terms of like a using AI for problem solving, for
[4:00] prediction, predictive modeling, things like that.
[4:03] Again, we can discuss the efficacy of it or the, the value
[4:06] of it, but I, I, well, not the value.
[4:07] I think the value is it going to be immense?
[4:09] Like it's going to be immense. It's going to be our, our world,
[4:12] our universe is going to be changing in the next 10 years
[4:14] immensely because of AI. And I think overwhelmingly
[4:17] positive, but like everything else, there's an incredible
[4:19] negative. I, as a prosecutor, prosecute
[4:22] some cybercrime and part of cybercrime is online sex abuse,
[4:26] right? We can criticize the Internet
[4:28] for the proliferation of incredible amounts of harmful
[4:31] data, but we would all agree that the Internet is the most
[4:34] incredible thing in humankind, right?
[4:36] So I think it's it's unbelievable.
[4:39] It's obviously used for negative and used for criminality, but
[4:41] the overwhelmingness. So same thing with AII think
[4:44] that's some of some of us, some people are taking a very, very
[4:47] cautious approach or very and I think that's nice, but you're
[4:52] not, you're not stopping the freight train.
[4:54] So let's embrace and let's figure out the methods.
[4:57] So we'll see. I don't know yet.
[4:59] Well, talk to me more about this tango that's going on between
[5:02] the progression of surveillance and body cams versus the
[5:05] limitations. Knowing that these can now be
[5:08] faked as footage. What are you actually dealing
[5:10] with on the ground as AD? As ADA?
[5:14] So in actuality, we're not. That's the truth.
[5:17] It always takes time for the criminals to do their thing and
[5:21] then for us to catch up to us. I always say laws very reactive
[5:24] and responsive to incidents that occur.
[5:26] It's not proactive, hence my my. But like I mentioned at the
[5:29] beginning of the interview, my article on deepfakes, I saw it
[5:32] coming for whatever reasons. Side note, I was tipped off by
[5:35] the Secret Service about the issue of deepfakes.
[5:37] Secret Service came to me and asked me to look into it because
[5:40] movie studios were concerned. So when it comes to find
[5:42] finance, they were concerned that someone's going to derail
[5:44] the release of a movie. We're here in LA, someone
[5:47] produces a deep fake of their major star doing something
[5:50] really bad. So this is going back seven
[5:52] years. They came to me and said, hey,
[5:54] Benny, would you look into this? And that's why I start looking
[5:56] into it. So it wasn't my brilliance and
[5:58] being on top of the game. But the idea is is right?
[6:01] It came to me and I was like, wow, that's a real issue.
[6:03] And then I discovered there's no law about deepfakes and, and our
[6:07] legislature, California legislature was not interested
[6:10] in producing a law. I tried to write legislation,
[6:12] they said no. So the question is, could we
[6:13] deal with it as from a prosecutorial perspective, using
[6:17] other laws to achieve the same goal.
[6:19] So the same thing with like AI. I'm not seeing AI on the ground
[6:23] yet in terms of like deepfaking a body Cam because I do think we
[6:29] have a traceable methodology to that.
[6:31] So that's what like me say there's an officer who will
[6:33] ultimately authenticate that this is the body Cam that that
[6:36] that observed what they physically observed and that
[6:39] like anything could be true or not true, but they subject to
[6:42] cross examination, stuff like that.
[6:44] The issue we're seeing in AI is AI modeling on the easy example,
[6:48] AI models of child pornography. How are we going to deal with
[6:51] that where people have AI generated contraband and is that
[6:58] legal or illegal? Whatever.
[7:00] California did pass a law pertaining to that, but I'm
[7:02] testing it right now as we speak.
[7:03] I have an, I have an AI case where we caught a guy with
[7:08] numerous videos of computer generated child pornography,
[7:11] adult men raping children. But they're not real, right?
[7:15] It's not a real victim. It's not a real human being.
[7:17] It's an AI generated model. How do we deal with that?
[7:20] And and so I'm trying to file a test case to see how our courts
[7:24] are going to deal with that actually as we speak well.
[7:27] No doubt about this with me, and please go into full depth.
[7:30] I can imagine that there's one argument where you could
[7:33] potentially go, why don't we allow this?
[7:37] Because it's not real and it's letting these people live out
[7:40] their sick fantasies without harming an actual person.
[7:45] And then there's where I land, which is intuitively going but
[7:48] this is still fucked up and we don't encourage this.
[7:51] This should be illegal surely just based on knee jerk reaction
[7:54] here. So let's let's nerd out about
[7:56] it. So years ago under the George W
[7:59] Bush administration and Donald Rumsfeld, Rumsfeld was the
[8:02] attorney general, we try to create an AI law.
[8:05] But the feds did. They try to create an AI law
[8:07] saying possession of AI generated child pornography is
[8:09] illegal and it was struck down by the Supreme Court of the
[8:12] United States. The idea behind it was like
[8:14] this. Look, the the we have a First
[8:16] Amendment that allows us to speak and engage in any way.
[8:20] The only time we can prohibit the First Amendment, that is
[8:23] prevent someone from speaking or engaging in action is we have to
[8:27] have basically what we might call a compelling government
[8:29] interest. So any piece of child
[8:34] pornographer, real child pornography involves the
[8:36] necessarily involves the actual harm to a child and what you're
[8:40] viewing is crime scene in evidence, right?
[8:42] We, we might call it. So in that case, the compelling
[8:45] interest in prohibiting possession of child pornography
[8:48] is the preventing of a child being harmed.
[8:50] Now the person might say, well, I didn't harm the child, someone
[8:52] else did. I'm just viewing that you're
[8:53] like, well, there's a compelling interest in not being prevented
[8:56] from being disposed, used or passed around.
[8:59] When it came to AI, the Supreme Court said, well, there's no
[9:01] interest, no child's being harmed, right?
[9:04] So there's, so you're right, there's no interest.
[9:06] Now Fast forward 25 years later, we're looking at this and seeing
[9:10] actual computer generated imagery happening and we're
[9:13] trying to figure out how do we figure, how do we deal with
[9:15] that? We also have side note, again to
[9:18] totally nerd out, we have obscenity statues.
[9:21] The Supreme Court has never held that obscenity is protected by
[9:24] the 1st Amendment. OK, so pornography is protected
[9:26] by the 1st Amendment. Engaging whatever weird ass
[9:29] behavior you want to engage in is protected, but obscenity is
[9:32] not What's obscenity? That's a question, right?
[9:34] Obscenity is they've defined as something that has no, no real,
[9:39] no social value at all and and doesn't doesn't appeal to any
[9:43] pure interest of human beings. And it's kind of like a loose
[9:46] terminology of it. So we've created AAI generated
[9:50] child pornography laws under the guise of obscenity.
[9:53] We're going to call it obscenity because AI generate porn in and
[9:56] of itself might not be. The bigger issue is, is if I,
[9:59] I'll give you an example. Many years ago, someone tipped
[10:01] me off about and I actually have a screenshot somewhere on my
[10:04] computer of this, which was someone took me off that on
[10:07] Amazon, they were selling child sex dolls.
[10:11] And I actually had found it and I took a screenshot of it and it
[10:14] was like 7 year old girl sex doll.
[10:18] Is that wrong? Well, Amazon pulled it down the
[10:20] moment they got notified of it. Obviously they pulled down.
[10:22] It's not in their business interest to have that being
[10:24] sold. But is that wrong?
[10:25] Can I possess that? And, and the answer is probably
[10:29] yes, unfortunately right. Like your your first statement
[10:31] was the same thing with like child pornography.
[10:34] If I create a computer generated image in my own home and I'm
[10:38] using it for my own sick fantasies, I guess it's
[10:42] protected. You can engage in whatever you
[10:44] want to do in in your home. Again, as long as no one's being
[10:46] harmed, no physical human being is being harmed.
[10:49] We the government don't have interest.
[10:51] The the question is as if I distribute it, now all of a
[10:55] sudden a secondary person's being affected by that.
[10:58] I don't want to say harm. They're not.
[10:59] Once I'm distributing, I'm creating a marketplace for this
[11:02] stuff and therefore what I call obscenity.
[11:04] So that's kind of where we're going with it.
[11:05] To be technical with the whole thing, we're kind of going down
[11:09] these obscenity statutes and saying, well, you can't share
[11:12] it. We can prevent the government
[11:14] can prohibit people from sharing, but possessing itself,
[11:17] you can do whatever weird shit you want to do.
[11:20] So that's kind of where it is. So you're right, there is an
[11:23] instinct to say live out your sick fantasy and don't harm a
[11:25] child. And that is a certain instinct.
[11:28] And this is now anecdotal, not legal.
[11:30] But anecdotally, having been in ADA for 20 years and dealing
[11:33] with a lot of sort of stuff, the proliferation of sick fantasy to
[11:39] reality has increasing with the access to the Internet.
[11:43] So I always try to talk about this idea of like early in the
[11:46] early days of, of criminality, you know, if a, if a person
[11:49] wanted access to this sort of contraband, it was hard to get,
[11:53] you had to know some creep who knew some creep who can get you
[11:56] a magazine. Nowadays you just go online,
[11:59] it's there, it's on Instagram, it's on Twitter, it's traded on
[12:01] Kik and Snapchat. I've got cases from all those
[12:04] places. And in a way, I think, again,
[12:09] not a psychologist, not a psychiatrist, but I think
[12:11] anecdotally that the access to could trigger interest in.
[12:17] So before, and it wasn't an access, it was a dormant sort of
[12:19] vice that you might have had that you weren't aware of.
[12:22] And now that we have the Internet, I'm, we're seeing like
[12:24] our child pornography prosecutions have increased
[12:28] exponentially since, you know, the 90s to today.
[12:31] And, and, and that obviously makes sense because it's being
[12:32] traded, but like, I don't truly believe there were that many
[12:35] people viewing child pornography in 1990 as they are today,
[12:39] right? And, and that, so that's a
[12:40] problem, right? The internet's giving access to
[12:42] that and maybe triggering a, a, a dormant interest in something
[12:47] and creating this, this fantasy or whatever it is.
[12:49] So that's a problem. And now we're just trying to
[12:53] track this information and it's, it's overwhelming.
[12:56] I, I, if you want me get in a little detail on that, that we
[12:58] can go nuts on that, but it is am I allowed to wear on a spot?
[13:02] It's. Fucking bananas.
[13:04] How many people have watched child pornography?
[13:06] It's insanity. It's terrifying.
[13:08] How are they accessing that? It's everywhere.
[13:12] So you have multiple different sites that that that exist in
[13:15] different ways or methods of trading or terminology that's
[13:18] being used. And so you might have known.
[13:21] We have like millions and millions of what we call known
[13:25] images, that is images that we already know who the child is,
[13:29] they've been tracked down. We have this international
[13:31] organization that that operates and keeps track of every single
[13:34] thing. And so we know who they are.
[13:36] And then there's there's a lot of groups like clubs, like a
[13:39] little while ago, federal government shut down the child
[13:41] pornography site that in order to access the child pornography
[13:44] on the site, you have to produce your own.
[13:47] That was your in, right? It's like snorting a line of
[13:50] cocaine so you can buy the coke, right?
[13:52] It's sort of like that, right? Like it's they had to submit
[13:55] their own new imagery that was vetted by the administrators of
[14:00] this dark website. And then you you then knowing
[14:03] that you're a predator yourself, you had access to their
[14:05] predatory stuff. You have to incriminate yourself
[14:07] to get into the criminal circles.
[14:09] And then you can get access to all this other people self
[14:12] creating child pornography. So there's that.
[14:16] But we're we're seeing there's a method to track a lot of the
[14:19] known child pornography online and we are tracking a lot of it.
[14:22] We can see it live like there's, there's live trading of
[14:27] Troponarfy and it's just it, it's overwhelming.
[14:30] We don't, haven't, we don't have enough human beings in the world
[14:33] to prosecute the cases. So every so often we do what we
[14:36] do, we do just like, it's like, it's like sampling a, a, you
[14:40] know, a bottle of Pepsi that just came out of the factory.
[14:43] We take one right to hopefully discourage the rest of them by
[14:46] which we test 1. So we might go in and just do
[14:48] different operations every so often and just grab whatever we
[14:51] can and then hopefully it scares more people.
[14:54] Well, I want us to talk more about how prominent these videos
[14:58] are online, and it's shocking you see a platform like Pornhub
[15:01] taking down 9,000,000 out of the 12 million videos they have on
[15:05] their website. You know that 9 million of 12
[15:07] million, is that true? Is that 3/4 was was contraband?
[15:12] They didn't. I know they took down somebody
[15:14] who knows that many. They didn't know confirmed, but
[15:16] they didn't have proof that it wasn't bad.
[15:19] But for now, I want to follow this breadcrumb trail of leaping
[15:24] from you, being able to do whatever you want with AI when
[15:26] you're by yourself, but potentially being able to
[15:30] incriminate someone that's then imposing it on others.
[15:33] It kind of doesn't check out logically.
[15:36] Someone's not committing a crime when it's for themself and then
[15:41] suddenly is a crime imposing this non criminal thing on
[15:44] someone else. And there's a deeper question
[15:48] there to be had about why it actually matters that these
[15:54] images are AI versus real and human.
[15:58] And I think this is the big question that we're going to
[16:00] have to unpack as humans with AI emerging, is what on earth
[16:05] actually gives us our human rights and what makes us
[16:08] different to these robots? Oh, that's, that's an incredible
[16:13] question. I mean, we, we from an American
[16:16] perspective, right? We look at the Bill of Rights in
[16:19] the Constitution as not something that the government
[16:22] has given us a right to exist. It's something that is
[16:26] inalienable to us. That is, it is natural to any
[16:30] human society and it should exist.
[16:32] And no one should be able to with take it away from you.
[16:34] So it's not the government saying you have the right to
[16:37] free speech. It's us.
[16:38] We do factually have the right to free speech.
[16:40] You can only limited in unique circumstances.
[16:43] And so that's where the beginning of this sort of idea
[16:46] that that we're talking about comes from is like, yes, I have
[16:49] an inalienable right to we're Nazi uniform, right?
[16:54] Like, I mean, just whatever it is, like I do have a right to do
[16:57] that. I have a right to engage or have
[17:00] whatever belief system I want. The the question is, is what
[17:04] does the government have a right to suppress that or not when it
[17:10] comes to you as an individual? It's less important than when
[17:12] the government when it comes to the secondary individual, which
[17:14] is the government then may have an obligation to protect its
[17:18] citizens from you. And therefore that that's that's
[17:22] where it might step in. But as far as you as an
[17:24] individual, you have like with very little limitation, you have
[17:29] rights to just exist, exist in any manner and form you want to
[17:32] exist in, right. So the, the, the, that is kind
[17:35] of the idea of the 1st amendment is I have the right to think and
[17:38] act for myself. The question is when you're
[17:40] impacting others. And now all of a sudden the
[17:42] government can step in because ultimately, in my opinion, the
[17:45] most basic role of government is to protect society, you from
[17:50] yourself or society from you. So that's where government role
[17:54] it is. But me to the exclusion of
[17:56] government, they have no right to step in as a general rule.
[18:00] Does that make sense? So I guess it's not really
[18:05] people trying to falsify crimes and incriminate others that
[18:10] aren't criminals, it's criminals who are perpetuating their own
[18:14] crimes and indulging in more excess now that they can fake
[18:19] certain fantasies. Do you see that going forward as
[18:22] being the main use of AI? Or do you think we will spill
[18:26] into me wanting to screw you over because I want to take your
[18:29] job position and incriminating you for something you didn't do?
[18:32] In my opinion, the advancement of technology is often pushed by
[18:36] pure by by perverse interests. I know I mean perverse and like
[18:39] you're disgusting. I mean just non traditional
[18:42] interests. So for example, before I went to
[18:45] law school, I worked for Worldcom, an international
[18:48] Internet company at the time. Lost a ton of money anyway and
[18:52] the the best sellers, this is in the 90's, the late 90s, early
[18:55] 2000. The best the salespeople.
[18:57] I was a salesperson selling Internet access for massive
[19:01] companies and it was lucrative job, but the people made the
[19:05] most money were people selling Internet to porn companies.
[19:09] Porn companies. If you can get a Web Web hosting
[19:12] of a porn site, you were doing amazing as a businessman, as a
[19:16] salesperson. Unfortunately, that pushes a lot
[19:20] of technology. A lot of things happen like you
[19:22] look at like Napster, do you know, like BitTorrent, Napster,
[19:24] those sort of peer-to-peer networking?
[19:27] Yeah, it was early on. It starts off, oh, this is a
[19:29] great way to share my music, right with one other.
[19:31] I like this album. I like this artist.
[19:33] I want to see one of those in their songs and quickly devolves
[19:36] and degenerates into pornography and which quickly devolves into
[19:39] the child pornography arena. And then that pushes regulation
[19:42] on things. Yeah, I think that the early
[19:45] days of the Internet or or websites, World Wide Web was
[19:49] just people just trying to make some little impact of their own
[19:53] on society, create something. But then it's sort of clarifies
[19:57] and ultimately the financially motivated criminal gets
[20:02] involved. So online pranks or hacks, the
[20:06] early hacks of Internet or of whatever it was, were more prank
[20:11] than financially motivated. Today they're totally
[20:14] financially motivated with some prank, right with some like
[20:17] white hat cracker groups, let's say anonymous if we've heard of
[20:21] anonymous like I, but they're the exclusion.
[20:23] The majority is so same things like this.
[20:25] I think that we're in the early stages of this AI and the
[20:28] negative use of AII think it's we'll start off with
[20:30] pornography. I think we'll devolve into real
[20:33] capability of of of creating financial incentive for people.
[20:38] So, yeah, I mean, that's a really interesting question and
[20:41] I think it will go down that path and that's that's when real
[20:44] regulation will start happening. What do you think to these
[20:47] vigilante groups like Anonymous taking justice into their own
[20:50] acts? It's complex.
[20:52] I teach anonymous in one of my classes.
[20:54] I mean, it's very complex. Like many other many radical
[20:57] groups that may have started off.
[20:59] I'm going to talk about I'm going to be controversial for
[21:01] five seconds, like the Black Panthers, for example, right.
[21:04] We've all heard of the Black Panthers.
[21:05] We've romanticized the Black Panthers in the early days of
[21:08] the Black Panthers. It's hard to argue with their
[21:11] platform agenda and perspective. We can, we can discuss whether I
[21:15] agree or disagree with what their attitude was, but it's
[21:18] it's an admirable place to to start.
[21:20] That is to protect African American people from police
[21:23] brutality. Why not?
[21:24] That's great, that's wonderful. If you could, that's amazing
[21:26] idea. But when you devolve into
[21:28] committing actual murder and bombings and get engaging,
[21:32] that's the thing with some of these organizations.
[21:34] Anonymous is theoretically great, but when you take into
[21:38] account your own moral value system without a checks and
[21:43] balances, without a value system in place, without a leadership
[21:47] sort of perspective, then you inevitably get perverted in the
[21:51] perspective that that you might be engaging in.
[21:53] So I hope they do good work. But you're basing it solely on
[21:57] the morals of some anonymous or group of anonymous individuals
[22:00] who you don't know their value systems, right?
[22:04] Even at the worst case scenario, we know government's value
[22:07] system and we vote on it. We might disagree with it,
[22:09] right? We might abhor it, we might
[22:11] dislike it. But if you live in a democracy,
[22:13] we know who our government is at the very least, and we can
[22:15] change opinions. It's all very muddy and
[22:19] especially what fascinates me is this intersection between law,
[22:25] justice, our morality, which perhaps we can speak about is is
[22:29] derived from something like judeo-christian values more than
[22:32] we think it is. And when it is acceptable to
[22:36] take matters into your own hands if you don't feel that the
[22:41] government's doing a good enough job of upholding those
[22:44] inalienable rights that you are meant to have.
[22:47] Oh, that's such a tough question because it discusses an idea of
[22:50] like, right? You're you're discussing
[22:52] philosophical ideas of where morality lies in the passage of
[22:57] law, and it presumes morality in law enforcement in their desire
[23:01] to pass law for the benefit of society.
[23:03] And it presumes many things, generally speaking.
[23:08] Many, many years ago, a student, early years of teaching, a
[23:10] student said to me along the lines of he said, you know,
[23:14] China will never surpass the United States.
[23:18] He was a Chinese national student and I was like, why?
[23:22] Like there's, there's so much more production than us, so many
[23:25] more people. And he said because we, we're,
[23:26] we're a country of law. They're not.
[23:29] And he says the, the moment when you have law that regulates and
[23:32] organizes and, and people follow, then you have a, you
[23:36] have a system that works. The other system could have
[23:39] highs and lows, but it will constantly devolve and there's
[23:44] no incentives for certain things.
[23:45] Creative incentives don't exist if you don't protect creative
[23:49] creativity, right? So patent, copyright, trademark,
[23:53] etcetera, laws that we might have, then they don't have as or
[23:56] or don't have as robust as us or don't really care about it.
[23:58] You'll lose the people quickly lose incentive if they don't
[24:01] have an incentive to create. It's an interesting concept.
[24:05] I don't know that that's not my area of expertise.
[24:07] But what I do know is so long as we recognize the general value
[24:11] of laws, that they are good and intended for our betterment, and
[24:16] we follow those laws, and to the extent we disagree with law, we
[24:19] elect legislators who will change that or fix it, then
[24:24] we're running in a good place. The moment we start to devalue
[24:27] government entirely and start totally distrusting government
[24:31] or totally distrusting laws, then all of a sudden you're in a
[24:33] place where there's chaos, chaos reigns.
[24:36] And we don't know what is or what isn't right.
[24:38] So, for example, some of these groups, again, to get totally,
[24:41] completely, utterly controversial, some of those
[24:43] groups that talk about like tearing down the criminal
[24:46] justice system, we need to start over.
[24:48] And, and my question for them, when they bring that up to me,
[24:52] the students, wherever we go. OK, starting with what?
[24:55] Like, yeah, OK, you think the system's broken and bad, and
[24:58] that's fantastic. Let's let's fix it.
[25:00] Where you starting? Tommy Doe shall not kill.
[25:04] Do we agree with that one? So we're going to keep that one
[25:06] on the books. Don't steal.
[25:07] OK, We're going to keep that one on the books.
[25:09] Don't kidnap. We should keep that the 10
[25:10] commandments. That's where we're starting.
[25:11] You know what I'm saying? It's like that's the point is
[25:13] like, what exactly are you talking about?
[25:15] And when you want to just tear down, then you don't have a
[25:17] structure in place. And that's my, my general
[25:19] concern when we talk about like law and morality, Our, our, our
[25:22] value system is derived from history and from the value
[25:27] system that the country was traded one on.
[25:30] And the perspectives that were there.
[25:31] We have, even though we're westernized democracies,
[25:34] England, Australian and, and the United States have varying
[25:38] values within the same range, but we have very varying values.
[25:42] We don't appreciate the, the, the, the British colonialist
[25:47] sort of countries, Canada, the the Commonwealth, they don't
[25:50] appreciate the 1st Amendment like the Americans do it.
[25:54] It's almost like they considered a grant of government, whereas
[25:56] we consider it's inalienable and the government can't take it
[25:59] away. We're looking at it from totally
[26:01] different perspective. We're to looking at it from the
[26:02] individual, you're looking at it from the government.
[26:04] So it's an interesting thing. I mean, in that sense.
[26:06] But even with all those different values, we're going to
[26:09] come up with certain types of moralistic based perspectives on
[26:14] crime and justice. Sat here at this podcast table
[26:18] in 2025. Do you think that our laws are
[26:21] more downstream from morality, or that our morality is more
[26:24] downstream from our laws? I don't understand the question.
[26:26] What do you mean downstream? Do the laws that we impose
[26:31] through government and potentially small circles at the
[26:33] top deciding how we should govern right, affect our moral,
[26:40] more personal understandings of the world?
[26:43] Or is it that our personal agreed upon morals have more
[26:48] weight than we would think on the laws that we have decided?
[26:52] I see the point. It's it's very hard to decide.
[26:54] I think historically the westernized philosophy and value
[27:00] system came from a judeo-christian values like the
[27:03] Bible does say don't kill. But I think most human societies
[27:07] figure that out on their own, right?
[27:09] We'd call that just a rational law.
[27:10] It's not, it's not a religious based law.
[27:13] We understand that as a value system, but there are laws
[27:17] within that morality, moral value system that do come down
[27:20] to us. I don't know, let's just say
[27:22] don't torture an animal, right? Why not?
[27:27] I mean, why not, right? Like it, it doesn't have
[27:29] feelings. It's not a human being and it
[27:30] doesn't have feelings. Same way people can make that
[27:32] argument. But we would understand that in
[27:36] in our society, that's important.
[27:38] We we have animal cruelty laws, right?
[27:40] Like if someone's torturing a dog, you're like, what?
[27:42] We would be furious and and rightfully so.
[27:45] How dare you? But but we someone may argue
[27:49] that's a moralistic law, right? Comes from a moral value system
[27:53] in other cultures. They might not appreciate that
[27:55] in the same way. So is that colored by biblical
[27:58] texts that say don't torture animals, right.
[28:01] Well, it's hard to trace any, any number of things.
[28:03] But we do know that we colored our, our environmental society 1
[28:07] nation under God, right? That sort of idea that exists
[28:09] with a certain moral value system that that may evolve and
[28:13] change, but that is the basis of, of Americanism or
[28:17] westernized ideologies may be the basis of those moral value
[28:21] systems that we've seen in, in the Judeo-christian system, or I
[28:24] would say Islamic as well in those sort of systems of, of how
[28:28] we should treat humanity or each other or animals or property or
[28:32] all those things. So there is certainly,
[28:33] definitely a moral, moralistic value system that we exist or we
[28:37] have in our, in our society. One of the first things I teach
[28:40] is about privacy law. And I talk about privacy law in
[28:44] the context of the Bible. Like what, what the Bible didn't
[28:48] have technology, but did they understand the idea of privacy?
[28:51] And there is, there is multiple instances across the Bible,
[28:53] which shows perspectives and appreciation for individual
[28:58] privacy, for cultural privacy, for the, you know, the physical
[29:03] engagement. So there's many different
[29:04] aspects where the Bible talks about those sort of things.
[29:07] And, and that extends to the New Testament and the Quran as well.
[29:10] And, and even, you know, Greek history and Roman history has
[29:14] has systems like that as well, but I think they're derived from
[29:17] the same. We're now in a digital world.
[29:19] We're in the information age. So there was a total ramble.
[29:23] I I don't know what the hell I just said that.
[29:24] Wasn't a ramble. Actually, this is great.
[29:27] We're in digital age. Yeah, go.
[29:28] We're in the digital age, and I would argue that social media
[29:33] governs reality more than reality governing social media
[29:36] at this point. People before in the past have
[29:41] been very strongly advocate advocating the death penalty.
[29:45] And I know it's still in place in some states in America.
[29:48] And now what do you think to the concept of something like a
[29:52] digital death penalty, where you've committed crimes online
[29:57] or you've used the Internet irresponsibly and you're not
[30:00] going to be put to death physically in corporeal form,
[30:04] but for life, you get this ban from the Internet where you're
[30:08] not trusted to use it. Several questions for that.
[30:11] It's a fascinating idea. How do you enforce that?
[30:18] I suppose it would take even more tracking of people's use of
[30:22] technology, and to buy a phone you'd have to bring your
[30:24] passport. So it's the.
[30:25] So let's back up. It's the removal of privacy of
[30:28] the individual, right? That's what it is.
[30:30] It's saying you're not going to have privacy anymore because in
[30:33] order to right implementation's very difficult.
[30:36] That could be certainly a negative and a very impactfully
[30:42] negative attitude. However, putting aside those
[30:47] crimes, like I think people in jail have an Internet ban,
[30:51] right? So you know what I'm saying?
[30:52] It's like if you're spending life in prison for murder, you
[30:54] have an Internet ban. But what if you you view child
[30:56] pornography? Do you deserve to be impacted by
[31:00] that action for the rest of your life?
[31:02] That's the bigger question, right?
[31:04] Yeah. How do we look at crime and
[31:05] punishment and should you be punished for yourself?
[31:07] Certainly. I will tell you with that part
[31:10] of our agreements, when people are released on bail or people
[31:14] plead guilty, we have prohibitions on their use of
[31:17] Internet in certain ways. We can't totally prohibit it.
[31:20] You have a First Amendment right to engage with another member of
[31:23] society in a legal manner to do to conduct business or things
[31:26] like that. So you're taking away certain
[31:28] basic rights when we talk about that right, My First Amendment
[31:31] right to speech, my First Amendment right to press, my
[31:34] First Amendment right to assembly, you're taking that
[31:36] away and for a lifetime impact, that's number one.
[31:39] And then number 2 is how, how far do we do we impact somebody?
[31:45] Like in my opinion, yeah, I would like child pornography,
[31:48] possession of child pornography to like be a life in prison.
[31:52] But practically, that's not a practical result, right?
[31:54] I understand. My my, the legislatures aren't
[31:56] going to do that. In California, possession of
[31:58] child pornography is a maximum of three years maximum.
[32:02] So should he be impacted for life?
[32:06] 20 year old looks at child pornography, has 10 images on
[32:09] their phone. We prosecute them.
[32:11] Let's presume they get the maximum three years in prison,
[32:13] which never happens. But let's say so for the next 80
[32:16] years of their life they should have no Internet access.
[32:19] Is that is that fair? Is that justice?
[32:22] I guess what interests me is taking the Internet from this
[32:27] tool and it seems that you would be closer to the side of
[32:31] actually almost bringing it into this inalienable right?
[32:35] It is. How so?
[32:37] Well, because it's not just because anything that exists in
[32:40] society is, is inalienable that the government shouldn't be able
[32:43] to take away from us. I can walk down the street.
[32:44] The government shouldn't be able to prevent me.
[32:46] Are there times and places? And look, can I have a
[32:48] restraining order against somebody?
[32:50] Prohibit. Sure, There's but there's time
[32:52] and space. I can't say you're prohibited
[32:53] from walking down the street. Anything that's created in
[32:57] society is is society's use. The government can only restrict
[33:00] it to the extent they have an interest in restricting it.
[33:02] You don't have a right to sit there and say you can't use the
[33:05] Internet to talk to your mother. Why?
[33:08] What's a your business government.
[33:10] It's so yes, every every platform is a creation of a
[33:13] place where I can speak right. The First Amendment says in our
[33:16] right and in the way we look at it as Americans is we have a
[33:19] right to get. The government shall not create
[33:22] any laws infringing the freedom of religion, the establishment
[33:26] of religion, the freedoms to practice, the freedom of speech,
[33:29] the freedom of the press. We have a right.
[33:32] And the Internet's just another platform, another variation of
[33:36] speech. And so, yes, if I want to have
[33:38] an assembly right, the Constitution says we have the
[33:41] right to free, freely assemble. If I want to assembly, it
[33:44] doesn't have to be physical. It can be virtual.
[33:45] I have a group of people. We believe in the devil, and we
[33:48] want to have a meeting online and talk about our dark belief.
[33:51] Why not? Yeah.
[33:53] So yes, government preventing you from accessing is certainly
[33:55] infringing on your ability to speak.
[33:59] I suppose it's difficult because you could do some sort of
[34:01] digital restraining order, but the point is that the people
[34:05] were accessing these sites that are already illegal.
[34:08] So to interrupt you for a second is that we do this sometimes
[34:11] federal feds are much better at this, but we can place tracking
[34:15] softwares on your on your various electronic device that
[34:18] prohibit you from going certain places.
[34:20] What if someone just buys a new iPhone?
[34:24] Correct. I mean, you say you're right,
[34:26] there's limitations to any sort of oversight of anybody.
[34:30] Just like we can put someone on probation or parole for
[34:34] committing a crime, they can still go out and commit a crime
[34:37] separately where we don't know about it.
[34:39] But but the point is, is that we'll place hindrances on you to
[34:42] prevent you from whatever it is right.
[34:45] And there there's various legal methodology, like for example,
[34:48] when people are on probation or parole in our system, they have
[34:50] to give up any rights they have in terms of search and seizure.
[34:54] So a, a, a parole officer, probation officer can go on to,
[34:58] can go into this criminal's house, search their devices, and
[35:02] if you find contraband, they'll be put in prison immediately
[35:06] like that. So we do have that ability to
[35:08] check on it in a way. And we, we, and maybe there's
[35:10] greater or lesser oversight that we have to figure out, but we do
[35:13] have that sort of ability. But human beings are human
[35:15] beings. They can bypass anything at any
[35:17] time right there. There's only so much we can do
[35:19] as government. We balance regulation with
[35:21] freedom, right? And we don't want over
[35:23] regulation. Yeah, and I guess it's so hard
[35:26] to put a digital ankle tag on someone because an ankle tag,
[35:30] you can't just cut off your leg and buy a new one, whereas you
[35:34] can buy a new phone. But you could to cut off your
[35:37] ankle monitor. People do, and you have to make.
[35:40] Stronger ankle tags. I'm just saying, like you see,
[35:43] I'm saying that people do do that.
[35:44] So yeah, there, there's various ways we can figure out like give
[35:50] you an example, like we do a lot of in Los Angeles, we do with
[35:52] wiretaps. We're tapping your phones.
[35:55] We're listening into major drug dealing core organizations.
[36:00] Those organizations are billion dollar businesses.
[36:02] They're smarter than us. They have more money than us.
[36:05] How do we keep tracking them? Right?
[36:07] They may, they're the, if I'm a smart, the drug dealer, I'm, I'm
[36:10] using a burner phone every single few hours.
[36:12] How's the government going to keep a wiretap?
[36:14] But we have methods. I'll give you 1 method, little
[36:18] tip. Criminals tend to call their mom
[36:21] a lot. If I know your mom's phone
[36:23] number and I see a new phone number coming in, I know your
[36:25] new phone number, your girlfriend, your mom, somebody,
[36:31] right? So let's just say you have
[36:32] you're working on a burner phone and I know that you call your
[36:34] mom. So I have your mom's number at
[36:36] the moment. I see a new number coming in.
[36:38] I know that's the new number for the burner phone.
[36:41] Easy life example. Where'd you go from there with
[36:45] that information? Then I'll immediately get the
[36:47] wiretap onto the new phone. I'll switch it over within
[36:51] within within minutes. I'll because I'm working on the
[36:53] phone companies at this time, I can just switch it over.
[36:55] So you call your mom everyday or a lot of criminals call their
[36:58] girlfriend, their mom, whatever, their sister, who cares?
[37:00] Some close relative and I have their information and I'm
[37:02] tapping their phones for the sake of getting your number.
[37:05] Then the moment I see a new random number coming in that's
[37:07] answered right, then I know, well, that's a good chance
[37:11] that's that new phone number. I mean, we can look at certain
[37:13] statistics, like depending on the length of the call, decide
[37:15] like we all now ignore unknown numbers on our phones, right?
[37:18] I do most people too. If the phone's answered and
[37:21] you're talking for two minutes, 3 minutes, it's probably not a
[37:25] not a solicitor, right? So then I then there's a good
[37:28] likelihood that's your phone number.
[37:29] Now I know your new phone number.
[37:30] Now I can switch the tap to that phone number.
[37:32] Listen in. Oh, it's the right guy.
[37:33] Oh, it's the wrong thing. Cut it off.
[37:35] But that's an easy low level method.
[37:37] There's a lot of other methods. What are the other methods?
[37:40] I don't know. There's a lot I don't know.
[37:42] I will tell you there's a lot I don't know and or nor could say,
[37:45] but there's there's experienced professional wiretap people who
[37:49] know how to do this. Something I've been talking
[37:52] about a lot over the last few years to friends and just unable
[37:56] to pin down, being unable to pin down is the fact that the
[38:00] Internet, it's a very easy place to spread hate on.
[38:05] And I don't mean this in a virtue signally words of
[38:10] violence type way. It just is easier, there's less
[38:14] friction and importantly, there are less consequences, right?
[38:18] If I say something about your mother to your face.
[38:20] Now, although we are granted sitting at a big table, you may
[38:23] still lean over it and punch me in the face.
[38:25] Whereas online I have the key thing of anonymity to hide
[38:30] behind. So with that comes more
[38:34] controversy, more people rage baiting and engaging in
[38:39] activities that ultimately, in my opinion, take society in the
[38:43] wrong direction, take us away from flourishing.
[38:45] How do we solve that? Well, that's so good.
[38:48] I love this question. Continue.
[38:49] Yeah. Potential thing here is ID.
[38:53] To sign up to Twitter, you need to verify your ID and your
[38:57] username is unique. It's your full name, followed by
[39:02] your birthday. Whatever.
[39:04] Now am I pitching that as an idea?
[39:07] Obviously not, because there are loads of problems with having to
[39:11] have ID given to any social media platform.
[39:14] So I want you to help me out here.
[39:16] How do we limit this detachment from morality, this anonymity
[39:20] that protects people and protects trolls, whilst also not
[39:23] infringing on our freedom and our rights?
[39:26] So let's get something out. First clear is that I do believe
[39:29] anonymity is a fundamental right, right?
[39:31] Like just going I have the right to choose to be anonymous,
[39:34] however. So let's let's back up for a
[39:36] second. People get a lot of worried
[39:37] about this. And I really love this because I
[39:39] love history. I'm a real fan of history.
[39:41] So I in the early days of the printing press, for example,
[39:46] let's even go further back. You follow, you know, the
[39:48] Crusades at all. Yeah, during the crusade period
[39:51] there were various absolute lunatics that people marched
[39:56] behind with a banner with the purposes of slaughtering non
[40:01] believers. So, famous story, there was a
[40:04] woman with a chicken. They followed the chicken where
[40:07] the chicken went. This woman can divine through
[40:10] the chicken and The Crusaders went with her.
[40:12] She had a troop of military people going around following a
[40:15] fucking chicken. OK, that's crazy, right?
[40:20] But during that era that we had, see, this is not a new problem
[40:23] we've had. This is a problem that has
[40:25] existed for all society. It's just we have a different
[40:27] amplified form of this during an era.
[40:30] People with incredible, perhaps mental illness or sociopathy or
[40:34] manipulativeness have been leading humanity all over the
[40:38] place and tragedies and and brutalities occur.
[40:42] But we tend to be good at figuring that out sooner or
[40:44] later. And so that does happen.
[40:47] And so that's not a new phenomenon that has been going
[40:49] on. That isn't a phenomenon as old
[40:51] as humanity has ever existed, that we have followed charlatans
[40:55] and cheaters and fakers and that sort of thing.
[40:58] If you read about the Anabaptists in Germany and the
[41:01] taking over of towns, it's phenomenal stories of actually
[41:05] insane, bipolar, mentally ill human beings leading masses of
[41:10] humanity. OK, the early days jumping
[41:13] ahead, right, The early days of Munster, I think it was Sorry,
[41:17] I'm just going back to the last three.
[41:19] Munster, I think it was a city taken over by the Anabaptist and
[41:22] the leader of the Munster, it was a walled city and they were
[41:24] surrounded by the Catholic Guard, military Bishop and
[41:28] Cardinals. And they were just total
[41:30] lunatics and slaughtered people and did crazy stuff.
[41:32] But like one of the great stories is like the leader of
[41:34] their, I forget his name, the leader of of this town.
[41:36] He has a vision one day. He says, listen, Abraham in the
[41:39] Bible, he fought the kings and to save his nephew Lot.
[41:43] I don't know if you're familiar with that story.
[41:44] It's a story. Lot, the nephew of Abraham gets
[41:48] kidnapped by a bunch of kings and and armies and Abraham goes
[41:51] up by himself and he destroys them by himself.
[41:54] OK, that's a biblical story with his servant, right?
[41:57] And this guy goes, I had this dream that I'm like, Abraham,
[41:59] I'm going to destroy all these forces, these military forces
[42:01] camped outside our city, me and 10 men.
[42:04] And they're like, Are you sure about this?
[42:06] He's like, yeah, yeah. And he rides out with his ten
[42:08] men, like just full force gallop towards these soldiers.
[42:11] And everybody's looking up. Are you kidding me right now?
[42:14] And he just rides out and they shoot a bunch of arrows and he's
[42:16] dead. That's it.
[42:18] Like the guy just dies. And like he really had a belief
[42:21] he was mentally ill. There's he's not a normal like
[42:23] he really believed he was like Abraham, he's going to destroy
[42:24] these armies. And they just shot him down.
[42:26] And then the next guy caught up and I was like, he
[42:28] misinterpreted the dream. I got it right.
[42:29] Doesn't I'm saying we have this problem.
[42:31] OK, Fast forward to the early 1900s, late 1800's, the printing
[42:33] press starts happening. Everybody's got a newspaper.
[42:36] Everybody has the capability of speaking.
[42:38] Despicable journalism is occurring in the late 1800s,
[42:43] early 1900's, the spread of gossip and and and destruction
[42:48] of people's reputation was going on all over the place.
[42:50] And then eventually it narrowed down, right?
[42:53] And we only have so many newspapers, far less newspapers
[42:56] than used to exist back in those days.
[42:58] Well, then we had the blogosphere, right?
[43:01] And everybody can blog whatever the F they wanted.
[43:03] And that's no longer really in existence.
[43:05] And now we have social media and every lunatic can get onto
[43:08] social media and say there and amplify their speech.
[43:12] It's dangerous. It's it's it's people who
[43:15] typically would just be your raving mad lunatics standing on
[43:18] their block and everybody be saying shut up.
[43:20] It's two AMI got to go to sleep and a few people might listen to
[43:23] them. Today they have a whole platform
[43:24] with 50 million listeners and people are dumbing down.
[43:26] But I do believe, I do believe in humanity figuring out those
[43:31] things, which is it will take us a few years to kind of narrow it
[43:34] down to those trustworthy sources who those people are,
[43:37] who will be more trustworthy and more decent materials that we
[43:43] can get from and understand and and read, right.
[43:46] And there will always be your lunatic publishing some
[43:48] pamphlets saying we fake the moon landing or whatever it is,
[43:51] right? Like, fine, whatever.
[43:52] But we'll recognize that more and more, I think, as time goes
[43:55] along, as these systems figure themselves out.
[43:59] So I have more faith in humanity than most people have.
[44:02] I do think there's a proliferation of stupid speech,
[44:04] right? I saw this speaker the other
[44:06] day, some cleric of some sort talking about, like, democracies
[44:09] for the people, by the people. Yeah, it's a wonderful
[44:12] institution, but the people are stupid, right?
[44:17] So back to anonymity here. Can we make any progress on
[44:21] actually clamping down on the problems that come with
[44:25] anonymity? Well, so without encroaching on
[44:27] it. Yeah, yeah.
[44:27] I mean, The thing is this where where does anonymity cross the
[44:30] line? That's the bigger question,
[44:32] right? I have a right to be anonymous
[44:33] and not tell people who I am. I don't, you don't get to check
[44:36] my ID when I walk through the door, right of any place or
[44:38] walking down the street. A law enforcement can't walk up
[44:41] to you and go give me your ID. It's we're not living in Russia
[44:43] and communist times. So you can't do that on the
[44:45] Internet. I mean, a company can create
[44:47] their own policy if they wanted to, right?
[44:49] Twitter can do our X can do that, but they would recognize
[44:53] the fallout of that, right? So I think that's a business
[44:56] related purpose. The question is, what are you
[44:58] doing? I can unmask you as a District
[45:00] Attorney. I can unmask you if you're
[45:01] committing crime, right? So if you threaten me with my
[45:05] life, I can unmask you. I can figure out who you are
[45:07] pretty quickly. How?
[45:09] Well, every every data company that you might be using has your
[45:12] has data on you, right. So take take any platform,
[45:16] whatever platform you want, Snapchat, OK, you log onto your
[45:21] Snapchat. Does Snapchat have your IP
[45:23] address where you just logged on From there we go.
[45:26] Now I know where you are. But is that really an effective
[45:29] approach here, when perhaps people are unaware of that and
[45:33] you're relying on something that is suboptimal to track people
[45:37] rather than actually just institutionalized?
[45:39] No, no, no, you're, I hear your point, but I'm saying is the
[45:41] point is, is if you're just engaged in stupidity, I as an
[45:46] individual have a right to ignore or listen to your
[45:48] stupidity. That's my right.
[45:49] Unfortunately, right. Unfortunately, there's people
[45:52] who will listen and that's unfortunate.
[45:53] Hopefully the, the, the way to the, the, the Justice Brandeis,
[45:57] one of the greatest Supreme Court justices in American
[45:59] history. Just like the way to the, the
[46:00] way to make to, to rectify speech is by allowing more.
[46:04] It's not by suppressing it. And so it's that sort of idea.
[46:06] We'll hopefully figure it out. People will see the truth.
[46:08] People will learn and and understand for themselves, but
[46:13] but when you cross the bear the line within your anonymity,
[46:19] there's a line that you cross where the government now gets
[46:22] involved. Then I could get involved and I
[46:24] could we get plenty of online extortion, sex extortion,
[46:28] criminal threats, right bomb threats, whatever they may be.
[46:32] The moment you do that, you cross that line of you have a
[46:35] right to just exist as whatever stupid moron you want to be.
[46:38] But now you cross a line of harm to society.
[46:40] I can get you fast. You can get me fast with
[46:44] something like an IP address, but what I'm trying to find out
[46:48] is an actual hard line in the sand where you're going.
[46:51] OK. So it should be the case that
[46:53] any platform has to have access to your IP address.
[46:57] Now, it just so happens at the moment that that is the case,
[47:01] right? And that's helpful for you guys
[47:02] prosecuting. No, I don't.
[47:04] I don't. Think it could also be the case
[47:05] that platforms don't have access to your IP address.
[47:09] They don't have any form of ID because we don't want to
[47:11] encroach on anonymity and now suddenly you don't have any way
[47:15] of catching these. Criminals.
[47:16] So let's slow down. I don't think what you're saying
[47:19] is completely accurate. Even without correct, even
[47:21] without physical ID of you, the the platforms are always going
[47:25] to collect data off certain points and that's necessary for
[47:29] the basic operation of their business.
[47:32] If you don't give an IP address, they're not that you can't log
[47:35] on. There's methods and the
[47:36] government's not going to restrict that these businesses
[47:39] have to operate with that information.
[47:41] The value of any information and not anonymous or otherwise of
[47:44] any individual is a marketing value, right?
[47:47] And then there's a huge value in information whether it's not
[47:50] unmasked or masked, there's value in that information.
[47:53] Media companies are utilizing that information to see trends,
[47:56] to see for marketing schemes, for sales, for product building,
[48:00] for whatever it is. There's a multi trillion dollar
[48:03] operation in that we will know you in some way or another.
[48:06] There's always traces of a human being existing no matter how
[48:10] anonymous. And so the question is to what
[48:13] extent really? The question is to what extent
[48:15] should the government be able to get involved in your life?
[48:18] I shouldn't be involved in your life now.
[48:20] So there's two parts. It's like should the media
[48:22] companies themselves, private businesses engage in their own
[48:25] regulation? Separate question, should the
[48:27] government engage in their own regulation?
[48:29] That's a different question. Government should only get
[48:31] involved in regulation when you commit a crime, right?
[48:34] And that sort of regulation? I don't think that's the
[48:36] question and I want to close this loop out.
[48:40] The question is what happens in a world when we're progressing
[48:43] forward with technology where people are all using VPNs.
[48:48] They, for whatever reason, don't have to give their IP address to
[48:51] companies or that IP address won't be given to companies.
[48:55] So they're anonymous, don't have IP address.
[48:58] Always traceable. What if it's not OK?
[49:04] Because then then they have what you are saying, which is the
[49:08] right to anonymity and complete anonymity.
[49:10] No, no, when I say sorry, let me correct because we're maybe
[49:13] we're talking a little when I say every right to anonymity,
[49:15] anonymity, it's to the government government
[49:19] regulation, right passage of laws that government regulates
[49:23] your anonymity is separate from your right to anonymity.
[49:26] Visit, you don't have right to anonymity.
[49:28] If you walk into my house, who are you?
[49:30] What are you doing here? Right?
[49:31] Like I'm going to find that out. The government regulating your
[49:34] anonymity, that's a different story.
[49:36] So if there was a way that you can be totally anonymous on a
[49:41] platform and the platform allows you to exist in that way, that's
[49:45] the world we're talking about, then what would be the
[49:48] responsibilities of any party? Does that make sense?
[49:52] I think that's what you're asking, right?
[49:53] That. Is what I'm asking.
[49:55] Then it's it's a social media issue, right?
[49:57] It's a company issue, if that really existed, if that is
[50:01] because I haven't seen that quite clearly yet.
[50:03] The absolute anonymity of an individual on a platform.
[50:07] Yeah, because there is methods to trace anything because
[50:09] eventually your your device tracks to a router and a router
[50:12] gives up an informant piece of it.
[50:13] It has to to exist, right? And so you can mail a letter
[50:18] from any mailbox in the world you want, but I know where that
[50:20] mail was mailed from and I can trace certain information back.
[50:23] It's like you have to give up an IP and I can get your Mac IP,
[50:27] which is IP of your device to that and there's various steps
[50:30] you can go along along in the hypothetical world where there's
[50:33] absolute anonymity, we have no idea who did what, then that's a
[50:37] more institutional issue for how businesses will handle that.
[50:41] Before we can even think about that, then we, I mean, the
[50:44] government think about that because the business is just
[50:48] going to say we have nothing on you and the end of the road,
[50:53] right? So if there's a mass Commission
[50:57] of a crime and we can't track, I mean, it actually does happen in
[51:00] some ways, right? There are masking of IP
[51:03] addresses on let's say dark web where we don't find the child
[51:06] pornography. I mean, it does happen in that
[51:07] sense, but to the large extent it doesn't.
[51:10] The production of this video is made possible by gear from
[51:13] dfirentalsbookyournextfilmequipmentinstantly@dfirentals.com. So let's keep going with this AI
[51:22] topic and the efficiency that comes with AI.
[51:27] What if we now take it from the efficiency for the criminals to
[51:30] produce more criminal footage or contraband to the efficiency of
[51:35] law and justice and enforcing it?
[51:37] Something like having certain stereotypes and profiles of
[51:42] people that are likely to commit crimes.
[51:46] How do we manage the use of AI without overstepping people's
[51:50] rights and going, hey Elliot, you're a Brit who's 20 coming to
[51:55] America. That gives you a 95% chance of
[51:59] committing X crime and perhaps speeding because you Brits are
[52:02] really bad at driving. You could then maybe and
[52:06] reasonably use that as an argument for you to knock on my
[52:08] door in America and arrest me under suspicion.
[52:12] Of speeding. That's horrifying.
[52:14] Where's the line there with efficiency and using AI as a
[52:17] tool to predict potential criminals and not overstepping
[52:20] the market? Yeah, it's a real, it's a real
[52:21] question because predictive, predictive modeling is generally
[52:25] a big issue. The ACLU, the EFF, the
[52:29] Electronic Freedom Frontier, which are like, you know, very,
[52:35] for lack of better word, maybe anti government organizations.
[52:39] I don't mean that in a negative, but anti government
[52:41] organizations are very concerned with the idea of profiling.
[52:44] Certainly the the that that's where law comes into real force,
[52:48] right? Like is there certain rational
[52:50] predictive modeling that law enforcement should engage in?
[52:55] Yes. But what you're asking is so
[52:57] complex. I, I can't possibly answer
[52:58] because it's a policy question, but here's what I'd tell you.
[53:01] It's like we have predictive modeling in a sense like this.
[53:03] If, if law enforcement is operating a certain district, a
[53:06] certain jurisdiction to use predictive modelling to figure
[53:09] out where crime rates are most likely to occur and therefore to
[53:13] have more patrol vehicles in the areas where crime rates are to
[53:16] occur versus not wasting resources, right.
[53:19] Like I live in the neighborhood. It's like if you put a bunch of
[53:22] patrol cars on my on my street, I'd be in, in heaven, man, I'd
[53:25] be so happy. But it really would be a waste
[53:27] of law enforcement time. So you use predictive modelling
[53:29] in that sense. But to start predicting future
[53:31] crimes like a minority report with Tom Cruise, if you ever
[53:34] seen that movie, oh, it's, it's all about predictive modelling.
[53:37] It's a great movie is terrifying.
[53:39] And, and, and that's why we do have a robust constitution,
[53:42] right? The, the, the, the, the right of
[53:44] the people to be secure against unreasonable search and seizures
[53:47] of the 4th Amendment. And, and, and that would not
[53:51] permit it, right? That would just not permit it.
[53:54] So I might haven't, let's say theoretically in, in a nefarious
[53:58] sort of scenario, OK, we, we see you coming in from the airport
[54:02] and we go, this person's going to be a problem.
[54:04] I could trail you right and what, wait till you commit a
[54:08] crime and then arrest you, But like I couldn't do anything
[54:12] beyond that. I couldn't just knock on your
[54:14] door and pre arrest because there's no basis for that.
[54:17] This Constitution doesn't allow that.
[54:19] And we have protections in place for that right.
[54:22] There are legal protections in place that do exist for that in,
[54:26] in the United States and my, in my knowledge of this area,
[54:29] right? Like there really is I'm not
[54:30] worried about that as an actuality.
[54:32] I am worried about the idea of predictive modeling, the sense
[54:35] that we maybe it tends to lean into what might be racial
[54:38] stereotypes or racist sort of behavior.
[54:41] And that's where we really have to be very careful about that.
[54:44] And also to allow the human being to be a human being, which
[54:48] is unpredictable, which is sometimes selfish, sometimes
[54:54] evil, sometimes good, sometimes, you know, enlightened for every
[54:58] single type of human being that might exist, right?
[55:01] We always say good people to come do bad things and bad
[55:03] people do good things, right? Like that's a true statement.
[55:06] And so know what you know. Let the human being the be the
[55:08] human being. Half of Americans use facial
[55:12] recognition to access their electronic devices.
[55:15] How does that play out with you and your work at the DA?
[55:20] So it's a great question. It's an area of research
[55:22] extensively. It's such that we can go for 10
[55:25] hours on this topic. But here's The thing is facial
[55:29] recognition is pitched by the, the, the providers, the the
[55:32] companies, the organizations as being the most robust security
[55:35] they can possibly have 'cause I, I, it really is right?
[55:39] It it takes certain biometric information and make sure that
[55:41] it's the correct individual logging into the device.
[55:46] The positive for law enforcement that I think has been
[55:48] frustrating companies is that now I have easy access to your
[55:54] device. I think companies are frustrated
[55:57] with that. OK, so your device is far more
[55:59] secure by facial recognition than it is with the password
[56:01] because the password I can guess, I can figure out, I can
[56:03] hack. Facial recognition is more of a
[56:06] personalized thing to you. Can we get really nerdy about
[56:10] this and actually speak about how facial recognition works and
[56:13] why a criminal can't just pull up a picture from me on
[56:16] Instagram and hold it up to my phone to unlock?
[56:19] It OK, I don't know the answer to that I'm not a tech so I
[56:23] can't get nerdy on that. How it actually works, OK,
[56:25] that's the truth. That's that.
[56:27] I can't if there's specific areas.
[56:30] But what I would say is that let's just presume it's strong
[56:35] and it's hard and people can't just hold up a fit picture and
[56:38] it takes certain points on your face and certain features.
[56:42] Like I switched glasses, my biometric still recognizes me
[56:47] and that's really awesome. That's really cool.
[56:48] And then they're making more and more robust.
[56:50] But here's the thing, if I, if I'm a cop and I go out and
[56:52] arrest you, right, and you have a phone on you and I want to
[56:56] access your phone, you can tell me I don't know the password.
[56:59] I'm not going to give you the password.
[57:01] What you can't do is deny the fact that I held it up to your
[57:04] face and it unlocked. That's huge.
[57:08] That makes it so much easier for us to access your phone.
[57:11] It really does, right? Like beforehand, we'd get these
[57:14] phones with device, with encryption, with whatever it is,
[57:16] and we can't figure out the password.
[57:17] We're trying to brute force. We're trying to access your
[57:19] device through whatever software.
[57:20] Now I can just go boom, it's yours.
[57:23] So it's great for us. It's wonderful.
[57:27] There's issues with that. There's a lot of court cases
[57:30] with that idea itself. Just so you know, the Supreme
[57:32] Court's going to have to decide the sooner or later, but there,
[57:34] there's legitimate issues. Well.
[57:36] Should you have, just like you do, the right to remain silent
[57:40] and not give your code to your phone, the right to avoid
[57:44] showing your face to it? Phenomenal question.
[57:48] That is a question that courts have asked throughout the
[57:51] country, but that has a very astute question for a non
[57:54] lawyer. The 4th Amendment prohibits me
[57:57] from unreasonable search and seizures.
[57:59] OK, hypothetically you commit a criminal act.
[58:02] Let's take us through it in the in brief, Hypothetically, you
[58:05] commit a criminal act, I'm going to charge you with robbery.
[58:08] OK, so you committed a criminal act and I'm investigating you.
[58:11] I come, I grab you, I grab your device.
[58:13] Now I get a warrant. I get a warrant to search your
[58:16] home. So the Constitution says and no
[58:18] warrant shall be issued, but upon probable cause specifically
[58:21] defining OK, so I get a warrant, it's legal.
[58:24] I know you. I have probable cause to believe
[58:26] you committed the crime. I have probable cause to believe
[58:27] you have evidence of the crime on your phone.
[58:29] Am I allowed to search your phone?
[58:31] You have a search warrant, right?
[58:32] OK, now I can't practically search it because it's
[58:35] biometric. So now, but I'm allowed to write
[58:40] me say I'm allowed to search that thing any way I can.
[58:43] The question you're getting into is now a Fifth Amendment.
[58:46] The 5th Amendment says no person shall be compelled to be a
[58:49] witness against themselves. It's not an issue of whether I
[58:51] can search. I could search your phone.
[58:53] Question is whether you're, well, I'm compelling you to
[58:55] incriminate yourself. And that's a big question.
[58:58] Are you, am I compelling you? And are you incriminating
[59:01] yourself by unlocking a device for me?
[59:04] Big legal question that's going on.
[59:05] I think the answer is no. Why?
[59:08] How did you incriminate yourself?
[59:10] The thing on your phone is what's incriminating.
[59:12] It's not your phone. I mean, say I'm not forcing you
[59:17] to do anything. It is or isn't, practically
[59:20] speaking, your, your, your device.
[59:23] That's the issue, right? So, for example, I'll give you a
[59:27] more physical robust example criminal, We find a a shirt at a
[59:35] scene of a murder that we believe the criminal left
[59:38] behind. Can I force you to put that on?
[59:41] No. Of course I can.
[59:43] Why not? It's not telling me anything
[59:45] that's in your mind. You're not being a witness.
[59:47] It is what it is. It's a physical fact.
[59:48] It is or isn't. It's not from your mind.
[59:51] Compelling you to be witness against yourself is testimony.
[59:54] Could you be for something to put anything on?
[59:55] Sure, all the time. I can force you to take a
[59:58] haircut. I can take your DNA.
[1:00:01] Let's take that as an example. Can I force you to give me your
[1:00:03] DNA? I have a murder that happens.
[1:00:05] There's a web. There's DNA on the weapon.
[1:00:07] I need your DNA. Can I force you to to give me
[1:00:09] your DNA? The answer is yes, 'cause it's
[1:00:11] not revealing any information that we might call a witness
[1:00:15] testimonial. It's not testimonial.
[1:00:17] Testimonial is information in your head.
[1:00:19] It's not that. It is what it is.
[1:00:21] It's a factual fact. It's a fact.
[1:00:23] It's a factual analysis. Are you this?
[1:00:25] It's like, should I be? Can you measure me how tall I
[1:00:28] am? Yeah, of course I can measure
[1:00:29] you. It's a fact.
[1:00:29] Whether one way or not, your DNA is a fact, your physical size is
[1:00:33] a fact. In courts where gang members
[1:00:36] have tattoos all over themselves and you want to illustrate to
[1:00:38] the jury back in the old days, you want to illustrate to the
[1:00:40] jury some of their tattoos to show them that this is you can
[1:00:43] take and make them take their shirt off in the middle of
[1:00:44] court. If I need a line up, you've seen
[1:00:46] line UPS, right? Visual line UPS in court.
[1:00:48] I can more make you be part of a line up.
[1:00:50] You go, well, that's my 5th amendment right.
[1:00:51] No, it's not. Those are cases that have been
[1:00:53] well established. So that sort of idea, it's the
[1:00:57] same kind of thing to sit there and say you, you of of yourself,
[1:01:01] if not revealing any information, but a physical
[1:01:04] component of yourself without you having to reveal information
[1:01:07] that's stored that we we're not is not compelling you to be
[1:01:10] tested testifying against yourself.
[1:01:12] So that's the very, very astute question and, and, and area very
[1:01:17] complex. It's all over the place.
[1:01:20] All over the United States. There are courts who agree with
[1:01:22] what you just said. Few, But there are courts that
[1:01:24] agree that that is compelling testimony.
[1:01:27] Most courts disagree. The bigger question is, can I
[1:01:29] force you to enter your password in a phone?
[1:01:31] That's another question. I want us to speak about
[1:01:34] surveillance, yes. And the protection of society
[1:01:37] that comes from surveillance, Yes.
[1:01:39] Where does the line sit there? Should we be pushing for ACCP
[1:01:44] model where you have social credit linked to every action
[1:01:48] and you have cameras on every corner?
[1:01:50] I can't remember the statistic about how many cameras they have
[1:01:52] per person. Perhaps you'll know, but but
[1:01:55] it's shocking, right? And it's terrifying.
[1:01:58] Then at the other end of the spectrum, you have New York City
[1:02:01] in the 1970s where I mean, you see a a movie like Joker
[1:02:06] inspired by that and he goes and kills a bunch of dudes on a
[1:02:09] train with no cameras and then runs off.
[1:02:11] Obviously that's fiction, but it conveys the idea here.
[1:02:15] How do we go forwards utilizing Evermore?
[1:02:19] First of all, high quality cameras that you can punch in on
[1:02:21] and identify people from, but also the technology that comes
[1:02:25] downstream from that, which is identifying individuals with AI
[1:02:29] and other cues built up from this network of cameras.
[1:02:32] It's. Such a hard question.
[1:02:33] I honestly don't know the answer because here if here's the hard
[1:02:37] question of it, I always tell my students the same thing, which
[1:02:39] is my generation had far more privacy than yours does, but not
[1:02:43] because the government necessarily because you guys
[1:02:47] right everything. I know everything about you, the
[1:02:50] vast majority of individuals of your generation online.
[1:02:54] I know everything about you constantly.
[1:02:56] There's so much information out that you put out there on a
[1:02:59] regular basis. So yeah, we should be deeply
[1:03:05] concerned about government surveillance.
[1:03:07] I I really like the idea of being able to be an idiot in my
[1:03:11] own private time, right. Like I, I do tell my students
[1:03:14] like there is a, here's a question I'll ask.
[1:03:16] I ask my students all this all time, if, if I give you an
[1:03:19] option and I'm going to search one thing and the other thing I
[1:03:23] can't. So you're going to choose which
[1:03:24] one I'm going to search and, and you can prohibit me from
[1:03:27] searching one. OK, so which one will you
[1:03:28] prohibit? I'm going to search your home,
[1:03:30] your entire home or your phone. Which one do you prohibit me
[1:03:33] from searching? Definitely the phone.
[1:03:35] Yeah, 100% of your generation says that, except one Jackass
[1:03:38] who always tries to throw off my statistics, right.
[1:03:39] It's always, but why? I always say, like in the
[1:03:42] history of human beings, in all of human history, 100% of
[1:03:48] humanity would have said my home until 15 years ago.
[1:03:53] That's a a monumental shift of human perspective, right?
[1:03:57] That entire civilizations would have said my home is my most
[1:04:01] sacrosanct area. It's my castle.
[1:04:03] It's most private. You shall not ever enter.
[1:04:06] William Pitt the junior gave a great speech in the 1500s on in
[1:04:10] in in England on the parliamentary floor, talking
[1:04:13] about how. It's a great quote about how I
[1:04:17] may live in a ruin tenement. The the wind may enter, the rain
[1:04:21] may enter, but all the King's forces shall not pass upon the,
[1:04:25] you know, the threshold, this idea that the government cannot
[1:04:29] enter your home ever, unless it's really appropriate, right?
[1:04:33] There are places for it. And my home is so important to
[1:04:36] me. And today it's like, whatever,
[1:04:37] what are you going to find in my underwear?
[1:04:39] Don't search my phone. Everybody will say that.
[1:04:42] Don't search my phone. And it's not because I suspect
[1:04:45] you of having illegal information on your phone.
[1:04:48] It's not because I suspect you of being a bad human being.
[1:04:50] It's just that in the privacy of our own existences, we engage
[1:04:55] differently in different manners, in different portions,
[1:04:58] whatever that may be, whether it's a medical illness that you
[1:05:01] don't share with anybody, whether it's a personal
[1:05:03] relationship that you don't share with anybody, whether it's
[1:05:05] just maybe talking with your fellows and you talk like a
[1:05:07] moron. Sometimes there's a place for
[1:05:10] that to exist. Sorry, we're often a tangible
[1:05:14] bit, but I asked my students, my generation, what do you think
[1:05:16] the greatest fear of my generation like tangible fear
[1:05:19] was not like being drowned or hung.
[1:05:21] But I'm talking about tangible fear, something we fear to do.
[1:05:24] Statistically, we feared public speaking.
[1:05:28] That was my generation, that was statistics.
[1:05:30] You can look it up that people feared public speaking.
[1:05:31] Your generation doesn't. You're all used to public
[1:05:33] speaking. Everybody's doing a vlog, right?
[1:05:35] It's not that. What's your biggest fear?
[1:05:37] Your biggest fear is being cancelled, right?
[1:05:41] It's someone finding out too much about you.
[1:05:44] And that's a dangerous ideology. Forget the government for a
[1:05:47] second. It's dangerous for a social
[1:05:48] value, which is there is a place to be an absolute idiot
[1:05:51] sometimes. There is a place for human
[1:05:54] beings to make mistakes and rectify them.
[1:05:56] There is a place to learn, right?
[1:05:59] I've done this throughout my career as a prosecutor where
[1:06:01] there's crimes that occur, that they're really rectifiable.
[1:06:05] I recognize that and I think it's important to give people
[1:06:08] the opportunity to rectify that. There are crimes that aren't
[1:06:12] unrectifiable, right? Like, and so I always, one of
[1:06:15] the things I like to talk about is this idea of like if we were
[1:06:17] sitting in class today and there's a person sitting next to
[1:06:20] you and he's a bit old of an older student.
[1:06:22] And during a break, you look at this guy and you say, hey, man,
[1:06:24] you're like 30 years old. What are you doing in an
[1:06:26] undergraduate class at University of Southern
[1:06:28] California? And he goes, well, funny you
[1:06:30] should ask. I was a juvenile delinquent and
[1:06:33] as a juvenile committed a murder and I spent 15 years in jail
[1:06:37] juvenile hall and I just got out.
[1:06:38] I've reformed my life, I've taken classes and I really want
[1:06:42] to get a degree and an education and really live a good life.
[1:06:44] You'd be like, wow, that's admirable.
[1:06:47] Wow, that's amazing. Same guy sitting next to you and
[1:06:50] one of your neighbors leans over and says that guy wrote put the
[1:06:53] N word on social media 15 years ago.
[1:06:55] Like Oh my God, what a racist. One guy took a life.
[1:07:00] One guy posted a horrible racist thing on social media.
[1:07:03] That's terrible. Hopefully you learned from that.
[1:07:05] But one guy took a life. Like it's unforgivable.
[1:07:07] We should have a place to forgive you or not forgive you
[1:07:09] but to allow you to re enter society.
[1:07:12] It's not my position to forgive you.
[1:07:13] You're it's an unforgivable crime.
[1:07:15] There's an important distinction here with forgiveness of crimes
[1:07:19] that have occurred and what you're saying, and I don't want
[1:07:23] to extrapolate here too much, so push back on me if I get this
[1:07:25] wrong. But linking this back to the
[1:07:28] surveillance point of always being surveilled and the
[1:07:33] government can tell if you're committing a crime or not.
[1:07:37] Is it that you're saying that you should have privacy to
[1:07:43] commit crimes and not be detected?
[1:07:46] Because right now I'm not seeing a problem with having
[1:07:50] surveillance everywhere, because if you're committing a crime,
[1:07:54] you should be punished for that. Right, so So what I'm talking
[1:07:57] about, you're right, I agree with you.
[1:07:59] Although I do like to sometimes speed or you know, roll through
[1:08:03] a stop sign, right. Imagine we just nothing we ever
[1:08:06] did was unsurveilable. And by the way, like this is
[1:08:09] obvious to anyone watching and listening.
[1:08:11] I would fucking hate to live in this place.
[1:08:13] Like high speed all the time, whatever.
[1:08:15] But if we're going super quantifiable, the law is the
[1:08:19] gospel mode here. That doesn't seem to be any
[1:08:22] strong argument against having surveillance.
[1:08:24] So that so you're right. So what you're very various good
[1:08:27] point to be making, which is I'm distinguishing between non
[1:08:30] criminal behavior, stupid behavior versus crime.
[1:08:32] I'm not advocating that the government shouldn't be able to
[1:08:34] surveil crime. I'm arguing that we we are, we
[1:08:37] do so many dumb things in any given day amongst each other and
[1:08:41] that yes, there is a place for that to exist.
[1:08:43] And if we're in constant surveillance, like I said, going
[1:08:46] back, your fear is of being cancelled, right?
[1:08:49] Means, say, we shouldn't have to live with that fear, we should
[1:08:52] behave appropriate. But you don't have to live with
[1:08:54] this fear because the surveillance only gets triggered
[1:08:57] and sent to the government if you commit a crime.
[1:08:59] There's no security on that, right?
[1:09:02] Imagine the amount of leaks we have of everything, anything
[1:09:04] that exists that anybody can access and like those things
[1:09:07] that come out, you just sit there and go.
[1:09:09] Imagine some the most stupid thing you've ever done with your
[1:09:12] friends humiliating thing in your life.
[1:09:15] Imagine that that was capable of becoming out.
[1:09:19] Should should we have to live under the fear of that?
[1:09:22] Like there's a statue of limitations for crimes, most
[1:09:24] crimes, right? Like that.
[1:09:25] If you committed a robbery, 3 years go by, we didn't solve the
[1:09:27] case, it's gone. We can't prosecute you ever.
[1:09:29] Well, you committed a terrible crime.
[1:09:30] Sure, it depends on the nature. There's no statue of limitations
[1:09:33] for murder or rape. But like, yeah, there's, there's
[1:09:35] has to be a certain level of human, human ability to exist
[1:09:38] and move on from past behaviors. And that's the worry of it,
[1:09:41] right? Like yes, theoretically in a
[1:09:43] theoretical world, but we're at we enter 1984 very quickly.
[1:09:48] Well, I agree with you that it's an implementation problem and.
[1:09:52] Like as a, as a prosecutor, I will say, like the more video
[1:09:54] there is, the better for me, right?
[1:09:56] Like I I'm I'm, I'm separating the libertarian of me versus the
[1:10:01] government employee of me. Certainly, And I think it's
[1:10:04] fascinating to drill down into your psychology and especially
[1:10:07] the sort of intergenerational dynamic here, because as someone
[1:10:11] who has grown up chronically online, I'm kind of indifferent
[1:10:16] to the idea of an AI camera constantly following me around.
[1:10:19] And as long as I don't commit any crimes, it won't log all the
[1:10:23] other private stuff. But my only problem there is the
[1:10:26] fact that I do speed sometimes, and I would get fucked for it.
[1:10:29] But in terms of the actual ability to commit stupid legal
[1:10:34] actions, I don't really care, whereas it seems like you do
[1:10:39] psychologically on some level. Yeah, So first of all, I mean,
[1:10:43] the in terms of the crime, the speeding, right, we would adjust
[1:10:45] our behaviors very quickly and we'd make society safer, right?
[1:10:49] That's the truth. We would adjust our behavior,
[1:10:51] right? We do speed chronically.
[1:10:52] You know, somebody like, all right, five tickets in a row,
[1:10:55] you're going to be able to stop speeding, right?
[1:10:56] Like we're we're we're decent people are susceptible to
[1:10:59] changing behaviors. But I do worry about mass
[1:11:01] oversight. I do worry about the the way we
[1:11:05] judge like we're we're we've jumped from topic to topic and
[1:11:08] in a way you're you're going back to that.
[1:11:10] It's like people could do anonymously to you, right, To
[1:11:15] cancel the destruction of you as a human being for being a dumb
[1:11:18] ass at one point in your life. That's what worries me.
[1:11:21] I really want the ability, like the freedom of people to think,
[1:11:25] to act, to gauge with one another in various ways as we
[1:11:28] should. It's good for human beings.
[1:11:30] It's what separates us from other creatures is that we do
[1:11:33] make mistakes and we do correct those mistakes.
[1:11:35] And no one's perfect and we're always going to make mistakes.
[1:11:38] The the flip side I worry about is surveillance by unfeeling
[1:11:42] unemotional groups, which is government and mass and media,
[1:11:46] right? Like I don't want Google knowing
[1:11:47] everything about me and I don't want the government knowing
[1:11:49] everything about me for the sake of just privacy.
[1:11:51] And you might sit there and say, I'm not worried, but it is
[1:11:54] worrisome. At some point, it does become
[1:11:55] worrisome. And you might get a social
[1:11:56] credit. And I don't think the CCP is
[1:11:58] great. That's terrible, right?
[1:11:59] That we should have that. But you quickly approach a world
[1:12:03] like that now. Now the flip side is let's look
[1:12:04] at the practicality of it. The practicality of it all is we
[1:12:07] understand that when we're in public, we're constantly
[1:12:09] surveilled because everybody's got a phone and everybody's
[1:12:13] recording and everybody's whatever.
[1:12:15] And we, we, we come to that social agreement with one
[1:12:17] another. I think we, we understand that.
[1:12:19] I'm not offended if you're standing outside with your phone
[1:12:22] recording and I happen to walk past, right?
[1:12:25] We understand it. 100 years ago, the idea of taking a picture of
[1:12:29] someone was horrendous without consent.
[1:12:31] There's literally cases on the subject talking about like, they
[1:12:35] took my photo, right? You're like, today you'd be
[1:12:37] like, So what? Right.
[1:12:38] So there is a differing evolution of how we engage and
[1:12:42] how we are. You're you're again, your, your
[1:12:43] generation appreciates privacy far less than mine in some ways.
[1:12:47] But you still would want to have the freedom to exist, the
[1:12:50] freedom to eat where you wanted to have a conversation without
[1:12:55] being constantly overheard, right?
[1:12:57] There's that. That's like fundamental to human
[1:12:59] beings just existing and being able to breathe and being able
[1:13:02] to live. But we've made a leap here from
[1:13:03] privacy to freedom, whereas I feel and sorry to push you on
[1:13:08] this. I think it's.
[1:13:09] Important. I just don't see an argument
[1:13:13] that's been compelling for privacy, for privacy's sake.
[1:13:18] And I've, I've been to, well, I've I've been to panels and is.
[1:13:22] Privacy, not a value. I'm asking that like
[1:13:25] fundamentally, we said it's great.
[1:13:26] We came full circle to this whole conversation.
[1:13:28] It's not a value. Like fundamentally as an idea,
[1:13:31] is it not a value? He's you.
[1:13:33] You. You would.
[1:13:34] Did you go to Christian School at all?
[1:13:35] No. No.
[1:13:36] Did you read any Bible stories? No.
[1:13:38] Do you know who Adam and Eve are?
[1:13:39] I do indeed. OK, we know who Adam and Eve
[1:13:41] are, right? And Adam and Eve, they're
[1:13:42] created by God in the Garden of Eden.
[1:13:45] What's the first thing that they do?
[1:13:48] Eve eats from the Tree of Knowledge, right?
[1:13:50] You know that? Yeah.
[1:13:51] The snake compels her to eat from or tells her to eat from
[1:13:54] Tree of Knowledge. And they eat from this tree and
[1:13:55] she shares it with Adam. And what happens to them?
[1:13:58] God starts looking for them. God's like, what the fuck did
[1:14:01] you just do? Right?
[1:14:02] And he's looking, by the way, I'm an ordained rabbi.
[1:14:04] OK, so God's like, what's going on, right?
[1:14:06] And he's and he said like the Bible writes like in the the
[1:14:08] actual text, it's like, God's like, where are you Adam?
[1:14:11] And Adam and Eve are ashamed. And they immediately cover
[1:14:14] themselves up. And you're like, wait, what does
[1:14:16] that mean? You mean you're ashamed?
[1:14:18] They were walking around naked before and also now they're
[1:14:20] ashamed and they wear loinclaws and God's asking, where are you?
[1:14:23] It's an idea of visual privacy. We understand instinctively the
[1:14:26] moment they get knowledge of their own physical limitations,
[1:14:30] of their own humanity. The first thing that happens
[1:14:32] that when human beings become self aware, they're not living
[1:14:36] like angels in an Eden, they're living as human beings.
[1:14:38] They become self aware and shame and privacy.
[1:14:42] The desire for privacy is immediately there and God
[1:14:44] respects that and God's therefore, again, if we believe
[1:14:47] in the biblical story, but if we're following that stream of
[1:14:49] consciousness, we're going God knows where they are, but God's
[1:14:53] respecting like where are you giving the respect?
[1:14:55] Knocking on a front door. I know where you are, but I'm
[1:14:57] knocking on your front door and and Adam and Eve are embarrassed
[1:15:00] of themselves and they they cover up their private parts.
[1:15:02] The idea of privacy. I think it what it's telling us
[1:15:05] biblically, but moving on is there is a value to just basic
[1:15:08] fundamental value to the idea of privacy.
[1:15:10] Interestingly, side note, to Fast forward to the United
[1:15:13] States, there's no word privacy in our Constitution at all.
[1:15:16] It doesn't mention the word privacy in England.
[1:15:17] They have the meant the word privacy in your constitution.
[1:15:20] In the United States, there is no constitution that says the
[1:15:22] word privacy in it. Actually local constitutions,
[1:15:26] California constitution has privacy, but like the United
[1:15:28] States constitution does have it.
[1:15:29] It implies that it's not an absolute, but it exists to the
[1:15:33] extent that it should, to the extent the government should
[1:15:36] have a right to take it away from you.
[1:15:38] So I have the right to have my own home and to do whatever I
[1:15:40] want to my home. But if you're committing a
[1:15:42] crime, the government can get a warranted bust in my house.
[1:15:44] So I do have the right to privacy, right?
[1:15:45] But the right to privacy we, we extrapolate into the right to
[1:15:49] gay marriage, right? Transgender issues, maybe
[1:15:53] abortion, right? Those very hot topic social
[1:15:56] issues are all based on a privacy concern, which is
[1:15:59] government. It's none of your business who I
[1:16:01] choose to marry. That's privacy, right?
[1:16:03] It's none of your business if I decide to eat meat or eat, eat
[1:16:07] vegan food or drink a large soda or small soda.
[1:16:09] It's a basic idea of privacy, right?
[1:16:11] The idea to exist. So I do think privacy is a
[1:16:14] fundamental idea. And by the way, not not just me,
[1:16:17] but like the UN Declaration of Human Rights recognizes privacy.
[1:16:20] A lot of countries recognize it explicitly.
[1:16:22] Well, it seems like there's this inextricable link between
[1:16:25] privacy and freedom that constantly overlaps.
[1:16:29] I guess I'm just work shopping here.
[1:16:31] Whether that can be severed and whether now with for the first
[1:16:35] time in history, the ability to use AI and sidestep humans, you
[1:16:42] can be monitored for everything and the AI, it's not this
[1:16:47] conscious sentient thing. It will be, I think.
[1:16:50] I don't know. I don't think so.
[1:16:52] I I don't know how we make that jump to a conscious AI.
[1:16:55] Hey man, I never figured out the iPhone right?
[1:16:58] Like so I'm saying it blew my mind.
[1:16:59] I don't know what could be come down, but yeah, I hear what
[1:17:02] you're saying. But the point being that it kind
[1:17:05] of depends on your definition of privacy and if privacy is
[1:17:10] specifically linked to another human observing you, right?
[1:17:15] Because if it is a machine that's observing you, I don't
[1:17:17] know. Let me.
[1:17:18] Ask you a simple. Freshman.
[1:17:19] Let me ask you a simple question, sorry.
[1:17:21] And again I interrupt, but I'm I'm moving quickly when you if
[1:17:25] you're at home by yourself, OK, this is a generalized question,
[1:17:29] not specific to you. If you're at home by yourself,
[1:17:30] no one's in your apartment, and you go to the bathroom, do you
[1:17:33] close the door? Nah, go #2 Nah.
[1:17:36] No, no, you're a weirdo. OK?
[1:17:39] Most people the answer would be yes.
[1:17:40] I explicitly keep it open for the freedom of being able to
[1:17:44] keep it open. But I think most people would
[1:17:46] close the door instinctively. It's AI think that's human error
[1:17:50] and that's or not error. That's harsh, but it's human
[1:17:54] emotion and habit rather than any actual logical grounding.
[1:17:59] It's reflecting a desire for privacy and on a very base,
[1:18:02] base, base form, the most private thing any human being
[1:18:06] does in any given day is go to the bathroom.
[1:18:08] You would always close it if someone else was there, not out
[1:18:11] of because you have concern for the smell in another individual,
[1:18:14] concern for yourself. I think that is a privacy thing,
[1:18:18] right? There's times when we just want
[1:18:20] to close the door and not be monitored.
[1:18:23] I think that is a fundamental human concept.
[1:18:25] Sorry. So to interrupt you I.
[1:18:26] Well, I, I agree that that probably certainly is the case.
[1:18:30] And we naturally feel this instinct for privacy.
[1:18:35] Does that necessitate that things should stay as they are
[1:18:38] and that we shouldn't have our privacy encroached upon?
[1:18:41] I mean no, it it, it, it doesn't mean that.
[1:18:43] But I, I really do love the idea of what you're discussing
[1:18:46] because the, the, the separation of freedom and privacy.
[1:18:49] And I don't, I, it's, I've never thought of it in those
[1:18:51] terminologies, but I do think that they're like offend, right?
[1:18:55] Again, workshopping. I think that they're synonymous.
[1:18:58] They have a certain synonymousness to us.
[1:19:01] You're not free if you're not private.
[1:19:04] I guess OK, let's like really draw this out here.
[1:19:08] Laws are decided upon to partly guide society towards
[1:19:14] flourishing. Can you give me perhaps a better
[1:19:17] take on the? Law.
[1:19:18] No, I, I, I guess I maybe have a very liberal.
[1:19:20] I'm not a libertarian, surprisingly, but I do have a
[1:19:22] libertarian view on it. I think that the baseline of the
[1:19:25] purpose of government is to protect us.
[1:19:28] Yeah, OK, so we have that in place, right?
[1:19:30] Protection of law. Now imagine a future where
[1:19:34] everyone goes and they take a shit in their own house and
[1:19:37] they've got a Ring doorbell camera watching them.
[1:19:40] They've got one in every room in the corner.
[1:19:43] That camera, it's not going to send that data anywhere.
[1:19:46] It's just being stored for a couple of seconds and then it
[1:19:49] gets deleted immediately. If a crime wasn't committed, if
[1:19:53] a burglar didn't jump through the window behind you, boss,
[1:19:55] you're taking your shit and violently rob you then run away.
[1:20:00] So in a sense of privacy, you're not having your privacy
[1:20:04] encroached upon by a human. It's it's just this AI machine.
[1:20:08] Now I hear what you're saying about humans wanting to close
[1:20:13] the door. Even if they're at home by
[1:20:14] themselves, that's I'm probably a weirdo for not doing that
[1:20:18] right. That's our instinct that's
[1:20:19] developed. But just play it forwards. 3
[1:20:22] generations of people taking shits with ring doorbell
[1:20:25] cameras. You're probably just going to
[1:20:27] get used to that. And then looping back to laws
[1:20:32] protecting your society. That's a much stronger society
[1:20:36] and safer society. It's a much more regulated
[1:20:40] society too. I mean, I hear you again.
[1:20:42] We're we're talking in such abstract theoretical right?
[1:20:46] I don't know if we are though. I think this is the direction
[1:20:48] because if government were to say something like that, I'd be
[1:20:51] appalled. I think most people would be
[1:20:54] like, I don't see a form of government that isn't fascist
[1:20:56] that can impose that what you're saying, right?
[1:21:00] It's it's very utopian. Like if we're coming from a
[1:21:02] place like strictly to for this, like every single thing we do is
[1:21:07] to protect human beings. And therefore it does not matter
[1:21:10] what right, we are going to be on top of you and we're going to
[1:21:13] watch everything you do. Then in that like scenario with
[1:21:17] the utter altruism of government and no nefarious forces at play,
[1:21:22] etcetera, then maybe there's a point to be made, but it's not
[1:21:26] it doesn't exist. And no one, I don't think
[1:21:28] anybody, nobody could ever implement that.
[1:21:32] The moment you have like those sort of things.
[1:21:34] Let's I'm trying to think of a more concrete example that we're
[1:21:38] talking about today here. Maybe this is helpful.
[1:21:40] I don't know to, to maybe extrapolate my position.
[1:21:44] Google collects data points on you.
[1:21:47] Every single thing you do, every single thing you do, it's
[1:21:51] collecting data points they they stored in something called the
[1:21:54] sensor vault. OK, so Google has a sensor
[1:21:57] vault, which you have a Android or if you have an iPhone, but
[1:22:01] the Android for sure, everything you do on Android, you have an
[1:22:03] iPhone, you have Gmail, right? Or you have other apps that
[1:22:06] Google owns or third party apps that they control.
[1:22:08] Every time you log on to one of those apps, you're sending a
[1:22:11] location. Google collects that location.
[1:22:17] More than numbers than I can count.
[1:22:18] I don't know. I don't know.
[1:22:20] Numbers past quintillion, right? They have more data points than
[1:22:23] that. I think it's all electronically
[1:22:25] generated and motivated. Now I have a murder.
[1:22:27] This is how I've hided this multiple times.
[1:22:29] I have a murder scene. Here's a location of a murder
[1:22:31] scene and murder happened. 2 AMI find a dead body here.
[1:22:34] I don't know who was there. I don't know what's going on.
[1:22:36] What do I do? I go to Google.
[1:22:38] I said give them a longitude, latitude, 4 points, whatever
[1:22:41] shape I want, small area. And I say during this time
[1:22:45] period from let's say 1:30, I found the body of 2.
[1:22:47] So I say from 1:00 to 3:00, how many phones connected?
[1:22:51] How many devices connected in this box?
[1:22:54] Google can give me data points on how many people connected in
[1:22:56] that box. They collect that data and then
[1:22:59] from there we can narrow it down and figure out who may be the
[1:23:02] perpetrator is who the criminals.
[1:23:03] Real life example, we find a dead body on top of a mountain
[1:23:07] in the Hollywood Hills one night.
[1:23:08] No one new was murdered. They collect the body.
[1:23:11] They put it in the freezer at the coroner's office for further
[1:23:13] examination. 5 days later, coroner unzips the frozen body
[1:23:16] and notices a bullet wound in the back of the guy's head.
[1:23:19] Cops go out to see and there's nothing there.
[1:23:22] You're 5 days too late, you morons.
[1:23:24] OK, so now we have a dead body. Who killed him?
[1:23:27] They go get a Geo fence. It's called the Geo warrant.
[1:23:29] Geo fence warrant, a geolocation warrant.
[1:23:31] It takes a certain geographical location.
[1:23:34] We get a warrant and we can see what devices. 1 device is the
[1:23:36] victims, so he's excluded as the murderer.
[1:23:39] There's a second device. That's it.
[1:23:41] That's probably our murderer. Now we can start tracking that
[1:23:44] individual. We then get all his his his text
[1:23:48] messages that he had sent in the past week before we knew it was
[1:23:52] a murder and he's texting they haven't found the body yet to
[1:23:56] his sister. OK, now we know you're the
[1:23:58] murderer, but the virtue of the fact you're techie said I did
[1:24:01] it, I killed him, but they haven't found the body yet.
[1:24:03] This isn't a time before anybody knew there was a murder, right?
[1:24:07] So it's a it's helpful for us to solving crime, but there's a lot
[1:24:10] of pushback on that. So a lot of pushback saying it's
[1:24:13] a mass surveillance, government surveillance to the extent that,
[1:24:16] for example, ICE not to get, I don't know how ICE is doing it,
[1:24:19] but ICE is using some version of geofence for whatever they're
[1:24:22] doing. So the California legislature
[1:24:24] recently proposed that limiting the ability of companies to
[1:24:27] collect geolocation information on you.
[1:24:29] So whatever app you have, I don't know if you have a 711
[1:24:31] app, a Starbucks app, a coffee bean app, these are like local
[1:24:34] play and you and you get alerts like, oh, there's whatever it is
[1:24:37] that's a geofence. They're collecting data.
[1:24:39] It's going to limit the amount of data the companies collect on
[1:24:42] you, the worry from law enforcement.
[1:24:43] So the pushback like to give your perspective, I'm writing a
[1:24:46] memo to my to my legislative people in the in my office
[1:24:48] going, Hey, this is a huge problem because sometimes crimes
[1:24:51] aren't solved for a year. And we the ability to go back a
[1:24:53] year ago and look at that data is wonderful.
[1:24:56] And so now we're pushing back saying, no, we don't want them
[1:24:58] to only collect for five days or a week, two weeks.
[1:25:00] We want to be able to them to collect indefinitely for the
[1:25:03] purposes of crime prevention. That's what ends up happening.
[1:25:05] That's the slow degradation of what would happen in your world.
[1:25:09] For me, I think it's good, but for you it's bad.
[1:25:10] But I'm saying that's the slow degradation.
[1:25:12] It's it's momentarily, it's hacked.
[1:25:15] The system's viewed right. There's so many things that can
[1:25:18] happen technologically that give fear to people in any given in
[1:25:21] every any given in way that what you're describing is abstractly
[1:25:25] perfection of society where we're all have each other's
[1:25:29] interests in mind but doesn't actually work.
[1:25:31] I agree, and I think pragmatically speaking here it
[1:25:37] would never work. The thing about what I just
[1:25:39] described, right, because I was putting it in more concrete
[1:25:41] forms. Or would you be concerned that I
[1:25:45] can take a geofence? Let's say the murder happens at
[1:25:48] 2:00 PM in Santa Monica in this area and I can take a geofence
[1:25:53] and I get 10,000 hits. Are you concerned about that?
[1:25:56] It doesn't tell me their names, it just tells me device.
[1:25:59] Well, yeah, I I think it's such an interesting concept to
[1:26:03] entertain, but pragmatically, there's always going to be
[1:26:07] someone nefarious that misuses your data.
[1:26:10] So we can agree on that. And I want to tie a ribbon on
[1:26:14] this section and sort of move us on from that and from the
[1:26:19] position that I was articulating and and sort of workshopping.
[1:26:23] Are there any other examples of that present day that concern
[1:26:27] you? Something like the use the such
[1:26:30] a, there's such a prevalent use of the word safety.
[1:26:34] I'm prioritizing people's safety.
[1:26:38] What's concerning you at the moment in terms of people's
[1:26:42] privacy and inalienable rights that's masked up in compassion
[1:26:47] and protection? Well, you just described it,
[1:26:49] right. No, I mean, I don't worry that
[1:26:51] much about it. Me say, I tend to have, even
[1:26:53] with the libertarian views, I just expressed a a good trust in
[1:26:56] my government and a good trust in the democratic system and my
[1:26:59] fellow citizens. I think I do have that.
[1:27:02] And so I look at it as as when my citizenry is LED astray with
[1:27:05] false beliefs on certain things, like as a professional field of
[1:27:09] criminal justice, and I see people advocating against that,
[1:27:12] right? And you go, OK, let's let's have
[1:27:14] a rational conversation without name calling.
[1:27:16] Can we do that? And let's figure out what's
[1:27:18] right or wrong. That's what worries me more,
[1:27:20] right? It's the subversion of humanity,
[1:27:22] which I hope always has a rebounded effect.
[1:27:25] I'm not that concerned yet about government surveillance.
[1:27:27] Me say as a person who's done these Geo fence warrants or
[1:27:30] something called tower dumps, I can go to a cell tower nearby
[1:27:33] and take all the data off it, right?
[1:27:36] And know every device that connected to that cell tower
[1:27:38] over any given period of time. I'm less concerned about that
[1:27:40] 'cause I know the regulation by which we operate and how we're
[1:27:42] using it. I am more concerned you're like
[1:27:45] we, we, we had discussed many times is the social manipulation
[1:27:48] of people and the perspectives that tend to alter this, the
[1:27:52] physical safety of our society that, that concerns me more than
[1:27:55] current government overreach. Like government engages,
[1:28:00] government will always push the boundaries and that's why it's
[1:28:03] really important to have a checks and balances.
[1:28:05] And I think we have a robust one.
[1:28:06] But like we saw with the NSA and what Snowden revealed, hero or
[1:28:10] hack, whatever you want to call him, that's not the issue.
[1:28:13] What he revealed to us was something significant that the
[1:28:15] government was collecting data on us and they shouldn't have
[1:28:17] been. That's significant.
[1:28:22] I have concern about that, but in general we have, I'm more
[1:28:24] concerned about Google and Amazon collecting data than I am
[1:28:27] about the government because we're far more regulated than
[1:28:31] they are. They collect all sorts of data
[1:28:33] on you that you have no idea about and it's within their
[1:28:36] contract contractual rights. I'm more, I'm more scared of
[1:28:39] them and then I'm more scared of the manipulation of society and
[1:28:43] the way society might move along and view things in perspectives
[1:28:47] and attitudes that ultimately result in danger to our my
[1:28:51] fellow beings. We had ADA at the District
[1:28:54] Attorney of Los Angeles. His name was George Gascon, who
[1:28:57] for four years was the District Attorney of Los Angeles.
[1:28:59] His experiment was a disaster. He was loathed by every person
[1:29:03] internally. Every District Attorney worked
[1:29:05] under him. We loathe him.
[1:29:06] We find him to be a despicable person.
[1:29:09] And his social experiment resulted in the actual death of
[1:29:11] people. More people were killed, more
[1:29:14] people were robbed, more properties were burglarized,
[1:29:17] more stores were were broken into because of your, your
[1:29:21] idiotic experiment that is factually and and and legally
[1:29:25] untrue. That's what worries me more.
[1:29:28] And and and he got elected in the largest county in the world.
[1:29:30] I mean, serious, right? We have 1000 prosecutors in Los
[1:29:34] Angeles, 1000. That's how big we are.
[1:29:38] New York is separated into boroughs.
[1:29:39] But just to give you an example, Brooklyn is like 350.
[1:29:42] Yeah. So we're humongous and we, our
[1:29:45] society elected this official to destroy their society, but
[1:29:49] because they're under delusion, unfortunately.
[1:29:51] So that's what worries me more than than government itself.
[1:29:54] Well, I want to speak to you more about local issues
[1:29:57] prosecuting narcotics gangs. Talk to me all about Skid Row
[1:30:02] and LA and the government in the last few years.
[1:30:04] But we can do that over on Sub Stack along with you answering
[1:30:07] some supporters questions that they've sent in for.
[1:30:09] Sure. I will suggest there is a guy
[1:30:11] that you have to track down to do a podcast with if you want to
[1:30:14] talk about Skid Row. His name is Officer Deon Joseph.
[1:30:17] DEON Joseph. He is the Skid Row senior lead
[1:30:22] officer for like 25 years. Humongous black dude, a
[1:30:25] wonderful guy. I think a hero, a a real
[1:30:30] Superman when it comes to these things save lives.
[1:30:33] But he's very hated by a lot of groups that want to regulate his
[1:30:37] and he understands Skid Row and the nature of the people there.
[1:30:39] But yeah, certainly I'm more than happy to answer.
[1:30:41] But there is a great resource here in LA that is unbelievable.
[1:30:46] Well, I'll have to go after him. I'm fascinated by Skid Row as
[1:30:50] this concept and I've been down there filming a documentary and
[1:30:53] researching into it, and so I'll press you on that on Subs.
[1:30:57] Anytime, and I'm telling Dion Joseph has been he knows every
[1:31:00] single person living on Skid Row for more than two months knows
[1:31:02] Dion Joseph. Wow.
[1:31:04] He is the most prolifically well known police officer I've ever
[1:31:08] met in my life. Every store, every business,
[1:31:11] every homeless person knows Dion Joseph, and he knows them.
[1:31:16] Benny, where can people find more of your work?
[1:31:18] Don't, no, I want privacy. No.
[1:31:20] OK, I, I'm a District Attorney in LA.
[1:31:23] My specialty is cybercrime. I love doing that.
[1:31:25] I've written 2 textbooks there on Amazon that I, I just self
[1:31:29] published one on cyber law and one on Law Without Borders.
[1:31:33] It's like a sampling of like copyright law and privacy and
[1:31:36] things like that. Online defamation, online
[1:31:39] copyrights, that sort of thing. And I teach at USCI, teach two
[1:31:42] classes there at the University of Southern California.
[1:31:44] And that's the amazing. And other than that, I don't
[1:31:47] have a website or post on social media, but I, I love teaching.
[1:31:50] I love being a District Attorney.
[1:31:52] It's the greatest. And head on over to Substack,
[1:31:54] where Benny's going to answer your questions and we're going
[1:31:57] to encroach on his privacy even more.
[1:31:59] Fantastic.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
