# The Revolution That Changed Christianity Forever - What Was the Reformation? - Suzannah Lipscomb | #47

An episode of [The Next Generation](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1772698742), 11 Oct 2025, 1 h 35 min.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/107851968/podcast/play/109022258/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2025-8-30%2F408418756-44100-2-7e72caa070ace.mp3

How did one man change the course of history, and how does his revolution still shape our lives today?From Luther to Henry VIII, historian Suzannah Lipscomb and I take a deep dive into this fascinating period. A fellow of the Royal Historical Society and professor emerita, Suzannah has written and edited a number of books, presented numerous TV programmes and is host of the podcast, Not Just the Tudors - available here: https://open.spotify.com/show/4cE3piJ1dtOB0Phe8LEBgW?si=f3fd55d6b6854eb3Follow Suzannah on X: https://x.com/sixteenthCgirl00:00 What was the Reformation?03:19 The impact of the Printing Press and new technologies12:39 How Martin Luther shaped history15:33 Henry VIII’s love life changes everything20:31 How religion dominated life24:52 Medieval vs Modern rhythms of life30:14 The creation of the Church of England37:32 Being ‘hung, drawn and quartered’40:14 Clashes and iconoclasm over the new CofE46:12 When Christianity is used for political ends54:10 Can grace and truth be reconciled in Christian societies?57:37 Why Suzannah was drawn to this era1:03:46 Does your personal faith get in the way of your studies?1:08:52 How modern is the meaning crisis? 1:18:42 We have a sickness of self-absorption1:23:33 A historian’s perspective on Gen Z1:33:49 Wrapping upMy Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotbewick/TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliotbewickX: https://x.com/elliotbewickABOUT THE NEXT GENERATION: In a world saturated by social media and marked by skyrocketing rates of anxiety, depression, and ADHD among Gen Z, young people are growing up in a landscape of chaos and contradiction. While protests swell in city streets and activists hurl soup at famous artworks to demand climate action, a quieter crisis unfolds within - the mental and emotional battles faced by a generation trying to make sense of it all.The Next Generation is hosted by 20-year-old Elliot Bewick, offering a raw and honest look at the world through the eyes of those living in it. Bringing together insight from professionals and young people on the ground, this podcast isn’t here to complain or chase clout. It’s here to bend the arc of the modern world towards solutions, truth and a love for the beautiful adventure of life itself.

## Transcript

[0:00] What on earth was the Reformation and how does it
[0:03] affect us today? The Reformation was a huge
[0:08] seismic change in ideas where people felt, not for the first
[0:14] time, but for the first time in that generation, that they could
[0:19] think things through themselves, but they didn't listen to or
[0:23] need to listen to priests. They didn't need to accept
[0:26] orthodoxies and that they could find their own way to salvation,
[0:32] which is how they understood what was going to come after
[0:36] death, but also how they would live in this life.
[0:39] So it is a radical breaking with traditional ideas about
[0:45] authority and about how you find meaning.
[0:48] Let's lay this out for everyone, including myself that has no
[0:52] idea. I mean, the Reformation happens
[0:54] some point between the Battle of Hastings and World War 2.
[0:58] That's as as far as most people's knowledge go.
[1:00] And it it seems to be a period, especially in my generation,
[1:03] that's just not discussed when it is so important.
[1:06] So when is this and what are the key factors that kick this all
[1:09] off? So this is in the 16th century,
[1:12] so the 1500s. And it starts with Martin Luther
[1:16] in 1517 pinning his 95 thesis on on a church door in Wittenberg.
[1:24] That's perhaps what happened. We don't actually know whether
[1:27] he did pin this document on this church door, but this is the
[1:31] idea. So Luther is a monk, and he is
[1:36] somebody who is an intellectual, and he has decided that the way
[1:41] that the church does things is not quite right.
[1:44] And among the things that he objects to is something called
[1:46] indulgences. And indulgences is a practice by
[1:50] which a person who's a believer can buy their way out of some
[1:56] time in purgatory. So this idea exists after you
[1:59] die, you'll go to a place of limbo between heaven and hell.
[2:03] And there you will work off. You will do penance for the
[2:07] things you've done wrong in your life, and you'll make your way
[2:10] to heaven. But you'll do that through pain.
[2:14] And that could be for 10,000 years.
[2:16] And this is a 13th century idea. It's not in the Bible, but this
[2:21] idea comes about that an indulgence means you can buy
[2:26] time off that pain, and you can buy an indulgence for your loved
[2:30] ones. So your mother has died, your
[2:31] grandmother has died. You don't want her to be going
[2:33] through these years of suffering.
[2:35] And so you will do something to purchase this indulgence.
[2:38] And Lisa thinks this is complete nonsense.
[2:40] And when he challenges this idea, to cut a Long story short,
[2:46] it challenges the sort of Riddle authority of the church.
[2:50] And eventually he comes to believe that the Pope who was
[2:52] saying these things are true must be fallible.
[2:56] He must be able to make mistakes, which is not something
[3:00] the Catholic Church believes. And it kind of kick starts this
[3:04] revolution in ideas. So it starts people thinking
[3:07] about what is true and what Can you believe and whose authority
[3:11] do you need to accept? And then people start to
[3:14] theorize about that in different ways.
[3:17] I want us to get this in early because someone listening at
[3:19] home might go it, revolutionize it revolutionizes this idea of
[3:23] thinking about what's actually true.
[3:25] But we're 1500 years after Christ at this point.
[3:30] Come on, guys, come on humanity. We've had 1500 years to think
[3:34] about what's true since Christ was alive, and we haven't.
[3:37] One of the limiting factors is the speed of communication here.
[3:42] Let's talk about the printing press.
[3:44] How does this impact the Reformation?
[3:47] I don't think that people haven't thought about what was
[3:50] true in 1500 years, but they have reached different
[3:53] conclusions about it. And yet you're absolutely right
[3:57] that technology is key to this change.
[4:00] So the printing press is only 50 something years old at this
[4:03] point in time. And up until this point, it's
[4:07] basically acted like a really quick way of making a, a
[4:10] handwritten book. But now it's started to use to
[4:13] disseminate ideas. So one of the ways Luther
[4:16] becomes so popular so quickly is that he's having these pamphlets
[4:20] produced, which are cheap as well, So people can afford them.
[4:23] Not loads of people can't read, by the way, but that isn't a
[4:26] real obstacle because as long as you know someone who can read,
[4:30] like today, you just need to know someone who can drive and
[4:32] you can get places right? So if you know someone who can
[4:34] read, they read it out loud and people know the ideas.
[4:37] What's the ballpark of how many people can actually read at this
[4:40] point? Is it a class thing?
[4:42] Is it some people went down different paths?
[4:44] They wanted to be farmers, but they did have access even at a
[4:47] lower class if they chose to read.
[4:50] So 10% of men, 5% of women can read by the beginning of the
[4:55] 16th century. And it's generally speaking,
[4:58] they've not really had any education at all.
[5:00] It's really hard to know because though, because we chart
[5:03] literacy by who could sign their names.
[5:07] And like, judging by my child, you learn to write your name
[5:11] pretty early before you can read a book.
[5:13] So they might have had really basic literacy.
[5:16] And quite a lot of people are still just signing with a mark.
[5:19] So who can read? I don't know.
[5:21] It's very small percentage of people.
[5:24] I'm happy for us to jump about a little bit here because I think
[5:26] there are so many interesting points to bring up early on.
[5:29] We've got the printing press and it feeds into something I've
[5:33] been thinking about a lot recently, which is
[5:36] communication. Nowadays we can all read and
[5:39] write, almost all of us things like 99.9% in most Western
[5:43] countries now. But the way that we have
[5:46] variation nowadays is through things like podcasts versus Tik
[5:50] Toks versus people who do still read and write.
[5:53] Actually now reading and writing isn't the new thing.
[5:57] It's the old thing. It's, it's a closed book,
[5:59] literally, right. And the thing that's fascinated
[6:02] me, even though I was about 5 years old when it all kicked off
[6:06] is the New atheist movement that happened in sort of the the
[6:09] early 2000s to 2000 and 10's. And how TV panels and debates
[6:15] impacted the level of depth of discussion.
[6:18] Especially with a topic like Christianity where it's probably
[6:22] not going to work. Just going on AGB news panel or
[6:26] BBC News night panel and fleshing out some talking points
[6:31] that you said a million times, not going into deeper depth that
[6:34] that kind of is anti technical to what faith and religion is,
[6:38] right? But what you see with the New
[6:40] Atheist movement is this unique prevalence of exactly that,
[6:45] these on stage debates that sometimes run for a couple of
[6:49] hours and go into more depth. But the thing that's the biggest
[6:52] variable there is the power of the orator and how skilled they
[6:56] are at a ration rather than philosophy or theology, right?
[7:00] So it's so cool to see back in the 1500's the limiting factors,
[7:05] reading and writing, and now it's the opposite.
[7:08] Now we have an abundance of technology and we're kind of
[7:10] frying our dopamine systems, trying to get shorter and
[7:14] shorter clips out to stimulate the viewer.
[7:17] And now we've almost had a regression back to surface level
[7:22] discussions because our technology is too powerful.
[7:25] I mean, you, you must see this a lot when you're studying history
[7:28] as a historian. The technology massively changes
[7:31] everything. Yes, and actually if we're
[7:34] thinking about the 16th century, there are two things that I
[7:37] think relate to the way we communicate today that are the
[7:40] same. And one that's quite different 1
[7:43] is that although there's all this printing, they're not just
[7:47] printing words, they're printing pictures.
[7:48] And quite a lot of those are vividly coloured.
[7:51] And so the pictures communicate to those who can't read.
[7:53] And so you've got Luther depicting the Pope as, you know,
[7:57] as a monster or as a, as a, as a kind of creature of Babylon and
[8:03] these ideas that are conveyed through pictures.
[8:06] So that's our memes or images today.
[8:09] And then also there's a lot of oration.
[8:11] So once we start to have what what kind of become the
[8:16] painfully carved out categories of Protestant and Catholic from
[8:19] one church, we have preachers who can preach with
[8:24] extraordinary oratory skill and they preach for hours.
[8:28] That's the bit that's different. People will listen to them for
[8:31] hours. I guess it's a bit like going to
[8:32] the cinema or going to the theatre.
[8:35] I think for people at the time, this is their entertainment.
[8:38] There are plays, of course, but you know, a really good and
[8:42] brothels. So just like, yes, that's a
[8:44] different sort of entertainment. If they're looking for
[8:47] intellectual stimulus, right, they might go to, I listen to a
[8:52] celebrity preacher, he's in town.
[8:54] So and they, they put up with that for hours.
[8:58] And but I guess a really good engaged speaker, engaging
[9:03] speaker is someone you can listen to for a while.
[9:05] And perhaps we've slightly lost the art of oratory today.
[9:09] There's this fascinating concept of how microphones specifically
[9:14] reduce speaking ability. Because back in the 50s you'd
[9:18] have to record mic, you'd have to record your songs as an
[9:20] artist on these awful microphones that couldn't really
[9:23] pick you up. So you'd really have to vary
[9:26] your intonation, how loudly you were speaking.
[9:28] Whereas now we've got 2 amazing sure SM 7B microphones in front
[9:32] of our faces and this is going to all get run through AI and
[9:35] sound perfect regardless. Even if a fire engine goes off
[9:37] in the background and you can get lazy, you don't have to vary
[9:41] your intonation. So again, it's technology and
[9:44] the development of it actually impeding on humanity and what it
[9:49] means to be an interesting human with proper ideas and skills.
[9:53] Yes, I suppose like a typewriter, you needed to be
[9:56] able to write your thoughts out pretty perfectly the first time.
[10:01] Whereas now you with a word processor, you can just change
[10:04] it around all the time. You can move your text around
[10:06] you. I mean, people wrote notes by
[10:09] hand, but then again, that's another form of technology.
[10:11] When I was teaching in universities, I would always
[10:14] encourage my students to write notes longhand unless they
[10:17] really needed a screen for, you know, a reason of accessibility
[10:21] because you process your thoughts differently when you
[10:24] write them out. It's not just sound waves.
[10:27] You, you kind of have to preciate in your own words and
[10:30] you write it down and, and then you would type something from
[10:35] that. But I'm sure it's different when
[10:37] you write, I don't know, an essay by hand than when you type
[10:41] it. And if you type it on a
[10:44] typewriter, that's different from type on a computer where
[10:46] you don't have to get it right. I'm always so grateful to be
[10:49] having these conversations. And I say this to my friends
[10:52] too, even when we're just having dinner and having a chat,
[10:54] because there's something so magical in conversation.
[10:57] And you see this in someone like Plato fleshing out philosophy.
[11:01] It's always via a dialogue and there are certain forms of
[11:05] thinking about things and writing about things and
[11:07] discussing things that you can't get in any other way.
[11:10] There's no other proxy to unlock that way of thinking.
[11:13] So it's, it's so important to speak to people instead of just
[11:17] text them on Snapchat, right? Or send pictures with a short
[11:20] caption because you'd look at something like philosophy papers
[11:23] where it is a dialogue. It's so much more substantive
[11:27] and I don't quite know why that is.
[11:29] It's maybe just something in human nature.
[11:32] I think it's because when you have a photograph with a text
[11:35] caption, what you're doing is you're seeing a reflection of
[11:37] yourself. You've got your own reading of
[11:39] that. You've put your own spin on
[11:41] those 5 words, which it could be completely different from what
[11:45] the person's sending it meant. But when you're in conversation,
[11:49] you're forced to engage with the other person's perspective.
[11:52] And of course we've got all this other information.
[11:54] That's the thing we learnt during COVID is that if you
[11:57] speak through screens, you get a tiny fraction of information.
[12:01] And it's not just that you know how tall the other person is,
[12:03] but you also like we're reading each other's bonded language
[12:07] just as much as we're having a conversation.
[12:09] So you pick up on a whole level of information that you can't
[12:16] put into 5 words text. Yeah, but I think a man can
[12:20] smell a lady's T-shirt and guess how close to being maximum
[12:25] fertility she is or something. And a woman can tell with a
[12:28] man's pheromones, again from the smell, apparently, whether they
[12:31] would have functioning babies or not.
[12:34] Yeah. It's fascinating.
[12:36] We've already talked about fertility.
[12:39] So Martin Luther. Yeah.
[12:41] What impact does he actually have?
[12:43] Does he just fade away into history after this 95 thesis
[12:45] gets pinned up on the church? No, absolutely not.
[12:48] So he becomes one of the foremost intellectuals of the
[12:53] age because he takes on the Pope.
[12:54] And he refuses to accept being silenced when he's
[13:01] excommunicated by the Church, even though this puts him in
[13:03] severe personal danger. And his ideas are ones that
[13:08] unfold and become very important to new thinkers coming up.
[13:13] So there are people like John Calvin, who was Zingley, who
[13:17] take on Luther's ideas and develop them in various ways.
[13:21] And there are people who go really radical with them.
[13:24] So some of the some of those ideas are beyond the pale from
[13:29] from the almost like 90% of the population in Europe at the
[13:33] time. Like people believe in baptism
[13:37] of infants, but there are Anabaptists who believe that you
[13:40] should only be able to decide whether you are baptized as an
[13:45] adult or not. This is an idea which might seem
[13:48] pretty arbitrary, but is about freedom of choice.
[13:52] And yet for people at the time, because it takes children
[13:57] outside the protection that baptism is thought to offer at
[14:01] the time, it's thought if a child dies without being
[14:03] baptized, it will never go to heaven.
[14:05] It will float in limbo. It wouldn't possibly go to hell.
[14:10] This idea is radical. There are people who are saying
[14:13] that women can preach, which is radical at the time.
[14:16] And so there's this big discussion about what's
[14:18] acceptable and what's not. And one of the things that the
[14:20] the debate comes down to is about the nature of the
[14:25] sacrament, which is the bread and wine in the Mass or the
[14:29] Eucharist or the Communion. And this can seem so alien to us
[14:33] because it's something that seems, I mean, does it matter
[14:38] whether it's really Christ's body and blood or, or, or just
[14:41] bread and wine? And at the time, it's a life and
[14:43] death issue, but it symbolizes the the fundamental kind of
[14:50] disagreement that people are having, which is about what
[14:54] really matters. So Catholics continue to believe
[14:57] that the blood and body of Jesus are present, physically present
[15:03] in the bread and the wine. Where are those others believe
[15:08] that that it hits present but it remains bread and wine and
[15:12] others believe it's a symbol. But in Henry the Eighth's
[15:14] England, for example, in the 1530s, to believe that the bread
[15:17] and wine are merely a symbol of Christ's body and blood is
[15:20] heresy that will lead to you being burnt at the stake.
[15:24] So these things which seem to us so arcane were life and death
[15:29] issues and and we have to try and think about why that is.
[15:33] How do we get from Luther to the biggest change happening in
[15:39] England, kicking everything off properly?
[15:41] Henry the eighth. Let's talk about him.
[15:44] It's a slightly convoluted journey because in England the
[15:48] Reformation doesn't happen because a great of a great
[15:50] upswell of Protestant belief, Protestant to what Luther's
[15:54] followers become called Protestant because they had
[15:57] protested, is an insult like most titles.
[16:01] But there are a few pockets of that kind of belief in London
[16:05] and Cambridge and some of the cities.
[16:07] But actually what happens in England is a kind of top down in
[16:10] position. So Henry the eighth is married
[16:13] to Catherine of Aragon, who was the daughter of Isabel of
[16:15] Castile, Fernando of Aragon, the Spanish Princess.
[16:20] They are very happily married at first, but over time they have
[16:26] this heartbreaking series of miscarriages and stillbirths,
[16:30] infant mortalities. In fact, I'm not sure if
[16:33] miscarriages is accurate. I think it's mainly child death,
[16:35] either in utero or just after one daughter survives.
[16:40] And by the 1520s, Henry, who's pretty chauvinistic, has decided
[16:44] that his daughter cannot inherit his throne.
[16:46] He needs a male heir. And then in the mid 1520s, he
[16:50] falls in love with a woman at the court, Anne Boleyn.
[16:55] How did they meet? How did they meet?
[16:57] She was in the service of his wife.
[17:00] She was one of Catherine Aragon's ladies in waiting.
[17:03] Henry's unusual in this period of time from monarch because he
[17:06] likes to pick his spouses among people he knows, so he knew
[17:10] Catherine Aragon. She was his brother's wife.
[17:13] How? How is that alien to usual?
[17:15] It's usually maybe more arranged marriage going across the pond
[17:18] somewhere to another high up royal family.
[17:21] Yeah, there's another moment later in the 1530s, when Henry
[17:24] is wifeless and looking for another wife, and he wants to
[17:27] meet the princesses of France. It's been suggested they might
[17:31] be a good match for him. And he says, well, why don't
[17:34] they go to Calais, which is an English territory at the time,
[17:37] and he can meet them then he can pick one.
[17:41] It's like a 16th century Tinder. Yeah, it was speed dating,
[17:44] perhaps. And the French ambassador at the
[17:47] time is so horrified by the suggestion that the princesses
[17:52] of France should be paraded before the King of England like
[17:55] horses that he says perhaps your Majesty wants to mount them as
[17:58] well. I mean, he's he's absolutely
[18:00] horrified. But Henry, the only time when
[18:04] marriage really goes wrong is when with Anne of Cleves, when
[18:06] he hasn't met her before. He's just seen her picture like
[18:08] Tinder. And that goes wrong.
[18:11] That date does not work out. You've.
[18:12] Got catfished. Yeah, that's right.
[18:14] So in practice with Cat, with Anne Boleyn, he knows her at the
[18:19] court and she's come from France.
[18:22] She's more French than English, she's cosmopolitan and she's
[18:25] brilliant. She's one of those brilliant
[18:26] women at court. And he falls in love with her.
[18:30] And the story goes that they don't consummate their
[18:35] relationship. Either she refuses or they both
[18:38] decide against it. And he wants to marry her and he
[18:41] wants to marry her and have a male heir with her.
[18:43] And Catherine won't bow out gracefully because she knows
[18:47] that she is really married to this man and she is stubborn as
[18:50] a mule because she's right. And in the end, Henry tries to
[18:57] find a way to get out of the marriage.
[18:59] First of all, he looks to have his marriage to Catherine
[19:03] annulled, which the Pope would have to grant.
[19:05] And this happens from time to time.
[19:06] Royal marriages are annulled. People say, oh, well, there, it
[19:09] never really happened. That's an enormities.
[19:11] It never occurred. You were never actually married.
[19:15] And that's happened with the king of France, Louis the 12th,
[19:18] for example. But the problem is, at the time
[19:23] the Pope has just been put, this is 1527, he's just been
[19:27] captured. This Rome has been captured by
[19:30] Charles the 5th, who's the emperor of the Holy Roman
[19:33] Empire, and he is Catherine of Aragon's nephew.
[19:37] And so he is not about to allow his aunt to be besmirched by the
[19:41] dishonor of a divorce. We say divorce.
[19:44] Divorce just means a separation. It's not like divorces.
[19:46] We think of it today. And so the Pope can't act, so he
[19:51] can't grant the annulment. So he puts it off and he tries
[19:53] to lead Henry down another path. The Long story short is that the
[19:58] annulment is not granted and Henry has to look for another
[20:00] way of doing it. And in the end he has to break
[20:04] with the Roman Catholic Church. He has to separate out the
[20:08] Church in England from the Roman Catholic Church so that his
[20:11] Archbishop of Canterbury can say he has an annulment.
[20:15] And then he's free to marry. He's an innovator nowadays.
[20:18] He would be an early AI adopter, creating new large language
[20:22] models on ChatGPT or something. Maybe, but only if it really
[20:26] benefited him. I mean, he's an innovator so far
[20:28] as it fulfills his own selfish desires.
[20:31] So he's massively constrained by the religion that's hovering
[20:37] over all of Western civilization at this point and.
[20:41] Or by massively constrained we mean he cannot shag the woman he
[20:44] wants to shag. Like to be really accurate about
[20:47] it. Exactly.
[20:48] And that obviously shows that religion plays a massive role in
[20:54] governing the everyday lives of the populations.
[20:56] Even the untouchables that have the divine right to be a king,
[21:01] they still have to play ball to a certain extent.
[21:03] So we know this, but I want us to go into that in more depth
[21:07] because I think this is so alien.
[21:08] Someone and especially me thinking and looking back at the
[21:11] 16th century and seeing people governed as a society by
[21:16] religion. Some people speak about now,
[21:18] someone like Tom Holland and Dominion speak about how we have
[21:20] all these fundamental Judeo-christian values that
[21:23] govern our morality nowadays, but that's a more covert thing,
[21:30] whereas now in the 16th century it seems more overt.
[21:37] I'd argue that maybe not covert, maybe it's internalised.
[21:41] What's the difference? Well, because one suggests a
[21:45] secret agenda, whereas internalised means that it's
[21:48] already kind of part of our formation, which perhaps is what
[21:51] Tom Holland was getting at. It's the air we breathe.
[21:54] It's the air we breathe, and it was the air they breathed in the
[21:56] 16th century. So it's part of the warp and
[21:59] weave of their everyday lives. I mean, there were different
[22:00] expectations. It was expected that everyone
[22:02] would go to church every Sunday. And in the late 16th century you
[22:06] can be fined for not going to church because it suggests that
[22:11] you're a Catholic as opposed to a proper upstanding member of
[22:14] the Anglican Church. But I think the ways it's
[22:18] affecting people is it's shaping what they think their final
[22:22] destination is, and it's shaping the rhythm of their days and
[22:26] their months. Like so it's the rhythm of the
[22:29] year. Is the church year the calendar
[22:31] of the church year? Talk to me more about that.
[22:33] How does that impact things? Well, so all of the events, so
[22:36] we're coming up to Saint Nicholas, which will be harvest.
[22:40] So there's the great festival of Saint Nicholas which coincides
[22:44] with the harvest. And this is so people are most
[22:47] people are agricultural again, maybe 5% of people live in
[22:51] cities at this time. And even if you live in a city,
[22:54] you might well work in the fields as well.
[22:57] So the rhythm of the seasons effects everything you do.
[23:02] And that has been tied up with the Saints days over the 1500
[23:06] years since the birth of Christ. And so the Saints days are high
[23:11] points or holy days of the calendar where you can celebrate
[23:16] some great achievement that's occurred in terms of the the
[23:20] rhythm of the year. And so you know, or Saint Lucy's
[23:25] Lucia, that the day at the where we now talk about the winter
[23:29] solstice, where the you celebrate light at the time
[23:33] where there's the most darkness in the Northern hemisphere.
[23:36] So the there is this sense that the church year, it gives you
[23:41] holidays, it punctuates the year with fun and festivity.
[23:46] It creates these moments of safety valve where people can
[23:50] run riot, whether that's at Christmas time, there's
[23:54] something called the Abbot of Mis rule where a boy will
[23:58] pretend to be an Abbot and we'll tell everybody what to do.
[24:01] Or that happens it just around show of Tuesday as well, just
[24:05] before Lent and the world turns upside down briefly in order to
[24:09] then be able to reassert the dominant hierarchy.
[24:14] So I think that that we, if we, it's really hard to examine your
[24:20] present age and figure out what the water is in which we swim,
[24:25] we can point to the 16th century and say, look, that's the water
[24:28] they're swimming in. Couldn't they see it?
[24:30] And it's like, no, when you're a fish in the water, you can't
[24:33] tell it's water. So it's hard for us to know what
[24:36] are all the ways in which we are shaped right now.
[24:39] And I long to be 50 years in the future and look back and say,
[24:42] oh, look, these are the things that they didn't even know that
[24:45] they were doing or they didn't even think about that idea.
[24:48] How obvious? Why did they not think about it?
[24:53] It's fascinating that idea of rest and organized breaks
[24:59] essentially in society because we often look back on peasants
[25:02] working in fields and we pity them, and rightly so.
[25:05] Tough jobs. But something that we do miss
[25:08] out in our historical framing a lot of the time, I think, is
[25:12] that lack of ability to see how it is today and realize how
[25:16] bloody busy we are today always compared to actually how busy
[25:21] someone was in the 16th century. They probably had slightly more
[25:24] free time. I don't know, you tell me.
[25:26] But I spoke to ABBA Christopher Jamison about this, who's a
[25:30] Benedictine monk. And he's written a whole book
[25:32] about how everyone always says, oh, yeah, I'm busy when they're
[25:36] asked how are you? And he always responds, I'm
[25:39] sorry to hear that. And it kind of catches them off
[25:42] guard because people are so perennially used to being busy
[25:45] nowadays, and they see it as a duty and as proof, as evidence
[25:49] that they're working hard and they're doing the right thing.
[25:52] So that must affect everything. Just having more time to
[25:56] ruminate and question if there is a man in the sky.
[26:00] Yes, it's interesting how we've valorized the expression.
[26:03] I'm busy, haven't we? I think that people worked very
[26:08] hard and that a lot of that was physical labour, but I think it
[26:14] had a completely different feeling about it.
[26:18] I'm sure that there were implications for women and
[26:21] domestic violence and all sorts of things, but a lot of the work
[26:24] is from the household. So a house could be a workshop
[26:27] if you're living in a in a city and women are involved in the
[26:30] work just as much as men or you're going out to do things.
[26:33] There are times of the year, there are seasons, bit harvest,
[26:36] everybody pitches in, everybody's busy.
[26:38] But then there are times of the year where there's not that much
[26:40] to do and you can sit around a bit.
[26:43] They followed the rhythm of the year in terms of the light as
[26:45] well. So they in the medieval period,
[26:48] the actually the hours of the day were not set at 60 minutes
[26:53] long. They vary depending on how many,
[26:55] on how many hours there were and how of light in the day.
[26:59] So the hours were variable. And in the winter, you know,
[27:04] candles are expensive. People have tallow candles
[27:06] generally rather than wax candles because they can't
[27:09] afford wax tallow. Tallow tallow is animal fat.
[27:11] OK, It's not that pleasant and it doesn't produce quite as much
[27:16] light and it smells and it's expensive still, so people are
[27:20] not staying up, so they're going to bed with one great debate.
[27:23] I find this fascinating. 1 Great debate among historians has been
[27:26] about the nature of sleep at this time, because it's said
[27:29] that people slept in two shifts. So they'd go to bed when it got
[27:33] dark and then they'd wake up. There'd be a pause in the middle
[27:35] of the night where they would get up and write a letter or
[27:38] pray or have sex, and then they would go back and have a second
[27:42] shift of sleep. But they would have a lot more
[27:44] sleep than us in winter, for example, but then a lot less
[27:47] than, Oh yeah, probably less than summer because they're
[27:50] making the most of the hours. But I love that seasonality of
[27:54] it. I think the part of the problem
[27:55] we have now is that there is no seasonality.
[27:58] It's just on all the time and electric light and our ability
[28:05] to communicate. You know, you fact, you can
[28:07] e-mail from your phone. There's never a stop point to
[28:11] your work. When we had a power cut quite
[28:13] recently and we had to use candles and it lasted all night.
[28:16] It was kind of amazing. Try it.
[28:21] Yeah, I've been thinking about this.
[28:22] I've done a few trips to Saudi Arabia, doing some videography
[28:25] work, and when I'm there, you're obviously immersed in this
[28:29] culture. Literally in the middle of the
[28:30] desert where I was away from a big city and lights and light
[28:35] pollution covering the stars. And first of all, just seeing
[28:39] stars for the first time in like 2 years was crazy.
[28:42] But then tying into that point on sleeping, especially in
[28:46] Islamic culture, their sleeping hours are completely messed up.
[28:50] Like I, I don't know how they function and it's so impressive,
[28:54] but they stay up late culturally.
[28:57] I mean, you, you'll see if you're in a shopping mall or if
[29:00] you're in a street or a market, you'll see all of these toddlers
[29:03] running around at 11:00 PM casually.
[29:05] And, and that's just the norm there.
[29:07] But then also you have to wake up for morning prayer, right?
[29:10] So. They must sleep during the day,
[29:13] the children especially. But they don't that they're
[29:15] working like I don't know when they sleep.
[29:17] I literally don't know. That's one of life's biggest
[29:20] unanswered questions for me. So hopefully this podcast will
[29:23] help me answer it. But but yeah, these, even these
[29:26] Christians, they have a completely different sleep
[29:28] schedule. They're certainly not optimizing
[29:30] their sleep, although it seems like maybe they slept better
[29:32] than us even without mouth strips and no strips.
[29:36] Yes, I don't know. Not many people have recorded
[29:39] their sleep diary. We don't, we don't have like
[29:42] quality of sleep, three stars, 90 percent, 69% or whatever.
[29:47] But I think that they they were sleeping more generally unless
[29:51] they were wealthy because they couldn't afford not to.
[29:55] They couldn't afford to stay up. What?
[29:57] Do you mean? Well, if you can't afford
[29:59] candles, then you can't afford to stay awake.
[30:03] So you go to sleep and what else is there to do?
[30:04] You can't. You know you need a candle to do
[30:06] anything, so you sleep. Or maybe that's why they had so
[30:12] many children. Yeah, so interesting.
[30:14] OK, so Henry the Eighth, Yeah, he wants this divorce and he
[30:18] actually wants a proper separation, not just one of
[30:22] these small fob offs. Or is that maybe what he has to
[30:26] do? He wants to have a legitimate
[30:28] child with Amber Lynn, a legitimate male heir, which
[30:31] means he has to be legitimately married to her, and therefore he
[30:36] has to have it declared that his first marriage was not a
[30:38] marriage. Which means that he draws on
[30:42] this idea that Catherine was not a virgin when she came to him
[30:47] because she'd been married to his brother.
[30:48] And that according to the Word of God, by Henry the Eighth's
[30:51] own interpretation, a woman can he, a man cannot marry his
[30:57] brother's widow. Now, there are verses in the
[30:59] viticus that rule that out. There's a verse in Deuteronomy
[31:02] that says you must marry your brother's widow, but he ignores
[31:05] that. And the verses in in the viticus
[31:08] that say you must not marry your brother's widow say that if you
[31:10] do, you will be childless. And Robert Wakefield, who's the
[31:14] leading a teacher of Hebrew at the time, conveniently translate
[31:19] childless to means you will have no sons.
[31:22] And so even though they have a daughter, it can be indication
[31:25] of God's disfavor with Henry for marrying his brother's widow.
[31:28] And therefore this marriage is against the law of God, and he
[31:32] must be freed from it. How often does this sort of
[31:37] mental gymnastic of interpretation, interpreting the
[31:40] Bible to best fit you, happen? I mean, you have these
[31:42] indulgences. Why did they happen in the first
[31:46] place? Well, that's a really good
[31:48] question. It's about the power of the
[31:49] Church, I suppose. I mean, there are quite a few
[31:54] things. I mean, I mentioned purgatory
[31:55] earlier and that gets codified in 1275, I think it is.
[31:59] And but before that it had been a popular idea and the Church
[32:04] adopts it. So sometimes it's a response to
[32:06] popular feeling to, to what the public believe.
[32:11] I mean, I think that Henry the Eighth's mental gymnastics are
[32:14] particularly unusual. And I mean, people at the time
[32:19] can see the problems with them. They can point out the flaws,
[32:23] but Henry is really attached to them because he's come up with
[32:26] it himself and it gives him the result he wants.
[32:29] So he pursues that means of trying to get a divorce.
[32:34] In fact, there probably were some other things he could have
[32:37] done under Canon Lauren. I can't go into them, but ways
[32:41] in which he could have more legitimately got himself out of
[32:45] the marriage to Catherine, Perhaps.
[32:47] But he is a man who has great capacity for self delusion, as
[32:53] so many of us do. There's this wonderful book I
[32:55] read years ago called Mistakes Were Made but Not by Me, which
[33:00] is about cognitive dissonance and our ability to tell
[33:03] ourselves that we've done the right thing at all times, no
[33:06] matter what. And Henry, it was a really good
[33:09] example of that. How do we get from Horny Henry
[33:14] wanting to get his way to the Church of England?
[33:17] So in order to be freed from Catherine, he has to be
[33:23] established as essentially Pope in England, Supreme Head of the
[33:27] Church of England, Supreme head not only of the secular, the
[33:32] temporal nature of society, but also of its religious nature.
[33:38] And that means that he is, in the end, the arbiter.
[33:42] He is the one who can say what is right and wrong.
[33:45] He comes up with the first doctrinal statement of the
[33:48] Church of England himself in 1536.
[33:50] He writes, these are the things that you should believe because
[33:54] that power has now been vested in him by the Reformation.
[33:58] So that's the creation of the Church of England.
[34:03] And then over over the 16th century, there's a lot of
[34:06] change. His son Edward is a child when
[34:09] he comes to the throne. His advisors are radically
[34:14] Protestant, and they have this kind of iconoclastic period of
[34:21] smashing things and statues and getting rid of stained glass.
[34:24] And his daughter Mary then turns the clock back towards
[34:27] Catholicism. And then his final daughter,
[34:29] Elizabeth. It institutes a form of the
[34:32] Anglican Church that we now have, more or less.
[34:34] But, you know, that's a that's a broad, sweeping overview.
[34:38] We've got a few key players here.
[34:40] How much of this change is Henry having absolute power?
[34:45] He's got the divine right of kings going in his favour, and
[34:48] how much is it him actually being fairly smart and seizing a
[34:53] unique moment in history? I mean, I think it can be both.
[35:00] I mean, he's getting what he wants, which involves a certain
[35:04] degree of being smart, but he's absolutely drawing on his power.
[35:10] I mean, Henry double s down on his power.
[35:13] He uses his rights as a king in various ways.
[35:19] So he starts to use in the 1530s something called an act of
[35:24] attainder, which is when you pass an act through Parliament,
[35:29] the statute that declares somebody guilty of treason.
[35:33] And of course you up until this point you can take someone to
[35:36] trial and find them guilty of treason.
[35:37] But the the beauty of an act of attainder is that you don't need
[35:41] to go through the trial process. You can declare them guilty of
[35:44] treason and you can therefore convict them by act of
[35:49] Parliament. And he does this to quite a
[35:51] number of his enemies because strangely enough, breaking with
[35:53] the Roman Catholic Church produces lots of enemies.
[35:57] And he, you know, he's, he's in a period where he's insecure and
[36:02] paranoid, you know, but as they say, that doesn't mean they're
[36:04] not out to get you. And so he establishes his power
[36:09] and starts to use it more forcibly.
[36:11] There's in 1539, there's an act passed through Parliament which
[36:16] says that King's proclamations have the same power as an act of
[36:20] Parliament. And so there's been lots of
[36:23] debates among historians about whether Henry the Eighth was a
[36:25] tyrant or not. And one of the arguments against
[36:28] him being a tyrant is, oh, but he uses parliament, but he uses
[36:31] parliament to enforce his will. So another act.
[36:35] I'm just bombarding you with dates and acts.
[36:38] But there's another act which makes treason by words illegal.
[36:42] So it becomes treason, IE you will be hung, drawn and courted
[36:47] for calling the king a schismatic, which he obviously
[36:50] is, calling him an infidel, calling him a tyrant.
[36:53] Is there anything more tyrannical than making it
[36:56] illegal to call someone a tyrant?
[37:00] And it's also says that if you imagine the death of the king in
[37:03] words, you have committed treason.
[37:07] So, so, so you even that's thought, basically words and
[37:11] thought become treasonous under Henry.
[37:13] So this is a kind of, if he could, it would be like thought
[37:17] police. He doesn't have the power, he
[37:19] doesn't have a police force, but he's trying to impose his his
[37:23] will on the people. They didn't have Douglas Murray
[37:25] railing for freedom of speech at that point.
[37:27] No, let's go down a little diversion and and rabbit hole
[37:31] here. Speak to me more about the
[37:33] punishment faced back then, being hung, drawn and courted.
[37:37] It fascinates me and it must play into the psyche here as a
[37:41] population, along with all the other factors that we've been
[37:44] outlining just, I mean, I suppose the way to frame it is
[37:48] that you've got the carrot in the stick.
[37:50] The carrot is religion. And at the same time, unlike
[37:54] now, you've got a much harsher stick with punishment.
[37:58] Yes. So people generally would only
[38:01] be punished with being hung, drawn and courted for treason.
[38:06] So that is something against the king, against the government.
[38:10] Though definitions of treason are expanding, as I say in this
[38:13] period. But being hung, drawn and
[38:14] courted means you have been hanged, half hanged.
[38:17] So you're not dead, you're just suffocated I guess to an extent.
[38:22] And then whilst you're still alive, they the executioner
[38:28] opens the body, takes out your innards, it takes out your
[38:33] heart. If you're a man, cuts off your
[38:37] genitals. Doesn't tend to happen.
[38:39] This doesn't tend to happen to women anyway.
[38:41] And then quartered means that the four, your 4 limbs will be
[38:44] cut off and your head. But I mean, obviously at some
[38:48] point in this process you have died.
[38:50] And then the limbs often are displayed in places.
[38:54] So when the Abbott of Glastonbury is hung, drawn,
[38:59] quartered on the tour at Glastonbury, his he's an old
[39:04] man. Glastonbury Festival.
[39:05] Yeah, Glastonbury Festival where the overlooking the Abbey of
[39:09] Glastonbury. So he was one of the three
[39:11] Abbotts out of about 800 who resisted the dissolution in the
[39:14] monasteries. He's dragged on a hurdle which
[39:18] is like a wooden bit like this table I guess, Like he's like
[39:23] he's bound to this hurdle behind horses dragged up to the top of
[39:27] Glastonbury tour and he's forced to.
[39:28] Listen to The Cure headlining. And then after that torture, he
[39:34] is then killed in this barbaric way, and then his legs are put
[39:39] above various gates, Ilchester wells, bath, various places, so
[39:44] that people will know that you have to obey the king.
[39:47] But the punishment for heresy is burning, so this really takes
[39:52] place under Mary the First, who is Henry's daughter.
[39:56] She returns the English church to Rome, so it's Roman Catholic
[40:01] again and she has 284 Protestants burnt at the stake
[40:07] in her five year reign because they believe in mainstream
[40:11] Protestantism and refused to conform to Catholicism.
[40:14] Well, before we get to Mary, let's stick for stick on Henry
[40:17] the eighth time span here. You've mentioned that he has a
[40:20] lot of enemies, as he naturally would do having such a large
[40:24] upheaval. How quickly does the Church of
[40:26] England actually seep into the public consciousness and and
[40:31] begin to take real root in our population?
[40:36] It's hard to know what that would look like, and it's also
[40:39] hard to know how we would find it out because the point we were
[40:44] making earlier about the lack of literacy means we don't have
[40:47] that many sources about what ordinary people believe or think
[40:51] or, you know, their interiority. I mean, even Anne Boleyn, we
[40:55] only have 7 letters that she wrote, but loads for Catherine
[40:58] of Aragon, but we've only got 7. You know, these are people about
[41:01] whom it's really hard to find out what they thought and felt.
[41:06] So we tend to get snippets of it when people do something that's
[41:10] considered to be wrong. So because of that Treasons Act,
[41:14] which makes words illegal, we have cases where somebody will
[41:18] say something like ambulance, a Google eyed whore, which is one
[41:23] woman says, and we know that because somebody else reported
[41:26] her saying it in a pub or a Tavern.
[41:29] And so there's probably a personal vendetta there.
[41:31] And then it becomes before the law courts.
[41:33] So we get moments where people do something they're not
[41:36] supposed to do or say something they're not supposed to say.
[41:39] And then that comes before the courts.
[41:41] But in terms of actually accessing what people thought or
[41:44] felt, it's much harder. I guess we get it at big moments
[41:47] like 1536 is a huge rebellion. It's called the Pilgrimage of
[41:52] Grace and somewhere between 30 and 50,000 people in
[41:58] Lincolnshire and Yorkshire at the time.
[42:01] The population of England is about 2 million.
[42:03] And this is 2 years after the Church of England's been
[42:05] established. Essentially yes.
[42:06] After the Henry's become supreme head of the church, they rise up
[42:12] in protest against the dissolution of the monasteries,
[42:16] which is the the shutting down of all the monasteries and
[42:19] nunneries. You know convents abbeys in the
[42:21] country. And one of the reasons they do
[42:25] that is according to somebody who's arrested and speaks or
[42:29] words that are overheard guy called John Hallam.
[42:31] He says that because the abbeys were put down, everyone believed
[42:36] all the rumours they'd heard about other things that were
[42:38] going to happen. So there were rumours about
[42:40] taxes being put on chickens, taxes being put on weddings,
[42:44] closing down churches, basically the intervention of the state
[42:49] into local life that people objected to and they thought
[42:54] this was going to happen because they'd seen the Abbey's close
[42:57] down. So what they wanted was to
[43:01] resist that. But how much they're resisting
[43:04] the religious agenda that they think's being pushed on them and
[43:08] how much they're saying bugger off out of our local area and,
[43:13] you know, don't try and put more taxes on me, it's hard to say.
[43:16] How does the Church of England change with the death of Henry
[43:19] the Eighth and when does that happen?
[43:21] So he dies in early 1547, and he has maintained a line between
[43:30] Catholicism and Protestantism that's really idiosyncratic.
[43:35] So he tries to steer a course between the two of them.
[43:39] He has his own kind of formation of belief, but when he died and
[43:44] his son Edward comes to the throne as a nine year old,
[43:48] Edward's uncle, his mother's brother, is really in charge of
[43:56] setting the course of policy. And immediately what we find is
[44:00] this really iconoclastic regime. And it's a regime that's
[44:06] enforcing Protestantism violently.
[44:09] So there's whitewashing, there's of walls, so there are beautiful
[44:13] medieval murals that get painted over.
[44:16] There are statues smashed, stained glass windows smashed
[44:20] because they're all thought to be idolatrous.
[44:24] And so we see this massive change to the kind of the visual
[44:28] experience of church. Unpick that for me to make it
[44:31] really obvious. What does idolatrous mean?
[44:34] Why is that a bad thing for these guys?
[44:35] So they think that there should be nothing between a believer in
[44:39] God. So it there's been priests.
[44:44] You don't need priests now. You don't need to confess to a
[44:46] priest. You can confess directly to God.
[44:48] They've been Saints that you can pray to and ask them to pray
[44:51] for. You shouldn't be that anymore.
[44:53] You shouldn't be courting, as it were, a St.
[44:56] You shouldn't be paying attention to relics, which are
[45:00] bits of Saints that are leftover like a death finger or cloth
[45:05] that they wore that people have gone to to pray at during
[45:09] pilgrimages. No longer should these things be
[45:12] paid attention. You should be working on your
[45:14] direct relationship with God and that should be created by
[45:18] reading the Bible, by singing Psalms, by something that is
[45:22] unmediated. And so a stained glass window
[45:26] with a picture of a St. a statue of a St. a rude screen, which is
[45:29] this beautiful carved wooden screen in a in a church with
[45:33] statues of Saints in them. All these things are complete, a
[45:36] complete distraction, A diversion from the truth, faith
[45:41] and actually can lead you woefully astray.
[45:44] That's what it's thought. So these things get destroyed.
[45:48] And the fascinating question here is how much people are
[45:52] going along with this, how much people are convinced in the
[45:55] 1550s that that this is the right thing to do.
[46:01] All those people doing the whitewashing, for example, do
[46:03] they do it because they're completely convinced by
[46:05] Protestant belief, or do they do it because they want to earn
[46:08] money for paying, you know, to pay their bills?
[46:12] Well, this is the big question that I want to put to you and
[46:15] it's a horrible one to answer, so apologies, but.
[46:17] OK, bring it on. You often hear this discussion,
[46:21] especially when I speak to Christians, of if something
[46:26] suboptimal happens societally and it's in relation to someone
[46:30] using Christianity as a vessel for imposing ideas on others,
[46:34] Christians will go, yeah, but that's that's not what
[46:36] Christianity is about. That was someone who is
[46:38] politically motivated. How often in history and the
[46:44] periods that you're well versed in, which I'm sure many, not
[46:49] just medieval times, how much of the change made is actually to
[46:55] do with theological claims and genuine belief, and how much is
[47:03] it just political ideology imposed on people for the
[47:09] benefits of one or two or a small handful of individuals?
[47:13] It's one almost impossible question to answer.
[47:15] I think you know that by asking, but because of the evidence and
[47:19] also because we don't, we don't ever know the nature of anyone
[47:22] else's motivations. We hardly know the nature of our
[47:26] own motivations. So I, I suggested that in
[47:30] England, the Reformation is something imposed.
[47:35] And sometimes you can do this. Like, you know, when smoking in
[47:40] restaurants and pubs became illegal, it wasn't the people
[47:45] wanted to stop smoking. It just was imposed on them and
[47:49] then they couldn't do it anymore.
[47:50] And sometimes we can see the imposition of a law.
[47:54] Here's my favorite fact about the imposition of a law.
[47:56] This is complete red herring. But the reason that public
[48:01] hanging stopped in England or Britain is not because people
[48:07] thought it was unsavory and it went out of fashion.
[48:10] It's because railways were invented and so many people
[48:14] flocked to public hangings that it became dangerous.
[48:17] They were so popular that hangings had to be made private
[48:21] anyway, So the so that, but that's the imposition of a law,
[48:26] the hanging public, someone publicly is no longer permitted.
[48:29] And then public attitudes change in response to the law rather
[48:33] than the the attitudes shaping the law.
[48:37] So what I'm suggesting is that quite often we might see in the
[48:41] period of the Reformation change happen in England at least,
[48:44] because a law has been passed. And then attitudes reflect that
[48:49] over time. And it's also generational
[48:52] therefore. So when you get to the end of
[48:55] the 16th century, you've got maybe 70 years.
[49:00] Like no one alive remembers the late medieval Catholic Church.
[49:05] No one has lived in that. They've all lived in the Church
[49:10] of England. They've grown up in it.
[49:12] That is now the water in which they swim.
[49:15] And so actually, you just have to wait, really.
[49:18] Like, change just takes time. It just takes a few generations
[49:22] and then it's embedded. So it's hard to say to what
[49:26] extent it's theological or it's just the temporal.
[49:31] Henry the Eighth dies. We've got the Church of England
[49:34] established. How does that impact the rest of
[49:37] Europe? That's an interesting question.
[49:40] So at the time we have in Europe, I mean, Europe is going
[49:45] through its own upheavals with regards to faith.
[49:48] So I mean, Henry, England is not that important in the story of
[49:54] Europe at this time. It's a fairly puny little
[49:56] country and there are much bigger and more important things
[50:00] happening. So over the succeeding decades,
[50:05] we've got, you know, the wars of religion that will kick off in
[50:09] France from the late 1550s where, you know, 1572, for
[50:15] example, there's the Saint Bartholomews de Massacre, which
[50:17] is a huge massacre of Protestants in Paris, 10,000
[50:23] people executed within a few days.
[50:25] And that's after a decade or so of toleration of Protestants in
[50:28] France. We have kind of similar things
[50:32] going on in the Netherlands about whether Protestants can
[50:37] thrive there or not. We've got the imposition of a
[50:43] kind of new form of Catholicism with the Council of Trent.
[50:46] So there's, there's, there's a lot going on in Europe to do
[50:51] with what one should believe. And the key thing I suppose here
[50:56] is that no one at the time thought that toleration was a
[51:02] good thing. Everybody thought that there was
[51:05] one truth. They just disagreed about what
[51:07] that one truth was. And so whether it's Protestants
[51:10] or Catholics in charge, on the whole they're trying to make
[51:13] other people agree with them or go along with them.
[51:17] And so we see violence, shocking violence against one's neighbors
[51:24] and erstwhile friends happening on the continent.
[51:28] By comparison, what's happening in England is relatively
[51:30] bloodless. Relatively.
[51:32] Yeah, well, there are estimates of between 7 to 17 million
[51:35] people dying in these religious wars.
[51:38] Seems quite the opposite to this idea of grace and loving your
[51:42] neighbor. It does, doesn't it?
[51:44] Rather, I think it's this point at which truth and grace abut.
[51:54] So whether you can, whether you have to reach what is true
[52:02] before you can extend grace, I don't know.
[52:05] But I think that's that's the that's what's happening in the
[52:08] 16th century. It's a massive tussle over what
[52:11] is true. I guess it speaks to something
[52:13] that everyone grapples with today, which is sort of if, if
[52:17] the means justify the ends or if the ends justify the means
[52:21] rather that you're going towards this virtuous, virtuous
[52:25] destination and that's all that matters.
[52:27] It's for the benefit of others. So you can cut a few corners,
[52:30] tell a few lies, and screw a few people over in the process as a
[52:34] necessity. Yes, and there are various ideas
[52:37] about this in the 16th century that facilitate that even more.
[52:40] So for example, as I say, after Edward, we have the backlash of
[52:49] Mary, which is the imposing Roman Catholicism again.
[52:53] And one of her bishops writes a series of sermons which explain
[52:57] that if part of the body is diseased, meaning the body of
[53:02] Christ, the, the, the, the country as a whole, then it is
[53:06] kind to the rest of the body to cut it off, right?
[53:10] You cut off that limb so that the gangrene doesn't grow over
[53:12] the rest of the body, say, right.
[53:15] That limb just might happen in this case to be a person or a
[53:20] set of people, but their death is considered to be something
[53:25] that is good for the people as a whole.
[53:27] So there were these. That's just one example of the
[53:29] kind of justifications that are made for violence in the name of
[53:35] producing truth and also peace. Like at the time in 16th century
[53:40] France during the wars of religion, it is thought that the
[53:46] wrath of God is what is causing this upset, this violence.
[53:53] And so the putting down of the other groups is one way of
[53:57] appeasing God and then producing peace.
[54:00] So that we have to look to some of the ways in which they
[54:04] understand what they're doing as being something that will
[54:09] produce the right outcome. Well, this is one of my problems
[54:12] with Christianity as someone who's agnostic.
[54:15] Then he's come up with a word that's better than agnostic.
[54:18] Someone who's I'm not a cultural Christian.
[54:20] I would say not, not by choice anyway.
[54:22] I'd hate to call myself that, but maybe something along the
[54:25] lines of Christian curious. I think you're a seeker, whether
[54:29] you're seeking Christianity or you're seeking answers.
[54:33] I'm seeking bedrock, I think. And the problem that I have with
[54:36] Christianity is biblical interpretations vary across time
[54:41] greatly. And you see, now you've got this
[54:44] prioritization of truth over grace.
[54:47] And it seems pretty convenient for people that perhaps don't
[54:51] want grace. It's not that they're aware of
[54:53] the importance of grace or that they're aware of the importance
[54:58] of truth over grace. It's perhaps that they just
[55:01] don't want to extend it to others.
[55:03] And this is a big problem because I've asked a few
[55:06] different Christians this and I still haven't really gotten a
[55:09] satisfactory answer of how you can actually know your
[55:13] interpretation of the Bible to be true because it fluctuates
[55:17] always. And I think that's what's so
[55:19] helpful about this period specifically, is seeing how much
[55:22] it can fluctuate and what it can lead to.
[55:26] It seems to me like more of the mapping on of logic after you've
[55:31] already made-up your mind and you've experienced your
[55:34] emotions, rather than a true source of bedrock for me.
[55:40] Yes. You won't get a satisfactory
[55:42] answer to that because you know the answer already, which is you
[55:45] can't know. And I think that idea I
[55:50] mentioned earlier about cognitive dissonance is really
[55:53] helpful. I love this idea.
[55:55] So it's the idea that it's humans don't like to have two
[55:59] ideas in their mind that conflict or so we seek to do
[56:04] anything we can to resolve them. So this explains all sorts of
[56:08] things. It's explains why you will value
[56:10] being a member of a club more if you've had to go through painful
[56:13] initiation rights to be a member of it.
[56:15] Because you can't think, oh, I went through all that pain and
[56:19] it didn't and it wasn't worth it, you have to assume it was
[56:22] worth it. Or why when you come eventually
[56:27] to buying a house, it doesn't matter whether you choose the
[56:30] house that has the small garden or the big garden, because
[56:33] afterwards you will convince yourself you were right.
[56:36] If you choose the house with a small garden, you will say, oh,
[56:37] the big garden would be far too much work.
[56:39] And if you choose the house with the large garden, you'll say,
[56:41] oh, the small garden would be far too tiny for us.
[56:43] You always convince yourself that the decision you've made is
[56:46] right. And I think we see this that
[56:48] work a lot in history, in humans.
[56:51] And so my suggestion would be that that's what's happening
[56:55] quite often with those interpretations you're talking
[56:57] about. But also, I think that when we
[57:00] see in the 16th century people using religion to do what they
[57:06] want to do, which is what you've essentially said, that's because
[57:11] religion is the discourse of the day.
[57:13] Today we use politics. What the problem here,
[57:16] fundamentally that we're wrestling with is the nature of
[57:19] humans. Well, how do you wrestle?
[57:20] With us as a historian. I mean, well, we're, we behave
[57:24] badly towards each other. Man is a wolf, you know, towards
[57:28] his neighbor. That that is, that is who we
[57:31] are. Which of course, fundamentally
[57:33] takes you back to the question of religion.
[57:35] And the circle starts again. What speaks to you personally
[57:39] most from this era? It's a fascinating question
[57:47] because of course I spent my life thinking about this period.
[57:51] And then one doesn't quite know why that is.
[57:54] I mean, I have answers that I would give.
[57:56] I'm going to give you some of my search answers and I'm trying to
[57:58] work out if those are true or not.
[58:00] So I would say that it's the period at which we, you know, we
[58:03] know what people look like. We start to have the kind of
[58:06] amounts of information I mentioned the lack of letters in
[58:08] some cases, but we have chronicles and ambassadorial
[58:11] reports and we, we can kind of get closer to them.
[58:14] Like I would hate to be an Anglo-Saxon historian, for
[58:18] example, where you're really working from utter scraps.
[58:20] You've got this tiny piece of stone and you have to, I mean,
[58:22] it's a lot of deduction. It's very intelligent, but I
[58:25] quite like having a bit more information.
[58:29] I like the fact that the change that happens is so seismic that
[58:33] it's completely revolutionary, that these tumults matter a lot.
[58:41] But I think what speaks to me actually is what speaks to me
[58:44] from this period as from other periods, which is that I'm
[58:47] always interested in trying to understand why people did what
[58:51] they did and how they felt. Because it's a distance of 500
[58:56] years, it's very easy to write them off and to think about them
[59:01] as somehow less human than us, more stupid, less rational.
[59:08] And yet everybody was making decisions that they thought were
[59:11] the most rational, most truthful, most sensible at the
[59:16] time, and they felt things. And we don't necessarily know
[59:19] what they felt because we don't have the evidence of that.
[59:22] But we can feel our way into it, I suppose.
[59:25] I guess I'm interested in, to put it in grandiose terms, kind
[59:30] of trying to resurrect, resurrect the dead, you know, to
[59:34] try and have an emotional encounter with the people who've
[59:37] died from 500 years ago. What are some nice little tips
[59:42] for someone at home who wants to look into history more and
[59:46] perhaps haven't in the past for them to actually humanize
[59:50] people? Because I find this hard.
[59:52] I mean, you see people in black and white even in photographs,
[59:55] and it's instantly just 20 times harder to imagine them actually
[59:58] going about their everyday. So what are some small
[1:00:00] techniques for actually immersing yourself into history
[1:00:03] more? That's an interesting question.
[1:00:06] I think that the stuff of the past helps us do that a bit.
[1:00:11] So if you can have an encounter with things of the past objects,
[1:00:16] clothing, I remember when I tried on 16th century clothing
[1:00:23] for the first time, the early 16th.
[1:00:25] It varies a lot over the period, of course, but and for women,
[1:00:29] all of the weight of everything they're wearing is on the hips.
[1:00:32] And the you know, when you see women in portraits at the time,
[1:00:35] their arms are like this. It's because the stitching on
[1:00:38] the arms means that they literally couldn't put their
[1:00:40] arms out there. And that just that kind of that
[1:00:43] embodying of history. And then I think where possible,
[1:00:50] where you can get at letters or diary entries by the 17th
[1:00:56] century or reports of what people did and try and imagine
[1:01:01] yourself into that space. It's difficult often because
[1:01:04] you're engaging with language that is unfamiliar.
[1:01:08] But like Shakespeare, you know, it's just about drenching
[1:01:12] yourself in it, and then it starts to become clearer and
[1:01:16] start to try and get at how people feel.
[1:01:18] But maybe start with the 17th century, because people do write
[1:01:22] things that are more emotional in a way that we can engage
[1:01:25] with. Rosa, a bit more formal in the
[1:01:27] 16th century. What can we draw from this
[1:01:29] period to actually help us today?
[1:01:34] Well, I think we've started to do some of it in this
[1:01:37] conversation, which is that we've started to point out the
[1:01:43] ways in which a culture is determined by, you know, these
[1:01:51] grand ideas, but also by the small actions of individuals and
[1:01:57] that you can see them from a distance.
[1:02:00] And we can start to think about how can we draw out the culture
[1:02:06] that we live in. I mean, basically, we have to
[1:02:08] historicize ourselves. I think we need to think about
[1:02:11] who, what period we're in and not take for granted everything
[1:02:15] that is around us in terms of not just the technology, but
[1:02:19] also the ideas. Because these are a lot of these
[1:02:24] are things that we have culturally internalized, but
[1:02:28] they doesn't, that doesn't mean that they are the only idea that
[1:02:32] exists. All the best.
[1:02:34] So my sense is that having the perspective of the past allows
[1:02:39] you to do that. And then also, and this is true
[1:02:42] of great literature or, or any kind of study of history, is
[1:02:48] that we have to think about other people being as real as we
[1:02:52] are. So my favorite quote is GM
[1:02:56] Trevelyan, who said the poetry of history lies in the quasi
[1:03:00] miraculous fact that once on this earth, on this familiar
[1:03:03] spot of ground, lived other men and women as actual as we are
[1:03:07] today, thinking their own thoughts, swayed by their own
[1:03:10] passions. But now all gone.
[1:03:12] Gone as we are, so shortly gone, like ghosts of cock crow.
[1:03:16] And this idea that we vanish one generation after another, but
[1:03:22] that we, each of us, have our own thoughts and our own
[1:03:25] passions, and that people, other people, are as real as we are,
[1:03:29] is fundamental to engaging with everybody.
[1:03:34] Whether it's the NPCS that you meet in the street or whether it
[1:03:38] is somebody of a completely different generation or a
[1:03:41] different culture to you, like trying to engage with their
[1:03:44] fundamental reality, I think is is crucial.
[1:03:47] Do you ever feel like your personal faith gets in the way
[1:03:49] of the way you look at history? I think that our personal
[1:03:55] perspectives get in the way of any attempt to look at history.
[1:04:00] And that is equally true whether you're a person of faith or a
[1:04:03] person who is not one of faith. It's also true, you know, coming
[1:04:09] to it as a man or as a woman or it's so absolutely the way, the
[1:04:15] way in which our own blinkers stop us seeing the past clearly
[1:04:21] is at work. And it's something we're always
[1:04:23] trying to fight against as historians, to try and see the
[1:04:26] past through on its own terms. I feel that that's more
[1:04:30] prevalent than ever. And again, I, I think it's this
[1:04:34] thing of, of mapping on logic to what you already emotionally
[1:04:39] decided. And it's funny actually seeing
[1:04:42] that comparison of truth being prioritized over grace.
[1:04:47] I can't think of a better concept than that to sum up what
[1:04:50] we're going through today. It's, it's always my truth on
[1:04:54] both sides of the political spectrum.
[1:04:57] Actually, not to diverge too much into politics here, but
[1:05:02] people often complain about people on the left and
[1:05:04] progressives having this arbitrary subjectivism of my
[1:05:08] truth. But I I think it's the same for
[1:05:11] everyone right now. It's just that one side takes
[1:05:14] this more secular approach where nothing's true, therefore my
[1:05:19] truth is all that matters, whereas the others say there is
[1:05:24] a truth, it's my truth and it's the objective truth, and that's
[1:05:28] what matters more than anything else.
[1:05:30] I was reading Farah Dubowala's new book or The History of the
[1:05:35] of Free Speech on the way here, and he raises this very
[1:05:41] interesting point, is looking at the kind of the development of
[1:05:44] press liberties over there from the 16th to the 19th, 20th
[1:05:48] centuries. And he talks about the fact that
[1:05:52] in the 18th and into the 19th century, there starts to be this
[1:05:57] sense that press liberty, the freedom of the press, the
[1:06:00] freedom to write or say what you wanted, was more important than
[1:06:05] anything else. And that today we often hold on
[1:06:09] to this idea as well. And yet that means that you're
[1:06:14] prioritizing freedom over truth or equity or kindness or or
[1:06:22] manner of other things. And I remember at school my
[1:06:25] history teacher talking to me about the fact that there is
[1:06:28] liberty to do things, liberty to speak freely, for example.
[1:06:33] And there's also liberty from things.
[1:06:36] And so there can never be unlimited liberty to do things
[1:06:43] without that affecting someone else's liberty from things.
[1:06:47] And so there's there is this balance to be struck between
[1:06:53] freedom, truth, equity, kindness, whether that's we're
[1:06:56] talking about speech and the sharing of ideas or actions.
[1:07:02] So I think that once you drive any one of those horses too fast
[1:07:10] then and the others lag behind, that's when things get out of
[1:07:13] kilter. You've spoken a lot about this
[1:07:19] period of time. You've read a lot about it.
[1:07:21] You've written a lot about it. As a Christian now in the UK, do
[1:07:25] you ever long for any attributes of the past and Christianity
[1:07:30] now? It's a minority religion in the
[1:07:32] UK. There must be some things that
[1:07:35] you look at today that are sort of out of line with what you've
[1:07:38] studied and that you wish were different now.
[1:07:42] I mean, I didn't really wish for anything of 16th, 15th or 16th
[1:07:46] century Christianity to be manifested now, except perhaps a
[1:07:51] kind of vigorous engagement with ideas that's interesting.
[1:07:55] But generally speaking, I mean, people often ask me which period
[1:07:59] I would like to live in. And I'm like, very much now,
[1:08:01] please, not just because of penicillin and traffic lights,
[1:08:06] but, you know, I don't wish to return to a murderous age.
[1:08:14] I believe in people being able to arrive at their own
[1:08:20] conclusions about faith. I'm a person of my own century.
[1:08:27] So not really, to be honest, Ellis.
[1:08:29] I think mostly if, if, if anything at all, it would be
[1:08:32] that it would be sensing the seriousness of the questions of
[1:08:42] life. And perhaps they were taking
[1:08:45] some of those questions more seriously in the 16th century.
[1:08:50] Well, I think this is exactly the problem, and it's obvious to
[1:08:53] not want to go back to the 16th century in many ways that are
[1:08:57] quantifiable. But perhaps when we scratch
[1:09:00] below the surface a little bit more and we look at the psyche
[1:09:03] of humans, then maybe in many ways they were more fulfilled.
[1:09:07] Even if they had a threat, a looming threat of being hung,
[1:09:11] drawn and courted if they misspoke or even had bad
[1:09:15] thoughts that they articulated once in the pub.
[1:09:19] I think it's so easy to be complacent nowadays when we are
[1:09:22] so materially prosperous, right? We would want to live now, of
[1:09:27] course we would. But that's why I think we've got
[1:09:31] this unfolding crisis of meaning happening because we've put the
[1:09:35] cart before the horse where we've gone from top down instead
[1:09:40] of bottom up with what's most important.
[1:09:42] We haven't got the foundations anymore.
[1:09:43] We've got all the jazz, we've got all the new iPhones and
[1:09:47] consumer culture. But I think what we really are
[1:09:51] lacking, and I say this as an agnostic slash atheist, is that
[1:09:56] deeper search of bedrock. What's true, and is there
[1:10:01] anything beyond what we're just experiencing and consciously
[1:10:04] aware of now? Yes.
[1:10:07] And I and fundamentally that's that's the question that we all
[1:10:12] must face. I mean, I think that in some
[1:10:16] ways today we are overwhelmed by choice.
[1:10:24] And probably in the 16th century they had far too little choice.
[1:10:28] They didn't have a choice, generally speaking, about what
[1:10:30] they were going to do. Although obviously we have some
[1:10:32] people who rise from the absolute bottom of society to
[1:10:37] become, I don't know, Chancellor of England or a great
[1:10:41] playwright. But the vast majority of people
[1:10:43] are set in their position and have to do what their father
[1:10:46] did. And they they don't have the
[1:10:48] kind of choice we have today to do anything, to be anything, to
[1:10:51] fall in love with anyone. But I think it is perhaps a
[1:11:01] tourism that when your focus is much more on sufficiency, on
[1:11:10] having enough, rather than having everything, you know,
[1:11:15] this is an age in which there's the specter of famine is ever
[1:11:20] present. There's lots of epidemic
[1:11:22] disease. Life is very much considered to
[1:11:29] be short. They they remarry as much as we
[1:11:31] do, but not because of dwarves, but because of death.
[1:11:37] I think that that does focus the mind somewhat on what matters,
[1:11:43] and I think it's absolutely possible to argue that ease does
[1:11:49] not produce quality of thought. That presence of death must
[1:11:56] massively impact a cultural psyche.
[1:12:00] I think so, yes. I mean, I was looking at the
[1:12:04] Ashmolean at some memento Morai people.
[1:12:07] In fact, I've put a picture of a skull on my on my Apple Watch as
[1:12:12] as my own little modern memento Mori to try and because people
[1:12:19] were acknowledging the presence of death in life.
[1:12:23] And I think that that is we see that being picked up by people
[1:12:30] who are writing about finitude today, the fact that we have
[1:12:33] limits and we have to recognise those limits in ourselves. 4000
[1:12:39] Weeks, that fabulous book, for example, talks about that.
[1:12:42] I think there is a sense that recognising mortality also means
[1:12:51] accepting things like ageing. It's accepting that you can't do
[1:12:55] everything that that you don't. You have one life and you have
[1:13:01] to make choices and those choices have implications that
[1:13:05] you then live with. I think the having death on your
[1:13:14] mind in a way that we shy away from would have been absolutely
[1:13:18] terrifying. But it does produce a certain
[1:13:20] focus perhaps. I mean, maybe I'm, it's really
[1:13:24] hard not to step into this sort of fallacy of thinking about the
[1:13:28] past as some sort of golden age. And everybody who has always
[1:13:31] done so, even Cicero, did. So like, you know, we've always
[1:13:35] thought that everything was better before and that's not
[1:13:38] obviously the case. But we can look to parts of the
[1:13:41] past as guidance, I think. My mantra at the moment is
[1:13:46] accept that you're limited by your biology.
[1:13:49] Now you're aware you're able to do anything.
[1:13:52] And it's sort of this, this balance between realizing that
[1:13:55] you're human and realizing that you're not immortal, but from
[1:14:00] there on out, actually being able to do a lot more than
[1:14:02] perhaps you could have done pretending that you are
[1:14:05] immortal. I was in Brazil recently on the
[1:14:08] holiday, and I spoke to a friend there who's a local, and she'd
[1:14:13] been in the favelas. She has loads of friends that
[1:14:15] live in abject poverty, and she'd also seen the nicest side
[1:14:19] of Rio de Janeiro, the beaches, Copacabana.
[1:14:21] And she made this fascinating point I think sums up all of
[1:14:25] this quite nicely. And that's the difference
[1:14:28] between I wish and I could and the poorest of people in the
[1:14:34] favelas. They're never really longing for
[1:14:38] anything beyond seeing the other people have it, alien to them,
[1:14:44] and thinking that's cool. They're wishing for it.
[1:14:48] And the wishing doesn't include believing that you'll ever have
[1:14:52] it. I think that's a distinction I'd
[1:14:55] make. Whereas with our growing middle
[1:14:59] class society who's materially very, very safe and, and you
[1:15:06] know, I think it, it baffles me that nowadays you can get a
[1:15:09] brand new iPhone, like iPhone 12, which is 4 years old now,
[1:15:13] five years old now, but still incredible, like newer than my
[1:15:15] phone for a couple of £100. And you've got access to the
[1:15:18] world through that. Being middle class in the West,
[1:15:23] you can do pretty much whatever you want if you work hard
[1:15:26] enough, I believe. But with that comes the I could
[1:15:31] and the awareness of our prosperity, even if perhaps it's
[1:15:35] not articulated, even if you don't have this active gratitude
[1:15:38] for everything you have, you do see that you have less
[1:15:41] limitations than someone in Brazil in a favela.
[1:15:45] And sometimes with that comes more distress and a
[1:15:48] prioritization of flashy goods rather than what's important.
[1:15:53] And this is the big thing that I saw going to the favelas in
[1:15:57] Brazil, speaking to people, townships in South Africa, even
[1:16:02] though the conditions they endure are horrible, they seem
[1:16:07] to know the right order of where to put things.
[1:16:11] They do have family, they do have communities, and they do
[1:16:15] gather in person sometimes. They don't have any other
[1:16:18] choice. They can't FaceTime.
[1:16:22] I mean, I don't think you're saying this, but I just put it
[1:16:25] explicitly. I think we we need to be careful
[1:16:27] that we're not valorizing poverty, but at the same time, I
[1:16:34] think that we need to distinguish that from the fact
[1:16:38] that we as a society have got confused about what matters.
[1:16:43] And I mean, without wishing to sound completely peremptory,
[1:16:52] because I'm do this exactly myself, but every time I travel
[1:16:55] on a tube, I see everybody on their phone absorbed.
[1:16:58] And we all know when we're on it, we're doing something really
[1:17:00] important like choosing what song we're going to listen to or
[1:17:02] writing an e-mail or whatever it is.
[1:17:03] It's vitally important that we do in that second.
[1:17:07] But then you look down the carriageway and all of everybody
[1:17:11] is there absorbed. And I noticed a little girl on
[1:17:17] the tube as I was coming in and and how everybody else in the
[1:17:24] carriage is looking down their phone.
[1:17:28] And I was sort of determined not to be just so that there was one
[1:17:32] other human face in that carriage that she could find
[1:17:35] that was in looking up and was like looking at the world.
[1:17:40] But I think that we we anaesthetize ourselves.
[1:17:50] I've been experimenting with coming off Instagram.
[1:17:52] I can still post to it through, you know, you've got third
[1:17:55] party, but like not actually being on it so that I have some
[1:18:01] freedom for my mind because I thought I realized I was looking
[1:18:04] at it too much. And and of course, the first day
[1:18:08] or two, an absolute torture because you're in total
[1:18:11] withdrawal mode and you're like, but it's worth doing, I think
[1:18:17] for a month every now and then because it helps you rethink.
[1:18:23] And you know, probably actually, I mean, I'm a real fan of Carl
[1:18:27] Newport and all his work on reducing digital minimalism and
[1:18:31] these things for things. Not because I do it all the
[1:18:33] time, but because I think if we do it every now and then, it
[1:18:36] helps us kind of refresh. I've gone a long tangent from
[1:18:40] where you started, but the what I think is that we do have a
[1:18:44] sickness in our society today. And it's a sickness where we are
[1:18:51] absorbed in ourselves and we walk alongside ourselves.
[1:18:55] We're constantly introspective. We're constantly focused on the
[1:18:59] self and, and our little friends and some devices in our pockets
[1:19:04] help us do that and they help us not look up and see the world.
[1:19:08] And I don't know whether that is more easily done if you have
[1:19:12] less. I suspect it might be.
[1:19:15] But I think the problem that we need to confront is, is where we
[1:19:19] are as a society, and that's a separate question.
[1:19:22] So do you think individualism is one of the biggest problems we
[1:19:26] face today? Not maybe individualism,
[1:19:29] certainly selfishness. Flesh out the difference.
[1:19:33] Well, you could make a case that the individualism is about
[1:19:43] celebrating the individual and understanding their recognising
[1:19:48] their rights. You can there certainly could be
[1:19:51] positives about what it is to celebrate each individual and
[1:19:56] treat them with equity, for example, whereas self absorption
[1:20:00] or selfishness, which is the outworking of self absorption
[1:20:05] are sort of more fundamental. It feels because really in the
[1:20:09] end, there's no benefit to anyone else from, from that.
[1:20:12] I don't think, I mean I, I think that I'm not suggesting that we
[1:20:17] should allow concepts of duty to, to mean that we don't listen
[1:20:24] to who we are like I, but I think that the I, I see, I see
[1:20:31] the fact that we have this kind of sense of putting ourselves at
[1:20:34] the heart of everything as something that's problematic.
[1:20:38] We're never going to I'm, I'm not suggesting that we can ever
[1:20:40] stop it completely. But I think if we can situate
[1:20:43] ourselves in the world, in communities, in understanding
[1:20:47] that other people as real as we are, then that is the beginning
[1:20:52] of a difference. Well, I wonder if it's the
[1:20:54] modern day equivalent of what was going on in the Reformation
[1:20:58] where actually we have some form of individualism, at least from
[1:21:02] being selfish. It's the justification after you
[1:21:05] turn it political after and you celebrate it because it's this
[1:21:10] retreat to the inner citadel and sort of just rationalizing
[1:21:14] everything after the fact and making yourself feel better
[1:21:17] about it. I think one of the things with
[1:21:20] Instagram, I mean, I did this too actually.
[1:21:21] I had it just on browser so I can check my messages every now
[1:21:24] and then, but when I'm out and about, I'm completely detached
[1:21:27] from everything else online. The problem is that everything
[1:21:31] does feel so important always, and it's so difficult to
[1:21:36] overcome. I mean, I've thought about this
[1:21:38] a lot and I've really analyzed my own behaviour when I am doom
[1:21:41] scrolling on Instagram and that's probably the biggest
[1:21:44] thing is the sense of importance.
[1:21:47] Yet if you ask yourself, can I remember the last three
[1:21:49] Instagram reels I watched, the answer's always no.
[1:21:52] Can I remember what life changing fact I learnt or even
[1:21:57] important message I sent on DMS? Because usually the more
[1:21:59] substantial conversation happens somewhere else away from social
[1:22:02] media. Because there's this certain
[1:22:04] vibe that comes with being on Instagram rather than on
[1:22:07] WhatsApp. So I think an important framing
[1:22:11] is just asking yourself, is someone going to die if I don't
[1:22:14] go on Instagram for two days? Am I going to miss something
[1:22:17] that's important in my life? And you'll 99% of the time find
[1:22:21] that the answer is no. But but a lot of the reason we
[1:22:23] are on these things is exactly that fear of missing out.
[1:22:27] So that that's a fundamental fear that drives people to get
[1:22:32] onto social media. I think missing out on something
[1:22:34] important because it's, you know that it's like playing the slot
[1:22:38] machines. They say you never know when
[1:22:40] your numbers going to come up. You don't know where something
[1:22:43] important is going to be on there.
[1:22:44] It could be could be something that was life changing.
[1:22:46] You know, it could be an opportunity.
[1:22:48] Back when Twitter was a nice place, the there used to be
[1:22:52] genuine opportunities and connections that came out of it.
[1:22:56] And so there was this sense that you couldn't be off it because
[1:22:59] you might get, you might miss out on something.
[1:23:02] And so I think the fear of missing out is very much a
[1:23:05] driver with regards to social media.
[1:23:08] And also because it substitutes that scroll for proper
[1:23:15] connection. So you, you cannot notice your
[1:23:19] own loneliness or you cannot notice that you haven't
[1:23:22] connected with a friends that mean something to you because
[1:23:29] that fills the gaps. It's the noise.
[1:23:33] You know, they say that it's really important for children to
[1:23:35] be bored because it fuels their creativity.
[1:23:38] Was obviously true for adults as well, right?
[1:23:40] We need to allow time for our brains to work between things,
[1:23:43] but we don't anymore and we fill it up with noise and therefore
[1:23:46] we don't, we don't reflect so much.
[1:23:50] What do you find yourself most shocked by looking at what Gen.
[1:23:53] Z are growing up with nowadays? As a historian, looking through
[1:23:57] a historical lens and comparing to the past, is there anything
[1:24:01] that's majorly different that we're experiencing now, or is it
[1:24:04] all overhyped? We're caught up in the moment.
[1:24:06] Actually, what we're experiencing is the same as the
[1:24:09] rest of time, just with new technology.
[1:24:16] I think our conversation suggests that it is the new
[1:24:19] technology that is the new thing.
[1:24:22] I mean, I think people have always lamented new technology.
[1:24:24] That's also worth bearing in mind.
[1:24:27] But the technology is reshaping our brains, and it's reshaping
[1:24:33] our modes of engagement and communication and therefore
[1:24:39] relationship and our sense of ourselves and the world and how
[1:24:43] important we are. So that seems to me
[1:24:47] fundamentally the challenge because, you know, we've talked
[1:24:53] about compassion fatigue, for example, because if you can see,
[1:24:59] I don't know, someone simply dressed, someone making an
[1:25:04] interesting point about the Roman Empire and someone saying,
[1:25:09] please give money to these children who are starving and
[1:25:12] you can scroll past. Don't know why I'm scrolling
[1:25:16] that way because don't go this way.
[1:25:17] Scroll scrolling past each of these with exactly the same
[1:25:23] degree of casualness, then you start to lose part of yourself,
[1:25:27] don't you? You start to lose part of who
[1:25:29] you are as a human, I think, because we're no longer engaging
[1:25:34] with the needs of the world. And I understand we can't all
[1:25:39] care about all the needs of all the world and that that's
[1:25:41] impossible. But that's why we have spheres
[1:25:45] in which we can care. The natural spheres around us or
[1:25:48] the people we know or the causes we find out about, the things
[1:25:51] that touch our hearts. And I think if we're distracted
[1:25:55] all the time, which as we are, then we don't listen to our
[1:26:01] hearts. We don't listen to the spirit
[1:26:03] within us saying this is something you should care about,
[1:26:09] or maybe you should give that person a call because you
[1:26:11] haven't spoken to them in ages. Or maybe you should arrange to
[1:26:16] see your aunt. So I feel like we fill up.
[1:26:24] I speak for myself as much as anyone else, so I don't know if
[1:26:27] it's a generational thing as it's certainly a zeitgeist.
[1:26:32] Certainly the cultural moment perhaps, I don't know.
[1:26:36] You tell me, have you ever had a moment in your life where you
[1:26:39] haven't had this distraction? You're trying to to be apart
[1:26:43] from it now, like I, I am old enough that I had time when I
[1:26:48] didn't have a phone, so I had time when to use the e-mail you
[1:26:54] had to go into an Internet cafe. So and I I have I my formative
[1:27:01] years as a teenager were lived without that shape.
[1:27:04] So I can't tell you exactly because we have different
[1:27:08] experiences growing up, but you tell me.
[1:27:10] Well, I think I was on the cusp. So I've certainly grown up
[1:27:14] alongside the iPhone and Internet going crazy.
[1:27:19] But I do remember being a kid, only child, sat at my mum's flat
[1:27:24] playing with Lego on the floor for hours on end because that
[1:27:26] was the only thing, or counting pennies, literally just to keep
[1:27:29] myself occupied. But as soon as I got into
[1:27:33] secondary school, everyone's got an iPhone, everyone's got
[1:27:36] Snapchat, they're always talking.
[1:27:38] And importantly, you don't have this escape from anything else
[1:27:42] because you take it back home with you.
[1:27:43] And it's interesting. I think our all bit of attention
[1:27:47] has completely flipped. So before it was a
[1:27:50] prioritization of things that are close to us in proximity
[1:27:52] physically, because that's all we knew, right?
[1:27:55] And now it's evolved to the point where actually the most
[1:27:58] interesting things are those that are alien to us and
[1:28:01] furthest away. So we do want to look at an
[1:28:03] influencer in their mansion in LA.
[1:28:06] And I don't think an influencer with a mansion in London would
[1:28:10] have the same effect as most people living here, for example,
[1:28:12] because it's it's less alien and foreign and cool and exclusive.
[1:28:16] And I think with that comes a detachment of morality as a
[1:28:20] whole, because when you don't see the direct manifestation of
[1:28:25] how your actions impact the world, you care less.
[1:28:30] And you see this with someone who would hate to have a little
[1:28:35] Chinese child there sewing their shirt for them, slaving away
[1:28:40] hours, illegally paid or not paid at all in the corner of the
[1:28:45] room. But they order something from
[1:28:47] Sheen every week that arrives on the weekend and it's a horrible
[1:28:50] example, but that's genuinely the reality of what we're doing
[1:28:55] nowadays. And there are a million other
[1:28:57] examples. And I'm not putting myself on a
[1:28:59] high horse above anyone else. I do this too, all the time.
[1:29:02] I do things that would impact someone in a way that I would
[1:29:06] never dream of trying to impact someone if they were close to me
[1:29:09] and I actually saw them physically.
[1:29:10] So there's something very unique I think about this time and the
[1:29:15] technology that enables us to have this detachment from
[1:29:17] reality. Yes.
[1:29:20] I mean, I remember when I was travelling in Egypt with my
[1:29:25] brother years and years ago, and we were in the desert and they
[1:29:34] were going to make supper, which was going to be a goat Curry.
[1:29:39] So someone carried out the goat and then killed it and then that
[1:29:44] was what made supper. I was a vegetarian by that point
[1:29:47] already. But the, the, my point is that
[1:29:51] it certainly changes your perspective when you see the
[1:29:54] goat before you have the Curry. And I think that exactly what
[1:30:01] you're saying is that we are able to look away from the
[1:30:06] consequences of actions. This is industrialisation, this
[1:30:08] is capitalism. This is the way in which we have
[1:30:13] the consequences of what we do shielded from us.
[1:30:17] I was thinking that we ought to make some like try and balance
[1:30:20] ourselves a little in terms of argument, though.
[1:30:22] I was thinking more, you know, if, if, if you grew up,
[1:30:28] actually, I think attitudes towards sexuality were very
[1:30:31] different, say in the 16th century, but let's say in a
[1:30:34] period where homosexuality or the practice of it at least was
[1:30:41] illegal. Or it, I mean, this happens
[1:30:43] around the world today, but you know, periods of, of Western
[1:30:46] history where that's been the case.
[1:30:48] It today, if you can find through social media, through
[1:30:54] the Internet, communities of people who look like you have
[1:30:58] the same orientations as you do want the same things that you
[1:31:02] do. That is facilitated by what the
[1:31:06] connections we have today. That's a real life connection, a
[1:31:09] real life perspective and something that is really
[1:31:15] important people's desires that that in the past would not have
[1:31:19] been facilitated by just what's around you, right?
[1:31:22] You couldn't necessarily find people who felt as you did and
[1:31:25] that matters. So there are like the we we have
[1:31:29] to acknowledge the good as well as the bad and finding people
[1:31:34] who can reflect yourself back is is important.
[1:31:41] But I mean, I think that we're, we're, we're we're grappling
[1:31:45] with a big problem here. And and then we let's think
[1:31:50] about how history can help us answer these things like what,
[1:31:54] what have been the things in the past that have been on this sort
[1:31:59] of scale of the significance, this sort of change?
[1:32:02] And we have been thinking about one which is the, the printing
[1:32:06] press suddenly now being able to spread ideas and being able to
[1:32:12] print things that could be bought cheaply as opposed to
[1:32:14] great big books that only rich people could afford.
[1:32:16] And the spread of ideas and the, and what we recognise from that.
[1:32:22] And again, 17th century happens when censorship has reduced for
[1:32:25] a while during the Civil War, for example, is that we see that
[1:32:29] the forces that are unleashed, the ideas that come out, loads
[1:32:33] of them are radical and brilliant and innovative and
[1:32:38] wonderful. But there are lots of ideas that
[1:32:40] come out that can't be can tailed.
[1:32:43] Natalie Haynes says it's Pandora's jar, not Pandora's
[1:32:46] box, but whatever it is, box or jar, when the stopper is taken
[1:32:50] off, then who knows what's going to come out into the world.
[1:32:54] And I think that's where we are now is we're kind of grappling
[1:32:57] with, OK, the, the iPhone took out the stopper.
[1:33:00] What do we? What are all these things that
[1:33:02] are floating around? Yeah, I often lambast social
[1:33:06] media whilst being ever present on it and it's made my career.
[1:33:11] I mean, being able to do videography and travel the world
[1:33:14] at such a young age is something that I'm eternally indebted to
[1:33:18] social media for being able to reach out to people and actually
[1:33:21] run the channels that are on these platforms.
[1:33:24] And I think even just looking at through an educational lens, the
[1:33:26] ability to learn so much, I mean, we're in the information
[1:33:29] age now. It's magical.
[1:33:31] And there's endless good to be taken from that if used
[1:33:34] appropriately. But there's also endless bad.
[1:33:37] So if there's there's one thing I've taken from this
[1:33:40] conversation, it's that we need more Go Curry moments.
[1:33:45] Who would have thought that would have been the the take
[1:33:47] away? No, it's been an amazing chat
[1:33:50] and I really appreciate your time.
[1:33:51] So Susanna Lipscomb, thank you so much for coming on the show.
[1:33:54] Where can people find more of your work?
[1:33:57] Well, social media, of course, my handle on social media is
[1:34:04] 16th C for Century Girl, which is holds me hostage fortune.
[1:34:10] But anyway, that's the that's where they can find me.
[1:34:12] And I have a podcast called Not Just The Tudors where we talk
[1:34:15] about history. So more historical chat there
[1:34:19] and TVI make things for old fashioned TV.
[1:34:23] So the next series that's coming out is on more Four later in
[1:34:27] September, and there will be other things later in the year
[1:34:30] on History Hit.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
