# High Finance: Navigating the skies of Aircraft Leasing - feat. Nitin Sarin (Sarin & Co)

An episode of [The Indian #AvGeek](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1759764345), 27 Oct 2024, 40 min.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/f945ecd8/podcast/play/93573442/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2024-9-26%2F388760380-44100-2-2644f0c6b1af2.m4a

This week’s guest is Nitin Sarin, Managing Partner at Sarin & Co, India’s only aviation law firm. The topics ranged from how aircraft leasing happens, to how an engine lessor takes the much bigger risk, to the Capetown convention, the emerging GIFT city, what MoCA and DGCA can do to make India more attractive for leasing companies, aircraft repossessions in India, and more. Nitin Sarin - @Deaphen Vishal Mehra - @vishal1mehra

## Transcript

[0:09] Hello. Hello, my fellow geeks.
[0:13] This is the Indian NAV Geek, and I'm Vishal Mehra.
[0:17] You know, it's one thing to be geeky about airlines, about
[0:23] airports, about aircrafts, about aviation at large, but its
[0:29] completely another to be curious about how does all of that falls
[0:35] into its right place. There's a very important
[0:38] ingredient and we have the right chef on board today.
[0:44] Nitin Sarin, like all of us listening, is an aviation geek.
[0:49] He's also the managing partner of Indias only aviation law
[0:54] focused firm. He's a qualified lawyer in India
[0:58] as well as a qualified solicitor in the United Kingdom, known to
[1:03] represent aircraft lessors, banks and other financial
[1:07] institutions in India and avid aviation photographer.
[1:12] Nitin also works in the drone and space sectors, and today he
[1:17] is with us right here. Hello there Nitin, welcome to
[1:21] the Indian App Geek. Hi Vishal, thank you for having
[1:24] me. I've heard a lot about your
[1:25] wonderful presentation and I'm it's an honour for me to be here
[1:29] with you. Tell us about your background,
[1:32] Nitin, and what got you interested in aviation.
[1:36] Well, Vishal, that's, that's a bit of a complex question, but
[1:40] the basic crux is that I come from a family of lawyers and my
[1:46] father especially has worked very hard in his lifetime, in
[1:50] his legal career. And it just so happened that
[1:54] whenever we had summer vacations, he needed to get out
[1:58] of the city or needed to get out of the country.
[2:00] Otherwise he would be bombarded by clients all the time.
[2:05] So that coupled with the fact that in 1992, my elder brother
[2:08] Nikhil got a Singapore Airline scholarship to Singapore, you
[2:13] know, after Class 10, those two facts together made us travel
[2:17] very often and resulted in lots of time spent on an aircraft as
[2:22] a result. The, the spark, you know, inside
[2:25] me really got, you know, lit. And, you know, things like flaps
[2:31] and different parts of the aircraft were always an
[2:33] interest. And my dad was always there to
[2:35] answer those questions as much as he could.
[2:38] And that was really where my interest sparked from.
[2:42] And and and is the genesis of. And that led you to running an
[2:47] aviation law firm somehow? Well, that's.
[2:52] Another bit of an interesting question.
[2:54] As I said, I come from a, you know, family of lawyers.
[2:58] So when I was at that age where I had to decide what I wanted to
[3:02] do, I was fairly aimless, you know, in all honesty, because it
[3:07] was a bit of a confusing phase in life.
[3:10] I didn't know what to do. And so the, the obvious choice
[3:13] was made to join law, which I did do while I was at law
[3:17] school. I, you know, decided to see and
[3:21] check whether I could combine my passion with what I was
[3:26] studying. And at that point, I, you know,
[3:28] I, I happened to check online at that point.
[3:31] And there were two universities, Leiden in the Netherlands and
[3:34] McGill in Canada that offered a master's degree in Air and Space
[3:39] law. And, you know, not knowing
[3:42] anything about the content of those programs, I took the
[3:45] plunge. I got a lot of support from,
[3:48] from my parents who allowed me and, you know, financed my, my
[3:53] legal higher legal education in the Netherlands at Leiden
[3:56] University. And that coupled with another
[3:59] very unique fact in, in, you know, which will you'll be
[4:02] interested to hear is that I went and did my masters in 2008.
[4:08] And the unique part about 2008 was that that was the time of
[4:11] the, the financial downturn, resulting in only three of us
[4:16] being in that LLM program in the Netherlands.
[4:18] So we got a real one-on-one sort of experience with the teachers,
[4:23] with the professionals who we met.
[4:25] And that really sparked my, my interest in aviation.
[4:31] And I also procured an internship with Air Cap at that
[4:35] point. This is now 2008.
[4:37] I'm talking about where I joined aircraft finance and had
[4:41] absolutely no clue about what it meant.
[4:43] I came back to India and and got my first break, you know, which
[4:47] we'll talk about in a while. And from then, there was no
[4:50] looking back. That's fascinating.
[4:53] Nitin, you run a company which primarily deals in aircraft
[4:58] finance related matters. Can you explain to our listeners
[5:02] what all does that entail? Well, yes, I can.
[5:08] It's very important for everyone to understand that when we're
[5:12] talking about aircraft, we are not talking about any other sort
[5:15] of asset. We're not talking about cars,
[5:17] we're not talking about trains. Now, the reason aviation is so
[5:22] an aircraft in particular is so unique is the high cost of, of
[5:27] acquisition of the asset. You know, we're talking about
[5:31] each aircraft. Now any AC20 you fly on is
[5:33] upward of, you know, we were talking about thousands of
[5:36] crores. We're not talking about hundreds
[5:37] of crores. So that's where the aspect of
[5:41] aircraft finance comes in because you know, going back to
[5:46] the 50s and 60s when aviation was really coming about after
[5:51] World War 2, you know, which really saw the spurt in, in
[5:54] global Civil Aviation, most airlines own their assets, their
[5:59] aircraft because assets were cheaper.
[6:02] Airlines could, you know, fund them through their cash flow,
[6:04] etcetera. But as time went by and values
[6:08] rose tremendously because safety, you know, increase the
[6:13] manufacturing processes and you know, changed etcetera, that
[6:17] resulted in aircraft becoming very high value, resulting in
[6:21] people requiring financing. Now when you finance an
[6:26] aircraft, it's very simply that someone is looking for money to
[6:29] buy an aircraft and all the legalities that are involved in
[6:33] that, all the paperwork, all the security aspects, because as you
[6:37] can imagine, it's a, it's a huge amount of money running into
[6:39] billions of dollars. All those legal aspects is our,
[6:44] our, our speciality essentially. So that's where we come in.
[6:48] So it's really a combination of finance law, it's a combination
[6:52] of tax law, it's a combination of, you know, international
[6:56] treaty law, etcetera. So it's a, you know, that's what
[7:00] aircraft finances in a in a nutshell.
[7:02] Suppose an airline based out of India orders an aircraft with a
[7:07] manufacturer in France or in the United States.
[7:12] What's usually the role of a firm like yours in such cases?
[7:16] How does an aircraft acquisition happens?
[7:20] Well, Vishal, that's a very interesting question which a PhD
[7:23] thesis can be written on, to be honest, but I'll try to
[7:26] summarize it. So the role of a lawyer or law
[7:31] firm comes in at the very, very nascent stage.
[7:34] So it could even be when an airline is looking for a
[7:38] particular asset. Now we must bear in mind that we
[7:43] get calls, I wouldn't say everyday, but every other week
[7:47] about enthusiastic Indians wanting to start airlines.
[7:51] And you know, my first question to them is what aircraft are you
[7:55] looking at? And they have no answer to that.
[7:57] And that's how we can shift through people who know what
[8:01] they're talking about vis a vis people who are just looking at
[8:04] it as a business case. Now, the reason I say that is
[8:07] because the choice of asset is paramount.
[8:11] You know, not just by you know how much it's going to cost you
[8:14] to operate, but also residual values also, you know, all other
[8:19] aspects as spare parts serviceability and those really
[8:24] make up a lot of decisions for people as to what aircraft
[8:27] they're going to choose. Now once that stage is done,
[8:31] then there is a tremendous amount of legal work that comes
[8:34] in, whether it's you know, approaching the OEM or the
[8:37] manufacturers negotiating purchase agreements with them.
[8:42] While you after you sign a purchase agreement and before
[8:45] delivery, there'll be lots of stages which will come up for
[8:48] pre delivery payments. As they call there is pre
[8:51] delivery payment agreements and financing and loans, you know
[8:56] that require paperwork. When the delivery is coming up,
[9:00] there is a another whole set of documents and paperwork that's
[9:04] required. Lots of airlines will finance
[9:08] the pre delivery payment as well as refinance at a later stage
[9:12] when delivery is coming up. So there's that paperwork that's
[9:15] involved. There is aircraft leasing, you
[9:18] know, sale and leasebacks where an airline will go to a
[9:21] manufacturer and take delivery and immediately back-to-back
[9:24] will sell it and lease it back from a leasing company.
[9:27] That's the model a lot of our Indian airlines have been
[9:30] following that lease work is also important and comes in.
[9:34] So it's a tremendous amount of aspects where lawyers get
[9:38] involved. And I have seen in my
[9:42] experience, I haven't got to that stage yet, but lawyers who
[9:46] are better technical people in in relation to aviation than
[9:50] actual technical people, because they have to understand the A-Z
[9:54] of everything related to the technical aspects, which is very
[9:58] interesting. All of this is very interesting.
[10:03] How does an aircraft acquisition goes through?
[10:06] So you were just telling us about these frequent calls you
[10:10] receive from folks looking to start an airline.
[10:14] Let's say you get a call from someone who's serious and has a
[10:17] viable business plan and knows his aircraft.
[10:22] How does that first acquisition happens?
[10:26] Well, you see, the first acquisition is always a
[10:28] difficult one because for every new airline, their their balance
[10:33] sheets are basically starting out of fresh, their financials
[10:36] are just starting out of fresh. So it takes a lot of convincing
[10:40] for someone who owns an asset, let's say a leasing company or
[10:43] even a manufacturer to agree to provide an aircraft.
[10:46] Because you see then there are a number of factors involved.
[10:50] As I mentioned, a leasing company for example, will not
[10:53] want to lease an aircraft to an entity that doesn't have a
[10:56] proven financial record. So, you know, the airline has to
[11:00] convince the leasing company that they are in a good position
[11:03] to, you know, make good their obligations.
[11:06] So that's one hurdle which airlines have to cross.
[11:10] Secondly, you'll be surprised if you want to go and buy an
[11:13] aircraft from one of the major manufacturers.
[11:15] They will very likely carry out a very stringent background
[11:19] check on you because they don't want to, you know, sell an
[11:22] aircraft and and you know, book valuable slots and make valuable
[11:27] commitments which will not be kept by by an airline.
[11:32] So the first step is always convincing the other party that
[11:36] you are, you are have a wise business model and that you
[11:40] deserve this aircraft and that, you know, after X amount of
[11:44] time, you'll actually be making money with that aircraft.
[11:46] So that's really the first stage in any aircraft acquisition.
[11:51] After that, and I'm going to just very briefly mention that
[11:54] is your the airline's ability and the airline's obligation.
[11:59] I would say self obligation because it's a very by little
[12:03] part of every airline is to negotiate very valuable
[12:07] commercial terms into your agreement.
[12:10] So now when you are, when we're talking about airlines like
[12:14] Indigo, airlines like Southwest, those guys are on top of their
[12:19] game. They know exactly what price
[12:21] they want, what asset at, and that is 90 percent, 99% of the
[12:26] game. Whom do you primarily work with?
[12:29] Is it airlines or is it lessors? What all do you assist them
[12:33] with? Well, you see by default, and
[12:37] I'm not complaining about that, we have become lawyers who
[12:40] represent banks and leasing companies who are either, you
[12:46] know, looking at some exposure into India or who already have
[12:49] exposure in, in India. And that basically means that we
[12:53] are there to assist them in securing their asset at both
[12:58] stages, at the beginning stage when the asset is being leased
[13:01] into India as well as at a subsequent stage in case there's
[13:04] any default. So we help them in getting their
[13:07] aircraft back. We have also in the past worked
[13:11] for airlines, but we have tried to stay clear of that, you know,
[13:15] lest there be any conflict for us to not represent.
[13:19] Some of all the banks are leasing company clients, you
[13:22] know, in in particular transactions.
[13:24] But we have over the years as I mentioned, we've done a lot of
[13:28] work with Indigo for matters not related to aircraft financing.
[13:33] We have done a lot of work for for other airlines also and it's
[13:37] been a big learning curve over the years.
[13:39] Do you work with airports as well, Nitin?
[13:42] If yes, in in what role we? Have worked with airports in the
[13:48] distant past, but not not very, very closely.
[13:52] In the recent past, we have worked with vendors who are
[13:57] looking to set up, you know, things like kiosks and other
[14:01] services at airports. Now, you know, now that you
[14:05] bring this up, it's very interesting for you to note
[14:08] that, you know, we all know about the new Noida airport
[14:10] that's coming up for those, you know, things like setting up
[14:15] kiosks, foreign exchange, you know, commercial activities have
[14:20] already started. So we are working on several
[14:23] transactions which are already dealing with people who have the
[14:26] foresight that they are going to be location and positioned in
[14:30] that airport. And you know that process has
[14:32] already started. So from that perspective, we
[14:34] have heavily involved in those things.
[14:37] Lots of chatter on X about the upcoming Noida International
[14:42] Airport of late. Is there a difference in buying
[14:45] a commercial jet visa vis a corporate jet in the country,
[14:50] especially from the perspective of the role that you and your
[14:54] firm plays? Yes, it differs fairly fairly
[14:58] substantially. Now the reason for that is look,
[15:01] a corporate jet client or a corporate jet purchaser is
[15:04] possibly going to be doing that as a one off, let's say A1 off
[15:08] in 10 years or one off in 15 years.
[15:10] So the whole, the whole attitude and the angle at which these are
[15:15] analysed is completely different.
[15:16] So there's, there's a lot more flexibility.
[15:20] Let's say there's a lot more, you know, the, the decisions are
[15:25] made by fewer people. Let's just say that as opposed
[15:29] to someone on the likes of who's got 100 aircraft on order
[15:33] because they will want standardization, they would want
[15:36] one sort of clause, one sort of agreement amongst all of those
[15:40] 100 aircraft. Whereas a corporate jet or you
[15:43] know, a business jet on the other hand, it'll be a one off
[15:46] purchase agreement, it'll be one A1 off lease agreement.
[15:49] So there is a, you know, there is a big difference.
[15:52] And in India especially the, the business business jet sector is,
[15:57] is a fairly unorganized sector at the moment because you know,
[16:00] the, the simple reason for that is the, the larger boys, the
[16:03] Tatas, the Ambanis, the reliances, etcetera.
[16:07] You know, they, they already have a very well established
[16:11] system in the non schedule operator arena.
[16:14] But there are a lot of business houses in India who have made a
[16:18] tremendous amount of money and continue to do so, who are now
[16:21] looking at, you know, they're done purchasing the Rolls Royces
[16:25] and Maybachs. They are now looking at buying
[16:28] aircraft assets. So there are a lot of these guys
[16:31] coming into the market. So it's a very unorganized
[16:34] sector. From that perspective, they
[16:35] think it's like buying a car, which it's not.
[16:38] So that's been a very interesting aspect and a big
[16:40] differentiator between you know, the commercial aspect and the
[16:43] the private jet aspect. GIFT City has been hailed in the
[16:49] media as the aircraft leasing hub of India.
[16:53] Talks from government also in that regard.
[16:57] Have you worked with entities based out of there?
[17:00] What's been your experience so far?
[17:03] Gift City, It's interesting you bring this up.
[17:06] I was just on a webinar yesterday with Gift City and the
[17:10] Embassy of India in Ireland and you see the Gift City initiative
[17:16] is a is a very novel 1. And I say that because this
[17:21] contrary to what a lot of people understand, started several
[17:24] years ago in, you know, it finds its genesis in this project
[17:29] report, which is called Rupi Raftar, where, you know, the
[17:33] Ministry of Civil Aviation got together virtually all the large
[17:37] players in the industry, sat them down and said, please help
[17:41] us carry out this research because we want to set up a
[17:44] leasing platform and and a leasing arena whereby Indians or
[17:50] actually the rest of the world can finance and lease through
[17:54] this, you know, big giant called Gift City.
[17:57] So so. Mocha sitting down with the
[17:59] airlines and asking for opinion. Not only airlines, they sat down
[18:04] with Airbus, they sat down with yes, correct, correct.
[18:08] And they carried out this would be in, I think this would be
[18:14] starting around 2016, two 1017, getting on for several years.
[18:19] All right, OK. And it's a, you know, they, they
[18:24] analyzed every angle of it. What is GST armor?
[18:27] GST is payable with the main aim to amend the laws and
[18:31] regulations to make it as you know, as feasible for someone to
[18:37] lease through a GIFT City entity as it is to lease through
[18:41] Ireland. You know, as you know, Ireland
[18:43] has negotiated double tracks avoidance treaties with most of
[18:47] the world in a very favourable atmosphere.
[18:50] So the main aim of GIFT at that point was to amend laws, to see
[18:54] what needs to be changed etcetera so that people can now
[18:56] start leasing through GIFT City. Over the years they have, you
[19:02] know, come out with several policies which are which are
[19:05] very, very good policies. But their main problem, let me
[19:09] start by by saying, you know, starting with the negative, why
[19:13] a lot of the large aircraft leasing companies are not going
[19:16] there. The main reason for that is that
[19:19] these leasing companies are so well established in Ireland
[19:21] already. They need a very good case study
[19:26] and a very good, you know, the reason to to to move, you know,
[19:32] lock, stock and barrel from Dublin to gift city.
[19:36] So a lot of them asking these questions, you know, we get
[19:39] questions everyday. Should we move to Gift And the
[19:43] whole, you know, answer that we have for them is that you can
[19:46] absolutely, but please analyse it as to what benefit you get,
[19:51] you know, being based in Gift Whizvi Dublin and a lot of them
[19:55] are waiting and watching. I think that's why there's been
[19:58] a little bit of hesitancy in the in the beginning of, you know,
[20:02] in GIFT, but a lot of people are waiting and watching and their
[20:05] main question is. Where is the Indian money, you
[20:09] know, in gift, we want to see more Indian banks financing.
[20:13] We want to see more Indian entities coming into the arena
[20:16] and then, you know, we want to take the plunge.
[20:18] So it's not a it's not a question of if it is a question
[20:23] of when you know gift city really sparks and and you know
[20:28] becomes a self oil machine. I remember A is Air India's
[20:33] first A 350 acquisition was done via finance lease transaction at
[20:38] Gift City, right? Yes.
[20:40] Been any other high profile transactions since then?
[20:44] Nitin. I believe apart from the Air
[20:47] India transaction, even Indigo has either signed or is in the
[20:51] process of signing transactions through GIFT.
[20:54] And you know, just Vishal, one important point I want to
[20:57] highlight there, which I highlighted yesterday also that
[21:02] the whole purpose of GIFT should not be to compete with Ireland.
[21:07] It needs to find its own sweet spot, which I believe it is
[21:10] finding now in in finance leases.
[21:12] I don't want to get very technical, but there is a big
[21:15] advantage of having a finance lease through GIFT, but to the
[21:18] Indian entity, not to the foreign entity.
[21:20] So that seems to be 1 sweet spot, which is, you know,
[21:24] cropping up. But you know, apart from Indigo
[21:27] and Air India, I think these two are the largest transactions
[21:30] that have happened through GIFT and we are hoping to see more in
[21:33] the near future. Let's say Indigo, you know,
[21:36] leases an aircraft, or rather buys an aircraft from Airbus,
[21:41] leases it back, sells it and leases it back from a lessor.
[21:47] Now, if that lessor is based out of Ireland or India, does that
[21:52] matter to Indigo? It does matter to Indigo, yes.
[21:56] It's very important for Indigo to have that entity being based
[22:01] in Ireland for the sole purpose that the double tax avoidance
[22:05] treaty between India and Ireland says that any amount that
[22:09] Indigo, for example, will remit to Ireland will be free of
[22:14] withholding tax and that entity will be taxed only in Ireland
[22:18] and not in India. So from that perspective, an
[22:23] Indian airline has a benefit to ask the counterparty to be based
[22:28] in Ireland so that those benefits may be accorded to the
[22:32] lessor. Otherwise, if those benefits
[22:35] don't accrue to the lessor, they will come ultimately back to
[22:39] Indigo because they are the ones who are using that facility of
[22:42] that lease and that financing. There have been issues lessors
[22:46] have had in repossessing aircraft from Indian airlines
[22:50] and I know you have helped out some lessors in the past in
[22:53] similar situations. In your experience, does that
[22:57] make it difficult for airlines in good standing to have issues
[23:01] with respect to their financing and leasing?
[23:05] Absolutely. It's a India apps track record
[23:08] has been fairly, fairly dismal, I would be very honest to say,
[23:13] not for the lack of the ministry's focus or the lack of
[23:17] the ministry's attempt, but at every insolvency, every
[23:21] bankruptcy, there's been some new problem that has come to
[23:24] light. You know, whether it's
[23:25] Kingfisher, whether it's Go First, whether it's Jet Airways,
[23:29] each one has shown a particularly unique problem
[23:33] which someone did not anticipate earlier, which someone did not,
[23:37] you know, see or you know, think about previously.
[23:40] So everyone has learnt according to those issues.
[23:45] And I will also say very candidly and honestly that the
[23:48] ministry has been Absolutely Fabulous in, in coming to the
[23:52] help of of leasing companies and entities, understanding that,
[23:56] you know, 99%, well, 90 above 90% of the fleet is through, you
[24:02] know, aircraft leasing companies.
[24:03] So yes, we have a fairly, you know, abysmal track record.
[24:10] But have we made progress? Yes, we have.
[24:12] But you're right, who does it hurt?
[24:14] You know, India is still looked at as a very unpredictable
[24:18] jurisdiction and no one knows what's going to happen in the
[24:22] next insolvency. Who does that hurt?
[24:26] That hurts the newer entrance into the market.
[24:29] That hurts the, you know, the startups that are coming into
[24:32] the market because people will be very scared and very hesitant
[24:36] to lease a new high value asset to a new entity.
[24:41] So while Indigo may not have a problem, Air India may not have
[24:45] a problem, even though let me, you know, put that in, in
[24:50] brackets that people have been fairly concerned about, you
[24:54] know, even the larger names just because it has the India tag.
[24:57] But, you know, those big boys can, you know, give a lot of
[25:01] assurances and, and, you know, they, they, they work it out.
[25:04] But it's the new entrants who find it very difficult.
[25:06] So that is where we have to work very hard.
[25:10] We need to get the Cape Town Convention properly enforced in
[25:15] India which will put us on a more level playing field, give a
[25:19] little bit of relaxation to the whole industry and as a result
[25:24] bring down the cost of of acquisition of aircraft and and
[25:28] credit. For those of our listeners who
[25:32] are not so sure about the Cape Town Convention, can you help us
[25:36] understand, please, about that a little bit more?
[25:40] Yes. So the Cape Town Convention is
[25:43] basically an International Convention which came about in
[25:46] 2001. And what that does is it deals
[25:49] with a number of assets. It deals with mobile assets,
[25:54] number one, with aviation or aircraft assets at #2 it deals
[25:59] with rolling stocks, so you know, trains and locomotives.
[26:03] It deals with space assets and it also deals with high high
[26:08] value farming equipment, etcetera.
[26:12] Now the India has ratified the convention and the aircraft
[26:16] protocol. So aircraft rolling stock, space
[26:19] farming equipment all come under separate protocols which
[26:22] countries can separately, you know adhere to or separately,
[26:27] you know basically sign up for India has signed up for the
[26:30] convention and the aircraft protocol.
[26:32] So what that essentially means is that because aircraft assets
[26:37] are changing borders, they're crossing borders just by nature
[26:41] of, you know, what they do. This tries to make an
[26:44] international legal regime where, you know, if Vishals
[26:49] financing an aircraft for Nitin and Nitin is operating it in,
[26:53] you know, a third country, that that third country will
[26:56] recognize Vishal's rights in that asset.
[26:59] So what that tries, what that tries and aims to do is to
[27:04] standardize legal procedures and legal regimes around the world
[27:08] so that the financing entities get their fair share of
[27:11] recognition of title and their interest in that asset
[27:15] irrespective of where that aircraft is.
[27:18] Now that also allows for you know, easy repossession, easy D
[27:22] registration, etcetera. And that is why despite India
[27:26] having ratified the convention, we need to bring it into local
[27:30] law. So there needs to be a Cape Town
[27:32] Convention Act of Parliament, which is passed whereby all
[27:36] other laws will be overridden and basically overrided.
[27:40] And that will allow an A creditor or a financier to come
[27:44] in. In case of a default file a
[27:46] single piece of paper, get the registration and procure export
[27:51] from India, which at the moment the registration is fairly
[27:54] straightforward. So you can ground the aircraft.
[27:57] But export is a bit of an issue at the moment.
[28:00] And that's what the Cape Town Convention, if brought into, you
[28:03] know, local law will will fix. You were just talking about how
[28:07] the ministry has been fabulous and very helpful.
[28:11] What steps do you think Mocha or DGCA have to take to make India
[28:15] much more attractive for aviation companies or lessors?
[28:20] How we have ratified Cape Town convention but implementing it?
[28:24] Would you know these things help?
[28:26] What else can we do? Well, I think apart the Cape
[28:31] Town convention, proper implementation will go a long,
[28:34] long way. I don't think we need to do much
[28:36] more, but at the same time I think what the ministry could
[28:41] really work on is a little bit of consistency.
[28:44] You know, for example, if there's an insolvency tomorrow,
[28:47] I am not able to give my client a clear cut legal opinion or
[28:52] answer as to what the reactions or actions will be from, you
[28:57] know, the various government entities.
[28:59] So I can't go and tell a leasing company client that look,
[29:02] tomorrow you have a default situation with a particular
[29:06] airline tomorrow. If you want to go and you know,
[29:09] pull the plug that Indian oil won't come out of the woodwork.
[29:14] You know, the GST department won't come out of the woodwork,
[29:16] that the customs won't come out of the woodwork and start, you
[29:20] know, demanding dues, which are of course payable by the by the
[29:24] airline, but demanding those dues from, from the lessor.
[29:28] So I cannot give a definitive answer to any of my clients.
[29:33] So that kind of makes it a very shaky jurisdiction.
[29:37] So if the ministry could work on on aspects like that where you
[29:41] know, a one stop shop solution, that would be very helpful and
[29:44] you know, give a little bit of predictability as to what would
[29:47] happen in India in a particular circumstance.
[29:52] Few minutes back you had mentioned about high value
[29:55] assets. Nitin, besides aircraft, other
[29:58] high value assets include engines, right?
[30:02] How is engine financing different from aircraft
[30:06] financing? I think that the the first
[30:10] difference is that engines have always been treated at a
[30:14] slightly lower, you know, they've always been put at a
[30:17] lower pedestal than an airframe. Now when you ask, you know, you
[30:22] ask why. You know, a simple answer is the
[30:25] current DGCA regulations, they don't record ownership rights in
[30:31] engines. They do on an airframe, but
[30:34] nowhere do they ask you, you know, who's the owner of the
[30:37] engines, you know, that are that are affixed to your aircraft.
[30:41] So they take a lot of risk. You know, the engine leasing
[30:46] companies unfortunately do have to take a lot of risk because
[30:51] they don't have such a clear cut path forward.
[30:53] They, they will always have to run, you know, the longest mile.
[30:56] They'll have to go to court, they'll have to prove that the
[30:58] engine is theirs, etcetera. As opposed to, you know, an
[31:01] airframe owner who can, you know, just show a certificate of
[31:04] registration and, and prove her or his ownership.
[31:09] And, you know, apart from that, there are certain jurisdictions
[31:13] in the world who have, you know, very strange.
[31:18] Well, I shouldn't call it strange.
[31:19] That's, you know, a very well established system of law.
[31:23] But there are certain jurisdictions in the world that
[31:26] consider engines that have been installed on an airframe to
[31:30] become the property of the owner of the airframe.
[31:33] So let's say I am an engine lessor.
[31:36] Vishal owns, you know, an airframe.
[31:39] I Nitin lease Vishal 2 engines. There are certain legal regimes
[31:43] in the world, not in India, who believe that the moment Nitin's
[31:48] engines are installed on Vishal's aircraft, Vishal
[31:50] becomes the owner of that aircraft.
[31:53] Sorry of those engines, because those are an integral part of
[31:57] the whole aircraft. Engines are on lease.
[32:02] Yes, yes, that's correct. That's correct.
[32:05] So, yes, so engine lessors and engine financiers have to be
[32:10] very, very careful. And you know, usually that's
[32:13] seen in the higher cost of leasing such assets because, you
[32:18] know, they have to absorb a lot more risk.
[32:21] Out of the three aspects of aviation law which is
[32:26] regulatory, which is financial and passenger rights, what keeps
[32:31] you most busy with respect to the Indian market?
[32:35] Well. Vishal, that's a very
[32:37] interesting question and that's something that, you know, is in
[32:39] my mind every day because at the end of the day, I'm responsible
[32:43] for procurement of work. I'm responsible for, you know,
[32:47] keeping my very, very highly talented and hard working team,
[32:51] you know, keeping them in business essentially.
[32:53] So it's been a very interesting ride.
[32:57] If I may start with a statistic as far as the aircraft financing
[33:01] work goes, I think we are doing less than 5% of all the work
[33:06] that there is. So we are very bullish on how
[33:09] much work increase we can see in the aircraft financing sphere.
[33:15] But we've seen that whenever the aircraft financing work tapers
[33:19] down, we have always seen a large spike in the regulatory
[33:22] work. So we'd, you know, just for a
[33:24] little bit of context, because we don't work for Indian
[33:27] airlines, we are OK with working for International Airlines.
[33:31] So we do a lot of consulting and regulatory work for some of the
[33:34] large International Airlines. So it's been a, you know, it's
[33:39] been a mix of the two, lots of financing.
[33:43] If the financing goes down, there's a lot of regulatory
[33:45] happening, but we've kept ourselves busy and you know, the
[33:49] third aspect with, you know, customer or consumer disputes,
[33:53] etcetera. We've even though I've done a
[33:55] lot of it in my career, I've tried to stay clear of that
[33:58] because you know, anything related to a court is time
[34:01] consuming, it's expensive and a lot of these claims are not very
[34:05] high value. So it's very difficult to
[34:08] justify, you know, charging a, a decent fee to our clients when
[34:13] you know, the, the whole claim is for a refund of 50,001 lakh,
[34:17] etcetera. So, you know, it's been a very
[34:20] interesting mix of all three. One aspect in the consumer
[34:23] department where we do get involved is where, you know,
[34:27] airlines will come to us and say, look, there's a consumer
[34:30] dispute that has been filed. We want to settle out of court
[34:33] either because the insurers have said so or they realize they're
[34:36] at a weaker footing. And that's where we get involved
[34:40] to try, you know, our negotiations team will reach out
[34:43] to the complainant and try and, you know, figure out a
[34:46] settlement between the two. So we have done a lot of that
[34:49] work, but apart from that, it's been very organic.
[34:53] I don't know where the work will come from tomorrow, but it's
[34:56] just been a very fantastic mix and I'm learning, learning as I
[35:00] live. You also work on UAVs, you work
[35:04] on drone related laws as well, if I'm correct.
[35:08] What's the progress on that front as far as our laws are
[35:13] concerned? Yes, Vishal, In fact we have
[35:16] been doing a lot of exciting work in that space.
[35:20] I'll be very honest, in the beginning I was slightly
[35:22] sceptical about, you know, how commercially viable that would
[35:26] be for us as a firm. But you know, we've, we've
[35:30] signed on some major, you know, clients, whether it's, you know,
[35:33] the the Google guys, Amazon guys and, and save several other
[35:37] people who are, you know, very exploratory right now in their
[35:42] ventures in India. And that takes me to the, you
[35:45] know, to answer your question, the drone laws of India have
[35:49] seen a tremendous change over the last five years or so, but
[35:54] we are still awaiting a number of regulations, you know, for
[35:57] example, beyond visual line of sight regulations are still
[36:03] awaited. Now, what that means is that if
[36:05] I want to deliver any package but the the drone or UAV is
[36:10] flying beyond my visual line of sight, I cannot do that legally
[36:14] at the moment. Those trials have been conducted
[36:17] and the regulations are still awaited.
[36:20] So there are a number of pieces of the jigsaw puzzle which have
[36:23] to still be put in place. But it has been very, very
[36:27] interesting the journey thus far.
[36:28] And that is a huge potential market in India in the next, you
[36:32] know, two or three decades. And finally, anybody following
[36:38] you on X knows fully well Nitin about your love affair with
[36:43] Emirates. What's so special about them?
[36:48] That's a, that's a funny 1. So #1 I'm probably the worst
[36:52] Emirates customer because I haven't bought a revenue ticket
[36:56] for several years now. I, I am also a big credit card
[37:01] enthusiast and I have used several credit cards, you know,
[37:05] for points and I do, you know, milk them to the Max as much as
[37:10] possible. And you know, that results in a
[37:12] lot of Emirates flying, particularly in first class.
[37:15] I cannot afford it. Let me be very clear to all the
[37:18] the listeners. But if not for those credit
[37:20] cards. Now you see the thing, what I
[37:23] love about Emirates is it is standard.
[37:26] You know, it's standardization. You know what you're going to
[37:29] get on board which aircraft. You know, I get a lot of Flack
[37:33] that oh, you're such a Emirates flag flyer, but you're always
[37:36] flying first class. Yes, I agree with that.
[37:38] But if I was to fly business class, I probably wouldn't fly
[37:42] Emirates because they have that ridiculous 232 on their 777.
[37:46] So it's not, you know, it's not like I love Emirates, but they
[37:50] are consistent. The Dubai airport is like a
[37:54] mini, you know, city. Your flight gets late.
[37:57] For example, you have an e-mail prior to that saying that, you
[38:00] know, you've been rebooked on the next flight.
[38:02] We have a hotel room ready for you.
[38:04] So it's just that, you know, the excitement of the product, the,
[38:09] the services that are provided on board, the food, the, you
[38:13] know, I'll be very honest, the, the champagne and the wine are
[38:16] absolutely fantastic. Their selection of, you know, in
[38:20] flight entertainment is you compare, you know, you can't
[38:24] compare that to anyone else in the world.
[38:26] So it creates a very comforting space for me at least I can get
[38:30] on. I can watch a movie, I can have
[38:32] a drink, I can have something, you know, delicious to eat.
[38:36] And I know what's going to be offered when, at how, and at
[38:39] what consistency. All right, Nathan, I just want
[38:45] to conclude now by thanking you for your time.
[38:48] This has been awesome, thank you very much.
[38:53] It's been a, it's been an absolute pleasure, Vishal.
[38:55] Thank you for having me and I look forward to being of
[38:59] assistance ever in the future. What a brilliant episode.
[39:05] This is the reason frankly I do this.
[39:08] I do this to get smarter and people like Nitin make you
[39:12] smarter. Well, time to say the usual
[39:16] before we say Vadiya Ji for the week.
[39:20] As always, we are streaming on Spotify, on Apple Podcasts, on
[39:25] Amazon and all other major podcast apps.
[39:30] Do take out those 30 seconds, Rate US, leave us a feedback, it
[39:35] helps. And with that, I wish you well
[39:39] and happy flying my friends.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
