# “If Mohammad, Jesus & Ram put forward an airport proposal” - feat. Sean Mendis

An episode of [The Indian #AvGeek](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1759764345), 20 Oct 2024, 39 min.

Audio: https://anchor.fm/s/f945ecd8/podcast/play/93269592/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2024-9-19%2F388382059-44100-2-5fcca238ca0e.m4a

This week our focus is entirely on Africa and the enormous potential it holds for the India-Africa market. Sean Mendis talks to us about the overall state of African aviation, why Ethiopian Airlines leads the market, Qatar’s buying spree in Africa, Carriers serving the Indo-Africa market, unserved markets on the route, How will A321 XLR EIS help in market stimulation, new carriers which may serve the market, Morocco’s market and the Adani controversy wrt to the Nairobi Airport. Sean Mendis - @SeanMendis Vishal Mehra - @vishal1mehra

## Transcript

[0:12] Hello, Hello my fellow geeks. This is the Indian App Geek and
[0:19] I am Vishal Mehra. Personally, I've been fascinated
[0:23] by Africa for a long time. Unfortunately, along with South
[0:28] America, it is a continent I haven't visited but hope to do
[0:32] soon. Till then, I cannot park my
[0:35] interest in African aviation so I reached out to Shawn Mendes
[0:40] and requested him to come on the show.
[0:43] Shawn is an experienced aviation professional with the track
[0:47] record of successfully launching and managing and restructuring
[0:52] airlines and aviation facilities.
[0:55] With over 20 years of industry experience, Shawn has completed
[0:59] three startup airline projects in Africa and developed a deep
[1:04] understanding of the complexities involved in
[1:07] managing airlines in those challenging environments.
[1:13] He serves on the Advisory Board of Avia Dev Africa and Aviators
[1:19] Africa and is currently based in Malawi where he offers executive
[1:24] level consulting and intelligence to aviation
[1:28] stakeholders. We get to benefit from some of
[1:31] it today. Welcome to the Indian app geek,
[1:35] Sean. Thank you, it is wonderful to be
[1:37] here. Let's start with your
[1:39] background, Sean, and what got you into aviation.
[1:43] Ah, how do I get into aviation? I think the easiest answer to
[1:47] that is I was born into it. Both my parents work for Air
[1:50] India. So, you know, when I was born, I
[1:54] don't think I ever considered a career outside of aviation.
[1:58] It was just a question of do I want to be a pilot?
[2:00] Do I want to be whatever? And I think sometime around my,
[2:05] my teens, I realized that that my real interest lay in the
[2:09] business side of the aviation industry.
[2:11] But of course as a good Indian child, I had to study
[2:14] engineering initially and went to the US, did my studied
[2:19] aerospace engineering initially, then did aviation management in
[2:22] Canada. 2005 I began getting involved with the African market
[2:30] and I I, I moved to Ghana where I set up the national airline of
[2:34] Ghana in 2005. Subsequently I've set up two
[2:38] more, so 3 in total airlines over the last 20 odd years.
[2:42] And currently I do well some scholar consulting work.
[2:48] I say I'm a mercenary that sells my services to the highest
[2:51] bidder primarily on startups and restructuring type projects in
[2:56] in, in the African market. That's where my my last 20 years
[2:59] of expertise is. So I split my time between India
[3:03] and Malawi, which are my homes. And I'm quite sure it's not just
[3:08] me, but a lot of listeners right now wondering how are your
[3:13] parents involved with Air India? So, yeah, you know, there's
[3:16] this, there's this famous picture which has been doing the
[3:19] rounds on social media again in the last, well, last year when
[3:23] Air India went to the Tatas and then again now that Ratan Tatas
[3:27] sat passing recently of these, these Air India cabin crew lined
[3:32] up on the steps as JRD Tata welcomes the 1st 747.
[3:36] And the lady who's wearing the yellow Salvar in that picture,
[3:39] that's my mother. So that was what my mother was
[3:42] doing in the 1970s. She was with Air India until I
[3:45] was born. And my dad was with Air India in
[3:48] various roles from 64 till he retired in 2001.
[3:52] So 37 years there as well. So as I said, Air India was very
[3:57] much in my blood at an early age.
[3:59] And the aviation industry in general was was was something I
[4:04] was bitten by early and have still are being cured from.
[4:08] What's the state of aviation in Africa, Sean, you're, you're the
[4:12] expert for the continent. So if you could just tell us
[4:16] briefly, what do you think, which regions, which carriers
[4:20] are doing well? Like an aviation, if you look at
[4:22] it from a macro level, I think African aviation has really
[4:26] transformed over the last two decades.
[4:28] And I think the main reason for that has been improved safety.
[4:32] You know, if you look back at African aviation and say the
[4:35] 1990s or even the early 2000s, Africa's safety record was, was
[4:40] woeful. It was well below the, the
[4:42] world's average and definitely well behind, you know, the, the
[4:46] leading regions of the world, whether that was Europe or North
[4:49] America, whatever else. But when you look at it today,
[4:51] African aviation is now above average.
[4:55] I mean, it's, it's better than the average in the world.
[4:58] It's still not the best in the world by any means, but it has
[5:01] improved by leaps and bounds. And it's improved to the point
[5:04] that African consumers no longer consider safety as a
[5:08] differentiating factor when choosing to fly.
[5:11] They, they don't not fly because they think it may be unsafe.
[5:16] To them, flying is just another, another means of transport now
[5:19] which they, you know, they look at schedule, they look at price
[5:21] and everything else. I think that's been a very
[5:23] important thing in terms of bringing African aviation
[5:26] towards the mainstream as a legitimate form of, of travel
[5:30] to, from and within Africa. Now if you look at it at a more
[5:35] detailed level, African aviation can basically be summarized as
[5:39] Ethiopian Airlines and everybody else because Ethiopian Airlines
[5:43] is, it is, I mean it is the behemoth already and it is just
[5:48] growing into by leaps and bounds.
[5:51] I mean it's growing at double digit growth every year for the
[5:55] last 12-15 years and just compounding that every time.
[6:00] So Ethiopian Airlines continues to grow from strength to
[6:03] strength, hundreds of aircraft, hundreds of destinations, 10
[6:07] destinations a year. Literally every time you, you,
[6:11] you open the press release page, you, you see that they've
[6:14] announced service to another destination or an increase of
[6:17] service here or there. And I think Ethiopian also with
[6:21] their partnerships with other airlines, you know, they, they
[6:24] own stakes in a Sky Airlines in Togo, they own stakes in Malawi
[6:28] airlines in Zambia Airways, they've had subsidiaries in
[6:31] Mozambique, in Chad, in Guinea. So, you know, with Ethiopians
[6:36] reached throughout the continent, there's Ethiopian
[6:38] Airlines Group, which is largely a successful grouping of, of
[6:42] airlines with a strong strategy, strong financial backing, strong
[6:46] commercial success. And then you have everyone else
[6:49] for the most part, certainly some do better than others.
[6:52] It's a cyclical thing. You know, you have the Kenya
[6:54] Airways, the South African Airways, which which have
[6:56] struggled in recent years. You have a lot of smaller
[6:59] airlines in pockets. But I'd say that all falls under
[7:02] the everybody else because, you know, there's, there's, there's
[7:06] really no comparison in terms of scale or success to what
[7:11] Ethiopian has been able to put together in Africa.
[7:15] I want to ask you about your thoughts on Qatar Airways buying
[7:20] a 25% stake in South African regional carrier Airlink, as
[7:26] well as 49% stake acquisition Rond Air talks apparently at the
[7:32] last stage after five years of negotiations.
[7:36] I think one of the biggest challenges that African aviation
[7:38] has suffered from over the last few decades has been lack of
[7:41] access to capital. You know, it's not that easy.
[7:45] I, I, I've started 3 airlines in Africa.
[7:47] So it's something I, it's, it's near and dear to my heart that
[7:50] you can't actually finance in most African countries,
[7:53] especially the smaller ones. You can't actually finance an
[7:57] airline by by going to a bank and saying hi, you know, I have
[8:01] this business plan, I want to set up an airline.
[8:03] There isn't enough private sector capital in many of these
[8:06] countries to even help you finance 1 aircraft.
[8:09] So you're stuck having to rely on on international or either on
[8:14] governments, which, you know, brings its own set of baggage
[8:16] and problems and everything else with government backed airlines
[8:20] to, you know, to high net worth individuals which bring their
[8:23] own set of baggage to multinational conglomerates
[8:26] which have their own issues or you have to look for
[8:29] international investors. And I think in a case like that,
[8:32] Rwanda started off as a government backed airline.
[8:36] It still is. It is an airline.
[8:37] In fact, it's one of the only airlines in the world which
[8:41] where the national budget of the country actually makes provision
[8:45] for financial support in hundreds of millions of EUR
[8:48] every year to the national airline.
[8:50] So effectively at the beginning of the budget year, they say
[8:54] this year €200 million of losses we're going to subsidise for
[8:58] Rwanda. If you only lose 190 million,
[9:00] you get to keep the other 10 million as so-called profits.
[9:03] So when you look in terms of an airline like that, especially in
[9:06] a poor country like Rwanda, the need to be able to to to not
[9:13] subsidized those losses while there's so many other priorities
[9:20] for development in that country is important.
[9:22] And I think that's where be able to look at the partner like
[9:26] Qatar Airways or or potentially any other partner.
[9:28] You know, it's not necessarily only Qatar saviour here, but to
[9:31] have an international investor who's coming in, not just the
[9:35] financial investor, but also the strategic investor to bring in
[9:38] expertise to bring in potential economies of scale and so forth
[9:42] is, is a huge benefit. And I think, you know, Qatar has
[9:45] recently made an investment in Airlink, another, you know what,
[9:51] the largest regional airline in Africa, they've got over 60
[9:55] aircraft and you know, Qatar has bought 25% of them.
[9:58] And I think this this is indicative of Qatar's strategy
[10:01] for growth in Africa is that they want to take minority
[10:05] equity positions in a number of, of strategically important
[10:09] African airlines. And I think in the right
[10:11] situations, such as with Airlink and potentially with Rwanda Air
[10:15] as well, this could be very good matches which are win, win for
[10:19] for both sides and consequently for the consumer as well.
[10:22] All right. Let's fly back to India and talk
[10:26] about the state of India, Africa market.
[10:29] How are we doing there, Sean? I think that market is
[10:34] significantly underserved, but it's probably served as well as
[10:39] it could be given current technology and market dynamics.
[10:44] The, you know, historically we've seen that most of the
[10:47] traffic between India and Africa has been diaspora driven.
[10:51] You know, there's a large Indian community ranging from colonial
[10:55] days. In fact, my wife's family, for
[10:57] example, is, you know, being in Malawi for for nearly 100 years
[11:01] now. But and consequently, those are
[11:04] the ties that have really driven the traffic between between
[11:08] India and Africa, but I think we're beginning to see changes
[11:13] in that right now. And the changes are coming from
[11:15] multiple from multiple fronts. Historical routes are are still
[11:22] there. And in fact, you know, as India
[11:24] makes more of an effort to reach out to the diaspora through OC
[11:28] is and you know, other, other efforts to, to keep the diaspora
[11:34] engaged with India even in in future generations that that
[11:37] continues to be maintained. But I think importantly, we're
[11:40] going to see how this market changes from a from market
[11:45] dynamics area from three particular sectors.
[11:49] The first sector is going to be tourism outbound from India to
[11:52] Africa. And, you know, we've seen over
[11:54] the last a couple of decades, but mostly in the last decade or
[11:58] so, that outbound tourism from India is growing by leaps and
[12:01] bounds. And most of this has been
[12:03] Southeast Asia, Middle East, Europe.
[12:07] But I think Africa, you know, is obviously somewhere that offers
[12:12] a very unique tourism offering. And I think Indians will begin
[12:18] to start getting attracted to that as a stepping stone.
[12:21] You know, it's not for beginners.
[12:22] It's not like, you know, you can take a package tour as they do
[12:26] to Bangkok or Dubai or whatever from, you know, a lot of these
[12:29] Indian cities. But I think that will continue
[12:32] to grow. It is growing already, but it'll
[12:34] continue to grow over the over the next decade or so.
[12:37] So I think that will be a driver, but it'll be a small
[12:40] driver because in contrast to India's expansion to many other
[12:45] markets in the world where so much of the growth in demand is
[12:49] generated from the Indian side, the growth of traffic from
[12:53] Africa between Africa and India is actually largely growing on
[12:57] the African side. And, and that's fascinating.
[13:00] And the two sectors in particular which have really
[13:03] driven growth very strongly. One of those is medical tourism.
[13:08] You know, Africa, it is a wonderful place, but medical
[13:12] capabilities are not widespread throughout most of the
[13:17] continent. I mean, certainly there are
[13:18] pockets in, you know, in South Africa, maybe in Kenya and here
[13:22] and there where there is, you know, world class
[13:24] infrastructure. But for the most part, if you're
[13:26] in a Malawi, if you're in a Ghana or whatever and you need
[13:29] advanced care, you, you have to travel out of out of the country
[13:33] for sure, and potentially out of the continent.
[13:35] And India has done an exceptional job.
[13:37] And you know, Apollo Hospitals in particular is, is everywhere
[13:41] in Africa in terms of being able to offer medical tourism
[13:44] packages and so forth. And that has really grown by
[13:47] leaps and bounds. I mean, I don't have specific
[13:49] figures because you know, that's very hard to segment.
[13:51] But I'll tell you from talking to airlines who who are who are
[13:54] moving this traffic, they're saying it's in where we're
[13:57] talking 100% plus growth over the course of the last decade.
[14:01] So I think medical tourism between Africa and India is
[14:03] something that continues to grow and will continue to grow as as,
[14:08] as as that market expands. And students as well.
[14:12] Once again, if you, you know, if you look at newspapers, social
[14:15] media and in Africa, you are constantly seeing Indian private
[14:20] universities advertising scholarships for African
[14:23] students everywhere you go, you know, but I see people applying
[14:28] for jobs in CVS. I'd say like you see, as many
[14:32] Africans have done an MBA in India as you do Africans who've
[14:36] done an MBA, you know, in Europe or wherever else right now.
[14:39] And I think that is somewhere else that India is, you know,
[14:42] using the soft power, using the power of an English language
[14:45] education in, in the English speaking parts of Africa and,
[14:48] and, and generating more demand for Africans to travel to India.
[14:53] So I think you know, the, the dynamics of this market are very
[14:56] different and it's probably why you're not seeing Indian
[14:59] carriers who specialized in India origin traffic really
[15:03] having expanded that much into Africa yet.
[15:05] The, the, the bulk of the traffic is still being
[15:08] transported by African carriers into India rather than the other
[15:11] way around. But I think it's a very
[15:12] fascinating dynamic as you look at it.
[15:15] And finally, one thing which may be a short term thing or maybe a
[15:18] longer term thing is the COVID pandemic.
[15:21] Because you know, in, in, in the previous two decades, say from
[15:25] 2004 onwards, still about 2020, the largest growing sector from
[15:30] Africa was traveled to China. I mean, it went from nothing to
[15:33] to literally millions in in 15 years.
[15:37] However, when China shut its borders, we saw that the trade
[15:41] traffic which went from, you know, that the traders from
[15:44] Africa would go to China, buy stuff, bring it back, you know,
[15:48] cheap manufacturing services, things like that.
[15:51] A lot of that was displaced to two particular regions.
[15:54] One of that was I1 of that was the Middle East.
[15:58] So Dubai, Doha, whatever else there.
[16:01] Now China has reopened, we still haven't seen whether that
[16:05] displaced traffic, whether the traffic that India picked up by
[16:09] default because China was closed that that trade is going to
[16:12] continue coming to India or whether that trade is going to
[16:16] once you know return to China. The market is out so far, China
[16:21] Africa capacity is up, but China Africa travel is still down.
[16:26] So the, the, the routes are, are are back, but they're not as
[16:30] good as they were pre COVID. So it's it's interesting to see
[16:33] how all of this is happening. But one thing we have seen is
[16:36] that India to Africa is continuing is growing at
[16:40] humongous numbers both in capacity as well as in actual
[16:45] volume over the Last Post COVID times.
[16:49] So which are the current major routes that you're seeing, Sean,
[16:53] Which ones are operated by Indian carriers?
[16:55] Which one? Which ones are operated by
[16:58] African carriers? I'm guessing there's a sizable
[17:02] number of presence, of course, of Ethiopian India.
[17:08] What else? What else are we seeing?
[17:11] You know, as I said at the beginning when you're discussing
[17:14] African aviation is Ethiopian and there's everybody else.
[17:16] And I think that is probably the reality with traffic to India as
[17:19] well. Ethiopian is currently flying 35
[17:23] * a week to twice a day to Mumbai, twice a day to Delhi,
[17:28] Bengaluru, Chennai. They've recently got the
[17:33] bilateral expanded to add flights to Hyderabad.
[17:35] So that's expected to come soon. And I think a, a majority, I'd
[17:40] say an actual majority, 50% plus of the traffic between Africa
[17:44] and India is currently flying on, on Ethiopia.
[17:47] So when they look at the direct routes between between and
[17:50] India, Ethiopian carries most of it.
[17:53] Behind that, you've got little pockets.
[17:55] You what? Kenya Airways is flying twice a
[17:57] day. Between Nairobi and Mumbai,
[17:59] you've got 8. Tanzania flies 3-4 times a week
[18:04] with the 787-737-8220 whatever takes their fancy this week, you
[18:11] know, to Mumbai and you've got Uganda Airlines, which flies an
[18:15] A3 3800 usually half empty from Entebbe to Mumbai as well three
[18:20] times a week. So you know, other than that,
[18:23] you know, you've got, you've also got stuff from the islands
[18:25] you've got like Seychelles and Mauritius.
[18:28] And then you've got North Africa, you've got Egypt Air
[18:30] who's made a push. But a lot of Egypt air traffic
[18:32] is not actually coming to Africa.
[18:34] It's actually connecting onwards to Europe because of Egypt's
[18:37] geographical location. But in terms of that, you know,
[18:39] again, as I said, it's Ethiopian and, and the rest of it from the
[18:42] Indian carrier side, again, if we exclude the islands with the,
[18:47] you know, the Mauritius and the Seychelles kind of things,
[18:50] Nairobi has been pretty much the, the only gateway that
[18:53] Indian carriers have hit her to looked at Air India's flying to
[18:57] Nairobi from Delhi. They, they previously flew it
[19:00] from Ahmedabad. They previously even before that
[19:02] flew it from from Mumbai with a 3/10.
[19:05] But they fly 7-8 sevens from Delhi to Nairobi.
[19:08] And Indigo has entered the Mumbai to Nairobi market last
[19:12] year with A320 Neos daily and have gone from zero to market
[19:17] leader in in under 12 months. So I think in fact that which is
[19:23] the the Indigo model narrow bodies flying between, between
[19:28] West Coast of India, East Coast of Africa is, is really what is
[19:31] going to transform the India to Africa market over the next
[19:35] decade or so. Yeah, that that brings me to my
[19:39] next question. That's a great segue.
[19:41] In fact, Sean, which routes do you think can open in the next 6
[19:46] to 12 months, especially considering Indigo is about to
[19:51] get its XLRS sometime early next year?
[19:55] The largest unserved market from between Africa and India by a
[20:01] long long long way. I mean when we're not even
[20:03] talking like the next two put together don't even add up to
[20:07] this is Johannesburg to Mumbai. This market had last year over
[20:11] 145,000 passengers. And you know, there is no direct
[20:15] flight. So one would think that that is
[20:18] the market that you know, that that can be targeted by Indigo.
[20:23] But I think humongous number that's I mean that's hundreds
[20:27] passengers a day. So you know, this is this is no
[20:30] joke, the bulk of which actually are currently flying on
[20:35] Ethiopian. Just just to say about 40
[20:37] something percent of that is flying on Ethiopian, followed by
[20:40] Kenya Airways, Emirates and you know a few others in that.
[20:44] In fact, a very interesting point.
[20:47] Airbus recently had a study which they looked at the top
[20:49] answer routes from Africa and this was the the second most.
[20:54] The second highest unserved route from Africa was
[20:58] Johannesburg to Mumbai. And one of the interesting
[21:00] things they pointed out was that between 2 and 4% of the
[21:03] passengers flying between Johannesburg and Mumbai fly via
[21:07] London on British Airways or Virgin simply because of the
[21:11] lack of direct options between them.
[21:14] However, the the flip side of this is a bulk of this traffic
[21:18] travels at very, very, very low fares.
[21:21] And you know the, the average yield between Johannesburg and
[21:25] Mumbai is 0.035, approximately cents per kilometer, US cents
[21:32] per kilometer, which gives you a one way sector fare of about
[21:35] $240. And quite simply with 80% load
[21:40] factors that won't even cover your fuel cost on a wide bodied
[21:43] aircraft. That means you know, if a if a
[21:46] 321 XLR could do the flight, it would be a game changer just
[21:51] like it has been. You know the A320 Neo has been a
[21:54] game changer for for Indigo's operations to Nairobi.
[21:58] However, the catch of course being is that Johannesburg is a
[22:02] high altitude airport. So performance limitations on
[22:05] departure and Mumbai is a relatively isolated airport
[22:12] relatively, it's not like an island or whatever, but any
[22:15] flight coming into Mumbai has to hold carry holding fuel because
[22:19] of air traffic congestion and has to carry enough fuel for
[22:21] diversion to Ahmedabad, Hyderabad or one of those
[22:24] others. So effectively, you're adding
[22:26] about an hour and a half to two hours of fuel just in the
[22:29] mandatory reserves flying into Mumbai.
[22:31] And consequently, and this is something that I've looked at
[22:34] myself that Airbus has looked at that you know a number of
[22:37] airlines have the A321, XLR will not be able to do Johannesburg
[22:41] to Mumbai non-stop. It could probably do it from
[22:43] Durban, which is on the coast at sea level.
[22:46] It could do it from a lot of other airports in the region at
[22:50] lower altitudes. But that particular Johannes.
[22:53] Would Cape Town be possible? Cape Town's too far Cape Town.
[22:56] Cape Town is further from Mumbai than London is.
[22:59] So I mean, where, you know, this is Cape Town is 2 further hours
[23:03] from than Johannesburg when you're flying from Mumbai.
[23:07] So it's, that's just a bit too far from that.
[23:10] So Cape Town would actually be a 787 type route if there were
[23:13] enough of a market for it. But you know, the, the reality
[23:16] is the Cape Town market to Mumbai is 45,000 passengers
[23:19] compared to 145,000 for Johannesburg.
[23:22] Durban is 12,000 passengers relative to the 145,000 for
[23:26] Johannesburg. So you know, the, the, the, the,
[23:31] the solution is going to have to be found to serve that
[23:33] Johannesburg to Mumbai market effectively rather than looking
[23:38] at alternatives. And I know people have said, oh,
[23:40] what about a triangle route? You can do Mumbai, Johannesburg.
[23:43] You know, you can fly into Johannesburg from Mumbai, which
[23:45] is sea level departure. You can't fly back non-stop.
[23:48] So what if you combine Johannesburg and came back via
[23:51] Durban or something? Maybe maybe that could work.
[23:53] Maybe that's something that Indigo would look at.
[23:55] The reality though is that 321 XLR is not going to be the magic
[23:59] bullet to solve the number one market unserved between what the
[24:03] number one market between India and and continental Africa.
[24:08] The number one market is Mauritius.
[24:09] But as I said, let's keep the islands sort of out of it for
[24:12] the purpose of this discussion. Where we will see things really
[24:16] improving is going to be East Africa and for that is, you
[24:19] know, following in this Nairobi, I think either Air India or
[24:23] Indigo, anyone who has an A320 neo or 321 Neo effectively would
[24:28] look at Dar es Salaam. Nairobi to Mumbai is 84,000
[24:31] passengers. Last year Dar es Salaam to
[24:33] Mumbai was 73,000 passengers. So effectively you're looking at
[24:36] similar market sizes. Air Tanzania has a weak
[24:39] competitor relative to Kenya Airways.
[24:41] And you know, if you look at terms of the the cost per seat
[24:44] kilometer, Indigo has a cost per seat kilometer network cost per
[24:48] seat kilometer in the range of 5.4 to 5.5 US cents per seat
[24:52] kilometer. If you look in terms of, you
[24:55] know, any of their competitors, they're in the range of 789 and
[24:59] above. So Indigo can really come into
[25:02] these markets with a high density A320 meal offer fares
[25:07] 30% lower than the competition and still make money doing it.
[25:11] And you know, that is transformational for markets
[25:13] like this, especially markets where you're looking to
[25:17] encourage, you know, those 3 sectors that I, that I mentioned
[25:20] before, as well as increase the diaspora ties.
[25:23] Because, you know, I'll tell you, I was talking to a Kenyan
[25:26] friend the other day. And one of the things that they
[25:28] said was now that Indigo's in the market, travelling to India
[25:32] has become like getting on a bus.
[25:34] Because you can literally buy a round trip ticket for a few $100
[25:38] and you know, go off just to visit family or come for
[25:41] Navratri or come for whatever else.
[25:43] You know, people are, are, are actually doing that.
[25:45] And that is stimulating the market further and which allows
[25:49] better economies of scale. And you know, that's why I think
[25:51] we're seeing, you know, further Indian carrier interest in this
[25:55] Nairobi market where where the rumours of Air India potentially
[25:58] launching Mumbai to Nairobi, There's rumours of Indigo
[26:01] potentially launching a second gateway to Nairobi.
[26:04] Now, whether that's going to be Bangalore or Ahmedabad, you
[26:06] know, there's, there's different versions of that rumour out
[26:09] there. But you know, I think it just
[26:11] goes to show that what Indigo been able to do in terms of
[26:14] stimulating that market with a very low cost reliable operation
[26:18] on 320. Neos can be duplicated probably
[26:21] and Dare Salaam may be able to be duplicated in Entebbe,
[26:25] although that may be slightly pushing the range of the 3:20
[26:29] that may need the 321, you know, and that potentially can be used
[26:33] in in in other destinations down the coast as the economies of
[26:38] scale grow. So yes, I think there's, you
[26:41] know, it's very interesting times ahead for this.
[26:43] I think that the challenge though, has always been that the
[26:49] Africa side of this is fragmented.
[26:51] While the traffic into India for the most part terminates, it's
[26:55] not at the metros, but in the metros in a handful of other
[26:58] cities. So, you know, Mumbai in
[27:00] particular has had the main ties from Africa and that if you
[27:02] think back in terms of the trading and the history, you
[27:05] know, that would make sense. Gujarat, again, because of the
[27:07] Gujarati diaspora has had a lot of ties over there.
[27:11] The South has had a fair bit in the last 10 to 15 years because
[27:15] of the medical tourism, you know, people going into, into
[27:18] Chennai, in particular, The Ethiopians route between Addis
[27:20] and Chennai is pretty much a success solely on the basis of
[27:25] their contract with Apollo Hospitals.
[27:27] They, they, 50% of that flight is people coming or going from
[27:30] Apollo Hospitals to Chennai three times a week.
[27:33] So, you know, we're, we're, we're seeing that as a humongous
[27:37] driver. But on the Africa side, the,
[27:41] the, there are far more fragmented pockets.
[27:45] You know, you, you've got certainly Nairobi and Dar es
[27:48] Salaam are, are big numbers, 80 and 85,000.
[27:51] But for the rest of the point, you know, other than a handful
[27:54] of those, the Lusaka, Lagos, Cape Town and Entebbe, there's
[27:57] nobody else above 30,000. When you start looking at the
[28:01] Adis, Kinshasa, Lubumbashi and things like that, these are all
[28:05] in the 20,000 passengers of the year.
[28:06] So those are still need to grow a lot more before nonstop
[28:10] service from India really becomes viable.
[28:12] And this is where the African carriers who have the ability to
[28:15] hub in Africa and collect from these points into a strong
[28:18] habitatis in Nairobi or wherever else still have the advantage
[28:21] over Indian carriers. While on the East Coast of
[28:24] Africa for these high OND points, I think the Indian
[28:27] carriers will have the advantage.
[28:29] Now, of course, as the Indian carriers areas grow and develop
[28:31] their own hubs and have, you know, better connections to
[28:34] Central Asia, to South East Asia and things like that, Africa to
[28:38] those destinations via India becomes a natural connecting
[28:41] point. And you know, as that happens,
[28:43] you know you'll, you'll see, you'll see routes which are
[28:47] currently not viable on O&D alone become more viable.
[28:50] And that's where I think the XLR will will really be able to now
[28:55] open up more coast, more cities in Central and Western Africa,
[28:59] potentially maybe a Lagos, Kinshasa and things like that.
[29:03] Yeah. I mean, I was about to ask you
[29:05] about Lagos and I was also thinking from a Delhi market
[29:10] perspective. There is Air India serving
[29:13] Delhi, Nairobi on a 787, but and we were also talking about how
[29:18] Indigo can stimulate a market when it enters, right.
[29:22] You're seeing that in many markets, in fact in Central
[29:25] Asian republics also, we have discussed that in the past and
[29:29] our our shows in the past. Do you think Delhi, Nairobi can
[29:32] be a market that Indigo can consider on an XLR or even Lagos
[29:37] for that you know from that point of view?
[29:40] Nairobi, Delhi is 42,000 passengers a year relative to
[29:43] 85,000 Nairobi, Mumbai. So, you know, it's, it's half
[29:47] the size. The reality is even if you look
[29:50] in terms of where Indigo's traffic in the Nairobi, Mumbai
[29:53] sector, yeah, it's going, I think the reality.
[29:57] Indigo can stimulate, right? That's what we've been
[30:00] discussing. Once you enter a market and you
[30:02] enter with let's say slightly more affordable fares, you and
[30:06] I'm sure that the way Indigo enters, you know, it goes to so
[30:09] many travel agents, it, you know, it would stimulate the
[30:12] market from that perspective also, you know, and it will
[30:15] probably take away some traffic from Kenya Airways or from Air
[30:18] India or even from these big connecting hubs in Middle East.
[30:22] I'm skeptical on that. I think that Indigo would, they
[30:27] would look at it from 2 potential perspectives #1 is to
[30:31] look at the O&D, the highest O&D market.
[30:33] And I think that would probably be Ahmedabad, which is also a
[30:35] significantly shorter sector than Delhi.
[30:38] So it'll have higher yields than Delhi potentially because Delhi
[30:40] would be primarily pulling connecting traffic and
[30:43] consequently lower yield, while Ahmedabad would have O&D at
[30:46] higher yield. Or they could look at a southern
[30:49] gateway, which is Bengaluru, which again would be
[30:52] distributing to a wider to a wider network than they have.
[30:57] If they went to the Ahmedabad way, the connection traffic
[30:59] would then flow over Mumbai. While if they went over
[31:02] Bengaluru, Mumbai would cater to the O&D and maybe the Gujarat
[31:04] and built kind of traffic, while Bengaluru would serve the
[31:06] southern traffic. So I don't actually think that
[31:09] that Delhi is going to be a a logical gateway to most parts of
[31:14] these African markets. In fact, now I'm looking at this
[31:16] list of the top markets between Africa and I12345678 9.
[31:23] The top nine markets are all to Mumbai rather than Delhi.
[31:26] And when Delhi even starts coming in, it is in second
[31:29] position. So like what's the highest
[31:30] market? African market from Delhi is
[31:32] Cairo and you know Cairo, Delhi is 45,000 relative to Cairo,
[31:36] Mumbai 90,000. Lagos Delhi is 44,000 relative
[31:40] to Lagos, Mumbai 68,000. So we've seen that, you know,
[31:44] the, the ties to, to Africa in particular because of the
[31:48] historical trade, because of the historical diaspora and
[31:51] everything else is not North India.
[31:53] You know, just like you've got the, the Punjabis went to
[31:56] Canada, the Gujaratis came to Africa and you know, that is
[32:00] the, that is the reality of where it is.
[32:02] So I think you, I, I don't think Delhi is a logical hub for
[32:06] serving Africa. I think you're going to have to
[32:09] look at the, the western South for that.
[32:13] And then like the logical point, Ahmedabad, Ahmedabad to Nairobi
[32:16] is, is that little niche which could make successful.
[32:19] Ahmedabad is not going to be able to to be a hub for serving
[32:23] Africa in general. For that, you know, Mumbai is,
[32:25] is the draw. Mumbai, you know, speaking as a
[32:27] proud Mumbaikar myself, you know Mumbai the city, Ahmedabad is a
[32:31] town becoming a city. In the last few years, India's
[32:36] relationship with Egypt has been elevated to a strategic
[32:40] partnership which has greatly helped the air travel between
[32:44] both the countries. I've been thinking about the
[32:47] north of North Africa, Morocco and and how's there's not even
[32:51] one non-stop route to Casablanca or Marrakesh from India.
[32:57] Do you see some potential there? While Morocco is geographically
[33:00] in Africa, for all practical purposes it's not.
[33:04] Moroccans don't even like to consider themselves Africans and
[33:10] every single, you know, thing that we've, we've spoken about
[33:13] here in terms of diaspora traffic potential of hitting it
[33:15] from there. Remember, India is closer to the
[33:18] East Coast of Africa than Morocco is close to the East
[33:20] Coast of Africa. You know, flying from say
[33:23] Nairobi to to Marrakesh is 8-9 hours.
[33:28] So you know, while it is technically in Africa, it is a
[33:31] very, very different dynamic. It's actually more of a Southern
[33:34] European dynamic rather than you know, than it is in terms of
[33:41] that. Certainly, I think, you know, as
[33:42] I said, outbound Indian tourism to these to these hit her to non
[33:47] traditional destinations is a growing sector.
[33:50] You know, we've seen it all over.
[33:51] We've seen booms in Central Asia.
[33:53] We've seen booms in, you know, in the Vietnams and places where
[33:56] Indians have not traditionally gone until now.
[33:58] And you know, Morocco will is already seeing some some
[34:02] benefits of an E visa policy and so forth.
[34:06] But I don't think we're going to see Morocco reap the same kind
[34:10] of benefits that the rest of sub-Saharan Africa in particular
[34:14] is going to in terms of ties to India, in terms of India's focus
[34:19] as well. You know, that kind of thing is,
[34:23] is very much going to be concentrated on sub-Saharan
[34:26] Africa and even further concentrated on Eastern and
[34:29] Southern Africa to the exception of Central and western.
[34:33] Do you see any new airlines entering the market, Sean?
[34:38] I know for a fact that ACASA has got East Africa on their list.
[34:42] The question is how much of that potentially unserved or
[34:48] underserved market is going to be left for them once Indigo and
[34:53] Air India, you know, jump at it in the next few months.
[34:56] While ACASA is obviously looking in a period of years, judging by
[35:00] how their aircraft deliveries are getting delayed by Boeing's
[35:03] again, you know all the issues there.
[35:04] Yeah, yeah, yeah, that's right. Definitely.
[35:09] I think a Casa, you know, it's optional for that model.
[35:11] You've got 737 Max's. Those can hit the same markets
[35:15] that we've been discussing the Nairobi's Daris alarms, Cairos
[35:18] and stuff like that non-stop. You know, you'd you'd want to
[35:21] take advantage of that. But do you want to take
[35:24] advantage of that if Indigo has come into it with a 5.5 cent
[35:29] cost per seat kilometer, which, you know, no matter how good a
[35:33] Casa's costs are, you don't want to poke the bear.
[35:37] And you know, they're probably better off in looking at Middle
[35:40] East where there's better yields to be had than than getting into
[35:45] a bloodmath in a market that needs to be stimulated.
[35:47] While the Middle East market, just, you know, has never needed
[35:50] stimulation for most of India. That's that's right.
[35:54] And I think if somebody like Acasa serves, let's say, a Cairo
[35:58] or or even a Nairobi for that matter, they would still require
[36:02] lots of local feed, which they'll need to figure out.
[36:06] So that'll be complex. OK, One, one last question
[36:08] quickly. Sean, there.
[36:10] There. We've been, you know, in the
[36:12] news we've been reading and hearing about this Adani Airport
[36:16] controversy in Nairobi. Do you have any comments on
[36:18] that? I, I have plenty of thoughts.
[36:20] I, I have, I have refrained from trying to voice them publicly
[36:24] because it's a no, it's a no win situation if I speak the truth.
[36:27] But I think what I can say is I think Adani is in the wrong
[36:33] place at the wrong time. Unfortunately, I think the
[36:35] political situation in Kenya right now is such that if the
[36:39] government brought forward, you know, a proposal to fix the
[36:43] airport from a conglomerate made-up of made-up of the
[36:46] Prophet Muhammad, Jesus Christ and, and, and you know, the God
[36:50] around himself came together and put a proposal.
[36:54] People would be suspicious of it simply because they don't trust
[36:58] any deal that the government's bringing to them.
[37:00] And I think, you know, Adani, whether it's a clean deal or
[37:03] not, I genuinely, I don't know the details of it, but I'll tell
[37:07] you that the, the opposition to any government proposal in Kenya
[37:12] right now is probably going to kill any potential foreign
[37:16] partnership on an infrastructure project there for now.
[37:19] So I think Adani's probably going to have to back off on it
[37:22] and then revisit it maybe towards the latter part of
[37:27] President Ruto's term or maybe, you know, after his term is over
[37:30] in a couple of years time. And you know, with the new
[37:32] administration, look at it in a more in a less tainted light.
[37:36] But I don't think that's that's to do with Adani's side of
[37:39] things. I think that's just to do with
[37:41] with the Kenyan politics and the situation in Kenya right now.
[37:45] Sean, this has been enlightening.
[37:49] We can keep talking forever, but for now, allow me to thank you.
[37:55] My absolute pleasure, it's been great being on and I hope to see
[37:58] the India Africa market knowing so strongly that I get to be a
[38:02] more regular guy. I certainly feel more richer in
[38:06] my knowledge about African aviation after this episode.
[38:10] Sean was wonderful. Well, time to say the usual
[38:15] things before we say adios for the week.
[38:19] As always, we are streaming on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon
[38:24] and all other major podcast apps.
[38:28] Do take out 30 seconds, rate US and leave us a feedback.
[38:33] It helps. And with that, I wish you well
[38:37] and happy flying my friends.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
