# Pressing JimmyTheGiant on Immigration Lies | #52

An episode of [The Next Generation](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1772698742), 4 Nov 2025, 1 h 42 min.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/107851968/podcast/play/110392168/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2025-9-29%2F410208799-44100-2-0ff04133d56f4.mp3

I sat JimmyTheGiant down to get a better understanding of his immigration stance and evolving worldviews. Having once been down the 'alt right pipeline' as he likes to call it, Jimmy now considers himself firmly on the left.I’ve been watching JimmyTheGiant for years, so I absolutely loved sitting down and talking through his ideas, both ones I agreed and disagreed with! Jimmy produces video essays on culture and current affairs such as 'Why You are Being LIED to About Immigration' and 'The "Islamification" of Britain?'Check out his Channel! https://www.youtube.com/@JimmyTheGiantJimmy on X: https://x.com/jimthegiant Jimmy on Insta: https://www.instagram.com/jimmythegiantuk/ CHAPTERS00:00 Are 40% of sexual assaults committed by foreigners?08:01 Is there misinformation on both political sides?13:24 Is the outrage over immigration just a moral panic?18:00 Are you happy with this level of illegal immigration?22:52 The migrant hotel problem26:46 Are migrants lying about where they’re from?28:42 The crackdown on spouse visas32:18 Are we xenophobic against brown people?39:23 Cringe corporate virtue signalling43:09 Wouldn’t a genuine asylum seeker stay in a safe country like France?47:59 “Some people have to come here because they are unable to apply for asylum in their own country”50:53 How many people should we be letting in?56:43 Are certain values incompatible with British society?1:02:20 Are Christianity and nationalism tools to control people?1:07:02 Elliot and Jimmy’s relationships with Christianity1:11:09 British complaint culture Vs American positivity1:18:50 The trade-offs of capitalism and socialism1:25:09 Should we even have billionaires?1:32:17 Do you have any ideological hangovers from when you were right wing?1:35:22 Smug centrism and the fear of joining a tribe1:41:11 Wrapping upMy Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotbewick/TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliotbewickX: https://x.com/elliotbewickABOUT THE NEXT GENERATION: In a world saturated by social media and marked by skyrocketing rates of anxiety, depression, and ADHD among Gen Z, young people are growing up in a landscape of chaos and contradiction. While protests swell in city streets and activists hurl soup at famous artworks to demand climate action, a quieter crisis unfolds within - the mental and emotional battles faced by a generation trying to make sense of it all.The Next Generation is hosted by 20-year-old Elliot Bewick, offering a raw and honest look at the world through the eyes of those living in it. Bringing together insight from professionals and young people on the ground, this podcast isn’t here to complain or chase clout. It’s here to bend the arc of the modern world towards solutions, truth and a love for the beautiful adventure of life itself.

## Transcript

[0:00] Jimmy the Giant, welcome to the next generation.
[0:02] Hello. Hello.
[0:03] Nice to see you. 40% of London sexual assaults were committed
[0:06] by foreigners and are. Some bloody foreigners, they're
[0:10] always doing it. They're always doing it.
[0:12] Yeah. I mean, I, we, I made a video
[0:14] you're referencing about. Well, I did too.
[0:17] I did like immigration and I did Islam and the Islamization of
[0:21] Britain. And there's a lot of this stuff
[0:24] where I've noticed there's all these statistics that get thrown
[0:26] around and they sound pretty legit.
[0:30] And once they're all layered on top of each other, they can be
[0:32] very believable. They sort of create a story.
[0:35] But then yeah, when you start like punching in on exacts, you
[0:39] start finding they're not as strong as maybe they come
[0:41] across. Well, there's this Afghan
[0:44] denominator here as well saying that Afghans are exponentially
[0:48] higher at risk people of committing these crimes.
[0:51] I can't remember the exact statistic, but you've honed in
[0:55] on that in your recent video and you showed that the stats
[0:58] crumble away pretty fast. And that's that's that have been
[1:01] used by pretty prominent figures in the media and politicians
[1:05] too. That's a whole other conundrum
[1:07] when people aren't just media commentators, but they're
[1:09] actually politicians citing this.
[1:11] So what's actually be going on here?
[1:14] So I don't know if you know that there's these two tick tockers.
[1:17] They're called sneaker and Lewis Aaron, and they basically do
[1:21] these kind of debunks into a lot of stuff.
[1:25] But specifically this one you're referring to is called they're
[1:27] called the Centre for Migration Control.
[1:30] And so this is AI guess you would call it like a think tank
[1:35] that has been bound around the media sort of reform forage.
[1:39] They're kind of like the, I guess the idea like the, the
[1:42] kind of statistical academic presenting force behind these
[1:47] kind of arguments and it gets regurgitated a lot, but then
[1:52] people don't really know who it is or what it is.
[1:54] So this this organization, from the work that these guys have
[1:57] done, I wish, you know, more academics and sort of reporters
[2:00] and journalists would look into it.
[2:01] It seems as though this is one guy.
[2:05] It doesn't seem like there's a team or the team's at least not
[2:07] available. There's very little knowledge of
[2:11] who or where he came from. He kind of just appeared in the
[2:14] media. He appeared on Russia Today of
[2:16] all places. His name is Robert Bates.
[2:20] And yeah, his first ever appearance was I think, 2017
[2:23] Russia Today. And yeah, he made this group
[2:27] called the Centre for Migration Control, and they often come out
[2:30] with these statistics and what it is that he tends to do.
[2:34] What it seems like is you take a small minority population and
[2:38] then you have, you know, say like, I don't know, maybe 20 or
[2:44] 30 crimes that might happen. And then he'll find, he'll look
[2:47] at numbers and he'll find like, what's the lowest population
[2:49] size I can make it a percentage of?
[2:52] So you could estimate. I think it's in Afghan.
[2:54] I think the Afghan population in the UK is expected to be
[2:57] somewhere between like 80 K, somewhere like 120K or
[3:00] something. Didn't he put it down to 12,000?
[3:03] I think in London, so I think he's specifically so he hones it
[3:06] in. That's what they do.
[3:07] They hone it in and they try and get a small, really specific
[3:11] place and then they take a really like on, what's the word,
[3:15] like an unflat. Yeah, this pro.
[3:18] So you'll take the lowest estimate of the population size.
[3:21] And it seemed like if I remember him rightly on that one in
[3:23] particular, he kind of looked like they just made-up that
[3:27] population size. And the more accurate population
[3:29] size is something like 50,000, whereas I think, and I can't
[3:32] remember exactly, I think they use like 10,000 or 12,000.
[3:35] And so yeah, if 20 crimes happen, you divide it by 12,000
[3:39] or however you do the maths versus 50,000, you're going to
[3:42] get a very different portion. And they'll do this a lot.
[3:45] So it will be quite shaky data and they will never account for,
[3:49] you know what all the fucking smart Bros will say is like
[3:52] social economic background. So it's like if you're comparing
[3:56] the entire British population, which is it's people from the
[4:00] age of 0 to 90, a hundred, and then you compare it by a group
[4:06] of people that are more likely to be about 20 to 40.
[4:11] This is the military age men thing that people speak about of
[4:13] the people that are coming over to the country.
[4:15] Yeah, exactly. And you're going to find that is
[4:18] a group of people that would do more crime just on that.
[4:21] If you were to do apples and apples and compare it against,
[4:25] you know, the British white population, whatever the same
[4:27] group, you'll find similar. You would find that if you were
[4:30] to compare the crime rates of 20 to 35 versus the entire British
[4:34] population. Pensioners that can't actually
[4:37] go out and commit any crime. Yeah.
[4:38] And some people will acknowledge this and they'll be like, well,
[4:40] yeah, we get that. But that's why we're saying we
[4:42] shouldn't allow young people to come, you know, we shouldn't
[4:44] allow these men to come or something like that.
[4:46] It's a different argument. There's different arguments
[4:48] against that. But when they present it like
[4:50] Afghans are more likely, they won't say typically they well,
[4:56] Nigel Farage and stuff like that, they might fill in the
[4:58] blank. They'll say it's culture.
[4:59] But a lot of the time the the quote academic people who put
[5:02] these papers out, they don't tend to say that because it's
[5:04] very hard. From what I've read, what I
[5:06] understand, it's very hard academically to find any backing
[5:10] for the idea that culture is the key thing that causes crime rate
[5:14] differences. It's always to do with socio
[5:16] economic factors like if you're born in a poor area, limited
[5:20] access to opportunities, unlimited resources as as well
[5:24] as age, if there's more men, men are more likely to commit crimes
[5:26] at a young age, stuff like that. So when you, when you look into
[5:30] like, yeah, I guess when you break down a lot of these
[5:33] statistics, especially from centre of migration control, you
[5:36] find out that they're, yeah, a little bit bullshit.
[5:38] And also the fact the guy Robert Bates didn't present this, but
[5:42] he's like the senior reform like campaigner.
[5:47] So he is, he works for reform and he is their main campaigner.
[5:52] He doesn't present that. And so it's a little bit shady
[5:54] when you're, you know, trying to pretend that you're an impartial
[5:56] academic when really you're campaigning for a political
[5:59] organization. I saw him in a video, I think
[6:02] some undercover video, of reform bragging or joking about the
[6:05] fact that they've used up twice of their legal budget for
[6:08] campaigning already. Yeah, yeah.
[6:10] And in that exact conversation, this one guy like, sees a
[6:14] fucking police car with some pride flags on it.
[6:17] It's like this degenerate flag of degeneracy.
[6:20] It's like, you know, if that's who he's hanging with, it's a
[6:22] bit different than if it's like serious academics who are really
[6:25] like looking into the data. But it's like you kind of start
[6:28] piercing things together. And the fact that his academic
[6:31] background, no one knows. They don't know where or, you
[6:33] know, they don't know where he went to school.
[6:36] It's like it's very shady. And usually, I mean, that is the
[6:39] problem generally with think tanks in general, a lot, there
[6:42] is a lot of shadiness in these think tanks and they do it a
[6:44] lot. They do it around like the
[6:46] billionaire Exodus and stuff like that.
[6:48] They, they tend to put out these reports that might be
[6:52] politically valuable depending on what your objectives are, but
[6:56] they're not very clear on how they get to these answers and
[6:59] stuff like that. And it only takes other
[7:00] academics, other think tanks to look into it.
[7:03] By which point the newspapers have run with a headline and
[7:06] it's everywhere. It was the same with the
[7:07] Billionaire. Exodus 1 was in impressive
[7:10] because they put out this report saying there was like a
[7:13] millionaire etcetera, saying that yeah, shit loads of people
[7:16] were fleeing the UK because of tax raids or whatever.
[7:19] And it got shared about 10,000 times.
[7:22] And then it took a while for this group called what are they
[7:25] called? It's a psych.
[7:29] I can't remember their name. They're, they're, no, yeah, I
[7:33] can't remember it, but they're basically a think tank more on
[7:35] the left. And they looked into the report.
[7:37] They like, crunched the numbers and they, it turned out this
[7:40] exodus of millionaires was about 0.3% of them, which happened as
[7:45] well in 2015. And no one really gave a shit
[7:47] about it then. But in the political context,
[7:50] you can sell a story around exodus.
[7:53] So yeah, it, that's sort of the, the think tanks.
[7:55] There's a lot of dark money that goes into all these and yeah,
[8:00] you've got to be really careful. How common do you think this
[8:03] problem actually is and do you think is explicitly on the right
[8:06] with things like immigration or does it go to both sides?
[8:09] I mean, doing this podcast now for a year, I've had to crunch
[8:12] the numbers a few times on different poles and especially
[8:15] looking at relationships in my generation and sexless men and
[8:18] all this jazz. Bros ain't fucking.
[8:21] Yeah. But you always see the data and
[8:23] it's different depending on the person that's conducted the
[8:25] survey. And obviously there's going to
[8:27] be variation, but sometimes I see conflicting evidence where
[8:30] you could literally construct different arguments based on
[8:33] these different polls. So how prominent do you actually
[8:36] think this is in politics? And is it a left and right
[8:39] issue? I'm sure there there must be.
[8:41] I obviously I lean to left so I'm more aware when the right
[8:45] there. I'm sure there's been examples
[8:47] of like it's hard to say because I always try and distinguish
[8:50] there's establishment left, which would be like the Labour
[8:52] sort of people and they're funded.
[8:54] They have their own way of looking at the world that is
[8:57] different, say me. And then there's the right and
[9:00] the think tanks there. I would say on the real like
[9:01] socialist left, there isn't a lot of money in that because
[9:04] it's, you know, it's kind of not really a profitable movement.
[9:09] So it's like, I'm sure there's probably been some dodgy signs
[9:13] because, you know, of course there always will be.
[9:15] But I notice it a lot when it comes to immigration and tax.
[9:19] They're big ones. But you're right, like polling
[9:21] and stuff like that. It's this sort of relationship,
[9:24] I guess with the media and holsters and academia where
[9:28] sometimes when you look at things hyper focused, you can
[9:31] create a whole story based on something that's happened in a
[9:34] small window of time. When you zoom out it's very
[9:37] different. Like crime rates is a massive 1.
[9:39] Crime has consistently come down exponentially since the 90's.
[9:43] The 90s crime rate was fucking insane.
[9:46] Like it was mental and it's just come down massively.
[9:49] And what will happen is new crimes will happen and they will
[9:52] spike. But the general story, if we
[9:54] take a sort of look at history is that crime has come down.
[9:56] Like, but what the newspapers will do, they'll go phone theft
[10:00] is up. Phone theft's up, crimes on the
[10:02] rise. Like we've had massive
[10:03] shopliftings up. And so you paint this narrative
[10:06] that crimes on the rise, but it really it's a specific one and
[10:09] they can be specific reasons as to why.
[10:11] So like phone theft has come up, but in the 90's, the 80s, it was
[10:16] radio theft. Some people used to just bash in
[10:18] a window and nick a radio because it was really easy to
[10:20] do. Criminals react to change in the
[10:23] market. There's like a name for this in
[10:24] criminology where I can't remember.
[10:25] It's like market substitution, blah, blah, blah.
[10:28] But basically like the market. You know, criminals are kind of
[10:31] in a sense capitalists like, or at least they're thinking it
[10:35] from a business perspective. And markets will appear come and
[10:38] go as the change of technology. So the car radio was a big
[10:42] problem for a long period of time, and then they just fucking
[10:46] built them into the car and now you've nullified a whole
[10:50] industry. Same for car theft, actually.
[10:52] They got better at installing these things called like
[10:54] demobilizers or immobilizers. And then you just see car theft
[10:57] comes down. And phones, at the moment,
[11:00] they're like a really perfect crime because it's just in your
[11:02] hand and it's expensive. You don't need to break into
[11:05] someone's house. I think home invasions will have
[11:07] come down massively since the 90s and stuff, but these create
[11:11] opportunities. They then make network.
[11:13] So you steal a phone, you give it to someone, he then knows the
[11:16] guy that you ship out and next thing it's in China being sold.
[11:19] Ironically, it gets built in China, stolen from people in
[11:21] London and it's sold back to China that.
[11:24] Reminds me of that South Park episode.
[11:25] Have you seen the cash for gold episode?
[11:28] They create this jewellery and it's all made in India and it's
[11:31] fake and they get pissed off and then they run out of money.
[11:34] So they end up selling this gold and they melt it back down and
[11:37] send it to India to. Get made in town again.
[11:39] It's. This whole cycle, it's amazing.
[11:41] Definitely, yeah, they figured it out.
[11:42] But I say it's kind of interesting.
[11:44] It like, and I wish like some of this stuff.
[11:46] It's it is interesting, but I hate when it gets politicized
[11:49] like that because you're like, there is interesting topics to
[11:51] understand how new emerging markets create new crimes and
[11:56] you have to protect against them.
[11:58] And like, yeah, I mean, phone theft sucks and it's it sucks as
[12:01] a person. It makes you feel unsafe.
[12:02] And that's another thing. It's like things like that, they
[12:05] make you feel unsafe, arguably maybe more unsafe than you
[12:08] actually are. So like, because it's visible, I
[12:11] think there's a thing as well in criminology, I think it's called
[12:13] like shattered window theory or something, broken window theory.
[12:18] And it's like when crime is visible and present, it makes
[12:21] you feel less safe and that actually creates conditions for
[12:23] more crime that occur. But it can sometimes be
[12:26] deceptive if you don't zoom out and understand things.
[12:29] Because if you're if you're seeing phone theft, maybe it's
[12:32] happened to your friend. But in reality, like homicide
[12:35] rates have come massively down since the 2000s.
[12:38] They were insanely high. I think the homicide rate, if
[12:41] I'm not mistaken, around about 2003, I think it was like 3 in
[12:45] 100,000. And now it's come down.
[12:47] This year was the lowest in a long period of time.
[12:49] And it's come down to something like 1.2 in North Europe, even
[12:54] including in places like Copenhagen.
[12:56] I think we have a lower murder rate than places like that.
[12:59] So we actually like, but that isn't the story that gets sold.
[13:02] Like it's. Yeah.
[13:04] And that's the thing. I hate the politics that gets
[13:06] played with this stuff because it's to build a fear and it's
[13:09] not to give you an accurate understanding.
[13:11] And then you sometimes it it handicaps you from actually
[13:15] solving crimes a lot of time because you become a hyper
[13:18] focused on certain things and maybe you don't take like a
[13:20] holistic approach to reducing crime overall.
[13:24] Well. Immigration's certainly the
[13:26] dominant thing at the moment to vote on, and I think I've even
[13:30] seen you quote the data that clearly shows that immigration
[13:32] is the number one thing for voters nowadays.
[13:36] Why is that the case then? Is it just a moral panic?
[13:40] It's not a moral like you're asking a lefty ear.
[13:44] So, you know, like bear that in mind, but like typically, I
[13:47] mean, when you look in history, you just this is, I know people
[13:51] say I'm sort of dismissing the argument, but when you look in
[13:54] history, there is a repetitive story that every time there's
[13:58] massive economic problems, you always blame the migrants.
[14:01] Like in 2015 in what's the film Big Short, you see Big Short, he
[14:07] goes, is it that scene at the end?
[14:09] And he's like, the guy was sort of looking depressed and he
[14:13] goes, what's up? And he goes, well, I know
[14:14] they're going to do what they do all the time.
[14:16] They'll they'll blame the migrants like this is after the
[14:18] financial crisis. They're like, give it a few
[14:20] years. They'll blame the migrants and
[14:22] they'll blame the poor people. That's what they do all the
[14:24] time. And exactly right now we had a
[14:27] financial crisis, 2008, living standards have dropped
[14:29] massively, inequality soar, The cost of everything, it's gone
[14:33] insane. It just feels strange.
[14:35] I know immigration's risen. Arguably immigration will always
[14:38] rise. I know it's there's specific
[14:40] like spikes, etcetera. But like it just feels a bit
[14:43] coincidental that right at the same time, there's this hyper
[14:47] focus on migration just as inequalities gone insane and
[14:51] living standards have dropped and it happened in the 70s,
[14:53] happened in the 30s is a typical trope.
[14:56] And that's just in Britain. Like you look around the world,
[14:58] it's the same thing. And typically it's because you
[15:00] know, people. I, I think it it when your
[15:04] living standards are dropping and you can feel it and you see
[15:08] something's wrong, you're looking for an enemy like you're
[15:11] looking for something to blame rightly, because your, your life
[15:14] is getting shit up. And the migrant can be sometimes
[15:19] quite an easy enemy because there will be like things that
[15:21] are different between you and them.
[15:23] Like they will live slightly differently.
[15:26] And if the media hyper focuses on it, you can kind of just make
[15:28] this narrative that they are the problem because there will be
[15:31] genuine issues like when, when you have migration, especially
[15:34] big waves, there will be cultural frictions like that
[15:36] will happen. But that sort of can get
[15:41] overblown, blown out of proportion.
[15:43] And things like, you know, ultimately at the end of the
[15:45] day, if you bring 100,000 migrants in there, you cannot
[15:48] expect that none of them are going to commit crime.
[15:50] So you can always point to crime.
[15:52] You can always say, look, migrants came in and there's
[15:54] more crime. Sort of like, well, there's
[15:57] they're humans, humans commit crime.
[15:58] It will happen. And it kind of becomes this sort
[16:01] of perfect scapegoat. And I think one of the
[16:04] narratives that gets built, especially now, is if you're in
[16:08] a time where you feel like our country has been taking away
[16:11] stuff from its people, which is true.
[16:14] Like it's hard to get a house on social housing, nearly
[16:17] impossible. Like it's very hard to do that.
[16:19] Your benefits gets caught. You know, also your town has
[16:24] like been gutted, high quality jobs have disappeared.
[16:28] And then you see, that's why the small boats thing is kind of
[16:33] perfect politically, is that there are people that come here
[16:36] and they have to be housed legally and they have to be
[16:39] given some form of food, like just legally.
[16:41] So there is an unfairness in that inherently because you're
[16:44] seeing that, I mean, from a perception, you're seeing that
[16:47] you're you're being not looked after by your country and then
[16:50] you're seeing a foreign entity is being now people.
[16:54] They sort of like embellish the story quite a lot.
[16:57] The migrants are living in pretty shit conditions and if
[17:00] they get food then they get about £9 a week.
[17:03] Like their life isn't great, they're not enjoying that
[17:05] situation. But you know, you can get some
[17:07] guy to go to like a four-star hotel that was converted into a
[17:12] what looks like a Bando like now.
[17:14] But you can create these stories someone gives, I don't know if a
[17:17] charity gives them phones. You take a picture of one of
[17:20] them, now he has an iPhone. You can create these stories
[17:22] that make people feel there's an unfairness, but they're
[17:26] diverting the attention to below them rather than above them.
[17:30] So it's like, I don't know, I have, I have this sort of belief
[17:34] or feeling that sometimes people prefer to feel that they are
[17:38] superior to something because it's easier to punch down than
[17:42] it is to punch up. Like it's very hard to effect
[17:45] change on such a monumental level from the people in power,
[17:49] the billionaires, the people that actually control the
[17:51] country. But, you know, you kind of have
[17:53] a chance at kicking the migrant or you kind of have a chance at
[17:56] kicking the refugee. People won't like that.
[17:58] They'll think I'm being a bit dismissive.
[18:00] Yeah, and I suppose what they would say to Steel Man, their
[18:03] argument is, as a lefty here, you're the one trying to feel
[18:07] superior to other people. And you're doing that by buying
[18:11] into these luxury beliefs and by helping out these illegal
[18:14] migrants and giving them mobile phones and prioritizing energy
[18:17] on them. But I don't know why it has to
[18:19] be one or the other. Well, I guess the question is
[18:21] are you happy with the levels of illegal immigration and people
[18:24] coming over on small boats and where the resource?
[18:26] Is not. I think it's a terrible
[18:28] situation. Like it's awful that we have
[18:31] created this problem. Like it is really quite a
[18:35] manufactured problem like. How so?
[18:38] Well, it's sort of like when we left the EU, from my
[18:41] understanding, we had a returns agreement.
[18:43] So we didn't used to see the boats weren't really a thing.
[18:46] We left the EU and then we created a wall, you know, like
[18:50] bureaucratic migration wall between what they used to come
[18:54] back on lorries or they would overstay visas and stuff like
[18:57] that. So that used to happen.
[19:01] And you, you know, you could say it's probably not a good thing
[19:03] that they snuck in or something like this.
[19:05] But they weren't being like we didn't have to house them in a
[19:08] hotel. We created this sort of our own
[19:12] chaos when we cut that way of them coming in.
[19:15] And then someone was smart and realized, hang on a second.
[19:18] If you come across a boat, you will, they will legally have to
[19:21] look after you. You claim asylum in the past,
[19:24] they probably just snuck into the underground economy.
[19:26] It's not a good thing. It's not something I think
[19:28] should happen, but like there wasn't this obvious problem.
[19:32] Well, I suppose what you're alluding to yourself is that the
[19:34] problem was still there, it just wasn't obvious.
[19:36] And it was a different problem. So back then, like now I think
[19:40] what people dislike, and I think this is fair, is that you're
[19:42] getting typically young men and putting them in a hotel for two
[19:45] years with nothing to do. And that's like not a good
[19:49] thing. Like young lads hanging out with
[19:52] nothing to do. They show like the first year,
[19:54] the crime rates tend to be pretty low.
[19:56] It's the second year where they're like probably start
[19:59] selling drugs, probably start nicking shit.
[20:00] Like not all of them. It just always bear that in
[20:02] mind. This is going to be a fraction
[20:03] of them. But you do see that the crime
[20:06] rates tend to in the second year.
[20:07] And like, you can argue that's bad, but if they just got into
[20:11] work, if we just allowed them to work, if we just accepted the
[20:14] situation, you will see better outcomes for society.
[20:20] But I think we've, we've taken this kind of like and I, you see
[20:23] it historically in Britain all the time, this sort of tough on
[20:26] approach to everything and we shit at it, everyone share it.
[20:29] It's the same with drugs. Same with in America.
[20:32] Instead of being smart about drugs and legalizing and heavily
[20:37] regulating it, which we used to do ironically back in like the
[20:41] Victorian age, we were more progressive with drugs.
[20:43] Back then. You used to have to go to like
[20:44] AGP and you could be like, there was like there were people
[20:48] addicted to opium and stuff. But the GPS, there was about 300
[20:52] addicts in the whole of the UK though.
[20:54] And it was only when we went this war on drugs and there's
[20:56] other factors like supply chains and, but it was only when we
[21:00] went war on drugs that it shot up usually.
[21:02] And I, I don't know if you maybe agree with this.
[21:05] I sort of think there's like like what's that sort of
[21:09] mythology of like the overbearing mother where they
[21:12] like they try, there's a problem or some there's a potential
[21:16] problem. And as a state, instead of like
[21:20] trusting and allowing humans to act and behave and just
[21:23] believing in their humanity, giving them resources and
[21:25] helping them, we have this fear that that freedom will cause
[21:30] them to do something terrible. And then you end up
[21:33] overprotecting them as. You coddle them and you become a
[21:36] nanny state. Yeah, yeah, you overcorrect the
[21:38] other way. Exactly.
[21:39] And it's the same with drugs. So like any, I mean, I don't
[21:43] know if you know about that story of like David Nutt, who
[21:45] was the you know, about this story.
[21:47] Tell me the story I know David Nutt.
[21:48] David Nutt was like the UK drug advisor and he is a scientist
[21:53] and he went look, the data says if we legalize, regulate,
[21:58] decriminalize, don't, don't criminalize the users, we allow
[22:02] them to get the drugs via you know the NHS, you know, other
[22:05] under controlled circumstances. We will see better outcomes, you
[22:11] know, like less death, less black.
[22:12] There will be no black market. You know, it will improve stuff.
[22:14] He said. Like alcohol is the most
[22:16] dangerous drug. We currently could do more to
[22:18] reduce the deaths from alcohol. He was saying like MDMA,
[22:22] cannabis, they're not that dangerous.
[22:23] Like realistically he was fired just for having that opinion.
[22:28] And that was a fact based, scientific based opinion.
[22:31] But it's an opinion that ran against society's morality.
[22:34] And that's where like British culture often goes wrong.
[22:38] I would say is that we don't follow scientific approaches.
[22:41] We often have this feeling of injustice or feeling of like
[22:44] morality. I think it stems way back to
[22:46] like Victorian Protestant work ethic, all this sort of stuff
[22:49] that then sometimes hands handcuffs us from doing the
[22:52] smart thing. So I had to bring it back to the
[22:55] small boat stuff like just realistically, if you were, you
[22:59] know, if there's countries around the world that have
[23:02] conflicts and you set up a, a scheme where they can come apply
[23:06] for asylum with their family and they can come to the UK.
[23:09] And what we do, we try and embed them into communities.
[23:13] We put them in wealthier areas because one of the big fucking
[23:16] problems is we've privatized that entire system.
[23:19] There is a guy, I forget his fucking name, I think he became
[23:22] a billionaire and he is in control of the the housing for
[23:28] asylum seekers. He became a billionaire because
[23:31] he got the contract from the government because we have
[23:33] privatized it. He makes money from housing
[23:36] asylum seekers. So how do you make money from
[23:38] housing asylum seekers? You go, well, I'm not going to
[23:40] house them in Chelsea in a respectable middle class.
[23:43] You know, like, I'm not going to put them in a nice area.
[23:45] I'm going to find the shit hole, the HMO.
[23:47] I'm going to find a derelict community that's already
[23:50] struggling because the house prices are cheap, so I can take
[23:52] more money from it. And so then you make a problem
[23:54] where you've got these towns that are overburdened already
[23:57] because they've just been, I could go on for ages about how
[24:01] they got to that point. They're already struggling.
[24:03] And then you put in people who are needing help, which is
[24:06] asylum seekers. You put them in these
[24:08] communities, there's going to be resentment.
[24:10] And that's completely fucking fair.
[24:11] But if we just took this attitude like.
[24:13] Do you think it is fair just to pick you up on that?
[24:15] Because I mean, these people have come seeking asylum
[24:20] allegedly and it feels like beggars can't be choosers.
[24:25] If you're coming to the UK, you can't expect to be put up in
[24:28] Chelsea in a manner house. This is where I have a very
[24:31] different perspective. Like so I we're, we're operating
[24:35] from this perspective of how things are right now in Britain
[24:37] and the way we do things. And you are right under that, in
[24:40] that morality and that structure.
[24:41] It is unfair. It would be ridiculous to treat
[24:43] them better than people in poor areas hit.
[24:45] But obviously, like my world view is that we should be
[24:48] massively helping poor people hit.
[24:50] So this is where I think the left can sometimes get a bit
[24:53] like cross swords is like when we focus on the illegal
[24:58] immigration, but we're not beating the drum that we want
[25:00] everyone to be having better living standards.
[25:01] We want, we want mass social housing.
[25:03] We want people to, we want to bring investment, big jobs back
[25:06] into poor areas. We want to like build lots of
[25:08] thing to lift everyone up. When we hyper focus on and
[25:13] asylum seekers, it does perhaps come across that we care more
[25:16] about them than the British people, which is, I mean, I, I
[25:18] done a couple, I've done 2 videos on it.
[25:20] But I think like generally people would get the like the
[25:24] impression from my videos that I want to lift everyone up.
[25:26] I want to do all this sort of stuff.
[25:28] But I think the left needs to be strong in its political frame it
[25:36] and like focus where we need to be like, don't let them just
[25:39] talk about asylum seekers because then then you are like,
[25:42] you're buying into that frame. But if you go like asylum
[25:44] seekers of people, people deserve to be treated well.
[25:46] And we want to treat all people well.
[25:48] We think you're absolutely right.
[25:49] These poor towns are being treated badly.
[25:52] Yeah. And we need to lift, lift all
[25:54] the and lift everyone up. But yeah, I completely see the
[25:58] argument, but it's the framework of like I believe we should be
[26:02] doing mass investment into people generally.
[26:04] And I think Keir Starmer's fucked himself here by over
[26:07] indexing on the immigration thing when he is meant to be
[26:10] part of a left wing party and the head of it.
[26:12] I want to prove into this a bit further because this fascinates
[26:15] me. And it's nice to have a
[26:17] conversation with a lefty about this as someone who's a 20 year
[26:20] old sort of politically non binary member.
[26:24] Because a lot of the time it's a conservative activist in that
[26:28] chair who has very strong opinions and they usually have
[26:32] similar talking points or identical talking points.
[26:34] And, and it's tough. Like we've outlined some of the
[26:37] reasons for why that may be the case that the right wing
[26:41] publications want to focus on these stories.
[26:43] It's expedient for them to do so, right?
[26:46] And so I want us to keep on going with this.
[26:49] What do you think to the argument that these refugees
[26:52] can't be genuine refugees if they've travelled through
[26:55] multiple Western countries to get here?
[26:58] Yeah. I mean, it's sort of like, I
[27:02] mean, they are coming from nation.
[27:05] Like it's very hard to fake where you're from.
[27:08] So if you were to go, if you were to claim asylum in America,
[27:12] Russia invades Britain and you would claim asylum in America,
[27:16] do you think that when you go through that asylum process, you
[27:20] could lie to them about, I don't know, let's say you were from
[27:24] Afghanistan, you needed to pretend you're from Britain.
[27:26] It would be quite hard to do that if like I needed to, if an
[27:30] American came to Britain and he was trying to tell me he was
[27:33] from somewhere else, I could probably sniff out, especially
[27:35] if I, the person doing the interview is my whole job is to
[27:40] understand their culture. I'm probably from that nation.
[27:43] I'd probably sniff them out pretty quickly.
[27:45] The, the we, we have a pretty thorough system of like sniffing
[27:50] these people out to work out if they are.
[27:53] And when they do the interviews, there's about, I think it's like
[27:56] a 60% rejection rate, 50% rejection rate in the first
[27:59] interview. The second one, it's like a
[28:02] sorry, Mark got that wrong way around.
[28:03] There's about a 50 or 60% approval rate and then when they
[28:07] come back it's like 70 to 80. So like the by and large
[28:09] majority are genuine refugees. It'd be very hard to fake being
[28:13] from Afghanistan if you're from Syria even because there's just
[28:17] things like accent and like local knowledge.
[28:19] And that's what they will test them on.
[28:22] Obviously like any system, and this is what I would say right
[28:25] when politics tends to do is they focus on when there is, you
[28:31] know, like people cheating the system.
[28:32] There will always be like any system you have, there will be
[28:34] some someone will cheat it, but they in my opinion, would throw
[28:38] the baby out with the bath water and you have to think
[28:41] holistically. So it's like if you make the
[28:45] system so shit to try and fix this smaller percentage that are
[28:50] like cheating it, it does that approach have good outcomes.
[28:54] So for I'll give you a really good example.
[28:55] Like for instance, my wife is Ukrainian, she is a refugee.
[29:01] And since Brexit, we, I personally as a British person
[29:06] have far less rights than I used to have with regards to like
[29:09] migration. So in back then my wife who I
[29:13] met, I'm like AI guess what would you call it like sort of
[29:17] middle class. Now, I guess I travel, I'm
[29:22] international, I'm like remote. I'm like paying good money to
[29:26] the taxman. I'm someone probably my country
[29:29] should want to keep right? People like me.
[29:33] When you travel a lot, you might meet someone abroad like that
[29:37] happens and then you might want to marry them.
[29:39] And in the past, when we were in the EUI would have been able to
[29:44] just by right, my wife can live with me.
[29:47] Just that's like a given. You'd instantly get that right
[29:53] because they now want to go tougher migration, tougher
[29:56] migration, they try and do it where they know they can do it
[29:59] and they targeted spouse visas. So now for my wife, she used to
[30:03] be out to like before Brexit, she would have been out to be
[30:05] here indefinitely. We now have to pay 7 odd grand
[30:08] for us to be here. That has made me and her think,
[30:10] well I'm half Irish, I get my Irish passport, I could move to
[30:14] Spain and she would get indefinite leave there.
[30:17] So by doing that, by having this system, making it 7 grand, in a
[30:20] perfect world, I might live in Britain for half the year, live
[30:23] in in Spain for the rest of the year or something like that.
[30:25] But what the system has created is Eva.
[30:28] Or so I Eva have to get her here, pay the money or I leave
[30:34] because like they make it so when you you have to pay the
[30:36] money and then you have to do like 6 months and stuff like
[30:39] that. So by doing this right, this, if
[30:43] you think about what I'm saying is like when you, you want to be
[30:46] seen as being tough on something, you then create these
[30:49] butterfly effects and things you might not have expected.
[30:52] So like they've potentially lost me as a taxpayer or something
[30:55] like that. And I think that's the thing.
[30:57] Sometimes when you hyper focus on these things, you don't ever
[31:01] on that small percent that are cheating in the system, you
[31:03] might not think what are the downstream effects of going
[31:07] after that? And it's, you know, we left the
[31:10] EU and that's had a very detrimental effect on our
[31:12] economy. So their obsession over
[31:15] immigration has I've seen no benefits of it.
[31:18] It's they've made immigration harder for people that typically
[31:21] want to, you know, they tend to say they want to have like high
[31:23] skilled people. They haven't achieved limit in
[31:26] numbers. Numbers have gone up.
[31:28] So everything's gone backwards from this thing that was over a
[31:31] small marginal issue, like reality of like illegal
[31:35] immigrants, they're like 0.5% of the population.
[31:38] It's a tiny fractional issue. But we have hyper obsessed over
[31:41] trying to fix it. And there's all these negative
[31:43] downstream effects, you know, like we lose 4% of GDP from
[31:46] leaving the EU. We lose all our rights as our
[31:49] generation. If you want to start a business
[31:51] in the UK and you want to sell to Europe, depending on the
[31:54] value of the product, you might get customs charged all these
[31:56] things for what Like to fix this very small issue.
[32:00] And they never, when they had focus on it, they never take
[32:02] this sort of step back and go, OK, this might be a problem, but
[32:06] what are the downstream effects of us going after it?
[32:08] And that's, yeah, I guess where I did.
[32:10] I can't even remember the question.
[32:11] I went on such a tangent. But, well, we're speaking about
[32:13] immigration and. Sort of where your stance falls
[32:15] in it. And I think the majority of the
[32:17] conversation here is about illegal migrants, specifically
[32:20] illegal immigration, rather than the legal, perhaps false
[32:23] dichotomies that we've set up like you've alluded to.
[32:27] I think they played together. Because I think like you can't
[32:29] know what an illegal immigrant is.
[32:31] You don't know is you haven't seen their papers, but you can
[32:33] know what someone who doesn't look like they're you.
[32:36] So you can see maybe some of an accent in someone who's got a
[32:41] different skin colour. And in the minds of people, it
[32:44] can become like these. They get messy, these borders.
[32:47] I know people say, look, it's about illegal immigration, but
[32:51] is it like like does it make people generally a bit more
[32:54] sceptical of foreigners than the other?
[32:56] Is it illegal immigration or is it now Islam?
[32:58] Like you start seeing people a bit more hyper focused on Islam
[33:01] and then it becomes is it Islam or is it brown people?
[33:04] Because you can't know what religion the fucking person is.
[33:06] And it becomes just this sort of a spiralling potential
[33:09] xenophobia. And it it's not everyone.
[33:11] There are people that you know, they, they specifically as
[33:15] illegal migrants. But it builds this narrative of,
[33:19] yeah, I would say xenophobia. And my problem with it is it
[33:22] doesn't, there's no way if you follow this politics of like
[33:26] kick out these group or it doesn't improve anything, like
[33:29] your society doesn't improve. So if you follow this, if Nigel
[33:32] Farage or someone is saying this is the problem, it's migrant.
[33:35] There's this specific, you know, illegal migrants, you kick them
[33:38] out, nothing improves. Who's next?
[33:40] Do they then go and tax the rich or do they go, or maybe it's
[33:43] this group of migrants? So it's like my problem with it
[33:47] is that it's a you're, you've caught, you're like a dog who's
[33:49] caught the wrong scent and you're going after something
[33:52] that can't improve living conditions.
[33:54] And I think that that's where we always worry on the left that
[33:57] it's going to spiral something worse and worse.
[33:58] The target will get bigger and bigger.
[34:00] And yeah, only if you don't improve people's living
[34:03] conditions and material conditions, they're not going to
[34:05] feel good. That same anxiety that they feel
[34:08] in life is still going to be there.
[34:10] And it just takes the right populist politician to come
[34:12] along, poke at that, and then point them to a new enemy
[34:16] because you're not fixing the underlying problem, which is
[34:18] their living standards of shit. I, I think I might be wrong.
[34:21] Maybe these guys, I don't know, maybe they love living in
[34:23] poverty. Maybe they love the
[34:25] industrialized towns. Maybe they love that.
[34:27] But I generally think that's the problem in the UK.
[34:30] And I want to speak about economics.
[34:32] Because it's a big blind spot for me, I've kind of been saving
[34:35] it for some reason to properly go into rather than just fucking
[34:38] getting my teeth. It will change your whole
[34:40] reading about it. Before we get on to that, I
[34:43] think it's important to outline. It'll be interesting to to hear
[34:47] about some examples of this slippery slope of people going
[34:49] from skepticism of illegal migrants to legal ones to
[34:55] Muslims to brown people. What do you mean by that?
[34:59] How do you how does that slip happen and has it happened?
[35:01] I mean, obviously it's happened. Historically, I guess I don't
[35:05] want to be like Nazi Germany, but obviously that's where it
[35:08] did happen. But it it's kind of like, yeah,
[35:12] xenophobia. I mean, I would say yeah, when
[35:15] you think about far right politics, it always adapts to
[35:18] the era it's in. So like, if we're talking really
[35:22] extreme, like fascist kind of views, it's rare you're going to
[35:25] see success if you come out like, hey, look, I believe the
[35:29] white race is superior. I just think, you know, like we
[35:33] should just hang out with the Bros.
[35:34] It should just be white dudes. Like that's not going to win.
[35:37] And these politicians, they, these people that believe that
[35:40] know that. So they adapt the tone into the
[35:45] era that you're in. And I would say it's not
[35:48] necessarily even intentional. There will be like I'd
[35:50] definitely I'd follow some people like these extreme kind
[35:53] of yeah people the minority the. Massive, just like the minority
[35:57] of left wing extremists is very true.
[36:00] But yeah, I notice they exist. But I think it what I would say
[36:03] is like this natural pool of these, of this, that political
[36:09] nature, because again, as I was saying earlier, it's trying to
[36:11] solve a problem. Society sucks, life is shit.
[36:14] Why is it shit? This guy's telling you it's the
[36:17] migrants or this guy's saying it's the illegal migrants, But
[36:19] it's just to me, it feels logical.
[36:21] It's like obviously the next step has to be because it again,
[36:24] it's not going to solve anything.
[36:26] And I think, yeah, you see it in like the 30s, you see it with, I
[36:30] would have to study Hitler maybe a bit better, but I think the
[36:33] target starts changing. So in the beginning, it wasn't
[36:37] they wanted to exterminate the Jews or it wasn't overtly.
[36:40] It was like, we need to just move them apart or something
[36:42] like that. And eventually you get there
[36:43] because again, you're not solving the problem.
[36:46] These things just tend to Orient to the most extreme point.
[36:50] If that's where you're, if all of your leadership in society is
[36:53] affirming this view that that is the problem, then it's just
[36:56] going to naturally go there. And I'd say, yeah, you see it
[36:58] like that. I think the National Front as
[37:02] well. Like if you kind of look at the
[37:03] 70s, that kind of. Did you ever watch This is
[37:08] England? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[37:09] And it was like in the beginning, they weren't, they
[37:11] didn't. They had their, I think his name
[37:12] was Milky Black Guy. I can't remember.
[37:15] Yeah, I can't. Remember it too well but.
[37:17] I should rewatch that. It's a good film.
[37:19] It's a very good film. Yeah.
[37:20] Yeah. It's really interesting.
[37:21] I love watching those kind of like 70s era films.
[37:24] Billy Elliot. It's really fucking good.
[37:26] Yeah. Bit grungy vibe it feels.
[37:29] More real, honestly, Yeah. And they were just so.
[37:31] Good at like capturing the the feeling of the country at the
[37:34] time. A lot of these, I think they
[37:36] were made like a little bit later.
[37:37] So you had that reflection, which is I'll be interested when
[37:39] they make films about now and check it.
[37:41] Oh my God. To be a more sober.
[37:43] Position to make it from yeah, but yeah, so this is England
[37:48] like they have a black mate and he goes from being one of the
[37:51] guys one of the skinheads to he's the enemy.
[37:54] And I think if I'm not mistaken, that was kind of true in the
[37:57] Skinhead era that you would actually have originally it was
[38:02] black skinheads came around because of like Jamaican rude
[38:05] boys and white mods kind of working in London in places like
[38:13] like the East End. They'd be working in like
[38:15] industrial kind of stuff and they worked together and they
[38:17] kind of built this culture. So it's like skinheads is an
[38:19] amalgamation of mods plus Jamaican rude boys and over time
[38:25] in the in the original days they didn't like I think they didn't
[38:29] like Indians. So even the black guys they
[38:30] didn't like the Indians and there was like this kind of like
[38:33] in Group out group. It's quite natural and
[38:34] subcultures anyway to have an in Group out.
[38:36] I'm I'm a free runner. We used to hate people.
[38:38] I was I was doing parkour. We used to hate people who did
[38:41] free running skaters and rollerbladers.
[38:43] They fucking hated each other. There is this kind of natural
[38:45] weird group tendency, especially with young lads.
[38:48] And yeah, so they originally the, the black guys were like
[38:54] part of the skinheads. And it took, you know, some
[38:57] years until eventually the black guys were no longer allowed to
[38:59] be part of the skinheads. And it was like they were like,
[39:01] wait, we thought we were part of, we didn't like the Indians.
[39:04] But over time it changes. And I think, yeah, it's like
[39:06] it's following the wrong scent. That's how I always put it.
[39:11] It's like you're trying to fix society's problems by chasing
[39:14] the wrong solution. And so naturally, you're going
[39:17] to go, well, that didn't work, what do we do next?
[39:19] And so, yeah, I think you do see it historically a few times.
[39:21] Yeah, I feel like it's. An over prioritisation of
[39:24] identity as well. And I, I think the left have
[39:27] fallen prey to that. They've been the kings and
[39:29] Queens and they them's of identity politics for the last
[39:32] decade. And then suddenly they're
[39:34] surprised when people invert it on the right.
[39:37] And I want us to get into other stuff because that's such,
[39:40] that's interesting point. It's just quickly, yeah, I would
[39:43] say like you see a lot of, I think where a lot of that came
[39:47] from was it was when corporations got involved,
[39:50] right. Or if you think of all the
[39:51] annoying, really woke shit, it was like Pepsi trying to fix
[39:56] Black Lives Matter. My hand, my fucking Pepsi.
[39:59] Who was it, Kylie Jenner or someone?
[40:01] Yeah, yeah, yeah. And you're like, OK, that's
[40:02] pretty lame. And then every fucking advert is
[40:06] trying to sort of like impose this progressive identity based
[40:10] politics. And yeah, if you're like a
[40:13] normal I, obviously I was on the right for a good period of time
[40:15] and I was like. It annoys you because it's so
[40:18] clearly hypocritical and it's so clearly like out of touch and it
[40:24] just feels cringe. And it's because it's a fucking
[40:27] market. Then they're trying to sell your
[40:28] product and they're reading the room.
[40:30] They're like, look, we're really fucking wealthy and you could
[40:33] critique Coca-Cola in a million different ways or Pepsi in a
[40:35] million different ways. We pay our people shit.
[40:37] We want to look good. So what are the kids talking
[40:39] about? Our Black Lives Matter, We'll
[40:41] jump on that. And then it feels so inherently
[40:43] out of touch and what's being presented.
[40:45] I would say this is sort of the mainstream liberal
[40:49] interpretation where they they realise they're no longer
[40:52] talking about economics. I don't know if you remember
[40:56] like Occupy Wall Street and all this stuff.
[40:57] No, that was before my time. OK, so.
[40:59] Like financial? Crash.
[41:01] Occupy Wall Street grows and it's like this.
[41:03] There's no left and right. It's US against the
[41:05] billionaires. They've just destroyed our
[41:07] entire fucking economy. We want to do something about
[41:10] it. They should be put in jail.
[41:11] Like it was fucking criminal, the shit they did.
[41:14] And so there was this growing movement of Occupy Wall Street,
[41:17] and it was like the 99% versus the 1%.
[41:20] And all of a sudden, right about 2015, all of the corporations
[41:24] sort of gathered around this identity issue because they can
[41:27] be like, look, we sound socially progressive.
[41:29] We don't have to be economically progressive.
[41:31] We can be socially progressive. And then that inherently is
[41:34] hollow because you're upholding the same system that created the
[41:37] fucking financial crash. But you seem like good people or
[41:40] something like this. And so, yeah, it caused a
[41:43] backlash because it's so inherently hypocritical and so
[41:45] out of touch with people and like the Gillette advert where
[41:47] it's like demonizing young lads for like, having a scrap and
[41:50] shit. And so it pisses people off and
[41:52] it's it. I found it fucking annoying.
[41:54] The funny thing as well, we're seeing these.
[41:56] Corporations, they've got Jaguar UK and then they've got Jaguar
[42:01] Middle East and the UK one has an LGBT flag but the Middle East
[42:05] one doesn't for some reason. And I wonder why that is.
[42:08] Disney. Disney like.
[42:10] Cutting out black dudes in the Chinese version and and gay
[42:14] kisses and all that. And it's like, that's the thing.
[42:16] And it was a really genuinely good critique from I guess what
[42:19] was the right at the time where they were like, this is
[42:20] hypocrisy from the corporations, But they try, in my opinion.
[42:24] They started tarring the entire left as this, this is liberals.
[42:28] This is like mainstream businesses, corporations, the
[42:32] liberal politicians that still believe in all the same
[42:35] economics that cause a financial crash.
[42:36] They're jumping on this shit because they can see that the
[42:39] young people are like, you know, they care about this stuff, but
[42:41] it's so inherently out of touch. And it's like if you're someone
[42:45] living in a poor decline in town and you see and you your
[42:49] impression of the left is all this corporate slop, then you're
[42:52] going to be like, yeah, these fucking work idiots.
[42:54] But there were people that whole time talking about taxes and
[42:57] talking about the economy, but they were drowned out by this
[43:00] fucking yeah. This like, identity politics
[43:02] stuff. Not saying none of that stuff
[43:04] matters, but it was just like, it was clearly a diversion
[43:06] tactic. So yeah, I want us to.
[43:09] Clarify a couple of things because my brain just goes into
[43:12] logic closing loop mode and I go crazy if I don't close the
[43:15] loops. Close the loops, Elliot one of.
[43:18] The things that we've. Spoken about with immigration is
[43:21] that these people can't be refugees if they're crossing
[43:23] borders and they're not just staying in France.
[43:26] I feel like we haven't answered the question so.
[43:30] What it is, right, So the way refugees tend to work is they
[43:33] try and go to a nation that they have some chance of building a
[43:36] life with. So to get someone to Britain, if
[43:39] you're from Syria, is like you need your entire family to save
[43:44] all of its money and send someone.
[43:47] You cannot go to an embassy. And then like, so OK, you're
[43:52] trying to save your family, right?
[43:53] You're in a war zone and you want your best chance of doing
[43:56] that. You could go to the neighboring
[43:57] country, which is what most of them do, like 80%, I think,
[44:00] something like that. Go to the neighboring country.
[44:03] The by and large, I think it is around 8% of all of the refugees
[44:06] in the world are in the developing world.
[44:08] But if you are a family that can pull together enough cash and
[44:12] you can pay someone, they call them like smugglers or mules or
[44:15] they is it mules, smugglers, coyotes or something like that?
[44:19] Yeah, give them some money. Some of these guys are criminals
[44:22] and like gangsters. Some of them are just like these
[44:24] fucking crazy, like super hippies who are like, you know,
[44:29] I want to fucking help these people.
[44:31] And so I'm going to risk my whole life just to get them out.
[44:33] They do it basically like on passion, sort of.
[44:34] They're a lot of criminals though.
[44:35] Yeah. Yeah, they are criminals.
[44:36] They're all criminals for sure. For sure, but it's the same as.
[44:39] Like guys who try and sell LSD because they really want to
[44:43] spread LSD because they, you know, if they enlighten jail or
[44:45] something. So it's like some of them are
[44:47] the dark type of criminal where you're thinking of like evil.
[44:50] Some of them are well meaning criminals.
[44:51] Yeah, some of them. Have got, you know, they got a
[44:52] little. Story they tell themselves, they
[44:54] may go OK, but anyway, so most of them goes to the the
[44:58] developing world. But then if you can pull enough
[45:00] cash together, you have like one, one person that you can
[45:04] afford to pay someone to get to Yeah, like the wealthy world
[45:08] because if they can get to the wealthy world, they can bring
[45:10] the family over you you guys are now good because that nation
[45:13] next to you, it also probably isn't that stable like and you
[45:17] know, you want to optimize your chances of your family's safety.
[45:20] So you pull your money together and you pay it.
[45:23] Who you going to send? You're obviously going to send
[45:25] the like young strong lad. You're not going to send fucking
[45:28] granny. So you're going to send like the
[45:30] young lad. He will make this journey.
[45:32] And they will typically aim for countries that have the closest
[45:35] historic tie to where they're from.
[45:37] So say like you're from Afghanistan's a good one.
[45:41] So like we, it's not a good one. It's a rough country right now.
[45:43] But they obviously quite a lot of them served in the military
[45:49] and they would have fought against the Taliban.
[45:51] So their obvious thinking is right, I'm trying to seek
[45:53] asylum. Maybe my best odds to evade the
[45:56] Taliban is to try and get to America or Britain because, you
[45:59] know, I can speak the language, I learnt it.
[46:01] I understand their culture a little bit.
[46:03] They might not want to go to, I don't know, a nation that wasn't
[46:06] in Afghanistan. But let's say they might not see
[46:08] China as like their option or something they did.
[46:10] So they're, they're trying to find their best option.
[46:13] And that's why you'll see it when you look at these nations.
[46:16] France will have different refugees in Spain.
[46:19] Spain will have different refugees in the UK.
[46:21] And when you trace it back, you tend to find colonial ties
[46:24] because typically, like if you're from I, I forget what the
[46:26] place in Africa it's called. It's like the Cote I fucking I
[46:30] know what you mean it I'm going to fuck it.
[46:31] Up even more than yeah, yeah. So it's a place.
[46:34] Google it. But it's, there's a lot of them
[46:38] there. And you'll find that if you
[46:40] actually look into the refugee, the people, it's like you'll see
[46:43] there are different, massively different populations of
[46:45] different types of refugees in different Western countries.
[46:48] And you can tie it right back to colonial tides typically or
[46:51] conflicts that were recent or something.
[46:54] So my point is they will go to this country because they have
[46:57] more chance. They understand the language or
[46:58] maybe just the culture a little bit better and they'll try it
[47:01] and then they'll make pockets there and it becomes a bit
[47:03] easier. Like, you know, I'm sure they're
[47:05] not called Barry, but like, you know, let's say I'm not going to
[47:08] try and make up a Middle Eastern name.
[47:10] I think that'll get me in trouble.
[47:11] But they'll, they'll try and like hang out with a group of
[47:13] similar people to them because it just offers you the best
[47:16] chance of like success. They get to the country, they
[47:19] claim asylum and then they go, right, I can bring my family.
[47:23] So you've pulled your family out of the country and you see this
[47:26] in the numbers. So when the boat crossings come
[47:28] across, it's disproportionately young men.
[47:31] But then when when time give it two years, the family
[47:35] reunification reunification scheme tends to be women and
[47:38] children. So it does even out.
[47:39] This narrative that it's just men is not true, but it evens
[47:42] out over time. So yeah, what they're doing,
[47:45] they're finding nations they have a good chance of.
[47:46] And if they can pull some money together, you would do the same
[47:48] thing. You would try and send someone
[47:49] to the developed Western world where they felt like they had an
[47:52] opportunity. And you know, we can all
[47:55] critique, we can say, well, you should have by law, you should
[47:57] have went here. Technically, by law, they
[47:59] actually do have the right to claim asylum in the UK.
[48:03] So they're not illegal migrants. They are technically, you can
[48:06] say you want to change that law. But like, legally speaking,
[48:09] they're not illegal migrants. They are asylum seekers by
[48:11] definition. What all the small boats people?
[48:14] Yeah, yeah. But why don't?
[48:15] They just apply. Though, because they can't, they
[48:17] have nowhere to. So if you're from Ukraine, you
[48:20] can go to your embassy and you can say I want to get away from
[48:23] this war and they will. It's very easy.
[48:26] You get a sponsor in the UK. So I sponsor my wife and within
[48:31] it was really fucking quick. I was impressed.
[48:32] Like within a week they say OK, and then so now she has a visa,
[48:37] refugee visa. That means that she can take a
[48:40] train, a fucking 16 hour train, wait 10 hours at the border, get
[48:43] to Poland and then fly from Poland.
[48:46] Whereas Baz from Afghanistan, who probably isn't from
[48:50] Afghanistan, but Baz, he can't go to the neighboring country.
[48:54] I don't know Pakistan, who I think they're at war with.
[48:57] So this also sort of explains, you know, some of these nations
[48:59] don't get along, so maybe you don't want to go there.
[49:01] He can't go to the British Embassy of Pakistan and say
[49:04] actually they can in Afghanistan was a bad example and not a
[49:07] country like Syria. Actually.
[49:10] Sorry, I'm confused myself. They can technically, but I
[49:14] don't think they actually have this available pathway like they
[49:16] do for Ukrainians many ways. So let's say Syria, they can't
[49:19] go to the neighboring country and then go to the embassy there
[49:21] and apply to legally commit. They just cannot do it.
[49:25] There's not a British embassy that will accept them.
[49:27] So we've not made a pathway for them to do it legally.
[49:29] And because we're scared, we're like, oh, they will come and
[49:31] abuse the system. That's our attitude.
[49:33] We always think. And so we go, well, let's make
[49:35] it really tough. So what do they do?
[49:36] You get some of them come across, walk all that way and
[49:38] then take a boat. And I would say personally, on a
[49:41] personal level, I think that's inhumane.
[49:43] I think we can deal with it better.
[49:44] We can have better outcomes if we allow them to do it legally
[49:48] through the correct means. You'll find that families will
[49:50] come. Family units are much better at
[49:52] keeping young lads out of crime. Like I think there's ways we can
[49:56] get better outcomes from society if we deal with it like adults
[50:01] in my opinion. But because we put these rules
[50:03] and regulations we end up making all of the worst shit because
[50:06] we're trying to stop them coming.
[50:08] We try and underfund the refugee scheme, so then it takes 2 years
[50:12] for them when they get here to get their finger proved and then
[50:16] you've them in a hotel for two years.
[50:18] There's more likely to have problems.
[50:19] So it's like by us making it so hard or trying to make it hard
[50:23] and it doesn't work because everyone's still unhappy, you
[50:26] end up getting all of the bad outcomes anyway.
[50:28] So it's like if we just took a more humanistic approach and
[50:31] looked at it like a real situation.
[50:34] Yeah, I think you would get better outcomes, I think.
[50:36] Yeah, make those safe routes. And then then we can come out
[50:39] about people on the boats because if they're coming over
[50:40] and they're safe routes, then, you know, those people are
[50:42] cheating it. There's no safe routes unless
[50:44] you're from Hong Kong, Ukraine, Afghanistan to a very limiting
[50:48] degree, but not really like their their system's a bit far.
[50:52] Well, let's tie a ribbon on this.
[50:53] Section, yeah, how many people should we have that we're
[50:56] letting in a year migrating? I don't know.
[50:58] It's really hard to say because. Obviously when conflicts happen,
[51:00] you're going to see spikes. So like for periods of time
[51:03] there's, you know, we had a lot of shit that happened in a short
[51:06] window of time, as I was called, like the 2015 migrant crisis,
[51:09] because there was a few wars that happened in that window.
[51:11] So you will have spikes. The other thing to bear in mind
[51:14] as well, if you treat them more humanly, they will probably
[51:18] return to their country after a period of time.
[51:21] So like if you make it more flexible, they probably don't.
[51:26] They probably want to be at home.
[51:27] Like realistically, if their home was safe, they'd probably
[51:30] want to return. I think that happened with the
[51:31] Syrians. Pardon me.
[51:33] I've got this new tonic. Certainly, Certainly fucking
[51:35] gassy. I think we saw.
[51:37] I think we're seeing it with Syrians or some Syrians are
[51:39] starting to go back. But yeah, like, I know, yeah, I
[51:43] get it. When you say a number, it's
[51:44] like, oh, that's too many. But if you just accept there
[51:47] will be spikes and we make the system as intelligently done as
[51:51] possible, you know, we try and avoid all the worst outcomes.
[51:54] Just have faith in humans that probably they want to go back
[51:56] home. Probably the whole world isn't
[51:58] going to come here. Let's not be so arrogant that we
[52:01] think Britain is this absolute fucking heaven that everyone
[52:04] wants to live in. A lot of people don't want to
[52:05] live here, but some do. And it's like just being kind of
[52:10] realistic that if we make it easier, it doesn't mean that
[52:13] everyone will fucking flood in. I don't think when you look
[52:15] historically, there's evidence of this.
[52:17] Like we used to have a very open migration policy with the
[52:21] Caribbean for a long period of time.
[52:23] It was only after we started restricting it did the numbers
[52:25] go up because we used to have a bang on about this, but we used
[52:29] to have like a flexible, you know, liquid circular migration.
[52:32] So people would live here for a bit, make some money, go back
[52:34] home. And that was kind of the
[52:35] process. When you start limiting and
[52:37] putting in rules, making it really tough, you actually cause
[52:40] the inverse. When most people go, well, I'm
[52:42] going to get kicked out, there's no way me coming back, I'll
[52:44] apply for citizenship. So you create more permanent
[52:47] populations of migrants. So I think, yeah, just sometimes
[52:50] having a more humane approach, you won't see this flood of
[52:53] billions of people come to the country.
[52:55] Well, I want to steal man. Your argument here because
[52:57] people love to whinge in the comments about people not
[53:00] actually giving solutions. And I whinge a little bit too
[53:03] much actually, well, not too much about people not giving
[53:05] solutions, just kind of giving these utopian ideas either on
[53:08] the right or on the left. So help me out, how many people
[53:12] should come annually and where should they be from?
[53:15] It's impossible for me to say I can't.
[53:16] Give you an answer, I'm sorry but I just can't say because it
[53:19] would depend on the year. Like we took 100,000 Ukrainian
[53:24] refugees and I don't think that many people are pissed about
[53:27] that. Like I suppose they'd say it's
[53:30] because of the. Culture being more similar in
[53:33] what specific like. How would you mean by that?
[53:36] Like what would? What specifically is more
[53:38] similar? Well, you look at something
[53:39] like. Jaguar not doing the pride flag
[53:42] in the Middle East on their brands on X the Ukraine is
[53:46] illegal for. That it's illegal for men and
[53:50] like, it's illegal for gay marriage in Ukraine.
[53:52] Really. Yeah.
[53:53] Yeah. Wow.
[53:53] They're getting a little bit better.
[53:54] On it, but it's still technically, well, maybe that's
[53:56] a poor example. But I I think something like
[53:59] actually standing for democracy and a lot of people would
[54:02] undercut that as well when it comes to Ukraine, but generally
[54:05] be being more aligned geopolitically with the West
[54:08] compared to somewhere in the Middle East.
[54:09] I suppose it's sort of this. Analysis that democracy is some
[54:15] individual belief system and maybe it is, but it's as opposed
[54:18] to a state imposed system. So if if you look at Afghanistan
[54:22] and we maybe say like they're not democratic, I don't think
[54:25] the Afghanis have much choice in that.
[54:28] So it's, it's the analysis of whether that's them as people or
[54:31] is it an authoritarian structure that's imposed on these people.
[54:35] Like a lot of people want democracy.
[54:37] Like, I don't know, it's hard to say.
[54:39] Maybe maybe that's not true. It's but it's whether you think
[54:41] this is like an individual human level or is it a state powerful
[54:45] imposition? Yeah, it's, it's AI guess a
[54:49] philosophical question, but I I tend to lean to, I think, I
[54:54] think good of people. I think that under the right
[54:57] circumstance with the right resource, people want to behave
[55:01] well and get along. And obviously they're going to
[55:03] have different opinion. But I, I tend to, you know, have
[55:06] a bit more of like hope, I guess, in people that they would
[55:09] come around to the way it be. And there will be it's, it's I
[55:12] did it in that video, we talk about Muslims.
[55:13] It's like they will have different attitudes on these
[55:15] things, but they tend to over generations assimilate.
[55:18] It might take time and it it can be a bit like, yeah, it can be
[55:22] jarring at first, but that's just how I see it there.
[55:25] Yeah, I struggle with. This one, and I'm outside of the
[55:28] UK now the majority of the year, so I'm kind of out of the loop
[55:31] with the day-to-day on the ground shit.
[55:34] Certainly just looking at first principles here, it makes no
[55:38] sense for me for anyone to condone illegal immigration.
[55:42] I mean by definition you're going against the law.
[55:45] So I would want to see that number drop to zero and well, my
[55:48] system it would drop. To 0 because I'm basically
[55:51] saying that if people come apply for asylum, they can come here.
[55:56] If they do it in the neighboring country, they would be allowed
[55:59] here. So that number would be 0.
[56:01] If people start sneaking across the border, then you have, yeah,
[56:03] you have more rights to refuse their entry because you know, if
[56:06] you've given them the resource and opportunity, they should
[56:09] have done it the right way. You can be more suspicious of
[56:11] people trying to sneak in the criminals, etcetera in that
[56:14] scenario, but we're not really giving that scenario.
[56:16] So yeah, I would agree with you. It would be 0, but zero on a
[56:19] technicality that's you'd be allowing refugees, but it'd be
[56:22] the assumption that they're not illegal migrants that we're
[56:24] allowing a number and I wouldn't have up end number of that.
[56:27] I would have faith that if we manage these systems
[56:29] effectively, there'd be circular migration and people would
[56:33] return if they wanted to return. And if we put resource and
[56:36] effort into doing it, well, I think we'd mitigate a lot of
[56:40] problems. But yeah, yeah.
[56:42] And I I think the point on. Individual humans is so
[56:45] important as well. We forget this all the time.
[56:47] We get caught up in these big systems.
[56:49] And something like I said of it, being a democratic country
[56:53] doesn't necessarily mean that the people do or don't hold that
[56:56] opinion. I mean, I think they're
[56:57] certainly more likely because they're going to be inculcated
[56:59] with those values, but we also we're a bit arbitrary.
[57:01] Of where we we apply that logic because we would happily allow
[57:04] Chinese people to come here. They live under authoritarian
[57:07] regime. We happily allow Americans to
[57:10] come here. Their murder rate is much higher
[57:12] than anywhere in Britain. But we don't go.
[57:14] All Americans are all natural killers.
[57:16] So I guess it's a values thing maybe?
[57:17] Maybe it's something, I mean, as someone who's not religious,
[57:21] maybe it's something more like the religious values that we've
[57:24] sort of had embedded in our culture.
[57:26] I mean, there are loads of books about this and I'm fascinated by
[57:29] things like Glenn Scrivener's The Air We Breathe, which is the
[57:32] idea. And it's based off Tom Holland's
[57:34] Dominion. I don't know if you've heard of
[57:35] this book. I've heard of that book, but.
[57:37] I'm ready. So I'm talking about yesterday.
[57:39] Really. Really.
[57:39] OK, Well, yeah, it's all about how.
[57:41] Judeo-christian values have basically shaped the West.
[57:44] And you and I, Are you religious?
[57:46] Yeah, I am, actually. You are.
[57:47] OK, well, we'll. Get to that later.
[57:48] I'm not yet. My morality is sort of shaped by
[57:52] these judeo-christian values that have, through osmosis,
[57:56] sepped into my conscience because our society was built
[58:00] off of them. And I guess somewhere like
[58:02] Ukraine maybe is a perfect example of this.
[58:04] They are Orthodox Christian. Yeah, their religious attitudes.
[58:09] And values are so removed from us, they're like connected.
[58:12] And this is where, yeah, I get this sort of general opinion,
[58:14] but then I, I find when you actually look closer, you see
[58:18] much more different. Their attitudes are very
[58:21] different around things like sex.
[58:24] Like British people are so bashful around sex and that has
[58:27] massive trickle down effects to behaviours, attitudes,
[58:31] insecurities, all this sort of stuff.
[58:34] Ukrainians are we a lot of people look at Eastern Europe
[58:38] like it's this, I don't know, super religious.
[58:41] It is more religious, but their religion is very different.
[58:44] So like British Christianity W typically like American as well
[58:48] is very like, it's like moralistic.
[58:52] So we believe that there is a way to behave.
[58:57] Our actions, our behaviours is what makes you closer to God.
[59:03] But in like Orthodox, it's more like Catholicism, which is more
[59:07] ritualistic. So they, the preacher doesn't go
[59:10] like, OK, Jesus, he was chilling with the fucking paws and he
[59:14] cured them all and he was sick and it was really nice.
[59:16] And you should heal the sick. Like that's a good thing to do.
[59:19] Like, look after poor people in like, Orthodox Christianity in
[59:25] Ukraine, they sing you these prayers in Old Slavic.
[59:29] You don't understand 90% what they're talking.
[59:31] So their relationship to religion is more of like a
[59:34] communal and a more ritualistic thing.
[59:36] You go through the process, you connect with God on a spiritual
[59:39] feeling. The preacher isn't really
[59:42] telling you what to think and what to do.
[59:44] So it's like, yeah, I find sometimes when you zoom in on
[59:46] these attitudes, these sort of like, yeah, like religious
[59:52] things, they're not quite the binary that we make them.
[59:55] It's the same of like I guess Judaism and Christian, we always
[59:59] say Judeo Christianity. Jewish people think very
[1:00:02] differently to Christians. It's like very differently.
[1:00:04] They don't see like the life of Christ and his behaviour as like
[1:00:07] a model. They are.
[1:00:08] I don't know a lot about Judaism, but I would imagine
[1:00:11] they're much more similar to the when I've watched I've watched
[1:00:14] this thing, it was called Orthodox.
[1:00:15] It was very good show. I don't know if you see, but
[1:00:18] they seem more ritualistic. Like it's a similar thing to the
[1:00:21] sort of. Same of Islam as well.
[1:00:23] Islam comes from this. We always say judeo-christian,
[1:00:25] but they're all Abrahamic I think if I'm not mistaken.
[1:00:27] And that is all a connection. So Islam has a connection to
[1:00:30] Christianity. They they worship Jesus as well
[1:00:33] and they but I don't know. I sometimes I see it as like
[1:00:36] this is really good video I watched.
[1:00:37] It was called like how Islam saved Western civilization.
[1:00:41] It's deliberately titled like that because it really like it
[1:00:44] contradicts a lot of stuff you might think.
[1:00:47] And he was painting this guy called Roy Sinatra or something
[1:00:49] like that. And he was painting this line of
[1:00:52] the dark ages. So Christianity, the dark ages,
[1:00:55] we become really anti science. And in this period of time,
[1:00:58] Islam, the Islamic world, the Muslim world was super pro
[1:01:01] science and they were carried on the tradition that we were
[1:01:04] doing, but we'd stopped it. And it wasn't until certain
[1:01:07] people, I think through the Crusades started to see what
[1:01:10] science was being conducted in the Muslim world.
[1:01:12] And we came back and went, you remember how like science shit
[1:01:15] we were doing. It was kind of tight that we
[1:01:16] should maybe do that again. And it's like, if that didn't
[1:01:19] happen, if that transition of like cultures didn't happen, who
[1:01:23] knows where it would be. So, you know, I think society,
[1:01:26] like civilizations are much more connected than we think they
[1:01:29] are. I think sometimes these, the
[1:01:33] separations are sometimes, I don't know.
[1:01:34] I don't know if I believe them so heavily.
[1:01:36] I know there's differences in the way people think and feel,
[1:01:38] but I I don't think humans are so, so inherently different.
[1:01:42] No, I'm not. Certainly.
[1:01:43] Don't think humans are inherently different.
[1:01:46] And we have all of these artificial boundaries that are
[1:01:48] put up between us. And I had a conversation with
[1:01:51] Charlie Downs earlier about this and about how much we should
[1:01:55] prioritise our ethnicity and if we're English.
[1:01:58] And should it be ideas? Should it be values?
[1:02:00] Like, what is it that we actually band together over?
[1:02:04] And a big thing is these ideas. And, you know, as someone who's
[1:02:08] not religious, I can say that Christianity is an idea.
[1:02:12] And Christians will hate me for that.
[1:02:13] Yeah. And it's like a lot of the time.
[1:02:15] I am doing this really interesting video about drugs.
[1:02:17] And it's interesting how, you know, like Christianity and
[1:02:22] nationalism evolved in the similarish kind of period and
[1:02:26] they were very much mechanisms of control like, and you're
[1:02:29] probably aware of that like Christianity.
[1:02:30] It was like a way of getting people to behave or justify
[1:02:34] treating people in a way that would seem abhorrent based even
[1:02:38] on the materials of the religion.
[1:02:39] So it'd be like what my understanding of it.
[1:02:42] So like industrial era happens and and you take an
[1:02:46] agricultural, it was like 80% agricultural in the 1800s, by
[1:02:50] the end of the 1800s, by 1900s it was 20% agricultural.
[1:02:54] So most people move to cities. So you're taking in 100 years,
[1:02:57] you're taking an entire way of living that's been lived
[1:03:00] agricultural Britain for a very long time, which the people
[1:03:05] argue this obviously like health outcomes.
[1:03:09] They would have died of diseases, plagues, probably a
[1:03:11] lot easier because medicine was shitter.
[1:03:12] But their lifestyle might have been arguably less exploitive
[1:03:16] because they would have worked the field.
[1:03:19] And you can only work the field when you can work the field.
[1:03:23] So it's like you would go wake up in the morning as sunrise
[1:03:26] because the sun would wake you up.
[1:03:27] You go work the field. By the end of the day, you've
[1:03:29] done all the tasks and you go to sleep and there'll be a there'll
[1:03:32] be sections of the year where there's nothing to do because
[1:03:35] you can't do the field. So you've taken this society
[1:03:38] that lived like this for a very long period of time and you've
[1:03:40] urbanized them and you've gone to them.
[1:03:43] Okay, you guys now need to work in factories and you and you
[1:03:48] know time is money, so you need to like work very long periods
[1:03:52] of time. And so you've now taken people
[1:03:55] and put them into a place that and it's going to pay you shit
[1:03:58] and you're going to be living in squalor.
[1:03:59] You'll be living in slums. You used to live in the nature
[1:04:01] and it was kind of chill. And now you're living in fucking
[1:04:04] yeah, industrial Victoria in London and you're living in a
[1:04:06] slum. There's fucking collar
[1:04:08] everywhere is pretty shit. You have to somehow make people
[1:04:12] believe that that is worthwhile doing because at the end of the
[1:04:15] day, them lock can revolt and burn down the factories if they
[1:04:17] want to do that. So you have to somehow control
[1:04:19] them. And it seems as though
[1:04:21] Christianity and also nationalism sort of came around
[1:04:24] in this period of time whereby the, I guess the rulers of
[1:04:27] society needed to justify this, this treatment of people.
[1:04:32] Because if you had the Bible, you'd probably come to the
[1:04:34] conclusion that that isn't the way you should treat people.
[1:04:36] Like, if you listen to Jesus, you'd be like, maybe we should
[1:04:39] look after the sick, the weak, the vulnerable.
[1:04:41] And so they had to do it. And they made this thing, I
[1:04:43] guess it's called like the Protestant work ethic, which
[1:04:45] was, you know, an interpretation of the Bible that would say that
[1:04:48] working hard is, is is it brings you closer to God, which is
[1:04:53] fine. Working hard brings you closer
[1:04:55] to God. And it also said that success is
[1:04:58] given to you. Do not demand anything of God.
[1:05:03] Like it's wrong to demand something of God.
[1:05:04] You deserve nothing. It's his attitude that we are
[1:05:06] like a lowly being and we deserve nothing inherently.
[1:05:10] So that paves the way for yeah, OK, You're saying to the, the
[1:05:15] workers don't expect much. And it also says if you're
[1:05:18] successful, it's because God chose you and you're successful.
[1:05:22] God, you are one of chosen people, blah, blah, blah.
[1:05:24] So you've now basically religiously justified the
[1:05:28] existence of deep inequality. And you've told people don't
[1:05:31] complain, sit down, shut up. Or like as we British people
[1:05:34] say, stiff upper lip or keep calm, carry on these all they
[1:05:39] come from this attitude because we have to justify our treatment
[1:05:42] of the workers in that period of time.
[1:05:44] And then you, you create. OK, so this really sucks, right?
[1:05:48] People don't like this. Even if you tell them it's about
[1:05:50] God and stuff, it sucks. So then you have to tell them
[1:05:53] that it's it's you have to make them feel that they're part of
[1:05:58] the team, right? You can't say you lot are all
[1:06:00] shit. You have to tell them actually
[1:06:02] you are workers building the holy British Empire.
[1:06:06] That is the white light of morality in this chaotic
[1:06:10] barbarian world. The, the British Empire, which
[1:06:15] you are part of is holy. So you create nationalism in
[1:06:19] that period of time because beforehand people were like, I'm
[1:06:21] from London, I'm a Londoner. But now you're, you're creating
[1:06:25] a cultural identity around these things, around a nation.
[1:06:30] It's for God, blah, blah, blah. And then you create the legal
[1:06:32] structures that keep it in place.
[1:06:33] So it's like, OK, the law comes in, you can't do this behaviour,
[1:06:36] you can't do this thing. So you've sort of morally
[1:06:37] justified an immoral action of treating people like shit and
[1:06:41] you've you've rationalized it in your own head because you've got
[1:06:44] to think these there's a priest class, There's also the
[1:06:46] industrialists. These people all have to like
[1:06:49] agree on a structure. And so they've created an
[1:06:51] agreement with this ideology. And then it means, OK, we don't
[1:06:55] have to look after the pool. I don't know how I connect that
[1:06:57] back to what we're talking about, but do you get what I'm
[1:06:59] saying? It's so interesting and like.
[1:07:01] As someone who engages with theological debates all the
[1:07:04] time, I'm very interested in Christianity specifically.
[1:07:08] I do struggle greatly with all these different denominations
[1:07:11] and all these different justifications and
[1:07:13] interpretations of the Bible. And people will say, well, just
[1:07:16] go by what the Scripture actually says.
[1:07:18] Then it's like, OK, how do you interpret that?
[1:07:19] And a lot of the time the arguments fall down to, well,
[1:07:23] the way it was written, it was guided by the Holy Spirit.
[1:07:26] And yeah, I guess I wish you chose.
[1:07:27] Yeah. Yeah.
[1:07:28] It's difficult to square. And you're basically as a
[1:07:31] Christian, we're told. To kind of reject the Old
[1:07:34] Testament, but at the same time pick the bits that we kind of
[1:07:36] like. It's like, I don't get it.
[1:07:38] Like my, This is why when I say I'm a Christian, I'm like, I, I
[1:07:41] think you'd call me like a hippie Christian.
[1:07:42] I just love Jesus and his story. I think he is a icon of great
[1:07:47] behaviour and the way that he treats people.
[1:07:50] He cared for the vulnerable and sick.
[1:07:52] He looked after people in society.
[1:07:54] I think they're great values. And I think he made critiques of
[1:07:57] the powerful people. He made critiques of rich people
[1:08:00] value and money over, you know, other things, community, family,
[1:08:04] taking care of people. So yeah, I, I guess that's my
[1:08:07] own relationship. And I just think the problem is
[1:08:09] you need. To go full send, you're either
[1:08:11] in or out and kind of trying to be a Christian cock.
[1:08:16] It doesn't work. Yeah, well that's what it was.
[1:08:18] If God is true and exists and Jesus walked on water and the
[1:08:22] rest of it, then everything else makes sense.
[1:08:25] And that's kind of ultimately what it always comes down to.
[1:08:27] It's like, this doesn't make sense and it can't be rationally
[1:08:31] justified unless there's a God, then it works.
[1:08:34] And I think that's again why I am skeptical of religion because
[1:08:38] the problem there is, would Jesus have actually condoned
[1:08:41] what the religious groups went on to do?
[1:08:44] Perhaps not. And it all gets very difficult,
[1:08:46] I think, like my root of Christianity.
[1:08:48] Is kind of interesting, right, because I, I was raised in a
[1:08:51] church and I kind of like had this, you know, I really believe
[1:08:53] Jesus walked on all this sort of stuff and then I got sent to a
[1:08:56] fucking Christian School and I became an atheist.
[1:08:59] I'm a natural like contrarian and then then I go through a bit
[1:09:03] later and I'm a bit older I do LSD.
[1:09:05] So then I become a fucking Buddhist or something.
[1:09:10] And so I'm reading all this like hippie shit.
[1:09:12] And then somehow I come back to Christianity in the sense of a
[1:09:15] really like, yeah, Christians won't call me Christian, but
[1:09:17] like in the sense of I believe there is some form of or even if
[1:09:21] there isn't, I even still hold this Jordan Peterson ISM that I
[1:09:26] obviously I don't love Jordan Peterson, but like this
[1:09:28] particular way of seeing Christianity as sort of like it
[1:09:32] doesn't matter if it's true or not.
[1:09:33] It's almost like a moral framework or a way of, yeah,
[1:09:37] it's, it's your relationship to God.
[1:09:39] And so I sort of think like, you know, humans inherently have
[1:09:42] this desire to worship or to give some feeling that their
[1:09:45] life is more important than it is definitely.
[1:09:47] And you see that in a lot of civilizations.
[1:09:50] And I think you find through your culture, through your
[1:09:53] upbringing, you find your connection to God.
[1:09:56] I was raised in near Luton. And so I am going to be, you
[1:10:01] know, following Christianity because it's like, well,
[1:10:03] actually people would probably say I'd follow Islam if you had
[1:10:05] interviewed Tommy Robinson. But if I, you know, I'm probably
[1:10:09] likely to follow Christianity. I don't judge someone from
[1:10:12] somewhere else for following a different thing.
[1:10:14] I think this is kind of where I was like a bit more Buddhist for
[1:10:16] a period of time. It was like, you know, as many
[1:10:18] roots, the top of the mountain. So whatever makes you connect
[1:10:20] with spirituality. I just, I feel culturally and
[1:10:23] historically tied to the story of Jesus, but I can take
[1:10:26] everything from other religions. I can see it and it sounds more
[1:10:29] like you're but high I. Think, I think there is a word
[1:10:31] like that, yeah. Yeah, because if you were.
[1:10:33] A Christian, you'd go, OK, these religions, I get what they're
[1:10:35] getting at, but they're misguided and they're false.
[1:10:37] Yeah, I feel like you can't have your cake and eat.
[1:10:40] You're probably right. I think if you were to be.
[1:10:41] Realistic, but I just like in my head, I think when I pray, I'm
[1:10:45] praying to Jesus and God and it's like, that's the phrase and
[1:10:48] it doesn't mean that I think, yeah, I, I know what you're
[1:10:51] saying and you probably are right.
[1:10:52] I'm probably not like a by the book Christian, but that's my
[1:10:54] relationship to I don't pray to Allah.
[1:10:56] I don't pray to Muhammad. Like so that's how I see it.
[1:10:59] But I also value some of the things about Buddhism like
[1:11:03] meditation. Not that I really do that
[1:11:05] anymore, but I used to, but I can see the value and stuff like
[1:11:08] that. Talk to me more about this
[1:11:09] Protestant. Work ethic because I find it so
[1:11:11] interesting. I've just been in Los Angeles
[1:11:13] for a month. Wanky, unintentional brag and
[1:11:17] coming back. The difference is so stark.
[1:11:21] This cynical crabs in a bucket mentality in the UK, tall poppy
[1:11:26] syndrome, the list goes on. The sayings go on and they're
[1:11:29] there for a reason in my opinion.
[1:11:31] And worst of all I think is this complaint culture that I keep on
[1:11:35] complaining about. Very British there's.
[1:11:38] This whole thing came out. With some fucking wanky phrase
[1:11:41] of like in America a problem is an inconvenience, in the UK it's
[1:11:46] something new to talk about and I came back to work here doing
[1:11:50] some videography jobs in the summer.
[1:11:52] First thing someone said to me that I hadn't met in months.
[1:11:56] It's like weather shit, isn't it?
[1:11:59] Hi to you too, welcome back to the country.
[1:12:02] Because people seem to just bond over hatred and pessimism and
[1:12:07] negativity rather than trying to create shit.
[1:12:10] Whereas before, in the nationalistic Christian empire,
[1:12:15] whatever you want to call, I'm sure those guys were miserable.
[1:12:17] But yeah, at least they were trying to build.
[1:12:20] Stuff, right? I think that's the story we
[1:12:22] would. Say.
[1:12:22] And I think that is so America, like I don't want to give my
[1:12:26] interpretation of the founding of America because I don't know
[1:12:29] it that well, but I seem to understand there was a
[1:12:31] religious, I think they were called the Puritans.
[1:12:33] I think it was like this really, really like, yeah, moralistic
[1:12:39] form of Christianity. And they were, they were saying,
[1:12:42] it's funny, If you listen to the American story of the founding
[1:12:44] of America, it's about religious freedom.
[1:12:46] If you listen to the British story, it's about a load of
[1:12:48] fucking religious fanatics that wouldn't just chill the fuck
[1:12:50] out. And they had to go find their
[1:12:52] own country to set up so they can do their Christian shit.
[1:12:54] So like there's like this sort of, yeah, religious pureness.
[1:12:59] And I don't know, Yeah, what attitudes they, I think they
[1:13:01] probably really valued the work ethic thing.
[1:13:03] I think it was a tension in Britain because we went through.
[1:13:06] It's just like it's hard to really believe it.
[1:13:09] Like when you in industrial Britain, it's pretty hard to
[1:13:13] convince people that if you work hard your life will improve
[1:13:17] because it didn't like these people lived in squalor.
[1:13:20] But when America comes along, and I would have to maybe
[1:13:22] understand it a bit more, there was probably more prosperity,
[1:13:25] especially if you're a white European because you know, it's
[1:13:27] off the backs, like very obviously off the backs of
[1:13:30] slavery. I'm sure white Europeans would
[1:13:32] have lived in pretty shit scenarios, but there was this.
[1:13:36] I don't know how much it would have been off the backs.
[1:13:38] Of slaves either I just had rave.
[1:13:40] Hadel Mancou is a British historian.
[1:13:41] In that chair, he speaks about how like sugar cane exports
[1:13:45] made-up like 1% of the population GDP and that.
[1:13:49] The Slave. Trade the ships were like one in
[1:13:52] 1000 or something crazy. Like much more negligible than
[1:13:56] people might. I think I would understand.
[1:13:58] Probably I'm I'm I don't really know until about it so
[1:14:00] specifically, but I would suspect a lot of the work that
[1:14:03] slaves are doing is the lowest shit stuff that sometimes has
[1:14:07] the most like knock on effect. So I don't know if you send the
[1:14:11] people down into the mines to get the coal, not that I'm
[1:14:13] saying this happened in America. That job might pay at pennies,
[1:14:16] might not be incredibly valuable in like the grand scheme, but it
[1:14:20] empowers other things to happen. So if you're the people who
[1:14:23] create the railway, you could say railway tickets didn't
[1:14:26] create that much money. But the what rail does connects
[1:14:30] entire economy so that they that sometimes this is like skeletal
[1:14:33] stuff for an economy where it's like, although it may not, you
[1:14:37] know, it's it's the same argument.
[1:14:38] People say Britain was built on migrants and then a lot of
[1:14:42] people on the right say it wasn't what the migrants did
[1:14:45] inside the Windrush generation is they came into very
[1:14:46] specifically important jobs. So like there was like for the
[1:14:50] amount of people that were Caribbean in the country in the
[1:14:52] 50s was tiny, but they made-up an insane amount of the NHS.
[1:14:56] And if you think the NHS, it might just sound like a small
[1:14:59] thing. You're ensuring the health of a
[1:15:00] nation of workers that go on to then do work that then gets
[1:15:04] makes profit. So it's like these things, they
[1:15:06] might not sound big in numbers, but in specific what they the
[1:15:10] function of these things, they're indirect.
[1:15:12] And it's like I always think about.
[1:15:15] The, the, the Underground in London, like the underground
[1:15:18] drivers, people were like, you paid a lot of money.
[1:15:19] You paid 70 grand a year and the job's super easy.
[1:15:22] And then you're like, yeah, but if they just didn't do it, if no
[1:15:25] one wanted to do it, London's economy stops.
[1:15:28] And the amount of money that is created from London just ends
[1:15:31] because they didn't do that job. They're skeletal.
[1:15:34] Like it's sort of the irony, I guess of capitalism is that it
[1:15:37] doesn't inherently reward the the things that create real
[1:15:42] value. It's hard to really say like
[1:15:44] what is real value And a lot of these things that are like
[1:15:47] functional tissue and connectiveness doesn't tend to
[1:15:50] get valued that highly. But it without them, your whole
[1:15:52] economy stops. It's this irony.
[1:15:54] I wonder how much of this as well.
[1:15:56] Is to do going back to the cynicism that you see in the UK.
[1:15:59] Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, at that point.
[1:16:01] I wonder how much of it is also to do with our.
[1:16:03] Rigid class structure here, that must feed into cynicism greatly.
[1:16:07] Yeah. So I'll wait to go.
[1:16:08] Back to your point, sorry, I do that sometimes.
[1:16:09] I'll just go off in a time. You made a really good.
[1:16:11] It's part of the magic of. Jimmy the Giant.
[1:16:13] Yeah, yeah, yeah. You made a.
[1:16:14] Really good point about Americans.
[1:16:16] I used to have this very positive attitude of Americans
[1:16:20] and there is a positivity to it because some of them, if you're
[1:16:23] from like a, if you have the ability to go and do stuff, it's
[1:16:26] good to have a good like can do attitude.
[1:16:28] But sometimes they delude themselves.
[1:16:30] Where I met you, there is like this.
[1:16:33] There's like a tragedy of the American life sometimes where
[1:16:36] they really buy into this narrative that you can do it,
[1:16:39] you can go and get it and they beat themselves to death to do
[1:16:43] it. And then they blame themselves
[1:16:44] for failing. And if you think about it, the
[1:16:46] amount we see that win are obviously the sliver of the
[1:16:48] people that tried. There was a story.
[1:16:50] Was it like the death of the salesman?
[1:16:52] Old story, we had to study in English and stuff and it was
[1:16:55] this whole thing of like this, this salesman that had these
[1:16:59] kids, I think they're called Biff and Chip or some shit like
[1:17:01] that, some really American last names.
[1:17:03] And it was like he was so convinced on this attitude that
[1:17:07] go get it, you can do it. And he just destroyed his whole
[1:17:10] life because he followed this and it didn't work out for him.
[1:17:13] So sometimes there is an element that it can be survivorship bias
[1:17:16] when someone has achieved and they have this attitude, you're
[1:17:19] like, yeah, I want a bit of that.
[1:17:21] But I sometimes worry how many people if if, if you don't take
[1:17:25] into account luck and all of the other things, they might have
[1:17:29] been brilliant, but things have to go their way.
[1:17:31] You know, if they got hit by a car randomly, they didn't
[1:17:33] achieve that thing. So like there is an element of
[1:17:35] luck, material privilege, whatever you want to call it
[1:17:39] that goes into it. And then by them sort of saying
[1:17:42] that they did it, they achieved it was all them because they're
[1:17:44] brilliant. And if society builds its if
[1:17:48] society builds it's kind of identity around that attitude,
[1:17:52] what do you tell people that don't make it?
[1:17:53] You didn't deserve it. You're a failure.
[1:17:55] And then I always think that ties very closely to like mental
[1:17:57] health in America. I think it honestly ties closely
[1:18:00] to even fucking, I don't know, school shootings, all this crazy
[1:18:04] shit that happens in America, all of the insane rates of drug
[1:18:06] addiction. I can't help but think there
[1:18:08] might be some connection between telling a whole generation of
[1:18:11] people that you, if you make it, you're brilliant, you're a
[1:18:15] genius. If you didn't make it, it's, I'm
[1:18:17] sorry, mate, unlucky, but you have to try and aspire to this.
[1:18:20] And so I think I, I, I get what you're saying about British
[1:18:22] people. I do think we're sometimes
[1:18:24] miserable. But I would say there is a
[1:18:26] realism to it, our problem, because I like the realism, I
[1:18:28] like it. But our problem is that we never
[1:18:31] do fuck all about it. We don't do anything about it.
[1:18:33] We'll just complain and we never seek unity.
[1:18:36] We rather feel more powerful than someone below us.
[1:18:39] Or we rather, I don't know, just make a good joke, then actually
[1:18:43] organise and do something about trying to fix our shit.
[1:18:47] Because it's harder. It's way harder.
[1:18:49] Yes. This is the eternal.
[1:18:51] Struggle between capitalism and socialism.
[1:18:55] And it's like, what would you rather have?
[1:18:57] Would you rather give people the agency and tell them that it's
[1:19:00] all their fault? Or would you rather give them no
[1:19:04] agency, no freedom, and tell them that they're at the mercy
[1:19:07] in the beck and call of the state?
[1:19:09] By the way, you get trade-offs. I would much rather live in a
[1:19:12] society where it is my fault and I have the agency.
[1:19:15] I think you got to change things some.
[1:19:17] Sort of mid ground between that because like, yeah, you want to
[1:19:20] inspire people to work and do stuff and like you want to
[1:19:23] reward people that go above the pale and do stuff, but at the
[1:19:26] same time you it it shouldn't be.
[1:19:29] I think they always say like people are OK with inequality as
[1:19:32] long as like I'm OK. I can't, I have the bare
[1:19:36] essentials, you know. So like I want a society that
[1:19:39] rewards really innovative people that want to go and work hard,
[1:19:42] make something, do something creative.
[1:19:44] Like I, I want that world, but I don't think we need it at the
[1:19:49] expense of a entire rest of the people.
[1:19:52] I don't think you have to. I don't think it has to be that
[1:19:53] trade off. I think you and we've proved it
[1:19:55] historically in this country from the 50s to the 70s and
[1:19:59] Scandinavian nation show it. You can look after the bottom of
[1:20:02] society, reward the winners and you can have your it's a sort of
[1:20:08] case. You can have your cake and eat
[1:20:09] to an extent, but there's a limit.
[1:20:11] You can't let these people get so wealthy that they then
[1:20:14] control everything and then make life shitter for these people.
[1:20:17] So there has to be like a limit to where you let them grow.
[1:20:20] And some will say that stifles, you know, people's.
[1:20:23] Work, I think, I don't know, you can make that argument, but also
[1:20:27] you have to answer, well, if you just let them grow, what happens
[1:20:30] then? Historically, like it never
[1:20:32] works out very well. So it's like, yeah, I think we
[1:20:34] can exist in a world like I'm very, I always say I'm very pro
[1:20:37] markets, I'm very probusiness. But I don't believe business can
[1:20:41] exist. Like you might have noticed it
[1:20:43] in Britain. It's very hard to get business
[1:20:46] kind of going at this point, like with just the cost of shit.
[1:20:49] Yeah, like, yeah, it's, it's very tough.
[1:20:52] And we exist. If, if your rent prices are
[1:20:54] insane, if your energy bills are insane.
[1:20:57] And I, I post the thing the other day, if you think of a
[1:21:00] coffee shop, like I love coffee, so I love going to these like
[1:21:03] hipster coffee places. And you look through it and you
[1:21:06] see like, you know, there's the barista, there's the people, the
[1:21:08] business owner, the beans person who moves the beans about the
[1:21:12] roaster, all these people, even the cleaners.
[1:21:15] And think about how much value that coffee shop brings.
[1:21:18] Maybe it's your favorite little half hour break from your day of
[1:21:21] work, maybe made friends there. It's like it brings a lot of
[1:21:24] value. The person who makes the most
[1:21:26] profit in that situation is the person who owns the land.
[1:21:29] So it's the land owner. They haven't really done a lot.
[1:21:32] They just own the bricks and mortar.
[1:21:34] And it's the people that did all this action that should be
[1:21:37] rewarded. But because of, you know,
[1:21:39] property price, etcetera, you're making it to the person who does
[1:21:43] the least contribution to society, gets rewarded the most.
[1:21:46] And you make it very hard for these people even to do that
[1:21:49] thing. And so like, I want a society
[1:21:50] where you can bring that property prices down, energy
[1:21:53] prices down, and then you can then talk about, yeah, go out
[1:21:57] and make things and do stuff. But that becomes very hard in a
[1:22:00] very unequal society. Basically it's it's kind of, I'm
[1:22:02] going to say a bunch of shit that's.
[1:22:04] Retarded because I know nothing about economics, but I think
[1:22:06] that's fun. We can have our cameras.
[1:22:07] I'm also I am very. Stupid as well, so I feel like
[1:22:10] yeah, but I mean, I'm half Swedish.
[1:22:13] I speak Swedish fluently and I go and visit my family.
[1:22:17] I mean, I used to do it a couple of times a year.
[1:22:18] I haven't, which is bad of me the last couple of years, but I
[1:22:21] went in the summer for the first time in a while and I just found
[1:22:25] myself coming back and I was like, you know, maybe socialism
[1:22:29] is the one and only answer. And what I've seen over there is
[1:22:32] a fucking utopia. Yeah, you have the.
[1:22:34] Scandinavian epiphany where you're like, wait, these guys,
[1:22:37] they're doing business That's not stopped.
[1:22:39] But there isn't fucking homeless people and drug addicts
[1:22:41] everywhere. Stockholm is like the San.
[1:22:43] Francisco of Europe, I think it's got the most Unicorn
[1:22:47] companies coming out of it as a city.
[1:22:49] Maybe it's just per capita, but I think it's overall, well, this
[1:22:52] is one of the other arguments. About like, you know, So this is
[1:22:55] maybe a roundabout way of saying if, if benefits didn't exist in
[1:22:59] this country, right? If if you couldn't not get a job
[1:23:02] and sit on the dole, where do you think half of our major
[1:23:05] music exports would have come from?
[1:23:06] The amount of them that were sitting doing drugs, claiming
[1:23:09] benefits and went on to be The Beatles or went on to be these
[1:23:13] big things. There is a honest thing of
[1:23:16] sometimes giving people money, investment in R&D and not always
[1:23:23] tying it to a direct profit motive.
[1:23:25] So like there was a period, if you think of like NASA, if you
[1:23:28] think of that era of like space race, they didn't go to the
[1:23:32] people to make the spaceship and say, look, you need to here's a
[1:23:36] load of money, but you have to show me there's an ROI and there
[1:23:38] has to be a return. They gave academics money and
[1:23:42] said figure some shit out and like they just trusted in these
[1:23:45] people and yeah, they might have wasted a lot of money on some
[1:23:48] shit, but that experimentation, when you foster the ability for
[1:23:51] people to spend time and experiment, you then create
[1:23:54] innovation. I always say in my career, the
[1:23:56] reason I was able to be a YouTube are I knew lots of
[1:23:59] people are way more talented than me and and could have
[1:24:01] easily have done something in entertainment, but they were
[1:24:03] just from slightly poorer families.
[1:24:05] My parents were able to keep me begrudgingly until about 25.
[1:24:10] So I had a few years and I didn't get a proper job until
[1:24:13] like 25. I was claiming job seekers for a
[1:24:15] while. I was a net drain on the economy
[1:24:19] for a good period of time. But that because, you know, just
[1:24:22] trust in people that they're not shit.
[1:24:23] And if you give them resource, eventually it led me because I
[1:24:26] was always trying to do something.
[1:24:27] I was always trying to do something.
[1:24:28] I was like making parkour clothes, trying to make a brand.
[1:24:32] And then I was like, I'll do street food.
[1:24:34] I set up a market store and we made fucking no money for a long
[1:24:37] period of time. And then finally something
[1:24:39] works. And I think that's the goal.
[1:24:41] And the dream is to just provide some resources to look after
[1:24:45] people at their basic and give them a little bit of breathing
[1:24:48] room. And then you can be creative.
[1:24:51] And I think you see that a lot. That's why middle class people
[1:24:54] tend to be over represented in politics and media because they
[1:24:57] have a little bit of a safety net that allows them to
[1:25:01] experiment and make mistakes. Whereas if you're from a very
[1:25:04] poor community, you don't have that luxury, you know?
[1:25:06] Yeah. And.
[1:25:08] You see right wingers who are pro capitalism and they love it.
[1:25:13] You could ask them what's the ROI on that Christian pastor
[1:25:17] that's working at your church giving out food to the food
[1:25:20] bank. You know, it's obvious that
[1:25:21] there are certain things where the value is just
[1:25:23] unquantifiable. And and I see that in Sweden,
[1:25:26] like that place is as close to having on earth that I've seen.
[1:25:31] And I'm sure I'm missing out loads of the problems, loads of
[1:25:33] the blah, blah, blah. But it's like, what are we
[1:25:36] prioritizing here? Does all human value, to take
[1:25:40] this a bit broader here, come from money and being able to
[1:25:43] earn as much of it as possible? I think that a lot of innovation
[1:25:46] and flourishing comes from being able to be an Elon Musk and pump
[1:25:50] loads of money into this business, these businesses.
[1:25:52] And without knowing anything about economic policy and wealth
[1:25:56] tax and the rest of it, it doesn't make sense to me to let
[1:26:00] people earn unlimited amounts of money and not get taxed heavily
[1:26:04] on it. Once they get past the 20 mil
[1:26:06] mark or 30 mil mark, I think that people should be able to
[1:26:09] enjoy the fruits of their labour.
[1:26:11] Yeah. Yeah.
[1:26:11] But there comes a point when what's the fucking point of
[1:26:15] having $33 million instead of 30?
[1:26:19] Yeah. And actually perhaps, and it'll
[1:26:21] be interesting to see some data on this.
[1:26:22] I don't know if this would be bagged like suspicion,
[1:26:25] suspicious of it, but it it might do is like maybe you
[1:26:29] actually do reach a point where you get more money and you get
[1:26:31] more depressed. That's a fact.
[1:26:33] There, there's, there. Is data on that.
[1:26:34] There's something along the lines of like money does buy you
[1:26:37] happiness. It's true up until about 100K,
[1:26:39] which would have changed now, but there is a point where it's
[1:26:42] like, it's something like this, it's like 100K.
[1:26:45] It's a really interesting chart. It goes like this and then like
[1:26:48] that. And obviously it's probably hard
[1:26:50] to really measure because there's not many people with
[1:26:52] like hundreds of mil, but it does seem to track that when you
[1:26:55] take care of your immediate material needs, which means
[1:26:58] you're not worried about, you know, house price, you're not
[1:27:02] worried about this stuff. Like you're kind of OK, if
[1:27:04] something went really wrong, you'll be all right.
[1:27:06] That does buy happiness. And I noticed this when I
[1:27:08] started to achieve a bit more money, I started to find like
[1:27:10] when I'm not thinking about these, you know, like rent and
[1:27:13] stuff, I did feel like a piece. But then I've noticed as like my
[1:27:16] business has become more, I guess like intense in a way that
[1:27:21] drains on your mental as well because you're stressed more.
[1:27:24] And there is this thing where they start, you go to a point,
[1:27:26] it's material needs to get covered.
[1:27:27] And then you go to a point where you're now juggling lots of
[1:27:29] stress because to organise it and keep all this shit going is
[1:27:33] like a lot and a lot of people rely on you and stuff.
[1:27:35] I don't have like a big team or something, but like the logic
[1:27:38] kind of makes sense. And I I sometimes wonder about
[1:27:42] the pathology of like a billionaire, like what in your
[1:27:45] brain must drive you at that to that level?
[1:27:50] Like I understand being like a multi millionaire, but I think
[1:27:53] there is a point where you're like how what is driving you?
[1:27:56] And that scares me. Like the to find and answer that
[1:28:00] question is really tough. I think OK, like this isn't.
[1:28:03] 100% of billionaires, obviously, because some people are so
[1:28:08] intelligent that they're going to create some beautifully
[1:28:10] useful product that gets them to the point of being a
[1:28:13] billionaire. But the billionaires that
[1:28:15] actually dabble in money and investments, I think there comes
[1:28:20] a point. And again, like, so happy to be
[1:28:21] proven wrong here, but I can imagine that you have to be a
[1:28:24] pretty sick fuck. I get to the point of billion.
[1:28:28] I used to have this thing right where I was.
[1:28:30] Like I couldn't understand when I was more on the right.
[1:28:32] I used to not understand when people on the left would be
[1:28:35] like, billionaires are like, yeah, dark.
[1:28:38] They want to control the world. Because I was always like, that
[1:28:40] sounds like a film. Like, it doesn't sound like
[1:28:42] reality. And I couldn't understand the
[1:28:43] pathology because in a personal level, I don't want to, like,
[1:28:47] own and control everything. I don't have this.
[1:28:48] And then I started to think about it a bit more over time.
[1:28:51] And I think there is a pathology of people.
[1:28:53] If you go through your life and you think about it and you ever
[1:28:55] meet those people who like, I don't know, you shake their hand
[1:28:58] and they shake, They shake it really hard.
[1:28:59] And then like those people that you have a bit of banter and
[1:29:03] they won't let you get the last joke.
[1:29:04] They will never be that guy to like take that last hit.
[1:29:08] And maybe they even get super defensive if you do Bant ram
[1:29:11] like those sort of people and there are people I do you do
[1:29:14] notice it that are like hyper competitive.
[1:29:17] Usually people don't like those people.
[1:29:19] They tend to not probably do that well socially, but that
[1:29:23] type of personality, that ruthless competitiveness is
[1:29:27] financially very rewarding. So if you are like that, if you
[1:29:31] don't care about other people around you, you just want to
[1:29:33] win. You want to be that guy who's
[1:29:35] always on top. You don't give a shit if you do
[1:29:38] some really immoral stuff in your business to make money
[1:29:41] because you don't, you see the end game as winning.
[1:29:43] And I think that's what drives these people that get to such
[1:29:46] far sums. And you are right.
[1:29:47] There will be some that don't live to that.
[1:29:48] I'm sure some just created something market value went in
[1:29:51] saying they're a billionaire. I'm sure that exists.
[1:29:53] But like, when you keep going, you keep going and you get more
[1:29:56] and more competitive and you're like, now I'm buying.
[1:29:59] I I had this company. Now I'm buying ownership of the
[1:30:01] media. I own this media thing.
[1:30:03] I'm changing what they can talk about.
[1:30:05] And like, I own, I don't know, vast sums of housing.
[1:30:08] It's like, what are you doing? Like, I don't know.
[1:30:11] Because I used to struggle to understand like what goes on in
[1:30:13] their brain. And I think I've started to
[1:30:15] understand it through getting older and meeting competitive
[1:30:17] types of people. Yeah.
[1:30:19] And it's like maybe there should be a.
[1:30:20] Limit to your materialistic pleasures, but not your or
[1:30:24] spiritual ones. And you should be encouraged
[1:30:26] once you get to a certain point to have a look at yourself and
[1:30:29] go, OK, would this actually make me more fulfilled?
[1:30:32] Does this contribute to the world?
[1:30:34] And you can still keep on growing your business and it can
[1:30:37] skyrocket in value. But personally, are you going to
[1:30:43] be happier? Yeah.
[1:30:44] And I think a lot of people. Like the Christian right tend to
[1:30:48] actually understand this. They say it.
[1:30:49] They're like money doesn't buy habit.
[1:30:50] You know, as I say, there's there's some truth there.
[1:30:53] Some of it's not true, but they tend to understand it.
[1:30:57] But they have been, in my opinion, Co opted by like a
[1:31:00] libertarian political ideology where they sort of say, but the
[1:31:05] state has no role in limiting that.
[1:31:07] So they believe, because they believe so deeply in
[1:31:10] individualism, they believe everyone should make this
[1:31:12] choice, that naively they believe in this sort of hands
[1:31:15] off approach. But like at the end of the day,
[1:31:18] yeah, you're kind of allowing it.
[1:31:19] I sort of think sometimes right wingers believe that culture on
[1:31:23] its own with no guards will some with with no legal power will
[1:31:28] somehow police its worst instincts.
[1:31:31] And I don't think it is because as I say, there are some people
[1:31:33] who just don't give a fuck. These people exist and they will
[1:31:36] see that you have this attitude around like, I don't know,
[1:31:40] giving to charity or doing something like that.
[1:31:41] They'll see that as your weak, your weak, I'm going to cut
[1:31:44] around you. I'm not going to do that.
[1:31:45] I'm going to do so. And I think like, you have to
[1:31:47] take these morals. That's why I like a lot of the
[1:31:49] Christian values and take them and find ways of legislating
[1:31:53] that again, you know, acknowledge the problem.
[1:31:55] If you stifle innovation and you stifle people's individual
[1:31:58] responsibility, that's also bad. But like, don't go so far the
[1:32:02] other way where it's just like your hands off.
[1:32:03] You can do whatever the fuck you want.
[1:32:05] Like a billionaire can own major media networks and that's just
[1:32:10] OK because, you know, whatever, it's like you, it's too much
[1:32:13] trust in people, you know what I mean?
[1:32:15] Like, yeah. Do you have any ideological?
[1:32:18] Hangovers from when you were right wing in sense of like.
[1:32:21] Things I still believe, I would say I am in on a personal level,
[1:32:26] more conservative in my beliefs and behaviours.
[1:32:30] I would say I more yeah, like my personal how I conduct my life.
[1:32:35] I still hold onto a lot of the sort of self help stuff, which
[1:32:38] I'm not saying that's a right wing thing, but it's just sort
[1:32:41] of quite coded. So it's like a lot of the kind
[1:32:45] of self help community tends to bind to a lot of the right wing
[1:32:47] ideology. There's I can explain why it's
[1:32:49] kind of long, but I, I believe in that on an interpersonal
[1:32:53] level. So I sort of have this attitude,
[1:32:54] while on an individual level, you have to act like no one's
[1:32:57] coming to save you. It's you against the world.
[1:33:00] You have to do that. You have to think like that to
[1:33:02] survive in this economy. But politically, I think that is
[1:33:06] shit. That's like handing out life
[1:33:09] vests on the Titanic and not thinking maybe we should, I
[1:33:13] don't know, you couldn't fix the Titanic.
[1:33:14] Bad, bad analogy. But maybe like addressing the
[1:33:17] root problem, which is a sinking ship.
[1:33:18] So politically, I think individualism and this hyper
[1:33:22] individualism will not save the world.
[1:33:24] It will a few life jackets. You might save yourself, maybe
[1:33:27] some of your friends will save themselves, but eventually
[1:33:29] you're all going to be eaten up because just the economy will
[1:33:32] just eat you and consume you. I think you have to go.
[1:33:36] Whilst it's true individually, I need to work hard, be
[1:33:38] disciplined, be focused. I also need to work collectively
[1:33:42] and politically to make it so that other people don't have to
[1:33:44] behave like this. And so like on an interpersonal
[1:33:46] level and like, you know, I'm married, I really value
[1:33:49] families. I really value like, I want to
[1:33:51] have kids. I think that's a, a
[1:33:53] responsibility of people to like do that.
[1:33:56] And if you can, God willing, but I, I don't impose that attitude
[1:34:01] on someone else. I don't see any difference in
[1:34:04] our, you know, someone has a totally different attitude to
[1:34:06] relationships. I'm like, that's fine for you,
[1:34:07] But I like the way I live how I live.
[1:34:10] It's weird that. The left are so individualistic
[1:34:13] it is weird sometimes you are right.
[1:34:15] Because I think, yeah, I don't know, there is this thing of
[1:34:19] like, I think especially for young people where they want to
[1:34:22] experiment with their identity and see who they are.
[1:34:24] Like, I did it, man. Like I used to fucking, I still
[1:34:27] rap, but like, I used to probably think I was blacker
[1:34:29] than I am. I used to like, I don't know, I
[1:34:32] you try different. I fucking yeah.
[1:34:34] Like you try different things when you're growing up and you
[1:34:36] should have that freedom to kind of experiment with your
[1:34:39] identity. But I think sometimes maybe the
[1:34:41] left puts a lot of stock in that, like, yeah, but yeah,
[1:34:47] you're right. It's like a individualistic
[1:34:49] expression. But politically, it's like their
[1:34:53] attitude to individualism would be different.
[1:34:54] It would come from like, I don't know, I can't even.
[1:34:58] I don't think I understand it enough.
[1:34:59] But they would have a understanding that by creating a
[1:35:03] more collectivist society, you allow individuals to express
[1:35:06] their individuality more. I think that's how they'd come
[1:35:09] to this conclusion. And I guess it's also the.
[1:35:11] Individual in the sense that you're taking responsibility for
[1:35:14] your actions and you don't need to give as much of your money to
[1:35:18] the others. We're individuals in that sense.
[1:35:21] But I mean, there's the toughest thing I've struggled with
[1:35:24] recently and especially done a big batch of recordings, all
[1:35:27] kinds of different people from walks of life and political
[1:35:29] orientations. And it's like there are certain
[1:35:32] things that are wired into US biologically as humans that we
[1:35:37] need for flourishing that we're disregarding in current
[1:35:40] societies. Something like this
[1:35:43] individualism rather than family and marriage and all the rest of
[1:35:46] it, and a prioritization of careers that we're now doing
[1:35:49] that stops us from having families.
[1:35:51] It's not working. And I find myself trapped here
[1:35:56] as someone who's not a conservative tweed jacket
[1:35:59] wearing fucking patriot or a nuts woke leftist.
[1:36:05] There are certain. Things that.
[1:36:07] They're just irrefutable facts that heavily considered
[1:36:11] conservative now. And maybe I'm a pussy for not
[1:36:15] just embracing them regardless of the labels that others
[1:36:17] wrongly put on them when they're just true.
[1:36:20] And there are certain things that actually more so
[1:36:23] politically that I'm on board with with the left.
[1:36:25] That again, maybe I'm being a pussy and not on boarding
[1:36:28] because I am myself in the pursuit of not trying to get
[1:36:32] caught up in ideology. I'm still scared of actually
[1:36:36] adopting certain viewpoints from either side because I don't want
[1:36:39] to be labeled A lefty or a righty.
[1:36:41] Yeah, yeah. And how old are you?
[1:36:43] Young 20 yeah. So it's like you you know, that
[1:36:45] is right. You should try and experiment
[1:36:48] because yeah, sometimes you can get yeah 2 bought in.
[1:36:50] I when I was your age, I got I was 2 bought in on like this
[1:36:53] identity of feeling like I was on the right, like it felt like
[1:36:56] an identity and then deviating from it is like almost
[1:37:00] dangerous. Like you're like if I listen to
[1:37:03] too much. I don't know.
[1:37:05] I remember, I remember specifically, and this might
[1:37:07] just be me. This is just probably how I am.
[1:37:09] But like I remember I it was Jordan Peterson.
[1:37:11] I love Jordan Peterson and he did a debate with probably
[1:37:15] Slavoj Zhujek mental name. Have you had him on?
[1:37:18] Am I right to think? No.
[1:37:19] OK, I thought it's sort of from the but yeah, he it was sort of
[1:37:24] they accepted that Slavage destroyed it.
[1:37:26] Like that was kind of like the general consensus.
[1:37:28] And I sort of remember not watching it because I was like,
[1:37:30] I don't want to be like exposed to this because he's an outright
[1:37:34] communist. And I was like, I don't want to
[1:37:35] be exposed to that because it conflicted with my identity as
[1:37:39] thinking that leftist for communism.
[1:37:42] All this sort of stuff is like deeply, intrinsically bad.
[1:37:45] And it's the opposite of me. And it was like, yeah, there can
[1:37:47] be a limitation. So it's good that you're not
[1:37:49] tied like that because it's it allows you to think more freely.
[1:37:53] But at some point, yeah, they could they it can be a thing of
[1:37:55] you can't have both sides can't be correct on an issue like, I
[1:37:59] don't know, billionaires. One side is right.
[1:38:01] It's either billionaires make the world better, I haven't seen
[1:38:03] much proof of that, or billionaires are a problem.
[1:38:06] You can't be like, you know, you can't really be in the same.
[1:38:10] You can the centre, I guess would be you can limit how much
[1:38:13] wealth you can have. I suppose that is a centrist
[1:38:15] perspective. Well, this is such an important.
[1:38:17] Point, to reiterate, from Kieran Andreu, who was in that seat
[1:38:19] from Novara Media, and he just looked me in the eyes and he was
[1:38:22] like, Ellie, you know, it's not always the rational, sensible
[1:38:26] option to be a centrist. Sometimes the reasonable and
[1:38:30] correct position is radical. I spoke with him.
[1:38:34] About that and. He imposed that on me and it's
[1:38:36] stuck. And I spoke with Charlie Towns,
[1:38:39] who's right wing working with Rupert Lowe, and he agrees too.
[1:38:43] And I think it's super true. Like sometimes we get caught up,
[1:38:49] especially myself. And like, there's probably been
[1:38:51] one of my biggest reflections the last month is in the pursuit
[1:38:55] of not being tribal, you end up tribally assigning yourself to
[1:39:00] the outer group, sat there on the fence, all virtuous and
[1:39:03] smug. But really, that's not.
[1:39:05] The answer either. And that's what I'm working
[1:39:08] through. Yeah, but there's no like, rush
[1:39:09] you. Know you're a young lad and it's
[1:39:11] like there's no rush for you to pick a side, but it's just
[1:39:14] important to not, uh, aggrandize the lack of decision.
[1:39:19] You know, like you shouldn't be certain on something you're not
[1:39:23] certain on, but don't take that uncertainty as like an end goal.
[1:39:27] There should be at some point you come to conclusions on
[1:39:29] certain things, but always still test those conclusions.
[1:39:31] So it's like you never get to a point where like this is what I
[1:39:34] am and that is very tough. And you're right to be scared of
[1:39:36] that, where it's like, this is what I am, this is who I am.
[1:39:39] And now I'm like, sort of I've done the, you know, you
[1:39:43] shouldn't get there, but you should risk being wrong.
[1:39:46] Like, you know, risk saying like, I stand on this.
[1:39:49] I think you have to do that. I think like, you can see where
[1:39:51] centrism goes wrong in Labour and the Labour Party.
[1:39:55] Keir Starmer and you see it as well, like the Democrats.
[1:39:58] They weren't they Especially Labour.
[1:40:01] They just want to have their cake and eat it.
[1:40:02] They want to seem like they're the good guys.
[1:40:04] So they they just nibble around the edges and then they lose
[1:40:07] because they don't have, they don't stand for something.
[1:40:09] Like it's better kind of to stand for something and be wrong
[1:40:11] than just to sort of go, I don't know, guys like, maybe it's what
[1:40:14] you're saying. Maybe it's what you're saying.
[1:40:16] And yeah, a lot of like people who I guess identify as
[1:40:19] completely centrist. I don't know.
[1:40:21] It sort of it depends on the issue for sure.
[1:40:25] But like on certain issues there is right and wrong and there is
[1:40:28] science as well. Like on I don't know if it's
[1:40:31] centrism on Flat Earth theory. You're in a confusing place.
[1:40:34] It's either the world is a globe or it's flat.
[1:40:36] There are issues where you should sort of, you know, pick a
[1:40:40] side. But like I don't think it's a
[1:40:42] rush to yeah. And I suppose it's.
[1:40:44] This tool of scepticism and when to implement it.
[1:40:47] But ultimately scepticism needs to be a tool in service of
[1:40:52] creating something. It's not a flex in and of
[1:40:54] itself, and it's kind of like using this scepticism to carve
[1:40:59] away a piece of marble. But eventually you need to stop
[1:41:02] to create the statue. That's a beauty of Elliot
[1:41:04] fucking. Rather than just obliterating
[1:41:08] it. So that's where I'm at and I
[1:41:11] appreciate you coming on the show.
[1:41:13] That's great. I've been a fan for a long time.
[1:41:15] Love your content. And we'll get into a few more
[1:41:18] questions because there's so many.
[1:41:19] We'll have to do a Rogan 6 hour episode next.
[1:41:22] Yeah, I can waffle cover your. There's probably like 80% of
[1:41:24] shit, but there'll be a good 20%.
[1:41:26] You'd be like, that was kind of cool.
[1:41:27] Yeah, well, we'll cut that up out of.
[1:41:29] Context and get you in trouble yeah social yeah, I'll tell you
[1:41:32] I've. Got a few questions on sub
[1:41:34] stack. But first, where can people find
[1:41:36] more of your work if they're not already subscribed?
[1:41:38] Yeah, I'm mainly YouTube. So Jimmy the Giant on YouTube,
[1:41:41] Instagram, Jimmy the giant, you care?
[1:41:43] Don't really post a lot on there Twitter.
[1:41:44] Don't follow me on Twitter. I'm I'm a Dick head on Twitter
[1:41:47] and I don't want to be on Twitter.
[1:41:48] I don't know why I'm on Twitter. I should go off for Twitter.
[1:41:50] But if you want to follow me, Jim the giant, I think on
[1:41:52] Twitter. So yeah, I haven't over to sub
[1:41:54] stack where I'm going. To ask Jimmy your questions.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
