# DEBATE: Should Gen Z Normalise Abortion? - Lois McLatchie Miller | #34

An episode of [The Next Generation](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1772698742), 18 Jul 2025, 1 h 10 min.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/107851968/podcast/play/105818687/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2025-6-22%2F404321001-44100-2-ea57750de1ad1.mp3

Is abortion murder? Is it a baby or just a clump of cells? How do we decide when a person is worthy of protection? I sat down with human rights commentator Lois McLatchie Miller to debate all these questions and more… Lois serves as the Senior Legal Communications Officer for ADF International and frequently defends the values of life, family and freedom of speech on the BBC, GB News, and various print media platforms. Find Lois on X: https://x.com/LoisMcLatch 00:00 Should Gen Z normalise abortion? 01:41 Why Lois is pro-life 02:26 The violinist argument 04:30 What about r*pe? 07:15 Where do we draw the line? 09:53 Should we restrict when we have sex more? 14:08 It’s impossible to live without taking risks 18:00 Is it just ‘a clump of cells’? 20:55 How abortions work at each stage 24:48 Abortion has been decriminalised up to birth 27:40 Would Lois make abortion illegal? 30:57 Elliot challenges Lois 33:58 Is abortion murder? 35:53 Have abortion laws been abused? 37:53 Potential consequences of my world view 39:17 What gives a person human rights? 44:20 Can human rights exist without God? 47:33 The slippery slope argument 51:02 The struggle to ground objective morality without God 56:36 Growing backlash against forms of abortion 59:45 Mothers are so undervalued 1:01:27 Most women don’t want ‘the feminist dream’ 1:03:39 Lois’ advice for a Gen Z girl 1:06:36 IVF is very unreliable 1:08:19 Our governments need to do better at supporting families 1:09:42 Wrapping up My Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/elliotbewick/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@elliotbewick X: https://x.com/elliotbewick ABOUT THE NEXT GENERATION: In a world saturated by social media and marked by skyrocketing rates of anxiety, depression, and ADHD among Gen Z, young people are growing up in a landscape of chaos and contradiction. While protests swell in city streets and activists hurl soup at famous artworks to demand climate action, a quieter crisis unfolds within - the mental and emotional battles faced by a generation trying to make sense of it all. The Next Generation is hosted by 20-year-old Elliot Bewick, offering a raw and honest look at the world through the eyes of those living in it. Bringing together insight from professionals and young people on the ground, this podcast isn’t here to complain or chase clout. It’s here to bend the arc of the modern world towards solutions, truth and a love for the beautiful adventure of life itself. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

## Transcript

[0:00] Lois Mcclatchy Miller, welcome to the next generation.
[0:02] Thank you. Exciting to be here. 86% of
[0:04] women under the age of 40 in the UK support some form of abortion
[0:08] rights. Is it time to normalize
[0:10] abortion? I think that we live in a
[0:13] society where abortion has been attempted to be normalized for
[0:17] the last few decades. But in the last few weeks, we
[0:20] saw superstar Lily Allen come out and talk quite callously
[0:24] about 5 abortions that she had laughing on a podcast, and the
[0:28] reaction has been overwhelmingly negative.
[0:32] I think that's really surprising, and I think that
[0:34] gives us a good moment to discuss.
[0:37] Are we happy with where we're at in society?
[0:39] Do we want abortion to be used as a form of contraception, for
[0:43] women to be having 5-6 abortions, laughing about it,
[0:46] not taking it seriously at all? Or do we want to reconsider what
[0:51] is a very serious moral question?
[0:54] What is a very serious matter of life and death and bring us
[0:58] ourselves back from that brink where abortion has become
[1:02] normalized to this extent. I think it will be useful for
[1:06] the viewers at home for us to just kind of lay out our world
[1:09] views and where we are on abortion.
[1:11] I, I feel like I need to be very careful discussing this issue
[1:13] because I'm a man and I'm going to get criticized for speaking
[1:16] about women's bodies, but I am pro-choice.
[1:19] I've grown up in Brighton, which is most atheist place in the UK
[1:23] and very pro-choice. I do know that there are some
[1:28] gaps in the pro-choice argument and I want us to expose those
[1:31] because it's something that I should have to grapple with and
[1:33] that anyone else at home should have to grapple with.
[1:35] I also want to hold you accountable and test your
[1:39] worldview. So so first lay out to me what
[1:41] your stance is on the board. All right, well I'm pro-life.
[1:44] I think that every human being has, no matter their age, stage
[1:48] of development, ability, intellect or dependency on their
[1:52] parents, has a right to life and that we should protect that at
[1:56] all costs. I find myself in a middle ground
[1:59] position actually a lot. There's some people out there
[2:02] who would say that only the woman matters and the baby
[2:05] doesn't matter at all. And I think as we can get into
[2:08] that's very problematic to have that kind of view.
[2:11] But there's also people on the other side that say only the
[2:13] child matters and the woman doesn't matter at all.
[2:14] And I don't think that is right either.
[2:16] I think we want a pro human stance.
[2:18] We want to find somewhere in the middle that says both lives
[2:20] matter. Let's take an approach in
[2:22] society that protects both mother and baby.
[2:27] Well, let's get into it. One of the most famous
[2:29] arguments, probably the most famous argument for pro-choice
[2:32] is this violinist argument by Judith Jarvis Thompson.
[2:36] And she lays out this thought experiment where you've been
[2:40] kidnapped by the Society of Music Lovers.
[2:42] You wake up in a bed and your kidney is attached to a
[2:46] violinist who's dying and he needs to use your kidney because
[2:49] you're the only one in the world with his blood type to keep him
[2:52] alive. Now he only needs it for nine
[2:54] months. After those nine months, you're
[2:56] free to go. She argues that it's well within
[3:00] your rights to detach yourself from the violinist, and this is
[3:05] analogous to abortion, that no one has a right to encroach on
[3:10] your rights and your body. Where does this argument go
[3:14] wrong? Where do we start?
[3:16] Gosh. Well, I mean, there's lengthy
[3:19] discussions and debates on this argument, but I think for me,
[3:22] one thing that stands out is in no circumstance is there an
[3:26] analogy where you're kidnapped in the middle of the night and
[3:28] start to talk to somebody that you don't know.
[3:31] What will happen is that you develop a child, your child, you
[3:37] are the mother of a child that is in your womb and your body is
[3:41] biologically programmed. There's nothing artificial going
[3:43] on here. This is a natural biological
[3:45] process to nurture and to keep that child safe for hopefully as
[3:49] long as nine months. So I think the starting premise
[3:53] that this is an outsider alien invader, it's something that's
[3:56] often put as in the framing of the protest argument that the
[3:59] baby is the enemy. And I don't think that is the
[4:01] way that we should view a harmless child who is innocent
[4:05] by all accounts and simply has, by a matter of biological fact
[4:10] began to develop in the his or her mother's womb.
[4:13] And so how do we reframe that conversation from being mother
[4:16] against child, which I think is unhelpful, to being pro mother
[4:21] and pro child? What can we do to support both
[4:23] lives, to help her have a healthy pregnancy and a
[4:25] supported motherhood, and also to keep that child alive,
[4:28] sustained and healthy too? Well, I guess what this argument
[4:33] gets at with the kidnapping is something more like unconsensual
[4:37] sex. You haven't chosen to be
[4:40] attached to this violinist. And we can keep coming back to
[4:43] this argument, even if there are the flaws.
[4:44] And I think it exposes nicely some flaws in the in the
[4:47] pro-choice movement. It's it's an A nice little hub
[4:49] to go back to throughout this conversation.
[4:51] So let's suppose you haven't chosen to engage in the sexual
[4:54] activity yet. You find yourself pregnant.
[4:58] Yeah. So and that's a really important
[5:00] point for us to discuss. What is also important to
[5:02] recognize is that's about 0.1% of abortion.
[5:05] So when we were talking about abortion generally, and I hope
[5:07] over the course of our conversation, we will be talking
[5:09] about the majority, the vast majority that that aren't as a
[5:12] result of violence or non consensual sex.
[5:15] But again, it's important to address these because this does
[5:18] affect a percentage of women who deserve an answer.
[5:21] And rape is probably one of the most brutal and horrible harms
[5:26] crimes that we can imagine in society.
[5:29] It's a total affront to the human person.
[5:31] And I think when a woman goes through that, the interesting
[5:36] kind of typical societal response is that, well, she must
[5:38] want to immediately have an abortion to get rid of what
[5:41] happened. But when we look at what happens
[5:45] when someone has it, suffers the trauma of a rape, and then has a
[5:48] trauma of abortion, that's just two traumas, one after the
[5:51] other. We're assuming there that
[5:53] abortion is going to heal and remove what happened.
[5:56] And that's not true at all. There's a really interesting
[5:58] study in the states from actually a pro-choice research
[6:02] group. It's called the turn away study
[6:03] and it comes to pro-choice conclusions.
[6:05] But one thing that's really interesting from it is it
[6:06] examines when women have been in a situation where they have not
[6:10] been allowed to access an abortion.
[6:12] For example, they'd be maimed or in another circumstance that and
[6:15] then they have not been allowed to access an abortion.
[6:18] And it's of course in that moment when someone finds out
[6:21] that they cannot have 1A panic. Oh my goodness, what am I going
[6:24] to do? But what the study shows is that
[6:28] by the time that that child has grown to the 5th birthday, 96%
[6:34] of women are glad they kept the child.
[6:36] They say this child gave me meaning.
[6:38] This child gave me hope in a dark time in my life.
[6:40] It gave me a reason to carry on and I'm glad I kept the child.
[6:44] The study also showed that most women did not go and seek an
[6:47] illegal abortion after they were denied one.
[6:49] Most women found the answer no, how to reset a rethink and
[6:54] decided to carry on with their pregnancy.
[6:56] So I think this is a really significant piece of data that's
[6:58] often overlooked. We just assume, I think to to
[7:02] our discredit what a woman should do in such a
[7:05] circumstance. And we don't look at the
[7:07] evidence, the data points and the experiences of women who
[7:09] have been through this and have said actually keeping a child
[7:12] can be a really positive thing. I guess even if it was 99%, the
[7:18] question lies in the fundamental conclusions that this argument
[7:22] may bring us to the fact that even though you haven't asked
[7:26] this to happen to you, it's happened and we're prioritizing
[7:30] a life. The question then becomes, at
[7:33] what point is this acceptable? If we take it further, at what
[7:37] point should we prioritize someone's life over your
[7:41] continued suffering? Even if it's 0.01% of people,
[7:44] Even if we accept that most people, you know, they're not
[7:46] traumatized by having that child, in principle, it seems
[7:51] like this could lead us down some pretty dark paths where
[7:54] you're forced into doing things in another realm where, where do
[7:57] we draw the line so this doesn't spill over into other real world
[8:01] implications? Where are the other kind of
[8:02] examples where we would be forced to do something?
[8:05] Well, you take the example of the kidney.
[8:09] At what point should you seed giving up your kidney for their
[8:13] life? Could you be attached for 90
[8:15] years of suffering? At at what point is it no longer
[8:18] OK? Interesting.
[8:20] I mean, this is really interesting to apply back to the
[8:23] life of a child, right? Because we know pregnancy is
[8:25] going to be 9 months, that's it's not going to be 90 years,
[8:27] it's going to be 9 months. And then after that, it's
[8:31] interesting because a lot of people would say, oh, abortion's
[8:36] up, OK, up to actually not that many.
[8:38] But some people would say abortion's OK up to birth, but
[8:40] not the moment after birth. And they would say, well,
[8:42] because the child is no longer dependent on its mother, it can
[8:46] survive its own, etcetera. But actually, how many day olds
[8:50] do you know? They're not dependent on their
[8:51] mother. How many week olds?
[8:52] Month olds. Your 40 year olds, yeah. 20 year
[8:56] olds. Mother exactly.
[8:57] I know a few. So to say that we started to
[9:01] bring in these arbitrary lines of when is it OK to abandon a
[9:06] child and put them in harm's way?
[9:09] And the ultimate answer is it's never really OK to abandon a
[9:12] child and put them in hands about.
[9:13] There can be traumatic circumstances where we seek what
[9:16] is best for the child, for example, adoption, you know, if
[9:20] they're, if a child cannot be cared for about its own parents,
[9:22] we can find alternatives. But to say that bringing harm to
[9:25] the life of that child and bring, you know, many
[9:28] circumstances, I mean, we'll feel pain during abortion after
[9:31] a certain number of weeks. Some people say it's 15, some
[9:33] say 12, some say even earlier. So when is it OK to inflict harm
[9:38] in pain or when is it OK to seek better alternatives or to step
[9:41] up and to to serve and to be a mother and to be united with
[9:46] that child? I think those two options are
[9:48] certainly more attractive to the average person than to cause
[9:52] harm. Yeah, strong points and and and
[9:55] taken I think one part of this linking on from that is actually
[9:59] going back to the act of sex itself.
[10:02] And that's something, you know, we could get lost in the weeds
[10:04] now me giving you rebuttals about abortion, but we're we're
[10:08] not speaking about what happens before that.
[10:10] And that's often missed out in these kind of fiery Ben Shapiro
[10:13] destroys pro-choice online conversations.
[10:17] I don't think they're particularly helpful for moving
[10:19] the needle in any direction. So, so, so let's speak about sex
[10:24] and the responsibilities lying in that.
[10:26] Judith Jarvis Thompson, she also says in this essay, she speaks
[10:29] about this idea of these human seeds that sort of float about
[10:32] in the air. You've got a stuffy house and
[10:35] you want to open your windows and you're aware that one of
[10:37] these human seeds might float in through the windows at some
[10:40] point and take root in your upholstery and grow into this
[10:43] human. So you buy the finest mesh
[10:47] curtains that protect you from these seeds drifting in, but
[10:51] sometimes these finest mesh curtains that you invest all
[10:54] your money into are going to have defects and the seed is
[10:58] going to get in and take root. Was it in your, should you have
[11:05] not had any sofas, any carpets, any paintings that this thing
[11:08] can't take root? Should you have closed your
[11:10] windows? And, and this is sort of an
[11:11] analogy for should you just not have any sex, right?
[11:17] Where do you stand on that? Is there a a responsibility
[11:20] always that you should not be having sex unless you're ready
[11:24] to carry that through as a kid? I think just the biological
[11:27] reality, and it sounds harsh, as if you consent to sex, you are
[11:30] consenting to pregnancy and with all the best will in the world
[11:32] and you know, even if you use contraceptives, it's just
[11:35] statistical data to show that. Goodness me, we've known this
[11:38] for millions of years, but now we seem to have to relearn that
[11:42] sex can lead to pregnancy. And so this attitude to sex
[11:46] really changed in the 60s during the sexual revolution.
[11:49] And we were kind of told that with the advent of the pill,
[11:52] advent of abortion being legalized, etcetera, that we now
[11:55] had this sexual freedom that we could do whatever we want with
[11:58] whomever we want at every time of day and it would be great.
[12:02] And I think there's many different avenues to go down to
[12:05] explore why that hasn't actually led to human flourishing, led to
[12:10] a better situation for women or men.
[12:12] And we have been given this ultimate unbridled freedom.
[12:17] But I don't, I can't remember who was that said freedom is a
[12:20] is a great horse, but what matters is where you're going to
[12:22] write it. You know, freedom is fine in
[12:25] itself, but freedom for what? To what?
[12:28] And if it's freedom just to have sex all the time with whoever,
[12:31] whenever we want, is that actually making us happier as
[12:34] humans? It doesn't seem so.
[12:35] I mean, there's a Yale study that shows that woman's
[12:37] happiness has declined both in relative and absolute terms and
[12:41] compression to men since the 70s, when we're supposed to be
[12:43] at our peak of feminism, right? We're supposed to have just
[12:46] achieved female emancipation, have all these rights, and yet
[12:49] we're more unhappy than every depression, anxiety and
[12:52] suicidality is more prevalent than ever amongst this
[12:54] generation. Why are we so unhappy?
[12:57] And why has it linked to that big change that happened that
[13:00] was supposed to be for our benefit?
[13:02] Doesn't seem to make sense. And of course now we have that
[13:05] severance of sex from relationship it has without
[13:12] having that expectation of a child.
[13:14] It means that one can sex doesn't have that expectation of
[13:18] commitment anymore. It used to be that women would
[13:20] gatekeep sex and men would gatekeep this kind of idea of a
[13:25] long term committed relationship, ideally a
[13:28] marriage, but without that kind of glue that holds together that
[13:32] expectation of we might have a child if we do this.
[13:34] So we better get ready to be married or to be engaged.
[13:38] That whole relationship between men and women falls apart and we
[13:41] have this kind of atomised society which hasn't seemed to
[13:44] be particularly beneficial. I think we have put freedom at
[13:49] the root of our society and we think that's what will make us
[13:51] flourish. I completely agree with that.
[13:53] And I, I saw at the art conference a couple of years
[13:54] ago, there was this great analogy of a tree and you put
[13:57] freedom at the root of it and then you think you're going to
[14:00] have all of these beautiful fruits.
[14:01] But that's not the case. Freedom is a fruit of
[14:05] responsibility, so I think that flip needs to take place.
[14:09] I'm not sure, though, where this worldview leads us in terms of
[14:12] every time we have sex, we are consenting to also having a
[14:16] child. I mean the child that we can't
[14:20] kill. What other activities do we
[14:24] engage in where there's that risk, yet we still engage in it.
[14:28] Something like getting in your car and driving.
[14:29] There's a risk that you might kill someone every day, but we
[14:31] take the risk and I think that's kind of a practical element of
[14:35] the world. We we are taking risks that we
[14:37] might do harm to someone always. A child isn't necessarily a harm
[14:42] though, is it? I mean, a child ultimately is a
[14:44] good thing. A life a human being is is not a
[14:46] bad thing. It's a it can be an impact your
[14:48] life negatively in the first instance perhaps, but it
[14:53] shouldn't be seen. I think we're framing this as if
[14:57] we have sex, a bad thing might happen, whereas it should be if
[15:01] we have sex, we should be prepared for this eventuality,
[15:03] which is different from if I have a car, I might crash it.
[15:07] Did you see the difference? So it's you're assuming a
[15:10] negative where it's actually meant to be positive.
[15:12] But that's why sex is meant to be encased in this structure of
[15:16] family, of commitment, of relationship and of love.
[15:19] Whereas pulling apart those structures leaves that baby,
[15:24] that child exposed. And then even the way you
[15:26] phrased it, I mean, I know you're probably talking a little
[15:28] bit flippantly about a child that we can't kill.
[15:30] Oh, no, no, we're not supposed to kill the children.
[15:33] We're supposed to be for providing and creating these
[15:35] structures that support. I feel like this still doesn't
[15:41] answer the question of practical reality, the fact that we are
[15:45] taking risks every day. We're taking the risk that we
[15:48] are going to do something harmful.
[15:51] And I know that you've said that having a baby isn't something
[15:53] harmful, but their life may end up a tragic one.
[15:58] They may have an awful mother that wasn't prepared to raise
[16:01] them. She she consented to the sex,
[16:04] but she didn't know the implications of that or she knew
[16:08] she was aware of it, that she's regretted it later down the
[16:11] line. Well, where do you stand on
[16:13] that? How do we navigate that sort of
[16:14] practical reality that we are always taking risks?
[16:17] Yeah. Well, I suppose when we take
[16:19] risks, we factor in the choices that we're making, right?
[16:22] So if you're getting in a car, if it's if you know the brakes
[16:24] don't work or if you know that car is likely to break down in
[16:27] the motorway, you're far likely to risk getting in it, right?
[16:30] So if you are having sex with somebody who is not going to be,
[16:35] I could, let's say if I'm a girl, a committed father who's
[16:38] not going to stick around and is, you know, at a frat party
[16:40] and I'm going to leave tomorrow morning, that's a very foolish
[16:44] risk for me to take. And it's interesting.
[16:46] There's studies of college campuses in America where there
[16:50] is a higher percentage of males on campus.
[16:54] There's actually a more conservative approach to sex on
[16:57] campus because if there is less females available, they're the
[17:01] higher commodity. They're more likely to be less
[17:05] risk taking. They want to have men prove to
[17:08] them, you know, it's this instinct, but to prove to them
[17:10] that they are willing, they're capable of taking care of them
[17:12] and potential child. It's just they're they're it
[17:16] leans towards a more conservative approach.
[17:17] Whereas when the females are not as first commodity, when there's
[17:20] more females than men, they have less of that kind of economics
[17:25] of this. You know, they, they're, they
[17:26] don't have that upper hand economically with sex and men
[17:30] are more likely to be risk taking in sex and they have
[17:34] ultimately biologically less of the consequences.
[17:37] Like ultimately a man can leave, it's not very good for them, but
[17:41] they'd have less of that consequence.
[17:42] So the burden falls more on females.
[17:45] We do see that play out. But ultimately, like hookup
[17:48] culture, messing up that kind of balanced equation has not only
[17:53] been bad in terms of seeing an increase in abortion, increase
[17:57] in harms caused to children, but also has not made women happy
[18:00] either. I suppose one of the pieces
[18:03] we're missing here when I say something like killing a child,
[18:06] which is an awful sentence to say, is the argument that it's
[18:10] not a child. What's your rebuttal to this
[18:15] concept that gets thrown around a lot by pro choices?
[18:17] That it's just a clump of cell, it's not a child?
[18:19] Yeah, no, it's a very common argument and it's really
[18:23] interesting to press and find out when somebody thinks a child
[18:27] or a person, uh, begins because although most people are not
[18:32] fully pro-life like I would be, most people don't think it
[18:36] should be any reason up to birth or even beyond birth.
[18:38] Um, so most people are not actually pro-choice.
[18:41] They everybody believes in some sort of restriction on choice.
[18:43] Most people would not allow a mother to kill a 5 year old and
[18:46] most people actually would not. Only 1% of women according to
[18:49] 2017 polling in the UK would allow abortion up to birth for
[18:52] any reason. So we're all for someone in the
[18:56] middle and where is that point that it becomes a life, or some
[18:59] people would say when it can survive on its own, But that's
[19:02] actually moving all the time with medical science.
[19:05] So it is a movable point that someone becomes a person.
[19:07] Or is it, you know, does it just depend on the country that they
[19:10] live in and the medical resources that they have?
[19:13] Is it when the heart starts to beat?
[19:14] People think that's six weeks because that's when you can
[19:16] start to hear it. Your heart starts to beat at 2
[19:18] 1/2 weeks. Most people don't know they're
[19:20] pregnant at 2 1/2 weeks. At 4:00 to five weeks, they
[19:23] start moving independently. At five to six weeks, they start
[19:26] having brain waves. At seven weeks, they can hiccup
[19:28] and swallow. Like the advancement of a child
[19:32] in those early stages is far beyond what most people would
[19:35] expect or imagine. And so I think the question to
[19:38] put to yourself or to anybody listening is when?
[19:41] When is it a child and when are you comfortable pronouncing
[19:45] yourself that? Now it has human rights, but it
[19:47] didn't yesterday. And I think this is such an
[19:50] important thing to speak about and we're going to iron out some
[19:54] of my world views in a minute and then sort of go down some
[19:57] sort of potentially dark roots where my world view takes me.
[20:01] But I'm, I'm open to that. And I want us to explore this on
[20:03] camera for people because, you know, anecdotally, I probably
[20:08] know very few girls that I'm friends with that haven't had an
[20:12] abortion like it's. Crazy and all of them will will
[20:16] accept when I've spoken to them that it's not an ideal thing
[20:19] that they're doing. It's it's not a good thing.
[20:21] We can pretty much all accept that.
[20:25] So so it's important to have this conversation.
[20:26] And I suppose one of the things with the argument of OK, it's OK
[20:32] to kill a Clumber cells or a baby until they can survive
[20:36] independently. Going back to this violinist
[20:38] analogy, it's this idea that you're detaching yourself from
[20:43] this baby, but you're not specifically guaranteeing its
[20:46] death that falls through, because in abortion, you're not
[20:52] just detaching yourself from this baby.
[20:54] So this is a a horrible conversation to have, but can
[20:58] you maybe just lay out how abortions actually work at each
[21:01] stage of pregnancy? Yeah, of course.
[21:03] So in the 1st 10 weeks you can get what's called pills by post
[21:07] abortion in the UK now, which means that you order, you phone
[21:10] up B pass or another perversion provider and say I would like
[21:13] some abortion pills. They'll ask you how long you
[21:15] are. You say you're under 10 weeks
[21:16] and you'll after a short conversation, be able to receive
[21:19] these pills. That's a mythopriston and a
[21:21] misoprostol so that they work by.
[21:24] The 1st pill will effectively suffocate the child.
[21:27] It will cut off the nutrient stream and the oxygen stream to
[21:31] the child in the womb. And then about 24 hours later
[21:33] you take a second pill which will eject the child from your
[21:38] uterus. It is definitely marketed as
[21:42] like the most pleasant abortion. But in Cosmopolitan magazine
[21:45] earlier this year, there was actually a thought piece from a
[21:48] pro-choice individual saying that she felt so hurt that the
[21:51] doctors had never told her how traumatic and difficult that was
[21:55] actually going to be. And it does involves it can be
[21:59] heavy cramping, heavy bleeding. Many girls that I've spoken to
[22:02] have had terrible incidents where they've, you know,
[22:04] witnessed things come out and toilets, etcetera.
[22:07] So a really horrific thing, especially to do as young women
[22:10] on your own in your bathroom floor.
[22:11] I think that's actually akin to kind of the backstreet abortions
[22:13] that we were meant to be avoiding.
[22:15] So that's first ten weeks and you can't actually take pills
[22:19] all the way through pregnancy, although later on obviously
[22:21] becomes far more difficult and traumatic to adjective enlarge
[22:24] your fetus as you go into second trimester.
[22:27] What might be recommended is a DNA abortion, which is when the
[22:31] surgeon or an abortionist will go in with tools and they will
[22:35] have to extract the baby physically from the uterus.
[22:38] The baby will be too large at that stage to be able to draw
[22:41] out in collision and so within the uterus they will detach arms
[22:45] and legs and pull them out individually.
[22:49] There'll be some instances when the skull is too big to come out
[22:52] with those tools and so they will crush the skull and they
[22:54] will draw the rest of the body out.
[22:56] At that stage, the abortionists will then have to piece together
[22:59] the baby again in their own unit to make sure that there was no
[23:03] pieces left behind, because leaving a piece behind can
[23:06] obviously lead to sepsis and serious medical harm.
[23:10] And so that is a DNA abortion. And then finally in the latest
[23:14] stages of pregnancy, you would the baby would be too big again
[23:20] for even that kind of system. And so the doctor would inject
[23:24] the hearts of the child through the mum's tummy and it would
[23:28] stop the fetus's heart. So that's got a fetus side.
[23:33] You can imagine homicide feticide ending the baby's life
[23:37] and the baby would then have to the mother then has to give
[23:42] birth to the child because at that stage, I mean, people think
[23:44] abortion, they think it will just make a child disappear.
[23:47] And but of course, you know, it's a physical baby.
[23:50] It can't just disappear as the mother actually has to give
[23:53] birth to that child, which has died as a result of the fetus
[23:57] side. And so my challenge at the those
[24:00] to those who support that kind of late stage abortion of a full
[24:04] living, viable, sometimes healthy child is if you are
[24:09] willing and the woman will have to give birth to this baby.
[24:13] Could there not be a solution where she gives birth to it
[24:16] alive, gives them that shot of life and finds another
[24:19] alternative through adoption or through another means?
[24:22] And to give this child a chance of like, why do we have to kill
[24:26] at that late stage of abortion when these children, you know,
[24:28] 30 to 40 weeks could survive, could be healthy?
[24:31] I find that particularly difficult.
[24:33] What's the breakdown of at what stage people usually have
[24:36] abortion and what are the laws in the UK and US at the moment?
[24:40] OK, well the US is a kind of mosaic so it's a little hard to
[24:45] summarize, but in the UK let's do first.
[24:47] So the abortion is most common in the 1st 10 weeks.
[24:51] Especially with the advent of pills by post abortion, it's
[24:54] become very easy to access those pills.
[24:56] Unfortunately, that's actually led to an increase in illegal
[25:01] abortions because women now are able, either by accident or
[25:05] through their own intent, to call up an abortion fighter and
[25:09] claim to be a different stage of pregnancy than they really are.
[25:12] So there's been cases. Carla Foster was a famous one in
[25:15] 2023. She called up and said she was
[25:17] less than 10 weeks when in fact she was about 30-4 weeks
[25:20] pregnant. And she was given those pills
[25:23] and she conducted an illegal abortion on herself at home.
[25:26] Then she gave birth to a child who she later named Lily.
[25:29] And she talked about how traumatic it was to see her
[25:32] child's face and she had killed and delivered it herself.
[25:37] She actually went to court and she was convicted for that.
[25:40] She was given a very light sentence and then actually too
[25:42] excited that since she was led out of jail entirely because
[25:46] obviously there is a significant media reaction when things like
[25:50] this happen. But I think in the culture, it
[25:53] was interesting to see that a lot of people did think that was
[25:56] wrong, what she did, and she did deserve some sort of criminal
[25:59] penalty because that's what we would do if she had killed a
[26:01] three month old or a three-week old.
[26:04] So there you can start to see the inconsistencies here with
[26:07] the kind of dominant media or political narrative and what
[26:09] most people would judge as being the right thing to do or being
[26:13] the wrong thing to do. So post by post, one to 10
[26:16] weeks, that is the most common. Plus those instances of illegal
[26:20] abortion. And how many of those happen, we
[26:23] don't really know. And there seems to be a slight
[26:25] increase in the numbers who are doing a very late term.
[26:29] Unfortunately, that was the impetus to make a change in the
[26:31] law recently where MPs voted to decriminalize abortion for women
[26:38] performed at those late stages. So now they can access those
[26:41] pills without being prosecuted without any sort of legal
[26:43] deterrent. Because of course, the law that
[26:45] was there not just criminalize, but to deter women from doing
[26:48] this really harmful act on themselves and on their
[26:49] children. Now that's gone.
[26:51] And so it's likely we'll see an increase again of those late
[26:54] term pregnancies. Could you?
[26:56] Steel man, the other argument of decriminalizing that.
[27:00] Yeah. So I think it's their case is
[27:01] pretty clear. It's that they think that women
[27:03] should not be prosecuted for making this decision, that it's
[27:05] their body, their choice, and that many would say, oh, you
[27:09] know, if if they're doing it at that late stage of pregnancy,
[27:12] they must be desperate. They must be.
[27:15] Why should we criminalize them for something that's been so
[27:17] difficult and hard for them? And abortion is really difficult
[27:20] and really hard. On that we can agree.
[27:22] But I would say that's why we have the law to prevent it and
[27:26] to deter it and to make sure it doesn't happen, whereas removing
[27:30] it is only going to allow more women to be in that situation
[27:34] and to be, you know, like Carla traumatized that horrific
[27:37] scenario with baby Lily. So would you want to see not
[27:42] only abortion made legal, but the women criminalized at every
[27:46] stage of abortion? It's a really tough question
[27:50] because it's just such a hypothetical one because our
[27:52] culture is nowhere and our political culture and our
[27:54] political life, you know, like I'm not the king of the UK.
[27:58] And so we have to work with the culture where we're at.
[28:02] Of course. I think ultimately I would like
[28:06] to see us move as a society to a place where we have far less
[28:10] abortions because we are recognizing the harms of it
[28:13] because we are stepping up to provide for mums and babies in
[28:17] that situation. Unfortunately, the government a
[28:19] couple of years ago criminalized charities from offering pro-life
[28:22] support in your abortion facilities, which I think it's
[28:24] such a regressive step because we should be moving towards a
[28:28] position where women are offered economic support, financial
[28:31] support, emotional and social support as well and to keep
[28:35] their children. So I think I would like to see
[28:36] society take steps in that direction to make abortion just
[28:39] seem so unnecessary and redundant that these criminal
[28:43] penalties are are barely talked about anyway because it's, you
[28:46] know, seen as such an irrelevant step.
[28:49] So you're not willing to put down an an objective stance on
[28:52] that, rather a pragmatic 1? Yeah, I think probably a bit
[28:55] pragmatic is the is the best way to be, you know, interacting in
[29:01] this society where we are or not.
[29:02] Is it helpful to say? I mean, is it, is there a moral
[29:06] case to say abortion should be banned from birth and it should
[29:08] be a criminal penalty? Of course it's a moral case, but
[29:11] what can we do about it? Well, how can we save the most
[29:13] lives? How can we support women to take
[29:16] that journey into motherhood and not consider abortion?
[29:18] I think there's more effective ways that we can take those
[29:22] steps. So it's saving the most lives,
[29:26] not necessarily prioritizing all life being sacred.
[29:30] Well, the law follows culture and culture follows the law.
[29:34] So I think, you know, there could be scenarios in different
[29:37] countries, different cultures, different times where we're able
[29:40] to move law and more effective ways.
[29:43] But I think for now, I'm heartened to see that.
[29:48] I think as the Reform Party have come out already, I think it was
[29:50] Nigel who said that he thinks 24 weeks is too high and would be
[29:55] considering, you know, reducing that.
[29:57] So that's at 2221, wherever he considers to be the next step.
[30:01] I think women in this country are very much on board with
[30:04] that. You know, 70% of women would
[30:05] like to see that 24 week limit that we currently have, although
[30:10] it's now decriminalized up to both for most situations at 24
[30:14] weeks is the cut off. If you want to have it done in a
[30:16] hospital by a doctor, most would like to see that move to
[30:19] something earlier. So that's in step with the
[30:22] culture. I think that could be a really
[30:24] positive move, especially considering by the way that the
[30:27] average European Union country has an abortion limit of 12 to
[30:31] 15 weeks. We are already double, double,
[30:34] double and that is before diagram.
[30:37] So we're already an extreme. I think there's steps that we
[30:40] can take already to that everybody would support to move
[30:44] to a more humane, compassionate abortion law for babies that are
[30:49] able to survive and thrive at 24 weeks with the right medical
[30:52] support. Gradually stepping that back I
[30:55] think is a helpful move for women and for children.
[30:58] Sure, but pro-choice is compassionate as well.
[31:00] It feels like you're not following the logical
[31:01] conclusions through of your argument, which is a pro-life
[31:04] one of all costs. You're making this argument of
[31:07] an objective morality where pro-life is valued at all costs,
[31:12] and then when pressed, you're saying that we should look at
[31:15] the pragmatic side, that that it doesn't matter.
[31:18] I think, no, I don't think it's that.
[31:19] I think it's just more realism. So I like I said, there could be
[31:21] a moral difference. There, flesh that out for me.
[31:22] Yeah, there's a moral case to protect all life.
[31:25] Absolutely. But are we able to physically do
[31:28] that in the UK right now? This political climate, this
[31:30] culture? No, we can, and I'm realistic
[31:32] about that. But what can we do?
[31:34] What steps can we take to move towards a society which is more
[31:38] respectful for life, which is more supportive of the most
[31:41] vulnerable? These are steps that we can take
[31:42] now. I think that's a fair, you know,
[31:45] we can't, we can't have ultimately what we want all the
[31:48] time, but we can help people get to a healthier place.
[31:53] Well, then it kind of feels like you're on par with these pro
[31:55] choices who think the greater good will be disposing of these
[31:59] clumps of cells because it will lead to more compassion and more
[32:03] flourishing. But there, there's nothing
[32:05] objective underpinning that. Just like you're not willing to
[32:08] place down the objective statement that pro, you're
[32:11] pro-life at all cost, you're prioritizing that.
[32:15] It feels like you're kind of just bringing yourself down to
[32:17] their subjective level here. I disagree because I said that
[32:20] morally that that is the ultimate good.
[32:22] So I I accept that this would be morally, there's a great moral
[32:25] case for banning version. So I already said that at the
[32:27] start. So I, I think there's a it's
[32:30] fair enough to look at the practical steps that you can
[32:33] take, knowing that certain steps are not in political reach right
[32:36] now. Like I said, I'm not the king of
[32:37] the UK and so I can't do everything that I would, you
[32:41] know, to, to make a legal claim for morality.
[32:45] I think we can do what we can at the moment.
[32:47] And you know, for the pro-choice side, they would they're kind
[32:51] of, there's only kind of two stances in the protest than the
[32:54] abortion to be right. I mean, we'd, we can model the
[32:57] round in the grey, but ultimately if it's a human life,
[33:00] then it's life from the start. And if it's not, then it doesn't
[33:03] matter at all. And so they would be attempting
[33:07] to decriminalize up to birth in all circumstances for doctors as
[33:11] well. And then, you know, if they want
[33:13] to follow that logic through to its own conclusion as well, they
[33:16] probably even do after birth because what is the difference
[33:20] between and Peter Singer has made this argument.
[33:23] What is the difference between the day before birth and day
[33:25] after? It's the same child, different,
[33:26] slightly different geographical location maybe, but same needs,
[33:29] same abilities, same cognitive consciousness.
[33:34] Why that? And so they would continue to
[33:36] crease that. And but I mean, they're not
[33:38] going to be able to get that tomorrow either.
[33:39] So they're incrementally working as well.
[33:42] And this is just the nature of politics.
[33:45] But we can look, we can look at legal claims and moral claims
[33:49] and the things that we can do physically in the meantime
[33:53] before, you know, if, if having that legal claim in law is not
[33:58] going to be possible tomorrow, what can we do tomorrow to save
[34:00] more lives? Would you say that abortion is
[34:02] akin to murder? Yeah, I think so.
[34:05] Because if it's if murder is intentionally ending a life, I
[34:12] think in most circumstances, abortion intentionally ends
[34:15] life. Now, there could be a small
[34:17] minority of cases, for example, where we're faced, and this
[34:20] isn't common, But if we're faced with a situation where a mother
[34:24] and a baby are going to die and the doctors can only save and
[34:28] the mother at the expense of the baby, like you want to save the
[34:31] most lives possible. That's the pro-life physician,
[34:33] right? You want to maximize life.
[34:34] And so rather than losing too, of course, with a heavy heart
[34:38] and with grief, you can find a situation where it's not
[34:41] intentionally murdering, but intentionally saving.
[34:44] So there's small sets of circumstances where I wouldn't
[34:47] count it as murder based on the intention.
[34:49] But I think a lot of the time there is an intention to end the
[34:52] life of the child, whether that's for the benefit of
[34:55] somebody socially, economically, whatever it may be.
[34:58] And it can be a very harsh and heavy word to use of course.
[35:01] And I appreciate that. And some people will find that
[35:03] really difficult and know there'll be people watching
[35:05] who've gone through this. One of three women in the UK
[35:07] has. And I understand that's a really
[35:08] difficult thing to hear. But I think we have to talk
[35:12] really truthfully about what this is and reckon with what is
[35:16] happening across the UK. And if a child's life does begin
[35:22] in the womb, if they are a member of this human race, no
[35:25] matter their dependency on their mother, no matter their
[35:27] intellect, no matter their viability, whether they're male,
[35:30] female, disabled, if none of that counts to be what counts as
[35:35] somebody who has human rights and you just get them because
[35:38] you're human, and that's what we believe this side of the womb,
[35:41] then we can't take someone on the other side of the womb and
[35:44] say what they don't count. So would you not want to
[35:47] criminalize or murder? Of course, I mean, we can go
[35:50] back and do this again if. You, I I would love to I I feel
[35:53] like we haven't really answered it.
[35:54] Yeah. So ultimately, I mean abortion
[35:56] is illegal by the way. It's under certain exceptions
[35:59] that it's not. So the law actually, although
[36:02] it's not well known, is does actually hold that threshold of
[36:07] recognising that it's wrong. Am I right in saying that it's
[36:09] the only medical procedure that's governed by criminal laws
[36:14] rather than safety laws? Interesting.
[36:17] Potentially euthanasia, but. Yeah.
[36:20] And potentially surrogacy, but there's so there's a few, but
[36:22] maybe I don't know, but but certainly one of the few.
[36:28] So, yeah, as as we were saying, the law as it stands currently
[36:31] does, it recognizes that. That's why I think it's helpful
[36:33] ultimately, even with a useless criminal law, to still have one
[36:36] that recognizes and upholds that basic principle that it is
[36:39] wrong. The law gives exceptions.
[36:41] It was intentionally, it was meant to be only on somebody's
[36:45] physical or mental health grounds off until 24 weeks.
[36:48] It was designed to be for a small minority of cases where
[36:53] things are just really difficult.
[36:54] And and of course those exceptions have been thoroughly
[36:58] abused to the extent that we now have 250,000 abortions per year
[37:02] in the UK, 250,000 per year. Think how many people that is
[37:06] year on year. No wonder we're having
[37:09] demographic crisis problems. But yeah, so the law's clearly
[37:15] abused, but I do appreciate that it is still recognised and I
[37:18] think it'd be helpful to maintain that whilst we work to
[37:22] reduce the number of abortions. I think a key piece of this to
[37:26] sort of expose my philosophical viewpoint is that everything has
[37:31] become subjective in our culture today.
[37:34] And that's not necessarily people doing years of philosophy
[37:38] and reading all these different arguments for morality and the
[37:41] existence of it or lack thereof. It's people that have kind of
[37:46] been given this morality through social media and through
[37:49] propaganda and through other activists, but they don't really
[37:53] know what they're buying into. The problem that I have being
[37:58] pro-choice is, I mean, I can't just say that this clump of
[38:02] cells isn't a human. So it's not killing I, I have to
[38:05] accept that objective fact. I'm not going to be someone that
[38:08] says there's no such thing as men or women or babies like
[38:12] it's, it's the same thing. Right.
[38:14] So then it becomes that I am willing to seed that there are
[38:19] situations where I would permit a human to be killed, which is
[38:26] pretty messed up. And it's in the name of what?
[38:28] A woman's choice for the sake of her feelings, her mental health,
[38:32] as stated. And that seems like a pretty
[38:36] poor argument. Ask me when something becomes a
[38:40] human life. I can't go 24 weeks 25, like,
[38:44] why not 26? You're going to corner me every
[38:46] time. So I have to accept that at
[38:49] conception, it's a human life. The thing that's missing, I
[38:54] think, is the theological lens in all of this, that all life is
[38:59] sacred. As someone that doesn't believe
[39:01] in God, I don't believe that by definition.
[39:05] I might act as though that's the case with my judeo-christian
[39:09] values that have been handed down to me, but I don't believe
[39:13] it definitionally that life is sacred.
[39:16] How? How does that sort of tie into
[39:18] all of this? Yeah.
[39:20] Well, let's examine some of those intuitions that you have
[39:22] then that are not based necessarily on faith, but just
[39:24] human instincts. So would you say you have a
[39:27] human instinct that a baby at, say, 12 weeks shouldn't be
[39:32] killed? Do you think by instinct lies
[39:36] with it always being wrong that that that shouldn't be
[39:39] impermissible? OK, and what about if that baby
[39:45] was taken out of the worm and this is really horrible, but
[39:49] what if it was like sexually molested?
[39:52] Does that seem worse to you? Or does it seem what's the
[39:55] instinct there? I mean, it's obviously worse.
[39:58] That's the instinct. And why do we think that it's
[40:01] worse to do that than to kill them?
[40:04] I would say, I mean, there are two things here.
[40:07] There's sort of the consequentialist argument of the
[40:09] ramifications of normalising that, that it would be normal to
[40:12] molest other people that are still alive.
[40:16] But there's also my intuition that's this kind of, you call it
[40:19] a deontological intuition that things in and of themselves are
[40:23] wrong. And I do possess that intuition.
[40:27] So there's a problem there, right?
[40:29] Yeah. So, yeah, I think bringing that
[40:32] analogy of kind of bringing out the worm because we don't, I can
[40:36] see for example, why people at like a very early start of life
[40:40] would say, oh, like this doesn't look like a human.
[40:42] It doesn't feel like a human there if I don't have that human
[40:44] instinct to protect it like I would, you know, Dave, my
[40:47] neighbor. And because I think if we don't
[40:50] see it or that take on that human form, we can sometimes
[40:53] just be a little bit more hesitant about what our moral
[40:56] claims are for this parent. Does it have a moral person
[40:58] head? And I think when we break down
[41:01] some of those, like, what are our assumptions in that
[41:03] situation that make it less valuable to us?
[41:06] Like is it because it isn't conscious?
[41:11] It can't sink thoughts the way that we do?
[41:13] Like, it may have brain waves at 5 weeks, but it's not thinking
[41:15] complex sarcastical thoughts. So is it that?
[41:19] Well, it's difficult because what about people who are
[41:22] sleeping? What about people who are
[41:23] knocked into a coma? You know, there's many ways in
[41:26] which people do have our human form are not don't have that
[41:30] element, and yet they don't. We don't instinctively think
[41:32] that it's OK. To I think it'd be interesting
[41:34] for people listening and watching at home just to hear
[41:36] your rebuttal to people saying, yeah, but those that are
[41:38] sleeping, those that are in a coma, they have a special human
[41:41] connection with other people. They've they've come out of the
[41:43] womb and they've kind of started, they've began their
[41:45] life. Sure.
[41:46] So then our then the kind of claim is that it's about
[41:49] relationships and not only does a child have in the womb, it
[41:54] does have a special relationship with his mother.
[41:55] It knows their mother's voice. It knows his mother's heartbeat.
[41:58] It's all that it knows. But even if that's not true,
[42:01] well, you could find a homeless man who has no relationships
[42:04] with anybody. You know, there's are we saying
[42:07] that the loneliest man on earth, and by the way, loneliness is
[42:09] incredibly prevalent probably in our society, are we saying that
[42:13] they don't count? They don't have the same human
[42:15] rights, I guess. That's a straw man because they
[42:17] would have had parents once they've had an impact on the
[42:18] world, they've they've connected with someone somehow, even if
[42:21] it's asking for them. To change.
[42:23] Those parents are dead. Who cares, right?
[42:25] Like if what what is about relationship that makes somebody
[42:29] more special than somebody else? What else?
[42:31] Those parents hated that child and they never had a good
[42:33] relationship. There's a million things that
[42:35] can happen that mean that that person is fundamentally on their
[42:38] own in this world, which a baby is not literally, literally
[42:41] inside somebody else. But I think it's hard to work
[42:45] out that argument in comparison outside of the womb.
[42:48] So again, we're kind of asking ourselves, what is it
[42:51] intuitively that makes us, you know, so horrified about killing
[42:57] a 5 year old girl that we don't have that intuitive horror.
[43:02] So it can it be, you know, consciousness?
[43:04] Well, it can't be that. Can it be a relationship?
[43:06] I don't think it can be that. Is it ability again?
[43:11] Yeah. If we're judging, if everybody
[43:12] used to claim is judging ability, then, you know, like
[43:15] this human rights don't just fall flat.
[43:17] And it's like, because they don't look like as well, you
[43:19] know, in historic times, people would go abroad to discover
[43:24] parts of the world and would find people with different
[43:26] colored skin and they'd say, oh, well, they can't be the same
[43:27] because they don't look like me, therefore they're not a member
[43:29] of my species. What about, you know, people who
[43:32] have been through horrific fire, scarring, lost limbs?
[43:35] Like there's, there isn't a claim to say that because you're
[43:39] in this kind of human form now today that you have rights and
[43:44] this other person doesn't. So when you start to unpack
[43:48] those, why you have that intuition, it does kind of just
[43:51] unveil a kind of like instinctive bias against the
[43:54] fact that we're born and they're not, which I don't think can be
[43:58] enough of a claim to say human rights don't count for these
[44:01] people. If human equality is because for
[44:03] all members of the human rights, no matter their background,
[44:06] their station in life, their this has been the principle of
[44:09] the West since like the Roman Empire is human equality.
[44:13] You don't have slaves. You don't have people who are
[44:15] worth valuable more than others, people who have more rights than
[44:18] others. If this is true, then abortion
[44:21] has to be wrong. It might seem like a horrible
[44:25] question to ask, but what? What is it that we actually
[44:29] agree upon to make those human rights a thing?
[44:32] What do we agree agreeing upon now?
[44:35] Like the basis of human rights, you mean?
[44:36] Yes. Well, I mean if you look at
[44:38] where it came from, it came out of that, the Roman Empire, which
[44:43] discarded little girls on rubbish heaps because females
[44:46] were not worth anything. Female doctors were not worth
[44:48] anything compared to their brothers and that had slavery
[44:52] and caste systems. And you know, people could be,
[44:56] it was like, I think lawful in some societies to kill your own
[44:59] children if they displeased you. You know, there we we had we
[45:02] came from roots, Pagan roots that were not respective of this
[45:07] idea of human equality. And when Christianity came in,
[45:11] that was one of the biggest changes that society ever seen.
[45:14] These ideas that the early church was teaching that
[45:18] everybody had the same form of respect and could equally be
[45:21] saved by a God completely turned at Roman society on its head and
[45:26] created this kind of stance of that developed over time that
[45:30] and was came to fruition later that slaver is on and that male
[45:33] and female had the same equality and and and rights and and basis
[45:38] for for claims in society. And that's something that we
[45:42] like you know everybody would agree now that men and women
[45:44] have are different but have equal value.
[45:47] Everybody agree that just because someone is disabled
[45:48] doesn't mean that they can be discarded.
[45:51] These are instinctive moral claims of Great Britain, of the
[45:55] West, of everything that we base our laws and expectations on.
[45:59] And yet somehow with abortion, it's we've been thrown out the
[46:04] window a little bit. We don't think this theory.
[46:06] Maybe it was because when these arguments being happened were
[46:09] happening last century, we didn't have all the medical data
[46:12] to show life in the moment. Maybe we just weren't familiar
[46:14] enough with the scientific evidence.
[46:16] But now we have the hard facts and we have to take a hard look
[46:21] at it and say if this is wrong, we have to stop it.
[46:23] If this is incoherent with the rest of our society, then we
[46:27] have to rethink this. Let's get down to the bedrock of
[46:31] this, the Roman Empire discarding little girls
[46:34] throwings rubbish heaps. That's horrible, that's
[46:37] disgusting. But let's separate our emotions
[46:40] from this for a second. Their empires managed to
[46:43] flourish. They managed to conquer.
[46:45] I'm sure a lot of them felt a lot more fulfilled than you
[46:47] know. Yeah, until the end.
[46:48] That's that's another conversation tab.
[46:51] I'm sure they felt a lot more fulfilled a lot of them than a
[46:53] lot of people do nowadays. But they had this kind of we, we
[47:00] have this emotive response to the fact that there were slaves
[47:03] and that there was the distarting of these people.
[47:07] That emotional instinct. I trust that and I rely on that
[47:12] and I act within the paradigm of that instinct.
[47:16] But there's nothing really grounding that for me that says
[47:19] anything more than this is emotion.
[47:23] Is that a fair analysis that this is just an emotional thing?
[47:26] Because I think if it is, then it opens up the possibility also
[47:30] for pro-choice to be a valid option sometimes, unless there
[47:33] isn't an objective thing grounding this.
[47:36] Yeah. So I guess if you work out then
[47:40] the other consequences of this though, so say that say that the
[47:44] human rights framework, if you don't have, I mean it is based
[47:48] on Christian principles. So say you don't have Christian
[47:50] principles and humanist framework is just floating and
[47:52] it has no basis. And therefore, there might be
[47:55] examples where abortion's OK. Unfortunately, that also opens
[47:59] up a million other things that might also be OK.
[48:02] In that scenario, it might be OK to kill somebody because they're
[48:07] sick and at the end of their life.
[48:08] It might be OK to kill someone because they're lonely at the
[48:10] end of their life. It might be OK to cook someone
[48:12] because they're lonely. It might be OK to cook someone
[48:15] because they're lonely. It might be OK to kill someone
[48:18] because they're disabled. It might be OK to strip someone
[48:20] of their rights because they can't process what's happening
[48:23] to them in the same way that another human being could.
[48:26] There's so many avenues that disintegrate into things that
[48:29] morally and objectively, it'd be very difficult to say that you
[48:33] do support and are OK with. I don't know about objectively,
[48:36] but morally. Certainly so morally.
[48:39] So there's a once you start to unpick what makes a human being
[48:45] hold moral value, once you've unpicked abortion, it's very
[48:49] hard to stop that Cypress slab. It's very hard to say what
[48:52] because because an unborn human is like this, they're different
[48:57] because there are other examples as well outside the one which
[49:00] are the same. So, and I think we actually do
[49:03] see that in our society as we've adopted a very pro abortion
[49:06] culture. And we have also seen the
[49:08] introduction of killing at the end of life as well, haven't we?
[49:11] In the UK in the last few weeks, but also in Canada, you know,
[49:13] you see these horrible stories in the Canadian Daily Mail about
[49:17] citizens being killed because they simply couldn't afford
[49:19] forward their medical bills and they thought that that was not a
[49:21] life worth living. What is a life worth living?
[49:24] If it isn't that it's all humans, then it'd be getting to
[49:28] very picky territory. And, and how, how could you
[49:32] personally make that claim for everybody?
[49:35] How can you decide this is what counts?
[49:38] This is what doesn't? And and if not you, then who?
[49:41] Who should decide? The government, They decide who,
[49:43] who holds human rights and who doesn't.
[49:45] Very, very difficult territory. Well, who?
[49:48] How are you deciding that? Because I'm saying that human,
[49:52] because I'm saying all humans hold human rights, because I'm
[49:55] saying all humans have a claim to equality.
[49:58] We have that protection. It isn't based on an object or a
[50:03] subjective factor that I've decided make someone a more
[50:05] client. Who has decided it?
[50:07] Because it's it's what being a member of the human race just
[50:11] biologically, but. Who's decided that?
[50:13] Well, this, it's that or you have to make a decision about
[50:16] what and where you see as I, I mean, you could say nobody, I
[50:19] suppose, but that's pretty dangerous for us on our survival
[50:23] instinct. And if you say you can either
[50:25] say everybody or nobody, but if you say some, then you have to
[50:28] make incredibly different difficult subjective decisions.
[50:31] And if not you, then somebody has to.
[50:33] And that somebody, you, maybe you agree with them, maybe you
[50:36] don't, but it's not going to be a a safe society isn't.
[50:40] No. And, and I think this is what
[50:41] I'm grappling with here. I so far, I'm not convinced play
[50:47] any objective grounding to all of this, but the slippery slope
[50:50] argument is convincing. I mean, you see it with
[50:53] euthanasia now you see it with assisted suicide.
[50:56] The people are saying that's OK, and that's a whole other rabbit
[51:01] hole to go down. But you see that the slippery
[51:03] slope is unfolding, but there's still this question of the, of,
[51:07] of truth. And at the moment the slippery
[51:10] slope argument it is, it's a pragmatic 1.
[51:13] So that's the argument I'm making for pro-choice too.
[51:15] That's a pragmatic argument. We can rely on this intuition
[51:20] that we won't kill people that are outside of the women.
[51:23] We have laws to protect against that.
[51:25] I think they're both equally subjective worldviews and I have
[51:30] no way to square this circle without God in my opinion.
[51:34] I just don't because I I I can't believe that life is sacred and
[51:38] that there is something objective.
[51:40] So then I am relying on this subjective slippery slope
[51:43] argument myself that if we prioritise life at all costs,
[51:47] where does that stop? Well, where?
[51:50] Where would you have it stop? This is the question where would
[51:57] I have it stop? What do you mean where would I
[52:01] have it stop? Festival, if you're asking, you
[52:03] know, where do we stop protecting life?
[52:05] Where do you think we should stop protecting life?
[52:07] What is your? What do you mean by that?
[52:11] This is the problem that I have because I my intuitions that I
[52:13] rely on, I'm not willing to say we should kill disabled kids
[52:18] outside of the womb. I I think that's disgusting.
[52:20] But what I'm trying to do is ground this in something.
[52:24] Frankly, my intuitions could be wrong.
[52:27] That's the fact of it. Now you can ask me, but do you
[52:32] act that way? I, I don't act that way.
[52:34] I act as though my intuitions are true, but I still haven't
[52:38] been killing anything that tells me that these intuitions are
[52:40] true. We, we could go down a slippery
[52:42] slope of killing disabled kids, of bringing back the Third Reich
[52:46] and the things that went on there.
[52:47] And, and it's disgusting. It's horrible, it's a nightmare.
[52:51] I oppose this greatly and I don't live my life like this in
[52:55] any way. And in fact, the intuitions I I
[52:57] hold don't even reflect this. But there's still nothing that
[53:02] grounds this. Would you consider it grounded
[53:04] in like biological reality, The fact that like from conception,
[53:11] a sperm and I come together, It is a unique human person that
[53:16] has never existed before and it will never exist again.
[53:18] It's not its mum, it's not his dad, it's nobody else's body,
[53:21] it's his own body. And from that moment it develops
[53:25] throughout his life, through the time in the womb, time as a
[53:29] baby, toddler, child, teenager, adult.
[53:31] It develops the whole way through, changing consistently
[53:34] but and holds the same intrinsic DNA that make it that human
[53:42] being that is a different human being to you.
[53:45] Is that something that is chiming with your intuitions?
[53:48] Is that something that helps you to base them in reality?
[53:52] Yeah, definitely. I mean, I mean, that's all true.
[53:56] That's objectively true. They've never been in existence
[53:58] before. Sperm meets the egg.
[54:00] It's all true. Where do we go from here?
[54:06] Right. So I mean, if that is the
[54:08] biological facts and we're, we like biological facts, we like
[54:12] truth, we like facing our our intuitions on truth.
[54:14] So we know that to be true. We know that biology to be
[54:16] grounded in biological fact. Who cares what religion or
[54:20] culture you come from? This is just true.
[54:22] And if that is true, then what are the implications if we think
[54:26] that human beings, for example, are different to animals, like
[54:28] we eat pigs, but we don't eat our sister.
[54:31] So if we think that they have a different status and people
[54:35] don't like the word sacred, that's fine.
[54:36] Call it special, you know, call it human beings have a unique,
[54:41] special, different status. And this is a human being.
[54:45] And so we don't, we, we don't kill it, we protect it.
[54:47] We find ways to support our fellow human being in life,
[54:53] whether that's a mother carrying that child, whether that's a
[54:57] community or a grandparent rallying around and giving
[54:59] support to help that child to flourish and grow in the womb
[55:03] and out these. That's if you bring it down to
[55:06] its baseline level of what truth is based on.
[55:09] It's based because it's a human being and we respect other human
[55:12] beings. Well, I feel like there's a
[55:14] gradient of specialness. I'd argue that other animals are
[55:17] special too, and that there's nothing that specifically
[55:21] separates us in another category of specialness from animals.
[55:26] But now I have to become vegan. You know, but what?
[55:30] Yeah, but you do eat other animals, right?
[55:31] But you don't eat other humans. No, I don't.
[55:34] OK, not at the moment. So we do have like some sort of.
[55:37] Yes, but what I'm saying is that's an intuition that could
[55:40] have evolved and it it's potentially based off of
[55:43] emotion. Whereas actually like, what is
[55:46] it other than God making man and giving him dominion over all
[55:51] animals and everything that crawls that separates us in
[55:54] specialness from those animals really when we break it down?
[55:57] So I think you can get to the pro-life stance based on
[56:02] biological reality, but I also think faith affirms it.
[56:05] And maybe that missing piece for you is that that that's true.
[56:10] Maybe that indelible mark on all human beings that they are
[56:13] created and that there is a God and they are they have this
[56:17] available sense of worth. Maybe that is your missing
[56:19] piece. That's what time's true to you
[56:20] because you've got there on other bases of human kind of
[56:24] instinct bases. And also, you know that it is
[56:27] based on true fact. There's nothing that's tangibly
[56:30] countering against your intuitions.
[56:32] So these seem to be pointing to something that's true.
[56:35] Yeah, maybe it is. OK.
[56:40] I want us to wrap up on the future of legislation,
[56:44] specifically what's going on politically, culturally.
[56:48] You're out on the streets a lot doing some activism.
[56:50] What? What are you seeing more
[56:51] broadly? Yeah, I actually am encouraged
[56:54] right now, which seems counterintuitive because a
[56:57] couple of weeks ago we decriminalized abortion to birth
[57:00] in certain circumstances, which feels like a huge death now to
[57:04] the pro-life movement. But I've never seen bigger
[57:07] backlash amongst the British people.
[57:09] I've never seen people so outraged, people that have never
[57:12] come forward with with public pro-life views before or saying
[57:14] this is way too far. I've seen people on talk TV call
[57:18] it baby killing, which I've never seen on any TV station
[57:20] ever in my life. And it is when we take abortion
[57:24] to that extreme and say it's OK all the way up to the day of
[57:27] birth, we all just know that's wrong.
[57:30] And I think that we needed this wake up call in the UK now this
[57:33] is one in three women are undergoing this.
[57:35] And by the way, the data on what abortion does to women is
[57:38] horrific. There's a pro-choice scholar in
[57:39] Australia. He's passed away now David
[57:41] Ferguson. He found that it increase drug
[57:44] abuse by like 70%, suicidality by another, you know, hundreds
[57:49] of percentage points. Again, anxiety, depression, the
[57:53] amount of harm that is caused on women as well as babies, of
[57:57] course, and men who are involved as well is horrific.
[58:00] I think we're starting to see that.
[58:01] We're starting to see that we don't, we're not all fully
[58:05] pro-choice because we can't all accept up to birth and beyond
[58:08] birth. So we do all draw the line
[58:10] somewhere and I think it's time to have that conversation, that
[58:13] really open and hard conversation of where do we draw
[58:16] the line? Now, we all know that I have a
[58:18] very like fully approached life and I respect that.
[58:20] Not everybody does. But we do have to have the
[58:22] honest conversation with us, like where is it and why?
[58:25] And if we can't decide why or when, maybe we have to rethink
[58:31] the whole thing. Yeah.
[58:32] And I think that was one of the biggest takeaways from preparing
[58:35] to speak to you today and really looking into the horrible
[58:38] details of this, is that I really do hope we can reach a
[58:43] point where we universally agree that abortion is certainly not
[58:47] ideal, to make a very British understatement, and that we
[58:51] should be moving away from it at all cost, at not at all cost,
[58:55] but but you know, we we should certainly be trying hard.
[58:59] And I agree, from what I've seen anecdotally amongst my female
[59:03] friends, even though a lot of them are having abortions,
[59:07] they're not going out and celebrating the fact that
[59:09] they've killed this baby, killed this human.
[59:12] There is this awareness. And from what I've seen before,
[59:16] I mean, again, this is the online world, so everything's
[59:18] polarized and extreme, but it seems that a couple of decades
[59:22] ago it wasn't the same, that there's this stronger intuition
[59:25] now. I agree this is not a good.
[59:27] Thing it's not the way it's meant to be yeah and so as we
[59:31] have that recognition hopefully we can work out policies but
[59:34] also community projects and systems where we can better
[59:39] protect and care for mothers and babies to go through this
[59:42] horrific episodes that that far fewer and hopefully in the
[59:45] future no woman has to undergo this and every child's life is
[59:48] protected I. Feel like mothers are so under
[59:53] noticed in our modern culture. I mean even I'm speaking to
[59:56] Stephen Jay Shaw later about depopulation and a key piece of
[1:00:00] this is that mums just aren't supported in any way, be it
[1:00:04] immediately following birth or even even later and before.
[1:00:07] It seems like this problem that we just can't wrap our heads
[1:00:11] around and no one really cares about.
[1:00:12] Which is. Crazy to me that should be like
[1:00:15] #1. I know it just doesn't fit the
[1:00:17] narrative that we've been sold right, Because I mean, we're
[1:00:20] about sexual revolution. We got abortion, we got the
[1:00:22] pill, we got freedom. This is supposed to be our
[1:00:24] freedom era. We're supposed to be having a
[1:00:26] great time. We're supposed to be being the
[1:00:27] CEO boss babe, the no, no man can hold us back.
[1:00:31] No kids can hold us back. And actually, what that's really
[1:00:33] translated for most women is how to, you know, sit nine to five
[1:00:37] in an office cubicle job with your kids in daycare and or, you
[1:00:40] know, not getting married until 38 because you were told that
[1:00:44] you didn't want to. And then you suddenly got, you
[1:00:46] know, to later in life and realized you've missed out on
[1:00:48] this great opportunity all along.
[1:00:50] It's feminism has failed women, that's for sure.
[1:00:52] And abortion and all these other consequences of that have just
[1:00:57] proved that and caused immense harm in, you know, proliferating
[1:01:03] across the generations at this point.
[1:01:04] But I do have hope when I see, I think Genzi are starting to come
[1:01:07] on to the lies that we've been told.
[1:01:10] And it's starting to push back and say, hang on, maybe, maybe
[1:01:13] there's something wrong here. Maybe women do have a different
[1:01:16] trajectory. Maybe we do want something
[1:01:18] better, something more. And maybe that does involve
[1:01:20] having husband and kids and and not being, you know, GDP
[1:01:25] training horses in the office every day.
[1:01:26] So, yeah. And let's see.
[1:01:27] What happens to just about afford your child's daycare and
[1:01:30] then working some more? Why do you think there is that
[1:01:32] double standard where we're said we're told that women should
[1:01:37] have choice, but then they don't have the choice to become
[1:01:39] mothers? It's looked down on.
[1:01:41] I know, well, in the 90s, I think a lot of governments kind
[1:01:45] of conned on to the fact that they could get a lot more tax
[1:01:47] from women who were in the workplace.
[1:01:49] And we kind of had this shift where my mom kind of was in
[1:01:53] there because I was born in 95. Sorry, I'm kind of old.
[1:01:56] And my mom was a stay at home mom.
[1:01:57] And that was quite common. But more and more moms were
[1:02:00] going back to work. And now it's very, very common.
[1:02:02] But I think it's 66% of women in the UK with, with children under
[1:02:06] 3. We'd like more time at home.
[1:02:08] So this isn't actually something it's touted as a feminist win,
[1:02:11] like, oh, we can be back in the workplace.
[1:02:13] But actually for most women, it's not a win.
[1:02:15] They'd much rather be nurturing the next generation.
[1:02:18] It'd be much better for children if they had their moms at home
[1:02:21] with them, taking care of them instead of being stuck in a
[1:02:23] daycare with like, you know, three staff to however many
[1:02:27] babies and not getting that skin, skin to skin contact, not
[1:02:31] getting that nurturing 1 to one attention that they need to
[1:02:35] deserve as little children. Yeah.
[1:02:38] I mean, the system's obviously broken and that's that element
[1:02:42] of womanhood has not been prioritized, I suppose, because
[1:02:44] it just seems old fashioned. But how can something seem old
[1:02:47] fashioned when it's dependent for the the human race to
[1:02:50] survive? I mean, technically it is old
[1:02:52] fashioned. It's very, very.
[1:02:53] Old fashioned, it's forever. Yeah, exactly.
[1:02:56] So yeah, I I'm glad to see that there was a resistance against
[1:02:59] that. You know, when Rachel Ziegler
[1:03:00] made her comments about Prince Charming not being necessary for
[1:03:03] Snow White, there was huge backlash.
[1:03:05] It was backlash and conversations happening around
[1:03:07] the Barbie movie when this kind of cultural moment of feminism
[1:03:10] was touted as well. And so I do think there's a big
[1:03:14] wake up call happening at the moment, umm, to younger women
[1:03:17] who are seeing that maybe happiness doesn't lie in an
[1:03:19] office cubicle. It can people.
[1:03:21] Some women will really enjoy their work and that's absolutely
[1:03:24] fine and they deserve the. Freedom to pursue that.
[1:03:26] Absolutely, but for most women, they don't have careers.
[1:03:29] They have jobs and actually would rather, yeah, meaning and
[1:03:32] fulfillment from their lives and the way that women for
[1:03:34] generations have had meaning and film their lives and being
[1:03:37] enjoying motherhood, enjoying taking care of their children
[1:03:40] and, yeah, allowing this kind of family to flourish.
[1:03:43] What would your advice be to a Gen.
[1:03:46] Z girl who's watching this and she's living in the world of
[1:03:51] boss bitches? She wants to climb the career
[1:03:53] ladder. How does she navigate that
[1:03:57] whilst also making sure she has enough time to have kids?
[1:04:00] All the stats point to I think it's 80% of women that want
[1:04:03] kids, 10% can't have them, 10% of them don't want them.
[1:04:07] So most women want kids, yet not all of them are having them
[1:04:11] because they're getting to the point where they're 30.
[1:04:13] Yeah, they're saying, OK, a couple of more years.
[1:04:15] I I still want to work for my career.
[1:04:17] Yeah. 323436 rolls on. They find the right man, and
[1:04:21] suddenly and suddenly they can't have kids.
[1:04:22] What would your advice be? Yeah, I think the best piece of
[1:04:25] advice that I was given is that women cannot have it all, but
[1:04:29] they can have different bits of it at different points.
[1:04:31] So you can't easily be ACEO and a mother of a newborn baby and a
[1:04:37] superwoman. You can't do it all at once, but
[1:04:40] you have different points of your lives and you don't.
[1:04:42] There's this pressure, I think PROC, because of the way the
[1:04:44] education system is set up, that we go straight to university at
[1:04:46] 18 and we go straight into the conveyor belt for career.
[1:04:48] It's felt that you need to be maximizing career right at the
[1:04:52] start, and you can, but you also can be really fruitful and
[1:04:58] successful in your career in your 40s and 50s.
[1:05:00] People forget that, I think. And there's this pressure to get
[1:05:02] it all done now and to put the family off to later.
[1:05:05] But the family is much more difficult later, whereas the
[1:05:08] career you can come back to. So I think, you know, enjoy
[1:05:12] building your career if that's what you want to do.
[1:05:13] There's nothing intrinsically wrong if you love your work and
[1:05:16] you want to enjoy it. But don't sacrifice
[1:05:19] relationships. Don't sacrifice finding a great
[1:05:22] husband who's can support you. Don't sacrifice having kids for
[1:05:25] the sake of that because you can pick it up again later.
[1:05:27] So find that kind of life rhythm that will allow you to do to
[1:05:31] flourish in different ways at different points.
[1:05:34] Yeah, it's an interesting point to bring up.
[1:05:36] And I did some public interviews in America last week in Denver,
[1:05:39] Co and I spoke to young Gen. Z girls about this and I kind of
[1:05:44] asked them, you do you want kids?
[1:05:45] And yeah, of course I want kids. So I want a couple kids.
[1:05:48] I want 3 kids. Like, okay, what age do you want
[1:05:50] kids? And be like maybe 32.
[1:05:53] So. OK, so you, you want to be
[1:05:55] married probably before you have kids.
[1:05:57] Yeah. Yeah.
[1:05:57] I want to be married for about two years.
[1:05:59] OK. Yeah, Yeah.
[1:06:00] And then you're going to be engaged for about a year.
[1:06:02] OK. So we're at 29 now.
[1:06:04] You need to start looking for that man or you need to be
[1:06:06] dating him before you're engaged.
[1:06:07] That's another two years. You're going to be 27.
[1:06:08] Then you need to find the man. And suddenly it's a 26 year old
[1:06:13] that realizes that they should have started looking for him
[1:06:14] when they were 24. I think it's just not kind of
[1:06:19] realizing the bigger picture. And that's part of kind of
[1:06:22] bigger things going on that we've been sold a lie in terms
[1:06:24] of what will bring us happiness, both men and women, by the way.
[1:06:28] So we need to, we need to root it out.
[1:06:30] And I think now's the time to do that.
[1:06:31] Otherwise, it's going to be too late.
[1:06:33] Yeah, that's, well, that's been the pattern for the kind of
[1:06:36] millennials, isn't it, that we have seen.
[1:06:38] And you know, Khloe Kardashian, for those who follow, talked
[1:06:43] about and in a recent interview, she, I think she's in her, she's
[1:06:46] 40 now. And she was having a cycle of
[1:06:47] IVF. And most people think that it's
[1:06:49] fine. I'll get to my late 30s and 40s,
[1:06:52] I'll have my IVF. It will be absolutely fine.
[1:06:54] A lot of a huge percentage. But I think it's only a third of
[1:06:57] the effect at me on that of times that IVF cycles actually
[1:07:00] are successful. It's immensely expensive and it
[1:07:02] takes a huge toll on a woman's body.
[1:07:03] And Chloe talked about how she didn't realize how like painful
[1:07:06] and and horrid it was going to be as to go through this.
[1:07:10] And so we just have this psychology of like, we can kick
[1:07:12] it down the road and there's all these medical interventions and
[1:07:15] cycle things that can kick in, but don't rely on that.
[1:07:19] Absolutely not. There's, it's great to find a
[1:07:23] partner when you're young. It's great to find somebody with
[1:07:25] similar values. You can grow together and being
[1:07:27] married is awesome. Like it's so much fun.
[1:07:30] You get to like do all the exciting things you're doing,
[1:07:33] but you do it with your best friend.
[1:07:36] So don't feel that you have to sacrifice these awesome things
[1:07:38] in life, like getting married and having kids just for a
[1:07:41] career that is not going to love you and keep you warm and, and
[1:07:44] be there for you when you're having a hard day and that you
[1:07:47] can pick up later in life. So my encouragement is just
[1:07:52] don't freak out about it, but get cracking.
[1:07:56] So with the IVF, the success rates, they're not fixed, but
[1:07:59] 5060% for under 35. But the problem is that no one's
[1:08:04] under. 35. Doing it so once you get into
[1:08:06] your late 30s, it drops 25 to 30%.
[1:08:09] Yeah, that's right. Which is wild.
[1:08:11] Wild, I know. And governments are touting as
[1:08:15] anyone in Scotland, governments are really touting kind of IVF
[1:08:18] and egg donation and things as a big solution to the fertility
[1:08:22] crisis. And what they should be touting
[1:08:25] is encouraging and helping couples to get married.
[1:08:27] There's no support for couples to get married in the UK.
[1:08:29] You don't get, you basically get no like tax benefit.
[1:08:32] You get no housing benefit. You're nothing.
[1:08:34] Imagine a government that actually supported young couples
[1:08:37] to get married, to be able to find a house, to be able to have
[1:08:41] kids, and you know, supported a mom to stay at home for a few
[1:08:45] years instead of just cutting her her maternity leave short
[1:08:49] and encouraging her to get back into the workplace as their
[1:08:51] feminist policy. Imagine a government that just
[1:08:53] imagined this differently and allowed couples to get married
[1:08:56] younger and encouraged that how society would be so different
[1:09:01] and especially how beneficial that would be for children
[1:09:03] growing up with married parents when you have so much data
[1:09:05] support, the incredible benefits that that has and the great
[1:09:10] inequalities that that has for children who don't benefit from
[1:09:12] having married parents. So if the government had could
[1:09:15] just be a bit more creative in its thinking and consider some
[1:09:18] of these ideals that family is the bedrock of society, that men
[1:09:23] and women both flourish when they're in that kind of stable
[1:09:25] relationship. And kids do so much better in
[1:09:28] terms of not being involved in crime, doing better at school,
[1:09:30] more likely to go university, all of these statistics.
[1:09:33] That is something that would be incredible to drive towards.
[1:09:36] But unfortunately, I suppose because it seemed to be
[1:09:38] conservative or it seemed to be too old fashioned, we never
[1:09:41] quite get it to the place that it would be actually able to be
[1:09:44] there to help society. Lois Mcclatchy Miller, thanks
[1:09:47] for coming on The Next Generation.
[1:09:49] Thank you. I hope you don't hate me too
[1:09:51] much after this conversation. I've, I've enjoyed it.
[1:09:53] I think it's been, it's been useful to, to flesh these ideas
[1:09:56] out and sort of to bring awareness to anyone in, in Gen.
[1:09:59] Z, whatever their orientation on, on the, the abortion debate.
[1:10:03] Yeah, absolutely. Thanks for chatting.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
