# Experiment: Can Humans Predict The Future? - Andrew Hartz

An episode of [The Next Generation](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1772698742), 23 Jul 2025, 15 min.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/107851968/podcast/play/105898098/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2025-6-23%2F404421012-44100-2-a48f8fa36806d.mp3

Andrew Hartz dives into the Psy Phenomena and how it could explain our consciousness, or, hint at our ability as humans to predict the future...

## Transcript

[0:00] Let's move away from that beautiful advice, OK?
[0:03] Something that we spoke about over dinner at ARC last year or
[0:07] earlier this year, and it just absolutely messed with my mind.
[0:12] It's been on my mind non-stop since we spoke.
[0:15] OK? I want us to mess with the
[0:17] audience's mind as well. So lay out to me what is side
[0:22] phenomena? OK, I'm, I'm super, I told you I
[0:25] was super hesitant to, to, to talk about this topic.
[0:28] I'm not a researcher on SI phenomena.
[0:31] It broadly, it's broadly related to ESP and it, it, it basically,
[0:35] I think what's ESP people that's extrasensory perception,
[0:40] basically, maybe an easier way. It's basically anything that's
[0:44] psychic is what people would say.
[0:47] And there's a, there's a, you know, technical definition of
[0:50] it, but I think for our purposes, it's like the ability
[0:53] to predict events in the future or read other people's minds or
[0:56] communicate non locally, you know, from one part of the world
[1:01] to another, somebody on the other side of the world or
[1:03] something like that. So it's, it's that type of
[1:05] thing. And there's, and the thing that
[1:07] was was the focus of our conversation is that there's way
[1:11] more research on this than people think and way more
[1:15] significant findings in research on this than people think.
[1:18] Now, maybe that's because there's just bad research
[1:23] findings across the field, and it's much easier to fake and
[1:28] force significant findings than people think.
[1:30] But if that's true, we should really question a ton of
[1:36] research in the field. Maybe that's the answer.
[1:38] It's all bullshit. But if it's not, to the extent
[1:42] that the research process is valid, there's a lot here that's
[1:48] worth contending with. And and there have been some
[1:51] people who have really advocated on this issue.
[1:54] The most famous is Daryl Bem, who's at Cornell, a psychologist
[1:58] at Cornell who's done a lot of studies in this area that got
[2:02] had meaningful significant findings.
[2:04] And I, you know, I just know what everybody else knows, which
[2:07] is that these have been published and the methodology on
[2:11] papers, correct? And the findings are not just
[2:16] statistically significant, they have meaningful effect sizes.
[2:19] And this literature exists. That was the bottom line of it.
[2:24] OK, so layout some of these studies.
[2:27] You spoke to me about a computer simulation that initially
[2:31] started off with cards. Yes, so Jung did.
[2:35] AI, please take this with a grain of salt because I didn't
[2:39] prepare in advance to talk about this subject, but my
[2:43] understanding is that Jung started with a, a study where
[2:46] there were cards that had four symbols on them.
[2:50] And I think other research, it wasn't just young, others did
[2:52] too. It was square, circle, triangle
[2:55] and star, I think were the four shapes.
[2:57] And so you just have a you just flip the cards one after the
[3:01] other and you right before you flip, you have the person
[3:04] predict what's the next card going to be.
[3:06] And so you give it a really good shuffle and then you just have
[3:09] them do this, you know, hundreds of times, maybe thousands of
[3:11] times if it's pure trance, which is what you'd guess the person
[3:18] is going to be right pretty close to 25% of the time.
[3:22] So the, the, the prediction is that they're going to get it
[3:26] right 25% of the time, very close to, I mean, if you do
[3:29] 1000, it's going to be pretty close to 25%.
[3:33] And what they were finding was that people were getting this
[3:37] right a bit higher than 25%. And I get what I remember was
[3:42] that it was close. It was about 29%, which was an
[3:48] absurd kind of frustrating but weird finding.
[3:51] But it was enough to say, you know, I'm sorry if you do this,
[3:55] if you have a, if you have hundreds of participants each
[3:58] doing it thousands of times. And the mean after all that is
[4:03] 29%. That's a big deal.
[4:05] That's, that's not something that can happen through through
[4:08] error. Now there are other things maybe
[4:13] the, maybe the they're not shuffling.
[4:16] It's hard to, it's hard to come up with a good explanation of
[4:18] how the researcher is going to fake this outside of fraud.
[4:22] But maybe, maybe there's different ways that they're
[4:24] putting their thumb on the scale, even people who are very
[4:27] critical of this. And now this is done through a
[4:29] computer simulation. So it's a random simulator.
[4:32] It'll just generate different numbers and or different,
[4:35] different shapes and the person predicts.
[4:38] But even people have been very critical.
[4:40] They've said, well, what do you think the specific thing is that
[4:43] they're getting wrong and they've struggled.
[4:46] They said, you know, we don't know what it is, but it must be
[4:49] something. At least that's my understanding
[4:53] of of of of one of the critiques of these the other, the other
[4:58] interesting critique. I mean there there's there's
[5:00] some really obvious critiques of this that are worth airing. 1 is
[5:03] if people can predict things better than chance, you would
[5:08] expect that to show up at casinos, which is a totally
[5:12] reasonable thing to say. Why doesn't this happen at
[5:14] casinos now? The response was again, as as I
[5:20] understood it was that when they do these studies, they have
[5:25] people in like noise cancelling rooms wearing like noise
[5:28] cancelling headphones and the sensory isolation of stimulation
[5:32] is crucial to the effect. So that if you're in a very
[5:36] noisy, cluttered, high activity environment, the effect is
[5:41] drowned out by the distractions or something.
[5:44] Like being in a casino. Like being in a casino so that
[5:46] if the if the casinos allowed you to do to gamble with noise
[5:51] cancelling headphones in private areas, they would lose or
[5:55] something. It was, was the proposal, but
[5:59] you know, you know, so I, I get why people think it's far
[6:03] fetched, but the methodology is consistent And they, they are
[6:08] there was very famously in 2017, there was a literature review of
[6:13] a few different meta analysis that were done of this research
[6:20] that they, you know, they had, they had meta analysis that
[6:24] showed an, a significant effect. And it was published in the
[6:27] American Psychologist, which is generally considered the top
[6:30] American psychology journal. So it, it got in there and it
[6:35] was a review of meta analysis and stirred an enormous amount
[6:40] of controversy. And but the, the, the, the
[6:44] interesting, you know, there's different ways of framing it,
[6:47] framing the discussion. One is to say that the critics
[6:53] are being overly, they're treating this too harshly.
[6:56] If this were studies of anything else that would have accepted
[6:58] the findings now. And so they're, they're holding
[7:02] it to a different standard. And their critiques are a little
[7:05] bit frustrating in the sense that they say, well, we don't
[7:07] know what the problem with the study is, but there must be 1
[7:11] that that's, that is a frustrating thing to say, you
[7:14] know, but well, what do we have? What could we possibly do to win
[7:16] you over? Apparently nothing, because we
[7:18] can have a study that you can't critique and you still say it's
[7:20] wrong. It fundamentally goes against
[7:22] what science is all about. It which should be following the
[7:25] data presumably. On the other hand, you know, you
[7:31] could say that these, these are very striking claims and they
[7:36] need very striking support. And the casino question, I mean,
[7:41] they have a nice answer to it, but it, I, I don't know that
[7:45] most people think that a quiet casino would lose money, but
[7:53] that's, that's the theory. Well, what is the claim then?
[7:58] If these studies are consistent, the methodology is consistent,
[8:03] there are no errors in the research, what's the claim?
[8:09] The claim consciousness, we don't know what consciousness is
[8:15] and it you know, and we have these the problem of
[8:22] consciousness, you know what is thought, you know, an old model
[8:27] would say you hit your brain is made-up of neurons.
[8:29] They're a particular type of cell and when they get triggered
[8:32] at one end of the cell, they send what's called an action
[8:35] potential from one end to the cell the other.
[8:38] Basically in a rapid period of time, like 1/10 of a second, a
[8:43] bunch of one type of ion gets pumped into the cell and a bunch
[8:45] of other, another type of ion gets pumped out and it sends
[8:48] this electrochemical charge that goes from one end of the neuron
[8:50] to the next and then that will trigger the adjacent neurons.
[8:56] So when these neurons are triggered in the brain, there's
[9:02] something about this electrochemical process that
[9:04] produces a thought and a thought is a non material entity or
[9:10] thing that is then produced from this neurological reaction.
[9:19] But why? Why do we produce thoughts?
[9:21] You know, if we're really machines, we don't need
[9:24] thoughts. We're just carrying out
[9:26] mechanical stuff. But is there nothing there that
[9:29] shows where the thought is? Is it not something physical
[9:32] that you can just? Trace back we know where.
[9:34] It will change. We know where action potentials
[9:37] you can, you can see when neurons are firing action
[9:40] potentials. But where's the thought you
[9:46] know? Is it?
[9:46] Is it producing the thought? Is it is the neuron, is it this?
[9:51] It's not the same thing as a thought.
[9:53] A neuron isn't the same neuron reaction isn't the same thing as
[9:56] a thought. So what is a thought and what's
[9:58] producing it? Where does it come from?
[10:00] And so one theory is we are just machines and thought is what's
[10:06] called an it's an epiphenomena. It just, it's just steam coming
[10:10] off of the machine. And it's basically this kind of
[10:13] weird by product of the body, but ultimately has no effect on
[10:17] anything. Now that's a very strange theory
[10:20] to think that probably the most interesting thing our bodies do
[10:23] is create these thoughts. That's that's the most
[10:25] interesting, mysterious and fascinating thing that the body
[10:29] would do. And yet they don't.
[10:31] These thoughts are totally pointless and they don't affect
[10:33] anything. That's very strange.
[10:35] Why would we evolve a capacity for that?
[10:39] On the other hand, if the thoughts then do something, you
[10:43] have to pause it. Basically a non material entity
[10:46] of a mind that would receive thoughts from the brain, process
[10:50] them somehow and then will thoughts and behaviors back onto
[10:54] the body. Now that non material mind that
[10:57] you've just proposed that makes thoughts meaningful looks a lot
[11:01] like a soul. It's a non material living
[11:03] entity that's basically you that receives information from the
[11:07] body and wills back through the body.
[11:10] So now you have a model that's a soul and it's basically a
[11:13] religious model and you get why people are uncomfortable with
[11:17] that. So we there's all kinds of other
[11:22] infinite theories of what thought is and where it comes
[11:25] from, but we don't know. And it's inherently hard to
[11:28] measure because you can't isolate the thoughts and measure
[11:30] them. You can look at the brain.
[11:35] So what is this stuff of thought?
[11:37] And it seems to some people, maybe it's not nothing.
[11:43] Maybe it's it is something and maybe it can operate
[11:47] independently from the body. Maybe it's even independently
[11:50] from from time to an extent and that it can see what a shape
[11:54] might be in a few seconds. And so this would indicate that
[12:01] thought is something more than just a brain product and that
[12:04] it's actually a very meaningful entity or substance in itself.
[12:10] And the theory isn't, you know, you know, in terms of its
[12:15] consistency, it's it's an it's an internally consistent theory
[12:19] of how consciousness would work. But it's a big claim and it, it,
[12:29] I, I think it claims like that do require significant evidence.
[12:34] But you know, the other side of it is we just don't know if we
[12:36] don't know what consciousness is so.
[12:39] And it's just this irritating 29.
[12:42] It's not as if it's like 63 or 44 or even 37 where it's like,
[12:47] yeah, something's going on here. Well, there we can clearly
[12:51] predict the future in some capacity as humans well.
[12:55] I, I, I am, I wouldn't think that there would be, you know,
[13:01] there was one guy, his name is Rupert Sheldrake, very famous, a
[13:06] Brit and he. Sounds very British.
[13:09] Yes, and he thought that, you know, which makes sense to me
[13:14] that you're your ability to see things like ESP type things,
[13:19] psychic things is related to them being emotionally or
[13:22] interpersonally significant. You know, a a random shape on a
[13:26] computer screen has no relevance.
[13:29] And that that that would seem to be a very hard thing to predict
[13:32] as opposed to something like a family member is in danger.
[13:38] That would be the type of thing where I would think that would
[13:42] be more meaningful. So it's it's it's such an
[13:46] arbitrary thing to pick a shape one second in the future.
[13:53] But yeah, we don't we don't. I mean, I, I think, well, it
[13:57] might surprise people how especially given how atheistic
[14:01] and and agnostic psychiatrists and psychologists are.
[14:04] What was some of the most the least religious profession
[14:07] really and and how many of them believe in this stuff and
[14:12] including like William James really was support a very famous
[14:15] psychologist really wanted to study this stuff.
[14:17] Freud studied this stuff and was more open to psychic phenomena
[14:21] than people think. Despite being such an ardent
[14:24] atheist. He was such a an atheist and he
[14:27] kind of, he has some essays on psychic stuff where he
[14:31] entertains it. So it's, it's more widely
[14:35] believed. And there's other Ivy League
[14:36] professors even now who are who dabble.
[14:40] But so it's it's it's but it's a bigger issue than field than
[14:44] most people realize, but not at all a there's a hot debate.
[14:51] It's not settled.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
