# The Life of the Greatest Philosopher Ever: Blaise Pascal - Graham Tomlin | #62

An episode of [The Next Generation](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1772698742), 22 Dec 2025, 1 h 22 min.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/107851968/podcast/play/112318261/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2025-11-8%2F413986172-44100-2-656cc5098e6a5.mp3

I’ve recently become fascinated by 17th century genius Blaise Pascal, so I was delighted to speak to Graham Tomlin, the author of ‘Blaise Pascal – The Man Who Made the Modern World’ (a book which I loved!) Graham Tomlin taught theology at Oxford University for many years and served as Bishop of Kensington from 2015 until 2022. He is Director of the Centre for Cultural Witness, the author of many books and articles, and the founder of Seen & Unseen. Subscribe to my Substack to send in questions for upcoming guests! https://elliotbewick.substack.com/ Get the book! https://www.amazon.co.uk/Blaise-Pascal-Made-Modern-World/dp/1399807641/ Graham on X: https://x.com/gtomlin CHAPTERS 00:00 What’s the biggest impact Blaise Pascal has had on the world? 01:10 Pascal’s early years 07:20 The religious makeup of Pascal’s family 10:21 Pascal’s health struggles 14:55 Pascal clashes with Descartes 16:14 “I think, therefore I am” 19:32 Pascal’s criticism of Descartes’ position 21:58 How these ideas still affect us today 25:49 The Infinite Pleasure Machine experiment 28:26 Do we value human life for evolutionary reasons? 32:22 Is it wrong to prioritise happiness? 38:44 Is ‘being yourself’ a good idea? 41:44 What even is ‘The Self’? 44:32 Pascal’s intellectual life in Paris 48:40 Pascal invents the Pascaline 51:58 The ‘Night of Fire’ and the Provincial Letters 59:59 How Pascal changed after his religious experience 1:03:08 What is Pascal’s Wager? 1:10:52 What is Pascal’s most important idea? 1:13:13 How can a God who hides Himself be benevolent? 1:16:37 How can young people learn from Pascal? 1:20:31 Find more from Graham My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotbewick/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliotbewick X: https://x.com/elliotbewick ABOUT THE NEXT GENERATION: In a world saturated by social media and marked by skyrocketing rates of anxiety, depression, and ADHD among Gen Z, young people are growing up in a landscape of chaos and contradiction. While protests swell in city streets and activists hurl soup at famous artworks to demand climate action, a quieter crisis unfolds within - the mental and emotional battles faced by a generation trying to make sense of it all. The Next Generation is hosted by 20-year-old Elliot Bewick, offering a raw and honest look at the world through the eyes of those living in it. Bringing together insight from professionals and young people on the ground, this podcast isn’t here to complain or chase clout. It’s here to bend the arc of the modern world towards solutions, truth and a love for the beautiful adventure of life itself.

## Transcript

[0:00] You've written an entire book about Blaise Pascal.
[0:04] What was the biggest impact he's had on the world?
[0:08] Well, I guess it would depend on who you ask.
[0:10] If you ask a physicist, they would probably tell you it's he
[0:13] proved the existence of a vacuum because people didn't tend to
[0:15] believe they existed before. If you asked an urban planner,
[0:19] he would say he invented buses. We could tell that story later
[0:23] on if you like, if you asked a mathematician it would, they
[0:28] would say he invented or helped you invent probability theory,
[0:31] which lies behind all the signs of insurance and pretty well
[0:35] everything we do these days. But I think for me, I would say
[0:37] the biggest impact he had on history is through one
[0:41] particular book. That is the one thing that he he
[0:43] he wrote, which is still read today, which is his passe, which
[0:46] is this remarkable book of reflections on human life, God,
[0:51] our place in the world. And yeah, people still read it
[0:55] today, you know, 400 years after he was born and that and after
[0:59] he lived. And so that is a is a set of
[1:01] reflections that makes people think still, you know, deep
[1:04] thoughts about the nature of human life and what it is and
[1:07] what we're doing here on this earth.
[1:08] That, I think, is his biggest legacy.
[1:10] This is an incredible man and I've really enjoyed reading your
[1:13] book, learning all about him. He's someone that essentially
[1:17] did the first scientific experiment properly and his
[1:21] legacy is incredible. So let's delve into this.
[1:23] I want us to set the scene here. He's born in 1623.
[1:26] What's going on here? This is somewhere between the
[1:30] Battle of Hastings and the invention of the iPhone.
[1:34] Yeah. So let's go from there.
[1:35] Exactly. Well, 1623, he was born in a
[1:38] place called Claremore in the the ovarian, which is kind of in
[1:42] the middle of the South of France in a kind of mountainous
[1:45] area or hilly area around there. And what's going on this time?
[1:49] Well, you got a 30 years War, which is a kind of a war that
[1:52] happened over 30 years, strangely enough, in the title,
[1:56] from 1618 to 1648, which is a huge war that consumed most of
[2:00] Europe and was a kind of big background to, to, to France.
[2:03] The life in France at the time, it was a time when the king was
[2:07] Louis the 13th during his lifetime, Pascal's lifetime
[2:11] became Louis the 14th. And at that time also the time
[2:16] of Pascal's lifetime, we have the Civil War here in England,
[2:20] which is again of time a real convulsion.
[2:22] So there's a lot of social change going on.
[2:24] So the backdrop to Pascal's life is a lot of warfare, a lot of
[2:27] dispute, a lot of controversy. You've got the current aftermath
[2:31] of the Reformation, struggles between Protestants and
[2:34] Catholics in Europe. What is Europe going to become,
[2:37] is going to become a Protestant, become a Catholic.
[2:38] You've got the rise of science, the sort of scientific endeavour
[2:42] they get, experimental method. You've got a lot of things going
[2:44] on in philosophy or in a Descartes and, and people like
[2:48] that. So you've got a lot going on in
[2:49] the background. So he lives at a really sort of
[2:51] a, a type of real turmoil in, in, in European life.
[2:55] And that's kind of where he is. So he's not quite at the iPhone,
[2:58] although he did have a little part to play in that.
[3:00] We can talk about that in a moment.
[3:01] It's not quite the Battle of Hastings, not much much to do
[3:04] with that either. He never visited England, so he
[3:06] never came here, but he lived in his entire life in France.
[3:09] But that's something about the background to his Life and
[3:11] Times. It's such an exciting time
[3:13] period, and I've never paid it any attention at all growing up,
[3:17] partly because I've never been taught it in school, and partly
[3:20] because the quantifiable nature of this period is less
[3:24] impressive than something like the advent of the Internet,
[3:27] right? Or the Industrial Revolution.
[3:29] I mean, this is an era of ideas and experimentation, and that's
[3:35] what I love so much, but what also perhaps makes it slightly
[3:38] inaccessible to people on the surface level until they scratch
[3:41] a bit deeper and find all of these amazing stories.
[3:44] So let's go back to Pascal. In his early years, you often
[3:48] hear him being described as this precocious talent, and you've
[3:53] got this. I don't know what the word would
[3:55] be for precociality or something similar.
[3:59] Precociousness. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[4:00] But you've got this precociousness paired with these
[4:04] physical ailments and struggles that he's having, which I think
[4:07] goes on to form his thinking quite fundamentally.
[4:10] So speak to me about Pascal and his early years.
[4:13] Yeah, well, let's say he born 6023.
[4:16] His his mother died when he was about 3 years old.
[4:18] That's quite a significant thing because it meant that he never
[4:22] had a he never even remembers his mother.
[4:23] His father was a really significant figure for him.
[4:26] His father was a kind of a kind of intellectual, like, like to
[4:30] think of himself as an intellectual, like to kind of
[4:32] gather with all the kind of clever people in Claremore where
[4:35] he lived. In fact, actually, when Pascal's
[4:37] nine years old, his father thinks, well, Claremore's a bit
[4:41] of a backwater. Not many bright people around
[4:43] here. I'm going to move the Paris, the
[4:45] family to Paris, which is what he does.
[4:47] And that was kind of big move for the family and big move for
[4:50] for Pascal himself. He had two sisters, an older
[4:53] sister, Gilbert, who was the kind of slightly bossy older
[4:56] sister who kind of organised the family and told everybody what
[4:58] to do. And her younger sister
[4:59] Jacqueline, who was in her own right, was quite a significant
[5:02] figure. She was a very artistic, quite
[5:05] in a poetic person, wrote poetry in his, her early years, but a
[5:09] very religious person. She became very, she joined a
[5:13] kind of convent, which is part of a movement called Jansenism,
[5:16] which Pascal was drawn to. So that's his kind of family
[5:18] background and, and, and his early years, he was recognised
[5:21] as being someone extraordinarily bright.
[5:23] There's a story that's told of him when he's really quite
[5:26] young. I think he's about 8 years old
[5:27] at the time when his father, he was home schooled.
[5:30] So he never went to school, never went to university in his
[5:33] entire life. His father homeschooled him.
[5:36] And there was a story about how his father thought that you
[5:39] should begin by teaching someone Latin.
[5:41] So he taught him how to speak Latin and how to read Latin,
[5:44] taught him some basics, sort of sort of language, all that kind
[5:46] of thing. But he thought mathematics.
[5:48] We'll leave that till later on because that's the kind of
[5:50] advanced science and we'll get on to that when he's a teenager.
[5:53] But Pascal, on one day, you know, his father comes into a
[5:58] room where Pascal is sort of drawing on the on, on the floor
[6:02] with the chalk and he looks and he thinks that's a bit weird.
[6:05] What's he drawing there? And he realised that he's
[6:07] basically drawing out Euclidean geometry.
[6:12] In other words, Pascal had kind of discovered the basic
[6:15] principles of one of the key theorems of Euclidean geometry
[6:18] at the age of 8. Now, you know, did he read it in
[6:21] a book when his dad wasn't looking?
[6:23] Well, had he worked this out himself?
[6:25] Probably he had worked it out himself.
[6:26] But he said one of those stories that he's told about him that
[6:29] gives you the impression here is a bit of a child genius, Here is
[6:32] someone who right from the early days, people realized had a more
[6:35] than average intelligence, ability to think new thoughts, a
[6:41] kind of boldness in his thinking.
[6:43] You know, he wasn't necessarily going to toe the line.
[6:45] He was going to, you know, take the risk of incurring his
[6:48] father's wrath by getting into maths too early.
[6:51] So it tells you a little bit about Pascal and just one of
[6:53] those stories. Am I right in thinking he's kept
[6:56] hope schooled because of his precociousness?
[6:59] Because of how intelligent he appears to be.
[7:01] Yeah, there's a certain element of that.
[7:02] His father kind of recognises I've got a bit of a genius on my
[7:05] hands here. I'm think his father probably
[7:08] didn't trust the kind of public education system, and so he kept
[7:12] all three children home, especially Blaze, to homeschool
[7:15] them. So.
[7:15] Exactly right. Yeah.
[7:16] I think it was because his father thought, you know this,
[7:19] this child needs special treatment.
[7:21] His older sister gets into the the field of Jansenism and and
[7:25] we can get on to that a bit later.
[7:27] But before that, would be interesting to hear about his
[7:29] father Etienne and his religious background raising Pascal as a
[7:33] kid. Well, Etienne Etienne is a
[7:35] fairly conventional Catholic. It seems that his Pascal's
[7:39] mother was quite a devout Christian.
[7:43] There are all the stories that are told of her is that she was
[7:45] a very, very sort of devoted to the the poor of the parish.
[7:49] She's very generous in giving and taking people into the home
[7:51] and so on. Pascal's father, they didn't
[7:54] speak much about his religious devotion.
[7:56] He was a kind of conventional Catholic, went to Mass, did the
[7:58] kind of religious stuff, but it wasn't a massive important part
[8:01] of his life. He was more interested in these
[8:03] philosophical and mathematical and philosophical questions that
[8:07] were debated in the sort of intellectual circles of
[8:10] Claremore at the time. How casual is his approach to
[8:13] Christianity and Catholicism for someone living in France in that
[8:16] period? Yeah, it's pretty typical, I
[8:18] guess. I guess today you might think,
[8:21] you know, the typical person in Britain isn't that interesting
[8:24] in religion. And there are some people who
[8:26] are quite interested. In those days, it was most
[8:30] people were kind of, you know, went to church, to Mass from
[8:33] time to time. Some were really focused on it,
[8:36] either to the extent of going, becoming, you know, part of a
[8:39] convent or a monastery or becoming a priest.
[8:42] So it was a sort of different stage, as it were.
[8:44] So he's a kind of fairly conventional Catholic, like
[8:47] many, many people in France at the time.
[8:49] But what happens to him at a particular period is that he,
[8:52] there's a story about how he, he goes out one winter's day.
[8:57] The story is told that he's meant to be the, the, the kind
[9:00] of the, the, the he's been to attend a duel between two
[9:05] gentlemen who've arranged to kind of shoot each other.
[9:07] And he was slightly underhand because that was meant to be
[9:09] banned at the time. Anyway, he was on his way to
[9:11] this. And he slips over in the ice
[9:12] and, and does something to his hip, either breaks his hip or
[9:15] dislocates his hip. And so he comes home in a bit of
[9:19] a bad way. And So what you do at the time
[9:20] is you don't go to A&E, but you get what are called bone setters
[9:23] to come round and treat you. And so he looked up the local
[9:27] bone setters and these these two guys come and they come and stay
[9:30] in the Pascal house for probably about a month or two just to
[9:32] kind of to give him medical treatment, put his bones back in
[9:36] place and so on. But these people happen to be
[9:39] what are called Jansenists, which is a very strict movement
[9:43] of 17th century Catholicism. Again, we can talk about what
[9:45] they believe, but and this was a significant moment for the
[9:48] family because they see their job not just as treating
[9:52] Etienne's hip, but also converting the family to
[9:56] Jansenism, which they do quite successfully, particularly for
[10:00] Pascal's younger sister Jacqueline and Blaise himself.
[10:04] So Jacqueline is the one who's most affected by them and a bit
[10:06] Gilbert, the older sister, Blaise is drawn to that sort of
[10:10] form of faith, Etienne kind of drawn to it, but still a little
[10:13] bit oldies distance. So that's that's kind of gives
[10:16] you a bit of the, the sort of map, map of the family religious
[10:20] outlook. The beauty in this book, and I
[10:23] usually don't big people's books up this much on the show,
[10:25] actually, I hate when people do that performatively.
[10:27] But the beauty in this one is that it really fleshes out the
[10:31] human condition felt by anyone, specifically philosophers, that
[10:35] we often dehumanise and just put into their ideas and that's it.
[10:39] When obviously the ideas are downstream from the experiences
[10:43] they've felt. And especially someone that's
[10:46] had such a large impact on the world as Pascal, He's got all of
[10:49] these interesting factors that we can get into influencing his
[10:53] ideas. Speak to me about his health
[10:55] struggles early on. Well, Pascal is someone he's
[10:59] struggled with poor health throughout his life.
[11:01] When he he died aged 39, he didn't live very long and he
[11:05] probably died of kind of stomach cancer, probably with
[11:08] secondaries in the brain because he, he had intense headaches and
[11:13] through but through most of it, even even in the early, early
[11:15] years, he there's an episode that's told about him when he
[11:18] was young where he nearly died because of an ailment that he
[11:23] had. There's a kind of story that was
[11:24] all to do with a curse and a witch and all that kind of
[11:26] thing. But was it that or was it, you
[11:28] know, you can make your mind upon that.
[11:30] But all the way through his life, he basically struggled
[11:32] with poor health. And he actually said at one
[11:33] point, I never had a day in my adult life without some form of
[11:37] pain. And it kind of came and went.
[11:38] Sometimes it was an intense sickness that basically sent me
[11:43] to bed. And he couldn't really sort of
[11:45] get up and be around. There's a famous time when he
[11:48] meets the philosopher Rene Descartes, who has been older
[11:50] than him. But Pascal is ill.
[11:52] He's in bed over the weekend and Descartes comes and visits him
[11:55] and and so on. And, and there were other times
[11:58] when he was able to be up and around and, you know, live a
[12:00] relatively normal life. So it came and went a bit.
[12:02] But he was always in some form of pain, especially towards the
[12:05] end of his life. And that was a big, big,
[12:07] significant part of Pascal's reflection on the human
[12:11] condition. They actually experienced a lot
[12:13] of pain. And of course for, I suppose if
[12:15] he'd been living now, he would have had medical treatment, did
[12:18] have had anaesthetics, he would have had the cancer, probably
[12:21] would have been diagnosed earlier, might even have been
[12:23] treated, he might have lived a lot longer.
[12:24] But at the time, of course, not much could be done about that.
[12:27] And so, so again, you know, we think of Pascal as someone who
[12:31] was unusually sick and he probably was unusually sick even
[12:35] for that period. But we also have to recognise
[12:37] that at that time that was a pretty common experience that,
[12:40] you know, people got ill and they experienced sickness and
[12:43] the mortality rate was a lot higher today than than it was
[12:46] now. So he's reflecting something
[12:48] that we probably don't think about quite so much the
[12:50] prevalence of, especially in the West and other parts of the
[12:53] world, you do think about it a lot more the, you know, the
[12:56] prevalence of disease and sickness as a part of the human
[12:58] condition. But Pascal's very aware of that
[13:00] all the way through his life. How does that impact his
[13:02] philosophy and how do you think that impacts our philosophy
[13:05] today sat here in an air conditioned studio?
[13:07] Yeah, well, I think it did affect his philosophy in the
[13:10] sense that he has a he has a kind of a a sense that the human
[13:15] experience is, it's difficult, it's complicated, it's not
[13:20] straightforward. And it's actually full of pain.
[13:23] And pain is something you have to deal with.
[13:25] You can't just sort of push it to one side and ignore it
[13:27] doesn't exist. It's something that is there now
[13:30] for him. It's strange enough he doesn't
[13:32] think of it as a thing that questions his belief in God,
[13:37] partly because I think for most people at the time, it was just
[13:39] such something that was just so prevalent.
[13:41] It was just around you all the time.
[13:43] You just accepted it. It's just the way things are.
[13:47] And I think it's more in our modern world where we've kind of
[13:49] been able to manage pain and put it to the to the to the margins
[13:52] that suddenly we think, well, pain is a bit of an anomaly in
[13:55] the world. Why is it here?
[13:57] Why does God allow it? All those kind of questions?
[13:59] I think Scott didn't really ask that question, nor did many of
[14:01] his contemporaries. That's a very modern question
[14:03] for us. And so I think it's, it is that
[14:06] and it it, and it does colour his view of the world.
[14:08] So if you compare him somewhere like, like Voltaire, for
[14:11] example, and it comes a little bit after Pascal, Voltaire is a
[14:15] sort of cheery kind of chap, you know, who thinks that the future
[14:18] is bright and it's all going to be fine.
[14:20] And, and it's partly because, you know, his life is relatively
[14:22] untroubled. And I think Pascal's sickness
[14:25] probably did make him feel, make him kind of identify with people
[14:31] who go through real struggles, whether mentally or physically.
[14:35] And so he's someone, I think he, you know who, who is a
[14:37] philosopher and a, and a, a thinker for people who know that
[14:40] life is complicated, it's difficult, it's often painful,
[14:44] it's not straightforward. He is someone rather than for
[14:46] the person who thinks, yeah, life is fine, no problem at all.
[14:50] You know that that I don't have to worry about questions like
[14:53] pain or difficulty or trauma. So Pascal, the Pascal family,
[14:58] have moved to Paris and this is going to make a massive impact
[15:01] on their lives. But before we get to how this
[15:04] impacts their lives and how Pascal grows up for a few years
[15:06] in Paris, we've got a big thinker here at the time who's a
[15:11] bit of a celebrity in France, and that is Rene Descartes.
[15:14] What are his ideas that are most popular in the time and how does
[15:20] he impact this whole unravelling situation with the Pascal family
[15:24] moving to Paris? Well, Descartes, as I say, is a
[15:28] little bit older than Blaise Pascal.
[15:30] They met once, as I say, when Pascal was ill and Descartes
[15:34] tried to lecture Pascal and what he ought to do about his health.
[15:37] It didn't go down too well. You know what it's like when
[15:39] someone when you're struggling and someone's trying to tell and
[15:41] give you all kinds of advice and.
[15:43] When they met once, they've LED up to this for quite a few
[15:46] years, they did. Pascal has been reading his work
[15:49] for a few years. He's always had quite the
[15:50] distaste for Descartes. Exactly.
[15:53] And after a few years, they finally meet.
[15:55] There's this anticipation and. The feelings mutually go because
[15:59] Descartes thinks, who is this young upstart?
[16:00] And people have been sending him papers that he'd written.
[16:03] Blaise Pascal and Descartes, you know, who is this guy?
[16:05] You know, you know, I'll put him in his place.
[16:07] There's a little bit of that going on.
[16:08] So take take us key ideas. I mean, I suppose 2 two things
[16:12] you could focus on. One is we're talking about the
[16:15] period after the Reformation. So the 16th century, you got the
[16:17] big Protestant Reformation. And as a result of that, you've
[16:20] got these two forms of Christianity in Europe,
[16:22] Protestantism, Catholicism. And so it's kind of broken apart
[16:25] the kind of unified Christendom of, of, of the Western world.
[16:30] And, and the kind of question is, well, who, who, who's right?
[16:33] Who are the Protestants or the Catholic right?
[16:34] And this question about certainty, where can you find
[16:37] certainty? Where can you find something
[16:39] that you can be absolutely sure of?
[16:41] It's a kind of philosophical question that's around at the
[16:43] time. And of course, Descartes is a
[16:45] famous moment in I think it's 1619 where he, he, he tries an
[16:50] experiment. He's a he's a, a kind of
[16:52] mercenary soldier at the time, but a kind of amateur
[16:56] philosopher. And he goes into he climbs into
[16:59] a room and he and he gets to 6 Brown.
[17:01] I'm not going to come out of this room until I can find
[17:02] something that I cannot doubt. And he tries to go through
[17:06] everything idea that comes into his mind either.
[17:08] Can I doubt that? You know, I can doubt it.
[17:09] I can put it to one side. This is all unfolding in a
[17:12] furnace room, right? Yeah, it's it's it's often
[17:15] called a stone, a stove filled room.
[17:17] So what it was is the way rooms were heated in, in cold Northern
[17:23] European houses, you'd have a big sort of stove in the corner
[17:29] with where you'd sort of, you know, there, there would be a
[17:31] fire in it and it, and it would basically heat the house.
[17:34] And so it was a room with a big stove in the corner.
[17:36] That's basically what it was. And so he didn't climb into a
[17:40] stove. If he climbed into a room with a
[17:41] stove in it, you'd have got rather hot otherwise.
[17:44] So he, he, you know, he spends his time in this room with this,
[17:46] this mental experiment. What can I find that I cannot
[17:49] doubt and he, and what he arrives at is to think.
[17:53] The thing that I cannot doubt is the fact that I'm thinking, the
[17:56] fact that I'm aware of myself. So the thinking self becomes
[18:00] the, the kind of basis of his philosophy.
[18:02] And he comes up with the most famous sound bite in Western
[18:05] European philosophical history, which is cogito ergo some I
[18:09] think, therefore I am. And he says, OK, that's the one
[18:13] thing I can be absolutely sure of that I'm thinking.
[18:16] And so he says, OK, we can rebuild a philosophical system
[18:19] from that starting point. You don't think it's OK?
[18:22] The first idea that the thinking self kind of perceives outside
[18:26] itself is the idea of God. Again, you know, think of DNA's
[18:29] working in the world of Christendom, where the kind of
[18:31] idea of God is pretty universal. So he has a place for God, but
[18:35] it's almost as if the world has shifted at that point.
[18:37] So rather than God being at the center of the thing, God has
[18:40] slightly shifted to the edge and the thinking self is coming to
[18:42] the middle of it. And so for him, the thinking
[18:46] self, the process of thinking, rationality, reason, that
[18:49] becomes the most important thing.
[18:51] And so he starts to think that actually the whole becomes very
[18:54] confident in the power of human reason to understand everything
[18:58] to to control everything, to to manage everything around.
[19:02] So he's supremely confident in reason.
[19:04] And that's the thing that got very people very excited at the
[19:06] time. And the the other thing about
[19:08] that is there is stray strong in in in Descartes, they could this
[19:12] kind of mind body dualism the the mind.
[19:16] For me. So, you know, if you think
[19:17] about, you know, we have minds, we have bodies.
[19:20] And in one way of thinking that we'd say, well, that's, it's all
[19:23] kind of one thing. We are sort of, you know, we're,
[19:27] we're one thing, which is, you know, bodies that have minds
[19:29] within them. He, he makes a quite short
[19:31] distinction between them. For him, the body doesn't really
[19:33] matter that much. The body is kind of sort of this
[19:36] is a material thing. What really matters is the mind.
[19:39] And so if you caricature it, you'd say we are basically
[19:42] brains on sticks. And that's kind of what
[19:44] Descartes is about, that he's this supremely confident in
[19:47] human reasoning, it's capacity to master and understand the
[19:50] world. And so that's really the kind of
[19:53] key key. There's a lot more to Descartes
[19:56] than that, but that's the key idea you've got to get your head
[19:58] around which Pascal reacts against.
[20:01] He doesn't really go down that line.
[20:04] And we can explore Pascal's ideas on on reason in the same
[20:07] sort of way, but that's the kind of key idea.
[20:09] The Descartes and so and so Pascal's already reacting to
[20:13] that, doesn't like it, doesn't think it works as I've got a way
[20:17] of thinking about the way in which human beings work.
[20:20] But Descartes and his followers are getting very excited about
[20:24] reason rather than revelation or the Bible or the Church telling
[20:28] you what it what how things are. No reason tells you how things
[20:31] are. Chopin's don't Jesuit.
[20:34] That's about all the French I know.
[20:36] Very good. I've seen someone interpret it
[20:38] as I am thinking therefore I am, rather than I think therefore I
[20:41] am. Because you could have this
[20:43] illusion of having thought, whereas if you're thinking in
[20:46] that moment, you at least can't doubt that you exist.
[20:50] Yeah, exactly. That's right.
[20:51] Yeah. And therefore the process of
[20:53] thinking becomes the most important thing about you.
[20:55] The fact that you can think, the fact that you are kind of aware
[20:58] of yourself, that's the kind of most important thing about
[21:00] humanity For, for, for Descartes.
[21:02] And, and that does shift the nature of the philosophical task
[21:07] in some ways that, you know, most of Western philosophy since
[21:10] then has been influenced by that single move.
[21:13] And, and you could argue that in recent times in the move from
[21:16] they've got a more modern to the postmodern, we've kind of gone
[21:19] become a little bit less sure that that thinking is the answer
[21:22] to everything. But that's very much for
[21:24] Descartes. You know, that thinking, the
[21:26] thinking self, you know, as you, as you say, you know, the fact
[21:29] that I'm thinking means I'm aware of myself self-awareness.
[21:33] And it's a very kind of individual type of philosophy,
[21:36] philosophy in that idea that the one thing I can be sure of is
[21:39] the fact that I'm thinking. There's no one else involved in
[21:41] that. You know, I mean, I can be aware
[21:43] of my thinking. The fact that you're there or
[21:45] anybody else that's in the room doesn't really matter that much.
[21:47] That's a secondary thing. It's the thinking self and it it
[21:50] it kind of leads towards a more individualistic view of the
[21:54] world I think, than than someone like Pascal or others would have
[21:57] had later on. But I think it's an important
[21:59] point to linger on before we get back into the Pascal action
[22:02] because I see this permeating all of culture today.
[22:05] I mean, the majority of people I have, maybe it says something
[22:10] more about the friends I have rather than the average person.
[22:12] But the majority of friends I speak to, they genuinely buy
[22:16] into some idea of a simulation and just existing in a
[22:21] simulation. And there it's, I think
[22:23] therefore I am. I mean, they know that even if
[22:26] they're in a simulation, they're a brain in a VAT, whatever it
[22:28] may be, they still exist. And therefore there's some sort
[22:33] of sort of intrinsic value to that.
[22:37] But other than that, other than their own presence of mind,
[22:40] everyone else, they're not irrelevant because they're part
[22:43] of the world and that landscape that that brain in a VAT
[22:46] operates within. But there is this decrease in
[22:50] empathy I've seen towards people by being sceptical of their
[22:55] existence. It's kind of actually, I'd call
[22:57] it Descartes wager. This idea you can't be certain
[23:01] that people actually exist, and it's more worthwhile when you
[23:06] know you exist to prioritize yourself.
[23:09] Yeah, true. Yeah.
[23:10] And there and there is A and there's a philosopher, Charles
[23:13] Taylor, this Canadian philosopher, he talks about what
[23:15] he calls about the subjective turn in modern culture, which he
[23:18] kind of locates around Descartes, Locke, Kant and
[23:22] others. And I suppose what, what,
[23:24] because you know, the next stage on with this is you've got
[23:26] Descartes saying it's the thinking self, me thinking about
[23:29] myself. That's what what gives me an
[23:31] assurance that I exist, that that's the one thing I can be
[23:33] sure of. Kant goes a stage beyond that to
[23:38] say, well, you know, can you be sure of what you see out there,
[23:42] the fact that you're there, you know, I've got an image of you
[23:44] in my mind, but can I be really sure that you really are there?
[23:48] Or is that just an image that I've got in my mind?
[23:49] All I can be sure of is my own subjectivity.
[23:52] And it kind of turns you into yourself.
[23:55] And I think that's, that's quite problematic in all kinds of
[23:57] ways. And that's, I think you're
[23:58] right, it is very typical of modern life that we, we, we kind
[24:01] of look inside ourselves to find out who we are, who our identity
[24:06] is. Then we kind of, you know, we,
[24:09] we are primarily individuals who then might, if we want to
[24:12] develop a relationship with other people, with the wider
[24:14] world outside. But a lot of it goes back to
[24:16] that turn that Descartes makes back in back in the early 17th
[24:19] century. I've seen people mentioning this
[24:22] fleetingly, but I think they miss out that core psychological
[24:25] element. Not to psychoanalyze people too
[24:27] much, but I think that really plays into it.
[24:30] And I can imagine if I had that same thought process, I would be
[24:34] like this, which is I'm uncertain that you actually
[24:37] exist and that your feelings are that of a human person.
[24:42] I can't doubt that I exist. Therefore, it's me, baby all the
[24:46] way. Exactly, Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[24:48] And I think that's exactly right.
[24:49] That's the kind of the outcome of the of the of the the longer
[24:53] term trajectory of the Descartes position that's shifting of the
[24:56] focus of things and and it's very interesting.
[24:59] You know, Pascal himself talks about the self, which is really
[25:03] interesting thing. You know, the self Lumois, this
[25:06] is what it what it is in French. And he talks in very strong
[25:10] terms about how you actually to to hate yourself.
[25:14] That's that language that's very uncomfortable for us.
[25:17] But he's sort of he sees this trajectory towards it's me baby
[25:22] at the end of the day and actually thinks it's quite
[25:24] destructive. It doesn't really build a good
[25:27] human life or a good human society or it's not actually
[25:29] true to the way things are. But actually he says we need a
[25:33] radical change from that. But, you know, we can get into
[25:35] that a little bit later on. But I think it's exactly right.
[25:38] I think you put your finger on it that, that that's where that
[25:40] goes. It goes to say, well, you know,
[25:42] I can't be sure about anything out there.
[25:43] I can't be sure about anybody else out there.
[25:44] What I can be sure about is myself.
[25:46] And there's a Therefore I am the centre of the universe.
[25:49] Something that speaks this as well is this idea of being human
[25:53] and the inherent value we all place on human experience.
[25:56] There's the classic infinite pleasure machine thought
[25:59] experiment in philosophy where you're offered a choice to enter
[26:03] this experience and it's unlimited pleasure, just the the
[26:08] best feeling you've ever felt. And I can't remember if the
[26:11] experiment goes on, say it's eternal or not.
[26:14] But the point being you can feel this incredible pleasure right
[26:18] now better than you can ever experience on earth in your
[26:21] human corporeal form. But the catch is it's a
[26:24] simulation and it's not reality, and people seem to be very
[26:28] hesitant to engage with that because there's something about
[26:32] your experience and your achievements in life actually
[26:36] being in human form rather than simulated.
[26:40] How does this play into all of this?
[26:43] And I think that does that instinct or that hesitation to
[26:47] take the better, or at least to to go down that line is it's, I
[26:51] think evidence for that, that we kind of feel that we need to
[26:54] have some purchase on reality beyond ourselves.
[26:58] It can't just be a game, a simulation, which doesn't really
[27:01] exist in any sort of objective way.
[27:04] We kind of have a need to connect with something beyond
[27:06] ourselves, which is which is kind of real.
[27:10] And we would feel very dissatisfied if actually what
[27:13] what if we ultimately decided that all that we knew is simply
[27:16] a simulation. It's the kind of Truman Show
[27:18] thing, you know, in that film where he just discovers the
[27:22] whole thing is a simulation. And he just can't, he can't live
[27:24] like that. You kind of have to break out to
[27:26] make some connection with reality beyond.
[27:29] And, and it seems to me that, and one of the things I and I
[27:32] often think of is one of my other great heroes beside Pascal
[27:35] is, is Martin Luther, the great sort of German reformer.
[27:39] And one of the things he said was that we have this human
[27:42] tendency. He said he talked about this
[27:45] the, you know, the Christian idea of sin, which is not a very
[27:47] popular word, but he describes it as the, the heart turned in
[27:51] upon itself. You know, core in covatos in say
[27:54] is the Latin phrase the heart turned in upon itself.
[27:57] And whereas actually what we really need as human beings is
[28:00] to be turned out of ourselves towards other people, towards
[28:03] the world, towards God. Actually, what this thing called
[28:07] sin does is to turn us inwards, to just focus upon ourselves.
[28:12] And then by turning inwards a bit like a sort of flower
[28:14] turning away from the sun, you ultimately sort of shrivel and
[28:17] die, as it were, if you don't have that purchase, that
[28:20] connection with something real beyond yourself.
[28:23] And so I think that's where that plays into it a bit.
[28:25] Yep. I.
[28:26] Want to press you on this a little bit more and you're going
[28:28] to give a different answer to me as a Christian about why we feel
[28:34] this inherent value that we then place on human existence and and
[28:38] real experience. It actually happened because
[28:42] from my perspective, I can imagine that this is an evolved
[28:45] instinct and that real life matters because if we butt up
[28:49] against reality, we won't survive.
[28:52] So right now, as I see it, we're going against our evolutionary
[28:57] wiring, and that's probably going to come at some pretty
[29:00] severe costs. I mean, you see suicide rates
[29:02] going up and this sort of cult of individualism that we can
[29:05] speak about later. It seems contrary to how we were
[29:09] evolved and how we've survived so far on planet.
[29:12] Yeah, yeah. I mean, you can argue that as a,
[29:16] but I suppose I suppose in terms of that you you kind of think,
[29:19] well, why? Because if evolution is about
[29:22] survival, it's about, you know, enabling the species to, to, to
[29:27] exist in the longer term, is it purely about that?
[29:30] Is it purely about a survival mechanism?
[29:32] And why would a connection with something outside ourselves make
[29:37] us more or less likely to survive?
[29:39] And so I, I guess I wonder whether there's something a bit
[29:41] more to it than that, that it's not just a kind of evolutionary
[29:45] process that we've developed in order to kind of make sure that
[29:48] our species survives over against other species, that it
[29:51] is actually a reflection of the way we were originally made.
[29:56] And this is again, what Pascal talks about.
[29:59] I mean, he, he actually talks about the, the idea of happiness
[30:02] back to your sort of pleasure image.
[30:07] Pascal talked, Pascal talked about happiness quite a lot.
[30:10] And he talks about how humans, everybody wants to be happy
[30:13] without exception, every human being wants to be happy.
[30:19] And he says that. But the problem is that, you
[30:21] know, we find happiness, but it's pretty fleeting.
[30:24] We find it for a moment and it lasts a little bit.
[30:27] For any of those golf fans watching, we might have seen
[30:29] that recent interview with Scottie Shafflow, who's that's
[30:34] got a #1 golfer in the world. And he did this extraordinary
[30:37] interview where he said, well, my husband was wondering why I
[30:39] play this game, you know, because I go into these
[30:42] tournaments and I win a tournament and it feels great
[30:44] for 10 minutes, but then I'm back to normal again.
[30:47] And that, that is a very Pascalian thing.
[30:49] It's a very human thing that, you know, we, we, we find
[30:51] happiness, but then it slips away from us.
[30:53] It's like trying to grasp water in your hands.
[30:55] You know, it just doesn't, doesn't last.
[30:57] And so Pascal says, you know, well, we've, we've got that
[31:00] instinct to, to seek happiness. But why, why, why do we think
[31:05] there is such a thing as happiness when it seems so
[31:06] fleeting? It's so sort of sorry,
[31:10] evanescent, especially given his own sort of experience of pain
[31:14] over his life. And he says, well, we only we
[31:17] only sense the lack of something that we once possessed.
[31:21] One of his lines says, nobody mourns the fact they haven't got
[31:27] three eyes, but someone who is blind is inconsolable.
[31:31] So in other words, you know, if you lose your sight of two eyes,
[31:33] which you once had, which is normal for human beings, then
[31:36] you, you know, you, you feel, you know, why?
[31:38] Why haven't they got this thing? But no one thought, I haven't
[31:40] got three eyes because we've never had three eyes.
[31:42] His point being that we once had a happiness.
[31:44] We once had this face to face encounter with the God who made
[31:49] us. We have a memory, a kind of
[31:52] corporate memory as human beings of this thing called happiness.
[31:55] And we're constantly seeking for it, constantly trying to find
[31:57] it. And every now and again we touch
[31:59] it. We taste it through, you know, a
[32:01] friendship or a relationship or a, a kind of, you know, a view
[32:05] of a sunset and on a summer's night or, or some sporting
[32:08] achievement, we find some middle of happiness, but then it
[32:11] vanishes from us. It's a very evocative way of
[32:13] saying, well, these things are not just kind of evolutionary
[32:17] developments, they are actually telling us something about who
[32:19] we are and what we were made for and where we came from
[32:22] originally. Do you think prioritizing the
[32:24] self over indexes and prioritizes happiness?
[32:31] Do you mean do you question? Happiness is sort of, and
[32:36] prioritising happiness too much is always downstream from
[32:39] individualism. Or Or do you think that the two
[32:42] can? So I, I don't, I don't think
[32:44] they are because, because I think certainly Pascal and his
[32:47] great theological hero, Saint Augustine don't think seeking
[32:50] happiness is a bad thing. Actually, Pascal doesn't think
[32:53] we shouldn't, shouldn't see happiness.
[32:55] We should be miserable all the time.
[32:59] He actually thinks that, you know, the, the desire to be
[33:01] happy is a, is a, is a right and proper human thing.
[33:04] And it's something he thinks is implanted in us by God.
[33:07] It's a yearning for true contentment, for true happiness.
[33:13] And this feeds into what Pascal says about this theme of what,
[33:15] what he calls distraction, that we are almost too easily
[33:18] pleased. We're too easily pleased by, you
[33:20] know, winning a golf game or, you know, winning the lottery
[33:25] or, or, or, or just, you know, seeing a nice view or whatever
[33:28] as it. Whereas actually there's a,
[33:29] there's a deeper and more lasting and constant happiness
[33:31] to be found in a kind of encounter in a relationship with
[33:35] the God who made us. So he actually thinks that,
[33:38] that, that the search for happiness is absolutely right
[33:40] and proper. It's not a, it's not an offshoot
[33:42] of self centeredness. There's a right.
[33:45] The question is, where do we find that that happiness And his
[33:48] his diagnosis is that the, the kind of Descartes line tells you
[33:52] that you'll be happy if you prioritise yourself, if you find
[33:56] the things that give you pleasure.
[33:57] And Pascal said that doesn't work that way.
[34:00] Yeah. Well, I think that's the key
[34:01] piece in all of this. I see this today and and
[34:05] quickly. I think I'd differ with Pascal
[34:07] on the fact that we're pleased too easily because I think it's
[34:11] important to be grateful for the small things.
[34:14] The missing piece being having some sort of North star that
[34:18] you're working towards that actually fulfills you.
[34:21] But otherwise you will be miserable even working towards
[34:23] that North star if you can't be grateful for the here and now
[34:25] and the sort of small magical moments along the way.
[34:28] But what I see today is we certainly have a sort of
[34:33] culture, culture of individualism now, and people
[34:38] are always seeking happiness rather than fulfilment.
[34:42] And as you said, maybe the two aren't mutually exclusive.
[34:46] But there's something very interesting in the fact that at
[34:50] least now, people that always seek happiness.
[34:54] I mean that there was this great study where people in the UK and
[34:58] the West, they tried to get happier by just making
[35:01] themselves happier. They just just said, you know,
[35:04] I'm just going to try to be happier and that will lead me to
[35:06] happiness. And they didn't get happier.
[35:10] Whereas people in Russia and some of Southeast Asia, Taiwan,
[35:15] they tried to get happier and they actually became happier.
[35:20] And one of the key distinctions that Johann Hari speaks about
[35:24] with this idea in his book Lost Connections is that those in
[35:29] Russia and in Taiwan and the rest of Southeast Asia, they had
[35:32] a much more family oriented view in life.
[35:35] Whereas the people in the West, to get happiness, they
[35:38] prioritised themselves. They looked within because I
[35:42] think therefore I am. And they didn't get happier
[35:44] because all the things they were doing were buying watches or
[35:49] trying to get more status in a career rather than moving
[35:53] perhaps closer to home for happiness.
[35:54] Yeah, Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
[35:56] No, exactly right. I mean, I, I, I read a book a
[35:59] couple of years ago called Why Being Yourself Is a Bad Idea.
[36:04] And the idea of it was basically that, you know, that one of the
[36:08] core things in modern life is, you know, be, be yourself.
[36:12] That's the kind of #1 command, you know, I've, I've been told
[36:14] it many times and, you know, it's the kind of heart of every
[36:17] Disney film and everything else. Just just be yourself where it
[36:20] seems to be. That's actually quite a
[36:22] confusing bit of advice because it, it assumes that I know who I
[36:26] am. It assumes that there is this
[36:28] inner pure self inside that, you know, is it?
[36:33] And I've just got to be that. But actually there's all kinds
[36:36] of stuff going on inside me, some of which I'm quite happy to
[36:38] let you see, some of which I don't want you to see.
[36:40] That's true of all of us. And so ourselves are much more
[36:43] complex than that. And therefore the advice to be
[36:46] yourself, in other words, to look inside yourself to find out
[36:49] who you really are and then express that it's just the wrong
[36:52] place to look. It's just turning you inside
[36:54] yourself instead of being turned outwards, as I say, towards
[36:57] other people, towards God, which is kind of what that that survey
[37:02] suggests. And, and in fact, actually, I
[37:04] think I mean Pascal, I think also, I think what Pascal would
[37:07] say about it is he, he says at one point the sole cause of
[37:12] man's unhappiness is his inability to stay alone in A
[37:16] room. And you've got to think about
[37:19] that for a while. You think, I don't know if
[37:21] you've ever tried sitting in a room with no book, no phone, no
[37:26] radio, no TV, nothing for an hour.
[37:29] It's pretty difficult. And he's just that, that,
[37:32] that's, that, that is the part of our problem.
[37:34] And we'd look for anything just to distract us.
[37:36] And we are the most distracted age of them all because we have
[37:38] these machines in our pockets that give us constant
[37:41] entertainment information and so on.
[37:43] So we are the most distracted generation and and age has ever
[37:47] been. And so, you know, even more than
[37:49] Pascal's age, but he knew that in his own time, there's just
[37:52] before that was one of the, you know, was one of Pascal's famous
[37:55] quotes that one there. But just before that he says
[37:57] something like this. He says, you know, in order, you
[37:58] know, in order to stop thinking about our wretchedness, our
[38:03] ignorance, our pain and our misery.
[38:07] We've decided in order to be happy, not to think about these
[38:09] things and instead to remain at that level of kind of, I think
[38:15] what he would call a sort of self centred kind of
[38:18] distraction. And he actually thinks that
[38:20] counter counterintuitively, you've got to almost give up
[38:23] that bit of seeking to be happy through these distracted, these
[38:27] distracted things to search for a deeper kind of happiness,
[38:30] which actually means by going to the the the I actually think
[38:33] there's a deeper sickness in the human condition, which is this
[38:36] radical self centredness. And that has to be addressed
[38:39] first before you can really breakthrough to a true contented
[38:43] happiness. One of the keywords used online
[38:46] nowadays is authenticity. Being your authentic self and
[38:51] especially in relationships. And you see dating coaches
[38:54] saying that you should show up as your authentic self right in
[38:57] front of your partner. Where is the line here between
[39:02] being authentic and misconstrued?
[39:05] Misconstruing what the self is. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[39:09] I think it's an interesting one because I can remember, I can
[39:13] remember, you know, as a, as a teenager going out for a, for a
[39:17] date with a, a girl I quite liked at the time.
[39:20] And I remember, you know, going to that same conversation, just
[39:24] go to a friend saying, oh, what should I do?
[39:25] And you said, oh, just just just be yourself.
[39:28] That's the kind of advice you get.
[39:29] And I can remember thinking that's the last thing I want to
[39:33] do when I meet this girl is to be myself.
[39:35] Because if she sees the kind of insecurities and fears and
[39:39] jealousies and all kind of stuff going on in my mind, there will
[39:42] not be a second date. So actually what we do is we, of
[39:45] course, we cultivate a kind of acceptable version of ourselves
[39:49] and we present that and we hide the other bits that we're not
[39:52] quite so sure about and we don't want other people to see.
[39:55] And so, so I think there's this thing, but you know, what is the
[39:58] authentic self? And I, I I suppose I I tend to
[40:00] think that ourselves are more created and formed rather than
[40:04] discovered. Others.
[40:06] When you asked me the question, who am I?
[40:09] There's always I don't know yet. I'm still being shaped.
[40:12] I'm still being formed. Even at my advanced age.
[40:14] You know, you are, you're quite younger than me, but you are
[40:16] being shaped. Who you are will be determined
[40:20] by the kind of decisions you make, the things you commit
[40:22] yourself to, the the relationships you enter into.
[40:25] Those are the things that shape us and form us and make us who
[40:28] we are. And over time you develop a kind
[40:31] of settled, sound sense of the self.
[40:35] And so so I think when we the the self is a more complex thing
[40:38] than we think it is, I think Pascal would say that there is
[40:41] the self that is, there is that self within me that wants
[40:45] everybody to admire me and think I'm wonderful and tells me I'm
[40:49] great and told me my books are wonderful a lot.
[40:50] You know that there's that self, but there's this other self
[40:54] which is capable of a deep happiness by finding security in
[40:59] relationship with other people and with the God who made me
[41:03] that is secure enough not to need all that kind of
[41:08] affirmation from other people. And there's that kind of very
[41:11] selfish self and there's a there's that other self.
[41:14] And in Christian terms in the Bible, Saint Paul talks about
[41:17] the old self and the new self, the old self, which is this
[41:19] self-centered. I want everything for myself.
[41:22] It's me, baby. But then there's the new self in
[41:25] Christ which he talks about, which is this new self being
[41:28] shaped by relationship with Jesus Christ, the one human
[41:32] being that shows us what it really is.
[41:34] To be truly human, those cells have to be disentangled and and
[41:40] discern within his anus. So the self is more complex
[41:43] complex thing than we think it is.
[41:45] How does the approach towards looking at the self differ
[41:48] throughout history Without asking too much of you to give a
[41:51] comprehensive guide? But even just looking at my own
[41:54] experience and it's been really hard to realise and feel but.
[42:01] And I feel even like a little bit uncomfortable speaking about
[42:04] it almost. It feels like I'm exposing a
[42:06] friend, but that friend's me. I feel like I have a true self
[42:12] that I feel within. That is the urge when I want to
[42:17] eat some Haribo's when I'm on a diet, the the true urge within
[42:22] that says no, don't do that. That's my true self.
[42:25] And it feels distinctly different.
[42:28] I don't know what's at play there, but it's just interesting
[42:30] that I, I always feel I, I have two different levels of
[42:35] thoughts. I have the deeper real
[42:38] connection to myself where I, I really feel comfortable with
[42:42] that voice. I feel like that's what I want.
[42:45] It's aligned with me, Elliot, and it's what I really think.
[42:50] Then layered on top of that, I kind of have these more shallow
[42:53] thoughts more tied viscerally to emotions and impulses.
[42:58] Yeah. And that kind of illustrates in
[43:00] some ways, I think what I'm saying about the complexity of
[43:03] the self. There's there actually may be a
[43:05] number of Elliots in there, you know, a number of voices that
[43:07] are going on. And the question is which one
[43:09] you feed, which one you you nurture within yourself, Because
[43:13] you could feed that voice that says just eat the Haribos, eat
[43:16] the Mars bars, eat. Well, you know, that's a
[43:18] terrible example, but that's under one thing.
[43:21] But you know, there's a, there is a voice inside us that
[43:23] actually, if we follow that voice, it's going to be quite
[43:25] destructive for us. And but then there's a then
[43:29] there are other voices that lead us in different directions.
[43:31] And I suppose what the, the, the kind of Christian take on that.
[43:34] And I think, you know, this is what, again, what Pascal would
[43:37] say is that you, you've got to have some, what kind of self do
[43:41] you want to aspire to be? If we are selves that are being
[43:45] created over time, we're being shaped, We're being formed by
[43:47] the emphasis upon us, by the things we commit ourselves to.
[43:50] What can you find that is the best thing to commit yourself
[43:53] to? What is the image of a human
[43:55] being, do you think? If that's what I want to be,
[43:57] that's where I want to go. That's my North Star.
[43:59] That's the kind of person I want to to, to be around.
[44:01] And for me as a Christian, that is Jesus Christ and that's why I
[44:05] want to try and follow him. Doesn't mean I get it always
[44:06] right, that boy, those voices are still inside me that say no,
[44:10] no, no, that's the way you want to go.
[44:11] But that's the way I think the the Christian thinks about the
[44:16] self. The self is being formed.
[44:18] It's being shaped over time. And the North Star to which we
[44:22] try and aspire to is this figure of Jesus Christ.
[44:25] He gives himself totally to other people, even to the point
[44:27] of going to a cross for the sake of the human race rising again
[44:31] after that. Let's get back to Pascal.
[44:34] He's in Paris. He's growing up rapidly.
[44:37] What is he doing? What's he publishing in terms of
[44:40] work? And he's moving in certain
[44:42] circles. Intellectually, what's going on?
[44:45] Yeah, well, he moved to Paris and as he grows up he joins a
[44:48] sort of circle of intellectuals for scientists, philosophers led
[44:54] by Michael Merrand Mercen, who was a Friar in a in a kind of
[44:59] religious order, but a bit of an intellectual of the time.
[45:01] He's got a well known figure that Pascal's father is part of.
[45:05] He brings young Pascal along. Pascal reads a paper he's done
[45:08] on a sort of mathematical question which everyone's quite
[45:11] wowed by, and that paper gets sent on to Descartes.
[45:13] And that's partly why Descartes gets a bit crossed because he
[45:16] thinks this young upstart and he's taking my taking my glory
[45:20] so in it. And as Pascal grows, grows up
[45:22] beyond that, what he's really known for in his time is, is
[45:25] really as a scientist. He's not known as a theologian
[45:27] or a philosopher or a somebody's writing about Christianity.
[45:30] He's more known as someone who engages in a number of
[45:35] mathematical geometrical questions at the time.
[45:39] He's particularly, he gets particularly well known for an
[45:41] experiment he did on the the, the existence of the vacuum.
[45:46] Until that point, people thought that there's no such thing as a
[45:48] vacuum on various philosophical grounds.
[45:52] And even Descartes thought that because there can be no such
[45:57] thing as nothing, there's always something.
[46:01] So a vacuum is filled with, you know, something that appears to
[46:04] be a vacuum is is something else.
[46:06] Anyway, Pascal actually takes, unusually for his time, takes an
[46:09] experimental approach to science.
[46:10] You should do the experiment, look at the evidence, see what
[46:13] the evidence tells you, find the best, the best explanation of
[46:17] that experiment and that of that evidence.
[46:19] And you should go with that. And so he does these series of
[46:21] experiments which involve carrying large tubes of mercury
[46:28] and buckets and, and bowls all the way up a mountain to take
[46:33] measurements on the height of mercury in a tube and all the
[46:36] way back down again. But he can't do it because he's
[46:38] I'll at the time. And he gets his brother-in-law
[46:40] and a kind of group of others to do this thing.
[46:43] And he, you know, he measures, they, they measure the, the, the
[46:46] height of the mercury all the way up the mountains in the back
[46:47] down again. It's all about atmospheric
[46:49] pressure. It's all about the existence of
[46:50] the vacuum. And he, he goes ahead and he
[46:54] publishes the results of this experiment.
[46:56] And it's been called the first truly modern experiment in
[47:00] European history. In other words, something where
[47:04] the, the, the, the, the experiment was measured very
[47:07] carefully. It was published for others to
[47:10] read and to kind of examine and, and that, and that goes viral
[47:17] around Europe. He becomes famous for this
[47:18] particular experiment, which pretty well proves that a, that
[47:21] a two things. It proves that A, there is such
[47:23] a thing as a vacuum and that air has weight.
[47:27] In other words, the air weighs something.
[47:29] It's not just nothing. And so, so, yeah, he's, he's
[47:34] known as this scientist. He gets involved in some
[47:36] mathematical things. So he has a, a correspondence
[47:41] with Pierre de Fermat's. You might have heard of Fermat's
[47:43] Last Theorem, a great mathematician, 17th century.
[47:47] They have this correspondence on probability.
[47:50] What happens is Pascal has a lot of friends who are kind of, you
[47:53] know, sophisticated people who go to the salons in Paris.
[47:57] They're into witty conversation. They're into impressing people.
[48:01] They go gambling, they play tennis, they go hunting.
[48:03] They're interested in all that kind of stuff.
[48:05] And one of them is a is a gambler who sets Pascal.
[48:08] I got a problem, he says, like if you if you have a game, maybe
[48:13] it's a game of cards or a game of tossing coins and it lasts a
[48:16] long time. People have put in their stakes
[48:18] and their betting on the game at the beginning of it and the game
[48:21] gets interrupted halfway through.
[48:22] How do you allocate the stake? In other words, how do you work
[48:26] out what might have happened as a result of that game?
[48:28] And Pascal and fair amount work on this and they come up with a
[48:31] theory, which is basically the origins of probability theory.
[48:35] And so these are the kind of things that Pascal's involved
[48:37] with during this middle period of his life.
[48:41] What comes next? I want us to jump forwards a
[48:43] little bit. He grows up, the family moving
[48:46] back and forth. He helps out his dad, who's now
[48:51] filing tax for the state, who's struggling with counting all
[48:55] this money. Talk to me about that invention
[48:58] from Yeah. Well, he watches his dad trying
[49:02] to get the tax sums right. He's a tax official in rural and
[49:05] now in, in, in France and and it's quite a cut tax is quite a
[49:08] controversial thing at the time because the king was trying to
[49:11] raise funds for his external wars.
[49:13] The taxes were very unpopular. They were kind of riots about it
[49:16] in the streets. And so being a tax collector was
[49:18] not a popular profession. And so Blaise Pascal gets, you
[49:24] know, he sees the stress on, on his father and he thinks, how
[49:27] can I help him? Because obviously if he gets the
[49:29] sums wrong and imposes too much tax on people, they get really
[49:32] cross and, you know, get riots and everything else.
[49:34] And so he thinks maybe I can invent a machine that does these
[49:37] calculations bit quicker and better than you can do it in
[49:40] your head. And so he invents this thing
[49:43] called the Pascalin, which is a, which is basically one of the
[49:48] first effective mechanical calculators in European history.
[49:53] And it can count up to hundreds and thousands of millions.
[49:58] And it's a series of dials, kind of carefully sort of engineered
[50:02] thing, which is he's got people to make.
[50:04] He designs it himself. He puts the bits together.
[50:06] He gets artisans in in the town where he lives to kind of make
[50:10] this thing. It's never a great business
[50:14] success. He tries to make a lot of them
[50:16] and sell them, but they're too expensive.
[50:18] And so no one really buys them. But it's a very successful
[50:21] machine in the sense that it's it's going to still remember
[50:24] today. There are still a number of them
[50:26] you can see in museums around France in particular.
[50:30] They're beautiful things. They're actually like a little
[50:32] box like this, lots of dials on the top and you kind of work the
[50:35] dials along and it's very, very clever.
[50:37] And it actually worked. And you could do sophisticated
[50:39] calculations of addition, subtraction, multiplication,
[50:42] division up to, as I say, hundreds of millions in a pretty
[50:46] accurate way and much quicker than doing it in your head and
[50:49] much more accurate. And, and it's, it's often been
[50:51] thought of as one of the precursors of the modern
[50:55] calculator and therefore the modern computer.
[50:57] So I often think, you know, when you open your laptop and you do
[51:01] your work on your computer, you kind of think of Pascal.
[51:04] Because when the story of computers is told, very often
[51:07] the Pascaline is one of the stages, the very first kind of
[51:11] mechanical calculator, digital calculator that actually worked.
[51:14] And that was a step towards the calculator in the computer in
[51:17] the longer term. It's crazy just thinking about
[51:21] this aptitude he has for thinking outside the box.
[51:24] Yeah. You've got numbers as this
[51:27] concept that's all mental and you're adding them up and he
[51:32] takes them into this physical form.
[51:35] And that might sound really trivial because we kind of just
[51:38] can't get out of our heads the fact that we have calculators
[51:40] now. But it just makes me wonder what
[51:42] we think about now that we think we can only think about that are
[51:46] later going to be put into systems and perhaps for good or
[51:49] bad. So Pascal's making all of these
[51:52] crazy inventions. He's a mathematician.
[51:54] He's messing around with probability very successfully.
[51:57] He's doing experiments. One of the key parts that I
[52:01] think make up, or at least form our understanding of Pascal
[52:04] today is the provincial letters. Talk to me about those.
[52:09] This seems like one of his first ventures into a more
[52:14] philosophical, theological approach to things.
[52:17] Well, an important precursor to the provincial letters, and
[52:20] again we may talk in detail about it in time, is this event
[52:23] that happens to him in November 1654, where which is called the
[52:27] Night of Fire, which seems to have been a very powerful,
[52:31] visceral kind of religious experience for him.
[52:34] Where for where he said for two hours on one particular night,
[52:36] he seems to have had this encounter with God, which didn't
[52:40] change everything, but it changed the whole way he thought
[52:42] about his life. I think until that point.
[52:45] I think there's always been two things going on in Pascal's
[52:47] mind. You know, he's got this, this
[52:48] very religious sister. He's got his family influenced
[52:51] by this Jansenist movement, which is, you know, and they
[52:55] tended to think, you know, you must either choose God or the
[52:57] world. And they were a bit suspicious
[52:59] about Pascal because he was this famous mathematician and and
[53:03] physicist. And they was like, well, you
[53:05] know, if you're really serious about God, you've got to leave
[53:07] all that stuff behind and go and join the monastery, which is
[53:10] kind of what Jacqueline's sister had done.
[53:13] And I think he was always so struggling with this, you know,
[53:14] what, what do I do, you know, to God or the world?
[53:16] That was the kind of that was the options that were given to
[53:19] him by this Jansenist movement. Now he has this experience in
[53:22] 6054, which shifts the ground, doesn't mean he gives up on the
[53:25] world entirely. He still does mathematical work.
[53:27] He still does experiments, but they take a lesser place in his
[53:30] life. And it sort of resolves a bit of
[53:32] a religious question for him anyway.
[53:34] What are the results of that? Is that he, he kind of throws
[53:38] his lot in with the, the Jansenists, which is this group
[53:42] of Christians in 70s century France who kind of think that
[53:48] the rest of the, the kind of Christian world in front,
[53:51] particularly the Jesuits are, they're a bit soft on religion
[53:55] really. And I think what, what's at the
[53:57] heart of it is that the, the Jesuits are kind of saying,
[54:00] well, we've got to make it easy to be a Christian.
[54:02] You know, there's all these sophisticated people who go
[54:04] gambling and hunting and they're the people, the people at
[54:07] Pascal's Friends. How can we make it easy for them
[54:10] to be Christian? And so they, they kind of
[54:12] stretch the tendons say, well, it's kind of OK if you just go
[54:15] to church every now and again, if you kind of turn up and even
[54:18] if you don't stay for the whole service, you sort of nod in the
[54:20] direction of the priest and you say the old prayer every now and
[54:24] again. Occasionally you might feel
[54:26] sorry for the sins that you commit.
[54:27] That's enough. That's all right, That's enough.
[54:30] And Pascal says, no, it's not enough.
[54:32] Actually, that's not going to make you happy.
[54:34] That's actually going to make you miserable because you're
[54:36] going to have in enough of not enough of the world to make you
[54:40] happy in that kind of surface sense, but certainly not enough
[54:42] of God to make you happy in the deeper sense.
[54:45] And he says, if you're really going to be Christian, you there
[54:47] has to be what he calls repentance.
[54:49] There has to be this real change of heart this this radical shift
[54:54] from the self-centered life to the God centered life.
[54:57] Anyway, in this this big debate going on between the Jesuits and
[55:01] the Jansenists and the Jesuits are basically when it's sort of
[55:03] the argument, the Jesuits are very powerful.
[55:06] The king is in favour of the Jesuits.
[55:08] The King's confessor is a Jesuit priest.
[55:11] The Jesuits are much more powerful than the Jansenists.
[55:13] The Jesuits are a kind of small group.
[55:15] And there's a meeting that happens quite soon after
[55:18] Pascal's night of fire where they're all sitting around.
[55:22] They're a bit bit fed up and glum because they're losing the
[55:24] argument. And the main guy who's the
[55:27] leader of the Jansenism, I can't, Antoine Arno, has been
[55:29] writing these long complicated theological treatises on why
[55:32] they're right and the Jesuits are wrong and they're not
[55:35] getting anywhere. And it seems like the Pope has
[55:38] condemned Jansenism and it's not going very well.
[55:41] And at one point they turn to Pascal and they say that you're,
[55:43] you're young, you know, can't you do something?
[55:46] And Pascal goes away. And a few days later he comes
[55:49] back and he reads from the beginnings of basically one of
[55:52] the greatest works of satirical literature in certainly in
[55:55] French literary history, perhaps even in Europe.
[55:58] And Pascal's genius is that what he does is he, he basically
[56:02] attacks, he approaches this conflict not through complicated
[56:06] philosophy or theology, but through comedy.
[56:10] And he's a genius at it. And what he does is he writes a
[56:12] series of letters from reportedly from a Parisian
[56:16] gentleman to a friend out in the Styx in the provinces.
[56:19] Therefore the provincial letters just describing the debate and
[56:23] showing how in a very, very clever, still very funny way
[56:28] even today, even when the, the, the, the kind of disputes are
[56:32] kind of lost in the midst of time, it's still quite funny to
[56:34] read. It's brilliant.
[56:35] And so that's what the provincial letters were.
[56:37] That's his first foray into sort of theological debate.
[56:41] And at the heart of it, I think, is his, his kind of sense that
[56:44] actually real religion means real change of heart.
[56:49] A surface religion which is just about Noddy in the direction of
[56:52] God isn't really worth the candle.
[56:54] So yeah. He has to publish these
[56:56] provincial letters anonymously to protect himself.
[57:00] He's taking a big risk here when he keeps on publishing them.
[57:04] I think there's a story of him almost getting caught with his
[57:07] friends publishing these letters and he sort of sneaks out with
[57:10] the machine to avoid them getting caught by the Jesuits
[57:14] and and them seeing that they had the printing machine to
[57:16] print these letters. He's taking a big risk here.
[57:21] You've mentioned the night of fire to get him to the point of
[57:25] taking such a big risk. This must have been a pretty
[57:28] profound experience. Yeah, yeah, it was exactly,
[57:32] Yeah, Yeah, it was. It was a big risk.
[57:33] And it's it's a great story, you know, of, of him hiding in
[57:38] cupboards and people finding the printing presses and the
[57:42] printing presses themselves having to move the equipment all
[57:44] over the time. But you're right.
[57:45] Yeah. I mean, the, the the heart of it
[57:47] is this this night of fire. And I think it was a a strange
[57:52] thing because he never told anybody about it.
[57:54] He was clearly had a really important experience for him and
[57:56] people kind of knew at the time something had happened, but he
[57:58] never told the soul. And the only reason that people
[58:01] know about it is that when he died, one of the servants who
[58:06] was preparing his body for burial cut open his jacket and
[58:10] felt something in the lining. And they opened up the jacket
[58:13] and they pulled out these two bits of paper, one's part 1's
[58:16] paper, one's parchment, on which were written 2 versions are
[58:20] basically the same. It's kind of like a poem.
[58:21] And, and it's, it's a very powerful point.
[58:26] Actually, I might, I might read a bit of it because it just
[58:28] gives you a sense of what, what this is about.
[58:30] And at the top of the page, it has the word for fire.
[58:35] And then it says God of Abraham, God of Isaac, God of Jacob, not
[58:41] of the philosophers and of the learn it certitude, certitude,
[58:45] feeling joy, peace, God of Jesus Christ, my God and your God,
[58:50] your God will may be my God. And it kind of goes on in that
[58:52] in that note. And it's clearly a very powerful
[58:55] experience of joy, of a sense of certainty, not intellectual
[58:59] certainty, but a kind of spiritual certainty that he's
[59:03] encountered something someone outside himself.
[59:06] And he's not the God of the philosophers.
[59:08] It's not the God of Descartes. It's not a God who is the
[59:11] product of a logical process of argumentation.
[59:15] It's not the God of, you know, the Jesuits, a God who is sort
[59:21] of distant. These nod out every now and
[59:23] again. Now this is a God who's
[59:24] intensely interested in you, who has to kind of almost consume
[59:27] your whole being and be the centre of your life from that
[59:30] point onwards. And so it's a, it is a very
[59:32] powerful experience for him. And, and I think people looking
[59:36] back when they read about this, and he dates it very precisely,
[59:39] November the 23rd, 6054, I think people, his friends who look
[59:44] like, Oh yeah, that kind of makes sense of what that shift
[59:46] we'd have perceived in his life. That's why he got involved in
[59:49] the provincial letters, that's why he got involved with the
[59:51] Jansenists, that's why he started writing the Ponce.
[59:53] And so it made sense of so much afterwards, even though he never
[59:58] said anything at the time. Eventually we get from this to
[1:00:01] Pascal's second conversion, as they call it.
[1:00:03] Yeah, talk to me about that. Yeah, yeah.
[1:00:07] Well, that's kind of what you know, people could talk about
[1:00:09] Pascal's first conversion as being his sort of first
[1:00:12] encounter with Jansenism when his dad had the the accident and
[1:00:16] the Jansenism bone setters came to the family.
[1:00:18] And at that stage he was sort of drawn to the Jansenists.
[1:00:21] He had a kind of burst of enthusiasm.
[1:00:23] It's kind of young bit naive a bit.
[1:00:25] And one of Pascal's less attractive characteristics was
[1:00:31] when he got into an argument. He liked to win and he would
[1:00:35] sort of pommel his adversaries. He's very bright.
[1:00:37] You wouldn't want to get into an argument with Pascal because you
[1:00:39] would not win it and he would pummel you into submission.
[1:00:42] And that was not an attractive thing.
[1:00:44] And he did that a few times in his early days as a kind of, you
[1:00:46] know, enthusiastic Johnsonist. But after that first conversion,
[1:00:50] there's a sense in which he kind of loses a bit of that fire.
[1:00:53] He gets more interested in the kind of science and, and, and,
[1:00:55] and the mathematics that his second conversion is this night
[1:00:59] of fire, the this, this profound experience of God that sets him
[1:01:03] on a new trajectory. And I think the two the two
[1:01:06] impacts of that, but 333 things I can say about 1 is that I
[1:01:10] think to say it, it didn't entirely get rid of the physics
[1:01:13] and the mathematics. They still happened.
[1:01:15] He still was interested in that, but it took a lesser place in
[1:01:17] his life. It wasn't the centre of who he
[1:01:18] was. He was not no longer Pascal, the
[1:01:21] famous scientist, because I think what it was it it's hard
[1:01:25] is that was the moment if he like he made that shift that
[1:01:27] actually himself back to the point about the self and the
[1:01:30] self centeredness. His own self had shifted to one
[1:01:33] side in which goes the opposite of Descartes.
[1:01:37] You know, Descartes feel like a shifted God out of the centre
[1:01:39] and put himself in the middle. This is the moment where Pascal
[1:01:42] puts himself out of the centre and puts God in the middle of
[1:01:44] his life. And so, so there's that sense of
[1:01:47] shifting the centre of gravity of his own person, his own self
[1:01:51] and who he is. And it issues and two things. 1
[1:01:53] is a desire to enable these sophisticated, trendy friends of
[1:01:58] his who go to the salons and, you know, engage in the
[1:02:00] conversations and so on. He wants to say, how can I help
[1:02:03] them discover they will only find true happiness not in
[1:02:08] gambling and playing tennis and being admired by everybody, but
[1:02:12] in a an encounter with God. How can I persuade them to take
[1:02:15] God seriously? Because they think God is
[1:02:18] boring. They think God is not arranging
[1:02:19] at all. That's the one thing.
[1:02:21] The second thing, he gets fascinated by poverty and he
[1:02:24] becomes very devoted to, to the poor, poor people of Paris, poor
[1:02:28] people in, in, in France generally.
[1:02:31] He starts giving away a lot of his possessions.
[1:02:33] He starts living a very austere life and he ends his life
[1:02:37] actually, he ends his life in voluntary destitution.
[1:02:41] Basically, he owns almost nothing.
[1:02:43] And he, you know, he lives in a very kind of bare room in the
[1:02:48] middle of Paris. And so and, and he, he says, you
[1:02:50] know, I love poverty because Jesus Christ love poverty.
[1:02:54] He felt that was a something that he was drawn to see what he
[1:02:57] could do to, to, to, to help the poor.
[1:02:59] So those two things, trying to help his sophisticated wealthy
[1:03:02] friends to find God, but also to serve the poor.
[1:03:05] Those are the two things that really came out of that
[1:03:07] experience, I think. What was Pascal's Wager?
[1:03:11] Yeah, well, Pascal's Wager is something that lots of people
[1:03:14] have thought about. It's, you know, philosophers
[1:03:16] think about it quite a bit. And he comes in.
[1:03:19] So one of the things he, he did when he started, when he had
[1:03:22] this night of fire, I think, OK, I, I need to try and think about
[1:03:24] how I'm going to persuade my friend.
[1:03:27] And he was going to write a big a book which would hopefully
[1:03:31] explain Christian faith and draw people into Christian faith.
[1:03:34] He never finished it because he died too young.
[1:03:37] But what he did leave behind was a whole realm of papers, some of
[1:03:43] which are sort of the line somewhere, a paragraph, some
[1:03:46] which are a bit longer. And they were collected together
[1:03:48] after he died, published as the Pulsais, the thoughts of Pascal.
[1:03:51] Now, one of these is a, is a, it's a, it's a fairly long piece
[1:03:54] of work, which is actually not called the wager.
[1:03:56] It's called Afini Ria Infinity nothing.
[1:03:58] That's the title he gives it. And it contains an argument
[1:04:02] which has become famous in philosophy and in kind of
[1:04:06] popular terms, it's often thought of as basically saying,
[1:04:09] look, you might as well believe in God because you've got a lot
[1:04:14] to lose if you don't believe in God.
[1:04:16] You've got a lot to gain if you do, putting it at its simplest.
[1:04:20] And a lot of philosophers have criticized the idea for all
[1:04:23] kinds of reasons. Well, you know, it doesn't
[1:04:25] necessarily prove the God of Christianity.
[1:04:26] You could say that about Islam or Judaism or Hinduism.
[1:04:29] People have said, well, it's bit arm's length is an argument.
[1:04:32] It feels a bit selfish. It's all about my own, you know
[1:04:35] what what my own salvation or whatever.
[1:04:38] But I actually think it's not an argument that is trying to
[1:04:41] strong arm people into belief in God.
[1:04:43] What it's there to try and do is to try to show people the real
[1:04:47] reasons why they believe or don't believe.
[1:04:49] And I think the way it works is like this.
[1:04:52] It's like, you know, I was talking about a little, we
[1:04:54] earlier on, we talked about these games of chance, you know,
[1:04:57] where he and Fermat did the probability thing.
[1:05:02] And it's kind of like that. So I think it would have come in
[1:05:05] the course of a conversation with a friend.
[1:05:08] And the friend is someone who is maybe just thinking about God as
[1:05:12] a possibility. God might be there, might God
[1:05:14] might not be there, I don't know, not quite sure.
[1:05:17] And Pascal is talking to this person.
[1:05:18] And this guy says to Pascal, well, you know, should I should
[1:05:23] I believe or should I not? But Pascal says, well, you, you
[1:05:25] should believe and you've got to bet one way or the other.
[1:05:29] And the guy says, well, do I have to bet?
[1:05:31] Pascal says, well, you do because you've already bet.
[1:05:34] You're already, you're already living your life as if God
[1:05:36] exists or as if God doesn't exist.
[1:05:38] So you've already cast your bet one side or the other.
[1:05:40] Question is, do you change your mind?
[1:05:42] And so the guy says, OK, well, if I got a bet, is there any
[1:05:46] evidence that would push me one way or the other?
[1:05:48] And Pascal says, well, there is, there's some good evidence for
[1:05:51] believing in God, but there's stuff that might push you in the
[1:05:54] other direction. And he says the evidence is not
[1:05:57] so much as to convince you, you know, you realise there's,
[1:06:02] there's stuff on both sides of this.
[1:06:04] And so then the guy said, well, what do I do then?
[1:06:07] And then that's why that's when Pascal says, well, let's do the
[1:06:09] probability on this. And so he does, OK, what's to
[1:06:12] the probability now? OK, if you believe in God, the
[1:06:15] probability goes like this that if you win, if you believe in
[1:06:18] God and you're right, then you stand to gain eternal life at
[1:06:22] the end of the day, the happiness and eternal happiness
[1:06:24] in presence of God. If you're wrong, well, you
[1:06:26] haven't lost a great deal, maybe a little bit of sacrifice in
[1:06:29] this life, but you haven't lost a great deal.
[1:06:31] But you stand to gain a great a great prize if you believe that
[1:06:35] God doesn't exist. And you're right.
[1:06:38] Well, you've gained a great deal, maybe a few more games of
[1:06:41] tennis and pretty gambling games and so on.
[1:06:43] But it's very short for a period of time.
[1:06:46] If you're wrong, you could stand to lose quite a lot eternal down
[1:06:50] nation and so on. And so he says, like, I don't
[1:06:53] think it's the point of the the point of the the wager is if
[1:06:55] you're really being rational, if you're really doing the
[1:06:58] probability, you'd always bet on God because you stand so much to
[1:07:01] gain through believing and you aim to and you stand to lose a
[1:07:07] lot for that. So you'd always bet on God.
[1:07:09] And then but then the guy comes back and says, well, yeah, but I
[1:07:12] can't make myself believe something I don't I don't feel.
[1:07:16] And that's what Pascal says, yeah, I get that.
[1:07:18] I get you can't do that. But he says this is the point of
[1:07:21] the way it is, but at least get it into your head that the
[1:07:23] reason you do not believe is not because of your reason, because
[1:07:26] of your passions. So that's the I think the the
[1:07:29] point he's driving at. He's not strong army people into
[1:07:31] belief. He's trying to uncover the fact
[1:07:33] that the real, the real reasons that push us towards belief or
[1:07:38] unbelief are not rational. They're actually more to do with
[1:07:41] our desires, our longings, our heart, what he calls the heart.
[1:07:45] And and that's when he get the guy says, OK, well, what do I do
[1:07:49] then? And Pascal says, well, his
[1:07:51] advice is we'll start living as if it's true, even if you don't
[1:07:55] believe it. Start living as a true, start
[1:07:57] going through every day as if God really is there that you
[1:08:00] talk to him as if he really, even if you're not sure he is
[1:08:02] there. Start praying, start reading the
[1:08:04] Bible as if it is God's word to you.
[1:08:06] Start to every day, start going to the church as if it really is
[1:08:09] the place where God's people are gathered and and you learn a new
[1:08:13] way of life. You know, start living the
[1:08:15] Christian life and then it might fall into place for you.
[1:08:17] So I think that's basically what the wager is.
[1:08:20] From this, and I don't know about the chronology on this one
[1:08:24] of place Pascal's most famous lines, The heart has its
[1:08:28] reasons, of which reason knows nothing.
[1:08:30] You know, I think that ties all of this in quite nicely.
[1:08:33] Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. And it's a, it's a line that's
[1:08:36] often misunderstood because it sounds like, you know, follow
[1:08:39] your heart in the kind of, you know, Disney film thing, just do
[1:08:44] your thing, which is actually not what it doesn't mean.
[1:08:47] That's more Descartes than it is Pascal.
[1:08:50] For for Pascal, the heart is it's kind of like a deep
[1:08:53] instinct that grasps things that cannot be grasped by reason.
[1:08:57] So he says there are certain things that we you, you can't
[1:09:00] reason yourself towards. So things like number, things
[1:09:02] like space, things like time, you can't, you can't reason
[1:09:06] yourself towards those things. We just experienced them as
[1:09:08] being there. We have this instinct that just
[1:09:09] grasps them. At the beginning of the wager.
[1:09:12] He has this thing about the, the concept of Infinity.
[1:09:15] He says, well, you know, Infinity is something we don't
[1:09:18] know much about Infinity. We don't even know whether it's
[1:09:21] an odd number or an even number, but we kind of sense there is
[1:09:24] this thing called Infinity, the biggest number you can ever
[1:09:26] think of. So he says it's possible to
[1:09:28] think about something that exists, but you don't know much
[1:09:31] about it. And it's kind of like that with
[1:09:32] with with God. He says so and what he says, you
[1:09:36] know that that that God is perceived by the heart and not
[1:09:39] the reason. This is his thing about not the
[1:09:42] God of the philosophers. And what he's saying is that God
[1:09:45] is not an object that you can kind of put in a test tube and
[1:09:48] analyse and ask, is there evidence for it, which is the
[1:09:51] biggest mistake. I think a lot of the, a lot of
[1:09:53] sort of atheists like Richard Dawkins and so on, they make
[1:09:55] they, they kind of say, well, you know, where's the evidence
[1:09:57] for God? Now I can say, you know, where's
[1:09:59] the evidence for this book or where's the evidence for this
[1:10:01] glass of water or where's the, you know, and I can give an
[1:10:04] account of how that came into being.
[1:10:07] I can, you know, tell the story of how this book came into being
[1:10:11] or that glass of water, whatever it might be, because it's an
[1:10:14] event, it's a thing within this space-time universe.
[1:10:18] Pascal says again, he says it towards the beginning of, of, of
[1:10:21] the, the wager. God is not that kind of being.
[1:10:24] He's not an event within the world.
[1:10:25] He's not a thing within the world that is subject to the
[1:10:28] normal processes of proof. He's outside that system and
[1:10:31] therefore you cannot access it hidden through reason.
[1:10:34] Now, there are reasons you can give that might point you in the
[1:10:37] direction of God, miracles, prophecies, and so on, but
[1:10:41] they're not conclusive, he says. Because ultimately, that
[1:10:44] decision, that ultimate decision about the most important
[1:10:48] decision we make as human beings, is not made by our
[1:10:50] reason. It's made by our hearts.
[1:10:53] What do you think is the most important idea from Pascal and
[1:10:56] his ponces? I think the most important idea
[1:11:01] for Pascal is that we find our true happiness by encountering
[1:11:12] the God who made us, and we can only find that through a radical
[1:11:18] change in the heart. And this displacement of
[1:11:22] ourselves is the centre of everything towards God is the
[1:11:26] centre of everything. That's the thing I think he's
[1:11:28] driving at. He's trying to kind of wean us
[1:11:30] away from this illusion that somehow we will find happiness
[1:11:34] through pleasure, through sort of fleeting things that we think
[1:11:39] are going to bring us happiness. And we will only find happiness
[1:11:44] by by stripping away that layer of distractions of things that
[1:11:49] we, and I think they're going to give us happiness to go deeper
[1:11:52] to the thing that really will give us happiness, which is the
[1:11:55] kind of thing that happened to him on the night of fire, that
[1:11:57] encounter with the God who made us, the God who shows himself to
[1:12:00] us in Jesus Christ, the God who is this hidden God, which is
[1:12:05] another big theme of Pascal, you know, that if there is a God, he
[1:12:09] must be a hidden God because he's not obvious.
[1:12:11] That's the great thing about Pascal.
[1:12:12] He, he loves the paradoxes, the, the weirdness of Christianity.
[1:12:17] You know, it's not obvious. Christianity is not obviously
[1:12:19] true. There wasn't obviously a God.
[1:12:21] He doesn't speak to you out of the clouds.
[1:12:22] He doesn't suddenly appear to you in the middle of the road.
[1:12:25] If there is a God, there's a hidden God.
[1:12:27] That's a very generative idea, the idea that there may be this
[1:12:30] God who is hidden. And Pascal says, hey, that makes
[1:12:34] sense of Christianity because actually that's exactly what
[1:12:36] Christianity says. If there is a God, there must be
[1:12:38] a hidden God. Well, Christianity says that
[1:12:41] when God came to us, he came to us in hidden form.
[1:12:45] In other words, he came to us in this person called Jesus Christ
[1:12:47] that you could meet Jesus, you could shake his hand and
[1:12:50] entirely miss the fact that you were talking to God because he's
[1:12:53] hidden in in the flesh of Jesus. Same he says in church and you
[1:12:56] go to church and you get given given a bit of bread and wine
[1:13:00] looks like bread and wine looks like ordinary stuff.
[1:13:03] But actually he says, Pascal, no, this is the body and blood
[1:13:05] of Christ. So you know, always he's in
[1:13:09] Christianity. This is a hidden gun.
[1:13:10] And that kind of makes sense of our experience of the world,
[1:13:12] that if there is a God, he's a hidden gun.
[1:13:14] How would you reconcile that divine hiddenness with God being
[1:13:18] Omni benevolent? Well, for Pascal, he, I think of
[1:13:22] the way he would say that is that God is not interested in a
[1:13:27] kind of arm's length relationship with us, the kind
[1:13:31] of relationship that says, OK, I believe God exists, take that
[1:13:33] box and get on with the rest of my life.
[1:13:35] Which is why God doesn't show himself to be obvious.
[1:13:39] Why God, if you like, hides himself on us because he waits
[1:13:46] to be found by those who are not content with that kind of
[1:13:50] relationship with God, who are, who are willing to go deeper
[1:13:54] into that, that deeper encounter that that Pascal himself had.
[1:14:00] So it's a kind of expression of God's benevolence and the fact
[1:14:02] that that's what he longs for us to have, that deep encounter
[1:14:06] with God. And therefore he doesn't allow
[1:14:07] us to just settle at that level of a kind of arm's length
[1:14:10] relationship with God that we sort of put to one side.
[1:14:13] I think the other thing Pascal would say and other Christian
[1:14:16] theologians have said is that in a way, because we are both
[1:14:20] creatures and because we are fallen, we are broken, we are
[1:14:24] fractured as people, we're kind of almost not capable of seeing
[1:14:27] God face to face. If if, if we saw God face to
[1:14:30] face, it would be so terrifying and so overwhelming, we would
[1:14:33] not be able to stand. And therefore God out of his
[1:14:35] mercy hides himself from us. That's another way in which he
[1:14:38] could express that same answer. It annoys me because I want
[1:14:42] everything to be quantifiable and easy, especially someone
[1:14:45] that doesn't believe in God. But I mean, Pascal sums it up so
[1:14:49] nicely. One of my favorite quiz to him
[1:14:50] is to make lighter philosophy is to be a true philosopher.
[1:14:53] And it it ties into all of this. It's it's a difficult one and
[1:14:57] and squaring faith with also not just having blind faith.
[1:15:04] These are some of the arguments they're having as well at the
[1:15:06] time. It's fascinating how that whole
[1:15:11] concept that Pascal spoke about is just ever more relevant now
[1:15:16] than ever. It it's, it's more relevant than
[1:15:19] in the time that he wrote it. And I, I feel like that's
[1:15:23] perhaps the sign of a great thinker, is that their ideas
[1:15:25] grow with time. Exactly.
[1:15:26] Yeah, that's right. Yeah.
[1:15:27] And one of his, again, one of his things is, you know, the
[1:15:30] greatness of reason is to know where it has to stop, you know,
[1:15:35] reason. And you know, he's not like a,
[1:15:39] you know, some like a Sur and Kirkuk or or a figure like that.
[1:15:41] He has no place for reason at all.
[1:15:43] He thinks reason is a is, is a thoroughly misleading Pasca has
[1:15:46] a place for it. He's a scientist.
[1:15:47] He really does believe in reason as helping us understand the way
[1:15:51] the world is. He just makes a big difference
[1:15:54] between distinction between physics and metaphysics, kind of
[1:15:57] helps us outside the physical world, doesn't help us much in
[1:16:00] understanding God. Now he thinks there are good
[1:16:02] reasons for believing in God, but he thinks they're only the
[1:16:05] kind of reasons that will convince you if you already
[1:16:07] believe, if you like. It's the heart that perceives
[1:16:11] God, not the reason. Now he says there are ways you
[1:16:14] can discover that by, as he says, acting as if you believe.
[1:16:17] So if he says if you have this instinct that maybe there is a
[1:16:19] God after all, maybe I should give it a go.
[1:16:22] He said, well, OK, just try this experiment, try living as if
[1:16:25] it's true for a while and see what happens.
[1:16:28] So it's not like so he doesn't have any place for reason at
[1:16:30] all, but he just thinks that thinking of God as something you
[1:16:34] can reason yourself towards just doesn't work.
[1:16:37] How can young people specifically learn from Pascal?
[1:16:41] Yeah. Well, I think Pascal, Pascal, I
[1:16:47] mean, I think number one, I think Pascal does talk to us
[1:16:50] about the limits of science, the limits of reason.
[1:16:54] You know, we live in a world which, as you say, is often
[1:16:56] told, and it's all about what you can measure, about what you
[1:16:58] can, what you can analyse, what you can.
[1:17:01] You can be put in a test tube, but there's a yeah, that's
[1:17:05] absolutely right and proper. But there's a limit to that.
[1:17:08] And, you know, and I think there are increasing numbers of young
[1:17:10] people today. You kind of sense there is
[1:17:12] something more than that. You know, there is that that
[1:17:15] approach to life is a very kind of limited and rather kind of
[1:17:18] shrivelled understanding of life.
[1:17:20] There's a much more to to to that beyond that.
[1:17:22] And so therefore Pascal is someone who I think helps us to
[1:17:25] see some of the limits of science and reason, the value of
[1:17:28] it at the same time and puts it in it's right sort of place.
[1:17:31] I think he's someone who can, it can help us sort of see the,
[1:17:37] the, the real nature of, of humanity.
[1:17:40] But one of the things I think that's interesting about Pascal
[1:17:42] is 2 inventions around just, that happened just before his
[1:17:45] own life, the telescope and the microscope.
[1:17:48] So you've got, you know, Galileo's telescope that
[1:17:50] suddenly enabled us to see into space and we could see the
[1:17:53] planets, we could see the stars, we could see how vast the
[1:17:56] universe was and we could see, you realise that we are not the
[1:18:00] centre of it, that the Earth is not the centre of everything.
[1:18:02] It revolves around the sun. So in other words, suddenly
[1:18:05] Pascal is someone is able to talk about the smallness, the
[1:18:09] insignificance of humanity. And he also the microscope,
[1:18:15] we're able to see the tiniest bits of a family and the leg is
[1:18:20] on a family and the hairs on the leg is the fly and the, you
[1:18:23] know, the the tiniest elements of reality.
[1:18:26] So Pascal's living in an age that has changed the way that we
[1:18:30] human beings see it. Think about ourselves, you know,
[1:18:32] 100 years ago, 100 years before him, you know, people like Tom
[1:18:36] Calvin or Martin Luther or Thomas Aquinas before that kind
[1:18:39] of believe that, you know, the humanity was the centre of
[1:18:42] everything. This world was the centre of
[1:18:45] everything. And Pascal is very modern in the
[1:18:47] sense that he, he realises that we are in the vastness of space.
[1:18:52] We're a pretty insignificant thing.
[1:18:54] And he he he talks about that's in ways that really resonate
[1:18:58] with us today. He has this great phrase, you
[1:19:00] know, the Sidon Seitanel is a spouse Hafeni mefre the you
[1:19:04] know, the eternal silence of infinite space terrifies me.
[1:19:07] That's a very modern thing to say.
[1:19:09] You know, Calvin and Ruther would never have said that a
[1:19:11] century before. So I think he's able to express
[1:19:14] that. But at the same time, he says
[1:19:16] there is this smallness, this insignificance, the fact that we
[1:19:19] are capable of great cruelty, of great harm to each other.
[1:19:23] We damage each other, we are selfish, we are all that stuff.
[1:19:27] But we have this extraordinary capacity to understand the
[1:19:30] world, to master it, to create amazing things even greater than
[1:19:35] the ones that he did, to love one another, to know God.
[1:19:40] And he really captures, I think, this sense of the, both the,
[1:19:43] the, the, the, the insignificance and the
[1:19:46] significance of humanity. You know, our weakness and our
[1:19:50] greatness more than almost anybody else.
[1:19:52] And I think when you're growing up realising that that's who you
[1:19:57] are, someone with enormous potential to do enormous things
[1:20:01] and to know God and to to flourish into someone who has
[1:20:05] that true happiness to be shaped in the form of true humanity.
[1:20:09] But also the possibility you might go in the other direction
[1:20:11] too. There's a real bit of wisdom.
[1:20:14] Graham Tomlin, thank you so much for coming on the show.
[1:20:16] I wish we had like 7 hours to speak about this because there's
[1:20:20] so much in the book and it's it's crazy to read it and then
[1:20:23] try and implement just the golden Nuggets because it's all
[1:20:26] great. So appreciate your time.
[1:20:28] Where can people find the book and more of your work?
[1:20:31] Yeah, thank you. Well, the book is published by
[1:20:34] Hodder and I get it on get Amazon or any sort of order
[1:20:38] through any bookshop based Pascal, the man who made the
[1:20:41] modern world. If you want to find out more
[1:20:43] about what I do is that I I I help to run a a website
[1:20:47] calledseen@unseen.com, which is trying to to think a little bit
[1:20:52] like Pascal does. What Pascal does is to try to
[1:20:55] help you see how Christian faith makes sense of the world.
[1:20:58] And that's kind of what this website does.
[1:21:00] It looks at all kinds of issues in contemporary life and
[1:21:02] culture, stuff that's in the news, bigger cultural questions
[1:21:06] and say, what does, what does Christian faith, how does
[1:21:09] Christian faith help you understand those better?
[1:21:10] How I shed a new light on it. And the idea is that, you know,
[1:21:13] we, there's all the scene stuff, you know, the politics and
[1:21:16] economics and history and stuff that we all talk about.
[1:21:19] But what does that look like in the light of the unseen
[1:21:21] realities of, of God and Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit and
[1:21:24] so on and faith. So CNN, unseen.com, that'll be
[1:21:27] the place to go. And there you'll find lots of
[1:21:29] material there, lots of other podcasts that we do, as well as
[1:21:32] articles and other material that hopefully we'll find really
[1:21:34] interesting.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
